WEBVTT

METADATA
Video-Count: 1
Video-1: youtube.com/watch?v=GczXQXN-t6U

Part: 1

1
00:03:04.959 --> 00:03:21.599
I'd like to call the meeting to order. In accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey Open Public Meeting Act of 1975, the Ottabon Board of Education transmitted notice of the meeting scheduled at 7 p.m. in the Ottabon Junior Senior High School Media Center to the Retrospect newspaper and the

2
00:03:21.599 --> 00:03:37.360
Burough Clerk and by postings on the Ottabon Public School District website and at the main and the Pine Street entrances of the Junior Senior High School. Roll call, please. Mrs. Ronase. >> Allison Lipsky, >> here. >> Mark Gaddy, >> here. Bill Wilson.

3
00:03:37.360 --> 00:03:52.799
>> Danielle D. Franchesco >> here. >> Allison Cox >> here. >> Andrea Robinson >> here. >> Amy Davis >> here. >> Steven Wilson >> here. >> Sarah Coolen >> here. >> Michelle Kennedy >> here. >> Ryan W >> motion pass.

4
00:03:52.799 --> 00:04:08.799
>> Thank you. Please stand for the flag salute. >> Where did it go? Okay. >> Yeah, you're right. I pledge algiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands,

5
00:04:08.799 --> 00:04:28.400
one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> All right, just to kind of lay a little foundation for this evening's meeting, we are having our public presentation on our budget hearing. So first our

6
00:04:28.400 --> 00:04:44.639
superintendent Miss Allen will present the um for the school year 2627. Then the board members will have an opportunity to ask questions, have discussion, make comments and after that

7
00:04:44.639 --> 00:05:00.320
we will open the meeting to publication which will be opportunities for anyone in the public that has questions or would like to make statements or a comment. So um Without further ado, I'd like to ask Miss Allen to give her

8
00:05:00.320 --> 00:05:24.400
presentation and Mrs. Ron case. >> Would you like me to have everybody turn around? >> We have a presentation. It's not necessarily the easiest thing to see. You guys actually probably have a better view of it than the board. The board members all have it in your folder. U so

9
00:05:24.400 --> 00:05:39.919
you can follow along there. It's not in color and pretty, but it's there. Um, so this is the public budget hearing presentation for the 2627 school year. The first slide goes over the things that we've looked at since last year,

10
00:05:39.919 --> 00:05:55.280
the things that were in the strategic plan. These were some of the areas that were identified as areas of need that we keep in our focus when we're building the uh budget for the year. the mental health staff's professional development, preschool for all, community

11
00:05:55.280 --> 00:06:11.919
involvement, uh, PTA at all levels, the Mal Ephraim collaboration, preparing the students for college and careers, better scores at the high school, life skills, PBIS and SEAL across the district, more course offerings, and a therapy dog.

12
00:06:11.919 --> 00:06:27.120
Those were all things that we had come up with after the um, forums and things from the strategic plan. We are now going into year two. We'll need to have a recap on that at another time, but that is still very paramount in our building of the budget. We make sure

13
00:06:27.120 --> 00:06:48.000
that we have those goals there with us when we're going through some things. Okay, this slide shows um how our district revenue is split out. So, uh, tax levy, we are able to, um, increase

14
00:06:48.000 --> 00:07:06.240
that by, uh, 2% increase, which gives us to the 15 million, um, over last year's budget. Um, there are some adjustments that the district is allowed or are eligible for. The biggest one is our

15
00:07:06.240 --> 00:07:22.800
health benefit adjustment. And we had discussed this before um regarding since our health care costs have increased over 30% most schools have received this healthcare adjustment. So you are able to raise unfortunately all it does is

16
00:07:22.800 --> 00:07:41.440
really raise taxes. Um, and the board, we were eligible to go up to over 1 million, but we opted to only use 858,000 of that. Uh, fund balance, that is funds that we use from the previous

17
00:07:41.440 --> 00:07:57.759
year's budget to roll over into the next year's. Um, according to the auditor, uh, last year we used 375,000. we um his advice was not to increase that. We do have in the budget other

18
00:07:57.759 --> 00:08:14.479
capital projects that we plan on pulling out of our capital reserve. This is money that sits in a reserve that we pull out for we have four projects that we want to accomplish um in the 26 27

19
00:08:14.479 --> 00:08:30.000
school year. Uh that really doesn't affect any taxes there. Just pulling out of a reserve and putting it in as revenue. Um tuition for Mount Ephraim. This is um

20
00:08:30.000 --> 00:08:45.600
our billing for 9th through 12th students to attend uh here in Ottabon. And then our state aid um this is given to us by the um by the state and this is

21
00:08:45.600 --> 00:09:02.480
based on our enrollment numbers. We are flat with a little bit of a decrease. So that's why we don't see a big increase at all in our um state aid numbers.

22
00:09:02.480 --> 00:09:19.760
Federal Medicaid is a figure of 31,000 that comes directly from the state. Also, um this is the number that they actually tell us to budget based on uh it's called SEMI. It's a huge application that we have to

23
00:09:19.760 --> 00:09:37.839
fill out to um get these funds, but it's more state for that. And then miscellaneous revenue. This would be our gates and gate fees, our paytoplay that we have for the kids, any

24
00:09:37.839 --> 00:09:52.959
Chromebook fees that we might need to collect, um any fines. It's also our extraordinary aid that is a separate application and that has to deal with uh special ed costs for that. So that's how

25
00:09:52.959 --> 00:10:08.399
we come to our total district revenue. And then we did a nice pie chart for you to see that uh breaks down on where the district revenue comes from.

26
00:10:08.399 --> 00:10:29.120
The largest part is the tax levy appropriations. The advertised budget is sort of broken down the they broke break it down into sections. every budget that you look at for a school district is broken down the

27
00:10:29.120 --> 00:10:45.120
same way. So, um in instructional programs, our employee benefits, you have the tuition that we pay for out of district students. Um we are able to

28
00:10:45.120 --> 00:11:01.040
supplement that was 350,000 to our grant funding. Um you have uh athletic and school activities, school sponsored events. Um they would be mostly stipens

29
00:11:01.040 --> 00:11:15.920
and supplies for them. Um district support would be all of the other support services, child study team, guidance, nurse. Um and then you broke down between school

30
00:11:15.920 --> 00:11:33.399
administration and then uh general and central administration would be the superintendent's office and the um business office and also uh technology is in there facilities and operations

31
00:11:33.760 --> 00:11:49.839
student transportation. This includes the bus drivers plus our transportation that we bus um out of district students to which we only do special education

32
00:11:49.839 --> 00:12:07.519
students. We bus uh to other locations. And then in that capital projects um is the 250,000 uh there plus some other equipment that we need. So as you can see revenues

33
00:12:07.519 --> 00:12:26.079
equal your expenditures of 31 million. And then we did another nice little pie chart there of our appropriations. And you can see that the most of our funds do go to instructional programs.

34
00:12:28.959 --> 00:12:46.279
I'm sorry. >> In personal services, personnel services is healthcare, >> right? So, instructional programs and um personnel services are with the health benefits.

35
00:12:48.000 --> 00:13:02.639
And then we wanted to show you the trend of the tax levy. So this year with the budget that is presented in front of you on a house assessed at 204,700

36
00:13:02.639 --> 00:13:25.279
uh taxes will increase $347.93 which is $28.99 a month. We do have a tax rate of 7.59. So, what kind of things did we do to get us to this budget to be able to balance

37
00:13:25.279 --> 00:13:40.560
what our needs are with what we have coming in? Um, we talked about some of these things. We're going to go into a little bit more specifics. The most important thing that I want to make sure everybody is aware of is that we're not cutting any positions in not

38
00:13:40.560 --> 00:13:57.199
non not riffing any positions. um with what's going on in in today's world, there's a whole lot of districts that are cutting millions of dollars in staff. Um some buildings are closing, some schools are closing. We don't have

39
00:13:57.199 --> 00:14:12.880
any of that. We found a way to keep everybody that we have still in their positions. That's not to say that we don't have to make some changes. Um, some of the conversations that were had here as a whole board, some of the conversations

40
00:14:12.880 --> 00:14:28.480
that we've had at committees has helped us decide some directions to look at. Historically at Mansion, there's been four home rooms for every grade level. And at Havlin, your K one and two have always had five for each grade level.

41
00:14:28.480 --> 00:14:45.120
The classes are not the the entire grade level size is not different, but the number of students per class was different. we had the ability and had the luxury of having them smaller. With all these cuts, with all these things going on and us having to try to make

42
00:14:45.120 --> 00:15:01.920
this budget balance, we have decided to collapse one first grade and one second grade classroom. That means that next year our first grade classrooms will be approximately 19 students each. Our second grade classrooms will be approximately 16 students each.

43
00:15:01.920 --> 00:15:18.959
These are still very very low numbers compared to what other districts are dealing with. There's many districts that are in the 25 28 almost up to 30 per classroom even at this age level. Not talking about high school level but at this elementary lower elementary. So

44
00:15:18.959 --> 00:15:35.519
we're we're very comfortable that 16 and 19 are still very manageable numbers. Obviously 12 and 15 is better, but that places we had to find places where we could do some things. Sorry, before I go on to the next one,

45
00:15:35.519 --> 00:15:51.680
um, an important fact when we sit down to look at the budget, we make sure that we are being very careful and deliberate to not target one area, target one building, make sure that we are trimming from

46
00:15:51.680 --> 00:16:10.000
everyone in every way in every building so that not one area is being felt. We had to sit down and look at everything from athletics to ac academics to numbers of classrooms. Everything was on the table for this negotiation.

47
00:16:10.000 --> 00:16:25.680
That being said, we are reducing one academic support teacher at Mansion. Um, obviously we want as much academic support as possible. We have been doing a lot of work with our RTI, which is our intervention period. We've been doing a lot of work with instructional counsel

48
00:16:25.680 --> 00:16:41.199
in looking at the multi-tiered uh systems of support, MTSS. We have some plans to put in place next year for that. And because we have that, we feel comfortable that letting go of one academic support person won't put us in a position where the kids aren't getting

49
00:16:41.199 --> 00:16:57.120
what they need. We think that we can still satisfy the needs with some of the programming that we're going to put in place and cut that one person from the um from the mansion school. I think I'm going to I think I'm going to need you

50
00:16:57.120 --> 00:17:12.000
to click for my next one. The next item is the item that's been talked about a lot is the music program. Uh we had originally talked about taking the two music people, the high school and the mansion position and combining

51
00:17:12.000 --> 00:17:28.240
them into one. This week we sat down uh curriculum administration. If you can click that blue thing link, thank you. Uh administration sat down. We had talked about we would not go out looking for a person for that position without really outlining what that position was

52
00:17:28.240 --> 00:17:45.520
going to look like. How would it work? We were able to come up with a schedule. We were able to come up with a plan that would facilitate one person working at both the high school and at Mansion being able to make sure we still have the same number of lesson times and all of that. That being said, there was

53
00:17:45.520 --> 00:18:02.080
still more conversation and someone said, "What if we did two part-time people instead of one full-time person?" There's a lot of advantages to that. The advantages are a part-time person is 29.5 hours. To have two people would be one at each site all the time. 29.5

54
00:18:02.080 --> 00:18:19.120
hours as opposed to one 40-hour person. We're actually getting more hours of support out of the person and it doesn't cost us as much. We can hire two part-time people for about the same thing that we can one full-time because of benefits. So, even though we talked

55
00:18:19.120 --> 00:18:34.400
about the one position and I'm now asking you to approve two part-time positions, it doesn't change the budget that I put forth to you last time because it is basically the same amount. Part of the reason that this came to light is because, like I said,

56
00:18:34.400 --> 00:18:51.919
everything had to be looked at. Um, we have talked about, we've we've been to the concerts, we've been to the things I, you know, we have a fabulous music program. It's very robust. But if you're looking at the numbers, I I always have to look at the data. We're very data driven. Back in 201718 is when the

57
00:18:51.919 --> 00:19:09.039
programs were I'm sorry, 1819. One more time. 2019 2020 is when the programs were I have numbers from both the the mansion school. You got to slide that up a little bit. It's not showing the whole There you go. Um at that time,

58
00:19:09.039 --> 00:19:25.679
it cut off the years at the top, but that's okay. At that time there was 111 students actively playing instruments at the high school and 117 actively playing instruments at Mansion. That meant that there was a total of and it's off the chart there but it's 228 total students

59
00:19:25.679 --> 00:19:43.039
in music. Fast forward to right now this year we have that say 65 students in the high school actively playing instruments and 41 students at Mansion for a grand total of 106 students. I don't take this lightly. It's not easy to make the

60
00:19:43.039 --> 00:19:59.520
decisions on where to make the cuts, but the numbers don't warrant two full-time positions at this time. We absolutely have faith that the program will come back to that level, but we need time to get it there. And so, we have things in place. We have ideas in place to make

61
00:19:59.520 --> 00:20:16.320
that happen. The two part-time will be much more effective and give them more time in the buildings. My only caution is hiring a part-time person is very different than looking for a full-time person. You're not going to get a veteran who has 20 years of music experience, who's been a conductor that wants to come on for a part-time

62
00:20:16.320 --> 00:20:32.640
position. You will find a younger novice person who's hungry, who really wants to build a program, who wants to make it their own. And that's what we're hoping to find, one for each position. We'll have to see how that hiring goes. I want to be very honest that if come

63
00:20:32.640 --> 00:20:48.159
end of July we're not able to find those candidates, we're going to need to sit and have another conversation about what do we do because trying to find part-time people is difficult. We've had this over the years. It's kind of like finding paras. There's not a lot of people. Our hope is that with things

64
00:20:48.159 --> 00:21:04.320
that are going on in the other school districts, with cuts being made, someone may be more willing to come on for a part-time job than have no job, especially knowing that they have the opportunity to grow it and turn it into their own program. We have every intention of budgeting next year to make

65
00:21:04.320 --> 00:21:23.039
these full-time positions, but you know, the situation we're in right now and that we have we have to make cuts. If you can go back to my original So, two part-time positions at 29.5. We have retirements and resignations

66
00:21:23.039 --> 00:21:38.960
that are happening within the district. We're not going to hire to replace them. So, for example, we have um a couple of fourth grade teachers leaving, but I'm collapsing a first and a second grade classroom and the academic support. So, those will fill in some of those spots. That's not to say we're not doing any

67
00:21:38.960 --> 00:21:55.039
hiring. We know that the preschool grant is an entirely separate entity. We are hiring new preschool people. We do at this point have our spots filled. So if anybody else resigns or retires, there will still be hiring. But the spots that are already available are already taken

68
00:21:55.039 --> 00:22:12.640
care of with some of these internal moves. Uh we have also done a significant amount of cutting back in supplies in our aotments of things in our quantities of new technology. Um I pause there for a minute. We talked about uh and it's

69
00:22:12.640 --> 00:22:28.080
happening a lot of places now that students are becoming far too reliant on technology. We are talking about being uh cell phone free from bell to bell. So these are conversations we're having. Do kids all need to have devices in their hands all day? So for kindergarten we're

70
00:22:28.080 --> 00:22:45.600
talking about not buying Chromebooks per student, which is what we have done historically so that they would we're going to buy carts to use. So, the students will still have exposure. The students will still see a keyboard and learn the letters, but they're not going to need technology that frequently that

71
00:22:45.600 --> 00:23:02.159
warrants us putting out for say a 100 Chromebooks where we can just get a cart of 30 and have some savings there. Um, summer work, we had talked a little bit at the education committee yesterday that we had all kinds of ideas of things that we wanted to do for summer work. A

72
00:23:02.159 --> 00:23:17.440
whole lot of that was cut. There is still a few po postings because there are some new initiatives. There's a handwriting um mandate now that didn't exist before. There's some things like that that we have to by code get in there. So those

73
00:23:17.440 --> 00:23:34.480
are the only summer curriculum type things that we have going on. We talked about our our at the upper level it's the um health curriculum with theCCL and the mental health. Those things are not in there and we need to get them in there. It's it's not um optional. Uh so there is very limited summer work

74
00:23:34.480 --> 00:23:50.000
happening in the world of curriculum. Uh we also had some new initiatives that we wanted to to launch next year for elementary. We're going to hold off on those. We don't have the money. Now is not the time. These are very worthwhile initiatives, but we're just going to have to hold on to them for a little bit

75
00:23:50.000 --> 00:24:04.640
until things become a little bit more comfortable. Um cut back on supplies a lotments. Those were the other Yeah. you know, just we we talked before again, I wanted to make sure that all areas and all departments

76
00:24:04.640 --> 00:24:22.640
were using their money wisely. So, in athletics, we went through and took some money out of some different sport areas to say you have to cut back the amount. In some science labs, we cut back the amounts. We asked people to consolidate things or to look at things, sharing things instead of everybody having their

77
00:24:22.640 --> 00:24:39.279
own sets of things in order to cut back on some of our expenses. Other cost-saving measures, we do have shared services. Our we uh our technology shares with Collingswood, with Belmar, with Ottabon Burrow. Um so the services that we provide, we're able

78
00:24:39.279 --> 00:24:56.480
to bill for this year. We started a new thing with Collingswood with all of their Chromebooks that were damaged. We actually are like a Chromebook repair store and we're billing them for the time that we're working on those things. Those are things that we work on outside of the day that they're working on our machines. So, there's people putting in

79
00:24:56.480 --> 00:25:12.720
some extra time, but it benefits us in that we can bill Collingswood for some of that work. We have a third party for energy. Um, this has been a savings. It's kind of like a reseller, but we're always looking for areas that we can save the district some money. We are member of

80
00:25:12.720 --> 00:25:29.600
the GIF, which is a co-op of a multiple multitude of different school districts in Burlington, Camden, and Gloucester County that come together for the casualty insurance and things of that nature. it's much cheaper for us to do it as a coalition or co-op. Um,

81
00:25:29.600 --> 00:25:45.600
fortunately, since the last time we met, we have found out that there is a possibility that we will be able to go out and shop for new healthcare insurance. Um, our I always say it wrong, our usage, our our experience number came back and it's something that

82
00:25:45.600 --> 00:26:02.480
will has improved and we think we will be able to. Unfortunately, that's not money we're going to feel right away. Everything takes time. Um, our brokers will will do some shopping. It's not a guarantee, but it's a lot more ideas than what we had before. So, we're very excited about that and that will

83
00:26:02.480 --> 00:26:18.240
hopefully get us some, if not this year, even if we could for next year, have that money to put back into our budget. Uh, we also apply for quite a few grants. There's an egrant that we get every year. Obviously, the preschool uh expansion grant is what's allowing us to

84
00:26:18.240 --> 00:26:34.880
do the things we're doing there. Um there's a focus grant that the uh curriculum department uh applies for. I'm sure there's others. This was these were just some of the larger ones that we put out there. Um these are other things. We're always looking for these opportunities. And then bulk purchasing.

85
00:26:34.880 --> 00:26:51.919
Uh what I've noticed when I came in last year was that all the teachers do their own little Amazon list and everybody orders the things that way. and that's great, but you're actually spending a lot more than instead of you getting pencils, you getting pencils, and you getting pencils, we're going to get a vat of pencils and we can just deal them out. So, that was a change. And we're

86
00:26:51.919 --> 00:27:07.360
going through some different vendors. Amazon is convenient. Amazon is easy. Amazon is not always the cheapest. There are many times it is, but there are times it's not. So, we've been making sure that we're using the um the corporate buying type things. Uh Quill is another wonderful resource that we

87
00:27:07.360 --> 00:27:23.600
use that we can get things very quickly for very good prices and it's not just what it looks like in the book. So, we have um all of our teachers and administrators using bulk trying to make sure that instead of we have so many little orders, we're in the September uh business office will tell you we get

88
00:27:23.600 --> 00:27:40.159
a whole lot of POS in the beginning of the year and we're trying to just do huge bulk orders and that's been helping even so far as with maintenance and things with the um paper towels and tissues and things like that instead of ordering of the the only other problem there becomes storage, but we have

89
00:27:40.159 --> 00:28:02.960
enough room for some of that. Uh, but it's much cheaper when you buy things in bulk. Questions? No. Yeah, it's their questions. >> Oh, they're turning around. Okay.

90
00:28:02.960 --> 00:28:18.799
I thought you wanted me to turn. Uh, so with the point about bulk purchasing, I imagine logistically this could be challenging, but has there ever been an exploration of ways to kind of join together with other school

91
00:28:18.799 --> 00:28:34.880
districts like for some sort of supplies that everybody kind of uses? So let's say like Haden Heights, you know, are you using these similar kind of things? I I understand the logistics would would be challenging, but would that potentially offer some means of savings

92
00:28:34.880 --> 00:28:50.880
if different school districts kind of banded together to purchase some of these things in bulk? >> I have no I've never never thought of that. Um I know that I was in a larger district before and they had the what was it called? It's um ED data that ED

93
00:28:50.880 --> 00:29:06.559
data and did things through that. Um that is something that we could explore. I will tell you that let's say at the elementary levels and it's only because I know she's here and she does it. Miss Martell has put together some spreadsheets where all the teachers put what extra supplies they have right now

94
00:29:06.559 --> 00:29:21.840
and put on a spreadsheet so that others will know it's there. So I mean we are doing a lot of things internally to make sure that we're not waste wasting like you don't just every year come in and go I'm buying a bunch more colored pencils. Well I have a box of color pencils I never opened last year. Do you want them? Yes I do. Things like that. So, we

95
00:29:21.840 --> 00:29:36.399
are working on that, but I, you know, especially the smaller districts around here, I'm friends with those superintendents. So, that is something that I'll go back and ask them about because we're all scrap scraping for pennies. So, if that's something that we could actually pull together and do,

96
00:29:36.399 --> 00:29:53.520
we'll check it out. >> Mr. Ron, on slide on slides five and six, the general appropriations funds come in at 31.1, but then on the next slide, it says appropriations 29.6. What's you just explain that? Uh, thank you for catching that. It is 30. The pie

97
00:29:53.520 --> 00:30:10.960
chart is does equal up to 31 >> 141. That was a slide that we added in um from we we presented this at the meet and greet but did not include the pie charts. So that pie chart was the numbers are correct. It's just the

98
00:30:10.960 --> 00:30:34.720
number at the top that should say 31,140. Um I have two questions. >> That's all. >> First the the chart that you gave uh I saw this this email earlier and I think this is a really it really demonstrates

99
00:30:34.720 --> 00:30:50.399
really effectively the thing that you were highlighting which is the enrollment issue in the bands uh declining so steeply over a seven-year period. And so we need to rebuild that program.

100
00:30:50.399 --> 00:31:08.000
And I guess my qu my first question is, do we have a sense of what contributed because I I don't know, my my neighbor was in band when I first moved here. Everybody's in band. Loves the band. Everybody loves the band. I'm curious. Do we have a sense of what contributed to the decline in enrollment? Why it's

101
00:31:08.000 --> 00:31:24.640
less than half of what it was seven years ago that we can work to rebuild? The only one that I know def definitively is CO happened through that time and that's that's a big factor. Um and it's hard to get the kids, >> you know, messed up. Yes, that messed up

102
00:31:24.640 --> 00:31:40.960
a cohort and things like that. Um >> there was also a change in personnel at Mansion and I I don't know that it's ever come back from what she had it as. So, um we intend to tap into that as much as we can to to try to, you know,

103
00:31:40.960 --> 00:31:57.360
pick our brain. What what did what did you do to get 100 kids to come and play? And how did you keep that all organized and how did you get I know that some of the frustration right now is the kids don't bring their instruments so they don't get to practice and then they're not growing and then they get frustrated and and the schedule um unfortunately

104
00:31:57.360 --> 00:32:12.159
our our teacher that's doing the music at Mansion is out a lot. She's got some health concerns so the kids practices get cancelled. It's it's hard to keep that momentum. Um I that I would think is easier to fix, but I don't know. I

105
00:32:12.159 --> 00:32:29.200
mean I we haven't really um dug in that deep to figure out exactly what it is. Um because I I you know my people were leaving, so I need to get new people there that come in with some new ideas and energy and enthusiasm and see what they can bring. >> Yeah. Because I I just think it's so

106
00:32:29.200 --> 00:32:43.919
important. I think this town just celebrates the band and make sure that that rich tradition stays there. So then my second concern is this. Um we had discussed that replacing it with one position to get somebody that could

107
00:32:43.919 --> 00:33:01.120
help regrow it and then expand it when you know in the future uh as our budget hopefully crunch is not as much of an issue. Uh but this um two part-time position idea was is is kind of news to me. I

108
00:33:01.120 --> 00:33:16.159
just saw it earlier today and then >> um that explained it and I think it's not so much a question as much a concern that you acknowledge which is it can be harder to fill part-time positions with highly

109
00:33:16.159 --> 00:33:33.519
qualified people. Can you tell me why you think that is truly the better idea than just doing one that would be split? I think I think everybody needs to be sold on that or they're going to be really frustrated by the idea and and that's the one >> I think both options are difficult. I

110
00:33:33.519 --> 00:33:49.919
think finding one person that can really embrace 7 to 12 which is one responsibility and the it's actually 4 to six because third grade doesn't do it and the four to six is a lot. Can it be done? Absolutely. All of our specials

111
00:33:49.919 --> 00:34:05.120
people right now go back and forth between buildings. So the concept of doing two buildings is not impossible. Is it a lot? Yes. Is it going to be a lot of organization running around things like that? Like I said, we created a schedule. We we made one. We

112
00:34:05.120 --> 00:34:20.720
were able to come up with the principles of both buildings and Mr. Burke sat down and came up with a schedule of exactly how it would work. Would it be easy? No. Is it doable? Yes. Our concern, and I'm going to use a term that Miss Davis said, is you're almost looking for a unicorn. You're looking for somebody who

113
00:34:20.720 --> 00:34:37.200
has the experience of whatever it is coming in that wants to do either high school band or wants to do elementary band and asking them to do both. That's going to be a hard find. Now you go to two part-time. The benefit is there's somebody in the building at all times. So you have the ability, like I said, if

114
00:34:37.200 --> 00:34:52.000
the kid forgot their instrument, but mom and dad bring it up, maybe we can have that lesson later in the day instead of earlier in the day. We also get a few more hours out of it. Are we going to be have any trouble finding that? I don't know. Um, the only thing I can relate it to is like the media program that we're

115
00:34:52.000 --> 00:35:08.720
starting here in the in the high school. That gentleman came in and yes, he's a full-time position, but he came in going, "Oh my god, if you're going to let me build this from the ground up, I am so excited. Give me five years. You're not going to believe what this is going to be like. I'm looking for somebody with that kind of energy and enthusiasm. I believe they exist. I

116
00:35:08.720 --> 00:35:26.079
don't know. I won't know until I cast the and see what I get." Um the position that's posted right now, just high school, we have 30 some applicants, but again, that's for a full-time high school position. I don't know if those people would also be interested in doing

117
00:35:26.079 --> 00:35:42.640
the the two schools. It's a small district. It's not uncommon for people to have to do. Like I said, all my specials go back and forth. This is just instrumental. My vocal goes back and forth between Havlin and Mansion. Now, um so there is no good answer. The best answer is find me more money so I can

118
00:35:42.640 --> 00:36:00.240
have two full-time people. But you're the ones that said to me, right? You know, I'm >> absolutely >> full-time positions. Absolutely. >> Correct me if I'm wrong, too. And when Miss Davis and you and I met on Monday

119
00:36:00.240 --> 00:36:16.079
and discussed this, having the part-time committed to each building allows them the opportunity to grow the program, right? especially at Mansion to spend that extra >> time to recruit or build enthusiasm or >> do whatever they need to do to get

120
00:36:16.079 --> 00:36:32.960
>> right. That's our hope, right? Get two people that have some fire in there and be like, you know, get it going once they and by the end of the year they have so many kids that are interested in picking it up for next year and healthc care doesn't kill me so that we're not having a a 37% increase and I'm able to

121
00:36:32.960 --> 00:36:54.599
take those two part-times and bump them up to full-time. Um just one thing I I wanted to kind of piggy back on what uh Mr. William Wilson said to how do you reg with my

122
00:36:56.640 --> 00:37:12.160
and >> maybe move it closer. I don't know you fade in and out. I I think one we can can help to grow the program is to ask the kids. I've gotten a lot of suggestions and inputs like I said around my dinner table

123
00:37:12.160 --> 00:37:28.640
especially in the junior senior high school um you know some of the the things that they might be be looking to do and I'm I'm sure it also exists over so I think asking is is a great place to >> I won't send them a survey because they

124
00:37:28.640 --> 00:37:49.359
don't do I'm sorry. I didn't mean to. I just want a clarification question. When you're talking about hiring two part-times, their focus would be instrumental instruction, not vocal instruction. That position's already covered. Correct. >> This is just an instrumental music

125
00:37:49.359 --> 00:38:06.320
position. Correct. >> So, they won't have double duty worrying about >> No, no, no. We have we have vocal people at we already have a vocal person that does both mansion and Havlin. So only Havlin four to six gets instruments third doesn't. Um and the so there's a vocal person that does both of those

126
00:38:06.320 --> 00:38:23.920
buildings and obviously a full vocal program here. So this is really just the instrumental piece. I'm curious with the on the high school side if there's enough hours in the day with a part-time job for the the instrumental teacher to really be able to cover all the bases with the students

127
00:38:23.920 --> 00:38:39.920
and really give them the proper help they need, especially with electives added on the side. I'm pretty sure there's a music theory class. I just I don't >> I I honestly right now they have a zero period and a first period. The whole rest of their day is just for lessons. And like I said, the numbers from before, you know, there used to be in

128
00:38:39.920 --> 00:38:56.079
the hundreds and now it's um much smaller. So it is actually manageable for within the day. Um you may not have lessons of three or four. You may have lessons with five or six instead of a smaller group. But it there's they would be here five days and able to do all of

129
00:38:56.079 --> 00:39:11.520
those periods. >> Right. But my concern is do we know the exact number of lessons they usually go on per day or Okay. >> Yeah. >> And how much is that? Usually >> they're different each day. I have his schedule but it's different each day. There's but there's days that are full.

130
00:39:11.520 --> 00:39:28.880
There's days that aren't as full. And same thing at Mansion. There's days where she's doing four lessons a day. There's days where she's doing two or three, >> which is what my concern was is it's not. >> Yes. >> Oh. >> Oh my goodness.

131
00:39:28.880 --> 00:39:44.560
>> I had a question about lessons as well. Um, what is the expectation if you play an instrument? Are you expected to take a lesson once a week or >> I believe it's once a week that they have lessons >> choice? >> I don't know the answer to that

132
00:39:44.560 --> 00:40:00.960
question. I know at Mansion. I know at Mansion every kid has it once a week. I know that the information he sent to me is that he's very careful in rotating the lessons to make sure that a kid doesn't miss third period every Thursday and things like that. So they rotate it. But yes, in general they have lessons. Everybody that has an instrument

133
00:40:00.960 --> 00:40:16.720
generally has lessons to improve their craft. >> Okay. But you you there's different kinds of lessons. You could have all the trumpets together. You could have brass together. You could have like over there they have beginner band and advanced band. Um he said he has you know sometimes you have students that are

134
00:40:16.720 --> 00:40:33.599
working on a solo piece to work on for college. >> The lesson I'm just curious much like Ryan just like >> how many kids out of the 70 are >> well 70 will get it but like I say 70 kids at five days a week for

135
00:40:33.599 --> 00:40:48.240
>> Well, right. But I don't think that's happening is what I'm saying. I mean, I have a band player and I think he's had two lessons this year >> by choice. He doesn't want to miss class. You know, it's his choice. But, you know, that's why I I don't know that the lessons are such a pressing issue.

136
00:40:48.240 --> 00:41:08.480
Um, it doesn't seem like they are at the high school level. I know when you're learning an instrument, obviously you have to learn it, but that's just seems to be sort of the feedback. >> I think you get a turn now. Uh, so if I'm understanding correctly,

137
00:41:08.480 --> 00:41:24.800
full-time teaching staff members at the high school >> have to do one period that's like a study hall or um bathroom monitoring or something like that. Okay. So, for this position being 29 and a half hours, would they still be required to do

138
00:41:24.800 --> 00:41:39.520
anything? >> They don't have to. now. And even the ones even like even if it was a full-time music teacher, we have the ability to say that they don't, you know, because they're doing an extra lesson. It's well, they'd have to sign off saying that it's okay for them to do an extra uh student contact time as opposed to having a duty. But yes,

139
00:41:39.520 --> 00:41:54.000
that's that's easily worked around. I don't believe we have our part-time people worrying about that. >> Okay. So if you're cutting back 10 hours a week, maybe five and a half of that is cutting back from potential instruction time if they don't actually have a duty, >> right,

140
00:41:54.000 --> 00:42:10.880
>> to do as well. Um general question about what we're voting for tonight. So when we vote to advance the budget, are we voting item by item or is it like um in total amount for instructional

141
00:42:10.880 --> 00:42:26.079
>> total amount for >> the total budget that that we're submitting the whole thing, right? >> Yes. for tonight. Even though when we presented the budget for you to submit

142
00:42:26.079 --> 00:42:42.400
to the county, it included uh one less music teacher like so a full-time music teacher with benefits. >> Okay. The total budget amount of 31 million is not changing. What's changing

143
00:42:42.400 --> 00:42:59.680
is how you're split how you're using those funds for that position. You're taking a full-time position plus benefits and breaking that down now into two part-time positions. >> So, are we voting for that or are we

144
00:42:59.680 --> 00:43:15.280
voting for this is your pot of money that's appropriated to instructional staff period and that theoretically shifts and changes. >> Correct. >> Okay. So, let's say we voted yes on the budget tonight. That's not saying 100% that this is the plan that's moving

145
00:43:15.280 --> 00:43:31.680
forward in terms of those positions. Let's say you have some people retire and you realize like, oh, we can do some attrition there and maybe that's giving us some extra funds that we could >> make other adjustments. >> So, we can correct >> we can still adjust if things change.

146
00:43:31.680 --> 00:43:48.480
>> Okay. Um, and my other question is not music related. Um, so you're reducing the academic support by one at Mansion. Do you know what position that is? Is it like um you know like a reading specialist or like a um basic skills push and support person?

147
00:43:48.480 --> 00:44:08.160
>> Okay, that's what it is. >> Okay, thank you. >> Collapsing one first one second grade classroom. So we're going from five to four. Presumably there's a teacher that doesn't have a class then. What are what's happening with them? >> We have two fourth grade openings.

148
00:44:08.160 --> 00:44:24.520
>> Okay. So one is going careful >> sorry one is going to fourth grade one actually has a preschool sir and is going to preschool and then the academic support person is going into a fourth grade. We also are losing a sixth grade language arts teacher that's posted.

149
00:44:31.680 --> 00:45:00.800
Any other questions or comments from board members? All right, as I stated earlier, we will now open the floor for public participation. Um, I would just ask that when you come up to the podium that you

150
00:45:00.800 --> 00:45:17.040
state your name and address so that we uh we know who you are. Um there is a three minute time limit per speaker and there is also a 15minute total topic limit. However, I given the fact that

151
00:45:17.040 --> 00:45:31.839
there's really only one topic to discuss tonight, I can anticipate with great certainty that we will make a motion to extend the discussion time uh on the topic of the budget. Um, we will listen

152
00:45:31.839 --> 00:45:49.119
to all the comments and questions and then at the conclusion of the public participation session, we'll take a little break. We'll we'll as board members be taking copious notes, take a little break and then answer questions as a group rather than answering

153
00:45:49.119 --> 00:46:04.880
questions one-on-one back and forth. I want to make sure everybody has an opportunity to be heard. So, we'll kind of take your questions and comments as a collective and then respond at the end. So, I'm now opening the public participation session. Just feel free to

154
00:46:04.880 --> 00:46:23.440
come on up to the microphone. Hello everyone. I'm Sue Moore. I live at 226 East Pine Street and I am the music teacher who was in the elementary school until three years ago. So, any questions you have about how that works, I can

155
00:46:23.440 --> 00:46:40.640
tell you how I did it. Um, I have a couple of questions and of course I'm I'm very keen on having full-time teachers because I feel like you get somebody with a lot of energy in the in the program, they're going to need some time to get things moving forward and um

156
00:46:40.640 --> 00:46:56.160
hopefully those numbers are going to go back to the way that they were several years back. Um, many of the band programs happen after school and uh I'm curious for a part-time person if they're planning to do the jazz band,

157
00:46:56.160 --> 00:47:11.119
how is that configured? The all-star band at elementary school used to be an afterchool program also. So, how are you planning to do that if a person is part-time? And I'm also curious, the marching band,

158
00:47:11.119 --> 00:47:26.640
is that considered a separate item from this? So, it's not part of the uh duties of the high school director. Yeah. All right. So, so my major concern is that a part-time person who's not

159
00:47:26.640 --> 00:47:44.960
getting any benefits may not be as committed to staying and also may not be as committed to, you know, producing a thriving program as somebody who's full-time and given a lot of support in their job. And I I have to

160
00:47:44.960 --> 00:48:02.400
say that this was I was surprised to hear that today. I think it's in some ways an improvement because at least it would be a dedicated staff person, but I am concerned that the band program that has always been so much pride and it's has a really big place in my heart is um

161
00:48:02.400 --> 00:48:17.440
you know it's it's definitely declined and it wasn't just because of COVID. CO did take a a bite out of it, but it was coming back. And uh you know, I feel like the things that need to be in place in order to build a positive band

162
00:48:17.440 --> 00:48:33.920
community is uh it has to be consistent. It has to be available. You have to have some challenging music and it has to be fun. And for that to happen, I think it's important to have somebody who's completely dedicated to the job. Um,

163
00:48:33.920 --> 00:48:48.480
you know, the uh item of group lessons, I cannot speak to the high school or the junior high. I don't exactly know how that works. But in the elementary school, it's uh with the fiveday schedule, it was once a week and uh six day schedule, whatever

164
00:48:48.480 --> 00:49:14.559
that issue was. Um >> 20 seconds. >> Yeah. If you have any other questions about how the band runs, I'd be happy to answer them for you. All right. Um, let's go band. >> Good evening. Sarah Barry, Lo Avenue.

165
00:49:14.559 --> 00:49:29.920
Miss Allen quoted data. Audabon residents contribute over 55% of our taxes to the school systems. Audabon under the radar added assistant superintendent of curriculum backfilled director of curriculum at a difference cost of almost $100,000 last year. We

166
00:49:29.920 --> 00:49:46.240
have not been told as to why this continues. If you believe that two part-time instructors for band will allow young robust graduates to build the program, it will not. Mounty from cut their program to a part-time band instructor. This has frequent turnover of

167
00:49:46.240 --> 00:50:03.200
instructors over there. If they are lower at their numbers that is affecting Ottabon and those Mounty from students coming into our system. So please take into account mounting from and what other districts are doing. Research shows that any school district

168
00:50:03.200 --> 00:50:19.599
with part-time teachers they leave for benefits and longevity. You cannot build a program by cutting numbers of direct care and to the students directly. This is true in any career field. Ottabban High School has had over in the past 1,000 students with less administration,

169
00:50:19.599 --> 00:50:35.599
but continue to add administrators. Band is a curriculum. You quoted, "We do we do not make cuts to these positions." But you did. You cut a band instructor. You just said it tonight. The band boosters also were fundraising at the

170
00:50:35.599 --> 00:50:51.200
elementary schools. They were selling food things at their um events over there, but we're told this week they are not allowed to fund raise anymore. That was a recruitment opportunity to recruit children into the ban and they were told

171
00:50:51.200 --> 00:51:09.040
they cannot do that. Why? Quality and time of one instructor will not serve and retention of two part-time will be abysmal. What cuts have you made to extracurriculars? You stated tonight that you are cutting to sports and other areas, but what exactly? What are the

172
00:51:09.040 --> 00:51:25.200
details? We want to know what those are. Other career fields conduct climate surveys. I challenge the board to send out these climate surveys to adults, not to the students. Ask us, the town members and the staff at the school and

173
00:51:25.200 --> 00:51:42.000
the district, what they want. It's important. It's important to hear from your people of how you're doing, how you as the board and the administration. Lessons are very, very important. I was a band member here in the 1990s. I was

174
00:51:42.000 --> 00:51:56.960
the drum major under Mr. Delo. I had many years in band and my children. And it would be horrible to see this in this town, the tradition of pride and excellence to cut back and not continue

175
00:51:56.960 --> 00:52:27.040
where it's at. I suggest a one full-time high school instructor with a part-time elementary. Trisha Martell, president of the Ottabon Education Association. Members of the board, community members, parents, and students, I'd like to express my gratitude for your attendance

176
00:52:27.040 --> 00:52:43.280
this evening. Your presence and willingness to share your perspective demonstrates a profound dedication to the welfare of our children. Uh ensuring that their needs remain our central focus and that their achievement is the ultimate objective and what truly fortifies this district. I sincerely

177
00:52:43.280 --> 00:52:58.640
appreciate every individual who has come this evening. Members of the board, I feel compelled to speak following the superintendent's comments. I am extremely concerned that staff attendance information was referenced in such an identifiable manner and in a public forum. Sharing details that can

178
00:52:58.640 --> 00:53:14.079
be linked to an individual employee is an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy and it compromises the trust that staff have and should be able to place in district leadership. I respectfully urge the board to address this matter and ensure that employee information is handled with the

179
00:53:14.079 --> 00:53:39.760
confidentiality and professionalism it requires. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Ro Romina MCO. I live on 28th North Davis Avenue and I'm a band student here at AHS. I just want to reiterate, I know that you've discussed these two part-time jobs, but

180
00:53:39.760 --> 00:53:56.319
as you heard and as the stats prove, that would just lead to a lack of commitment from these two people. And additionally, combining these positions would also eliminate opportunities for students to improve their skills under the guidance of a teacher. Band lessons

181
00:53:56.319 --> 00:54:13.359
at the high school are just as important as at lower levels. I'll give you personal experience. I only started learning the clarinet in seventh grade and I had no idea what I was doing. I felt lost and I felt hopeless. But with some extra encouragement and help from

182
00:54:13.359 --> 00:54:28.559
Mr. Delo, I was able to learn the instrument quickly and continue improving. Now students won't have the support to try something new like I did and they'll be discouraged from joining band and will that will probably only increase or well decrease the numbers of

183
00:54:28.559 --> 00:54:44.640
attendance in band. Additionally, if you did combine the positions, the teacher would have to handle senior high, junior high, jazz, and various level mansion bands. The teacher's attention would be too divided to benefit any party. That is exactly what has happened with our

184
00:54:44.640 --> 00:55:01.280
new mental health counselor. She has been spread so thin students have limited opportunities to visit her. If combining positions resulted in a worse mental health program, then how could it possibly benefit the bands? It would only set the teacher up for failure. Furthermore, uh I feel and others feel

185
00:55:01.280 --> 00:55:16.000
as well this decision has been dealt with in a manner that has blindsided people involved. Neither Mr. Delo nor Mrs. Swinny were aware of this development until less than a week ago. A number of band students also cannot attend this meeting to defend the department because they are away

186
00:55:16.000 --> 00:55:31.680
performing. Even if it is a result of poor planning, it shows that you are making this decision without considering the impact it may have on those affected. I feel you should strive to make decisions that have that take community input into consideration. You

187
00:55:31.680 --> 00:55:56.799
may save money for the school, but it's I feel you fail to see the longlasting consequences that could result from this decision. I implore you to remember the dozens of students whose musical education will suffer as a result of your possible decision. >> Hi, good evening. Um, my name is D. De

188
00:55:56.799 --> 00:56:13.520
Barnett. I live at 139 Virginia Avenue in Ottabon. I am here and I'm going to read a statement. Roina just spoke about the present and I'm going to ask you to think from this moment and the students that you saw perform at the concert last night. Those of you who were there for Mr. Deloch's last concert, seventh

189
00:56:13.520 --> 00:56:28.799
graders, eighth graders and they're coming up through this program and I want you to think about the future as I talk about my daughter Marin Barnett who wrote something from her past. I'm reading this as her statement. She's a graduate of 2021.

190
00:56:28.799 --> 00:56:43.839
My name is Maron Barnett and I graduated from Ottabon High School in 2021. Since then, I've earned my Bachelor of Music in music therapy and I now work as a music therapist in Florida, helping individuals with special needs to

191
00:56:43.839 --> 00:57:01.040
develop communication, self-expression, social connection, motor skills, and so much more through the power of music. Ottabbon's music program as a whole changed the course of my life. As a

192
00:57:01.040 --> 00:57:16.480
student, I participated in choir and I studied music theory under Mr. Delo and musical theater. Those classes gave me far more than credits towards graduation. They gave me mentors who invested time and individualized

193
00:57:16.480 --> 00:57:33.359
attention into helping their students grow. That kind of growth does not happen through a factory model approach where fewer staff are expected to do more and more and more for less. Music education is built on relationships,

194
00:57:33.359 --> 00:57:49.920
guidance, and specialized instruction. When one music position is removed, it affects the strength of the entire program. And it also sends a message that the arts programs are expendable. It raises concerns for what may be taken

195
00:57:49.920 --> 00:58:06.160
next. One programs once they're cut piece by piece, rebuilding them later is far more difficult than preserving them. Now, for students, music programs are often the one place they find belonging,

196
00:58:06.160 --> 00:58:22.720
motivation, confidence, community. For some of us, it also becomes the foundation for future careers. Without this district's music program, I would not be doing the work I do today. I, as an alumni, gradually, you graduated

197
00:58:22.720 --> 00:58:38.640
class of 21, respectfully ask you to protect and invest in a full music program so future students have the same opportunities that help to shape my future. Thank you for your time and consideration. Those are the words of my

198
00:58:38.640 --> 00:58:54.240
daughter who went through this program, both taught by Mr. the Loach and Miss Swinny. And I ask as her mother, as I've watched her take lessons and learn and grow and become someone who heals through music, >> 10 seconds,

199
00:58:54.240 --> 00:59:13.839
>> to think about the power of music because you have the power right now to decide whether or not the music will play on the way it has in this tradition of pride and excellence. Um, okay. We've had uh hang on just one

200
00:59:13.839 --> 00:59:34.960
second, Mr. Bradshaw. We've had we've had um five speakers now, so we have reached our 15 minute uh limit on the topic. Can I have a motion to extend that for another 15 minutes? >> Motion to extend another 15 minutes. >> Second. >> Thank you. >> My name is Rob Bradshaw. I live at 434

201
00:59:34.960 --> 00:59:51.680
West Graberry, right down the street. I walked here. I first of all, thank you for for hearing us out tonight. I appreciate that and thank you for extending the time. I come at this from I'm I'm here to support the music program as you may have guessed. I I come from maybe a unique perspective in

202
00:59:51.680 --> 01:00:08.319
that I am an Ottabon High School graduate, class of a long time ago, 1997. My uh so I was born and raised here. I still live here. My kid, one of my children still goes here, one just graduated. Both products of the music program. So it means a lot to us. Since

203
01:00:08.319 --> 01:00:23.599
graduating here, I have made a career out of music. I founded and operated a music school for 20 years. I'm an orchestra conductor and I now work with the New Jersey Symphony. And that's relevant here because at the New Jersey Symphony, I'm in charge of about $30

204
01:00:23.599 --> 01:00:41.359
million of budget. So, I hear you. I I see both sides of this and I understand the passion from students and from parents. I I understand it. I share it. I share that passion. When I got here tonight, I had a different idea of what I was going to say because I learned

205
01:00:41.359 --> 01:00:57.280
that you've rethought the concept of maybe making this two part-time positions. I'm not going to die on this hill. I think that's an improvement. I think that's better. One of my major concerns was that it's there's a skill set involved in teaching very young

206
01:00:57.280 --> 01:01:14.240
people how to hold their instrument without dropping it and how to blow into a clarinet without making it squeak and teaching them how to love it at that young age. Most of the time people with that skill set are not the same people who can inspire people like children who are in

207
01:01:14.240 --> 01:01:30.480
11th and 12th grade. It's a very different skill set. And so I thank you for taking the time and the energy to discuss that and come up with a solution in that regard. I thank you for that. I do however share a concern because uh when I hear that you're looking to grow

208
01:01:30.480 --> 01:01:47.359
the program, I do believe you there there's a cliche sometimes nobody cares about music. I've never thought that about Audabon. I still don't think that about Audabon and I don't think that now. But I think it will be difficult to grow a program with part-time positions.

209
01:01:47.359 --> 01:02:04.160
These are people who who of course you might find some young and hungry people. But those young and hungry people are going may be offered a better position elsewhere. I've been in this position myself. I understand. So it will be difficult to grow the program. And if that is your goal, and I do believe that

210
01:02:04.160 --> 01:02:27.920
it is, I implore you to keep this at full-time positions. Thank you for your time. Hi, my name is Mary Jane Fulton. I live at 113 Harding F and I'm a band student here at Ottabon. Before I begin, I want you to think about the most challenging class you've ever took. Now, I want you

211
01:02:27.920 --> 01:02:43.520
to imagine that everyone is learning something different and you only have 45 minutes. The bell rings and there's still just that one part of lesson that you can't understand. You try to find time during the school day where a teacher can help, but they're just not available. After school, you have sports. Maybe you can find an answer online. The questions are so specific,

212
01:02:43.520 --> 01:03:00.240
you just can't find an answer. Ask a friend, they're learning something totally different than you. So now you're lost, frustrated, and you don't know what to do. While I speak, I'd like you to remember the scenario. I'm here today to present to you the problems that combining the teaching positions may cause for students. I do understand

213
01:03:00.240 --> 01:03:15.920
that combining these positions will save money on a limited budget, but I believe that the educational experience of your students should come first. The biggest problem that I can see with combining these two positions is the limit of lessons that the high school students will get throughout the day. The lesson periods give students a chance to have a

214
01:03:15.920 --> 01:03:31.200
one-on-one lesson with the band teacher. This helps those who are scared to ask questions during class and especially for those who have solos. If someone has a solo, the teacher cannot focus on that one particular person because they have this entire class to teach. During class time, the teacher should be there for every student and worry about the ones

215
01:03:31.200 --> 01:03:46.799
who need help later. Admittedly, students could work with a band teacher during home room, but this will not be nearly as beneficial as having a lesson during a regular period. If student has to choose between having a 10-minute lesson period and a 45minute lesson period, I can guarantee you that most

216
01:03:46.799 --> 01:04:03.680
of, if not every student in the school would rather have the 45 minutes. To put it in perspective, if um a student had to take what if student had accomplished something in 45 minutes and they could only get those lessons during a 10-minute home room, they would have to miss home room for the entire week.

217
01:04:03.680 --> 01:04:18.640
Another option would be to work on the music by yourself. And while some students do this, it's only semeneficial. Students can practice for hours, but who's going to tell them if they're playing a wrong note or rhythm? Being able to practice with a band teacher who can listen to you play and look at your music helps a lot learning

218
01:04:18.640 --> 01:04:34.160
to play it. Just the other day, I had a band lesson with Mr. Delo on the Tony drums because I was confused about timing and a few notes on this one song we were playing for a concert. He sat down with me and I played it over and over again until he was confident that I knew what I was doing. And going back to the thing about the part-time position.

219
01:04:34.160 --> 01:04:49.760
I know the Mount from I came from Mount so I know the schools have a bunch of tr bunch of problems paying part-time teachers for music. We had Mr. Clark. He was there for maybe less than two years and then he left. We had another teacher who was there for a month, left because

220
01:04:49.760 --> 01:05:05.760
of the small pay. We now have one band teacher that's been there for about two years and from what I've heard, she's like on the fence, like she's starting to think about it cuz now she has a child to take care of and she's working full-time but only getting paid part. It's just not enough. Now remember the scenario in the beginning, that's how it

221
01:05:05.760 --> 01:05:22.079
would feel to be a band student without lesson periods. We came to the school >> we come to the school an hour before everyone else cuz music is something that we're so passionate about in our lives. So I ask you when you consider the idea of combining these two music positions, please keep us in mind and

222
01:05:22.079 --> 01:05:45.119
how not having a teacher here throughout the day will impact our ability to learn and succeed in our music education. Thank you. My name is Valerie Messer. I live at 216 Wyoming Aban Ottabon. Sorry, I'm not good with this stuff. Um, so my eldest

223
01:05:45.119 --> 01:06:01.520
child started with Mrs. Moore and you know they went through COVID and everything like that. They continued through the program and right now they're in Wildwood. They're doing awesome. their um for colleges their list of academics or all the band stuff

224
01:06:01.520 --> 01:06:17.039
is like this long which has helped them get into college multiple um admissions merit aid which I'm sure is important to a lot of the kids in this town because not everybody qualifies for financial aid but it's still a hardship right

225
01:06:17.039 --> 01:06:33.039
um what concerns me most is when I look at the ex the uh when I look at the situation that we had with my youngest, which is I'm going to answer your question. You said earlier, what was the reason for the drop enrollment?

226
01:06:33.039 --> 01:06:50.160
My youngest when um she's in eighth grade now, but when she was in sixth grade, after Mrs. Moore retired, the new teacher came in and you know, she was jazzed. We bought her a new flute because she had prior lessons. Um she

227
01:06:50.160 --> 01:07:05.920
would go to school and the teacher wouldn't be there. So the principal would be letting them in in the morning. They would miss lessons constantly. It was such a um negative experience for her that she gave up. That's your

228
01:07:05.920 --> 01:07:20.960
reason. That's your answer in my honest opinion is it is co is part of it. I know that happened but a lot part of it with the younger children that didn't get just went through the experience with the new elementary teacher. It was

229
01:07:20.960 --> 01:07:36.960
lack of consistency is my and and let down expectations when they get up early to go to a class to learn band and the teachers doesn't show up. What does that say? And regardless of reason, if you get somebody who's part-time, are you really going to get somebody that's

230
01:07:36.960 --> 01:07:52.960
committed that's going to do that for their children? Because I'll be honest, it hurts me that she is no longer interested in it because she'll pull out a guitar and play with a guitar in the house. But b, she lost her interest in it because of that. But my oldest one, like I, you know, they're

231
01:07:52.960 --> 01:08:10.480
17. I can't get them to do chores, but they'll be up crackad of dawn, you know, run into band in the morning, you know, and they've been doing it throughout. Marching band, jazz. I mean, honestly, any band thing, you slap band on it and they're there. I'm telling you. And, you

232
01:08:10.480 --> 01:08:26.080
know, through all the kids like went through co had challenges. music has been such a important part to them and you know the community that those kids have together >> 20 seconds >> it just they support each other and it's

233
01:08:26.080 --> 01:08:42.400
just heart-wrenching that I feel that this program is going to get ripped apart to save a few dollars there on the slide it said that there was like 250 and then some extra 350,000 that's earmarked for something special what is that

234
01:08:42.400 --> 01:09:13.520
because 250 $300,000 sounds like enough to afford a full-time teacher. >> My name is Jay Tessator. I uh reside at 27 Jefferson A in Mount Ephraim. Last night, I asked my daughter, she's a freshman, to reach out to her bandmates

235
01:09:13.520 --> 01:09:28.960
for the limited information that they knew of what was going on and write their concerns. I got one letter. I don't know if the others were scared or not, but um before I start that, I do second everyone's opinions here. I believe that they're all very valid. I

236
01:09:28.960 --> 01:09:44.239
don't believe two people are going to have the passion, two part-time people are going to have the passion to uh give these kids what they need moving forward. Someone said last night that uh when you wake up or when you have a baby, you put music to your you put a

237
01:09:44.239 --> 01:09:59.600
music to the baby's ears. When someone's dying, they put the music to their ears. These kids are going to be the ones that are creating this music. So, I'm going to go ahead and read this before any of my time runs out. I'm very slow at reading, so I apologize. It says, "Hello, my name is Aaron Messer, and I

238
01:09:59.600 --> 01:10:16.159
am a senior at Audabon High School. Right now I am one hour 20 minutes and a handful of change away at the Wildwood Indoor Championship. Besides me, beside me is the rest of the percussion group. All year we have fought for the

239
01:10:16.159 --> 01:10:31.360
privilege to be here. This doesn't only mean Thursday practice, but it it entails every second we've been in band room working on our craft. The passion I've seen exhibits exhibited by my peers is as is outstanding.

240
01:10:31.360 --> 01:10:46.960
And if this proposal goes through, we can't bring that passion to the next generation of music or u musicians. Education should mean enrichment in all courses of studies. I am heartbroken we

241
01:10:46.960 --> 01:11:04.719
would sacrifice any facet of of that for any reason at all. the arts. Uh, let me say yeah, let me show. Yep. The arts are just as important as other classes. And had I not been involved, I would be a different person. School played a huge

242
01:11:04.719 --> 01:11:22.320
part in shaping a child's mind. And it is their duty to do so in a meaningful way. To have one person jump between schools would desecrate the meaning of our program. We would we wouldn't ask that of a math teacher or an English

243
01:11:22.320 --> 01:11:37.520
teacher. So why must we ask that of the music teacher? It wouldn't only be two or three classes. That direct uh that director would be in charge of jazz band, winter, and spring concerts for middle school, high school, advanced

244
01:11:37.520 --> 01:11:54.000
band, and beginner band, graduations, project memorial, and personal lessons at mansion every day for every instrument section. the quality of the teaching would diminish due to the high amount of work and we would lose the we would lose the

245
01:11:54.000 --> 01:12:10.239
respect of other schools the other schools have for us. I am so proud of the point everyone in the band is at in this year. Uh I've seen so much improvement in all areas. All I want is for the students

246
01:12:10.239 --> 01:12:34.000
around me right now and the students coming in the future to have options to become a good musician and to and to be changed by the program in this positive way that I've been. Thank you. Um before we continue, if there's anyone

247
01:12:34.000 --> 01:12:51.320
else that would like to speak, I I would ask you to um be respectful and refrain from mentioning faculty members either by name or position when you're making your comments.

248
01:13:01.440 --> 01:13:17.120
Sarah Barry, Leo Avenue. Uh, one quick thing I just wanted to add. These children after school and sports and other curriculars have almost five days a week to practice to protect their and to protect themselves um, safety wise,

249
01:13:17.120 --> 01:13:33.280
health-wise. The mind is important for these kids. These kids cannot afford with their families in Ottabon to take private music lessons. So if you can consider that in a full-time staff member to give the opportunity for these

250
01:13:33.280 --> 01:13:49.840
children in this district that they have more time with a full-time instructor, especially at the high school where they're going to be going off on their own at 18 years old, they're still have underdeveloped minds. ban children, especially when they get

251
01:13:49.840 --> 01:14:12.800
older. If you look at all the statistics of any scientist, doctors, politicians in this world, they contribute a lot of their success to their time in the ban. Thanks. So that hang on one second, man.

252
01:14:12.800 --> 01:14:30.400
I believe that's another 15 minutes. So, I would like to ask for another extension of 15 minutes. May I have a motion? >> Thank you. Okay. Mia. >> Hi, my name is Mia Kugan and I currently live at 213 Yale Road in Ottabon. Um, I

253
01:14:30.400 --> 01:14:45.760
would like to share some more perspective from the marching band and per indoor percussion ensemble. Um, as for myself, I've done almost everything Ottabbon has to offer music-wise. I've been in marching band for the past four years. I've gotten ear I've gotten up early to come to concert band. I'm a member of the jazz band. I took music

254
01:14:45.760 --> 01:15:01.840
theory last year and I was stage manager of this year's musical. I fully intend to continue my involvement in the arts through college, but if it wasn't for my instructor's dedication to their students, I don't think I would have discovered my love for music, at least not to the same degree. I think that mer or making these positions part-time

255
01:15:01.840 --> 01:15:19.600
would be a disservice to both my peers and the classes to come. Um, I would also like to congratulate the indoor percussion for getting an 89.9 on their um performance tonight, which is out of a 100 point score. That's very good. And um we were talking about how numbers

256
01:15:19.600 --> 01:15:36.640
have dropped since co um me and my peers and the current teachers and instructors have been really trying to increase um involvement. And in my first year in indoor we had nine people including myself and this year they have over 20.

257
01:15:36.640 --> 01:15:51.920
So, it's not from a lack of effort, it's just from a lack of time. And I really think that we should consider that when making these position positions part-time. Um, and I really think that in doing that, member retention is going to be really difficult if you don't have consistency in the teachers and a lack

258
01:15:51.920 --> 01:16:08.560
of dedication. And a lot of the people in the band are very scared that a lack of younger kids coming into the system through a change or I don't know just a difference in the way that um beginning band is starting

259
01:16:08.560 --> 01:16:24.080
would lead to a slow death in all of our band programs. And it's really bigger than just um concert band and jazz band and everything. like if we don't have people coming in then we won't have

260
01:16:24.080 --> 01:16:40.719
enough people to upkeep the current programs that we have. Um and overall I think that music is not a quick or easy thing to dedicate yourself to and I feel like we should not treat this position as such. I think that this

261
01:16:40.719 --> 01:16:59.760
should be taken like thought about over a course of time and that's all I have. Sorry. Uh, thank you for your time. >> I'll go up. Hi everybody. My name is Olivia Pella, a Washington Terrace. I'm

262
01:16:59.760 --> 01:17:17.679
a 2016 Ottabban grad. Um, and all of my brothers are also Ottabban grads, class of 2018, 19, and 23. All four of us have been in marching band and concert band and all of that band since for all of our fourth grade years. Um, I did

263
01:17:17.679 --> 01:17:33.679
marching man in college. I wouldn't have been able to do that without a letter of recommendation from a high school band teacher. I got scholarships for that in college. And I am currently a teacher at Woodbury High School where I am a tech for the marching band. We are building a

264
01:17:33.679 --> 01:17:50.320
program there. It is very very important that you have a full-time teacher to build that pro program and have consistency with the students from grades 7 through 12. I think having another teacher at the elementary level is also just as important so that you

265
01:17:50.320 --> 01:18:07.320
can separate the two. A fourth grader is way different than an eighth grader, way different than a senior. I know that. I'm a teacher. I see that like firsthand now. Um that's all. Thank you. I urge you to consider like re, you know, with the budget and everything. Thank you.

266
01:18:16.239 --> 01:18:32.800
Hello. Um, Roxanne Fletcher, Washington Terrace Autobon. I'm actually Olivia's mother, even though I have a different last name. Um, so I'm Olivia's mother, Jacob, Nathan, and Lucas. I did not realize until last night that I have

267
01:18:32.800 --> 01:18:49.440
been a part of the music program for 15 years, since 2008 when Olivia basically is like, "Hey, I'm joining the marching band." And we're like, "Okay." Um, but she started off with Mrs. Moore and Mrs. Moore has a wonderful program where she brings them or we brought them to the

268
01:18:49.440 --> 01:19:06.000
high school as a recruiting tactic and they all come up here. The first time I heard that, closing my eyes, Lee had done a whole uh movie montage of that. You would have thought you were hearing a a an orchestra, a professional orchestra. Those kids are they're

269
01:19:06.000 --> 01:19:22.640
fabulous. They've always been fabulous. Having two part-times I I feel is not the answer as well because these kids not only do they need lessons and stuff but my boy they've they go down there and

270
01:19:22.640 --> 01:19:39.760
they eat lunch um you know with them because they're band geeks. We are a band family. Um I've been in Ottabon for 30 years. Not once have I ever come to a board meeting or heard anything about, hey, we're cutting the football team to this

271
01:19:39.760 --> 01:19:57.760
or the soccer team. It's always always we're here fighting for the arts band, the um choir, the musicals, everything. At one point there was a fall. We had a fall play. Um that's long

272
01:19:57.760 --> 01:20:15.280
gone. And that was something that once kids were done marching band, they just plpped themselves into the auditorium and took that over as well. It we're good. Th this this band community, the program is known far

273
01:20:15.280 --> 01:20:31.840
and wide. I like I said been in it a long time as a band parent for 11 years. We would go places and I wouldn't even have on Audabon and we say, "Oh, we're from Ottabbon." They're like, "Oh, there's a high there was a high standard and we were known for we're known far and wide for it. We've been to Mainland

274
01:20:31.840 --> 01:20:49.199
regional all over out to Allentown. We also have I would have to say the biggest trophies here. I don't think anybody can say that about sports teams. We've brought home many uh uh championship. We've gone against 25 bands and come out number one

275
01:20:49.199 --> 01:21:05.520
consistently. That doesn't happen with part-time people. Sure, you're going to get a young person in here. I'm going to tell you this. Once they turn 26 and they're off their parents' insurance, they're going to be looking for another job. That's the bottom line. That's reality. And it Yes. You can't You just

276
01:21:05.520 --> 01:21:21.520
can't do it part-time. And the You say the promise of making it a full-time position. Um, we've heard promises before >> from a lot of different people higher up.

277
01:21:21.520 --> 01:22:03.679
it doesn't happen. There'll be another excuse next year and the year after that and then we'll be down to nothing. Thank you. anyone? Absolutely. >> Hi, good evening. I'm Mrs. Webb. I live on South Lo Avenue.

278
01:22:03.679 --> 01:22:20.239
Um, I guess my main question is, um, because logistically thinking, having one full-time person manage both schools, you know, it wasn't working out in my head, but this two part-time scenario, how are you planning to have the part-time hours spread out? Do you anticipate the person being in the

279
01:22:20.239 --> 01:22:37.120
building five days a week or will they be set up so that they have like three or four full long school days a week with one day of flex that essentially gives them a personal day each week. Um so that's my main clarification I would

280
01:22:37.120 --> 01:22:51.920
like to know in these part-time positions. Um I guess I'd also like to let it be known I'm a related services provider. I provide occupational therapy in the schools and um I have 27 years

281
01:22:51.920 --> 01:23:08.239
experience and I am a part-time employee. I have been since the birth of my daughter. I've been happily a part-time employee for over 13 years. Um my one school I was in for seven years and then with my company now they've

282
01:23:08.239 --> 01:23:24.480
continued to contract me to the same school. What am I going into now? Like four or five years. Anyhow, for someone like me, you can find it may be different in the applicant pool. It's

283
01:23:24.480 --> 01:23:40.960
not necessarily going to be a young person. It's not going to necessarily be somebody that's going to bolt at age 26. It might be a dream job. It might work out for somebody who is like me whose kid may happen to have every Friday a month be a half day that then they're at

284
01:23:40.960 --> 01:23:56.239
home every Friday a month and they're picking up their child and taking them to lunch. and also if their child ends up being sick. When I call out, I call my principles and I let my supervisor know. Well, the luxury of this schedule

285
01:23:56.239 --> 01:24:13.360
for a person like me is that because I'm off Fridays, if I miss a Tuesday, my students aren't missing, I can look at my schedule and I'll call them and I'll say I can come in Friday and do my sessions. Now, granted, I'm not a music teacher. I work related services. So,

286
01:24:13.360 --> 01:24:30.000
it's a slightly different beast. But if it is giving band lessons, then at least some of the work could be flexed. And for somebody that works part-time, you know, finding the right person and the right fit might be a bit more difficult, but maybe we can find that unicorn. And they might be somebody like

287
01:24:30.000 --> 01:24:45.280
me that'll stay in a district for seven years and happily do their job and service their students. So I guess just my main question is the five day a week versus providing somebody the flexibility because it might be a dream job out

288
01:24:45.280 --> 01:25:27.040
there for somebody Anyone else? All right, seeing no one leaping up for the podium, I'm going to close this public participation session. Um, if you would just give us a few minutes here. There were some uh questions raised. I

289
01:25:27.040 --> 01:29:15.000
just want to make sure that we highlight everything and and and have some answers for you. Um, I know. That's true. That's true. doesn't look right. Exactly.

290
01:29:32.639 --> 01:31:38.560
That was Yeah, exactly. Oh my goodness. Okay, I think I think we have um an idea of um

291
01:31:38.560 --> 01:31:53.199
some of the the questions that we can answer for this evening. Um first of all, I'd like to reiterate what Miss Martell said. Thank you very much for coming this evening. Um it was wonderful to see so many people at a at a board

292
01:31:53.199 --> 01:32:10.880
meeting and it was um very heartfelt to listen to um your personal stories and and your input and um your passion for the arts here in Ottabon. There are many of us here at this table

293
01:32:10.880 --> 01:32:25.760
whose children are directly involved in the arts right now in the building um or have graduated and have participated in those programs. So um we share your passion and your and your dedication um

294
01:32:25.760 --> 01:32:42.480
to what those programs can and have done for our students. So um Miss Allen is going to answer some of the questions that were raised. Is that my three minutes? >> You were done. >> Do I get to go home? >> No.

295
01:32:42.480 --> 01:32:59.120
>> Um, again, thank you. Um, I I just want to reiterate this is not an easy decision for me either. I was was in band from the time I was in fourth grade as well. I was very active in music programs. I very much believe in it. I have other people that have done musical music therapy. I do agree with it. I do

296
01:32:59.120 --> 01:33:14.560
believe in it. I I'm not doing this because I want to. Um, some of the questions I probably have out of order, but there were some things that I jotted down why people were saying. For example, the bands that are after school, like jazz band, concert band, all of those are after school activities. There's

297
01:33:14.560 --> 01:33:28.880
>> concert band >> the jazz banding, >> marching band, >> mansions bands. These are stip allstar bands. These are stipended positions. So, that means that they get an extra allotment of money to do those things.

298
01:33:28.880 --> 01:33:45.600
so they wouldn't have to um miss out on those opportunities even if they were a part-time employee. Uh the the one thing that I do want to make sure everybody's aware of as far as sports, uh this is only my second year doing budget. This is only my second year here, but the year that I was coming into the

299
01:33:45.600 --> 01:34:01.440
position, Dr. Davis was here and I came for this May meeting with Dr. Davis and they cut all of the freshman sport positions that year. Um even some assistant positions and things were cut back. So it it's not there's no area that we don't look at. Um the question

300
01:34:01.440 --> 01:34:16.960
that was asked about a climate survey actually we did that last year with our strategic plan. We surveyed all the students, all the teachers, parent and community members. Um we had an outside vendor that or consultant that came in and helped us with that and consolidated a lot of that information. That was some

301
01:34:16.960 --> 01:34:33.520
of what was used for the beginning of the presentation with the um focus groups. Yes, we had focus groups besides Yes, it's all still on the website. Um, under BOE it says strategic plan. So, all of the results of that are there. Um, I'm going to let Miss Ron Casease

302
01:34:33.520 --> 01:34:49.120
ask to answer some of the questions about the capital um projects money, but not yet because I don't have that one. And then the which days would they be would it be four days with a flex day or five days? It kind of depends on each building and we're going to have to work a little bit with the

303
01:34:49.120 --> 01:35:04.239
administration. Um, I think there's pros and cons to both. At the high school, we have a zero period. So in theory, you want them here every day, but also if they went four days and were here as late, that would also make the after school things a little bit easier. At Mansion is a six-day rotating cycle. So

304
01:35:04.239 --> 01:35:20.719
it's not quite a 4-day, five-day thing. The current part-time staff we have comes in a little bit later and leaves a little bit later and does it that I don't know that that's conducive for what we're looking at. So, we will custom make it for whatever is going to work best to meet the needs of the students and make sure that the band is

305
01:35:20.719 --> 01:35:40.480
covered and the lessons are covered and that we're not impacting students aren't having to miss the same class all the time so that they feel comfortable participating in all of those things. There was a question on the uh capital projects of the 250,000 that is

306
01:35:40.480 --> 01:35:57.679
restricted to only to be used for capital improvements. It cannot pay for any salaries. So it's only for improvements to the the buildings HVAC system that that we might need. Um I'm just using that as an example, but has

307
01:35:57.679 --> 01:36:12.159
to go through for capital improvements to your buildings. So that's why that money cannot be used to supplement a teaching position. Oh, that is state law. Yeah, that's not

308
01:36:12.159 --> 01:36:38.239
it's not that's just not a Audabon rule. That is um the regulations by the Department of Ed. >> Um any other board member comments? Miss Skolen? >> I thought um Mrs. Web's point about a

309
01:36:38.239 --> 01:36:53.520
potential flexible schedule was really interesting um in order to sweeten sweeten the deal a little bit for somebody doing part-time. My question is just if anybody here happens to know if our union contract allows for say one

310
01:36:53.520 --> 01:37:10.400
part-time position to have a flexible schedule like that whereas our part-time um power professionals and things like that have an expectation of being here five days a week. Like is it allowed to have something different? um for one or two particular teachers over the other

311
01:37:10.400 --> 01:37:37.840
part-time staff. >> If uh we currently have staff that don't work 5 days a week that are part-time question. Um I I do appreciate the um comment also about um part-time work. I I think that

312
01:37:37.840 --> 01:37:53.920
um being a part-time employee myself um it doesn't necessarily mean less commitment. Um as a matter of fact, it often for me anyway means um quite consistent commitment because I'm able to focus my time on that particular thing. And I have a student in beginner

313
01:37:53.920 --> 01:38:09.600
band and advanced band and in jazz band. And um I can't get the fourth one to play the clarinet again, but that's probably best for all of us. Um so music is extremely important to us. Um I love the idea also of a potential flex time part-time position. Um being able to

314
01:38:09.600 --> 01:38:25.679
create something that works. I also understand that this is for the next year if I'm not mistaken. So that doesn't mean that this has to be a permanent change. we do have hopefully um the ability to grow the program again

315
01:38:25.679 --> 01:38:41.600
seeing that there's a small smaller amount of people um I think having two part-time people would possibly give the energy that we need to get the numbers back up because we're going from potentially 40 hours to almost 60 hours

316
01:38:41.600 --> 01:38:57.280
in that case. So, you actually have more capacity to do the recruitments and to get the numbers back up. And there's going to be a good amount of part-time people who are going to be hopeful that it will be full-time eventually. Um, and that they would be even more committed

317
01:38:57.280 --> 01:39:17.679
and productive to make sure that they grew the program so that that would be necessary. >> Okay. Sorry. >> Stop marrying me. >> Sorry. Uh, so one of the big things that I've always loved about Ottabon is the love

318
01:39:17.679 --> 01:39:32.960
of arts and the commitment to the arts and not just music, it's, you know, drama, art. When one of the things that I loved when my daughter was in the elementary schools was when we would come in at the end of the year and they

319
01:39:32.960 --> 01:39:48.639
would have all their artwork up on all the walls. And what I loved is that it wasn't just here's a pretty picture of a, you know, of a flower. It was Aboriginal art and you got to see all these different they got to learn

320
01:39:48.639 --> 01:40:05.600
culture with it. And that's also in music. You learn different cultures. And I don't think there is any member of this board that does not have a personal connection either them themselves or through their children to the arts and

321
01:40:05.600 --> 01:40:21.840
don't have that. None of us were happy with the position we were in with this budget. Um it's something that I think we've all struggled with. We listened when we first the budget came out. We learned that we lost even

322
01:40:21.840 --> 01:40:38.880
more money. And then we learned that the the health insurance, no one had ever seen this, no one could predict this, went up 37%. That's never happened. We've been trying to get different providers of insurance. No one wanted

323
01:40:38.880 --> 01:40:55.280
us. We are hopeful because we went out again, fingers crossed, knocking on all the wood, kin or her poo poo poo, and if I had salt, I'd throw it over the shoulder. We're hopeful because we did get better numbers that we will get into a better health insurance program. But

324
01:40:55.280 --> 01:41:09.119
once again, remember, we are contractually obligated to do the same or better for our staff. And we want to do the same or better for our staff, right? We want happy staff, happy

325
01:41:09.119 --> 01:41:25.920
students makes a good school district. Um, but when we first were looking at this and it was coming out that if we took the full million that we could with the healthc care subsidy, which would mean a nine, I think a 9.5% tax

326
01:41:25.920 --> 01:41:42.880
increase, we listened to the community. Miss Allen listened to the community. We went back to her and said, "Find something. Do something. We can't have it be this high. We all live in Ottabon. We all pay the taxes with you." And what

327
01:41:42.880 --> 01:41:58.639
came back was, "Okay, we've really looked. We've dug. We're doing this. We're doing that. No one is cutting the band program. No one wants it cut. Everyone wants this to succeed. We want all the arts to succeed. We do know that

328
01:41:58.639 --> 01:42:13.600
music improves math, improves disposition, improves mental health, which then improves everything else. We all understand that and believe that. And that is why we are going to hold

329
01:42:13.600 --> 01:42:28.639
Miss Allen and the administrators to this is a one-year thing. Understanding too that when people are coming in, I thought it was wonderful. I didn't know about the two part-time because we were looking at combining one. But I was very

330
01:42:28.639 --> 01:42:44.080
excited when I looked at this and saw that Miss Allen went back and said, "Hey, this is awesome." You know, let's look at this. This is a problem. Okay, we can do this with one. But you know what we can do? We can get

331
01:42:44.080 --> 01:43:00.880
60 hours versus 40 hours if we do two part-time. And we can have someone dedicated to the students in the elementary school because they are different. We do listen high school students. And I think and when I'm hearing this and I'm hearing

332
01:43:00.880 --> 01:43:16.960
unicorns and I'm sorry, I really do like unicorns. Small fact. National animal of Scotland. Hey. Hey. learning a little something here. Um, maybe there is that unicorn when I hear someone talking with passion about part-time employees and having been a

333
01:43:16.960 --> 01:43:32.080
part-time employee at different times in my life. If you know that there's a chance that you can then become a full-time employee and control a program and a program like this that does have the respect

334
01:43:32.080 --> 01:43:46.880
and the credentials that Ottabon School District's music program has, I think you're going to find people that are going to say, "All right, maybe I'm I'm gonna it's going to be more difficult. and I'm not going to get everything I need as a part-time employee for right

335
01:43:46.880 --> 01:44:03.600
now, but if I show and I can get that energy and do this and this means that I can now be a full-time director of a program with this type of reputation. I think that's not, oh, 26 and I'm hitting it. I think that's 26 and I'm

336
01:44:03.600 --> 01:44:20.000
getting this job and I'm going to become the director. But understand, none of us here want this to be longer than a shortterm fix in the hopes that we will find something wonderful and great and this program will be back up into the

337
01:44:20.000 --> 01:44:39.280
200s and maybe the 300s. And that that for me personally and I think just in talking to everyone in every meeting that we have been in, that's what I've gotten from every board member here. So, Uh I would just like to start by uh

338
01:44:39.280 --> 01:44:54.719
commending the students especially that came up and talked tonight. It takes a lot to be able to do that. Uh it's really great. It's I know it's scary but to have your voices heard is really a great thing. And I want to further your your sentiments shared and I I have a question for the board. Is there really

339
01:44:54.719 --> 01:45:12.960
a plan to push for like a increased enthusiasm with ban because yes there is a steep drop but and there's mentions that there's that we can build a plan but like will there be a plan is I know I phrase that pretty badly but I just want assurance that and I I would

340
01:45:12.960 --> 01:45:28.400
imagine the community would like that as well that there will be a plan for that. >> Um absolutely and that was that was one of the main questions that Mr. Steven Wilson and I had in our conversation with Miss Allen, what does growing the

341
01:45:28.400 --> 01:45:46.159
program look like? Right. Right. So, I think combined with, you know, Miss Allen and our administrators in the two buildings as well as, you know, we still have our instrumental director here. Um, Mrs. Moore has offered her expertise and

342
01:45:46.159 --> 01:46:02.960
her historical knowledge as well. I mean, these are all resources to pull on. I think we need to reach out to the students to find out, hey, what was working uh, you know, when they were in fourth through sixth grade? What's working, you know, seventh through 12th grade? What would they like to see? I

343
01:46:02.960 --> 01:46:20.000
think those are all important um important factors to to draw on because I think you're absolutely right. I mean, that I'm a music teacher, okay? So, this is near and dear to my heart. Um, I know

344
01:46:20.000 --> 01:46:36.880
historically if you look at what happens to music programs, they're full-time, then they're part-time, and then they're gone. I I I deeply understand that. I've watched colleagues live through it. That is that is not what I personally

345
01:46:36.880 --> 01:46:52.880
want to see happen. And I can say you have 10 individuals up here that are highly invested in the success of of this of this program. This is a stinky situation that we're in right

346
01:46:52.880 --> 01:47:09.600
now. But um I I do have full faith and confidence that it it will not remain this way and that we will reinvigorate and um bring these programs back to to

347
01:47:09.600 --> 01:47:25.280
where they were. I really do. >> Good. I wanted to just make sure that that was uh that was covered because I it was mentioned a couple times there's a that there would be a plan but I just wanted to make sure yeah this is talked about in this >> Yep. Yep. And again 10 sets of eyes making sure that that's getting

348
01:47:25.280 --> 01:47:45.520
accomplished. >> I just want to be clear because Miss Coulen asked earlier when we're voting tonight we're voting on the topline numbers. We're not locked into this plan. We I'd still like to discuss the comments we heard at HR committee. Again, go over with a fine tooth comb

349
01:47:45.520 --> 01:48:01.199
just to make sure our numbers are all where they are. Um I just want to be clear that not locked into this right now, >> but the top line numbers. Yes. >> Exact. Exactly. So, it's the total dollar amounts, right? And the line item

350
01:48:01.199 --> 01:48:18.159
amounts, but it's not specific >> position. Am I saying that correctly? It's not specific positions because people could retire over the summer, right? Um people could decide to, you know, move out of the state and have to take another job someplace else. You know, we may have,

351
01:48:18.159 --> 01:48:32.239
you know, budgeted for five English teachers, but all of a sudden we don't have five English teachers any, you know. So, it's it's the total dollar amount. Is that and that's what I'm understanding correctly. >> Correct. The total dollar amount is the total dollar amount. you every month you

352
01:48:32.239 --> 01:48:47.119
see where I present you with budget line item transfers so monies can be moved um >> you know there's there's restrictions to to that

353
01:48:47.119 --> 01:49:03.119
>> you know but um yes they they you know right now you're voting on the total >> amount >> so I I want to thank everybody for sharing their opinions and their comments and we really appreciate that and we'll will at the next HR committee meeting discuss everything that was

354
01:49:03.119 --> 01:49:21.520
discussed tonight and you just kind of stepped on my toes. I just wanted to say >> yeah u I just want to say first off that I really genuinely appreciate uh everybody that came up and shared their

355
01:49:21.520 --> 01:49:37.440
experiences and um and their insight and when when people come out sometimes the board meetings are just us sitting here talking to ourselves a and trying to figure something out and and hearing some of these other opinions. I' I've I've gone

356
01:49:37.440 --> 01:49:52.719
through a lot of different thoughts and feelings because of what you shared about the part-time versus full full-time just sitting here listening to you uh or about you know the shape of this program and and where it's going and um

357
01:49:52.719 --> 01:50:09.760
some of you really made me realize we're just looking at the numbers and that's why I said you know part-time is that really the the but then when you say teaching a fourth grader is much different than teaching teaching a 12th Duh. I should know that. And that is a

358
01:50:09.760 --> 01:50:26.400
very different very different. Something saying that just kind of smacks me in the face with it and makes me realize you really to do all of that. Uh, and just all your ideas and your experiences really

359
01:50:26.400 --> 01:50:42.159
helps us to see it a little more more clearly and and open our eyes, I think. Um, so we can enrich the discussion further. I am one of those people with a fourth grader that just started this year playing the clarinet trying to figure out how to make it not squeal.

360
01:50:42.159 --> 01:50:58.239
That has been tough this year. So, I am in the earliest phases of this program and I want to see it >> soon. She's uh but she she's working on it and I want to see that and uh I you

361
01:50:58.239 --> 01:51:13.440
know I I really want to see this program get and get more invested and so uh that's that's really where I come from. I I came into this thinking I don't want this to go away. I want this to get get stronger and continue to get stronger to

362
01:51:13.440 --> 01:51:36.639
get these grow well invested in a community like these people are describing see going forward. So >> I am a bit outspoken on the board. I think some people will know that. I know it's shocking and I think I'm also known as something that I'm passionate about.

363
01:51:36.639 --> 01:51:52.239
I'm like a dog with a bone and I'll keep coming back. Keep coming back. This is something I'm passionate about. So, I'll make you my personal promise that it will be something that I'll bring up and watch what will happen. Just talking about a dog with a bone. My first year on the board, one book, one town. Still

364
01:51:52.239 --> 01:52:08.320
looking for it, Amy. See? See? She's just like, "Oh, God. Not the one book, one town." I will personally, I promise it's something I know you don't know me personally. pro. Some of you know me a little bit, but that's something the only thing we can do is tell you that

365
01:52:08.320 --> 01:52:29.040
this is something that we believe in and that we are going to stay on top of it. And our goal is to have it be full-time to people. So, I've been on the board for many, many years. We're not going to discuss how many. Um, however, if I weren't on

366
01:52:29.040 --> 01:52:44.719
the board, I'd be sitting out with everybody sitting there and I would have been at the podium championing championing the um band uh 100%. So, thank you very much. Um, I just want to go on record

367
01:52:44.719 --> 01:53:03.280
2006, 2010, 11, and 2013, four children all through the band. Okay. 13 years as a marching band parent. And um my two sons both did football and marching band and during halftime they took off their uh uh

368
01:53:03.280 --> 01:53:19.040
uniforms in order to compete or to participate in the marching band at home home games. So thank you very much. It does it I'm getting all emotional because I'm that passionate about it. It takes a lot to get up at the podium. uh

369
01:53:19.040 --> 01:53:43.440
we do very much listen to everybody and what they want to say. Um we don't take this lightly at all. So thank you. >> So I am a graduate of Audaban High School um a music therapist and um so

370
01:53:43.440 --> 01:54:00.560
grateful for Mr. Deloch's music theory class. I talked about it at our last meeting. Do No, I don't want a part-time job. I'm not qualified anyway. I'm a music therapist, not a music instructor. Um, so, you know, again, that that personal

371
01:54:00.560 --> 01:54:15.760
connection to music and the arts and everything like that here. Um, to Ryan's question, you were asking about like what is the plan to grow? And I think there's an opportunity um Miss Allen as you're interviewing candidates for the position to ask them how do you see us

372
01:54:15.760 --> 01:54:32.480
potentially growing these programs? What have you seen out in the field or maybe you saw in school to help you know grow programs and using that potentially? I know I can't tell you how to hire people, but potentially using that to um kind of choose those candidates that

373
01:54:32.480 --> 01:54:48.320
seem to have a really clear idea and have that passion and could incorporate that into their plans. I will also say that I'm happily happily a part-time employee. Um, my husband has benefits through his job, which allows me the opportunity to be part-time and be on

374
01:54:48.320 --> 01:55:05.679
the board and be on Ottabon Celebration Committee and all these things that take so many hours, but I don't have to spend all that time at work because I have benefits provided already. So, but I'm very very dedicated to my jobs, too. So, I understand that you're you are narrowing your um your employment field

375
01:55:05.679 --> 01:55:21.520
a little bit by having part-time as opposed to full-time, but please don't be super discouraged that there's going to be no one that would want a part-time position at least to start because like Miss D. Franchesco said, like there are those of us out there who appreciate

376
01:55:21.520 --> 01:55:42.480
that and look for those opportunities, too. And I'm 20 years in my field and happily part-time. So, I'm going to go back to our agenda. We do not have any items under governance.

377
01:55:42.480 --> 01:56:04.320
Uh so I'd like to recognize Mr. Gaddy for operations. >> Mark Gaddy, uh percussion pit boss from 2016 to 2020. Believe me, I will be uh a thorn in the side here to make sure that this program

378
01:56:04.320 --> 01:56:19.520
grows, not just uh stays where it's at, it grows. I would like to thank everybody tonight, which does not surprise me by the way, that band parents and band members came out. Um but also at previous meetings where we have discussed the budget, we've had a

379
01:56:19.520 --> 01:56:35.599
lot of uh input on this and it has given um a good view of what the community is looking for and their understanding of it. Um I'm fairly new to being the chair of operations, but I can tell you one of the things I did learn is that the

380
01:56:35.599 --> 01:56:51.920
budget as as um our BA says is uh it's it's a living uh organism really. It shifts constantly. People come, people go. Uh, normally, uh, we hear about the hits, but sometimes it's just moving money around

381
01:56:51.920 --> 01:57:06.480
and we do a fantastic job with that. And I'm sure that if funding comes along, uh, it will be considered for this. So, tonight we have one thing to vote for on Shouldn't say vote for

382
01:57:06.480 --> 01:57:27.040
don't want to anybody that way. It is to approve the adoption of the 2026 27 school budget. >> Okay. >> Just the the numbers in the total just for everybody. If you notice there's an

383
01:57:27.040 --> 01:57:44.800
extra zero um at the end of under 2627 budget and under the >> Yeah. Yeah. Sure. >> And under the tax levy. So those zeros at the end of those two do take them off.

384
01:57:44.800 --> 01:58:02.400
>> Got it. >> All right. May I have a motion for item number one under operations? >> Motion. >> Roll call, please. >> Jeff Candidate, >> yes. >> Alison Cox, >> yes. >> Danielle D. Franchesco,

385
01:58:02.400 --> 01:58:17.520
>> yes. >> Mark Gaddy, >> yes. >> Sarah Cen, >> yes. Alison Lipsky, >> yes. >> Andrea Robinson, >> yes. >> Bill Wilson, >> Steven Wilson, >> yes. >> Amy Davis, >> yes. >> Motions pass. >> Thank you. All right. Uh, we have a second public

386
01:58:17.520 --> 01:58:41.119
participation session. Um, this can be on any topics. It does not have to be specific to the agenda. So, if there's anyone who would like to come up and make a comment on anything, you're welcome to. Hi again. Um, Valerie Messer, 26 Wyoming

387
01:58:41.119 --> 01:58:57.280
A. So, just a general question because I don't normally come to these things. You just kind of lit my fire with the topic this evening to be honest with you. Um, but just in general, like one thing I've seen is with my eighth grader is that specifically in math, um, sometimes in

388
01:58:57.280 --> 01:59:12.960
their science class, they will get, uh, like they'll do poorly on a test and they don't really get the appropriate feedback or a breakdown of how they did a problem wrong. And I don't know if this is the right forum for this or not.

389
01:59:12.960 --> 01:59:28.880
No. Okay. How do we address that? because I feel that there's a I learn from seeing my mistakes and I tell them you did something wrong, fix it like figure it out. Who do we address with that? >> Absolutely encourage you to write to the

390
01:59:28.880 --> 01:59:45.520
teacher first. If you don't get the um kind of response that you want or they don't respond to you, then go to the principal. Um we have curriculum people also that will help get involved if you're not getting the answer. But start with the teacher and ask them what's going on. I mean is your child in class asking, not asking, whatever. curious to

391
01:59:45.520 --> 02:00:01.360
see what they say, but always start there and then from there you can always go to a vice principal or principal. Just continue until you get um someone to answer you and help you with the concerns. It's a very valid concern. >> Okay. It's just it's something that I've seen with several classes over the years with my kids and it's ever since we have

392
02:00:01.360 --> 02:00:22.719
this whole Chromebook thing, >> right? >> We don't they don't get the sheets back like we used to. >> Yes. Thank you. >> Yes. You know who I am. >> I want to thank the board for their time, energy, and thoughtful debate. You've always dedicated to this process,

393
02:00:22.719 --> 02:00:39.599
as well as to community members uh and students who have spoken up throughout the discussions. Your commitment to working through the very difficult task of balancing the budget is appreciated. I also want to clarify an important point about employee benefits. Benefits include health insurance and dental

394
02:00:39.599 --> 02:00:56.239
coverage, but just as importantly, they include membership in the state pension system. Employees working fewer than 32 hours per week are not eligible for TPAF, that's the teachers pension annuity fund, and must instead be enrolled in

395
02:00:56.239 --> 02:01:14.400
DCRP, the defined contribution retirement plan. While DCRP is part of the broader pension system, it does not function as a pension. And time acred in DCP cannot be rolled into TPAF. That is you put money into an

396
02:01:14.400 --> 02:01:32.159
account can't really judge very much what gets done with it. And when it comes to retire, you can't consolidate it with anything else. And when it comes time to retire, you withdraw money from that account. And when it's gone, it's gone. So, point of education, thank you

397
02:01:32.159 --> 02:01:56.000
for your attention to these details and for your continued commitment to making informed decisions on behalf of our district. My name is Claire Hendricks. I'm at 127 Oakland Avenue. I had a couple questions. Why do we need a um assistant

398
02:01:56.000 --> 02:02:19.679
superintendent? And can they be part-time if instead of our um music directors? That's it. Thank you. It's been a long night. I'll be very fast. Um this this has been bothering me

399
02:02:19.679 --> 02:02:35.040
a little bit. I from a personal perspective, I for those of you who spoke up about the benefits of being a part-time employee. Uh several people said that. I I want to say personally I mean no disrespect when I voice my concerns about a part-time employee in

400
02:02:35.040 --> 02:02:51.199
the band. I am a full-time employee and a part-time employee. Uh and I give everything to both and I understand that. And from a personal level, I I meant no disrespect there and I do understand that yes, we might this could work. we might be able to find someone part-time who could really build this

401
02:02:51.199 --> 02:03:07.119
program. I I know it can be done. I've done it myself. Um so that's it's been eating at me. So I wanted to make sure I got that out before I left. Thank you again for your time. >> One other thing. Sorry, it's Sue Moore again. You were talking about how you would increase the program. And part of

402
02:03:07.119 --> 02:03:23.199
the way that I would do it is being around a lot. I had lunch duty every day and I would be with the third graders and I would be talking to them about the band. What are you going to play when you're in fourth grade, when you're old enough to be in band? And uh I mean

403
02:03:23.199 --> 02:03:44.000
that's just being there is a really important aspect and another reason why I think full-time is an important part of the job. That's all. Um, one more thought myself. Do Pernets 139 Virginia Avenue. Um, I am also a

404
02:03:44.000 --> 02:04:01.360
teacher as many of you are aware. I teach at a local district where I have a superintendent who likes to say to us, um, students spell trust. T I M. Time. Okay. Very famous superintendent. Um, he

405
02:04:01.360 --> 02:04:17.760
knows who he is. I'm sure you know him as well. Um he says that and that is my concern with having two part-time positions. Ottabon statistically has high levels of all sales students, all state students, all eastern students in

406
02:04:17.760 --> 02:04:34.800
both the choir and the band. And this doesn't happen by accident. This happens by time. Those lessons you talk about, that's how they prepare for those auditions. That's how your name gets out there. Audabon has such a respected music program. I know because my school

407
02:04:34.800 --> 02:04:50.800
that I work at is down there trying to beat them right now. They're indoor percussion in Wildwood. My student, you know, my I have students that I direct in theater that are down there right now. So, um and it's it's this lovely camaraderie and this beautiful community

408
02:04:50.800 --> 02:05:07.040
and um you have such a beautiful thing here, but time is necessary to grow a program. time is necessary to complete you know to to to forge trust in relationships and that's what my children who have come through this

409
02:05:07.040 --> 02:05:34.920
school got from their instructors they got time they got knock knock someone was there I hope when they knock knock someone will still be there to open that door if there are two part-time positions anyone else?

410
02:05:35.440 --> 02:05:52.239
All right. Um, thank you to everyone for your time this evening. I know some people needed to leave. I understand because of the late hour. Um, again, we do appreciate your time and your contribution this evening. The board is going to go into another executive session. Well, no, actually, we didn't have a first executive, did we? We're

411
02:05:52.239 --> 02:06:07.840
going into executive session. Um, the next meeting, uh, our regular scheduled meeting is actually Wednesday, May 13th. It's a little bit early because of, um, the obligation to have our contracts approved by May 15th. So, uh, it will be

412
02:06:07.840 --> 02:06:25.400
6:30 p.m. here in the media center. The action meeting will begin at 7. Can I have a motion into executive session? >> Second. >> All in favor? Any opposed? Okay. Thank you. Be taken.