WEBVTT

METADATA
Video-Count: 2
Video-1: youtube.com/watch?v=-e5dyl6zakw
Video-2: youtube.com/watch?v=X2cSbDPH3xA

Part: 1

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:36.399
--------- committee. I'm chairperson Jerry Robinson. We'll begin with the pledge of allegiance. >> I pledge algiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and

2
00:00:36.399 --> 00:00:58.719
justice for all. I want to welcome everyone who is joining us tonight in person on Boston City TV and on Zoom. Please note that we are starting at 5:00 p.m. this week in order to accommodate a very packed

3
00:00:58.719 --> 00:01:14.720
agenda. I'm going to ask everyone here in the chamber to please turn off the volume on your laptops or other devices so it does not interfere with the audio for tonight's meeting. Thank you all for your cooperation. Tonight's meeting documents are posted

4
00:01:14.720 --> 00:01:32.400
on the committee's web page bostonschools.org/schoolcommittee under the June 10th meeting link. For those joining us in person, you can access the meeting documents by scanning the QR code that's posted by the doors. The meeting documents have been

5
00:01:32.400 --> 00:01:48.720
translated into all of the major BTS languages. Any translations that are not ready prior to the start of the meeting will be posted as soon as they are finalized. The meeting will be rebroadcast on Boston City TV and posted on the school

6
00:01:48.720 --> 00:02:06.640
committee's web page and on YouTube. The committee is pleased to offer live simultaneous interpretation virtually in Spanish, Haitian Creole, Cverian, Cantonese, Mandarin, Vietnamese, and American Sign Language.

7
00:02:06.640 --> 00:02:21.920
The Zoom interpretation feature has been activated. Zoom participants should click the globe icon at the bottom of your screen to select your language preference. I'd like to remind everyone to speak at a slower pace to assist our

8
00:02:21.920 --> 00:02:37.440
interpreters. We'll begin the meeting with the approval of minutes. I will now entertain a motion to approve the minutes of the May 6th meeting and the May 20th retreat. Is there a motion? >> So moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Second.

9
00:02:37.440 --> 00:02:53.680
>> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Is there any objection to approving the motion by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the minutes are approved. We'll now move on to the superintendent's report. I present to you our superintendent, Mary Skipper.

10
00:02:53.680 --> 00:03:08.720
>> Uh wonderful. Uh thank you, chair, and welcome to everyone tonight. Um many of our BTU members uh in the audience. Uh so, as we close out the school year, I want to begin tonight by honoring the members of the Boston Public Schools family and the city's larger educational

11
00:03:08.720 --> 00:03:26.319
community that we lost this year. These are some of the individuals remembered for their dedication to BPS students, their families and staff, and the lasting impact that they had on many young lives. Rosco Baker, legendary athlete, community leader, trailblazer,

12
00:03:26.319 --> 00:03:42.239
educator, and mentor to countless Boston youth over his decades of service to the city of Boston. Mario Fina, a BPS bus monitor known for his patience and compassion that he showed to every child.

13
00:03:42.239 --> 00:03:58.560
Zachary Schwarz, a math teacher at the Holland High School of Technology, at the Al Holland High School of Technology, formerly the Burke, for his 10 years, all of the time he gave as the adviser for music and sports and the

14
00:03:58.560 --> 00:04:13.599
analytic club. Janette Cisco, retired media specialist at the former West Roxbury High School, who served BPS for 41 years. Gloria Smith, longtime director of welcome services, known for her

15
00:04:13.599 --> 00:04:29.840
dedication and passion for centering our students and families. Benjamin Julian Tan, a music teacher at the Ellis Elementary School, remembered for his talent, joy, and laughter. Tommy Glavin, a member of the district's

16
00:04:29.840 --> 00:04:46.320
facility staff, a hard worker who took pride in making sure our facilities were ready for our students and staff every day. And Yolanda Allison, a retired school counselor at the O'Briant High School, who had 33 years of service in the district and positively impacted

17
00:04:46.320 --> 00:05:19.600
generations of students in BPS. Please join me in a moment of silence in the memory of these individuals and any other members of the greater BPS community who we have lost this year. Thank you. I'd like to begin with an update on our

18
00:05:19.600 --> 00:05:34.960
budget. Last week, the Boston City Council took the important and difficult step to approve the FY27 Boston Public Schools budget and the supplemental appropriation re-requested for FY26.

19
00:05:34.960 --> 00:05:51.759
I want to extend my deepest appreciation to Mayor Woo for her unwavering support of BPS. This is not easy work. Our students deserve the careful consideration and thoughtful deliberation that was given to these budget decisions. As we've said from the beginning of this

20
00:05:51.759 --> 00:06:07.680
year's process, this was a very difficult budget. The BPS finance team worked hard to balance the rising costs of health insurance, transportation, increased special education services, and all of our collective bargaining

21
00:06:07.680 --> 00:06:22.800
obligations with an enrollment decline of approximately 3,000 students since last school year. The approval of this budget means a few things for us. That we will continue to build on our progress and invest in our long-standing

22
00:06:22.800 --> 00:06:39.919
academic priorities. It will help us to continue to build on inclusive education, the expansion of bilingual and multilingual programming, expanded access to early college and career pathways, and implementation of highquality instructional materials and

23
00:06:39.919 --> 00:06:54.720
strong instructional practices in programming to name a few. I also want to take a few minutes to clarify some information around hiring um and particularly staff positions as well as provide an update on hiring for the next school year which members have

24
00:06:54.720 --> 00:07:10.000
asked for. There's been some confusion around positions that were impacted by the FY27 budget. To ground everyone, we experienced an enrollment decrease of 3,000 students over two years, which includes a large

25
00:07:10.000 --> 00:07:26.400
decrease in multilingual learners due to the current federal immigration landscape. The district has also been in the long-term process of closing schools and consolidating classrooms to match enrollment needs even before this recent

26
00:07:26.400 --> 00:07:43.039
decline. An important point to remember is that even with the elimination of positions for FY2627, because we have 3,000 less students to educate, our teacher to student, PAR to student, and support staff to student

27
00:07:43.039 --> 00:07:59.199
ratios will remain at the same levels as last year. There are 368 permanent educators who were initially accessed. All permanent teachers and paras with seniority to whom we have a contractual

28
00:07:59.199 --> 00:08:14.560
obligation to find a position are guaranteed a position for the upcoming school year. The majority of the 368 permanent educators have already secured a position. 66 remain unassigned but we will

29
00:08:14.560 --> 00:08:31.199
identify a position for them before the next school year. There were initially 205 paras excessed 46 remain unassigned and again we'll find positions before the end of the school school year. So to be clear there

30
00:08:31.199 --> 00:08:46.959
will be no layoffs for this group of permanent teachers and par profofessionals. As with every year due to a number of reasons such as positional changes at the local school and district level um could also be a lensure issue,

31
00:08:46.959 --> 00:09:03.680
performance issues. Uh only provisional teachers and paraprofessionals without seniority may be affected. In the coming weeks and months, schools and the district will continue hiring for vacant positions with an intentional focus to help those provisional

32
00:09:03.680 --> 00:09:20.720
educators who have been with us to find open positions. I also want to shift over to an update on hiring for next year, which Dr. Alkins and others requested at last month's meeting. BPS staffing data is still in flux due to the ongoing hiring transfers and

33
00:09:20.720 --> 00:09:36.640
non-renewal decisions that happen at this time of year. As a reminder, October 1st serves as the district's annual snapshot for the data in in when we look at actual final staffing data. Office of Human Resources Chief Francis

34
00:09:36.640 --> 00:09:51.519
Kanty recently provided an update to the OAG task force and I think that information is important to share with you as well. Our current data snapshot from October shows 58.8% of the district staff members who

35
00:09:51.519 --> 00:10:07.600
identify as a person of color. Staff diversity for vital studentfacing positions, teachers, and school counselors reached 43.4% marking a 5-year high for the district.

36
00:10:07.600 --> 00:10:22.560
Language fluency has risen significantly with 275 educators reporting fluency in the 2025 cycle or what equivalent is equivalent to 42.7%. And to give you a sense that's up from

37
00:10:22.560 --> 00:10:40.399
what was 31% in 2021. As this data shows, OHR continues the hard work to recruit and retain our educators of color and multilingual staff. This continues to be our focus as we work with our provisional staff to

38
00:10:40.399 --> 00:10:57.760
find open positions and resolve any outstanding lensure issues or waiverss that may be needed as we move into the next fiscal year. We expect to provide an update to the committee with finalized numbers in the fall. There's also conversation about state pilot when

39
00:10:57.760 --> 00:11:13.519
it comes to MTEL and some other ways to be able to get lenture. And so we very much look forward to hearing more about that and being part of that. Um is that has been a challenge and a barrier particularly to our educators who themselves are English language learners

40
00:11:13.519 --> 00:11:30.240
with the MTEL. Quick update on school leader PD. Last week BPS school leaders gathered here for our professional development of the last one of the school year. This was a time for us to reflect on our achievements and growth, celebrate all

41
00:11:30.240 --> 00:11:45.920
the goals that we've met and those that we're working toward, note changes in leadership, and wish our retirees and colleagues well as they move on. We celebrated the retirement of three longtime school leaders who have given so much to our community. Tracy Walker

42
00:11:45.920 --> 00:12:01.920
Griffith, who is retiring from the Elliot K to8 innovation school with 33 years of service. Michelle Bernett, who's retiring from the Chitik Elementary with 34 years of service, and Paula Gonzalez, who's retiring from the Otis Elementary with 37 years of

43
00:12:01.920 --> 00:12:16.720
service. And actually tomorrow in in this room, uh we'll be celebrating all retirees um across the district as well. Uh another update on summer programming. As we close out the school year, we are

44
00:12:16.720 --> 00:12:33.680
excited to launch the 2026 fifth quarter summer and beyond season. This marks an important transition from the regular school year into summer learning enrichment and continued student support and engagement. In partnership with Boston After School and Beyond and our

45
00:12:33.680 --> 00:12:50.560
expanded learning opportunities department, which we call ELO, BPS will offer programming from Tuesday, July 7th through Friday, August 7th. Staff will also attend a professional development which will be held on Monday, July 6th.

46
00:12:50.560 --> 00:13:08.480
To this point, 4,631 students have enrolled in summer learning academy programs. We have a total capacity of 5850 for seats. So, there's roughly about 1,219 seats remaining for interested

47
00:13:08.480 --> 00:13:24.399
families. We have the second round being assigned this Thursday. We anticipate many of those available seats will be filled, but nonetheless, as I'll talk about later, we want families to continue to register. In addition, we have 2,856

48
00:13:24.399 --> 00:13:39.200
students who are currently enrolled in high school credit recovery across 12 sites and 625 students at the middle school level who are current currently enrolled in middle school course recovery opportunities.

49
00:13:39.200 --> 00:13:55.600
The exa uh annual exam school initiative is almost at capacity with 277 students enrolled with a total capacity of 290 seats. So, we're pretty close there, but we anticipate that that will fill. Families can continue to register their children

50
00:13:55.600 --> 00:14:10.880
at bostonschools.org and it's also on the homepage for easy family access. The district's user-friendly summer registration platform, ALA, is available in all BPS languages.

51
00:14:10.880 --> 00:14:28.480
The BPS specialized services office launched our extended school year 2026 or what we call ESY registration on March 16th. As of today, we have 2544 students who are currently enrolled in ESY with 8,241

52
00:14:28.480 --> 00:14:44.560
eligible students invited. ESY is our summer programming for students with disabilities and provide students with the opportunity to retain skills, build confidence, and prepare for the next school year in a structured, supportive environment. For

53
00:14:44.560 --> 00:15:03.279
support with registration, please email us at esy@ bostonschools.org or call 617-6358599. We encourage families to enroll in ESY in all summer programming as soon as possible to ensure their child has a seamless transition to summer. To

54
00:15:03.279 --> 00:15:19.920
support full cap enrollment capacity across fifth quarter programs, ELO is monitoring enrollment weight lists and remaining seats while coordinating outreach priorities with site coordinators and regional teams. School leaders are identifying students who are

55
00:15:19.920 --> 00:15:35.839
placed, weight listed, eligible but not yet enrolled or in need of additional summer support. Family liaison are helping coordinate direct family outreach through calls, texts, and language access supports. Offa is aligning clear and consistent

56
00:15:35.839 --> 00:15:51.040
family-f facing communications while the office of data accountability is supporting the use of enrollment data to guide targeted outreach. ESI is being engaged to confirm and align any additional invitation waiverss

57
00:15:51.040 --> 00:16:07.920
to eligible students and families and ESY special education and student support teams are coordinating with ELO to ensure students with support needs receive accurate information about available opportunities. The BPS helpline and welcome centers are

58
00:16:07.920 --> 00:16:24.160
providing stu families with registration, weight list, language access, and aa navigation support while site coordinators and regional operational leaders are confirming student participation, identifying barriers and ensuring outreach staffing

59
00:16:24.160 --> 00:16:40.000
and program operations and making sure they're aligned to fill any remaining seats so that we're full before programming begins. Finally, there's a limited number of youth summer jobs that are still available for youth who are interested in working and have not yet secured a

60
00:16:40.000 --> 00:16:56.160
job. Youth who have not been hired yet are urged to visit right away boston.gov/feutureboss as soon as possible. A quick update on the cell phone policy. As we mentioned at the last school committee meeting, we continue to move

61
00:16:56.160 --> 00:17:11.919
forward on drafting a policy on personal devices in schools. We continue to engage with the community and gather input from stakeholders including students and school leaders and staff. We are also tracking legislative actions

62
00:17:11.919 --> 00:17:28.480
at the state level on this topic in the fall. We expect to receive additional guidance from DESIE. We know this is an issue on top of mind for many students. We've heard public comment about it from families and from educators. We'll continue to keep this body and the

63
00:17:28.480 --> 00:17:46.640
public updated as we finalize that policy next fall. Couple couple bright spots knowing how long the agenda is. Um first, I'm thrilled to share that BBS has been chosen to participate in Bloomberg Philanthropy's new national skilled trades initiative, an exciting first of

64
00:17:46.640 --> 00:18:02.640
its kind in the nation initiative designed to offer high school students a direct path to apprenticeships and high wage careers in the skilled trades. Here in Boston, one of nine regions nationally, the initiative will be based at Madison Park Technical Vocational

65
00:18:02.640 --> 00:18:23.360
High School. Boston will receive $12.8 million to build a pathway for at least a 100 BPS students each year to secure apprenticeships in the construction trades and water utility management sectors. >> There's a loud applause from the crowd.

66
00:18:23.360 --> 00:18:39.919
BPS is grateful to Bloomberg Philanthropies for this powerful recognition of BPS's commitment to providing students with sustainable, viable career pathways and opportunities. It's truly exciting for our students. Also, congratulations to the English High School baseball team.

67
00:18:39.919 --> 00:18:56.240
Expect another huge round of applause. Which advanced to the division five finals this week for the third year in a row. Is anyone from English out there? Go on. That's good news. Um, this is the third year in a row that they they've done this. Uh, you might remember that they won the D5 championship back in

68
00:18:56.240 --> 00:19:12.799
2024. So, please join me in rooting for the Eagles as they start their next series against Georgetown on Friday. Good luck and go. In closing, we'd like to share a video of highlights from the 2025 2026 school year. This look back is over an incredible school year capturing

69
00:19:12.799 --> 00:19:28.960
some of the most memorable people and moments. I want to thank the talented BPS digital content team under the leadership of Chris McKinnon, our chief of comms, for putting this together. The team visited 80 schools this year and covered more than 300 events in a

70
00:19:28.960 --> 00:20:37.520
stories across the district. So, you can imagine it was tough to squeeze everything in into just a few minutes, but we hope you enjoy it. So, with that, we'll play our video and then I'll hand it back to you, Chair. Heat. Heat. And I remember storming into my

71
00:20:37.520 --> 00:20:52.720
principal's office demanding that we get this course. Can we just do that real quick? I'm tired of life. Then I need one more over here. >> I like to think that I' I've played a part in um you know, really creating a culture of fitness and strength. >> Um I'm hoping after I graduate, I get

72
00:20:52.720 --> 00:21:07.760
hired here and I'll work here for a couple years. And after that first year of playing, I just didn't want to stop playing. Just wanted to continue and get better. >> I had heard a lot of good things about the fact that it was a healthc career school and the fact that it was

73
00:21:07.760 --> 00:21:50.000
vocational. I am a finalist for the Massachusetts State Educator of the Year. I'm tremendously grateful for Boston Mountain Schools giving me my start in 2010 as a long-term sub. Thank you, Superintendent. Um, given the length of tonight's meeting, I'm going

74
00:21:50.000 --> 00:22:12.799
to ask members to submit their questions to Miss PVX for us to answer at a later date. But if anyone has any quick comments, I will take that. But longer questions should be submitted. You can go ahead. Go ahead. >> Um just

75
00:22:12.799 --> 00:22:29.520
feeling so much pressure with the length of the agenda. Um just uh very much appreciate superintendent the updates on where we are with um staff who was who were affected by the budget. Um I'll I'll submit my actual questions, but I do appreciate that update. Just want to

76
00:22:29.520 --> 00:22:45.440
clarify that MTEL for folks who may not be familiar is testing um for educators related to lensure. just for folks who may not um know the uh the initials and also helpful to hear the summer numbers, the distinction between summer

77
00:22:45.440 --> 00:23:00.799
programming and credit recovery. I think is important for folks to know the difference between and just an early flag that in the fall when we have our update on summer programming, we would love the data team to think about how to connect participation in those summer

78
00:23:00.799 --> 00:23:16.159
programming with effects on summer learning loss or whether the intention of the program such as the exam school initiative actually um results in a higher yield for students who participate in those programs. Actually

79
00:23:16.159 --> 00:23:30.720
just on that uh that point because I know uh member scar you had asked this before. Uh we will we can say that in in 2025 uh 2024 into 2025 about half of the students that participated in ESI also

80
00:23:30.720 --> 00:23:46.320
received an exam school seat and in this last cycle it was it increased to 63%. So that is uh we're our goal is 100% but uh we're working really hard on that and and a big piece of this is making sure that that program is full every summer. >> Thank you.

81
00:23:46.320 --> 00:24:01.840
>> Well, no problem. >> Thank you, Superintendent. I just want to bring the attention back quickly to what you said about that there are still youth jobs available. Um, in my house, we are describing that process this year

82
00:24:01.840 --> 00:24:19.039
as a a crush course on adulthood given the amount of paperwork that has to be gone through. But it's worth it. And I really want to encourage all our youth 14 and above, if you still don't have a job, contact the office because they can

83
00:24:19.039 --> 00:24:37.760
guide you through the process. It's an intense process, but they are there to help you. Thank you. No. Um, I just wanted to do one quick shout out about what happened this morning at the O'Donnell School. Um the mayor and many of our partners who are

84
00:24:37.760 --> 00:24:54.880
working in the Wicked Math program were at the O'Donnell this morning to celebrate a young fourth grader um who achieved the highest score on the math um champion test and is going off to represent the state of Massachusetts um

85
00:24:54.880 --> 00:25:11.200
in Texas. >> Um he's a fourth grader. Um we we we we had a wonderful opportunity to both observe and participate in math games with um a wonderful group of third and fourth graders who come to school

86
00:25:11.200 --> 00:25:28.400
early two mornings a week um to um play all kinds of math games and clearly love math. And so there's a lot of good work out there. I don't know if other people here are part of Wicked Math, but we really got to see what it looks like and hope that all of our schools will make

87
00:25:28.400 --> 00:25:44.640
this possible for all of our kids. It was quite inspiring. See, >> so thank you. >> Okay. So anyway, thank you all and I will now entertain a motion to receive the superintendent report. Is there a motion? >> So moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second?

88
00:25:44.640 --> 00:25:58.799
>> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Is there any objection to approving the motion by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the superintendent's report is approved. We will now move on to general public comment. Miss Prebex.

89
00:25:58.799 --> 00:26:14.960
>> Thank you, chair. The public comment period is an opportunity for individuals to address the school committee on school related issues. Questions on specific school matters are referred to the superintendent. Questions on policy matters may be discussed by the committee later. The meeting will

90
00:26:14.960 --> 00:26:30.480
feature two public comment periods with the first comment period limited to one hour. After one hour, anyone who hasn't testified will have the opportunity to do so at the end of the meeting. We have 27 speakers this evening. Each person will

91
00:26:30.480 --> 00:26:46.159
have two minutes to speak and I will remind you when you have 30 seconds remaining. Please feel free to email your comments for distribution to the committee. Speakers may not reassign their time to others. The time that an interpreter uses for English interpretation will not be deducted from

92
00:26:46.159 --> 00:27:02.000
a speaker's allotted time. Please direct your comments to the chair and refrain from addressing individual school committee members or district staff. Please note that the comments of any public speaker do not represent the Boston public schools or the Boston school committee. Please state your

93
00:27:02.000 --> 00:27:18.240
name, affiliation, and where you live before you begin. Please sign in on Zoom using the name you register with for public comment and be ready to unmute and turn on your camera when it's your turn to speak. Please raise your virtual hand when I call your name. To support interpretation, please speak slowly and

94
00:27:18.240 --> 00:27:36.039
clearly. We will start with our in-person speakers. Our first speakers are Jess Butler, Hope Bastian, Sulea Sto, John Mud, and Camille Stub. Jess Butler.

95
00:27:44.480 --> 00:27:59.520
My name is Jess Butler. I'm from Dorchester. This is Odis and this is Brick. We start them young at BPS. Um we're here to share our concerns about the placement process for students with IEPs. My son's transferring next year. I submitted a letter from a

96
00:27:59.520 --> 00:28:16.480
provider on his team detailing the clinical reasons why this placement would be the safest, most appropriate fit. It's a school that's 2 miles outside of our zone in Dorchester. We've been sent from the welcome center to the coast to the OSS to the welcome center back to OSS. Everyone's saying they do

97
00:28:16.480 --> 00:28:33.120
not have the power to assist us, but you all make the policy, so you can. The welcome center is making placement decisions but has never attended an IEP with my child. In section 1414E of of individuals with disabilities educations acts, educational agencies will ensure

98
00:28:33.120 --> 00:28:48.000
that parents of children with disabilities are members of the decision process of the educational placement of their child. There's no mention of the welcome center, which isn't to diss them, but they're not in that. We have great schools in our zone, but for a variety of reasons, whether it's too

99
00:28:48.000 --> 00:29:04.960
large of a school, will require him to transfer after one year, or was not able to explain how inclusion will be implemented in their classrooms, they aren't a good fit. I understand the district is firm in saying that all schools are inclusive. But I have not seen communication on what that looks like as a policy and within the classroom. When I asked the district for

100
00:29:04.960 --> 00:29:21.360
who was staffing classrooms, what license they had, and what services were offered in schools in our zone, I was told that this sort of list does not exist. There's no clear, easily accessible information on what our inclusive district looks like. >> And parents and guardians are being asked to trust what an algorithm will

101
00:29:21.360 --> 00:29:37.520
make the best decision for our children, especially at a time when teacher and parlay layoffs are coming and not just from the closed schools. The district needs to change the placement policy. All schools in the district are being called inclusive, but not all schools are inclusive. The simple act of labeling a school does not make it real.

102
00:29:37.520 --> 00:29:57.760
Students already are feeling the consequences of this decision. When classroom staff can't meet our children's needs, they are moved to a more restrictive environment. There is intentional harm. And >> thank you. The time is up. >> Thank you. >> Hope Bastion.

103
00:29:57.760 --> 00:30:17.120
Hope Bastion. >> Hello. I've heard many times that students should not have to go Oh, Pope Bastion, Roxbury. Um, I've read heard many times that students should not have to go to school outside their community to get the supports they need. And I

104
00:30:17.120 --> 00:30:34.000
agree. Um, I also know that that's the law of the land. And I know that that's the law because people with disabilities and parents like us won those rights through decades of tireless struggle. We know that the school our child was assigned, a wonderful school, a school

105
00:30:34.000 --> 00:30:49.200
less than a mile from our home, does not have the capacity today to offer meaningful inclusion to our child. How could they? There was a magic wand. It was waved. It was said that all schools can impride

106
00:30:49.200 --> 00:31:11.520
inclusion. Now, we know this is not true. There's no way that it could be. We have schools in the district that know what inclusion is. We have school leaders. We have teachers who've been doing it for decades. Instead of learning from their successes, these stories are being hidden with the magic

107
00:31:11.520 --> 00:31:27.279
wound tale that all schools are created equal. We know that they're not. I'm seeking an appropriate placement for my child. This winter, I requested information about the district where a co-eing model is in place where a special educator works together with a general educator to provide the supports

108
00:31:27.279 --> 00:31:43.679
that their students need. I was told by the office of specialized services by the director that she doesn't know where that model is in place. Two seconds. Um I that I was speechless. Um for two

109
00:31:43.679 --> 00:32:00.000
years every morning my child is in tears. I don't want to go back to that school. I don't know what school is the school that he needs. But I know that I've asked I know that I've asked the coasts. I know that I've asked the welcome center. I know that I've asked the office of specialized services. Um

110
00:32:00.000 --> 00:32:17.080
this is not the way that it's supposed to be and you guys have the ability to change it. >> Thank you. Your time is up. If you you can always send it by email. You can send me your testimony by email if you didn't have time to read it all.

111
00:32:20.960 --> 00:32:49.840
Photo John Mud. >> My name is John Mud. I'm a resident of Cambridge and a longtime education advocate in Boston. I want to speak tonight to focus on the implementation of the new opportunity and achievement

112
00:32:49.840 --> 00:33:07.760
gap policy. The policy coming before you continues the commitment to eliminating achievement gaps and increasing the racial and linguistic diversity of teachers. It calls for annual smart goals in each area. These smart goals are crucial. The policy also includes

113
00:33:07.760 --> 00:33:25.279
strengthening the education of multilingual learners through the development of long-term plans with milestones and timelines for expanding bilingual education and bilingual teachers with instruction in native language. All three goals are critically

114
00:33:25.279 --> 00:33:42.559
important. We also know that implementation is key. Putting policy into practice so that it makes a difference to students in their classrooms is what will make a difference in student outcomes. That is why the promised strategic implementation plan must include smart

115
00:33:42.559 --> 00:33:57.760
goals. When will you see it and who will be included in developing it? I want again to make a plea that the committee and the superintendent take the lead in convening working groups of committee members, BPS staff, and selected

116
00:33:57.760 --> 00:34:15.760
experts, stakeholders, advocates to work together to develop strategies and plans that we could all rally behind. Such collaborative work would have the potential to bake through the current dysfunctional structures like these meetings where we talk at each other

117
00:34:15.760 --> 00:34:34.480
rather than talking with each other. Isn't it worth a try? The new policy which is before you to approve tonight gives new guidance. Let's try to follow through to implement it together. Thank you. >> Thank you.

118
00:34:34.480 --> 00:34:56.960
Camille Stub. >> Hello, my name is Camille Stubby. I am a seventh grade math teacher at the Margarita Mun Academy. I live in Somerville, Massachusetts. Less than two weeks ago, the district cut two of our SCYE positions and mandated that 19 of

119
00:34:56.960 --> 00:35:13.520
our 22 SCE students exit the program this year. I am speaking with great concern about the guidelines used to exit students from the programs and these teacher cuts. Slife exits are supposed to be individualized based on native literacy and math level as stated in the meta consent degree filed with

120
00:35:13.520 --> 00:35:29.359
the department of justice. And this past month lowered the access score requirements from 2.5 to 1.7s in meetings with our schools and did not consider native literacy in their exit assessments. They simply exited all students who have been in the program

121
00:35:29.359 --> 00:35:44.560
for two years. Native literacy is critical for student success in general education. Many of my students are former Slife students. One in particular was exited prematurely from his previous school last year. This student is still learning to read and write in Spanish,

122
00:35:44.560 --> 00:36:01.839
his native language. Uh I read everything aloud to this student in Spanish and he needs the help of a computer to describe his responses. in advisory at the beginning of the year. Um, this student shared his goal for the year to learn how to read and write. The entire class fell silent. One student

123
00:36:01.839 --> 00:36:19.040
piped up and said, "You don't know how to read?" And the student simply responded, "No, no puo." This year, luckily, he has a gap in his schedule where he receives foundational native literacy support like decoding and phonics in Spanish. He's gone from refusing to write anything in Spanish to

124
00:36:19.040 --> 00:36:34.560
at least trying to write something down phonetically in Spanish. This teacher who's providing him the support was informed last week that they would be cut next year. The student will enter 8th grade without foundational native literacy and without support. The struggle the struggles the student experienced foretell the reality Slife

125
00:36:34.560 --> 00:36:57.760
students will face when forced out of the program. I'm asking the district to stop last minute life cuts and to stop the forced student exits. Also, please stop creating more barriers for our most vulnerable students. Thank you. >> Thank you very much. >> Our our next group of speakers are

126
00:36:57.760 --> 00:37:22.480
Elizabeth Nibbridge, Kimberly Hirs, Jen Hayes, Vana Dear Rocha, and Anna Ard. Elizabeth Nibberish. Good evening, school committee members. My name is Beth Nibrich. I live in Hyde Park. I'm a proud BPS parent and Slife

127
00:37:22.480 --> 00:37:38.800
ESL teacher at Boston International Newcomers Academy. I'm here tonight in solidarity with our SLY community. You're going to hear tonight about the Slife program model and who it is designed to serve. But I want you to really understand what this looks like at the secondary level. At Binka, we

128
00:37:38.800 --> 00:37:55.839
welcome 16, 17, 18-year-old students who are still learning how to write their name. Their circumstances are all different. They've grown up in countries with political turmoil and violence. Their families couldn't afford to send them to school, or they haven't had access to education because of barriers

129
00:37:55.839 --> 00:38:12.560
that are almost always outside of their control. So, imagine these students entering a BPS high school and being asked to go to a 10th grade history or chemistry class where the content is presented in English. We can all agree that that would most certainly lead to failure. And that's why our Slife

130
00:38:12.560 --> 00:38:28.240
programs are so critical. They're not a magic wand and students absolutely need support when they exit. But in BPS programs, our students are taught by skilled educators who often share the same linguistic and cultural backgrounds as our students. Students have

131
00:38:28.240 --> 00:38:43.440
individualized goals and teams of educators who track their academic progress and help them adjust to an unfamiliar school system. Most importantly for our overaged life, we teach them how to read in English and in their native language.

132
00:38:43.440 --> 00:38:59.119
Yes, our students are in many ways some of BPS's most vulnerable. >> 30 seconds. >> But in my 16 years as an educator, I've personally witnessed how they are also some of our most resilient. With the right supports, they go on to learn English, graduate from high school, and work and live in our communities. In

133
00:38:59.119 --> 00:39:15.280
fact, one of my former Sly students works in this very building. So, in a moment when the political climate has turned on our Slife students, let us be the ones who do not abandon them. I urge you to continue to prioritize explicit instruction and literacy, to honor individualized transition plans and

134
00:39:15.280 --> 00:39:49.920
timelines, and to continue to fund this life program model as outlined in the Medicaid. Jen Hayes. >> Hi, I'm Jen Hayes. I am a slave teacher at the Margarita Monise Academy and I live in Rivier, Massachusetts. Dr. Jim Dr. Dr. Jim Cummings, a renowned

135
00:39:49.920 --> 00:40:06.320
theorist in second language acquisition, has found that students who are not yet literate in their first language may require between seven and 10 years to develop academic language proficiency in English. This research, which is

136
00:40:06.320 --> 00:40:23.040
included in DESIE's MTELS for both ESL and bilingual educator endorsement exams, directly contradicts the current mandate to exit Slife students after only two years. The rationale we have received from M is that remaining in

137
00:40:23.040 --> 00:40:39.760
Slife programs for longer periods is exclusionary or unsustainable in the current political climate. However, literacy research consistently demonstrates that students learn to read most effectively through explicit systematic instruction. Students with

138
00:40:39.760 --> 00:40:57.040
interrupted or limited formal education often require highly individualized and intensive literacy support in order to develop foundational reading and writing skills. If acade if academic language acquisition can take many years and literacy development requires explicit

139
00:40:57.040 --> 00:41:13.119
systematic instruction, why is the district limiting specialized slave services to two years? How does this policy align with the research on language acquisition, the documented needs of students with interrupted formal education, and the professional

140
00:41:13.119 --> 00:41:29.119
judgment of educators working directly with these students? Will exited Slife students have the literacy skills necessary to thrive independently in mainstream academic settings? Is the district planning to provide professional development for educators working with former SLI students? There

141
00:41:29.119 --> 00:41:55.359
is not sufficient capacity for educators to teach foundational literacy skills while simultaneously teaching grade level content. I believe these students deserve access to personalized explicit literacy. Your time is up. Vana de la Rocha.

142
00:41:55.359 --> 00:42:21.520
No. Vana. No. Anna Ard. Um, good evening. My name is Anna Varde. I live in Somerville and I am a sixth and seventh grade dual language science teacher at the Mariomana Academy in East Boston and I'm also a proud member of the Boston Teachers Union. I am here

143
00:42:21.520 --> 00:42:37.200
today to speak about the importance of protecting safe programs. Since the beginning of the year, sixth grade native literacy teacher who was notified that was cut last minute has spent time in my classroom supporting students in Spanish. Her work has been

144
00:42:37.200 --> 00:42:53.839
essential. She helps students access grade level content. She develops literacy and challenges that come with entering a new school system. Two months ago, after a teacher unexpectedly retired, she was resigned to cover a general education history class. And the absence has been

145
00:42:53.839 --> 00:43:11.599
felt students who no longer of students and educational backgrounds require expertise that I, as a general education teacher, cannot provide alone. This experience has shown that

146
00:43:11.599 --> 00:43:34.800
services are extra instruction stretched classroom teachers. A site program that instructions their language, their educational backgrounds and their own needs. I urge

147
00:43:34.800 --> 00:43:50.319
the district and the school community to protect sty programs to preserve native literacy positions and ensure that decisions about students and services are driven by what our students actually need and not by staffing shortages or budget cuts. Thank you.

148
00:43:50.319 --> 00:44:12.000
>> Thank you. >> I want to remind the speakers that we have interpreters in the channels. So, if you can slow down a little bit, please. Thank you. The next group is Alicia Silva, Ariana Cyros McCarthy, Shaina Gilbert, Robin Kelly, and Juan

149
00:44:12.000 --> 00:44:32.000
Gutierrez. Alicia Silva. >> Good evening, Buenas. I'm Alicia Sova. I live in Newton. I'm an 18-year teaching veteran of the Boston public schools. I am honored to work with students that have had limited access to formal education at least for 11 more days

150
00:44:32.000 --> 00:44:49.520
because my job was cut. Our children have experienced unthinkable trauma and we asked them to come to school and behave normally. And I think how much time would my child need in school to learn her letters if she had seen me shot in the head at our dinner table because I refused to sell drugs. How

151
00:44:49.520 --> 00:45:06.560
much time would your child need if they had juvenile arthritis and were unable to walk the five miles to school or in a wheelchair in the middle of a desert in a refugee camp? What is the time limit on trauma? When do I tell my baby students, "Okay, get over it. Get out."

152
00:45:06.560 --> 00:45:22.079
And by the way, the one person it took you 15 to 16 months to trust is telling you goodbye. It has been decades for me watching courts tell BPS what to do. But we all know what is right. Aren't you tired of

153
00:45:22.079 --> 00:45:38.000
that? We understand change. Teachers understand change. BPS wrote that teachers would be consulted if this life program were to change. Were we consulted? No. Students with limited formal education

154
00:45:38.000 --> 00:45:55.440
have traveled to our shores, our coast, not for the American dream, but for the Boston dream. They just want to be safe and learn how to read. Big Poppy said it best when he said, "This is our city." >> 30 seconds. >> The Bostononians I surround myself with take care

155
00:45:55.440 --> 00:46:09.599
surround myself with take care of children and they listen to teachers. Fully fun life classrooms, two teachers. I work by myself. I'm not bilingual. Slife is not for life. We know that. But

156
00:46:09.599 --> 00:46:35.520
love is for life. Love is for life. What are we modeling for our future citizens, our future Bostononians? >> Ariana Cayos McCarthy. >> Hi, Ariana Cigaros McCarthy. I live in Rosendale.

157
00:46:35.520 --> 00:46:52.800
I am a BPS alumni, parent, and ESL teacher of SLIE students at Boston International Newcomers Academy. I'm here tonight in solidarity with the Slife community. This is my 19th year of teaching in BPS, almost half of which has been working with Slife students.

158
00:46:52.800 --> 00:47:08.240
SLIFE programs serve students who come into BPS with a wide range of skills. Students have the opportunity to learn from educators who understand that our job is to adapt and meet them where they are. By design and the meta consent

159
00:47:08.240 --> 00:47:25.119
degree, Slife programs provide intensive instruction in students native languages. This is supported by decades of research that show how strong literacy skills in native language are an indicator of literacy skills for second or third languages. Our students

160
00:47:25.119 --> 00:47:40.079
who are coming in need time with specialized and skilled teachers to fill those gaps. As a district, we should be staffing programs that enhance our students ability to acquire language and not cutting those supports. This past January, the district told us

161
00:47:40.079 --> 00:47:55.920
that best practices included a support plan for students who exit Slife. The plan detailed supports like reading intervention, co-eing and content classes, and the support of Slice social workers. But instead of providing schools with enough staff to ensure the

162
00:47:55.920 --> 00:48:13.359
long-term success of Slice students, BPS is cutting the positions as recently as last week. >> Without Slifice specific supports, how can a student who arrived as a non-reader in Spanish in 9th grade fully access a grade level text in English? At

163
00:48:13.359 --> 00:48:28.559
the secondary level, former SLE students are overwhelmed by the sheer length of texts being put in front of them. This leads to disengagement in class, frustration, increased absences, and eventually dropping out. BPS needs to

164
00:48:28.559 --> 00:48:52.400
pause and consider the needs of life students before putting a timeline on their learning. Our students deserve better. >> Shaina Gilbert. >> Hello, my name is Shaina Gilbert and I'm from Boston. I'm a proud graduate of Boston public schools, a second

165
00:48:52.400 --> 00:49:09.040
generation Slife educator and have taught Haitian newcomers at Tech Boston for 16 years. I'm here reg I'm here regarding the district's recent decision to prematurely exit nearly all Sly students from their program against teacher recommendations. Slife students

166
00:49:09.040 --> 00:49:25.200
are English learners with interrupted education often due to trauma. Many enter BPS with major gaps in literacy and math. They require specialized instruction to build foundational skills. The Sly program prepares them to succeed in grade level classrooms

167
00:49:25.200 --> 00:49:42.400
alongside their peers. The goal of Sly is not to be in SLE for life, but to benefit from Sly for a better life. Slife is described by the district as a 2-year transitional program, but some need more time. My Haitian students have experienced political instability,

168
00:49:42.400 --> 00:49:59.760
dangerous migration, disrupted schooling, and now they live in fear around immigration policies. These are some of our most vulnerable learners. How we choose to support those with the fewest advantages reflects who we are as a district. For over 16 years,

169
00:49:59.760 --> 00:50:16.240
I have seen Slife students become college graduates and professionals because because BPS provided the proper instruction in the time they needed. But today, the district plans to use a single metric to abruptly exit students from Slife. This decision will weaken

170
00:50:16.240 --> 00:50:33.599
the program and 30 seconds and deprive students of critical support. I urge the school committee to ensure that slight program decisions from entry to exit remain grounded in equity, educator expertise, evidence, and the long-term

171
00:50:33.599 --> 00:51:03.599
success of our students. Thank you. >> Thank you, >> Robin Kelly. Robin Kelly. Good evening. I'm Robin Kelly from Dorchester. I've been teaching middle school Slife at the Mario Yamana Academy

172
00:51:03.599 --> 00:51:18.800
for 11 years in which I have witnessed muddled messaging and inconsistent application of the Slife program as it is outlined by the META consent decree. The district's concern over length of time in Slife is valid. However, the two-year max does not address the route of the ad.

173
00:51:18.800 --> 00:51:33.599
>> Sorry. The district is encouraging us to exit kids who are not ready. This year, the district and M have sent conflicting messages. Guidance in our Google classroom says students need a 2.5 overall in access to exit. In December, Mailed some schools saying the goalpost

174
00:51:33.599 --> 00:51:50.480
has been lowered to 1.7. Which is it? Claiming that students have been in the program for too long based on a set length of time follows a one-sizefits-all model. We know life is anything but. For some students, a few months since life is enough. For others, it's longer. We must ask, has the

175
00:51:50.480 --> 00:52:06.640
district actually been providing our students with the full services and supports needed to make meaningful academic progress per the meta decree? Most recently, no. Not in terms of consistent foundational native literacy, appropriate ESL, and a clear infrastructure to support students whose

176
00:52:06.640 --> 00:52:22.319
progress is limited. I have loads of examples. Furthermore, at our school, M has proposed staffing cuts that would eliminate native language literacy, an essential and legal requirement of Slife. The native language component is necessary for development in English and for a successful transition to general

177
00:52:22.319 --> 00:52:39.200
education. We oppose these cuts as well as the restructuring of Slife exit guidelines without educator and community input. We teachers are in the front lines. We know our students best and we know what they need. I've seen the consequences of exiting students before they're ready. Students forced to exit because the district timed them out

178
00:52:39.200 --> 00:52:54.880
have struggled with attendance and engagement. In some cases dropped out. Conversely, I recently spoke with a former Slife student who was in the program for three or four years. Now she's in college. This juxtaposition between what teachers think and current guidance shows what happens when SLE students are rushed into general

179
00:52:54.880 --> 00:53:18.160
education. And it should not be a mistake that the district continues to make. Thank you. Thank you, Juan >> Gutierrez. My name is Juan Gutierrez. I'm a resident of East Boston uh BPS alum and now a native life educator at the

180
00:53:18.160 --> 00:53:35.280
Marioan Academy. During our last contract campaign, educators and families fought for inclusion done right. We demanded that inclusion cannot mean putting students with many different needs with uh into classrooms without the appropriate staffing, ade adequate services and specialized supports required for them to succeed.

181
00:53:35.280 --> 00:53:52.160
That same principle applies to SLI students. We believe in meaningful inclusion opportunities for SLIE students. We want students learning alongside their peers and transitioning successfully into appropriate educational settings. But those opportunities have to be planned for and supported by a team of educators. They

182
00:53:52.160 --> 00:54:08.240
cannot be created by removing the very educators who provide specialized instruction. For CLI students, native literacy is an essential support and required component of the Slife model under the meta consent decree. Every student deserves the opportunity to develop literacy in their native

183
00:54:08.240 --> 00:54:25.280
language. That means explicit native literacy instruction. And as it stands, the district is cutting the native literacy component at my school. If BPS continues to operate a SLIFE program while removing native language literacy instruction, then the district is fundamentally altering the very model

184
00:54:25.280 --> 00:54:42.319
students are entitled to receive. There's a difference between content instruction in students native language and native literacy instruction. Content classes in students native language can support literacy development, but they cannot replace explicit native language reading instruction. And at the UMAN,

185
00:54:42.319 --> 00:54:58.319
that is what the district is proposing. And let's be clear, services for students with disabilities, multilingual learners, and SLI students were not simply given. They were fought for and won by families, students, educators, and community members. And now the

186
00:54:58.319 --> 00:55:13.359
district cries budget constraints when it comes to special education, ESL, and SLE services. Inclusion does not mean placing students in classrooms without support, without planning, or without a real transition plan. The fight to ensure that inclusion is done right is not over and it is our duty to keep

187
00:55:13.359 --> 00:55:41.599
fighting for our slide students. Our last in inerson speakers are Myra de Rocha, Dedra Manning, Paulo Devaros, Caris Mclofflin, and Kelsey Brandell. Myra de Rocha I'm Myra D Rosha, Spanish native

188
00:55:41.599 --> 00:55:58.160
literacy life teacher at the Margarita Munas Academy. Boston calls itself a sanctuary city. Yet, we are dismantling the some of the very educational sanctuaries our newest immigrant students rely on. During COVID, Slife students were identified as some of the most vulnerable and we're in the first wave of students to return to in-person

189
00:55:58.160 --> 00:56:14.880
learning. Now, when they need us the most, the district has decided to exit them from the program regardless of where they are academically. The meta consent decree is a legal document that is very explicit about what criteria life students need to meet before entering the general education classroom, which includes native

190
00:56:14.880 --> 00:56:30.880
literacy and math proficiency. BPS is replacing an individual, student- centered, and evidence-based process with a one-sizefits-all model that they have admitted will put students into gened classes that they will not be prepared for, violating this Department of Justice order. We'll be pushing these

191
00:56:30.880 --> 00:56:47.079
students into classes where they are doomed to fail when Slice students are already statistically more likely to drop out of school. How many futures are we willing to sacrifice in order to satisfy a standardized timeline? That's why it's so important to stand up.

192
00:57:10.640 --> 00:58:16.880
30 seconds. Our next speaker is still remaining. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Dear Danning. I'm a Dorchester resident, single parent of two public school students. I'd like to make a few points this evening. Um

193
00:58:16.880 --> 00:58:32.240
the first is that it's been three admission cycles since the superintendent stated that there would be data made available on the outcomes of students who have gone through the exam school admission process. My understanding is that data has not been

194
00:58:32.240 --> 00:58:47.920
made available. The second point that I'd like to make is that it's been two months since the last admission cycle concluded and I do not believe any of that information about um low cutoff scores or any of that has been made available. Um the third point that I'd

195
00:58:47.920 --> 00:59:04.480
like to make is that this exam school construct continues to put certain students at a disadvantage. My daughter is friends with a girl who will be a rising seventh grader. She is black. uh she lives in Madapan which inexplicably

196
00:59:04.480 --> 00:59:21.440
is considered a tier 4 neighborhood. I think that just about anybody would laugh if you stated that a girl who lives in Madapan has anywhere near the resources that a student who lives in Charlestone or the Back Bay or the North

197
00:59:21.440 --> 00:59:38.319
End. Yet this girl was put at a disadvantage because she was considered a tier 4 student. Across the street from her was tier 2. So, if she lived across the street, the outcome would have been very different. This particular girl has a brother who's already at BLS. Now, I

198
00:59:38.319 --> 00:59:54.960
know that she's a high performing student, even though I don't know her composite score, because she did actually get a seat at an exam school, but she did not get her first choice, which was BLS. Is really strange that a girl who lives in a neighborhood that is underresourced, yet she is not allowed

199
00:59:54.960 --> 01:00:11.440
to join the school that her brother attends. Um there's a huge disconnect there and I wish that the committee would take a really hard look as how you divide students into tier groups. It's extremely inequitable. Thank you. >> Thank you. Our next speaker is Paulo

200
01:00:11.440 --> 01:00:39.440
Dearos. No. Caris Mclofflin. >> Thank you. Oh, I'm Caris Mclofflin. I live in Roxbury and I'm the mom of a former Boston public school student. And so I attended

201
01:00:39.440 --> 01:00:57.200
your retreat um I guess a few weeks ago. And what I heard at that retreat was I basically the comment that school committee members were not sure what their task is. And so what I did in

202
01:00:57.200 --> 01:01:13.040
response to that when I hear things I say, okay, so what can I do to be helpful? I went down to the Mass Massachusetts Association of School Committees and got the um Massachusetts General Loss. So, this is the work that

203
01:01:13.040 --> 01:01:29.440
guides school committees. And I'm not sure if you're aware, but a lawsuit is coming that will state clearly that none of the gateway cities are preparing kids well enough. And there's going to be a

204
01:01:29.440 --> 01:01:46.319
recommendation that um they need to leave these gateway cities and be educated in neighboring um communities that may have more money. You know, that's simplistically put, but you should be aware of that lawsuit. And

205
01:01:46.319 --> 01:02:02.720
that lawsuit will look at historically what Boston has been unable to do for too many neighborhood school kids. Every kid should be able to look at their neighborhood school, no matter where it

206
01:02:02.720 --> 01:02:18.799
is, and know that they will get a good education. It's the least that we can do for them. and I support kids going to school wherever they choose, but in their neighborhood I think is most important. So, I hope that you will look

207
01:02:18.799 --> 01:02:33.280
into the lawsuit. It's already filed. It's at Suffach Superior Court. It is serious and there are answers that you're going to need to give. And so, school committee that will be your Thank you.

208
01:02:33.280 --> 01:03:16.160
>> Next speaker is Kelsey Brundell. Good evening, school committee chair Robinson, Superintendent Skipper. I'm Kelsey Brendelle, parent of a child with multiple and severe disabilities. You may see him and likely you've probably already heard him despite my best efforts. Um, he, like so many of our

209
01:03:16.160 --> 01:03:32.400
students with disabilities, can't speak, at least out loud, and that's part of the reason I am here. I try very hard at trying to hear and listen for the voices of many students in BPS and our city. And I've been so lucky to have met and spoken with so many students like him

210
01:03:32.400 --> 01:03:49.359
who may not have words, but they and their families can more than make themselves heard. As you know, it's such a privilege to be able to bear witness to their eagerness when talking about their child, their lived experience, and how they might contribute themselves to a bigger conversation about BPS with

211
01:03:49.359 --> 01:04:06.799
curiosity, civility, and passion. And I'm here tonight because I'm noticing something that started as a whisper and now is a scream in the world of special ed here in Boston. And we have got to get back to prioritizing some of the ways in which we could actually make a material difference in the lives of

212
01:04:06.799 --> 01:04:22.319
those most vulnerable who navigate BPS every day and who would tell you that some of the fissures and pain points are not always too daunting to solve. We're becoming, I fear, distracted by conversations and people that scare us rather than inspire us. And we have

213
01:04:22.319 --> 01:04:40.640
families waiting for real solves. And sometimes they are very meaningful solves that are achievable and speak to the everyday experiences of our special educ. Uh I I I well understand, you know, it's not a mystery many of the topics that we

214
01:04:40.640 --> 01:04:56.720
talk about here tonight, school closures, the enormity of budgetary restraints, how the plan for inclusion has sparked critical debate about whether and how we are actually serving with this plan as it evolves. But I really want to remind us and this body about who we are really really talking

215
01:04:56.720 --> 01:05:13.119
about and invite a more robust and candid conversation than the ones that we've been having. Who are we leaving out and how can we create additional ways for families to be heard and truly considered as partners? >> Please send you can send the test

216
01:05:13.119 --> 01:05:28.960
written testimony to >> Yes. Thank you so much. Thank you. >> Thank you. >> We will now transition to Zoom um public comment. Our first the first speakers are Kimberly Hirs, Cheryl Buckman, April Wong, and Eugenia Corbbo.

217
01:05:28.960 --> 01:05:54.880
Kimberly Hirs Yes. Hello. Um, my name is Kimberly Hirsch and I'm here to address the accessing of SLE teachers. During the last school year, I was an ESL life teacher at Charles Town High School. I was also a district life teacher leader with the telescope network in M. In that

218
01:05:54.880 --> 01:06:11.280
capacity, I wrote a district-wide newsletter and facilitated two district-wide professional development series. I was also part of an own working group adapting open sedife and I had a grant from the teacher leader fund to adapt the DKP civics curriculum for life. I had planned to continue this

219
01:06:11.280 --> 01:06:26.240
important work but two weeks before school started last August the district closed my scythe program and all the work that I was doing to support the scythe community stopped. My knowledge, experience and curriculum completely cut

220
01:06:26.240 --> 01:06:42.400
off from the students who need it most. In a few years, the political climate is going to change again, and someone in the central office will determine that there's a need for a life program in Charlestone, and those teachers will have to start over from scratch, like I

221
01:06:42.400 --> 01:06:58.960
did. They will have to fundra to rebuild a culturally linguistically relevant classroom library. They will have to train again in rules-based reading intervention. They will have to rewrite weekly restorative circles and trauma-informed lessons and reestablish field relationships at field trip sites.

222
01:06:58.960 --> 01:07:14.559
They'll have to discover again how to meet the incredibly unique needs of this life students who come to Charlestone. The decision to get life teachers was made because our student population has decreased. We understand that too many resources.

223
01:07:14.559 --> 01:07:32.640
It's inefficient. But it is also inefficient to force schools and teachers to reinvent the wheel every four years because of national politics. Life educators and students need you to find another way.

224
01:07:32.640 --> 01:08:02.960
>> Thank you. >> Thank you very much. Our next speaker is Cheryl Buckman. Good evening. My name is Cheryl Buckman. I'm a parent to a seventh grader at the Ruth Batson Academy, the parent lead at the DER and resident of South Boston.

225
01:08:02.960 --> 01:08:18.400
I'm here to express my deepest gratitude for all the hard work, engagement, and collaboration with the DER community throughout this challenging transition process. I stand before you today in immense pride. The build the physical

226
01:08:18.400 --> 01:08:35.440
building may close but the spirit of the devil cannot be contained by brick or mortar. Its legacy is going to be spread far and wide across this entire district. As our students, families, and phenomenal educators carry its values

227
01:08:35.440 --> 01:08:51.600
into their next chapters. For my family, the Denver is not just a school. It's a cornerstone of our lives. I'm forever grateful for the education I received within those halls many years ago. That legacy continued when my

228
01:08:51.600 --> 01:09:08.319
brother walked those same halls and it came full circle when my own son became a Denver student. This community ran on family. It was built on the belief that we lifted each other up, looked out for one another, and fought for every single

229
01:09:08.319 --> 01:09:24.159
child's future. It's truly been an honor to serve my voice for this community, to advocate for our kids and our fantastic educators. Thank you for listening to us, working alongside us, and recognizing the heart

230
01:09:24.159 --> 01:09:40.159
of our community as we move forward. We trust that you'll help us carry the DER's deeprooted commitment to family and excellence into the future of this entire district. The doors may close, but the Denver Dolphins will keep moving

231
01:09:40.159 --> 01:10:05.280
together. Thank you. >> Thank you. Our next speaker is April Wang. Hi, my name is April Boang. I live in Fields Corner and I am the mother of a 4-year-old rising K1 BPS student. We are Chinese American. We decided to raise

232
01:10:05.280 --> 01:10:21.600
our family here because we wanted our children to be exposed to their heritage culture, food, and language. So, when the K1 lottery opened in January, I was devastated to learn that my son was ineligible to attend Josiah Quincy Elementary, which has the only bilingual Chinese program in the district. In

233
01:10:21.600 --> 01:10:38.800
December, the district said that opening city-wide access to low incidence language programs would result in relatively small student impact, which essentially means you are denying hyper minoritized students access to heritage language learning. This is the opposite of equitable policy. Equitable policy

234
01:10:38.800 --> 01:10:53.920
does not diminish students needs because they don't meet a certain population threshold. This current school year, JQEs had a capacity of 36 seats in its K1 program. only 23 were filled. This is a waste of resources and an underutilization of a

235
01:10:53.920 --> 01:11:11.120
program. The district said it couldn't open up these bilingual programs citywide because of transportation costs. Let's talk about that. In an ideal world, we would have invest resources to ensure all kids have district transportation to their schools. But you all know that education

236
01:11:11.120 --> 01:11:27.280
doesn't operate in an ideal world, which means that we need to think creatively about solutions rather than just saying no. In the face of a broken education system, our communities have always found solutions to intractable problems. For 3 years, my family has spent between 90 minutes to 3 hours when the red line

237
01:11:27.280 --> 01:11:43.280
was getting fixed. >> 30 seconds. >> My son to a daycare in Taiong Village, Chinatown. This was a sacrifice. My husband and I both work full-time jobs. But it was worth it to ensure that our son would start life learning his heritage language. If given access to the bilingual program at JQEs, we would

238
01:11:43.280 --> 01:11:57.920
continue to take him on public transportation every day. BPS enrollment is plummeting. The district is losing families and kids left and right. And the ones you seek to serve in equitably are the ones leaving first. Do something. Fix it. Open access to your bilingual programs and stop dismissing

239
01:11:57.920 --> 01:12:21.679
language as low incidents. >> Thank you. Your time is up. Our next speaker is Eugenia Corbbo. >> Hello. Can you hear me? >> Yes, we can hear you. You can start. >> Good evening. My name is Cororo and I'm the parent a parent at the Marana

240
01:12:21.679 --> 01:12:38.880
Academy in East Boston. I have a child in fifth grade. On May 20th, our school building was hot. Very hot. By mid-after afternoon of 73 classroom sensors, 70 were flag high, 41 classroom were at or over or above 85 degrees. We were at or

241
01:12:38.880 --> 01:12:55.920
over 90 and the hottest room read 95° inside where children are trying to learn. The building averaged 85° and most of those classrooms have no windows that can be opened. Uh this was the second day in a row that our children sat in that heat with no air

242
01:12:55.920 --> 01:13:11.360
conditioning. two days. We could watch the temperature climb through the morning and into the afternoon, and there was nothing the school itself could do about it. I know at least one family that pulled their kids out of school that day because of the high heat. And this was not just our school.

243
01:13:11.360 --> 01:13:27.199
Uh at 2 p.m. the same day, across the 125 Boston schools uh being monitored, more than a thousand rooms were at or above 80°, 305 rooms were at and or above 85. 31 rooms top 90 with one

244
01:13:27.199 --> 01:13:43.600
reading 97°. The schools heat hardest including hours where the buildings with modern central air. The wind the schools with uh window units were generally fine. The buildings didn't overheat because the equipment failed. It happened because the central

245
01:13:43.600 --> 01:14:00.880
air could not be switched on yet. We've been informed that the heating cannot be turned off until until May 15th. And only at that point can the process start for cooling and that can take up to 3 weeks and that is too long. So that's

246
01:14:00.880 --> 01:14:17.120
scheduling failure and a schedule failure is fixable. High heat in May is no longer a surprise. I'm asking BPS and the city to make sure the startup process for cooling is sped up so that our buildings are ready before the first hot week and not after. Thank you.

247
01:14:17.120 --> 01:14:34.400
>> Thank you. Our next speaker uh the next speakers are Jessica Curtis, Melanie Kaine, and Mariva Duva and Courtney Fily Karp. Jessica Curtis. >> Good evening. My name is Jessica Curtis and I'm a parent at the Mario UMA

248
01:14:34.400 --> 01:14:51.440
Academy in East Boston. Following up on Ohena's testimony, I want to talk about who was sitting in those 90°ree rooms for the second day in a row. Yuma is about 90% Hispanic and we're a title one school with large numbers of English learners and students with disabilities

249
01:14:51.440 --> 01:15:07.920
including an ABA program and a special ed program. These are exactly the children the district says it's committed to serving first. The research is unambiguous. Children are physically more vulnerable to heat than adults. Their bodies don't shed heat as efficiently and their comfortable

250
01:15:07.920 --> 01:15:24.400
learning temperature is lower than ours. Studies find the temperature for best concentration is around 72° and that student performance can rise by roughly 20% when a classroom is cooled from the high 80s to the high60s. Researchers have also found that classroom heat

251
01:15:24.400 --> 01:15:41.360
widens the achievement gap, hurting disadvantaged students the most, and that air conditioning closes that gap, especially for students who are struggling. So, when our central air sits idle in a highne school, we are not being neutral. We're widening the gap that we say we're trying to close.

252
01:15:41.360 --> 01:15:57.679
And here is the part that's so important. This is not the first hot May in Boston, and it will not be the last. Late spring heat has become predictable. We learned the system couldn't run because the steps to bring it online take up to 3 weeks, and the Eversource meter read for our school wasn't

253
01:15:57.679 --> 01:16:12.640
scheduled until the end of the month. So, I'm asking BPS to work with the city and with Eversource to speed up the seasonal cooling startup so that our kids can get the building that they deserve before the thermometer climbs. Thank you so much.

254
01:16:12.640 --> 01:16:35.239
>> Thank you. Our next Melanie Kane is not in the meeting, so we will continue with Anmarie Vaduva followed by Courtney Felicarp. Anmarie Baduva, please accept the prompt.

255
01:16:40.080 --> 01:17:13.679
Okay, she declined the um so we will continue with Courtney Phyarp. Coordinate Billy Karp. Please turn on your camera there. Thank you. >> Hi. Can you hear me? >> Yeah, we can hear you. >> Hi, good evening. Uh, my name is

256
01:17:13.679 --> 01:17:30.080
Courtney Philly Karp. I am a West Roxberry resident and a parent of a sixth grader who previously attended the Henderson School and currently attends the Roosevelt K through8. Um I come tonight um to join the other parents who are requesting action of this school committee in reviewing the policies

257
01:17:30.080 --> 01:17:44.560
around the placement of inclusion students. I heard an earlier um person testifying that there seemed to be some confusion among school committee members about what their responsibilities may or may not be. I would refer you to your own website where it specifically says

258
01:17:44.560 --> 01:18:02.880
that your role is to establish, set, and review the policies to support student achievement. I think what you have consistently heard from both Spedpack and individual parents is that there is a huge disconnect between the school labeling rooms schools as full inclusion

259
01:18:02.880 --> 01:18:19.199
and saying that any one of those services any one of those rooms can serve as any individual student in their individual needs with an IEP. That is simply not true. I don't know how many parents need to come here and tell you that is not the case. There are countless incidents of parents trying to find the right placement for their

260
01:18:19.199 --> 01:18:35.120
student and going to a welcome center. The specific charge I have for you tonight is what is you as a school committee, the oversight body of this school district going to do in response to the parent outcry? You have legal obligations to serve students with disabilities and it is important that

261
01:18:35.120 --> 01:18:51.600
the public understand what you are doing. I ask that you ask the superintendent and the staff to explain how the welcome center process works, whether OSS is involved. My experience is that it is not um and how parents are expected to go to the welcome center

262
01:18:51.600 --> 01:19:08.560
with an IEP and figure out a placement for their student when there's no universal definition of inclusion, no universal staffing of those rooms, and no information for parents to access to help decide what the right choice is for their student. So my ask you tonight is to please put these questions to the

263
01:19:08.560 --> 01:19:36.480
district for a future committee meeting so the public can benefit from the answers. >> Thank you. >> We need now. Thank you. >> So we will try with Anmarie Vuva again. >> Hi. Um, this is Enmarie Vadiv Diva. I am

264
01:19:36.480 --> 01:19:54.400
a parent of a BPS student enrolled at the Mary Lion School in fifth grade who has not been able to attend school since September and has been in receiving inhome um tutoring that has been ineffective. And I'm going to read uh my

265
01:19:54.400 --> 01:20:10.159
statement. Um in general um my statement is more for the parents. I'm providing solidarity and support uh to parents of autistic students who are navigating um

266
01:20:10.159 --> 01:20:26.640
inclusion uh placements that uh are non-existent or that don't work for them. Um, and basically, um, my experience very quickly, um, sorry,

267
01:20:26.640 --> 01:20:42.400
sorry, not right now. Sorry. >> I need the charger. >> Sorry. Uh, sorry, not right now. Um, I'm going to skip to the end since I'm not going to be able to read everything. I just want to say um on behalf of all parents of autistic students who are not

268
01:20:42.400 --> 01:20:58.560
able to access general inclusion settings and who are not having being allowed to have real dialogues with uh administrators about how to access education. I challenge BPS uh if they are serious about proving that they are

269
01:20:58.560 --> 01:21:14.719
not discriminating against a minority as a result of a disability which many of us feel like is what is happening. FBPS is really serious about educating children with disabilities to invite all parents of BPS autistic students who are struggling to go to school to come to a

270
01:21:14.719 --> 01:21:28.719
public meeting and to hear what all parents of such children are saying their children need to access a school environment and to invite the parents and the students to design school environments in BPS buildings um where the needs identified by the parents and

271
01:21:28.719 --> 01:21:46.640
the students are fulfilled and um we are that is not happening. We are being stonewalled and we actually need BPS to work with parents to help our children otherwise. >> Thank you very much. >> discrimination. >> Hi. >> Thank you, >> chair. That concludes public comment.

272
01:21:46.640 --> 01:22:07.080
>> Thank you, Miss Parex. And thank you to those of you who spoke this evening and shared your perspectives. Your testimony is very important to us. Our first two action items this evening are the grants for approval totaling $5,39,61 and the inind donations of $5,22549.

273
01:22:08.080 --> 01:22:23.199
Now I'd like to turn it over to the superintendent for final comments. >> Uh great. Thank you, chair. So excuse me. So before you tonight, there are 14 grants for your consideration which total approximately $5 million.

274
01:22:23.199 --> 01:22:40.159
Rather than name all of the grants, I'll give a brief overview in the interest of time. The grants fall into several focus areas. Social emotional learning, there are three grants totaling nearly $186,000. Health and wellness, there are two grants totaling just over 350,000.

275
01:22:40.159 --> 01:22:56.320
College and career readiness, one is a summer continuation funding, which is total of 7,500. Grant technical education, one grant for more than $920,000. Madison Park High School facility improvement. There's four community

276
01:22:56.320 --> 01:23:13.199
preservation act grants totaling over $3.5 million for schoolyard improvements at the Conley Everett Troder and UP Academy schools, UP Academy Doorchester. Um and then academic instruction, there's two grants for $20,000 for the Everett and Jaziah Quinsey Elementary

277
01:23:13.199 --> 01:23:31.040
Schools and the Elliot Innovation Schools. There are also before you two inind donations uh one that totalif uh $5,200. There's a book donation to the Sarah Roberts Elementary School which is valued uh at $1,350 and a donation of

278
01:23:31.040 --> 01:23:48.000
more than $ 3,800 from the New England Dairy and Food Council for handheld immersion blenders for the BPS Central Kitchen. We ask the committee to vote in favor of accepting these grants um and certainly these generous donations. uh CFO Bloom uh is here as well as uh

279
01:23:48.000 --> 01:24:09.920
Marcala to answer any questions. >> Thank you. No, I'd like to turn it over to Oh, sorry. Want to turn it over to our members for any comments, questions and just quickly want to know the community preservation act which are

280
01:24:09.920 --> 01:24:27.280
the biggest grants here. How is the process for selecting the schools that are going to receive those improvement those grants given that we have many schools with many needs? >> So the the city runs an application

281
01:24:27.280 --> 01:24:43.120
process for community preservation act um projects. Um any member of the Boston community can submit a proposal. Um, in the past, uh, there were definitely moments where BPS was not taking full

282
01:24:43.120 --> 01:25:00.239
advantage of our opportunity to propose things. As well, um, over the last few years, we've done a better job of reviewing data on sort of what projects are eligible and where our schools saying the having the most need. So, we're definitely able to propose more

283
01:25:00.239 --> 01:25:20.239
relevant projects, but there are still projects that get proposed by the community and and can be selected. Is is the facility plan in involved in this at all or >> it's a separate process? >> Yeah. So, it's it's not a part of the

284
01:25:20.239 --> 01:25:36.960
long-term facilities plan because it's run directly by the city. Um I see Sam walking up, so I'm just going to wait for him to get all the way up here. It's in case I >> It is a separate It is a separate process. It's a se it's a separate process run by the city but uh Sam

285
01:25:36.960 --> 01:25:52.719
>> hi good evening everyone. Yes it is a separate process but our teams are very involved in the process and we um coordinate with um the folks that involved on city side and as we implement the the construction projects our team's heavily involved in that part of it as well.

286
01:25:52.719 --> 01:26:08.960
>> Right. So I'm just trying to understand how you choose a school A versus a school B to get those grants and those >> So that decision is um largely not in our control. Uh however, we do make recommendations based on our facilities condition assessments that we've

287
01:26:08.960 --> 01:26:24.400
conducted. We've ranked all of our playgrounds um in their conditions, safety, years, danger, equipment failures. So we have a ranked list of how bad our playgrounds are. So we do have our internal list and that's public information as well. So we make

288
01:26:24.400 --> 01:26:40.159
recommendations to that committee based on that information that collectively a decision is made. >> Thank you. >> Anyone else? >> I have a question um about the Madison Park um that is one

289
01:26:40.159 --> 01:26:55.679
of the largest uh grant in there. So it's a new grant. So, I was just wondering uh and it's 220 students that have are going to be assigned to this. I just was wondering if the uh what

290
01:26:55.679 --> 01:27:13.520
happened to the students if the grant is not renewed. >> Thank you for the question. Um that that grant supports two new programs at Madison Park that are currently in uh part B desi status waiting for approval. The bulk of that grant um will go to uh

291
01:27:13.520 --> 01:27:28.320
construction craft labor and robotics for all the startup equipment and supplies that are needed for the program. The construction craft labor consumable supplies on an annual basis are at a fairly low cost. So we believe we can pull all of those expenses into

292
01:27:28.320 --> 01:27:45.120
the Perkins grant and the robotics uh program for the second year. Um the grant will support a second teacher who will then be absorbed into Madison Park's budget and also um you heard the superintendent's um announcement about the Bloomberg grant for the construction

293
01:27:45.120 --> 01:28:00.400
trades that will also support the construction craft labor. So we think those programs are off to a very solid launch. >> So the so they're in it to win it. So it will they will be renewed. Is that what we're saying? If the grant is not

294
01:28:00.400 --> 01:28:17.120
renewed, um the equipment that is needed for the grant is front-loaded and the consumables that are needed to maintain the program are a fairly low cost and and Desi asked us the same questions that you are about it. Um if the grant is not renewed, we feel very confident

295
01:28:17.120 --> 01:28:32.400
that through other grant funding, the Perkins grant in particular, we can sustain the programs for the students at Madison Park. >> Thank you. >> Okay. Thank you. Anybody else is fine?

296
01:28:32.400 --> 01:28:48.080
>> Okay. So, thank you. So, if there are no further questions, no further discussion, I'll now entertain a motion to approve the grants as presented. Is there a motion? >> So, moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Second. >> Thank you. Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Is there any

297
01:28:48.080 --> 01:29:04.239
objection to approving the grants by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the grants are approved. Thank you. I will now entertain a motion to approve the inind donations as presented. Is there a motion? >> So moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second?

298
01:29:04.239 --> 01:29:19.679
>> Second. >> Is there any discussion objection to the motion? Is there any objection to approving the inind donation by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the inkind donations are approved. Our next action item is the fisc year

299
01:29:19.679 --> 01:29:35.920
2027 school trust funds. You may recall that we voted on the school trust funds policy at the June 17, 2025 meeting to allow the school committee to annually approve expenditures from the trust fund

300
01:29:35.920 --> 01:29:50.880
allowing BPS finance to load the trust funds directly into school budgets. I will now invite the superintendent to offer any final comments. >> Wonderful. Thank you, chair. So, in addition to the grants, we're asking the school committee for two additional

301
01:29:50.880 --> 01:30:08.080
approvals tonight as we close out the FY uh 26 year. Chief Financial Officer David Bloom is here to review the items. The first, as the chair said, is the FY27 school trust funds. The second is the FY27 interim salary and non-personnel payments on external

302
01:30:08.080 --> 01:30:25.760
funds, which we presented during the May 6th meeting. >> Um, I know we still have a lot to get to, but Chief Bloom is here. Were you have any questions? Thank you. And I'll just say, you know, we've um been really trying to be more proactive since meeting with the committee last year. Um

303
01:30:25.760 --> 01:30:41.600
we're especially uh proud of progress on the Mary Dorothia Devo award. Um which is one of our most active awards. Um and uh you know, we're working closely with all of the schools involved to make sure that awards are getting out. There

304
01:30:41.600 --> 01:30:57.920
was one just in my inbox yesterday. Um, so we're actively working through each of those items. >> Okay. >> You have a question? Go ahead. >> Um, thank you for these. Just, um, understanding the helpfulness of

305
01:30:57.920 --> 01:31:13.199
frontloading these dollars so that schools can apply them to the benefit of students. Makes sense. just wondering what impact it has on the oversight of expenditures um and just the monitoring of appropriate

306
01:31:13.199 --> 01:31:28.320
spending. Um >> so um since the school committee vote on this last year, we formed a finance trust committee to monitor um the all expenses on and uh our tracker which is like all the requests that come in um to

307
01:31:28.320 --> 01:31:45.600
ensure that all next steps are completed and everything is sort of following um the regulation. Everything so far has been good since um last summer. Um and I will say, you know, we do also have an example of a sort of good news, good news, bad news situation, which is one

308
01:31:45.600 --> 01:32:02.960
of our scholarship funds is actually um now suns setting because we've sp it's spent all of its money um in providing scholarships for our students, which is, you know, wonderful and that it provided all the scholarships it was meant to, but a little bit sad that it's it's coming to the end of its life. And that's the grace as knife scholarship.

309
01:32:02.960 --> 01:32:23.360
So, um, yeah, we're continuing to work and monitor this very actively. >> Thank you. >> No. >> All right. Thank you all. If there no further discussion, I will entertain a motion to approve the fiscal year 2027 school trust funds as presented. Is

310
01:32:23.360 --> 01:32:39.360
there a motion? >> So moved. >> Is there a second? >> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? >> Miss Parvox, will you please call the role? Thank you chair Dr. Alkins. >> Yes. >> Mr. Peralta. >> Yes. >> Miss Palanka Garcia. Miss Torres.

311
01:32:39.360 --> 01:32:53.760
>> Yes. >> Mr. Tran. >> Yes. >> Miss Garage. >> Yes. >> Miss Robinson. >> Yes. >> The motion is approved. >> Thank you. Our next action item is the approval of the fisc year 27 interim salary and non-personnel payments on

312
01:32:53.760 --> 01:33:10.639
external funds. This was presented at the May 6 meeting by Chief Financial Officer David Boom. I will now turn it over to the superintendent for final comments. >> Uh this is just a process that we do each year to enable us to be able to begin to spend money. Um it's really

313
01:33:10.639 --> 01:33:26.560
prefuncter in a lot of ways, but David, I don't know if there's anything else. >> No, I think we discussed it uh in our last meeting and and we're we're definitely um both Marcel and I are here if you have any final questions before the vote. >> Thank you. Any questions? No questions,

314
01:33:26.560 --> 01:33:41.840
but just a reminder from the last meeting that I think we did ask around whether there had been any history of kind of default or incidents with this act and you had replied that there had not. Is that correct? >> Yes, I can confirm that that's correct.

315
01:33:41.840 --> 01:33:58.159
>> Thank you. Okay. >> Thank you. I will now entertain a motion to approve the fiscal year 27 interim salary and non-personnel payments on external funds as presented. Is there a motion? >> So moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Second.

316
01:33:58.159 --> 01:34:13.679
>> Thank you. Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? >> Miss Pavix, will you please call the role? >> Thank you. Dr. Alkins, >> yes. >> Mr. Peralta, >> yes. >> Miss Panco Garcia, Miss Torres, >> yes. >> Mr. Tran, >> yes. >> Miss Garrett, >> yes. >> Miss Robinson, >> yes.

317
01:34:13.679 --> 01:34:29.840
>> The motion is approved. >> Thank you. Our next action item is the approval of the Le Street Neighborhood Charter School Renewal Application. This was presented at the May 6th meeting by Elijah Hexl, principal of Dudley Street Neighborhood um schools and Jesse

318
01:34:29.840 --> 01:34:46.480
Solomon, executive director of BPE. We'll be voting on the following items. Renewal application, accountability plan, memorandum of agreement, revised expulsion policy. I will now turn it over to the superintendent for final

319
01:34:46.480 --> 01:35:02.080
comments. >> Uh great. Thank you, chair. So tonight, uh, we're seeking approval for the Dudley Street Neighborhood Charter Schools charter renewal application. I think if you remember at the last meeting, uh, Principal Hexel, who is, um, awesome, principal of Dudley Street

320
01:35:02.080 --> 01:35:18.800
Neighborhood, uh, sorry, Dudley Street Charter, and Jesse Solomon, who's the executive director of the Boston Plan for Excellence. Uh, they both spoke about the school's academic progress, student outcomes, overall success. The school is requesting votes on four items. The first is the approval of its

321
01:35:18.800 --> 01:35:34.239
application for renewal of its public school charter. The second is its approval of its accountability plan. This outline um includes its intended outcomes and metrics. The third is its approval of the memorandum of agreement between the school's board of trustees

322
01:35:34.239 --> 01:35:50.239
and the Boston plan for excellence which serves as the school's educational management organization. And finally, its revised expulsion policy which aligns to the updated guidance from DESIE. Uh, as I indicated, May 6th, we recommend the renewal. Um, we see

323
01:35:50.239 --> 01:36:06.239
Dudley, although it is a Horus man in district charter as a BPS school. Uh, a little later in the agenda, we're also going to ask the committee to consider updates to the charters of several other Horus man charter schools. Um, just as a technical reminder, Horseman District

324
01:36:06.239 --> 01:36:23.199
charters, they are independent public schools that operate under a five-year charter that's granted by the Commonwealth's Board of Elementary and Secondary Education. We're bringing all of these changes together in a combined presentation in an effort to move all of the necessary governance documents

325
01:36:23.199 --> 01:36:39.440
forward before the end of the school year. It's an effort by our district to help the schools get their approvals as needed. Each Horus man charter school will have an opportunity to present a more complete overview of their school in the fourth year of their respective charter terms as Dudley Street did this

326
01:36:39.440 --> 01:37:03.679
year to this body. >> Questions, comments? >> Yes. >> No, she has something to say, but we'll do it in line right now. I'm just calling for questions, concerns. Okay, before we move to the vote,

327
01:37:03.679 --> 01:37:20.560
>> out of abundance of cautions due to the relationship with Dudley Street School, I am recusing myself from the vote. >> Okay. Thank you. All right. So now I will entertain a motion to approve the Dudley Street neighborhood charter school renewal application, accountability plan, memorandum of

328
01:37:20.560 --> 01:37:36.639
agreement, and revised expulsion policy is presented. Is there is there a motion? >> So move. >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Miss Pavvice, will you please call the role? >> Thank you. Dr. Alkins, >> yes.

329
01:37:36.639 --> 01:37:52.080
>> Mr. Peralta, >> yes. >> Miss Polano Garcia. Miss Torres, >> Mr. Tran? >> Yes. >> Miss Garrett? >> Yes. >> Miss Robinson's? >> Yes. >> The motion is approved. >> Thank you. >> Okay. Our next role is the approval of

330
01:37:52.080 --> 01:38:08.719
two private schools, the Alpha School and the Dunas Ridley School. You'll recall that development officer for strategy, partnerships, and innovation, Ann Clark, presented these schools at the April 15th meeting. As we take this vote, I want to make sure everyone

331
01:38:08.719 --> 01:38:24.960
understands that the school committee's role in this process is to verify that the private schools that come before us have met the criteria recommended by the Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education, Desicy Desi,

332
01:38:24.960 --> 01:38:40.400
which is implemented through the policy established by the school committee in alignment with Massachusetts General Law, Chapter 76, Section One, Boston families, your role is to determine the school that best meets the needs of your

333
01:38:40.400 --> 01:38:56.800
students and families. As the chair of this body, I want to reaffirm our commitment to Boston families. Boston Public Schools takes pride in serving all students and the the diverse needs they bring. I will now turn it over to the superintendent for final comments.

334
01:38:56.800 --> 01:39:13.440
>> Thank you, chair. So, um, tonight we're asking for a vote on two new private schools being proposed in the city of Boston. the Alpha School and the Douglas Ridley School. As was presented at the May 6th meeting, the Alpha School Boston is an independent non- sectarian K to8

335
01:39:13.440 --> 01:39:30.239
school focused on personalized learning with the help of artificial intelligence. The Douglas Ridley School is a K to2 through six school model in the Reglia approach to education which is rooted in equity and anti-racist practice.

336
01:39:30.239 --> 01:39:46.560
Again, I want to be clear. The district's role in this process is strictly administrative. BPS has two primary responsibilities. One, to ensure all private schools seeking approval meet the requirements of Massachusetts general law, and two, make recommendations to superintendent and

337
01:39:46.560 --> 01:40:02.080
the Boston School Committee. The school committee is responsible for approval of any private school wishing to operate within the city of Boston. Both applications meet the district's requirements. We are joined today by JC Fiser, executive vice president of

338
01:40:02.080 --> 01:40:20.320
operations and Dr. Tasha Arnold, head of schools for Alpha School and Douglas Ridley School founder Courtney Schwarz. I would um Ann is Ann Clark is also here were there to be any questions about the applications.

339
01:40:20.320 --> 01:40:38.080
>> Thank you. I'll now open it up to questions and comments from the committee. Um, Dr. Hopkins, >> uh, one thing that I will say that I I think this conversation, um, has brought up for me particularly,

340
01:40:38.080 --> 01:40:55.679
um, has been around clarifying exactly when we say administratively, like what is our oversight and what is our role? um in that sense um particularly because um anything that we do oversee takes resources away from

341
01:40:55.679 --> 01:41:11.040
overseeing our own district. Um and so I think that's a concern that's been brought up for me. I think additionally um it it has already been said um in regard to just the oddity that it is

342
01:41:11.040 --> 01:41:27.119
that we are put in this position um to make decisions on schools that are operating within with within our district. And um the concern that I particularly have with any school

343
01:41:27.119 --> 01:41:43.360
um is truly its commitment to serving all students. And we've already seen an example of it this year where when students weren't appropriately served because for whatever reason the adults in the room couldn't get it together,

344
01:41:43.360 --> 01:42:00.320
um the students are the ones who suffer and the district is is the one that's left picking up the pieces. And so, um, you know, a message to all of our schools that are seeking to operate that, um, yes, we do this in

345
01:42:00.320 --> 01:42:18.639
partnership. Um, but please keep in mind that, um, if to abide by your mission, um, to make space, truly make space for all those students um, who are walking through your halls. Um and um to the to

346
01:42:18.639 --> 01:42:33.280
the families that are considering um any school option that isn't um BPS, those same uh anything that should be considered, we would also ask look at the schools within BPS and see

347
01:42:33.280 --> 01:42:51.360
that our schools also do offer a wide range of options that are available for like your family. Um, and there are resources that are willing to work with you to figure out what those best options are. Um, so, um, I'll stop

348
01:42:51.360 --> 01:43:06.880
there. >> Okay. Anyone else? >> Yeah, I I would love to just, um, echo Dr. Alen's sentiments. I think that the just even coming off of this hour or so

349
01:43:06.880 --> 01:43:23.920
of public comment and the understandable rigor with which we're asking to be uh to apply a lens to our staffing models, the way that we're serving our most vulnerable students, etc., and our obligation um and and honor to continue to work to

350
01:43:23.920 --> 01:43:38.560
do so, and we know we have a lot of work to do. it is an extremely uncomfortable position to evaluate um a potential school on paper uh and then have no more oversight um on this important

351
01:43:38.560 --> 01:43:54.480
initiative. Um the majority of states nationally do not have this practice. >> Um there are some states in New England who do. There are other districts around the state who have not universally approved private schools who have come

352
01:43:54.480 --> 01:44:09.920
before us. And I think it's our duty as a committee to explore all of those best practices to re-evaluate the criteria that we currently have. Um we have a very um saturated market for a declining

353
01:44:09.920 --> 01:44:26.159
student population in the city. >> I think there may need to be an ask of what is missing to Dr. Alen's point of the wide variety of options that already exist. Um, and I think that that research um should really be undertaken

354
01:44:26.159 --> 01:44:47.040
in a rigorous way and in partnership with Desi um before we have this challenge before us again. >> And um I'll chime in. Um having founded a school uh I can say that what lies on paper and what

355
01:44:47.040 --> 01:45:02.719
actually it takes to operationalize it and make it successful are very different things and what happens in those years uh between um there's lots of twists and turn and I think we have an example recently of a school where there may have been excellent intentions

356
01:45:02.719 --> 01:45:19.440
but the result ended up being an extreme disruption for many many families. amilies uh within the city limit. Uh so I would again just encourage the schools that are putting in these applications um the when I look at the guidelines they're very base very very base from

357
01:45:19.440 --> 01:45:35.040
DESI and I think there's just so much more that goes into actually operating a school successfully. Um so we have what we have. I think we uh this is a huge district resource for us and so I think to doc Dr. Alkins point

358
01:45:35.040 --> 01:45:52.480
like Ann Clark has spent a considerable amount of time as have the departments in reviewing the portions that we can review. But again, I just don't I just want to be clear this is just fundamentals. That's it. And once this gets approval, it's really up to the public and to the parents that become

359
01:45:52.480 --> 01:46:11.440
part of those schools uh to hold folks accountable to them >> as okay. uh an understanding that our role in voting on these two private schools are pretty much administrative.

360
01:46:11.440 --> 01:46:31.280
Um I don't see how uh Desi is charging us with some kind of a duty to do something that doesn't have that doesn't carry any weight. assuming just assuming

361
01:46:31.280 --> 01:46:48.880
that our body rejected the applications. Does that stop the schools these private schools from being uh from being um established? I doubt it. So if if we

362
01:46:48.880 --> 01:47:04.239
vote yes or we vote no pretty much we voted uh we will vote based upon our own assessment of the situation. Right. >> Right. Our our job as the district officials is to look at the guidelines

363
01:47:04.239 --> 01:47:22.320
that DESIE has provided uh and to ensure that the schools have checked those boxes. If they have >> then our recommendation needs to be that they be granted to open. >> Right. While I understand that um given the list of jacks that we you know we

364
01:47:22.320 --> 01:47:38.960
must go through in order to assess a school and I I I I do know that your staff has performed the uh the inspection

365
01:47:38.960 --> 01:47:57.199
not only adequately but promptly and thoroughly. I understand that but that doesn't equate to my own assessment of the situation >> and whether my own vote will somehow

366
01:47:57.199 --> 01:48:16.760
uh influence the process or not I doubt it but I just because of that I'll state right here before this board both of the schools I'm going to vote no >> that's my pretty much my my my status my Y

367
01:48:17.520 --> 01:48:32.000
we have nothing. Yeah. >> Um this for several years we've had schools come before us. I think um this year because of a number of issues that have occurred. It's been the first time that

368
01:48:32.000 --> 01:48:49.760
we've done two things. want to look at the um amount of time our own staff take to go through this process. Acknowledging the fact that we are basically um approving competitors at a

369
01:48:49.760 --> 01:49:07.119
time when um resources are short and parents have needs and the needs are great. understanding what happens, for example, when a school that looked great on paper was unable to complete. And then what

370
01:49:07.119 --> 01:49:22.480
happens with when the district had to open its arms quickly to be able to provide opportunities for those families that we don't know whether or not they will take advantage of, but this district steps up. So, there's a lot of

371
01:49:22.480 --> 01:49:38.639
resources coming out of the district. Um, right now we have the we have the process that we have, but before we get to this point next year, Superintendent, we're really asking that you and Desi sit down for us to take a different look

372
01:49:38.639 --> 01:49:55.440
at this because we do not if if nothing else, um, we should be paid for our time to do the work and it's been a significant amount of work. I know that in the past there have been other schools that have started the process but were not approved at the district

373
01:49:55.440 --> 01:50:11.840
level so they never came before us. >> Um it would be great if we could even take a look at over the past decade how many applications have been both successful how many have not gotten to the end but also what is happening with those schools

374
01:50:11.840 --> 01:50:28.400
>> so that we can also make sure that families and others um are aware of it. The other issue is that this the assumption was often that schools that were being proposed would be bringing new ideas or doing things differently to

375
01:50:28.400 --> 01:50:44.719
add value so that they would not be duplicating what was already in existence. And I'm not sure if our application critically looks at those issues as well. So, we have we have what we have for this evening and the information that we have, but we're

376
01:50:44.719 --> 01:50:58.960
asking that as we move forward in the future that we take a very close look at this so that um we can be sure that we're moving in the right direction. >> Thank you, Chair. >> So, at this moment, I will now entertain a motion to approve the alpha school as

377
01:50:58.960 --> 01:51:16.239
presented. Is there a motion? >> So, moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second? Second. Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Miss Pix, will you please call the RO? >> Thank you, Chair. Dr. Alkins. >> Yes. >> Mr. Peralta,

378
01:51:16.239 --> 01:51:32.159
>> I am boring. Yes. This private school have met the criteria set forward by the Massachusetts Department of Education to operate in our city. >> Miss Panco Garcia. Miss Torres. >> Yes. >> Mr. Tran. Oh,

379
01:51:32.159 --> 01:51:51.080
>> Miss Garrett. >> Yes. Miss Robinson. >> Yes. >> The alpha school is approved with um five. No, sorry. >> One two

380
01:51:51.199 --> 01:52:08.320
one. >> Yeah. Five and one. Thank you. >> Okay. I will now entertain a motion to approve the Douglas Ridley School as presented. Is there a motion? So moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second?

381
01:52:08.320 --> 01:52:23.679
>> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Miss Pravic, will you please call the role? >> Thank you. Dr. Alkins, >> yes. >> Mr. Peralta, >> yes. >> Miss Pano Garcia, Miss Torres, >> yes.

382
01:52:23.679 --> 01:52:40.719
>> Mr. Tran, >> no. >> Miss Garrett, >> yes. >> Miss Robinson, >> yes. The Douglas Whitney School is approved with five yays. >> Thank you.

383
01:52:40.719 --> 01:52:56.639
All right. Our next action item is the approval of the artificial intelligent policy that was presented at the May 6th meeting. I will now turn it over to the superintendent for final comments. >> Uh wonderful. Thank you, chair. So at the May 6th meeting, PPS chief

384
01:52:56.639 --> 01:53:11.920
technology officer Lisa II and the deputy chief of teaching and learning Tony Beatatrice presented the district's proposed AI or artificial intelligence policy and guidelines. This work started more than three years ago with the release of the district's initial AI

385
01:53:11.920 --> 01:53:28.159
guidelines. This year, following a thorough community engagement process, we developed this draft policy. The proposed policy does several things. It provides clear guidelines for safe, responsible, and ethical use. It includes strong student safety

386
01:53:28.159 --> 01:53:45.360
protections, clear expectations for academic integrity, and requirements for AI training and literacy for both students and staff. The policy defines the boundaries that will govern AI usage and the guidelines define how we will work within those boundaries. Policy and

387
01:53:45.360 --> 01:54:00.320
guidelines are designed to work together. Right now, BPS is incorporating AI into student learning to enhance students understanding and critical thinking. Our goal is to enhance outcomes, not replace human interaction or instruction.

388
01:54:00.320 --> 01:54:21.119
Tonight, we ask the school committee to vote in favor of this policy. And Lisa and Tony are here with us. >> Thank you. I'll now open it up to questions and comments from the committee. Thank you. I I just want for the record

389
01:54:21.119 --> 01:54:36.400
to clarify that yesterday um I have a a long conversation with with the department about particular issue that I have been approached by families of the district and our concerns on my own families about the

390
01:54:36.400 --> 01:54:53.920
unfortunate and misuse of interf artificial intelligent to create um photos of students mostly girls with a object with a objective of basically sexual harassment. Um, we had

391
01:54:53.920 --> 01:55:09.920
a long conversation about how what the policy can do about this. I was told that it is included when it says that AI cannot be used for any kind of discrimination. I also was told that it's going to be included in the Q&A

392
01:55:09.920 --> 01:55:26.080
that's going to appear as part of the of the process. Um, I'm going to leave it there. I think as we were told in the last meeting, this must be a living document given the nature of what we are

393
01:55:26.080 --> 01:55:44.400
treating here, which is changing by the minute. I I would really appreciate if you keep an eye on this. Thank you. You >> I have two questions. I'm wondering if um you could narrate any adjustments or

394
01:55:44.400 --> 01:56:01.440
additional um thinking in relation to the policy since the presentation. If um I know that there's been a lot of community engagement, if there was any new information that affected wording of the policy, additions, um deletions

395
01:56:01.440 --> 01:56:18.239
since the full presentation at um a previous meeting. >> Yeah. So there's not a lot of change specifically in the wording in this current version. I think um what we're doing is updating the FAQ sheet with things that we have learned um that we

396
01:56:18.239 --> 01:56:32.639
want to include in the next version of the guidelines. So we met with the students for example from Sociad Latina um and one of the things that we heard there was about when educators are using AI detection

397
01:56:32.639 --> 01:56:50.719
tools for example sometimes those AI tools um will say that a student used generative AI to create um a a piece of writing from scratch when in fact a student might have been using a a translation device that was approved um

398
01:56:50.719 --> 01:57:06.320
and readily available to that student, but because there was an AI portion on the back end of that, it popped up on the AI detector. Um and so we want to call that out along with anytime that um a student is using a online tool um that's part of their accommodation or

399
01:57:06.320 --> 01:57:23.679
modification within their IEP. Um so now that AI isn't being embedded in so many of the um online tools that we're using, we need to make sure that our faculty and staff are aware of that. Um and so we've inputed that in our FAQ sheet. Um

400
01:57:23.679 --> 01:57:39.440
and then additionally talking about there was a question from the school committee about how we're going to um really meet as a district and what are the metrics that we're going to look at and and who's going to take a look at those metrics and we're going to develop a steering committee. Um and one of the

401
01:57:39.440 --> 01:57:55.119
things that came up associated with Latina was making sure that the student voice was being heard. Um and so we want to make sure that we have students on those committees going forward. And so we've added that in the FAQ sheet as well. >> Thank you. Um just extending um member

402
01:57:55.119 --> 01:58:10.560
Peralta's point around how this policy intersects with existing policies. I think it's also just worth underscoring that there are a lot of links and connections to other key documents in these guidelines. um particularly the

403
01:58:10.560 --> 01:58:26.239
BPSA at eye guidelines which give a lot more detail around kind of teaching and learning expectations with this document being more of like a goals and gu like a guard rails document um or kind of a guiding principles document there's also

404
01:58:26.239 --> 01:58:43.440
a reference to the code of conduct there references to Massachusetts state guidelines um so would you know just encourage that um lens with a read of understanding this as a key addition to those other um foundational documents.

405
01:58:43.440 --> 01:59:01.520
Um but my last question is related to how fast this is going to move and appreciate the language about revisiting the policy annually. Um but a lot of the work that's going to be most relevant to educators are best practices related to the use of AI both for themselves and

406
01:59:01.520 --> 01:59:17.599
for their students. Um there will be situations that come up next week that have never happened before. uh and schools will be looking to the central office for guidance around those. Um I understand the steering committee is kind of an ongoing body to look at the

407
01:59:17.599 --> 01:59:33.920
policy. But is there a centralized point of contact for a school leader to be able to call with a new situation um as related to teaching and learning or some issue in their building uh and its connection to AI? >> That's a really great question. Um uh I

408
01:59:33.920 --> 01:59:49.679
am that contact for anyone who has questions and in addition to the steering committee for using this document and our guidelines to govern the use of AI and decide whether or not we want to pursue new initiatives and

409
01:59:49.679 --> 02:00:05.840
how we're going to roll that out thoughtfully. Um there will be a a separate and higher level executive oversight committee made up of um chief officers and deputy superintendent who

410
02:00:05.840 --> 02:00:22.320
will be one step higher making some of those higher level decisions for the district um and taking recommendations from the steering committee um on how we move this forward. So the governing structure will be multi-layered um and making sure that there's voice

411
02:00:22.320 --> 02:00:39.360
represented um across levels >> and I appreciate it that it's both of you in partnership for example like kind of on the tech side and the teaching and learning and would just think about how that continues for those phone calls

412
02:00:39.360 --> 02:00:55.520
because I think some of the phone calls will not be related to tech they will be related to best practices in terms of classroom room use and so it actually might need to be directed to teaching and learning more so and so thinking about what that guidance is for school

413
02:00:55.520 --> 02:01:12.400
leaders in terms of how to get um how to get that clarity. >> Absolutely. Thank you. >> Yeah, I also think uh student conduct will be another through line and so there'll absolutely be this interdep departmental uh overseeing.

414
02:01:12.400 --> 02:01:27.760
>> I have I have a question. Um it have to do with our second language learners and I know that uh this the entire toolkit is in English and um how were there the multilingual and uh the different

415
02:01:27.760 --> 02:01:44.400
community with different languages were included as part of knowing the needs and what the the expectations are when it comes to AI. >> Yes. So when we did our community engagements this spring, all of our materials we had translated into the

416
02:01:44.400 --> 02:02:03.280
major BPS languages and um we held Zoom that was able to handle translation in in their native language. Um and then once we get um this policy approved and we have our guidelines updated um those

417
02:02:03.280 --> 02:02:19.679
will also be translated into our major languages for our multilingual families. Is this a this is going to be like the this policy going to be a mandate or is it a choice by school

418
02:02:19.679 --> 02:02:36.960
you know uh all the schools in Boston public school will be using this policy or is it something that is only what so so if it's yes what about the schools in the community that cannot afford or are disadvantaged when it

419
02:02:36.960 --> 02:02:53.679
comes to internet and all that. What happens there? >> I mean, all of our schools are equipped with network. So, we have internet at every single site. We've equipped every school with one device per student and

420
02:02:53.679 --> 02:03:09.520
all of our like all of our teachers, all of our staff um at the school, they have internet. And so, I want to be clear, this is not a mandate that we are making people use AI. This is a policy saying we're protecting you

421
02:03:09.520 --> 02:03:26.639
>> with this policy and what we are mandating is that you learn about AI because it's already being used in your life and you're being impacted by this technology and you deserve to understand how.

422
02:03:26.639 --> 02:03:42.400
>> Yeah. So probably professional development around um what are the guard rails um so students, teachers and everyone involved that be using this will be aware of where to do it and what where to go. >> Yes.

423
02:03:42.400 --> 02:03:57.119
>> When anything happens when it comes to AI >> correct? >> Correct. And we already we we've heard from the students um many many times at school committee they're really asking for this. They they want the guardrails.

424
02:03:57.119 --> 02:04:13.119
>> They want to become >> um int like they want to understand and become proficient >> at >> the components of AI that are going to make them, >> you know, an ethical user of it, a

425
02:04:13.119 --> 02:04:27.920
responsible user of it. Um and they're really not getting that anywhere else. >> And so that's why much like education in general, it's incumbent on us >> to bring that to them. And I think that's they've done an excellent job doing that.

426
02:04:27.920 --> 02:04:44.880
>> Yeah. I think in addition also that it training is going to be made available to all of us because many of us have very li limited understanding as well. So that we'll be able to um participate first in the you know personal online

427
02:04:44.880 --> 02:05:01.599
training that is provided to district staff and then in addition there is other training once we get that foundational piece. So I feel it's just as important that we understand >> what it is we have a policy for and understanding what is going on in our

428
02:05:01.599 --> 02:05:18.480
schools making sure everybody including ourselves. Yes. Absolutely. >> And chair I'm sorry just that made me think about one other piece too when we're thinking about professional learning for students around use and being judicious around that use. I think

429
02:05:18.480 --> 02:05:36.239
>> building in um and underscoring when not using um when not using AI is um more appropriate um some of the disproportionate use by demographic groups that's coming out uh in terms of research in terms of overuse and over

430
02:05:36.239 --> 02:05:52.880
reliance on AI to complete assignments um particularly for populations of color I think is is also really important and if there's some way to also include um the impact on the environment um on for things like data centers etc. Um that

431
02:05:52.880 --> 02:06:12.320
all go into students understanding of responsible use um and being um really um equipped and informed consumers of what's available to them. >> Okay, everybody set? Okay. All right, then. I

432
02:06:12.320 --> 02:06:28.000
will now entertain a motion to approve the artificial intelligence policy as presented. Is there a motion? >> So moved. >> Is there a second? >> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Miss Pravix, will you please call the >> Thank you, Chair. Dr. Alkins, >> yes.

433
02:06:28.000 --> 02:06:43.840
>> Mr. Peralta, >> yes. >> Miss Pelanka Garcia, Miss Torres, >> yes. >> Mr. Tran, >> yes. >> Miss Garrett, >> yes. >> Miss Robinson, >> yes. >> The policies approved. >> Thank you. Thank you. >> Thank you. Nice job. >> Thank you. >> Yeah.

434
02:06:43.840 --> 02:06:58.880
>> Our final vote tonight is the approval of the 2026 policy to advance academic excellence and eliminate opportunity and achievement gaps as presented at the April 15th meeting. I want to invite the superintendent to give following

435
02:06:58.880 --> 02:07:15.760
following remarks final sorry final remarks. >> Wonderful. Thank you chair. Um, so as we presented on April 15th, the intent of the opportunity achievement gaps policy is to close opportunity and achievement gaps for every single student in the district with a focus on groups that

436
02:07:15.760 --> 02:07:31.679
have been historically marginalized and ensure they have the opportunity to reach their full potential. After nearly a decade since the policy was updated, delayed in part to the pandemic, we ask the committee to approve this new policy. Dr. Colin Rose, members of my

437
02:07:31.679 --> 02:07:48.159
team, and the OAG task force that guides the district's work are working to seamlessly align the goals of the policy and the strategic goals of the district. There's several members of the task force in attendance tonight and joining us online for tonight's vote. I want to

438
02:07:48.159 --> 02:08:13.920
acknowledge them and ask them to stand so they can be recognized for their great work. Senior adviser for strategy and opportunity gaps, Dr. Rose, the OAG task force co-chairs, Ayelli Shakur, and as well as school committee member Dr. Alkins are here to provide any

439
02:08:13.920 --> 02:08:28.320
additional information you need. As a district, my team and I see this policy as incredibly thorough and critical northstar for the goals we set in the work we do now and in the years to come. So with this I'll turn back to chair.

440
02:08:28.320 --> 02:08:48.400
>> Okay. So I'll now retain questions, comments. >> I just I just want to say you are a beautiful sight to see. >> Thank you so much. I trust you as very intelligent and capable people. You

441
02:08:48.400 --> 02:09:10.079
brought us here. Now let's h help us to implement this policy and not come back in 10 years and say we got to do it again because we are basically in the same place. I trust you. Thank you. Um just also want to express

442
02:09:10.079 --> 02:09:25.440
appreciation for um the thoughtfulness and work that goes into this set of goals and objectives and the collaborative nature of um you know key invested constituents who move this forward both in and out of the district.

443
02:09:25.440 --> 02:09:44.159
Um I would um love if a little bit of narration in terms of what the expected like crosswalk or relation between the forthcoming strategic plan and what we're voting on this evening will how they live together um both in relation

444
02:09:44.159 --> 02:09:59.840
to like will all of these things literally show up in the the plan? Will the plan be in service of these? Um will kind of the the measures by which we update our success be reflective in both um just

445
02:09:59.840 --> 02:10:16.480
any forecasting um around what to expect um with that would be helpful. Thank you. as as much as we can. I believe that our strategic plan should be in service of this policy and align to this policy, right? So that the metrics and I know we've had conversations around

446
02:10:16.480 --> 02:10:31.199
school committee metrics but also the KPIs for for the uh strategic plan align to the values and the the things that are being asked to be measured in the OEG policy. So I mean the experience of having implemented a OEG policy with a

447
02:10:31.199 --> 02:10:47.599
strategic plan on the other side uh and having people serve two major documents uh in the district and focus is what I think we want to avoid. Um and so as much as we can uh we need to outline exactly what we're doing as a district in our strategic plan and make specific

448
02:10:47.599 --> 02:11:03.199
crosswalk to uh the policy and speak to it. That will really be the ongoing work of the task force is to to really monitor sort of working with uh Dr. Rose as he's working with his district working groups

449
02:11:03.199 --> 02:11:20.560
um to develop the actual goals the smart goals that will be in the strategic plan and the implementation component and to make sure they they crosswalk with the policy. So, we'll be looking at the KPIs. We'll be looking at, you know, lots of different things and reporting

450
02:11:20.560 --> 02:11:36.719
back to the school committee on a regular basis. >> Yeah. The only other thing is, you know, I know the school committee is working on kind of a cadence of where you want to see certain topics and we've been talking about how we could use the OG policy um and task force meetings to deepen some of those conversations

451
02:11:36.719 --> 02:11:51.760
because again, the stuff that we do as a district and we're prioritizing should be aligned to this policy. So, how do we do deeper dives in those task force meeting where there's more dialogue and back and forth with some experts uh to really uh take a look at what we're doing and and the data that's connected

452
02:11:51.760 --> 02:12:09.040
to it? >> Yes. >> Um I had an opportunity to uh observe uh you guys at work uh two weeks ago, three weeks, I don't remember. I I I would

453
02:12:09.040 --> 02:12:28.719
have to say that you comprised of a group of well educated, well learned and very much uh committed to uh the interest of the

454
02:12:28.719 --> 02:12:45.119
students. I and and and I do see that during that that um meeting the only thing the only thing that I I I'm I'm thinking that you are facing

455
02:12:45.119 --> 02:13:02.480
pretty diff you know difficulty right now a pretty uh a difficult situation is that there are two of us who are before you for a vote I wish uh that I I I I don't know

456
02:13:02.480 --> 02:13:19.360
what happened but you know I wish that both of us I not me but you know both of of of my committee members can join you and assist you you know in in your work given the fact that um

457
02:13:19.360 --> 02:13:36.320
Dr. Alpens has been there for quite a while. I I I I I know he he he he's missing his friends, but uh if you have to make a decision on on the two candidates, uh please be discreet.

458
02:13:36.320 --> 02:13:52.880
It's it's it's not going to be easy. But and one more thing I like to remind you I I know that the policy is somehow uh a mirror or for lack of better term

459
02:13:52.880 --> 02:14:13.280
is mirror imaging our u strategic plan. But then again during the school year, during our our performance of our duty, of course, there are times that we lose sight of our uh of of our strategic plan. And you

460
02:14:13.280 --> 02:14:29.920
are the people that could hit on our head and make sure that we stay in line, stay, you know, within the the within the boundary of of of the road. Okay. So uh please keep that in mind

461
02:14:29.920 --> 02:14:46.639
because I am a very forgetful guy. So please make sure that I I I get hit in the head as frequently as possible. Thank you. >> I have one one question for you guys on goal. So I was reading the goals and

462
02:14:46.639 --> 02:15:02.639
objectives like I was told and on uh goal three advance academic excellent contains 11 objectives. How are we prioritizing? How we attack this? Which goes first?

463
02:15:02.639 --> 02:15:18.239
How are we doing that as a task force? How would you go about doing it? >> And I I think that um you know, goal three, which is specifically on academics, >> is really looking at um all of the levers that the district is already

464
02:15:18.239 --> 02:15:33.920
focused on, but we want that laser focus to really continue. Um, I think one of the the ways that it crosswalks with the strategic plan already is the literacy goal is really elevated. The equitable literacy is elevated in the strategic

465
02:15:33.920 --> 02:15:49.760
plan um as a as a starting point as well as um inclusion. We've heard a lot tonight about inclusion and the needs to get that right and I think that's um reflected as well. So all of those things are happening. You have an amazing superintendent. Skipper has an

466
02:15:49.760 --> 02:16:05.760
amazing team that's hard at work. And so all of those things are moving along all 11 of those goals. But I think that that's um literacy is where it all starts. Um including numerousy, right? Because you need to computation is also part of literacy and making sure young

467
02:16:05.760 --> 02:16:20.960
people across all content areas and grade levels are reading at or above grade level. It's really important. >> Yeah. and and all that those 11 objectives should be connected to what what we say is high quality instruction which is kind of that overarching

468
02:16:20.960 --> 02:16:36.479
umbrella to that first objective in the upcoming >> there will be criteria as to when we do meet or >> I mean to me everything is in in in implement it uh it gets spelled out in implementation right so what are we focusing on what are our strategies and what are we working on

469
02:16:36.479 --> 02:16:53.280
>> so sorry and so like one of the ways that the data will sort of inform the uh the task force will be able to come back and make very more specific recommendations I think to what you're talking about. And then for us, I think where the rubber meets the road really will come down to budget

470
02:16:53.280 --> 02:17:07.760
season like in particular. So like when we're really thinking about >> not wanting to in a in a year like we just saw um wanting to you know mitigate learning loss for example um and maintain all of the gains that we made

471
02:17:07.760 --> 02:17:23.519
across like the district. Um so it will really depend on um that's like one where where we have the lever as a school committee to really think about it. >> Thank you. >> Mhm. Yeah. And I would just add that I think this is the deep work that the

472
02:17:23.519 --> 02:17:39.679
working groups and the uh the deputies and the chiefs are working on right now and will be throughout the summer which is to really look to make sure that we've accounted for each of the goals where they are the baselines and then the disagregation of them which I think

473
02:17:39.679 --> 02:17:55.040
is incredibly important >> um that hasn't been done consistently in the district. So, and I think that's something that school committee has also asked for as well relative to, you know, its measures. So, I think there's really great alignment and I can just say from

474
02:17:55.040 --> 02:18:10.240
my perspective that's half the key to success is having that alignment, having a strong implementation plan and having a task force that's willing to walk with us in that accountability. >> Yeah. >> All I can say to you is um

475
02:18:10.240 --> 02:18:26.479
congratulations. um 20 years ago plus this work began. Um and this district has always given lip service to the fact that this was important work. >> What I feel is different now that there

476
02:18:26.479 --> 02:18:44.240
is a partnership between the task force and the district to move the work forward. Um it's the best shot that we will have ever had. um to you I thank you for being the fearless consistent leader for the past decade um through

477
02:18:44.240 --> 02:19:01.120
thick and thin and through all the other iterations of many people there many folks sitting in this room that have been on this journey for at least the past 11 years 12 years some people who are at the reiterated um task force but

478
02:19:01.120 --> 02:19:16.880
also to the energy and excitement that the new members ers bring and returning bring um that as we look at the strategic plan and this this um the OG

479
02:19:16.880 --> 02:19:32.800
work together. Um as I say it it feels like the best shot that we will have to actually beginning to make some real movement on the um strategic plan. So so thank you and I know the work is just

480
02:19:32.800 --> 02:19:48.319
beginning certainly not over. This is just turning the first page in it. So, let's get on with the vote for tonight. >> Thank you, Chair Robinson. And I just want to just take a moment to just thank and acknowledge you for being the co-chair, working with me on the the

481
02:19:48.319 --> 02:20:05.520
task force for those 10 years. Um, and just, you know, what a testament that is to your strength to be chairing the school committee, but also serving as co-chair of the task force because that work was deeply important to you and important to the district. So, thank you. >> Yep. some of the most important work we

482
02:20:05.520 --> 02:20:22.080
continuously say we need to do in this district and now hopefully we'll be able to move forward on it. So I will now entertain a motion to approve the 2026 policy to advance academic excellence and eliminate opportunity and achievement gaps as presented. I'm going

483
02:20:22.080 --> 02:20:39.200
to read the motion so it's clear what we're voting on. ordered that the Boston School Committee hereby approves the opportunity and achievement gaps OAG policy goals and objectives outlined in the attached document. This approval

484
02:20:39.200 --> 02:20:55.840
applies only to the goals and objectives and does not constitute approval of any accompanying recommendations. >> Is there a motion? >> So moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Second. >> There any discussion or objection to the motion? this props. Will you please call the

485
02:20:55.840 --> 02:21:12.000
role >> chair? Dr. Alkins. >> Yes. >> Mr. Peralta. >> With a lot of hope and excitement. Yes. >> Garcia. Miss Torres. >> Yes. >> Mr. Tran. >> You guys are Thors. You hold the hammer.

486
02:21:12.000 --> 02:21:33.600
That hammer away the lip service. >> Yes. >> Miss Garrett. >> Yes. >> Miss Robinson. >> Yes. The OG policy is approved. >> Thank you. Thank you so much. We will now transition to reports. And again, since we have a full agenda

487
02:21:33.600 --> 02:21:48.560
tonight, I'd like to ask all presenters to please be mindful of their aotted times. Our first presentation tonight is the Horus man charter governing updates. Let's try to keep this presentation to under 12 minutes. I'd like to remind our

488
02:21:48.560 --> 02:22:05.359
presenters to please speak at a slower pace to assist our interpreters and I want to invite the superintendent to give introductory remarks. >> Wonderful. So, the horseman charter schools require updates to their charter documents as part of the standard

489
02:22:05.359 --> 02:22:21.840
renewal process and occasionally when changes are made to the technical guidance from the state. The reason these documents are coming forward now rather than with the typical charter renewal timelines is because they are either one-offs like the expulsion policy or they weren't ready in time for

490
02:22:21.840 --> 02:22:37.200
those presentations like the accountability policy. So this language gives a little bit of that flexibility. These charter governing updates require school committee approval as well as approval from the charter schools boards of trustees, the Boston teachers union,

491
02:22:37.200 --> 02:22:52.479
and the department of elementary and secondary education. There are several items before you tonight. BPS development officer for strategy, partnerships, and innovation. Ann Clark will lead the presentation and walk you through the process. Um there's

492
02:22:52.479 --> 02:23:07.840
representatives. We have a star cast here tonight. Uh we have Allison Hermick from um BDA. Karen Walker Gregory head of school at EMK, Patina Toner, the lawyer representing BDA and EMK. Uh BGA

493
02:23:07.840 --> 02:23:23.280
school leader, Boston Green Academy, Matt Holtzer sitting in the back. Uh and Mike Bower, chief operating officer of UP uh education network. Oh, she he's joining us remotely. and a representation from our office of legal

494
02:23:23.280 --> 02:23:39.760
uh who is our office of legal advisor Lorenzo D Silvio. So with that I will turn it to Ann. Good evening madame chair, madame vice chair and members of the school committee this evening. I am presenting governance

495
02:23:39.760 --> 02:23:56.560
documents from our five Horus man charter schools for your approval. I will begin with a brief overview of Horus man charter schools and then I will turn it over to my esteemed colleagues. As Superintendent Skipper mentioned, there are many members of BPS

496
02:23:56.560 --> 02:24:15.359
staff and Horus man charters here tonight to answer any questions you may have. Horus man charter schools were created by the Massachusetts legislature in 1997 as a middle path between traditional district schools and independent

497
02:24:15.359 --> 02:24:32.720
Commonwealth charter schools offering charter-like autonomy while maintaining union membership and a close district partnership. All five operating Horus man charters in Massachusetts are located in Boston. Teachers at all five

498
02:24:32.720 --> 02:24:49.359
schools remain BTU members, acrew seniority, and are paid according to the BTU salary schedule. Autonomies of a horseman charter school include the following. Horseman operating funds come directly from the

499
02:24:49.359 --> 02:25:04.479
district where the school is located. A horseman's budget allocation must be consistent with other public schools in the district. Other federal, state, and private funds come directly to the horseman charter school.

500
02:25:04.479 --> 02:25:21.439
Horse mans are attended are intended to be autonomous to the extent provided by the terms of their charters. Boris man charter schools may be exempt from local collective bargaining agreements and all union and school committee work rules

501
02:25:21.439 --> 02:25:37.120
provided that employees of the school will continue to be members of the local collective bargaining unit to acrew seniority and to receive at minimum the salary and benefits established by the local collective bargaining agreement.

502
02:25:37.120 --> 02:25:53.840
The documents before you tonight fall into four categories. with BPS and the BTU accountability plans, mission statement and enrollment policy updates and expulsion policies. On the expulsion

503
02:25:53.840 --> 02:26:11.600
policies specifically, DESIE recently updated its requirements and all five schools are required to revise their policies accordingly. All documents before you have received provisional DESIE approval where required. Your vote tonight enables

504
02:26:11.600 --> 02:26:29.840
final submission to the commissioner. Boston public schools, as I said, has five Horus man charter schools. Three are secondary schools. Two are elementary schools. There are two relevant subtypes of Horus man charter schools. Type one schools, Boston and

505
02:26:29.840 --> 02:26:46.880
Evening Academy and the Edward M. Kennedy Academy for Health Careers require approval from both the BTU and the school committee. Type three schools, Boston Green Academy, Dudley Street Neighborhood Charter School, and UP Academy Doorchester require school

506
02:26:46.880 --> 02:27:03.280
committee approval with good faith BTU negotiation. The demographics of each school are listed here and this information was also in your cover memo. All of these schools have required some document updates this year.

507
02:27:03.280 --> 02:27:19.760
In summary, the specific documents you have before you this evening are as follows. For EMK, you have an accountability plan and an updated application enrollment policy. for BDEA, a revised mission statement and

508
02:27:19.760 --> 02:27:37.840
accountability plan for both BDEA and EMK jointly MOUA with BPS and for BDEA MOUB with the BTU and finally for BDEA, EMK, Boston Green, and UP Academy

509
02:27:37.840 --> 02:27:55.120
Doorchester updated expulsion policies. Please note that Dudley Street Neighborhood Charter School submitted its comparable documents alongside its charter renew presentation on May 6th and you voted on these documents earlier in the evening. I now pass off the

510
02:27:55.120 --> 02:28:11.840
presentation to Dr. Karen Walker Gregory. >> Good evening everyone. Just wanted to summarize the our accountability plan. Every five years we are required to submit a five-year accountability plan

511
02:28:11.840 --> 02:28:27.200
and we're actually in our third year of it but we needed final um approval from DESIE board of trustees and now requires obviously the school committee approval. The three main elements are positive school culture,

512
02:28:27.200 --> 02:28:42.800
health careers preparation and college readiness. When we talk about positive school culture, we're really really looking at positive responses on Panorama climate survey and we're really looking at increasing engagement in

513
02:28:42.800 --> 02:29:00.000
extracurricular activities. When we talk about health careers preparation, we're looking in our lovely CNA and ENT credentials that our students are earning each and every year and looking at reflections on engagement with health careers exposure activities

514
02:29:00.000 --> 02:29:16.640
in collaboration with Mass General Bighgam. When we talk about college readiness, we're looking at 75% of the seniors enroll in and pass at least one AP class dual enrollment early college or DESIE advanced course. We're looking also at

515
02:29:16.640 --> 02:29:34.160
95% of all graduates admitted to a two or four-year college. And we're using u MAP testing uh to measure growth in ELA and math. Those are the three big bul bullet points around accountability. The next

516
02:29:34.160 --> 02:29:48.960
one is charter enroll uh charter amendment around enrollment policy and application. And this is just really a request that was um Desi asked us to update our enrollment and application and so that we're in alignment with

517
02:29:48.960 --> 02:30:06.319
their their guidelines. So now it aligns EMK practices with more recent detailed desi guidance. It incorporates our approved enrollment maximum and our expanded CTE. It also clarifies um and uh accepts new students into grades 9

518
02:30:06.319 --> 02:30:23.439
and 10. Reflects a shift from paper applications to online application. It establishes clear non-discrimination and privacy protection policies and simplifies application questions. It now establishes enrollment preferences for

519
02:30:23.439 --> 02:30:40.960
siblings o of VMK students and VPS students >> and we um also continue with a lottery process and we all um we have received preliminary approval granted already by the desi charter school office.

520
02:30:40.960 --> 02:30:58.240
Now we're going to move on to Boston D. >> Good evening. Um thank you for the opportunity to present. It's been a while since BDA has been here and there's a lot of new members. So, we welcome the opportunity to introduce our school to the school committee. Um, our first document is the mission statement.

521
02:30:58.240 --> 02:31:15.200
Um, the mission statement defines the school's role and purpose within the Boston public school landscape. Um, back in 2018, uh, we engaged our community to revise the statement as part of our strategic planning process. Uh these revisions

522
02:31:15.200 --> 02:31:31.280
were made through a collaborative process that included input from students, staff, and the board of trustees. Um perhaps the students were most um articulate about how they wanted this mission statement to be changed. Um the revisions um are intentionally

523
02:31:31.280 --> 02:31:46.640
removing deficitbased language and center and centers student voice and experience. Move on to next. And then, excuse me, the next document is our accountability plan. Um, similar

524
02:31:46.640 --> 02:32:03.600
to EMK, this was created in uh 2324. Um, and this one is uh significantly different than EMK's because we are an alternative school. Um, at in 2324, DESIE established new alternative ed

525
02:32:03.600 --> 02:32:19.600
school guidelines in partnership with alt ed leaders and researchers. unique to ALT ed, we were asked to group our students into engagement phases. And I think this is a pretty unique um feature of our accountability plan. Students

526
02:32:19.600 --> 02:32:36.960
were grouped based on uh historical data um and trends that we saw in our data, but they're grouped by connected, partially connected, and minimally connected. And we then set up goals um for students that fell into those three categories. Um our accountability plan

527
02:32:36.960 --> 02:32:53.280
includes goals for each of our key design principles. So we have academic growth and achievement and that is where the engagement levels are um specific goals excuse me for students in those um in those phases and then we have post-graduate readiness goals and social

528
02:32:53.280 --> 02:33:14.720
emotional development um goals. Um, this accountability plan now serves as our strategic plan. >> Thank you. Good evening. My name is Betina Toner. Uh, I'm a partner at the law firm of Citus and Blue Steam. K&B is proud to represent four of the five

529
02:33:14.720 --> 02:33:32.560
Horus man charter schools, EMK, BDEA, Austin Green Academy, and UP Academy Dorchester. I'm going to provide a brief background on EMK and BDEA's recent updates to their memoranda of understanding with BPS and BDEA's

530
02:33:32.560 --> 02:33:50.479
with the BTU. I will also briefly describe the basis for recent updates to the expulsion policies for EMK, BDEA, BGAA and UAD. First, a bit of background on the memoranda of understanding or MOUAS. As

531
02:33:50.479 --> 02:34:07.200
you saw on a previous slide, in accordance with the Massachusetts charter school statute, Horus man charter schools have an MOUA uh with BPS that defines services and facilities to be provided by the district to charter to Horus man charter schools and which

532
02:34:07.200 --> 02:34:22.399
states the funding of the charter school by the district and also certain Horus man charter schools as you heard also have what's called anub with the local collective bargaining units which describe any waiverss to applicable

533
02:34:22.399 --> 02:34:39.120
collective bargaining agreements. This slide provides at a high level um the key provisions that eachou has historically included. Um so it's a bit of a laundry list. I won't read it. It's in the materials. Um the items highlighted on the list are the ones

534
02:34:39.120 --> 02:34:57.280
that have most significantly um have been most significantly updated in the most um in the current versions that are before you. I will describe those updates in more detail on the next slide. >> So, first, as part of the recent

535
02:34:57.280 --> 02:35:13.280
renegotiations regarding EMK and BDEA's MOUA, um those schools have made a couple of notable updates from the last versions of those. First with respect to EMK and BDEASUAS,

536
02:35:13.280 --> 02:35:31.760
BPS and BPS and EMK and BDEA have made changes to their current to better distinguish between certain discretionary and non-discretionary services provided by BPS to each horseman charter school. Discretionary

537
02:35:31.760 --> 02:35:48.800
services are those services that are provided those services that the Horus man's charter school can elect to receive from BPS and pay BPS for the non-discretionary services are those services provided by BPS to the Horus

538
02:35:48.800 --> 02:36:05.760
man charter school at no extra cost to the to the school to the charter school and are generally services that are provided to other BPS schools. past practice was for certain um certain services such as the use of BPS's office

539
02:36:05.760 --> 02:36:22.800
of legal advisor um office for civil rights and certain special education and student discipline services to be provided to BDA and EMK by BPS as essentially non-discretionary services as they would be provided to to other

540
02:36:22.800 --> 02:36:38.000
BPS schools. the the new MOUA for EMK and BDEA shifts the designation of those services to to the discretionary bucket so to speak and adds provision for BPS funding for EMK

541
02:36:38.000 --> 02:36:55.040
and BDEA to pay for certain independent legal counsel for certain matters. This is a positive addition for uh for BDA and EMK and BPS in that it helps to avoid legal risk for BPS and the torist

542
02:36:55.040 --> 02:37:12.080
man charter schools when those schools um or those entities have different or conflicting interests. Um this was a request that was made by BPS legal and it makes a lot of sense. Um, for example, there can be situations um, for example, in a special education matter

543
02:37:12.080 --> 02:37:28.640
where a parent uh is maybe looking for an out of district placement. In that situation, the Horus man charter school and BPS may have conflicting interests and so it it doesn't wouldn't make sense for BPS legal to represent both BPS and the charter school. So, it's a great um

544
02:37:28.640 --> 02:37:44.800
it's a great change and to to the benefit of all parties. Um, so that was one major change. The other change is um the uh with respect to indemnification. Um the previous had a modest indemnification provision. A broader

545
02:37:44.800 --> 02:38:00.560
indemnification provision was added in favor of BPS to address certain um to address concern expressed by BPS legal that there was certain risk to BPS uh in providing uh discretionary and non-discretionary services to the

546
02:38:00.560 --> 02:38:16.720
horseman charter schools. So the the significant change with respect to indemnification is a broader indemnification in favor of BPS. Um it's not a mutual indemnification. It's in the Horusman charter schools indemnifying BPS. Uh so that was the

547
02:38:16.720 --> 02:38:34.000
other major change. Um very quickly with respect to theubou between EMK and BTU uh EM between BDEA and the BTU, the one significant update um was a change to the dispute resolution process. Um that

548
02:38:34.000 --> 02:38:49.439
change was made in response to a request from BTU membership um to allow members to access the arbitration process in the BTU CBA. Um so um that change was added to the the BDEAUB

549
02:38:49.439 --> 02:39:06.800
um to include that option. Um with respect to the theUB for EMK um the parties have been engaging in good faith negotiations with respect to thatub but were not able to finalize um finalize that agreement prior to this evening's meeting. Um, and then very quickly, if I

550
02:39:06.800 --> 02:39:23.680
may, I did just want to um mention the expulsion policy for um for EMK, BDEA, uh, UA, UAD, and um, Boston Green Academy. Um, by law, uh, long-term, as folks probably know, long-term expense

551
02:39:23.680 --> 02:39:41.200
expulsions, long-term suspensions and expulsions for certain serious violations of the student code of conduct permit an appeal to the superintendent. Um, as mentioned earlier, I think in another presentation, perhaps, EMKBD,

552
02:39:41.200 --> 02:39:55.760
uh, all of the charter schools, the horseman charter schools, uh, adopt the BPS code of conduct. Um, in the past, some of the larger Massachusetts public school districts had a practice of allowing the superintendent to delegate

553
02:39:55.760 --> 02:40:13.439
the hearing of suspension, long-term suspensions and expulsions um to a design. Um there was a lawsuit um that was decided by the Supreme Judicial Court in in 2020 um whereby the SJC said no the statute says that the

554
02:40:13.439 --> 02:40:30.000
superintendent actually needs to hear those appeals. So Desi has rec recently requested um that all of this the Horus man charter schools update their expulsion policies um to reflect that change in the law or that clarification in the law. Um so that's the change to

555
02:40:30.000 --> 02:40:51.920
to the expulsion policies. Thank you. Thank you. >> Not going to hear from green candidates. >> Is there anything else from PGA? >> No. >> Good. >> All right. >> Okay. Then I'll now open it up to

556
02:40:51.920 --> 02:41:07.040
questions, comments. >> Anyone? >> Just appreciation for the school teams. Um, particularly appreciate the specificity of your school improvement goals as aligned by your as aligned to

557
02:41:07.040 --> 02:41:22.640
your key mission. Um, with targets and growth goals that reflect both academic growth and holistic indicators of student perception, data, school culture. Um, I think these are some of the things that we've been talking about

558
02:41:22.640 --> 02:41:37.920
as a committee to have macro at the district level um, for multi-year growth. And so it's just helpful to see how you all are measuring uh growth and success at the school level. >> I will just say this has been a lot of

559
02:41:37.920 --> 02:41:53.520
work to align but I think to all the positive um these schools are our schools. Um you know they they are independent um and yet they are very much a vibrant part of the BPS. Our students see that our parents see that. So I think there's just great alignment

560
02:41:53.520 --> 02:42:09.760
in the document. Um, so I want to I want to thank all of our leaders for that and the attorneys, right, and Lorenzo for your work on this as well. >> Great. Yes. Great. Thank you all and we will vote on these items at the July 8th

561
02:42:09.760 --> 02:42:26.240
meeting. >> So, thank you. >> Thank you. >> Okay. Okay. Our next presentation tonight is an update from the Boston Special Education Parent Advisory Council Spac. Let's aim to keep this presentation to

562
02:42:26.240 --> 02:42:43.240
under 20 minutes. Now, I'd like to turn it over to the superintendent for introductory remarks and invite Edith Bazil and the parents who are presenting with her to come forward. >> Yep. Where are they?

563
02:43:01.359 --> 02:43:17.520
And Edith, was I right? Before 8:00, right? 7:48. See, >> so tonight, Boston Special Education Parent Advisory Council or Spedpac Chair Edith Brazil is with us tonight and will provide an update on Spedpac's work. Spedpack empowers our BPS parents and

564
02:43:17.520 --> 02:43:32.000
caregivers by providing support and education. Thank you to Chair Brazil and check. Thank you to the Spedpac executive board for their advocacy on behalf of our district students and their families. At this point, I will

565
02:43:32.000 --> 02:43:49.520
turn it over to Chair Pizz. Thank you so much, Superintendent. Good evening, Chair Robinson, Vice Chair Scarit, members of the school committee, district leadership, families, and community members. My name is Edith Vazil, chair of Spedpac.

566
02:43:49.520 --> 02:44:04.399
>> Hi, my name is Shenik Marino. I'm vice chair of Spedpac. >> I want to acknowledge first of all as we give our presentation the partnership with Chief K Seal in the office of specialized services team over the past

567
02:44:04.399 --> 02:44:19.840
year. And I really want to give a special shout out to those who work behind the scenes, particularly Melissa Melissa Mendoza Patterson and Oolene Griffin, who really are the muscle behind all of the work that we do and

568
02:44:19.840 --> 02:44:35.760
often do not get acknowledgment. So tonight, the concerns highlighted in tonight's presentation extend beyond any single um particular highlighted event that has happened over the years. The

569
02:44:35.760 --> 02:44:50.640
concerns extend beyond any single department and require leadership, vision, and accountability at the district level to develop and sustain the systems necessary for meaningful and lasting change. Tonight's presentation

570
02:44:50.640 --> 02:45:06.080
reflects what families have been telling us throughout the year and how those experiences align with the district's own data. These themes do not emerge from a single meeting or event. They emerge through family conversations,

571
02:45:06.080 --> 02:45:21.760
support requests, public testimony, community events, district engagement sessions, spedpack general meetings, and our own inclusion town hall, which I'm thankful that Chair Robinson attended,

572
02:45:21.760 --> 02:45:38.800
uh, which was held last month. What stood out was not what families were saying, but how many families were saying the same thing across schools, neighborhoods, language backgrounds, and lived experiences. The same concerns

573
02:45:38.800 --> 02:45:56.000
surfaced repeatedly. Those concern became SPEAC priorities because they emerged consistently across the district and often mirrored patterns reflected in the district's own data. At their core, these concerns are about equity, access,

574
02:45:56.000 --> 02:46:11.279
literacy, things we heard tonight, inclusion outcomes, accountability, and trust. For students facing the greatest barriers, families want to know that their children are receiving the services, supports, and opportunities

575
02:46:11.279 --> 02:46:27.040
they need to succeed. Family feedback is one of the district's most valuable sources of information and an opportunity for continuous improvement. Tonight's presentation candidly reflects what families have been telling us, what

576
02:46:27.040 --> 02:46:43.600
the district's own data is telling us and what both suggest about the work that remains ahead. A strong theme we heard throughout the year was the need for more responsive partnership between families in the district. Schools have children for six

577
02:46:43.600 --> 02:47:00.319
hours a day. Families have them for the other 18 hours plus weekends, summers, and across a lifetime. Parents understand their children's strengths, challenges, histories, cultures, languages, and lived experience in ways that no report or data dashboard can

578
02:47:00.319 --> 02:47:15.840
fully capture. Many families describe navigating the district's system of opening tickets to solve problems. Rather than being connected to someone empowered to resolve concerns, family off families often feel sent into a maze that delays solutions and allow concerns to

579
02:47:15.840 --> 02:47:32.560
escalate. At its core, this is an inequity issue. A responsive system should work for each family, not just those with time, resources, advocates, or attorneys needed to navigate complex systems. Families repeatedly told us that access

580
02:47:32.560 --> 02:47:47.840
to support should not depend on who knows how to escalate concerns. These concerns surface surface across autism programming, school closures, inclusion, transportation, placement, school assignments, ESY, and district

581
02:47:47.840 --> 02:48:04.000
planning. Families noted that system failures often fall the hardest on students with disabilities and racial and linguistic groups that already face the greatest barriers. Before making decisions, family want families want the district to ask who is impacted, who

582
02:48:04.000 --> 02:48:21.600
benefits, who bears the burden, who has been engaged, whose voices are missing. Families emphasize that trust is not built through engagement alone. Trust is built when families are authentic partners and see their voices reflected in decisions,

583
02:48:21.600 --> 02:48:36.399
implement implementation, and student outcomes. Yes. Yeah. >> Families consistently state they want students to learn alongside peers in environments where they feel welcomed, supported, challenged, safe, and

584
02:48:36.399 --> 02:48:52.479
experience a genuine sense of belonging. They want inclusion that provides access not only to classrooms, but also to services, interventions, and opportunities that set students up for success. Families want the district to ask and

585
02:48:52.479 --> 02:49:09.439
answer. What makes inclusion successful? What are some schools uh more successful at? Why why are some schools more successful than others? How is success measured? Why are Henderson and Mary Lion 9 through 12, the district's only

586
02:49:09.439 --> 02:49:26.319
high school inclusion pathways being closed rather than strengthened? Families express concern that in school closures like Henderson Upper represents the loss of institutional knowledge. More importantly, families ask, "How does the district learn from success

587
02:49:26.319 --> 02:49:43.439
instead of repeating cycles of dismantling, reinventing, and rebuilding?" Inclusion is not new to BPS. For decades, school leaders and educators across the district developed expertise in building successful inclusive models. Inclusion depends on

588
02:49:43.439 --> 02:50:00.240
strong leadership. But school leaders cannot build inclusive schools without district support, staffing, resources, and clear expectations. Inclusion is built, not assigned. It requires infrastructure. Teachers,

589
02:50:00.240 --> 02:50:16.560
staffing, coaching, mentoring, collaborative planning, professional learning. When those investments are reduced, inclusion weakens. When inclusion weakens, outcomes suffer. Families expressed concern that while

590
02:50:16.560 --> 02:50:32.560
staffing expertise and institutional knowledge are being reduced, district spending on contracted services in outofd district tuition continues to grow. The question families are asking is whether resources are being invested

591
02:50:32.560 --> 02:50:48.319
in building district capacity instead of increasing dependence on services provided elsewhere. The cost of underinvesting in inclusion is not savings. It is a lost opportunity to strengthen the district's ability to

592
02:50:48.319 --> 02:51:05.279
serve students successfully in the district while shifting costs to outsourcing litigation and out of district placements. Families consistently pointed out that BPS has decades of experience educating students with disabilities and asks, "What have

593
02:51:05.279 --> 02:51:20.000
we learned? What has worked? What should we be uh what should be replicated? What mistakes should not be repeated? The district already has successfully successful schools, experienced educators, family expertise, audits,

594
02:51:20.000 --> 02:51:36.560
evaluations, and years of data. Yet, long-standing challenges continue to persist despite decades of study, planning, and recommendations. For this past year, for the past year, BPS has conducted an independent autism audit.

595
02:51:36.560 --> 02:51:53.279
Families welcome the effort but asked a simple question. Why hasn't family experience and expertise in informed this work? And how will families be engaged before recommendations are finalized implemented, monitored, and measured? Families raise similar concerns

596
02:51:53.279 --> 02:52:08.960
regarding literacy. Families are less interested in newly named initiatives and more interested in results. They want effective curriculum, strong in uh in instruction and interventions to improve literacy outcomes. Families want students to

597
02:52:08.960 --> 02:52:23.040
become stronger readers, stronger writers, and successful learners. Families emphasize that instit institutional learning must lead to better curriculum, stronger instruction, effective interventions, accountability

598
02:52:23.040 --> 02:52:43.840
without change, and sustained progress. Families raise concerns regarding the experiences and outcomes of black students with disabilities. District data show that onethird of students receiving special education services remain in substantially

599
02:52:43.840 --> 02:53:00.880
separate placements. Although black students only comprise 29% of district enrollment, they are the only group disproportionately represented in substantially separate placements. But the disparities do not stop there. Black

600
02:53:00.880 --> 02:53:15.439
students are disproportionately represented across multiple indicators, including identification in categories such as emotional impairment and intellectual impairment. the highest rates of suspensions, physical

601
02:53:15.439 --> 02:53:31.680
restraint, and seclusion. For example, while black students comprise only 29% of the district enrollment, they account for 51% of all of the seclusion incidents. Given the rising mental health needs across Boston, families

602
02:53:31.680 --> 02:53:47.680
question why black students remain disproportionately concentrated in the district's most restrictive therapeutic settings, including substantially separate EI programs and the Malvin H. Kingmies. Families see these patterns not as

603
02:53:47.680 --> 02:54:03.680
isolated outcomes, but as evidence of unmet needs, missed opportunities for intervention and the district's failure to deliver the transformational changes long promised at the Mel Kingmies. Melvin H. King was a civil rights

604
02:54:03.680 --> 02:54:18.960
leader, community organizer, champion of educational equity, and fierce advocate against displacement, gentrification, exclusion, and systemic injustice. Imagine this. Three therapeutic school

605
02:54:18.960 --> 02:54:35.120
sites in the south end in Fenway serving primarily black boys. schools named after a man who spent his life fighting displacement, gentrification, and racial inequity. Buildings in chronic disrepair with

606
02:54:35.120 --> 02:54:52.399
rotting bars on the windows while new schools rise across the city. BPS quietly closed two of the Mel King schools located in Fenway's most valuable real estate without meaningful family and community engagement. BPS

607
02:54:52.399 --> 02:55:09.040
notified virtually all Mel King Academy black educators that they will be displaced. Sound familiar? This is not the vision of equity Mel King fought for. It is the very inequity he fought against and a reminder that displacement of black

608
02:55:09.040 --> 02:55:25.359
educators continues in BPS with the racial equity planning tool or without the racial equity planning tool or racial equity checkpoints. Families emphasized that equity must be examined through the intersection of

609
02:55:25.359 --> 02:55:43.359
race, disability, and language. Families consistently raised concerns about the supports for multilingual learners with disabilities and the need for ESL, SEI, and native language instruction and special education services working

610
02:55:43.359 --> 02:55:59.439
together rather than operating in separate systems. Families caution the district not to conflate inclusion with immersion. Inclusion means students receive appropriate ESL, SEI, native

611
02:55:59.439 --> 02:56:16.080
instruction, specialized instruction, and accommodations necessary to access learning. Placing multilingual learners with disabilities in settings without those supports is not inclusion. It is immersion. Families also express concern

612
02:56:16.080 --> 02:56:33.040
that language differences may sometimes be mistaken for disabilities and disabilities may sometimes be overlooked because of language differences. District data raised concerns about both underidentification and over

613
02:56:33.040 --> 02:56:49.040
identification of multilingual learners, underscoring the importance of culturally and linguistically responsive evaluations conducted by highly skilled bilingual and bicultural assessor and service providers. families raised

614
02:56:49.040 --> 02:57:04.800
concerns about the need for more bilingual educators, bilingual service providers, and staff who understand students cultural and linguistic backgrounds. Most importantly, families stressed that multilingual learners with disabilities should not have to choose

615
02:57:04.800 --> 02:57:20.240
between native language supports, English language acquisition supports, and disability supports. They are entitled to all three. One-third of students receiving special education services are multilingual learners.

616
02:57:20.240 --> 02:57:36.479
Families believe staffing, expertise, and resources should reflect that reality. Rather than reducing bilingual staff, families want BPS to strengthen its capacity to serve multilingual learners with disabilities and ensure schools have the staffing and expertise

617
02:57:36.479 --> 02:57:53.439
necessary for students to thrive. Equity ensuring that l is never a barrier to identif literacy, opportunity, student outcomes, or long-term success. Families repeatedly raise concerns

618
02:57:53.439 --> 02:58:10.880
regarding appropriate autism service. Literacy intervention, specialized instruction, transition planning, access to culturally responsive evaluations emerged as reoccurring themes throughout the year. Families emphasize that access should not depend upon extraordinary

619
02:58:10.880 --> 02:58:26.960
advocacy. Students should not have to wait extended periods for evaluation services, interventions, or appropriate placements. Literacy emerged as one of the most urgent concerns. Families repeatedly emphasize that strong literacy

620
02:58:26.960 --> 02:58:43.520
instruction is fun foundational to all student success and express concern that current approaches are not producing the outcome students deserve, particularly for students with disabilities and students educated in substantially separate settings. Families also question how

621
02:58:43.520 --> 02:59:00.160
recommendations emerging from the autism audit will be implemented, monitored, and communicated with families. Families repeatedly emphasize that access on loan is not the goal. The goal is improved outcomes. Families want to know whether students are learning, progressing, becoming more independent, developing

622
02:59:00.160 --> 02:59:16.000
literacy, achieving their goals, and preparing for successful futures. This happens when dollars are allotted to improve practice through consistent professional learning and investments in supporting schools principles and teachers with adequate staffing resources, technology, professional

623
02:59:16.000 --> 02:59:33.439
development, coaching, and mentoring. This means building a strong workforce in the district, not outsourcing services, and using funding on costly litigation and outside placements because BPS programs cannot serve the need of the majority of students within the district.

624
02:59:33.439 --> 02:59:49.640
Families want solutions when students are not making progress and greater transparency about the decisions are how decisions are made when students when supports are not working that lead to stronger and more successful in district programs.

625
02:59:49.760 --> 03:00:06.800
families consistent consistently connected student outcomes to people. Whether discussing inclusion, literacy, autism services, multilingual learner supports, transportation, or program quality, conversations repeatedly return to the same themes: teacher development,

626
03:00:06.800 --> 03:00:22.319
coaching, mentoring, collaborative planning, staff retention, and specialized expertise. Families describe staffing shortages and turnover not as operational challenges but as student outcome issues. When schools lose a

627
03:00:22.319 --> 03:00:37.200
dynamic multicultural workforce of experienced educators with specialized expertise, students lose con sorry continuity, support and um opportunities to succeed. Families also emphasized the

628
03:00:37.200 --> 03:00:54.479
importance of educator diversity and expressed a strong desire to recruit, retain, and support more black educators, bilingual educators, and service providers who reflect the racial, cultural, and linguistic diversity of BPS students. Research consistently demonstrates that

629
03:00:54.479 --> 03:01:09.439
students benefit when they see themselves reflected in the educator workforce and when educators understand the communities they serve. The communities they served. Families repeatedly pointed out that successful schools are built through intentional sustained investment in educators,

630
03:01:09.439 --> 03:01:26.160
strong staffing pipelines, professional learning, coaching, mentoring, and collaborative planning. Families are concerned about investment in stable teaching force necessary to sustain and expand successful practices across the district versus funds for use for outsourcing.

631
03:01:26.160 --> 03:01:43.439
Families repeatedly emphasize that when budgets are tight, the last cut should be made to the people closest to the students because staffing decisions are ultimately student support decisions, student opportunity decisions, and student outcome decisions. Perhaps the strongest emotional theme

632
03:01:43.439 --> 03:01:59.279
that emerged throughout the year was urgency. Families understand that systems change takes time, but the pace of change must align with the pace of childhood development because students experience educational opportunities in

633
03:01:59.279 --> 03:02:15.920
real time in critical developmental periods only once. Families conveyed that delayed services, delayed interventions, delayed staffing decisions, delayed transportation solutions, delayed implementation,

634
03:02:15.920 --> 03:02:31.520
delayed accountability, and delayed action can have lifelong consequences. The concern is that BPS often focuses on process when opportunities for action already exist. One family member

635
03:02:31.520 --> 03:02:47.439
captured this concern by noting that systems may operate on strategic plans, but childhood operates on developmental timelines. Students cannot be put on hold while systems try to catch up. Students experience each stage of

636
03:02:47.439 --> 03:03:04.240
development only once. That is why urgency emerged as such a powerful theme throughout the year. Families emphasize that urgency must also be reflected in budget decisions, staffing, and school level supports. Inclusion cannot succeed

637
03:03:04.240 --> 03:03:21.359
without fully staffed schools, strong classroom supports, clear expectations, and consistent implementation. Families urged the district to build on what it already knows works. strengthen successful practices without with

638
03:03:21.359 --> 03:03:38.080
intention and evidence. Invest in district capacity and reduce reliance on outsourcing and outofd district placements by ensuring every school has the infrastructure necessary to support students successfully.

639
03:03:38.080 --> 03:03:53.520
Our last slide is our six recommendations. I'm sorry we over time >> that we have which we think is the most powerful and important part of our presentation because this is not just about assessing what the concerns are

640
03:03:53.520 --> 03:04:08.720
but it's making recommendations in terms of you know what where do we go from here what is what are the possibilities and opportunities. So these six recommendations reflect what families have consistently communicated throughout the year. Families are asking

641
03:04:08.720 --> 03:04:25.840
not simply for engagement, but rather meaningful partnership as co-creators in decisionmaking. They also want transparency, accountability in a district that responds to concerns before they escalate. Two, families are calling for meaningful engagement in

642
03:04:25.840 --> 03:04:41.840
autism programming and implementation, stronger literacy, multilingual learner supports, and intentional efforts to address long-standing disparities and disproportionalities affecting Can I turn this off? Uh, black

643
03:04:41.840 --> 03:04:58.720
students. Three, families want a clear definition of inclusion, stronger implementation of inclusive practices and equity measured not only by access but by outcomes. Four, families want an infrastructure of successful inclusion models that are preserved, strengthened,

644
03:04:58.720 --> 03:05:15.520
and scale. Five families are asking for sustained investment in educator development, coaching, mentoring, staffing, and educated diversity, including targeted efforts to recruit, retain, and support black educators, bilingual educators, literacy specialists, and staff with ex expertise

645
03:05:15.520 --> 03:05:33.200
across all disability categories. Six. Families want school closures, program design, and system transformation efforts to meaningfully consider educational impact, disability impact, and racial equity impact, and

646
03:05:33.200 --> 03:05:50.680
community impact. At the core, these recommendations are about equity, opportunity, accountability, and outcomes for students with disabilities. >> In closing, we want you to hear from a student of Spec Pack. This is Elijah. Elijah.

647
03:05:51.040 --> 03:06:10.080
>> Thank you. >> Good evening. My name is Elijah and I'm a student at Melvin H. King Health and Academy. I have dreams and goals for my future. I passed the MCCAST, but I was held back twice during my senior year. I want to go to college, continue my education, and build a successful life.

648
03:06:10.080 --> 03:06:26.640
But like many students, I face challenges. I am here because students need more than a place to sit and complete worksheets. We need meaningful instruction, meaningful support, and adults who listen when we tell them what we need to be successful. I have spent times in classes where I was the only student in the room. I often felt

649
03:06:26.640 --> 03:06:41.840
disconnected from what was happening in class, and I do not feel the work is preparing me for college or my future. I have told my school team that I do not feel ready to leave school. I want support that helps me succeed, not just graduate. I don't want to leave school with a diploma and still feel unprepared

650
03:06:41.840 --> 03:06:59.920
for my future. Thank you for listening. >> Thank you. Thank you very much. >> Thank you all so much. Thank you. >> Thank you very much for the presentation all of you. Very very helpful. I want to open it up to members for questions and

651
03:06:59.920 --> 03:07:20.560
comments. Um first uh just very grateful for the presentation um and to hear um directly the feedback um from families and I actually I'm kind of curious uh on a couple of things um one if you've heard

652
03:07:20.560 --> 03:07:37.520
directly from families or either um BPS staff that have attended about what their particular experience has been with um service mapping and sort of that shift that the district is putting in place. Is it working? Like what are some of the complexities that maybe they've

653
03:07:37.520 --> 03:07:53.040
faced with that? >> You want to take that question or I can. >> Mhm. >> I can. Um so for parents that are dual language the the main concern is getting information in their language in their

654
03:07:53.040 --> 03:08:08.960
preferred language whether they're using the app that allows them to talk directly with the teacher and not getting feedback from the teacher just understanding the curriculum that their child is in and knowing how to get services through the IEP. not understanding the IEP and just getting a

655
03:08:08.960 --> 03:08:24.160
packet that says this is the parents information isn't enough if I don't speak English and the packet sometimes does not come in a different language. So if your child has an IEP and this is your first experience with an IEP and they're not getting their due diligence done on their behalf of their child to

656
03:08:24.160 --> 03:08:39.760
understand what they're even signing. Some parents are just signing and not understanding that they're not getting their child's needs met. Not because they don't want them to, but because it wasn't explained to them. And when the services are offered, they often aren't people in place that have the correct

657
03:08:39.760 --> 03:08:56.399
need or like we have TAs helping with ABA students. ABA students should have ABA staff and it's there's no ABA staff available. So that's a concern right now. >> And and I think um just to add to that um you're really asking about accountability and outcomes. So service

658
03:08:56.399 --> 03:09:13.600
mapping really has to do with um you know what what families told us is that they want the district to measure success through outcomes rather than access alone. So >> the key question is not whether students receive services and that's part of

659
03:09:13.600 --> 03:09:29.760
service mapping. How many hours did a student receive speech because that's in the IEP >> and is the speech actually helping them >> right? But the key question is whether the services improved outcomes. And that was the key thing that parents focused on. Families want outcomes measured tied

660
03:09:29.760 --> 03:09:46.160
to literacy, inclusion, belonging, graduation, post-secondary readiness, independence, and long-term success. So, you heard from one of our students who's also a Spedpack member. Uh what we see service mapping as the floor of of

661
03:09:46.160 --> 03:10:01.279
compliance. What we are talking about is the ceiling of best practices. So how do we maximize those best practices to ensure that when the student receives for example that 30 minute block of

662
03:10:01.279 --> 03:10:19.120
whatever instruction that it results in outcomes and and that's really the shift in saying that we want best practices and scale those practices that we know result in outcomes.

663
03:10:19.120 --> 03:10:35.840
>> No, I agree with you. I think that's why I'm particularly asking about it because I agree outputs are the is the currency that we're really talking about and to get there we also need to understand are the right inputs in place right and so

664
03:10:35.840 --> 03:10:52.080
and actually in and what you said was also very interesting to me just to hear in it a teacher or a teacher not giving feedback >> sometimes the teacher isn't equipped to give feedback because they don't know the the child's history but that that's the disconnect the conversations aren't being had.

665
03:10:52.080 --> 03:11:07.600
There's a lot of students that come to me and they're getting certificates of completion and they want to continue their education. They shouldn't be going through a process where they weren't taught to read in third, fourth, fifth, sixth, but so by the time they're in ninth and tth grade, their reading level

666
03:11:07.600 --> 03:11:22.399
isn't at the level where they can take the MCCAST. I know that's since changed, but at one point it was you needed to pass the MCCAST. And a lot of kids got certificates of completion and now they're only able to get jobs and that's not all they want. And then you have a child here saying the same thing. I'm

667
03:11:22.399 --> 03:11:42.160
I'm I'm choosing to stay back so I can be more educated when that should have happened during the 12 years they were in school. >> I I have Yeah. >> Okay. >> So um I thank you for the presentation. Um,

668
03:11:42.160 --> 03:12:00.319
I was wondering about um how families are notified. I know we you talked about IEPs and uh how are families notified in a when a child is coming up for an IEP at the school? Have they spoken to

669
03:12:00.319 --> 03:12:17.439
you guys about that? Are they notified on time so they'll be present? So you're really talking about is the district committing to timelines for evaluations for IEP team meetings. I know that with early intervention there's a lot of diligent work to make sure that students

670
03:12:17.439 --> 03:12:33.279
are captured by the time they are they're turning three years old because that's when they transition into BPS and they get their services. And on Monday we met with OSS and we we met the person that is doing that work. um BPS in the

671
03:12:33.279 --> 03:12:49.920
past has struggled with that. I think there has been progress in that area. So we always like to highlight the the good things that are happening as well as the challenges. Um in terms of assessment completion, uh yes. So there are some

672
03:12:49.920 --> 03:13:06.720
families that have talked about there are you know assessments may not be completed on time and part of it is what when we talked about the itinerant services so there's a lot of outsourcing of related service providers like speech

673
03:13:06.720 --> 03:13:23.600
OT ABA um what we are saying that as the district moves towards inclusion developing pathways and being creative about that so that you have in district staff planning. Inclusion requires

674
03:13:23.600 --> 03:13:40.720
planning and it requires planning of all team members and if someone is contracted they come and provide a service and they leave and so they're not available to see how the student function say in an afterchool program or a before school meeting because

675
03:13:40.720 --> 03:13:56.000
contracted services are blocks of time that are dedicated to payment and it's a contractual arrangement. What we are saying at BPS is building and scaling inclusion. There has to be investment in

676
03:13:56.000 --> 03:14:12.960
teachers in the district who can co-plan, who can problem solve, who see students across multiple settings throughout the day and really get to know the student because that's what builds belongingness and and

677
03:14:12.960 --> 03:14:30.479
understanding the whole child. I would just add to that that one parent I met with had a child that needed ABA. The school didn't have that available. They got an email saying when they did have someone that met those requirements, they would put that in place. Luckily, her child's teacher has

678
03:14:30.479 --> 03:14:45.920
an autistic child. So, because of that, you know, the wraparound was there because of that teacher. But if that teacher didn't have that support from being a parent, that child would have fell between the cracks. And reading is a struggle for the regular child, whatever regular may be. So if a child

679
03:14:45.920 --> 03:15:01.840
has disabilities and they're not able to read at grade level and they continue to be moved to the next grade, they max out when they get to 12th grade, not even having a third or fourth grade reading level. And that's a concern for parents because the reality is the average kid

680
03:15:01.840 --> 03:15:19.279
in Boston right now can't read on grade level. And that's that's a fact. And I'm a parent of deaf adult kids now. Luckily, they had good teachers. I mean, teachers are great in Boston, but if they don't have the services, this is where we're at. And it's a it's a continuous pattern of reading inclusion.

681
03:15:19.279 --> 03:15:34.880
So, like Edith said, having to having someone that I can go to that I remember that I can connect with. Kids need that connection because if it's a new person every time, they're not going to want to adapt to a new person. So, then they they lose that continuous support >> and they fall through because they

682
03:15:34.880 --> 03:15:50.720
either don't come to school with it. With high school kids, they won't show up anymore. Like I've taught at some of these schools, they won't show up and their response is because no one cares. So when a child tells you no one cares and you know the teachers care, it's the programming that's not consistent. If the program is not consistent, what am I

683
03:15:50.720 --> 03:16:07.840
coming for? I'm not going to get what I want in the end. And there's a child here again saying, "I'm I want to be kept back because I want to learn before I go to college. I don't want to get to college and struggle." That's what we don't want to continue to happen because they have a disability. I have another question. Um, you talked

684
03:16:07.840 --> 03:16:23.680
about engagement. So, I was wondering if you guys have a protocol in place to engage the families. How >> Yes. So, I'm really happy that you asked that question because it's really critical. So, we're talking about, you

685
03:16:23.680 --> 03:16:39.439
know, how do we have a, you know, stronger um sense of governance around parent engagement? Parents come with expertise, not just they know their students best. So

686
03:16:39.439 --> 03:16:55.520
feedback is important, but the expertise that families have can be crit critical to developing better programming because parents know what works and what does not work. And so we want the district to

687
03:16:55.520 --> 03:17:11.680
move beyond engagement and really build the district capacity with families by investing in families really working collaboratively with the district. Not after decisions are made but prior to decisions being

688
03:17:11.680 --> 03:17:27.760
made. Developing the planning for implementation. monitoring the success of programs and then really getting the the family's perspective on how it's working because

689
03:17:27.760 --> 03:17:43.200
oftent times especially with students with disabilities uh students with autism they hold things in all day long because they want to feel a sense of belonging and then when they get home that's when they let loose and they tell

690
03:17:43.200 --> 03:18:00.560
family they tell their parents well you know they may be um self-injuring, but it could be that's that's data around my school day has not worked for me or they may be excessively tired, exhausted because they're masking the fact that

691
03:18:00.560 --> 03:18:17.359
their instruction is not working for them. The family piece is critical and we have availed ourselves. Like for example with the autism audit, it's been going on for a whole year and every family member that we talked to that have children

692
03:18:17.359 --> 03:18:32.160
with autism, they have not been contacted. They have not been surveyed. How can the district create a program without collaborating with families to get their feedback on what is and is not working? because you want to you want to

693
03:18:32.160 --> 03:18:48.720
continue those parts that are successful and build capacity where there are challenges. >> So I agree with Edith said if children are being challenged in the ways they need to be there is there isn't going to be any growth. A lot of these children are getting just a

694
03:18:48.720 --> 03:19:04.319
packet of paper. This is your homework. You go home. There's no followth through. There's no conversation with the parents. There's no There used to be reading logs. Reading logs are gone. So kids are not even having the back and forth that we did have at one point with teachers.

695
03:19:04.319 --> 03:19:20.800
When parents come to us and say, "My concern is that my child doesn't speak." Most of the time it's not that they have speech delays. They don't know how to read. they don't know how to to express how they're feeling based on not having language because they don't know how to read, that's all-encompassing. So, if

696
03:19:20.800 --> 03:19:36.640
they don't have those supports and you're not engaging them in the way that they learn, it's a disservice to them. It's a continuous disservice because they're going to go through and they're going to go through the motions, but they're never retaining anything they learn. So, having an extended school year is great, but if they don't meet those requirements, then that's another

697
03:19:36.640 --> 03:19:52.560
loop they fall through and it continues and it continues. So, it's a cycle. So what we're saying basically is family engagement should move beyond consultation and become a governance strategy and >> parents know best. >> Yes. And and and families are asking to

698
03:19:52.560 --> 03:20:09.760
be engaged before decisions are made not after decisions are finalized. Um the recommendation that we'd like to make is to establish clear expectations for family engagement during planning, implementation, monitoring, and evaluation of major initiatives that

699
03:20:09.760 --> 03:20:32.080
impact students with disabilities so that family voice is treated as a source of expertise and accountability for the district, not just simply feedback. >> Thank you. Thank you for your presentation. Well, uh couple of uh

700
03:20:32.080 --> 03:20:48.720
uh presumptions will predicate my questions. The first presumption is that this document right here and your and your presentation relies on parents with

701
03:20:48.720 --> 03:21:06.399
children with disability. Right. So most of the the the uh the information you provided here are from parents with uh children with disability. Okay. Um the second uh presumption is that from your

702
03:21:06.399 --> 03:21:23.200
from your remark from your presentation I presume that you are in favor of inclusion done right. Isn't that right? >> Yes. inclusion is focused on student

703
03:21:23.200 --> 03:21:36.640
outcomes. >> Okay. Okay. Now, just back to this. So, I'm some some Okay. I'm I'm a parent with children with disability and part of my legal work is dealing with

704
03:21:36.640 --> 03:21:55.359
disability issues for the last 35 years. So when you put here the black students represent 29% of enrollment. I would presume that those 29% of black students are students with

705
03:21:55.359 --> 03:22:12.399
disability. >> Yes. Oh no no no 29% in the total district. >> I see. >> So what we're doing is we are comparing the um number of students in the district. >> Okay. compared to when we look at how many students for example are secluded,

706
03:22:12.399 --> 03:22:30.560
how many students are suspended. Okay, how many students are in substantially separate programs. So that's a that is >> that leads to my question right there. >> But disability indicator right there, but not all of them. the 29 everybody um if 43% of students in substantially

707
03:22:30.560 --> 03:22:46.319
separate separate classrooms are students with disability or or are black students with disability. Is that is that correct? >> So I don't know the exact number of black students who are in substantially

708
03:22:46.319 --> 03:23:02.880
separate programs off the top of my head. Okay. But I know that there are more black students in subsparate programs than any other demographic group. >> Talking about all students, all black students, not not just students with

709
03:23:02.880 --> 03:23:18.319
disability. So if you look at this >> the data that you provided here indicated that 29% represent black students represent 79% of enrollment meaning

710
03:23:18.319 --> 03:23:34.720
the entire student body right but 43% of students again I would presume that's black students are placed in substantially separate classrooms. So, for example, I

711
03:23:34.720 --> 03:23:50.800
I I get where you're going that um so >> black black I think black students represent 29% of the total enrollment of the district, they represent 43% >> of the total enrollment of substantially separate classrooms.

712
03:23:50.800 --> 03:24:06.720
>> So, in other words, you would want if if black students were 29% of the total population be commensurate, you would say, well, they're 29% of the students in special ed. We look at that would be another suspension data. We look at lots of different kinds of data through this

713
03:24:06.720 --> 03:24:23.439
lens where we look at the overall population of BPS and then we look at the different demographic groups. We look at gender. We look at um socioeconomic to see if there's disproportionate numbers. We also have

714
03:24:23.439 --> 03:24:41.439
we are also disproportionate in the number of students who have IEPs and who are then served in substantially separate settings. >> Right. >> And to Edah's point of that group, our black students are I think it's almost

715
03:24:41.439 --> 03:24:58.239
like 175% greater chance uh based on that data. >> So uh okay, that clarifies a couple of things. The the issue now boils down to the substantially separate classrooms.

716
03:24:58.239 --> 03:25:14.319
>> Are those classroom reserved for students with disability or what? >> Can you say that I separate classes? Are those classes just for students with disability? >> The the three separate classrooms means that a student is segregated from the

717
03:25:14.319 --> 03:25:30.239
general population >> 75% or more of the day. >> Uhhuh. So in other words, they are not with their general education peers >> because of their disability or because of what? >> Well, you know, that's sort of getting

718
03:25:30.239 --> 03:25:46.399
into the weeds of why. And so when we talk about disproportionality and we think about, for example, Mel King Academy, I think, has maybe 40% black students or higher than that. Even though black students are 29% of the

719
03:25:46.399 --> 03:26:03.279
population, the majority of them are also black males. So you have to think about why are there so many black males in this particular category just like you want to think about when it comes to multilingual learners you have under and

720
03:26:03.279 --> 03:26:20.000
over representation in communication impairment. So that's a category of disability. So that's connected to language difference. So, are we determining disability based on language difference or is there a disability related to language? So, that's

721
03:26:20.000 --> 03:26:36.880
something that the district needs to address in terms of disproportionality. So, it could be two-sided. It could be under representation. I'm not catching the disability because I don't know how to navigate where you are with your language. So, I'm not going to identify

722
03:26:36.880 --> 03:26:53.920
you even though you may be dyslexic and you speak a different language because I'm not assessing you in your native language. Or it could be, well, gee, I'm looking at you don't you you are say a um an ELD 2 or three and I am

723
03:26:53.920 --> 03:27:11.040
misclassifying you. So, it's two-sided when it comes to multilingual learners. When it comes to black students, it's over representation in substantially separate classroom suspension, seclusion, and in disability categories

724
03:27:11.040 --> 03:27:27.359
like emotional impairment and intellectual impairment. And so that's work that the district has to do around doing a better job with assessment. It also has to do with ensuring that your assesses are bilingual, bicultural, but

725
03:27:27.359 --> 03:27:44.160
also are representative of understanding how to do assessments on students who don't look like them >> and are not using tools that are not culturally responsive. >> Right?

726
03:27:44.160 --> 03:28:01.120
And the other thing I want to say is more expensive to educate a student in substantially separate placements. So if they're mclassified, not only are you paying more money, but you're not getting the results. And so if you look at data on student outcomes, the student

727
03:28:01.120 --> 03:28:15.920
outcomes are poor. When you mclassify students, so you look at the Mel King data, the the outcomes are poor. I >> I hear you and I see where you're coming from and I understand all that. Uh the issue I have here is that you know

728
03:28:15.920 --> 03:28:34.160
the the the data that are before us 29% of black students in enrollment 43% of them are in substantially separate classroom. >> No >> no that's not the data point. >> No >> it's it's it's that >> right here. It's that of the students in

729
03:28:34.160 --> 03:28:49.840
substantially se separate programs of those specific students who are served in substantially separate programs 43% of those students are black. >> So 43% of the students are are disabled. 40%

730
03:28:49.840 --> 03:29:06.080
>> 100% of students in substantially separate programs have disabilities, but 43% of the students in those classrooms are black when only 29% of stu of students in the district are black. So if it were a proportional representation, they would be the same,

731
03:29:06.080 --> 03:29:20.960
>> right? >> But those two percentages, I can see why it's the two percentages in this sentence represent two different proportions of students. One is students at large that share the same racial group, the first one. And the other is

732
03:29:20.960 --> 03:29:36.720
measuring the percent of students in a specific program type. So it's not 43% of the 29%. >> I see. >> Yeah. >> So, okay. >> Okay. >> All right. I I'll I'll

733
03:29:36.720 --> 03:29:52.640
>> stop my questions. >> I >> It's complicated >> because I was trying to understand >> Yeah. whether that helps with the inclusion or that doesn't help with the inclusion uh that you're trying to

734
03:29:52.640 --> 03:30:07.840
identify the issue. >> It raises the concerns. Well, when it if I could say when it comes to inclusion, you know, our position is that we don't want to simply expand inclusion, right? Like the recommendation is to build an infrastructure

735
03:30:07.840 --> 03:30:24.080
>> for inclusion. And so the district, what we're recommending is that the district should first identify successful inclusion models. >> What is the definition or the metrics for an inclusion model as successful?

736
03:30:24.080 --> 03:30:40.800
And then establish non-negotiables for every school that must be in place. So what are the elements that should be in place in every school that is an inclusion school? And then the other piece is um including uh staffing,

737
03:30:40.800 --> 03:30:56.399
collaborative planning, coaching, professional development cannot be understated and implementation supports um for that. So families are asking the district not to re to stop reinventing

738
03:30:56.399 --> 03:31:14.399
inclusion to look at the models that exist in the district that are working and replicate that success by looking at what are they doing that needs to be replicated across every school in the district. Not just saying a school is an

739
03:31:14.399 --> 03:31:31.680
inclusion school. I mean, I was going to say when the kids thrive, the district thrives. The numbers will speak, but when parents get involved, um I I actually said that at the Hannes EC, I asked Miss Wood, I'm like, "Can you tell the other schools how to do this?" But it only goes to sec uh to first grade.

740
03:31:31.680 --> 03:31:47.680
So, I was kind of sad when my son had to leave, but um I agree like when there's consistency across the board and parents are involved, even if they don't speak English, if they can come in and show you how this works for their kid and then the other parents do it, it's more so like parents getting to know other

741
03:31:47.680 --> 03:32:04.479
parents and then parents talking with the district. But when the parents don't even know how to navigate that, it's like a domino effect. It just keeps falling. But we have great teachers. We have the supports. It's just everyone coming to a meeting of the minds and having a conversation that helps the

742
03:32:04.479 --> 03:32:19.600
kids move forward. >> And there are models that that that are successful. So I can go back to we we had on one of the slides in 1989 the Henderson the Patrick O'Harn is what it was called then um became an inclusion model. It's very unique but we also got

743
03:32:19.600 --> 03:32:36.160
the Mason and the Elliott. in many schools the Roosevelt and and so what what happened then and this is institutional knowledge and that's why we're saying don't reinvent the wheel think about what worked in the past where a school that was successful was

744
03:32:36.160 --> 03:32:51.680
matched with a school that was on their way so you don't want to take for example the Elliot is kind of a unicorn you can't really replicate that because of the variables but you could take a school that is a strong inclusion model and pair it with a school that could

745
03:32:51.680 --> 03:33:08.000
benefit from reaching up to that level. Um, you know, it's sort of like you don't want um to pair a student who is an advanced learner with someone who is struggling with a concept. You want you want a school you want to pair schools that are on the way with a school that

746
03:33:08.000 --> 03:33:23.680
can see themselves achieving that level >> in orchard gardens. That would be a great feeling. >> Yeah. A lot of different languages are spoken at both schools and the kids can transition to eighth grade. I've been looking at I've been doing the I I've I'm from Boston so I look at um

747
03:33:23.680 --> 03:33:40.160
different demographics at the schools and I'm also I speak three languages so when parents talk to me the main thing is I don't want my kid to only have one school as an option but I don't want to lose the supports I have at this school. So when they're getting ready to transition it's like well this school doesn't go to eighth grade so where do I

748
03:33:40.160 --> 03:33:55.439
go but I also don't want to put my kids somewhere where they're not happy and then I have to wait to like that's always the cycle when summer comes. So parents are just selecting one school real not realizing your kids are going to go somewhere random. So this is this is the thing every school year like

749
03:33:55.439 --> 03:34:11.840
right now that's the crunch time. And I mean the other thing is you have collaborative co-planning with teachers. Why not have collaborative co-planning with schools school to school? So you may have teachers from one school that is struggling with a practice to visit

750
03:34:11.840 --> 03:34:27.359
you know another school to observe what they're doing. like how can you pair schools up a school that is doing a little better not you know far ahead but is is achievable for another school. How do you pair within the district a

751
03:34:27.359 --> 03:34:42.720
struggling school with a school that is on its way so that they learn from each other? Because you have models. We often think about, you know, how do we address failure, but how do you replicate success is a different way to look at it

752
03:34:42.720 --> 03:34:59.880
in terms of what is one thing that a particular school can do that's going to make the biggest difference and really scale that. You can't do everything, but really thinking about incremental continuous improvement.

753
03:35:00.080 --> 03:35:20.080
You said it well. following up on we cannot do everything. Uh thank you so much for the work that you are doing uh to the three of you and the entire um uh uh group of the spec pack. Um thank you for putting together

754
03:35:20.080 --> 03:35:35.600
the six recommendations. My question is again is there's a lot of work in front of us but I would like to know you you use the word urgency several times and I want to know about the

755
03:35:35.600 --> 03:35:52.880
urgency of the urgency. Let's think about next school year that is about to start in a couple months. My kids don't want me to say that but that's the reality. In a couple months we're starting a new school year. what we to the members of this committee

756
03:35:52.880 --> 03:36:11.600
as a government committee what is it that we should be paying the most attention to in fis in the school year 25 26 or 26 27 >> so I would say what families are asking for with regard to urgency is execution

757
03:36:11.600 --> 03:36:27.600
prioritization like what is the biggest challenge what how can you prioritize adverise a goal to for example close literacy gaps and and that goes into staffing. What are the staffing gaps? Because if you don't

758
03:36:27.600 --> 03:36:42.800
have the people and you don't they don't have the expertise and the specialization, you can't do the work. So that really goes into professional learning. Um and then resource allocation. How are schools being supported?

759
03:36:42.800 --> 03:36:59.279
Shemica said, "We have fantastic teachers and school leaders, but they need support and and this has to come from the district level." Um, and so, um, the it's really thinking about the district t identifying actions that can

760
03:36:59.279 --> 03:37:15.520
be taken immediately. what can you do right now and having that prioritization um and and and and and taking action within a year like what is my goal for the next year? How can it be prioritized

761
03:37:15.520 --> 03:37:30.160
for this school to grow for that year and then taking actions um that require longer planning? So really thinking in the short term, what are the immediate steps that can be taken and how do they

762
03:37:30.160 --> 03:37:48.000
roll into the longer range planning and and when we talk about urgency, it has to be reflected not only in plans but in decisions in budgets. Budgets are important because we know right now there's an increase in outsourcing and

763
03:37:48.000 --> 03:38:04.160
out of district in litigation. How can we recoup those funds to build the kind of programs that we're losing students with disabilities to? What are those out of district schools doing that BPS can

764
03:38:04.160 --> 03:38:20.080
replicate? >> And do you need to partner with one of those schools to build those programs in the district so students aren't getting up 5:00 in the morning? You're not only paying for expensive tuition, but you're also paying for transportation, which

765
03:38:20.080 --> 03:38:37.680
often can be more than than curriculum with more than tuition costs. And then students are getting home late, exhausted, cannot be part of the community placements. That's the biggest budget killer is the out of district placements. If they can get the services

766
03:38:37.680 --> 03:38:53.840
in the district, that would be preferred for parents. And I mean, I think for the district. >> Yeah. Parents do not want their children leaving 5:00 in the morning, going on a van, um out of their community, and then coming home late at night. Um they can't

767
03:38:53.840 --> 03:39:09.520
take advantage of after school programs and do other things. >> Have community. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. I mean, the main thing is having community. It's great to have an option to go out of district, but the the choice would be to stay where your family and your friends are, people you know at school. >> And so we're what we're saying is the

768
03:39:09.520 --> 03:39:25.200
district doesn't need to start over. The district needs to look at what is already working. >> And you know, often you think, well, we have re reinventing and rebuilding and dismantling. That is that that's the problem that

769
03:39:25.200 --> 03:39:41.520
parents talk about and and they they really focus on schools that have closed on the backs of students with disabilities that were working and now they have to start over. and and so how can you preserve and strengthen programs instead of closing

770
03:39:41.520 --> 03:39:57.040
them? >> Thank you so much. I'm gonna stick with closure closing the the literacy gap and investment on and in district services. I think that's something that will come up like at the the next agenda item. We

771
03:39:57.040 --> 03:40:12.479
talk a lot about in the evaluation of the superintendent and the district about we need data from K to2 on literacy. how how are the students doing for third grade on up is is too maybe too late. We need to see how they are

772
03:40:12.479 --> 03:40:28.560
doing in this in this first year. So, thank you so much. >> Do you want me to speak about literacy? So, families repeatedly identify literacy as one of the most urgent issues facing students with disabilities because reading is the foundation of learning. Students who cannot read

773
03:40:28.560 --> 03:40:43.200
proficiently struggle to access curriculum, demonstrate knowledge, build independence, achieve positive long-term outcomes. The concern is not simply lit literacy intervention. It is literacy outcomes. MCCAST. I don't know how to

774
03:40:43.200 --> 03:40:59.279
pronounce I have a list. I'm sorry name. >> I'm sorry. I have a list. So, um, data have shown persistent literacy challenges for years, particularly for students with disabilities. multilingual learners. I've experienced this with my kids because we're multilingual learners

775
03:40:59.279 --> 03:41:15.359
and we have deaf people in our family. So, it's really hard when you don't hear people speak a different language in your house and then you go to school. >> So, just navigating that. Um, families are asking whether the district has spent enough time evaluating effectiveness of the core instruction

776
03:41:15.359 --> 03:41:30.960
itself and a strong multi-tered system of support. Tier one instruction should successfully meet the needs of most students. intervention should supplement strong instruction, not compensate for weak instruction. Families families expressed concern that the district has

777
03:41:30.960 --> 03:41:47.920
responded to disappointing literacy outcomes by layering additional initiatives, interventions and supports onto existing practices without fully examining whether the foundation is producing the outcome students need. A strong intervention cannot fully compensate for a weak foundation just as

778
03:41:47.920 --> 03:42:03.680
exercise cannot overcome poor nutrition. intervention alone can't overcome an effective core instruction. The recommendation is to evaluate literacy efforts through outcomes rather than implementation alone. Families want the district to identify which instructional

779
03:42:03.680 --> 03:42:18.800
practices are producing measurable g measurable gains in reading proficiency. Strengthen what works, continue what doesn't uh discontinue what does not, and hold itself accountable for results. The question is not how many literacy initiatives exist. The question is whether more students are becoming

780
03:42:18.800 --> 03:42:34.800
proficient readers. And I'll say to that, um, parents are the first teacher. But if we're not engaging the families, we're doing a disservice to the kids. Your kid can go to school and learn all the things, but parents need to be involved because if parents not involved, we got

781
03:42:34.800 --> 03:42:51.359
latchy kids. They're not going home to do homework. They're just going home to do whatever at their leisure. But if there's a reading log that goes home and holds the parent accountable, the teacher accountable, everyone's checking in on that child's reading. But if there's nothing like that happening, you know, pipeline to prison's real. I I

782
03:42:51.359 --> 03:43:06.800
grew up in Boston. I worked in the criminal justice system. I've taught enrichment classes. So, I've seen people I grew up in the community go through the prison system because they have a middle school barely education. So, I've lived it. I'm almost 40. I don't want to be fighting this when my kids are 40. So, I'm trying to change this now.

783
03:43:06.800 --> 03:43:24.560
Reading should be the main thing. Like that should be something you graduate with. It's reading really is fundamental. >> And I mean it's like having a home is a foundation. Being able to read is a foundation. I'm a child of an immigrant who does not read or write in English or Spanish. My mom has dyslexia. I

784
03:43:24.560 --> 03:43:40.960
graduated with high honors. So I had to fight through chapter one. I don't know if you guys remember when it was chapter one in ESOL. And um and here I am. So, I'm a lived experienced Boston public student and I loved all my teachers. I had great teachers and I just want that for the next generation.

785
03:43:40.960 --> 03:43:56.479
>> And I just want to say we need to debunk the myth that some students cannot learn to read because we know from the research that 95% of students regardless of disability can learn to read with the right intervention. >> Oh, and I'm autistic as well. So,

786
03:43:56.479 --> 03:44:13.840
>> so I'm I'm all of the things. So, and and >> thank you. I appreciate that. Um, first of all, thank you to the three of you. Um, and I don't know if Elijah's coming back, but um, okay. Um, I actually had a question that, but um,

787
03:44:13.840 --> 03:44:30.880
>> the really appreciate uh, you're bringing these themes from parents and also bringing the student voice um, for that perspective as well is so helpful. um also appreciate the emphasis on tier one instruction as being the place where students receive the most of their um

788
03:44:30.880 --> 03:44:45.199
most of their teaching and learning experiences as they should and and the emphasis you had on acting on what we already know um and building on successes as we work to create a collective definition of strong

789
03:44:45.199 --> 03:45:02.720
inclusion practices. Um I know uh Chair Brazil you mentioned some historical examples of strong inclusion practices. was wondering if there were any um that parents are speaking about in the present that combine a strong um like

790
03:45:02.720 --> 03:45:18.160
pedagogical and like staffing or model for inclusion and growth outcomes like in the present that we might be able to um look at as we seek for that more universal definition of a strong

791
03:45:18.160 --> 03:45:34.479
inclusion model. So I think a a strong inclusion model really means investing in educators, investing in teachers. When we say that cut should um the last the last thing you want to do is cut those individuals who were closest with

792
03:45:34.479 --> 03:45:50.399
the students. I can say that in the first round of inclusion, you know, way back in the day, 1989, it was really investing in professional development, giving teachers time to plan and ensuring teachers had the

793
03:45:50.399 --> 03:46:07.840
expertise, but also ensuring that the the class size was right and making sure that each adult had, you know, it's it's sort of the the collaborative planning is probably the biggest piece because

794
03:46:07.840 --> 03:46:25.199
the collaborative planning has more to do with um teachers having the opportunity to plan in advance. So I'll give you an example of Mary Lion if that's okay and say how that developed. So Mary Lions became such a strong

795
03:46:25.199 --> 03:46:41.520
inclusion model because teachers led the professional development on site. So instead of teachers going to professional development, professional development came to them. And so there's always going to be one teacher that, you know, loves professional development and

796
03:46:41.520 --> 03:46:58.319
wants to lead the team. And you know, that's their thing. That's their jam. And so that teacher would get the PD and lead the PD in the school. What makes that authentic is they understand their student population. And so if they get a new student, those teachers will

797
03:46:58.319 --> 03:47:15.439
collaborate, get together, do the co-planning, talk on the weekends. When teachers are successful, they work beyond the school day. They meet for coffee. Uh they talk on the phone. They say, "Oh, we're getting a new student. What can we do? Let's get

798
03:47:15.439 --> 03:47:33.199
together and discuss it." It's really investing in teachers. when teachers feel that they have that agency to uh really create the instructional infrastructure and like if they don't have um if if if

799
03:47:33.199 --> 03:47:48.160
there's a lot of students who are struggling with reading, give them a reading specialist. You know, a lot of times we look at uh students who are acting out, but that's a data point. students act out when something is not

800
03:47:48.160 --> 03:48:04.080
working. And so what we've seen over the years is you know m what we see what we saw initially is it didn't I wouldn't I'm not going to say it didn't matter who the principal was but the principal could change but this those teachers who

801
03:48:04.080 --> 03:48:20.399
are have stable teaching forces they don't leave they've been at the school for 30 years 25 years when someone comes in new they orient that individual to the way that school runs I can point to the Manning as an example They were an

802
03:48:20.399 --> 03:48:35.680
extremely strong inclusion model where they previously had substantially separate classroom for students with emotional impairment. They partnered with um Italian home. They they um had um partnerships with local um community

803
03:48:35.680 --> 03:48:52.720
centers and and and health centers and and they and they invested in their teachers. And so when a an inclusion model unravels, the first question that I have is, is there teacher turnover? Because teachers are are

804
03:48:52.720 --> 03:49:08.239
you know when the model is successful and the teachers are engaged in professional learning, you ultimately have a stable teaching force. And I'm not saying they never change, but the culture the the the culture of a professional learning community is there

805
03:49:08.239 --> 03:49:24.319
and that is what fosters success is investing in teachers who are working close closest to the students. >> I appreciate that and agree. I'm wondering how parents are assessing whether that is present from what you

806
03:49:24.319 --> 03:49:41.199
all are hearing. You know, we heard a lot of public comment today around um student assignment and feeling as if some schools are ready and truly living an inclusion model versus just having the model more by label or as was

807
03:49:41.199 --> 03:49:57.840
expressed. Um and just wondering what are you hearing from parents in terms of how they're differentiating the two? Um because to your point Sh I agree professional development is so important but parents might not even know the level of professional development that's happening from one school to the other

808
03:49:57.840 --> 03:50:13.439
in as much detail. So what are some of the indicators that parents are using to say this school not this school when determining that the inclusion model is in place in terms of >> for me it's most parents talking to each other.

809
03:50:13.439 --> 03:50:29.760
>> Okay. So, not knowing how to even find sometimes the welcome center is an issue. Um, a lot of people don't even know this building exists. So, that's one thing. A lot of the parents have issues finding where to register their kids and when they register their kids, what programs are offered. They see the

810
03:50:29.760 --> 03:50:45.680
list and that's as far as they go because they don't know there's an option to go do a deep dive and actually visit the school and learn what what they offer. So if that's explained in layman's terms to them, not just a packet that says parents rights, parents don't really know what their rights are,

811
03:50:45.680 --> 03:51:01.279
they can read that. If they don't speak English, they don't understand their rights. And then they go to the welcome center, they'll get a list, and then they'll check off the list, and then their kid gets placed somewhere. Now, because they didn't know that they had the right to go visit the school or call the school and find out what services off or even know what services their

812
03:51:01.279 --> 03:51:17.439
child needs, that's the issue. The IEP being done is one thing, but half of the time it's them getting support from the social worker at their PCP. It's not because they're getting support from the district. So if they if they didn't have a a social worker or they don't go to a primary care doctor, they go to a

813
03:51:17.439 --> 03:51:33.920
clinic, now they're not even getting that social worker's help. So that's the issue. They're not having someone that there's not a point a point person. So they're navigating it from hearsay from another parent. And I would add I would add to that that uh what does success look like in terms of an inclusion

814
03:51:33.920 --> 03:51:49.840
school? Yes, the metrics can be parent feedback. >> And so if you you think of say the Henderson, which is kind of a unicorn too because um of the nature of why it was designed, but part of it was to

815
03:51:49.840 --> 03:52:06.080
include students who would otherwise go out of district. And it it worked really really well because parents felt that their children were safe. They felt welcomed. They there was a sense of belonging and they were making progress.

816
03:52:06.080 --> 03:52:22.239
>> H forest man. Um so my son's 24 now, but when he went to Horus man, there were hearing kids in his class as well. It wasn't just all inclusive to deaf kids. >> And um eventually he had to go out of district, but he I didn't want him to go out of district because that was his community. So he had to go to the learning center for deaf to learn how to

817
03:52:22.239 --> 03:52:38.800
read at 21. He should have gotten that at Horus man, but it was specifically ASL for deaf kids. And to Edith's point, when you're in sub substantial um separate classes, he missed out on that reading aspect because he wasn't around his hearing peers, only when they did

818
03:52:38.800 --> 03:52:54.399
recess or lunchtime. But they were always in the same school together. So if they would have merged them together, his language would have belt. his he has friends that speak that are profoundly deaf, but he doesn't because he didn't have that connection and he didn't have that community. And then he had to go out of district for two more years past

819
03:52:54.399 --> 03:53:09.279
the time he wanted to stay in and he was given a completion of um high school. But I said no and um now he has a diploma. But parents should parents that don't know how to navigate that end up with a kid that just has that completion. And I would say that um

820
03:53:09.279 --> 03:53:26.319
success should also be measured on reducing um dependence on outsourcing. >> Yes. >> Uh reducing dependence on litigation and reducing um uh spending on out of district placements over time. M

821
03:53:26.319 --> 03:53:43.600
>> so for example when the Henderson 9 through 12 is closed those parents whose children go to the lower school are thinking where is my child going to fit >> thinking that right now what school has the capacity for my child

822
03:53:43.600 --> 03:53:59.920
>> and then all the other things that come with it like the child might be bullied at the new school they don't have supports this their their teacher that may have encouraged them to get to the next grade now that teacher that they're familiar with that would have been their teacher in the next school year is gone. So the comfort of knowing I'm going to

823
03:53:59.920 --> 03:54:16.880
be here till 8th grade is now taken away from them and they're in a whole new school setting where they have to learn to adapt to things that they're not used to. It it really affects the kid overall when they're not good with transition and then drastically their school has changed overnight. It's not an easy way

824
03:54:16.880 --> 03:54:32.640
to adapt for them when they whether they have a disability or not, but definitely when they have a disability >> and and it's where can where how does a district build capacity to have that seamless alignment for transition for children who would otherwise go to the

825
03:54:32.640 --> 03:54:49.120
Henderson and and so that really includes the staff who have the specialization, who have the professional development, the expertise and also have that collaborative planning ing model like where does that exist for in that way

826
03:54:49.120 --> 03:55:05.359
for those students and I I really think that parent feedback is an assessment because you know there's a bottleneck effect on you know trying to get into certain schools that may be outside of your region and when you see that bottleneck effect and and and parents

827
03:55:05.359 --> 03:55:22.720
for example because we've talked to them decide oh I'm going to homeschool my child I'm gonna take my chances on a charter school >> or I'm gonna um you go some maybe primoco because parents are out of desperation they want to find a a model

828
03:55:22.720 --> 03:55:40.560
that works and and and so it's it's it's not that they don't want to be in BPS they want to be in a neighborhood school in in in the district but when parents go to advocates and attorneys and through litigation is because they're desperate and those metrics that I

829
03:55:40.560 --> 03:55:57.520
talked about welcome challenge sense of belonging and making progress are not there for their children. >> Yeah. I just wanted to um engage um Elijah briefly before we moved on because I really appreciated I think we all did um the clarity and and honesty

830
03:55:57.520 --> 03:56:14.640
of your sharing your student experience. So, thank you for doing that. And we were talking a little bit um on this last question about bright spots or where things have worked. And you talked about some of your experiences where you felt like your um classroom experiences were not preparing you at the level that

831
03:56:14.640 --> 03:56:30.239
you wanted and was wondering if you have had any experiences over the course of time in your school that were opposite that and what they looked like that were more engaging and more positive than some of the ones that you said. as we think about trying to build on

832
03:56:30.239 --> 03:56:47.880
successes. >> Um, there's not many that I can think of. I feel like I've always felt like like the work was just never challenging. >> Just something I can bang out in 5 10 minutes. And um,

833
03:56:47.920 --> 03:57:03.520
one way that I really learn, one way that I learned that the work was to prepare me for college was my aunt was in college and she was talking to me about all the work she has to get done. And I'm like, that doesn't seem like anything I'm doing or even close to it. Like, that seems way more complicated.

834
03:57:03.520 --> 03:57:19.040
I'm not prepared for that at all. Like, the way the assignments they give us to me, it's insulting almost cuz it's just like I feel like we're we're in high school, we're in 12th grade. This is like I say sixth, seventh grade level work. >> So,

835
03:57:19.040 --> 03:57:40.160
>> thank you for sharing that. Thank you. >> Thank you. Um, I feel what has been very helpful for me this year has been able to listen in on your monthly phone calls where we can hear the voices of parents and recognizing that almost a quarter of

836
03:57:40.160 --> 03:57:56.319
our district are have our families who have children with special ed. So that's almost what 11,000 families and we don't hear from nearly that if we hear from 1%. And so my question to you is like

837
03:57:56.319 --> 03:58:11.920
what can we do? I mean I understand and agree with all of the things that you have raised as concerns as well as recommendations for improvements. But what can we do as a collective, a

838
03:58:11.920 --> 03:58:29.199
district and sped PAC, etc. to reach out to make sure that all families are aware and then trying to look collectively at do we have the resources

839
03:58:29.199 --> 03:58:44.319
to actually do what families need when we have that significant number of families. many of the things you talk about are the same things we need to do for our typically developing students

840
03:58:44.319 --> 03:59:02.080
and it's not happening for them either. So the question is, you know, how do we really become a district that is in strong partnership with all families, but especially our families with children with special needs, so that

841
03:59:02.080 --> 03:59:19.840
these things get discussed and grown in ways that we can begin to make the difference. Well, I would say I'm glad uh Chair Robinson that you came to our table because coming to our table would allowed you to hear the perspective of

842
03:59:19.840 --> 03:59:36.880
families. So, our town hall that we had on May 28th was the highest attended general meeting that we had this year >> and because it was led by Family Voice, one of the things that we have asked for and we believe would be helpful is for

843
03:59:36.880 --> 03:59:52.560
us to be part of an inclusion task force where we can make recommendations and bring that parent expertise and voice into what makes a good inclusion school. We have the questions. We have the data

844
03:59:52.560 --> 04:00:09.600
on what is and is not working. And parents have that expertise on knowing what works. And and it's it's it's it's tough right now going for parents to the welcome center. And I I just have to be um clear and say

845
04:00:09.600 --> 04:00:25.439
that some families have told us they've gone and and they looked at a school and they think that is a possibility and the school will quietly tell them we can implement your child's IEP. The school just does not have the resources. And parents appreciate that,

846
04:00:25.439 --> 04:00:42.319
but it's scary to hear it >> as well because what school what other schools are not being as candid about what they can and cannot do because I think schools need to be supported and that's where that infrastructure comes in the district saying what are the

847
04:00:42.319 --> 04:00:59.920
non-negotiables? How can schools be fully resourced and staffed? Because that's really where it is. You cannot have an inclusion school unless you have an infrastructure for staffing and and all of the things that we talked about this evening. And that takes more

848
04:00:59.920 --> 04:01:17.840
money. It is expensive. Inclusion means that there's a place in in the school for every student regardless of the nature and impact of their disability. And to do that, you're going to have to not just look at your staffing, but

849
04:01:17.840 --> 04:01:32.720
you're going to have to look at environmental adaptations. Do you have a sensory room? Do you have technology? Do you have specialized equipment? Do you have um are you able to adapt the environment so that the school looks

850
04:01:32.720 --> 04:01:48.960
like an inclusion school and and students and and it's and it's accessible to all students. And so that that takes the lens of parents who know what their children need to say we've

851
04:01:48.960 --> 04:02:04.960
captured that and and that's where building trust and partnership comes in as well. I mean, you've responded to you took the words out. I was going to say the something similar, but

852
04:02:04.960 --> 04:02:21.760
>> I mean, just to piggyback on what you said earlier about um implementing spaces like the sensory spaces, orchard gardens does do that. So, I've seen at different schools, I've seen a little bit of everything that you discussed. But if all of the schools had a quiet corner, so when you're unregulated, you

853
04:02:21.760 --> 04:02:36.880
can just sit there and they have sensorary toys or you can read your book. Like if a child brings a book to school, they can go sit in that corner. The teachers do that at Orchard Gardens, but I don't see that at other schools. But that was just the teacher doing that because that's something they thought would work. It's not the school telling

854
04:02:36.880 --> 04:02:54.960
them to do it. these teachers just, you know, they know their student and they were like, "Okay, I'll make this area." So, it was nice to go to parent teacher night and see that they had these spaces, but it wasn't in every classroom. It was just certain teachers doing it. >> Well, thank you again for tonight. Um,

855
04:02:54.960 --> 04:03:11.840
this has been very, very helpful and we look forward to meeting with you again um in the fall. But if in closing, if there's one thing that we can do to start the new year off better next year, what would be a top thing that community

856
04:03:11.840 --> 04:03:26.560
engagement, >> pardon me? >> Community engagement. Like having some sort of outreach for the family so that they know in verbiage they can understand because that a lot of the times if they'll look at that paper, I don't know what this is about and that's it. So they won't come out if they they're reading words they don't

857
04:03:26.560 --> 04:03:41.920
understand. And if English is a second language, just forget about it. They're not going to come. And I I would say yes strengthening parent partnership which has to do with the shared the co-creation shared decision making implementation planning but I would also

858
04:03:41.920 --> 04:03:58.560
say I would go back to the beginning and say look at what is working >> you know replicate and scale success whether it's a program whether it's an intervention how do you do that across the district and create that infrastructure

859
04:03:58.560 --> 04:04:14.640
by looking at what what is a district already doing successfully and because like I said we look at problems and look at data but what is the action plan and how do you replicate best practices in

860
04:04:14.640 --> 04:04:31.040
schools that are struggling working hard but don't know what to do. >> Great. Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you very much. Um before we do the last part of the meeting, we're going to take a five minute break and then we will come back to do the next two two

861
04:04:31.040 --> 04:19:19.279
pieces. >> Thank you. >> Thanks. teachers that >> Thank you. Thank you, Spedpack. Thank you very much. We appreciate you guys. >> On to the next item. >> Okay. >> Yeah, I I'll be

862
04:19:19.279 --> 04:19:35.120
>> Thank you. >> No, we're we're doing good. We're going we're going to get out of here by 11:00. All right. Thank you. Our next presentation tonight is the superintendent school year 202526 summitive evaluation.

863
04:19:35.120 --> 04:19:52.080
Evaluating the superintendent is among the chief responsibilities of the school committee. The superintendent completed her self-ealuation and shared it with the committee for review. Each committee member completed an an individual evaluation providing their insights and

864
04:19:52.080 --> 04:20:09.520
assessments of the superintendent's performance. Dr. Alkins and vice scar vice chair scarret led the process this year and consolidated our feedback into a comprehensive summitive evaluation which will be presented this

865
04:20:09.520 --> 04:20:25.600
evening. We will vote on the superintendent summit of evaluation at our virtual meeting on July 8th. I will now turn it over to the superintendent remarks followed by Dr. Alkins and vice chair scarret. After the

866
04:20:25.600 --> 04:20:42.239
presentation, I will open it up to the other members for comments on the superintendent's evaluation. I'd like you to I would like to remind you to speak at a slower pace to assist our interpreters. And I now invite the superintendent to give introductory remarks.

867
04:20:42.239 --> 04:20:57.680
>> Wonderful. Thank you, Chair Robinson. I'm I'm certainly grateful for this opportunity to reflect on my work as superintendent and the progress that we're making as a district. I first want to thank Chair Robinson, Vice Chair Scarit, and all of the members of school committee for your continued support and

868
04:20:57.680 --> 04:21:14.880
guidance as I begin the fifth year of my superintendency. I also want to give thanks to Vice Chair Scarit and Dr. Alkins for their work in directing the evaluation process. Certainly, the questions, the feedback, the collaboration from this committee helps me and my team continually

869
04:21:14.880 --> 04:21:30.720
evaluate our work and improve. And I'm deeply grateful for our partnership and our shared belief in the potential of every BPS student. I'd not be able to do my work without my talented and dedicated team. I just tried to get them to leave and they were like, "No."

870
04:21:30.720 --> 04:21:46.239
Um, this year was especially challenging as we faced new budget pressures, some of which were out of our control and could not be predicted, including changes in federal immigration policies and the rising cost of health care, transportation, and special ed services.

871
04:21:46.239 --> 04:22:02.960
My team has worked hard to find operational efficiencies. We've eliminated vacant positions. We've made difficult staff reductions to ensure the district's priorities were not impacted and student services were protected. And we're especially grateful to the district's school leaders for working

872
04:22:02.960 --> 04:22:18.560
with us to navigate these changes. I've said before, every day I wake up feeling positive and excited about the work ahead and proud of what we've accomplished together. And that holds true literally every day. I've always said when that stops being true, it's

873
04:22:18.560 --> 04:22:35.359
probably time for me to go. Good news is that's not yet. feeling um certainly for school year 2526 has been one of a lot of reward. There's just a ton of high points to celebrate as we come to the end of this school year. We began the

874
04:22:35.359 --> 04:22:51.680
school year with historic highs in bus on-time performance, higher attendance rates, and 99% of school meals being prepared in-house with locally sourced fresh ingredients. students returned to improved and upgraded facilities. And we cut the ribbon on two new schools, the

875
04:22:51.680 --> 04:23:07.680
Sarah Roberts Elementary School and the state-of-the-art Carter School and celebrated the renovation of East Boston's PJ Kennedy Elementary School. Over the past four years, we've intentionally created the foundation for academic growth. We're now starting to

876
04:23:07.680 --> 04:23:24.000
see the results of our work. Six BPS schools were named as schools of recognition by DESIE, the highest number of BPS schools ever honored in one year. Two schools exited the highest level of DESIE oversight, and six schools rose from the 10th accountability percentile,

877
04:23:24.000 --> 04:23:39.279
more than any other year before. We saw historic gains in the access assessment for our English language learners and increases in reading and math at nearly every grade level on our MAP growth assessments. As a district, we met three end of the year targets at midyear.

878
04:23:39.279 --> 04:23:54.800
Reading achievement, grade three to five rigorous expecta expectations, and chronic absenteeism. In fact, we're close to meeting our chronic absenteeism on target for 28% by the end of the school year. We also improve from baselines on nine metrics. Additionally,

879
04:23:54.800 --> 04:24:11.840
seeing higher CGP fall to winter this year than fall to spring last year on reading and math. We are also seeing significant strides at the secondary level, too. Earlier this spring, Desi released graduation data that showed the district's 2025 4-year cohort graduation

880
04:24:11.840 --> 04:24:29.199
rate increased to 81.3%, which was a 1.6 percentage point increase from last year, marking strongest graduation outcome the district has recorded since records were began being kept about 20 years ago. Simultaneously, we saw a decline in the

881
04:24:29.199 --> 04:24:45.680
number of students leaving school before earning a diploma, a historic low. Our annual dropout rate fell to 3.6%, which was almost a full percentage point decrease from the previous year, and it was really the lowest on record, minus the pandemic year of 2021.

882
04:24:45.680 --> 04:25:01.760
We've expanded the availability and range of AP courses to students with approximately 3,800 students enrolled in an AP course in 2025. And we've seen a huge success in the exam scores with 68% receiving a score of three or higher.

883
04:25:01.760 --> 04:25:18.159
This year more than a thousand students participated in early college and 2500 students participated in career tech education which will lead to a certification. We still have a lot of work to do, but I'm confident that we can build on this momentum. And by continuing to build

884
04:25:18.159 --> 04:25:34.960
sustainable systems that lead to long-term progress after many years of inconsistent growth and incremental movement for the district, we're starting to see results. We're getting closer to closing learning and achievement gaps, not widening them, and actually not starting them.

885
04:25:34.960 --> 04:25:49.520
I just want to again thank you for the opportunity to speak tonight and and I really do look forward to my partnership with each of you and I really do appreciate the genuine feedback you've given me in my evaluation. Chair, I'll pass it back to you, >> Dr. Wilkins.

886
04:25:49.520 --> 04:26:07.120
>> Uh thank you uh school committee. Uh thank you superintendent. Um and uh I want to give a shout out uh one to former vice chair Michael O'Neal who used to chair this and so now uh he has

887
04:26:07.120 --> 04:26:23.359
passed the duty on to me and the new vice chair. Um but uh thanking him for his uh continued insight. Um, and also I want to send a shout out to Rebecca Granger who had a huge hand in organizing um, us and just sort of

888
04:26:23.359 --> 04:26:39.279
wrangling us, making sure that we were on top of getting all the evaluations put together and just aggregating um, all of this. So, thank you. So, um, the Boston School Committee has a number

889
04:26:39.279 --> 04:26:55.199
of responsibilities, um, including defining the vision, the mission, the goals of BPS, establishing and monitoring our annual operating budget, hiring and managing and valu and evaluating the superintendent, and setting and reviewing district policies

890
04:26:55.199 --> 04:27:11.520
and practices to support student achievement. um to give some uh knowledge around the evaluation steps and just what the process is. Um so for for the public uh annually the school committee does have

891
04:27:11.520 --> 04:27:27.279
a school or a school committee retreat where among other things we discuss um goals and priorities um with the superintendent in collaboration with the superintendent um so that we can have alignment with how we want to assess

892
04:27:27.279 --> 04:27:43.439
progress uh in for the district for the year and also in thinking about um its long-term sustainability and success. Um and in the evaluation process, those goals are um then reflected upon by the superintendent in in her um

893
04:27:43.439 --> 04:28:00.159
self-evaluation. Then following that um individual members will also submit their their own evaluations and then we pull together a summit of evaluation um reflective of all of our feedback. And then finally um per our vote in July

894
04:28:00.159 --> 04:28:17.680
uh we will vote on the summit of evaluation and performance rating. So a little bit behind the actual standards. Um so DESIE um provides um the standards for the superintendent evaluation across four different domains. One being instructional

895
04:28:17.680 --> 04:28:34.239
leadership, the second being management and operations, the third being family and community engagement, and the fourth being professional culture. Um and you'll understand a little bit more uh around that just given the feedback. And so to reflect on um what the school

896
04:28:34.239 --> 04:28:51.439
committee priorities are uh and what was agreed upon um like at our retreat and through numerous conversations um the school committee has prioritized accelerating academic performance. So, for example, um utilizing highquality instructional materials and our

897
04:28:51.439 --> 04:29:07.040
evidence-based practice um our um use and our um support for multi-tered systems of support throughout the district. U improving our access to advanced coursework and the continued um educator professional learning.

898
04:29:07.040 --> 04:29:24.479
For priority two, we always want to ensure access for all students. And so that consists of a couple of different dimensions um which consists of continuing to refine the structures and processes that prioritize learning experiences for students with disabilities, multilingual learners and

899
04:29:24.479 --> 04:29:40.080
multilingual learners with disabilities. Um expansion of all programming and courses that build multilingualism and multiculturalism um including a like host of uh of examples within there. So, dual

900
04:29:40.080 --> 04:29:57.120
language, transitional bilingual um education and heritage language courses. And then the last priority is uh making sure that we maintain consistency and highquality learning opportunities. So, and continuing our implementation of the long-term facilities plan and ensuring

901
04:29:57.120 --> 04:30:12.000
access for every student to a highquality student experience um and rigorous uh and culturally affirming learning experiences that include wellness and enrichment, a supporting network of caring adults and the physical spaces that do support

902
04:30:12.000 --> 04:30:29.040
learning. So within the evaluation um we we assessed the superintendent across a number of goals. Um and so the first goal that was aligned um to that first priority was accelerating academic

903
04:30:29.040 --> 04:30:45.040
performance that was measured through um national metrics and performance on those state and national metrics such as MCCAST access and NAPE and advanced placement some of which you heard um in the superintendent's introduction. Um

904
04:30:45.040 --> 04:31:01.279
also uh and data related to increased student engagement um including decreasing chronic absenteeism and dropout rates and increasing rates of graduation and secondary pathways um secondary pathways enrollment. And so I

905
04:31:01.279 --> 04:31:17.520
will not necessarily reiterate all of the statistics but I think some of them bear uh mentioning again. So, the historic 81.3 um percent graduation rate uh particularly um with increases for black and latine students, students with

906
04:31:17.520 --> 04:31:32.800
disabilities and multilingual learners alongside a nearrecord low dropout rate of uh 3.6%. Um, superintendent also noted the 38% increase in early college um, enrollment

907
04:31:32.800 --> 04:31:49.199
with about 2500 students participating in CTE programs and about 68% of advanced placement um, students scoring a three or higher on their exams and of course a surge of students who received a seal of biiteracy.

908
04:31:49.199 --> 04:32:04.880
Uh the committee also recognized the proficiency increases in grades 3 through eight uh ELA and math MCCAST uh which is the third consecutive year of meeting chronic absent uh I'm sorry um the third consecutive year of meeting chronic absenteeism targets and

909
04:32:04.880 --> 04:32:21.359
improvements in access scores for multilingual learners. And while celebrating these milestones, um the committee noted that we must work urgently to accelerate progress for the majority of our students. Most critically, uh despite progress, only a

910
04:32:21.359 --> 04:32:36.880
third of BPS students are meeting or exceeding expectations on the MCCAST in grades 3 to 8 across core subjects. But to accelerate the rate of progress, the district must strengthen early education or that prek to two uh range in terms of

911
04:32:36.880 --> 04:32:51.279
literacy practices to ensure that students have a strong foundation. Further, with the statewide elimination of state exams graduation requirement, Mass Core must reflect a commitment to rigorous academic experiences consistent

912
04:32:51.279 --> 04:33:09.199
across all of our schools. related to student learning goal two for ensuring access to all students. Um the district would like to celebrate uh the annual progress toward full implementation of the inclusive

913
04:33:09.199 --> 04:33:26.959
education plan. So uh we are in the uh third ending the third year of a complete five-year rollout. Uh the committee um noted also the expansion of inclusive settings into the additional grades, inclusion planning teams in every school, service mapping efforts to

914
04:33:26.959 --> 04:33:43.039
align supports and resources and opportunities for multilingual learners through the expansion of dual language and bilingual uh programming and of course the launch of the reimagined school funding formula. The committee also applauds the district's sustained

915
04:33:43.039 --> 04:33:59.920
investment in HQIM um and the associated professional development and focus resources uh for students with disabilities and multilingual learners. And while this growth um signals commitment to equitable access and inclusion, the

916
04:33:59.920 --> 04:34:15.600
committee stressed that the successful implementation must be determined and measured by reported family experiences and academic outcomes, not solely by input milestones. Collectively, we named the need for greater transparency and communication

917
04:34:15.600 --> 04:34:34.959
around the impact of inclusive education efforts and more concrete data around classroom level implementation and application of professional development learning. for um student learning goal three or consistency or ensuring consistency in

918
04:34:34.959 --> 04:34:52.719
highquality learning opportunities. Under the leadership of Superintendent Skipper, the district has continued to make notable progress um in our gains to rightsize the the district and move towards the 2030 vision of approximately 95 highquality schools. This includes

919
04:34:52.719 --> 04:35:10.160
the uh 10 capital projects that are currently underway and the continued refinement of programs that meet the needs of our students. Of particular importance is the timeline leading up to public announcements and committee votes. The current window between

920
04:35:10.160 --> 04:35:26.480
announcement and school committee vote left some affected communities expressing feelings of being caught off guard and excluded from meaningful participation before decisions were finalized. The long-term success of this plan will depend largely on whether the affected

921
04:35:26.480 --> 04:35:46.719
communities feel they were true participants in the process. And so for everyone um watching at home um this is a representation of the DESIE rubric. um BPS um or the the school committee has adapted uh Desi's four

922
04:35:46.719 --> 04:36:08.080
category superintendent evaluation rubric into a more nuanced five category rubric that subdivides the proficiency rating into developing and effective. So when we look at the first standard um regarding instructional leadership um

923
04:36:08.080 --> 04:36:24.480
again we want to note some of the the highlights. Um the district-wide implementation of highquality instructional materials across all grades and continued examination and refinement of their use is a significant step uh towards the consistency of

924
04:36:24.480 --> 04:36:40.639
highquality classroom experiences. Additionally, we can note that the that the superintendent and her team um has allowed for and has created that HQM is now paired with 12 hours of additional

925
04:36:40.639 --> 04:36:55.279
um professionally of professional development um focused on inclusive and culturally responsive teaching practices. And BPS has strengthened its multi-tered systems of support across all schools uh leveraging um AI to

926
04:36:55.279 --> 04:37:15.520
support this work. And if we look at the distribution of ratings for our for our school committee, we can see that six um folks on the committee noted um gave the rating of effective. So just

927
04:37:15.520 --> 04:37:32.959
highlighting again that uh five dimension rubric um that we have looking towards standard two around management and operations. Fiscally, we applaud the roll out of the reimagined school funding formula that focuses on

928
04:37:32.959 --> 04:37:48.561
the instructional needs rather than on enrollment. Uh the mid-year deficit of 53 million, however, begs our attention to strengthen proactive rather than reactive measures that support long-term sustainability. The escalating costs such as health

929
04:37:48.561 --> 04:38:04.639
insurance and transportation are of particular importance to the committee and the district. Operationally, the administration demonstrated strong execution capacity by advancing MSBA core projects over multiple years, securing invitations for the accelerated

930
04:38:04.639 --> 04:38:20.080
repair program, and opening two new school buildings, the Sarah Roberts and the Carter. This school year marked an increase in in bus on time performance driven by the success successful deployment of the zoom tracking application which increased athletic

931
04:38:20.080 --> 04:38:37.119
trip coverage and even uh our district has received national recognition for green initiatives such as the fleet electrification and the indoor air quality monitoring system. Our focus areas, as mentioned earlier, do include reducing chronic absenteeism rate of

932
04:38:37.119 --> 04:38:53.119
30.9 and outstanding um work orders that still exist for capital repairs. Further, we want to note that the district has made gains in its racial, ethnic, and linguistic diversity of educators, suggesting a more well-prepared workforce for our

933
04:38:53.119 --> 04:39:10.799
students. The committee remains concerned about our impending reduction of staff and how this impacts the gains that our students have seen and um the the staff themselves. Just looking at the distribution

934
04:39:10.799 --> 04:39:33.520
bearings very similar to uh standard one. Standard three, as we think about family and community engagement, we've heard um a bit about that in our previous presentation. Um and I think it's fair to say that um our evaluation um

935
04:39:33.520 --> 04:39:51.040
reflects an alignment there. Um so the district we note has strengthened its communication efforts and infrastructure and the touch points that enhance access to information for families. And some of those noteworthy accomplishments include the successful implementation and use of

936
04:39:51.040 --> 04:40:07.520
parent square, the increased multilingual communication support from uh through the office of language access, improvements to our own district website, responsive family support system such as the BPS helpline and our focus outreach efforts that have increased the district's ability to

937
04:40:07.520 --> 04:40:25.280
connect with families. Moving forward, the district has to continue to cultivate um and include timely responsiveness to follow-up inquiries from families to ensure our accountability and particularly during complex decisions. We must unpack what

938
04:40:25.280 --> 04:40:43.718
transparency means for communities, i.e. It means earlier engagement that clarifies roles and decisions, ensures that there's adequate representation and opportunities for collaborative problem solving with the community rather than one-way communication.

939
04:40:46.798 --> 04:41:07.040
And so the distribution of responses shows um um the superintendent and um her team receiving effective and both developing um ratings. and rounding out um the evaluation with um standard 4 and professional culture.

940
04:41:07.040 --> 04:41:22.480
Under the superintendent's leadership, central office has successfully established a robust feedback structure driven by the superintendent's personal participation in monthly meetings with regional superintendent, operational leaders, and the school leader cabinet

941
04:41:22.480 --> 04:41:37.600
allowing for quick responses and continuous improvement. We applaud the successful roll out of broad-reaching professional learning, including those additional 12 hours of district-wide professional development. And also under um the superintendent's guidance, the

942
04:41:37.600 --> 04:41:54.320
district has launched a comprehensive process to develop the new BPS strategic plan serving in tight alignment to the revised opportunity and achievement gap policy. Moving forward, the committee um advises that the district must ensure that

943
04:41:54.320 --> 04:42:09.040
families, students, and stakeholders clearly understand how their valued perspectives and lived experiences actively drive the content and implementation of the strategic plan and are active partners in supporting the vision.

944
04:42:09.040 --> 04:42:26.718
With PD as a core priority, the district must continue to build a safe and inclusive organizational culture that's built upon mutual trust and respect to sustained continuous learning and ensure that educator voices are heard and encouraged. Professional learning should

945
04:42:26.718 --> 04:42:46.958
be aligned to practical classroom conditions and the needs of our educators. And so highly effective and an effective rating. And so together um these overall ratings average um a score of four 4.0 out of

946
04:42:46.958 --> 04:43:03.360
five. Um and so this um as per the the DESIE uh rubric this um indicates that performance consistently and consistently exceeded expectations in all essential areas of responsibility and the quality of the work overall was

947
04:43:03.360 --> 04:43:22.400
excellent and that annual goals were met. And so just showing a distribution across all the dimensions of uh each school committee member. Our aim is for all of these to be in

948
04:43:22.400 --> 04:43:38.400
that highly effective rating. And just another way just to to show the entire distribution of all responses. And so family and community engagement um always is challenging I think um to

949
04:43:38.400 --> 04:44:00.958
just to to acknowledge um but it is very doable um for our district. >> So just um showing the average uh numerical uh breakdown for each rating. And so in summary uh we highlighted um

950
04:44:00.958 --> 04:44:17.520
certain areas of strength. Um so of course the institutional stability and steadfast leadership uh superintendent has consistently used the image of sort of riding the ship and sort of needing to slow it down before you pivot and turn it in a direction where we know

951
04:44:17.520 --> 04:44:34.240
that we are moving in uh in a positive direction and um I think our evaluation is reflective that um that that's what we exactly what we're doing and so uh we are thankful for her commitment. Um we are thankful for um the strategic

952
04:44:34.240 --> 04:44:49.520
direction that's uh that she is providing and that the team is enacting. Additionally um areas of strength that we noted were increases in those indicators that were tied to student success. So many of the the national

953
04:44:49.520 --> 04:45:05.440
scores and the in in the growth still acknowledging that we have a ways to go. the commitment to equity and cultural competency. Um the superintendent has demonstrated a deep commitment to our workforce diversity and us um

954
04:45:05.440 --> 04:45:20.878
implementing and sustaining those culturally sustaining practices and u moving the district's curriculum and programming to be reflective of the rich diversity that our students and our families bring to the district. Um and

955
04:45:20.878 --> 04:45:38.480
of course uh last um the sup superintendent has uh successfully executed critical operational upgrades including more equitable school funding in the reimagined school funding model, a supportive regional model and an improved transportation efficiency as

956
04:45:38.480 --> 04:45:56.638
well as infrastructure for effective educator and school leader hiring and retention that has a direct impact on student achievement. So areas um for continued growth um as stated earlier uh community enga community and family engagement is by

957
04:45:56.638 --> 04:46:13.760
far the the the biggest challenge that we face. um transitioning from a culture of post-decision communication to one of early communication um that really discusses clarity of roles um one that um really thinks about how we're

958
04:46:13.760 --> 04:46:29.840
establishing those part those participation roles uh earlier in our process um and that we're conducting an equity analyses before announcing such structural changes and so um I think over the next uh year uh we're going to

959
04:46:29.840 --> 04:46:46.400
work collaboratively to revisit these systems to ensure timely and responsive feedback loops to uh constituent issues and inquiries. And of course, student proficiency and and um wide performance gaps. Um the the

960
04:46:46.400 --> 04:47:01.920
district we acknowledge is showing areas of improvement. However, we understand that overall student outcomes remain largely unchanged and the progress is not even across our schools. Um and so we understand that this issue is urgent

961
04:47:01.920 --> 04:47:18.240
for everyone and um knowing that we need to accelerate these academic outcomes and close and close persistent achievement gaps for multilingual learners, students with disabilities and our historically marginalized student groups. And so uh we look forward uh so

962
04:47:18.240 --> 04:47:35.440
we just voted on the policy. So um this is one step in the right direction. Um but um we do look forward to making progress and receiving updates as a committee on many of the key indicators named in the OAG policy and also

963
04:47:35.440 --> 04:47:51.680
including some monitoring on um preK2 literacy and numeracy um which we and also uh data on our educator uh diversity workforce and the how we're developing relational trust where our

964
04:47:51.680 --> 04:48:08.638
students and our families are partners in ensuring their their student success. Additionally, we noted areas in goal setting and accountability where we are looking to establish long-term measures and targets um to be reported annually.

965
04:48:08.638 --> 04:48:23.920
Um thinking about smart goals is another way to to put it where we are looking at annual targets as u measures and indicators of progress. um and looking at um measures um um tied

966
04:48:23.920 --> 04:48:40.480
to key inputs and investments to track whether or not our district is successfully moving our strategic levers identified um to drive student outcomes. And last, um thinking about how we are preserving our key investments. Um, so

967
04:48:40.480 --> 04:48:55.360
this is going to involve working more closely with the city to carefully manage and forecast these escalating operational costs such as transportation, health insurance, um, and utilities that really to limit the impact on studentf facing resources and

968
04:48:55.360 --> 04:49:12.000
district priorities. uh as a key example of district prioritization, the superintendent um and her team must execute a deliberate strategy to protect the gains that we've made in our workforce diversity amid shifts in the staffing and upcoming contract negotiations.

969
04:49:12.000 --> 04:49:26.718
And so as we enter into our new year, we understand that the the district must actively gather feedback on the re-imagine school funding formula and partner with school committee and the wider BPS community to identify areas of

970
04:49:26.718 --> 04:49:49.520
improvement and additional investment. So as we look forward to what our next steps in the evaluation process, um we think about a vote on the summit of evaluation and the performance rating on July 8th and thank you.

971
04:49:49.520 --> 04:50:06.160
>> Thank you. >> Yeah. Very good. Thank you all. >> Yeah. Very good question. >> All right. So opening it up for questions, concerns. Cole. >> Sure. Um, I want to thank Dr. Alkins for leading that um, astute summary uh, and

972
04:50:06.160 --> 04:50:23.120
for your leadership through this process. I want to thank Superintendent Skipper and your team for your leadership. Um, and I also just wanted to maybe narrate a little bit about our approach and kind of guiding principles to the um, evaluation itself uh, with a

973
04:50:23.120 --> 04:50:38.480
real commitment to it being a datadriven document. um with that data being about student outcomes first and foremost um also about the programmatic updates that we've received throughout the year from various team members on your team,

974
04:50:38.480 --> 04:50:55.600
Superintendent Skipper. And um last but certainly not least on the community engagement and feedback that we've heard throughout the year. Um, I think today was a great example with the diversity of testimony in terms of things that are of great importance to families and

975
04:50:55.600 --> 04:51:11.760
staff. Um, that our hope is that some of those themes um are reflected in some of the areas for continued growth. Um, and that that um those themes are reflected in some of the things that we want to continue to monitor. I know that

976
04:51:11.760 --> 04:51:29.600
sometimes the nature of public comment at these meetings can feel like I'm able to quote it because I have a written one. We talk at each other rather than talking with each other. Um but we are listening as a school committee and while we're not always able to respond in the moment, um those testimonies um

977
04:51:29.600 --> 04:51:44.718
and collective experiences really serve to push our probing and thinking around where the district um can strengthen. And so, um, really just appreciate all of, um, my colleagues, uh, in using

978
04:51:44.718 --> 04:52:00.718
those data points to, um, really celebrate successes, uh, and by next year be able to be at an even greater capacity to have a datadriven evaluation as those goals that Dr. Alkins referred

979
04:52:00.718 --> 04:52:18.560
to will be clarified um, and those long-term targets will be set. Thank you. Others >> I have a glow that we forgot is the uh we put in the uh the the

980
04:52:18.560 --> 04:52:34.718
launch the nation's first gay viant >> uh on ever. So that's a globe >> and and also the um one thing a growth

981
04:52:34.718 --> 04:52:51.760
for me will be probably to think about how um is family engagement and how to build a concrete measurable uh process for families to feel heard and uh before

982
04:52:51.760 --> 04:53:08.400
anything is discussed. >> Yeah. Microphone. Okay. Anyway, thank you for a very thorough and thoughtful analysis with your you know with your input

983
04:53:08.400 --> 04:53:24.798
regarding the the uh overall picture of everything. I I appreciate that. The only the only thing that I noticed uh among us among the members of the committee, we all each of

984
04:53:24.798 --> 04:53:41.360
us look at the same exact data uh under each criteria uh look at the same uh um information as well as the narrative

985
04:53:41.360 --> 04:53:56.320
everything we look at the same. The funny thing is each of us come up with a different rating. Um so what I'm trying to convey here is that

986
04:53:56.320 --> 04:54:12.480
regardless of what we do everything that we have been doing so far there is always an element of subjectivity in it. So we'll we'll have to carry that with us.

987
04:54:12.480 --> 04:54:30.400
and um the the uh evaluation that we we've we've done while I I appreciate it but um in my mind even this this subjectivity of each of us I uh really

988
04:54:30.400 --> 04:54:47.120
really do not agree with the you know with the overall uh rating that's that's just me. Thank you. >> Okay. Do you want to clarify that anymore? >> Do you want to clarify what you mean by that?

989
04:54:47.120 --> 04:55:04.638
>> No, there there is no need to to to to to clarify anything. Each of us is entitled to our own subjectivity in uh putting down the rating or the performance evaluation whatever. Even

990
04:55:04.638 --> 04:55:20.320
though we are all looking at the exact same information, data, narrative regarding each each category, >> but when we put down when we put down the rating >> Mhm.

991
04:55:20.320 --> 04:55:35.920
>> each of us come come with different you know different rating anyway. some with you know some cluster together some some are not so it

992
04:55:35.920 --> 04:55:54.160
just that I know the the the reason I'm I'm raising this is it's not is it's is nothing is nothing of a a critique no it it's just that um >> I uh enjoy the diversity

993
04:55:54.160 --> 04:56:10.000
put it that way >> that's why there's seven of us. >> Also, Mr. Tran, I think it is important that we retain our individual interpretations of the data. I do think there is alignment in that um none of

994
04:56:10.000 --> 04:56:25.360
the categories has us further than one rating apart um from one another. And so, while there isn't sameness, there is some level of um closeness in terms of where we're viewing successes. So I um

995
04:56:25.360 --> 04:56:42.080
>> I think as Dr. Akins showed in the distribution there are different ratings but not there there aren't outliers that's that stand multiple steps away from another either. Um, but I appreciate the point that we should

996
04:56:42.080 --> 04:56:57.440
probably should not all have identical interpretations of the same data, but should be able to substantiate our Yeah, we should be able to substantiate our um positions. And what we tried to do was take the most prevalent themes from everyone's

997
04:56:57.440 --> 04:57:19.040
individual um report and rise those to the summitative. But the public does have our individual reports as well um if folks wanted to read those. um so that you can get everyone's specific feedback. >> I' I've read most of your evaluation as

998
04:57:19.040 --> 04:57:32.878
well. >> Mhm. >> And I've read evaluations of other members before. Um I myself sometimes do have issues or

999
04:57:32.878 --> 04:57:54.000
or ideology that may be far different from what that Mary is implementing. Uh I be very frank inclusion right now I I I don't really the inclusion practice is something that I don't really buy

1000
04:57:54.000 --> 04:58:10.958
into it yet but looking at everything given before me based on information maybe I'm maybe I'm such a mechanical guy or >> put the mic >> I have the mic >> yeah maybe I'm I'm such a mechanical guy

1001
04:58:10.958 --> 04:58:28.000
even though there are things that I may not agree with uh Mary but when it comes to making a determination on you know on the four corners of the performance. I believe that is where I I

1002
04:58:28.000 --> 04:58:44.400
put myself down >> where where I I I put the assessment in regardless of whether the programs the projects the uh initiative is something that I have concern with. But if if if the per

1003
04:58:44.400 --> 04:58:59.040
performance is there that I believe is far exceed what what we expect then so be it. She deserves it. That's all I say. Well, what what I would say is that um

1004
04:58:59.040 --> 04:59:17.280
what is comforting is that within our evaluations there was um and I I'm just saying this more like qualitatively like there was consistency in what we identified as areas for growth. Mhm.

1005
04:59:17.280 --> 04:59:33.680
>> There was consistency in and I think where the differences I think some of the things that you're pointing out some of the differences were actually in highlighting certain accomplishments, right? So some things might resonate more with us on an individual basis for

1006
04:59:33.680 --> 04:59:49.520
in terms of accomplishments, but we were all pretty consistent on what we identified as areas for growth. >> And it's comforting to know that that aligns with even what we've heard here tonight from other presentations. Um, and not just that, but it's also in

1007
04:59:49.520 --> 05:00:06.718
alignment with what the superintendent identified herself as like I know that this is an area that like we need to address. And so, um, you know, I take that as a, you know, as a strong as like a as a strong indicator that like moving

1008
05:00:06.718 --> 05:00:22.798
forward that there's like that there's, um, agreement in how maybe not necessarily always how we go about the change, but that this area needs to be addressed. And so, um, yeah, >> thank you.

1009
05:00:22.798 --> 05:00:40.480
>> I agree. >> Thank you so much. I I just want to start by saying thank you to um members Alkins and and Scar because we have to do individual evaluations and you have to do yours and also combine all of

1010
05:00:40.480 --> 05:00:56.718
ours. So thank you so much for for that work and to superintendent um skipper I said in my evaluation that this is not an annual evaluation. This is for me it's a four months evaluation >> because that in my capacity of a of a

1011
05:00:56.718 --> 05:01:10.718
member of the committee has been four or five months working with you. But I I do want to say thank you so much uh for the things that been mentioned here for your leadership for the stability that you are bringing to the district for your

1012
05:01:10.718 --> 05:01:27.040
commitment that is clear. Um anybody working with you knows that your heart is on this work and and that's really really appreciated and we have we hope to keep you for a long time so you can keep uh driving this ship in the

1013
05:01:27.040 --> 05:01:45.040
right direction. Um, in terms of things that I I'm really hoping that was you were able to to see, uh, I was happy to see uh, me member Tran that even though I'm the new guy, I wasn't too far away from the rest of my partners in terms of

1014
05:01:45.040 --> 05:02:01.600
uh, a couple things like like um, family and community engagement. U, I think that's that's an area that we all need to keep growing. Um I personally would like to see you uh in the room with the families and and it may be uh looking

1015
05:02:01.600 --> 05:02:19.120
for the different rooms >> than what we are accustom like where else are are our families that you will be good for you to be there and and and be available to to the families. And the last thing is about uh outcomes. When

1016
05:02:19.120 --> 05:02:37.520
when uh Dr. I said goals were met. Yes. And for next year I would like to see those outcomes with the metrics like you know we were in a on a retreat on May 20. Your team said that yes we are going

1017
05:02:37.520 --> 05:02:54.240
to work on on on those metrics and bring it to you before the end of this school year. I I I hoping that that's going to happen because for me it's going to be easier to to do this evaluation next year if I

1018
05:02:54.240 --> 05:03:11.520
know what was the goal like where are we trying to hit that target did we did it or not it's going to be easier in talking about subjectivity and and trying to align that subjectivity with the objectivity of having those metrics.

1019
05:03:11.520 --> 05:03:31.440
So thank you so much for your work. >> So yes, well first of all I want to say thank you to Dr. Alkins and to vice chair Scarret um for leading the superintendent evaluation process and to thank you to all the members for doing

1020
05:03:31.440 --> 05:03:48.000
your part also in getting us here. Um, and particularly want to say thank you to you, superintendent, and your team for all of the work that you've accomplished in this past year. Um, we thank you for the way you engaged in the evaluation process. That's always never

1021
05:03:48.000 --> 05:04:04.878
easy, but you gave us a lot. 34 pages worth of district accomplish, which is great. and your commitment to continuous growth and improvement in service of your team, the district and our students and their families is clear in the data you presented, the reflections you

1022
05:04:04.878 --> 05:04:21.680
shared, and your openness to discourse. And we talk often about what we're going to do to improve the family and community engagement, and I know you're right there with us. >> Absolutely. >> So, thank you again. And we will vote on the superintendent's evaluation at our

1023
05:04:21.680 --> 05:04:39.760
July 8th meeting. Okay, we're in the home stretch here, folks. So, our final presentation tonight, >> come on down. Is the private school

1024
05:04:39.760 --> 05:04:55.600
application for the South End Village Academy Private School. Let's aim to keep the presentation to four minutes. I'd like to rem remind our presenters to please speak at a slower pace to assist our interpreters and I want to invite

1025
05:04:55.600 --> 05:05:11.200
the superintendent to give introductory remarks. >> Great. So I will be brief. Um South End Village Academy Sila has submitted an application to operate at the site of the former Croft School on Washington Street in the South End. Uh, and as I

1026
05:05:11.200 --> 05:05:27.440
stated earlier in the meeting, the district's role in the process of approving a private schools application to operate in Boston is strictly administrative. At this point, I will turn it over to Ann Clark for the review of the process and the school's application. We plan to bring this to

1027
05:05:27.440 --> 05:05:44.560
our school committee on Wednesday, July 8th for the vote. >> Good evening again, Madame Chair, Madame Vice Chair, and members of the school committee. As you know from our earlier presentations this year, the Boston School Committee is responsible for

1028
05:05:44.560 --> 05:06:01.680
approving any private school wishing to operate within Boston city limits under Massachusetts General Law Chapter 76 section 1. Our internal review teams follows the process outlined in the school committee policy and evaluates

1029
05:06:01.680 --> 05:06:17.360
applicants against a defined set of criteria covering curriculum and instruction design, staff qualifications, facility safety and compliance, organizational governance, and financial stability.

1030
05:06:17.360 --> 05:06:34.560
The review follows a five-step process. application review, site visit, leadership interview, evaluation, and a formal recommendation to the superintendent and school committee. All five steps are now complete for the application before you this evening.

1031
05:06:34.560 --> 05:06:48.798
Tonight, as the superintendent said, you will hear from Southoun Village Academy, a new independent school proposed for 1525 Washington Street in Boston South End, serving students from preschool through grade three in its first year

1032
05:06:48.798 --> 05:07:05.760
with plans to expand to grade 6 over time. The application was received this spring. A site visit was conducted on June 3rd and the review team's recommendation has been submitted to the superintendent. The review team found

1033
05:07:05.760 --> 05:07:23.638
that SA meets the criteria outlined by the Boston school committee with conditions which are detailed in the review team report included in your materials. I'll now pass the presentation to head of school Christina Lopez from Southoun Village Academy.

1034
05:07:24.878 --> 05:07:42.240
Good evening, members of the Boston School Committee. Thank you so much for the opportunity to present tonight. My name is Christina Lopez. I'm here in my role as head of school and I'm here representing teachers and families that are intent on the survival of their beloved school community. The Southoun

1035
05:07:42.240 --> 05:07:58.798
Village Academy, or SA for short, was born from the wreckage that was left after the crisis at the Croft schools. We learned in early March about the inexcusable actions of the school's founder. We were informed that there was no more money left and I was tasked to

1036
05:07:58.798 --> 05:08:15.040
close school within a week. To me and to many parents and teachers in our community, closing early was not an option. SA immediately was established by parents as a nonprofit corporation to collect donations to fund the remainder of the school year at the South End.

1037
05:08:15.040 --> 05:08:31.280
They secured a 50 501c3 status and continued to raise over a million dollars in record time. Concurrently, they made plans to be an option in case a buyer was not secured for all three Croft schools. After months of a failed

1038
05:08:31.280 --> 05:08:46.480
sale process, SA exercised a purchase agreement to acquire the assets and the lease of the South End location. The possibility for a future of our new school was taking place. Our ability to mobilize, to raise

1039
05:08:46.480 --> 05:09:02.560
funds, and to create the plans necessary to responsibly run a school speaks volumes of how much we love our school, we need our school, and of our confidence that we can do a phenomenal job if given the opportunity. Our school is designed to be a

1040
05:09:02.560 --> 05:09:19.600
neighborhood school. We want to help be part of the reason why families can stay in our vibrant city. Our program is rigorous and joyful for students in and out of the classroom and also flexible, communicative, and supportive for all of our families. We are a village within a

1041
05:09:19.600 --> 05:09:35.840
neighborhood. It is grounded in the basics. We ensure the use of quality researchbacked curriculum. Give teachers ample time to plan together, to collaborate, respond to data, and communicate with families. We use project-based learning to get kids into the neighborhood to connect with and

1042
05:09:35.840 --> 05:09:54.000
learn from their neighbors. art, local organizations, and small businesses. Being a neighborhood school means that we have a priority to welcome and support all of our neighbors. We believe that diversity in all meanings of the word creates a rich community. We commit

1043
05:09:54.000 --> 05:10:10.080
to meeting students where they are academically and all families where they are financially. We want to make sure everyone belongs. I'm going to talk a little bit about some of the crucial components that we have secured or changed to ensure a viable path forward.

1044
05:10:10.080 --> 05:10:25.680
These are our lead teachers for each grade level next year. They accomplished the unimaginable this year through immense uncertainty. They are committed to this community unwaveringly and they are excited to continue their work with SA. The second is our building. Through

1045
05:10:25.680 --> 05:10:42.160
the purchase agreement, CA signed the lease at our 1525 Washington location. This has been our home since 2022. We have 5 years left on the lease with the option of two 5-year extensions. The next is enrollment. There has been

1046
05:10:42.160 --> 05:10:58.638
no existing independent school in the South End. There is demand. The Croft School in the South End went from zero to 145 within 5 years with no marketing. At this moment, we have almost 80 students enrolled across grades preschool through grade three for next

1047
05:10:58.638 --> 05:11:15.120
year. and we receive interest emails every day. The SA board did a lot of thorough work on our financial model. We have proven that we have enrollment which brings in tuition. We have a philanthropically committed family community and our financial models of our standalone

1048
05:11:15.120 --> 05:11:31.360
school apart from the rest of the Croft schools show that we can get to sustainable operating surplus over the next couple of years. In the meantime, there will be a deficit, but we were gifted a $1 million donation to help continue cover the commitment of financial aid and so that our program is

1049
05:11:31.360 --> 05:11:50.240
delivered with fidelity. Can I keep going? Lastly, we have a responsibility to establish a professional institutional-grade operation. We have set up all parts of the school thoughtfully with experts. It is a requirement after what we went through to be transparent, responsible

1050
05:11:50.240 --> 05:12:06.958
stewards of the school and this includes the SIA board. They are parents who are incredibly smart, committed to the mission and can oversee the proper execution of the school. They have already been doing this since March, meeting every other night after their day jobs, sometimes until midnight. They

1051
05:12:06.958 --> 05:12:22.638
have a wide range of backgrounds from nonprofit to business to education, and it has been a privilege to work with them. I'm grateful tonight to share with you why I am confidently believe in the future of SA and I thank you so much for your thoughtful feedback, questions, and

1052
05:12:22.638 --> 05:12:42.240
consideration. >> Thank you. And I'll open it up to the committee for questions. >> Right away, >> go ahead. >> To save time, very bluntly, what's the uh tuition?

1053
05:12:42.240 --> 05:12:59.920
$34,000 is the set tuition. >> And uh I I see that you have approximately 42% of students receiving uh tuition support or scholarship. >> That's correct. Okay. Around 30% of our

1054
05:12:59.920 --> 05:13:18.120
tuition dollars go to financial aid and that impacts 40% of our students. >> Right. So the the 77 the 77 students that you have right now uh um 42% that's pretty good and um

1055
05:13:18.160 --> 05:13:35.520
talk about the diversity and and and the soio economic uh status of of of students. >> The financial aid speaks to the socioeconomic diversity. Um so we use clarity to determine need um for financial aid. Uh for diversity, 40% of

1056
05:13:35.520 --> 05:13:51.440
our students identify as students of color. >> Good. Okay. Thank you. That's all I need to ask. >> I have one question. What is the admission process? >> The admissions process is very personalized. We get to know families um

1057
05:13:51.440 --> 05:14:08.638
very closely. And so after they express interest in our school, we invite them in immediately to meet the family, to bring them into their space, and to learn about them to see if it would be a good fit. They fill out an application. Um and then we decide on admitting them from there. If they are admitted, they

1058
05:14:08.638 --> 05:14:25.638
can choose to go through the program uh the clarity application to get financial aid. Um if they qualify financial for financial aid and there's enough room in our budget, we will populate a personalized tuition for them. Yeah,

1059
05:14:26.560 --> 05:14:42.240
>> like what I was going to ask was along the lines of the financial aid, is that 40% lower than what you had originally had as >> it's actually higher for next year um

1060
05:14:42.240 --> 05:14:57.920
given the attrition of students through the crisis. >> Yes. Um, and so the people who are staying were really committed to maintaining the financial aid status. And so we maintained a higher percentage of our financial aid students. >> And and so does your model also project

1061
05:14:57.920 --> 05:15:14.320
that like you'll be able to stay at about that 40% mark or higher? >> It's actually going to go down over the next few years. Would you like to speak to this? >> Sure. Um, thank you for the time. Um, so I spent I've um I've uh joined the CA board kind of in the in the midst of the

1062
05:15:14.320 --> 05:15:31.760
crisis and so we now have pretty have a pretty good picture of of the economics of the school just as we've basically been uh funding the bills basically for the school since March. Um and basically the the the crux of it is that um we have um our aroma is down and as you

1063
05:15:31.760 --> 05:15:45.680
might expect uh the people who were paying full tuition were more likely to leave than the people who are on some sort of financial need. And so now the number of that are on scholarship has gone up. Um the reality is that and you can see it in in the projections is that

1064
05:15:45.680 --> 05:16:01.840
the um absent uh significant philanthropic help over the course of on a sustainable basis that 40% or 40% of students or 30% of the kind of gross revenue number in aid is an

1065
05:16:01.840 --> 05:16:19.600
unsustainable figure. And so over time um we um it is an enormous priority for us to try to make that number as high as possible while also being financially sustainable. And so over time we project in you can see in our projections that that number comes down to something in

1066
05:16:19.600 --> 05:16:35.920
the in the order of 20% of gross tuition which probably means something closer to 25% are on some sort of aid which is and that's that's what we think is is um is feasible given kind of what we think is our fundraising capacity. I think it's

1067
05:16:35.920 --> 05:16:51.120
going to be an it's a it's a really a crucial part of what we are being a neighborhood school trying to serve um as socioeconomically diverse group as we possibly can um while also being financially viable. >> So I was probably going to ask more

1068
05:16:51.120 --> 05:17:07.360
about like just what you all had in the pipeline for philanthropy and just fundraising. >> Yep. So the um we have um you know I think I think we sort of surprised uh we were surprised by the um the generosity

1069
05:17:07.360 --> 05:17:23.040
that we had just within our parent community. Um and uh the the fundamentals of these independent schools and you guys know school economics better than I do, I'm sure, but these they they they're expensive to run. Um and the the major things are um

1070
05:17:23.040 --> 05:17:39.840
payroll which is it it costs what it costs to get great educators and um facilities are in in Boston in particular very expensive. Um and so part of our plan is um the the next major step for us is to um find a site

1071
05:17:39.840 --> 05:17:58.400
in which to uh in which to grow so we can actually get to basically to get back to the enrollment where we were at around 140 150 kids. Uh we have uh we have 140 uhish in the projections. Um and so we are um actively um actively in

1072
05:17:58.400 --> 05:18:14.480
negotiations for leasing a new space. And um as part of that, we're going to have to do a capital campaign to do the tenant improvements. And those tenant improvements are expensive. Uh this is like a two3 million kind of project. Uh and so we're going to have to start a

1073
05:18:14.480 --> 05:18:32.320
capital campaign very quickly. Um uh this summer we have um quite a bit of it already spoken for in terms of just interest from uh you know uh philanthrop people who are really eager to see the school succeed. Uh and so that's that's given us a head start. Um but that's

1074
05:18:32.320 --> 05:18:48.878
it's going to be it's going to be different than the than the cross school which was a for-profit school which didn't have uh philanthropic access. This is something that we um do have. We have it within our community and we think we have um a compelling story to tell to the to the larger um Boston

1075
05:18:48.878 --> 05:19:08.718
community as well. >> Um sorry, sorry. Um good evening. the 77 enrolled students right now. Do you have capacity to enroll more um for the 26 27 year and all all of your

1076
05:19:08.718 --> 05:19:25.120
budget assumptions based on the 77 as if you were to get no more students? This would be where you were. Are you still actively recruiting students? >> We're going slowly because of space. Um our building can accommodate I think 90 94

1077
05:19:25.120 --> 05:19:40.638
>> 94 kids. So we do have space where we can enroll more. However, um we are making sure that we are growing responsibly and making sure that next year's um there's stability. Um and so we could

1078
05:19:40.638 --> 05:19:57.360
enroll more. Um we don't necessarily want to. Was the budget built off of that number? 77. >> Yeah, the 77 we're a little higher now just as we're 81 now, >> but we're being cautious. I mean we can we can get to 94 or 95 based on kind of

1079
05:19:57.360 --> 05:20:12.480
what we think the occupancy is but it's it gets tight and so we're trying to be cautious about that. We we do have um you want to talk about some of the other alter space alternatives we >> Yeah, we build a lot of partnerships with neighborhood organizations and so currently we share space with the

1080
05:20:12.480 --> 05:20:29.280
Salvation Army for the past year and so we have a continuing with them to use their second floor which is a full gym and also classrooms. Um, and so we do have kind of across the street ability to walk across the street and have space there to continue to learn in their beautiful classrooms. We're also in

1081
05:20:29.280 --> 05:20:46.000
conversations with United South Settlements um to create anou there as well. >> Thank you. Um, just to extend on Dr. Alen's question around philanthropy, your model for this 26 27 year is very dependent on the pledge and annual fund

1082
05:20:46.000 --> 05:21:02.480
line in order to >> the black. How committed is that funding um versus in hand versus pledged? >> Um it is um it is pledged and ready to be delivered um by the this particular

1083
05:21:02.480 --> 05:21:18.718
um this it's actually a board member. Um, and so I think that's as it's as secured as it as it as it possibly could be a absent it actually being in our bank account, which it which it it's um right now we have um we have sufficient funds to uh to operate in the in the

1084
05:21:18.718 --> 05:21:34.958
bank account for now and so that'll be called when it's needed. Mhm. Um and are the projections for on the philanthropy line for the 2728 and 2829 year um based on kind of the internal board capacity

1085
05:21:34.958 --> 05:21:50.400
to give at that level or imagining that you would bring someone to focus on development or would that be kind of built into some of your existing roles in terms of where are the where are the projections coming based on?

1086
05:21:50.400 --> 05:22:06.958
Uh the projections are are really based on kind of what we think we can do within just the parent community. The um um we're hoping we can do more especially when it comes to the capital campaign which isn't in this budget. Um the just because that's it. This kind of contemplates the lease expense but not

1087
05:22:06.958 --> 05:22:23.040
the actual tenant improvement buildout which would be required. Um, and so right now we're kind of thinking that most of our philanthropy is going to be from, you know, the parent community, but we're we're we're hopeful and we have several um very skilled fundraisers

1088
05:22:23.040 --> 05:22:38.320
that are on the board um to be able to reach out to a broader um broader, you know, philanthropic group. I think over time we would love to add actual you know um uh professional development uh capabilities inhouse to to help with

1089
05:22:38.320 --> 05:22:54.000
this over time as we scale. But in the in the in the meantime in the interest of sort of being financially um prudent that's it's like that's a cost item we're just not prepared yet for but which is and the board is kind of doing a lot of that leg work for now. And just

1090
05:22:54.000 --> 05:23:11.440
related to the board um in terms of the I think um you said head of school Lopez that it's completely comprised of parents currently. >> Currently yes. >> Um is is there a um intention to seek

1091
05:23:11.440 --> 05:23:27.520
expertise in gap areas um that parents may not have? um what is the imagined kind of growth for the um for the board. It is a very impressive um set of experiences but particularly in the area

1092
05:23:27.520 --> 05:23:44.000
of finance for example um you know if you want to have a finance committee things of that nature um are you ex uh looking beyond the parent community and were any of these board members board members before um board members of

1093
05:23:44.000 --> 05:24:00.240
Croft? None of these board members were board members of Croft. These are all parents. Um we will definitely this this board was born in an emergency situation and we are still operating as such. We end school on Friday. Um and so

1094
05:24:00.240 --> 05:24:16.878
once school ends and SA begins on Monday, we can turn our eyes to see um what what will the board look like um and open procedures there. Um we also have we've had um we reach out to some

1095
05:24:16.878 --> 05:24:32.480
consultants too to kind of bridge the gap in some areas that we are missing um so that we can ask for advice um and make sure that we're taking the right steps. And so um an example of that is we hired a bookkeeper or we hired a consultant who has run um a school

1096
05:24:32.480 --> 05:24:47.680
similar to ours um and reached out as needed to be coached. Um and so we know when to ask for help and we've really appreciated that help. Um but the board is really doing most of it now. >> Great. Thank you. And my my very last

1097
05:24:47.680 --> 05:25:05.120
question just with the um public nature of um how you all have been birthed and what the school community has been through over the last year. Um do you have planned um more public communication updates around the

1098
05:25:05.120 --> 05:25:23.680
financial health um overall health of the school? um already set or is that something that you imagine are building into your plans um moving forward? >> So just to be clear on the question,

1099
05:25:23.680 --> 05:25:38.240
it's how are we going to share the message of our school more broadly within the public? >> Not really the message of your school. I I really mean like the um like the the financial health of the of the school

1100
05:25:38.240 --> 05:25:54.560
specifically um six months from now, one year, you know, like >> what does that look like? >> Yeah, I mean I think that's um that's a good question. The um because I think it's something that um we've had as as we've enrolled students, I think a lot of uh a lot of folks were, you know,

1101
05:25:54.560 --> 05:26:11.200
asking, you know, how does the how does the model work? Um, and so I think that's something that we haven't we haven't we haven't um laid out a precise roadmap in terms of how we're going to um communicate that to the community, but it's definitely on our radar screen. I mean uh we've we've lined up an

1102
05:26:11.200 --> 05:26:27.760
auditor as a nonprofit. We have much a much higher standard uh in terms of of of um of reporting. We are required to uh file a form 990. Um and we will get audited financials. Um, and so those are those are two things we're going to do.

1103
05:26:27.760 --> 05:26:42.718
Um, but in addition to that, I think we're going to be much more transparent about how things are evolving, you know, as the school year progresses. I think, um, I I think, you know, some sort of quarterly or or semiannual update about, you know, what our cash position looks

1104
05:26:42.718 --> 05:26:59.760
like, what are, you know, what our cost needs are for the next, you know, six months. I think those would be go a long way in terms of building back this the trust that we we need in in this community. Um obviously we we no one here was a part of kind of what happened

1105
05:26:59.760 --> 05:27:16.480
uh at Oxford Street, but you know we we have a we have I think what is like a kind of a traumatized group of of parents um who obviously didn't had no idea what what they what they were had gotten themselves into. And so I think we're going to on the side of um you know communicating and being as

1106
05:27:16.480 --> 05:27:33.200
transparent as we possibly can about how we're doing financially. >> Thank you. >> Um >> I'll keep my question I got a ton but I'll keep my question short. Um you mentioned in the equitable access multilingual learners saw that. I didn't

1107
05:27:33.200 --> 05:27:50.320
see anything about students with disabilities and so I was just wondering like >> what is your thinking about that model? Sure. Um so for our enrolled students for next year, we have 27% of them get services um based on an evaluation. We

1108
05:27:50.320 --> 05:28:05.840
work very um collaboratively to personally support each child. We bring in outside providers. Um we meet with them. Some of those providers have um executed parent workshops to learn a little bit more about their approach and

1109
05:28:05.840 --> 05:28:21.680
also trained teachers. So we have a wider skill base on their approach. Um and then we work with families very um like in in tight feedback loops so they understand what interventions are we doing, how is the service provider working at school. Um and we have seen a

1110
05:28:21.680 --> 05:28:38.000
lot of success with students who have pretty significant diagnosis. >> Do you have a sense of like your current population that you're projecting of the 77 what portion have an IEP? We I think for next year there's no confirmed IPS although there's a few in

1111
05:28:38.000 --> 05:28:54.160
process right now but like I said 27% receive services based on an evaluation. Got it. I mean I only say this because of the conversation I was having earlier which is facilities is definitely your driving cost. Staffing unknowns

1112
05:28:54.160 --> 05:29:12.240
>> in the form of what students need is like another. And so I think I would just think about having funding set aside for those kinds of unknowns to keep sustainable. The other thing is when you jump from 77 to 140, are you

1113
05:29:12.240 --> 05:29:27.920
you're not building up third to fourth, you're taking in a block of grades at that point. We will grow by one grade every year. But the but the to answer I think your your question is the the the bulk of um of the enrollment increase

1114
05:29:27.920 --> 05:29:43.520
comes from the lower grades which is which is uh which is uh which we what we've historically had we've had two preschool classes two go >> exactly and that's and that's actually I mean in some respects in terms of what's like most uh e easiest to rely on is

1115
05:29:43.520 --> 05:29:59.760
that is the demand at that young at that younger level uh for preschool and prek and there where there's a lot of demand and in our neighborhood. And so that I think we're very very confident in those things where where it's harder and I'm sure you guys know this as well just in terms of enrollment at the higher grades

1116
05:29:59.760 --> 05:30:16.240
it's harder it'll be harder to backfill any of the students that we lost in the crisis basically in the you know third grade fourth grade but we're going to try our best to get to um to add because you know once we have we have incredible teachers there in a classroom with 10 kids that could easily have 11 or 12. We

1117
05:30:16.240 --> 05:30:33.120
would love to add additional students there. Um you know, and now that could be somebody that can pay full pay and that could in many cases those are great opportunities for uh very high need uh students because there's that those are places we have a lot of access capacity

1118
05:30:33.120 --> 05:30:48.798
and so that's that's uh what we'd like to do. >> Historically, we have added at our higher grades. So this past year with second grade, which is our oldest grade, we had four new students. One came from abroad and a few came from private schools where they were getting on a bus to go outside the city. And so families

1119
05:30:48.798 --> 05:31:04.558
who decide that they really want to raise their kid in the city and chose something outside of the city originally kind of were looking at us as a solution to staying in the neighborhood. Um and similarly before this crisis when we were adding third grade we had three families interested in joining third grade. Um so there is a little bit

1120
05:31:04.558 --> 05:31:21.840
there. Got it. Um and last um the material component of what currently exists with Croft that will go away but these are things like technology desks furniture >> is it a clean break as in

1121
05:31:21.840 --> 05:31:35.920
>> yes >> every okay so just clean breaks >> on Friday it will cease to be crafts and on the next day it will be seas so that was our purchase agreement >> does the lawsuit that has been filed seize asset

1122
05:31:35.920 --> 05:31:53.760
of what was crossed >> not in the south end because of our purchase agreement. >> I see. Okay. >> Hi. Um question about um I know you're going to be operating in the south and are children from the Jamaica plane site

1123
05:31:53.760 --> 05:32:08.240
also coming to join you in this endeavor? I have spoken to 25 of the Croft JP families um as they are navigating this next step. Um I'm hoping that we'll be able to welcome a few of

1124
05:32:08.240 --> 05:32:23.520
them um at SIA next year. >> How long had crop been operating before this crisis? >> In the south end uh for four years. I was the founding head of school in the south end. >> And what about in Jamaica plane? In

1125
05:32:23.520 --> 05:32:40.480
Jamaica plane it was six years. >> Six years >> and Providence eight years. >> Okay. >> What was the what was the Oh god, I'm so interested. What was what was the initial since you were the founding? What was the initial enrollment at the

1126
05:32:40.480 --> 05:32:55.520
beginning in South? >> Oo, you're testing me very late at night. >> Um, we had two preschool classes and one prek class. I can't remember the number. It was roughly 50. >> Yeah. Like maybe more. Yeah.

1127
05:32:55.520 --> 05:33:13.080
>> And then what what did it max out at? >> Uh yeah. 124 >> this past year. 124. >> So there's a lot of good information in that about your financial sustainability.

1128
05:33:15.120 --> 05:33:32.638
>> I'm telling the K0 to K2 really the K to third grade is the most expensive grade. So anyways, there's a lot there to unearth but >> what is your financial plan

1129
05:33:32.638 --> 05:33:48.320
stability so that 3 years from now history does not repeat itself. I think first and foremost history will not repeat itself because we were one school of three and when we peeled back

1130
05:33:48.320 --> 05:34:06.320
the layers um there was just incredible inconsistency with how um like where the money was going and so our our financial analysis of our school as a standalone school was actually viable. I think JP's was viable as well. um it was Providence

1131
05:34:06.320 --> 05:34:22.480
um that was really struggling and so some of our um revenue was actually going to um so it's a totally different scenario which is why we've looked really hard at what is within our four walls and what is viable in the south end. Mhm.

1132
05:34:22.480 --> 05:34:38.638
>> I mean, I think um in terms of viability, that's kind of ultimately what's leading to the projections, which is is going to be a less is going to be a more moderate amount of financial aid, >> which is just a it's an unfortunate reality of trying to make this more

1133
05:34:38.638 --> 05:34:55.200
viable. Um, and then I think it's going to be exercising a muscle of of um of or developing a strong like philanthropy muscle to uh to basically be able to fund both um the kind of scholarship uh

1134
05:34:55.200 --> 05:35:11.600
part of the budget but also you know ongoing capital projects as needed. And so I think we're going to um we're going to start um be this we're going to start looking more like other independent schools which you know they have scholarship they have a certain amount of financial aid and then they have an

1135
05:35:11.600 --> 05:35:28.320
annual fund and then capital needs and we're going to be I think I don't think our um real estate is going to be the fanciest. I think we'd rather spend we it'll be adequate and and good but and we we'd rather allocate more resources to financial aid. That would be to us

1136
05:35:28.320 --> 05:35:45.440
that would seem like uh an accomplishment to be to be something that's like to to be to to make that more of a priority than our peers. And that's what we're going to do the best we can to to do. >> I know you're saying that this year the amount of financial aid is quite

1137
05:35:45.440 --> 05:36:00.558
substantial, but you would assume it will go down in future years. What does that do to the commitment to families who are there on financial aid because their need will probably not change but exactly how will you balance that?

1138
05:36:00.558 --> 05:36:18.000
>> Yeah. Which and so the we that was a promise we kind of when we decided we were going to take on the task of of continuing the school. We made a kind of a commit a commitment to that anyone that was here we were going to keep and and make sure that there was a spot for for them. And um that that is something

1139
05:36:18.000 --> 05:36:34.958
we honored. Um what it basically means that it on the incremental enrollment is going to be we're going to have to be um much like I think we're going to have to do less financial aid. So we're going to have more financial aid in the upper grades in in this next kind of interim

1140
05:36:34.958 --> 05:36:50.080
period. There's going to be more financial aid in the upper grades, less kind of at the preschool prek level. And over time it'll probably average out to more of a standard. you know, each class kind of has a certain amount. Um, but so but in this interim period, it's going to be a little lopsided because of

1141
05:36:50.080 --> 05:37:09.760
because of what we just described. >> Thank you. Anybody else have anything else? >> All right. Well, then thank you so much and we will vote on this at our July 8th meeting. >> Thank you so much. >> Is the extended day a separate financial

1142
05:37:09.760 --> 05:37:27.600
model? separate >> is it? Yeah. Is it a separate but No, it's in >> No, it's in our financial it's kind of like a pass through. We, you know, everyone's kind of build uh to the extent they sign up for extended day. Um and we're we're still um figuring out uh how we're going to manage financial aid

1143
05:37:27.600 --> 05:37:44.798
on that. Um but that's something that um it's a smaller number. It's something that's more manageable. Um and we're we're still kind of figuring that out uh as as we go. We're we've got um Clarity who's the the provider that we use there. They have a lot of good advice on this because they see this, you know,

1144
05:37:44.798 --> 05:38:00.638
every single day they see how schools are doing this and so we we're we're working with them to come up with something that feels um both, you know, financially responsible but equitable as well. >> Okay, great. Thank you. >> Thank you, Mr. Pav. We'll now return to public comment.

1145
05:38:00.638 --> 05:38:25.040
>> Yeah, John Mud. >> Thank you. Thank you. >> Thank you. I'm sorry to keep you at this hour but uh I'll try to keep it short. Uh uh I think it is important to try and put the

1146
05:38:25.040 --> 05:38:41.520
rich discussion you had around special education and inclusion in context. I started working around special education in Boston public schools in the 1990s. I hate to say and inclusion for special education students has traditionally

1147
05:38:41.520 --> 05:38:58.240
meant shifting special education students from substantially separate classes into mainstream regular education classes with the necessary training staffing and resources uh and with a special concern for the

1148
05:38:58.240 --> 05:39:13.360
disproportionate assignment of black boys into substantially separate classes. Research shows that this kind of inclusion can be good for students if done right.

1149
05:39:13.360 --> 05:39:28.160
But this kind of full inclusion of students with disabilities is apparently not happening. In its memo answering questions about the proposed FY27 budget, BPS that the school commit the

1150
05:39:28.160 --> 05:39:45.600
city council wrote requested. BPS wrote it could report no reduction in substantially separate classes, no reduction in the number of students in subpasses and no cost savings.

1151
05:39:45.600 --> 05:40:00.798
The number of percentage of students in sub classes I think is still hovering about a third >> and uh we do not have goals for the achievement of sub uh reduction of

1152
05:40:00.798 --> 05:40:17.040
subset or the reduction of black students in subset classes. you. Somebody asked what is one concrete suggestion to this bed pack and I would say take them up or you should take the

1153
05:40:17.040 --> 05:40:38.558
lead in collaborative planning. You have an institution under the the >> Okay. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. new business. >> My shout outs because of time

1154
05:40:38.558 --> 05:40:54.000
constraint. My shout outs will be on July 8th. >> Appreciate you. Thank you very much. >> I I say the same. I have some question about this live program, but hopefully we can talk about that in our next meeting. Do >> you have a memo?

1155
05:40:54.000 --> 05:41:10.240
>> You have a memo in your packet also some question some context. Yes. Okay. >> Oh, just to follow up on Mr. Peralta uh remark slide. >> Mhm. We have a P.

1156
05:41:10.240 --> 05:41:27.360
>> Yes. But could we have a member? >> Very office meet with us. >> Absolutely. Absolutely. Yeah. I I can call and explain it or Joel will. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. >> Thank you.

1157
05:41:27.360 --> 05:41:44.240
>> Okay. So, please note that our next meeting will be remote on Zoom on July 8th and will start at 5:30 p.m. So, if there's nothing further, I'll entertain a motion to adjourn the meeting. Is there a motion? >> So, moved.

1158
05:41:44.240 --> 05:41:58.878
>> Is there a second? >> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Is there any objection to approving the motion by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the meeting is adjourned. Thank you all. Have a good night. single out there.

1159
05:41:58.878 --> 05:42:02.680
>> Look at that same thing.

Part: 2

1
00:00:16.240 --> 00:00:36.399
committee. I'm chairperson Jerry Robinson. We'll begin with the pledge of allegiance. >> I pledge algiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and

2
00:00:36.399 --> 00:00:58.719
justice for all. I want to welcome everyone who is joining us tonight in person on Boston City TV and on Zoom. Please note that we are starting at 5:00 p.m. this week in order to accommodate a very packed

3
00:00:58.719 --> 00:01:14.720
agenda. I'm going to ask everyone here in the chamber to please turn off the volume on your laptops or other devices so it does not interfere with the audio for tonight's meeting. Thank you all for your cooperation. Tonight's meeting documents are posted

4
00:01:14.720 --> 00:01:32.400
on the committee's web page bostonschools.org/schoolcommittee under the June 10th meeting link. For those joining us in person, you can access the meeting documents by scanning the QR code that's posted by the doors. The meeting documents have been

5
00:01:32.400 --> 00:01:48.720
translated into all of the major BTS languages. Any translations that are not ready prior to the start of the meeting will be posted as soon as they are finalized. The meeting will be rebroadcast on Boston City TV and posted on the school

6
00:01:48.720 --> 00:02:06.640
committee's web page and on YouTube. The committee is pleased to offer live simultaneous interpretation virtually in Spanish, Haitian Creole, Cverian, Cantonese, Mandarin, Vietnamese, and American Sign Language.

7
00:02:06.640 --> 00:02:21.920
The Zoom interpretation feature has been activated. Zoom participants should click the globe icon at the bottom of your screen to select your language preference. I'd like to remind everyone to speak at a slower pace to assist our

8
00:02:21.920 --> 00:02:37.440
interpreters. We'll begin the meeting with the approval of minutes. I will now entertain a motion to approve the minutes of the May 6th meeting and the May 20th retreat. Is there a motion? >> So moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Second.

9
00:02:37.440 --> 00:02:53.680
>> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Is there any objection to approving the motion by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the minutes are approved. We'll now move on to the superintendent's report. I present to you our superintendent, Mary Skipper.

10
00:02:53.680 --> 00:03:08.720
>> Uh wonderful. Uh thank you, chair, and welcome to everyone tonight. Um many of our BTU members uh in the audience. Uh so, as we close out the school year, I want to begin tonight by honoring the members of the Boston Public Schools family and the city's larger educational

11
00:03:08.720 --> 00:03:26.319
community that we lost this year. These are some of the individuals remembered for their dedication to BPS students, their families and staff, and the lasting impact that they had on many young lives. Rosco Baker, legendary athlete, community leader, trailblazer,

12
00:03:26.319 --> 00:03:42.239
educator, and mentor to countless Boston youth over his decades of service to the city of Boston. Mario Fina, a BPS bus monitor known for his patience and compassion that he showed to every child.

13
00:03:42.239 --> 00:03:58.560
Zachary Schwarz, a math teacher at the Holland High School of Technology, at the Al Holland High School of Technology, formerly the Burke, for his 10 years, all of the time he gave as the adviser for music and sports and the

14
00:03:58.560 --> 00:04:13.599
analytic club. Janette Cisco, retired media specialist at the former West Roxbury High School, who served BPS for 41 years. Gloria Smith, longtime director of welcome services, known for her

15
00:04:13.599 --> 00:04:29.840
dedication and passion for centering our students and families. Benjamin Julian Tan, a music teacher at the Ellis Elementary School, remembered for his talent, joy, and laughter. Tommy Glavin, a member of the district's

16
00:04:29.840 --> 00:04:46.320
facility staff, a hard worker who took pride in making sure our facilities were ready for our students and staff every day. And Yolanda Allison, a retired school counselor at the O'Briant High School, who had 33 years of service in the district and positively impacted

17
00:04:46.320 --> 00:05:19.600
generations of students in BPS. Please join me in a moment of silence in the memory of these individuals and any other members of the greater BPS community who we have lost this year. Thank you. I'd like to begin with an update on our

18
00:05:19.600 --> 00:05:34.960
budget. Last week, the Boston City Council took the important and difficult step to approve the FY27 Boston Public Schools budget and the supplemental appropriation re-requested for FY26.

19
00:05:34.960 --> 00:05:51.759
I want to extend my deepest appreciation to Mayor Woo for her unwavering support of BPS. This is not easy work. Our students deserve the careful consideration and thoughtful deliberation that was given to these budget decisions. As we've said from the beginning of this

20
00:05:51.759 --> 00:06:07.680
year's process, this was a very difficult budget. The BPS finance team worked hard to balance the rising costs of health insurance, transportation, increased special education services, and all of our collective bargaining

21
00:06:07.680 --> 00:06:22.800
obligations with an enrollment decline of approximately 3,000 students since last school year. The approval of this budget means a few things for us. That we will continue to build on our progress and invest in our long-standing

22
00:06:22.800 --> 00:06:39.919
academic priorities. It will help us to continue to build on inclusive education, the expansion of bilingual and multilingual programming, expanded access to early college and career pathways, and implementation of highquality instructional materials and

23
00:06:39.919 --> 00:06:54.720
strong instructional practices in programming to name a few. I also want to take a few minutes to clarify some information around hiring um and particularly staff positions as well as provide an update on hiring for the next school year which members have

24
00:06:54.720 --> 00:07:10.000
asked for. There's been some confusion around positions that were impacted by the FY27 budget. To ground everyone, we experienced an enrollment decrease of 3,000 students over two years, which includes a large

25
00:07:10.000 --> 00:07:26.400
decrease in multilingual learners due to the current federal immigration landscape. The district has also been in the long-term process of closing schools and consolidating classrooms to match enrollment needs even before this recent

26
00:07:26.400 --> 00:07:43.039
decline. An important point to remember is that even with the elimination of positions for FY2627, because we have 3,000 less students to educate, our teacher to student, PAR to student, and support staff to student

27
00:07:43.039 --> 00:07:59.199
ratios will remain at the same levels as last year. There are 368 permanent educators who were initially accessed. All permanent teachers and paras with seniority to whom we have a contractual

28
00:07:59.199 --> 00:08:14.560
obligation to find a position are guaranteed a position for the upcoming school year. The majority of the 368 permanent educators have already secured a position. 66 remain unassigned but we will

29
00:08:14.560 --> 00:08:31.199
identify a position for them before the next school year. There were initially 205 paras excessed 46 remain unassigned and again we'll find positions before the end of the school school year. So to be clear there

30
00:08:31.199 --> 00:08:46.959
will be no layoffs for this group of permanent teachers and par profofessionals. As with every year due to a number of reasons such as positional changes at the local school and district level um could also be a lensure issue,

31
00:08:46.959 --> 00:09:03.680
performance issues. Uh only provisional teachers and paraprofessionals without seniority may be affected. In the coming weeks and months, schools and the district will continue hiring for vacant positions with an intentional focus to help those provisional

32
00:09:03.680 --> 00:09:20.720
educators who have been with us to find open positions. I also want to shift over to an update on hiring for next year, which Dr. Alkins and others requested at last month's meeting. BPS staffing data is still in flux due to the ongoing hiring transfers and

33
00:09:20.720 --> 00:09:36.640
non-renewal decisions that happen at this time of year. As a reminder, October 1st serves as the district's annual snapshot for the data in in when we look at actual final staffing data. Office of Human Resources Chief Francis

34
00:09:36.640 --> 00:09:51.519
Kanty recently provided an update to the OAG task force and I think that information is important to share with you as well. Our current data snapshot from October shows 58.8% of the district staff members who

35
00:09:51.519 --> 00:10:07.600
identify as a person of color. Staff diversity for vital studentfacing positions, teachers, and school counselors reached 43.4% marking a 5-year high for the district.

36
00:10:07.600 --> 00:10:22.560
Language fluency has risen significantly with 275 educators reporting fluency in the 2025 cycle or what equivalent is equivalent to 42.7%. And to give you a sense that's up from

37
00:10:22.560 --> 00:10:40.399
what was 31% in 2021. As this data shows, OHR continues the hard work to recruit and retain our educators of color and multilingual staff. This continues to be our focus as we work with our provisional staff to

38
00:10:40.399 --> 00:10:57.760
find open positions and resolve any outstanding lensure issues or waiverss that may be needed as we move into the next fiscal year. We expect to provide an update to the committee with finalized numbers in the fall. There's also conversation about state pilot when

39
00:10:57.760 --> 00:11:13.519
it comes to MTEL and some other ways to be able to get lenture. And so we very much look forward to hearing more about that and being part of that. Um is that has been a challenge and a barrier particularly to our educators who themselves are English language learners

40
00:11:13.519 --> 00:11:30.240
with the MTEL. Quick update on school leader PD. Last week BPS school leaders gathered here for our professional development of the last one of the school year. This was a time for us to reflect on our achievements and growth, celebrate all

41
00:11:30.240 --> 00:11:45.920
the goals that we've met and those that we're working toward, note changes in leadership, and wish our retirees and colleagues well as they move on. We celebrated the retirement of three longtime school leaders who have given so much to our community. Tracy Walker

42
00:11:45.920 --> 00:12:01.920
Griffith, who is retiring from the Elliot K to8 innovation school with 33 years of service. Michelle Bernett, who's retiring from the Chitik Elementary with 34 years of service, and Paula Gonzalez, who's retiring from the Otis Elementary with 37 years of

43
00:12:01.920 --> 00:12:16.720
service. And actually tomorrow in in this room, uh we'll be celebrating all retirees um across the district as well. Uh another update on summer programming. As we close out the school year, we are

44
00:12:16.720 --> 00:12:33.680
excited to launch the 2026 fifth quarter summer and beyond season. This marks an important transition from the regular school year into summer learning enrichment and continued student support and engagement. In partnership with Boston After School and Beyond and our

45
00:12:33.680 --> 00:12:50.560
expanded learning opportunities department, which we call ELO, BPS will offer programming from Tuesday, July 7th through Friday, August 7th. Staff will also attend a professional development which will be held on Monday, July 6th.

46
00:12:50.560 --> 00:13:08.480
To this point, 4,631 students have enrolled in summer learning academy programs. We have a total capacity of 5850 for seats. So, there's roughly about 1,219 seats remaining for interested

47
00:13:08.480 --> 00:13:24.399
families. We have the second round being assigned this Thursday. We anticipate many of those available seats will be filled, but nonetheless, as I'll talk about later, we want families to continue to register. In addition, we have 2,856

48
00:13:24.399 --> 00:13:39.200
students who are currently enrolled in high school credit recovery across 12 sites and 625 students at the middle school level who are current currently enrolled in middle school course recovery opportunities.

49
00:13:39.200 --> 00:13:55.600
The exa uh annual exam school initiative is almost at capacity with 277 students enrolled with a total capacity of 290 seats. So, we're pretty close there, but we anticipate that that will fill. Families can continue to register their children

50
00:13:55.600 --> 00:14:10.880
at bostonschools.org and it's also on the homepage for easy family access. The district's user-friendly summer registration platform, ALA, is available in all BPS languages.

51
00:14:10.880 --> 00:14:28.480
The BPS specialized services office launched our extended school year 2026 or what we call ESY registration on March 16th. As of today, we have 2544 students who are currently enrolled in ESY with 8,241

52
00:14:28.480 --> 00:14:44.560
eligible students invited. ESY is our summer programming for students with disabilities and provide students with the opportunity to retain skills, build confidence, and prepare for the next school year in a structured, supportive environment. For

53
00:14:44.560 --> 00:15:03.279
support with registration, please email us at esy@ bostonschools.org or call 617-6358599. We encourage families to enroll in ESY in all summer programming as soon as possible to ensure their child has a seamless transition to summer. To

54
00:15:03.279 --> 00:15:19.920
support full cap enrollment capacity across fifth quarter programs, ELO is monitoring enrollment weight lists and remaining seats while coordinating outreach priorities with site coordinators and regional teams. School leaders are identifying students who are

55
00:15:19.920 --> 00:15:35.839
placed, weight listed, eligible but not yet enrolled or in need of additional summer support. Family liaison are helping coordinate direct family outreach through calls, texts, and language access supports. Offa is aligning clear and consistent

56
00:15:35.839 --> 00:15:51.040
family-f facing communications while the office of data accountability is supporting the use of enrollment data to guide targeted outreach. ESI is being engaged to confirm and align any additional invitation waiverss

57
00:15:51.040 --> 00:16:07.920
to eligible students and families and ESY special education and student support teams are coordinating with ELO to ensure students with support needs receive accurate information about available opportunities. The BPS helpline and welcome centers are

58
00:16:07.920 --> 00:16:24.160
providing stu families with registration, weight list, language access, and aa navigation support while site coordinators and regional operational leaders are confirming student participation, identifying barriers and ensuring outreach staffing

59
00:16:24.160 --> 00:16:40.000
and program operations and making sure they're aligned to fill any remaining seats so that we're full before programming begins. Finally, there's a limited number of youth summer jobs that are still available for youth who are interested in working and have not yet secured a

60
00:16:40.000 --> 00:16:56.160
job. Youth who have not been hired yet are urged to visit right away boston.gov/feutureboss as soon as possible. A quick update on the cell phone policy. As we mentioned at the last school committee meeting, we continue to move

61
00:16:56.160 --> 00:17:11.919
forward on drafting a policy on personal devices in schools. We continue to engage with the community and gather input from stakeholders including students and school leaders and staff. We are also tracking legislative actions

62
00:17:11.919 --> 00:17:28.480
at the state level on this topic in the fall. We expect to receive additional guidance from DESIE. We know this is an issue on top of mind for many students. We've heard public comment about it from families and from educators. We'll continue to keep this body and the

63
00:17:28.480 --> 00:17:46.640
public updated as we finalize that policy next fall. Couple couple bright spots knowing how long the agenda is. Um first, I'm thrilled to share that BBS has been chosen to participate in Bloomberg Philanthropy's new national skilled trades initiative, an exciting first of

64
00:17:46.640 --> 00:18:02.640
its kind in the nation initiative designed to offer high school students a direct path to apprenticeships and high wage careers in the skilled trades. Here in Boston, one of nine regions nationally, the initiative will be based at Madison Park Technical Vocational

65
00:18:02.640 --> 00:18:23.360
High School. Boston will receive $12.8 million to build a pathway for at least a 100 BPS students each year to secure apprenticeships in the construction trades and water utility management sectors. >> There's a loud applause from the crowd.

66
00:18:23.360 --> 00:18:39.919
BPS is grateful to Bloomberg Philanthropies for this powerful recognition of BPS's commitment to providing students with sustainable, viable career pathways and opportunities. It's truly exciting for our students. Also, congratulations to the English High School baseball team.

67
00:18:39.919 --> 00:18:56.240
Expect another huge round of applause. Which advanced to the division five finals this week for the third year in a row. Is anyone from English out there? Go on. That's good news. Um, this is the third year in a row that they they've done this. Uh, you might remember that they won the D5 championship back in

68
00:18:56.240 --> 00:19:12.799
2024. So, please join me in rooting for the Eagles as they start their next series against Georgetown on Friday. Good luck and go. In closing, we'd like to share a video of highlights from the 2025 2026 school year. This look back is over an incredible school year capturing

69
00:19:12.799 --> 00:19:28.960
some of the most memorable people and moments. I want to thank the talented BPS digital content team under the leadership of Chris McKinnon, our chief of comms, for putting this together. The team visited 80 schools this year and covered more than 300 events in a

70
00:19:28.960 --> 00:20:37.520
stories across the district. So, you can imagine it was tough to squeeze everything in into just a few minutes, but we hope you enjoy it. So, with that, we'll play our video and then I'll hand it back to you, Chair. Heat. Heat. And I remember storming into my

71
00:20:37.520 --> 00:20:52.720
principal's office demanding that we get this course. Can we just do that real quick? I'm tired of life. Then I need one more over here. >> I like to think that I' I've played a part in um you know, really creating a culture of fitness and strength. >> Um I'm hoping after I graduate, I get

72
00:20:52.720 --> 00:21:07.760
hired here and I'll work here for a couple years. And after that first year of playing, I just didn't want to stop playing. Just wanted to continue and get better. >> I had heard a lot of good things about the fact that it was a healthc career school and the fact that it was

73
00:21:07.760 --> 00:21:50.000
vocational. I am a finalist for the Massachusetts State Educator of the Year. I'm tremendously grateful for Boston Mountain Schools giving me my start in 2010 as a long-term sub. Thank you, Superintendent. Um, given the length of tonight's meeting, I'm going

74
00:21:50.000 --> 00:22:12.799
to ask members to submit their questions to Miss PVX for us to answer at a later date. But if anyone has any quick comments, I will take that. But longer questions should be submitted. You can go ahead. Go ahead. >> Um just

75
00:22:12.799 --> 00:22:29.520
feeling so much pressure with the length of the agenda. Um just uh very much appreciate superintendent the updates on where we are with um staff who was who were affected by the budget. Um I'll I'll submit my actual questions, but I do appreciate that update. Just want to

76
00:22:29.520 --> 00:22:45.440
clarify that MTEL for folks who may not be familiar is testing um for educators related to lensure. just for folks who may not um know the uh the initials and also helpful to hear the summer numbers, the distinction between summer

77
00:22:45.440 --> 00:23:00.799
programming and credit recovery. I think is important for folks to know the difference between and just an early flag that in the fall when we have our update on summer programming, we would love the data team to think about how to connect participation in those summer

78
00:23:00.799 --> 00:23:16.159
programming with effects on summer learning loss or whether the intention of the program such as the exam school initiative actually um results in a higher yield for students who participate in those programs. Actually

79
00:23:16.159 --> 00:23:30.720
just on that uh that point because I know uh member scar you had asked this before. Uh we will we can say that in in 2025 uh 2024 into 2025 about half of the students that participated in ESI also

80
00:23:30.720 --> 00:23:46.320
received an exam school seat and in this last cycle it was it increased to 63%. So that is uh we're our goal is 100% but uh we're working really hard on that and and a big piece of this is making sure that that program is full every summer. >> Thank you.

81
00:23:46.320 --> 00:24:01.840
>> Well, no problem. >> Thank you, Superintendent. I just want to bring the attention back quickly to what you said about that there are still youth jobs available. Um, in my house, we are describing that process this year

82
00:24:01.840 --> 00:24:19.039
as a a crush course on adulthood given the amount of paperwork that has to be gone through. But it's worth it. And I really want to encourage all our youth 14 and above, if you still don't have a job, contact the office because they can

83
00:24:19.039 --> 00:24:37.760
guide you through the process. It's an intense process, but they are there to help you. Thank you. No. Um, I just wanted to do one quick shout out about what happened this morning at the O'Donnell School. Um the mayor and many of our partners who are

84
00:24:37.760 --> 00:24:54.880
working in the Wicked Math program were at the O'Donnell this morning to celebrate a young fourth grader um who achieved the highest score on the math um champion test and is going off to represent the state of Massachusetts um

85
00:24:54.880 --> 00:25:11.200
in Texas. >> Um he's a fourth grader. Um we we we we had a wonderful opportunity to both observe and participate in math games with um a wonderful group of third and fourth graders who come to school

86
00:25:11.200 --> 00:25:28.400
early two mornings a week um to um play all kinds of math games and clearly love math. And so there's a lot of good work out there. I don't know if other people here are part of Wicked Math, but we really got to see what it looks like and hope that all of our schools will make

87
00:25:28.400 --> 00:25:44.640
this possible for all of our kids. It was quite inspiring. See, >> so thank you. >> Okay. So anyway, thank you all and I will now entertain a motion to receive the superintendent report. Is there a motion? >> So moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second?

88
00:25:44.640 --> 00:25:58.799
>> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Is there any objection to approving the motion by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the superintendent's report is approved. We will now move on to general public comment. Miss Prebex.

89
00:25:58.799 --> 00:26:14.960
>> Thank you, chair. The public comment period is an opportunity for individuals to address the school committee on school related issues. Questions on specific school matters are referred to the superintendent. Questions on policy matters may be discussed by the committee later. The meeting will

90
00:26:14.960 --> 00:26:30.480
feature two public comment periods with the first comment period limited to one hour. After one hour, anyone who hasn't testified will have the opportunity to do so at the end of the meeting. We have 27 speakers this evening. Each person will

91
00:26:30.480 --> 00:26:46.159
have two minutes to speak and I will remind you when you have 30 seconds remaining. Please feel free to email your comments for distribution to the committee. Speakers may not reassign their time to others. The time that an interpreter uses for English interpretation will not be deducted from

92
00:26:46.159 --> 00:27:02.000
a speaker's allotted time. Please direct your comments to the chair and refrain from addressing individual school committee members or district staff. Please note that the comments of any public speaker do not represent the Boston public schools or the Boston school committee. Please state your

93
00:27:02.000 --> 00:27:18.240
name, affiliation, and where you live before you begin. Please sign in on Zoom using the name you register with for public comment and be ready to unmute and turn on your camera when it's your turn to speak. Please raise your virtual hand when I call your name. To support interpretation, please speak slowly and

94
00:27:18.240 --> 00:27:36.039
clearly. We will start with our in-person speakers. Our first speakers are Jess Butler, Hope Bastian, Sulea Sto, John Mud, and Camille Stub. Jess Butler.

95
00:27:44.480 --> 00:27:59.520
My name is Jess Butler. I'm from Dorchester. This is Odis and this is Brick. We start them young at BPS. Um we're here to share our concerns about the placement process for students with IEPs. My son's transferring next year. I submitted a letter from a

96
00:27:59.520 --> 00:28:16.480
provider on his team detailing the clinical reasons why this placement would be the safest, most appropriate fit. It's a school that's 2 miles outside of our zone in Dorchester. We've been sent from the welcome center to the coast to the OSS to the welcome center back to OSS. Everyone's saying they do

97
00:28:16.480 --> 00:28:33.120
not have the power to assist us, but you all make the policy, so you can. The welcome center is making placement decisions but has never attended an IEP with my child. In section 1414E of of individuals with disabilities educations acts, educational agencies will ensure

98
00:28:33.120 --> 00:28:48.000
that parents of children with disabilities are members of the decision process of the educational placement of their child. There's no mention of the welcome center, which isn't to diss them, but they're not in that. We have great schools in our zone, but for a variety of reasons, whether it's too

99
00:28:48.000 --> 00:29:04.960
large of a school, will require him to transfer after one year, or was not able to explain how inclusion will be implemented in their classrooms, they aren't a good fit. I understand the district is firm in saying that all schools are inclusive. But I have not seen communication on what that looks like as a policy and within the classroom. When I asked the district for

100
00:29:04.960 --> 00:29:21.360
who was staffing classrooms, what license they had, and what services were offered in schools in our zone, I was told that this sort of list does not exist. There's no clear, easily accessible information on what our inclusive district looks like. >> And parents and guardians are being asked to trust what an algorithm will

101
00:29:21.360 --> 00:29:37.520
make the best decision for our children, especially at a time when teacher and parlay layoffs are coming and not just from the closed schools. The district needs to change the placement policy. All schools in the district are being called inclusive, but not all schools are inclusive. The simple act of labeling a school does not make it real.

102
00:29:37.520 --> 00:29:57.760
Students already are feeling the consequences of this decision. When classroom staff can't meet our children's needs, they are moved to a more restrictive environment. There is intentional harm. And >> thank you. The time is up. >> Thank you. >> Hope Bastion.

103
00:29:57.760 --> 00:30:17.120
Hope Bastion. >> Hello. I've heard many times that students should not have to go Oh, Pope Bastion, Roxbury. Um, I've read heard many times that students should not have to go to school outside their community to get the supports they need. And I

104
00:30:17.120 --> 00:30:34.000
agree. Um, I also know that that's the law of the land. And I know that that's the law because people with disabilities and parents like us won those rights through decades of tireless struggle. We know that the school our child was assigned, a wonderful school, a school

105
00:30:34.000 --> 00:30:49.200
less than a mile from our home, does not have the capacity today to offer meaningful inclusion to our child. How could they? There was a magic wand. It was waved. It was said that all schools can impride

106
00:30:49.200 --> 00:31:11.520
inclusion. Now, we know this is not true. There's no way that it could be. We have schools in the district that know what inclusion is. We have school leaders. We have teachers who've been doing it for decades. Instead of learning from their successes, these stories are being hidden with the magic

107
00:31:11.520 --> 00:31:27.279
wound tale that all schools are created equal. We know that they're not. I'm seeking an appropriate placement for my child. This winter, I requested information about the district where a co-eing model is in place where a special educator works together with a general educator to provide the supports

108
00:31:27.279 --> 00:31:43.679
that their students need. I was told by the office of specialized services by the director that she doesn't know where that model is in place. Two seconds. Um I that I was speechless. Um for two

109
00:31:43.679 --> 00:32:00.000
years every morning my child is in tears. I don't want to go back to that school. I don't know what school is the school that he needs. But I know that I've asked I know that I've asked the coasts. I know that I've asked the welcome center. I know that I've asked the office of specialized services. Um

110
00:32:00.000 --> 00:32:17.080
this is not the way that it's supposed to be and you guys have the ability to change it. >> Thank you. Your time is up. If you you can always send it by email. You can send me your testimony by email if you didn't have time to read it all.

111
00:32:20.960 --> 00:32:49.840
Photo John Mud. >> My name is John Mud. I'm a resident of Cambridge and a longtime education advocate in Boston. I want to speak tonight to focus on the implementation of the new opportunity and achievement

112
00:32:49.840 --> 00:33:07.760
gap policy. The policy coming before you continues the commitment to eliminating achievement gaps and increasing the racial and linguistic diversity of teachers. It calls for annual smart goals in each area. These smart goals are crucial. The policy also includes

113
00:33:07.760 --> 00:33:25.279
strengthening the education of multilingual learners through the development of long-term plans with milestones and timelines for expanding bilingual education and bilingual teachers with instruction in native language. All three goals are critically

114
00:33:25.279 --> 00:33:42.559
important. We also know that implementation is key. Putting policy into practice so that it makes a difference to students in their classrooms is what will make a difference in student outcomes. That is why the promised strategic implementation plan must include smart

115
00:33:42.559 --> 00:33:57.760
goals. When will you see it and who will be included in developing it? I want again to make a plea that the committee and the superintendent take the lead in convening working groups of committee members, BPS staff, and selected

116
00:33:57.760 --> 00:34:15.760
experts, stakeholders, advocates to work together to develop strategies and plans that we could all rally behind. Such collaborative work would have the potential to bake through the current dysfunctional structures like these meetings where we talk at each other

117
00:34:15.760 --> 00:34:34.480
rather than talking with each other. Isn't it worth a try? The new policy which is before you to approve tonight gives new guidance. Let's try to follow through to implement it together. Thank you. >> Thank you.

118
00:34:34.480 --> 00:34:56.960
Camille Stub. >> Hello, my name is Camille Stubby. I am a seventh grade math teacher at the Margarita Mun Academy. I live in Somerville, Massachusetts. Less than two weeks ago, the district cut two of our SCYE positions and mandated that 19 of

119
00:34:56.960 --> 00:35:13.520
our 22 SCE students exit the program this year. I am speaking with great concern about the guidelines used to exit students from the programs and these teacher cuts. Slife exits are supposed to be individualized based on native literacy and math level as stated in the meta consent degree filed with

120
00:35:13.520 --> 00:35:29.359
the department of justice. And this past month lowered the access score requirements from 2.5 to 1.7s in meetings with our schools and did not consider native literacy in their exit assessments. They simply exited all students who have been in the program

121
00:35:29.359 --> 00:35:44.560
for two years. Native literacy is critical for student success in general education. Many of my students are former Slife students. One in particular was exited prematurely from his previous school last year. This student is still learning to read and write in Spanish,

122
00:35:44.560 --> 00:36:01.839
his native language. Uh I read everything aloud to this student in Spanish and he needs the help of a computer to describe his responses. in advisory at the beginning of the year. Um, this student shared his goal for the year to learn how to read and write. The entire class fell silent. One student

123
00:36:01.839 --> 00:36:19.040
piped up and said, "You don't know how to read?" And the student simply responded, "No, no puo." This year, luckily, he has a gap in his schedule where he receives foundational native literacy support like decoding and phonics in Spanish. He's gone from refusing to write anything in Spanish to

124
00:36:19.040 --> 00:36:34.560
at least trying to write something down phonetically in Spanish. This teacher who's providing him the support was informed last week that they would be cut next year. The student will enter 8th grade without foundational native literacy and without support. The struggle the struggles the student experienced foretell the reality Slife

125
00:36:34.560 --> 00:36:57.760
students will face when forced out of the program. I'm asking the district to stop last minute life cuts and to stop the forced student exits. Also, please stop creating more barriers for our most vulnerable students. Thank you. >> Thank you very much. >> Our our next group of speakers are

126
00:36:57.760 --> 00:37:22.480
Elizabeth Nibbridge, Kimberly Hirs, Jen Hayes, Vana Dear Rocha, and Anna Ard. Elizabeth Nibberish. Good evening, school committee members. My name is Beth Nibrich. I live in Hyde Park. I'm a proud BPS parent and Slife

127
00:37:22.480 --> 00:37:38.800
ESL teacher at Boston International Newcomers Academy. I'm here tonight in solidarity with our SLY community. You're going to hear tonight about the Slife program model and who it is designed to serve. But I want you to really understand what this looks like at the secondary level. At Binka, we

128
00:37:38.800 --> 00:37:55.839
welcome 16, 17, 18-year-old students who are still learning how to write their name. Their circumstances are all different. They've grown up in countries with political turmoil and violence. Their families couldn't afford to send them to school, or they haven't had access to education because of barriers

129
00:37:55.839 --> 00:38:12.560
that are almost always outside of their control. So, imagine these students entering a BPS high school and being asked to go to a 10th grade history or chemistry class where the content is presented in English. We can all agree that that would most certainly lead to failure. And that's why our Slife

130
00:38:12.560 --> 00:38:28.240
programs are so critical. They're not a magic wand and students absolutely need support when they exit. But in BPS programs, our students are taught by skilled educators who often share the same linguistic and cultural backgrounds as our students. Students have

131
00:38:28.240 --> 00:38:43.440
individualized goals and teams of educators who track their academic progress and help them adjust to an unfamiliar school system. Most importantly for our overaged life, we teach them how to read in English and in their native language.

132
00:38:43.440 --> 00:38:59.119
Yes, our students are in many ways some of BPS's most vulnerable. >> 30 seconds. >> But in my 16 years as an educator, I've personally witnessed how they are also some of our most resilient. With the right supports, they go on to learn English, graduate from high school, and work and live in our communities. In

133
00:38:59.119 --> 00:39:15.280
fact, one of my former Sly students works in this very building. So, in a moment when the political climate has turned on our Slife students, let us be the ones who do not abandon them. I urge you to continue to prioritize explicit instruction and literacy, to honor individualized transition plans and

134
00:39:15.280 --> 00:39:49.920
timelines, and to continue to fund this life program model as outlined in the Medicaid. Jen Hayes. >> Hi, I'm Jen Hayes. I am a slave teacher at the Margarita Monise Academy and I live in Rivier, Massachusetts. Dr. Jim Dr. Dr. Jim Cummings, a renowned

135
00:39:49.920 --> 00:40:06.320
theorist in second language acquisition, has found that students who are not yet literate in their first language may require between seven and 10 years to develop academic language proficiency in English. This research, which is

136
00:40:06.320 --> 00:40:23.040
included in DESIE's MTELS for both ESL and bilingual educator endorsement exams, directly contradicts the current mandate to exit Slife students after only two years. The rationale we have received from M is that remaining in

137
00:40:23.040 --> 00:40:39.760
Slife programs for longer periods is exclusionary or unsustainable in the current political climate. However, literacy research consistently demonstrates that students learn to read most effectively through explicit systematic instruction. Students with

138
00:40:39.760 --> 00:40:57.040
interrupted or limited formal education often require highly individualized and intensive literacy support in order to develop foundational reading and writing skills. If acade if academic language acquisition can take many years and literacy development requires explicit

139
00:40:57.040 --> 00:41:13.119
systematic instruction, why is the district limiting specialized slave services to two years? How does this policy align with the research on language acquisition, the documented needs of students with interrupted formal education, and the professional

140
00:41:13.119 --> 00:41:29.119
judgment of educators working directly with these students? Will exited Slife students have the literacy skills necessary to thrive independently in mainstream academic settings? Is the district planning to provide professional development for educators working with former SLI students? There

141
00:41:29.119 --> 00:41:55.359
is not sufficient capacity for educators to teach foundational literacy skills while simultaneously teaching grade level content. I believe these students deserve access to personalized explicit literacy. Your time is up. Vana de la Rocha.

142
00:41:55.359 --> 00:42:21.520
No. Vana. No. Anna Ard. Um, good evening. My name is Anna Varde. I live in Somerville and I am a sixth and seventh grade dual language science teacher at the Mariomana Academy in East Boston and I'm also a proud member of the Boston Teachers Union. I am here

143
00:42:21.520 --> 00:42:37.200
today to speak about the importance of protecting safe programs. Since the beginning of the year, sixth grade native literacy teacher who was notified that was cut last minute has spent time in my classroom supporting students in Spanish. Her work has been

144
00:42:37.200 --> 00:42:53.839
essential. She helps students access grade level content. She develops literacy and challenges that come with entering a new school system. Two months ago, after a teacher unexpectedly retired, she was resigned to cover a general education history class. And the absence has been

145
00:42:53.839 --> 00:43:11.599
felt students who no longer of students and educational backgrounds require expertise that I, as a general education teacher, cannot provide alone. This experience has shown that

146
00:43:11.599 --> 00:43:34.800
services are extra instruction stretched classroom teachers. A site program that instructions their language, their educational backgrounds and their own needs. I urge

147
00:43:34.800 --> 00:43:50.319
the district and the school community to protect sty programs to preserve native literacy positions and ensure that decisions about students and services are driven by what our students actually need and not by staffing shortages or budget cuts. Thank you.

148
00:43:50.319 --> 00:44:12.000
>> Thank you. >> I want to remind the speakers that we have interpreters in the channels. So, if you can slow down a little bit, please. Thank you. The next group is Alicia Silva, Ariana Cyros McCarthy, Shaina Gilbert, Robin Kelly, and Juan

149
00:44:12.000 --> 00:44:32.000
Gutierrez. Alicia Silva. >> Good evening, Buenas. I'm Alicia Sova. I live in Newton. I'm an 18-year teaching veteran of the Boston public schools. I am honored to work with students that have had limited access to formal education at least for 11 more days

150
00:44:32.000 --> 00:44:49.520
because my job was cut. Our children have experienced unthinkable trauma and we asked them to come to school and behave normally. And I think how much time would my child need in school to learn her letters if she had seen me shot in the head at our dinner table because I refused to sell drugs. How

151
00:44:49.520 --> 00:45:06.560
much time would your child need if they had juvenile arthritis and were unable to walk the five miles to school or in a wheelchair in the middle of a desert in a refugee camp? What is the time limit on trauma? When do I tell my baby students, "Okay, get over it. Get out."

152
00:45:06.560 --> 00:45:22.079
And by the way, the one person it took you 15 to 16 months to trust is telling you goodbye. It has been decades for me watching courts tell BPS what to do. But we all know what is right. Aren't you tired of

153
00:45:22.079 --> 00:45:38.000
that? We understand change. Teachers understand change. BPS wrote that teachers would be consulted if this life program were to change. Were we consulted? No. Students with limited formal education

154
00:45:38.000 --> 00:45:55.440
have traveled to our shores, our coast, not for the American dream, but for the Boston dream. They just want to be safe and learn how to read. Big Poppy said it best when he said, "This is our city." >> 30 seconds. >> The Bostononians I surround myself with take care

155
00:45:55.440 --> 00:46:09.599
surround myself with take care of children and they listen to teachers. Fully fun life classrooms, two teachers. I work by myself. I'm not bilingual. Slife is not for life. We know that. But

156
00:46:09.599 --> 00:46:35.520
love is for life. Love is for life. What are we modeling for our future citizens, our future Bostononians? >> Ariana Cayos McCarthy. >> Hi, Ariana Cigaros McCarthy. I live in Rosendale.

157
00:46:35.520 --> 00:46:52.800
I am a BPS alumni, parent, and ESL teacher of SLIE students at Boston International Newcomers Academy. I'm here tonight in solidarity with the Slife community. This is my 19th year of teaching in BPS, almost half of which has been working with Slife students.

158
00:46:52.800 --> 00:47:08.240
SLIFE programs serve students who come into BPS with a wide range of skills. Students have the opportunity to learn from educators who understand that our job is to adapt and meet them where they are. By design and the meta consent

159
00:47:08.240 --> 00:47:25.119
degree, Slife programs provide intensive instruction in students native languages. This is supported by decades of research that show how strong literacy skills in native language are an indicator of literacy skills for second or third languages. Our students

160
00:47:25.119 --> 00:47:40.079
who are coming in need time with specialized and skilled teachers to fill those gaps. As a district, we should be staffing programs that enhance our students ability to acquire language and not cutting those supports. This past January, the district told us

161
00:47:40.079 --> 00:47:55.920
that best practices included a support plan for students who exit Slife. The plan detailed supports like reading intervention, co-eing and content classes, and the support of Slice social workers. But instead of providing schools with enough staff to ensure the

162
00:47:55.920 --> 00:48:13.359
long-term success of Slice students, BPS is cutting the positions as recently as last week. >> Without Slifice specific supports, how can a student who arrived as a non-reader in Spanish in 9th grade fully access a grade level text in English? At

163
00:48:13.359 --> 00:48:28.559
the secondary level, former SLE students are overwhelmed by the sheer length of texts being put in front of them. This leads to disengagement in class, frustration, increased absences, and eventually dropping out. BPS needs to

164
00:48:28.559 --> 00:48:52.400
pause and consider the needs of life students before putting a timeline on their learning. Our students deserve better. >> Shaina Gilbert. >> Hello, my name is Shaina Gilbert and I'm from Boston. I'm a proud graduate of Boston public schools, a second

165
00:48:52.400 --> 00:49:09.040
generation Slife educator and have taught Haitian newcomers at Tech Boston for 16 years. I'm here reg I'm here regarding the district's recent decision to prematurely exit nearly all Sly students from their program against teacher recommendations. Slife students

166
00:49:09.040 --> 00:49:25.200
are English learners with interrupted education often due to trauma. Many enter BPS with major gaps in literacy and math. They require specialized instruction to build foundational skills. The Sly program prepares them to succeed in grade level classrooms

167
00:49:25.200 --> 00:49:42.400
alongside their peers. The goal of Sly is not to be in SLE for life, but to benefit from Sly for a better life. Slife is described by the district as a 2-year transitional program, but some need more time. My Haitian students have experienced political instability,

168
00:49:42.400 --> 00:49:59.760
dangerous migration, disrupted schooling, and now they live in fear around immigration policies. These are some of our most vulnerable learners. How we choose to support those with the fewest advantages reflects who we are as a district. For over 16 years,

169
00:49:59.760 --> 00:50:16.240
I have seen Slife students become college graduates and professionals because because BPS provided the proper instruction in the time they needed. But today, the district plans to use a single metric to abruptly exit students from Slife. This decision will weaken

170
00:50:16.240 --> 00:50:33.599
the program and 30 seconds and deprive students of critical support. I urge the school committee to ensure that slight program decisions from entry to exit remain grounded in equity, educator expertise, evidence, and the long-term

171
00:50:33.599 --> 00:51:03.599
success of our students. Thank you. >> Thank you, >> Robin Kelly. Robin Kelly. Good evening. I'm Robin Kelly from Dorchester. I've been teaching middle school Slife at the Mario Yamana Academy

172
00:51:03.599 --> 00:51:18.800
for 11 years in which I have witnessed muddled messaging and inconsistent application of the Slife program as it is outlined by the META consent decree. The district's concern over length of time in Slife is valid. However, the two-year max does not address the route of the ad.

173
00:51:18.800 --> 00:51:33.599
>> Sorry. The district is encouraging us to exit kids who are not ready. This year, the district and M have sent conflicting messages. Guidance in our Google classroom says students need a 2.5 overall in access to exit. In December, Mailed some schools saying the goalpost

174
00:51:33.599 --> 00:51:50.480
has been lowered to 1.7. Which is it? Claiming that students have been in the program for too long based on a set length of time follows a one-sizefits-all model. We know life is anything but. For some students, a few months since life is enough. For others, it's longer. We must ask, has the

175
00:51:50.480 --> 00:52:06.640
district actually been providing our students with the full services and supports needed to make meaningful academic progress per the meta decree? Most recently, no. Not in terms of consistent foundational native literacy, appropriate ESL, and a clear infrastructure to support students whose

176
00:52:06.640 --> 00:52:22.319
progress is limited. I have loads of examples. Furthermore, at our school, M has proposed staffing cuts that would eliminate native language literacy, an essential and legal requirement of Slife. The native language component is necessary for development in English and for a successful transition to general

177
00:52:22.319 --> 00:52:39.200
education. We oppose these cuts as well as the restructuring of Slife exit guidelines without educator and community input. We teachers are in the front lines. We know our students best and we know what they need. I've seen the consequences of exiting students before they're ready. Students forced to exit because the district timed them out

178
00:52:39.200 --> 00:52:54.880
have struggled with attendance and engagement. In some cases dropped out. Conversely, I recently spoke with a former Slife student who was in the program for three or four years. Now she's in college. This juxtaposition between what teachers think and current guidance shows what happens when SLE students are rushed into general

179
00:52:54.880 --> 00:53:18.160
education. And it should not be a mistake that the district continues to make. Thank you. Thank you, Juan >> Gutierrez. My name is Juan Gutierrez. I'm a resident of East Boston uh BPS alum and now a native life educator at the

180
00:53:18.160 --> 00:53:35.280
Marioan Academy. During our last contract campaign, educators and families fought for inclusion done right. We demanded that inclusion cannot mean putting students with many different needs with uh into classrooms without the appropriate staffing, ade adequate services and specialized supports required for them to succeed.

181
00:53:35.280 --> 00:53:52.160
That same principle applies to SLI students. We believe in meaningful inclusion opportunities for SLIE students. We want students learning alongside their peers and transitioning successfully into appropriate educational settings. But those opportunities have to be planned for and supported by a team of educators. They

182
00:53:52.160 --> 00:54:08.240
cannot be created by removing the very educators who provide specialized instruction. For CLI students, native literacy is an essential support and required component of the Slife model under the meta consent decree. Every student deserves the opportunity to develop literacy in their native

183
00:54:08.240 --> 00:54:25.280
language. That means explicit native literacy instruction. And as it stands, the district is cutting the native literacy component at my school. If BPS continues to operate a SLIFE program while removing native language literacy instruction, then the district is fundamentally altering the very model

184
00:54:25.280 --> 00:54:42.319
students are entitled to receive. There's a difference between content instruction in students native language and native literacy instruction. Content classes in students native language can support literacy development, but they cannot replace explicit native language reading instruction. And at the UMAN,

185
00:54:42.319 --> 00:54:58.319
that is what the district is proposing. And let's be clear, services for students with disabilities, multilingual learners, and SLI students were not simply given. They were fought for and won by families, students, educators, and community members. And now the

186
00:54:58.319 --> 00:55:13.359
district cries budget constraints when it comes to special education, ESL, and SLE services. Inclusion does not mean placing students in classrooms without support, without planning, or without a real transition plan. The fight to ensure that inclusion is done right is not over and it is our duty to keep

187
00:55:13.359 --> 00:55:41.599
fighting for our slide students. Our last in inerson speakers are Myra de Rocha, Dedra Manning, Paulo Devaros, Caris Mclofflin, and Kelsey Brandell. Myra de Rocha I'm Myra D Rosha, Spanish native

188
00:55:41.599 --> 00:55:58.160
literacy life teacher at the Margarita Munas Academy. Boston calls itself a sanctuary city. Yet, we are dismantling the some of the very educational sanctuaries our newest immigrant students rely on. During COVID, Slife students were identified as some of the most vulnerable and we're in the first wave of students to return to in-person

189
00:55:58.160 --> 00:56:14.880
learning. Now, when they need us the most, the district has decided to exit them from the program regardless of where they are academically. The meta consent decree is a legal document that is very explicit about what criteria life students need to meet before entering the general education classroom, which includes native

190
00:56:14.880 --> 00:56:30.880
literacy and math proficiency. BPS is replacing an individual, student- centered, and evidence-based process with a one-sizefits-all model that they have admitted will put students into gened classes that they will not be prepared for, violating this Department of Justice order. We'll be pushing these

191
00:56:30.880 --> 00:56:47.079
students into classes where they are doomed to fail when Slice students are already statistically more likely to drop out of school. How many futures are we willing to sacrifice in order to satisfy a standardized timeline? That's why it's so important to stand up.

192
00:57:10.640 --> 00:58:16.880
30 seconds. Our next speaker is still remaining. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Dear Danning. I'm a Dorchester resident, single parent of two public school students. I'd like to make a few points this evening. Um

193
00:58:16.880 --> 00:58:32.240
the first is that it's been three admission cycles since the superintendent stated that there would be data made available on the outcomes of students who have gone through the exam school admission process. My understanding is that data has not been

194
00:58:32.240 --> 00:58:47.920
made available. The second point that I'd like to make is that it's been two months since the last admission cycle concluded and I do not believe any of that information about um low cutoff scores or any of that has been made available. Um the third point that I'd

195
00:58:47.920 --> 00:59:04.480
like to make is that this exam school construct continues to put certain students at a disadvantage. My daughter is friends with a girl who will be a rising seventh grader. She is black. uh she lives in Madapan which inexplicably

196
00:59:04.480 --> 00:59:21.440
is considered a tier 4 neighborhood. I think that just about anybody would laugh if you stated that a girl who lives in Madapan has anywhere near the resources that a student who lives in Charlestone or the Back Bay or the North

197
00:59:21.440 --> 00:59:38.319
End. Yet this girl was put at a disadvantage because she was considered a tier 4 student. Across the street from her was tier 2. So, if she lived across the street, the outcome would have been very different. This particular girl has a brother who's already at BLS. Now, I

198
00:59:38.319 --> 00:59:54.960
know that she's a high performing student, even though I don't know her composite score, because she did actually get a seat at an exam school, but she did not get her first choice, which was BLS. Is really strange that a girl who lives in a neighborhood that is underresourced, yet she is not allowed

199
00:59:54.960 --> 01:00:11.440
to join the school that her brother attends. Um there's a huge disconnect there and I wish that the committee would take a really hard look as how you divide students into tier groups. It's extremely inequitable. Thank you. >> Thank you. Our next speaker is Paulo

200
01:00:11.440 --> 01:00:39.440
Dearos. No. Caris Mclofflin. >> Thank you. Oh, I'm Caris Mclofflin. I live in Roxbury and I'm the mom of a former Boston public school student. And so I attended

201
01:00:39.440 --> 01:00:57.200
your retreat um I guess a few weeks ago. And what I heard at that retreat was I basically the comment that school committee members were not sure what their task is. And so what I did in

202
01:00:57.200 --> 01:01:13.040
response to that when I hear things I say, okay, so what can I do to be helpful? I went down to the Mass Massachusetts Association of School Committees and got the um Massachusetts General Loss. So, this is the work that

203
01:01:13.040 --> 01:01:29.440
guides school committees. And I'm not sure if you're aware, but a lawsuit is coming that will state clearly that none of the gateway cities are preparing kids well enough. And there's going to be a

204
01:01:29.440 --> 01:01:46.319
recommendation that um they need to leave these gateway cities and be educated in neighboring um communities that may have more money. You know, that's simplistically put, but you should be aware of that lawsuit. And

205
01:01:46.319 --> 01:02:02.720
that lawsuit will look at historically what Boston has been unable to do for too many neighborhood school kids. Every kid should be able to look at their neighborhood school, no matter where it

206
01:02:02.720 --> 01:02:18.799
is, and know that they will get a good education. It's the least that we can do for them. and I support kids going to school wherever they choose, but in their neighborhood I think is most important. So, I hope that you will look

207
01:02:18.799 --> 01:02:33.280
into the lawsuit. It's already filed. It's at Suffach Superior Court. It is serious and there are answers that you're going to need to give. And so, school committee that will be your Thank you.

208
01:02:33.280 --> 01:03:16.160
>> Next speaker is Kelsey Brundell. Good evening, school committee chair Robinson, Superintendent Skipper. I'm Kelsey Brendelle, parent of a child with multiple and severe disabilities. You may see him and likely you've probably already heard him despite my best efforts. Um, he, like so many of our

209
01:03:16.160 --> 01:03:32.400
students with disabilities, can't speak, at least out loud, and that's part of the reason I am here. I try very hard at trying to hear and listen for the voices of many students in BPS and our city. And I've been so lucky to have met and spoken with so many students like him

210
01:03:32.400 --> 01:03:49.359
who may not have words, but they and their families can more than make themselves heard. As you know, it's such a privilege to be able to bear witness to their eagerness when talking about their child, their lived experience, and how they might contribute themselves to a bigger conversation about BPS with

211
01:03:49.359 --> 01:04:06.799
curiosity, civility, and passion. And I'm here tonight because I'm noticing something that started as a whisper and now is a scream in the world of special ed here in Boston. And we have got to get back to prioritizing some of the ways in which we could actually make a material difference in the lives of

212
01:04:06.799 --> 01:04:22.319
those most vulnerable who navigate BPS every day and who would tell you that some of the fissures and pain points are not always too daunting to solve. We're becoming, I fear, distracted by conversations and people that scare us rather than inspire us. And we have

213
01:04:22.319 --> 01:04:40.640
families waiting for real solves. And sometimes they are very meaningful solves that are achievable and speak to the everyday experiences of our special educ. Uh I I I well understand, you know, it's not a mystery many of the topics that we

214
01:04:40.640 --> 01:04:56.720
talk about here tonight, school closures, the enormity of budgetary restraints, how the plan for inclusion has sparked critical debate about whether and how we are actually serving with this plan as it evolves. But I really want to remind us and this body about who we are really really talking

215
01:04:56.720 --> 01:05:13.119
about and invite a more robust and candid conversation than the ones that we've been having. Who are we leaving out and how can we create additional ways for families to be heard and truly considered as partners? >> Please send you can send the test

216
01:05:13.119 --> 01:05:28.960
written testimony to >> Yes. Thank you so much. Thank you. >> Thank you. >> We will now transition to Zoom um public comment. Our first the first speakers are Kimberly Hirs, Cheryl Buckman, April Wong, and Eugenia Corbbo.

217
01:05:28.960 --> 01:05:54.880
Kimberly Hirs Yes. Hello. Um, my name is Kimberly Hirsch and I'm here to address the accessing of SLE teachers. During the last school year, I was an ESL life teacher at Charles Town High School. I was also a district life teacher leader with the telescope network in M. In that

218
01:05:54.880 --> 01:06:11.280
capacity, I wrote a district-wide newsletter and facilitated two district-wide professional development series. I was also part of an own working group adapting open sedife and I had a grant from the teacher leader fund to adapt the DKP civics curriculum for life. I had planned to continue this

219
01:06:11.280 --> 01:06:26.240
important work but two weeks before school started last August the district closed my scythe program and all the work that I was doing to support the scythe community stopped. My knowledge, experience and curriculum completely cut

220
01:06:26.240 --> 01:06:42.400
off from the students who need it most. In a few years, the political climate is going to change again, and someone in the central office will determine that there's a need for a life program in Charlestone, and those teachers will have to start over from scratch, like I

221
01:06:42.400 --> 01:06:58.960
did. They will have to fundra to rebuild a culturally linguistically relevant classroom library. They will have to train again in rules-based reading intervention. They will have to rewrite weekly restorative circles and trauma-informed lessons and reestablish field relationships at field trip sites.

222
01:06:58.960 --> 01:07:14.559
They'll have to discover again how to meet the incredibly unique needs of this life students who come to Charlestone. The decision to get life teachers was made because our student population has decreased. We understand that too many resources.

223
01:07:14.559 --> 01:07:32.640
It's inefficient. But it is also inefficient to force schools and teachers to reinvent the wheel every four years because of national politics. Life educators and students need you to find another way.

224
01:07:32.640 --> 01:08:02.960
>> Thank you. >> Thank you very much. Our next speaker is Cheryl Buckman. Good evening. My name is Cheryl Buckman. I'm a parent to a seventh grader at the Ruth Batson Academy, the parent lead at the DER and resident of South Boston.

225
01:08:02.960 --> 01:08:18.400
I'm here to express my deepest gratitude for all the hard work, engagement, and collaboration with the DER community throughout this challenging transition process. I stand before you today in immense pride. The build the physical

226
01:08:18.400 --> 01:08:35.440
building may close but the spirit of the devil cannot be contained by brick or mortar. Its legacy is going to be spread far and wide across this entire district. As our students, families, and phenomenal educators carry its values

227
01:08:35.440 --> 01:08:51.600
into their next chapters. For my family, the Denver is not just a school. It's a cornerstone of our lives. I'm forever grateful for the education I received within those halls many years ago. That legacy continued when my

228
01:08:51.600 --> 01:09:08.319
brother walked those same halls and it came full circle when my own son became a Denver student. This community ran on family. It was built on the belief that we lifted each other up, looked out for one another, and fought for every single

229
01:09:08.319 --> 01:09:24.159
child's future. It's truly been an honor to serve my voice for this community, to advocate for our kids and our fantastic educators. Thank you for listening to us, working alongside us, and recognizing the heart

230
01:09:24.159 --> 01:09:40.159
of our community as we move forward. We trust that you'll help us carry the DER's deeprooted commitment to family and excellence into the future of this entire district. The doors may close, but the Denver Dolphins will keep moving

231
01:09:40.159 --> 01:10:05.280
together. Thank you. >> Thank you. Our next speaker is April Wang. Hi, my name is April Boang. I live in Fields Corner and I am the mother of a 4-year-old rising K1 BPS student. We are Chinese American. We decided to raise

232
01:10:05.280 --> 01:10:21.600
our family here because we wanted our children to be exposed to their heritage culture, food, and language. So, when the K1 lottery opened in January, I was devastated to learn that my son was ineligible to attend Josiah Quincy Elementary, which has the only bilingual Chinese program in the district. In

233
01:10:21.600 --> 01:10:38.800
December, the district said that opening city-wide access to low incidence language programs would result in relatively small student impact, which essentially means you are denying hyper minoritized students access to heritage language learning. This is the opposite of equitable policy. Equitable policy

234
01:10:38.800 --> 01:10:53.920
does not diminish students needs because they don't meet a certain population threshold. This current school year, JQEs had a capacity of 36 seats in its K1 program. only 23 were filled. This is a waste of resources and an underutilization of a

235
01:10:53.920 --> 01:11:11.120
program. The district said it couldn't open up these bilingual programs citywide because of transportation costs. Let's talk about that. In an ideal world, we would have invest resources to ensure all kids have district transportation to their schools. But you all know that education

236
01:11:11.120 --> 01:11:27.280
doesn't operate in an ideal world, which means that we need to think creatively about solutions rather than just saying no. In the face of a broken education system, our communities have always found solutions to intractable problems. For 3 years, my family has spent between 90 minutes to 3 hours when the red line

237
01:11:27.280 --> 01:11:43.280
was getting fixed. >> 30 seconds. >> My son to a daycare in Taiong Village, Chinatown. This was a sacrifice. My husband and I both work full-time jobs. But it was worth it to ensure that our son would start life learning his heritage language. If given access to the bilingual program at JQEs, we would

238
01:11:43.280 --> 01:11:57.920
continue to take him on public transportation every day. BPS enrollment is plummeting. The district is losing families and kids left and right. And the ones you seek to serve in equitably are the ones leaving first. Do something. Fix it. Open access to your bilingual programs and stop dismissing

239
01:11:57.920 --> 01:12:21.679
language as low incidents. >> Thank you. Your time is up. Our next speaker is Eugenia Corbbo. >> Hello. Can you hear me? >> Yes, we can hear you. You can start. >> Good evening. My name is Cororo and I'm the parent a parent at the Marana

240
01:12:21.679 --> 01:12:38.880
Academy in East Boston. I have a child in fifth grade. On May 20th, our school building was hot. Very hot. By mid-after afternoon of 73 classroom sensors, 70 were flag high, 41 classroom were at or over or above 85 degrees. We were at or

241
01:12:38.880 --> 01:12:55.920
over 90 and the hottest room read 95° inside where children are trying to learn. The building averaged 85° and most of those classrooms have no windows that can be opened. Uh this was the second day in a row that our children sat in that heat with no air

242
01:12:55.920 --> 01:13:11.360
conditioning. two days. We could watch the temperature climb through the morning and into the afternoon, and there was nothing the school itself could do about it. I know at least one family that pulled their kids out of school that day because of the high heat. And this was not just our school.

243
01:13:11.360 --> 01:13:27.199
Uh at 2 p.m. the same day, across the 125 Boston schools uh being monitored, more than a thousand rooms were at or above 80°, 305 rooms were at and or above 85. 31 rooms top 90 with one

244
01:13:27.199 --> 01:13:43.600
reading 97°. The schools heat hardest including hours where the buildings with modern central air. The wind the schools with uh window units were generally fine. The buildings didn't overheat because the equipment failed. It happened because the central

245
01:13:43.600 --> 01:14:00.880
air could not be switched on yet. We've been informed that the heating cannot be turned off until until May 15th. And only at that point can the process start for cooling and that can take up to 3 weeks and that is too long. So that's

246
01:14:00.880 --> 01:14:17.120
scheduling failure and a schedule failure is fixable. High heat in May is no longer a surprise. I'm asking BPS and the city to make sure the startup process for cooling is sped up so that our buildings are ready before the first hot week and not after. Thank you.

247
01:14:17.120 --> 01:14:34.400
>> Thank you. Our next speaker uh the next speakers are Jessica Curtis, Melanie Kaine, and Mariva Duva and Courtney Fily Karp. Jessica Curtis. >> Good evening. My name is Jessica Curtis and I'm a parent at the Mario UMA

248
01:14:34.400 --> 01:14:51.440
Academy in East Boston. Following up on Ohena's testimony, I want to talk about who was sitting in those 90°ree rooms for the second day in a row. Yuma is about 90% Hispanic and we're a title one school with large numbers of English learners and students with disabilities

249
01:14:51.440 --> 01:15:07.920
including an ABA program and a special ed program. These are exactly the children the district says it's committed to serving first. The research is unambiguous. Children are physically more vulnerable to heat than adults. Their bodies don't shed heat as efficiently and their comfortable

250
01:15:07.920 --> 01:15:24.400
learning temperature is lower than ours. Studies find the temperature for best concentration is around 72° and that student performance can rise by roughly 20% when a classroom is cooled from the high 80s to the high60s. Researchers have also found that classroom heat

251
01:15:24.400 --> 01:15:41.360
widens the achievement gap, hurting disadvantaged students the most, and that air conditioning closes that gap, especially for students who are struggling. So, when our central air sits idle in a highne school, we are not being neutral. We're widening the gap that we say we're trying to close.

252
01:15:41.360 --> 01:15:57.679
And here is the part that's so important. This is not the first hot May in Boston, and it will not be the last. Late spring heat has become predictable. We learned the system couldn't run because the steps to bring it online take up to 3 weeks, and the Eversource meter read for our school wasn't

253
01:15:57.679 --> 01:16:12.640
scheduled until the end of the month. So, I'm asking BPS to work with the city and with Eversource to speed up the seasonal cooling startup so that our kids can get the building that they deserve before the thermometer climbs. Thank you so much.

254
01:16:12.640 --> 01:16:35.239
>> Thank you. Our next Melanie Kane is not in the meeting, so we will continue with Anmarie Vaduva followed by Courtney Felicarp. Anmarie Baduva, please accept the prompt.

255
01:16:40.080 --> 01:17:13.679
Okay, she declined the um so we will continue with Courtney Phyarp. Coordinate Billy Karp. Please turn on your camera there. Thank you. >> Hi. Can you hear me? >> Yeah, we can hear you. >> Hi, good evening. Uh, my name is

256
01:17:13.679 --> 01:17:30.080
Courtney Philly Karp. I am a West Roxberry resident and a parent of a sixth grader who previously attended the Henderson School and currently attends the Roosevelt K through8. Um I come tonight um to join the other parents who are requesting action of this school committee in reviewing the policies

257
01:17:30.080 --> 01:17:44.560
around the placement of inclusion students. I heard an earlier um person testifying that there seemed to be some confusion among school committee members about what their responsibilities may or may not be. I would refer you to your own website where it specifically says

258
01:17:44.560 --> 01:18:02.880
that your role is to establish, set, and review the policies to support student achievement. I think what you have consistently heard from both Spedpack and individual parents is that there is a huge disconnect between the school labeling rooms schools as full inclusion

259
01:18:02.880 --> 01:18:19.199
and saying that any one of those services any one of those rooms can serve as any individual student in their individual needs with an IEP. That is simply not true. I don't know how many parents need to come here and tell you that is not the case. There are countless incidents of parents trying to find the right placement for their

260
01:18:19.199 --> 01:18:35.120
student and going to a welcome center. The specific charge I have for you tonight is what is you as a school committee, the oversight body of this school district going to do in response to the parent outcry? You have legal obligations to serve students with disabilities and it is important that

261
01:18:35.120 --> 01:18:51.600
the public understand what you are doing. I ask that you ask the superintendent and the staff to explain how the welcome center process works, whether OSS is involved. My experience is that it is not um and how parents are expected to go to the welcome center

262
01:18:51.600 --> 01:19:08.560
with an IEP and figure out a placement for their student when there's no universal definition of inclusion, no universal staffing of those rooms, and no information for parents to access to help decide what the right choice is for their student. So my ask you tonight is to please put these questions to the

263
01:19:08.560 --> 01:19:36.480
district for a future committee meeting so the public can benefit from the answers. >> Thank you. >> We need now. Thank you. >> So we will try with Anmarie Vuva again. >> Hi. Um, this is Enmarie Vadiv Diva. I am

264
01:19:36.480 --> 01:19:54.400
a parent of a BPS student enrolled at the Mary Lion School in fifth grade who has not been able to attend school since September and has been in receiving inhome um tutoring that has been ineffective. And I'm going to read uh my

265
01:19:54.400 --> 01:20:10.159
statement. Um in general um my statement is more for the parents. I'm providing solidarity and support uh to parents of autistic students who are navigating um

266
01:20:10.159 --> 01:20:26.640
inclusion uh placements that uh are non-existent or that don't work for them. Um, and basically, um, my experience very quickly, um, sorry,

267
01:20:26.640 --> 01:20:42.400
sorry, not right now. Sorry. >> I need the charger. >> Sorry. Uh, sorry, not right now. Um, I'm going to skip to the end since I'm not going to be able to read everything. I just want to say um on behalf of all parents of autistic students who are not

268
01:20:42.400 --> 01:20:58.560
able to access general inclusion settings and who are not having being allowed to have real dialogues with uh administrators about how to access education. I challenge BPS uh if they are serious about proving that they are

269
01:20:58.560 --> 01:21:14.719
not discriminating against a minority as a result of a disability which many of us feel like is what is happening. FBPS is really serious about educating children with disabilities to invite all parents of BPS autistic students who are struggling to go to school to come to a

270
01:21:14.719 --> 01:21:28.719
public meeting and to hear what all parents of such children are saying their children need to access a school environment and to invite the parents and the students to design school environments in BPS buildings um where the needs identified by the parents and

271
01:21:28.719 --> 01:21:46.640
the students are fulfilled and um we are that is not happening. We are being stonewalled and we actually need BPS to work with parents to help our children otherwise. >> Thank you very much. >> discrimination. >> Hi. >> Thank you, >> chair. That concludes public comment.

272
01:21:46.640 --> 01:22:07.080
>> Thank you, Miss Parex. And thank you to those of you who spoke this evening and shared your perspectives. Your testimony is very important to us. Our first two action items this evening are the grants for approval totaling $5,39,61 and the inind donations of $5,22549.

273
01:22:08.080 --> 01:22:23.199
Now I'd like to turn it over to the superintendent for final comments. >> Uh great. Thank you, chair. So excuse me. So before you tonight, there are 14 grants for your consideration which total approximately $5 million.

274
01:22:23.199 --> 01:22:40.159
Rather than name all of the grants, I'll give a brief overview in the interest of time. The grants fall into several focus areas. Social emotional learning, there are three grants totaling nearly $186,000. Health and wellness, there are two grants totaling just over 350,000.

275
01:22:40.159 --> 01:22:56.320
College and career readiness, one is a summer continuation funding, which is total of 7,500. Grant technical education, one grant for more than $920,000. Madison Park High School facility improvement. There's four community

276
01:22:56.320 --> 01:23:13.199
preservation act grants totaling over $3.5 million for schoolyard improvements at the Conley Everett Troder and UP Academy schools, UP Academy Doorchester. Um and then academic instruction, there's two grants for $20,000 for the Everett and Jaziah Quinsey Elementary

277
01:23:13.199 --> 01:23:31.040
Schools and the Elliot Innovation Schools. There are also before you two inind donations uh one that totalif uh $5,200. There's a book donation to the Sarah Roberts Elementary School which is valued uh at $1,350 and a donation of

278
01:23:31.040 --> 01:23:48.000
more than $ 3,800 from the New England Dairy and Food Council for handheld immersion blenders for the BPS Central Kitchen. We ask the committee to vote in favor of accepting these grants um and certainly these generous donations. uh CFO Bloom uh is here as well as uh

279
01:23:48.000 --> 01:24:09.920
Marcala to answer any questions. >> Thank you. No, I'd like to turn it over to Oh, sorry. Want to turn it over to our members for any comments, questions and just quickly want to know the community preservation act which are

280
01:24:09.920 --> 01:24:27.280
the biggest grants here. How is the process for selecting the schools that are going to receive those improvement those grants given that we have many schools with many needs? >> So the the city runs an application

281
01:24:27.280 --> 01:24:43.120
process for community preservation act um projects. Um any member of the Boston community can submit a proposal. Um, in the past, uh, there were definitely moments where BPS was not taking full

282
01:24:43.120 --> 01:25:00.239
advantage of our opportunity to propose things. As well, um, over the last few years, we've done a better job of reviewing data on sort of what projects are eligible and where our schools saying the having the most need. So, we're definitely able to propose more

283
01:25:00.239 --> 01:25:20.239
relevant projects, but there are still projects that get proposed by the community and and can be selected. Is is the facility plan in involved in this at all or >> it's a separate process? >> Yeah. So, it's it's not a part of the

284
01:25:20.239 --> 01:25:36.960
long-term facilities plan because it's run directly by the city. Um I see Sam walking up, so I'm just going to wait for him to get all the way up here. It's in case I >> It is a separate It is a separate process. It's a se it's a separate process run by the city but uh Sam

285
01:25:36.960 --> 01:25:52.719
>> hi good evening everyone. Yes it is a separate process but our teams are very involved in the process and we um coordinate with um the folks that involved on city side and as we implement the the construction projects our team's heavily involved in that part of it as well.

286
01:25:52.719 --> 01:26:08.960
>> Right. So I'm just trying to understand how you choose a school A versus a school B to get those grants and those >> So that decision is um largely not in our control. Uh however, we do make recommendations based on our facilities condition assessments that we've

287
01:26:08.960 --> 01:26:24.400
conducted. We've ranked all of our playgrounds um in their conditions, safety, years, danger, equipment failures. So we have a ranked list of how bad our playgrounds are. So we do have our internal list and that's public information as well. So we make

288
01:26:24.400 --> 01:26:40.159
recommendations to that committee based on that information that collectively a decision is made. >> Thank you. >> Anyone else? >> I have a question um about the Madison Park um that is one

289
01:26:40.159 --> 01:26:55.679
of the largest uh grant in there. So it's a new grant. So, I was just wondering uh and it's 220 students that have are going to be assigned to this. I just was wondering if the uh what

290
01:26:55.679 --> 01:27:13.520
happened to the students if the grant is not renewed. >> Thank you for the question. Um that that grant supports two new programs at Madison Park that are currently in uh part B desi status waiting for approval. The bulk of that grant um will go to uh

291
01:27:13.520 --> 01:27:28.320
construction craft labor and robotics for all the startup equipment and supplies that are needed for the program. The construction craft labor consumable supplies on an annual basis are at a fairly low cost. So we believe we can pull all of those expenses into

292
01:27:28.320 --> 01:27:45.120
the Perkins grant and the robotics uh program for the second year. Um the grant will support a second teacher who will then be absorbed into Madison Park's budget and also um you heard the superintendent's um announcement about the Bloomberg grant for the construction

293
01:27:45.120 --> 01:28:00.400
trades that will also support the construction craft labor. So we think those programs are off to a very solid launch. >> So the so they're in it to win it. So it will they will be renewed. Is that what we're saying? If the grant is not

294
01:28:00.400 --> 01:28:17.120
renewed, um the equipment that is needed for the grant is front-loaded and the consumables that are needed to maintain the program are a fairly low cost and and Desi asked us the same questions that you are about it. Um if the grant is not renewed, we feel very confident

295
01:28:17.120 --> 01:28:32.400
that through other grant funding, the Perkins grant in particular, we can sustain the programs for the students at Madison Park. >> Thank you. >> Okay. Thank you. Anybody else is fine?

296
01:28:32.400 --> 01:28:48.080
>> Okay. So, thank you. So, if there are no further questions, no further discussion, I'll now entertain a motion to approve the grants as presented. Is there a motion? >> So, moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Second. >> Thank you. Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Is there any

297
01:28:48.080 --> 01:29:04.239
objection to approving the grants by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the grants are approved. Thank you. I will now entertain a motion to approve the inind donations as presented. Is there a motion? >> So moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second?

298
01:29:04.239 --> 01:29:19.679
>> Second. >> Is there any discussion objection to the motion? Is there any objection to approving the inind donation by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the inkind donations are approved. Our next action item is the fisc year

299
01:29:19.679 --> 01:29:35.920
2027 school trust funds. You may recall that we voted on the school trust funds policy at the June 17, 2025 meeting to allow the school committee to annually approve expenditures from the trust fund

300
01:29:35.920 --> 01:29:50.880
allowing BPS finance to load the trust funds directly into school budgets. I will now invite the superintendent to offer any final comments. >> Wonderful. Thank you, chair. So, in addition to the grants, we're asking the school committee for two additional

301
01:29:50.880 --> 01:30:08.080
approvals tonight as we close out the FY uh 26 year. Chief Financial Officer David Bloom is here to review the items. The first, as the chair said, is the FY27 school trust funds. The second is the FY27 interim salary and non-personnel payments on external

302
01:30:08.080 --> 01:30:25.760
funds, which we presented during the May 6th meeting. >> Um, I know we still have a lot to get to, but Chief Bloom is here. Were you have any questions? Thank you. And I'll just say, you know, we've um been really trying to be more proactive since meeting with the committee last year. Um

303
01:30:25.760 --> 01:30:41.600
we're especially uh proud of progress on the Mary Dorothia Devo award. Um which is one of our most active awards. Um and uh you know, we're working closely with all of the schools involved to make sure that awards are getting out. There

304
01:30:41.600 --> 01:30:57.920
was one just in my inbox yesterday. Um, so we're actively working through each of those items. >> Okay. >> You have a question? Go ahead. >> Um, thank you for these. Just, um, understanding the helpfulness of

305
01:30:57.920 --> 01:31:13.199
frontloading these dollars so that schools can apply them to the benefit of students. Makes sense. just wondering what impact it has on the oversight of expenditures um and just the monitoring of appropriate

306
01:31:13.199 --> 01:31:28.320
spending. Um >> so um since the school committee vote on this last year, we formed a finance trust committee to monitor um the all expenses on and uh our tracker which is like all the requests that come in um to

307
01:31:28.320 --> 01:31:45.600
ensure that all next steps are completed and everything is sort of following um the regulation. Everything so far has been good since um last summer. Um and I will say, you know, we do also have an example of a sort of good news, good news, bad news situation, which is one

308
01:31:45.600 --> 01:32:02.960
of our scholarship funds is actually um now suns setting because we've sp it's spent all of its money um in providing scholarships for our students, which is, you know, wonderful and that it provided all the scholarships it was meant to, but a little bit sad that it's it's coming to the end of its life. And that's the grace as knife scholarship.

309
01:32:02.960 --> 01:32:23.360
So, um, yeah, we're continuing to work and monitor this very actively. >> Thank you. >> No. >> All right. Thank you all. If there no further discussion, I will entertain a motion to approve the fiscal year 2027 school trust funds as presented. Is

310
01:32:23.360 --> 01:32:39.360
there a motion? >> So moved. >> Is there a second? >> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? >> Miss Parvox, will you please call the role? Thank you chair Dr. Alkins. >> Yes. >> Mr. Peralta. >> Yes. >> Miss Palanka Garcia. Miss Torres.

311
01:32:39.360 --> 01:32:53.760
>> Yes. >> Mr. Tran. >> Yes. >> Miss Garage. >> Yes. >> Miss Robinson. >> Yes. >> The motion is approved. >> Thank you. Our next action item is the approval of the fisc year 27 interim salary and non-personnel payments on

312
01:32:53.760 --> 01:33:10.639
external funds. This was presented at the May 6 meeting by Chief Financial Officer David Boom. I will now turn it over to the superintendent for final comments. >> Uh this is just a process that we do each year to enable us to be able to begin to spend money. Um it's really

313
01:33:10.639 --> 01:33:26.560
prefuncter in a lot of ways, but David, I don't know if there's anything else. >> No, I think we discussed it uh in our last meeting and and we're we're definitely um both Marcel and I are here if you have any final questions before the vote. >> Thank you. Any questions? No questions,

314
01:33:26.560 --> 01:33:41.840
but just a reminder from the last meeting that I think we did ask around whether there had been any history of kind of default or incidents with this act and you had replied that there had not. Is that correct? >> Yes, I can confirm that that's correct.

315
01:33:41.840 --> 01:33:58.159
>> Thank you. Okay. >> Thank you. I will now entertain a motion to approve the fiscal year 27 interim salary and non-personnel payments on external funds as presented. Is there a motion? >> So moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Second.

316
01:33:58.159 --> 01:34:13.679
>> Thank you. Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? >> Miss Pavix, will you please call the role? >> Thank you. Dr. Alkins, >> yes. >> Mr. Peralta, >> yes. >> Miss Panco Garcia, Miss Torres, >> yes. >> Mr. Tran, >> yes. >> Miss Garrett, >> yes. >> Miss Robinson, >> yes.

317
01:34:13.679 --> 01:34:29.840
>> The motion is approved. >> Thank you. Our next action item is the approval of the Le Street Neighborhood Charter School Renewal Application. This was presented at the May 6th meeting by Elijah Hexl, principal of Dudley Street Neighborhood um schools and Jesse

318
01:34:29.840 --> 01:34:46.480
Solomon, executive director of BPE. We'll be voting on the following items. Renewal application, accountability plan, memorandum of agreement, revised expulsion policy. I will now turn it over to the superintendent for final

319
01:34:46.480 --> 01:35:02.080
comments. >> Uh great. Thank you, chair. So tonight, uh, we're seeking approval for the Dudley Street Neighborhood Charter Schools charter renewal application. I think if you remember at the last meeting, uh, Principal Hexel, who is, um, awesome, principal of Dudley Street

320
01:35:02.080 --> 01:35:18.800
Neighborhood, uh, sorry, Dudley Street Charter, and Jesse Solomon, who's the executive director of the Boston Plan for Excellence. Uh, they both spoke about the school's academic progress, student outcomes, overall success. The school is requesting votes on four items. The first is the approval of its

321
01:35:18.800 --> 01:35:34.239
application for renewal of its public school charter. The second is its approval of its accountability plan. This outline um includes its intended outcomes and metrics. The third is its approval of the memorandum of agreement between the school's board of trustees

322
01:35:34.239 --> 01:35:50.239
and the Boston plan for excellence which serves as the school's educational management organization. And finally, its revised expulsion policy which aligns to the updated guidance from DESIE. Uh, as I indicated, May 6th, we recommend the renewal. Um, we see

323
01:35:50.239 --> 01:36:06.239
Dudley, although it is a Horus man in district charter as a BPS school. Uh, a little later in the agenda, we're also going to ask the committee to consider updates to the charters of several other Horus man charter schools. Um, just as a technical reminder, Horseman District

324
01:36:06.239 --> 01:36:23.199
charters, they are independent public schools that operate under a five-year charter that's granted by the Commonwealth's Board of Elementary and Secondary Education. We're bringing all of these changes together in a combined presentation in an effort to move all of the necessary governance documents

325
01:36:23.199 --> 01:36:39.440
forward before the end of the school year. It's an effort by our district to help the schools get their approvals as needed. Each Horus man charter school will have an opportunity to present a more complete overview of their school in the fourth year of their respective charter terms as Dudley Street did this

326
01:36:39.440 --> 01:37:03.679
year to this body. >> Questions, comments? >> Yes. >> No, she has something to say, but we'll do it in line right now. I'm just calling for questions, concerns. Okay, before we move to the vote,

327
01:37:03.679 --> 01:37:20.560
>> out of abundance of cautions due to the relationship with Dudley Street School, I am recusing myself from the vote. >> Okay. Thank you. All right. So now I will entertain a motion to approve the Dudley Street neighborhood charter school renewal application, accountability plan, memorandum of

328
01:37:20.560 --> 01:37:36.639
agreement, and revised expulsion policy is presented. Is there is there a motion? >> So move. >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Miss Pavvice, will you please call the role? >> Thank you. Dr. Alkins, >> yes.

329
01:37:36.639 --> 01:37:52.080
>> Mr. Peralta, >> yes. >> Miss Polano Garcia. Miss Torres, >> Mr. Tran? >> Yes. >> Miss Garrett? >> Yes. >> Miss Robinson's? >> Yes. >> The motion is approved. >> Thank you. >> Okay. Our next role is the approval of

330
01:37:52.080 --> 01:38:08.719
two private schools, the Alpha School and the Dunas Ridley School. You'll recall that development officer for strategy, partnerships, and innovation, Ann Clark, presented these schools at the April 15th meeting. As we take this vote, I want to make sure everyone

331
01:38:08.719 --> 01:38:24.960
understands that the school committee's role in this process is to verify that the private schools that come before us have met the criteria recommended by the Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education, Desicy Desi,

332
01:38:24.960 --> 01:38:40.400
which is implemented through the policy established by the school committee in alignment with Massachusetts General Law, Chapter 76, Section One, Boston families, your role is to determine the school that best meets the needs of your

333
01:38:40.400 --> 01:38:56.800
students and families. As the chair of this body, I want to reaffirm our commitment to Boston families. Boston Public Schools takes pride in serving all students and the the diverse needs they bring. I will now turn it over to the superintendent for final comments.

334
01:38:56.800 --> 01:39:13.440
>> Thank you, chair. So, um, tonight we're asking for a vote on two new private schools being proposed in the city of Boston. the Alpha School and the Douglas Ridley School. As was presented at the May 6th meeting, the Alpha School Boston is an independent non- sectarian K to8

335
01:39:13.440 --> 01:39:30.239
school focused on personalized learning with the help of artificial intelligence. The Douglas Ridley School is a K to2 through six school model in the Reglia approach to education which is rooted in equity and anti-racist practice.

336
01:39:30.239 --> 01:39:46.560
Again, I want to be clear. The district's role in this process is strictly administrative. BPS has two primary responsibilities. One, to ensure all private schools seeking approval meet the requirements of Massachusetts general law, and two, make recommendations to superintendent and

337
01:39:46.560 --> 01:40:02.080
the Boston School Committee. The school committee is responsible for approval of any private school wishing to operate within the city of Boston. Both applications meet the district's requirements. We are joined today by JC Fiser, executive vice president of

338
01:40:02.080 --> 01:40:20.320
operations and Dr. Tasha Arnold, head of schools for Alpha School and Douglas Ridley School founder Courtney Schwarz. I would um Ann is Ann Clark is also here were there to be any questions about the applications.

339
01:40:20.320 --> 01:40:38.080
>> Thank you. I'll now open it up to questions and comments from the committee. Um, Dr. Hopkins, >> uh, one thing that I will say that I I think this conversation, um, has brought up for me particularly,

340
01:40:38.080 --> 01:40:55.679
um, has been around clarifying exactly when we say administratively, like what is our oversight and what is our role? um in that sense um particularly because um anything that we do oversee takes resources away from

341
01:40:55.679 --> 01:41:11.040
overseeing our own district. Um and so I think that's a concern that's been brought up for me. I think additionally um it it has already been said um in regard to just the oddity that it is

342
01:41:11.040 --> 01:41:27.119
that we are put in this position um to make decisions on schools that are operating within with within our district. And um the concern that I particularly have with any school

343
01:41:27.119 --> 01:41:43.360
um is truly its commitment to serving all students. And we've already seen an example of it this year where when students weren't appropriately served because for whatever reason the adults in the room couldn't get it together,

344
01:41:43.360 --> 01:42:00.320
um the students are the ones who suffer and the district is is the one that's left picking up the pieces. And so, um, you know, a message to all of our schools that are seeking to operate that, um, yes, we do this in

345
01:42:00.320 --> 01:42:18.639
partnership. Um, but please keep in mind that, um, if to abide by your mission, um, to make space, truly make space for all those students um, who are walking through your halls. Um and um to the to

346
01:42:18.639 --> 01:42:33.280
the families that are considering um any school option that isn't um BPS, those same uh anything that should be considered, we would also ask look at the schools within BPS and see

347
01:42:33.280 --> 01:42:51.360
that our schools also do offer a wide range of options that are available for like your family. Um, and there are resources that are willing to work with you to figure out what those best options are. Um, so, um, I'll stop

348
01:42:51.360 --> 01:43:06.880
there. >> Okay. Anyone else? >> Yeah, I I would love to just, um, echo Dr. Alen's sentiments. I think that the just even coming off of this hour or so

349
01:43:06.880 --> 01:43:23.920
of public comment and the understandable rigor with which we're asking to be uh to apply a lens to our staffing models, the way that we're serving our most vulnerable students, etc., and our obligation um and and honor to continue to work to

350
01:43:23.920 --> 01:43:38.560
do so, and we know we have a lot of work to do. it is an extremely uncomfortable position to evaluate um a potential school on paper uh and then have no more oversight um on this important

351
01:43:38.560 --> 01:43:54.480
initiative. Um the majority of states nationally do not have this practice. >> Um there are some states in New England who do. There are other districts around the state who have not universally approved private schools who have come

352
01:43:54.480 --> 01:44:09.920
before us. And I think it's our duty as a committee to explore all of those best practices to re-evaluate the criteria that we currently have. Um we have a very um saturated market for a declining

353
01:44:09.920 --> 01:44:26.159
student population in the city. >> I think there may need to be an ask of what is missing to Dr. Alen's point of the wide variety of options that already exist. Um, and I think that that research um should really be undertaken

354
01:44:26.159 --> 01:44:47.040
in a rigorous way and in partnership with Desi um before we have this challenge before us again. >> And um I'll chime in. Um having founded a school uh I can say that what lies on paper and what

355
01:44:47.040 --> 01:45:02.719
actually it takes to operationalize it and make it successful are very different things and what happens in those years uh between um there's lots of twists and turn and I think we have an example recently of a school where there may have been excellent intentions

356
01:45:02.719 --> 01:45:19.440
but the result ended up being an extreme disruption for many many families. amilies uh within the city limit. Uh so I would again just encourage the schools that are putting in these applications um the when I look at the guidelines they're very base very very base from

357
01:45:19.440 --> 01:45:35.040
DESI and I think there's just so much more that goes into actually operating a school successfully. Um so we have what we have. I think we uh this is a huge district resource for us and so I think to doc Dr. Alkins point

358
01:45:35.040 --> 01:45:52.480
like Ann Clark has spent a considerable amount of time as have the departments in reviewing the portions that we can review. But again, I just don't I just want to be clear this is just fundamentals. That's it. And once this gets approval, it's really up to the public and to the parents that become

359
01:45:52.480 --> 01:46:11.440
part of those schools uh to hold folks accountable to them >> as okay. uh an understanding that our role in voting on these two private schools are pretty much administrative.

360
01:46:11.440 --> 01:46:31.280
Um I don't see how uh Desi is charging us with some kind of a duty to do something that doesn't have that doesn't carry any weight. assuming just assuming

361
01:46:31.280 --> 01:46:48.880
that our body rejected the applications. Does that stop the schools these private schools from being uh from being um established? I doubt it. So if if we

362
01:46:48.880 --> 01:47:04.239
vote yes or we vote no pretty much we voted uh we will vote based upon our own assessment of the situation. Right. >> Right. Our our job as the district officials is to look at the guidelines

363
01:47:04.239 --> 01:47:22.320
that DESIE has provided uh and to ensure that the schools have checked those boxes. If they have >> then our recommendation needs to be that they be granted to open. >> Right. While I understand that um given the list of jacks that we you know we

364
01:47:22.320 --> 01:47:38.960
must go through in order to assess a school and I I I I do know that your staff has performed the uh the inspection

365
01:47:38.960 --> 01:47:57.199
not only adequately but promptly and thoroughly. I understand that but that doesn't equate to my own assessment of the situation >> and whether my own vote will somehow

366
01:47:57.199 --> 01:48:16.760
uh influence the process or not I doubt it but I just because of that I'll state right here before this board both of the schools I'm going to vote no >> that's my pretty much my my my status my Y

367
01:48:17.520 --> 01:48:32.000
we have nothing. Yeah. >> Um this for several years we've had schools come before us. I think um this year because of a number of issues that have occurred. It's been the first time that

368
01:48:32.000 --> 01:48:49.760
we've done two things. want to look at the um amount of time our own staff take to go through this process. Acknowledging the fact that we are basically um approving competitors at a

369
01:48:49.760 --> 01:49:07.119
time when um resources are short and parents have needs and the needs are great. understanding what happens, for example, when a school that looked great on paper was unable to complete. And then what

370
01:49:07.119 --> 01:49:22.480
happens with when the district had to open its arms quickly to be able to provide opportunities for those families that we don't know whether or not they will take advantage of, but this district steps up. So, there's a lot of

371
01:49:22.480 --> 01:49:38.639
resources coming out of the district. Um, right now we have the we have the process that we have, but before we get to this point next year, Superintendent, we're really asking that you and Desi sit down for us to take a different look

372
01:49:38.639 --> 01:49:55.440
at this because we do not if if nothing else, um, we should be paid for our time to do the work and it's been a significant amount of work. I know that in the past there have been other schools that have started the process but were not approved at the district

373
01:49:55.440 --> 01:50:11.840
level so they never came before us. >> Um it would be great if we could even take a look at over the past decade how many applications have been both successful how many have not gotten to the end but also what is happening with those schools

374
01:50:11.840 --> 01:50:28.400
>> so that we can also make sure that families and others um are aware of it. The other issue is that this the assumption was often that schools that were being proposed would be bringing new ideas or doing things differently to

375
01:50:28.400 --> 01:50:44.719
add value so that they would not be duplicating what was already in existence. And I'm not sure if our application critically looks at those issues as well. So, we have we have what we have for this evening and the information that we have, but we're

376
01:50:44.719 --> 01:50:58.960
asking that as we move forward in the future that we take a very close look at this so that um we can be sure that we're moving in the right direction. >> Thank you, Chair. >> So, at this moment, I will now entertain a motion to approve the alpha school as

377
01:50:58.960 --> 01:51:16.239
presented. Is there a motion? >> So, moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second? Second. Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Miss Pix, will you please call the RO? >> Thank you, Chair. Dr. Alkins. >> Yes. >> Mr. Peralta,

378
01:51:16.239 --> 01:51:32.159
>> I am boring. Yes. This private school have met the criteria set forward by the Massachusetts Department of Education to operate in our city. >> Miss Panco Garcia. Miss Torres. >> Yes. >> Mr. Tran. Oh,

379
01:51:32.159 --> 01:51:51.080
>> Miss Garrett. >> Yes. Miss Robinson. >> Yes. >> The alpha school is approved with um five. No, sorry. >> One two

380
01:51:51.199 --> 01:52:08.320
one. >> Yeah. Five and one. Thank you. >> Okay. I will now entertain a motion to approve the Douglas Ridley School as presented. Is there a motion? So moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second?

381
01:52:08.320 --> 01:52:23.679
>> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Miss Pravic, will you please call the role? >> Thank you. Dr. Alkins, >> yes. >> Mr. Peralta, >> yes. >> Miss Pano Garcia, Miss Torres, >> yes.

382
01:52:23.679 --> 01:52:40.719
>> Mr. Tran, >> no. >> Miss Garrett, >> yes. >> Miss Robinson, >> yes. The Douglas Whitney School is approved with five yays. >> Thank you.

383
01:52:40.719 --> 01:52:56.639
All right. Our next action item is the approval of the artificial intelligent policy that was presented at the May 6th meeting. I will now turn it over to the superintendent for final comments. >> Uh wonderful. Thank you, chair. So at the May 6th meeting, PPS chief

384
01:52:56.639 --> 01:53:11.920
technology officer Lisa II and the deputy chief of teaching and learning Tony Beatatrice presented the district's proposed AI or artificial intelligence policy and guidelines. This work started more than three years ago with the release of the district's initial AI

385
01:53:11.920 --> 01:53:28.159
guidelines. This year, following a thorough community engagement process, we developed this draft policy. The proposed policy does several things. It provides clear guidelines for safe, responsible, and ethical use. It includes strong student safety

386
01:53:28.159 --> 01:53:45.360
protections, clear expectations for academic integrity, and requirements for AI training and literacy for both students and staff. The policy defines the boundaries that will govern AI usage and the guidelines define how we will work within those boundaries. Policy and

387
01:53:45.360 --> 01:54:00.320
guidelines are designed to work together. Right now, BPS is incorporating AI into student learning to enhance students understanding and critical thinking. Our goal is to enhance outcomes, not replace human interaction or instruction.

388
01:54:00.320 --> 01:54:21.119
Tonight, we ask the school committee to vote in favor of this policy. And Lisa and Tony are here with us. >> Thank you. I'll now open it up to questions and comments from the committee. Thank you. I I just want for the record

389
01:54:21.119 --> 01:54:36.400
to clarify that yesterday um I have a a long conversation with with the department about particular issue that I have been approached by families of the district and our concerns on my own families about the

390
01:54:36.400 --> 01:54:53.920
unfortunate and misuse of interf artificial intelligent to create um photos of students mostly girls with a object with a objective of basically sexual harassment. Um, we had

391
01:54:53.920 --> 01:55:09.920
a long conversation about how what the policy can do about this. I was told that it is included when it says that AI cannot be used for any kind of discrimination. I also was told that it's going to be included in the Q&A

392
01:55:09.920 --> 01:55:26.080
that's going to appear as part of the of the process. Um, I'm going to leave it there. I think as we were told in the last meeting, this must be a living document given the nature of what we are

393
01:55:26.080 --> 01:55:44.400
treating here, which is changing by the minute. I I would really appreciate if you keep an eye on this. Thank you. You >> I have two questions. I'm wondering if um you could narrate any adjustments or

394
01:55:44.400 --> 01:56:01.440
additional um thinking in relation to the policy since the presentation. If um I know that there's been a lot of community engagement, if there was any new information that affected wording of the policy, additions, um deletions

395
01:56:01.440 --> 01:56:18.239
since the full presentation at um a previous meeting. >> Yeah. So there's not a lot of change specifically in the wording in this current version. I think um what we're doing is updating the FAQ sheet with things that we have learned um that we

396
01:56:18.239 --> 01:56:32.639
want to include in the next version of the guidelines. So we met with the students for example from Sociad Latina um and one of the things that we heard there was about when educators are using AI detection

397
01:56:32.639 --> 01:56:50.719
tools for example sometimes those AI tools um will say that a student used generative AI to create um a a piece of writing from scratch when in fact a student might have been using a a translation device that was approved um

398
01:56:50.719 --> 01:57:06.320
and readily available to that student, but because there was an AI portion on the back end of that, it popped up on the AI detector. Um and so we want to call that out along with anytime that um a student is using a online tool um that's part of their accommodation or

399
01:57:06.320 --> 01:57:23.679
modification within their IEP. Um so now that AI isn't being embedded in so many of the um online tools that we're using, we need to make sure that our faculty and staff are aware of that. Um and so we've inputed that in our FAQ sheet. Um

400
01:57:23.679 --> 01:57:39.440
and then additionally talking about there was a question from the school committee about how we're going to um really meet as a district and what are the metrics that we're going to look at and and who's going to take a look at those metrics and we're going to develop a steering committee. Um and one of the

401
01:57:39.440 --> 01:57:55.119
things that came up associated with Latina was making sure that the student voice was being heard. Um and so we want to make sure that we have students on those committees going forward. And so we've added that in the FAQ sheet as well. >> Thank you. Um just extending um member

402
01:57:55.119 --> 01:58:10.560
Peralta's point around how this policy intersects with existing policies. I think it's also just worth underscoring that there are a lot of links and connections to other key documents in these guidelines. um particularly the

403
01:58:10.560 --> 01:58:26.239
BPSA at eye guidelines which give a lot more detail around kind of teaching and learning expectations with this document being more of like a goals and gu like a guard rails document um or kind of a guiding principles document there's also

404
01:58:26.239 --> 01:58:43.440
a reference to the code of conduct there references to Massachusetts state guidelines um so would you know just encourage that um lens with a read of understanding this as a key addition to those other um foundational documents.

405
01:58:43.440 --> 01:59:01.520
Um but my last question is related to how fast this is going to move and appreciate the language about revisiting the policy annually. Um but a lot of the work that's going to be most relevant to educators are best practices related to the use of AI both for themselves and

406
01:59:01.520 --> 01:59:17.599
for their students. Um there will be situations that come up next week that have never happened before. uh and schools will be looking to the central office for guidance around those. Um I understand the steering committee is kind of an ongoing body to look at the

407
01:59:17.599 --> 01:59:33.920
policy. But is there a centralized point of contact for a school leader to be able to call with a new situation um as related to teaching and learning or some issue in their building uh and its connection to AI? >> That's a really great question. Um uh I

408
01:59:33.920 --> 01:59:49.679
am that contact for anyone who has questions and in addition to the steering committee for using this document and our guidelines to govern the use of AI and decide whether or not we want to pursue new initiatives and

409
01:59:49.679 --> 02:00:05.840
how we're going to roll that out thoughtfully. Um there will be a a separate and higher level executive oversight committee made up of um chief officers and deputy superintendent who

410
02:00:05.840 --> 02:00:22.320
will be one step higher making some of those higher level decisions for the district um and taking recommendations from the steering committee um on how we move this forward. So the governing structure will be multi-layered um and making sure that there's voice

411
02:00:22.320 --> 02:00:39.360
represented um across levels >> and I appreciate it that it's both of you in partnership for example like kind of on the tech side and the teaching and learning and would just think about how that continues for those phone calls

412
02:00:39.360 --> 02:00:55.520
because I think some of the phone calls will not be related to tech they will be related to best practices in terms of classroom room use and so it actually might need to be directed to teaching and learning more so and so thinking about what that guidance is for school

413
02:00:55.520 --> 02:01:12.400
leaders in terms of how to get um how to get that clarity. >> Absolutely. Thank you. >> Yeah, I also think uh student conduct will be another through line and so there'll absolutely be this interdep departmental uh overseeing.

414
02:01:12.400 --> 02:01:27.760
>> I have I have a question. Um it have to do with our second language learners and I know that uh this the entire toolkit is in English and um how were there the multilingual and uh the different

415
02:01:27.760 --> 02:01:44.400
community with different languages were included as part of knowing the needs and what the the expectations are when it comes to AI. >> Yes. So when we did our community engagements this spring, all of our materials we had translated into the

416
02:01:44.400 --> 02:02:03.280
major BPS languages and um we held Zoom that was able to handle translation in in their native language. Um and then once we get um this policy approved and we have our guidelines updated um those

417
02:02:03.280 --> 02:02:19.679
will also be translated into our major languages for our multilingual families. Is this a this is going to be like the this policy going to be a mandate or is it a choice by school

418
02:02:19.679 --> 02:02:36.960
you know uh all the schools in Boston public school will be using this policy or is it something that is only what so so if it's yes what about the schools in the community that cannot afford or are disadvantaged when it

419
02:02:36.960 --> 02:02:53.679
comes to internet and all that. What happens there? >> I mean, all of our schools are equipped with network. So, we have internet at every single site. We've equipped every school with one device per student and

420
02:02:53.679 --> 02:03:09.520
all of our like all of our teachers, all of our staff um at the school, they have internet. And so, I want to be clear, this is not a mandate that we are making people use AI. This is a policy saying we're protecting you

421
02:03:09.520 --> 02:03:26.639
>> with this policy and what we are mandating is that you learn about AI because it's already being used in your life and you're being impacted by this technology and you deserve to understand how.

422
02:03:26.639 --> 02:03:42.400
>> Yeah. So probably professional development around um what are the guard rails um so students, teachers and everyone involved that be using this will be aware of where to do it and what where to go. >> Yes.

423
02:03:42.400 --> 02:03:57.119
>> When anything happens when it comes to AI >> correct? >> Correct. And we already we we've heard from the students um many many times at school committee they're really asking for this. They they want the guardrails.

424
02:03:57.119 --> 02:04:13.119
>> They want to become >> um int like they want to understand and become proficient >> at >> the components of AI that are going to make them, >> you know, an ethical user of it, a

425
02:04:13.119 --> 02:04:27.920
responsible user of it. Um and they're really not getting that anywhere else. >> And so that's why much like education in general, it's incumbent on us >> to bring that to them. And I think that's they've done an excellent job doing that.

426
02:04:27.920 --> 02:04:44.880
>> Yeah. I think in addition also that it training is going to be made available to all of us because many of us have very li limited understanding as well. So that we'll be able to um participate first in the you know personal online

427
02:04:44.880 --> 02:05:01.599
training that is provided to district staff and then in addition there is other training once we get that foundational piece. So I feel it's just as important that we understand >> what it is we have a policy for and understanding what is going on in our

428
02:05:01.599 --> 02:05:18.480
schools making sure everybody including ourselves. Yes. Absolutely. >> And chair I'm sorry just that made me think about one other piece too when we're thinking about professional learning for students around use and being judicious around that use. I think

429
02:05:18.480 --> 02:05:36.239
>> building in um and underscoring when not using um when not using AI is um more appropriate um some of the disproportionate use by demographic groups that's coming out uh in terms of research in terms of overuse and over

430
02:05:36.239 --> 02:05:52.880
reliance on AI to complete assignments um particularly for populations of color I think is is also really important and if there's some way to also include um the impact on the environment um on for things like data centers etc. Um that

431
02:05:52.880 --> 02:06:12.320
all go into students understanding of responsible use um and being um really um equipped and informed consumers of what's available to them. >> Okay, everybody set? Okay. All right, then. I

432
02:06:12.320 --> 02:06:28.000
will now entertain a motion to approve the artificial intelligence policy as presented. Is there a motion? >> So moved. >> Is there a second? >> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Miss Pravix, will you please call the >> Thank you, Chair. Dr. Alkins, >> yes.

433
02:06:28.000 --> 02:06:43.840
>> Mr. Peralta, >> yes. >> Miss Pelanka Garcia, Miss Torres, >> yes. >> Mr. Tran, >> yes. >> Miss Garrett, >> yes. >> Miss Robinson, >> yes. >> The policies approved. >> Thank you. Thank you. >> Thank you. Nice job. >> Thank you. >> Yeah.

434
02:06:43.840 --> 02:06:58.880
>> Our final vote tonight is the approval of the 2026 policy to advance academic excellence and eliminate opportunity and achievement gaps as presented at the April 15th meeting. I want to invite the superintendent to give following

435
02:06:58.880 --> 02:07:15.760
following remarks final sorry final remarks. >> Wonderful. Thank you chair. Um, so as we presented on April 15th, the intent of the opportunity achievement gaps policy is to close opportunity and achievement gaps for every single student in the district with a focus on groups that

436
02:07:15.760 --> 02:07:31.679
have been historically marginalized and ensure they have the opportunity to reach their full potential. After nearly a decade since the policy was updated, delayed in part to the pandemic, we ask the committee to approve this new policy. Dr. Colin Rose, members of my

437
02:07:31.679 --> 02:07:48.159
team, and the OAG task force that guides the district's work are working to seamlessly align the goals of the policy and the strategic goals of the district. There's several members of the task force in attendance tonight and joining us online for tonight's vote. I want to

438
02:07:48.159 --> 02:08:13.920
acknowledge them and ask them to stand so they can be recognized for their great work. Senior adviser for strategy and opportunity gaps, Dr. Rose, the OAG task force co-chairs, Ayelli Shakur, and as well as school committee member Dr. Alkins are here to provide any

439
02:08:13.920 --> 02:08:28.320
additional information you need. As a district, my team and I see this policy as incredibly thorough and critical northstar for the goals we set in the work we do now and in the years to come. So with this I'll turn back to chair.

440
02:08:28.320 --> 02:08:48.400
>> Okay. So I'll now retain questions, comments. >> I just I just want to say you are a beautiful sight to see. >> Thank you so much. I trust you as very intelligent and capable people. You

441
02:08:48.400 --> 02:09:10.079
brought us here. Now let's h help us to implement this policy and not come back in 10 years and say we got to do it again because we are basically in the same place. I trust you. Thank you. Um just also want to express

442
02:09:10.079 --> 02:09:25.440
appreciation for um the thoughtfulness and work that goes into this set of goals and objectives and the collaborative nature of um you know key invested constituents who move this forward both in and out of the district.

443
02:09:25.440 --> 02:09:44.159
Um I would um love if a little bit of narration in terms of what the expected like crosswalk or relation between the forthcoming strategic plan and what we're voting on this evening will how they live together um both in relation

444
02:09:44.159 --> 02:09:59.840
to like will all of these things literally show up in the the plan? Will the plan be in service of these? Um will kind of the the measures by which we update our success be reflective in both um just

445
02:09:59.840 --> 02:10:16.480
any forecasting um around what to expect um with that would be helpful. Thank you. as as much as we can. I believe that our strategic plan should be in service of this policy and align to this policy, right? So that the metrics and I know we've had conversations around

446
02:10:16.480 --> 02:10:31.199
school committee metrics but also the KPIs for for the uh strategic plan align to the values and the the things that are being asked to be measured in the OEG policy. So I mean the experience of having implemented a OEG policy with a

447
02:10:31.199 --> 02:10:47.599
strategic plan on the other side uh and having people serve two major documents uh in the district and focus is what I think we want to avoid. Um and so as much as we can uh we need to outline exactly what we're doing as a district in our strategic plan and make specific

448
02:10:47.599 --> 02:11:03.199
crosswalk to uh the policy and speak to it. That will really be the ongoing work of the task force is to to really monitor sort of working with uh Dr. Rose as he's working with his district working groups

449
02:11:03.199 --> 02:11:20.560
um to develop the actual goals the smart goals that will be in the strategic plan and the implementation component and to make sure they they crosswalk with the policy. So, we'll be looking at the KPIs. We'll be looking at, you know, lots of different things and reporting

450
02:11:20.560 --> 02:11:36.719
back to the school committee on a regular basis. >> Yeah. The only other thing is, you know, I know the school committee is working on kind of a cadence of where you want to see certain topics and we've been talking about how we could use the OG policy um and task force meetings to deepen some of those conversations

451
02:11:36.719 --> 02:11:51.760
because again, the stuff that we do as a district and we're prioritizing should be aligned to this policy. So, how do we do deeper dives in those task force meeting where there's more dialogue and back and forth with some experts uh to really uh take a look at what we're doing and and the data that's connected

452
02:11:51.760 --> 02:12:09.040
to it? >> Yes. >> Um I had an opportunity to uh observe uh you guys at work uh two weeks ago, three weeks, I don't remember. I I I would

453
02:12:09.040 --> 02:12:28.719
have to say that you comprised of a group of well educated, well learned and very much uh committed to uh the interest of the

454
02:12:28.719 --> 02:12:45.119
students. I and and and I do see that during that that um meeting the only thing the only thing that I I I'm I'm thinking that you are facing

455
02:12:45.119 --> 02:13:02.480
pretty diff you know difficulty right now a pretty uh a difficult situation is that there are two of us who are before you for a vote I wish uh that I I I I don't know

456
02:13:02.480 --> 02:13:19.360
what happened but you know I wish that both of us I not me but you know both of of of my committee members can join you and assist you you know in in your work given the fact that um

457
02:13:19.360 --> 02:13:36.320
Dr. Alpens has been there for quite a while. I I I I I know he he he he's missing his friends, but uh if you have to make a decision on on the two candidates, uh please be discreet.

458
02:13:36.320 --> 02:13:52.880
It's it's it's not going to be easy. But and one more thing I like to remind you I I know that the policy is somehow uh a mirror or for lack of better term

459
02:13:52.880 --> 02:14:13.280
is mirror imaging our u strategic plan. But then again during the school year, during our our performance of our duty, of course, there are times that we lose sight of our uh of of our strategic plan. And you

460
02:14:13.280 --> 02:14:29.920
are the people that could hit on our head and make sure that we stay in line, stay, you know, within the the within the boundary of of of the road. Okay. So uh please keep that in mind

461
02:14:29.920 --> 02:14:46.639
because I am a very forgetful guy. So please make sure that I I I get hit in the head as frequently as possible. Thank you. >> I have one one question for you guys on goal. So I was reading the goals and

462
02:14:46.639 --> 02:15:02.639
objectives like I was told and on uh goal three advance academic excellent contains 11 objectives. How are we prioritizing? How we attack this? Which goes first?

463
02:15:02.639 --> 02:15:18.239
How are we doing that as a task force? How would you go about doing it? >> And I I think that um you know, goal three, which is specifically on academics, >> is really looking at um all of the levers that the district is already

464
02:15:18.239 --> 02:15:33.920
focused on, but we want that laser focus to really continue. Um, I think one of the the ways that it crosswalks with the strategic plan already is the literacy goal is really elevated. The equitable literacy is elevated in the strategic

465
02:15:33.920 --> 02:15:49.760
plan um as a as a starting point as well as um inclusion. We've heard a lot tonight about inclusion and the needs to get that right and I think that's um reflected as well. So all of those things are happening. You have an amazing superintendent. Skipper has an

466
02:15:49.760 --> 02:16:05.760
amazing team that's hard at work. And so all of those things are moving along all 11 of those goals. But I think that that's um literacy is where it all starts. Um including numerousy, right? Because you need to computation is also part of literacy and making sure young

467
02:16:05.760 --> 02:16:20.960
people across all content areas and grade levels are reading at or above grade level. It's really important. >> Yeah. and and all that those 11 objectives should be connected to what what we say is high quality instruction which is kind of that overarching

468
02:16:20.960 --> 02:16:36.479
umbrella to that first objective in the upcoming >> there will be criteria as to when we do meet or >> I mean to me everything is in in in implement it uh it gets spelled out in implementation right so what are we focusing on what are our strategies and what are we working on

469
02:16:36.479 --> 02:16:53.280
>> so sorry and so like one of the ways that the data will sort of inform the uh the task force will be able to come back and make very more specific recommendations I think to what you're talking about. And then for us, I think where the rubber meets the road really will come down to budget

470
02:16:53.280 --> 02:17:07.760
season like in particular. So like when we're really thinking about >> not wanting to in a in a year like we just saw um wanting to you know mitigate learning loss for example um and maintain all of the gains that we made

471
02:17:07.760 --> 02:17:23.519
across like the district. Um so it will really depend on um that's like one where where we have the lever as a school committee to really think about it. >> Thank you. >> Mhm. Yeah. And I would just add that I think this is the deep work that the

472
02:17:23.519 --> 02:17:39.679
working groups and the uh the deputies and the chiefs are working on right now and will be throughout the summer which is to really look to make sure that we've accounted for each of the goals where they are the baselines and then the disagregation of them which I think

473
02:17:39.679 --> 02:17:55.040
is incredibly important >> um that hasn't been done consistently in the district. So, and I think that's something that school committee has also asked for as well relative to, you know, its measures. So, I think there's really great alignment and I can just say from

474
02:17:55.040 --> 02:18:10.240
my perspective that's half the key to success is having that alignment, having a strong implementation plan and having a task force that's willing to walk with us in that accountability. >> Yeah. >> All I can say to you is um

475
02:18:10.240 --> 02:18:26.479
congratulations. um 20 years ago plus this work began. Um and this district has always given lip service to the fact that this was important work. >> What I feel is different now that there

476
02:18:26.479 --> 02:18:44.240
is a partnership between the task force and the district to move the work forward. Um it's the best shot that we will have ever had. um to you I thank you for being the fearless consistent leader for the past decade um through

477
02:18:44.240 --> 02:19:01.120
thick and thin and through all the other iterations of many people there many folks sitting in this room that have been on this journey for at least the past 11 years 12 years some people who are at the reiterated um task force but

478
02:19:01.120 --> 02:19:16.880
also to the energy and excitement that the new members ers bring and returning bring um that as we look at the strategic plan and this this um the OG

479
02:19:16.880 --> 02:19:32.800
work together. Um as I say it it feels like the best shot that we will have to actually beginning to make some real movement on the um strategic plan. So so thank you and I know the work is just

480
02:19:32.800 --> 02:19:48.319
beginning certainly not over. This is just turning the first page in it. So, let's get on with the vote for tonight. >> Thank you, Chair Robinson. And I just want to just take a moment to just thank and acknowledge you for being the co-chair, working with me on the the

481
02:19:48.319 --> 02:20:05.520
task force for those 10 years. Um, and just, you know, what a testament that is to your strength to be chairing the school committee, but also serving as co-chair of the task force because that work was deeply important to you and important to the district. So, thank you. >> Yep. some of the most important work we

482
02:20:05.520 --> 02:20:22.080
continuously say we need to do in this district and now hopefully we'll be able to move forward on it. So I will now entertain a motion to approve the 2026 policy to advance academic excellence and eliminate opportunity and achievement gaps as presented. I'm going

483
02:20:22.080 --> 02:20:39.200
to read the motion so it's clear what we're voting on. ordered that the Boston School Committee hereby approves the opportunity and achievement gaps OAG policy goals and objectives outlined in the attached document. This approval

484
02:20:39.200 --> 02:20:55.840
applies only to the goals and objectives and does not constitute approval of any accompanying recommendations. >> Is there a motion? >> So moved. >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Second. >> There any discussion or objection to the motion? this props. Will you please call the

485
02:20:55.840 --> 02:21:12.000
role >> chair? Dr. Alkins. >> Yes. >> Mr. Peralta. >> With a lot of hope and excitement. Yes. >> Garcia. Miss Torres. >> Yes. >> Mr. Tran. >> You guys are Thors. You hold the hammer.

486
02:21:12.000 --> 02:21:33.600
That hammer away the lip service. >> Yes. >> Miss Garrett. >> Yes. >> Miss Robinson. >> Yes. The OG policy is approved. >> Thank you. Thank you so much. We will now transition to reports. And again, since we have a full agenda

487
02:21:33.600 --> 02:21:48.560
tonight, I'd like to ask all presenters to please be mindful of their aotted times. Our first presentation tonight is the Horus man charter governing updates. Let's try to keep this presentation to under 12 minutes. I'd like to remind our

488
02:21:48.560 --> 02:22:05.359
presenters to please speak at a slower pace to assist our interpreters and I want to invite the superintendent to give introductory remarks. >> Wonderful. So, the horseman charter schools require updates to their charter documents as part of the standard

489
02:22:05.359 --> 02:22:21.840
renewal process and occasionally when changes are made to the technical guidance from the state. The reason these documents are coming forward now rather than with the typical charter renewal timelines is because they are either one-offs like the expulsion policy or they weren't ready in time for

490
02:22:21.840 --> 02:22:37.200
those presentations like the accountability policy. So this language gives a little bit of that flexibility. These charter governing updates require school committee approval as well as approval from the charter schools boards of trustees, the Boston teachers union,

491
02:22:37.200 --> 02:22:52.479
and the department of elementary and secondary education. There are several items before you tonight. BPS development officer for strategy, partnerships, and innovation. Ann Clark will lead the presentation and walk you through the process. Um there's

492
02:22:52.479 --> 02:23:07.840
representatives. We have a star cast here tonight. Uh we have Allison Hermick from um BDA. Karen Walker Gregory head of school at EMK, Patina Toner, the lawyer representing BDA and EMK. Uh BGA

493
02:23:07.840 --> 02:23:23.280
school leader, Boston Green Academy, Matt Holtzer sitting in the back. Uh and Mike Bower, chief operating officer of UP uh education network. Oh, she he's joining us remotely. and a representation from our office of legal

494
02:23:23.280 --> 02:23:39.760
uh who is our office of legal advisor Lorenzo D Silvio. So with that I will turn it to Ann. Good evening madame chair, madame vice chair and members of the school committee this evening. I am presenting governance

495
02:23:39.760 --> 02:23:56.560
documents from our five Horus man charter schools for your approval. I will begin with a brief overview of Horus man charter schools and then I will turn it over to my esteemed colleagues. As Superintendent Skipper mentioned, there are many members of BPS

496
02:23:56.560 --> 02:24:15.359
staff and Horus man charters here tonight to answer any questions you may have. Horus man charter schools were created by the Massachusetts legislature in 1997 as a middle path between traditional district schools and independent

497
02:24:15.359 --> 02:24:32.720
Commonwealth charter schools offering charter-like autonomy while maintaining union membership and a close district partnership. All five operating Horus man charters in Massachusetts are located in Boston. Teachers at all five

498
02:24:32.720 --> 02:24:49.359
schools remain BTU members, acrew seniority, and are paid according to the BTU salary schedule. Autonomies of a horseman charter school include the following. Horseman operating funds come directly from the

499
02:24:49.359 --> 02:25:04.479
district where the school is located. A horseman's budget allocation must be consistent with other public schools in the district. Other federal, state, and private funds come directly to the horseman charter school.

500
02:25:04.479 --> 02:25:21.439
Horse mans are attended are intended to be autonomous to the extent provided by the terms of their charters. Boris man charter schools may be exempt from local collective bargaining agreements and all union and school committee work rules

501
02:25:21.439 --> 02:25:37.120
provided that employees of the school will continue to be members of the local collective bargaining unit to acrew seniority and to receive at minimum the salary and benefits established by the local collective bargaining agreement.

502
02:25:37.120 --> 02:25:53.840
The documents before you tonight fall into four categories. with BPS and the BTU accountability plans, mission statement and enrollment policy updates and expulsion policies. On the expulsion

503
02:25:53.840 --> 02:26:11.600
policies specifically, DESIE recently updated its requirements and all five schools are required to revise their policies accordingly. All documents before you have received provisional DESIE approval where required. Your vote tonight enables

504
02:26:11.600 --> 02:26:29.840
final submission to the commissioner. Boston public schools, as I said, has five Horus man charter schools. Three are secondary schools. Two are elementary schools. There are two relevant subtypes of Horus man charter schools. Type one schools, Boston and

505
02:26:29.840 --> 02:26:46.880
Evening Academy and the Edward M. Kennedy Academy for Health Careers require approval from both the BTU and the school committee. Type three schools, Boston Green Academy, Dudley Street Neighborhood Charter School, and UP Academy Doorchester require school

506
02:26:46.880 --> 02:27:03.280
committee approval with good faith BTU negotiation. The demographics of each school are listed here and this information was also in your cover memo. All of these schools have required some document updates this year.

507
02:27:03.280 --> 02:27:19.760
In summary, the specific documents you have before you this evening are as follows. For EMK, you have an accountability plan and an updated application enrollment policy. for BDEA, a revised mission statement and

508
02:27:19.760 --> 02:27:37.840
accountability plan for both BDEA and EMK jointly MOUA with BPS and for BDEA MOUB with the BTU and finally for BDEA, EMK, Boston Green, and UP Academy

509
02:27:37.840 --> 02:27:55.120
Doorchester updated expulsion policies. Please note that Dudley Street Neighborhood Charter School submitted its comparable documents alongside its charter renew presentation on May 6th and you voted on these documents earlier in the evening. I now pass off the

510
02:27:55.120 --> 02:28:11.840
presentation to Dr. Karen Walker Gregory. >> Good evening everyone. Just wanted to summarize the our accountability plan. Every five years we are required to submit a five-year accountability plan

511
02:28:11.840 --> 02:28:27.200
and we're actually in our third year of it but we needed final um approval from DESIE board of trustees and now requires obviously the school committee approval. The three main elements are positive school culture,

512
02:28:27.200 --> 02:28:42.800
health careers preparation and college readiness. When we talk about positive school culture, we're really really looking at positive responses on Panorama climate survey and we're really looking at increasing engagement in

513
02:28:42.800 --> 02:29:00.000
extracurricular activities. When we talk about health careers preparation, we're looking in our lovely CNA and ENT credentials that our students are earning each and every year and looking at reflections on engagement with health careers exposure activities

514
02:29:00.000 --> 02:29:16.640
in collaboration with Mass General Bighgam. When we talk about college readiness, we're looking at 75% of the seniors enroll in and pass at least one AP class dual enrollment early college or DESIE advanced course. We're looking also at

515
02:29:16.640 --> 02:29:34.160
95% of all graduates admitted to a two or four-year college. And we're using u MAP testing uh to measure growth in ELA and math. Those are the three big bul bullet points around accountability. The next

516
02:29:34.160 --> 02:29:48.960
one is charter enroll uh charter amendment around enrollment policy and application. And this is just really a request that was um Desi asked us to update our enrollment and application and so that we're in alignment with

517
02:29:48.960 --> 02:30:06.319
their their guidelines. So now it aligns EMK practices with more recent detailed desi guidance. It incorporates our approved enrollment maximum and our expanded CTE. It also clarifies um and uh accepts new students into grades 9

518
02:30:06.319 --> 02:30:23.439
and 10. Reflects a shift from paper applications to online application. It establishes clear non-discrimination and privacy protection policies and simplifies application questions. It now establishes enrollment preferences for

519
02:30:23.439 --> 02:30:40.960
siblings o of VMK students and VPS students >> and we um also continue with a lottery process and we all um we have received preliminary approval granted already by the desi charter school office.

520
02:30:40.960 --> 02:30:58.240
Now we're going to move on to Boston D. >> Good evening. Um thank you for the opportunity to present. It's been a while since BDA has been here and there's a lot of new members. So, we welcome the opportunity to introduce our school to the school committee. Um, our first document is the mission statement.

521
02:30:58.240 --> 02:31:15.200
Um, the mission statement defines the school's role and purpose within the Boston public school landscape. Um, back in 2018, uh, we engaged our community to revise the statement as part of our strategic planning process. Uh these revisions

522
02:31:15.200 --> 02:31:31.280
were made through a collaborative process that included input from students, staff, and the board of trustees. Um perhaps the students were most um articulate about how they wanted this mission statement to be changed. Um the revisions um are intentionally

523
02:31:31.280 --> 02:31:46.640
removing deficitbased language and center and centers student voice and experience. Move on to next. And then, excuse me, the next document is our accountability plan. Um, similar

524
02:31:46.640 --> 02:32:03.600
to EMK, this was created in uh 2324. Um, and this one is uh significantly different than EMK's because we are an alternative school. Um, at in 2324, DESIE established new alternative ed

525
02:32:03.600 --> 02:32:19.600
school guidelines in partnership with alt ed leaders and researchers. unique to ALT ed, we were asked to group our students into engagement phases. And I think this is a pretty unique um feature of our accountability plan. Students

526
02:32:19.600 --> 02:32:36.960
were grouped based on uh historical data um and trends that we saw in our data, but they're grouped by connected, partially connected, and minimally connected. And we then set up goals um for students that fell into those three categories. Um our accountability plan

527
02:32:36.960 --> 02:32:53.280
includes goals for each of our key design principles. So we have academic growth and achievement and that is where the engagement levels are um specific goals excuse me for students in those um in those phases and then we have post-graduate readiness goals and social

528
02:32:53.280 --> 02:33:14.720
emotional development um goals. Um, this accountability plan now serves as our strategic plan. >> Thank you. Good evening. My name is Betina Toner. Uh, I'm a partner at the law firm of Citus and Blue Steam. K&B is proud to represent four of the five

529
02:33:14.720 --> 02:33:32.560
Horus man charter schools, EMK, BDEA, Austin Green Academy, and UP Academy Dorchester. I'm going to provide a brief background on EMK and BDEA's recent updates to their memoranda of understanding with BPS and BDEA's

530
02:33:32.560 --> 02:33:50.479
with the BTU. I will also briefly describe the basis for recent updates to the expulsion policies for EMK, BDEA, BGAA and UAD. First, a bit of background on the memoranda of understanding or MOUAS. As

531
02:33:50.479 --> 02:34:07.200
you saw on a previous slide, in accordance with the Massachusetts charter school statute, Horus man charter schools have an MOUA uh with BPS that defines services and facilities to be provided by the district to charter to Horus man charter schools and which

532
02:34:07.200 --> 02:34:22.399
states the funding of the charter school by the district and also certain Horus man charter schools as you heard also have what's called anub with the local collective bargaining units which describe any waiverss to applicable

533
02:34:22.399 --> 02:34:39.120
collective bargaining agreements. This slide provides at a high level um the key provisions that eachou has historically included. Um so it's a bit of a laundry list. I won't read it. It's in the materials. Um the items highlighted on the list are the ones

534
02:34:39.120 --> 02:34:57.280
that have most significantly um have been most significantly updated in the most um in the current versions that are before you. I will describe those updates in more detail on the next slide. >> So, first, as part of the recent

535
02:34:57.280 --> 02:35:13.280
renegotiations regarding EMK and BDEA's MOUA, um those schools have made a couple of notable updates from the last versions of those. First with respect to EMK and BDEASUAS,

536
02:35:13.280 --> 02:35:31.760
BPS and BPS and EMK and BDEA have made changes to their current to better distinguish between certain discretionary and non-discretionary services provided by BPS to each horseman charter school. Discretionary

537
02:35:31.760 --> 02:35:48.800
services are those services that are provided those services that the Horus man's charter school can elect to receive from BPS and pay BPS for the non-discretionary services are those services provided by BPS to the Horus

538
02:35:48.800 --> 02:36:05.760
man charter school at no extra cost to the to the school to the charter school and are generally services that are provided to other BPS schools. past practice was for certain um certain services such as the use of BPS's office

539
02:36:05.760 --> 02:36:22.800
of legal advisor um office for civil rights and certain special education and student discipline services to be provided to BDA and EMK by BPS as essentially non-discretionary services as they would be provided to to other

540
02:36:22.800 --> 02:36:38.000
BPS schools. the the new MOUA for EMK and BDEA shifts the designation of those services to to the discretionary bucket so to speak and adds provision for BPS funding for EMK

541
02:36:38.000 --> 02:36:55.040
and BDEA to pay for certain independent legal counsel for certain matters. This is a positive addition for uh for BDA and EMK and BPS in that it helps to avoid legal risk for BPS and the torist

542
02:36:55.040 --> 02:37:12.080
man charter schools when those schools um or those entities have different or conflicting interests. Um this was a request that was made by BPS legal and it makes a lot of sense. Um, for example, there can be situations um, for example, in a special education matter

543
02:37:12.080 --> 02:37:28.640
where a parent uh is maybe looking for an out of district placement. In that situation, the Horus man charter school and BPS may have conflicting interests and so it it doesn't wouldn't make sense for BPS legal to represent both BPS and the charter school. So, it's a great um

544
02:37:28.640 --> 02:37:44.800
it's a great change and to to the benefit of all parties. Um, so that was one major change. The other change is um the uh with respect to indemnification. Um the previous had a modest indemnification provision. A broader

545
02:37:44.800 --> 02:38:00.560
indemnification provision was added in favor of BPS to address certain um to address concern expressed by BPS legal that there was certain risk to BPS uh in providing uh discretionary and non-discretionary services to the

546
02:38:00.560 --> 02:38:16.720
horseman charter schools. So the the significant change with respect to indemnification is a broader indemnification in favor of BPS. Um it's not a mutual indemnification. It's in the Horusman charter schools indemnifying BPS. Uh so that was the

547
02:38:16.720 --> 02:38:34.000
other major change. Um very quickly with respect to theubou between EMK and BTU uh EM between BDEA and the BTU, the one significant update um was a change to the dispute resolution process. Um that

548
02:38:34.000 --> 02:38:49.439
change was made in response to a request from BTU membership um to allow members to access the arbitration process in the BTU CBA. Um so um that change was added to the the BDEAUB

549
02:38:49.439 --> 02:39:06.800
um to include that option. Um with respect to the theUB for EMK um the parties have been engaging in good faith negotiations with respect to thatub but were not able to finalize um finalize that agreement prior to this evening's meeting. Um, and then very quickly, if I

550
02:39:06.800 --> 02:39:23.680
may, I did just want to um mention the expulsion policy for um for EMK, BDEA, uh, UA, UAD, and um, Boston Green Academy. Um, by law, uh, long-term, as folks probably know, long-term expense

551
02:39:23.680 --> 02:39:41.200
expulsions, long-term suspensions and expulsions for certain serious violations of the student code of conduct permit an appeal to the superintendent. Um, as mentioned earlier, I think in another presentation, perhaps, EMKBD,

552
02:39:41.200 --> 02:39:55.760
uh, all of the charter schools, the horseman charter schools, uh, adopt the BPS code of conduct. Um, in the past, some of the larger Massachusetts public school districts had a practice of allowing the superintendent to delegate

553
02:39:55.760 --> 02:40:13.439
the hearing of suspension, long-term suspensions and expulsions um to a design. Um there was a lawsuit um that was decided by the Supreme Judicial Court in in 2020 um whereby the SJC said no the statute says that the

554
02:40:13.439 --> 02:40:30.000
superintendent actually needs to hear those appeals. So Desi has rec recently requested um that all of this the Horus man charter schools update their expulsion policies um to reflect that change in the law or that clarification in the law. Um so that's the change to

555
02:40:30.000 --> 02:40:51.920
to the expulsion policies. Thank you. Thank you. >> Not going to hear from green candidates. >> Is there anything else from PGA? >> No. >> Good. >> All right. >> Okay. Then I'll now open it up to

556
02:40:51.920 --> 02:41:07.040
questions, comments. >> Anyone? >> Just appreciation for the school teams. Um, particularly appreciate the specificity of your school improvement goals as aligned by your as aligned to

557
02:41:07.040 --> 02:41:22.640
your key mission. Um, with targets and growth goals that reflect both academic growth and holistic indicators of student perception, data, school culture. Um, I think these are some of the things that we've been talking about

558
02:41:22.640 --> 02:41:37.920
as a committee to have macro at the district level um, for multi-year growth. And so it's just helpful to see how you all are measuring uh growth and success at the school level. >> I will just say this has been a lot of

559
02:41:37.920 --> 02:41:53.520
work to align but I think to all the positive um these schools are our schools. Um you know they they are independent um and yet they are very much a vibrant part of the BPS. Our students see that our parents see that. So I think there's just great alignment

560
02:41:53.520 --> 02:42:09.760
in the document. Um, so I want to I want to thank all of our leaders for that and the attorneys, right, and Lorenzo for your work on this as well. >> Great. Yes. Great. Thank you all and we will vote on these items at the July 8th

561
02:42:09.760 --> 02:42:26.240
meeting. >> So, thank you. >> Thank you. >> Okay. Okay. Our next presentation tonight is an update from the Boston Special Education Parent Advisory Council Spac. Let's aim to keep this presentation to

562
02:42:26.240 --> 02:42:43.240
under 20 minutes. Now, I'd like to turn it over to the superintendent for introductory remarks and invite Edith Bazil and the parents who are presenting with her to come forward. >> Yep. Where are they?

563
02:43:01.359 --> 02:43:17.520
And Edith, was I right? Before 8:00, right? 7:48. See, >> so tonight, Boston Special Education Parent Advisory Council or Spedpac Chair Edith Brazil is with us tonight and will provide an update on Spedpac's work. Spedpack empowers our BPS parents and

564
02:43:17.520 --> 02:43:32.000
caregivers by providing support and education. Thank you to Chair Brazil and check. Thank you to the Spedpac executive board for their advocacy on behalf of our district students and their families. At this point, I will

565
02:43:32.000 --> 02:43:49.520
turn it over to Chair Pizz. Thank you so much, Superintendent. Good evening, Chair Robinson, Vice Chair Scarit, members of the school committee, district leadership, families, and community members. My name is Edith Vazil, chair of Spedpac.

566
02:43:49.520 --> 02:44:04.399
>> Hi, my name is Shenik Marino. I'm vice chair of Spedpac. >> I want to acknowledge first of all as we give our presentation the partnership with Chief K Seal in the office of specialized services team over the past

567
02:44:04.399 --> 02:44:19.840
year. And I really want to give a special shout out to those who work behind the scenes, particularly Melissa Melissa Mendoza Patterson and Oolene Griffin, who really are the muscle behind all of the work that we do and

568
02:44:19.840 --> 02:44:35.760
often do not get acknowledgment. So tonight, the concerns highlighted in tonight's presentation extend beyond any single um particular highlighted event that has happened over the years. The

569
02:44:35.760 --> 02:44:50.640
concerns extend beyond any single department and require leadership, vision, and accountability at the district level to develop and sustain the systems necessary for meaningful and lasting change. Tonight's presentation

570
02:44:50.640 --> 02:45:06.080
reflects what families have been telling us throughout the year and how those experiences align with the district's own data. These themes do not emerge from a single meeting or event. They emerge through family conversations,

571
02:45:06.080 --> 02:45:21.760
support requests, public testimony, community events, district engagement sessions, spedpack general meetings, and our own inclusion town hall, which I'm thankful that Chair Robinson attended,

572
02:45:21.760 --> 02:45:38.800
uh, which was held last month. What stood out was not what families were saying, but how many families were saying the same thing across schools, neighborhoods, language backgrounds, and lived experiences. The same concerns

573
02:45:38.800 --> 02:45:56.000
surfaced repeatedly. Those concern became SPEAC priorities because they emerged consistently across the district and often mirrored patterns reflected in the district's own data. At their core, these concerns are about equity, access,

574
02:45:56.000 --> 02:46:11.279
literacy, things we heard tonight, inclusion outcomes, accountability, and trust. For students facing the greatest barriers, families want to know that their children are receiving the services, supports, and opportunities

575
02:46:11.279 --> 02:46:27.040
they need to succeed. Family feedback is one of the district's most valuable sources of information and an opportunity for continuous improvement. Tonight's presentation candidly reflects what families have been telling us, what

576
02:46:27.040 --> 02:46:43.600
the district's own data is telling us and what both suggest about the work that remains ahead. A strong theme we heard throughout the year was the need for more responsive partnership between families in the district. Schools have children for six

577
02:46:43.600 --> 02:47:00.319
hours a day. Families have them for the other 18 hours plus weekends, summers, and across a lifetime. Parents understand their children's strengths, challenges, histories, cultures, languages, and lived experience in ways that no report or data dashboard can

578
02:47:00.319 --> 02:47:15.840
fully capture. Many families describe navigating the district's system of opening tickets to solve problems. Rather than being connected to someone empowered to resolve concerns, family off families often feel sent into a maze that delays solutions and allow concerns to

579
02:47:15.840 --> 02:47:32.560
escalate. At its core, this is an inequity issue. A responsive system should work for each family, not just those with time, resources, advocates, or attorneys needed to navigate complex systems. Families repeatedly told us that access

580
02:47:32.560 --> 02:47:47.840
to support should not depend on who knows how to escalate concerns. These concerns surface surface across autism programming, school closures, inclusion, transportation, placement, school assignments, ESY, and district

581
02:47:47.840 --> 02:48:04.000
planning. Families noted that system failures often fall the hardest on students with disabilities and racial and linguistic groups that already face the greatest barriers. Before making decisions, family want families want the district to ask who is impacted, who

582
02:48:04.000 --> 02:48:21.600
benefits, who bears the burden, who has been engaged, whose voices are missing. Families emphasize that trust is not built through engagement alone. Trust is built when families are authentic partners and see their voices reflected in decisions,

583
02:48:21.600 --> 02:48:36.399
implement implementation, and student outcomes. Yes. Yeah. >> Families consistently state they want students to learn alongside peers in environments where they feel welcomed, supported, challenged, safe, and

584
02:48:36.399 --> 02:48:52.479
experience a genuine sense of belonging. They want inclusion that provides access not only to classrooms, but also to services, interventions, and opportunities that set students up for success. Families want the district to ask and

585
02:48:52.479 --> 02:49:09.439
answer. What makes inclusion successful? What are some schools uh more successful at? Why why are some schools more successful than others? How is success measured? Why are Henderson and Mary Lion 9 through 12, the district's only

586
02:49:09.439 --> 02:49:26.319
high school inclusion pathways being closed rather than strengthened? Families express concern that in school closures like Henderson Upper represents the loss of institutional knowledge. More importantly, families ask, "How does the district learn from success

587
02:49:26.319 --> 02:49:43.439
instead of repeating cycles of dismantling, reinventing, and rebuilding?" Inclusion is not new to BPS. For decades, school leaders and educators across the district developed expertise in building successful inclusive models. Inclusion depends on

588
02:49:43.439 --> 02:50:00.240
strong leadership. But school leaders cannot build inclusive schools without district support, staffing, resources, and clear expectations. Inclusion is built, not assigned. It requires infrastructure. Teachers,

589
02:50:00.240 --> 02:50:16.560
staffing, coaching, mentoring, collaborative planning, professional learning. When those investments are reduced, inclusion weakens. When inclusion weakens, outcomes suffer. Families expressed concern that while

590
02:50:16.560 --> 02:50:32.560
staffing expertise and institutional knowledge are being reduced, district spending on contracted services in outofd district tuition continues to grow. The question families are asking is whether resources are being invested

591
02:50:32.560 --> 02:50:48.319
in building district capacity instead of increasing dependence on services provided elsewhere. The cost of underinvesting in inclusion is not savings. It is a lost opportunity to strengthen the district's ability to

592
02:50:48.319 --> 02:51:05.279
serve students successfully in the district while shifting costs to outsourcing litigation and out of district placements. Families consistently pointed out that BPS has decades of experience educating students with disabilities and asks, "What have

593
02:51:05.279 --> 02:51:20.000
we learned? What has worked? What should we be uh what should be replicated? What mistakes should not be repeated? The district already has successfully successful schools, experienced educators, family expertise, audits,

594
02:51:20.000 --> 02:51:36.560
evaluations, and years of data. Yet, long-standing challenges continue to persist despite decades of study, planning, and recommendations. For this past year, for the past year, BPS has conducted an independent autism audit.

595
02:51:36.560 --> 02:51:53.279
Families welcome the effort but asked a simple question. Why hasn't family experience and expertise in informed this work? And how will families be engaged before recommendations are finalized implemented, monitored, and measured? Families raise similar concerns

596
02:51:53.279 --> 02:52:08.960
regarding literacy. Families are less interested in newly named initiatives and more interested in results. They want effective curriculum, strong in uh in instruction and interventions to improve literacy outcomes. Families want students to

597
02:52:08.960 --> 02:52:23.040
become stronger readers, stronger writers, and successful learners. Families emphasize that instit institutional learning must lead to better curriculum, stronger instruction, effective interventions, accountability

598
02:52:23.040 --> 02:52:43.840
without change, and sustained progress. Families raise concerns regarding the experiences and outcomes of black students with disabilities. District data show that onethird of students receiving special education services remain in substantially

599
02:52:43.840 --> 02:53:00.880
separate placements. Although black students only comprise 29% of district enrollment, they are the only group disproportionately represented in substantially separate placements. But the disparities do not stop there. Black

600
02:53:00.880 --> 02:53:15.439
students are disproportionately represented across multiple indicators, including identification in categories such as emotional impairment and intellectual impairment. the highest rates of suspensions, physical

601
02:53:15.439 --> 02:53:31.680
restraint, and seclusion. For example, while black students comprise only 29% of the district enrollment, they account for 51% of all of the seclusion incidents. Given the rising mental health needs across Boston, families

602
02:53:31.680 --> 02:53:47.680
question why black students remain disproportionately concentrated in the district's most restrictive therapeutic settings, including substantially separate EI programs and the Malvin H. Kingmies. Families see these patterns not as

603
02:53:47.680 --> 02:54:03.680
isolated outcomes, but as evidence of unmet needs, missed opportunities for intervention and the district's failure to deliver the transformational changes long promised at the Mel Kingmies. Melvin H. King was a civil rights

604
02:54:03.680 --> 02:54:18.960
leader, community organizer, champion of educational equity, and fierce advocate against displacement, gentrification, exclusion, and systemic injustice. Imagine this. Three therapeutic school

605
02:54:18.960 --> 02:54:35.120
sites in the south end in Fenway serving primarily black boys. schools named after a man who spent his life fighting displacement, gentrification, and racial inequity. Buildings in chronic disrepair with

606
02:54:35.120 --> 02:54:52.399
rotting bars on the windows while new schools rise across the city. BPS quietly closed two of the Mel King schools located in Fenway's most valuable real estate without meaningful family and community engagement. BPS

607
02:54:52.399 --> 02:55:09.040
notified virtually all Mel King Academy black educators that they will be displaced. Sound familiar? This is not the vision of equity Mel King fought for. It is the very inequity he fought against and a reminder that displacement of black

608
02:55:09.040 --> 02:55:25.359
educators continues in BPS with the racial equity planning tool or without the racial equity planning tool or racial equity checkpoints. Families emphasized that equity must be examined through the intersection of

609
02:55:25.359 --> 02:55:43.359
race, disability, and language. Families consistently raised concerns about the supports for multilingual learners with disabilities and the need for ESL, SEI, and native language instruction and special education services working

610
02:55:43.359 --> 02:55:59.439
together rather than operating in separate systems. Families caution the district not to conflate inclusion with immersion. Inclusion means students receive appropriate ESL, SEI, native

611
02:55:59.439 --> 02:56:16.080
instruction, specialized instruction, and accommodations necessary to access learning. Placing multilingual learners with disabilities in settings without those supports is not inclusion. It is immersion. Families also express concern

612
02:56:16.080 --> 02:56:33.040
that language differences may sometimes be mistaken for disabilities and disabilities may sometimes be overlooked because of language differences. District data raised concerns about both underidentification and over

613
02:56:33.040 --> 02:56:49.040
identification of multilingual learners, underscoring the importance of culturally and linguistically responsive evaluations conducted by highly skilled bilingual and bicultural assessor and service providers. families raised

614
02:56:49.040 --> 02:57:04.800
concerns about the need for more bilingual educators, bilingual service providers, and staff who understand students cultural and linguistic backgrounds. Most importantly, families stressed that multilingual learners with disabilities should not have to choose

615
02:57:04.800 --> 02:57:20.240
between native language supports, English language acquisition supports, and disability supports. They are entitled to all three. One-third of students receiving special education services are multilingual learners.

616
02:57:20.240 --> 02:57:36.479
Families believe staffing, expertise, and resources should reflect that reality. Rather than reducing bilingual staff, families want BPS to strengthen its capacity to serve multilingual learners with disabilities and ensure schools have the staffing and expertise

617
02:57:36.479 --> 02:57:53.439
necessary for students to thrive. Equity ensuring that l is never a barrier to identif literacy, opportunity, student outcomes, or long-term success. Families repeatedly raise concerns

618
02:57:53.439 --> 02:58:10.880
regarding appropriate autism service. Literacy intervention, specialized instruction, transition planning, access to culturally responsive evaluations emerged as reoccurring themes throughout the year. Families emphasize that access should not depend upon extraordinary

619
02:58:10.880 --> 02:58:26.960
advocacy. Students should not have to wait extended periods for evaluation services, interventions, or appropriate placements. Literacy emerged as one of the most urgent concerns. Families repeatedly emphasize that strong literacy

620
02:58:26.960 --> 02:58:43.520
instruction is fun foundational to all student success and express concern that current approaches are not producing the outcome students deserve, particularly for students with disabilities and students educated in substantially separate settings. Families also question how

621
02:58:43.520 --> 02:59:00.160
recommendations emerging from the autism audit will be implemented, monitored, and communicated with families. Families repeatedly emphasize that access on loan is not the goal. The goal is improved outcomes. Families want to know whether students are learning, progressing, becoming more independent, developing

622
02:59:00.160 --> 02:59:16.000
literacy, achieving their goals, and preparing for successful futures. This happens when dollars are allotted to improve practice through consistent professional learning and investments in supporting schools principles and teachers with adequate staffing resources, technology, professional

623
02:59:16.000 --> 02:59:33.439
development, coaching, and mentoring. This means building a strong workforce in the district, not outsourcing services, and using funding on costly litigation and outside placements because BPS programs cannot serve the need of the majority of students within the district.

624
02:59:33.439 --> 02:59:49.640
Families want solutions when students are not making progress and greater transparency about the decisions are how decisions are made when students when supports are not working that lead to stronger and more successful in district programs.

625
02:59:49.760 --> 03:00:06.800
families consistent consistently connected student outcomes to people. Whether discussing inclusion, literacy, autism services, multilingual learner supports, transportation, or program quality, conversations repeatedly return to the same themes: teacher development,

626
03:00:06.800 --> 03:00:22.319
coaching, mentoring, collaborative planning, staff retention, and specialized expertise. Families describe staffing shortages and turnover not as operational challenges but as student outcome issues. When schools lose a

627
03:00:22.319 --> 03:00:37.200
dynamic multicultural workforce of experienced educators with specialized expertise, students lose con sorry continuity, support and um opportunities to succeed. Families also emphasized the

628
03:00:37.200 --> 03:00:54.479
importance of educator diversity and expressed a strong desire to recruit, retain, and support more black educators, bilingual educators, and service providers who reflect the racial, cultural, and linguistic diversity of BPS students. Research consistently demonstrates that

629
03:00:54.479 --> 03:01:09.439
students benefit when they see themselves reflected in the educator workforce and when educators understand the communities they serve. The communities they served. Families repeatedly pointed out that successful schools are built through intentional sustained investment in educators,

630
03:01:09.439 --> 03:01:26.160
strong staffing pipelines, professional learning, coaching, mentoring, and collaborative planning. Families are concerned about investment in stable teaching force necessary to sustain and expand successful practices across the district versus funds for use for outsourcing.

631
03:01:26.160 --> 03:01:43.439
Families repeatedly emphasize that when budgets are tight, the last cut should be made to the people closest to the students because staffing decisions are ultimately student support decisions, student opportunity decisions, and student outcome decisions. Perhaps the strongest emotional theme

632
03:01:43.439 --> 03:01:59.279
that emerged throughout the year was urgency. Families understand that systems change takes time, but the pace of change must align with the pace of childhood development because students experience educational opportunities in

633
03:01:59.279 --> 03:02:15.920
real time in critical developmental periods only once. Families conveyed that delayed services, delayed interventions, delayed staffing decisions, delayed transportation solutions, delayed implementation,

634
03:02:15.920 --> 03:02:31.520
delayed accountability, and delayed action can have lifelong consequences. The concern is that BPS often focuses on process when opportunities for action already exist. One family member

635
03:02:31.520 --> 03:02:47.439
captured this concern by noting that systems may operate on strategic plans, but childhood operates on developmental timelines. Students cannot be put on hold while systems try to catch up. Students experience each stage of

636
03:02:47.439 --> 03:03:04.240
development only once. That is why urgency emerged as such a powerful theme throughout the year. Families emphasize that urgency must also be reflected in budget decisions, staffing, and school level supports. Inclusion cannot succeed

637
03:03:04.240 --> 03:03:21.359
without fully staffed schools, strong classroom supports, clear expectations, and consistent implementation. Families urged the district to build on what it already knows works. strengthen successful practices without with

638
03:03:21.359 --> 03:03:38.080
intention and evidence. Invest in district capacity and reduce reliance on outsourcing and outofd district placements by ensuring every school has the infrastructure necessary to support students successfully.

639
03:03:38.080 --> 03:03:53.520
Our last slide is our six recommendations. I'm sorry we over time >> that we have which we think is the most powerful and important part of our presentation because this is not just about assessing what the concerns are

640
03:03:53.520 --> 03:04:08.720
but it's making recommendations in terms of you know what where do we go from here what is what are the possibilities and opportunities. So these six recommendations reflect what families have consistently communicated throughout the year. Families are asking

641
03:04:08.720 --> 03:04:25.840
not simply for engagement, but rather meaningful partnership as co-creators in decisionmaking. They also want transparency, accountability in a district that responds to concerns before they escalate. Two, families are calling for meaningful engagement in

642
03:04:25.840 --> 03:04:41.840
autism programming and implementation, stronger literacy, multilingual learner supports, and intentional efforts to address long-standing disparities and disproportionalities affecting Can I turn this off? Uh, black

643
03:04:41.840 --> 03:04:58.720
students. Three, families want a clear definition of inclusion, stronger implementation of inclusive practices and equity measured not only by access but by outcomes. Four, families want an infrastructure of successful inclusion models that are preserved, strengthened,

644
03:04:58.720 --> 03:05:15.520
and scale. Five families are asking for sustained investment in educator development, coaching, mentoring, staffing, and educated diversity, including targeted efforts to recruit, retain, and support black educators, bilingual educators, literacy specialists, and staff with ex expertise

645
03:05:15.520 --> 03:05:33.200
across all disability categories. Six. Families want school closures, program design, and system transformation efforts to meaningfully consider educational impact, disability impact, and racial equity impact, and

646
03:05:33.200 --> 03:05:50.680
community impact. At the core, these recommendations are about equity, opportunity, accountability, and outcomes for students with disabilities. >> In closing, we want you to hear from a student of Spec Pack. This is Elijah. Elijah.

647
03:05:51.040 --> 03:06:10.080
>> Thank you. >> Good evening. My name is Elijah and I'm a student at Melvin H. King Health and Academy. I have dreams and goals for my future. I passed the MCCAST, but I was held back twice during my senior year. I want to go to college, continue my education, and build a successful life.

648
03:06:10.080 --> 03:06:26.640
But like many students, I face challenges. I am here because students need more than a place to sit and complete worksheets. We need meaningful instruction, meaningful support, and adults who listen when we tell them what we need to be successful. I have spent times in classes where I was the only student in the room. I often felt

649
03:06:26.640 --> 03:06:41.840
disconnected from what was happening in class, and I do not feel the work is preparing me for college or my future. I have told my school team that I do not feel ready to leave school. I want support that helps me succeed, not just graduate. I don't want to leave school with a diploma and still feel unprepared

650
03:06:41.840 --> 03:06:59.920
for my future. Thank you for listening. >> Thank you. Thank you very much. >> Thank you all so much. Thank you. >> Thank you very much for the presentation all of you. Very very helpful. I want to open it up to members for questions and

651
03:06:59.920 --> 03:07:20.560
comments. Um first uh just very grateful for the presentation um and to hear um directly the feedback um from families and I actually I'm kind of curious uh on a couple of things um one if you've heard

652
03:07:20.560 --> 03:07:37.520
directly from families or either um BPS staff that have attended about what their particular experience has been with um service mapping and sort of that shift that the district is putting in place. Is it working? Like what are some of the complexities that maybe they've

653
03:07:37.520 --> 03:07:53.040
faced with that? >> You want to take that question or I can. >> Mhm. >> I can. Um so for parents that are dual language the the main concern is getting information in their language in their

654
03:07:53.040 --> 03:08:08.960
preferred language whether they're using the app that allows them to talk directly with the teacher and not getting feedback from the teacher just understanding the curriculum that their child is in and knowing how to get services through the IEP. not understanding the IEP and just getting a

655
03:08:08.960 --> 03:08:24.160
packet that says this is the parents information isn't enough if I don't speak English and the packet sometimes does not come in a different language. So if your child has an IEP and this is your first experience with an IEP and they're not getting their due diligence done on their behalf of their child to

656
03:08:24.160 --> 03:08:39.760
understand what they're even signing. Some parents are just signing and not understanding that they're not getting their child's needs met. Not because they don't want them to, but because it wasn't explained to them. And when the services are offered, they often aren't people in place that have the correct

657
03:08:39.760 --> 03:08:56.399
need or like we have TAs helping with ABA students. ABA students should have ABA staff and it's there's no ABA staff available. So that's a concern right now. >> And and I think um just to add to that um you're really asking about accountability and outcomes. So service

658
03:08:56.399 --> 03:09:13.600
mapping really has to do with um you know what what families told us is that they want the district to measure success through outcomes rather than access alone. So >> the key question is not whether students receive services and that's part of

659
03:09:13.600 --> 03:09:29.760
service mapping. How many hours did a student receive speech because that's in the IEP >> and is the speech actually helping them >> right? But the key question is whether the services improved outcomes. And that was the key thing that parents focused on. Families want outcomes measured tied

660
03:09:29.760 --> 03:09:46.160
to literacy, inclusion, belonging, graduation, post-secondary readiness, independence, and long-term success. So, you heard from one of our students who's also a Spedpack member. Uh what we see service mapping as the floor of of

661
03:09:46.160 --> 03:10:01.279
compliance. What we are talking about is the ceiling of best practices. So how do we maximize those best practices to ensure that when the student receives for example that 30 minute block of

662
03:10:01.279 --> 03:10:19.120
whatever instruction that it results in outcomes and and that's really the shift in saying that we want best practices and scale those practices that we know result in outcomes.

663
03:10:19.120 --> 03:10:35.840
>> No, I agree with you. I think that's why I'm particularly asking about it because I agree outputs are the is the currency that we're really talking about and to get there we also need to understand are the right inputs in place right and so

664
03:10:35.840 --> 03:10:52.080
and actually in and what you said was also very interesting to me just to hear in it a teacher or a teacher not giving feedback >> sometimes the teacher isn't equipped to give feedback because they don't know the the child's history but that that's the disconnect the conversations aren't being had.

665
03:10:52.080 --> 03:11:07.600
There's a lot of students that come to me and they're getting certificates of completion and they want to continue their education. They shouldn't be going through a process where they weren't taught to read in third, fourth, fifth, sixth, but so by the time they're in ninth and tth grade, their reading level

666
03:11:07.600 --> 03:11:22.399
isn't at the level where they can take the MCCAST. I know that's since changed, but at one point it was you needed to pass the MCCAST. And a lot of kids got certificates of completion and now they're only able to get jobs and that's not all they want. And then you have a child here saying the same thing. I'm

667
03:11:22.399 --> 03:11:42.160
I'm I'm choosing to stay back so I can be more educated when that should have happened during the 12 years they were in school. >> I I have Yeah. >> Okay. >> So um I thank you for the presentation. Um,

668
03:11:42.160 --> 03:12:00.319
I was wondering about um how families are notified. I know we you talked about IEPs and uh how are families notified in a when a child is coming up for an IEP at the school? Have they spoken to

669
03:12:00.319 --> 03:12:17.439
you guys about that? Are they notified on time so they'll be present? So you're really talking about is the district committing to timelines for evaluations for IEP team meetings. I know that with early intervention there's a lot of diligent work to make sure that students

670
03:12:17.439 --> 03:12:33.279
are captured by the time they are they're turning three years old because that's when they transition into BPS and they get their services. And on Monday we met with OSS and we we met the person that is doing that work. um BPS in the

671
03:12:33.279 --> 03:12:49.920
past has struggled with that. I think there has been progress in that area. So we always like to highlight the the good things that are happening as well as the challenges. Um in terms of assessment completion, uh yes. So there are some

672
03:12:49.920 --> 03:13:06.720
families that have talked about there are you know assessments may not be completed on time and part of it is what when we talked about the itinerant services so there's a lot of outsourcing of related service providers like speech

673
03:13:06.720 --> 03:13:23.600
OT ABA um what we are saying that as the district moves towards inclusion developing pathways and being creative about that so that you have in district staff planning. Inclusion requires

674
03:13:23.600 --> 03:13:40.720
planning and it requires planning of all team members and if someone is contracted they come and provide a service and they leave and so they're not available to see how the student function say in an afterchool program or a before school meeting because

675
03:13:40.720 --> 03:13:56.000
contracted services are blocks of time that are dedicated to payment and it's a contractual arrangement. What we are saying at BPS is building and scaling inclusion. There has to be investment in

676
03:13:56.000 --> 03:14:12.960
teachers in the district who can co-plan, who can problem solve, who see students across multiple settings throughout the day and really get to know the student because that's what builds belongingness and and

677
03:14:12.960 --> 03:14:30.479
understanding the whole child. I would just add to that that one parent I met with had a child that needed ABA. The school didn't have that available. They got an email saying when they did have someone that met those requirements, they would put that in place. Luckily, her child's teacher has

678
03:14:30.479 --> 03:14:45.920
an autistic child. So, because of that, you know, the wraparound was there because of that teacher. But if that teacher didn't have that support from being a parent, that child would have fell between the cracks. And reading is a struggle for the regular child, whatever regular may be. So if a child

679
03:14:45.920 --> 03:15:01.840
has disabilities and they're not able to read at grade level and they continue to be moved to the next grade, they max out when they get to 12th grade, not even having a third or fourth grade reading level. And that's a concern for parents because the reality is the average kid

680
03:15:01.840 --> 03:15:19.279
in Boston right now can't read on grade level. And that's that's a fact. And I'm a parent of deaf adult kids now. Luckily, they had good teachers. I mean, teachers are great in Boston, but if they don't have the services, this is where we're at. And it's a it's a continuous pattern of reading inclusion.

681
03:15:19.279 --> 03:15:34.880
So, like Edith said, having to having someone that I can go to that I remember that I can connect with. Kids need that connection because if it's a new person every time, they're not going to want to adapt to a new person. So, then they they lose that continuous support >> and they fall through because they

682
03:15:34.880 --> 03:15:50.720
either don't come to school with it. With high school kids, they won't show up anymore. Like I've taught at some of these schools, they won't show up and their response is because no one cares. So when a child tells you no one cares and you know the teachers care, it's the programming that's not consistent. If the program is not consistent, what am I

683
03:15:50.720 --> 03:16:07.840
coming for? I'm not going to get what I want in the end. And there's a child here again saying, "I'm I want to be kept back because I want to learn before I go to college. I don't want to get to college and struggle." That's what we don't want to continue to happen because they have a disability. I have another question. Um, you talked

684
03:16:07.840 --> 03:16:23.680
about engagement. So, I was wondering if you guys have a protocol in place to engage the families. How >> Yes. So, I'm really happy that you asked that question because it's really critical. So, we're talking about, you

685
03:16:23.680 --> 03:16:39.439
know, how do we have a, you know, stronger um sense of governance around parent engagement? Parents come with expertise, not just they know their students best. So

686
03:16:39.439 --> 03:16:55.520
feedback is important, but the expertise that families have can be crit critical to developing better programming because parents know what works and what does not work. And so we want the district to

687
03:16:55.520 --> 03:17:11.680
move beyond engagement and really build the district capacity with families by investing in families really working collaboratively with the district. Not after decisions are made but prior to decisions being

688
03:17:11.680 --> 03:17:27.760
made. Developing the planning for implementation. monitoring the success of programs and then really getting the the family's perspective on how it's working because

689
03:17:27.760 --> 03:17:43.200
oftent times especially with students with disabilities uh students with autism they hold things in all day long because they want to feel a sense of belonging and then when they get home that's when they let loose and they tell

690
03:17:43.200 --> 03:18:00.560
family they tell their parents well you know they may be um self-injuring, but it could be that's that's data around my school day has not worked for me or they may be excessively tired, exhausted because they're masking the fact that

691
03:18:00.560 --> 03:18:17.359
their instruction is not working for them. The family piece is critical and we have availed ourselves. Like for example with the autism audit, it's been going on for a whole year and every family member that we talked to that have children

692
03:18:17.359 --> 03:18:32.160
with autism, they have not been contacted. They have not been surveyed. How can the district create a program without collaborating with families to get their feedback on what is and is not working? because you want to you want to

693
03:18:32.160 --> 03:18:48.720
continue those parts that are successful and build capacity where there are challenges. >> So I agree with Edith said if children are being challenged in the ways they need to be there is there isn't going to be any growth. A lot of these children are getting just a

694
03:18:48.720 --> 03:19:04.319
packet of paper. This is your homework. You go home. There's no followth through. There's no conversation with the parents. There's no There used to be reading logs. Reading logs are gone. So kids are not even having the back and forth that we did have at one point with teachers.

695
03:19:04.319 --> 03:19:20.800
When parents come to us and say, "My concern is that my child doesn't speak." Most of the time it's not that they have speech delays. They don't know how to read. they don't know how to to express how they're feeling based on not having language because they don't know how to read, that's all-encompassing. So, if

696
03:19:20.800 --> 03:19:36.640
they don't have those supports and you're not engaging them in the way that they learn, it's a disservice to them. It's a continuous disservice because they're going to go through and they're going to go through the motions, but they're never retaining anything they learn. So, having an extended school year is great, but if they don't meet those requirements, then that's another

697
03:19:36.640 --> 03:19:52.560
loop they fall through and it continues and it continues. So, it's a cycle. So what we're saying basically is family engagement should move beyond consultation and become a governance strategy and >> parents know best. >> Yes. And and and families are asking to

698
03:19:52.560 --> 03:20:09.760
be engaged before decisions are made not after decisions are finalized. Um the recommendation that we'd like to make is to establish clear expectations for family engagement during planning, implementation, monitoring, and evaluation of major initiatives that

699
03:20:09.760 --> 03:20:32.080
impact students with disabilities so that family voice is treated as a source of expertise and accountability for the district, not just simply feedback. >> Thank you. Thank you for your presentation. Well, uh couple of uh

700
03:20:32.080 --> 03:20:48.720
uh presumptions will predicate my questions. The first presumption is that this document right here and your and your presentation relies on parents with

701
03:20:48.720 --> 03:21:06.399
children with disability. Right. So most of the the the uh the information you provided here are from parents with uh children with disability. Okay. Um the second uh presumption is that from your

702
03:21:06.399 --> 03:21:23.200
from your remark from your presentation I presume that you are in favor of inclusion done right. Isn't that right? >> Yes. inclusion is focused on student

703
03:21:23.200 --> 03:21:36.640
outcomes. >> Okay. Okay. Now, just back to this. So, I'm some some Okay. I'm I'm a parent with children with disability and part of my legal work is dealing with

704
03:21:36.640 --> 03:21:55.359
disability issues for the last 35 years. So when you put here the black students represent 29% of enrollment. I would presume that those 29% of black students are students with

705
03:21:55.359 --> 03:22:12.399
disability. >> Yes. Oh no no no 29% in the total district. >> I see. >> So what we're doing is we are comparing the um number of students in the district. >> Okay. compared to when we look at how many students for example are secluded,

706
03:22:12.399 --> 03:22:30.560
how many students are suspended. Okay, how many students are in substantially separate programs. So that's a that is >> that leads to my question right there. >> But disability indicator right there, but not all of them. the 29 everybody um if 43% of students in substantially

707
03:22:30.560 --> 03:22:46.319
separate separate classrooms are students with disability or or are black students with disability. Is that is that correct? >> So I don't know the exact number of black students who are in substantially

708
03:22:46.319 --> 03:23:02.880
separate programs off the top of my head. Okay. But I know that there are more black students in subsparate programs than any other demographic group. >> Talking about all students, all black students, not not just students with

709
03:23:02.880 --> 03:23:18.319
disability. So if you look at this >> the data that you provided here indicated that 29% represent black students represent 79% of enrollment meaning

710
03:23:18.319 --> 03:23:34.720
the entire student body right but 43% of students again I would presume that's black students are placed in substantially separate classrooms. So, for example, I

711
03:23:34.720 --> 03:23:50.800
I I get where you're going that um so >> black black I think black students represent 29% of the total enrollment of the district, they represent 43% >> of the total enrollment of substantially separate classrooms.

712
03:23:50.800 --> 03:24:06.720
>> So, in other words, you would want if if black students were 29% of the total population be commensurate, you would say, well, they're 29% of the students in special ed. We look at that would be another suspension data. We look at lots of different kinds of data through this

713
03:24:06.720 --> 03:24:23.439
lens where we look at the overall population of BPS and then we look at the different demographic groups. We look at gender. We look at um socioeconomic to see if there's disproportionate numbers. We also have

714
03:24:23.439 --> 03:24:41.439
we are also disproportionate in the number of students who have IEPs and who are then served in substantially separate settings. >> Right. >> And to Edah's point of that group, our black students are I think it's almost

715
03:24:41.439 --> 03:24:58.239
like 175% greater chance uh based on that data. >> So uh okay, that clarifies a couple of things. The the issue now boils down to the substantially separate classrooms.

716
03:24:58.239 --> 03:25:14.319
>> Are those classroom reserved for students with disability or what? >> Can you say that I separate classes? Are those classes just for students with disability? >> The the three separate classrooms means that a student is segregated from the

717
03:25:14.319 --> 03:25:30.239
general population >> 75% or more of the day. >> Uhhuh. So in other words, they are not with their general education peers >> because of their disability or because of what? >> Well, you know, that's sort of getting

718
03:25:30.239 --> 03:25:46.399
into the weeds of why. And so when we talk about disproportionality and we think about, for example, Mel King Academy, I think, has maybe 40% black students or higher than that. Even though black students are 29% of the

719
03:25:46.399 --> 03:26:03.279
population, the majority of them are also black males. So you have to think about why are there so many black males in this particular category just like you want to think about when it comes to multilingual learners you have under and

720
03:26:03.279 --> 03:26:20.000
over representation in communication impairment. So that's a category of disability. So that's connected to language difference. So, are we determining disability based on language difference or is there a disability related to language? So, that's

721
03:26:20.000 --> 03:26:36.880
something that the district needs to address in terms of disproportionality. So, it could be two-sided. It could be under representation. I'm not catching the disability because I don't know how to navigate where you are with your language. So, I'm not going to identify

722
03:26:36.880 --> 03:26:53.920
you even though you may be dyslexic and you speak a different language because I'm not assessing you in your native language. Or it could be, well, gee, I'm looking at you don't you you are say a um an ELD 2 or three and I am

723
03:26:53.920 --> 03:27:11.040
misclassifying you. So, it's two-sided when it comes to multilingual learners. When it comes to black students, it's over representation in substantially separate classroom suspension, seclusion, and in disability categories

724
03:27:11.040 --> 03:27:27.359
like emotional impairment and intellectual impairment. And so that's work that the district has to do around doing a better job with assessment. It also has to do with ensuring that your assesses are bilingual, bicultural, but

725
03:27:27.359 --> 03:27:44.160
also are representative of understanding how to do assessments on students who don't look like them >> and are not using tools that are not culturally responsive. >> Right?

726
03:27:44.160 --> 03:28:01.120
And the other thing I want to say is more expensive to educate a student in substantially separate placements. So if they're mclassified, not only are you paying more money, but you're not getting the results. And so if you look at data on student outcomes, the student

727
03:28:01.120 --> 03:28:15.920
outcomes are poor. When you mclassify students, so you look at the Mel King data, the the outcomes are poor. I >> I hear you and I see where you're coming from and I understand all that. Uh the issue I have here is that you know

728
03:28:15.920 --> 03:28:34.160
the the the data that are before us 29% of black students in enrollment 43% of them are in substantially separate classroom. >> No >> no that's not the data point. >> No >> it's it's it's that >> right here. It's that of the students in

729
03:28:34.160 --> 03:28:49.840
substantially se separate programs of those specific students who are served in substantially separate programs 43% of those students are black. >> So 43% of the students are are disabled. 40%

730
03:28:49.840 --> 03:29:06.080
>> 100% of students in substantially separate programs have disabilities, but 43% of the students in those classrooms are black when only 29% of stu of students in the district are black. So if it were a proportional representation, they would be the same,

731
03:29:06.080 --> 03:29:20.960
>> right? >> But those two percentages, I can see why it's the two percentages in this sentence represent two different proportions of students. One is students at large that share the same racial group, the first one. And the other is

732
03:29:20.960 --> 03:29:36.720
measuring the percent of students in a specific program type. So it's not 43% of the 29%. >> I see. >> Yeah. >> So, okay. >> Okay. >> All right. I I'll I'll

733
03:29:36.720 --> 03:29:52.640
>> stop my questions. >> I >> It's complicated >> because I was trying to understand >> Yeah. whether that helps with the inclusion or that doesn't help with the inclusion uh that you're trying to

734
03:29:52.640 --> 03:30:07.840
identify the issue. >> It raises the concerns. Well, when it if I could say when it comes to inclusion, you know, our position is that we don't want to simply expand inclusion, right? Like the recommendation is to build an infrastructure

735
03:30:07.840 --> 03:30:24.080
>> for inclusion. And so the district, what we're recommending is that the district should first identify successful inclusion models. >> What is the definition or the metrics for an inclusion model as successful?

736
03:30:24.080 --> 03:30:40.800
And then establish non-negotiables for every school that must be in place. So what are the elements that should be in place in every school that is an inclusion school? And then the other piece is um including uh staffing,

737
03:30:40.800 --> 03:30:56.399
collaborative planning, coaching, professional development cannot be understated and implementation supports um for that. So families are asking the district not to re to stop reinventing

738
03:30:56.399 --> 03:31:14.399
inclusion to look at the models that exist in the district that are working and replicate that success by looking at what are they doing that needs to be replicated across every school in the district. Not just saying a school is an

739
03:31:14.399 --> 03:31:31.680
inclusion school. I mean, I was going to say when the kids thrive, the district thrives. The numbers will speak, but when parents get involved, um I I actually said that at the Hannes EC, I asked Miss Wood, I'm like, "Can you tell the other schools how to do this?" But it only goes to sec uh to first grade.

740
03:31:31.680 --> 03:31:47.680
So, I was kind of sad when my son had to leave, but um I agree like when there's consistency across the board and parents are involved, even if they don't speak English, if they can come in and show you how this works for their kid and then the other parents do it, it's more so like parents getting to know other

741
03:31:47.680 --> 03:32:04.479
parents and then parents talking with the district. But when the parents don't even know how to navigate that, it's like a domino effect. It just keeps falling. But we have great teachers. We have the supports. It's just everyone coming to a meeting of the minds and having a conversation that helps the

742
03:32:04.479 --> 03:32:19.600
kids move forward. >> And there are models that that that are successful. So I can go back to we we had on one of the slides in 1989 the Henderson the Patrick O'Harn is what it was called then um became an inclusion model. It's very unique but we also got

743
03:32:19.600 --> 03:32:36.160
the Mason and the Elliott. in many schools the Roosevelt and and so what what happened then and this is institutional knowledge and that's why we're saying don't reinvent the wheel think about what worked in the past where a school that was successful was

744
03:32:36.160 --> 03:32:51.680
matched with a school that was on their way so you don't want to take for example the Elliot is kind of a unicorn you can't really replicate that because of the variables but you could take a school that is a strong inclusion model and pair it with a school that could

745
03:32:51.680 --> 03:33:08.000
benefit from reaching up to that level. Um, you know, it's sort of like you don't want um to pair a student who is an advanced learner with someone who is struggling with a concept. You want you want a school you want to pair schools that are on the way with a school that

746
03:33:08.000 --> 03:33:23.680
can see themselves achieving that level >> in orchard gardens. That would be a great feeling. >> Yeah. A lot of different languages are spoken at both schools and the kids can transition to eighth grade. I've been looking at I've been doing the I I've I'm from Boston so I look at um

747
03:33:23.680 --> 03:33:40.160
different demographics at the schools and I'm also I speak three languages so when parents talk to me the main thing is I don't want my kid to only have one school as an option but I don't want to lose the supports I have at this school. So when they're getting ready to transition it's like well this school doesn't go to eighth grade so where do I

748
03:33:40.160 --> 03:33:55.439
go but I also don't want to put my kids somewhere where they're not happy and then I have to wait to like that's always the cycle when summer comes. So parents are just selecting one school real not realizing your kids are going to go somewhere random. So this is this is the thing every school year like

749
03:33:55.439 --> 03:34:11.840
right now that's the crunch time. And I mean the other thing is you have collaborative co-planning with teachers. Why not have collaborative co-planning with schools school to school? So you may have teachers from one school that is struggling with a practice to visit

750
03:34:11.840 --> 03:34:27.359
you know another school to observe what they're doing. like how can you pair schools up a school that is doing a little better not you know far ahead but is is achievable for another school. How do you pair within the district a

751
03:34:27.359 --> 03:34:42.720
struggling school with a school that is on its way so that they learn from each other? Because you have models. We often think about, you know, how do we address failure, but how do you replicate success is a different way to look at it

752
03:34:42.720 --> 03:34:59.880
in terms of what is one thing that a particular school can do that's going to make the biggest difference and really scale that. You can't do everything, but really thinking about incremental continuous improvement.

753
03:35:00.080 --> 03:35:20.080
You said it well. following up on we cannot do everything. Uh thank you so much for the work that you are doing uh to the three of you and the entire um uh uh group of the spec pack. Um thank you for putting together

754
03:35:20.080 --> 03:35:35.600
the six recommendations. My question is again is there's a lot of work in front of us but I would like to know you you use the word urgency several times and I want to know about the

755
03:35:35.600 --> 03:35:52.880
urgency of the urgency. Let's think about next school year that is about to start in a couple months. My kids don't want me to say that but that's the reality. In a couple months we're starting a new school year. what we to the members of this committee

756
03:35:52.880 --> 03:36:11.600
as a government committee what is it that we should be paying the most attention to in fis in the school year 25 26 or 26 27 >> so I would say what families are asking for with regard to urgency is execution

757
03:36:11.600 --> 03:36:27.600
prioritization like what is the biggest challenge what how can you prioritize adverise a goal to for example close literacy gaps and and that goes into staffing. What are the staffing gaps? Because if you don't

758
03:36:27.600 --> 03:36:42.800
have the people and you don't they don't have the expertise and the specialization, you can't do the work. So that really goes into professional learning. Um and then resource allocation. How are schools being supported?

759
03:36:42.800 --> 03:36:59.279
Shemica said, "We have fantastic teachers and school leaders, but they need support and and this has to come from the district level." Um, and so, um, the it's really thinking about the district t identifying actions that can

760
03:36:59.279 --> 03:37:15.520
be taken immediately. what can you do right now and having that prioritization um and and and and and taking action within a year like what is my goal for the next year? How can it be prioritized

761
03:37:15.520 --> 03:37:30.160
for this school to grow for that year and then taking actions um that require longer planning? So really thinking in the short term, what are the immediate steps that can be taken and how do they

762
03:37:30.160 --> 03:37:48.000
roll into the longer range planning and and when we talk about urgency, it has to be reflected not only in plans but in decisions in budgets. Budgets are important because we know right now there's an increase in outsourcing and

763
03:37:48.000 --> 03:38:04.160
out of district in litigation. How can we recoup those funds to build the kind of programs that we're losing students with disabilities to? What are those out of district schools doing that BPS can

764
03:38:04.160 --> 03:38:20.080
replicate? >> And do you need to partner with one of those schools to build those programs in the district so students aren't getting up 5:00 in the morning? You're not only paying for expensive tuition, but you're also paying for transportation, which

765
03:38:20.080 --> 03:38:37.680
often can be more than than curriculum with more than tuition costs. And then students are getting home late, exhausted, cannot be part of the community placements. That's the biggest budget killer is the out of district placements. If they can get the services

766
03:38:37.680 --> 03:38:53.840
in the district, that would be preferred for parents. And I mean, I think for the district. >> Yeah. Parents do not want their children leaving 5:00 in the morning, going on a van, um out of their community, and then coming home late at night. Um they can't

767
03:38:53.840 --> 03:39:09.520
take advantage of after school programs and do other things. >> Have community. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. I mean, the main thing is having community. It's great to have an option to go out of district, but the the choice would be to stay where your family and your friends are, people you know at school. >> And so we're what we're saying is the

768
03:39:09.520 --> 03:39:25.200
district doesn't need to start over. The district needs to look at what is already working. >> And you know, often you think, well, we have re reinventing and rebuilding and dismantling. That is that that's the problem that

769
03:39:25.200 --> 03:39:41.520
parents talk about and and they they really focus on schools that have closed on the backs of students with disabilities that were working and now they have to start over. and and so how can you preserve and strengthen programs instead of closing

770
03:39:41.520 --> 03:39:57.040
them? >> Thank you so much. I'm gonna stick with closure closing the the literacy gap and investment on and in district services. I think that's something that will come up like at the the next agenda item. We

771
03:39:57.040 --> 03:40:12.479
talk a lot about in the evaluation of the superintendent and the district about we need data from K to2 on literacy. how how are the students doing for third grade on up is is too maybe too late. We need to see how they are

772
03:40:12.479 --> 03:40:28.560
doing in this in this first year. So, thank you so much. >> Do you want me to speak about literacy? So, families repeatedly identify literacy as one of the most urgent issues facing students with disabilities because reading is the foundation of learning. Students who cannot read

773
03:40:28.560 --> 03:40:43.200
proficiently struggle to access curriculum, demonstrate knowledge, build independence, achieve positive long-term outcomes. The concern is not simply lit literacy intervention. It is literacy outcomes. MCCAST. I don't know how to

774
03:40:43.200 --> 03:40:59.279
pronounce I have a list. I'm sorry name. >> I'm sorry. I have a list. So, um, data have shown persistent literacy challenges for years, particularly for students with disabilities. multilingual learners. I've experienced this with my kids because we're multilingual learners

775
03:40:59.279 --> 03:41:15.359
and we have deaf people in our family. So, it's really hard when you don't hear people speak a different language in your house and then you go to school. >> So, just navigating that. Um, families are asking whether the district has spent enough time evaluating effectiveness of the core instruction

776
03:41:15.359 --> 03:41:30.960
itself and a strong multi-tered system of support. Tier one instruction should successfully meet the needs of most students. intervention should supplement strong instruction, not compensate for weak instruction. Families families expressed concern that the district has

777
03:41:30.960 --> 03:41:47.920
responded to disappointing literacy outcomes by layering additional initiatives, interventions and supports onto existing practices without fully examining whether the foundation is producing the outcome students need. A strong intervention cannot fully compensate for a weak foundation just as

778
03:41:47.920 --> 03:42:03.680
exercise cannot overcome poor nutrition. intervention alone can't overcome an effective core instruction. The recommendation is to evaluate literacy efforts through outcomes rather than implementation alone. Families want the district to identify which instructional

779
03:42:03.680 --> 03:42:18.800
practices are producing measurable g measurable gains in reading proficiency. Strengthen what works, continue what doesn't uh discontinue what does not, and hold itself accountable for results. The question is not how many literacy initiatives exist. The question is whether more students are becoming

780
03:42:18.800 --> 03:42:34.800
proficient readers. And I'll say to that, um, parents are the first teacher. But if we're not engaging the families, we're doing a disservice to the kids. Your kid can go to school and learn all the things, but parents need to be involved because if parents not involved, we got

781
03:42:34.800 --> 03:42:51.359
latchy kids. They're not going home to do homework. They're just going home to do whatever at their leisure. But if there's a reading log that goes home and holds the parent accountable, the teacher accountable, everyone's checking in on that child's reading. But if there's nothing like that happening, you know, pipeline to prison's real. I I

782
03:42:51.359 --> 03:43:06.800
grew up in Boston. I worked in the criminal justice system. I've taught enrichment classes. So, I've seen people I grew up in the community go through the prison system because they have a middle school barely education. So, I've lived it. I'm almost 40. I don't want to be fighting this when my kids are 40. So, I'm trying to change this now.

783
03:43:06.800 --> 03:43:24.560
Reading should be the main thing. Like that should be something you graduate with. It's reading really is fundamental. >> And I mean it's like having a home is a foundation. Being able to read is a foundation. I'm a child of an immigrant who does not read or write in English or Spanish. My mom has dyslexia. I

784
03:43:24.560 --> 03:43:40.960
graduated with high honors. So I had to fight through chapter one. I don't know if you guys remember when it was chapter one in ESOL. And um and here I am. So, I'm a lived experienced Boston public student and I loved all my teachers. I had great teachers and I just want that for the next generation.

785
03:43:40.960 --> 03:43:56.479
>> And I just want to say we need to debunk the myth that some students cannot learn to read because we know from the research that 95% of students regardless of disability can learn to read with the right intervention. >> Oh, and I'm autistic as well. So,

786
03:43:56.479 --> 03:44:13.840
>> so I'm I'm all of the things. So, and and >> thank you. I appreciate that. Um, first of all, thank you to the three of you. Um, and I don't know if Elijah's coming back, but um, okay. Um, I actually had a question that, but um,

787
03:44:13.840 --> 03:44:30.880
>> the really appreciate uh, you're bringing these themes from parents and also bringing the student voice um, for that perspective as well is so helpful. um also appreciate the emphasis on tier one instruction as being the place where students receive the most of their um

788
03:44:30.880 --> 03:44:45.199
most of their teaching and learning experiences as they should and and the emphasis you had on acting on what we already know um and building on successes as we work to create a collective definition of strong

789
03:44:45.199 --> 03:45:02.720
inclusion practices. Um I know uh Chair Brazil you mentioned some historical examples of strong inclusion practices. was wondering if there were any um that parents are speaking about in the present that combine a strong um like

790
03:45:02.720 --> 03:45:18.160
pedagogical and like staffing or model for inclusion and growth outcomes like in the present that we might be able to um look at as we seek for that more universal definition of a strong

791
03:45:18.160 --> 03:45:34.479
inclusion model. So I think a a strong inclusion model really means investing in educators, investing in teachers. When we say that cut should um the last the last thing you want to do is cut those individuals who were closest with

792
03:45:34.479 --> 03:45:50.399
the students. I can say that in the first round of inclusion, you know, way back in the day, 1989, it was really investing in professional development, giving teachers time to plan and ensuring teachers had the

793
03:45:50.399 --> 03:46:07.840
expertise, but also ensuring that the the class size was right and making sure that each adult had, you know, it's it's sort of the the collaborative planning is probably the biggest piece because

794
03:46:07.840 --> 03:46:25.199
the collaborative planning has more to do with um teachers having the opportunity to plan in advance. So I'll give you an example of Mary Lion if that's okay and say how that developed. So Mary Lions became such a strong

795
03:46:25.199 --> 03:46:41.520
inclusion model because teachers led the professional development on site. So instead of teachers going to professional development, professional development came to them. And so there's always going to be one teacher that, you know, loves professional development and

796
03:46:41.520 --> 03:46:58.319
wants to lead the team. And you know, that's their thing. That's their jam. And so that teacher would get the PD and lead the PD in the school. What makes that authentic is they understand their student population. And so if they get a new student, those teachers will

797
03:46:58.319 --> 03:47:15.439
collaborate, get together, do the co-planning, talk on the weekends. When teachers are successful, they work beyond the school day. They meet for coffee. Uh they talk on the phone. They say, "Oh, we're getting a new student. What can we do? Let's get

798
03:47:15.439 --> 03:47:33.199
together and discuss it." It's really investing in teachers. when teachers feel that they have that agency to uh really create the instructional infrastructure and like if they don't have um if if if

799
03:47:33.199 --> 03:47:48.160
there's a lot of students who are struggling with reading, give them a reading specialist. You know, a lot of times we look at uh students who are acting out, but that's a data point. students act out when something is not

800
03:47:48.160 --> 03:48:04.080
working. And so what we've seen over the years is you know m what we see what we saw initially is it didn't I wouldn't I'm not going to say it didn't matter who the principal was but the principal could change but this those teachers who

801
03:48:04.080 --> 03:48:20.399
are have stable teaching forces they don't leave they've been at the school for 30 years 25 years when someone comes in new they orient that individual to the way that school runs I can point to the Manning as an example They were an

802
03:48:20.399 --> 03:48:35.680
extremely strong inclusion model where they previously had substantially separate classroom for students with emotional impairment. They partnered with um Italian home. They they um had um partnerships with local um community

803
03:48:35.680 --> 03:48:52.720
centers and and and health centers and and they and they invested in their teachers. And so when a an inclusion model unravels, the first question that I have is, is there teacher turnover? Because teachers are are

804
03:48:52.720 --> 03:49:08.239
you know when the model is successful and the teachers are engaged in professional learning, you ultimately have a stable teaching force. And I'm not saying they never change, but the culture the the the culture of a professional learning community is there

805
03:49:08.239 --> 03:49:24.319
and that is what fosters success is investing in teachers who are working close closest to the students. >> I appreciate that and agree. I'm wondering how parents are assessing whether that is present from what you

806
03:49:24.319 --> 03:49:41.199
all are hearing. You know, we heard a lot of public comment today around um student assignment and feeling as if some schools are ready and truly living an inclusion model versus just having the model more by label or as was

807
03:49:41.199 --> 03:49:57.840
expressed. Um and just wondering what are you hearing from parents in terms of how they're differentiating the two? Um because to your point Sh I agree professional development is so important but parents might not even know the level of professional development that's happening from one school to the other

808
03:49:57.840 --> 03:50:13.439
in as much detail. So what are some of the indicators that parents are using to say this school not this school when determining that the inclusion model is in place in terms of >> for me it's most parents talking to each other.

809
03:50:13.439 --> 03:50:29.760
>> Okay. So, not knowing how to even find sometimes the welcome center is an issue. Um, a lot of people don't even know this building exists. So, that's one thing. A lot of the parents have issues finding where to register their kids and when they register their kids, what programs are offered. They see the

810
03:50:29.760 --> 03:50:45.680
list and that's as far as they go because they don't know there's an option to go do a deep dive and actually visit the school and learn what what they offer. So if that's explained in layman's terms to them, not just a packet that says parents rights, parents don't really know what their rights are,

811
03:50:45.680 --> 03:51:01.279
they can read that. If they don't speak English, they don't understand their rights. And then they go to the welcome center, they'll get a list, and then they'll check off the list, and then their kid gets placed somewhere. Now, because they didn't know that they had the right to go visit the school or call the school and find out what services off or even know what services their

812
03:51:01.279 --> 03:51:17.439
child needs, that's the issue. The IEP being done is one thing, but half of the time it's them getting support from the social worker at their PCP. It's not because they're getting support from the district. So if they if they didn't have a a social worker or they don't go to a primary care doctor, they go to a

813
03:51:17.439 --> 03:51:33.920
clinic, now they're not even getting that social worker's help. So that's the issue. They're not having someone that there's not a point a point person. So they're navigating it from hearsay from another parent. And I would add I would add to that that uh what does success look like in terms of an inclusion

814
03:51:33.920 --> 03:51:49.840
school? Yes, the metrics can be parent feedback. >> And so if you you think of say the Henderson, which is kind of a unicorn too because um of the nature of why it was designed, but part of it was to

815
03:51:49.840 --> 03:52:06.080
include students who would otherwise go out of district. And it it worked really really well because parents felt that their children were safe. They felt welcomed. They there was a sense of belonging and they were making progress.

816
03:52:06.080 --> 03:52:22.239
>> H forest man. Um so my son's 24 now, but when he went to Horus man, there were hearing kids in his class as well. It wasn't just all inclusive to deaf kids. >> And um eventually he had to go out of district, but he I didn't want him to go out of district because that was his community. So he had to go to the learning center for deaf to learn how to

817
03:52:22.239 --> 03:52:38.800
read at 21. He should have gotten that at Horus man, but it was specifically ASL for deaf kids. And to Edith's point, when you're in sub substantial um separate classes, he missed out on that reading aspect because he wasn't around his hearing peers, only when they did

818
03:52:38.800 --> 03:52:54.399
recess or lunchtime. But they were always in the same school together. So if they would have merged them together, his language would have belt. his he has friends that speak that are profoundly deaf, but he doesn't because he didn't have that connection and he didn't have that community. And then he had to go out of district for two more years past

819
03:52:54.399 --> 03:53:09.279
the time he wanted to stay in and he was given a completion of um high school. But I said no and um now he has a diploma. But parents should parents that don't know how to navigate that end up with a kid that just has that completion. And I would say that um

820
03:53:09.279 --> 03:53:26.319
success should also be measured on reducing um dependence on outsourcing. >> Yes. >> Uh reducing dependence on litigation and reducing um uh spending on out of district placements over time. M

821
03:53:26.319 --> 03:53:43.600
>> so for example when the Henderson 9 through 12 is closed those parents whose children go to the lower school are thinking where is my child going to fit >> thinking that right now what school has the capacity for my child

822
03:53:43.600 --> 03:53:59.920
>> and then all the other things that come with it like the child might be bullied at the new school they don't have supports this their their teacher that may have encouraged them to get to the next grade now that teacher that they're familiar with that would have been their teacher in the next school year is gone. So the comfort of knowing I'm going to

823
03:53:59.920 --> 03:54:16.880
be here till 8th grade is now taken away from them and they're in a whole new school setting where they have to learn to adapt to things that they're not used to. It it really affects the kid overall when they're not good with transition and then drastically their school has changed overnight. It's not an easy way

824
03:54:16.880 --> 03:54:32.640
to adapt for them when they whether they have a disability or not, but definitely when they have a disability >> and and it's where can where how does a district build capacity to have that seamless alignment for transition for children who would otherwise go to the

825
03:54:32.640 --> 03:54:49.120
Henderson and and so that really includes the staff who have the specialization, who have the professional development, the expertise and also have that collaborative planning ing model like where does that exist for in that way

826
03:54:49.120 --> 03:55:05.359
for those students and I I really think that parent feedback is an assessment because you know there's a bottleneck effect on you know trying to get into certain schools that may be outside of your region and when you see that bottleneck effect and and and parents

827
03:55:05.359 --> 03:55:22.720
for example because we've talked to them decide oh I'm going to homeschool my child I'm gonna take my chances on a charter school >> or I'm gonna um you go some maybe primoco because parents are out of desperation they want to find a a model

828
03:55:22.720 --> 03:55:40.560
that works and and and so it's it's it's not that they don't want to be in BPS they want to be in a neighborhood school in in in the district but when parents go to advocates and attorneys and through litigation is because they're desperate and those metrics that I

829
03:55:40.560 --> 03:55:57.520
talked about welcome challenge sense of belonging and making progress are not there for their children. >> Yeah. I just wanted to um engage um Elijah briefly before we moved on because I really appreciated I think we all did um the clarity and and honesty

830
03:55:57.520 --> 03:56:14.640
of your sharing your student experience. So, thank you for doing that. And we were talking a little bit um on this last question about bright spots or where things have worked. And you talked about some of your experiences where you felt like your um classroom experiences were not preparing you at the level that

831
03:56:14.640 --> 03:56:30.239
you wanted and was wondering if you have had any experiences over the course of time in your school that were opposite that and what they looked like that were more engaging and more positive than some of the ones that you said. as we think about trying to build on

832
03:56:30.239 --> 03:56:47.880
successes. >> Um, there's not many that I can think of. I feel like I've always felt like like the work was just never challenging. >> Just something I can bang out in 5 10 minutes. And um,

833
03:56:47.920 --> 03:57:03.520
one way that I really learn, one way that I learned that the work was to prepare me for college was my aunt was in college and she was talking to me about all the work she has to get done. And I'm like, that doesn't seem like anything I'm doing or even close to it. Like, that seems way more complicated.

834
03:57:03.520 --> 03:57:19.040
I'm not prepared for that at all. Like, the way the assignments they give us to me, it's insulting almost cuz it's just like I feel like we're we're in high school, we're in 12th grade. This is like I say sixth, seventh grade level work. >> So,

835
03:57:19.040 --> 03:57:40.160
>> thank you for sharing that. Thank you. >> Thank you. Um, I feel what has been very helpful for me this year has been able to listen in on your monthly phone calls where we can hear the voices of parents and recognizing that almost a quarter of

836
03:57:40.160 --> 03:57:56.319
our district are have our families who have children with special ed. So that's almost what 11,000 families and we don't hear from nearly that if we hear from 1%. And so my question to you is like

837
03:57:56.319 --> 03:58:11.920
what can we do? I mean I understand and agree with all of the things that you have raised as concerns as well as recommendations for improvements. But what can we do as a collective, a

838
03:58:11.920 --> 03:58:29.199
district and sped PAC, etc. to reach out to make sure that all families are aware and then trying to look collectively at do we have the resources

839
03:58:29.199 --> 03:58:44.319
to actually do what families need when we have that significant number of families. many of the things you talk about are the same things we need to do for our typically developing students

840
03:58:44.319 --> 03:59:02.080
and it's not happening for them either. So the question is, you know, how do we really become a district that is in strong partnership with all families, but especially our families with children with special needs, so that

841
03:59:02.080 --> 03:59:19.840
these things get discussed and grown in ways that we can begin to make the difference. Well, I would say I'm glad uh Chair Robinson that you came to our table because coming to our table would allowed you to hear the perspective of

842
03:59:19.840 --> 03:59:36.880
families. So, our town hall that we had on May 28th was the highest attended general meeting that we had this year >> and because it was led by Family Voice, one of the things that we have asked for and we believe would be helpful is for

843
03:59:36.880 --> 03:59:52.560
us to be part of an inclusion task force where we can make recommendations and bring that parent expertise and voice into what makes a good inclusion school. We have the questions. We have the data

844
03:59:52.560 --> 04:00:09.600
on what is and is not working. And parents have that expertise on knowing what works. And and it's it's it's it's tough right now going for parents to the welcome center. And I I just have to be um clear and say

845
04:00:09.600 --> 04:00:25.439
that some families have told us they've gone and and they looked at a school and they think that is a possibility and the school will quietly tell them we can implement your child's IEP. The school just does not have the resources. And parents appreciate that,

846
04:00:25.439 --> 04:00:42.319
but it's scary to hear it >> as well because what school what other schools are not being as candid about what they can and cannot do because I think schools need to be supported and that's where that infrastructure comes in the district saying what are the

847
04:00:42.319 --> 04:00:59.920
non-negotiables? How can schools be fully resourced and staffed? Because that's really where it is. You cannot have an inclusion school unless you have an infrastructure for staffing and and all of the things that we talked about this evening. And that takes more

848
04:00:59.920 --> 04:01:17.840
money. It is expensive. Inclusion means that there's a place in in the school for every student regardless of the nature and impact of their disability. And to do that, you're going to have to not just look at your staffing, but

849
04:01:17.840 --> 04:01:32.720
you're going to have to look at environmental adaptations. Do you have a sensory room? Do you have technology? Do you have specialized equipment? Do you have um are you able to adapt the environment so that the school looks

850
04:01:32.720 --> 04:01:48.960
like an inclusion school and and students and and it's and it's accessible to all students. And so that that takes the lens of parents who know what their children need to say we've

851
04:01:48.960 --> 04:02:04.960
captured that and and that's where building trust and partnership comes in as well. I mean, you've responded to you took the words out. I was going to say the something similar, but

852
04:02:04.960 --> 04:02:21.760
>> I mean, just to piggyback on what you said earlier about um implementing spaces like the sensory spaces, orchard gardens does do that. So, I've seen at different schools, I've seen a little bit of everything that you discussed. But if all of the schools had a quiet corner, so when you're unregulated, you

853
04:02:21.760 --> 04:02:36.880
can just sit there and they have sensorary toys or you can read your book. Like if a child brings a book to school, they can go sit in that corner. The teachers do that at Orchard Gardens, but I don't see that at other schools. But that was just the teacher doing that because that's something they thought would work. It's not the school telling

854
04:02:36.880 --> 04:02:54.960
them to do it. these teachers just, you know, they know their student and they were like, "Okay, I'll make this area." So, it was nice to go to parent teacher night and see that they had these spaces, but it wasn't in every classroom. It was just certain teachers doing it. >> Well, thank you again for tonight. Um,

855
04:02:54.960 --> 04:03:11.840
this has been very, very helpful and we look forward to meeting with you again um in the fall. But if in closing, if there's one thing that we can do to start the new year off better next year, what would be a top thing that community

856
04:03:11.840 --> 04:03:26.560
engagement, >> pardon me? >> Community engagement. Like having some sort of outreach for the family so that they know in verbiage they can understand because that a lot of the times if they'll look at that paper, I don't know what this is about and that's it. So they won't come out if they they're reading words they don't

857
04:03:26.560 --> 04:03:41.920
understand. And if English is a second language, just forget about it. They're not going to come. And I I would say yes strengthening parent partnership which has to do with the shared the co-creation shared decision making implementation planning but I would also

858
04:03:41.920 --> 04:03:58.560
say I would go back to the beginning and say look at what is working >> you know replicate and scale success whether it's a program whether it's an intervention how do you do that across the district and create that infrastructure

859
04:03:58.560 --> 04:04:14.640
by looking at what what is a district already doing successfully and because like I said we look at problems and look at data but what is the action plan and how do you replicate best practices in

860
04:04:14.640 --> 04:04:31.040
schools that are struggling working hard but don't know what to do. >> Great. Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you very much. Um before we do the last part of the meeting, we're going to take a five minute break and then we will come back to do the next two two

861
04:04:31.040 --> 04:19:19.279
pieces. >> Thank you. >> Thanks. teachers that >> Thank you. Thank you, Spedpack. Thank you very much. We appreciate you guys. >> On to the next item. >> Okay. >> Yeah, I I'll be

862
04:19:19.279 --> 04:19:35.120
>> Thank you. >> No, we're we're doing good. We're going we're going to get out of here by 11:00. All right. Thank you. Our next presentation tonight is the superintendent school year 202526 summitive evaluation.

863
04:19:35.120 --> 04:19:52.080
Evaluating the superintendent is among the chief responsibilities of the school committee. The superintendent completed her self-ealuation and shared it with the committee for review. Each committee member completed an an individual evaluation providing their insights and

864
04:19:52.080 --> 04:20:09.520
assessments of the superintendent's performance. Dr. Alkins and vice scar vice chair scarret led the process this year and consolidated our feedback into a comprehensive summitive evaluation which will be presented this

865
04:20:09.520 --> 04:20:25.600
evening. We will vote on the superintendent summit of evaluation at our virtual meeting on July 8th. I will now turn it over to the superintendent remarks followed by Dr. Alkins and vice chair scarret. After the

866
04:20:25.600 --> 04:20:42.239
presentation, I will open it up to the other members for comments on the superintendent's evaluation. I'd like you to I would like to remind you to speak at a slower pace to assist our interpreters. And I now invite the superintendent to give introductory remarks.

867
04:20:42.239 --> 04:20:57.680
>> Wonderful. Thank you, Chair Robinson. I'm I'm certainly grateful for this opportunity to reflect on my work as superintendent and the progress that we're making as a district. I first want to thank Chair Robinson, Vice Chair Scarit, and all of the members of school committee for your continued support and

868
04:20:57.680 --> 04:21:14.880
guidance as I begin the fifth year of my superintendency. I also want to give thanks to Vice Chair Scarit and Dr. Alkins for their work in directing the evaluation process. Certainly, the questions, the feedback, the collaboration from this committee helps me and my team continually

869
04:21:14.880 --> 04:21:30.720
evaluate our work and improve. And I'm deeply grateful for our partnership and our shared belief in the potential of every BPS student. I'd not be able to do my work without my talented and dedicated team. I just tried to get them to leave and they were like, "No."

870
04:21:30.720 --> 04:21:46.239
Um, this year was especially challenging as we faced new budget pressures, some of which were out of our control and could not be predicted, including changes in federal immigration policies and the rising cost of health care, transportation, and special ed services.

871
04:21:46.239 --> 04:22:02.960
My team has worked hard to find operational efficiencies. We've eliminated vacant positions. We've made difficult staff reductions to ensure the district's priorities were not impacted and student services were protected. And we're especially grateful to the district's school leaders for working

872
04:22:02.960 --> 04:22:18.560
with us to navigate these changes. I've said before, every day I wake up feeling positive and excited about the work ahead and proud of what we've accomplished together. And that holds true literally every day. I've always said when that stops being true, it's

873
04:22:18.560 --> 04:22:35.359
probably time for me to go. Good news is that's not yet. feeling um certainly for school year 2526 has been one of a lot of reward. There's just a ton of high points to celebrate as we come to the end of this school year. We began the

874
04:22:35.359 --> 04:22:51.680
school year with historic highs in bus on-time performance, higher attendance rates, and 99% of school meals being prepared in-house with locally sourced fresh ingredients. students returned to improved and upgraded facilities. And we cut the ribbon on two new schools, the

875
04:22:51.680 --> 04:23:07.680
Sarah Roberts Elementary School and the state-of-the-art Carter School and celebrated the renovation of East Boston's PJ Kennedy Elementary School. Over the past four years, we've intentionally created the foundation for academic growth. We're now starting to

876
04:23:07.680 --> 04:23:24.000
see the results of our work. Six BPS schools were named as schools of recognition by DESIE, the highest number of BPS schools ever honored in one year. Two schools exited the highest level of DESIE oversight, and six schools rose from the 10th accountability percentile,

877
04:23:24.000 --> 04:23:39.279
more than any other year before. We saw historic gains in the access assessment for our English language learners and increases in reading and math at nearly every grade level on our MAP growth assessments. As a district, we met three end of the year targets at midyear.

878
04:23:39.279 --> 04:23:54.800
Reading achievement, grade three to five rigorous expecta expectations, and chronic absenteeism. In fact, we're close to meeting our chronic absenteeism on target for 28% by the end of the school year. We also improve from baselines on nine metrics. Additionally,

879
04:23:54.800 --> 04:24:11.840
seeing higher CGP fall to winter this year than fall to spring last year on reading and math. We are also seeing significant strides at the secondary level, too. Earlier this spring, Desi released graduation data that showed the district's 2025 4-year cohort graduation

880
04:24:11.840 --> 04:24:29.199
rate increased to 81.3%, which was a 1.6 percentage point increase from last year, marking strongest graduation outcome the district has recorded since records were began being kept about 20 years ago. Simultaneously, we saw a decline in the

881
04:24:29.199 --> 04:24:45.680
number of students leaving school before earning a diploma, a historic low. Our annual dropout rate fell to 3.6%, which was almost a full percentage point decrease from the previous year, and it was really the lowest on record, minus the pandemic year of 2021.

882
04:24:45.680 --> 04:25:01.760
We've expanded the availability and range of AP courses to students with approximately 3,800 students enrolled in an AP course in 2025. And we've seen a huge success in the exam scores with 68% receiving a score of three or higher.

883
04:25:01.760 --> 04:25:18.159
This year more than a thousand students participated in early college and 2500 students participated in career tech education which will lead to a certification. We still have a lot of work to do, but I'm confident that we can build on this momentum. And by continuing to build

884
04:25:18.159 --> 04:25:34.960
sustainable systems that lead to long-term progress after many years of inconsistent growth and incremental movement for the district, we're starting to see results. We're getting closer to closing learning and achievement gaps, not widening them, and actually not starting them.

885
04:25:34.960 --> 04:25:49.520
I just want to again thank you for the opportunity to speak tonight and and I really do look forward to my partnership with each of you and I really do appreciate the genuine feedback you've given me in my evaluation. Chair, I'll pass it back to you, >> Dr. Wilkins.

886
04:25:49.520 --> 04:26:07.120
>> Uh thank you uh school committee. Uh thank you superintendent. Um and uh I want to give a shout out uh one to former vice chair Michael O'Neal who used to chair this and so now uh he has

887
04:26:07.120 --> 04:26:23.359
passed the duty on to me and the new vice chair. Um but uh thanking him for his uh continued insight. Um, and also I want to send a shout out to Rebecca Granger who had a huge hand in organizing um, us and just sort of

888
04:26:23.359 --> 04:26:39.279
wrangling us, making sure that we were on top of getting all the evaluations put together and just aggregating um, all of this. So, thank you. So, um, the Boston School Committee has a number

889
04:26:39.279 --> 04:26:55.199
of responsibilities, um, including defining the vision, the mission, the goals of BPS, establishing and monitoring our annual operating budget, hiring and managing and valu and evaluating the superintendent, and setting and reviewing district policies

890
04:26:55.199 --> 04:27:11.520
and practices to support student achievement. um to give some uh knowledge around the evaluation steps and just what the process is. Um so for for the public uh annually the school committee does have

891
04:27:11.520 --> 04:27:27.279
a school or a school committee retreat where among other things we discuss um goals and priorities um with the superintendent in collaboration with the superintendent um so that we can have alignment with how we want to assess

892
04:27:27.279 --> 04:27:43.439
progress uh in for the district for the year and also in thinking about um its long-term sustainability and success. Um and in the evaluation process, those goals are um then reflected upon by the superintendent in in her um

893
04:27:43.439 --> 04:28:00.159
self-evaluation. Then following that um individual members will also submit their their own evaluations and then we pull together a summit of evaluation um reflective of all of our feedback. And then finally um per our vote in July

894
04:28:00.159 --> 04:28:17.680
uh we will vote on the summit of evaluation and performance rating. So a little bit behind the actual standards. Um so DESIE um provides um the standards for the superintendent evaluation across four different domains. One being instructional

895
04:28:17.680 --> 04:28:34.239
leadership, the second being management and operations, the third being family and community engagement, and the fourth being professional culture. Um and you'll understand a little bit more uh around that just given the feedback. And so to reflect on um what the school

896
04:28:34.239 --> 04:28:51.439
committee priorities are uh and what was agreed upon um like at our retreat and through numerous conversations um the school committee has prioritized accelerating academic performance. So, for example, um utilizing highquality instructional materials and our

897
04:28:51.439 --> 04:29:07.040
evidence-based practice um our um use and our um support for multi-tered systems of support throughout the district. U improving our access to advanced coursework and the continued um educator professional learning.

898
04:29:07.040 --> 04:29:24.479
For priority two, we always want to ensure access for all students. And so that consists of a couple of different dimensions um which consists of continuing to refine the structures and processes that prioritize learning experiences for students with disabilities, multilingual learners and

899
04:29:24.479 --> 04:29:40.080
multilingual learners with disabilities. Um expansion of all programming and courses that build multilingualism and multiculturalism um including a like host of uh of examples within there. So, dual

900
04:29:40.080 --> 04:29:57.120
language, transitional bilingual um education and heritage language courses. And then the last priority is uh making sure that we maintain consistency and highquality learning opportunities. So, and continuing our implementation of the long-term facilities plan and ensuring

901
04:29:57.120 --> 04:30:12.000
access for every student to a highquality student experience um and rigorous uh and culturally affirming learning experiences that include wellness and enrichment, a supporting network of caring adults and the physical spaces that do support

902
04:30:12.000 --> 04:30:29.040
learning. So within the evaluation um we we assessed the superintendent across a number of goals. Um and so the first goal that was aligned um to that first priority was accelerating academic

903
04:30:29.040 --> 04:30:45.040
performance that was measured through um national metrics and performance on those state and national metrics such as MCCAST access and NAPE and advanced placement some of which you heard um in the superintendent's introduction. Um

904
04:30:45.040 --> 04:31:01.279
also uh and data related to increased student engagement um including decreasing chronic absenteeism and dropout rates and increasing rates of graduation and secondary pathways um secondary pathways enrollment. And so I

905
04:31:01.279 --> 04:31:17.520
will not necessarily reiterate all of the statistics but I think some of them bear uh mentioning again. So, the historic 81.3 um percent graduation rate uh particularly um with increases for black and latine students, students with

906
04:31:17.520 --> 04:31:32.800
disabilities and multilingual learners alongside a nearrecord low dropout rate of uh 3.6%. Um, superintendent also noted the 38% increase in early college um, enrollment

907
04:31:32.800 --> 04:31:49.199
with about 2500 students participating in CTE programs and about 68% of advanced placement um, students scoring a three or higher on their exams and of course a surge of students who received a seal of biiteracy.

908
04:31:49.199 --> 04:32:04.880
Uh the committee also recognized the proficiency increases in grades 3 through eight uh ELA and math MCCAST uh which is the third consecutive year of meeting chronic absent uh I'm sorry um the third consecutive year of meeting chronic absenteeism targets and

909
04:32:04.880 --> 04:32:21.359
improvements in access scores for multilingual learners. And while celebrating these milestones, um the committee noted that we must work urgently to accelerate progress for the majority of our students. Most critically, uh despite progress, only a

910
04:32:21.359 --> 04:32:36.880
third of BPS students are meeting or exceeding expectations on the MCCAST in grades 3 to 8 across core subjects. But to accelerate the rate of progress, the district must strengthen early education or that prek to two uh range in terms of

911
04:32:36.880 --> 04:32:51.279
literacy practices to ensure that students have a strong foundation. Further, with the statewide elimination of state exams graduation requirement, Mass Core must reflect a commitment to rigorous academic experiences consistent

912
04:32:51.279 --> 04:33:09.199
across all of our schools. related to student learning goal two for ensuring access to all students. Um the district would like to celebrate uh the annual progress toward full implementation of the inclusive

913
04:33:09.199 --> 04:33:26.959
education plan. So uh we are in the uh third ending the third year of a complete five-year rollout. Uh the committee um noted also the expansion of inclusive settings into the additional grades, inclusion planning teams in every school, service mapping efforts to

914
04:33:26.959 --> 04:33:43.039
align supports and resources and opportunities for multilingual learners through the expansion of dual language and bilingual uh programming and of course the launch of the reimagined school funding formula. The committee also applauds the district's sustained

915
04:33:43.039 --> 04:33:59.920
investment in HQIM um and the associated professional development and focus resources uh for students with disabilities and multilingual learners. And while this growth um signals commitment to equitable access and inclusion, the

916
04:33:59.920 --> 04:34:15.600
committee stressed that the successful implementation must be determined and measured by reported family experiences and academic outcomes, not solely by input milestones. Collectively, we named the need for greater transparency and communication

917
04:34:15.600 --> 04:34:34.959
around the impact of inclusive education efforts and more concrete data around classroom level implementation and application of professional development learning. for um student learning goal three or consistency or ensuring consistency in

918
04:34:34.959 --> 04:34:52.719
highquality learning opportunities. Under the leadership of Superintendent Skipper, the district has continued to make notable progress um in our gains to rightsize the the district and move towards the 2030 vision of approximately 95 highquality schools. This includes

919
04:34:52.719 --> 04:35:10.160
the uh 10 capital projects that are currently underway and the continued refinement of programs that meet the needs of our students. Of particular importance is the timeline leading up to public announcements and committee votes. The current window between

920
04:35:10.160 --> 04:35:26.480
announcement and school committee vote left some affected communities expressing feelings of being caught off guard and excluded from meaningful participation before decisions were finalized. The long-term success of this plan will depend largely on whether the affected

921
04:35:26.480 --> 04:35:46.719
communities feel they were true participants in the process. And so for everyone um watching at home um this is a representation of the DESIE rubric. um BPS um or the the school committee has adapted uh Desi's four

922
04:35:46.719 --> 04:36:08.080
category superintendent evaluation rubric into a more nuanced five category rubric that subdivides the proficiency rating into developing and effective. So when we look at the first standard um regarding instructional leadership um

923
04:36:08.080 --> 04:36:24.480
again we want to note some of the the highlights. Um the district-wide implementation of highquality instructional materials across all grades and continued examination and refinement of their use is a significant step uh towards the consistency of

924
04:36:24.480 --> 04:36:40.639
highquality classroom experiences. Additionally, we can note that the that the superintendent and her team um has allowed for and has created that HQM is now paired with 12 hours of additional

925
04:36:40.639 --> 04:36:55.279
um professionally of professional development um focused on inclusive and culturally responsive teaching practices. And BPS has strengthened its multi-tered systems of support across all schools uh leveraging um AI to

926
04:36:55.279 --> 04:37:15.520
support this work. And if we look at the distribution of ratings for our for our school committee, we can see that six um folks on the committee noted um gave the rating of effective. So just

927
04:37:15.520 --> 04:37:32.959
highlighting again that uh five dimension rubric um that we have looking towards standard two around management and operations. Fiscally, we applaud the roll out of the reimagined school funding formula that focuses on

928
04:37:32.959 --> 04:37:48.561
the instructional needs rather than on enrollment. Uh the mid-year deficit of 53 million, however, begs our attention to strengthen proactive rather than reactive measures that support long-term sustainability. The escalating costs such as health

929
04:37:48.561 --> 04:38:04.639
insurance and transportation are of particular importance to the committee and the district. Operationally, the administration demonstrated strong execution capacity by advancing MSBA core projects over multiple years, securing invitations for the accelerated

930
04:38:04.639 --> 04:38:20.080
repair program, and opening two new school buildings, the Sarah Roberts and the Carter. This school year marked an increase in in bus on time performance driven by the success successful deployment of the zoom tracking application which increased athletic

931
04:38:20.080 --> 04:38:37.119
trip coverage and even uh our district has received national recognition for green initiatives such as the fleet electrification and the indoor air quality monitoring system. Our focus areas, as mentioned earlier, do include reducing chronic absenteeism rate of

932
04:38:37.119 --> 04:38:53.119
30.9 and outstanding um work orders that still exist for capital repairs. Further, we want to note that the district has made gains in its racial, ethnic, and linguistic diversity of educators, suggesting a more well-prepared workforce for our

933
04:38:53.119 --> 04:39:10.799
students. The committee remains concerned about our impending reduction of staff and how this impacts the gains that our students have seen and um the the staff themselves. Just looking at the distribution

934
04:39:10.799 --> 04:39:33.520
bearings very similar to uh standard one. Standard three, as we think about family and community engagement, we've heard um a bit about that in our previous presentation. Um and I think it's fair to say that um our evaluation um

935
04:39:33.520 --> 04:39:51.040
reflects an alignment there. Um so the district we note has strengthened its communication efforts and infrastructure and the touch points that enhance access to information for families. And some of those noteworthy accomplishments include the successful implementation and use of

936
04:39:51.040 --> 04:40:07.520
parent square, the increased multilingual communication support from uh through the office of language access, improvements to our own district website, responsive family support system such as the BPS helpline and our focus outreach efforts that have increased the district's ability to

937
04:40:07.520 --> 04:40:25.280
connect with families. Moving forward, the district has to continue to cultivate um and include timely responsiveness to follow-up inquiries from families to ensure our accountability and particularly during complex decisions. We must unpack what

938
04:40:25.280 --> 04:40:43.718
transparency means for communities, i.e. It means earlier engagement that clarifies roles and decisions, ensures that there's adequate representation and opportunities for collaborative problem solving with the community rather than one-way communication.

939
04:40:46.798 --> 04:41:07.040
And so the distribution of responses shows um um the superintendent and um her team receiving effective and both developing um ratings. and rounding out um the evaluation with um standard 4 and professional culture.

940
04:41:07.040 --> 04:41:22.480
Under the superintendent's leadership, central office has successfully established a robust feedback structure driven by the superintendent's personal participation in monthly meetings with regional superintendent, operational leaders, and the school leader cabinet

941
04:41:22.480 --> 04:41:37.600
allowing for quick responses and continuous improvement. We applaud the successful roll out of broad-reaching professional learning, including those additional 12 hours of district-wide professional development. And also under um the superintendent's guidance, the

942
04:41:37.600 --> 04:41:54.320
district has launched a comprehensive process to develop the new BPS strategic plan serving in tight alignment to the revised opportunity and achievement gap policy. Moving forward, the committee um advises that the district must ensure that

943
04:41:54.320 --> 04:42:09.040
families, students, and stakeholders clearly understand how their valued perspectives and lived experiences actively drive the content and implementation of the strategic plan and are active partners in supporting the vision.

944
04:42:09.040 --> 04:42:26.718
With PD as a core priority, the district must continue to build a safe and inclusive organizational culture that's built upon mutual trust and respect to sustained continuous learning and ensure that educator voices are heard and encouraged. Professional learning should

945
04:42:26.718 --> 04:42:46.958
be aligned to practical classroom conditions and the needs of our educators. And so highly effective and an effective rating. And so together um these overall ratings average um a score of four 4.0 out of

946
04:42:46.958 --> 04:43:03.360
five. Um and so this um as per the the DESIE uh rubric this um indicates that performance consistently and consistently exceeded expectations in all essential areas of responsibility and the quality of the work overall was

947
04:43:03.360 --> 04:43:22.400
excellent and that annual goals were met. And so just showing a distribution across all the dimensions of uh each school committee member. Our aim is for all of these to be in

948
04:43:22.400 --> 04:43:38.400
that highly effective rating. And just another way just to to show the entire distribution of all responses. And so family and community engagement um always is challenging I think um to

949
04:43:38.400 --> 04:44:00.958
just to to acknowledge um but it is very doable um for our district. >> So just um showing the average uh numerical uh breakdown for each rating. And so in summary uh we highlighted um

950
04:44:00.958 --> 04:44:17.520
certain areas of strength. Um so of course the institutional stability and steadfast leadership uh superintendent has consistently used the image of sort of riding the ship and sort of needing to slow it down before you pivot and turn it in a direction where we know

951
04:44:17.520 --> 04:44:34.240
that we are moving in uh in a positive direction and um I think our evaluation is reflective that um that that's what we exactly what we're doing and so uh we are thankful for her commitment. Um we are thankful for um the strategic

952
04:44:34.240 --> 04:44:49.520
direction that's uh that she is providing and that the team is enacting. Additionally um areas of strength that we noted were increases in those indicators that were tied to student success. So many of the the national

953
04:44:49.520 --> 04:45:05.440
scores and the in in the growth still acknowledging that we have a ways to go. the commitment to equity and cultural competency. Um the superintendent has demonstrated a deep commitment to our workforce diversity and us um

954
04:45:05.440 --> 04:45:20.878
implementing and sustaining those culturally sustaining practices and u moving the district's curriculum and programming to be reflective of the rich diversity that our students and our families bring to the district. Um and

955
04:45:20.878 --> 04:45:38.480
of course uh last um the sup superintendent has uh successfully executed critical operational upgrades including more equitable school funding in the reimagined school funding model, a supportive regional model and an improved transportation efficiency as

956
04:45:38.480 --> 04:45:56.638
well as infrastructure for effective educator and school leader hiring and retention that has a direct impact on student achievement. So areas um for continued growth um as stated earlier uh community enga community and family engagement is by

957
04:45:56.638 --> 04:46:13.760
far the the the biggest challenge that we face. um transitioning from a culture of post-decision communication to one of early communication um that really discusses clarity of roles um one that um really thinks about how we're

958
04:46:13.760 --> 04:46:29.840
establishing those part those participation roles uh earlier in our process um and that we're conducting an equity analyses before announcing such structural changes and so um I think over the next uh year uh we're going to

959
04:46:29.840 --> 04:46:46.400
work collaboratively to revisit these systems to ensure timely and responsive feedback loops to uh constituent issues and inquiries. And of course, student proficiency and and um wide performance gaps. Um the the

960
04:46:46.400 --> 04:47:01.920
district we acknowledge is showing areas of improvement. However, we understand that overall student outcomes remain largely unchanged and the progress is not even across our schools. Um and so we understand that this issue is urgent

961
04:47:01.920 --> 04:47:18.240
for everyone and um knowing that we need to accelerate these academic outcomes and close and close persistent achievement gaps for multilingual learners, students with disabilities and our historically marginalized student groups. And so uh we look forward uh so

962
04:47:18.240 --> 04:47:35.440
we just voted on the policy. So um this is one step in the right direction. Um but um we do look forward to making progress and receiving updates as a committee on many of the key indicators named in the OAG policy and also

963
04:47:35.440 --> 04:47:51.680
including some monitoring on um preK2 literacy and numeracy um which we and also uh data on our educator uh diversity workforce and the how we're developing relational trust where our

964
04:47:51.680 --> 04:48:08.638
students and our families are partners in ensuring their their student success. Additionally, we noted areas in goal setting and accountability where we are looking to establish long-term measures and targets um to be reported annually.

965
04:48:08.638 --> 04:48:23.920
Um thinking about smart goals is another way to to put it where we are looking at annual targets as u measures and indicators of progress. um and looking at um measures um um tied

966
04:48:23.920 --> 04:48:40.480
to key inputs and investments to track whether or not our district is successfully moving our strategic levers identified um to drive student outcomes. And last, um thinking about how we are preserving our key investments. Um, so

967
04:48:40.480 --> 04:48:55.360
this is going to involve working more closely with the city to carefully manage and forecast these escalating operational costs such as transportation, health insurance, um, and utilities that really to limit the impact on studentf facing resources and

968
04:48:55.360 --> 04:49:12.000
district priorities. uh as a key example of district prioritization, the superintendent um and her team must execute a deliberate strategy to protect the gains that we've made in our workforce diversity amid shifts in the staffing and upcoming contract negotiations.

969
04:49:12.000 --> 04:49:26.718
And so as we enter into our new year, we understand that the the district must actively gather feedback on the re-imagine school funding formula and partner with school committee and the wider BPS community to identify areas of

970
04:49:26.718 --> 04:49:49.520
improvement and additional investment. So as we look forward to what our next steps in the evaluation process, um we think about a vote on the summit of evaluation and the performance rating on July 8th and thank you.

971
04:49:49.520 --> 04:50:06.160
>> Thank you. >> Yeah. Very good. Thank you all. >> Yeah. Very good question. >> All right. So opening it up for questions, concerns. Cole. >> Sure. Um, I want to thank Dr. Alkins for leading that um, astute summary uh, and

972
04:50:06.160 --> 04:50:23.120
for your leadership through this process. I want to thank Superintendent Skipper and your team for your leadership. Um, and I also just wanted to maybe narrate a little bit about our approach and kind of guiding principles to the um, evaluation itself uh, with a

973
04:50:23.120 --> 04:50:38.480
real commitment to it being a datadriven document. um with that data being about student outcomes first and foremost um also about the programmatic updates that we've received throughout the year from various team members on your team,

974
04:50:38.480 --> 04:50:55.600
Superintendent Skipper. And um last but certainly not least on the community engagement and feedback that we've heard throughout the year. Um, I think today was a great example with the diversity of testimony in terms of things that are of great importance to families and

975
04:50:55.600 --> 04:51:11.760
staff. Um, that our hope is that some of those themes um are reflected in some of the areas for continued growth. Um, and that that um those themes are reflected in some of the things that we want to continue to monitor. I know that

976
04:51:11.760 --> 04:51:29.600
sometimes the nature of public comment at these meetings can feel like I'm able to quote it because I have a written one. We talk at each other rather than talking with each other. Um but we are listening as a school committee and while we're not always able to respond in the moment, um those testimonies um

977
04:51:29.600 --> 04:51:44.718
and collective experiences really serve to push our probing and thinking around where the district um can strengthen. And so, um, really just appreciate all of, um, my colleagues, uh, in using

978
04:51:44.718 --> 04:52:00.718
those data points to, um, really celebrate successes, uh, and by next year be able to be at an even greater capacity to have a datadriven evaluation as those goals that Dr. Alkins referred

979
04:52:00.718 --> 04:52:18.560
to will be clarified um, and those long-term targets will be set. Thank you. Others >> I have a glow that we forgot is the uh we put in the uh the the

980
04:52:18.560 --> 04:52:34.718
launch the nation's first gay viant >> uh on ever. So that's a globe >> and and also the um one thing a growth

981
04:52:34.718 --> 04:52:51.760
for me will be probably to think about how um is family engagement and how to build a concrete measurable uh process for families to feel heard and uh before

982
04:52:51.760 --> 04:53:08.400
anything is discussed. >> Yeah. Microphone. Okay. Anyway, thank you for a very thorough and thoughtful analysis with your you know with your input

983
04:53:08.400 --> 04:53:24.798
regarding the the uh overall picture of everything. I I appreciate that. The only the only thing that I noticed uh among us among the members of the committee, we all each of

984
04:53:24.798 --> 04:53:41.360
us look at the same exact data uh under each criteria uh look at the same uh um information as well as the narrative

985
04:53:41.360 --> 04:53:56.320
everything we look at the same. The funny thing is each of us come up with a different rating. Um so what I'm trying to convey here is that

986
04:53:56.320 --> 04:54:12.480
regardless of what we do everything that we have been doing so far there is always an element of subjectivity in it. So we'll we'll have to carry that with us.

987
04:54:12.480 --> 04:54:30.400
and um the the uh evaluation that we we've we've done while I I appreciate it but um in my mind even this this subjectivity of each of us I uh really

988
04:54:30.400 --> 04:54:47.120
really do not agree with the you know with the overall uh rating that's that's just me. Thank you. >> Okay. Do you want to clarify that anymore? >> Do you want to clarify what you mean by that?

989
04:54:47.120 --> 04:55:04.638
>> No, there there is no need to to to to to clarify anything. Each of us is entitled to our own subjectivity in uh putting down the rating or the performance evaluation whatever. Even

990
04:55:04.638 --> 04:55:20.320
though we are all looking at the exact same information, data, narrative regarding each each category, >> but when we put down when we put down the rating >> Mhm.

991
04:55:20.320 --> 04:55:35.920
>> each of us come come with different you know different rating anyway. some with you know some cluster together some some are not so it

992
04:55:35.920 --> 04:55:54.160
just that I know the the the reason I'm I'm raising this is it's not is it's is nothing is nothing of a a critique no it it's just that um >> I uh enjoy the diversity

993
04:55:54.160 --> 04:56:10.000
put it that way >> that's why there's seven of us. >> Also, Mr. Tran, I think it is important that we retain our individual interpretations of the data. I do think there is alignment in that um none of

994
04:56:10.000 --> 04:56:25.360
the categories has us further than one rating apart um from one another. And so, while there isn't sameness, there is some level of um closeness in terms of where we're viewing successes. So I um

995
04:56:25.360 --> 04:56:42.080
>> I think as Dr. Akins showed in the distribution there are different ratings but not there there aren't outliers that's that stand multiple steps away from another either. Um, but I appreciate the point that we should

996
04:56:42.080 --> 04:56:57.440
probably should not all have identical interpretations of the same data, but should be able to substantiate our Yeah, we should be able to substantiate our um positions. And what we tried to do was take the most prevalent themes from everyone's

997
04:56:57.440 --> 04:57:19.040
individual um report and rise those to the summitative. But the public does have our individual reports as well um if folks wanted to read those. um so that you can get everyone's specific feedback. >> I' I've read most of your evaluation as

998
04:57:19.040 --> 04:57:32.878
well. >> Mhm. >> And I've read evaluations of other members before. Um I myself sometimes do have issues or

999
04:57:32.878 --> 04:57:54.000
or ideology that may be far different from what that Mary is implementing. Uh I be very frank inclusion right now I I I don't really the inclusion practice is something that I don't really buy

1000
04:57:54.000 --> 04:58:10.958
into it yet but looking at everything given before me based on information maybe I'm maybe I'm such a mechanical guy or >> put the mic >> I have the mic >> yeah maybe I'm I'm such a mechanical guy

1001
04:58:10.958 --> 04:58:28.000
even though there are things that I may not agree with uh Mary but when it comes to making a determination on you know on the four corners of the performance. I believe that is where I I

1002
04:58:28.000 --> 04:58:44.400
put myself down >> where where I I I put the assessment in regardless of whether the programs the projects the uh initiative is something that I have concern with. But if if if the per

1003
04:58:44.400 --> 04:58:59.040
performance is there that I believe is far exceed what what we expect then so be it. She deserves it. That's all I say. Well, what what I would say is that um

1004
04:58:59.040 --> 04:59:17.280
what is comforting is that within our evaluations there was um and I I'm just saying this more like qualitatively like there was consistency in what we identified as areas for growth. Mhm.

1005
04:59:17.280 --> 04:59:33.680
>> There was consistency in and I think where the differences I think some of the things that you're pointing out some of the differences were actually in highlighting certain accomplishments, right? So some things might resonate more with us on an individual basis for

1006
04:59:33.680 --> 04:59:49.520
in terms of accomplishments, but we were all pretty consistent on what we identified as areas for growth. >> And it's comforting to know that that aligns with even what we've heard here tonight from other presentations. Um, and not just that, but it's also in

1007
04:59:49.520 --> 05:00:06.718
alignment with what the superintendent identified herself as like I know that this is an area that like we need to address. And so, um, you know, I take that as a, you know, as a strong as like a as a strong indicator that like moving

1008
05:00:06.718 --> 05:00:22.798
forward that there's like that there's, um, agreement in how maybe not necessarily always how we go about the change, but that this area needs to be addressed. And so, um, yeah, >> thank you.

1009
05:00:22.798 --> 05:00:40.480
>> I agree. >> Thank you so much. I I just want to start by saying thank you to um members Alkins and and Scar because we have to do individual evaluations and you have to do yours and also combine all of

1010
05:00:40.480 --> 05:00:56.718
ours. So thank you so much for for that work and to superintendent um skipper I said in my evaluation that this is not an annual evaluation. This is for me it's a four months evaluation >> because that in my capacity of a of a

1011
05:00:56.718 --> 05:01:10.718
member of the committee has been four or five months working with you. But I I do want to say thank you so much uh for the things that been mentioned here for your leadership for the stability that you are bringing to the district for your

1012
05:01:10.718 --> 05:01:27.040
commitment that is clear. Um anybody working with you knows that your heart is on this work and and that's really really appreciated and we have we hope to keep you for a long time so you can keep uh driving this ship in the

1013
05:01:27.040 --> 05:01:45.040
right direction. Um, in terms of things that I I'm really hoping that was you were able to to see, uh, I was happy to see uh, me member Tran that even though I'm the new guy, I wasn't too far away from the rest of my partners in terms of

1014
05:01:45.040 --> 05:02:01.600
uh, a couple things like like um, family and community engagement. U, I think that's that's an area that we all need to keep growing. Um I personally would like to see you uh in the room with the families and and it may be uh looking

1015
05:02:01.600 --> 05:02:19.120
for the different rooms >> than what we are accustom like where else are are our families that you will be good for you to be there and and and be available to to the families. And the last thing is about uh outcomes. When

1016
05:02:19.120 --> 05:02:37.520
when uh Dr. I said goals were met. Yes. And for next year I would like to see those outcomes with the metrics like you know we were in a on a retreat on May 20. Your team said that yes we are going

1017
05:02:37.520 --> 05:02:54.240
to work on on on those metrics and bring it to you before the end of this school year. I I I hoping that that's going to happen because for me it's going to be easier to to do this evaluation next year if I

1018
05:02:54.240 --> 05:03:11.520
know what was the goal like where are we trying to hit that target did we did it or not it's going to be easier in talking about subjectivity and and trying to align that subjectivity with the objectivity of having those metrics.

1019
05:03:11.520 --> 05:03:31.440
So thank you so much for your work. >> So yes, well first of all I want to say thank you to Dr. Alkins and to vice chair Scarret um for leading the superintendent evaluation process and to thank you to all the members for doing

1020
05:03:31.440 --> 05:03:48.000
your part also in getting us here. Um, and particularly want to say thank you to you, superintendent, and your team for all of the work that you've accomplished in this past year. Um, we thank you for the way you engaged in the evaluation process. That's always never

1021
05:03:48.000 --> 05:04:04.878
easy, but you gave us a lot. 34 pages worth of district accomplish, which is great. and your commitment to continuous growth and improvement in service of your team, the district and our students and their families is clear in the data you presented, the reflections you

1022
05:04:04.878 --> 05:04:21.680
shared, and your openness to discourse. And we talk often about what we're going to do to improve the family and community engagement, and I know you're right there with us. >> Absolutely. >> So, thank you again. And we will vote on the superintendent's evaluation at our

1023
05:04:21.680 --> 05:04:39.760
July 8th meeting. Okay, we're in the home stretch here, folks. So, our final presentation tonight, >> come on down. Is the private school

1024
05:04:39.760 --> 05:04:55.600
application for the South End Village Academy Private School. Let's aim to keep the presentation to four minutes. I'd like to rem remind our presenters to please speak at a slower pace to assist our interpreters and I want to invite

1025
05:04:55.600 --> 05:05:11.200
the superintendent to give introductory remarks. >> Great. So I will be brief. Um South End Village Academy Sila has submitted an application to operate at the site of the former Croft School on Washington Street in the South End. Uh, and as I

1026
05:05:11.200 --> 05:05:27.440
stated earlier in the meeting, the district's role in the process of approving a private schools application to operate in Boston is strictly administrative. At this point, I will turn it over to Ann Clark for the review of the process and the school's application. We plan to bring this to

1027
05:05:27.440 --> 05:05:44.560
our school committee on Wednesday, July 8th for the vote. >> Good evening again, Madame Chair, Madame Vice Chair, and members of the school committee. As you know from our earlier presentations this year, the Boston School Committee is responsible for

1028
05:05:44.560 --> 05:06:01.680
approving any private school wishing to operate within Boston city limits under Massachusetts General Law Chapter 76 section 1. Our internal review teams follows the process outlined in the school committee policy and evaluates

1029
05:06:01.680 --> 05:06:17.360
applicants against a defined set of criteria covering curriculum and instruction design, staff qualifications, facility safety and compliance, organizational governance, and financial stability.

1030
05:06:17.360 --> 05:06:34.560
The review follows a five-step process. application review, site visit, leadership interview, evaluation, and a formal recommendation to the superintendent and school committee. All five steps are now complete for the application before you this evening.

1031
05:06:34.560 --> 05:06:48.798
Tonight, as the superintendent said, you will hear from Southoun Village Academy, a new independent school proposed for 1525 Washington Street in Boston South End, serving students from preschool through grade three in its first year

1032
05:06:48.798 --> 05:07:05.760
with plans to expand to grade 6 over time. The application was received this spring. A site visit was conducted on June 3rd and the review team's recommendation has been submitted to the superintendent. The review team found

1033
05:07:05.760 --> 05:07:23.638
that SA meets the criteria outlined by the Boston school committee with conditions which are detailed in the review team report included in your materials. I'll now pass the presentation to head of school Christina Lopez from Southoun Village Academy.

1034
05:07:24.878 --> 05:07:42.240
Good evening, members of the Boston School Committee. Thank you so much for the opportunity to present tonight. My name is Christina Lopez. I'm here in my role as head of school and I'm here representing teachers and families that are intent on the survival of their beloved school community. The Southoun

1035
05:07:42.240 --> 05:07:58.798
Village Academy, or SA for short, was born from the wreckage that was left after the crisis at the Croft schools. We learned in early March about the inexcusable actions of the school's founder. We were informed that there was no more money left and I was tasked to

1036
05:07:58.798 --> 05:08:15.040
close school within a week. To me and to many parents and teachers in our community, closing early was not an option. SA immediately was established by parents as a nonprofit corporation to collect donations to fund the remainder of the school year at the South End.

1037
05:08:15.040 --> 05:08:31.280
They secured a 50 501c3 status and continued to raise over a million dollars in record time. Concurrently, they made plans to be an option in case a buyer was not secured for all three Croft schools. After months of a failed

1038
05:08:31.280 --> 05:08:46.480
sale process, SA exercised a purchase agreement to acquire the assets and the lease of the South End location. The possibility for a future of our new school was taking place. Our ability to mobilize, to raise

1039
05:08:46.480 --> 05:09:02.560
funds, and to create the plans necessary to responsibly run a school speaks volumes of how much we love our school, we need our school, and of our confidence that we can do a phenomenal job if given the opportunity. Our school is designed to be a

1040
05:09:02.560 --> 05:09:19.600
neighborhood school. We want to help be part of the reason why families can stay in our vibrant city. Our program is rigorous and joyful for students in and out of the classroom and also flexible, communicative, and supportive for all of our families. We are a village within a

1041
05:09:19.600 --> 05:09:35.840
neighborhood. It is grounded in the basics. We ensure the use of quality researchbacked curriculum. Give teachers ample time to plan together, to collaborate, respond to data, and communicate with families. We use project-based learning to get kids into the neighborhood to connect with and

1042
05:09:35.840 --> 05:09:54.000
learn from their neighbors. art, local organizations, and small businesses. Being a neighborhood school means that we have a priority to welcome and support all of our neighbors. We believe that diversity in all meanings of the word creates a rich community. We commit

1043
05:09:54.000 --> 05:10:10.080
to meeting students where they are academically and all families where they are financially. We want to make sure everyone belongs. I'm going to talk a little bit about some of the crucial components that we have secured or changed to ensure a viable path forward.

1044
05:10:10.080 --> 05:10:25.680
These are our lead teachers for each grade level next year. They accomplished the unimaginable this year through immense uncertainty. They are committed to this community unwaveringly and they are excited to continue their work with SA. The second is our building. Through

1045
05:10:25.680 --> 05:10:42.160
the purchase agreement, CA signed the lease at our 1525 Washington location. This has been our home since 2022. We have 5 years left on the lease with the option of two 5-year extensions. The next is enrollment. There has been

1046
05:10:42.160 --> 05:10:58.638
no existing independent school in the South End. There is demand. The Croft School in the South End went from zero to 145 within 5 years with no marketing. At this moment, we have almost 80 students enrolled across grades preschool through grade three for next

1047
05:10:58.638 --> 05:11:15.120
year. and we receive interest emails every day. The SA board did a lot of thorough work on our financial model. We have proven that we have enrollment which brings in tuition. We have a philanthropically committed family community and our financial models of our standalone

1048
05:11:15.120 --> 05:11:31.360
school apart from the rest of the Croft schools show that we can get to sustainable operating surplus over the next couple of years. In the meantime, there will be a deficit, but we were gifted a $1 million donation to help continue cover the commitment of financial aid and so that our program is

1049
05:11:31.360 --> 05:11:50.240
delivered with fidelity. Can I keep going? Lastly, we have a responsibility to establish a professional institutional-grade operation. We have set up all parts of the school thoughtfully with experts. It is a requirement after what we went through to be transparent, responsible

1050
05:11:50.240 --> 05:12:06.958
stewards of the school and this includes the SIA board. They are parents who are incredibly smart, committed to the mission and can oversee the proper execution of the school. They have already been doing this since March, meeting every other night after their day jobs, sometimes until midnight. They

1051
05:12:06.958 --> 05:12:22.638
have a wide range of backgrounds from nonprofit to business to education, and it has been a privilege to work with them. I'm grateful tonight to share with you why I am confidently believe in the future of SA and I thank you so much for your thoughtful feedback, questions, and

1052
05:12:22.638 --> 05:12:42.240
consideration. >> Thank you. And I'll open it up to the committee for questions. >> Right away, >> go ahead. >> To save time, very bluntly, what's the uh tuition?

1053
05:12:42.240 --> 05:12:59.920
$34,000 is the set tuition. >> And uh I I see that you have approximately 42% of students receiving uh tuition support or scholarship. >> That's correct. Okay. Around 30% of our

1054
05:12:59.920 --> 05:13:18.120
tuition dollars go to financial aid and that impacts 40% of our students. >> Right. So the the 77 the 77 students that you have right now uh um 42% that's pretty good and um

1055
05:13:18.160 --> 05:13:35.520
talk about the diversity and and and the soio economic uh status of of of students. >> The financial aid speaks to the socioeconomic diversity. Um so we use clarity to determine need um for financial aid. Uh for diversity, 40% of

1056
05:13:35.520 --> 05:13:51.440
our students identify as students of color. >> Good. Okay. Thank you. That's all I need to ask. >> I have one question. What is the admission process? >> The admissions process is very personalized. We get to know families um

1057
05:13:51.440 --> 05:14:08.638
very closely. And so after they express interest in our school, we invite them in immediately to meet the family, to bring them into their space, and to learn about them to see if it would be a good fit. They fill out an application. Um and then we decide on admitting them from there. If they are admitted, they

1058
05:14:08.638 --> 05:14:25.638
can choose to go through the program uh the clarity application to get financial aid. Um if they qualify financial for financial aid and there's enough room in our budget, we will populate a personalized tuition for them. Yeah,

1059
05:14:26.560 --> 05:14:42.240
>> like what I was going to ask was along the lines of the financial aid, is that 40% lower than what you had originally had as >> it's actually higher for next year um

1060
05:14:42.240 --> 05:14:57.920
given the attrition of students through the crisis. >> Yes. Um, and so the people who are staying were really committed to maintaining the financial aid status. And so we maintained a higher percentage of our financial aid students. >> And and so does your model also project

1061
05:14:57.920 --> 05:15:14.320
that like you'll be able to stay at about that 40% mark or higher? >> It's actually going to go down over the next few years. Would you like to speak to this? >> Sure. Um, thank you for the time. Um, so I spent I've um I've uh joined the CA board kind of in the in the midst of the

1062
05:15:14.320 --> 05:15:31.760
crisis and so we now have pretty have a pretty good picture of of the economics of the school just as we've basically been uh funding the bills basically for the school since March. Um and basically the the the crux of it is that um we have um our aroma is down and as you

1063
05:15:31.760 --> 05:15:45.680
might expect uh the people who were paying full tuition were more likely to leave than the people who are on some sort of financial need. And so now the number of that are on scholarship has gone up. Um the reality is that and you can see it in in the projections is that

1064
05:15:45.680 --> 05:16:01.840
the um absent uh significant philanthropic help over the course of on a sustainable basis that 40% or 40% of students or 30% of the kind of gross revenue number in aid is an

1065
05:16:01.840 --> 05:16:19.600
unsustainable figure. And so over time um we um it is an enormous priority for us to try to make that number as high as possible while also being financially sustainable. And so over time we project in you can see in our projections that that number comes down to something in

1066
05:16:19.600 --> 05:16:35.920
the in the order of 20% of gross tuition which probably means something closer to 25% are on some sort of aid which is and that's that's what we think is is um is feasible given kind of what we think is our fundraising capacity. I think it's

1067
05:16:35.920 --> 05:16:51.120
going to be an it's a it's a really a crucial part of what we are being a neighborhood school trying to serve um as socioeconomically diverse group as we possibly can um while also being financially viable. >> So I was probably going to ask more

1068
05:16:51.120 --> 05:17:07.360
about like just what you all had in the pipeline for philanthropy and just fundraising. >> Yep. So the um we have um you know I think I think we sort of surprised uh we were surprised by the um the generosity

1069
05:17:07.360 --> 05:17:23.040
that we had just within our parent community. Um and uh the the fundamentals of these independent schools and you guys know school economics better than I do, I'm sure, but these they they they're expensive to run. Um and the the major things are um

1070
05:17:23.040 --> 05:17:39.840
payroll which is it it costs what it costs to get great educators and um facilities are in in Boston in particular very expensive. Um and so part of our plan is um the the next major step for us is to um find a site

1071
05:17:39.840 --> 05:17:58.400
in which to uh in which to grow so we can actually get to basically to get back to the enrollment where we were at around 140 150 kids. Uh we have uh we have 140 uhish in the projections. Um and so we are um actively um actively in

1072
05:17:58.400 --> 05:18:14.480
negotiations for leasing a new space. And um as part of that, we're going to have to do a capital campaign to do the tenant improvements. And those tenant improvements are expensive. Uh this is like a two3 million kind of project. Uh and so we're going to have to start a

1073
05:18:14.480 --> 05:18:32.320
capital campaign very quickly. Um uh this summer we have um quite a bit of it already spoken for in terms of just interest from uh you know uh philanthrop people who are really eager to see the school succeed. Uh and so that's that's given us a head start. Um but that's

1074
05:18:32.320 --> 05:18:48.878
it's going to be it's going to be different than the than the cross school which was a for-profit school which didn't have uh philanthropic access. This is something that we um do have. We have it within our community and we think we have um a compelling story to tell to the to the larger um Boston

1075
05:18:48.878 --> 05:19:08.718
community as well. >> Um sorry, sorry. Um good evening. the 77 enrolled students right now. Do you have capacity to enroll more um for the 26 27 year and all all of your

1076
05:19:08.718 --> 05:19:25.120
budget assumptions based on the 77 as if you were to get no more students? This would be where you were. Are you still actively recruiting students? >> We're going slowly because of space. Um our building can accommodate I think 90 94

1077
05:19:25.120 --> 05:19:40.638
>> 94 kids. So we do have space where we can enroll more. However, um we are making sure that we are growing responsibly and making sure that next year's um there's stability. Um and so we could

1078
05:19:40.638 --> 05:19:57.360
enroll more. Um we don't necessarily want to. Was the budget built off of that number? 77. >> Yeah, the 77 we're a little higher now just as we're 81 now, >> but we're being cautious. I mean we can we can get to 94 or 95 based on kind of

1079
05:19:57.360 --> 05:20:12.480
what we think the occupancy is but it's it gets tight and so we're trying to be cautious about that. We we do have um you want to talk about some of the other alter space alternatives we >> Yeah, we build a lot of partnerships with neighborhood organizations and so currently we share space with the

1080
05:20:12.480 --> 05:20:29.280
Salvation Army for the past year and so we have a continuing with them to use their second floor which is a full gym and also classrooms. Um, and so we do have kind of across the street ability to walk across the street and have space there to continue to learn in their beautiful classrooms. We're also in

1081
05:20:29.280 --> 05:20:46.000
conversations with United South Settlements um to create anou there as well. >> Thank you. Um, just to extend on Dr. Alen's question around philanthropy, your model for this 26 27 year is very dependent on the pledge and annual fund

1082
05:20:46.000 --> 05:21:02.480
line in order to >> the black. How committed is that funding um versus in hand versus pledged? >> Um it is um it is pledged and ready to be delivered um by the this particular

1083
05:21:02.480 --> 05:21:18.718
um this it's actually a board member. Um, and so I think that's as it's as secured as it as it as it possibly could be a absent it actually being in our bank account, which it which it it's um right now we have um we have sufficient funds to uh to operate in the in the

1084
05:21:18.718 --> 05:21:34.958
bank account for now and so that'll be called when it's needed. Mhm. Um and are the projections for on the philanthropy line for the 2728 and 2829 year um based on kind of the internal board capacity

1085
05:21:34.958 --> 05:21:50.400
to give at that level or imagining that you would bring someone to focus on development or would that be kind of built into some of your existing roles in terms of where are the where are the projections coming based on?

1086
05:21:50.400 --> 05:22:06.958
Uh the projections are are really based on kind of what we think we can do within just the parent community. The um um we're hoping we can do more especially when it comes to the capital campaign which isn't in this budget. Um the just because that's it. This kind of contemplates the lease expense but not

1087
05:22:06.958 --> 05:22:23.040
the actual tenant improvement buildout which would be required. Um, and so right now we're kind of thinking that most of our philanthropy is going to be from, you know, the parent community, but we're we're we're hopeful and we have several um very skilled fundraisers

1088
05:22:23.040 --> 05:22:38.320
that are on the board um to be able to reach out to a broader um broader, you know, philanthropic group. I think over time we would love to add actual you know um uh professional development uh capabilities inhouse to to help with

1089
05:22:38.320 --> 05:22:54.000
this over time as we scale. But in the in the in the meantime in the interest of sort of being financially um prudent that's it's like that's a cost item we're just not prepared yet for but which is and the board is kind of doing a lot of that leg work for now. And just

1090
05:22:54.000 --> 05:23:11.440
related to the board um in terms of the I think um you said head of school Lopez that it's completely comprised of parents currently. >> Currently yes. >> Um is is there a um intention to seek

1091
05:23:11.440 --> 05:23:27.520
expertise in gap areas um that parents may not have? um what is the imagined kind of growth for the um for the board. It is a very impressive um set of experiences but particularly in the area

1092
05:23:27.520 --> 05:23:44.000
of finance for example um you know if you want to have a finance committee things of that nature um are you ex uh looking beyond the parent community and were any of these board members board members before um board members of

1093
05:23:44.000 --> 05:24:00.240
Croft? None of these board members were board members of Croft. These are all parents. Um we will definitely this this board was born in an emergency situation and we are still operating as such. We end school on Friday. Um and so

1094
05:24:00.240 --> 05:24:16.878
once school ends and SA begins on Monday, we can turn our eyes to see um what what will the board look like um and open procedures there. Um we also have we've had um we reach out to some

1095
05:24:16.878 --> 05:24:32.480
consultants too to kind of bridge the gap in some areas that we are missing um so that we can ask for advice um and make sure that we're taking the right steps. And so um an example of that is we hired a bookkeeper or we hired a consultant who has run um a school

1096
05:24:32.480 --> 05:24:47.680
similar to ours um and reached out as needed to be coached. Um and so we know when to ask for help and we've really appreciated that help. Um but the board is really doing most of it now. >> Great. Thank you. And my my very last

1097
05:24:47.680 --> 05:25:05.120
question just with the um public nature of um how you all have been birthed and what the school community has been through over the last year. Um do you have planned um more public communication updates around the

1098
05:25:05.120 --> 05:25:23.680
financial health um overall health of the school? um already set or is that something that you imagine are building into your plans um moving forward? >> So just to be clear on the question,

1099
05:25:23.680 --> 05:25:38.240
it's how are we going to share the message of our school more broadly within the public? >> Not really the message of your school. I I really mean like the um like the the financial health of the of the school

1100
05:25:38.240 --> 05:25:54.560
specifically um six months from now, one year, you know, like >> what does that look like? >> Yeah, I mean I think that's um that's a good question. The um because I think it's something that um we've had as as we've enrolled students, I think a lot of uh a lot of folks were, you know,

1101
05:25:54.560 --> 05:26:11.200
asking, you know, how does the how does the model work? Um, and so I think that's something that we haven't we haven't we haven't um laid out a precise roadmap in terms of how we're going to um communicate that to the community, but it's definitely on our radar screen. I mean uh we've we've lined up an

1102
05:26:11.200 --> 05:26:27.760
auditor as a nonprofit. We have much a much higher standard uh in terms of of of um of reporting. We are required to uh file a form 990. Um and we will get audited financials. Um, and so those are those are two things we're going to do.

1103
05:26:27.760 --> 05:26:42.718
Um, but in addition to that, I think we're going to be much more transparent about how things are evolving, you know, as the school year progresses. I think, um, I I think, you know, some sort of quarterly or or semiannual update about, you know, what our cash position looks

1104
05:26:42.718 --> 05:26:59.760
like, what are, you know, what our cost needs are for the next, you know, six months. I think those would be go a long way in terms of building back this the trust that we we need in in this community. Um obviously we we no one here was a part of kind of what happened

1105
05:26:59.760 --> 05:27:16.480
uh at Oxford Street, but you know we we have a we have I think what is like a kind of a traumatized group of of parents um who obviously didn't had no idea what what they what they were had gotten themselves into. And so I think we're going to on the side of um you know communicating and being as

1106
05:27:16.480 --> 05:27:33.200
transparent as we possibly can about how we're doing financially. >> Thank you. >> Um >> I'll keep my question I got a ton but I'll keep my question short. Um you mentioned in the equitable access multilingual learners saw that. I didn't

1107
05:27:33.200 --> 05:27:50.320
see anything about students with disabilities and so I was just wondering like >> what is your thinking about that model? Sure. Um so for our enrolled students for next year, we have 27% of them get services um based on an evaluation. We

1108
05:27:50.320 --> 05:28:05.840
work very um collaboratively to personally support each child. We bring in outside providers. Um we meet with them. Some of those providers have um executed parent workshops to learn a little bit more about their approach and

1109
05:28:05.840 --> 05:28:21.680
also trained teachers. So we have a wider skill base on their approach. Um and then we work with families very um like in in tight feedback loops so they understand what interventions are we doing, how is the service provider working at school. Um and we have seen a

1110
05:28:21.680 --> 05:28:38.000
lot of success with students who have pretty significant diagnosis. >> Do you have a sense of like your current population that you're projecting of the 77 what portion have an IEP? We I think for next year there's no confirmed IPS although there's a few in

1111
05:28:38.000 --> 05:28:54.160
process right now but like I said 27% receive services based on an evaluation. Got it. I mean I only say this because of the conversation I was having earlier which is facilities is definitely your driving cost. Staffing unknowns

1112
05:28:54.160 --> 05:29:12.240
>> in the form of what students need is like another. And so I think I would just think about having funding set aside for those kinds of unknowns to keep sustainable. The other thing is when you jump from 77 to 140, are you

1113
05:29:12.240 --> 05:29:27.920
you're not building up third to fourth, you're taking in a block of grades at that point. We will grow by one grade every year. But the but the to answer I think your your question is the the the bulk of um of the enrollment increase

1114
05:29:27.920 --> 05:29:43.520
comes from the lower grades which is which is uh which is uh which we what we've historically had we've had two preschool classes two go >> exactly and that's and that's actually I mean in some respects in terms of what's like most uh e easiest to rely on is

1115
05:29:43.520 --> 05:29:59.760
that is the demand at that young at that younger level uh for preschool and prek and there where there's a lot of demand and in our neighborhood. And so that I think we're very very confident in those things where where it's harder and I'm sure you guys know this as well just in terms of enrollment at the higher grades

1116
05:29:59.760 --> 05:30:16.240
it's harder it'll be harder to backfill any of the students that we lost in the crisis basically in the you know third grade fourth grade but we're going to try our best to get to um to add because you know once we have we have incredible teachers there in a classroom with 10 kids that could easily have 11 or 12. We

1117
05:30:16.240 --> 05:30:33.120
would love to add additional students there. Um you know, and now that could be somebody that can pay full pay and that could in many cases those are great opportunities for uh very high need uh students because there's that those are places we have a lot of access capacity

1118
05:30:33.120 --> 05:30:48.798
and so that's that's uh what we'd like to do. >> Historically, we have added at our higher grades. So this past year with second grade, which is our oldest grade, we had four new students. One came from abroad and a few came from private schools where they were getting on a bus to go outside the city. And so families

1119
05:30:48.798 --> 05:31:04.558
who decide that they really want to raise their kid in the city and chose something outside of the city originally kind of were looking at us as a solution to staying in the neighborhood. Um and similarly before this crisis when we were adding third grade we had three families interested in joining third grade. Um so there is a little bit

1120
05:31:04.558 --> 05:31:21.840
there. Got it. Um and last um the material component of what currently exists with Croft that will go away but these are things like technology desks furniture >> is it a clean break as in

1121
05:31:21.840 --> 05:31:35.920
>> yes >> every okay so just clean breaks >> on Friday it will cease to be crafts and on the next day it will be seas so that was our purchase agreement >> does the lawsuit that has been filed seize asset

1122
05:31:35.920 --> 05:31:53.760
of what was crossed >> not in the south end because of our purchase agreement. >> I see. Okay. >> Hi. Um question about um I know you're going to be operating in the south and are children from the Jamaica plane site

1123
05:31:53.760 --> 05:32:08.240
also coming to join you in this endeavor? I have spoken to 25 of the Croft JP families um as they are navigating this next step. Um I'm hoping that we'll be able to welcome a few of

1124
05:32:08.240 --> 05:32:23.520
them um at SIA next year. >> How long had crop been operating before this crisis? >> In the south end uh for four years. I was the founding head of school in the south end. >> And what about in Jamaica plane? In

1125
05:32:23.520 --> 05:32:40.480
Jamaica plane it was six years. >> Six years >> and Providence eight years. >> Okay. >> What was the what was the Oh god, I'm so interested. What was what was the initial since you were the founding? What was the initial enrollment at the

1126
05:32:40.480 --> 05:32:55.520
beginning in South? >> Oo, you're testing me very late at night. >> Um, we had two preschool classes and one prek class. I can't remember the number. It was roughly 50. >> Yeah. Like maybe more. Yeah.

1127
05:32:55.520 --> 05:33:13.080
>> And then what what did it max out at? >> Uh yeah. 124 >> this past year. 124. >> So there's a lot of good information in that about your financial sustainability.

1128
05:33:15.120 --> 05:33:32.638
>> I'm telling the K0 to K2 really the K to third grade is the most expensive grade. So anyways, there's a lot there to unearth but >> what is your financial plan

1129
05:33:32.638 --> 05:33:48.320
stability so that 3 years from now history does not repeat itself. I think first and foremost history will not repeat itself because we were one school of three and when we peeled back

1130
05:33:48.320 --> 05:34:06.320
the layers um there was just incredible inconsistency with how um like where the money was going and so our our financial analysis of our school as a standalone school was actually viable. I think JP's was viable as well. um it was Providence

1131
05:34:06.320 --> 05:34:22.480
um that was really struggling and so some of our um revenue was actually going to um so it's a totally different scenario which is why we've looked really hard at what is within our four walls and what is viable in the south end. Mhm.

1132
05:34:22.480 --> 05:34:38.638
>> I mean, I think um in terms of viability, that's kind of ultimately what's leading to the projections, which is is going to be a less is going to be a more moderate amount of financial aid, >> which is just a it's an unfortunate reality of trying to make this more

1133
05:34:38.638 --> 05:34:55.200
viable. Um, and then I think it's going to be exercising a muscle of of um of or developing a strong like philanthropy muscle to uh to basically be able to fund both um the kind of scholarship uh

1134
05:34:55.200 --> 05:35:11.600
part of the budget but also you know ongoing capital projects as needed. And so I think we're going to um we're going to start um be this we're going to start looking more like other independent schools which you know they have scholarship they have a certain amount of financial aid and then they have an

1135
05:35:11.600 --> 05:35:28.320
annual fund and then capital needs and we're going to be I think I don't think our um real estate is going to be the fanciest. I think we'd rather spend we it'll be adequate and and good but and we we'd rather allocate more resources to financial aid. That would be to us

1136
05:35:28.320 --> 05:35:45.440
that would seem like uh an accomplishment to be to be something that's like to to be to to make that more of a priority than our peers. And that's what we're going to do the best we can to to do. >> I know you're saying that this year the amount of financial aid is quite

1137
05:35:45.440 --> 05:36:00.558
substantial, but you would assume it will go down in future years. What does that do to the commitment to families who are there on financial aid because their need will probably not change but exactly how will you balance that?

1138
05:36:00.558 --> 05:36:18.000
>> Yeah. Which and so the we that was a promise we kind of when we decided we were going to take on the task of of continuing the school. We made a kind of a commit a commitment to that anyone that was here we were going to keep and and make sure that there was a spot for for them. And um that that is something

1139
05:36:18.000 --> 05:36:34.958
we honored. Um what it basically means that it on the incremental enrollment is going to be we're going to have to be um much like I think we're going to have to do less financial aid. So we're going to have more financial aid in the upper grades in in this next kind of interim

1140
05:36:34.958 --> 05:36:50.080
period. There's going to be more financial aid in the upper grades, less kind of at the preschool prek level. And over time it'll probably average out to more of a standard. you know, each class kind of has a certain amount. Um, but so but in this interim period, it's going to be a little lopsided because of

1141
05:36:50.080 --> 05:37:09.760
because of what we just described. >> Thank you. Anybody else have anything else? >> All right. Well, then thank you so much and we will vote on this at our July 8th meeting. >> Thank you so much. >> Is the extended day a separate financial

1142
05:37:09.760 --> 05:37:27.600
model? separate >> is it? Yeah. Is it a separate but No, it's in >> No, it's in our financial it's kind of like a pass through. We, you know, everyone's kind of build uh to the extent they sign up for extended day. Um and we're we're still um figuring out uh how we're going to manage financial aid

1143
05:37:27.600 --> 05:37:44.798
on that. Um but that's something that um it's a smaller number. It's something that's more manageable. Um and we're we're still kind of figuring that out uh as as we go. We're we've got um Clarity who's the the provider that we use there. They have a lot of good advice on this because they see this, you know,

1144
05:37:44.798 --> 05:38:00.638
every single day they see how schools are doing this and so we we're we're working with them to come up with something that feels um both, you know, financially responsible but equitable as well. >> Okay, great. Thank you. >> Thank you, Mr. Pav. We'll now return to public comment.

1145
05:38:00.638 --> 05:38:25.040
>> Yeah, John Mud. >> Thank you. Thank you. >> Thank you. I'm sorry to keep you at this hour but uh I'll try to keep it short. Uh uh I think it is important to try and put the

1146
05:38:25.040 --> 05:38:41.520
rich discussion you had around special education and inclusion in context. I started working around special education in Boston public schools in the 1990s. I hate to say and inclusion for special education students has traditionally

1147
05:38:41.520 --> 05:38:58.240
meant shifting special education students from substantially separate classes into mainstream regular education classes with the necessary training staffing and resources uh and with a special concern for the

1148
05:38:58.240 --> 05:39:13.360
disproportionate assignment of black boys into substantially separate classes. Research shows that this kind of inclusion can be good for students if done right.

1149
05:39:13.360 --> 05:39:28.160
But this kind of full inclusion of students with disabilities is apparently not happening. In its memo answering questions about the proposed FY27 budget, BPS that the school commit the

1150
05:39:28.160 --> 05:39:45.600
city council wrote requested. BPS wrote it could report no reduction in substantially separate classes, no reduction in the number of students in subpasses and no cost savings.

1151
05:39:45.600 --> 05:40:00.798
The number of percentage of students in sub classes I think is still hovering about a third >> and uh we do not have goals for the achievement of sub uh reduction of

1152
05:40:00.798 --> 05:40:17.040
subset or the reduction of black students in subset classes. you. Somebody asked what is one concrete suggestion to this bed pack and I would say take them up or you should take the

1153
05:40:17.040 --> 05:40:38.558
lead in collaborative planning. You have an institution under the the >> Okay. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. new business. >> My shout outs because of time

1154
05:40:38.558 --> 05:40:54.000
constraint. My shout outs will be on July 8th. >> Appreciate you. Thank you very much. >> I I say the same. I have some question about this live program, but hopefully we can talk about that in our next meeting. Do >> you have a memo?

1155
05:40:54.000 --> 05:41:10.240
>> You have a memo in your packet also some question some context. Yes. Okay. >> Oh, just to follow up on Mr. Peralta uh remark slide. >> Mhm. We have a P.

1156
05:41:10.240 --> 05:41:27.360
>> Yes. But could we have a member? >> Very office meet with us. >> Absolutely. Absolutely. Yeah. I I can call and explain it or Joel will. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. >> Thank you.

1157
05:41:27.360 --> 05:41:44.240
>> Okay. So, please note that our next meeting will be remote on Zoom on July 8th and will start at 5:30 p.m. So, if there's nothing further, I'll entertain a motion to adjourn the meeting. Is there a motion? >> So, moved.

1158
05:41:44.240 --> 05:41:58.878
>> Is there a second? >> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Is there any objection to approving the motion by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the meeting is adjourned. Thank you all. Have a good night. single out there.

1159
05:41:58.878 --> 05:42:02.680
>> Look at that same thing.