WEBVTT

METADATA
Video-Count: 2
Video-1: youtube.com/watch?v=0pZzBziiwPc
Video-2: youtube.com/watch?v=614KgKI2BoY

Part: 1

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:06:01.680
--------- Good evening and welcome to this meeting of the Boston School Committee. I'm Chairperson Jerry Robinson. We'll begin with the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge algiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the

2
00:06:01.680 --> 00:06:28.639
republic for which it stands. One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. I want to welcome everyone who is joining us in tonight in person on Boston City TV and on Zoom. I'm going to

3
00:06:28.639 --> 00:06:44.240
ask everyone here in the chamber to please turn off the volume on your laptops or other devices so it does not interfere with the audio for tonight's meeting. Thank you for your cooperation. Tonight's meeting documents are posted

4
00:06:44.240 --> 00:07:03.199
on the committee's web page, bostonschools.org/schoolcommittee, under the April 15 meeting link. >> For those joining us in person, you can access the meeting documents by scanning the QR code that's posted by the doors. The meeting documents have been

5
00:07:03.199 --> 00:07:20.000
translated into all of the major BPS languages. Any translations that are not ready prior to the start of the meeting will be posted as soon as they are finalized. The meeting will be rebroadcast on Boston City TV and posted

6
00:07:20.000 --> 00:07:37.599
on the school committee's web page and on YouTube. The commit is pleased to offer live simultaneous interpretation virtually in Spanish, Haitian Creole, Cape Verdian, Cantonese, Mandarin, Vietnamese, and

7
00:07:37.599 --> 00:07:53.440
American Sign Language. Zoom interpretation feature has been activated. Zoom participants should click the globe icon at the bottom of your screen to select your language preference. I'd like to remind everyone

8
00:07:53.440 --> 00:08:09.919
to please speak at a slower pace to assist our interpreters. We'll begin the meeting with the approval of minutes. I will now entertain a motion to approve the minutes of the March 25th meeting. Is there a motion? So move. >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Second.

9
00:08:09.919 --> 00:08:26.639
>> Thank you. Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Is there any objection to approving the motion by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the minutes are approved. We'll now move on to the superintendent's report. I present to you our superintendent, Mary Skipper.

10
00:08:26.639 --> 00:08:42.800
>> So, good evening and thank you, Chair Robinson, and good evening to our school committee members and to our public. It's wonderful to see everybody in person. We have a packed agenda, so I'm just going to take a few minutes to share an announcement from our BPS Office of College, Career, and Life

11
00:08:42.800 --> 00:08:58.720
Readiness, and some recent bright spots before we get into the presentations. First, the BPS Office of College Career and Life Readiness, which we call CCLR, invites grade 12 students, parents, and

12
00:08:58.720 --> 00:09:16.399
caregivers to join a support session on the free application for federal student aid or what we call FAFSA, and the Massachusetts Alternative Financial Aid Application or what we call MASA on Wednesday, April 22nd from

13
00:09:16.399 --> 00:09:34.080
8:30 a.m. until 2:00 p.m. here at the Bowling Building. The parents of 12th graders will receive an electronic communication from us on Thursday, tomorrow, April 16th, with local and statewide resources, as well

14
00:09:34.080 --> 00:09:49.839
as information on school counselors and partners available at their home school for support. The Massachusetts financial aid priority deadline is May 1st, which maximizes students eligibility for state aid for

15
00:09:49.839 --> 00:10:07.519
those entering colleges in the fall of 2026. Completing the FASA or MASA by this date is very important and a key step for students in terms of accessing grants, scholarships, tuitionfree opportunities,

16
00:10:07.519 --> 00:10:26.480
and other supports. Please email the office of college career and life readiness at cclrbostonchools.org with any questions. Few bright spots. Um so I'm proud to share the winners of this year's Aspen Challenge. You may remember that last

17
00:10:26.480 --> 00:10:42.480
year BPS began its participation in this two-year national education program that challenges high school students to design solutions to social justice issues. This year, teams of eight students from

18
00:10:42.480 --> 00:10:59.600
13 BPS schools, as well as students from Lawrence High and Somerville High, spent 10 weeks developing their ideas, including how to address food insecurity, make resources available to immigrant communities, address the

19
00:10:59.600 --> 00:11:15.519
connection between academics and mental health, create more green space for youth, and connect students to work training. opportunities. Those ideas were presented to a panel of judges composed of community leaders,

20
00:11:15.519 --> 00:11:32.959
educators, and experts at the solution showcase last week. Thank you, Chair Robinson, for being there to cheer our students on. The grand prize winners are headed to the annual Aspen Ideas Festival in Colorado in June, where they will have the opportunity to learn from

21
00:11:32.959 --> 00:11:48.720
global leaders confronting the most pre pressing issues of our time. So the drum roll. Congratulations to Boston International Newcomers Academy or Binka and Tech Boston Academy on this welldeserved honor. Additional awards

22
00:11:48.720 --> 00:12:06.000
included Brighton High School for originality. Another course to college for collaboration, Charlestown High School for community engagement, and New Mission High School was honored with the people's choice award. Lawrence High School was also recognized with the resilience award.

23
00:12:06.000 --> 00:12:22.160
for me as superintendent, you know, just to be able to see the talent, the creativity of our young people. I was so impressed with the quality of the projects, um, and just the excitement and enthusiasm of the students. And I told them the first day when the competition kicked off, it would be a

24
00:12:22.160 --> 00:12:38.880
life-changing event if they put hard work into it. And then in talking with young people the day that before they knew who was going to Denver, they all sort of agreed it was in fact a life-changing event. Um I couldn't have been more proud of them as I know chair was. Um and so many different people

25
00:12:38.880 --> 00:12:54.320
from the city and the district came to cheer them on. Uh similarly for the two teams that will go on to Colorado will be doing the same. Um I'm just really thankful to the Basos Foundation and the Aspen um Institute for giving our

26
00:12:54.320 --> 00:13:11.760
students, you know, such a wonderful opportunity these last two years. And we're working very hard right now to figure out how that Aspen challenge model will continue in our city in the years to come. >> Red Sox. So last week I joined Mayor

27
00:13:11.760 --> 00:13:28.959
Woo, the Sarah Greenwood dual language school community and several special guests for the annual Red Sox hat day. Um this marks, this is sort of a tradition. It marks the arrival of spring and the start of the baseball season. And you can see from some of these photos just the joy, the

28
00:13:28.959 --> 00:13:44.000
excitement that happens in this event. Um, I think Wall-E and Tess are definitely the celebrities at the event. The kids love them. Um, and one of the highlights was seeing all of the kids find out that they were getting tickets

29
00:13:44.000 --> 00:14:01.360
to a Red Sox game in the future. Um, they literally just jumped with joy. Um, thank you to Chair Robinson and member Paralta for helping to re to distribute the Red Sox hats to the students. Also, thanks to our mayor for making all of this happen for us, to Red Sox president

30
00:14:01.360 --> 00:14:18.800
and CEO Sam Kennedy, Red Sox partner and foundation board member Linda Henry. Um, and really just the whole organization of the Red Sox. They show up for our kids always. And on this particular day, it's just one of our best times with Wall-E and Tessie. Uh, in all the Red

31
00:14:18.800 --> 00:14:36.800
Sox donated 40,000 hats across the BPS to all of our schools, our K8 schools, and we're just incredibly grateful to them and to JetBlue, who also was a sponsor um, for making that day such a wonderful day across our district. Lastly, I was honored to attend the

32
00:14:36.800 --> 00:14:52.959
Denver Elementary School's recent digitizing day. This was a special opportunity for the school community to come together to contribute to an online an online archive that will hold many of the school's memories as their last year

33
00:14:52.959 --> 00:15:08.720
comes to a close. I want to thank members Palanco Garcia and member Torres for coming as well um and really uplifting the community. The attendees contributed photos, apparel, notes, recorded interviews. These will all be

34
00:15:08.720 --> 00:15:23.760
uploaded to a new collection that's in collaboration with UMass Boston's Healey Library, University Archives, and Special Collections. The Deborah has truly been a cornerstone of the Columbia Point community for nearly 70 years. The

35
00:15:23.760 --> 00:15:40.079
event reflected the connection, the the different kinds of connections and memories that have just been created across so many different people. It was incredibly meaningful to see and hear from former students and families and staff members who gathered to share

36
00:15:40.079 --> 00:15:56.959
stories and really celebrate what the schools meant to them. By preserving these memories, we're honoring the legacy of the Denver and we're ensuring that its impact continues to be felt for years to come. As part of the event, a commemorative city of Boston street sign

37
00:15:56.959 --> 00:16:13.519
was unveiled. the Denver school drive. All roads lead through the dever. Um, this was installed to honor that legacy of the Denver's decadesl long impact to the community. I also want to extend a heartfelt thank you to those who came out to share memories and preserve and

38
00:16:13.519 --> 00:16:29.920
make available for the deversary's legacy for future generations, especially project manager Megan Schroeder, parent leader Cheryl Buckman, and principal Margaret Renon. Going forward, the BPS Capital team will continue working with our emerging and

39
00:16:29.920 --> 00:16:46.720
closing school communities to determine the best way to celebrate and honor them. Each school community is different and many have their own ideas of how to commemorate their story and their history and just huge applause for the Denver for really really expressing to

40
00:16:46.720 --> 00:17:02.000
us the importance of this piece of closure for the community um so that we can then take it and be able to build this set of closure for the other communities as they go through closures and mergers. Um later this spring, we'll share an update with the committee on

41
00:17:02.000 --> 00:17:17.919
where students from the closing schools are going next year and report on the progress of the long-term facilities plan implementation. Uh so with that, chair, many many bright spots. Wanted to call out a few, but um I will turn it back over to you. Thank you, Superintendent. Um I'll now open

42
00:17:17.919 --> 00:17:33.200
the floor for questions and discussion. Please remember our norm is five minutes per person per member per round not including district responses and keep questions related to the superintendent's report. Other topics can be raised during new business. BPS

43
00:17:33.200 --> 00:17:49.679
staff, please keep responses brief and speak slowly to support our interpreters. Since I know this is your first in-person meeting, I'll just tell you what I usually do. I usually will look to my left and ask for people on this side if they have something to say and then go that way. So, we're not

44
00:17:49.679 --> 00:18:08.720
doing a zigzag. Okay. So, >> I'm okay. >> You have no >> You have questions? >> I I do. Um well, a couple I guess uh I can share an announcement um for myself. Um

45
00:18:08.720 --> 00:18:26.400
I had the uh the privilege to attend the National School Boards Association conference in um San Antonio with uh Jake Lacy from our facilities management. uh department. Um BPS was receiving the Magna Award for its work on the installation of its internal air

46
00:18:26.400 --> 00:18:42.000
quality monitors and that project has been in the works since 2014. And so I think uh being recognized um nationally for the work is something that is just a testament to uh what these investments

47
00:18:42.000 --> 00:18:58.720
very early on what they yield and um particularly the the the data dashboard that was created as a result of that. And so being able for families to check that dashboard to look at what the air quality is. Um but also how those

48
00:18:58.720 --> 00:19:16.320
monitors were able to inform what are the types of renovations and upgrades that each of our buildings need. I learned a little bit more. I mean not just that our average building age goes all the way back to 1942, but you of course we still have some buildings that were built in the 1800s. So that's just

49
00:19:16.320 --> 00:19:32.400
a testament to how much these buildings need upkeep. um and investment. Um and so it was good to be uh recognized as a district and it was also good to hear from peers from across the country just about um some of their challenges that

50
00:19:32.400 --> 00:19:48.559
they're experiencing um and how they're addressing some of them. So uh just a shout out to uh Jake for for attending and uh the the entire team uh Katherine Walsh like like her team as well. So um that um and I did and I did have a

51
00:19:48.559 --> 00:20:04.960
question. So you mentioned at the at the end of your report around hearing an update around where students are going. Is it possible to get also an update around how our faculty and staff are sort of fairing um as well? Um yeah, >> absolutely. We'll make sure that that's

52
00:20:04.960 --> 00:20:21.520
part of it >> cuz I I'm pretty sure we're we're going to hear like later today or later today around um just some shifting in the district around around um particularly like our social workers and thinking really about uh one those that may not

53
00:20:21.520 --> 00:20:39.360
have permanent status but um have been in contract positions. um are they going to be offered permanent status? And you know, our social workers when we start talking about all the issues right in the district, chronic absenteeism um from that to academic outcomes like

54
00:20:39.360 --> 00:20:56.720
our social workers are a critical part of that. So hopefully we're able to to to get some some of your um your thoughts on that. >> Absolutely. >> It was great to hear about the Aspen Aspen challenge and the um the value of

55
00:20:56.720 --> 00:21:13.039
that for participants. I think it'll be useful to save some of those models and structures for as Desi works through what graduation requirements are going to be for high school students, especially if there's a community component or some sort of portfolio

56
00:21:13.039 --> 00:21:30.000
component. Um, thinking about the social impact that this has. It could be something that could be replicated at at the district level outside of the national context if it aligns well to anything that they put online. >> Yeah. No, I think this is a great point and I think, you know, as uh the

57
00:21:30.000 --> 00:21:46.960
graduation recommendations come out at the state level, the idea of capstone is, you know, a critical one. This is a mini capstone in that it was the 10 weeks, but certainly like I know at Tech Boston though they did not win last year, they undertook a housing

58
00:21:46.960 --> 00:22:02.880
initiative for housing instability and that team stayed together as seniors and they actually made it a year-long project where they just launched their own nonprofit. >> So I think the agency that it teaches our young people, you can do a lot. Um,

59
00:22:02.880 --> 00:22:17.679
and so we're right now we're we're talking with several partners about how to be able now that we know what to do, how to be able to take that and continue to build that challenge into the fabric of BPS and to your point, member scar,

60
00:22:17.679 --> 00:22:34.400
like how to use that as a springboard for bigger things when it comes to our our high school students. >> Yeah, it's great. >> Yeah. I also just want to comment on the Aspen challenge because you know I'm a big fan of it and um what I saw in that

61
00:22:34.400 --> 00:22:50.080
room that morning were kids from 15 high schools, very diverse kids. Um these were not just the best and the brightest. Everybody was there. And not only were their projects incredible in

62
00:22:50.080 --> 00:23:06.320
terms of these being clearly examples of strong student voice and efficacy, but all the work that they put into it, how they supported each other. I mean, we had what 200 kids from every, you know, from 15 different schools across the

63
00:23:06.320 --> 00:23:22.960
city. There was nobody fighting. They were not, you know, posturing against each other. there was more collaboration that I've seen in a long time. They were clearly interested in the projects that each other had done and I'm hoping that

64
00:23:22.960 --> 00:23:40.000
there will be a way that we can share some of that good news here. Uh, our media is often interested in what's not working, but those projects and those student voices as well as the people that supported them are just prime

65
00:23:40.000 --> 00:23:57.600
examples of what students can do when the learning is meaningful to them and they have the support to actually make the actions happen. So, >> that's right. And I was extremely proud >> that we that our students embraced >> Somerville High and Lawrence High

66
00:23:57.600 --> 00:24:15.039
students who they didn't formerly know um and they weren't part of the fabric of the city. And yet you'd never know that with how they embraced them and and worked with them and cheered each other on. And that's where when we lay the table well for students, you get great results. And so that's that's a kudos to

67
00:24:15.039 --> 00:24:31.200
all the coaches, the staff. Ian Clark is here who just does tremendous um work in lifting this up. Um and so yeah, so I think there's a lot to build on in this and we just thank you for your continued support here. >> Thank you. >> Thank you all. I will now entertain a

68
00:24:31.200 --> 00:24:48.240
motion to receive the superintendent's report. Is there a motion? >> So move. >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Is there any objection to approving the motion by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the superintendent's report is approved.

69
00:24:48.240 --> 00:25:03.840
We will continue with re a brief report on the Massachusetts School Building Authority MSBA core program 2026 statement of interest for the Melvin H. King Southend Academy. Due to MSBA's

70
00:25:03.840 --> 00:25:20.080
April 17th deadline, the presentation and vote will take place tonight. Let's aim to keep the presentation within 10 minutes. I'll now turn it over to the superintendent. >> Wonderful. Thank you, chair. So, I'm pleased to share that we plan to submit

71
00:25:20.080 --> 00:25:35.600
a statement of interest or an SOI to the Massachusetts School Building Authorities 2026 core program for the renovation of the Melvin H. King South End Academy. As a reminder, the MSBA is

72
00:25:35.600 --> 00:25:51.760
a state agency that offers competitive grants to municipalities to support school construction and renovation projects. The core program supports renovations, additions, and new school construction.

73
00:25:51.760 --> 00:26:08.159
The application will be submitted in collaboration with our partners in the city's public facilities department and the mayor's office. This afternoon, the Boston City Council voted to approve the application following a hearing of the council's Ways and Means Committee

74
00:26:08.159 --> 00:26:23.600
earlier in the day. The next step in the process is the approval of this body. We are very excited about this opportunity to provide Melvin H. King Southend Academy students with a state-of-the-art therapeutic school

75
00:26:23.600 --> 00:26:39.120
building that is designed to meet their academic, social, emotional, and mental health needs. This will bring the district another step closer to our long-term goal of giving our students with different abilities the supports they need and the highquality

76
00:26:39.120 --> 00:26:54.640
educational experience they deserve. At this time, I'll turn the meeting over to our BPS chief of capital planning delannis and Dr. Assistant and assistant superintendent Dr. Harold Miller Jr. for

77
00:26:54.640 --> 00:27:09.679
the presentation and then later this evening we'll ask the committee for its support of this application. I would just like to say personally I am over the moon on this particular project. It is so long due to our community and our

78
00:27:09.679 --> 00:27:27.760
students and um I just want to thank uh all those that have supported it thus far and would ask the committee support tonight. Dell Harold. >> Uh thank you superintendent. Um good evening chair and members of the school committee. Um I am very excited to be

79
00:27:27.760 --> 00:27:46.159
joined here tonight um with Dr. Harold Miller um to present the core application for Melvin H. King Southend Academy. As the superintendent shared, the MSBA is a state authority that funds public

80
00:27:46.159 --> 00:28:02.720
school construction and renovation across Massachusetts through a one penny of sales tax supported reimbursement program. It has two programs. The core program for major school construction projects

81
00:28:02.720 --> 00:28:22.799
and the accelerated program for roofs, windows, HVAC upgrades. Over the past several years, Boston has made an effort to increase their participation in the MSBA programs, and we are incredibly grateful for their

82
00:28:22.799 --> 00:28:38.399
partnership. The MSBA, City of Boston, and Boston public schools have collaborated on 57 program projects, sorry, over the years. Seven core projects, the Dearborn, BAA,

83
00:28:38.399 --> 00:28:55.279
JQS, and most recently the Carter are completed. One school, the Shaw Taylor, is finishing design selection. The Root Batson Academy will begin procuring an owner's project manager in May.

84
00:28:55.279 --> 00:29:10.480
Madison Park will be starting the eligibility period on July 1st. Under the accelerated repair program led by our operations division, 34 projects have completed construction. One is

85
00:29:10.480 --> 00:29:27.679
currently in construction and seven are in design slated for 2027 construction and eight projects will be starting design this summer. These collaborative efforts with the MSBA reflect $696

86
00:29:27.679 --> 00:29:45.760
million in construction costs with just over 263 million in reimbursement coming back to the city of Boston. We are excited to submit the statement of interest to the MSBA 2026 core

87
00:29:45.760 --> 00:30:00.880
program for the Melvin H. King South End Academy. If we are accepted into the program this year, the school will be on a path towards a significant capital investment in the future. I'll now pass it on to Dr. Harold Miller.

88
00:30:00.880 --> 00:30:17.919
>> Hello everyone, superintendent, chair, and school committee members. It's a great honor to be here to discuss uh not only the building project, but just a little bit about the Melvin H. King. So, the Melvin H. King Southern Academy is a specialized public day school serving

89
00:30:17.919 --> 00:30:34.720
students with diverse strengths and complex needs. As a special education program, Melvin H. King South Academy supports students from across the city who have not been well served in traditional settings. As the district has expanded inclusive

90
00:30:34.720 --> 00:30:53.760
practices and increased therapeutic supports in traditional schools, enrollment has declined. Overall enrollment has increased from approximately 300 students in 2020 to 160 in 2023 and 80 students in 2025.

91
00:30:53.760 --> 00:31:10.640
After COVID, the roll out of the inclusive education plan and the redesign of entry and exit criteria to better align the least restrictive environment have also contributed to this decline. In 2024,

92
00:31:10.640 --> 00:31:27.279
Superintendent Skipper established a moratorum on new placements to initiate a comprehensive reset and restructure of the school's leadership, staff, and support model for school year 2627. Enrollment is projected at approximately

93
00:31:27.279 --> 00:31:43.760
65 students. Melvin H. King Southn Academy is now in an active rebuilding phase, grounded in the Melvin H. King way asking ourselves what would Melvin H. King do and our core values safety respect

94
00:31:43.760 --> 00:32:00.320
responsibility perseverance and kindness and a clear commitment to equitydriven transformation through extensive engagement with school and district community members. Five strategic goals and priorities have been identified. One being highquality

95
00:32:00.320 --> 00:32:17.919
therapeutic and academic programming. Second, operational systems alignment, external collaboration and partnerships, especially with inter aent inter agency collaboration and alignment, physical plant improvements, and clear entry and

96
00:32:17.919 --> 00:32:34.000
exit protocols. This work will be supported by an August institute to align all staff along with tiered home and community visits prior to the start of the school year. Looking ahead, Melvin H. King Southern Academy

97
00:32:34.000 --> 00:32:51.039
is transitioning to a 5 through 12th grade model with long-term enrollment projected at approximately 100 students. And I'll pass it back to Chief Status Los. >> Thank you. For context, the school was previously split across three buildings,

98
00:32:51.039 --> 00:33:06.399
all of which are amount amongst the lowest quality facilities in the district according to the district-wide facilities condition assessment. In school year 2526, the school vacated the St. Mary's space. And in school year

99
00:33:06.399 --> 00:33:23.600
2627, the Melvin H. King South End Academy will vacate the Peterborough building and consolidate into one building on Warrenav in the South End. If this project advances into the eligibility phase, the MSBA will evaluate the Warrenav site along with

100
00:33:23.600 --> 00:33:42.960
other potential locations. The current facility was not designed to be a therapeutic school and it is in poor condition. According to our facilities condition assessment across every domain, the building at Warren A fails

101
00:33:42.960 --> 00:33:57.919
falls sorry well below the district's average. We are confident in this application to invest in this community. I'm going to be honest, the MSBA core projects and all construction projects take time. If we are accepted into this

102
00:33:57.919 --> 00:34:14.639
program, there are years of planning and design work with the school community. Construction likely would not begin until 2031 per the timeline for the MSBA projects. As with all of our MSBA core projects,

103
00:34:14.639 --> 00:34:30.399
this is a multi-generational investment, and our facilities and operation teams will continue to make all necessary upgrades to maintain a safe, well functioning learning space for students. In the meantime,

104
00:34:30.399 --> 00:34:46.480
for next steps on this application, we are asking for your vote tonight. The statement of interest is due this Friday, April 17th, and we've been working closely with the school community to prepare it. We expect to hear about advancement at the end of

105
00:34:46.480 --> 00:35:11.200
2026, and we'll keep you updated. This concludes our presentation and I'll now pass it back to the chair. >> Thank you. I'll now open it up to questions and comments from the committee. Go ahead. >> Um, first of all, thank you so much for

106
00:35:11.200 --> 00:35:26.640
the presentation and I just have a quick question. Since the school serve students with complex academic and social emotional needs, how will students be involved in like the designing or giving feedback of um on

107
00:35:26.640 --> 00:35:42.560
the new facility and programs? >> Thank you for that question. um as part of the MSBA um design process um the the when we select a design team for the MSBA um it includes a team that focuses

108
00:35:42.560 --> 00:35:58.640
on engaging the community as part of that engagement work students teachers community members of the um Melvin HK King community will be engaged um as part of that process so there's a dedicated team that leads the engagement

109
00:35:58.640 --> 00:36:20.200
>> all right thank you >> welcome Okay, sure. >> Hi. Um, assuming that everything goes as planned and

110
00:36:20.560 --> 00:36:44.000
M MSBA approved uh our project the construction will start in 2031. >> Yes, 2031. How come it takes that long from now is 20 26? >> Y >> so the process of getting paper and

111
00:36:44.000 --> 00:37:00.480
everything takes about five years. >> Yeah. So we currently have three other projects in the MSBA um pipeline. So currently we have the Shaw Taylor that's heading into design. We have the Root Batson and also Madison Park. Um, and

112
00:37:00.480 --> 00:37:17.680
with that, we will go into the eligibility period for the MSBA if selected at the end of the year. So, usually we'll hear back from the MSBA in December. Um, so that takes a couple of months and it takes um about sort of closer to another year to move through

113
00:37:17.680 --> 00:37:34.720
the the eligibility period. And then there's procurement timelines to procure an an owner's project manager. Um and once an ownus project manager is on board, it takes like another um it's like another like long timeline to procure a designer to go through the

114
00:37:34.720 --> 00:37:50.560
process. It's quite an extensive process and when we're going into design um we the engagement piece is really extensive engaging students and families and staff. Um because a part of this is like we want to do it right. We're building a

115
00:37:50.560 --> 00:38:05.599
building that will be in our community for generations to come. Yeah. So, while the construction wouldn't happen until then, there's many other parts that of engagement with the community um building out their educ our

116
00:38:05.599 --> 00:38:22.160
educational vision for it. Um all of So, the community will be very much involved in all of that over the three years leading up to when construction actually happens. >> I see. Just just another um

117
00:38:22.160 --> 00:38:38.720
dumb question from me. Uh given the the project of of this size and that it takes a while to to to put together you know uh the construction

118
00:38:38.720 --> 00:38:56.160
and and and to complete it u during that time. Is there any inind from from us or is that or the the uh the money comes directly from from MSBA? >> Sorry, do you mind repeating the

119
00:38:56.160 --> 00:39:11.760
question? >> What I'm asking is uh the the process is pretty lengthy. >> Yep. >> And the there are steps along the line. >> Yes. >> The the final uh budget for the for for

120
00:39:11.760 --> 00:39:28.800
the construction Will it be 100% from MSBA or is there a uh >> No, no, >> no. >> Good. >> Okay. Um um no. Uh MSBA does not cover

121
00:39:28.800 --> 00:39:46.400
100% of the cost. um when we hear back from the MSBA in December, if we're moving through the eligibility period, we'll go through um we'll go to the city council to request um the first phase, which is a smaller amount of money um to cover like cost through the eligibility

122
00:39:46.400 --> 00:40:03.200
period. Um and um we'll go back to the city council a second time, but this is uh the MSBA and Brian Mclofflin is here. he can share the percentage in which we we are reimbursed by the MSBA um on

123
00:40:03.200 --> 00:40:18.000
projects. So it's not a they don't fully cover the cost. Um there is a certain percentage that the city is like reimbursed on all of on all of the MSBA projects. >> Sure. So >> Brian, can you come up to the mic just because the people at home need

124
00:40:18.000 --> 00:40:32.880
>> um the calculation rate for MSBA projects are calculated on an annual basis for 2025. um the reimbursement rate will be just over 61%. >> 61% >> um but by the time we enter into the feasibility study agreement with the

125
00:40:32.880 --> 00:40:48.400
MSBA it may change. They usually don't fluctuate that much. So it'll be probably around 60% of eligible costs >> I see >> of the project. >> So the changes may be increased in terms of uh reimbursement or is there a

126
00:40:48.400 --> 00:41:05.200
likelihood of of of that um being somehow decreased? Yeah, it it will likely be right around that 60% over the past several years. We've seen it fluctuate from high 50s to the low 60s. So, it's usually right around that. >> I see. And of course, we have budget for

127
00:41:05.200 --> 00:41:20.000
that. >> So, this will come out of capital um capital dollars. Uh but again, with capital because we have three large projects that are over the course of the next five years, this is a little bit more forward-looking. But in order to be

128
00:41:20.000 --> 00:41:37.760
considered, we have to enter eligibility now. Thank you. >> Um, this might be I'm sorry. Did you I'm sorry. Um, this might be too premature as we're not talking about breaking ground until 2031.

129
00:41:37.760 --> 00:41:53.200
Um, but has there been any consideration around the particular staffing model that might exist like at this like at this school? >> So, Dr. Miller um and the staff uh

130
00:41:53.200 --> 00:42:10.960
leadership at Mel H Melvin H. King has been doing a lot of work around this as part of the rebuild. H you want to speak to that? >> Yes. Uh what I'll just say is that um right now with the student population decreasing um we have had cuts but we

131
00:42:10.960 --> 00:42:28.280
were at a 3:1 ratio with staffing. We're at a 1:1 ratio right now. So, we still do have enough staffing to support the project to 65 students. Um, I could break it down by teachers. I mean, we have a lot of different roles, but um staffing wise, we're in a good place.

132
00:42:29.119 --> 00:42:47.359
>> Yeah, they've come up with a um a true therapeutic design >> so that it's teams of teachers that are supporting and grade appropriate. So instead of stretching across, you know, a second or first grade to graduation,

133
00:42:47.359 --> 00:43:03.599
they're really focusing on grade appropriate 5 through 12, >> particularly with the high school component of building out the things that high schoolers want >> and need. Um because for too for too long, we've asked students with the highest level of need to trade off

134
00:43:03.599 --> 00:43:19.920
getting that need fulfilled for sacrificing these other things. And we cannot do that anymore. >> Right. And and I would also just add that aligning to Mass Core and making sure that we have, you know, we offer Spanish classes, we offer instructional technology, we offer cosmetology,

135
00:43:19.920 --> 00:43:38.480
um art, and just making sure that students have a full experience. >> I think that um connects well to um one of my questions which was around the ultimate enrollment go uh goal. I think Dr. Dr. Miller, you said that for um the longer term it's at 100 students. And

136
00:43:38.480 --> 00:43:55.760
I'm curious um whether that's because of the narrowing of focus to grades 5 through 12, whether that's because we're coming down to a single site or whether that's actually the full need of the student um fit for that level of therapeutic care. Um just transparently

137
00:43:55.760 --> 00:44:11.119
having a a building that's going to receive that level of investment and will have the academic program to match. I think the natural question is why not more than a hundred if it serves the students well? And so I'm just curious on on where that number comes from.

138
00:44:11.119 --> 00:44:27.200
>> Well, obviously we've had a lot of data over years where we're looking at enrollment patterns as well as with our inclusive education plan. So schools are building capacity to um you know keep students and not just move them. And then at the same time we're looking at

139
00:44:27.200 --> 00:44:43.839
the Melvin H. King as a sort of a bridge in a way that when a student comes to Melvin King, if they're referred to Melvin King, one, what is the support that the school needs to refer a student? How are we um transitioning a student, but also how are we um making

140
00:44:43.839 --> 00:45:01.040
sure that students don't just stay at the Mel King and they can actually go back to a traditional setting. So, that is a shift. Um as we know for many years students would go and too many would just stay for many years. and we're trying to look at if a student does enter, how long does that need to be?

141
00:45:01.040 --> 00:45:16.400
And um using the expertise of the sending school, the expertise of our current um staff to really look at a lot of data to determine how long a student needs to stay. >> Yeah. And I also I think that Dr. Miller and Principal O'Shea have done a really

142
00:45:16.400 --> 00:45:31.440
good job with staff of establishing clear entrance criteria, which I don't think was in place. And so what you actually had were students being assigned to a more restrictive setting than they needed. This is the most

143
00:45:31.440 --> 00:45:48.000
restrictive setting we have in the sense of much like the Carter, it is a particular profile of student that needs the therapeutic component. Um and so this would be a step even beyond a self-contained program.

144
00:45:48.000 --> 00:46:02.960
We just need to make sure that students are appropriate for that setting. And to Dr. Miller's point, that we are building up for students and stabilizing students and giving them the skills and supports

145
00:46:02.960 --> 00:46:19.359
so that they can re-enter a less restrictive environment with the right supports. So that's much different than what has happened over history with Melvin H. King School. And so the hundred is a fluid number,

146
00:46:19.359 --> 00:46:36.240
>> right? Not the goal that like like other schools you fill at 100 and you keep the hundred. The hundred students today are going to look different than the hundred students next year. They're going to be different kids. >> That that said, are is the plan to still ensure that it's a diploma granting

147
00:46:36.240 --> 00:46:51.760
institution? >> Yes, absolutely. >> Yes. And with you know the narrower um criteria as are you imagining potential out of district placements as well as a therapeutic day school I mean meaning

148
00:46:51.760 --> 00:47:07.440
receiving from other districts? >> Yes potentially. So Melvin H. King always had a history of when a student would come from another district or come from an out of district school, if the IEP were appropriate and the services needed, they would um they would be able

149
00:47:07.440 --> 00:47:23.520
to attend Melvin H. King to get those needs met, that would continue. I think the the main uh point with that Dr. Miller made is that the goal here is mass core for our students at Melvin H. King going forward. Um, and so that is

150
00:47:23.520 --> 00:47:39.440
the academic and the rigor of the academic will be there but with therapeutic support. That is the goal. So whether a student is there freshman year or sophomore year and they're attaining their credits and then going back into another high school, that student can take those mass core

151
00:47:39.440 --> 00:47:54.480
eligible credits with them. >> Right. Um my last question was just um where this falls kind of in the larger long-term facilities planning in terms of how was Melvin H. King South End

152
00:47:54.480 --> 00:48:10.880
Academy going to be modernized and addressed without MSBA or was the plan always for MSBA but the opportunity has come earlier than expected? Um just where does this fall in our larger view of of plans for for schools across the

153
00:48:10.880 --> 00:48:26.480
district? >> Um so uh so on the for the Melvin H. King and where it falls into sort of like the broader investments across like um capital. So um there is um as I think

154
00:48:26.480 --> 00:48:43.359
everyone probably knows there's like a list of schools right um that we have like or made commitment to so mayor superintendent has made um sort of like capital commitment to and one of the things that our team does um year

155
00:48:43.359 --> 00:48:58.720
overyear as we're looking at mergers and closures right we have we do sort of like a comprehensive look across all of our schools, high schools, elementary schools, where we can do either larger

156
00:48:58.720 --> 00:49:14.960
investments or smaller investments. Melvin H. King is one of the schools back in 2022 um where a commitment was made um for a new building um for that school community. some vision and work started

157
00:49:14.960 --> 00:49:32.160
then um and it ended at vision and work um and so this is like a next step forward in the process um I think all of the schools that we have moved forward with some sort of vision and work andor commitment was made to communities um

158
00:49:32.160 --> 00:49:47.680
and I think one of the things that was really essential before we could move forward with any of that work we had to do the facilities condition assessment to understand buildings and we had to have a a long-term facilities plan and also look at data to think through how

159
00:49:47.680 --> 00:50:09.839
are we um how are we sort of like right doing some right sizing work in the district and where we should actually be investing year overyear. So this is some of the work that the um our team has been doing. >> Thank you for your presentation. um very

160
00:50:09.839 --> 00:50:25.839
excited to see this coming before us and not only just about the building itself, which as you said going back to 2022, there was a promise, but the fact that this time as we move forward, we're taking a strong look at the overall programming

161
00:50:25.839 --> 00:50:43.520
um to make sure that the programming for this this group of students um is what it needs to be. Um, many people have said that the school has just been a landing place disproportionately for black and brown young men. Um, and that

162
00:50:43.520 --> 00:50:58.640
the fact that we are going from 300 to 80 to 65 to 100 means that we are taking a look at these young people as individuals and looking across our district to create the better kinds of

163
00:50:58.640 --> 00:51:14.960
opportunities for them. So, um, looking forward to seeing what this school can become, um, as a model for us as we think about some of our most vulnerable students in terms of creating a wide

164
00:51:14.960 --> 00:51:33.119
range of opportunities so that they can get their needs met. So, thank you and we look forward to taking action on this um, later this evening. >> Thank you. Thank you. >> Thank you, team. >> Thank you. So we will move on to general public

165
00:51:33.119 --> 00:51:48.960
comment. Miss Parex. >> Thank you chair. The public comment period is an opportunity for individuals to address the school committee on school related issues. Questions on specific school matters are referred to the superintendent. Questions on policy matters may be discussed by the

166
00:51:48.960 --> 00:52:05.200
committee later. The meeting will feature two public comment periods with the first comment period limited to one hour. After one hour, anyone who hasn't testified will have the opportunity to do so at the end of the meeting. We have 20 speakers this evening. Each person

167
00:52:05.200 --> 00:52:22.000
will have two minutes to speak, and I will remind you when you have 30 seconds remaining. Please feel free to email your comments for distribution to the committee. Speakers may not reassign their time to others. The time that an interpreter uses for English interpretation will not be deducted from

168
00:52:22.000 --> 00:52:37.920
a speaker's allotted time. Please direct your comments to the chair and refrain from addressing individual school committee members or district staff. Please note the comments of any public speaker do not represent the Boston public schools or the Boston school committee. Please state your name,

169
00:52:37.920 --> 00:52:53.760
affiliation, and where you live. Before you begin, please sign in on Zoom using the name you registered with for public comment and be ready to unmute and turn on your camera when it's your turn to speak. Please raise your virtual hand when I call your name. And to support interpretation, please speak slowly and

170
00:52:53.760 --> 00:53:11.079
clearly. We will start with our in um with our in-person speakers. Um our first speakers are John Mud, Julian Leani, Julia Morales, and Betsy Santana. John Mud.

171
00:53:23.920 --> 00:53:40.960
Good evening. My name is John Mud. I'm a a resident of Cambridge, a longtime education advocate in Boston. Uh the 2026 opportunity and achievement gap policy of the opportunity and achievement gap task force that will be presented to you later tonight is often

172
00:53:40.960 --> 00:53:56.000
eloquent, thoughtful, and thorough. I strongly urge the school committee to adopt it as the official policy of EPS. Most important, it continues the commitment to the elimination of opportunity and achievement gaps as the

173
00:53:56.000 --> 00:54:12.480
north star priority for the district and makes clear that it will remain a core and urgent priority for the district regardless of challenges changes, excuse me, in leadership. It ensures that the OAG task force will serve as the

174
00:54:12.480 --> 00:54:27.599
external advisory board of the school committee. It states the superintendent will appoint a senior leader reporting directly to the superintendent with authority to coordinate and monitor all aspects of the policy. It reaffirms the

175
00:54:27.599 --> 00:54:44.400
racial, cultural and linguistic diversity of teachers and paraprofessionals shall reflect the diversity of the students and it speaks to the importance of establishing measurable annual goals and accountability on an issue I have testified about repeatedly. It

176
00:54:44.400 --> 00:55:00.079
establishes a priority for the significant expansion of bilingual education and the development of long-term plans with clear goals and timetables to guide the growth of bilingual education programs for multilingual learners and the

177
00:55:00.079 --> 00:55:16.960
recruitment of bilingual educators. As policy, all of this is admirable and should be adopted. But as long-term observer, we all know that the critical issue for overcoming opportunity and achievement gaps is implementation. I hope you adopt the the plan and

178
00:55:16.960 --> 00:55:35.079
policy, but I also implore you to follow up with urgency to monitor programs to insist on change where it is necessary. And thank you. >> Our next speaker is Jillian Lani.

179
00:55:36.079 --> 00:56:12.319
Julian Lurani. We will continue with Julia Morales. Betsy Santana. Good evening, members of the school committee. My name is Betsy Santana. I'm a BPS alum and licensed independent clinical social worker in Boston public schools with nearly two decades of

180
00:56:12.319 --> 00:56:28.400
experience serving students and families in high need communities. I'm here today not to criticize but to bring clarity to a critical gap that directly impacts student care, staff safety, sta safety, and district liability. BPS social

181
00:56:28.400 --> 00:56:44.480
workers are being asked to provide clinical services, including IEP counseling, crisis intervention, and trauma-informed care. Yet, there is no consistent district-wide structure for clinical supervision to support the work. In any other clinical setting, this would be not optional. It would be

182
00:56:44.480 --> 00:56:59.760
required. Without supervision, there is no standardization of oversight of clinical quality. Social workers are left personally liable for complex clinical decisions. Staff are navigating trauma-heavy environments without adequate professional support and

183
00:56:59.760 --> 00:57:15.440
ultimately students receive inconsistent levels of care across schools. This is not just a workforce issue. This is a system and riskmanagement issue. We cannot define this role as cl as clinical and convenient and then fail to provide the clinical infrastructure that

184
00:57:15.440 --> 00:57:31.040
sustains it. I also want to name that many social workers have been operating in silence without clarity, without communication and without support. That silence is now breaking and what is surfacing is concern, confusion and in some cases harm. We have an opportunity

185
00:57:31.040 --> 00:57:48.559
right now to correct this. My ask is simple and actionable. Establish a district-wide clinical supervision structure for social workers align with lensure requirements. compensate and utilize independently licensed clinicians to provide supervision as a standard across all clinical fields.

186
00:57:48.559 --> 00:58:04.480
Create a clinician-led advisory group to help design and implement this structure with fidelity and sustainability. We are not asking for anything extra. We are asking for alignment between what is expected of us and what is required to do that work safely and and efficiently. >> Thank you.

187
00:58:04.480 --> 00:58:27.359
>> Thank you. Our next speak, our next group of speakers, um, our next speakers are an Hernandez, Julie Valencia, and Pete Mullen. >> Good evening, chair person and members of the school committee and superintendent skipper, and thank you

188
00:58:27.359 --> 00:58:41.920
for the opportunity to speak. My name is Annne Hernandez. I'm a BPS alum, a Boston resident, and a social worker for the last 26 years. I want to put a a human face on what it means to four district social workers, which includes

189
00:58:41.920 --> 00:58:59.760
a Slife um DSW from next year's budget cuts. Cutting three district social workers from next year's budget is not a small adjustment as it directly affects 37 schools, over 13,000 students, and 71 school-based social workers who will not

190
00:58:59.760 --> 00:59:15.760
have who will have to be redistributed to the six remaining district social workers. These roles are student centered positions that anchor safety, stability, and coherence across our systems. The district social workers currently lead high level case

191
00:59:15.760 --> 00:59:32.480
consultations, provide ongoing mentoring and clinical support to school-based social workers, train staff in deescalation, safety care, and trauma responsive practices. In 2024 2025, we trained 329 BPS staff and 179 to date

192
00:59:32.480 --> 00:59:49.760
this school year. We are also the district's crisis response team. We coordinate safe, supported placement and transitions for v vulnerable students and strengthen student support teams. To make this cons more concrete, one of our district social workers, uh, who is

193
00:59:49.760 --> 01:00:04.400
currently not on the budget for next year, >> 30 seconds, >> I'm sorry, say that again. >> 30 seconds. >> 30 seconds. trained 140 staff members in safety care, provided 68 instances of clinical support and mentoring to school-based social workers, completed

194
01:00:04.400 --> 01:00:20.480
96 highlevel case consultations, coordinated support for 45 students in transition to ensure they landed in safe, supportive environments, participated in 49 student support teams. Eliminating four of these positions does not cut extras. It

195
01:00:20.480 --> 01:00:42.559
dismantles a critical safety and support infrastructure that holds our schools together on the hardest days. Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Our next speaker is Julie Valencia. Hello chairperson and members of the school committee. I'm Julie Valencia.

196
01:00:42.559 --> 01:00:58.480
I'm a district social worker. I live in West Roxbury. I am speaking tonight about the three district social worker positions being cut for the upcom up upcoming school year. This is a third of our team as there are 10 of us this year to support the nine school regions as well as the

197
01:00:58.480 --> 01:01:14.240
life programs. I urge you to reconsider this decision in order to provide the support that BPS students, families, and school communities deserve. While some aspects of the DSW role are systemic, there are also pieces of our role that include direct work with students and

198
01:01:14.240 --> 01:01:29.920
families. Most of our role, including both systemic and direct work, is done inside school buildings and in collaboration with school-based staff as well as with students and families when needed. In terms of direct support with students, we assist with crisis support and

199
01:01:29.920 --> 01:01:46.880
stabilization, risk assessments, and safety planning. We make up the crisis team that responds to school crises across the city. The crisis work includes supporting schools in the aftermath of school-based or community based emergencies, often for days after the event. We also

200
01:01:46.880 --> 01:02:02.720
provide the deescalation and physical management training for BPS schools. This de decrease in our team will affect our capacity to train schoolbased staff. Direct service work also includes IEP counseling, home visits, and parent

201
01:02:02.720 --> 01:02:19.040
interviews as part of the IEP evaluation process. These home visits with both schoolbased and district staff further fills the support gaps that schools struggle to meet, >> especially when there are barriers that impact students getting to school, such as chronic absenteeism, school

202
01:02:19.040 --> 01:02:34.640
avoidance, mental health needs, and other factors in the community that may impact students and families and their movement within their communities. Systemically, we work on lots of systems like school culture and climate, coaching, leading professional

203
01:02:34.640 --> 01:02:51.839
development, collaborating with student success teams, and streamlining resources across the city. >> Thank you. >> If you if you weren't able to finish it, the two speakers, you can always send the testimonies to me, okay? And then I

204
01:02:51.839 --> 01:03:19.920
send it to the members. Pete Mullen Um, good evening. Uh, my name is Pete Mullen. I'm an educator at the Curley School and a member of the Boston Teacher Union working group on multilingual education. I would like to comment on the opportunity and achievement gaps task force policy. As

205
01:03:19.920 --> 01:03:36.319
an educator for multilingual learners, I can speak for many of my colleagues when I say that this policy represents a welcome shift in our goals for multilingual learners. We're especially grateful to see the language that explicitly names that the cultural and linguistic assets of multilingual learners should be valued. We also appreciate the commitment to move with

206
01:03:36.319 --> 01:03:52.799
all deliberate speed to strengthen bilingual education and expand access to highquality programs that develop academic English while sustaining students home and native languages as well as the creation of a long-term plan with clear goals and timelines. In the BTU working group, we discuss what we

207
01:03:52.799 --> 01:04:08.799
see as best practices and challenges to ensuring multilingual learners have the best possible opportunities. We hope that the following ideas can also be considered going forward with this policy. to ensure that multilingual learners with suspected disabilities are assessed in their home language in order to properly identify learning

208
01:04:08.799 --> 01:04:24.400
challenges. To research and obtain strong native language curriculum with all of the materials, modification and training needed for full implementation. Provide full libraries of home language books, not just translated copies of English language titles. Provide

209
01:04:24.400 --> 01:04:40.799
meaningful teacher professional development for targeted language instruction and for language acquisition. hope that supporting and preparing teachers to acquire all the licenses and endorsements they need. Recruiting and retaining bilingual teachers requires clear accessible pathways to lensure and

210
01:04:40.799 --> 01:04:56.079
endorsements, but currently dual language bilingual teachers are expected to pass four MTELs and get two endorsements at a minimum. Lastly, a program review of inclusive SEI to ensure that multilingual learners are truly being provided with the best possible opport options for high

211
01:04:56.079 --> 01:05:12.480
achievement. multilingual learners being included in the same way as students with disabilities fails to value their cultural and linguistic assets, which is something this task force and educators of multilingual learners agree is incredibly important. Thank you. >> Thank you. We will now transition to our

212
01:05:12.480 --> 01:05:52.400
zoom our speakers on Zoom. Um the speakers are councelor Julia Mahia, Laa Larasoto, Kenneth Francisco, and Dora Sandoval. Councelor Mahia. Good evening. Can you hear me? >> Yes, we can hear you. You can start.

213
01:05:52.400 --> 01:06:06.960
>> Okay. >> Uh good evening um members of the school committee and the superintendent. Uh today I just want to quickly uh speak on the impact of the district social workers cuts will have on Boston public schools. As a city counselor who

214
01:06:06.960 --> 01:06:24.720
represents all of Boston, the families and the faculty and staff. Right now, four positions are being eliminated, including three regional district social workers. These roles have um supported 37 schools and over 13,000 students, and

215
01:06:24.720 --> 01:06:41.839
they provide guidance to more than 70 school-based social workers across those schools. Their work includes um crisis response, staff training, and helping schools navigate complex student needs. They also pay play a role in supporting

216
01:06:41.839 --> 01:06:58.319
the school climate and making sure that uh the teams have what they need to respond effectively. With these cuts, the number of district social workers goes from 9 to six. The responsibilities do not change, but the capacity does.

217
01:06:58.319 --> 01:07:16.160
Schools will be reassigned. casea case loads will increase and there will be less availability for training crisis response and the day-to-day support. We're also hearing concerns from staff about feeling um limited in their ability to advocate which is something

218
01:07:16.160 --> 01:07:31.200
that we should take seriously. I'm asking that these positions be reconsidered and that these core supports for students and school communities um and reducing them and the real impact that they have. And I'll just end with, you know, at a time when we're dealing with so much on the

219
01:07:31.200 --> 01:07:47.760
national level and families are dealing with a lot of crisis now more than ever, we need to make sure that at the very least in our schools are we're equipped to be able to support the social and emotional um well-being of all of our students, especially in this moment in time. And I ask the committee to

220
01:07:47.760 --> 01:08:11.640
reconsider these cuts. Thank you. >> Thank you, counselor. Our next two speakers are not signing to the meeting. So we will continue with Dora Sandoval and she will be um we need a Spanish interpretation for her. Dora sandoval.

221
01:08:23.279 --> 01:08:51.359
Hello. >> Okay. >> Can you hear me? Hello, my name is Sonia and I live in the uh Good afternoon. My name is uh Sonia Sandoval and I live in the community of Roxberry and I am also

222
01:08:51.359 --> 01:09:40.560
I serve as a coordinator at the program at St. Stevens. >> I want to begin by sharing a personal story. Um, which I feel very proud of. Um so last week um so about this personal story I am a mother of two

223
01:09:40.560 --> 01:09:57.360
children and one of them attends the Hurley school and my other student um attends 12th grade. And actually last week we received a wonderful news that he got accepted to the University of Norristo and he actually received a full

224
01:09:57.360 --> 01:10:42.800
scholarship that is going to cover tuition and other expenses 100%. And this is just an example as a mother that I'm very proud of because this represents the years of hope, sacrifice and also hard work. And this story is an example of what is

225
01:10:42.800 --> 01:10:57.840
possible. when given real opportunities for families. And it is not a coincidence, but it is a result of hard work and also programs, educational programs, bilingual programs that support students. For instance, these programs that supported my son in being

226
01:10:57.840 --> 01:11:56.000
able to develop trust in himself and um Go. For talesa. And this is why I am in full support and I appreciate the 2026 policy to eliminate the opportunity and

227
01:11:56.000 --> 01:12:20.159
achievement gaps because this policy strengthens the equity and and to be able to appreciate the different languages of students. And it also recognizes that the families are a core um a fundamental and core

228
01:12:20.159 --> 01:13:06.719
part of of the development of our children. Inverases. And my story is not the only one and it's not unique. Um it is one of many stories and this is what happens when the correct investments are made in

229
01:13:06.719 --> 01:13:28.239
students and families and communities that are the key for full opportunities to be just. Thank you so much. Next speakers are Dedra Manning, Ari Brandt, Hi Hayden Shernov, and Yaris

230
01:13:28.239 --> 01:13:52.719
Matias. Dedra Manning. >> Good evening. My name is Dear Ger Manning. I am a Dorchester resident and parent of two public school students. I wanted to remind the school committee and district staff that superintendent

231
01:13:52.719 --> 01:14:09.280
Skipper promised now three admission cycles ago that she would provide us with data on student outcomes. And as of yet, my understanding is that data has not been released and rather than hiring a consultant or doing it inhouse, it's been farmed out to um two different two

232
01:14:09.280 --> 01:14:24.400
separate groups of graduate students at two different universities, I feel this information is critical and it really should be provided. um already should have provided. Um this evening I wanted to speak about um charter school students. So charter school students

233
01:14:24.400 --> 01:14:39.679
some of them receive standardsbased grades. These are the grades that BPS fifth graders receive. But BPS fifth graders because the district understood that these grades were a barrier for these students to get into exam schools.

234
01:14:39.679 --> 01:14:57.120
They devised a special process that would allow BPS students only to receive a bit of a boost um when converting those grades to the A to F or the I don't know um 1 to 11 scale that is used for calculation for the composite score.

235
01:14:57.120 --> 01:15:14.320
Boston Collegiate is a charter school. Boston Conservatory Lab is another charter schools that uses standardsbased grades with four inputs just like Boston public schools do. Am I understanding that Excel Academy, a charter school, >> uses standardsbased grades but with only

236
01:15:14.320 --> 01:15:31.199
state inputs. So I would like the school committee to look into why there isn't this process allowed for these um charter school students. I wanted to remind people that these are exam school seats are publicly funded educational opportunities and there shouldn't be a

237
01:15:31.199 --> 01:16:01.920
special process for BPS students that is not allowed for nonBPS students. This is not equitable and something should be done to fix it. Thank you. >> Thank you. Our next speaker is Ari Brands. All right. Um, good evening everyone. My

238
01:16:01.920 --> 01:16:17.920
name is Ari Brans. I'm a resident of Matipan and the co-executive director of St. Stevens Youth Programs. However, tonight I'm here representing the Multilingual Learners Alliance or the MLA. The MLA is a broad coalition of parents, teachers, education experts,

239
01:16:17.920 --> 01:16:33.040
and advocates who are committed to improving the education of multilingual learners in the Boston public schools. We have some core principles that we're advocating for. Add languages, don't lose them. Substantially increase access to bilingual education programs.

240
01:16:33.040 --> 01:16:48.480
meaningfully engage families, develop a city-wide assetbased mindset on multilingualism, recruit, develop, and retain bilingual staff, um, spend Title One funds equitably and with accountability, and provide appropriate services for

241
01:16:48.480 --> 01:17:04.000
multilingual learners with disabilities. We are so glad to see these policies reflected, these principles reflected in essential ways in the revised policy of the opportunity and achievement gap task force being presented to you tonight. It calls for expanding access to bilingual

242
01:17:04.000 --> 01:17:20.640
education with a long-term plan that has explicit goals and timelines. A long-term plan to expand the number of bilingual educators, encouraging the use of home language by parents, and recognizing the importance of home language in the education of MLS with disabilities and so much more. We urge

243
01:17:20.640 --> 01:17:36.320
you to make this the official policy of the school committee and implement it. It's time for a fresh start on this issue. It's time to have a policy for MLS that we can all join hands and rally behind. >> 30 seconds. >> Since our inception, the MLA has been anxious to work with the district in

244
01:17:36.320 --> 01:17:52.159
joining together with our mutual resources and energies to improve the education of MLS and MLS with disabilities. This new policy presents us with that opportunity. We strongly encourage you to approve the revised OAG policy. Thank you so much.

245
01:17:52.159 --> 01:18:18.400
>> Thank you very much. Our next speaker is Hayden Cherno. Hi, my name is Hayden Cherno. I am a Boston public schools alum, class of 2023 and the current community liaison for the Center for Law and Education or CLLE. At CLE, we work with families and

246
01:18:18.400 --> 01:18:35.520
advocates to help students, especially students with disabilities, access the education they are entitled to under the law. We are a legal resource and advocacy organization focused on ensuring that all students, particularly those from low-income communities, can learn to high standards. I'm here today

247
01:18:35.520 --> 01:18:51.679
to speak about the MCCAST alternative assessment or MCCASA alt. While passing MCCAST is no longer a graduation requirement, all students are still expected to learn grade level content. But students identified as having the quote most significant cognitive disabilities may be placed on the MCCAST

248
01:18:51.679 --> 01:19:07.360
ALT. And in practice, once students are placed on this track, they can be taught to lower standards and to lower expectations. This has serious consequences. We continue to see that multilingual learners, black and Latinx students, and students from lowincome families are

249
01:19:07.360 --> 01:19:23.280
disproportionately placed on this track. Through our work with families, we've seen that some students can be placed on the MCCAST AL inappropriately and are not fully informed about what that placement means. And that's where we see CL's work come in. We offer trainings to help families understand what the MCCAST

250
01:19:23.280 --> 01:19:39.120
AL is, what their rights are, and how to best advocate and prepare their children for success. We would welcome the opportunity to partner with the district and community organizations in making sure parents understand how this system works and how to support their child in a pathway to success. For more

251
01:19:39.120 --> 01:20:03.840
information and interest, please reach out to the Center for Law and Education. Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Marius Matias is our next speaker. Hi, good evening. My name is Mari Matias

252
01:20:03.840 --> 01:20:22.320
and I live in South. I'm a single mom. My son I'm a single mom of two. My son attended O'Brien Math Math and Science High School. and as and as well I'm a former a BPS graduated

253
01:20:22.320 --> 01:20:39.199
and a par professional and I would like to uh to thank the dean that worked so hard on the 2026 policy to promote the academic excellence and eliminate opportunities and achievements gap by

254
01:20:39.199 --> 01:20:55.040
consider the families and the community and the usage actions. I would like to tell you a little bit about my story. When I was a a youth and in the opport when I was a youth, when I came to this country at 13 years

255
01:20:55.040 --> 01:21:12.320
old, I came with not um not but not knowing any English and not understanding anything at all. I was lucky enough to came to a high school which had a vocational program and also

256
01:21:12.320 --> 01:21:27.760
a bilingual program thanks to my parents to enroll me to that school. I'm a I'm proud to say that I'm bilingual right now and I graduated high school and thanks to that I passed my par

257
01:21:27.760 --> 01:21:44.000
profofessional exam. I'm ready to go back to BPS to become an Thanks again to the team for your hard work and creating and to keep advocating to creating new bilingual programs and

258
01:21:44.000 --> 01:22:01.440
opportunity to new students that like me come to this country not knowing English and having this program accessible for them will be great addition to their education. Thank you. >> Thank you. Our next speakers are Katie Dear Rosa,

259
01:22:01.440 --> 01:22:31.600
George Physic, and David Dave Edwards, Katie Dear Rosa. Good evening. My name is Katie Darosa. I'm the inclusion liaison at the Boston Teachers Union and I'm a Boston resident. Tonight I'm representing the BTU inclusion done right committee to

260
01:22:31.600 --> 01:22:48.320
speak in support of the opportunity and achievement gaps policy specifically objective 3.9 advancing inclusion and accelerating learning for students with disabilities. We believe that the policy correctly centers equity for black, latino, and multilingual learners with disabilities

261
01:22:48.320 --> 01:23:04.960
to have full access to inclusive settings and grade level curriculum. We applaud the goals of reducing the disproportionate placement of black and Latino boys in substantially separate settings and reducing the concentration of students with disabilities in chronically underperforming and

262
01:23:04.960 --> 01:23:20.719
transformation schools. As a committee, we have an urgent ask which is to pair the policy's commitments with fully funded implementation of evidence-based models and resources. We ask for the school committee and the OAG task force to include the following recommendations

263
01:23:20.719 --> 01:23:37.360
to the policy implementation. One, appropriately value the role of the paraprofessional as an essential member of the inclusive instructional team. Two, adopt and scale proven inclusive instructional models and ensure classroom teams receive sustained

264
01:23:37.360 --> 01:23:54.560
collaboration time and professional development. Three, require fidelity checks for IEP referral processes and resource allocations to ensure the necessary supports are consistently provided for students with disabilities to have access to grade level standard.

265
01:23:54.560 --> 01:24:10.000
>> We urge you to pair the priorities of closing opportunity gaps and reducing disproportionate restrictive pl placements with the proven tools, sustained funding and accountability needed to implement at scale. Thank you. >> Thank you very much. Our next five

266
01:24:10.000 --> 01:24:25.760
speakers are not signed into the meeting. So we that concludes public comment chair. >> Thank you. >> Thank you Miss Parex and thank you to those of you who spoke this evening and shared your perspectives. Your testimony

267
01:24:25.760 --> 01:24:44.719
is very important to us. Our two first action items this evening are the grants for approval totallying $478,158.82 82 cents and the inind donation for approval totaling $1,500. Now, I'd like to turn it over to the

268
01:24:44.719 --> 01:25:00.000
superintendent for any final comments. Uh, wonderful. Thank you, chair. So, uh, as chair said, nine grants for your consideration tonight, uh, totaling more than $478,000. The largest grants are a $200,000

269
01:25:00.000 --> 01:25:17.440
Massachusetts Department of Education playground earmark increasing uh increase which then serves 1,68 students at the O'Donnell and Hail Elementary Schools and English High School for the redesign and rehabilitation of outdoor

270
01:25:17.440 --> 01:25:34.320
recreation spaces for students of varying abilities including multi-port courts and playground and exercise equipment. Second is a more than $66,000 community biodiversity grant serving

271
01:25:34.320 --> 01:25:49.520
2,339 students at the Curley Hurley and Higginson Lewis K28. So, Baby Higgy and the 3 to8 Lee Academy and the Manning and King elementary schools. The funding

272
01:25:49.520 --> 01:26:06.159
will be used to restore degraded urban habitat by removing invasive species and restoring habitat for pollinators and birds that will serve as both a hands-on classroom and community garden.

273
01:26:06.159 --> 01:26:21.199
Next, there is a nearly $49,000 Aspen Challenge grant that will serve 112 students in 28 coaches across 14 schools. The funding will support the Aspen Challenge, a project-based program where students develop solutions to

274
01:26:21.199 --> 01:26:37.679
social issues in their communities, as you saw earlier in the presentation. And finally, every year, BPS receives a mid-year adjustment to our main federal entitlement grants that may result in an increase of funding to the district. The

275
01:26:37.679 --> 01:26:53.840
district will receive approximately $162,000 in addition in additional title one, two, three, and four funding from our federal grants through the state. These increases will fund academic instruction, student opportunities, and

276
01:26:53.840 --> 01:27:08.639
family engagement under title one, educator effectiveness under title two, English language uh acquisition under title three, and college and career readiness, social emotional wellness, and technology

277
01:27:08.639 --> 01:27:25.679
access under title 4. There is also before you an inind donation. Uh, this is from the friends of the Raphael Hernandez Dual Language School who have donated kindly an outdoor storage shed to the school valued at

278
01:27:25.679 --> 01:27:46.400
$1,500. We would ask the committee to vote in favor of accepting this donation as well as our grants. >> Thank you. I will now open it up to questions and comments from the committee. >> Anything? No.

279
01:27:46.400 --> 01:28:01.679
>> Okay. There's no further discussion. I will now entertain a motion to approve the grants as presented. Is there a motion? >> So move. >> Is there a second? >> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Is there any objection to approving the grants by unanimous

280
01:28:01.679 --> 01:28:17.280
consent? Hearing none, the grants are approved. And if there is no further discussion, I will now entertain a motion to approve the inind donation as presented. Is there a motion? So, >> thank you. Is there a second? >> Second.

281
01:28:17.280 --> 01:28:34.400
>> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? >> Is there any objection to approving the inind donation by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the inind donation is approved. Our third action item this evening is the approval of the MSBA core program

282
01:28:34.400 --> 01:28:50.159
2026 statement of interest for the Melvin H. King Southen Academy that was presented earlier tonight. Are there any additional questions or comments before we move to a vote? No. Okay. If there are no further

283
01:28:50.159 --> 01:29:05.679
questions, I will entertain a motion to approve the MSBA core program 2026 statement of interest for the Melvin H. Ken King Southbend Academy as presented. Is there a motion? >> So move. >> Is there a second? >> Second.

284
01:29:05.679 --> 01:29:21.520
>> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? >> Miss Provix, will you please call the role? Thank you, Chair. Dr. Alkins, >> yes. >> Mr. Peralta, Miss Pano Garcia, >> yes. >> Miss Torres, >> yes. >> Mr. Tran, >> yes. >> Miss Garrett,

285
01:29:21.520 --> 01:29:37.360
>> yes. >> Miss Robinson, >> yes. >> The motion is approved. >> Thank you. Our final action item this evening is the Mass Core graduation requirement policy amendment. As you might remember, this was presented at the March 25th meeting. I will now turn

286
01:29:37.360 --> 01:29:54.800
it over to the superintendent for final comments. Wonderful. And congratulations to the leadership and staff of the Melvin H. King Southend Academy. >> Uh so at the last school committee meeting on Wednesday, March 25th, uh my

287
01:29:54.800 --> 01:30:11.040
team presented an update on the Mass Core graduation requirement. Tonight, we are asking the committee to reaffirm our existing policy that states mass core is the BPS graduation requirement. In addition, we are asking members to approve our recommendations for

288
01:30:11.040 --> 01:30:26.560
alternative measures to address rare or extenduating circumstances. As we reviewed last week, Mass Core was first adopted by this committee in the spring of 2021. Over the past several years, we've been working to ensure that

289
01:30:26.560 --> 01:30:44.159
the course coding, standards, credits, and schedule alignment in our secondary schools meet the BPS mass core requirement. Over the past five years, we have made real progress in supporting our students toward Mass Core completion, including

290
01:30:44.159 --> 01:31:01.120
the use of highquality instructional materials, equitable literacy implementation, a review of the district's course catalog, 1,800 courses, early college and CTE pathway expansion, and AP, IB,

291
01:31:01.120 --> 01:31:16.880
art, and music classes, elective offerings, and course schedules to support Mass Core. Our school teams continue to work directly with students and families to ensure they are on track to meet the requirements of Mass Core or

292
01:31:16.880 --> 01:31:33.760
graduation in general and to help them get back on track if they're behind. Last week, we shared the details on the acceptable replacements and comparatable alternatives for different student groups. Many of these situations are addressed through DESIE guidance. We ask

293
01:31:33.760 --> 01:31:49.199
for the committee support of this vote tonight. Dr. Wright, deputy superintendent of academics, Brett Dickens, assistant superintendent, college, career and life readiness, and Dr. Angela Hedley Mitchell, chief of teaching and learning are all here

294
01:31:49.199 --> 01:32:10.639
tonight to assist with answering any remaining questions that members may have. Back to you, chair. >> Thank you. I'll now open it up to questions and comments from the committee. Garrett, >> thank you. Um I think that this is um an

295
01:32:10.639 --> 01:32:27.600
important carve out for special circumstances as we've discussed in detail in previous meetings. Uh really understanding that mass is the standard and the bar for the vast majority of students. >> And I think it's well timed that we are

296
01:32:27.600 --> 01:32:43.120
talking about strategic planning this evening. uh which we know will lead to some outcomes and measures discussion about what our set of metrics are going to be that will be examined every year and improved upon every year. Um and so

297
01:32:43.120 --> 01:32:59.120
I don't have a question. I just um really look forward to the percent of students graduating with Mass Core as an annual measure um that has an ambitious 5-year target um and that continues to

298
01:32:59.120 --> 01:33:16.000
increase every year just so that it's clear to us and to the public um that this is really a special circumstance um and that we are still seeking for the very vast majority of our students to earn um a ask for a diploma.

299
01:33:16.000 --> 01:33:43.600
>> Absolutely. >> Absolutely. >> Manka Garcia. >> Thank you, Madame Chair. Um I'd like to echo what my colleague is saying here regarding the vulnerability that our students the ELLs to English

300
01:33:43.600 --> 01:34:18.239
language students show when they come to this country. We have to take in consideration that the mass score is a great opportunity to improve the academic performance and preparedness of all our students. So you have to consider as well without

301
01:34:18.239 --> 01:34:34.719
the proper support we might be incurring in not promoting the equalities that should exist in our learners with our learners because we have to consider that there is the language vulnerability this

302
01:34:34.719 --> 01:35:05.679
population. >> Because it is important for the families to know that there is there will be an evaluation. There will be a team giving that particular evaluation. And we have to consider as well that every student has a vulnerability different

303
01:35:05.679 --> 01:35:21.679
vulnerability. >> Thank you for pay attention in that part because it's important for the students English learner you see the why is important the student English learner

304
01:35:21.679 --> 01:35:38.320
you superintendent your team putting attention in that. >> Thank you. Also building on that and what we heard from public comment today about really having an assetbased approach. Um my understanding is that a lot of examples

305
01:35:38.320 --> 01:35:55.520
of the exceptions that are considered is really giving honor to courses taken in other countries before students have transferred here and evaluating those transcripts really carefully and thoroughly as an example. Um, and also appreciate just the framing of the

306
01:35:55.520 --> 01:36:12.000
exceptions as being in the realm of similarity to the already existing alternative school requirements. Um, just as a frame for where that leniency might be and that there is kind of a floor that we're still expecting in in

307
01:36:12.000 --> 01:36:27.679
situations that are exceptions. >> Yeah. Thank you. >> Yes, I would echo that. And when I listen to you speak, I think about the original intent of the policy >> being to prepare students for all of the universities in Massachusetts and and

308
01:36:27.679 --> 01:36:43.280
reminding ourselves that that's why we're doing it. And so we see multilingualism as an asset. Um, and we want to make sure that all students can thrive, whatever their post-secondary path. And that's really why we we do what we do.

309
01:36:43.280 --> 01:36:59.040
>> Yeah. I just want to thank everybody who has worked on this over the years. Um when we first um approached this in 2021, I think we were naive as a school committee as to what it was. We were trying to make sure students who didn't

310
01:36:59.040 --> 01:37:15.360
have access to foreign language had access to it because we understood they couldn't they they they weren't having the courses because they weren't being offered. So, we knew that there were disparities in what the offerings were across our high schools. But, um, as the

311
01:37:15.360 --> 01:37:32.080
work moved forward, we saw that there were many, many disparities and issues that needed to be approved and the 1,800 courses that needed to be aligned and everything. So, I really want to thank the district for getting us thus far. um knowing that there still is work to do

312
01:37:32.080 --> 01:37:48.159
but that we are we are on our way and that I think our students will be better off for it with the opportunities. >> Absolutely >> right. So thank you. So I will now read the motion language so that all members are clear and public too on what we'll

313
01:37:48.159 --> 01:38:05.840
be voting on. So, it's ordered that the Boston School Committee hereby reaffirms their commitment to the 2021 Mass Core Graduation Requirements Policy, including the 2025 alternative education amendment with

314
01:38:05.840 --> 01:38:21.119
additional flexibility for individual student circumstances. There are student situations that may require different but comparable alternatives to courses determined to meet Massore graduation requirements.

315
01:38:21.119 --> 01:38:38.000
The superintendent or their design has the authority to review each student's situation to identify alternative courses or exceptions for specific credits. In alignment with the alternative education requirement, all

316
01:38:38.000 --> 01:38:53.760
students must successfully complete a minimum of 18 credits across the four core subjects of English language arts, mathematics, history, and science in order to graduate.

317
01:38:53.760 --> 01:39:10.320
If there are no further questions, I'll entertain a motion to approve the Mass graduation requirements policy amendment as presented. Is there a motion? >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Second. >> Thank you. Is there any discussion or objection to the motion?

318
01:39:10.320 --> 01:39:25.440
>> Miss Pavves, will you please call the role? >> Thank you, Chair. Dr. Alkins, >> yes. >> Mr. Pan, Miss Palano Garcia, >> yes. >> Miss Torres, >> yes. >> Mr. Tran, >> yes. >> Miss Garrett, >> yes. >> Miss Robinson, >> yes. >> The motion is approved. Right.

319
01:39:25.440 --> 01:39:54.520
>> Thanks. Um, because we have a long evening ahead of us with a couple of pretty significant um presentations. We're going to just take a five minute break so people can uh take care of their needs and can come back. >> I know.

320
01:50:46.000 --> 01:51:00.400
Now we now we will transition to our reports. Our first two reports tonight are the presentation of the 2026 policy to advance academic excellence and eliminate opportunity and achievement

321
01:51:00.400 --> 01:51:18.239
gaps. Followed by an update on the 2026 to 2031 strategic road map. Let's aim to keep each of these presentations to 15 minutes. And I'd like to remind our presenters to please speak at a slower pace to assist

322
01:51:18.239 --> 01:51:35.520
our interpreters. And I want the to invite the superintendent to give introductory remarks. >> Wonderful. Thank you, chair. So, very special night. Um, as a district, we strive to put the opportunity and achievement gap policy into practice every day. in our decision- making, in

323
01:51:35.520 --> 01:51:52.080
our goal setting, and in our strategic planning. And you'll hear this shortly. The intent of the policy is to close opportunity and achievement gaps for every single student in the district with intentional focus on groups that have been historically marginalized and

324
01:51:52.080 --> 01:52:07.920
ensure they have the opportunity to reach their full potential. It has been nearly a decade since the policy was updated, delayed in part to the pandemic. I am truly so happy to be here. Um, this is definitely been one of the best

325
01:52:07.920 --> 01:52:23.760
things that we've worked on this year uh to bring the updated OAG policy forward for the committee's consideration. With the OAG policy as our northstar, we have developed a strategic road map that will guide our mission into the

326
01:52:23.760 --> 01:52:38.719
next decade. Tonight we will also present an updated update to our draft plan. Our vision to unlock and support the brilliance and potential of every BPS student in clear actionable steps that will guide us to

327
01:52:38.719 --> 01:52:54.560
the end of the decade. In a few minutes, I will turn the meeting over to senior adviser for strategy and opportunity gaps who you know well, Dr. Colin Rose, an OAG task force coaches Ellie Shakur, and school committee member who you know

328
01:52:54.560 --> 01:53:11.840
well, Dr. Steven Akins. After they present the OAG policy, Dr. Rose will walk members through our work to date and lay out the next steps in the strategic planning process. Dr. Rose, members of my team, and the OAG task force that guides the district's

329
01:53:11.840 --> 01:53:28.800
work, have worked hard to align the goals of the policy and the goals of the district. It is fitting that we will also present our initial thinking on our strategic plan in this meeting as the two must work in tandem for our district to be

330
01:53:28.800 --> 01:53:44.400
successful. I want to wholeheartedly thank the OG task force for its partnership and for working with BPS to monitor the district's progress, guide its decision-making, provide support, and hold it accountable. We look forward to

331
01:53:44.400 --> 01:54:01.119
continuing to work with the task force to ensure that the goals of the OAG policy are at the center as we go through the district's strategic planning process. We'll ask the committee for its support of the updated policy at a future school committee meeting and we will continue to update

332
01:54:01.119 --> 01:54:18.159
members on our strategic planning. At this point, I will now turn the meeting over to senior adviser for strategy and opportunity gaps, Dr. Rose and OG task force co-chair. Good evening and thank you to the members of the Boston school committee

333
01:54:18.159 --> 01:54:34.239
and to chair Robinson and Superintendent Skipper for the opportunity to present today. I'm Ale Shakur, co-chair of the opportunity and achievement gaps task force. Um, and I am here on behalf of the entire task force. We are so excited

334
01:54:34.239 --> 01:54:51.040
for today's presentation. Um, as Superintendent Skipper said, I'm also joined today by our co-chair, Dr. Steven Alkins uh who is also a member of the Boston school committee and by Dr. Colin Rose who is senior adviser for strategy and opportunity gaps. This policy

335
01:54:51.040 --> 01:55:07.760
represents two years of focused work and nearly two decades of commitment to ensuring every student in Boston has access to an excellent education. So let's start with why this policy matters. As Superintendent Skipper said,

336
01:55:07.760 --> 01:55:23.440
this policy is intended to be the northstar for the district. It defines who we are accountable to and what success must look like. It centers the students who make up the majority of BPS, students of color, multilingual

337
01:55:23.440 --> 01:55:39.840
learners, students with disabilities, economically disadvantaged students. These identities are not separate. They overlap. Many of our students sit at the intersection of multiple systems of inequity. That means this policy is not

338
01:55:39.840 --> 01:55:57.760
about a subset of students. It's about the core of our district. The policy is meant to be revised every six years. We are presenting today after 10. And as Superintendent Skipper said, there have been delays due to COVID and

339
01:55:57.760 --> 01:56:14.880
leadership transitions, but the urgency has only grown. The data continues to show persistent gaps, particularly for black and Latino students, multilingual learners, and students with disabilities. That is why this work is not optional. It is essential.

340
01:56:14.880 --> 01:56:30.320
So, let's give some historic grounding in terms of how we got to this point with the policy. The OAG policy has deep roots in advocacy, particularly through Black Educators Alliance for Massachusetts, also known as BEAM. The

341
01:56:30.320 --> 01:56:47.679
policy was first adopted back in 2006, updated in 2016, and now strengthened in 2026. This is legacy work, and we stand on the shoulders of advocates and leaders like Barbara Fields, the late George Cox,

342
01:56:47.679 --> 01:57:03.199
Janet Williams, and Nora Tony. The task force itself was created to ensure this policy remains a living breathing accountability tool. I want to acknowledge the advocacy of chairman Michael O'Neal who was the one who

343
01:57:03.199 --> 01:57:21.280
actually called for the creation of the task force back in 2015 and then the 2016 policy was adopted a year later by the Boston school committee. And then that brings us to the role of the task force. We are not symbolic. We

344
01:57:21.280 --> 01:57:37.599
are active partners in accountability. Our role is to monitor progress, provide guidance, elevate community voice, ensure this policy translates into real change in schools. I co-chair alongside Dr. Steven Alkins and we work closely

345
01:57:37.599 --> 01:57:53.679
with Dr. Colin Rose as I mentioned before. And we want to give a shout out to Chair Robinson who was the prior co-chair for the task force and served for a period of 10 years. So, thank you so much, Chair Robinson. I want to transition to Dr. Alkins, who will share

346
01:57:53.679 --> 01:58:09.520
a little bit about why we are here and what the data shows. >> Dr. Rose, >> sorry, you said Dr. Alkins. Dr. >> Sorry, Dr. Dr. Rose. >> Hi. Uh, good good evening, uh, school committee members. Um, the urgency of

347
01:58:09.520 --> 01:58:24.719
this work is self-evident. Um, here you have a literal illustration of the problem. This is a graphic showing fourth grade ELA and eighth grade math scores from the start of MCCAST through today. Between the dotted lines, you'll

348
01:58:24.719 --> 01:58:41.199
see uh park testing which was used in between the old and the new generation MCCAST. Um and the blank sta space is a time we would all like to forget the pandemic. Um, as you can see, performance has ebbed and flow, but gaps towards proficiency remain similar

349
01:58:41.199 --> 01:58:56.960
across time and have been extremely large for the group's ILA outlined above. Even as we see a bit of an uptick now, we need to find the conditions and support them that allow those lines to consistently rise towards proficiency

350
01:58:56.960 --> 01:59:16.800
for these measures and all others. As we begin to close the chapter on the 2016 policy uh and the version of the policy, we want to acknowledge the many steps forward that came from that work. Um this includes everything from CLSP which brought form and definition to

351
01:59:16.800 --> 01:59:31.599
culturally responsive practice in the district to the opportunity index which created a tangible and scientific way to measure student need outside the context of schools and everything in between. Much of what you see here was part of

352
01:59:31.599 --> 01:59:48.239
the bright spots uh in Desi's 2019 review of the district. >> Thank you, Dr. Rose. And so in terms of the policy that we are about to discuss today, there are a number of stakeholders who provided feedback. Uh we had extensive meetings with Superintendent Skipper and her

353
01:59:48.239 --> 02:00:05.440
leadership team, the division of schools, academics, the inclusion planning team, instructional leadership team, student input from Boston student advisory council, and various members of the OAG task force who are listed here. a 15 member task force representing

354
02:00:05.440 --> 02:00:20.000
parents, school leaders, teachers, Boston Teachers Union representatives, community advocates, people with expertise in black student achievement, multilingual learners, as well as students with disabilities and sense of

355
02:00:20.000 --> 02:00:36.560
belonging and wellness. Those task force members were served as co-authors together with members of the district and the broader community. So here are the six goals that are outlined in the policy. Notably, the 2016 policy

356
02:00:36.560 --> 02:00:53.360
also had six goals, the same six goals, although we've added more form and structure to each of them. The first goal, goal one, is really about accountability and systems. And this goal is really designed to provide a clear outline of how accountability

357
02:00:53.360 --> 02:01:08.239
begins with those members here on the bench with the school committee then flowing to the superintendent, the superintendent's leadership team, the role of the task force and the design of the superintendent all the way down to the school building level and what

358
02:01:08.239 --> 02:01:24.639
happens with our schools. It also includes the accountability, how the policy will be measured and evaluated over time, a dashboard, the metrics and so forth. Goal number two is really designed to give the uh conditions under

359
02:01:24.639 --> 02:01:40.960
which closing achievement gaps would need to happen because we know that mindsets are important that everyone at all levels in BPS needs to understand culturally and linguistically affirming and sustaining practices and that includes professional development at all

360
02:01:40.960 --> 02:01:57.520
district levels so that everyone in BPS is holding high expectations and high standards for our young people. Goal number three is around advancing academic excellence and this is the goal where achievement is fully centered.

361
02:01:57.520 --> 02:02:15.040
Here we have focused on schools as the unit of change. This is where the magic happens on the front lines with our teachers and our young people. So here we focus on the importance of strong school leadership, highquality teachers in every classroom, the importance of

362
02:02:15.040 --> 02:02:32.960
literacy and academic rigor, student wellness and belonging and inclusion and supports for diverse learners. As you heard from many of the people during public comment, we also point out here the importance of bilingual education, bilingualism, and home language. And we

363
02:02:32.960 --> 02:02:49.199
talk about inclusion, making sure that we are looking out for this disproportionate placement of black and Latino students in in substantially separate environments and instead making sure all young people are getting the supports that they need to thrive. If we

364
02:02:49.199 --> 02:03:06.000
get this right, students will experience the policy in their classrooms each and every day. Goal number four is really about education and leadership diversity. Our young people deserve to see teachers who look like them. They deserve to have teachers that reflect

365
02:03:06.000 --> 02:03:22.480
their languages and their lived experience. And so therefore, we really want to focus on the recruitment, the retention, and the support for teachers of color. Um, and this is actually again one of the priorities that's been with us from the very beginning back in 2006

366
02:03:22.480 --> 02:03:39.599
when Black Educators Alliance of Massachusetts drafted the very first policy. Goal five is really centering our families, our parents, our partners, our students themselves. And so this is the one that's really looking at reciprocal partnerships with those

367
02:03:39.599 --> 02:03:55.119
members of our community. It's about shared responsibility because we know that schools cannot do this work alone. So here we're elevating student voice, agency, and leadership, looking at families as true partners, and looking at the importance of community partners,

368
02:03:55.119 --> 02:04:09.760
higher ed, and industry partners as well. And finally, goal number six, which intentionally comes last, really centers on the role of central office because we need central office to exist to support schools, not the other way

369
02:04:09.760 --> 02:04:27.280
around. And so here the goal is focused on equitable and transparent and efficient operations. And we're looking at things about how funding decisions are made, transparency in school closures and mergers, capital investments and facilities and so forth.

370
02:04:27.280 --> 02:04:42.639
I've already outlined some of the things that are different in this policy. Again, centering schools as that unit of change, having more rigor here around accountability and reporting, stronger focus on academic excellence, and really we center joyful learning because at the

371
02:04:42.639 --> 02:04:58.480
end of the day, if the classrooms are not joyful places, we will not be able to close achievement gaps. And then finally, I'll turn it over to Dr. Alkins, who will talk about the connection between the policy and the strategic plan that you'll hear about next.

372
02:04:58.480 --> 02:05:15.199
>> Thank you. Um so on the left you see a flowchart demonstrating how this policy connects to and informs other key levers for change within our district. So for context throughout several conversations with the task force uh I myself was able to explore uh and learn the history

373
02:05:15.199 --> 02:05:33.199
around the 2016 policy um and how it has been taken up by the district and how it's been operationalized over the past 10 years. So in short alongside with its many accomplishments, the sense that I got was that sometimes the policy was seen as either operating in parallel uh

374
02:05:33.199 --> 02:05:49.280
with the BPS strategic plan and with certain components and tasks being assigned to either individual groups or departments. In many cases, this led to misunderstandings and a lack of clarity around accountability structures. But as you can see, as it's described as our

375
02:05:49.280 --> 02:06:05.840
northstar, this policy aims to create better alignment in that this policy should inform school committee priorities, our questions, and the presentations that come before the body. These priorities will in turn inform the development of the strategic plan and

376
02:06:05.840 --> 02:06:20.719
have which will then be carried out by an implementation plan with key performance indicators. Our hope is to create a feedback loop of communication around data that will result in elimination of these gaps permanently and give our students pathways to

377
02:06:20.719 --> 02:06:37.920
unbridled success in BPS and beyond. This means that as a school committee, we must be proactive in asking for key data updates at critical junctures to inform our decisions. The elimination of OAGs is not just support for our most vulnerable

378
02:06:37.920 --> 02:06:53.840
populations. It will result in a removal of barriers for all students. The work of this task force represents a collective viewpoint that we are not just an external arm of the school committee, but we are thought partners intimately involved in this work and equally committed to the success of our

379
02:06:53.840 --> 02:07:09.920
students. In that sense, the structure of this policy that will support monitoring and implementation aims not to silo the work but create cross collaborative teams to address its goals. The task force will work in partnership with district

380
02:07:09.920 --> 02:07:26.880
representatives to ensure that goals, allocations, and implementation efforts align and progress with cohesive strategy, consistent monitoring, transparency with the public, and urgency. And now I'll pass it over to Dr. Colin Rose to talk through more

381
02:07:26.880 --> 02:07:46.480
about the strategic plan. >> That's the next presentation. So you want me to pause or you want me to go directly into Perfect. Let me see if I could get the tech. >> So for our public that concludes the presentation specifically on the policy

382
02:07:46.480 --> 02:08:03.360
but again as Dr. Alkins just explained the strategic plan is really how the policy is implemented. So that's the next section. >> Perfect. Good evening again. So, uh, today, uh, alongside the OEG policy, we want to give an update, uh, to the

383
02:08:03.360 --> 02:08:19.840
burgeoning strategic planning that's going on in the district. Um, as the OEG policy is touted as the northstar of the district, we believe an approstate update forward as we're bringing forward the policy. During the last iteration of the OG policy, there was an

384
02:08:19.840 --> 02:08:36.480
implementation plan created, which was under my purview at the time. Uh part of the reason I came back was to support this endeavor but an opportunity arose. In the past the OAG implementation plan was a separate implementation plan from

385
02:08:36.480 --> 02:08:53.760
the district implementation plan. Uh now that we have uh we are embarking on a strategic plan as a district. Um the thought was to create a plan in alignment with the OG policy so that we don't have two separate comprehensive implementation plans uh and one can

386
02:08:53.760 --> 02:09:11.760
serve both. So tonight we'll provide an update on the development of our strategic plan. Uh the goal of this presentation is to share information and invite school committee to give input on the strategic roadmap. and we'll stay kind of at a

387
02:09:11.760 --> 02:09:31.760
high level uh next to the objectives. This slide shows our vision for every student in our district. And I'll read a quote that comes from the 2016 version um and still finds its way into the 2026 language. Uh this is credited to Sam

388
02:09:31.760 --> 02:09:48.320
Asdo who was one of the chairs, Reverend um who's one of the chairs of the task force at the time. Every child in every classroom in every Boston school has the same opportunity to achieve the greatness as anyone else with the same

389
02:09:48.320 --> 02:10:04.400
unfettered access to excellent teaching, joyful learning, and every conceivable tool needed to unlock their brilliance. We want that to be true for every kid in BPS. Um below we have a graphic for the high

390
02:10:04.400 --> 02:10:19.760
quality student experience that was created a few years ago with a massive amount of community engagement. Uh the four components include rigorous and culturally affirming learning experiences, supportive network of caring adults, wellness and enrichment

391
02:10:19.760 --> 02:10:38.000
uh undergirded by physical spaces that support learning. The thought being that the closer we are at creating this type of experience, the closer we can get to our vision. As leadership started thinking about a new strategic plan uh and the high

392
02:10:38.000 --> 02:10:53.360
quality student experience um with it, we wanted to leverage multiple foundational building blocks that have been built over the past few years under the current strategic plan. These include the regional school model uh with academic and wraparound supports

393
02:10:53.360 --> 02:11:09.520
for schools. High quality instructional materials and equitable literacy uh was a lot of the academic work that was going on. The MTSS framework uh both thinking about the core instruction that happens in the classroom but also those tier 2 tier three supports that students

394
02:11:09.520 --> 02:11:25.599
need to be able to be regulated and ready for class. inclusive education, uh making sure that uh we provide the least restrictive environment for students. Long-term facilities planning, which is changing and shifting the footprint, um and hopefully providing better spaces

395
02:11:25.599 --> 02:11:42.079
and support for our students. language access. So the increase of bilingual and dual languual programming um as well as um clearer exit and entrance uh criteria for students who are learning English career pathways. So

396
02:11:42.079 --> 02:12:00.159
expanding access to college and career pathways and post-secondary partnerships uh and community hub schools, right? How do we embed community resources and coordinate with the communities to make our schools better? From these foundational elements and the

397
02:12:00.159 --> 02:12:15.520
definition of the high quality student experience as well as the school committee priorities as you all worked on last year and the OEG policy leadership decided to create three buckets to organize the current impactful work and also identify improvement and new elements to ensure

398
02:12:15.520 --> 02:12:31.280
student success. These buckets are high quality instruction. This is a category in which Dr. Simone Wright had great influence in shaping as a leader of the academic strategy. This speaks to how we improve teaching and learning for the diverse set of learners we have in

399
02:12:31.280 --> 02:12:47.040
Boston and especially those who have historically been under or miss served by our instruction. Holistic student supports is the second bucket um which speaks to the conditions and support students need to be in school and ready to learn in our

400
02:12:47.040 --> 02:13:03.679
classrooms. And then we have high quality programming and facilities which speaks to the programming and physical plant we need as a district as well as well as throughout the city to be able to support the teaching learning environment supports student need

401
02:13:03.679 --> 02:13:21.199
students need to be ready for college career and life. Our theory of action comes from the notion that Boston is resourcerich but at times coordination poor. The thought here is that if we align the resources and energies between schools, central

402
02:13:21.199 --> 02:13:39.679
office and the community towards these three focus areas in an aligned and coherent way, we will make major strides towards our vision for all students. To start drafting the raw materials for objectives and goals, we enlisted the

403
02:13:39.679 --> 02:13:56.800
support of numerous members of our BPS community to work together by topic in cross functional groups. These groups included folks from different perches, perspectives in the district that have strong connection to relevant topics connected to those three bucket areas.

404
02:13:56.800 --> 02:14:13.040
Members of the team might work in family engagement, they might work in operations, they might be part of our school's team. uh the thought was that they can bring their particular perspective, their experience, their wisdom to the table as we envision and then work to improve

405
02:14:13.040 --> 02:14:31.119
that particular phenomenon we were looking at in that group. To do this, we utilize the racial equity planning tool, especially steps one through four, uh which I'll go into a bit detail in in the next couple of slides. Step one of the REP process is connected

406
02:14:31.119 --> 02:14:48.159
to understanding the general context and coming to consensus on what improvements the group would like to see at the end of the day, especially as it relates to equitable outcomes for students. That included understanding the current research in the area. So there's there's

407
02:14:48.159 --> 02:15:04.000
an image here around the NCL um report on disproportionality. Disproportionality was one of our groups. Um these readings grounded groups in a shared understanding of the issue so that we had a solid foundation. Groups also talked about the current and

408
02:15:04.000 --> 02:15:20.800
past initiatives and district context connected to the topic as well as any connect connections to the OEG policy that was burgeoning and the school committee pri priorities before identifying some broad desired outcomes. You can go back.

409
02:15:20.800 --> 02:15:37.040
Step two of the RAP asked groups to dig into the BPS context a bit uh deeper through data. All groups were aided by a dedicated member of the data and accountability team which brought specific data connected to the issues they were exploring.

410
02:15:37.040 --> 02:15:57.199
Through this data, groups identified trends and key takeaways. Step three, each group was given a detailed report built from numerous focus groups conducted across the BPS community. I would like to acknowledge Tamika uh

411
02:15:57.199 --> 02:16:14.400
Buckmeer, Dr. Tuni uh Adamant Mande Stacy Stacy Guerrero among others who organized engagements connected the sessions and collected data as well as the office of data and accountability who helped synthesize and provide themes uh across those focus

412
02:16:14.400 --> 02:16:30.560
groups. Cross functional team members also conducted empathy interviews with stakeholders from their particular area of the organization to get even more detailed information connected to the current context. groups created takeaways that in tandem with steps one and two began to identify

413
02:16:30.560 --> 02:16:47.120
some root causes and clear opportunities. In step four, u these groups started refining objectives, defining broad goals and core actions, taking in the current context, root causes while also reimagining uh what improvement would

414
02:16:47.120 --> 02:17:01.599
look like in five years. These raw materials from these groups continue to be refined. Today we are bringing forward some solidify highlevel objectives in each focus area. These would be the anchors for discrete goals

415
02:17:01.599 --> 02:17:18.719
and action steps for implementation. So uh in the first focus area highquality instruction there's really two objectives. One around systematic effectiveness of our instruction. So, increasing the effectiveness of high-quality teaching at scale uh by

416
02:17:18.719 --> 02:17:34.000
leveraging highquality instructional materials, integrating high impact literacy practices and other evidence-based practices that support high levels of student engagement and learning for each student across BPS and especially black, latinx, multilingual

417
02:17:34.000 --> 02:17:54.080
learners and students with disabilities. And the second sentence there deals with um how we need to share that work across our our full broad community. jumping the gun there. Um the the second objective is really around uh educator capacity. So how do we match our

418
02:17:54.080 --> 02:18:09.280
professional development to ensure that teachers uh instructors and everybody within the district can actually do that. Focus area two holistic student supports um has three objectives. One around attendance and engagement, right? So

419
02:18:09.280 --> 02:18:24.479
increase student attendance and engagement in school through aligned school central office and community based strategies. Uh in order for students to take advantage of high quality instruction, they need to be in school. And so how do we bring down even more of the barriers? We've done a good job over the last few years and in

420
02:18:24.479 --> 02:18:40.479
lowering chronic absenteeism, but continuing on that road and also making our schools places that are so engaging that if there are barriers, families and students will jump over them to get to our schools. Second, student readiness to MTSS, right? increase student readiness to engage with grade level

421
02:18:40.479 --> 02:18:57.840
tasks by grow growing clear, aligned and effective MTSS, including academic and whole student supports. Right? So, making sure that students are regulated and ready uh in our classrooms. And then third, equity and accountability. Uh and this is a topic that's been brought up multiple times tonight. um how do we

422
02:18:57.840 --> 02:19:13.439
reduce disproportionality and increase accountability for students in subsearate settings, especially black and Latino boys who often are those in that gap. Um this to me is a a pressure test really of all of our systems. Um

423
02:19:13.439 --> 02:19:30.639
because uh those Oh, sorry. I'll slow down a little bit. Um black and Latino boys are have historically been uh stuck in the disproportionality gap. And if we truly have the MTSS, those systems and the core teaching happening in classrooms

424
02:19:30.639 --> 02:19:47.439
that we that we really want, um this should decrease. And finally, focus area three, high high quality student experience through programming and facilities. So one is really just access to high quality student experience through those uh

425
02:19:47.439 --> 02:20:02.720
through that programming in school buildings that align to HQSC. Um, this is why we're doing all that work around long-term facilities planning. Hopefully, students are landing in spaces where they have the programming in the building to support their learning uh and growth into their life

426
02:20:02.720 --> 02:20:19.040
uh their life and career in college. Transition supports. So, increased supports for students and communities who are directly impacted by grade reconfiguration, school mergers and closures. So, we know that our footprint is going to continue to change. How do we ensure that we are increasing the

427
02:20:19.040 --> 02:20:35.520
supports for individual families and students and also school communities that are taking in students and families? Uh and then finally community integration into all our strategies. Right? So how do we coordinate and utilize utilize community resources to extend access to a high quality student

428
02:20:35.520 --> 02:21:00.319
experience? Both bringing partners into our schools but also using the spaces in the city as our classroom. When thinking about objectives, it's not only important to identify shared priorities. It's also important to discuss conditions necessary to effectively execute and hold ourselves

429
02:21:00.319 --> 02:21:16.640
accountable mutually to those priorities as a entire community. Um, this is key for alignment and coherence. We call these enabling conditions. Uh there are three areas we'll need to explicitly focus on. Uh one creating and maintaining equity centered culture and

430
02:21:16.640 --> 02:21:34.080
practice. Two, strengthening the systems structures and practices for collaboration as a district. And three, aligning resources to our priorities and ensuring structures for continuous improvement and accountability. Moving forward towards implementation,

431
02:21:34.080 --> 02:21:54.399
we'll continue to use uh the RAP process as we refine and create smart goals and action steps for our objectives as well as build out the overall metrics for student success. Finally, um our next immediate steps. Um there are a few discussion points for

432
02:21:54.399 --> 02:22:10.000
tonight. Namely, are these the right focus areas and objectives? Uh and to a bit of a start to a discussion around goals andor metrics um we will use to measure progress. Um, as we continue to develop the plan

433
02:22:10.000 --> 02:22:26.720
through the spring, there'll be opportunities to collaborate with you all as school committee and the OG task force. Uh, this could include that working session that you have on May 20th. Um, and then below you see our timeline for bringing forth the full plan this summer and into next fall. Um,

434
02:22:26.720 --> 02:22:42.080
with that, that's me. I'm under 15 minutes by 30 seconds, so I made it. uh and I open up uh for for discussion uh for both presentations and especially those uh two key questions that we asked in this slide. >> Yeah, thank you both. Um and I will now

435
02:22:42.080 --> 02:22:57.600
open it up to questions and comments from members. >> Go ahead. >> Um first of all, thank you so much for the presentations and um my question is more towards um how you said that you want learning to

436
02:22:57.600 --> 02:23:13.359
be more joyful. So, how will like schools make learning more joyful while still focusing on some of the academic goals that we have? >> I think that uh that's a good question. So, it our policy is calling out the

437
02:23:13.359 --> 02:23:30.479
importance of joyful learning. I think some of that is going to come through professional development for our teachers, understanding that when you are working with students of color, multilingual learners, students with disabilities, really all students, um it has to be engaging and fun. And so I

438
02:23:30.479 --> 02:23:45.760
think there's ways that that can be done through project- based learning, music, getting kids out of their seats, getting them to be interactive. I think that type of professional development is is as important as other types of PD. And then it's also listening for young

439
02:23:45.760 --> 02:24:02.880
people, right? I think young people know what's exciting to them. And it's important that, you know, that's why we really put so much energy into goal number five where it talks about student leadership, students having a role on their school site councils or in their school leadership at their sites. Um,

440
02:24:02.880 --> 02:24:19.280
and really just listening to what young people want to bring the learning to life. I think we had a great example with the Aspen challenge. When you give students real world learning, it feels connected to their lives and communities. That's really the things that really make them most excited. >> Yeah, I'll piggyback. There is no

441
02:24:19.280 --> 02:24:35.040
learning without engagement. So, >> no, I totally agree with T. I totally agree. Um my second question is related more towards goal number four, which says um increase educator and leadership diversity across the district. So um

442
02:24:35.040 --> 02:24:50.319
what are like some of the changes that students will notice in terms of like teacher diversity or staff diversity and do you guys have like data? Are you guys like collecting data from eight schools and then like seeing like who would recruit or something like that?

443
02:24:50.319 --> 02:25:07.280
>> This has been a really challenging area for the district. As you know there um as some of you know there was a judge Garity order that goes all the way back to the 70s. are supposed to be 25% black teachers across the district. Um, at the time that stat was based on the student enrollment. Now we have, you know,

444
02:25:07.280 --> 02:25:23.200
significant number of Latino students. Uh, we have all sorts of languages across the district. So, it needs to be racial diversity and linguistic diversity in terms of the languages as well. Um, unfortunately because of union rules, we know that there's been quite a

445
02:25:23.200 --> 02:25:39.680
few teachers that are like sort of the last hired who are now in in danger of losing their positions. That's something the task force is focusing on and that we'll really ask this body to really take up because, you know, just as quickly as we're bringing diverse

446
02:25:39.680 --> 02:25:55.760
teachers into classrooms now, we're starting to lose them at the same time. Uh but what it should look like is every young person has a chance to experience not all of your teachers but there's a good munch a healthy mix of teachers in your schools so that you know we've had some students who say they've gone all

447
02:25:55.760 --> 02:26:11.200
the way through BPS and never had a teacher of color like that really shouldn't be the experience. Um so go ahead Dr. So something I think I would add on to that um is the also the lensure process that also exists and um

448
02:26:11.200 --> 02:26:28.160
I think we already do have some data that's around sort of the differences that like we find from uh some of our more underrepresented demographics in terms of educators and how they're able to get through um those MTELs. So I think part of what our role will be as a

449
02:26:28.160 --> 02:26:45.840
as a body will be asking for that data so that we can say like oh we should be investing more in support for those lure preparation supports um for those um you know like for those for those teachers as well. Um, also, um, I'm not quite

450
02:26:45.840 --> 02:27:01.760
sure what the data is around mentorship, uh, programs that exist for our educators and for our school principles like as well because it's not just about, um, recruiting, but it's about retaining um, like our our educators and our and our school leaders. So, that's

451
02:27:01.760 --> 02:27:16.960
all just relevant things that we're going to have to look at as a school committee and um, and really think about just the data behind it. Um, which is especially relevant now that we've just passed the budget. So now looking at what is the impact um that first data

452
02:27:16.960 --> 02:27:35.760
set that we're going to receive around what has happened to our underrepresented educators. >> Yep. Thank you. >> Hi guys. Uh thank you for the presentation. This is my first time here. So um one of my question is around

453
02:27:35.760 --> 02:27:52.000
I read the preamble. >> Yes. >> And I think it was fantastic. It was great thing. And one of the questions that I have is about uh clarifying accountability and uh is this um is going to be always updated and what

454
02:27:52.000 --> 02:28:08.319
information will be in the dashboard for our families and communities and um to see. >> Yes. Um so the policy is supposed to be updated every six years. Um and so there will it will move in a cycle with the strategic plan as well. I think we

455
02:28:08.319 --> 02:28:23.200
actually looked at five years. So as as the strategic plan is being updated, the policy will be refreshed. It's not designed to be completely rewritten, but at least we will take a look at it to see what might need to be revised. Um, in terms of the dashboard, there will be

456
02:28:23.200 --> 02:28:38.399
a data dashboard. The task force is deciding like which data would be maybe shared in more internally versus what would be the public facing dashboard. And at our next meeting in May, we'll be deciding on the key performance indicators. So a set of like five to 10

457
02:28:38.399 --> 02:28:54.240
key things that we'll be monitoring from one year to the next or even on a quarterly basis. So that will be shared with of course with the school committee. So you all are also being able to sort of follow the progress as we go. Do you want to add? >> Yeah, I think the that second question

458
02:28:54.240 --> 02:29:11.040
around goals and metrics you know I think the task force are going to want to see certain metrics. I know you all are going to want to see certain metrics or certain metrics that are important to us internally. I think it would be good to align those. Yes. In a way so we again >> we're not looking at five different data

459
02:29:11.040 --> 02:29:27.680
sets, but there is a a core group of data that we're looking at disagregating and making sure that that all bodies are paying attention to. So I think that would be one of the hopes this spring to try to get us aligned. >> And and to clarify, the task force will make a recommendation. It will then come to the school committee and

460
02:29:27.680 --> 02:29:44.000
superintendent and you all will whittle that list down. So because we can't boil the ocean, right? we have to make sure we're focusing on a key set of indicators. And so, you know, we're looking at trying to keep that narrow to about >> and I think Dr. Rose's position is a really important one because it is the

461
02:29:44.000 --> 02:30:00.399
linkage between the district and all of our teams and the task force to make sure that we're all rowing in the same direction. >> That's right. So uh to continue with that question, will the dashboard include uh information about the

462
02:30:00.399 --> 02:30:17.200
schools? >> That's yeah, that was a question that we discussed at length with the task force. We would love to see it be school by school data. Um for some of the metrics, it might be by region as opposed to by school. So I think that would be one of the things that we will need to decide

463
02:30:17.200 --> 02:30:32.399
certainly with guidance from the school commission. >> If a family wants some information around a school, they'd be able to go to the dashboard. >> That's right. That's right. >> Find it. >> Yeah, there's likely there there's likely um quite a bit of data that can be disagregated to the school level if

464
02:30:32.399 --> 02:30:48.720
it's not already. There would be some things that um we would not want to uh put out there because it could be personnel or it could it be more sensitive data in which case we would do it at a more aggregate level >> but we'll work together to make sure

465
02:30:48.720 --> 02:31:05.040
that that data is available. >> Yes. And my other question is around staff training. I know that uh you talked about the cultural and linguistic and uh sustainable practice. >> Yes. >> So will BPS but what measures will we

466
02:31:05.040 --> 02:31:22.720
actually have in classrooms so we can see the impact? >> Yes. And I will say the CLSP is one of the things that Dr. Rose brought to us back in 2016 and is really been rolling across the district. But why don't you speak to how you're measuring that? Yeah, I think any tool that we're using

467
02:31:22.720 --> 02:31:40.160
around classroom practice um should embed CLSP. Um when we think about climate and culture, uh in our spaces, um we that should be reflected in kind of what families feel, what students feel when they come into the buildings, when they come into bowling. Um so I

468
02:31:40.160 --> 02:31:57.040
think we have existing some existing measures that already do that. Now training is another thing that's got to be embedded in our professional development at all levels. uh so folks are prepared to really in a in a real way live that value out so that we can see improvement. I think it's also

469
02:31:57.040 --> 02:32:12.479
embedded in quality school plans and performance evaluations and >> yeah and any any major measures it should be embedded >> so that way we can see if the implementation is working and uh and if

470
02:32:12.479 --> 02:32:29.200
it's not what will be in place to support >> yes that is a that's a good point >> okay >> because it's not always working so we have to be able to monitor that as well >> so My other question, I don't know if I go into the strategic plan.

471
02:32:29.200 --> 02:32:44.560
>> Sure. >> Yeah. Sure. >> Okay. >> Yes. >> So, in the equity impact statement, it was like um there was a a statement in the last page that talked about a tracker >> and the development of the

472
02:32:44.560 --> 02:33:02.160
implementation of is of that tracker and there is a designated owner of that tracker. So my my question is what is the intent of the tracker and how do you imagine this will roll

473
02:33:02.160 --> 02:33:18.560
out? >> Yeah. So the original implementation plan in 2017 we had a tracker so it really tracked where we were in our goals. So we had put out what the goals were to the community and you could see kind of our progress as goals were being

474
02:33:18.560 --> 02:33:35.120
met um if they were overdue, if they were kind of late. So it gave the community uh a chance to see where we were in progress to the things that we committed to. Uh and so the hope would be to to have a similar process with our goals at at the strategic plan level. Um

475
02:33:35.120 --> 02:33:49.840
you know that's separate from the met like the the main metrics of the of the district, but it would be just a way to hold ourselves accountable to doing the things we say that we're going to do in the plan. And then just as the way that actually played out, I mean there were the departments would come and really

476
02:33:49.840 --> 02:34:07.120
present on progress towards goals and we would look at the original goals and sort of track as green meant they were on target. Yellow was like yeah it's in progress and then red meant like this is like we're not seeing the progress we needed to see. So I would imagine there'd be something along those same

477
02:34:07.120 --> 02:34:23.280
lines. Yeah, there was a it was like an internal there was an internal way for us to figure out like where people were, but it was it was a dashboard connected to the actual goals to say where we were. >> So when you talk about a designated owner, what is that mean >> uh in the district?

478
02:34:23.280 --> 02:34:40.479
>> Well, yeah, it said that there will be a designated owner for the major step like designated to follow up on >> Oh, you're talking about the actual goals. Yeah. >> Yeah. Yeah. So like action steps and goals would be owned by folks right in in offices so that it's not just this

479
02:34:40.479 --> 02:34:57.520
ambiguous like hey we have this goal around something >> folks need to own goals >> right >> yeah I think this was one of the challenges from before that >> it didn't filter beyond the highest levels >> and this has to be the core work of

480
02:34:57.520 --> 02:35:13.359
every person in the district for it to work >> and that means every department leads The deputies will all be taking this and internalizing this and it comes out in the prioritization of and their own kind

481
02:35:13.359 --> 02:35:30.240
of goals. How are they going to be measuring it? In what order are they doing it? What's the resources they going to be using? So, this is really to go across the district. >> And I just add to that point when we back in 2016, each department had its

482
02:35:30.240 --> 02:35:46.560
own goals, but now it's crossf functional teams. So it's no longer being siloed like one department's doing this, another department's doing that. Whereas now it's it's cutting across departments as it needs to. >> Thank you. >> Thank you.

483
02:35:46.560 --> 02:36:03.520
>> Okay, >> Mr. Ch. >> Um, thank you for developing a very thorough and welldetailed uh policy. Thank you. And I noticed that um well

484
02:36:03.520 --> 02:36:19.520
just a comment that um I know that you you gauge your expectations in developing this depending dependent upon the percentage of students meeting or

485
02:36:19.520 --> 02:36:34.720
exceeding MCAST MCAST is no longer part of our equation. But looking at the graph on whatever page that is >> it's very depressing you know um

486
02:36:34.720 --> 02:36:50.960
uh the policy exists since uh 2006 now 2026 I know that we we we have continuously uh revised it every six year except for for those two years I I

487
02:36:50.960 --> 02:37:06.800
was here too. So I except for two those two years of um co but still >> I'm hoping I I'm really hoping that with this thoroughly planned

488
02:37:06.800 --> 02:37:23.359
particularly on I I I stress as um member >> yes >> mention professional development >> uh one way or another student's

489
02:37:23.359 --> 02:37:38.560
achievement depends on the the the the teacher's uh emotional intelligence and other intelligence relating to his or her teaching capability

490
02:37:38.560 --> 02:37:55.680
that graph below 50%. >> Yes. since uh I don't know since 2006 until now. Hopefully with what you are doing right now the next time that we have some

491
02:37:55.680 --> 02:38:12.640
graphical data it shows a little above 50%. >> Right. >> Yes. Uh I I don't know but um that got to be the reality of of our situation otherwise we'll keep divi develop developing it keep putting it together

492
02:38:12.640 --> 02:38:29.040
another six years we come up with other plans but the reality is there opportunity uh and achievement gap has been the controversial issues even be before I I get on board here. Yes,

493
02:38:29.040 --> 02:38:45.120
>> it was one of the ma major questions when I was interviewed. So, eight years down the road is still here. >> That's right. 20 years down the road, it's still here. So, we have a lot of work to do and I think that there has

494
02:38:45.120 --> 02:39:00.319
been just a lack of coherence and alignment in the strategies. Um we have seen in past iterations where you know there was a strategic plan sitting there was a the policy sitting on one shelf and as Dr. Rose said a different

495
02:39:00.319 --> 02:39:15.120
strategic plan with a different set of goals over here and then the school committee would go set a set of priorities over there and none of those documents were speaking to each other. And so really what we tried to do here with this policy is is create that line

496
02:39:15.120 --> 02:39:30.800
of coherence. This is the first time in the district's history where the policy and the actual implementation and strategic plan is being connected through the same person through the superintendent's design which is Dr.

497
02:39:30.800 --> 02:39:47.680
Colin Rose. So that's a huge change in the way this was implemented where you had different people sort of running different pieces of the strategy. Now we've got the coherence and alignment that is really important and of course leadership matters. We've got Superintendent Skipper. We've got Dr.

498
02:39:47.680 --> 02:40:02.880
Rose. You got the task force monitoring. You've got now the school committee where you all have weighed in on the policy. We've got Dr. Alkins. We're going to ask for a second school committee member to also serve on the task force. And again, that just creates

499
02:40:02.880 --> 02:40:20.640
more of that alignment. It has to be one set of sheet music for the district that too often the district is moving to multiple pieces of sheet music. It's all playing wonderful songs, but none of it's coordinated, right? It's just sort of it has to be everyone moving in that

500
02:40:20.640 --> 02:40:36.640
same direction. I think we have the shot at this based on the players and the policy and the strategic plan being aligned directly to the policy. >> I would say you have deputies and chiefs that need to be highly involved obviously. And then um I think for improve like I talked about es and flows. I think we're trying to see

501
02:40:36.640 --> 02:40:53.120
steady improvement, right? not some miracle but that our these lines don't eb and flow that we are we have a strategy that has continuous improvement throughout the years that is steady >> I don't see it >> I see some >> and the boots on the ground I I want to

502
02:40:53.120 --> 02:41:10.160
reinfor you the school is the unit of change so this policy is really trying to focus more heavily what's happening in our schools with strong leaders strong teachers and student engagement and joy >> my my Last comment before I yield to

503
02:41:10.160 --> 02:41:26.800
other members. >> Thank you for having u special paying a special attention to language, you know, ELLL and students with disability. >> Yes, >> I I I do appreciate that. Hopefully

504
02:41:26.800 --> 02:41:43.760
uh the graph regarding those uh category will somehow fluctuate upward. Thank you. >> Yes, thank you. You want to pretend you want to? >> No, I was just going to say just one quick clarification. We we still are

505
02:41:43.760 --> 02:42:00.240
using MCCAST, right, as part of the benchmark, but not singularly, >> right? This is also where like MAP and some of our internal um assessments are really important. And I think that's one of the great things that's come out of um working together with the task force

506
02:42:00.240 --> 02:42:18.240
is it's not just one measure, it is multiple measures, right? So just want to like >> give you a shout out for staying focused on that as well. >> Yes. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. I want to say thank you team. Excellent job.

507
02:42:18.240 --> 02:42:43.359
>> Thank you. >> I think it's really really really good. >> Thank you very much to to the team. As Rafa said, I was able to notice that you really identified what the problem was. >> You identified their problem. You heard

508
02:42:43.359 --> 02:43:11.760
the community and you proposed very solid solutions. So you did designate and you created a strategic plan that is connected to the policies that were to be implemented. >> I also believe that the language that

509
02:43:11.760 --> 02:43:32.760
you use in this process is very important as well as we're trying to convey what we are trying to Which indicates that we can we have the ability and the potential to become a very solid district.

510
02:43:43.840 --> 02:44:05.840
There are so many things that are happening. There's so many people doing great things. that sometimes we are not aware of this because they do not align the things they're not communicated. >> I do believe that the solution is in being aligned. The solution is in in

511
02:44:05.840 --> 02:44:38.960
alignment itself. You also mentioned about the fieldwork that you were going to go directly to schools to be able to monitor the progress that was embedded there. >> So that will be critical in terms of determining what is it to be improved

512
02:44:38.960 --> 02:45:06.800
and what is that we can improve as well. I do not have a question per se, but I would like when you guys look at objective number one in one of the slides. >> We're talking about alignment and the sustainability of structures in the

513
02:45:06.800 --> 02:45:32.800
district itself across the district. to be able to promote and revise accountability >> and supervision as well >> and at the same time the policies that are being implemented I believe I heard that there is a team

514
02:45:32.800 --> 02:45:49.439
that will be in charge in doing this is that correct or it will be an assigned team of doing this >> well it's really up to the superendent attendance team, her leadership team, all of the different deputy super regional superintendent and so forth to carry out the work all the way down to

515
02:45:49.439 --> 02:46:05.760
the school leader level and to the teachers on that front line. Our job as the task force is just to monitor to be critical friends to really just make sure progress is being made >> and also to provide uh recommendations. I think one of the things we didn't

516
02:46:05.760 --> 02:46:22.000
necessarily go into was actually the breadth of expertise that is sitting on the task force and the different sectors that they represent. Um, and so hearing much of the feedback around the development of the policy,

517
02:46:22.000 --> 02:46:39.359
um, I'm just very reflective on the the amount of time that we went back and forth on just the verbiage of every single section. And so that has come out. Um, but really I think where the task force also has that power is in

518
02:46:39.359 --> 02:46:54.960
coming with recommendations that are coming from a range of just different expertises and and then sectors. And so in that sense um it can be collaborative with the district like there is flexibility within the policy to understand that the district has to be

519
02:46:54.960 --> 02:47:11.040
able to figure out how to best implement this. Um and at the same time the task force like does have a lot of wisdom to to to offer in that regard. >> Yeah. Thank you so much. >> Wisdom and recommendations that are also

520
02:47:11.040 --> 02:47:28.720
listed in the policy. Um I will also just add for goal number one. I'm I'm so glad that you you pointed out goal one uh Miss Garcia because the task force at one point felt like if we had goal one we didn't need the other goal. So it was really focused on how are we aligning

521
02:47:28.720 --> 02:47:45.040
this work? And so I think as the school committee as you all think like where should you as a body really be focusing your energy like if you're really focused on how is goal one flowing from the school committee to the superintendent to the leadership team

522
02:47:45.040 --> 02:48:00.240
all the way down to those school letter school leaders. Um that's really where you know we tried to put a lot of energy into that first goal. Okay. Thank you. And the last thing I will say about that and I that was why like my last

523
02:48:00.240 --> 02:48:17.439
statement was around for us I I think as a school committee it's going to be critical like when we receive updates on certain pieces of data and also what we're asking for right and so as we for example enter into the budget season for

524
02:48:17.439 --> 02:48:32.880
example this conversation might have been better pri prior to having the budget season right Um, so that's also something for us to to keep in mind as we're going through the academic year to say, "Wait a second, I would love an

525
02:48:32.880 --> 02:48:49.920
update on the state of our diversity of our teachers. I would love an update of MAP of MAP goals, where we are, where have we grown, where have we not grown, um, what are the factors that have gone into that." So, I think everything is going to depend on us in terms of what

526
02:48:49.920 --> 02:49:10.800
we're specifically asking for. and um and then also just the schedule of presentations that we'll have over the next well the years to come really. >> Thank you. >> Thank you so much team. Um, you know, this OAG policy is described as a north

527
02:49:10.800 --> 02:49:27.760
star, but it really has an incredible amount of detail um and the thoroughess and and thoughtfulness uh created by committee. I can't even imagine the amount of time um required to do that um to get to this point. So, so tremendous appreciation for a team of volunteers

528
02:49:27.760 --> 02:49:45.200
who are just really unified by their commitment to the students of Boston. So, a lot of gratitude there. Um, I think building off of where member Palano Garcia left off and what you were just discussing, Dr. Alkins, I think we are eager to dig into that goal one and

529
02:49:45.200 --> 02:49:59.600
think about how our oversight can move this work forward. Um, and so a lot of my questions are maybe a little bit more technical about how we can get to that point that Dr. Alkins described in terms of having the policy and the strategic

530
02:49:59.600 --> 02:50:16.800
plan really dictate our um cycle of presentations, our expectations of interim data throughout the year. Um our determination of what you know um what work is for year one, year two, year three of the plan. Um and so that's kind

531
02:50:16.800 --> 02:50:34.080
of where because I think what I might suggest to Dr. Alan's point that it would be on us to determine the right agenda for that time. Really, I think the plan should have the level of detail where it's really dictating to us what the work is of that time frame so that

532
02:50:34.080 --> 02:50:50.800
it's really um like informing the whole year at a glance in terms of what we need updates with. So I think a question I'm maybe getting to by the end is when will that level of detail be completed to really have this work sequenced

533
02:50:50.800 --> 02:51:08.160
because um this OG policy is has a lot of longevity to it. You know there is multi-year work here um and the superintendent can't be expected to take up every recommendation immediately next year. Um, but I think it would be fair to the superintendent and to us to know

534
02:51:08.160 --> 02:51:23.680
which of those things is being taken up sooner, later etc. and have that mapped out and then have what the indicators of success would be for each of those um, initiatives. So, um, maybe I'll stop there for the first question and just

535
02:51:23.680 --> 02:51:39.760
ask thoughts on kind of that next level of specificity. Yeah, I mean I think we have a lot of raw materials right now that we need to sift through, work with chiefs, uh, department heads, um, and leaders of offices to make sure that we have the

536
02:51:39.760 --> 02:51:56.640
right sequencing. Um, we're going to be working throughout the spring, uh, into the summer on that. I think the goal was to bring more detailed goals to you all this summer and then have that level of detail by early fall. um and really work

537
02:51:56.640 --> 02:52:12.720
intimately with offices and individuals to make sure that we have uh ambitious and realistic goals. We know that this is a five-year window. This policy should I mean the there might be refreshes, but the essence and the

538
02:52:12.720 --> 02:52:27.920
objectives in this policy should be able to last decades, right? And we can't do everything all at once. And so, you're right, we need to come back with like the meat on the bones right now. I see these objectives as those bones and kind of asking are we going the right

539
02:52:27.920 --> 02:52:44.560
direction and if we are great we'll start building those uh that meet this spring and summer. >> Yeah and oh sorry please go ahead. >> Well I I would just add to that I think that um you know even when when Dr. Rose was building out the strategic plan with

540
02:52:44.560 --> 02:53:00.399
the department uh the cross functional teams. It was not the idea of we're going to take every single goal and drill down on every single possible goal and objective, but we're going to focus on these three or four key areas. And I think that's how the school committee

541
02:53:00.399 --> 02:53:16.319
could could look at this is okay, you've got this full document where what are the areas that the school committee wants to focus in on. You might decide the teacher diversity, retention and support is one of the areas, right? It could be certainly around the achievement pieces and the academic

542
02:53:16.319 --> 02:53:33.120
goals, but is there something in academics? The strategic plan is really calling out literacy as the focus area, right? So that's one of the focus areas as well as >> quality instruction, >> high quality instruction and high quality student experiences. So I think it's like really using the policy itself

543
02:53:33.120 --> 02:53:50.399
as the school committee goes into your retreat to say okay based on what we see here where do we want to start the process and where do we want to put the focus for this year and sort of deciding that you know year over year that's how I see that that piece now the specific

544
02:53:50.399 --> 02:54:06.720
goals won't be available to the fall but you have the road map here to be able to go into your next retreat and start to say where the priorities Sir, >> I don't really have much to add other than I think these were some of the

545
02:54:06.720 --> 02:54:25.200
conversations that we did have like in in the meetings like one about one the policy being a balance of being too prescriptive perhaps like um but also what would be the process? So after the cross functional teams are able to meet,

546
02:54:25.200 --> 02:54:40.560
how would we as a task force come together and decide like, well, wait a second, which goal should we prioritize? How does that get to the school committee? So we I don't think we've actually figured that out yet as a as a group. Um, but that's one of those things that like we really do need to

547
02:54:40.560 --> 02:54:55.840
nail down. >> Yeah. and the superintendentship news is that >> there's multiple places where the work has started. Right. >> Right. And so I think that's going to be one of the sorting exercises that

548
02:54:55.840 --> 02:55:12.880
happens with the deputies and the chiefs is to build on the work that is already in motion and accelerate wherever we can as quickly as possible and get the input from school committee as to in the areas that may not yet have been started, what

549
02:55:12.880 --> 02:55:28.560
would be the priorities, right? >> So that we have kind of like a reasonable menu for that year one. Some things in progress and moving faster, other things beginning, and then as we go through the years, more new things come on to being. It's

550
02:55:28.560 --> 02:55:43.200
not unlike, you know, the like the inclusion plan or the long-term facilities where it it's it's a it's a five-year plan. And so that first year is a lot of the work right now that we're doing, which is the

551
02:55:43.200 --> 02:55:58.800
mapping and figuring out, you know, with the the deputies and the the chiefs how they're going to be in the cross functional teams, how they're going to be taking that work into the departments and making it concrete and actionable. And I think that's what I appreciate is

552
02:55:58.800 --> 02:56:16.080
that there is this level of detail and yet northstar. And I think it'll be that collaborative process of sorting with school committee, with the task force, and with leadership that will get us where we need to be going. >> Yeah. I I think folks that are responsible for implementing need to

553
02:56:16.080 --> 02:56:32.560
have a strong voice in how that happens, right? And I think they come back for feedback and you know we we you know the task force gives feedback but we we need the folks the leaders in in the district have I think the right to take a look at what the policy is and how they best

554
02:56:32.560 --> 02:56:48.720
will approach kind of coming up with the answers. >> Right. I think that's an important distinction that you know the expertise of the of the task force really lent itself to being very specific with the recommendations with the understanding that when we vote on the policy we're

555
02:56:48.720 --> 02:57:04.240
voting at the level of the goals and objectives for the district to consider the recommendations as potential levers to achieve those goals and objectives. Um I think when thinking about a strategic plan holistically

556
02:57:04.240 --> 02:57:22.720
um it should include in-flight work um especially when that work is still going to require a significant lift from staff. And so I guess one of my questions around the strategic plan um objectives right now is you know during

557
02:57:22.720 --> 02:57:39.520
the budget season we really emphasize the priority of inclusion roll out and multilingual learner supports expansion of dual language etc. Um and right now those aren't specifically named in the strategic plan document. They're named

558
02:57:39.520 --> 02:57:56.720
in the OAG policy. So just wondering where they live. Is it that they would live as sub initiatives under what's listed here? Um but I just wanted to make sure that those would be clearly delineated in the strategic plan with work sequenced by year.

559
02:57:56.720 --> 02:58:11.600
>> Yeah. I mean I think these objectives are again the uh the schema that we would attach um more specific goals. So if we're talking about like bilingual programming that would be in like 3.1 when we're talking about pro like programming for students. um the

560
02:58:11.600 --> 02:58:29.040
multilingual work um in the classroom would be one point in 1.1 when we talk about high quality instruction. So there'll be more detailed goals in inside of those objectives that would spell that out. >> It's also making me think that we may need like our next update on strategic

561
02:58:29.040 --> 02:58:45.840
planning like some alignment on terms because when I hear the word goals I think of like a metric whereas I think that when you were saying goals you're talking about like an initiative or a body of work. Yeah. >> Um and so I I think that there may we may need to like gloss >> core actions

562
02:58:45.840 --> 02:59:01.920
just think so that we're all um talking about the same thing. >> Um >> I think in terms of the what's here um what I would say is that like the preamble um of the OAG policy talked about literacy and numeracy but numeracy

563
02:59:01.920 --> 02:59:18.080
feels very absent from the rest of the policy. I know that literacy is the foundation of all subjects and I appreciate the discussion about literacy across the uh curriculum, but we also know about the importance of algebra 1 as a gateway um to high school

564
02:59:18.080 --> 02:59:34.880
completion. We know that a lot of the um you know new career pathways emphasize STEM. Um so just thinking about um where that could be called out more um in the next level of work. Um, and I would also note that the emphasis on advanced

565
02:59:34.880 --> 02:59:51.439
coursework in high school, I think is a natural emphasis because there are a lot of designations for advanced coursework in high school, AP, early college, CTE, IB, etc. Um, but that work is not as easily accessed if there is not advanced

566
02:59:51.439 --> 03:00:06.560
coursework from the beginning. Um, and I think defining what that is for the district and making sure that we are um that making sure that there's remediation and acceleration for all of our students is really important. There was the excellence for all pilot that

567
03:00:06.560 --> 03:00:23.279
was named um in the bullets that had an end date um which replaced a different advanced program. Um it seems like that work is really at risk when we're looking at budget cuts. And so I would just um encourage us to consider uh advanced coursework as a K12 initiative

568
03:00:23.279 --> 03:00:44.720
and not just a high school initiative. >> Um and I'll I'll stop there. Thank you. >> Yeah. So it's me. Yeah. So thinking back that this work has been going on for 20 years. Um, and there

569
03:00:44.720 --> 03:01:02.479
was, I'm sure, as much enthusiasm about this work 20 years ago as there was 10 years ago. And here we are yet again. And I guess my question for me is what will be different this time. >> Yes, I'm so glad you asked that question, chair. I can I want to give

570
03:01:02.479 --> 03:01:18.240
the historical context because leadership matters. This is why the superintendent role is so critical to the access the success of the initiative. the 2006 policy was drafted and then came a new superintendent and

571
03:01:18.240 --> 03:01:34.720
she did not see where she didn't have ownership of that policy. It sat up on a shelf and it was never implemented. So that was 2006. 2016 policy comes along. We have a superintendent who's part of the process

572
03:01:34.720 --> 03:01:51.680
writing and drafting of the policy together with Dr. Rose. I was there on the task force. Christ as chair, you were there as well. And um and so then and we had all the departments providing their guidance and weighing in tons of meetings. It took a full year to draft

573
03:01:51.680 --> 03:02:08.080
that document. When it was done, the same superintendent then started a strategic planning process that was totally separate. And so that strategic plan had an implementation plan and the policy had an implementation plan. So

574
03:02:08.080 --> 03:02:23.760
what happens when a district has two sets of implementation plans? Everyone ignores both. That's what happened. Um and so no one knew what sheet music they were following. So it was like we're not going to follow any of it. And so both documents went up on

575
03:02:23.760 --> 03:02:40.880
a shelf. Um but now we did do a lot of implementation. I will say there was a lot of implementation and work done for the OAG plan. But people kept saying what about the strategic plan? Which one am I following? lots of confusion again lack of alignment and coherence. So this

576
03:02:40.880 --> 03:02:58.800
really is the first time that the OAG policy is being positioned as that north star. So first comes the policy, then comes the strategic plan. This is where superintendent skipper then figures out the how and then we've got crossf functional teams. We have an actual

577
03:02:58.800 --> 03:03:14.640
design. We have a the OAG task force still standing as a monitoring body. So I think again it's about alignment and coherence. That's what's going to be different and that the superintendent and their leadership team were really involved in being able to weigh in. So

578
03:03:14.640 --> 03:03:30.080
there's also that sense of ownership which is why it's so important that the policies refreshed every five or so years. A lot of the people who were here back in 2016 are not here anymore. So this new team now has had a chance to

579
03:03:30.080 --> 03:03:46.399
read, to review, to weigh in, to make comments and edits. Um so I do think that sense of ownership is is here and the alignment. >> Yeah. Over the years we've known that there have been some things that have impeded our progress in terms of this

580
03:03:46.399 --> 03:04:02.240
one is data and getting data disagregated really disagregated which is something I think we've asked for for a decade or more. um true accountability um being able to name things that we

581
03:04:02.240 --> 03:04:16.640
know are not working >> um and holding people accountable for those things. And to that point, my question is where is the union? >> This the union for years has had um an

582
03:04:16.640 --> 03:04:33.600
issue around um inclusion inclusion done right. So we we need a O a done right strategy because they are critical >> at every single step from who is actually sitting in front of our

583
03:04:33.600 --> 03:04:49.120
students to their own mindset and commitment into this work the belief that this is possible. Um we provide tons of training. Does it is it more than just a checking of the box? where

584
03:04:49.120 --> 03:05:06.240
is the true embodiment about what this this training means and how are we going to see that showing up for our students in this next six years. >> Yeah, two things there. One is that u we were just really excited to have uh Leia

585
03:05:06.240 --> 03:05:22.160
Serena, vice president of the Boston Teachers Union, now on the task force. That's a first where we actually have the union represented in a seat and I think that's really important and her voice has just been really powerful to have. Um I think in terms of data the

586
03:05:22.160 --> 03:05:38.560
district has to become more transparent in data. We we ask for data it takes months to get it. there's sort of like let's present it in the best possible light and then you don't have transparency from that very moment

587
03:05:38.560 --> 03:05:54.720
because the data is not good in a lot of these areas and I think that transparency is important I think the that the community the public at large you know if the data is transparent the community has to be willing to say like

588
03:05:54.720 --> 03:06:09.120
having the data is not a place for attack it's a place for collaboration and partnership because now we know what we need to all work on together and collectively to make the data better. So I think that the data is really really important. I

589
03:06:09.120 --> 03:06:26.399
think um I you know and I see a lot of folks nodding their heads on the bench. I mean you know you ask for data and you get 50 pages because it's like there's almost like an intent that you're not able to even digest the data. >> Meaningful data is what >> meaningful data is what I would love.

590
03:06:26.399 --> 03:06:41.040
>> Not just data. >> Yes. Yeah, I think it's it's it's going to be taking the needing to take the step of it being from data to information. >> I think that's where sometimes we can stumble. >> Um I also think that there's sometimes

591
03:06:41.040 --> 03:06:57.600
the data we get back at the state level doesn't lend itself to disagregate in the way that we need to. And so that's something that our own ODA has been really trying to get at. you know, you will ask the question, you know, how are our African-American students who were

592
03:06:57.600 --> 03:07:14.560
born here in Boston doing relative to other students who may identify as black but not born here? And that's very hard to get at sometimes with the way that things get disagregated. But that is something that the ODA team is committed

593
03:07:14.560 --> 03:07:30.240
to and we're trying to figure out. And I think to Ellie's like point being collaborative about this that this is like there is a problem. How do we know there's a problem? This data has not changed in forever

594
03:07:30.240 --> 03:07:46.160
>> anywhere nationally, statewide. It is a problem. We know that. So let's get together to figure this out so Boston can be the place that all of our kids are served well. Like that is the spirit of this policy. more important it's the

595
03:07:46.160 --> 03:08:03.600
intentionality with the steps that we have to take and some of that is going to mean on our district side and central side doing things differently in order to get at the information in a way that's actionable right

596
03:08:03.600 --> 03:08:20.160
>> I would probably say something that I appreciated about uh the conversations and the processes um is that we've started to name the importance of time bound goals And when we are looking at KPIs

597
03:08:20.160 --> 03:08:36.080
um doesn't matter necessarily if you know you you know you score a touchdown on on a Hail Mary. It's you know what I I mean in in like in one play but it's about the incremental progress and then like

598
03:08:36.080 --> 03:08:51.439
that's what we're hoping to see. And so in a year the idea is to not see it'd be great if you jump five points whatever it is but it's about being realistic and saying like okay this is a timebound goal did we make it did we not and if we

599
03:08:51.439 --> 03:09:05.840
didn't okay but are we making progress and I think that adds to the sense of that everybody understands that this is urgent work um and so um I think that that's something that I've appreciated about the strategic plan as well as the

600
03:09:05.840 --> 03:09:28.560
um uh the O a um policy as well. >> Just want to thank you all and we look forward to voting on the policy in a future meeting. >> Thank you very much. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Okay. Our third presentation is the

601
03:09:28.560 --> 03:09:44.960
private school applications for two schools. First the Alpha School followed by the Douglas Ridley School. Let's aim to keep the presentations of each of these schools to seven minutes. I'd like to remind our presenters to please speak at a slower pace to assist our

602
03:09:44.960 --> 03:10:01.120
interpreters. And I want to invite the superintendent to give introductory remarks. >> Uh wonderful. Thank you, chair. So, um in a very few moments, I'll be turning the meeting over to Dr. Anne Clark, who's our BPS development officer for strategy, partnerships, and innovation.

603
03:10:01.120 --> 03:10:15.840
Uh this will be a presentation for two private school applications, the Alpha School and the Douglas Ridley School. The Alpha School Boston uh which will be going first is an independent non- sectarian K to8 school focused on

604
03:10:15.840 --> 03:10:32.880
personalized learning. the Douglas uh and then I'll come back and explain but the Douglas Ridley school is a K2 through6 school uh that is modeled after the Reio Amelia uh approach to education which is rooted in equity and anti-racist practice.

605
03:10:32.880 --> 03:10:49.040
Most importantly to ground us Dr. Clark's going to explain the process for opening a nonBPS school in Boston, including the role of the district and the required approval of this committee. You're also going to hear from the

606
03:10:49.040 --> 03:11:05.040
administration of both schools. Some of you may be new to the process. We have a role in BPS um which is strictly administrative. In this case, the district's responsible for ensuring all private schools seeking

607
03:11:05.040 --> 03:11:20.720
approval meet the requirements of Massachusetts general law and for making recommendations to me and the Boston school committee. The committee is responsible for approval of any private school wishing to operate within the

608
03:11:20.720 --> 03:11:36.720
city of Boston. So, at this point, I'll talk turn it over to Dr. Clark for the presentation. Uh, and then we'll entertain questions as we go through. Dr. Clark. >> Thank you, Superintendent. Good evening, Madame Chair, Madame Vice

609
03:11:36.720 --> 03:11:52.399
Chair, and members of the school committee. Um, as I was introduced, my name is Anne Clark, and I am serving in the role of overseeing the private school application process this school year, and I'm pleased to present the findings of our internal review team

610
03:11:52.399 --> 03:12:08.880
this evening. As you know, the Boston School Committee is responsible for approving any private school wishing to operate within Boston City limits under Massachusetts General Law, Chapter 76,

611
03:12:08.880 --> 03:12:23.600
Section 1. In 2011, the Boston School Committee established a formal private school policy, creating an internal review team process to evaluate applications from

612
03:12:23.600 --> 03:12:41.040
any interested parties and assess whether a proposed private school meets the standards set out by Massachusetts law. That internal review team evaluates applicants against a defined set of

613
03:12:41.040 --> 03:12:57.439
criteria covering everything from curriculum and education materials to staff qualifications to student records and financial solveny. This slide shows some of those criteria

614
03:12:57.439 --> 03:13:38.160
and I'll give you a moment to read. and this slide shows the rest of the criteria. I'll give you another moment to read. The review itself follows a fivestep process. application review, site visit,

615
03:13:38.160 --> 03:13:53.520
leadership interview, evaluation, and a formal recommendation to the superintendent and school committee. For the two schools before you today, the Alpha School and the Douglas Ridley School, all steps in that process are

616
03:13:53.520 --> 03:14:09.600
now complete. Both applications were received earlier this year. Site visits were conducted in March and recommendations have been submitted to the superintendent. The internal internal review team found that both

617
03:14:09.600 --> 03:14:26.640
schools met the criteria outlined by the Boston school committee policy. Tonight, you will hear from the school leaders at each of these schools who will give an overview of their proposal. On June 10th, you will vote on whether to approve these private schools

618
03:14:26.640 --> 03:15:03.760
applications to open. I'll now pass the presentation to the team from Alpha School. Good evening, superintendent, chair, chair, board. Um, I'm Dr. Tasha Arnold. I'm the head of Alpha Schools, and it's

619
03:15:03.760 --> 03:15:19.439
with great privilege that I'm here before you today to share what it is that our our school is about. Um, I originally started as a a school teacher in Chicago and Milwaukee public schools. I've had the privilege to work around the world in Europe, the UAE, and

620
03:15:19.439 --> 03:15:35.840
most recently starting and opening schools in Mumbai, India. And with me today, I have my colleague JC Fisher Fischer. >> Hi. Thank you all for having us here. I also want to thank Dr. Clark and her team and uh our council from Foleyhoag for helping us understand what it means

621
03:15:35.840 --> 03:15:52.960
to be a part of the community here in Boston and prepare an application that hopefully meets the standards that that we seek to meet here. So, Alpha School, as we've already touched upon, is a mastery focused school. So, we have it's it's a it's a

622
03:15:52.960 --> 03:16:08.640
typical school with regards to students come into the school for a full school day. Our mission is to ensure students achieve academic mastery while also developing cognitive, social, and personal competencies needed for success

623
03:16:08.640 --> 03:16:25.439
in school and then also postchool life. Our standards align academics with student with teacher support. So our core frameworks are completely aligned with the state of Massachusetts curriculum frameworks across all subject areas. And

624
03:16:25.439 --> 03:16:40.160
our instructional features include adaptive mastery based pathways. We use both formative and summitative assessments. We have teacher coaching and intervention models that are developed. We also have a reading specialist that works with our students

625
03:16:40.160 --> 03:16:56.479
for pull out sessions. And of course, we use benchmark assessments including MAP assessments as well as our own internal um unit and grade level assessments. And so you'll see at the bottom it says students progress based on demonstr

626
03:16:56.479 --> 03:17:14.319
demonstrated mastery rather than seat time alone. Here's a typical school day. Um we know that um well we've implemented a drop off time slot so from 8:15 to 8:45 uh you know to in order to allow for um

627
03:17:14.319 --> 03:17:31.520
um an influx of any sort of traffic. We have a morning launch where students come and it's about um mindfulness getting yourself ready and excited for the school day. Then we have our core academic blocks with some breaks built in there. lunchtime we um will we hope

628
03:17:31.520 --> 03:17:47.520
to walk to a park which is a five minute walk from the school for outdoor play and then we have our interdisciplinary workshops in the afternoon um and then we have closing and of course pickup. The calendar year is similar to um the

629
03:17:47.520 --> 03:18:03.040
public school system in regards to it achieving 180 days and um we also have professional development days allocated for our teachers. So in addition to having core mastery in academics, we are also focused on life

630
03:18:03.040 --> 03:18:18.880
skills. So life skills include for example teamwork, storytelling, entrepreneurship, financial literacy, um relationship building and socialization and of course the concept of grit and perseverance. So our afternoon workshops

631
03:18:18.880 --> 03:18:35.520
um include that core academic as I mentioned interdisciplinary crossplanning subjects. So, for example, um our students might be working on carpentry, but they're applying geometric principles from geometry, history, knowing that the wood, you know, where did the wood come from, and

632
03:18:35.520 --> 03:18:50.560
then also giving presentations to larger groups. Um, and we're working on developing those skills through something that's of interest to our students. >> Our site is already ready. We have the certificate of occupancy and inspection

633
03:18:50.560 --> 03:19:08.319
from the city. Uh we've passed all fire, alarm, sprinkler, tests, etc. We're also located right across the street from Mass General Brighgam so we can have a place to receive if we ever have any medical emergencies and we're very close to fire engine number four um so that we

634
03:19:08.319 --> 03:19:24.800
have close proximity to the appropriate emergency services as well. Um you'll notice we're on the fourth floor of a building. The second and third floor are operated by a Monasuri school. Um, and previously this floor was used for educational use as well. So, we're maintaining the same use of the site. We

635
03:19:24.800 --> 03:19:41.040
have four classrooms, commons area, indoor play area, support space for our one-on-one meetings between our teachers and students for additional support, as well as staff admin, and your classic, you know, plenty of bathrooms, eating area, etc. Um, lots of security. We have

636
03:19:41.040 --> 03:19:57.920
controlled building access on the way up, um, and separation from other tenants to ensure children's safety. So we have a we have strong interest in the school. Um when we initially were starting conversations with families, we

637
03:19:57.920 --> 03:20:14.479
had 252, this was back in February um towards the end of February, we had 252 families interested um 20 parents uh prepaid deposits should we be approved um by the committee. And um in year one we're looking to launch with 25 students

638
03:20:14.479 --> 03:20:31.359
and then year two the capacity would be at 50. So that's um our our projections for year two. Um our model is really focused on highly personalized um instruction with our students. So our um ratios are quite low. 1:6 is our um

639
03:20:31.359 --> 03:20:46.640
teacher to student ratio in year one. And then as we grow to 50 it will be 1 to um eight. So in year one, we would have a headteer, um two additional teachers, a reading specialist, a role that we call dean of parents. So that's

640
03:20:46.640 --> 03:21:06.319
helping parents understand our model and working them through. And then I operate as the head of school from um a regional position. Um so I will also be here in Boston as much as possible. you know, part of one of the privileges of starting a school is really being

641
03:21:06.319 --> 03:21:22.319
able to integrate into a community and um Boston's such a wonderful community with regards to um you know, inclusion and diversity. And so for us as a school, we're really looking forward to be a part of that. One of the things that we think we can bring to the

642
03:21:22.319 --> 03:21:38.239
community is offering um workshops for AI instruction for students where our our students are already um at our other campuses are already thinking about um hosting a hackathon for all students in the area to participate in. So, we

643
03:21:38.239 --> 03:21:55.760
really hope to be um a piece to add to the community and um that's something that we're really excited about is building those opportunities in a way that makes sense and also that excite you know students and teachers alike. >> So, I think we just made it in our time

644
03:21:55.760 --> 03:22:13.200
slot, but we we would we would love to, you know, um answer any questions you may have or um continue the conversation. >> Great. Thank you. I'll open it up to the committee for questions. >> I have one question. How are the

645
03:22:13.200 --> 03:22:28.000
students and families selected? What is the process? >> Yeah. So students um parents express interest and then so they attend an information session. They learn about the school. Is this a good fit for my family, for my child in particular? Then

646
03:22:28.000 --> 03:22:44.160
the child comes for the shadow day. Um they they complete a MAP assessment, but we are we don't accept students based on their scores. That's that's not how we accept students. What we're looking for are things such as coachability, interest, and ability to engage with our

647
03:22:44.160 --> 03:22:59.680
model. That's our our standard for assessment. We also do a family interview because we we're looking for alignment as um you know, from our families. And then from there, um that's that's really how we decide our acceptance. I also do a family interview

648
03:22:59.680 --> 03:23:19.279
um with the parents as we build this community. >> Yeah. the number of uh sorry the number of uh parents who have uh expressed their interest. What's the breakdown in terms of diversity?

649
03:23:19.279 --> 03:23:34.560
Yeah, we've had um I don't have the exact breakdown, but we've had all sorts of um interests from all across the levels. And so, you know, the the nice thing I would say about our model is it doesn't matter if you know you are the

650
03:23:34.560 --> 03:23:49.359
student who always raises their hand, if you're an ELLL student, if you are a neurodeiverse student, you know, we're able to meet you right where you're at um for your own specific academic needs. And so what we notice is parents um see

651
03:23:49.359 --> 03:24:04.960
that so it it attracts all sorts of interest from across you know the whole scope and sequence. >> Are you equipped to uh uh uh accommodate a student with disability?

652
03:24:04.960 --> 03:24:22.319
>> Yeah. So, you know, we have um we look at our student if a student comes to us with a 504 plan depending on what those accommodations are, yes, we can be able to provide that. But if a student um s certain services we don't provide during the school day, so if a student um needs

653
03:24:22.319 --> 03:24:38.160
a speech pathology, we're partnered with um experts in that area, clinical psychologist um that were able to recommend and also help build those relationships with our families. So um our program a lot of accommodations that

654
03:24:38.160 --> 03:24:53.680
students receive for dyslexia, disgraphia, dcalculia. Um extra time is already built in. So you're working at your own pace. So if you need 50% extra time, well all students actually get that. Um if we need to adjust font size

655
03:24:53.680 --> 03:25:08.720
or you need movement breaks, that's that's built into the system. So the accommodations that we give neurodeiverse students actually all of our students are receiving and so we see that that's um that's been quite successful for many students. Um but

656
03:25:08.720 --> 03:25:24.960
yes, some of those occupational therapy um supports that would take place outside of school, but we would be monitoring that from their IEP forms um if it's a 504 plan, whatever it might be. Um we're working with the families to make sure that students are receiving

657
03:25:24.960 --> 03:25:40.640
those supports outside of school as well. And one of our next steps were we to receive your approval is we have an initial list. We're doing procurement for the right contractors for special education needs and for mental health services that we don't provide during the school day to ensure children have

658
03:25:40.640 --> 03:25:55.600
access to them. So if we were to receive approval, we will finalize and formalize those agreements with the appropriate local contractors. >> Yeah. See, just one last question out of curiosity. What's the uh annual tuition?

659
03:25:55.600 --> 03:26:12.000
Our initial tuition planned is 65,000 a year. >> 65,000 a year per student. >> Correct. >> Thank you. >> We do we are building out uh so the founding family members for the first year it's 10,000 um um discount per

660
03:26:12.000 --> 03:26:26.960
year. So 55,000. >> Um as a national movement we are bu we're working towards scholarships. We want to be able to provide this opportunity. you know, our we we want to bring this to a billion students in 10

661
03:26:26.960 --> 03:26:45.840
years, which I know sounds quite lofty. Um, but we do want to provide this opportunity to multiple students and so we are working towards building a scholarship program as a national push. >> Thank you. >> Yeah. >> Thank you for Thank you, Madam Chair.

662
03:26:45.840 --> 03:27:03.040
Thank you for the presentation. Uh it's interesting the the school process the curriculum because uh they putting the the skilled the student is very important.

663
03:27:03.040 --> 03:27:19.200
My question is um about the scholar scholarship because some family maybe is interesting but don't have lot of money. I don't know if you you have financial or

664
03:27:19.200 --> 03:27:36.319
complete completely um scholarship for the family. We're working towards that. So, we are um we we've secured um we're starting to secure funds for that. We really want to be able to provide scholarships. It's not probably going to

665
03:27:36.319 --> 03:27:53.840
happen in year one. Um year two, more of a likely probability. Year three, we think we'll be able to be providing scholarships. And that outreach would be directly within within the community as well. Um, you know, we want we want to, as we said, we want to integrate into the community. So, we want to provide

666
03:27:53.840 --> 03:28:08.800
opportunities for students who can't pay that tuition fee. Yes, absolutely. >> Thank you so much. >> Yeah. Um >> could you speak a little bit more just about how uh your funding is sort of

667
03:28:08.800 --> 03:28:24.319
managed like either through a board or and just that just that structure and I mean just for full transparency we've recently had a school in the district a private school that had to close multiple locations.

668
03:28:24.319 --> 03:28:39.520
not going to go into details like about it, but you know, at the end of the day, it impacts our students and and so like we want to know that another a private school that will be in the district, you

669
03:28:39.520 --> 03:28:55.439
know, is is is managed properly. >> Of course. >> Go ahead. >> Okay. Um, so we're part of an over 30 school network nationally right now and we're managed centrally. Um, we have a centralized professional financial management team. Um, we're privately

670
03:28:55.439 --> 03:29:11.120
held. We have a strong corporate governance with a clear board oversight that handles all of the alpha school program. Um, we have a fairly capital light model, which means rather than buying real estate and running the risk of being overleveraged and collapsing under the weight of a balance sheet,

671
03:29:11.120 --> 03:29:27.840
right, we're keeping that bunny and putting it back into our schools. Um, and then on top of that, we have over a billion dollars committed from our founder to make sure that this happens and that we go through the next 5 to 10 years because our mission and goal is to truly take this model, prove it works,

672
03:29:27.840 --> 03:29:43.279
and then expand it across the Oh, my mic went and then expand it across the globe um to everybody, right? Over a billion children is literally the goal that we espouse every time somebody asks and we talk about it. And it's a very missiondriven organization.

673
03:29:43.279 --> 03:29:59.760
>> And I think this is not necessarily a question for y'all, but just a question for also the district of what data do we have particularly around students um either returning to the district if perhaps they're they go elsewhere and

674
03:29:59.760 --> 03:30:15.279
they're not the right fit or however else they make their way back to the district. Do we just have data around that? Um >> yeah so we are the landing pad for all students >> right for sure

675
03:30:15.279 --> 03:30:32.160
>> and um that means when a student is counseledled out or doesn't fit um either the model from inception or the experience it is BPS that is here every step of the way for those students. Um and so I think you can understand why

676
03:30:32.160 --> 03:30:49.760
for us >> um you know when a a new entity comes into being uh for us it's a question of who are you really serving and um are you serving the average student in in Boston? Um I was just curious I I've

677
03:30:49.760 --> 03:31:05.760
looked at your website how what's your total enrollment across all your sites? Yeah. So, um around 500 students that's as of now. So, our Austin campus opened 12 years ago. I guess you could say 12 years ago. And then, um two years ago,

678
03:31:05.760 --> 03:31:22.479
we really launched uh a second location in Miami. And then this past year, we've had um greater expansion. We we have lots of demand across the country, but at the same time, we're not just opening up anywhere and everywhere. Uh it's been it's been through the demand of parents

679
03:31:22.479 --> 03:31:38.000
and us meeting with parents having many conversations right um you know our parents triing the model um you know it's not just you have an info session and oh let's open up a school it very much has been you know this is what they want and so that's they they brought us

680
03:31:38.000 --> 03:31:54.399
to Boston essentially if you will and so um yeah so it's it's it's expanding but we're also being very intentional with how we scale >> right so sorry I just missed who Who brought you to Boston? >> The parents that are that are interested in in joining, they they said, "Please

681
03:31:54.399 --> 03:32:09.760
come to Boston." That was >> Oh, I see. Okay. >> Yeah, that was >> Yeah, cuz I was just wondering because like when I looked right like I didn't see any demographic data of the kids enrolled in any of the sites. I didn't see anything about students with IEPs, like what the percent was enrolled or

682
03:32:09.760 --> 03:32:26.399
multilingual learners. So, is like do you have that data for your >> Yeah, I it's pretty tradition. you know, about 20% are neur on the neurodeiverse scale um within the within the school. We don't we don't have that data published. Um but yeah, I'm I'm happy to share about that. It's the diversity

683
03:32:26.399 --> 03:32:42.880
reflects the cities that they're in um pretty pretty accurately, I would say. So, you know, our campus in Georgia, for example, is reflecting that diversity of that city. Um same, you know, in New York as well. So there's it's reflective of the community largely of course you

684
03:32:42.880 --> 03:32:59.760
know within within a little bit um depending on the city. >> Gotcha. Yeah. I think that would just be really good data for the committee to have >> right uh to Dr. Alan's point just you know sort of um and then just like another question can you just speak a little bit about like are your teachers

685
03:32:59.760 --> 03:33:17.279
certified? Like do you are your administrators certified? Like how does that work in the model? Yeah. So most of our teachers and that's about 65% come from traditional teaching backgrounds. Um all educators have degrees. Um you know they

686
03:33:17.279 --> 03:33:33.520
would have had to have worked extensively with children in some sort of capacity. That could have been um a sports coach. It you know it could be um a guide of some sort thinking like scouts. Um and uh yeah the senior leadership um tends to be um you know

687
03:33:33.520 --> 03:33:50.640
from education backgrounds. um for myself you know I have a doctorate in education um you know all of our other deans of parents many of them I want to say 80 75 80% all have doctorate degrees um so there's you know a large investment in education background but

688
03:33:50.640 --> 03:34:07.520
we also you know as we have these life skills workshops um you know people that have strong coaching backgrounds tend to be really good fit for our model um so we have you know um those that have coached at the college level for example um and also quite a few professors as

689
03:34:07.520 --> 03:34:23.680
well have been working with our students. So, it's a wide range, but many have that traditional teaching um background and are getting, you know, um teachers or those that aren't teachers are also pursuing that as well as part of their PD development.

690
03:34:23.680 --> 03:34:40.640
>> Got it. Okay, great. I'll you'll >> that role for a while. So, >> no, those are my next questions actually about just getting some of the the basic demographic data of where your school currently is like across the across the country.

691
03:34:40.640 --> 03:34:56.479
>> Um, because I'm I'm not as familiar with like who specifically like you serve or just like are you seeing that you're you're you're growing in particular demographics versus others? Um and then just like echoing um superintendent just

692
03:34:56.479 --> 03:35:11.840
like support for multilingual learn just some digging in a little bit more like to to that for for for me. >> Yeah. Because your sites are very much oriented in the major cities, right? Or the more diverse locations within those

693
03:35:11.840 --> 03:35:26.880
states. So that's why I think the data would be important. It would also be important to see again to Dr. Alkins point, but like what your retention data looks like, >> you know, like when students start, how long do they go, do they finish, right? Because that's going to be of concern

694
03:35:26.880 --> 03:35:42.960
for us, you know, we we um when we get students back that have gone through some place and not um had a positive experience, then we're picking pieces up. And so that's why for us, we want to make sure that kids are going to be cared for,

695
03:35:42.960 --> 03:35:59.920
right? if they're in your model. Um, that would that would be important. >> So, this past year I said around 500 students, we only have 6% turnover and when I've broken that down, most of that is parents moving to another city where they don't have an alpha school. Um, and

696
03:35:59.920 --> 03:36:15.680
so they actually some of them opt for additional private school options. We also have something called alpha anywhere which is a homeschool model. So, we see parents selecting that. where we do see turnover and I just want to you know students that are coming to us

697
03:36:15.680 --> 03:36:31.920
tend to not be coming from the public schools they're coming from other private school competitors. Um uh so you know that's just kind of a caveat there but um sorry I lost my train of thought there. >> That's cool. >> I normally am in bed at this time.

698
03:36:31.920 --> 03:36:49.040
>> No, it's all good. Yeah, I was just also the the other thing was just noticing some of the places, but it's also some of the places where vouchers tend to be used and so I was just kind of curious like how much of the business model is that? >> You know, are most of your clients private paying or are you seeing, you

699
03:36:49.040 --> 03:37:05.279
know, such as in Arizona more of a voucher trend? >> We do have um a percentage of our students, I want to say it's 25, but I need to check that um that are using the voucher system in Arizona. So yes, to your point, that is that is correct. But

700
03:37:05.279 --> 03:37:20.319
our other cities where we don't have the vouchers approved, it is primarily private school students um that are that are coming over to our school. Yeah. >> Time back. >> Oh, the thing I was going to say about

701
03:37:20.319 --> 03:37:35.840
turnover, that's it. Um where we do see a shift is at the high school level. Um, so some students they want, you know, our schools are very small, so they want, you know, to be the the quarterback on the team or they want a

702
03:37:35.840 --> 03:37:52.880
prom with 300 students or other reasons as well, be part of a large band, for example. Um, so we do see students switching at that point. But what's interesting, at least I find what's interesting, students that have left us, a little bit more than 50% actually come

703
03:37:52.880 --> 03:38:07.760
back after doing a year um in high school at their at at at a at an another option of a school. So I would say that is the that is a pinch point that 8th to 9th grade there is a change, but those students are also often opting

704
03:38:07.760 --> 03:38:26.640
to then go to private schools. Thank you for the presentation and I'm one of the new members for whom this is the first season of approving um private school applications. So you'll have to forgive that some of my questions are related to alpha schools and others are more to further understand the process.

705
03:38:26.640 --> 03:38:43.279
So sorry that you guys are the victims, but um the un it's a little uncomfortable. I think I'll just speak in I statements to hold a responsibility to approve a school for which we will have no oversight or future updates. So I think

706
03:38:43.279 --> 03:38:59.439
we sit with that as we you know are deeply invested in the the success of students across the city regardless of the schools that they go to and understanding that we have not had any real vantage point into the school um and carry this responsibility. So I

707
03:38:59.439 --> 03:39:16.000
think it's just it's a it's an odd um it's an odd responsibility that Desi has assigned to individual school committees to carry carry this for a few reasons. One is um Dr. Dr. Clark, you walked through some of the things that BPS has

708
03:39:16.000 --> 03:39:33.520
put in place to make a process to review applications. Um, that sound like it probably involves a significant amount of time from you or someone on the BPS team. Um, so we have more information I imagine than some other districts that just might not be as big or have the

709
03:39:33.520 --> 03:39:48.880
capacity to invest in research because it's my understanding that this review process is a BPS review process, not a required desi process. So, I just think it is important to understand that the state has tasked districts with

710
03:39:48.880 --> 03:40:04.000
approving independent schools with very little guidance around how we're supposed to determine whether they meet the requirements. So, just wanted to mention that. Um I think also the the

711
03:40:04.000 --> 03:40:21.439
list of criteria from um is challenging as DESIE has very strict criteria for public schools around a variety of things from teacher certification and lenture to literal

712
03:40:21.439 --> 03:40:36.080
number of hours that students are required to be in school. Um, we've you've had to sit through our Mass Corp vote earlier today, and I know you all aren't applying to be a high school in this case, but a lot of what has been

713
03:40:36.080 --> 03:40:52.960
criticized by BPS is, oh, I I can't believe we're having students do admentum to make up credits. You know, where is the rigor? I can't believe we're thinking about making exceptions for for students to take fewer than 24 classes. Um, and then to sit with

714
03:40:52.960 --> 03:41:10.560
someone paying $65,000 to do two hours of academic instruction is just it it's really surreal. Then it's on us to then make that decision. Um, so I would love to hear a little bit about the two hours of academics um, and how that gets

715
03:41:10.560 --> 03:41:26.720
students to to mastery. Um, I would say also maybe even for the public to understand that there are different ways to arrive at at mastery and some of the things that maybe folks are stressing um in terms of what define rigor um when

716
03:41:26.720 --> 03:41:42.399
we're looking at different populations, we might have different expectations for how to get there. So I would love to to hear um about how that works. >> Yeah. So um the two hours I would say that's core content learning, right? So

717
03:41:42.399 --> 03:41:59.840
um you know think of learning your math facts. We have an app called fast math. So you literally are it's the automaticity of knowing your facts. And you mentioned earlier you know that pinch point of algebra really being um you know critical in your success especially in high school. So we the

718
03:41:59.840 --> 03:42:16.239
whole idea is you have to have mastery in certain subjects before you can kind of move on. So we require our students to have 90% mastery at a subject level um per per subject um in order to move on advance to the next level of of of

719
03:42:16.239 --> 03:42:31.600
academics. Now that's measured through MAP three times a year. As I mentioned we also have our own internal assessments as well. So that takes place in the morning. Now it's it's you know our teachers get um this is what my students are working on that day.

720
03:42:31.600 --> 03:42:46.640
They're quality checking. They're deciding when kids are taking a unit or a subject matter test. Um, you know, a child has a question, the teacher is there to to to jump in and to, you know, help them use strategies in order to um,

721
03:42:46.640 --> 03:43:02.640
you know, master that learning. And then it's it's not that that's the only learning that occurs. I would say in addition to that, our teachers are building these life skills workshops which are completely interdisciplinary. So you are having these cross subjects.

722
03:43:02.640 --> 03:43:19.120
So it's not just applying your math understanding in a times test, right? It's now that application of understanding um you know how do I how do I measure how do I find the area? How do I you know in a real context that they might

723
03:43:19.120 --> 03:43:34.800
experience and then also develop life skills that maybe encourage them to pursue a career in the future. So I used the example before about carpentry. So, you know, that that has inspired one of our students to really dive deep into wood carving and and you know, it's not

724
03:43:34.800 --> 03:43:51.359
just he's showed mastery in the content area of math and now he's been able to apply it. So, the afternoon is is very much an education. It's not just, you know, playtime. It is it's woven. It's very specific. Um when it comes to the number of hours, yes, our school day is

725
03:43:51.359 --> 03:44:08.160
aligned to um actually exceed what you know is is being done in the in the state of Massachusetts. Um we also, you know, open our school up in the afternoons if kids want to stay after school. We have after school um academics. Um we do Olympiads, we do all

726
03:44:08.160 --> 03:44:24.399
sorts of um you know, robotics, all sorts of STEM focused uh activities as well. Um, so I think I think part of it is there's a misconception that it's just, you know, two hours and then in the afternoon we play. That's really not what's happening. It's, you know, when I

727
03:44:24.399 --> 03:44:40.880
was an educator, I I tried to really provide opportunities where my kids could apply the learning. Um, and I know myself that's how I actually knew I learned it. And so that's really what kind of guides our afternoon focus. Does that does that answer what you're >> very helpful? Yeah. Um, I think it's,

728
03:44:40.880 --> 03:44:56.960
you know, incumbent on us too as a as a school district to pay attention to what parents are asking for so that we remain competitive in an environment with declining enrollment in the city. Um, you talked about, I mean, it's a it's a modest enrollment right now, but you've

729
03:44:56.960 --> 03:45:13.040
also named wanting to serve a billion students, which I imagine when you're ready to do that, you'll be coming back to Boston to seek to expand or open a high school or do something else. So, I think it is important that we understand how we can um be competitive in this in

730
03:45:13.040 --> 03:45:28.560
this market to remind families that we're always here to serve students. So, I would just be curious when you talk about families asking you to come to Boston, what is the value proposition or the element of your school specifically

731
03:45:28.560 --> 03:45:44.800
that they define that they're looking for that they don't feel like they could um find in the existing like plethora of independent schools, faith-based schools, parochial schools, charter schools, public schools. Now, um especially hearing that you all use the Massachusetts grade level frameworks,

732
03:45:44.800 --> 03:46:00.800
you give the same assessment that we do. um have the same school day 180 school days. There's a lot of similarity to a typical school day. So what is the the specific element that is the distinguishing factor?

733
03:46:00.800 --> 03:46:18.239
>> So our our program that we use is called time back >> and so a lot of our parents have been spending eye watering amounts in tutoring after school. Um the idea is our students are achieving mastery and they're not having to do homework after

734
03:46:18.239 --> 03:46:34.080
school. And um the feedback that I get by and large is I'm giving you're giving my child their childhood back. They're now able to stay at soccer practice an extra 15 minutes, not hurry up, pack up your stuff, and run home to have to go do your homework. That's one of the

735
03:46:34.080 --> 03:46:49.520
major um one of the benefits that parents are highlighting. And also um just a love for school. You know, our you know, I've heard this talked about a lot today, right? Like kids enjoying school. That's our number one commitment is that kids love school. We spend a lot

736
03:46:49.520 --> 03:47:05.120
of time coaching our children. Um our teachers have meetings with our kids onetoone, multiple times a week. Um and so they and it's not just about academic coaching or life skill coaching or what are your aspirations or any key guy

737
03:47:05.120 --> 03:47:22.560
workshop. It's about knowing, you know, who their cousin is, who's, you know, where where are you spending your time on the weekends. So, I think it's it's the sense of belonging that kids feel at school contributes to the happiness. Um, so I think giving families time back um

738
03:47:22.560 --> 03:47:38.560
not having to focus on extra work when we're able to do that in the school day is a huge value proposition for our parents. Um, so it's it's it's it is it is different. Um, and then you know, we wouldn't have standardized tests for

739
03:47:38.560 --> 03:47:54.720
the most part, but except for the fact that people wouldn't believe what we're doing, right? We need to show this is the data. They're not just coming in in for two hours and, you know, yes, we think they're learning. There is, you know, data to show that our students are growing. And it's, you know, it's been

740
03:47:54.720 --> 03:48:09.600
really powerful for me to see how our program has worked in Brownsville, for example, in Texas where the students are, you know, bottom 3 to 7% um in the country. Um I I think the second poorest

741
03:48:09.600 --> 03:48:26.800
um you know, uh area in the country and to see that model be implemented and the success that those students have had has been for me has been really inspiring as an educator. And so I think that it's it's something that can be applied in in many areas and I hope we would love to

742
03:48:26.800 --> 03:48:43.439
partner you know I mean it's a privilege to be here in Boston. I mean think of the educational institutions here in the history even of you know BPS in and of itself. So we're we're happy to to work with provide you know trainings or people that are curious learn about the

743
03:48:43.439 --> 03:48:58.080
model. Um, you know, we've had schools approach us that they're like, "Hey, can we do some trials?" And and we are doing that with some schools around the country, some public schools. Um, so, you know, we're we're happy to explore that as well.

744
03:48:58.080 --> 03:49:15.120
>> I'd also say, oh, sorry. Operationally, because of our size and resources, we have a lot of flexibility to serve our families, right? So, children can come in early, they can stay late, we have the right afterchool programs that are very easy for them to access. And even to the point that in Austin, I think it

745
03:49:15.120 --> 03:49:31.439
was last year, you'll correct me, the students wanted to spend more time in school. So, we reopened the school during the summer so they could come back in because they wanted to engage in the core learning apps and then have meetings with each other that were semi like self-organized and led to continue those life skills workshops and

746
03:49:31.439 --> 03:49:47.680
learnings and things that they had just finished doing that they didn't really want to be done yet. Uh, and so they wanted to spend multiple days a week just coming back to school like they had for most of the year, which again, like operationally, it's kind of nice to have that flexibility. Like that's my role, right? I'm I'm not a teacher. I I run

747
03:49:47.680 --> 03:50:04.000
our operations nationally. Uh, and so to be able to do that at these different schools and provide that level of opportunity, that's another thing that I think sets us apart. >> Yeah. >> And and can we go doc Dr. All where was the place that you mentioned that students were in the bottom 3 to 7% there?

748
03:50:04.000 --> 03:50:18.880
>> Brownsville, Texas. And they're your student like so you accepted students who were in like the 3 to seven percentile for math. >> Yeah. >> Okay. >> And they worked with us. Um we're now in year two. Um so there's and those

749
03:50:18.880 --> 03:50:35.760
students were full tuition students. >> So the tuition there is much lower. Um yes. So they um they will be using in the future their their vouchers. But yeah, so for so we have alpha schools. I guess I I should say that that school's under the umbrella of Alpha, so they use

750
03:50:35.760 --> 03:50:49.920
the two-hour learning. So, it's a slightly different um model with regards to the tuition pricing, but yes, it's the same it's the same format, the same program. >> Okay. Um I I'm at the end of my time. I

751
03:50:49.920 --> 03:51:06.640
think I would just consider um I know a billion dollars um is a lot of money and I think it would be a powerful statement of access to figure out how immediately opportunities could be made um to make

752
03:51:06.640 --> 03:51:21.680
the tuition more affordable. It it's difficult to hear that kind of financial backing and and hear that there's no avenue at this time for for financial support. So I would that would be my last uh recommendation. >> Yeah. No, we totally agree. You know,

753
03:51:21.680 --> 03:51:38.319
we've applied for voucher status in we've been denied in eight states and the only state that approved us currently is um Arizona. So we are continuing that work. And with regards to scholarships in particular, we are triing that at some of our campuses. It's just not going to be in Boston for

754
03:51:38.319 --> 03:51:52.640
next year. Um so this is it's something that we're building up. We're reaching out um and and building this fund. We want to be able to do that. And as the tech price comes down over time, it will make our schools more affordable to for

755
03:51:52.640 --> 03:52:08.560
for us to offer even more scholarships. >> Yeah. So just one scholarship for one out of 25 and finding the 65k to recoup would be my recommendation. We're not a voucher state. >> Right. Exactly.

756
03:52:08.560 --> 03:52:26.239
>> Yeah. >> More questions. >> I do too. Yeah. So I have >> I mean I know where Yeah. >> Yeah. >> So I have a pointed question. Um because I find myself really interested in your financial model.

757
03:52:26.239 --> 03:52:41.920
>> Um so you guys are a forprofit, correct? >> Currently, yes. >> Okay. And so what is the I know you have the billion dollar backing, but what is your actual what is the net value of the

758
03:52:41.920 --> 03:52:59.120
of your for-profit company? >> I'll I'll turn that over to my operations guy because my numbers would be >> is it is it by franchise or is it one entire >> It's one company. >> It's one company. >> Yeah. >> We're all privately held by one owner of

759
03:52:59.120 --> 03:53:14.800
a school. It's not like um >> not like Tasha just went and did one in New York and one in Boston and Joe is doing one in Texas and Sally's doing one in Miami. It it's all one company like central. >> And what and what is that value?

760
03:53:14.800 --> 03:53:32.640
>> You mean like a valuation if we were to IPO or something? >> Yeah. What is your net value as a company? Because like that really is >> Well, it's privately it's privately owned. So I I that's not public knowledge. I I couldn't I don't know the e actual

761
03:53:32.640 --> 03:53:47.760
exact number personally. >> Okay. I mean >> I would have to actually guess at like an IBIDA multiple or what it would come from. I >> Yeah, >> I don't want to make up an answer for you. >> That would be helpful to get. I mean simply because it's been sensitive for

762
03:53:47.760 --> 03:54:05.199
us in seeing not just private schools go under for financial reasons but also charters, >> right? And so I think too right now. >> Correct. And so like I think for us like we have to have our doors open to our

763
03:54:05.199 --> 03:54:21.199
kids. So I think it's just important to kind of understand. It's great to see the backing, but sometimes things change, people make different decisions, philanthropic dollars go away, and

764
03:54:21.199 --> 03:54:36.880
you know, the committee is tasked with deciding whether this is going to be stable going forward in the future. So I just think some of those answers of the financial book piece would be important for the committee to look at just given the history of a couple of things that

765
03:54:36.880 --> 03:54:53.439
have happened recently here. >> Of course our our proforma for Boston I can share in the application because I don't have to make it up because I made it. Um in year two and three we're looking at 25 to 30% ebida margins. And so as soon as we hit that 25 30% range,

766
03:54:53.439 --> 03:55:09.439
that's when we start to take, okay, great. The school is sustainable. We know it's going to work. We know it's delivering what we need. Now we can take the excess. And that's why we start funding the scholarship model off of that is once we prove >> we're actually going to be viable. We know it's going to work. We're hitting our targets. That's when we start

767
03:55:09.439 --> 03:55:26.880
funneling money back into access as well. >> Okay. And what can one last question uh because I like Dr. Hawkins, I could just keep going, but um just one last question. What is the a what is your average teacher salary? >> Uh 120,000 starting

768
03:55:26.880 --> 03:55:45.279
>> and does that does that hold true across you you do a cost of living or does that hold true? >> Yeah, there's a slight cost of living. So um some some cities are 150,000 starting um depending. Yeah, >> got it. Okay, thank you. >> You're welcome. So Boston it starts 120.

769
03:55:45.279 --> 03:56:01.520
Sorry, I sorry I did I did have just one question about um and I promise you had mentioned Dr. Arnold that you were a regional head of school. You said you'd be in Boston as much as possible. So does that mean you have um responsibility for other schools and and

770
03:56:01.520 --> 03:56:17.760
travel between them? So I operate like a superintendent essentially. Um, so I have um deans of parents at each of my campuses that act um, you know, as senior leadership within the school and then obviously I have, you know, weekly standups multiple times a week with all

771
03:56:17.760 --> 03:56:35.199
of them as a cohort. But then I also do visit all of my campuses. I'm based in New York, so Boston's very easy for me to get to. Um, I love Boston. Uh, my nonprofit's based here, so I'm here often anyway. But yes, so I op I operate as a um as a regional or as a

772
03:56:35.199 --> 03:56:49.600
superintendent across the country. >> So the highest kind of ranking person in the building daily would be the dean like that >> dean of parents and the head teacher who acts we we we don't call them a principal but yes they're like the principal the headteer and then the dean

773
03:56:49.600 --> 03:57:06.880
of parents the two of them. >> And what is the for the Boston population um or for for For schools ini in cities that do not use vouchers, are what is the typical

774
03:57:06.880 --> 03:57:22.880
MAP score that students are coming in with at the out at the outset? Is it is it fairly aligned to grade level, above grade level, below grade level, like on an on an average? >> On average, it's about two grades below level on average. Yeah.

775
03:57:22.880 --> 03:57:37.279
>> And then within one year, our our what we see is after one year, we have them at grade level. And then when they're with us for two years, that's when they start to get to that top one to three percentile. >> I think with that kind of acceleration,

776
03:57:37.279 --> 03:57:53.760
thinking about what the contribution to the larger education space in Boston would be important beyond semianual AI workshops. Absolutely. I think if we're accelerating outcomes at that level that we need to do some deep sharing um and

777
03:57:53.760 --> 03:58:09.279
you know classroom observations and sharing of best practices um >> for sure >> you know what we're open to it and we've been waiting for a public school district to say hey come on in. So we would love that. >> Yeah.

778
03:58:09.279 --> 03:58:24.319
>> Yep. >> Um just particular like two two questions. I'll I'll cap it at that. Um you mentioned sort of like families bringing you to Boston. I'm just curious if we can actually see that data, just

779
03:58:24.319 --> 03:58:40.319
survey data I imagine that you gathered or >> so it's it started with parents that were in Austin. They actually moved from Boston to Austin. Not trying to rhyme, but it does. Um and so they wanted to they want to move back to Boston. So

780
03:58:40.319 --> 03:58:57.040
they said, "Hey, we have a group of families that are in private schools that really want to bring Alpha to Boston." And so we said, "Okay, you know, we can start having conversations." And those parents came down to our Austin campus, um did the

781
03:58:57.040 --> 03:59:12.800
shadow, went through the whole admissions process, shadow day, were interested, and then we said, "Well, you know, we'll let let's let's see if we can if we can bring it to Boston." So that's actually how the cohort here came to be. Um and then through that word of mouth

782
03:59:12.800 --> 03:59:29.680
>> has been you know can we have another you know can we get a group together for a small coffee or a small dinner and then it's kind of spread that way really. >> Okay. So not necessarily like a formal >> not a >> formal questions that you might have asked or things like that. >> Right. Exactly. There is you can go on

783
03:59:29.680 --> 03:59:46.000
our website there is a map and there's it's an interest map. So when people are interested in a location, they can log it and then you they you can see clusters. Um so when parents are, you know, they get a cluster together, they reach out and they say, "Hey, there's,

784
03:59:46.000 --> 04:00:03.120
you know, 40 of us. We're really interested in bringing Alpha to this city." And that's that's really how we have been moving from city to city. Of course, we do all their diligence. And you know, as you could imagine, real estate and permitting tends to be something that holds you up. Um but for

785
04:00:03.120 --> 04:00:17.680
the most part that's that's how we get brought to the the various cities. >> Thank you. Um and so one one more question is just around this is a proposed K to8. So do you have particular data about how your students

786
04:00:17.680 --> 04:00:33.120
fare once they are either transitioning to another private school per se like a public school setting just how they're fairing um academically, socially, emotionally. We we have anecdotal evidence when it

787
04:00:33.120 --> 04:00:50.960
comes to the social part. We don't have um necessarily I would say robust data on if you've left us and gone to a you know at 8th grade and went to a high school. Um like I said I think the 50% or 52% that come back to us I think is is to me signals something. um when it

788
04:00:50.960 --> 04:01:06.960
at univers at the university level um so we had um our first graduating class 11 of the 12 went to their top university choice um Stanford you know Vanderbilt you're talking top universities the 12th is a professional water skier so he

789
04:01:06.960 --> 04:01:22.560
opted not to go to college um and all of those students those 11 of the 12 their first year both semesters or trimesters uh Stanford as a trimester um had 4.0's. Um, now when we asked them how was it

790
04:01:22.560 --> 04:01:39.439
transitioning to college, um, you know, they said, well, the hundred large lecture rooms didn't, you know, felt to them like a waste of time when we interviewed them after. Um, what they loved, as you know, college is a total bundle. So, they loved the the group

791
04:01:39.439 --> 04:01:56.239
projects, the the critical thinking, joining clubs, being being with their with their team members. Um, you know, I said to them, "How was it transitioning to these large groups?" And they're like, "It's not that difficult to learn how to sit in a lecture." Um, so from the social part, you know, they they

792
04:01:56.239 --> 04:02:13.439
feel very well equipped to lead. So a lot of them are leading in clubs. They're, you know, starting up different projects. They're we, you know, they're they're inventing things. One of our key mottos at Alpha is to be um a creator, not a consumer. So we don't want you

793
04:02:13.439 --> 04:02:29.439
consuming Tik Tok, right? We want you creating things that inspire the world. So our, you know, we take that very seriously and I think our students have said that that's they brought that with them into the university space. So more more data to come. This is our

794
04:02:29.439 --> 04:02:46.640
second um this year is going to be our second graduating class. That first class, most of those students started with us from third grade um through through 12th grade. This will be our second graduating class from Austin. So, obviously more data to to come from that. Um, but you know, our students are

795
04:02:46.640 --> 04:03:03.840
averaging 1540 SATs, 1560 if you're on, you know, the that honors track. Um, so we're seeing not just the academic success, but we are seeing um our students being able to um, you know, put themselves forward in social situations,

796
04:03:03.840 --> 04:03:19.439
not just be bystanders, but really, you know, take ownership of things. I know we're not talking about high school tonight uh but in the same way that where we go geographically is very demandled, right? It's go where people are asking for us and then we go try to

797
04:03:19.439 --> 04:03:35.920
say, "Okay, if we want to be in this city, where's the best real estate? How can we kind of figure it out? How can we get a building permitted? How can we make it happen for them?" High school is the same way. And so in some of our other cities like Miami, we have recently expanded to high school because we had enough of the older cohort that

798
04:03:35.920 --> 04:03:51.760
wanted to stay and wanted to figure out how can we stay at Alpha and how can we do high school there. We made that happen for another cohort of like 8 to 12 high school students um that were just hey we had a couple in seventh eighth grade they were getting up there. I was like okay cool let's figure out how we expand and how we keep that going

799
04:03:51.760 --> 04:04:07.520
for them because they didn't want to leave. So we would if we you know chose to have a high school we would you know our eighth grade would become our ninth would become our tenth would become you know we wouldn't just oh you know now we're applying for a 9th through 12 school we would want to grow it

800
04:04:07.520 --> 04:04:22.319
organically within our within our students if that's what the parents demand if that's where the demand is. >> And could you just remind me of what your nonprofit is? No, that's mine personally. The Interchange Institute um which um is about building cultural

801
04:04:22.319 --> 04:04:37.760
competence around the world. Um and yeah, a lot of work in the um yeah >> intercultural space. >> No, thank you. >> That's I meant that's why I come to Boston in addition my own personal my own personal reasons. >> Yeah. Well, my my colleagues have asked

802
04:04:37.760 --> 04:04:53.840
most of my questions, but I have a question about the younger end. Um so I'm am I right in in understanding that your model is um device-based? So is that 2hour time period are kids

803
04:04:53.840 --> 04:05:09.760
utilizing screens to do their work or are there other opportunities particularly well but what does it look like for your younger students I guess is basically my question. >> Yeah that's that's one of the things. So we yeah we have that reading specialist um that um you know has extensive

804
04:05:09.760 --> 04:05:26.560
training um as a teacher. So all of our reading specialists are certified teachers and have um reading specialties. So they do pull outs with our students. Again our ratio is 1 to six. So um imagine you know until students learn to read they're seeing that reading specialist. It could be

805
04:05:26.560 --> 04:05:42.399
three times a week for 30 minute pullouts. Um, and then once they, you know, then you read to learn, right? There's that sort of transition. But we also have students um who are reading at really high levels, you know, I have a a first grader, for example, who's reading at a eighth grade level. So, she's also

806
04:05:42.399 --> 04:05:58.160
meeting with the reading specialist to understand how do you comprehend things like allegory, for example, in a text. So, that reading specialist is also individual or meeting individual students needs. Um, you know, we use something called the Pomodoro method. I don't know if you're familiar with that,

807
04:05:58.160 --> 04:06:13.840
but essentially it's you work for 25 minutes, you have a break, 25 minutes, a longer break, 20 and then rinse and repeat for that sort of two-hour block. Um, you know, the the younger students get many more breaks. Um, that time is kind of stretched over a longer period

808
04:06:13.840 --> 04:06:30.560
of time. But the engagement um is on is on the screens. Um, you know, we we teach our students what is good screen time, what is bad screen time. We have all sorts of, you know, safety features on the software. There's even, you know,

809
04:06:30.560 --> 04:06:46.239
the blue lights and the, you know, a lot of research has gone into the text font size we use, the color of the text, all of that sort of stuff as part of it as well. But it's it yeah, our younger students are, you know, not just on the screens. One thing I forgot to mention

810
04:06:46.239 --> 04:07:03.120
is we also have something called check charts. So, this is this also happens in the afternoon. And for example, that's where we're we're kind of targeting some of those social emotional um aspects. So a kindergartener, you know, needs to be able to tie their shoes. Um another

811
04:07:03.120 --> 04:07:19.760
check we have is you need to be able to um lose at a game and not cry. Uh so there's all these sorts of, you know, little tasks that they have that they're doing between their breaks or, you know, during other time allocated slots. So yeah, there's there's the academic part,

812
04:07:19.760 --> 04:07:35.120
but then there's a lot of play. Um, in some ways at the younger stage it does kind of reflect a monastery approach. You know, we we start the day with the little ones. It's called mindful mornings. So the day before they would have picked what they want to work on. It could be kinetic sand, it could be a

813
04:07:35.120 --> 04:07:50.640
puzzle, it could be some of our kids are playing musical instruments. Um, and then we do that morning launch where it's getting the body moving and, you know, talking about what it means to be a learner. And then they they start to do that pomodoro method engaged with the software with all the brakes. And then

814
04:07:50.640 --> 04:08:07.520
we have that extended lunch and recess and then our life skills workshops in the afternoon. Are >> are there any traditional what you would consider seeing in a kindergarten classroom? Are there centers? Are there free play opportunities? >> Absolutely. Yeah. Free play. There's libraries in every class. We one people

815
04:08:07.520 --> 04:08:22.880
often ask me do you guys do do your kids read books? Yes, of course they read books. They do book reports. Um maybe the difference is you know and depending on the standards, right? um for each grade. Of course, we're adhering to those, but maybe not everyone's reading The Scarlet Letter, but you're reading,

816
04:08:22.880 --> 04:08:38.080
you need to pick from a classical genre piece, and then, you know, we would help you select that book that's of interest to you. So, that's kind of where the differentiation, I think, is as well. Um, you know, when we talk about students loving school, you know, it was many times, you've said it tonight, it's

817
04:08:38.080 --> 04:08:54.640
it's a bit of that voice and choice, that autonomy, um, obviously with guidance, right? We we want to be able to guide them. But yes, it it very much looks like a um primary school with their artwork on the walls and um you know, lots of games for the kids to play

818
04:08:54.640 --> 04:09:11.199
and again books. You know, we we know how important it is for children to be fluent readers, but to love reading and that's something that we're always trying to to build in them, that love for reading, too. That's that's a strong theme throughout all of our schools is is a love for reading

819
04:09:11.199 --> 04:09:27.199
>> and particularly when you talk about the younger children, right? the building comes into play in a weird way that matters a lot. So we have things we designate spaces we call them like roar rooms like roar like a lion where those younger children who need the breaks more often throughout the day or have a

820
04:09:27.199 --> 04:09:42.960
little more of we call like the wiggles etc right where can they go to be younger children that's not disruptive to maybe the other kids who happen to be in that grade who are really trying to focus or engaged and what can we do to make that something where the right teacher supervision is there with the

821
04:09:42.960 --> 04:09:58.160
right opportunities for their children are there and where kind of the architecture and how we do things are supporting the learning model and supporting what our children are doing as well. >> Yeah. Flexible seating as well, you know. Um it's not all just chairs and and desks. There's, you know, especially

822
04:09:58.160 --> 04:10:14.640
with the little ones, they love the little donuts that they like, you know, sink into and and have a book with. So, it's it's yeah, the the space is purposeful. And actually, our students do have do play a role in designing that um designing their own spaces as well. and they try different furniture and you

823
04:10:14.640 --> 04:10:30.080
know they understand the the the architecture of how it's created and you know they they will tell us no this is distracting actually well it's fun and I love it you know I this isn't a good choice for me so yeah that that part's quite fun too to have them have a bit of say

824
04:10:30.080 --> 04:10:47.040
>> in in the actual space design >> yeah there's a group there's growing research and push back now particularly in early childhood of people wanting to see children becoming being screen free because of what's happened pan pan you

825
04:10:47.040 --> 04:11:02.479
know past pandemic in terms of more and more screen time for very young children and less time to be interactive etc. Um it' be interesting to see as you are a very screenbased program how families

826
04:11:02.479 --> 04:11:18.800
will think about that particularly for their youngest children. >> Yeah. You know, I would what we notice is our students when they go home, they're not on their screens, though. They see screen time at school, you know, as something that's at school. So, when they go home, they're >> This was about screen time in schools.

827
04:11:18.800 --> 04:11:34.800
So, getting away from screen time in schools, not necessarily just at home, but period. >> Right. I mean, you know, I it's as an as a fellow academic, I you know, I love sort of debating these sorts of things, but I there's good screen time and there's bad screen time. And I I

828
04:11:34.800 --> 04:11:50.399
personally don't think if we pull screen time away, we're serving our students well. They have to, you know, it's going to be part, but the balance is so important. It's so important. That's why our afternoon work, it's not, our kids are not on screens all day. Um, you know, there's some research that came

829
04:11:50.399 --> 04:12:06.800
out of Harvard that on average children in public schools um are, you know, on screens for over two hours a day. Um, as well, you know, whether that's looking at a Smartboard or, you know, all sorts of different things. high school. Actually, middle school was found to have the most screen time, even more than high school, which I thought was

830
04:12:06.800 --> 04:12:22.479
quite interesting. But I think, yeah, it let's watch the space and continue to see the research that comes out on it. >> Okay. >> Well, thank you very much and we look forward to taking um a vote on this in future meeting. >> Yeah. And thank you guys for all the

831
04:12:22.479 --> 04:12:56.640
work you do for students across Boston and the time you give as a board. I know it's it's a lot. So, thank you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. Now we will hear from the Douglas Ridley School. >> Hi.

832
04:12:56.640 --> 04:13:13.040
>> Hi. Good evening, Chair Robinson, members of the Boston School Committee, and Superintendent Skipper. Thank you for the opportunity to speak tonight. My name is Courtney Schwarz. I am a BPS parent, and the founder of the Douglas Ridley School. I've spent 20 years in

833
04:13:13.040 --> 04:13:29.600
education as a teacher, instructional coach, a school and network leader, and a believer in high expectations and a relentless focus on results. I've worked in schools in DC, in Chicago, and Boston. Experiences that deeply shaped

834
04:13:29.600 --> 04:13:44.880
who I am as an educator and leader. I believed in what we were doing, and I still really honor that work. But then I had children, and I watched them experience something completely different. They entered a learning environment

835
04:13:44.880 --> 04:14:02.479
built on relationships, curiosity, and community. A place where children were deeply known, where their questions shaped the curriculum, where teachers co-created learning with students instead of delivering it to them. And I saw something powerful. I saw children

836
04:14:02.479 --> 04:14:18.720
who were confident in their ideas, children who asked thoughtful questions, children who worked through disagreements and learned to listen to one another. I saw learning that felt joyful but also deeply rigorous. Students were reading, writing,

837
04:14:18.720 --> 04:14:34.319
researching, collaborating, and solving problems because they cared about what they were exploring. It changed what I thought about what school could be. At the same time, I began to reflect on

838
04:14:34.319 --> 04:14:50.319
the broader world our children are growing up in. We're living in a moment where our society is struggling. We're struggling to talk, to listen, to think critically together. We're flooded with information, yet rarely

839
04:14:50.319 --> 04:15:05.840
taught how to question, analyze, or understand nuance. Skills that are vital for a healthy democracy, empathy, and leadership. These are not extra skills. They are foundational. So, I began to ask myself, what would it look like to

840
04:15:05.840 --> 04:15:21.040
build a school around these ideas? A place where curiosity drives the learning. Where students are deeply known, where academic rigor and joyful exploration coexist. Where children learn not only content, but they learn

841
04:15:21.040 --> 04:15:37.439
how to think, question, and work together. Our school is named in honor of Frederick Douglas and Fita Ruffen Ridley, leaders who believe deeply in education as a pathway to empowerment and social progress. Their legacies

842
04:15:37.439 --> 04:15:53.120
remind us that education is not only about individual success, but about preparing young people to contribute meaningfully to their communities. The Douglas Ridley School is a reio inspired inquirydriven elementary school designed

843
04:15:53.120 --> 04:16:08.239
to expand access to interest driven learning here in Boston. Our approach is grounded in the belief that children are capable, curious, and creative. And that when students have a voice in their learning, they develop ownership,

844
04:16:08.239 --> 04:16:26.319
agency, and a lasting love of learning. This does not mean less academic rigor. In fact, the opposite is true. Our classrooms are aligned to the Massachusetts State standards with strong foundations in literacy and mathematics. Students engage in daily

845
04:16:26.319 --> 04:16:42.239
small groupoup reading instruction, problembased math exploration, and interdisciplinary inquiry in science and social studies, all connected to the students questions and interests, making learning more meaningful and memorable.

846
04:16:42.239 --> 04:16:59.199
Work from Harvard's project zero demonstrates that when students engage in inquirybased learning, they develop deeper understanding, stronger reasoning skills, and greater ability to transfer knowledge to new contexts. Social emotional learning is also embedded

847
04:16:59.199 --> 04:17:14.239
throughout our design. Students participate in daily community meetings, collaborative problem solving, and realworld in the- moment conflict resolution. And with small class sizes, two teachers in each classroom, flexible

848
04:17:14.239 --> 04:17:30.319
small groups, and the ability to utilize equitable services through Boston public schools and outside providers will be able to thoughtfully meet the needs of all learners. But beyond just the research, this work is deeply personal.

849
04:17:30.319 --> 04:17:46.800
I want to build a place where kids are seen and heard. Where curiosity drives the learning. Where we grow together across lines of difference. A place that equips children not just to succeed but to shape a more just and con and

850
04:17:46.800 --> 04:18:02.080
connected world. We will launch with a single kindergarten class and grow responsibly over time. Our slow, measured growth allows us to build systems thoughtfully, ensure quality, and remain fiscally responsible as we

851
04:18:02.080 --> 04:18:18.560
expand. By adding just one grade level at a time, we're able to al align staffing, enrollment, and resources in a sustainable way that p that prioritizes long-term stability. And our tiered tuition model ensures

852
04:18:18.560 --> 04:18:36.880
that the Douglas Ridley School remains accessible to all families. This work is also guided by a deeply experienced and engaged board of directors with members from education, business, law, and nonprofit leadership.

853
04:18:36.880 --> 04:18:53.920
The board provides active oversight of our financial planning, governance, and strategic growth, ensuring that we remain accountable, missiondriven, and responsible stewards of resources as we grow. This intentional approach allows us to prioritize both quality and

854
04:18:53.920 --> 04:19:11.120
sustainability from the very beginning. We are also grateful to be launching within Temple Israel a partnership that provides not only a beautiful and accessible space, but a supportive environment for thoughtful growth. We are inspired to be starting in the same

855
04:19:11.120 --> 04:19:27.840
building where Beacon Academy first launched and we hope to follow in those footsteps growing intentionally within a community that has already supported innovative school models. With the support from the temple, pro bono support from Baker Hostetler and

856
04:19:27.840 --> 04:19:44.080
critical mentorship from the Boston business mentors. we can focus our resources on students, teaching and community while growing within a stable and supportive environment. Ultimately, this work is about possibility. It's about creating

857
04:19:44.080 --> 04:20:00.880
environments where children feel safe to ask questions, where they learn to listen to perspectives different from their own, where they develop both academic skills and a sense of responsibility to one another. where they see themselves as thinkers, collaborators, and problem

858
04:20:00.880 --> 04:20:18.000
solvers. That is the vision behind the Douglas Ridley School. Thank you for your time. >> Thank you. We'll now open it up to questions and thoughts from members. >> Let's start. U same question. How the

859
04:20:18.000 --> 04:20:34.560
students are chosen? What is the process? >> Yes. >> Have two questions. Okay. >> Yes. So, my goal is to make the enrollment process as low barrier as possible. I want this to this school to be accessible to any family that wants to be a part of it. There's a very

860
04:20:34.560 --> 04:20:52.239
simple application form online where you can record a video if you want to, where you can type if you want to, where you can like record a video or an audio message because I want it to be accessible to any families. Then we have

861
04:20:52.239 --> 04:21:09.680
like um an inquiry session where like families come and they can sign up for a zoom and we have like an info session together and then they apply online. Um and right now because we're starting right

862
04:21:09.680 --> 04:21:26.479
it's like most of the families who are applying are being welcome to our community. Um, but it is more important to me to know that the families want to be there and that they're invested in this kind of a model. >> Is there tuition involved?

863
04:21:26.479 --> 04:21:41.600
>> Yes. Yes. So, we have a tiered tuition model. Um, so the max tuition is $35,000, but the tiered tuition model ensures that it is accessible to all families. I did not want to set up like a

864
04:21:41.600 --> 04:21:59.680
scholarship model so that it forced this like you're a full pay family, you're a scholarship family, but there is a tier tuition model so that all families pay their own fair share. And so it's all based on a percentage of your adjusted gross family income um and your the

865
04:21:59.680 --> 04:22:18.159
number of dependents um determines what your tier is for your tuition. >> Good. No questions for you. >> No, no question. >> I just have a a question. Could you speak a little bit to the special education supports that you all are able

866
04:22:18.159 --> 04:22:33.120
to provide? >> Yes. So, we will be able to utilize the like equitable services through BPS. We're less than a mile from the Tobin. Um, so we can walk students over there to receive services there. We have some

867
04:22:33.120 --> 04:22:48.479
families who have reached out who have enrolled and they their students already have IEPs and they already have service providers that they want to bring with them and all they're asking is like is that okay? And of course like they can

868
04:22:48.479 --> 04:23:03.680
bring whatever service providers we have like I think we have like the perfect model um for OT and speech um and like self-regulation support to happen within the context of our model. So I think a

869
04:23:03.680 --> 04:23:21.840
combination of both the service providers that families already have relationships with and utilizing services through BPS. question. >> Yeah, I think the part um I think you heard first of all, good to see you.

870
04:23:21.840 --> 04:23:38.080
>> Um I think the the part I um am going to poke at the most is the financial sustainability. >> Yes, >> it works particularly in the tiers you lay out when you have full enrollment. >> Correct. But when you don't, which is

871
04:23:38.080 --> 04:23:55.760
the problem that schools are having, >> that's when it becomes harder to fund the model without raising dollars. And so, can you just talk a little bit about >> your approach to the finances, >> how much you're anticipating needing to

872
04:23:55.760 --> 04:24:13.920
raise each year to make it sustainable, >> what the enrollment needs to look like, what the backdoor plan is if the enrollment falls. >> Yes, for sure. So, we are a nonprofit and so we will be able to raise money. Um, we have

873
04:24:13.920 --> 04:24:30.880
committed support from our board members already, long-term committed support from our board members. Um, I have re written several grants already and waiting for those to come in. Um, so part of our financial model will rely on

874
04:24:30.880 --> 04:24:48.720
fundraising. Um, and part of our financial model will rely on tuition. Um, and I like I've seen the Morgan Oliver School in Georgia has a similar tier tuition model and they have at each

875
04:24:48.720 --> 04:25:06.080
tuition tier there's a certain number of spots that you could like directly apply for a tier one spot or a tier three spot and that ensures that they have like a balanced financial model. Um, and that I think after year one is what is what we

876
04:25:06.080 --> 04:25:22.239
are aiming for. so that just based on our enrollment and application process, we will ensure a balanced financial model. Um, and I think like to be totally honest like at the beginning we're going to be

877
04:25:22.239 --> 04:25:39.359
small and scrappy and we're gonna make it work with me and our pedigogista and one teacher and we're very lucky to be in Temple Israel and the support that they're giving us with um the rent that we're paying there really supports us

878
04:25:39.359 --> 04:25:57.520
being able to get off the ground in a responsible way. And I think like you I have no that way like we will wait to add a second strand um in each grade

879
04:25:57.520 --> 04:26:15.680
level after we see enrollment and demand and we will prioritize supporting the students that are there currently over trying to expand. Um so our financial model will be a mix of

880
04:26:15.680 --> 04:26:40.000
like the tuition and raising money. >> Great. Thank you. um appreciate the the thoughtfulness around access um and the expertise you bring as a career educator um that has like deep

881
04:26:40.000 --> 04:26:55.199
experience and commitment in public schools up to this point. Um so I guess I'll ask just one question the same one of the same questions I asked um to the other team which is um you talked a little bit about your impetus to go in

882
04:26:55.199 --> 04:27:11.520
this direction but can you just clarify a little bit what the unique delivery model is of this program that could not be found in like the variety of schools that you've served at such high leadership levels yes

883
04:27:11.520 --> 04:27:27.600
>> to this point. >> Yep. Yeah. So the Reio Amelia philosophy believes that children are capable, curious, and creative and full of so much potential. And it's the job of the teacher to see that and notice that and see what kids are genuinely excited

884
04:27:27.600 --> 04:27:43.600
about and interested in and build the curriculum around that. So instead of having a scripted curriculum where all teachers are teaching the same exact thing to the same to all the students in the second grade, this second grade will

885
04:27:43.600 --> 04:28:00.720
have a curriculum that is designed around what these second graders are really excited about and really interested in and will weave in the second grade standards >> into whatever that topic is. So, for example, like if you have a class where

886
04:28:00.720 --> 04:28:16.000
you notice that they're really into the Titanic and this group of kids, they're really excited about reading about the Titanic, then the teacher will take that and build a curriculum and build learning experiences around that topic

887
04:28:16.000 --> 04:28:33.600
that connect to math and science and literacy and social studies. So it's the it's the agency and autonomy of the teacher to design curriculum which is that that true you. >> Yes. >> Um >> yeah I think it's it's it's challenging because as a system we're obligated to

888
04:28:33.600 --> 04:28:50.800
ensure that consistency of experience especially with our transient students and moving from school to school and having kind of a a a set curriculum that we can guarantee families and being that small. um there's just an ease in kind

889
04:28:50.800 --> 04:29:08.319
of quality inspection of whether that teacher created curriculum meets those expectations. And so I think um >> I think it's just another another place that feels like such a disconnect between the state's guidance around

890
04:29:08.319 --> 04:29:24.560
instructional materials and the direction that we're expected to go as a set of school systems and then the agency um that you know schools with a smaller footprint have to um you know go in different directions and then for us

891
04:29:24.560 --> 04:29:43.040
to establish whether it's um whether it's beating the need is just a a a really um odd task I think for the committee. Yeah. >> Um but I appreciate um what you shared. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. And one of my hopes is that this

892
04:29:43.040 --> 04:29:59.920
model will prove that there is a different way that we can do school. That it doesn't have to be this standardized model where we're delivering this scripted curriculum. that we can honor the the questions and the curiosities of kids and still meet

893
04:29:59.920 --> 04:30:17.520
the the second grade standards, third grade standards. And I'm really grateful that our pedigogista is a PhD student with a background in research. And so part of what she's going to be doing with us is this research piece so that

894
04:30:17.520 --> 04:30:34.960
we can show that there is another way that you can do school. I think I think we know there are other ways to do school. I think >> a a a a school this small scaling up >> is just a difficult proof point for us

895
04:30:34.960 --> 04:30:52.319
to adopt as a system. Um while I totally believe that all schools can learn from each other regardless of school type. I think we we do need to break down silos that way. I think to identify something as small as a proof point is a little challenging. um with the work in front

896
04:30:52.319 --> 04:31:08.800
of us and this the scope in front of us. Um but but I but I understand where you're coming from. >> Yeah, it's great. So I'm very familiar with Reio Millia at the preschool level. Um, so I'm interested in understanding

897
04:31:08.800 --> 04:31:25.760
how this gets implemented into the elementary school and if there are other I know that there are a number of Rejoins inspired preschools in the greater Boston area. Are there others who have also taken on moving the model into the elementary grades?

898
04:31:25.760 --> 04:31:42.080
>> Yes. And I think that's sort of part of my hope or part of how we want to show that there is another way to do school. That why is it in preschool that we can capitalize on the curiosities and the

899
04:31:42.080 --> 04:31:59.439
excitement of kids and then once they get to kindergarten, first grade, we no longer care about their questions and their curiosities and their excitement. And so I I see this in first, second, third grade the same way that I would see it in preschool that for the same

900
04:31:59.439 --> 04:32:16.080
example, if the kids were really excited about the Titanic, great. Like we can read about we can read second grade texts about the Tit Titanic. We can incorporate science stand second grade science standards about the Titanic. We can incorporate math standards about the

901
04:32:16.080 --> 04:32:33.920
Titanic. So I think like we can still do the same model that is so effective and successful in preschools in first, second, third, fourth up through sixth grade. Um because I think we see like

902
04:32:33.920 --> 04:32:51.600
kids are so excited in preschool about learning. they're so excited to be there and then by the time they get to second, third, fourth grade, they're like school is not no longer an exciting and fun place for them to be. Um, and so we want to make sure that that happens,

903
04:32:51.600 --> 04:33:08.639
that kids continue to have this love of learning and curiosity, um, and autonomy. And schools like the Advent are reioinspired schools that go up through the elementary grades. I think Shady Hill is sort of similar. They have

904
04:33:08.639 --> 04:33:25.760
more of like a topic themebased and within there they sort of go based on what student interests are. Um but there's not a lot and that's part of this like expanding access to inquirydriven instruction in Boston.

905
04:33:25.760 --> 04:33:41.760
>> Okay. Thank you. Are there any more questions? If not, thank you very much and we look forward to um taking a vote on this in a future meeting. >> Thank you very much. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Okay.

906
04:33:41.760 --> 04:34:00.799
>> All right, folks. Our last presentation tonight is the fiscal year 26 supplemental appropriation request for 22,845,672 to Boston public schools in support of a balanced budget. I'd like to turn it over to the superintendent for any final

907
04:34:00.799 --> 04:34:16.400
comments, but I want to say one thing because um this may happen at 11 o'clock and I know yeah, you've never experienced this. The lights >> the lights will go out, but they will come back on. So, >> will they come back on? >> Someone has to put them on. So, >> Oh, someone will have to put them back on.

908
04:34:16.400 --> 04:34:31.199
>> Deputy. >> All right. So, Deputy Pen's back there. Okay. He'll be our man for the evening. I just didn't want you to Well, I'll turn our cell phone last night. We'll get through it. Okay, we're going to be quick >> into the into the final stretch. Okay,

909
04:34:31.199 --> 04:34:47.359
so um as we presented to the school committee earlier this year, the district continues to address a fiscal year 2026 budget deficit due to several factors, including significant cost increases related to historically high health care premium increases and

910
04:34:47.359 --> 04:35:02.799
inflation impacting out of district special education cost, yellow bus transportation, and student food services. Since our conversation in December, our team has taken action to save funding by reviewing and managing the cost of our most expensive

911
04:35:02.799 --> 04:35:19.680
programming, things like transportation. And through first um first we did the school level pause and then the district-wide spending pause. These efforts have led to $26 million in savings. However, these actions alone are not enough to close

912
04:35:19.680 --> 04:35:37.359
the gap. Our current projections show a remaining FY26 deficit of 28 million due mostly to health insurance and utility cost. We are now asking the committee to approve a request for a supplemental appropriation from the Boston City Council for a total of 22.8 million.

913
04:35:37.359 --> 04:35:54.639
This will cover the projected o overages in health insurance and utilities. Both of these areas are budgeted in collaboration with the city and have seen very unusual and unexpected cost growth. The remaining overages should be able to be managed down over the last

914
04:35:54.639 --> 04:36:09.359
three months of the year through the continuation of our spending pause and review of available grant funding. Chief financial officer David Bloom is here to walk through the specifics of the request and to support any questions you may have. We plan to return to the

915
04:36:09.359 --> 04:36:26.000
committee on Wednesday, May 6th, and ask for your support before the measure is sent to the city council for its review and consideration. David, >> thank you, superintendent, and thank you everyone for bearing with me. I only have 35 slides for you tonight.

916
04:36:26.000 --> 04:36:44.000
Um, >> sorry. It's the kind of joke you make when your kid was up all night last night. Uh so um when we came before you in December uh we shared a financial projection that had four main cost drivers.

917
04:36:44.000 --> 04:37:00.480
Um those cost drivers are still the same ones we're seeing leading to overrun. health insurance, a decrease in vacancy rate leading to higher employee um just salaries,

918
04:37:00.480 --> 04:37:16.320
transportation costs, special education costs, and then one new item since the projection we brought before you. Um which is utility costs over the course of this winter have significantly exceeded our expectations.

919
04:37:16.320 --> 04:37:33.279
Um it was a very cold winter in part. Um so so these things sort of are the same right uh than what we expected them to be more or less. What's changed is what we've been doing about them. Uh we've

920
04:37:33.279 --> 04:37:49.359
been working since uh diligently since even before we came with the committee um to identify ways to save money to be able to cover these deficits. We've saved approximately $20 million to date from our spending pauses, which started

921
04:37:49.359 --> 04:38:05.279
with a pause of central hiring, stipens, and contract spending, and then a pause on school-based discretionary spending at the end of the calendar year. We've been also been working actively with some of our bigger operational departments to save money and cost

922
04:38:05.279 --> 04:38:19.920
management. Our transportation deficit projection is continuing to decrease. Um, this is one of the areas of good news that I didn't highlight fully on the previous slide. Um, and we're hoping that will continue to improve over the rest of the year and indications are it

923
04:38:19.920 --> 04:38:36.320
will. Um, we've also been looking at grant funding um, in particular to identify areas of potential underpending on grants that can be used to help cover areas of overspending on the general fund within the allowable uses of those

924
04:38:36.320 --> 04:38:52.480
grants. So, as the superintendent said, right now, our projection, and you have sort of a memo and some spreadsheets that that give you this information, leave us with approximately $28.3 million in overages to resolve.

925
04:38:52.480 --> 04:39:08.799
Uh, as the superintendent said, there are two main drivers of this overage that is remaining. The first is a relatively consistent health insurance projection. Um the rates for this are set early in the year and it's based on the number of employees we have which is

926
04:39:08.799 --> 04:39:24.400
also pretty static over the course of the year. So we were not really expecting this cost overrun to change and it has not. Um our utility projection has increased especially uh the cost of natural gas but also electricity

927
04:39:24.400 --> 04:39:41.200
um since our initial projection we shared with you in December. Both of these items are areas we work on in collaboration with the city, but both of our parties are setting this with limited information at the time. Um, this year we've been sort of faced a

928
04:39:41.200 --> 04:39:57.200
confluence of factors that have led to these items to over to, you know, go over and we've been working with the city with the understanding that there might be some potential need for supplemental appropriation as we've worked to save funding. If that uh request is approved, that

929
04:39:57.200 --> 04:40:14.240
would leave us with a projected $5.5 million um deficit. We're con we're confident that over the last quarter of our fiscal year, we can manage that down through continued operational savings, savings from the pause and other grant available funding. And with that, I'll

930
04:40:14.240 --> 04:40:35.520
turn it back to the committee for questions. >> Okay. Thank you. You >> have questions? I I would just say that the the easiest way to sort of understand this is as we went through the 27 budget process, we

931
04:40:35.520 --> 04:40:52.080
were given an allocation and then there was an adjustment made from the city when they realized that and we realized that the projections for health benefits would be much higher than what we were given in the original allocation. They

932
04:40:52.080 --> 04:41:09.680
then gave a supplement as part of the FY27 budget process. If that had happened last year for FY26, we would not have run the $22 million deficit that we've run since the fall.

933
04:41:09.680 --> 04:41:26.400
utilities. To David's point, we've done an amazing job with the buildings, adding in a great deal of AC and AC units and additional heat. But in a cold winter, those are variables. And in a warm summer, those are variables. So,

934
04:41:26.400 --> 04:41:43.440
these are the two areas that are really just beyond our control in many ways. And um we thank the city very much for recognizing in this budget in FY27 that we needed to make that adjustment before your vote. This here for FY26 is really

935
04:41:43.440 --> 04:42:03.600
just correcting that. So this is the basis for the supplemental that if affirmative from you will then go to city council for appropriation. So I just a couple of clarifying questions to build on that um context

936
04:42:03.600 --> 04:42:21.280
superintendent which is very helpful. Um when we have a year like this year whether it's based on climate or needing more heat or electricity um and we have a a high point on utilities, is that going to be the budget on which we're basing for the next year? Is this a

937
04:42:21.280 --> 04:42:38.638
message that we need to not assume as many savings or being able to recoup as we have been in the past and then building on that high watermark as opposed to um historical as an extra protection and do we feel like we did that for the FY27 budget?

938
04:42:38.638 --> 04:42:54.638
>> Yes. So um our risk here is that often our projections lag a year behind um because it's hard to have perfect information sort of in the right year. So for health insurance that's why we had to go through the process the

939
04:42:54.638 --> 04:43:11.680
superintendent outlined. Um, I think utilities is, to be quite honest, the area where I have the most concern for FY27, if for no other reason than the geopolitical factors we're seeing, which will impact the price of natural gas and

940
04:43:11.680 --> 04:43:29.680
other issues. What I would say though is in a typical year we might see a $5 million cost overrun in any one given area of our budget, but we often have a savings somewhere else that will enable

941
04:43:29.680 --> 04:43:47.360
us to sort of offset and manage through that through either some sort of targeted spending slowdowns or just sort of the normal course of business. I think the thing the two things together this year that made it particularly hard for us to balance were the vacancy rate

942
04:43:47.360 --> 04:44:03.840
change and health insurance. Both of which we've adjusted in our FY27 budget. Those were the two major drivers. Sorry. And transportation which we've also adjusted. So >> So we're assuming a higher fill on vacancies. >> Yes.

943
04:44:03.840 --> 04:44:26.480
>> Next year. So again basing it on the higher >> yes >> marks correct. >> No other questions. >> Okay. Thank you. And we will vote to approve this supplemental appropriation

944
04:44:26.480 --> 04:44:42.958
at the May 6 meeting. Thank you. Um we'll now return to public comment. >> No public comments. public comment. >> Okay. Any new business? Um my my only request will be that we

945
04:44:42.958 --> 04:44:58.958
can take another look at the issues around the social workers. >> Understand that process. Yeah. >> Yes, chair. I will um Deputy Deina and I will be having conversation uh tomorrow. >> Yes.

946
04:44:58.958 --> 04:45:14.638
>> As we see one another for city council hearing. >> Yes. Thank you. All right. The next school committee meeting will take place in person on Wednesday, May 6th at 6 PM. If there's nothing further, I'll entertain a motion to adjourn the meeting. Is there a motion? >> So moved.

947
04:45:14.638 --> 04:45:29.600
>> Is there a second? >> Second. >> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? >> Hearing none. This Oh, excuse me. Is there any objection to approving the motion by unanimous consent? >> Hearing none, the meeting is adjourned.

948
04:45:29.600 --> 04:45:35.320
Thank you all. Have a good night. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. Thank you.

Part: 2

1
00:00:06.799 --> 00:00:32.000
Good evening and welcome to this meeting of the Boston School Committee. I'm chairperson Jerry Robinson. We'll begin with the pledge of allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation

2
00:00:32.000 --> 00:00:58.000
under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. I want to welcome everyone who is joining us in tonight in person on Boston City TV and on Zoom. I'm going to ask everyone here in the chamber to

3
00:00:58.000 --> 00:01:13.200
please turn off the volume on your laptops or other devices so it does not interfere with the audio for tonight's meeting. Thank you for your cooperation. Tonight's meeting documents are posted on the committee's web page,

4
00:01:13.200 --> 00:01:33.360
bostonschools.org/schoolcommittee, under the April 15 meeting link. >> For those joining us in person, you can access the meeting documents by scanning the QR code that's posted by the doors. The meeting documents have been translated into all of the major BPS

5
00:01:33.360 --> 00:01:49.360
languages. Any translations that are not ready prior to the start of the meeting will be posted as soon as they are finalized. The meeting will be rebroadcast on Boston City TV and posted on the school committee's web page and

6
00:01:49.360 --> 00:02:04.640
on YouTube. The commit is pleased to offer live simultaneous interpretation virtually in Spanish, Haitian Creole, Averian, Cantonese, Mandarin, Vietnamese, and

7
00:02:04.640 --> 00:02:20.480
American Sign Language. The Zoom interpretation feature has been activated. Zoom participants should click the globe icon at the bottom of your screen to select your language preference. I'd like to remind everyone

8
00:02:20.480 --> 00:02:36.959
to please speak at a slower pace to assist our interpreters. We'll begin the meeting with the approval of minutes. I will now entertain a motion to approve the minutes of the March 25th meeting. Is there a motion? So move. >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Second.

9
00:02:36.959 --> 00:02:53.680
>> Thank you. Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? >> Is there any objection to approving the motion by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the minutes are approved. We'll now move on to the superintendent report. I present to you our superintendent, Mary Skip.

10
00:02:53.680 --> 00:03:09.760
>> So, good evening and thank you, Chair Robinson, and good evening to our school committee members and to our public. It's wonderful to see everybody in person. We have a packed agenda, so I'm just going to take a few minutes to share an announcement from our BPS Office of College, Career, and Life

11
00:03:09.760 --> 00:03:25.680
Readiness, and some recent bright spots before we get into the presentations. First, the BPS Office of College Career and Life Readiness, which we call CCLR, invites grade 12 students, parents, and

12
00:03:25.680 --> 00:03:43.360
caregivers to join a support session on the free application for federal student aid or what we call FAFSA, and the Massachusetts Alternative Financial Aid Application or what we call MASSA on Wednesday, April 22nd from

13
00:03:43.360 --> 00:04:01.040
8:30 a.m. until 2:00 p.m. here at the Bowling Building. The parents of 12th graders will receive electronic communication from us on Thursday, tomorrow, April 16th, with local and statewide resources, as well

14
00:04:01.040 --> 00:04:16.799
as information on school counselors and partners available at their home school for support. The Massachusetts financial aid priority deadline is May 1st, which maximizes students eligibility for state aid for

15
00:04:16.799 --> 00:04:33.360
those entering colleges in the fall of 2026. Completing the FASA or MASSA by this date is very important and a key step for students in terms of accessing grants, scholarships, tuition free

16
00:04:33.360 --> 00:04:50.800
opportunities, and other supports. Please email the office of college career and life readiness at cclrustinubschools.org with any questions. Few bright spots. Um so I'm proud to share the winners of this year's Aspen

17
00:04:50.800 --> 00:05:06.560
Challenge. You may remember that last year BPS began its participation in this 2-year national education program that challenges high school students to design solutions to social justice issues.

18
00:05:06.560 --> 00:05:22.240
This year, teams of eight students from 13 BPS schools, as well as students from Lawrence High and Somerville High, spent 10 weeks developing their ideas, including how to address food insecurity,

19
00:05:22.240 --> 00:05:38.160
make resources available to immigrant communities, address the connection between academics and mental health, create more green space for youth, and connect students to work training opportunities. ities. Those ideas were

20
00:05:38.160 --> 00:05:55.600
presented to a panel of judges composed of community leaders, educators, and experts at the solution showcase last week. Thank you, Chair Robinson, for being there to cheer our students on. The grand prize winners are headed to the annual Aspen Ideas Festival in

21
00:05:55.600 --> 00:06:12.800
Colorado in June, where they will have the opportunity to learn from global leaders confronting the most pre pressing issues of our time. So the drum roll. Congratulations to Boston International Newcomers Academy or Binka and Tech Boston Academy on this

22
00:06:12.800 --> 00:06:29.039
welldeserved honor. Additional awards included Brighton High School for originality. Another course to college for collaboration, Charlestown High School for community engagement, and New Mission High School was honored with the people's choice award. Lawrence High

23
00:06:29.039 --> 00:06:43.919
School was also recognized with the resilience award. for me as superintendent, you know, just to be able to see the talent, the creativity of our young people. I was so impressed with the quality of the projects, um, and just the excitement

24
00:06:43.919 --> 00:06:59.039
and enthusiasm of the students. And I told them the first day when the competition kicked off, it would be a life-changing event if they put hard work into it. And then in talking with young people the day that before they knew who was going to Denver, they all sort of agreed it was in fact a

25
00:06:59.039 --> 00:07:15.120
life-changing event. Um, I couldn't have been more proud of them as I know chair was. Um, and so many different people from the city and the district came to cheer them on. Uh, similarly for the two teams that will go on to Colorado will be doing the same. Um, I'm just really

26
00:07:15.120 --> 00:07:31.520
thankful to the Basos Foundation and the Aspen um, Institute for giving our students, you know, such a wonderful opportunity last two years. And we're working very hard right now to figure out how that Aspen challenge model will continue in our city in the years to

27
00:07:31.520 --> 00:07:49.759
come. >> Red Sox. So last week I joined Mayor Woo, the Sarah Greenwood dual language school community and several special guests for the annual Red Sox hat day. Um this marks, this is sort of a tradition. It marks the arrival of

28
00:07:49.759 --> 00:08:07.440
spring and the start of the baseball season. And you can see from some of these photos just the joy, the excitement that happens in this event. Um, I think Wall-E and Tess are definitely the celebrities at the event. The kids love them. Um, and one of the

29
00:08:07.440 --> 00:08:23.759
highlights was seeing all of the kids find out that they were getting tickets to a Red Sox game in the future. Um, they literally just jumped with joy. Um, thank you to Chair Robinson and member Paralta for helping to re to distribute the Red Sox hats to the students. Also,

30
00:08:23.759 --> 00:08:40.959
thanks to our mayor for making all of this happen for us to Red Sox president and CEO Sam Kennedy, Red Sox partner and foundation board member Linda Henry. Um, and really just the whole organization of the Red Sox. They show up for our kids always. And on this particular day,

31
00:08:40.959 --> 00:08:55.440
it's just one of our best times with Wall-E and Tessie. Uh, in all the Red Sox donated 40,000 hats across the BPS to all of our schools, our K8 schools, and we're just incredibly grateful to them and to JetBlue, who also was a

32
00:08:55.440 --> 00:09:10.880
sponsor um for making that day such a wonderful day across our district. Lastly, I was honored to attend the Denver Elementary School's recent digitizing day. This was a special opportunity for the school community to

33
00:09:10.880 --> 00:09:27.040
come together to contribute to an online an online archive that will hold many of the school's memories as their last year comes to a close. I want to thank members Palano Garcia and member Torres for coming as well um and really

34
00:09:27.040 --> 00:09:43.120
uplifting the community. The attendees contributed photos, apparel, notes, recorded interviews. These will all be uploaded to a new collection that's in collaboration with UMass Boston's Healey Library, University Archives, and

35
00:09:43.120 --> 00:09:59.519
Special Collections. The DER has truly been a cornerstone of the Columbia Point community for nearly 70 years. The event reflected the connection, the the different kinds of connections and memories that have just been created across so many different people. It was

36
00:09:59.519 --> 00:10:16.000
incredibly meaningful to see and hear from former students and families and staff members who gathered to share stories and really celebrate what the schools meant to them. By preserving these memories, we're honoring the legacy of the Denver and we're ensuring

37
00:10:16.000 --> 00:10:31.760
that its impact continues to be felt for years to come. As part of the event, a commemorative city of Boston street sign was unveiled. the de school drive, all roads lead through the dever. Um, this was installed to honor that legacy of

38
00:10:31.760 --> 00:10:47.040
the de's decades long impact to the community. I also want to extend a heartfelt thank you to those who came out to share memories and preserve and make available for the deversary's legacy for future generations, especially project manager Megan

39
00:10:47.040 --> 00:11:03.839
Schroeder, parent leader Cheryl Buckman, and principal Margaret Renon. Going forward, the BPS Capitol team will continue working with our emerging and closing school communities to determine the best way to celebrate and honor them. Each school community is different

40
00:11:03.839 --> 00:11:20.560
and many have their own ideas of how to commemorate their story and their history and just huge applause for the deever for really really expressing to us the importance of this piece of closure for the community um so that we can then take it and be able to build

41
00:11:20.560 --> 00:11:35.360
the set of closure for the other communities as they go through closures and mergers. Um later this spring, we'll share an update with the committee on where students from the closing schools are going next year and report on the progress of the long-term facilities

42
00:11:35.360 --> 00:11:52.240
plan implementation. Uh so with that, chair, many many bright spots. Wanted to call out a few, but um I will turn it back over to you. Thank you, Superintendent. Um I'll now open the floor for questions and discussion. Please remember our norm is five minutes per person per member per round not

43
00:11:52.240 --> 00:12:08.639
including dis responses and keep questions related to the superintendent's report. Other topics can be raised during new business. BPS staff, please keep responses brief and speak slowly to support our interpreters. Since I know this is your first in-person meeting, I'll just tell

44
00:12:08.639 --> 00:12:25.839
you what I usually do. I usually will look to my left and ask for people on this side if they have something to say and then go that way. So we're not >> doing a zigzag. Okay. So >> Okay. Do you have any >> you have any question?

45
00:12:25.839 --> 00:12:40.639
>> What question? >> Well, I do. Um well, a couple I guess. Uh I can share an announcement um for myself. Um, I had the uh the the privilege to attend the National School Boards Association

46
00:12:40.639 --> 00:12:56.560
conference in um San Antonio with Jake Lacy from our facilities management uh department. Um BPS was receiving the Magna Award for its work on the installation of its internal air quality monitors and that project has been in

47
00:12:56.560 --> 00:13:12.720
the works since 2014. So I think uh being recognized um nationally for the work is something that is just a testament to uh what these investments very early on what they yield and um

48
00:13:12.720 --> 00:13:28.399
particularly the the the data dashboard that was created as a result of that. And so being able for families to check that dashboard to look at what the air quality is. Um but also how those monitors were able to inform what are

49
00:13:28.399 --> 00:13:45.920
the types of renovations and upgrades that each of our buildings need. I learned a little bit more. I mean not just that our average building age goes all the way back to 1942, but you of course we still have some buildings that were built in the 1800s. So that's just a testament to how much these buildings

50
00:13:45.920 --> 00:14:01.519
need upkeep. um and investment. Um and so it was good to be uh recognized as a district and it was also good to hear from peers from across the country just about um some of their challenges that they're experiencing um and how they're

51
00:14:01.519 --> 00:14:17.600
addressing some of them. So uh just a shout out to uh Jake for for attending and uh the the entire team uh Katherine Walsh like like her team as well. So um that um and I did and I did have a question. So you mentioned at the at the

52
00:14:17.600 --> 00:14:34.560
end of your report around hearing an update around where students are going. Is it possible to get also an update around how our faculty and staff are sort of fairing um as well? Um yeah, >> absolutely. We'll make sure that that's part of it >> cuz I I'm pretty sure we're we're going

53
00:14:34.560 --> 00:14:51.600
to hear like later today or later today around um just some shifting in the district around around um particularly like our social workers and thinking really about uh one those that may not have permanent status but um have been

54
00:14:51.600 --> 00:15:08.320
in contract positions. um are they going to be offered permanent status? And you know, our social workers when we start talking about all the issues right in the district, chronic absenteeism, um from that to academic outcomes, like our social workers are a critical part

55
00:15:08.320 --> 00:15:25.839
of that. So hopefully we're able to to to get some some of your um your thoughts on that. >> Absolutely. It was great to hear about the Aspen Aspen challenge and the um the value of that for participants. I think it'll be

56
00:15:25.839 --> 00:15:42.399
useful to save some of those models and structures for as Desi works through what graduation requirements are going to be for high school students, especially if there's a community component or some sort of portfolio component. um thinking about the social

57
00:15:42.399 --> 00:15:59.759
impact that this has. It could be something that could be replicated at at the district level outside of the national con uh context if it aligns well to anything that they put online. >> Yeah. No, I think this is a great point and I think, you know, as uh the graduation recommendations come out at

58
00:15:59.759 --> 00:16:17.519
the state level, the idea of capstone is, you know, a critical one. This is a mini capstone in that it was the 10 weeks but certainly like I know at Tech Boston though they did not win last year they undertook a housing initiative for housing instability and that team stayed

59
00:16:17.519 --> 00:16:34.079
together as seniors and they actually made it a year-long project where they just launched their own nonprofit. So I think the agency that it teaches our young people you can do a lot. Um, and so we're right now we're we're talking with several partners about how to be

60
00:16:34.079 --> 00:16:50.399
able now that we know what to do, how to be able to take that and continue to build that challenge into the fabric of BS and to your point, Member Scar, like how to use that as a springboard for bigger things when it comes to our our

61
00:16:50.399 --> 00:17:07.039
high school students. >> Yeah, it's great. Yeah. I also just want to comment on the Aspen challenge. You know, I'm a big fan of it. And um what I saw in that room that morning were kids from 15 high schools, very diverse kids.

62
00:17:07.039 --> 00:17:23.199
Um these were not just the best and the brightest. Everybody was there. And not only were their projects incredible in terms of these being clearly examples of strong student voice and efficacy, but

63
00:17:23.199 --> 00:17:38.240
all the work that they put into it, how they supported each other. I mean, we had what 200 kids from every, you know, from 15 different schools across the city. There was nobody fighting. They were not, you know, posturing against

64
00:17:38.240 --> 00:17:55.760
each other. there was more collaboration that I've seen in a long time. They were clearly interested in the projects that each other had done and I'm hoping that there will be a way that we can share some of that good news here. Uh, our

65
00:17:55.760 --> 00:18:13.200
media is often interested in what's not working, but those projects and those student voices as well as the people that supported them are just prime examples of what students can do when the learning is meaningful to them and

66
00:18:13.200 --> 00:18:28.480
they have the support to actually make the actions happen. So, >> yeah, >> that's right. And I was extremely proud >> that we that our students embraced Someville High and Lawrence High students who they didn't formerly know um and they weren't part of the fabric

67
00:18:28.480 --> 00:18:44.720
of the city. And yet you'd never know that with how they embraced them and and worked with them and cheered each other on. And that's where when we lay the table well for students, you get great results. And so that's that's a kudos to all the coaches, the staff. Ian Clark is

68
00:18:44.720 --> 00:19:00.080
here who just does tremendous um work in lifting this up. Um and so yeah, so I think there's a lot to build on in this and we just thank you for your continued support. Chair, >> thank you. >> Thank you all. I will now entertain a motion to receive the superintendent's

69
00:19:00.080 --> 00:19:16.880
report. Is there a motion? >> So move. >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? >> Is there any objection to approving the motion by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the superintendent's report is approved. We will continue with the re a

70
00:19:16.880 --> 00:19:33.280
brief report on the Massachusetts School Building Authority MSBA core program 2026 statement of interest for the Melvin H. King Southbend Academy. Due to MSBA's April 17th deadline, the

71
00:19:33.280 --> 00:19:50.720
presentation and vote will take place tonight. Let's aim to keep the presentation within 10 minutes. I'll now turn it over to the superintendent. >> Wonderful. Thank you, chair. So, I'm pleased to share that we plan to submit a statement of interest or an SOI to the

72
00:19:50.720 --> 00:20:05.440
Massachusetts School Building Authorities 2026 core program for the renovation of the Melvin H. King South End Academy. As a reminder, the MSBA is a state agency that offers competitive

73
00:20:05.440 --> 00:20:22.880
grants to municipalities to support school construction and renovation projects. The core program supports renovations, additions, and new school construction. The application will be submitted in collaboration with our partners in the

74
00:20:22.880 --> 00:20:37.760
city's public facilities department and the mayor's office. This afternoon, the Boston City Council voted to approve the application following a hearing of the council's Ways and Means Committee earlier in the day. The next step in the

75
00:20:37.760 --> 00:20:55.520
process is the approval of this body. We are very excited about this opportunity to provide Melvin H. King Southend Academy students with a state-of-the-art therapeutic school building that is designed to meet their academic, social, emotional, and mental

76
00:20:55.520 --> 00:21:10.799
health needs. This will bring the district another step closer to our long-term goal of giving our students with different abilities the supports they need and the highquality educational experience they deserve. At this time, I'll turn the meeting over

77
00:21:10.799 --> 00:21:26.720
to our BPS chief of capital planning delannis loss and Dr. Asant and assistant superintendent Dr. Harold Miller Jr. for the presentation and then later this evening we'll ask the committee for its support of this

78
00:21:26.720 --> 00:21:43.280
application. I would just like to say personally I am over the moon on this particular project. It is so long due to our community and our students and um I just want to thank uh all those that have supported it thus far and would ask

79
00:21:43.280 --> 00:22:00.400
the committee support tonight. Dell Herald. >> Uh thank you superintendent. Um good evening chair and members of the school committee. Um I am very excited to be joined here tonight um with Dr. Harold Miller um to present the core

80
00:22:00.400 --> 00:22:19.600
application for Melvin H. King Southend Academy. As the superintendent shared, the MSBA is a state authority that funds public school construction and renovation across Massachusetts through a one penny

81
00:22:19.600 --> 00:22:36.000
of sales tax supported reimbursement program. It has two programs, the core program for major school construction projects and the accelerated program for roofs, windows, HVAC upgrades.

82
00:22:36.000 --> 00:22:54.480
Over the past several years, Boston has made an effort to increase their participation in the MSBA programs, and we are incredibly grateful for their partnership. The MSBA, City of Boston, and Boston

83
00:22:54.480 --> 00:23:11.440
Public Schools have collaborated on 57 program projects, sorry, over the years. Seven core projects, the Dearborn, BAA, JQS, and most recently the Carter are completed.

84
00:23:11.440 --> 00:23:27.440
One school, the Shaw Taylor, is finishing design selection. The Root Batson Academy will begin procuring an owner's project manager in May. Madison Park will be starting the eligibility period on July 1st.

85
00:23:27.440 --> 00:23:44.880
Under the accelerated repair program led by our operations division, 34 projects have completed construction. One is currently in construction and seven are in design slated for 2027 construction

86
00:23:44.880 --> 00:24:00.400
and eight projects will be starting design this summer. These collaborative efforts with the MSBA reflect $696 million in construction cost with just over 263

87
00:24:00.400 --> 00:24:19.039
million in reimbursement coming back to the city of Boston. We are excited to submit the statement of interest to the MSBA 2026 core program for the Melvin H. King South End Academy. If we are accepted into the program this year, the school will be on

88
00:24:19.039 --> 00:24:35.279
a path towards a significant capital investment in the future. I'll now pass it on to Dr. Harold Miller. >> Hello everyone, superintendent, chair, and school committee members. It's a great honor to be here to discuss uh not

89
00:24:35.279 --> 00:24:50.000
only the building project, but just a little bit about the Melvin H. King. So, the Melvin H. King Southern Academy is a specialized public day school serving students with diverse strengths and complex needs. As a special education

90
00:24:50.000 --> 00:25:06.559
program, Melvin H. King South Academy supports students from across the city who have not been well served in traditional settings. As the district has expanded inclusive practices and increased therapeutic supports in traditional schools,

91
00:25:06.559 --> 00:25:23.440
enrollment has declined. Overall enrollment has increased from approximately 300 students in 2020 to 160 in 2023 and 80 students in 2025. After COVID, the roll out of the

92
00:25:23.440 --> 00:25:39.840
inclusive education plan and the redesign of entry and exit criteria to better align the least restrictive environment have also contributed to this decline. In 2024, Superintendent Skipper established a

93
00:25:39.840 --> 00:25:56.960
moratorum on new placements to initiate a comprehensive reset and restructure of the school's leadership, staff, and support model for school year 2627. Enrollment is projected at approximately 65 students.

94
00:25:56.960 --> 00:26:13.919
Melvin H. King Southern Academy is now in an active rebuilding phase, grounded in the Melvin H. King way asking ourselves what would Melvin H. King do and our core values safety respect responsibility perseverance and kindness

95
00:26:13.919 --> 00:26:30.080
and a clear commitment to equitydriven transformation through extensive engagement with school and district community members. Five strategic goals and priorities have been identified. One being highquality therapeutic and academic programming.

96
00:26:30.080 --> 00:26:47.120
Second, operational systems alignment, external collaboration and partnerships, especially with inter agent inter agency collaboration and alignment, physical plant improvements, and clear entry and exit protocols.

97
00:26:47.120 --> 00:27:03.360
This work will be supported by an August institute to align all staff along with tiered home and community visits prior to the start of the school year. Looking ahead, Melvin H. King Southern Academy is transitioning to a 5 through 12th

98
00:27:03.360 --> 00:27:20.559
grade model with long-term enrollment projected at approximately 100 students. And I'll pass it back to Chief Status Los. >> Thank you. For context, the school was previously split across three buildings, all of which are amount amounts the

99
00:27:20.559 --> 00:27:36.159
lowest quality facilities in the district according to the district-wide facilities condition assessment. In school year 2526, the school vacated the St. Mary's space. And in school year 2627, the Melvin H. King Southoun

100
00:27:36.159 --> 00:27:50.960
Academy will vacate the Peterborough building and consolidate into one building on Warrenav in the South End. If this project advances into the eligibility phase, the MSBA will evaluate the Warav site along with other

101
00:27:50.960 --> 00:28:09.919
potential locations. The current facility was not designed to be a therapeutic school and it is in poor condition. According to our facilities condition assessment across every domain, the building at Warren A fails

102
00:28:09.919 --> 00:28:24.960
falls sorry well below the district's average. We are confident in this application to invest in this community. I'm going to be honest, the MSBA core projects and all construction projects take time. If we are accepted into this

103
00:28:24.960 --> 00:28:41.679
program, there are years of planning and design work with the school community. Construction likely would not begin until 2031 per the timeline for the MSBA projects. As with all of our MSBA core projects,

104
00:28:41.679 --> 00:28:57.440
this is a multi-generational investment, and our facilities and operation teams will continue to make all necessary upgrades to maintain a safe, well functioning learning space for students. In the meantime,

105
00:28:57.440 --> 00:29:13.440
for next steps on this application, we are asking for your vote tonight. The statement of interest is due this Friday, April 17th, and we've been working closely with the school community to prepare it. We expect to hear about advancement at the end of

106
00:29:13.440 --> 00:29:36.320
2026, and we'll keep you updated. This concludes our presentation and I'll now pass it back to the chair. >> Thank you. I'll now open it up to questions and comments from the committee. Anybody? Go ahead.

107
00:29:36.320 --> 00:29:53.200
>> Um, first of all, thank you so much for the presentation and I just have a quick question. Since the school serve students with complex academic and social emotional needs, how will students be involved in like the designing or giving feedback

108
00:29:53.200 --> 00:30:09.520
um on the new facility and programs? >> Thank you for that question. um as part of the MSBA um design process um the the when we select a design team for the MSBA um it includes a team that focuses

109
00:30:09.520 --> 00:30:25.679
on engaging the community as part of that engagement work students teachers community members of the um Melvin HK King community will be engaged um as part of that process so there's a dedicated team that leads the engagement

110
00:30:25.679 --> 00:30:47.240
>> all right thank you >> welcome Okay, sure. Hi. Um, assuming that everything goes as planned and

111
00:30:47.600 --> 00:31:07.200
M MSBA approved our our project. I think >> the construction will start in 2031. >> Yes. 2031. >> How come it takes that long from now is

112
00:31:07.200 --> 00:31:24.080
2026? And >> so the process of getting paper and everything takes about 5 years. >> Yeah. So we currently have three other projects in the MSBA um pipeline. So currently we have the Shaw Taylor that's heading into design. we have the root

113
00:31:24.080 --> 00:31:40.480
vaten and also Madison Park. Um and with that we will go into the eligibility period for the MSBA if selected at the end of the year. So usually we'll hear back from the MSBA in December. Um so that takes a couple of months and it

114
00:31:40.480 --> 00:31:56.159
takes um about sort of closer to another year to move through the the eligibility period and then there's procurement timelines to procure an an owner's project manager. Um and once an owner's project manager is on board it takes

115
00:31:56.159 --> 00:32:11.120
like another um it's like another like long timeline to procure a designer to go through the process. It's quite an extensive process and when we're going into design um we the engagement piece is really extensive engaging students

116
00:32:11.120 --> 00:32:28.559
and families and staff um because a part of this is like we want to do it right we're building a building that will be in our community for generations to come. >> Yeah. So while the construction wouldn't happen until then, there's many other parts that of engagement with the

117
00:32:28.559 --> 00:32:45.799
community um building out their educa our educational vision for it. Um all of so the community will be very much involved in all of that over the three years leading up to when construction actually happens.

118
00:32:46.000 --> 00:33:01.760
>> Just just another um question from me. Uh even the the project of of this size and that it takes a while to to to put

119
00:33:01.760 --> 00:33:21.279
together you know uh the construction and and and to complete it. um during that time is there any inind from us or is that the the the uh the money comes directly from from MSBA?

120
00:33:21.279 --> 00:33:38.880
>> Sorry, do you mind repeating the question? >> What I'm asking is uh the the process is pretty lengthy. >> Yeah. >> And the there are steps along the line. >> Yes. the the final uh budget for the for for

121
00:33:38.880 --> 00:33:55.919
the construction will it be 100% from MSBA or is there a uh >> no >> no >> no >> go ahead >> okay uh um no uh MSBA does not cover

122
00:33:55.919 --> 00:34:13.359
100% of the cost um when we hear back from the MSBA in December if we're moving through the eligibility period will go through um we'll go to the city council to request um the first phase which is a smaller amount of money um to cover like cost through the eligibility

123
00:34:13.359 --> 00:34:30.159
period um and um we'll go back to the city council a second time but this is uh the MSBA and Brian Mclofflin is here he can share the percentage in which we we are reimbursed by the MSBA um on

124
00:34:30.159 --> 00:34:47.200
projects so it's not a they fully cover the cost. Um there is a certain percentage that the city is like reimbursed on all of on all of the MSBA projects. >> Brian, can you come up to the mic just because the people at home need >> um the calculation rate for MSBA

125
00:34:47.200 --> 00:35:02.640
projects are calculated on an annual basis for 2025. Um the reimbursement rate will be just over 61%. >> 61%. Um but by the time we enter into the feasibility study agreement with the MSBA it it may change. They usually

126
00:35:02.640 --> 00:35:18.560
don't fluctuate that much. So it'll be probably around 60% of eligible costs >> I think >> of the project. >> So the changes may be increased in terms of uh reimbursement or is there a likelihood of of of that

127
00:35:18.560 --> 00:35:35.839
being somehow decreased? >> Yeah, it it will likely be right around that 60% over the past several years. We've seen it fluctuate from high 50s to the low 60s. So it's usually right around that. >> See, and of course we have budget for that. >> So this will come out of capital um

128
00:35:35.839 --> 00:35:53.640
capital dollars. Uh but again with capital because we have three large projects that are over the course of the next 5 years. This is a little bit more forward-looking, but in order to be considered, we have to enter eligibility now. >> Thank you.

129
00:35:54.240 --> 00:36:10.000
Um, this might be I'm sorry. Did y um this might be too premature as we're not talking about breaking ground until 2031. Um, but has there been any consideration around the particular staffing model

130
00:36:10.000 --> 00:36:25.839
that might exist like at this like at this school? >> So, Dr. Miller um and the staff uh leadership at Mel H Melvin H. King has been doing a lot of work around this as

131
00:36:25.839 --> 00:36:43.040
part of the rebuild. H you want to speak to that? >> Yes. Um what I'll just say is that um right now with the student population decreasing um we have had cuts but we were at a 3:1 ratio with staffing. We're at a 1:1 ratio right now. So, we still

132
00:36:43.040 --> 00:37:02.240
do have enough staffing to support the projected 65 students. Um, I could break it down by teachers. I mean, we have a lot of different roles, but um, staffing wise, we're in a good place. >> Yeah, they've come up with a um, a true therapeutic design so that it's teams of

133
00:37:02.240 --> 00:37:18.960
teachers that are supporting and grade appropriate. So instead of stretching across, you know, a second or first grade to graduation, they're really focusing on grade appropriate 5 through 12,

134
00:37:18.960 --> 00:37:34.160
>> particularly with the high school component of building out the things that high schoolers want and need. Um because for too for too long, we've asked students with the highest level of need to trade off getting that need fulfilled for sacrificing these other

135
00:37:34.160 --> 00:37:48.640
things. And we cannot do that anymore. And >> and I would also just add that aligning to Mass Core and making sure that we have, you know, we offer Spanish classes, we offer instructional technology, we offer cosmetology, um art, and just making sure that

136
00:37:48.640 --> 00:38:07.920
students have a full experience. >> I think that um connects well to um one of my questions which was around the ultimate enrollment go uh goal. I think Dr. Miller, you said that for um the longer term it's at 100 students. And I'm curious um whether that's because of

137
00:38:07.920 --> 00:38:24.400
the narrowing of focus to grades 5 through 12, whether that's because we're coming down to a single site or whether that's actually the full need of the student um fit for that level of therapeutic care. Um just transparently having a a building that's going to

138
00:38:24.400 --> 00:38:40.240
receive that level of investment and will have the academic program to match. I think the natural question is why not more than 100 if it serves the students well? And so I'm just curious on on where that number comes from. >> Well, obviously we've had a lot of data

139
00:38:40.240 --> 00:38:57.040
over years where we're looking at enrollment patterns as well as with our inclusive education plan. So schools are building capacity to um you know keep students and not just move them. And then at the same time we're looking at the Melvin H. King as a sort of a bridge

140
00:38:57.040 --> 00:39:12.800
in a way that when a student comes to Melvin King, if they're referred to Melvin King, one, what is the support that the school needs to refer a student? How are we um transitioning a student, but also how are we um making sure that students don't just stay at

141
00:39:12.800 --> 00:39:28.000
the Mel King and they can actually go back to a traditional setting. So, that is a shift. Um as we know for many years students would go and too many would just stay for many years. and we're trying to look at if a student does enter, how long does that need to be?

142
00:39:28.000 --> 00:39:43.359
And um using the expertise of the sending school, the expertise of our current um staff to really look at a lot of data to determine how long a student needs to stay. >> Yeah. And I also I think that Dr. Miller and Principal O'Shea have done a really

143
00:39:43.359 --> 00:39:58.480
good job with staff of establishing clear entrance criteria, which I don't think was in place. And so what you actually had were students being assigned to a more restrictive setting than they needed. This is the most

144
00:39:58.480 --> 00:40:14.960
restrictive setting we have in the sense of much like the Carter, it is a particular profile of student that needs the therapeutic component. Um and so this would be a step even beyond a self-contained program.

145
00:40:14.960 --> 00:40:29.920
We just need to make sure that students are appropriate for that setting. And to Dr. Miller's point, that we are building up for students and stabilizing students and giving them the skills and supports

146
00:40:29.920 --> 00:40:46.240
so that they can re-enter a less restrictive environment with the right supports. So that's much different than what has happened over history with Melvin H. King School. And so the 100 is a fluid number,

147
00:40:46.240 --> 00:41:03.200
>> right? Not the goal that might like like other schools you fill at 100 and you keep the hundred. The 100 students today are going to look different than the hundred students next year. They're going to be different kids. >> That that said, are is the plan to still ensure that it's a diploma granting

148
00:41:03.200 --> 00:41:18.720
institution? >> Yes, absolutely. >> Yes. And with you know the narrower um criteria as are you imagining potential out of district placements as well as a therapeutic day school I mean meaning

149
00:41:18.720 --> 00:41:34.560
receiving from other districts. >> Yes potentially. So Melvin H. always had a history of when a student would come from another district or come from an out of district school, if the IEP were appropriate and the services needed, they would um they would be able to

150
00:41:34.560 --> 00:41:51.359
attend Melvin H. King to get those needs met. That would continue. I think the the main uh point with that Dr. Miller made is that the goal here is mass core for our students at Melvin H. King going forward. Um, and so that is the academic

151
00:41:51.359 --> 00:42:08.160
and the rigor of the academic will be there but with therapeutic support. That is the goal. So whether a student is there freshman year or sophomore year and they're attaining their credits and then going back into another high school, that student can take those mass core eligible credits with them.

152
00:42:08.160 --> 00:42:24.319
>> Right. Um my last question was just um where this falls kind of in the larger long-term facilities planning in terms of how was Melvin H. King South End Academy going to be modernized and

153
00:42:24.319 --> 00:42:39.440
addressed without MSBA or was the plan always for MSBA but the opportunity has come earlier than expected? Um just where does this fall in our larger view of of plans for for schools across the district?

154
00:42:39.440 --> 00:42:55.119
>> Um so uh so on the for the Melvin H. King and where it falls into sort of like the broader investments across like um capital. So um there is um as I think everyone probably knows there's like a

155
00:42:55.119 --> 00:43:13.680
list of schools right um that we have or made commitment to so mayor superintendent has made um sort of like capital commitment to and one of the things that our team does um year overyear as we're looking at mergers and

156
00:43:13.680 --> 00:43:31.359
closures right we have we do sort of like a comprehensive look across all of our schools, high schools, elementary schools, where we can do either larger investments or smaller investments. Melvin H. King is one of the schools

157
00:43:31.359 --> 00:43:46.480
back in 2022 um where a commitment was made um for a new building um for that school community. some vision and work started then um and it ended at vision and work

158
00:43:46.480 --> 00:44:02.960
um and so this is like a next step forward in the process um I think all of the schools that we have moved forward with some sort of vision and work andor commitment was made to communities um and I think one of the things that was really essential before we could move

159
00:44:02.960 --> 00:44:19.520
forward with any of that work we had to do the facilities condition assessment to understand buildings and we had to have a a long-term facilities plan and also look at data to think through how are we um how are we sort of like right doing some right sizing work in the

160
00:44:19.520 --> 00:44:39.839
district and where we should actually be investing year-over-year. So this is some of the work that the um our team has been doing. >> Thank you for your presentation. um very excited to see this coming before us and

161
00:44:39.839 --> 00:44:56.079
not only just about the building itself, which as you said going back to 2022, there was a promise, but the fact that this time as we move forward, we're taking a strong look at the overall programming um to make sure that the programming for

162
00:44:56.079 --> 00:45:13.839
this this group of students um is what it needs to be. Um, many people have said that the school has just been a landing place disproportionately for black and brown young men. Um, and that the fact that we are going from 300 to

163
00:45:13.839 --> 00:45:29.119
80 to 65 to 100 means that we are taking a look at these young people as individuals and looking across our district to create the better kinds of opportunities for them. So, um, looking

164
00:45:29.119 --> 00:45:46.400
forward to seeing what this school can become, um, as a model for us as we think about some of our most vulnerable students in terms of creating a wide range of opportunities so that they can get their needs met. So, thank you and

165
00:45:46.400 --> 00:46:05.760
we look forward to taking action on this um, later this evening. >> Thank you. Thank you. >> Thank you, team. So we will move on to general public comment. Miss Parvox. >> Thank you chair. The public comment period is an opportunity for individuals

166
00:46:05.760 --> 00:46:22.240
to address the school committee on school related issues. Questions on specific school matters are referred to the superintendent. Questions on policy matters may be discussed by the committee later. The meeting will feature two public comment periods with the first comment period limited to one

167
00:46:22.240 --> 00:46:38.880
hour. After one hour, anyone who hasn't testified will have the opportunity to do so at the end of the meeting. We have 20 speakers this evening. Each person will have two minutes to speak and I will remind you when you have 30 seconds remaining. Please feel free to email

168
00:46:38.880 --> 00:46:54.800
your comments for distribution to the committee. Speakers may not reassign their time to others. The time that an interpreter uses for English interpretation will not be deducted from a speaker's allotted time. Please direct your comments to the chair and refrain from addressing individual school

169
00:46:54.800 --> 00:47:11.359
committee members or district staff. Please note the comments of any public speaker do not represent the Boston public schools or the Boston school committee. Please state your name, affiliation, and where you live. Before you begin, please sign in on Zoom using the name you registered with for public

170
00:47:11.359 --> 00:47:26.480
comment and be ready to unmute and turn on your camera when it's your turn to speak. Please raise your virtual hand when I call your name. And to support interpretation, please speak slowly and clearly. We will start with our in um with our in-person speakers.

171
00:47:26.480 --> 00:47:58.880
Um our first speakers are John Mud, Julian Lirani, Julia Morales, and Betsy Santana. John Mud. >> Good evening. My name is John Mud. I'm a a resident of Cambridge, a longtime education advocate in Boston. Uh the

172
00:47:58.880 --> 00:48:16.160
2026 opportunity and achievement gap policy of the opportunity and achievement gap task force that will be presented to you later tonight is often eloquent, thoughtful, and thorough. I strongly urge the school committee to adopt it as the official policy of VPS.

173
00:48:16.160 --> 00:48:31.359
Most important, it continues the commitment to the elimination of opportunity and achievement gaps as the north star priority for the district and makes clear that it will remain a core and urgent priority for the district

174
00:48:31.359 --> 00:48:48.880
regardless of challenges changes, excuse me, in leadership. It ensures that the OAG task force will serve as the external advisory board of the school committee. It states the superintendent will appoint a senior leader reporting directly to the superintendent with

175
00:48:48.880 --> 00:49:04.240
authority to coordinate and monitor all aspects of the policy. It reaffirms the racial, cultural and linguistic diversity of teachers and par profofessionals shall reflect the diversity of the students and it speaks to the importance of establishing

176
00:49:04.240 --> 00:49:20.880
measurable annual goals and accountability on an issue I have testified about repeatedly. It establishes a priority for the significant expansion of bilingual education and the development of long-term plans with clear goals and

177
00:49:20.880 --> 00:49:36.240
timetables to guide the growth of bilingual education programs for multilingual learners and the recruitment of bilingual educators. As policy, all of this is admirable and should be adopted. But as long-term observer, we all know that the critical

178
00:49:36.240 --> 00:49:53.760
issue for overcoming opportunity and achievement gaps is implementation. I hope you adopt the the plan and policy, but I also implore you to follow up with urgency to monitor programs to insist on change where it is necessary.

179
00:49:53.760 --> 00:50:18.040
And thank you. >> Our next speaker is Chileian Lani. Julian running. No. We will continue with Julia Morales. No. Betsy Santana.

180
00:50:28.400 --> 00:50:43.280
Good evening members of the school committee. My name is Betsy Santana. I'm a BPS alum and licensed independent clinical social worker in Boston public schools with nearly two decades of experience serving students and families in high need communities. I'm here today

181
00:50:43.280 --> 00:50:59.599
not to criticize but to bring clarity to a critical gap that directly impacts student care, staff safety safe safety and district liability. BPS social workers are being asked to provide clinical services including IEP

182
00:50:59.599 --> 00:51:16.079
counseling, crisis intervention, and trauma-informed care. Yet, there is no consistent district-wide structure for clinical supervision to support the work. In any other clinical setting, this would be not optional. It would be required without supervision. There is no standardization of oversight of

183
00:51:16.079 --> 00:51:31.680
clinical quality. Social workers are left personally liable for complex clinical decisions. Staff are navigating trauma-heavy environments without adequate professional support and ultimately students receive inconsistent levels of care across schools. This is

184
00:51:31.680 --> 00:51:49.040
not just a workforce issue. This is a system and riskmanagement issue. We cannot define this role as cl as clinical and convenient and then fail to provide the clinical infrastructure that sustains it. I also want to name that many social workers have been operating in silence without clarity, without

185
00:51:49.040 --> 00:52:04.720
communication and without support. That silence is now breaking and what is surfacing is concern, confusion, and in some cases harm. We have an opportunity right now to correct this. My ask is simple and actionable. Establish a district-wide clinical supervision

186
00:52:04.720 --> 00:52:19.520
structure for social workers align with lensure requirements. compensate and utilize independently licensed clinicians to provide supervision as a standard across all clinical fields. Create a clinician-led advisory group to help design and implement this structure

187
00:52:19.520 --> 00:52:34.880
with fidelity and sustainability. We are not asking for anything extra. We are asking for alignment between what is expected of us and what is required to do that work safely and and efficiently. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. Our next speak our next group

188
00:52:34.880 --> 00:52:56.880
of speakers um our next speakers are an Hernandez, Julie Valencia and Pete Mullen. >> Good evening chair person and members of the school committee and superintendent skipper and thank you for the opportunity to speak. My name is Annne

189
00:52:56.880 --> 00:53:14.000
Hernandez. I'm a BPS alum, a Boston resident, and a social worker for the last 26 years. I want to put a a human face on what it means to four district social workers, which includes a SLI um DSW from next year's budget cuts.

190
00:53:14.000 --> 00:53:29.680
Cutting three district social workers from next year's budget is not a small adjustment as it directly affects 37 schools, over 13,000 students, and 71 school-based social workers. We will not have will have to be redistributed to

191
00:53:29.680 --> 00:53:44.800
the six remaining district social workers. These roles are student centered positions that anchor safety, stability, and coherence across our systems. The district social workers currently lead high level case consultations, provide ongoing mentoring

192
00:53:44.800 --> 00:54:01.920
and clinical support to school-based social workers, train staff in deescalation, safety care, and trauma responsive practices. In 2024 2025, we trained 329 BPS staff and 179 to date this school year. We are also the

193
00:54:01.920 --> 00:54:18.880
district's crisis response team. We coordinate safe supported placement and transitions for v vulnerable students and strengthen student support teams. To make this cons more concrete, one of our district social workers uh who is currently not on the budget for next

194
00:54:18.880 --> 00:54:35.520
year, >> I'm sorry, say that again. >> 30 seconds. 30 seconds. Trained 140 staff members in safety care. Provided 68 instances of clinical support and mentoring to school-based social workers, completed 96 highlevel case consultations, coordinated support for

195
00:54:35.520 --> 00:54:51.520
45 students in transition to ensure they landed in safe, supportive environments, participated in 49 student support teams. Eliminating four of these positions does not cut extras. It dismantles a critical safety and support infrastructure that holds our schools

196
00:54:51.520 --> 00:55:13.520
together on the hardest days. Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Our next speaker is Julie Valencia. >> Hello chairperson and members of the school committee. I'm Julie Valencia. I'm a district social worker. I live in West Roxbury.

197
00:55:13.520 --> 00:55:30.079
I am speaking tonight about the three district social worker positions being cut for the upcom up upcoming school year. This is a third of our team as there are 10 of us this year to support the nine school regions as well as the Slife programs. I urge you to reconsider this decision in order to provide the

198
00:55:30.079 --> 00:55:46.400
support that BPS students, families, and school communities deserve. While some aspects of the DSW role are systemic, there are also pieces of our role that include direct work with students and families. Most of our role, including both systemic and direct work, is done

199
00:55:46.400 --> 00:56:02.559
inside school buildings and in collaboration with school-based staff, as well as with students and families when needed. In terms of direct support with students, we assist with crisis support and stabilization, risk assessments, and safety planning. We make up the crisis team that responds to

200
00:56:02.559 --> 00:56:18.400
school crises across the city. The crisis work includes supporting schools in the aftermath of school-based or community- based emergencies, often for days after the event. We also provide the deescalation and physical management training for BPS schools.

201
00:56:18.400 --> 00:56:35.599
This de decrease in our team will affect our capacity to train schoolbased staff. Direct service work also includes IEP counseling, home visits, and parent interviews as part of the IEP evaluation process. These home visits with both schoolbased

202
00:56:35.599 --> 00:56:52.799
and district further fills the support gaps that schools struggle to meet, especially when there are barriers that impact students getting to school, such as chronic absenteeism, school avoidance, mental health needs, and other factors in the community that may impact students and families and their

203
00:56:52.799 --> 00:57:08.720
movement within their communities. Systemically, we work on lots of systems like school culture and climate, coaching, leading professional development, collaborating with student success teams, and streamlining resources across the city.

204
00:57:08.720 --> 00:57:36.559
>> Thank you. >> If you if you weren't able to finish it to speakers, you can always send the testimonies to me, okay? And then I will send it to the members. Uh Pete Mullen Um, good evening. Uh, my name is Pete

205
00:57:36.559 --> 00:57:51.920
Mullen. I'm an educator at the Curley School and a member of the Boston Teacher Union working group on multilingual education. I would like to comment on the opportunity and achievement gaps task force policy. As an educator for multilingual learners, I can speak for many of my colleagues when I say that this policy represents a

206
00:57:51.920 --> 00:58:07.359
welcome shift in our goals for multilingual learners. We're especially grateful to see the language that explicitly names that the cultural and linguistic assets of multilingual learners should be valued. We also appreciate the commitment to move with all deliberate speed to strengthen bilingual education and expand access to

207
00:58:07.359 --> 00:58:23.200
highquality programs that developed academic English while sustaining students home and native languages as well as the creation of a long-term plan with clear goals and timelines. In the BTU working group, we discuss what we see as best practices and challenges to ensuring multilingual learners have the

208
00:58:23.200 --> 00:58:40.000
best possible opportunities. We hope that the following ideas can also be considered going forward with this policy. to ensure that multilingual learners with suspected disabilities are assessed in their home language in order to properly identify learning challenges. To research and obtain strong native language curriculum with

209
00:58:40.000 --> 00:58:56.000
all of the materials, modification and training needed for full implementation. Provide full libraries of home language books, not just translated copies of English language titles. Provide meaningful teacher professional development for targeted language instruction and for language

210
00:58:56.000 --> 00:59:11.359
acquisition. Hope that supporting and preparing teachers to acquire all the licenses and endorsements they need. Recruiting and retaining bilingual teachers requires clear accessible pathways to lensure and endorsements, but currently dual language bilingual teachers are expected

211
00:59:11.359 --> 00:59:28.160
to pass four MTELs and get two endorsements at a minimum. Lastly, a program review of inclusive SEI to ensure that multilingual learners are truly being provided with the best possible opport options for high achievement. Multilingual learners being included in the same way as students with disabilities fails to value their

212
00:59:28.160 --> 00:59:43.119
cultural and linguistic assets, which is something this task force and educators of multilingual learners agree is incredibly important. Thank you. >> Thank you. We will now transition to our zoom our speakers on Zoom. Um the

213
00:59:43.119 --> 01:00:22.319
speakers are councelor Julia Mahia, Laara Larasoto, Kenneth Francisco, and Dora Sandoval. Councelor Mahia. >> Good evening. Can you hear me? >> Yes, we can hear you. We can start. >> Uh, good evening. Um members of the

214
01:00:22.319 --> 01:00:38.559
school committee and the superintendent, uh today I just want to quickly uh speak on the impact that the district social workers cuts will have on Boston public schools. As a city counselor who represents all of Boston, the families and the faculty and staff. Right now,

215
01:00:38.559 --> 01:00:54.000
four positions are being eliminated, including three regional district social workers. These roles have um supported 37 schools and over 13,000 students and they provide guidance to more than 70

216
01:00:54.000 --> 01:01:11.119
school-based social workers across those schools. Their work includes um crisis response, staff training, and helping schools navigate complex student needs. They also pay play a role in supporting the school climate and making sure that

217
01:01:11.119 --> 01:01:28.240
uh the teams have what they need to respond effectively. With these cuts, the number of district social workers goes from 9 to six. The responsibilities do not change, but the capacity does. Schools will be reassigned. casea case

218
01:01:28.240 --> 01:01:45.040
loads will increase and there will be less availability for training crisis response and the day-to-day support. We're also hearing concerns from staff about feeling um limited in their ability to advocate which is something that we should take seriously. I'm

219
01:01:45.040 --> 01:02:00.640
asking that these positions be reconsidered and that these core supports for students and school communities um and reducing them and the real impact that they have. And I'll just end with, you know, at a time when we're dealing with so much on the national level and families are dealing

220
01:02:00.640 --> 01:02:17.760
with a lot of crisis now more than ever, we need to make sure that at the very least in our schools are we're equipped to be able to support the social and emotional um well-being of all of our students, especially in this moment in time. And I ask the committee to reconsider these cuts. Thank you.

221
01:02:17.760 --> 01:02:54.880
>> Thank you, counselor. Our next two speakers are not signing to the meeting. So we will continue with Dora Sandoval and she will be um we need a Spanish interpretation for her. Hello. Okay.

222
01:02:54.880 --> 01:03:18.000
>> Can you hear me? Steven. >> Hello, my name is Sonia Sandoval and I live in the And uh good afternoon. My name is uh Sonia Sandoval and I live in the community of Roxberry and I am also

223
01:03:18.000 --> 01:04:07.200
I serve as a coordinator at the program at St. Stevens. I want to begin by sharing a personal story um which I feel very proud of. Um so last week um so about this personal story I am a mother of two

224
01:04:07.200 --> 01:04:24.000
children and one of them attends the Hurley school and my other student um attends 12th grade. And actually last week we received a wonderful news that he got accepted to the University of Norristo and he actually received a full

225
01:04:24.000 --> 01:05:09.440
scholarship that is going to cover tuition and other expenses 100%. And this is just an example as a mother that I'm very proud of because this represents the years of hope, sacrifice, and also hard work. And this story is an example of what is

226
01:05:09.440 --> 01:05:24.400
possible when given real opportunities for families. And it is not a coincidence, but it is a result of hard work and also programs, educational programs, bilingual programs that support students. For instance, these programs that supported my son in being

227
01:05:24.400 --> 01:06:22.559
able to develop trust in himself and um Go. Foresa. And this is why I am in full support and I appreciate the 2026 policy to eliminate the opportunity and

228
01:06:22.559 --> 01:06:46.880
achievement gaps because this policy strengthens the equity and and to be able to appreciate the different languages of students. And it also recognizes that the families are a core um a fundamental and core

229
01:06:46.880 --> 01:07:33.359
part of of the development of our children. Correct. Um, and my story is not the only one and it's not unique. Um, it is one of many stories and this is what happens when the correct investments are made in

230
01:07:33.359 --> 01:07:53.359
students and families and communities that are the key for full opportunities to be just. Thank you so much. Gracias. >> Next speakers are Dedra Manning, Ari

231
01:07:53.359 --> 01:08:17.359
Hayden Chernobyl and Maris Vatias Draanning. >> Good evening. My name is Dear Manning. I am a Dorchester resident and parent of two public school students. I wanted to remind the school committee and district

232
01:08:17.359 --> 01:08:33.440
staff that Superintendent Skipper promised now three admission cycles ago that she would provide us with data on student outcomes. And as of yet, my understanding is that data has not been released. and rather than hiring a consultant or doing it in-house, it's

233
01:08:33.440 --> 01:08:48.560
been farmed out to um two different two separate groups of graduate students at two different universities. I feel this information is critical and it really should be provided um already should have provided um this evening I wanted to speak about um charter school

234
01:08:48.560 --> 01:09:03.359
students. So charter school students some of them receive standardsbased grades. These are the grades that BPS fifth graders receive. But BPS fifth graders, because the district understood that these grades were a barrier for

235
01:09:03.359 --> 01:09:21.279
these students to get into exam schools, they devised a special process that would allow BPS students only to receive a bit of a boost um when converting those grades to the A to F or the I don't know um 1 to 11 scale that is used

236
01:09:21.279 --> 01:09:37.600
for calculation for the composite score. Boston Collegiate is a charter school. Boston Conservatory Lab is another charter schools that uses standardsbased grades with four inputs just like Boston public schools do. And my understanding that Excel Academy, a charter school in

237
01:09:37.600 --> 01:09:53.839
East Boston, uses standardsbased grades but with only three inputs. So I would like the school committee to look into why there isn't this process allowed for these um charter school students. I wanted to remind people that these are

238
01:09:53.839 --> 01:10:10.000
exam seats are publicly funded educational opportunities and there shouldn't be a special process for BPS students that is not allowed for nonBPS students. This is not equitable and something should be done to fix it. Thank you. >> Thank you. Our next speaker is Arie

239
01:10:10.000 --> 01:10:42.400
Brands. All right. Um, good evening everyone. My name is Ari Brans. I'm a resident of Matipan and the co-executive director of St. Stevens Youth Programs. However, tonight I'm here representing the Multilingual Learners Alliance or the MLA. The MLA is a broad coalition of

240
01:10:42.400 --> 01:10:59.600
parents, teachers, education experts, and advocates who are committed to improving the education of multilingual learners in the Boston public schools. We have some core principles that we're advocating for. Add languages, don't lose them. Substantially increase access to bilingual education programs.

241
01:10:59.600 --> 01:11:15.679
Meaningfully engage families. Develop a citywide assetbased mindset on multilingualism. Recruit, develop, and retain bilingual staff. um spend Title One funds equitably and with accountability and provide appropriate services for multilingual

242
01:11:15.679 --> 01:11:32.719
learners with disabilities. We are so glad to see these policies reflected these principles reflected in essential ways in the revised policy of the opportunity and achievement gap task force being presented to you tonight. It calls for expanding access to bilingual education with a long-term plan that has

243
01:11:32.719 --> 01:11:49.199
explicit goals and timelines. a long-term plan to expand the number of bilingual educators, encouraging the use of home language by parents, and recognizing the importance of home language in the education of MLS with disabilities and so much more. We urge you to make this the official policy of

244
01:11:49.199 --> 01:12:06.159
the school committee and implement it. It's time for a fresh start on this issue. It's time to have a policy for MLS that we can all join hands and rally behind. >> 30 seconds. Since our inception, the MLA has been anxious to work with the district in joining together with our mutual resources and energies to improve

245
01:12:06.159 --> 01:12:21.440
the education of MLS and MLS with disabilities. This new policy presents us with that opportunity. We strongly encourage you to approve the revised OAG policy. Thank you so much. >> Thank you very much. Our next speaker is

246
01:12:21.440 --> 01:12:47.920
Hayden Cherno. Hi, my name is Hayden Cherno. I am a Boston public schools alum, class of 2023 and the current community liaison for the Center for Law and Education or CLLE. At CLE, we work with families and advocates to help students, especially

247
01:12:47.920 --> 01:13:04.000
students with disabilities, access the education they are entitled to under the law. We are a legal resource and advocacy organization focused on ensuring that all students, particularly those from low-income communities, can learn to high standards. I'm here today to speak about the MCCAST alternative

248
01:13:04.000 --> 01:13:20.719
assessment or MCCAST ALT. While passing MCCAST is no longer a graduation requirement, all students are still expected to learn grade level content, but students identified as having the quote most significant cognitive disabilities may be placed on the MCCAST ALT. And in practice, once students are

249
01:13:20.719 --> 01:13:36.000
placed on this track, they can be taught to lower standards and held to lower expectations. This has serious consequences. We continue to see that multilingual learners, black and Latinx students, and students from lowincome families are disproportionately placed on this track.

250
01:13:36.000 --> 01:13:52.159
Through our work with families, we've seen that some students can be placed on the MCCAST AL inappropriately and are not fully informed about what that placement means. And that's where we see CL's work come in. We offer trainings to help families understand what the MCCAST all is, what their rights are, and how

251
01:13:52.159 --> 01:14:07.120
to best advocate and prepare their children for success. We would welcome the opportunity to partner with the district and community organizations in making sure parents understand how this system works and how to support their child in a pathway to success. For more information and interest, please reach

252
01:14:07.120 --> 01:14:35.679
out to the Center for Law and Education. Thank you. >> Thank you. Maris Matias is our next speaker. Hi, good evening. My name is Mari Matias and I live in South. I'm a single mom.

253
01:14:35.679 --> 01:14:51.920
My son I'm a single mom of two. My son attended at O'Brien Math was math and science high school. and as and as well I'm a former a BPS graduated and a par professional and I would like

254
01:14:51.920 --> 01:15:08.000
to uh to thank the deans that works so hard on the 2026 policy to promote the academic excellence and eliminate opportunities and achievements gap by consider the families and the community

255
01:15:08.000 --> 01:15:24.000
in the usage actions. I would like to tell you a little bit about my story. When I was a a youth and in the opport when I was a youth, when I came to this country at 13 years old, I came with not

256
01:15:24.000 --> 01:15:41.679
um not but not knowing any English and not understanding anything at all. I was lucky enough to came to a high school which had a vocational program and also a bilingual program thanks to my parents

257
01:15:41.679 --> 01:15:57.040
to enroll me to that school. I'm a I'm proud to say that I'm bilingual right now and I graduated high school and thanks to that I passed my par profofessional exam. I'm ready to go

258
01:15:57.040 --> 01:16:13.840
back to BPS to become an Thanks again to the team for your hard work and creating and to keep advocating to creating new bilingual programs and opportunity to new students that like me

259
01:16:13.840 --> 01:16:28.480
come to this country not knowing English and having this program accessible for them will be great addition to their education. Thank you. >> Thank you. Our next speakers are Katie Dear Rosa,

260
01:16:28.480 --> 01:16:58.159
George Physic, and David Dave Edwards, Katie Dear Rosa. Good evening. My name is Katie Darosa. I'm the inclusion liaison at the Boston Teachers Union and I'm a Boston resident. Tonight, I'm representing the BTU inclusion done right committee to

261
01:16:58.159 --> 01:17:14.880
speak in support of the opportunity and achievement gaps policy, specifically objective 3.9, advancing inclusion and accelerating learning for students with disabilities. We believe that the policy correctly centers equity for black, latino, and multilingual learners with disabilities

262
01:17:14.880 --> 01:17:31.600
to have full access to inclusive settings and grade level curriculum. We applaud the goals of reducing the disproportionate placement of black and Latino boys in substantially separate settings and reducing the concentration of students with disabilities in chronically underperforming and

263
01:17:31.600 --> 01:17:47.280
transformation schools. As a committee, we have an urgent ask which is to pair the policy's commitments with fully funded implementation of evidence-based models and resources. We ask for the school committee and the OAG task force to include the following recommendations

264
01:17:47.280 --> 01:18:03.920
to the policy implementation. One, appropriately value the role of the PAR professional as an essential member of the inclusive instructional team. Two, adopt and scale proven inclusive instructional models and ensure that classroom teams receive sustained

265
01:18:03.920 --> 01:18:21.199
collaboration time and professional development. Three, require fidelity checks for IEP referral processes and resource allocations to ensure the necessary supports are consistently provided for students with disabilities to have access to grade level.

266
01:18:21.199 --> 01:18:37.040
>> We urge you to pair the priorities of closing opportunity gaps and reducing disproportionate restricted pl placements with the proven tools, sustained funding and accountability needed to implement at scale. Thank you. >> Thank you very much. Our next five

267
01:18:37.040 --> 01:18:52.800
speakers are not signed into the meeting. So we that concludes public comment chair. >> Thank you. >> Thank you Miss Farbex and thank you to those of you who spoke this evening and shared your perspectives. Your testimony

268
01:18:52.800 --> 01:19:11.760
is very important to us. Our two first action items this evening are the grants for approval totally $478,158.82 82 and the inind donation for approval totaling $1,500. Now, I'd like to turn it over to the

269
01:19:11.760 --> 01:19:27.040
superintendent for any final comments. >> Uh, wonderful. Thank you, chair. So, uh, as chair said, nine grants for your consideration tonight, uh, totaling more than $478,000. The largest grants are a $200,000

270
01:19:27.040 --> 01:19:44.400
Massachusetts Department of Education playground earmark increasing uh increase which then serves 1,68 students at the O'Donnell and Hail Elementary Schools and English High School for the redesign and rehabilitation of outdoor

271
01:19:44.400 --> 01:19:58.480
recreation spaces for students of varying abilities including multiport courts and playground and exercise equipment. Second is a more than $66,000 community

272
01:19:58.480 --> 01:20:16.480
biodiversity grant serving 2,339 students at the Curley Hurley and Higginson Lewis K28. So Baby Higgy and the 3 to8 Lee Academy and the Manning and King elementary schools. The funding

273
01:20:16.480 --> 01:20:33.199
will be used to restore degraded urban habitat by removing invasive species and restoring habitat for pollinators and birds that will serve as both a hands-on classroom and community garden.

274
01:20:33.199 --> 01:20:48.159
Next, there is a nearly $49,000 Aspen Challenge grant that will serve 112 students in 28 coaches across 14 schools. The funding will support the Aspen Challenge, a project-based program where students develop solutions to

275
01:20:48.159 --> 01:21:04.719
social issues in their communities, as you saw earlier in the presentation. And finally, every year, BPS receives a mid-year adjustment to our main federal entitlement grants that may result in an increase of funding to the district. The

276
01:21:04.719 --> 01:21:20.880
district will receive approximately $162,000 in addition in additional title one, two, three, and four funding from our federal grants through the state. These increases will fund academic instruction, student opportunities, and

277
01:21:20.880 --> 01:21:36.640
family engagement under title one, educator effectiveness under title two, English language uh acquisition under title three, and college and career readiness, social emotional wellness and technology access

278
01:21:36.640 --> 01:21:52.719
under title 4. There is also before you an inkind donation. Uh, this is from the friends of the Raphael Hernandez Dual Language School who have donated kindly an outdoor storage shed to the school valued at

279
01:21:52.719 --> 01:22:13.440
$1,500. We would ask the committee to vote in favor of accepting this donation as well as our grants. >> Thank you. I will now open it up to questions and comments from the committee. No.

280
01:22:13.440 --> 01:22:28.719
>> Okay. There's no further discussion. I will now entertain a motion to approve the grants as presented. Is there a motion? >> So move. >> Is there a second? >> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Is there any objection to approving the grants by unanimous

281
01:22:28.719 --> 01:22:44.320
consent? Hearing none, the grants are approved. Okay. And if there is no further discussion, I will now entertain a motion to approve the inind donation as presented. Is there a motion? >> So, thank you. Is there a second? >> Second.

282
01:22:44.320 --> 01:22:58.960
>> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Is there any objection to approving the inind donation by unanimous consent? Hearing none, the inind donation is approved. Our third action item this evening is the approval

283
01:22:58.960 --> 01:23:16.880
of the MSBA core program 2026 statement of interest for the Melvin H. King Southen Academy that was presented earlier tonight. Are there any additional questions or comments before we move to a vote? Anybody? Nope. Okay. If there are no

284
01:23:16.880 --> 01:23:32.639
further questions, I will entertain a motion to approve the MSBA core program 2026 statement of interest for the Melvin H. Ken King Southbend Academy as presented. Is there a motion? >> So move. >> Is there a second? >> Second.

285
01:23:32.639 --> 01:23:48.560
>> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? Miss Provix, will you please call the role? >> Thank you, Chair. Dr. Alkins, >> yes. >> Mr. Peralta, Miss Palanka Garcia, >> yes. >> Miss Torres, >> yes. Mr. Tran, >> yes. >> Miss Garrett,

286
01:23:48.560 --> 01:24:04.400
>> yes. >> Miss Robinson, >> yes. >> The motion is approved. >> Thank you. Our final action item this evening is the Mass Core graduation requirement policy amendment. As you might remember, this was presented at the March 25th meeting. I will now turn

287
01:24:04.400 --> 01:24:21.840
it over to the superintendent for final comments. >> Wonderful. And congratulations to the leadership and staff of the Melvin H. King Southend Academy. Uh so at the last school committee meeting on Wednesday, March 25th, uh my

288
01:24:21.840 --> 01:24:38.080
team presented an update on the Mass Core graduation requirement. Tonight, we are asking the committee to reaffirm our existing policy that states mass core is the BPS graduation requirement. In addition, we are asking members to approve our recommendations for

289
01:24:38.080 --> 01:24:53.600
alternative measures to address rare or extenduating circumstances. As we reviewed last week, Mass Core was first adopted by this committee in the spring of 2021. Over the past several years, we've been working to ensure that

290
01:24:53.600 --> 01:25:09.360
the course coding, standards, credits, and schedule alignment in our secondary schools meet the BPS mass core requirement. Over the past five years, we have made real progress in supporting our students toward Mass Core

291
01:25:09.360 --> 01:25:23.600
completion, including the use of highquality instructional materials, equitable literacy implementation, a review of the district's course catalog, 1,800 courses, early college and CTE

292
01:25:23.600 --> 01:25:41.520
pathway expansion, and AP, IB, art, and music classes, elective offerings, and course schedules to support Mass Core. Our school teams continue to work directly with students and families to ensure they are on track to meet the

293
01:25:41.520 --> 01:25:57.840
requirements of Mass Core or graduation in general and to help them get back on track if they're behind. Last week, we shared the details on the acceptable replacements and comparatable alternatives for different student groups. Many of these situations are

294
01:25:57.840 --> 01:26:14.159
addressed through DESIE guidance. We ask for the committee support of this vote tonight. Dr. Wright, deputy superintendent of academics. Brett Dickens, assistant superintendent, college, career, and life readiness. Dr. Angela Hedley Mitchell, chief of

295
01:26:14.159 --> 01:26:37.600
teaching and learning are all here tonight to assist with answering any remaining questions that members may have. Back to you, chair. >> Thank you. I'll now open it up to questions and comments from the committee. Thank you. Um I think that this is um an

296
01:26:37.600 --> 01:26:53.040
important carve out for special circumstances as we've discussed in detail in previous meetings. uh really understanding that mascore is the standard and the bar for the vast majority of students and I think it's

297
01:26:53.040 --> 01:27:08.560
well timed that we are talking about strategic planning this evening uh which we know will lead to some outcomes and measures discussion about what our set of metrics are going to be that will be examined every year and improved upon

298
01:27:08.560 --> 01:27:24.560
every year um and so I don't have a question I just um really look forward to the percent of students graduating with Mass Core as an annual measure um that has an ambitious 5-year target. Um

299
01:27:24.560 --> 01:27:41.520
and that continues to increase every year just so that it's clear to us and to the public um that this is really a special circumstance um and that we are still seeking for the very vast majority of our students to earn um a Massore

300
01:27:41.520 --> 01:28:10.159
diploma. Absolutely. >> Absolutely. >> Miss Panka Garcia. >> Thank you, Madame Chair. Um I would like to echo what my colleague is saying here regarding the vulnerability that our students the ELLs

301
01:28:10.159 --> 01:28:37.239
to English language students show when they come to this country. You have to take in consideration that the mass score is a great opportunity to improve the academic performance and preparedness of all our students.

302
01:28:43.840 --> 01:29:01.760
So have to consider as well without the proper support we might be incurring in not promoting the equalities that should exist in our learners with our learners because we have to consider that there is the language vulnerability in this

303
01:29:01.760 --> 01:29:32.719
population. >> Because it is important for the families to know that there is there will be an evaluation. There will be a team giving that particular evaluation. And we have to consider as well that every student has a vulnerability different

304
01:29:32.719 --> 01:29:48.719
vulnerability. >> Thank you for pay attention in that part because it's important for the students English learner you see the why is important the student English learner

305
01:29:48.719 --> 01:30:05.280
you superintendent your team putting attention in that. Thank you. Also building on that and what we heard from public comment today about really having an assetbased approach. Um my understanding is that a lot of examples

306
01:30:05.280 --> 01:30:22.480
of the exceptions that are considered is really giving honor to courses taken in other countries before students have transferred here and evaluating those transcripts really carefully and thoroughly as an example. Um, and also appreciate just the framing of the

307
01:30:22.480 --> 01:30:39.040
exceptions as being in the realm of similarity to the already existing alternative school requirements. Um, just as a frame for where that leniency might be and that there is kind of a floor that we're still expecting in in

308
01:30:39.040 --> 01:30:54.719
situations that are exceptions. >> Yeah. Thank you. >> Yes, I would echo that. And when I listen to you speak, I think about the original intent of the policy >> being to prepare students for all of the universities in Massachusetts and and

309
01:30:54.719 --> 01:31:10.320
reminding ourselves that that's why we're doing it. And so we see multilingualism as an asset. Um, and we want to make sure that all students can thrive, whatever their post-secary path. And that's really why we we do what we do.

310
01:31:10.320 --> 01:31:26.080
>> Yeah. I just want to thank everybody who has worked on this over the years. Um when we first um approached this in 2021, I think we were naive as a school committee as to what it was. We were trying to make sure students who didn't

311
01:31:26.080 --> 01:31:42.400
have access to foreign language had access to it because we understood they couldn't they they they weren't having the courses because they weren't being offered. So, we knew that there were disparities in what the offerings were across our high schools, but um as the

312
01:31:42.400 --> 01:31:59.120
work moved forward, we saw that there were many, many disparities and issues that needed to be approved and the 1,800 courses that needed to be aligned and everything. So, I really want to thank the district for getting us thus far. um knowing that there still is work to do

313
01:31:59.120 --> 01:32:15.280
but that we are we are on our way and that I think our students will be better off for it with the opportunities. >> Absolutely >> right. So thank you. So I will now read the motion language so that all members are clear and public to on what we'll be

314
01:32:15.280 --> 01:32:32.880
voting on. So, it's ordered that the Boston School Committee hereby reaffirms their commitment to the 2021 Massore Graduation Requirements Policy, including the 2025 alternative education amendment with

315
01:32:32.880 --> 01:32:48.159
additional flexibility for individual student circumstances. There are student situations that may require different but comparable alternatives to courses determined to meet mass core graduation requirements.

316
01:32:48.159 --> 01:33:05.040
The superintendent or their design has the authority to review each student's situation to identify alternative courses or exceptions for specific credits. In alignment with the alternative education requirement, all

317
01:33:05.040 --> 01:33:20.800
students must successfully complete a minimum of 18 credits across the four core subjects of English language arts, mathematics, history, and science in order to graduate.

318
01:33:20.800 --> 01:33:37.360
If there are no further questions, I'll entertain a motion to approve the Mass graduation requirements policy amendment as presented. So, >> is there a motion? >> Thank you. Is there a second? >> Thank you. Is there any discussion or objection to the motion?

319
01:33:37.360 --> 01:33:52.000
>> Miss Pavix, will you please call the role? >> Thank you, Chair. Dr. Alkins, >> yes. >> Mr. Para, Miss Palanka Garcia, >> yes. >> Miss Torres, >> yes. >> Mr. Tran, >> yes. >> Miss Garrett, >> yes. >> Miss Robinson, >> yes. >> The motion is approved.

320
01:33:52.000 --> 01:34:11.800
>> Right. Thanks. Um because we have a long evening ahead of us with a couple of pretty significant um presentations, we're going to just take a five minute break so people can uh >> take care of their needs and can come back to

321
01:34:14.639 --> 01:45:27.440
during Now we now we will transition to our reports. Our first two reports tonight will be presentation of the 2026 policy to advance academic excellence and eliminate opportunity and achievement

322
01:45:27.440 --> 01:45:44.000
gaps, followed by an update on the 2026 to 2031 strategic roadmap. Let's aim to keep each of these presentations to 15 minutes. And I'd like to remind our presenters to please speak at a slower

323
01:45:44.000 --> 01:46:00.000
pace to assist our interpreters. And I want the to invite the superintendent to give introductory remarks. >> Wonderful. Thank you, chair. So, very special night. Um, as a district, we strive to put the opportunity and achievement gap policy into practice

324
01:46:00.000 --> 01:46:16.880
every day in our decision-making, in our goal setting, and in our strategic planning. And you'll hear this shortly. The intent of the policy is to close opportunity and achievement gaps for every single student in the district with intentional focus on groups that

325
01:46:16.880 --> 01:46:32.719
have been historically marginalized and ensure they have the opportunity to reach their full potential. It has been nearly a decade since the policy was updated, delayed in part to the pandemic. I am truly so happy to be here. Um, this

326
01:46:32.719 --> 01:46:48.960
has definitely been one of the best things that we've worked on this year uh to bring the updated OAG policy forward for the committee's consideration. With the OAG policy as our north star, we have developed a strategic road map that

327
01:46:48.960 --> 01:47:05.600
will guide our mission into the next decade. Tonight we will also present an updated update to our draft plan. Our vision to unlock and support the brilliance and potential of every BPS student in clear actionable steps that will guide us

328
01:47:05.600 --> 01:47:22.960
through the end of the decade. In a few minutes, I will turn the meeting over to senior adviser for strategy and opportunity gaps who you know well, Dr. Colin Rose, an OAG task force co-chairs Ellie Shakur, and school committee member who you know well, Dr. Steven

329
01:47:22.960 --> 01:47:38.880
Akins. After they present the OAG policy, Dr. Rose will walk members through our work to date and lay out the next steps in the strategic planning process. Dr. Rose, members of my team, and the OAG task force that guides the district's

330
01:47:38.880 --> 01:47:55.840
work, have worked hard to align the goals of the policy and the goals of the district. It is fitting that we will also present our initial thinking on our strategic plan in this meeting as the two must work in tandem for our district to be

331
01:47:55.840 --> 01:48:11.440
successful. I want to wholeheartedly thank the OAG task force for its partnership and for working with BPS to monitor the district's progress, guide its decision-making, provide support, and hold it accountable. We look forward to

332
01:48:11.440 --> 01:48:28.159
continuing to work with the task force to ensure that the goals of the OAG policy are at the center as we go through the district's strategic planning process. We'll ask the committee for its support of the updated policy at a future school committee meeting and we will continue to update

333
01:48:28.159 --> 01:48:45.199
members on our strategic planning. At this point, I will now turn the meeting over to senior adviser for strategy and opportunity gaps, Dr. Rose and OG task force co-chair. Good evening and thank you to the members of the Boston School Committee

334
01:48:45.199 --> 01:49:01.280
and Chair Robinson and Superintendent Skipper for the opportunity to present today. I'm Ale Shakur, co-chair of the opportunity and achievement gaps task force. Um, and I am here on behalf of the entire task force. We are so excited

335
01:49:01.280 --> 01:49:18.719
for today's presentation. Um, as Superintendent Skipper said, I'm also joined today by our co-chair, Dr. Steven Alkins uh who's also a member of the Boston school committee and by Dr. Colin Rose who senior adviser for strategy and opportunity gaps. This policy represents

336
01:49:18.719 --> 01:49:34.800
two years of focused work and nearly two decades of commitment to ensuring every student in Boston has access to an excellent education. So let's start with why this policy matters. As Superintendent Skipper said,

337
01:49:34.800 --> 01:49:50.480
this policy is intended to be the northstar for the district. It defines who we are accountable to and what success must look like. It centers the students who make up the majority of BPS, students of color, multilingual

338
01:49:50.480 --> 01:50:06.880
learners, students with disabilities, economically disadvantaged students. These identities are not separate. They overlap. Many of our students sit at the intersection of multiple systems of inequity. That means this policy is not

339
01:50:06.880 --> 01:50:24.800
about a subset of students. It's about the core of our district. The policy is meant to be revised every six years. We are presenting today after 10. And as Superintendent Skipper said, there have been delays due to COVID and

340
01:50:24.800 --> 01:50:41.920
leadership transitions, but the urgency has only grown. The data continues to show persistent gaps, particularly for black and Latino students, multilingual learners, and students with disabilities. That is why this work is not optional. It is essential.

341
01:50:41.920 --> 01:50:57.360
So, let's give some historic grounding in terms of how we got to this point with the policy. The OAG policy has deep roots in advocacy, particularly through Black Educators Alliance for Massachusetts, also known as BEAM. The

342
01:50:57.360 --> 01:51:14.719
policy was first adopted back in 2006, updated in 2016, and now strengthened in 2026. This is legacy work, and we stand on the shoulders of advocates and leaders like Barbara Fields, the late George Cox,

343
01:51:14.719 --> 01:51:30.239
Janet Williams, and Norah Tony. The task force itself was created to ensure this policy remains a living breathing accountability tool. I want to acknowledge the advocacy of chairman Michael O'Neal who was the one who

344
01:51:30.239 --> 01:51:48.239
actually called for the creation of the task force back in 2015 and then the 2016 policy was adopted a year later by the Boston school committee. And then that brings us to the role of the task force. We are not symbolic. We

345
01:51:48.239 --> 01:52:04.560
are active partners in accountability. Our role is to monitor progress, provide guidance, elevate community voice, ensure this policy translates into real change in schools. I co-chair alongside Dr. Steven Alkins and we work closely

346
01:52:04.560 --> 01:52:20.400
with Dr. Colin Rose as I mentioned before. And we want to give a shout out to Chair Robinson who was the prior co-chair for the task force and served for a period of 10 years. So, thank you so much, Chair Robinson. >> I want to transition to Dr. Alkins, who

347
01:52:20.400 --> 01:52:36.480
will share a little bit about why we are here and what the data shows. >> Dr. Rose, >> sorry, you said Dr. Alkins, Dr. Dr. Rose. >> Hi. Uh, good good evening, uh, school committee members. Um, the urgency of

348
01:52:36.480 --> 01:52:51.760
this work is self-evident. Um, here you have a literal illustration of the problem. This is a graphic showing fourth grade ELA and eighth grade math scores from the start of MCCAST through today. Between the dotted lines, you'll

349
01:52:51.760 --> 01:53:08.239
see uh park testing which was used in between the old and the new generation MCCAST. Um and the blank sta space is a time we would all like to forget, the pandemic. Um, as you can see, performance has ebed and flow, but gaps towards proficiency remain similar

350
01:53:08.239 --> 01:53:24.000
across time and have been extremely large for the groups ILA outlined above. Even as we see a bit of an uptick now, we need to find the conditions and support them that allow those lines to consistently rise towards proficiency

351
01:53:24.000 --> 01:53:43.840
for these measures and all others. As we begin to close the chapter on the 2016 policy uh the version of the policy, we want to acknowledge the many steps that came from that work. Um this includes everything from CLSP which brought form and definition to

352
01:53:43.840 --> 01:53:58.639
culturally responsive practice in the district to the opportunity index which created a tangible and scientific way to measure student need outside the context of schools and everything in between. Much of what you see here was part of

353
01:53:58.639 --> 01:54:15.280
the bright spots uh in Desi's 2019 review of the district. >> Thank you, Dr. Rose. And so, in terms of the policy that we are about to discuss today, there are a number of stakeholders who provided feedback. Uh we had extensive meetings with superintendent Skipper and her

354
01:54:15.280 --> 01:54:32.480
leadership team, the division of schools, academics, the inclusion planning team, instructional leadership team, student input from Boston student advisory council, and various members of the OAG task force who are listed here. a 15 member task force representing

355
01:54:32.480 --> 01:54:47.040
parents, school leaders, teachers, Boston Teachers Union representatives, community advocates, people with expertise in black student achievement, multilingual learners, as well as students with disabilities and sense of

356
01:54:47.040 --> 01:55:03.599
belonging and wellness. Those task force members were served as co-authors together with members of the district and the broader community. So here are the six goals that are outlined in the policy. Notably, the 2016 policy

357
01:55:03.599 --> 01:55:20.400
also had six goals, the same six goals, although we've added more form and structure to each of them. The first goal, goal one, is really about accountability and systems. And this goal is really designed to provide a clear outline of how accountability

358
01:55:20.400 --> 01:55:35.280
begins with those members here on the bench with the school committee then flowing to the superintendent, the superintendent's leadership team, the role of the task force and the design of the superintendent all the way down to the school building level and what

359
01:55:35.280 --> 01:55:51.679
happens with our schools. It also includes the accountability, how the policy will be measured and evaluated over time, a dashboard, the metrics and so forth. Goal number two is really designed to give the uh conditions under

360
01:55:51.679 --> 01:56:08.000
which closing achievement gaps would need to happen because we know that mindsets are important that everyone at all levels in BPS needs to understand culturally and linguistically affirming and sustaining practices and that includes professional development at all

361
01:56:08.000 --> 01:56:24.560
district levels so that everyone in BPS is holding high expectations and high standards for our young people. Goal number three is around advancing academic excellence and this is the goal where achievement is fully centered.

362
01:56:24.560 --> 01:56:42.080
Here we have focused on schools as the unit of change. This is where the magic happens on the front lines with our teachers and our young people. So here we focus on the importance of strong school leadership, high quality teachers in every classroom, the importance of

363
01:56:42.080 --> 01:56:57.280
literacy and academic rigor. student wellness and belonging and inclusion and supports for diverse learners. As you heard from many of the people during public comment, we also point out here the importance of bilingual education,

364
01:56:57.280 --> 01:57:13.520
bilingualism and home language. And we talk about inclusion, making sure that we are looking out for this disproportionate placement of black and Latino students and in substantially separate environments and instead making sure all young people are getting the

365
01:57:13.520 --> 01:57:30.639
supports that they need to thrive. If we get this right, students will experience the policy in their classrooms each and every day. Goal number four is really about education and leadership diversity. Our young people deserve to see teachers who look like them. They

366
01:57:30.639 --> 01:57:46.880
deserve to have teachers that reflect their languages and their lived experience. And so therefore, we really want to focus on the recruitment, the retention, and the support for teachers of color. Um, and this is actually again one of the priorities that's been with

367
01:57:46.880 --> 01:58:04.159
us from the very beginning back in 2006 when Black Educators Alliance of Massachusetts drafted the very first policy. Goal five is really centering our families, our parents, our partners, our students themselves. And so this is the one that's really looking at

368
01:58:04.159 --> 01:58:20.080
reciprocal partnerships with those members of our community. It's about shared responsibility because we know that schools cannot do this work alone. So here we're elevating student voice, agency, and leadership, looking at families as true partners, and looking

369
01:58:20.080 --> 01:58:36.719
at the importance of community partners, higher ed, and industry partners as well. And finally, goal number six, which intentionally comes last, really centers on the role of central office because we need central office to exist to support schools, not the other way

370
01:58:36.719 --> 01:58:54.239
around. And so here the goal is focused on equitable and transparent and efficient operations. And we're looking at things about how funding decisions are made, transparency in school closures and mergers, capital investments and facilities and so forth.

371
01:58:54.239 --> 01:59:09.679
I've already outlined some of the things that are different in this policy. Again, centering schools as that unit of change, having more rigor here around accountability and reporting, stronger focus on academic excellence, and really we center joyful learning because at the

372
01:59:09.679 --> 01:59:25.520
end of the day, if the classrooms are not joyful places, we will not be able to close achievement gaps. And then finally, I'll turn it over to Dr. Alkins who will talk about the connection between the policy and the strategic plan that you'll hear about next.

373
01:59:25.520 --> 01:59:42.239
>> Thank you. Um so on the left you see a flowchart demonstrating how this policy connects to and informs other key levers for change within our district. So for context throughout several conversations with the task force uh I myself was able to explore uh and learn the history

374
01:59:42.239 --> 02:00:00.159
around the 2016 policy um and how it has been taken up by the district and how it's been operationalized over the past 10 years. So in short alongside with its many accomplishments, the sense that I got was that sometimes the policy was seen as either operating in parallel uh

375
02:00:00.159 --> 02:00:16.239
with the BPS strategic plan and with certain components and tasks being assigned to either individual groups or departments. In many cases, this led to misunderstandings and a lack of clarity around accountability structures. But as you can see, as it's described as our

376
02:00:16.239 --> 02:00:32.880
northstar, this policy aims to create better alignment in that this policy should inform school committee priorities, our questions, and the presentations that come before the body. These priorities will in turn inform the development of the strategic plan and

377
02:00:32.880 --> 02:00:47.760
have which will then be carried out by an implementation plan with key performance indicators. Our hope is to create a feedback loop of communication around data that will result in elimination of these gaps permanently and give our students pathways to

378
02:00:47.760 --> 02:01:04.880
unbridled success in BPS and beyond. This means that as a school committee, we must be proactive in asking for key data updates at critical junctures to inform our decisions. The elimination of OAGs is not just support for our most vulnerable

379
02:01:04.880 --> 02:01:20.880
populations. It will result in a removal of barriers for all students. The work of this task force represents a collective viewpoint that we are not just an external arm of the school committee, but we are thought partners intimately involved in this work and equally committed to the success of our

380
02:01:20.880 --> 02:01:36.960
students. In that sense, the structure of this policy that will support monitoring and implementation aims not to silo the work but create cross collaborative teams to address its goals. The task force will work in partnership with district

381
02:01:36.960 --> 02:01:53.920
representatives to ensure that goals, allocations, and implementation efforts align and progress with cohesive strategy, consistent monitoring, transparency with the public, and urgency. And now I'll pass it over to Dr. Colin Rose to talk through more

382
02:01:53.920 --> 02:02:13.440
about the strategic plan. That's the next presentation. So you want me to pause or you want me to go directly into Perfect. Let me see if I could get the text. >> So for our public that concludes the presentation specifically on the policy

383
02:02:13.440 --> 02:02:31.040
but again as Dr. Alkins just explained the strategic plan is really how the policy is implemented. So that's the next se >> Good evening again. So, uh, today, uh, alongside the OEG policy, we want to give an update, uh, to the burgeoning

384
02:02:31.040 --> 02:02:46.080
strategic planning that's going on in the district. Um, as the OG policy is touted as the northstar of the district, we believe it anro an appropriate time to bring this upstate update forward as we're bringing forward the policy. During the last iteration of the OEG

385
02:02:46.080 --> 02:03:00.719
policy, there was an implementation plan created, which was under my purview at the time. uh part of the reason I came back was to support this endeavor but an opportunity arose. In the past the OAG implementation plan

386
02:03:00.719 --> 02:03:16.239
was a separate implementation plan from the district implementation plan. Uh now that we have uh we are embarking on a strategic plan as a district. Um the thought was to create a plan in alignment with the OG policy so that we

387
02:03:16.239 --> 02:03:34.320
don't have two separate comprehensive implementation plans uh and one can serve both. So tonight we'll provide an update on the development of our strategic plan. Uh the goal of this presentation is to share information and invite school

388
02:03:34.320 --> 02:03:52.719
committee to give input on the strategic roadmap and we'll stay kind of at a high level uh next to the objectives. This slide shows our vision for every student in our district and I'll read a quote that comes from the 2016 version

389
02:03:52.719 --> 02:04:08.560
um and still finds its way into the 2026 language. Uh this is credited to Sam Acavdo who was one of the chairs, Reverend um who's one of the chairs of the task force at the time. Every child in every classroom in every Boston

390
02:04:08.560 --> 02:04:24.639
school has the same opportunity to achieve the greatness as anyone else with the same unfettered access to excellent teaching, joyful learning, and every conceivable tool needed to unlock their brilliance. We want that to be

391
02:04:24.639 --> 02:04:41.199
true for every kid in BPS. Um below we have a graphic for the high quality student experience that was created a few years ago with a massive amount of community engagement. Uh the four components include rigorous and culturally affirming learning

392
02:04:41.199 --> 02:04:56.159
experiences, supportive network of caring adults, wellness and enrichment uh undergarded by physical spaces that support learning. The thought being that the closer we are at creating this type of experience, the closer we can get to

393
02:04:56.159 --> 02:05:15.760
our vision. As leadership started thinking about a new strategic plan uh and the high quality student experience um with it, we wanted to leverage multiple foundational building blocks that have been built over the past few years under the current strategic plan. These

394
02:05:15.760 --> 02:05:32.159
include the regional school model uh with academic and wraparound service for schools. High quality instructional materials and equitable literacy uh was a lot of the academic work that was going on. The MTSS framework uh both thinking about the core instruction that

395
02:05:32.159 --> 02:05:48.880
happens in the classroom but also those tier 2 tier three supports that students need to be able to be regulated and ready for class. inclusive education, uh, making sure that, uh, we provide the least restrictive environment for students. Long-term facilities planning, which is

396
02:05:48.880 --> 02:06:05.679
changing and shifting the footprint, um, and hopefully providing better spaces and support for our students. language access. So the increase of bilingual and dual language programming um as well as um clearer exit and entrance uh criteria for students who

397
02:06:05.679 --> 02:06:23.880
are learning English career pathways so expanding access to college and career pathways and post-secondary partnerships uh and community hub schools right how do we embed community resources and coordinate with the communities to make our schools better

398
02:06:25.199 --> 02:06:40.320
from these foundational elements and the definition of the high quality student experience as well as the school committee priorities as you all worked on last year in the OEG policy leadership decided to create three buckets to organize the current impactful work and also identify

399
02:06:40.320 --> 02:06:56.639
improvement and new elements to ensure student success. These buckets are high quality instruction. This is a c a category in which Dr. Simone Wright had great influence in shaping as a leader of the academic strategy. This speaks to how we improve teaching and learning for

400
02:06:56.639 --> 02:07:12.480
the diverse set of learners we have in Boston and especially those who have historically been under or missed by our instruction. Holistic student supports is the second bucket um which speaks to the conditions and supports students need to be in

401
02:07:12.480 --> 02:07:28.880
school and ready to learn in our classrooms. And then we have high quality programming and facilities which speaks to the programming and physical plant we need as a district as well as well as throughout the city to be able to support the teaching learning

402
02:07:28.880 --> 02:07:45.520
environment support student need students need to be ready for college career and life. Our theory of action comes from the notion that Boston is resourcerich but at times coordination poor. The thought here is that if we align the

403
02:07:45.520 --> 02:08:04.400
resources and energies between schools, central office and the community towards these three focus areas in an aligned and coherent way, we will make major strides towards our vision for all students. To start drafting the raw materials for

404
02:08:04.400 --> 02:08:21.119
objectives and goals, we enlisted the support of numerous members of our BPS community to work together by topic in cross functional groups. These groups included folks from different perches perspectives in the district that have strong connection to relevant topics

405
02:08:21.119 --> 02:08:36.159
connected to those three bucket areas. Members of the team might work in family engagement. They might work in operations. They might be part of our school's team. uh the thought was that they can bring their particular perspective, their experience, their

406
02:08:36.159 --> 02:08:52.159
wisdom to the table as we envision and then work to improve that particular phenomenon we were looking at in that group. To do this, we utilize the racial equity planning tool, especially steps one through four, uh which I'll go into a bit detail in in the next couple of

407
02:08:52.159 --> 02:09:10.639
slides. Step one of the REP process is connected to understanding the general context and coming to consensus on what improvements the group would like to see at the end of the day, especially as it relates to equitable outcomes for students.

408
02:09:10.639 --> 02:09:25.760
That included understanding the current research in the area. So there's there's an image here around the NCL um report on disproportionality. Disproportionality was one of our groups. Um these readings grounded groups in a shared understanding of the

409
02:09:25.760 --> 02:09:42.480
issue so that we had uh a solid foundation. Groups also talked about the current and past initiatives and district context connected to the topic as well as any connect connections to the OG policy that was burgeoning and the school committee pri priorities before identifying some broad desired

410
02:09:42.480 --> 02:09:58.320
outcomes. You can go back. Step two of the RAP asked groups to dig into the BPS context a bit uh deeper through data. All groups were aided by a dedicated member of the data and accountability

411
02:09:58.320 --> 02:10:17.440
team which brought specific data connected to the issues they were exploring. Through this data, groups identified trends and key takeaways. Step three, each group was given a detailed report built from numerous

412
02:10:17.440 --> 02:10:33.119
focus groups conducted across the BPS community. I would like to acknowledge Tamika uh Buckmeer, Dr. Tunji uh Adamant Mande Stacy Stacy Guerrero among others who organized engagements

413
02:10:33.119 --> 02:10:49.440
connected the sessions and collected data as well as the office of data and accountability who helped synthesize and provide themes uh across those focus groups. Cross functional team members also conducted empathy interviews with stakeholders from their particular area of the organization to get even more

414
02:10:49.440 --> 02:11:06.079
detailed information connected to the current context. groups created takeaways that in tandem with steps one and two began to identify some root causes and clear opportunities. In step four, um these groups started refining objectives, defining broad

415
02:11:06.079 --> 02:11:22.719
goals and core actions, taking in the current context, root causes while also reimagining uh what improvement would look like in five years. These raw materials from these groups continue to be refined. Today we are bringing forward some solidify highlevel

416
02:11:22.719 --> 02:11:39.679
objectives in each focus area. These would be the anchors for discrete goals and action steps for implementation. So uh in the first focus area highquality instruction there's really two objectives. One around systematic

417
02:11:39.679 --> 02:11:55.520
effectiveness of our instruction. So, increasing the effectiveness of high-quality teaching at scale uh by leveraging high quality instructional materials, integrating high impact literacy practices and other evidence-based practices that support high levels of student engagement and

418
02:11:55.520 --> 02:12:12.199
learning for each student across BPS and especially black, latinx, multilingual learners and students with disabilities. And the second sentence there deals with um how we need to share that work across our our full broad community.

419
02:12:13.679 --> 02:12:31.679
jumping the gun there. U the second objective is really around uh educator capacity. So how do we match our professional development to ensure that teachers uh instructors and everybody within the district can actually do that. Focus area two holistic student supports

420
02:12:31.679 --> 02:12:48.719
um has three objectives. One around attendance and engagement, right? So increase student attendance and engagement in school through aligned school central office and community based strategies. Uh in order for students to take advantage of high quality instruction, they need to be in school. And so how do we bring down even

421
02:12:48.719 --> 02:13:03.920
more of the barriers? We've done a good job over the last few years in and lowering chronic absenteeism, but continuing on that road. And also making our schools places that are so engaging that if there are barriers, families and students will jump over them to get to our schools. Second, student readiness,

422
02:13:03.920 --> 02:13:20.719
MTSS, right? increase student readiness to engage with grade level tasks by grow growing clear, aligned and effective MTSS, including academic and whole student supports. Right? So, making sure that students are regulated and ready uh in our classrooms. And then third, equity and accountability. Uh and this

423
02:13:20.719 --> 02:13:37.599
is a topic that's been brought up multiple times tonight. um how do we reduce disproportionality and increase accountability for students in subsearate settings, especially black and Latino boys who often are those in that gap. Um this to me is a a pressure

424
02:13:37.599 --> 02:13:52.480
test really of all of our systems. Um because uh those Oh, sorry. I'll slow down a little bit. Um black and Latino boys are have historically been uh stuck in the disproportionality gap. And if we truly

425
02:13:52.480 --> 02:14:07.840
have the MTSS, those systems and the core teaching happening in classrooms that we that we really want, um this should decrease. And finally, focus area three, high high quality student experience through

426
02:14:07.840 --> 02:14:24.400
programming and facilities. So one is really just access to high quality student experience, those uh through that programming in school buildings that align to HQSC. Um, this is why we're doing all that work around long-term facilities planning. Hopefully, students are landing in

427
02:14:24.400 --> 02:14:39.599
spaces where they have the programming in the building to support their learning and growth into their life uh their life and career in college transition supports. So, increased supports for students and communities who are directly impacted by grade reconfiguration, school mergers and

428
02:14:39.599 --> 02:14:56.400
closures. So, we know that our footprint is going to continue to change. How do we ensure that we are increasing the supports for individual families and students and also school communities that are taking in students and families? Uh and then finally community integration into all our strategies.

429
02:14:56.400 --> 02:15:19.520
Right? So how do we coordinate and utilize community resources to extend access to a high quality student experience? Both bringing partners into our schools but also using the spaces in the city as our classroom. When thinking about objectives, it's not

430
02:15:19.520 --> 02:15:35.040
only important to identify shared priorities. It's also important to discuss conditions necessary to effectively execute and hold ourselves accountable mutually to those priorities as a entire community. Um, this is key for alignment and coherence. We call

431
02:15:35.040 --> 02:15:50.639
these enabling conditions. Uh there are three areas we'll need to explicitly focus on. Uh one, creating and maintaining equity centered culture and practice. Two, strengthening the systems structures and practices for collaboration as a district. And three,

432
02:15:50.639 --> 02:16:08.560
aligning resources to our priorities and ensuring structures for continuous improvement and accountability. Moving forward towards implementation, we'll continue to use uh the RAP process as we refine and create smart goals and action steps for our objectives as well

433
02:16:08.560 --> 02:16:29.040
as build out the overall metrics for student success. Finally, um our next immediate steps. Um there are a few discussion points for tonight. Namely, are these the right focus areas and objectives? uh and to a bit of a start to a discussion around

434
02:16:29.040 --> 02:16:45.920
goals and or metrics um we will use to measure progress. Um as we continue to develop the plan for the spring, there'll be opportunities to collaborate with you all school committee and the OG task force. Uh this could include that working session that you have on May

435
02:16:45.920 --> 02:17:01.840
20th. Um and then below you see our timeline for bringing forth the full plan this summer and into next fall. Um with that, that's me. I'm under 15 minutes by 30 seconds, but I made it. Uh, can I open up uh for for discussion

436
02:17:01.840 --> 02:17:18.960
uh for both presentations and especially those uh two key questions that we asked in this slide? >> Yeah, thank you both. Um, and I will now open it up to questions and comments from members. >> Go ahead. Um first of all thank you so much for the presentations

437
02:17:18.960 --> 02:17:35.359
and um my question is more towards um how you said that you want learning to be more joyful. So how will like schools make learning joyful while still focusing on some of the academic goals that we have?

438
02:17:35.359 --> 02:17:50.800
>> I think that uh that's a good question. So our policy is calling out the importance of joyful learning. I think some of that is going to come through professional development for our teachers, understanding that when you're working with students of color,

439
02:17:50.800 --> 02:18:05.840
multilingual learners, students with disabilities, really all students, um it has to be engaging and fun. And so I think there's ways that that can be done through project-based learning, music, getting kids out of their seats, getting them to be interactive. I think that

440
02:18:05.840 --> 02:18:21.120
type of professional development is is as important as other types of PD. And then it's also listening for young people, right? I think young people know what's exciting to them. And it's important that, you know, that's why we really put so much energy into goal

441
02:18:21.120 --> 02:18:37.040
number five where it talks about student leadership, students having a role on their school site councils or in their school leadership at their sites. Um, and really just listening to what young people want to bring the learning to life. I think we had a great example with the Aspen challenge. When you give

442
02:18:37.040 --> 02:18:52.880
students real world learning, it feels connected to their lives and communities, that's really the things that really make them most excited. >> Yeah, I'll piggy back. There is no learning without engagement. So, >> no, I totally agree with that. I totally agree. Um, my second question is related

443
02:18:52.880 --> 02:19:09.760
more to where it's goal number four, which says um increase educator and leadership diversity across the district. So um what are like some of the changes that students will notice in terms of like teacher diversity or staff diversity and do you guys have like

444
02:19:09.760 --> 02:19:24.719
data? Are you guys like collecting data from eight schools and then like seeing like what it recruit or something like that? >> This has been a really challenging area for the district. As you know there um as some of you know there was a judge Garity order that goes all the way back

445
02:19:24.719 --> 02:19:40.240
to the 70s. There's supposed to be 25% black teachers across the district. Um, at the time that stat was based on the student enrollment. Now we have, you know, significant number of Latino students. Uh, we have all sorts of languages across the district. So, it

446
02:19:40.240 --> 02:19:56.960
needs to be racial diversity and linguistic diversity in terms of the languages as well. Um, unfortunately because of union rules, we know that there's been quite a few teachers that are like sort of the last hired who are now in in danger of losing their

447
02:19:56.960 --> 02:20:12.160
positions. That's something the task force is focusing on and that we'll really ask this body to really take up because, you know, just as quickly as we're bringing diverse teachers into classrooms now, we're starting to lose them at the same time. Uh but what it

448
02:20:12.160 --> 02:20:27.439
should look like is every young person has a chance to experience not all of your teachers but there's a good munch a healthy mix of teachers in your schools so that you know we've had some students who say they've gone all the way through BPS and never had a teacher of color like that really shouldn't be the

449
02:20:27.439 --> 02:20:44.640
experience. Um so go ahead. So something I think I would add on to that um is the also the lensure process that also exists and um I think we already do have some data that's around sort of the differences that like we find from uh some of our more

450
02:20:44.640 --> 02:21:01.359
underrepresented demographics in terms of educators and how they're able to get through um those MTELs. So I think part of what our role will be as a as a body will be asking for that data so that we can say like oh we should be investing

451
02:21:01.359 --> 02:21:17.760
more in support for those lure preparation supports um for those um you know like for those for those teachers as well. Um also, um I'm not quite sure what the data is around mentorship, uh programs that exist for our educators

452
02:21:17.760 --> 02:21:33.359
and for our school principles like as well because it's not just about um recruiting, but it's about retaining um like our our educators and our and our school leaders. So, that's all just relevant things that we're going to have to look at as a school committee and um

453
02:21:33.359 --> 02:21:49.280
and really think about just the data behind it. Um which is especially relevant now that we've just passed the budget. So now looking at what is the impact um that first data set that we're going to receive around what has happened to our underrepresented

454
02:21:49.280 --> 02:22:07.040
educators. >> Yep. Thank you. >> Hi guys. Uh thank you for the presentation. This is my first time here. So um one of my question is around I read the preamble. >> Yes. >> And I think it was fantastic. It was

455
02:22:07.040 --> 02:22:21.600
great thing. And one of the questions that I have is about uh clarifying accountability and uh is this um is going to be always updated and what information will be in the dashboard for

456
02:22:21.600 --> 02:22:37.359
our families and community and um to see. >> Yes. Um so the policy is supposed to be updated every six years. Um and so there will it will move in a cycle with the strategic plan as well. I think we actually looked at five years. So as as

457
02:22:37.359 --> 02:22:52.720
the strategic plan is being updated, the policy will be refreshed. It's not designed to be completely rewritten, but at least we will take a look at it to see what might need to be revised. Um, in terms of the dashboard, there will be a data dashboard. The task force is

458
02:22:52.720 --> 02:23:08.319
deciding like which data would be maybe shared in more internally versus what would be the public facing dashboard. And at our next meeting in May, we'll be deciding on the key performance indicators. So a set of like five to 10 key things that we'll be monitoring from

459
02:23:08.319 --> 02:23:24.560
one year to the next or even on a quarterly basis. So that will be shared with of course with the school committee. So you all are also being able to sort of follow the progress as we go. Do you want to add that? >> Yeah, I think the that second question around goals and metrics. You know the I think the task force are going to want

460
02:23:24.560 --> 02:23:40.640
to see certain metrics. I know you all are going to want to see certain metrics. There are certain metrics that are important to us internally. I think it would be good to align those. Yes. In a way so we again >> we're not looking at five different data sets, but there is a a core group of

461
02:23:40.640 --> 02:23:56.240
data that we're looking at disagregating and making sure that that all bodies are paying attention to. So I think that would be one of the hopes this spring to try to get us aligned. >> And and to clarify, the task force will make a recommendation. It will then come to the school committee and superintendent and you all will whittle

462
02:23:56.240 --> 02:24:13.600
that list down. So because we can't boil the ocean, right? we have to make sure we're focusing on a key set of indicators. And so, you know, we're looking at trying to keep that narrow to about >> and I think Dr. Rose's position is a really important one because it is the linkage between the district and all of

463
02:24:13.600 --> 02:24:29.520
our teams and the task force to make sure that we're all rowing in the same direction. That's right. the uh to continue with that question. Will the dashboard include uh information about the schools?

464
02:24:29.520 --> 02:24:45.600
>> That's yeah, that was a question that we discussed at length with the task force. We would love to see it be school by school data. Um for some of the metrics, it might be by region as opposed to by school. So I think that would be one of the things that we will need to decide certainly with guidance from the school

465
02:24:45.600 --> 02:25:02.080
committee. >> Family wants some information around a school, they be able to go to the dashboard. >> That's right. That's right. Find it. >> Yeah, there's likely there's likely um quite a bit of data that can be disagregated to the school level if it's not already. There would be some things

466
02:25:02.080 --> 02:25:19.600
that um we would not want to uh put out there because it could be personnel or it could it be more sensitive data in which case we would do it at a more aggregate level >> but we'll work together to make sure that that data is available. >> Yes. And my other question is around

467
02:25:19.600 --> 02:25:35.439
staff training. I know that uh you talked about the cultural and linguistic and uh sustainable practice. >> Yes. >> So will BPS but what measures will be actually have in classroom so we can see

468
02:25:35.439 --> 02:25:49.680
the impact? >> Yes. And I will say the CLSP is one of the things that Dr. Rose brought to us back in 2016 and is really been rolling across the district. But why don't you speak to how you're measuring that? Yeah, I think any tool that we're using

469
02:25:49.680 --> 02:26:07.520
around classroom practice um should embed CLSP. Um when we think about climate and culture uh in our spaces um we that should be reflected in kind of what families feel, what students feel when they come into the buildings, when they come into bowling. Um so I think we

470
02:26:07.520 --> 02:26:23.280
have existing some existing measures that already do that. Now training is another thing that's got to be embedded in our professional development at all levels. uh so folks are prepared to really in a in a real way live that value out so that we can see improvement.

471
02:26:23.280 --> 02:26:37.520
>> I think it's also embedded in quality school plans and performance evaluations and >> yeah and any any major measures it should be embedded >> so that way we can see if the implementation is working

472
02:26:37.520 --> 02:26:54.080
>> and uh and if it's not what will be in place to support. >> Yes. Yeah. That is a that's a good point. >> Okay. >> Because it's not always working. So we have to be able to monitor that as well. >> So my other question I don't know if I

473
02:26:54.080 --> 02:27:10.240
go into the strategic plan. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. Sure. >> Okay. >> Yes. So in the equity impact statement it was like um there was a a statement in the last page they talked about a tracker

474
02:27:10.240 --> 02:27:26.560
>> and the development of the implementation of is of that tracker >> and there is a designated owner of that tracker. So my my question is what is the intent of the tracker

475
02:27:26.560 --> 02:27:43.040
and how do you imagine this will roll out? >> Yeah. So the original implementation plan in 2017 we had a tracker so it really tracked where we were in our goals. So we had put out what the goals were to the community and you could see

476
02:27:43.040 --> 02:27:59.280
kind of our progress as goals were being met um if they were overdue if they were kind of late. So it gave the community uh a chance to see where we were in progress to the things that we committed to. Uh and so the hope would be to to have a similar process with our goals at

477
02:27:59.280 --> 02:28:16.880
the strategic plan level. Um you know that's separate from the met like the the main metrics of the of the district, but it would be just a way to hold ourselves accountable to doing the things we say that we're going to do in the plan. And then just as the way that actually played out, I mean there were the departments would come and really

478
02:28:16.880 --> 02:28:34.160
present on progress towards goals and we would look at the original goals and sort of track as green meant they were on target. Yellow was like yeah it's in progress and then red meant like this is like we're not seeing the progress we needed to see. So I would imagine there'd be something along those same

479
02:28:34.160 --> 02:28:50.240
lines. Yeah, there was a it was like an internal there was an internal way for us to figure out like where people were, but it was it was a dashboard connected to the actual goals to say where we were. >> So when you talk about a designated owner, what does that mean? >> Uh in the district,

480
02:28:50.240 --> 02:29:07.520
>> well, yeah, it said that there will be a designated owner for the major step like designated to follow up on the >> Oh, you're talking about the actual goals. Yeah. >> Yeah. Yeah. So like action steps and goals would be owned by folks right in in offices so that it's not just this

481
02:29:07.520 --> 02:29:24.560
ambiguous like hey we have this goal around something folks need to own goals >> right. Mhm. >> Yeah. I think this was one of the challenges from before that >> it didn't filter beyond the highest levels >> and this has to be the core work of

482
02:29:24.560 --> 02:29:40.399
every person in the district for it to work >> and that means every department leads the deputies will all be taking this and internalizing this and it comes out in the prioritization of and their own kind

483
02:29:40.399 --> 02:29:57.280
of goals. How are they going to be measuring it? In what order are they doing it? What's the resources they're going to be using? So, this is really to go across the district. >> And I'll just add to that point when we back in 2016, each department had its

484
02:29:57.280 --> 02:30:13.600
own goals, but now it's crossf functional teams. So, it's no longer being siloed like one department's doing this, another department's doing that, whereas now it's it's cutting across departments as it needs to. Thank you. >> Thank you.

485
02:30:13.600 --> 02:30:30.640
>> Okay, Mr. Ch. >> Uh, thank you for developing a very thorough and welldetailed uh policy. >> Thank you. And I noticed that um well

486
02:30:30.640 --> 02:30:49.040
just a comment uh that um I know that you you you gauge your expectations in developing this depending dependent upon the percentage of students meeting or exceeding MCAST.

487
02:30:49.040 --> 02:31:06.080
MCAST is no longer part of our equation. But looking at the graph on whatever page that is >> it's very depressing you know um uh the policy exists since uh 2006

488
02:31:06.080 --> 02:31:23.840
now 2026 I know that we we we have continuously uh revised it every six year except for for those two years I I was here too. So I except for those two years of um co

489
02:31:23.840 --> 02:31:38.640
>> but still I'm hoping I I'm really hoping that with this thoroughly planned uh particularly on I I I stress as um

490
02:31:38.640 --> 02:31:56.319
member >> yes >> mention professional development. >> Mhm. M >> um one way or another student's achievement depends on the the the the teachers uh

491
02:31:56.319 --> 02:32:13.520
emotional intelligence and other intelligence relating to his or her teaching capability that graph below 50%. since uh I don't know since 2006 until

492
02:32:13.520 --> 02:32:32.000
now. Hopefully with what you are doing right now the next time that we have some graphical data it shows a little above 50%. >> Right. Yes. Uh I I don't know but um

493
02:32:32.000 --> 02:32:48.640
that had to be the reality of of our situation otherwise we'll keep dei develop developing it keep putting it together another six years >> we come up with other plans but the reality is there opportunity uh and

494
02:32:48.640 --> 02:33:05.120
achievement gap has been the controversial issues even be before I I get on board here. Yes, >> it was one of the ma major questions when I was interviewed. So 8 years down the road is still here.

495
02:33:05.120 --> 02:33:20.560
>> That's right. 20 years down the road, it's still here. So we have a lot of work to do and I think that there has been just a lack of coherence and alignment in the strategies. Um we have seen in past iterations where you know

496
02:33:20.560 --> 02:33:37.680
there was a strategic plan sitting there was a the policy sitting on one shelf and as Dr. Rose said a different strategic plan with a different set of goals over here and then the school committee would go set a set of priorities over there and none of those documents were speaking to each other.

497
02:33:37.680 --> 02:33:53.280
And so really what we tried to do here with this policy is is create that line of coherence. This is the first time in the district's history where the policy and the actual implementation and strategic plan is being connected

498
02:33:53.280 --> 02:34:09.920
through the same person to the superintendent's design which is Dr. Colin Rose. So that's a huge change in the way this was implemented where you had different people sort of running different pieces of the strategy. Now we've got the coherence and alignment

499
02:34:09.920 --> 02:34:25.200
that is really important and of course leadership matters. We've got Superintendent Skipper. We've got Dr. Rose. You got the task force monitoring. You've got now the school committee where you all have weighed in on the policy. We've got Dr. Alkins. We're going to ask for a second school

500
02:34:25.200 --> 02:34:40.960
committee member to also serve on the task force. And again, that just creates more of that alignment. It has to be one set of sheet music for the district that too often the district is moving to multiple pieces of sheet music. It's all

501
02:34:40.960 --> 02:34:56.479
playing wonderful songs, but none of it's coordinated, right? It's just sort of it has to be everyone moving in that same direction. I think we have the shot at this based on the players and the policy and the strategic plan being aligned directly to the policy. >> I would say you have deputies and chiefs

502
02:34:56.479 --> 02:35:13.120
that need to be highly involved obviously and then um I think for improve like I talked about es and flows. I think we're trying to see steady improvement, right? not some miracle but that our these lines don't eb and flow that we are we have a strategy that has continuous improvement

503
02:35:13.120 --> 02:35:29.520
throughout the years that is steady >> I see some of >> and the boots on the ground I I want to reinfor you the school is the unit of change so this policy is really trying to focus more heavily what's happening in our schools with strong leaders

504
02:35:29.520 --> 02:35:45.840
strong teachers and student engagement and joy >> my My last comment before I yield to other members. >> Thank you for having u special paying a special attention to language, you know,

505
02:35:45.840 --> 02:36:01.520
ELLL and students with disability. >> Yes, >> I I I I do appreciate that. Hopefully uh the graph regarding those u category will somehow fluctuate upward. Thank you.

506
02:36:01.520 --> 02:36:20.560
>> Yes, thank you. You want to finish? >> No, I was just going to say just one quick clarification. We we still are using MCCAST, right, as part of the benchmark, but not singularly, right? This is also where like MAP and some of our internal um assessments are really

507
02:36:20.560 --> 02:36:36.960
important and I think that's one of the great things that's come out of um working together with the task force is it's not just one measure, it is multiple measures, right? Just want to like give you a shout out for staying focused on that as well.

508
02:36:36.960 --> 02:36:59.280
>> Yes. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. I want to say thank you team. Excellent job. >> Thank you. >> I think it's really really really good. >> Thank you very much to to the team. As Rafa said, I was able to notice that you

509
02:36:59.280 --> 02:37:26.960
really identified what the problem was. >> You identified the problem. You shared the community and you proposed very solid solutions. So you designate and you created a strategic plan that is connected to the

510
02:37:26.960 --> 02:37:55.120
policies that were to be implemented. >> I also believe that the language that you use in those process is very important as well as we're trying to convey what we are trying to Which indicates that we can we have the ability and the potential to become a

511
02:37:55.120 --> 02:38:30.240
very solid district. There's so many things that are happening. There are so many people doing great things. But sometimes we are not aware of this because they do not align these things. They're not communicated. >> I do believe that the solution is in

512
02:38:30.240 --> 02:38:57.240
being aligned. The solution is in in alignment itself. You also mentioned about via Philsburg that you were going to go directly to schools to be able to monitor the progress that was embedded there.

513
02:39:01.600 --> 02:39:25.240
So that will be critical in terms of determining what is it to be improved and what is that we can improve as well. I do not have any question per se but I would like when you guys look at objective number one in one of the slides

514
02:39:29.200 --> 02:39:48.399
we're talking about alignment and the sustainability of structures in the district itself across the district. to be able to promote and revise accountability >> and supervision as well.

515
02:39:48.399 --> 02:40:08.319
>> And at the same time the policies that are being implemented I believe I heard that there is a team that will be in charge in doing this. Is that correct or will be an assigned team of doing this? Well, it's really up to the superintendent's team, her

516
02:40:08.319 --> 02:40:23.520
leadership team, all of the different deputy super regional superintendent and so forth to carry out the work all the way down to the school leader level and to the teachers on that front line. Our job as the task force is just to monitor

517
02:40:23.520 --> 02:40:39.840
to be critical friends to really just make sure progress is being made do >> and also to provide uh recommendations. I think one of the things we didn't necessarily go into was actually the breadth of expertise that is sitting on the task force and the different sectors

518
02:40:39.840 --> 02:40:57.359
that they represent. Um, and so hearing much of the feedback around the development of the policy, um, I'm just very reflective on the the amount of time that we went back and forth on just the verbiage of every

519
02:40:57.359 --> 02:41:12.800
single section. And so that has come out. Um, but really I think where the task force also has that power is in coming with recommendations that are coming from a range of just different expertises and and then sectors. And so

520
02:41:12.800 --> 02:41:28.319
in that sense um it can be collaborative with the district like there is flexibility within the policy to understand that the district has to be able to figure out how to best implement this. Um and at the same time the task

521
02:41:28.319 --> 02:41:46.000
force like does have a lot of wisdom to to to offer in that regard. >> Yeah. Thank you so much. >> The recommendations that are also listed in the policy. Um I will also just add for goal number one. I'm I'm so glad that you you pointed out goal one uh

522
02:41:46.000 --> 02:42:03.439
Miss Garcia because the task force at one point felt like if we had goal one we didn't need the other goal. So it was really focused on how are we aligning this work and so I think as the school committee as you all think like where should you as a body really be focusing

523
02:42:03.439 --> 02:42:18.960
your energy like if you're really focused on how is goal one flowing from the school committee to the superintendent to the leadership team all the way down to those school letter school leaders. Um that's really where you know we tried to put a lot of energy

524
02:42:18.960 --> 02:42:35.760
into that first goal. Okay. Thank you. And the last thing I will say about that and that was why like my last statement was around for us I I think as a school committee it's going to be critical like when we receive updates on certain

525
02:42:35.760 --> 02:42:53.359
pieces of data and also what we're asking for right and so as we for example enter into the budget season for example this conversation might have been better pri prior to having the budget season right Um, so that's also

526
02:42:53.359 --> 02:43:08.720
something for us to to keep in mind as we're going through the academic year to say, "Wait a second, I would love an update on the state of our diversity of our teachers. I would love an update of MAP of MAP goals, where we are, where

527
02:43:08.720 --> 02:43:24.160
have we grown, where have we not grown, um, what are the factors that have gone into that." So, I think everything is going to depend on us in terms of what we're specifically asking for. and um and then also just the schedule of presentations that we'll have over the

528
02:43:24.160 --> 02:43:43.439
next well the years to come really. >> Great. >> Thank you. >> Thank you so much team. Um you know this OAG policy is described as a north star but it really has an incredible amount of detail um and the thoroughess and and

529
02:43:43.439 --> 02:43:59.920
thoughtfulness uh created by committee. I can't even imagine the amount of time um required to do that um to get to this point. So, so tremendous appreciation for a team of volunteers who are just really unified by their commitment to the students of Boston. So, a lot of

530
02:43:59.920 --> 02:44:16.160
gratitude there. Um I think building off of where member Palano Garcia left off and what you were just discussing, Dr. Alkins, I think we are eager to dig into that goal one and think about how our oversight can move this work forward.

531
02:44:16.160 --> 02:44:31.439
Um, and so a lot of my questions are maybe a little bit more technical about how we can get to that point that Dr. Alkins described in terms of having the policy and the strategic plan really dictate our um cycle of presentations,

532
02:44:31.439 --> 02:44:48.160
our expectations of interim data throughout the year. Um our determination of what you know um what work is for year 1, year two, year three of the plan. Um and so that's kind of where because I think what I might suggest to Dr. Alen's point that it

533
02:44:48.160 --> 02:45:05.840
would be on us to determine the right agenda for that time. Really, I think the plan should have the level of detail where it's really dictating to us what the work is of that time frame so that it's really um like informing the whole year at a glance in terms of what we

534
02:45:05.840 --> 02:45:21.920
need updates with. So I think a question I'm maybe getting to by the end is when will that level of detail be completed to really have this work sequenced because um this OAG policy is has a lot

535
02:45:21.920 --> 02:45:37.359
of longevity to it. You know there is multi-year work here um and the superintendent can't be expected to take up every recommendation immediately next year. Um, but I think it would be fair to the superintendent and to us to know which of those things is being taken up

536
02:45:37.359 --> 02:45:53.520
sooner, later etc. and have that mapped out and then have what the indicators of success would be for each of those um, initiatives. So, um, maybe I'll stop there for as the first question and just ask thoughts on kind of that next level

537
02:45:53.520 --> 02:46:11.520
of specificity. Yeah, I mean I think we have a lot of raw materials right now that we need to sift through, work with chiefs, uh, department heads, um, and leaders of offices to make sure that we have the right sequencing. Um, we're going to be working throughout the spring, uh, into

538
02:46:11.520 --> 02:46:28.479
the summer on that. I think the goal was to bring more detailed goals to you all this summer and then have that level of detail by early fall. um and really work intimately with offices and individuals to make sure that we have uh ambitious

539
02:46:28.479 --> 02:46:44.640
and realistic goals. We know that this is a five-year window. This policy should I mean the there might be refreshes, but the essence and the objectives in this policy should be able to last decades, right? And we can't do

540
02:46:44.640 --> 02:47:00.880
everything all at once. And so, you're right, we need to come back with like the meat on the bones right now. I see these objectives as those bones and kind of asking are we going the right direction and if we are great we'll start building those uh that meet this

541
02:47:00.880 --> 02:47:16.319
spring and summer. >> Yeah and oh sorry please go. >> Well I I would just add to that I think that um you know even when when Dr. Rose was building out the strategic plan with the department uh the cross functional teams. It was not the idea of we're

542
02:47:16.319 --> 02:47:32.000
going to take every single goal and drill down on every single possible goal and objective, but we're going to focus on these three or four key areas. And I think that's how the school committee could could look at this is okay, you've got this full document where what are

543
02:47:32.000 --> 02:47:47.840
the areas that the school committee wants to focus in on. You might decide that teacher diversity, retention and support is one of the areas, right? It could be certainly around the achievement pieces in the academic goals, but is there something in academics? The strategic plan is really

544
02:47:47.840 --> 02:48:05.200
calling out literacy as the focus area, right? So that's one of the focus areas as well as >> quality instruction, >> high quality instruction and high quality student experiences. So I think it's like really using the policy itself as the school committee goes into your retreat to say okay based on what we see

545
02:48:05.200 --> 02:48:22.560
here where do we want to start the process and where do we want to put the focus for this year and sort of deciding that you know year overyear that's how I see that that piece now the specific goals won't be available to the fall but you have the road map here to be able to

546
02:48:22.560 --> 02:48:38.160
go into your next retreat and start to say where the priorities Sir, >> I don't really have much to add other than I think these were some of the conversations that we did have like in in the meetings like one about one the

547
02:48:38.160 --> 02:48:56.000
policy being a balance of being too prescriptive perhaps like um but also what would be the process? So after the cross functional teams are able to meet, how would we as a task force come together and decide like well wait a

548
02:48:56.000 --> 02:49:12.240
second, which goal should we prioritize? How does that get to the school committee? So we I don't think we've actually figured that out yet as a as a group. Um but that's one of those things that like we really do need to nail down. Yeah, the superintendent

549
02:49:12.240 --> 02:49:29.520
leadership is that >> there's multiple places where the work has started. Right. >> Right. And so I think that's going to be one of the sorting exercises that happens with the deputies and the chiefs is to build on the work that is already

550
02:49:29.520 --> 02:49:46.240
in motion and accelerate wherever we can as quickly as possible and get the input from school committee as to in the areas that may not yet have been started, what would be the priorities, right? >> So that we have kind of like a reasonable menu for that year one. Some

551
02:49:46.240 --> 02:50:03.439
things in progress and moving faster, other things beginning, and then as we go through the years, more new things come on to being. It's not unlike, you know, the like the inclusion plan or the long-term facilities where it it's

552
02:50:03.439 --> 02:50:20.399
it's a it's a five-year plan. And so that first year is a lot of the work right now that we're doing, which is the mapping and figuring out, you know, with the the deputies and the the chiefs how they're going to be in the cross functional teams, how they're going to be taking that work into the departments

553
02:50:20.399 --> 02:50:36.399
and making it concrete and actionable. And I think that's what I appreciate is that there is this level of detail and yet northstar. And I think it'll be that collaborative process of sorting with school committee, with the task force,

554
02:50:36.399 --> 02:50:52.479
and with leadership that will get us where we need to be going. >> Yeah. I I think folks that are responsible for implementing need to have a strong voice in how that happens, right? Right. And I think they come back for feedback and you know we we you know the task force gives feedback but we we

555
02:50:52.479 --> 02:51:07.760
need the folks the leaders in in the district have I think the right to take a look at what the policy is and how they best will approach kind of coming up with the answers. I think that's an important distinction that you know the expertise of the of

556
02:51:07.760 --> 02:51:25.120
the task force really lent itself to being very specific with the recommendations with the understanding that when we vote on the policy we're voting at the level of the goals and objectives for the district to consider the recommendations as potential levers to achieve those goals and objectives.

557
02:51:25.120 --> 02:51:42.160
Um I think when thinking about a strategic plan holistically um it should include in-flight work um especially when that work is still going to require a significant lift from staff. And so I guess one of my

558
02:51:42.160 --> 02:51:58.479
questions around the strategic plan um objectives right now is you know during the budget season we really emphasize the priority of inclusion roll out and multilingual learner supports expansion

559
02:51:58.479 --> 02:52:15.439
of dual language etc. Um and right now those aren't specifically named in the strategic plan document they're named in the OAG policy. So just wondering where they live. Is it that they would live as sub initiatives under what's listed

560
02:52:15.439 --> 02:52:31.600
here? Um but I just wanted to make sure that those would be clearly delineated in the strategic plan with work sequenced by year. >> Yeah. I mean I think these objectives are again the uh the schema that we would attach um more specific goals. So if we're talking about like bilingual

561
02:52:31.600 --> 02:52:46.720
programming that would be in like 3.1 when we're talking about pro like programming for students. um the multilingual work um in the classroom will be one in 1.1 when we talk about high quality instruction. So there'll be

562
02:52:46.720 --> 02:53:02.640
more detailed goals in inside of those objectives that would spell that out. It's also making me think that we may need like our next update on strategic planning like some alignment on terms because when I hear the word goals I think of like a metric whereas I think

563
02:53:02.640 --> 02:53:18.960
that when you are saying goals you're talking about like an initiative or a body of work um and so I I think that there may we may need to like gloss just think so that we're all um talking about the same thing. Um I think in

564
02:53:18.960 --> 02:53:34.960
terms of the what's here um what I would say is that like the preamble um of the OAG policy talked about literacy and numeracy but numeracy feels very absent from the rest of the policy. I know that literacy is the foundation of all

565
02:53:34.960 --> 02:53:50.399
subjects and I appreciate the discussion about literacy across the uh curriculum but we also know about the importance of algebra 1 as a gateway um to high school completion. We know that a lot of the um you know new career pathways emphasize

566
02:53:50.399 --> 02:54:06.240
STEM. Um so just thinking about um where that could be called out more um in the next level of work. Um and I would also note that the emphasis on advanced course work in high school I think is a natural emphasis because there are a lot

567
02:54:06.240 --> 02:54:22.640
of designations for advanced coursework in high school AP, early college, CTE, IB, etc. Um but that work is not as easily accessed if there is not advanced coursework from the beginning. Um and I think defining what that is for the

568
02:54:22.640 --> 02:54:38.560
district and making sure that we are um that making sure that there's remediation and acceleration for all of our students is really important. There was the excellence for all pilot that was named um in the bullets that had an end date um which replaced a different

569
02:54:38.560 --> 02:54:53.359
advanced program. um it seems like that work is really at risk when we're looking at budget cuts. And so I would just um encourage us to consider u advanced course work as a K12 initiative and not just a high school initiative.

570
02:54:53.359 --> 02:55:14.479
>> Um and I'll I'll stop there. Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Yeah. So it's me. Yeah. So thinking back that this work has been going on for 20 years um and there was I'm sure as a much

571
02:55:14.479 --> 02:55:29.840
enthusiasm about this work 20 years ago as there was 10 years ago and here we are yet again and I guess my question for me is what will be different this time? >> Yes, I'm so glad you asked that question chair. I can I want to give the

572
02:55:29.840 --> 02:55:47.200
historical context because leadership matters. This is why the superintendent role is so critical to the excess the success of the initiative. The 2006 policy was drafted and then came a new superintendent and she did not see where

573
02:55:47.200 --> 02:56:04.240
she didn't have ownership of that policy. It sat up on a shelf and it was never implemented. So that was 2006. 2016 policy comes along. We have a superintendent who's part of the process writing and drafting of the policy

574
02:56:04.240 --> 02:56:18.720
together with Dr. Rose. I was there on the task force. Christian as chair, you were there as well. And um and so then and we had all the departments providing their guidance and weighing in tons of meetings. It took a full year to draft

575
02:56:18.720 --> 02:56:35.040
that document. When it was done, the same superintendent then started a strategic planning process that was totally separate. And so that strategic plan had an implementation plan and the policy had an implementation plan. So

576
02:56:35.040 --> 02:56:50.800
what happens when a district has two sets of implementation plans? Everyone ignores both. That's what happened. Um and so no one knew what sheet music they were following. So it was like we're not going to follow any of it. And so both documents went up on

577
02:56:50.800 --> 02:57:07.920
a shelf. Um but now we did do a lot of implementation. I will say there was a lot of implementation and work done for the OAG plan but people kept saying what about the strategic plan? Which one am I following? Lots of confusion. Again, lack of alignment and coherence. So this

578
02:57:07.920 --> 02:57:25.840
really is the first time that the OAG policy is being positioned as that north star. So, first comes the policy, then comes the strategic plan. This is where Superintendent Skipper then figures out the how. And then we've got cross functional teams. We have an actual

579
02:57:25.840 --> 02:57:41.680
design. We have a the OAG task force still standing as a monitoring body. So, I think again it's about alignment and coherence. That's what's going to be different. And that the superintendent and their leadership team were really involved in being able to weigh in. So

580
02:57:41.680 --> 02:57:57.120
there's also that sense of ownership which is why it's so important that the policies refreshed every five or so years. A lot of the people who were here back in 2016 are not here anymore. So this new team now has had a chance to

581
02:57:57.120 --> 02:58:13.439
read, to review, to weigh in, to make comments and edits. Um so I do think that sense of ownership is is here and the alignment. >> Yeah. Over the years, we've known that there have been some things that have impeded our progress in terms of this.

582
02:58:13.439 --> 02:58:29.200
One is data and getting data disagregated, really disagregated, which is something I think we've asked for for a decade or more. Um, true accountability, um, being able to name things that we

583
02:58:29.200 --> 02:58:43.600
know are not working, um, and holding people accountable for those things. And to that point, my question is where is the union? >> This the union for years has had um an

584
02:58:43.600 --> 02:59:00.640
issue around um inclusion inclusion done right. So we we need a O a done right strategy because they are critical >> at every single step from who is actually sitting in front of our

585
02:59:00.640 --> 02:59:16.160
students to their own mindset and commitment into this work the belief that this is possible. Um we provide tons of training. Does it is it more than just a checking of the box? where

586
02:59:16.160 --> 02:59:33.279
is the true embodiment about what this this training means and how are we going to see that showing up for our students in this next six years. >> Yeah, two things there. One is that u we were just really excited to have uh Leia

587
02:59:33.279 --> 02:59:49.200
Serena, vice president of the Boston Teachers Union now on the task force. That's a first where we actually have the union represented in a seat and I think it's really important and her voice has just been really powerful to have. Um I think in terms of data the

588
02:59:49.200 --> 03:00:05.600
district has to become more transparent in data. We we ask for data it takes months to get it. there's sort of like let's present it in the best possible light and then you don't have transparency from that very moment

589
03:00:05.600 --> 03:00:22.800
because the data is not good in a lot of these areas and I think that transparency is important I think that that the the community the public at large you know if the data is transparent the community has to be willing to say like having the data is

590
03:00:22.800 --> 03:00:39.520
not a place for attack it's a place for collaboration and partnership it because now we know what we need to all work on together and collectively to make the data better. So I think that the data is really really important. I think um I you know and I see a lot of folks

591
03:00:39.520 --> 03:00:56.319
nodding their heads on the bench. I mean you know you ask for data and you get 50 pages because it's like there's almost like an intent that you're not able to even digest the data. >> Meaningful data is what >> meaningful data is what data is I would love. >> Not just data. >> Yes. Yeah, I think it's it's it's going

592
03:00:56.319 --> 03:01:12.640
to be taking the needing to take the step of it being from data to information. >> I think that's where sometimes we can stumble. >> Um I also think that there's sometimes the data we get back at the state level doesn't lend itself to disagregate in

593
03:01:12.640 --> 03:01:28.880
the way that we need to. And so that's something that our own ODA has been really trying to get at. you know, you will ask the question, you know, how are our African-American students who were born here in Boston doing relative to

594
03:01:28.880 --> 03:01:44.240
other students who may identify as black but not born here. And that's very hard to get at sometimes with the way that things get disagregated. But that is something that the ODA team is committed to and we're trying to figure out. And I

595
03:01:44.240 --> 03:02:00.240
think to Ellie's like point being collaborative about this that this is like there is a problem. How do we know there's a problem? This data has not changed in forever >> anywhere nationally, statewide. It is a

596
03:02:00.240 --> 03:02:17.120
problem. We know that. So let's get together to figure this out so Boston can be the place that all of our kids are served well. Like that is the spirit of this policy. more important it's the intentionality with the steps that we have to take and some of that is going

597
03:02:17.120 --> 03:02:34.960
to mean on our district side and central side doing things differently in order to get at the information in a way that's actionable right >> I would probably say something that I appreciated about uh the conversations

598
03:02:34.960 --> 03:02:53.040
and the processes um is that we've started to name the importance of time bound goals And when we are looking at KPIs um doesn't matter necessarily if you know

599
03:02:53.040 --> 03:03:09.279
you you know you score a touchdown on on a Hail Mary. It's you know what I I mean in in like in one play but it's about the incremental progress and then like that's what we're hoping to see. And so in a year the idea is to not see it'd be

600
03:03:09.279 --> 03:03:26.000
great if you jump five points. whatever it is, but it's about being realistic and saying like, okay, this is a timebound goal. Did we make it? Did we not? And if we didn't, okay, but are we making progress? And I think that adds to the sense of that everybody understands that this is urgent work.

601
03:03:26.000 --> 03:03:46.160
Um, and so um I think that that's something that I've appreciated about the strategic plan as well as the um uh the OAG um policy as well. Just want to thank you all and we look forward to voting on the policy in a

602
03:03:46.160 --> 03:04:02.720
future meeting. >> Thank you very much. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Okay. Our third presentation is the private school applications for two schools. First, the Alpha School, followed by the Douglas Ridley School.

603
03:04:02.720 --> 03:04:19.760
Let's aim to keep the presentations of each of these schools to seven minutes. I'd like to remind our presenters to please speak at a slower pace to assist our interpreters and I want to invite the superintendent to give introductory remarks. >> Uh wonderful. Thank you, chair. So, um

604
03:04:19.760 --> 03:04:34.479
in a very few moments, I'll be turning the meeting over to Dr. Anne Clark who's our BPS development officer for strategy, partnerships, and innovation. Uh this will be a presentation for two private school applications, the Alpha School and the Douglas Ridley School.

605
03:04:34.479 --> 03:04:52.000
The Alpha School Boston uh which will be going first is an independent non sectarian K to8 school focused on personalized learning. The Douglas uh and then I'll come back and explain but the Douglas Ridley School is a K2 through six school uh that is modeled

606
03:04:52.000 --> 03:05:09.279
after the Reio Amelia uh approach to education which is rooted in equity and anti-racist practice. Most importantly to ground us, Dr. Clark's going to explain the process for opening a nonBPS school in Boston,

607
03:05:09.279 --> 03:05:24.319
including the role of the district and the required approval of this committee. You're also going to hear from the administration of both schools. Some of you may be new to the process. We have a role in BPS

608
03:05:24.319 --> 03:05:40.960
um which is strictly administrative. In this case, the district's responsible for ensuring all private schools seeking approval meet the requirements of Massachusetts general law and for making recommendations to me and the Boston

609
03:05:40.960 --> 03:05:56.720
school committee. The committee is responsible for approval of any private school wishing to operate within the city of Boston. So, at this point, I'll talk turn it over to Dr. Clark for the presentation uh and then we'll entertain questions as

610
03:05:56.720 --> 03:06:12.319
we go through. Dr. Clark. >> Thank you, Superintendent. Good evening, Madame Chair, madame vice chair, and members of the school committee. Um, as I was introduced, my name is Anne Clark, and I am serving in the role of overseeing the private

611
03:06:12.319 --> 03:06:29.279
school application process this school year, and I'm pleased to present the findings of our internal review team this evening. As you know, the Boston School Committee is responsible for approving any private school wishing to

612
03:06:29.279 --> 03:06:46.479
operate within Boston City limits under Massachusetts General Law, Chapter 76, Section 1. In 2011, the Boston School Committee established a formal private school policy, creating an internal

613
03:06:46.479 --> 03:07:01.760
review team process to evaluate applications from any interested parties and assess whether a proposed private school meets the standards set out by Massachusetts law.

614
03:07:01.760 --> 03:07:18.240
That internal review team evaluates applicants against a defined set of criteria covering everything from curriculum and education materials to staff qualifications to student records and financial

615
03:07:18.240 --> 03:07:47.160
solveny. This slide shows some of those criteria and I'll give you a moment to read. and this slide shows the rest of the criteria. I'll give you another moment to read.

616
03:07:58.080 --> 03:08:15.840
The review itself follows a fivestep process. Application review, site visit, leadership interview, evaluation, and a formal recommendation to the superintendent and school committee. For the two schools before you today,

617
03:08:15.840 --> 03:08:31.359
the Alpha School and the Douglas Ridley School, all steps in that process are now complete. Both applications were received earlier this year. Site visits were conducted in March and recommendations have been submitted to

618
03:08:31.359 --> 03:08:48.800
the superintendent. The internal internal review team found that both schools met the criteria outlined by the Boston school committee policy. Tonight, you will hear from the school leaders at each of these schools who will give an overview of their proposal.

619
03:08:48.800 --> 03:09:25.120
On June 10th, you will vote on whether to approve these private schools applications to open. I'll now pass the presentation to the team from Alpha School. Good evening, superintendent, chair,

620
03:09:25.120 --> 03:09:41.680
chair, board. Um, I'm Dr. Tasha Arnold. I'm the head of Alpha Schools, and it's with great privilege that I'm here before you today to share what it is that our our school is about. Um, I originally started as a a school teacher in Chicago and Milwaukee public

621
03:09:41.680 --> 03:09:57.920
schools. I've had the privilege to work around the world in Europe, the UAE, and most recently starting and opening schools in Mumbai, India. And with me today, I have my colleague JC Fisher Fischer. >> Hi. Thank you all for having us here. I also want to thank Dr. Clark and her

622
03:09:57.920 --> 03:10:14.000
team and uh our council from Fully Hoag for helping us understand what it means to be a part of the community here in Boston and prepare an application that hopefully meets the standards that that we seek to meet here. So, Alpha School, as we've already

623
03:10:14.000 --> 03:10:30.560
touched upon, is a mastery focused school. So, we have it's it's a it's a typical school with regards to students come into the school for a full school day. Our mission is to ensure students achieve academic mastery while also

624
03:10:30.560 --> 03:10:47.760
developing cognitive, social, and personal competencies needed for success in school and then also postchool life. Our standards align academics with student with teacher support. So our core frameworks are completely aligned with

625
03:10:47.760 --> 03:11:02.960
the state of Massachusetts curriculum frameworks across all subject areas. And our instructional features include adaptive mastery based pathways. We use both formative and summitive assessments. We have teacher coaching and intervention models that are

626
03:11:02.960 --> 03:11:19.600
developed. We also have a reading specialist that works with our students for pull out sessions. And of course, we use benchmark assessments including MAP assessments as well as our own internal um unit and grade level assessments.

627
03:11:19.600 --> 03:11:33.680
And so you'll see at the bottom it says students progress based on demonstr demonstrated mastery rather than seat time alone. Here's a typical school day. Um we know that um well we've implemented a drop

628
03:11:33.680 --> 03:11:50.800
off time slot so from 8:15 to 8:45 uh you know to in order to allow for um um an influx of any sort of traffic. We have a morning launch where students come and it's about um mindfulness getting yourself ready and excited for

629
03:11:50.800 --> 03:12:05.439
the school day. Then we have our core academic blocks with some breaks built in there. lunchtime we um will we hope to walk to a park which is a 5-minute walk from the school for outdoor play and then we have our interdisciplinary

630
03:12:05.439 --> 03:12:22.080
workshops in the afternoon um and then we have closing and of course pickup. The calendar year is similar to um the public school system in regards to it achieving 180 days and um we also have professional development days allocated

631
03:12:22.080 --> 03:12:38.160
for our teachers. So in addition to having core mastery in academics, we are also focused on life skills. So life skills include for example teamwork, storytelling, entrepreneurship, financial literacy, um

632
03:12:38.160 --> 03:12:54.560
relationship building and socialization and of course the concept of grit and perseverance. So our afternoon workshops um include that core academic as I mentioned interdisciplinary crossplanning subjects. So, for example, um our students might be working on

633
03:12:54.560 --> 03:13:10.640
carpentry, but they're applying geometric principles from geometry, history, knowing that the wood, you know, where did the wood come from, and then also giving presentations to larger groups. Um, and we're working on developing those skills through something that's of interest to our

634
03:13:10.640 --> 03:13:26.000
students. >> Our site is already ready. We have the certificate of occupancy and inspection from the city. Uh we've passed all fire, alarm, sprinkler, tests, etc. We're also located right across the street from

635
03:13:26.000 --> 03:13:42.479
Mass General Brighgam so we can have a place to receive if we ever have any medical emergencies and we're very close to fire engine number four. Um so that we have close proximity to the appropriate emergency services as well. Um you'll notice we're on the fourth floor of a building. The second and

636
03:13:42.479 --> 03:13:58.239
third floor are operated by a Monasuri school. Um, and previously this floor was used for educational use as well. So, we're maintaining the same use of the site. We have four classrooms, commons area, indoor play area, support space for our one-on-one meetings

637
03:13:58.239 --> 03:14:12.479
between our teachers and students for additional support, as well as staff, admin, and your classic, you know, plenty of bathrooms, eating area, etc. Um, lots of security. We have controlled building access on the way up, um, and separation from other tenants to ensure

638
03:14:12.479 --> 03:14:30.239
children's safety. So we have a we have strong interest in the school. Um when we initially were starting conversations with families, we had 252, this was back in February um towards the end of February, we had 252

639
03:14:30.239 --> 03:14:46.399
families interested um 20 parents u prepaid deposits should we be approved um by the committee. And um in year one we're looking to launch with 25 students and then year two the capacity would be at 50. So that's um our our projections

640
03:14:46.399 --> 03:15:04.479
for year two. Um our model is really focused on highly personalized um instruction with our students. So our um ratios are quite low. 1:6 is our um teacher to student ratio in year 1. And then as we grow to 50 it will be 1 to um

641
03:15:04.479 --> 03:15:19.920
8. So in year one, we would have a headteer, um two additional teachers, a reading specialist, a role that we call dean of parents. So that's helping parents understand our model and working them through. And then I operate as the head of school from um a regional

642
03:15:19.920 --> 03:15:38.640
position. Um so I will also be here in Boston as much as possible. you know, part of one of the privileges of starting a school is really being able to integrate into a community and um Boston's such a wonderful community

643
03:15:38.640 --> 03:15:56.000
with regards to um you know, inclusion and diversity. And so for us as a school, we're really looking forward to be a part of that. One of the things that we think we can bring to the community is offering um workshops for AI instruction for students where our

644
03:15:56.000 --> 03:16:12.239
our students are already um at our other campuses are already thinking about um hosting a hackathon for all students in the area to participate in. So, we really hope to be um a piece to add to the community and um that's something that we're really excited about is

645
03:16:12.239 --> 03:16:28.000
building those opportunities in a way that makes sense and also that excite you know students and teachers alike. So, I think we just made it in our time slot, but we we would we would love to, you know, um answer any questions you

646
03:16:28.000 --> 03:16:46.560
may have or um continue the conversation. Thank you. I'll open it up to the committee for questions. >> I have one question. How are the students and families selected? What is the process? >> Yeah. So students um parents express

647
03:16:46.560 --> 03:17:02.000
interest and then so they attend an information session. They learn about the school. Is this a good fit for my family, for my child in particular? Then the child comes for the shadow day. Um they they complete a MAP assessment, but we are we don't accept students based on

648
03:17:02.000 --> 03:17:19.120
their scores. That's that's not how we accept students. What we're looking for are things such as coachability, interest, an ability to engage with our model. That's our our standard for assessment. We also do a family interview because we we're looking for alignment as um you know, from our

649
03:17:19.120 --> 03:17:38.080
families. And then from there, um that's that's really how we decide our acceptance. I also do a family interview um with the parents as we build this community. >> Yeah. the number of uh sorry the number of uh

650
03:17:38.080 --> 03:17:54.160
parents who have uh expressed their interest what's the breakdown in terms of diversity >> yeah we've had um I don't have the exact breakdown but we've had all sorts of um interest from all across the levels and

651
03:17:54.160 --> 03:18:11.840
so you know the the nice thing I would say about our model is it doesn't matter if you know you are the student who always raises their hand, if you're an ELLL student, if you are a neurodeiverse student, you know, we're able to meet you right where you're at um for your

652
03:18:11.840 --> 03:18:27.359
own specific academic needs. And so what we notice is parents um see that. So it it attracts all sorts of interest from across you know the whole scope and sequence. Are you equipped to uh

653
03:18:27.359 --> 03:18:44.560
uh uh accommodate a student with disability? >> Yeah. So, you know, we have um we look at our student if a student comes to us with a 504 plan depending on what those accommodations are. Yes, we can be able to provide that. But if a student um ser

654
03:18:44.560 --> 03:18:59.359
certain services we don't provide during the school day. So if a student um needs uh speech pathology, we're partnered with um experts in that area, clinical psychologists um that we're able to recommend and also help build those

655
03:18:59.359 --> 03:19:16.319
relationships with our families. So um our program a lot of accommodations that students receive for dyslexia, disgraphia, dcalculia, um extra time is already built in. So you're working at your own pace. So, if you need 50% extra time, well, all

656
03:19:16.319 --> 03:19:32.319
students actually get that. Um, if we need to adjust font size or you need movement breaks, that's that's built into the system. So, the accommodations that we give neurodeiverse students, actually, all of our students are receiving. And so, we see that that's um

657
03:19:32.319 --> 03:19:47.439
that's been quite successful for many students. Um but yes, some of those occupational therapy um supports that would take place outside of school, but we would be monitoring that from their IEP forms um if it's a 504 plan,

658
03:19:47.439 --> 03:20:03.439
whatever it might be. Um we're working with the families to make sure that students are receiving those support outside of school as well. And one of our next steps were we to receive your approval is we have an initial list. We're doing procurement for the right contractors for special education needs

659
03:20:03.439 --> 03:20:19.040
and for mental health services that we don't provide during the school day to ensure children have access to them. So if we were to receive approval, we will finalize and formalize those agreements with the appropriate local contractors. >> Yeah. See, >> just one last question out of curiosity.

660
03:20:19.040 --> 03:20:35.200
What's the uh annual tuition? Our initial tuition planned is 65,000 a year. >> 65,000 a year per student. >> Correct. >> Thank you. >> We do we are building out uh so the founding family members for the first

661
03:20:35.200 --> 03:20:51.439
year it's 10,000 um um discount per year. So 55,000 >> um as a national movement we are bu we're working towards scholarships. We want to be able to provide this opportunity. you know, our we we want to

662
03:20:51.439 --> 03:21:06.800
bring this to a billion students in 10 years, which I know sounds quite lofty. Um, but we do want to provide this opportunity to multiple students and so we are working towards building a scholarship program as a national push. >> Thank you.

663
03:21:06.800 --> 03:21:26.640
>> Yeah. >> Thank you for Thank you, Madame Chair. Thank you for the presentation. Uh it's interesting the the school process the curriculum because uh they putting the the skill the

664
03:21:26.640 --> 03:21:42.560
student is very important. My question is um about the scholar scholarship because some family maybe is interesting but don't have lot of money. I don't

665
03:21:42.560 --> 03:21:59.200
know if you you have financial or complete completely um scholarship for the family. We're working towards that. So, we are um we we've secured um we're starting to secure funds for that. We

666
03:21:59.200 --> 03:22:15.120
really want to be able to provide scholarships. It's not probably going to happen in year one. Um year two, more of a likely probability. Year three, we think we'll be able to be providing scholarships. And that outreach would be directly within within the community as

667
03:22:15.120 --> 03:22:30.319
well. Um, you know, we want we want to, as we said, we want to integrate into the community. So, we want to provide opportunities for students who can't pay that tuition fee. Yes, absolutely. >> Thank you so much. >> Yeah. Good.

668
03:22:30.319 --> 03:22:46.239
>> Could you speak a little bit more just about how uh your funding is sort of managed like either through a board or and just that just that structure and I mean just for full transparency we've recently had a school in the district a

669
03:22:46.239 --> 03:23:03.120
private school that had to close multiple locations. not going to go into details like about it, but you know, at the end of the day, it impacts our students and and so like we want to know that another a private

670
03:23:03.120 --> 03:23:20.160
school that will be in the district, you know, is is is managed properly. >> Of course. Go ahead. Okay. >> Um so we're part of an over 30 school network nationally right now and we're managed centrally. Um, we have a centralized professional financial

671
03:23:20.160 --> 03:23:36.800
management team. Um, we're privately held. We have a strong corporate governance with a clear board oversight that handles all of the Alpha School program. Um, we have a fairly capital light model, which means rather than buying real estate and running the risk of being overleveraged and collapsing

672
03:23:36.800 --> 03:23:52.399
under the weight of a balance sheet, right, we're keeping that bunny and putting it back into our schools. Um, and then on top of that, we have over a billion dollars committed from our founder to make sure that this happens and that we go through the next five to 10 years because our mission and goal is

673
03:23:52.399 --> 03:24:07.040
to truly take this model, prove it works, and then expand it across the oh, my mic went and then expand it across the globe um to everybody, right? Over a billion children is literally the goal that we espouse every time somebody asks and we talk about it. And it's a very

674
03:24:07.040 --> 03:24:23.439
missiondriven organization. Thank you. And I think this is not necessarily a question for y'all, but just a question for also the district of what data do we have particularly around students um either returning to the

675
03:24:23.439 --> 03:24:40.319
district if perhaps they're they go elsewhere and they're not the right fit or however else they make their way back to the district. Do we just have data around that? Um >> yeah so we are the landing pad for

676
03:24:40.319 --> 03:24:56.479
all students >> right for sure >> and um that means when a student is counseledled out or doesn't fit um either the model from inception or the experience it is BPS that is here every step of the way for those students. Mhm.

677
03:24:56.479 --> 03:25:13.200
>> Um and so I think you can understand why for us >> um you know when a a new entity comes into being uh for us it's a question of who are you really serving and um are you serving the average student in in

678
03:25:13.200 --> 03:25:30.080
Boston? Um I was just curious I I've looked at your website how what's your total enrollment across all your sites? Yeah. So, um around 500 students that's as of now. So, our Austin campus opened 12 years ago. I guess you could say 12

679
03:25:30.080 --> 03:25:47.680
years ago and then um two years ago we really launched uh a second location in Miami. And then this past year, we've had um greater expansion. We we have lots of demand across the country, but at the same time, we're not just opening up anywhere and everywhere. Uh it's been

680
03:25:47.680 --> 03:26:02.560
it's been through the demand of parents and us meeting with parents having many conversations right um you know our parents triing the model um you know it's not just you have an info session and oh let's open up a school it very much has been you know this is what they

681
03:26:02.560 --> 03:26:19.600
want and so that's they they brought us to Boston essentially if you will and so um yeah so it's it's it's expanding but we're also being very intentional with how we scale >> right so sorry I just missed Who who brought you to Boston? >> The parents that are that are interested

682
03:26:19.600 --> 03:26:34.399
in in joining, they they said, "Please come to Boston." That was >> Oh, I see. Okay. >> Yeah, that was >> Yeah, cuz I was just wondering cuz like when I looked right like I didn't see any demographic data of the kids enrolled in any of the sites. I didn't see anything about students with IEPs,

683
03:26:34.399 --> 03:26:51.359
like what the percent was enrolled or multilingual learners. So, is like do you have that data for your >> Yeah, I it's pretty tradition. know about 20% are neur on the neurodeiverse scale um within the within the school. We don't we don't have that data published. Um but yeah, I'm I'm happy to

684
03:26:51.359 --> 03:27:07.600
share about that. It's the diversity reflects the cities that they're in um pretty pretty accurately I would say. So you know our campus in Georgia for example is reflecting that diversity of that city. Um same you know in New York as well. So there's it's reflective of

685
03:27:07.600 --> 03:27:23.200
the community largely of course you know within within a little bit um depending on the city. >> Gotcha. Yeah. I think that would just be really good data for the committee to have >> right uh to Dr. Alan's point just you know sort of um and then just like

686
03:27:23.200 --> 03:27:37.920
another question can you just speak a little bit about like are your teachers certified? Like do you are your administrators certified? Like how does that work in the model? Yeah. So, most of our teachers and that's about 65% come from

687
03:27:37.920 --> 03:27:53.520
traditional teaching backgrounds. Um, all educators have degrees. Um, you know, they would have had to have worked extensively with children in some sort of capacity. That could have been um a sports coach. It, you know, it could be um a guide of some sort, thinking like

688
03:27:53.520 --> 03:28:09.680
scouts. Um, and uh yeah, the senior leadership um tends to be um you know, from education backgrounds. um for myself you know I have a doctorate in education um you know all of our other deans of parents many of them I want to

689
03:28:09.680 --> 03:28:27.359
say 80 75 80% all have doctorate degrees um so there's you know a large investment in education background but we also you know as we have these life skills workshops um you know people that have strong coaching backgrounds tend to be really good fit for our model um so

690
03:28:27.359 --> 03:28:44.479
we have you know um those that have coached at the college level for example um and also quite a few professors as well have been working with our students. So, it's a wide range, but many have that traditional teaching um background and are getting, you know, um

691
03:28:44.479 --> 03:28:59.439
teachers or those that aren't teachers are also pursuing that as well as part of their PD development. >> Okay, great. I'll you could be on a roll for a while. So, >> no, those my next question is actually

692
03:28:59.439 --> 03:29:15.439
about just getting some of the the basic demographic data of where your school currently is like across the across the country. >> Um cuz I'm I'm not as familiar with like who specifically like you serve or just like are you seeing that you're you're

693
03:29:15.439 --> 03:29:30.960
you're growing in particular demographics versus others? Um and then just like echoing um superintendent and just like support for multilingual learn just some digging in a little bit more like to to that for for for me.

694
03:29:30.960 --> 03:29:46.640
>> Yeah. Cuz your sites are very much oriented in the major cities, right? Or the more diverse locations within those states. So that's why I think the data would be important. It would also be important to see again to Dr. Alkins point, but like what your retention data

695
03:29:46.640 --> 03:30:02.239
looks like, >> you know, like when students start, how long do they go, do they finish, right? Because that's going to be of concern for us, you know, we we um when we get students back that have gone through some place and not um had a positive

696
03:30:02.239 --> 03:30:19.279
experience, then we're picking pieces up. And so that's why for us, we want to make sure that kids are going to be cared for, right? If they're in your model, >> um that would that would be important. So this past year I said around 500 students. We only have 6% turnover and

697
03:30:19.279 --> 03:30:35.760
when I've broken that down most of that is parents moving to another city where they don't have an alpha school. Um and so they actually some of them opt for additional private school options. We also have something called alpha anywhere which is a homeschool model. So

698
03:30:35.760 --> 03:30:51.279
we see parents selecting that where we do see turnover. And I just want to, you know, students that are coming to us tend to not be coming from the public schools. They're coming from other private school competitors. Um, uh, so, you know, that's just kind of a caveat

699
03:30:51.279 --> 03:31:07.120
there, but, um, sorry, I lost my train of thought there. >> That's cool. >> I normally am in bed at this time. >> No, it's all good. Yeah, I was just also the the other thing was just noticing some of the places, but it's also some of the places where vouchers tend to be

700
03:31:07.120 --> 03:31:23.920
used. And so I was just kind of curious like how much of the business model is that you know are most of your clients private paying or are you seeing you know such as in Arizona more of a voucher trend? >> We do have um a percentage of our students I want to say it's 25 but I

701
03:31:23.920 --> 03:31:39.279
need to check that um that are using the voucher system in Arizona. So yes, to your point, that is that is correct. But our other cities where we don't have the vouchers approved, it is primarily private school students um that are that

702
03:31:39.279 --> 03:32:00.160
are coming over to our school. Yeah. >> Oh, the thing I was going to say about turnover, that's it. Um where we do see a shift is at the high school level. Um, so some students they want, you know, our schools are very small, so they want, you know, to be the the

703
03:32:00.160 --> 03:32:17.760
quarterback on the team or they want a prom with 300 students or other reasons as well, be part of a large band, for example. Um, so we do see students switching at that point. But what's interesting, at least I find what's interesting, students that have left us,

704
03:32:17.760 --> 03:32:32.880
a little bit more than 50% actually come back after doing a year um in high school at their at at at a at an another option of a school. So I would say that is the that is a pinch point that 8th to 9th grade there is a change,

705
03:32:32.880 --> 03:32:49.520
but those students are also often opting to then go to private schools. Yeah, >> thank you for the presentation and I'm one of the new members for whom this is the first season of approving um private school applications. So you'll have to forgive that some of my questions are

706
03:32:49.520 --> 03:33:06.080
related to alpha schools and others are more to further understand the process. So sorry that you guys are the victims but um the un it's a little uncomfortable I think I'll just speak in I statements to hold a responsibility to approve a

707
03:33:06.080 --> 03:33:21.040
school for which we will have no oversight or future updates. So I think we sit with that as we you know are deeply invested in the the success of students across the city regardless of the schools that they go to and understanding that we have not had any

708
03:33:21.040 --> 03:33:37.600
real vantage point into the school um and carry this responsibility. So I think it's just it's a it's an odd um it's an odd responsibility that Desi has assigned to individual school committees to carry carry this for a few reasons.

709
03:33:37.600 --> 03:33:53.520
One is um Dr. Clark, you walked through some of the things that BPS has put in place to make a process to review applications. Um, that sound like it probably involves a significant amount of time from you or someone on the BPS

710
03:33:53.520 --> 03:34:10.720
team. Um, so we have more information I imagine than some other districts that just might not be as big or have the capacity to invest in research because is my understanding that this review process is a BPS review process, not a required DESIE process. So, I just think

711
03:34:10.720 --> 03:34:26.319
it is important to understand that the state has tasked districts with approving independent schools with very little guidance around how we're supposed to determine whether they meet the requirements. So, just wanted to

712
03:34:26.319 --> 03:34:43.279
mention that. Um I think also the the list of criteria from um is challenging as DESIE has very strict criteria for public schools around a

713
03:34:43.279 --> 03:34:58.160
variety of things from teacher certification and lenture to literal number of hours that students are required to be in school. Um, we've you've had to sit through our mask vote earlier today and I know you all aren't

714
03:34:58.160 --> 03:35:14.160
applying to be a high school in this case, but a lot of what has been criticized by BPS is, oh, I I can't believe we're having students do admentum to make up credits. You know, where is the rigor? I can't believe we're thinking about making exceptions

715
03:35:14.160 --> 03:35:32.000
for for students to take fewer than 24 classes. Um, and then to sit with someone paying $65,000 to do two hours of academic instruction is just it it's really surreal. Then it's on us to then make that decision. Um, so I would love

716
03:35:32.000 --> 03:35:47.359
to hear a little bit about the two hours of academics um, and how that gets students to to mastery. Um, I would say also maybe even for the public to understand that there are different ways to arrive at at mastery and some of the

717
03:35:47.359 --> 03:36:05.120
things that maybe folks are stressing um in terms of what define rigor um when we're looking at different populations, we might have different expectations for how to get there. So I would love to to hear um about how that works. >> Yeah. So um the two hours I would say

718
03:36:05.120 --> 03:36:22.399
that's core content learning, right? So, um, you know, think of learning your math facts. We have an app called Fast Math. So, you literally are, it's the automaticity of knowing your facts. And you mentioned earlier, you know, that pinch point of algebra really being um,

719
03:36:22.399 --> 03:36:36.880
you know, critical in your success, especially in high school. So, we the whole idea is you have to have mastery in certain subjects before you can kind of move on. So we require our students to have 90% mastery at a subject level

720
03:36:36.880 --> 03:36:54.720
um per per subject um in order to move on advance to the next level of of of academics. Now that's measured through MAP three times a year as I mentioned. We also have our own internal assessments as well. So that takes place in the morning. Now it's it's you know

721
03:36:54.720 --> 03:37:10.640
our teachers get um this is what my students are working on that day. They're quality checking. They're deciding when kids are taking a unit or a subject matter test. Um, you know, a child has a question, the teacher is there to to to jump in and to, you know,

722
03:37:10.640 --> 03:37:27.120
help them use strategies in order to um, you know, master that learning. And then it's it's not that that's the only learning that occurs. I would say in addition to that, our teachers are building these life skills workshops which are completely interdisciplinary.

723
03:37:27.120 --> 03:37:44.399
So you are having these cross subjects. So it's not just applying your math understanding in a times test right it's now that application of understanding um you know how do I how do I measure how do I find the area how do I you know

724
03:37:44.399 --> 03:37:59.439
in a real context that they might experience and then also develop life skills that maybe encourage them to pursue a career in the future. So I used the example before about carpentry. So, you know, that that has inspired one of our students to really dive deep into

725
03:37:59.439 --> 03:38:16.160
wood carving and and you know, it's not just he's showed mastery in the content area of math and now he's been able to apply it. So, the afternoon is is very much an education. It's not just, you know, playtime. It is it's woven. It's very specific. Um when it comes to the

726
03:38:16.160 --> 03:38:31.760
number of hours, yes, our school day is aligned to um actually exceed what you know is is being done in the in the state of Massachusetts. Um we also, you know, open our school up in the afternoons if kids want to stay after school. We have after school um

727
03:38:31.760 --> 03:38:47.920
academics. Um we do Olympiads, we do all sorts of um you know, robotics, all sorts of STEM focused uh activities as well. Um, so I think I think part of it is there's a misconception that it's just, you know, two hours and then in

728
03:38:47.920 --> 03:39:04.239
the afternoon we play. That's really not what's happening. It's, you know, when I was an educator, I I tried to really provide opportunities where my kids could apply the learning. Um, and I know myself, that's how I actually knew I learned it. And so that's really what kind of guides our afternoon focus. Does

729
03:39:04.239 --> 03:39:20.239
that does that answer what you're >> very helpful? Yeah. Um, I think it's, you know, incumbent on us too as a as a school district to pay attention to what parents are asking for so that we remain competitive in an environment with declining enrollment in the city. Um,

730
03:39:20.239 --> 03:39:36.239
you talked about, I mean, it's a it's a modest enrollment right now, but you've also named wanting to serve a billion students, which I imagine when you're ready to do that, you'll be coming back to Boston to seek to expand or open a high school or do something else. So, I think it is important that we understand

731
03:39:36.239 --> 03:39:52.560
how we can um be competitive in this in this market to remind families that we're always here to serve students. So, I would just be curious when you talk about families asking you to come to Boston, what is the value proposition or

732
03:39:52.560 --> 03:40:08.319
the element of your school specifically that they define that they're looking for that they don't feel like they could um find in the existing like plethora of independent schools, faith-based schools, parochial schools, charter schools, public schools. Now, um

733
03:40:08.319 --> 03:40:23.920
especially hearing that you all use the Massachusetts grade level frameworks, you give the same assessment that we do. um have the same school day 180 school days. There's a lot of similarity to a typical school day. So what is the the

734
03:40:23.920 --> 03:40:40.960
specific element that is the distinguishing factor? So our our program that we use is called time back. And so a lot of our parents have been spending eye watering amounts in tutoring after school. Um the idea is

735
03:40:40.960 --> 03:40:57.279
our students are achieving mastery and they're not having to do homework after school. And um the feedback that I get by and large is I'm giving you're giving my child their childhood back. They're now able to stay at soccer practice an extra 15 minutes, not hurry up, pack up

736
03:40:57.279 --> 03:41:14.319
your stuff, and run home to have to go do your homework. That's one of the major um one of the benefits that parents are highlighting. And also um just a love for school. You know, our you know, I've heard this talked about a lot today, right? Like kids enjoying school. That's our number one commitment

737
03:41:14.319 --> 03:41:29.840
is that kids love school. We spend a lot of time coaching our children. Um our teachers have meetings with our kids onetoone, multiple times a week. Um and so they and it's not just about academic coaching or life skill coaching or what

738
03:41:29.840 --> 03:41:46.160
are your aspirations or any key guy workshop. It's about knowing, you know, who their cousin is, who's, you know, where where are you spending your time on the weekends. So, I think it's it's the sense of belonging that kids feel at school contributes to the happiness. Um,

739
03:41:46.160 --> 03:42:03.520
so I think giving families time back um not having to focus on extra work when we're able to do that in the school day is a huge value proposition for our parents. Um, so it's it's it's it is it is different. Um, and then you know,

740
03:42:03.520 --> 03:42:19.200
we wouldn't have standardized tests for the most part, but except for the fact that people wouldn't believe what we're doing, right? We need to show this is the data. They're not just coming in and for 2 hours and, you know, yes, we think they're learning. There is, you know, data to show that our students are

741
03:42:19.200 --> 03:42:36.640
growing. And it's, you know, it's been really powerful for me to see how our program has worked in Brownsville, for example, in Texas where the students are, you know, bottom 3 to 7% um in the country. Um I I think the second poorest

742
03:42:36.640 --> 03:42:53.840
um you know, uh area in the country and to see that model be implemented and the success that those students have had has been for me has been really inspiring as an educator. And so I think that it's it's something that can be applied in in many areas and I hope we would love to

743
03:42:53.840 --> 03:43:10.479
partner you know I mean it's a privilege to be here in Boston. I mean think of the educational institutions here in the history even of you know BPS in and of itself. So we're we're happy to to work with provide you know trainings or people that are curious learn about the

744
03:43:10.479 --> 03:43:25.120
model. Um, you know, we've had schools approach us that they're like, "Hey, can we do some trials?" And and we are doing that with some schools around the country, some public schools. Um, so, you know, we're we're happy to explore that as well.

745
03:43:25.120 --> 03:43:42.160
>> I'd also say, oh, sorry. Operationally, because of our size and resources, we have a lot of flexibility to serve our families, right? So, children can come in early, they can stay late, we have the right afterchool programs that are very easy for them to access. And even to the point that in Austin, I think it

746
03:43:42.160 --> 03:43:58.479
was last year, you'll correct me, the students wanted to spend more time in school. So, we reopened the school during the summer so they could come back in because they wanted to engage in the core learning apps and then have meetings with each other that were semi like self-organized and led to continue those life skills workshops and

747
03:43:58.479 --> 03:44:14.720
learnings and things that they had just finished doing that they didn't really want to be done yet. Uh, and so they wanted to spend multiple days a week just coming back to school like they had for most of the year, which again, like operationally it's kind of nice to have that flexibility. Like that's my role, right? I'm I'm not a teacher. I I run

748
03:44:14.720 --> 03:44:30.720
our operations nationally. Uh, and so to be able to do that at these different schools and provide that level of opportunity, that's another thing that I think sets us apart. >> Yeah. >> And and can we go do Dr. All where was the place that you mentioned that students were in the bottom 3 to 7%

749
03:44:30.720 --> 03:44:45.920
there? Texas >> and they're your stu like so you accepted students who were in like the 3 to 7 percentile for MAP. >> Yeah. >> Okay. >> And they worked with us. Um we're now in year two. Um so there's and those

750
03:44:45.920 --> 03:45:02.800
students were full tuition students. >> So the tuition there is much lower. Um yes. So they um they will be using in the future their their vouchers. But yeah, so for so we have alpha schools. I guess I I should say that that school is under the umbrella of ALPA, so they use

751
03:45:02.800 --> 03:45:16.960
the two-hour learning. So, it's a slightly different um model with regards to the tuition pricing, but yes, it's the same it's the same format, the same program. >> Okay. Um I I'm at the end of my time. I

752
03:45:16.960 --> 03:45:33.680
think I would just consider um I know a billion dollars um is a lot of money and I think it would be a powerful statement of access to figure out how immediately opportunities could be made um to make

753
03:45:33.680 --> 03:45:48.720
the tuition more affordable. It it's difficult to hear that kind of financial backing and and hear that there's no avenue at this time for for financial support. So I would that would be my last uh recommendation. >> Yeah. No, we totally agree. You know,

754
03:45:48.720 --> 03:46:05.359
we've applied for voucher status in we've been denied in eight states and the only state that approved us currently is um Arizona. So we are continuing that work. And with regards to scholarships in particular, we are triing that at some of our campuses. It's just not going to be in Boston for

755
03:46:05.359 --> 03:46:23.520
next year. Um so this is it's something that we're building up. We're reaching out um and and building this fund. We want to be able to do that. And as the tech price comes down over time, it will make our schools more affordable to for for us to offer even more scholarships.

756
03:46:23.520 --> 03:46:40.000
>> Yeah. >> So just just one scholarship for one out of 25 and finding the 65k to recoup would be my recommendation. We're not a voucher state. >> Right. Exactly. Yeah. >> More questions.

757
03:46:40.000 --> 03:46:55.680
>> I do too. Yeah. So I have >> I mean I know where Yeah. >> Yeah. >> So I have a pointed question. Um >> because I find myself really interested in your financial model. >> Um

758
03:46:55.680 --> 03:47:11.760
so you guys are a forprofit, correct? >> Currently, yes. >> Okay. And so what is the I know you have the billion dollar backing, but what is your actual what is the net value of the of your for-profit company?

759
03:47:11.760 --> 03:47:26.160
>> I'll I'll turn that over to my operations guy because my numbers would be >> is it is it by franchise or is it one entire >> It's one company. >> It's one company. >> Yeah. >> We're all privately held by one owner of

760
03:47:26.160 --> 03:47:41.760
a school. It's not like um >> not like Tasha just went and did one in New York and one in Boston and >> Joe is doing one in Texas and Sally's doing one in Miami. It it's all one company like central. >> And what and what is that valued?

761
03:47:41.760 --> 03:47:57.600
>> You mean like a valuation if we were to IPO or something? >> Yeah. What is your net value as a company? Because like that really is >> Well, it's privately it's privately owned. So I I that's not public knowledge. I

762
03:47:57.600 --> 03:48:14.800
>> I couldn't I don't know the actual exact number personally. Okay. I mean >> I would have to actually guess at like an Ebida multiple or what it would come from. I >> Yeah, >> I don't want to make up an answer for you. >> That would be helpful to get. I mean, simply because it's been sensitive for

763
03:48:14.800 --> 03:48:32.160
us in seeing not just private schools go under for financial reasons, but also charters, >> right? And so I think >> okay let's do it right now. >> Correct. And so like I think for us like we have to have our doors open to our

764
03:48:32.160 --> 03:48:48.239
kids. So I think it's just important to kind of understand it's great to see the backing but sometimes things change, people make different decisions. philanthropic dollars go away and

765
03:48:48.239 --> 03:49:03.920
you know the committee is tasked with deciding whether this is going to be stable going forward in the future. So I just think some of those answers of the financial book piece would be important for the committee to look at just given the history of a couple of things that

766
03:49:03.920 --> 03:49:21.040
have happened recently here. Of course, our our proforma for Boston, I can share in the application because I don't have to make it up because I made it. Um, in year two and three, we're looking at 25 to 30% ebida margins. And so, as soon as we hit that 25 30% range, that's when we

767
03:49:21.040 --> 03:49:36.479
start to take, okay, great. The school is sustainable. We know it's going to work. We know it's delivering what we need. Now, we can take the excess. And that's why we start funding the scholarship model off of that is once we prove >> we're actually going to be viable, we know it's going to work, we're hitting our targets, that's when we start

768
03:49:36.479 --> 03:49:53.920
funneling money back into access as well. >> Okay. And what one last question uh because I like Dr. Hawkins, I could just keep going, but um just one last question. What is the a what is your average teacher salary? >> Uh 120,000 starting.

769
03:49:53.920 --> 03:50:12.319
And does that does that hold true across you you do a cost of living or does that >> Yeah, there's a slight cost of living. So um some some cities are 150,000 starting um depending Yeah. >> Got it. Okay. Thank you. >> Welcome. So Boston starts 120.

770
03:50:12.319 --> 03:50:28.560
>> Sorry, I sorry I did I did have just one question about um and I promise you had mentioned Dr. Arnold that you were a regional head of school. you said you'd be in Boston as much as possible. So, does that mean you have um responsibility for other schools and and

771
03:50:28.560 --> 03:50:44.239
travel between them? >> So, I operate like a superintendent essentially. Um so, I have um deans of parents at each of my campuses that act um you know, as senior leadership within the school and then obviously I have you know weekly standups multiple times a

772
03:50:44.239 --> 03:50:59.439
week with all of them as a cohort. But then I also do visit all of my campuses. I'm based in New York, so Boston's very easy for me to get to. Um I love Boston. Uh my nonprofit's based here, so I'm here often anyway. But yes, so I op I

773
03:50:59.439 --> 03:51:15.600
operate as a um as a regional or as a superintendent across the country. >> So the highest of ranking person in the building daily would be the dean like that and the headteer who acts we we we don't call them a principal, but yes, they're like the principal, the head

774
03:51:15.600 --> 03:51:31.279
teacher and then the dean of parents, the two of them. Mhm. >> And what is the for the Boston population um or for for schools in in cities that do not use

775
03:51:31.279 --> 03:51:46.560
vouchers? Are what is the typical MAP score that students are coming in with at the outs at the outset? Is it is it barely aligned to grade level, above grade level, below grade level? like on an on an average >> on average it's about two grades below

776
03:51:46.560 --> 03:52:04.319
level on average. Yeah. >> And then within one year our our what we see is after one year we have them at grade level and then when they're with us for two years that's when they start to get to that top 1 to 3 percentile. I think with that kind of acceleration,

777
03:52:04.319 --> 03:52:21.680
thinking about what the contribution to the larger education space in Boston would be important beyond semianual AI workshops. Absolutely. >> I think if we're accelerating outcomes at that level that we need to do some deep sharing um and you know classroom

778
03:52:21.680 --> 03:52:37.920
observations and sharing of best practices. Um >> yeah, for sure. You know what? We're open to it and we've been waiting for a public school district to say, "Hey, come on in." So, we would love that. >> Yeah. >> Yeah.

779
03:52:37.920 --> 03:52:54.720
>> Um just particular like two two questions. I'll I'll cap it at that. Um for you mentioned sort of like families bringing you to Boston. I'm just curious if we can actually see that data. Just survey data I imagine that you gathered or

780
03:52:54.720 --> 03:53:10.000
>> so it's it started with parents that were in Austin. They actually moved from Boston to Austin. Not trying to rhyme, but it does. Um and so they wanted to they want to move back to Boston. So they said, "Hey, we have a group of

781
03:53:10.000 --> 03:53:25.040
families that are in private schools that really want to bring Alpha to Boston." And so we said, "Okay, you know, we can start having conversations." And those parents came down to our Austin campus, um did the shadow, went through the whole

782
03:53:25.040 --> 03:53:41.680
admissions process, shadow day, were interested, and then we said, "Well, you know, well, let let's let's see if we can if we can bring it to Boston." So that's actually how the cohort here came to be. Um and then through that word of mouth >> has been you know can we have another

783
03:53:41.680 --> 03:53:56.720
you know can we get a group together for a small coffee or a small dinner and then it's kind of spread that way really. >> Okay. So not necessarily like a formal >> not a >> formal questions that you might have asked or things like that. >> Right. Exactly. There is you can go on

784
03:53:56.720 --> 03:54:13.040
our website there is a map and there's it's an interest map. So when people are interested in a location, they can log it and then you they you can see clusters. Um so when parents are, you know, they get a cluster together, they reach out and they say, "Hey, there's,

785
03:54:13.040 --> 03:54:30.080
you know, 40 of us. We're really interested in bringing Alpha to the city." And that's that's really how we have been moving from city to city. Of course, we do all their diligence and, you know, as you could imagine, real estate and permitting tends to be something that holds you up. Um but for

786
03:54:30.080 --> 03:54:44.720
the most part that's that's how we get brought to the the various cities. >> Thank you. Um and so one one more question is just around this is a proposed K to8. So do you have particular data about how your students

787
03:54:44.720 --> 03:55:00.720
fare once they are either transitioning to another private school for say like a public school setting just how they're fairing um academically, socially, emotionally. Have any data? We we have anecdotal evidence when it comes to the

788
03:55:00.720 --> 03:55:15.199
social part. We don't have um necessarily I would say robust data on if you've left us and gone to a you know at 8th grade and went to a high school. Um like I said I think the 50% or 52% that come back to us I think is is to me

789
03:55:15.199 --> 03:55:32.560
signals something. um when it at univers at the university level um so we had um our first graduating class 11 of the 12 went to their top university choice um Stanford you know Vanderbilt you're talking top universities the 12th is a

790
03:55:32.560 --> 03:55:49.520
professional water skier so he opted not to go to college um and all of those students those 11 of the 12 their first year both semesters or trimesters Stanford as a trimester um had 4.0's. Um, now when we asked them how was it

791
03:55:49.520 --> 03:56:07.120
transitioning to college, um, you know, they said, well, the 100 large lecture rooms didn't, you know, felt to them like a waste of time when we interviewed them after. Um, what they loved, as you know, college is a total bundle. So, they loved the the group projects, the

792
03:56:07.120 --> 03:56:24.000
the critical thinking, joining clubs, being being with their with their team members. Um, you know, I said to them, "How was it transitioning to these large groups?" And they're like, "It's not that difficult to learn how to sit in a lecture." Um, so from the social part, you know, they they feel very well

793
03:56:24.000 --> 03:56:39.439
equipped to lead. So a lot of them are leading in clubs. They're, you know, starting up different projects. They're we, you know, they're they're inventing things. One of our key mottos at Alpha is to be um a creator, not a consumer.

794
03:56:39.439 --> 03:56:56.399
So we don't want you consuming Tik Tok, right? We want you creating things that inspire the world. So our, you know, we take that very seriously and I think our students have said that that's they brought that with them into the university space. So more more data to come. This is our

795
03:56:56.399 --> 03:57:13.680
second um this year is going to be our second graduating class. That first class, most of those students started with us from third grade um through through 12th grade. This will be our second graduating class from Austin. So obviously more data to to come from that. Um but you know our students are

796
03:57:13.680 --> 03:57:30.880
averaging 1540 SATs 1560 if you're on you know the that honors track. Um so we're seeing not just the academic success but we are seeing um our students being able to um you know put themselves forward in social situations.

797
03:57:30.880 --> 03:57:46.479
Not just be bystanders but really you know take ownership of things. I know we're not talking about high school tonight. Um, but in the same way that where we go geographically is very demandled, right? It's go where people are asking for us and then we go try to

798
03:57:46.479 --> 03:58:03.120
say, "Okay, if we want to be in this city, where's the best real estate? How can we kind of figure it out? How can we get a building permit? How can we make it happen for them?" High school is the same way. And so in some of our other cities like Miami, we have recently expanded to high school because we had enough of the older cohort that wanted

799
03:58:03.120 --> 03:58:19.199
to stay and wanted to figure out how can we stay at Alpha and how can we do high school there. We made that happen for another cohort of like 8 to 12 high school students um that were just hey we had a couple in seventh eighth grade they were getting up there. I was like okay cool let's figure out how we expand and how we keep that going for them

800
03:58:19.199 --> 03:58:35.439
because they didn't want to leave. So we would if we you know chose to have a high school we would you know our eighth grade would become our ninth would become our 10th would become you know we wouldn't just oh you know now we're applying for a 9 through 12 school we would want to grow it organically within

801
03:58:35.439 --> 03:58:51.520
our within our students if that's what the parents demand if that's where the demand is. >> And could you just remind me of what your nonprofit is? No, that's mine personally. The Interchange Institute um which um is about building cultural competence around the world. Um and

802
03:58:51.520 --> 03:59:07.279
yeah, a lot of work in the um Yeah. >> Okay. >> intercultural space. >> No, thank you. >> That's I meant that's why I come to Boston in addition my own personal my own personal reasons. >> Yeah. Well, my my colleagues have asked most of my questions, but I have a

803
03:59:07.279 --> 03:59:24.239
question about the younger end. Um so um am I right in understanding that your model is um device-based? So is that 2hour time period are kids utilizing screens to do their work or

804
03:59:24.239 --> 03:59:39.520
are there other opportunities particularly well what does it look like for your younger students I guess is basically my question. >> Yeah that's that's one of the things. So we yeah we have that reading specialist um that um you know has extensive training um as a teacher. So all of our

805
03:59:39.520 --> 03:59:55.040
reading specialists are certified teachers and have um reading specialties. So they do pull outs with our students. Again our ratio is 1 to six. So um imagine you know until students learn to read they're seeing that reading specialist. It could be three times a week for 30 minute

806
03:59:55.040 --> 04:00:12.080
pullouts. Um, and then once they, you know, then you read to learn, right? There's that sort of transition. But we also have students um, who are reading at really high levels, you know, I have a a first grader, for example, who's reading at an eighth grade level. So, she's also meeting with the reading specialist to understand how do you

807
04:00:12.080 --> 04:00:27.520
comprehend things like allegory, for example, in a text. So, that reading specialist is also individual or meeting individual students needs. Um, you know, we use something called the Pomodoro method. I don't know if you're familiar with that, but essentially it's you work

808
04:00:27.520 --> 04:00:42.399
for 25 minutes, you have a break, 25 minutes, a longer break, 20 and then rinse and repeat for that sort of two-hour block. Um, you know, the the younger students get many more breaks. Um, that time is kind of stretched over a longer period of time. But the

809
04:00:42.399 --> 04:01:00.479
engagement um is on is on the screens. Um, you know, we we teach our students what is good screen time, what is bad screen time. We have all sorts of, you know, safety features on the software. There's even, you know, the blue lights and the, you know, a lot of research has

810
04:01:00.479 --> 04:01:16.239
gone into the text font size we use, the color of the text, all of that sort of stuff as part of it as well. But it's it yeah, our younger students are, you know, not just on the screens. One thing I forgot to mention is we also have something called check charts. So, this

811
04:01:16.239 --> 04:01:33.199
is this also happens in the afternoon. And for example, that's where we're we're kind of targeting some of those social emotional um aspects. So a kindergartenner, you know, needs to be able to tie their shoes. Um another check we have is you need to be able to

812
04:01:33.199 --> 04:01:49.199
um lose at a game and not cry. Uh so there's all these sorts of, you know, little tasks that they have that they're doing between their breaks or, you know, during other time allocated slots. So yeah, there's there's the academic part, but then there's a lot of play. Um, in

813
04:01:49.199 --> 04:02:06.239
some ways at the younger stage it does kind of reflect a monatory approach. You know, we we start the day with the little ones. It's called mindful mornings. So, the day before they would have picked what they want to work on. It could be kinetic sand, it could be a puzzle, it could be some of our kids are playing musical instruments. Um, and

814
04:02:06.239 --> 04:02:21.840
then we do that morning launch where it's getting the body moving and, you know, talking about what it means to be a learner. And then they they start to do that Pomodoro method engaged with the software with all the brakes. And then we have that extended lunch and recess and then our life skills workshops in

815
04:02:21.840 --> 04:02:37.680
the afternoon. >> Are there any traditional what you would consider seeing in a kindergarten classroom? Are there centers? Are there replay opportunities? >> Absolutely. Yep. Free play. There's libraries in every class. We one people often ask me, do you guys do do your kids read books? Yes, of course they

816
04:02:37.680 --> 04:02:54.479
read books. They do book reports. Um maybe the difference is, you know, and depending on the standards, right? Um for each grade, of course, we're adhering to those. But maybe not everyone's reading The Scarlet Letter, but you're reading you need to pick from a classical genre piece and then, you know, we would help you select that book

817
04:02:54.479 --> 04:03:10.720
that's of interest to you. So that's kind of where the differentiation I think is as well. Um, you know, when we talk about students loving school, you know, many times you've said it tonight, it's it's a bit of that voice and choice, that autonomy. Um, obviously with guidance, right? We we want to be

818
04:03:10.720 --> 04:03:26.239
able to guide them. But yes, it it very much looks like a um primary school with their artwork on the walls and um you know, lots of games for the kids to play and again books. You know, we we know how important it is for children to be

819
04:03:26.239 --> 04:03:42.319
fluent readers, but to love reading and that's something that we're always trying to to build in them, that love for reading, too. That's that's a strong theme throughout all of our schools is is a love for reading. And particularly when you talk about the younger children, right, the building comes into

820
04:03:42.319 --> 04:03:59.439
play in a weird way that matters a lot. So we have things we designate spaces, we call them like roar rooms, like roar like a lion where those younger children who need the breaks more often throughout the day or have a little more of we call like the wiggles etc. Right? Where can they go to be younger children

821
04:03:59.439 --> 04:04:16.319
that's not disruptive to maybe the other kids who happen to be in that grade who are really trying to focus or engaged and what can we do to make that something where the right teacher supervision is there with the right opportunities for the children are there and where kind of the architecture and how we do things are supporting the learning model and supporting what our

822
04:04:16.319 --> 04:04:32.479
children are doing as well. >> Yeah. Flexible seating as well. You know um it's not all just chairs and and desks. there's, you know, especially with the little ones, they love the little donuts that they like, you know, sink into and and have a book with. So, it's it's yeah, the the space is

823
04:04:32.479 --> 04:04:49.520
purposeful and actually our students do have do play a role in designing that um designing their own spaces as well and they try different furniture and you know, they understand the the the architecture of how it's created and you know, they they will tell us, "No, this is distracting. Actually, while it's fun

824
04:04:49.520 --> 04:05:04.720
and I love it, you know, I this isn't a good choice for me." So yeah, that that part's quite fun too to have them have a bit of say in in the actual space design. >> Yeah, there's a group there's growing research and push back now particularly

825
04:05:04.720 --> 04:05:23.120
in early childhood of people wanting to see children becoming screenfree because of what's happened pan pan you know past pandemic in terms of more and more screen time for very young children and less time to be interactive etc. Um, it'

826
04:05:23.120 --> 04:05:39.520
be interesting to see as you are a very screenbased program how families will think about that particularly for their youngest children. >> Yeah. You know, I would what we notic is our students when they go home they're not on their screens though. They see

827
04:05:39.520 --> 04:05:54.960
screen time at school you know as something that's at school. So when they go home they're >> this was about screen time in schools of getting away from screen time in schools not necessarily just at home but period >> right I mean you know I it's as an as a

828
04:05:54.960 --> 04:06:11.520
fellow academic I you know I love sort of debating these sorts of things but I there's good screen time and there's bad screen time and I I personally don't think if we pull screen time away we're serving our students well they have to you know it's going to be part but the balance is so important it's so

829
04:06:11.520 --> 04:06:28.000
important That's why our afternoon work it's not our kids are not on screens all day. Um you know there's some research that came out of Harvard that on average children in public schools um are you know on screens for over two hours a day um as well you know whether that's looking at a Smartboard or you know all

830
04:06:28.000 --> 04:06:44.479
sorts of different things. High school actually middle school was found to have the most screen time even more than high school which I thought was quite interesting. But I think yeah it let's watch the space and continue to see the research that comes out on it. Okay. >> Well, thank you very much and we look

831
04:06:44.479 --> 04:07:01.359
forward to taking um a vote on this in a future meeting. >> Yeah. And thank you guys for all the work you do for students across Boston and the time you give as a board. I know it's it's a lot. So, >> thank you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Now, we will hear from the Douglas

832
04:07:01.359 --> 04:07:37.199
Ridley School. Hi. >> Hi. >> Good evening, Chair Robinson, members of the Boston School Committee, and Superintendent Skipper. Thank you for the opportunity to speak tonight. My name is Courtney Schwarz. I am a BPS parent and the founder of the Douglas

833
04:07:37.199 --> 04:07:53.359
Ridley School. I've spent 20 years in education as a teacher, instructional coach, a school and network leader, and a believer in high expectations and a relentless focus on results. I've worked in schools in DC, in Chicago, and

834
04:07:53.359 --> 04:08:10.080
Boston. Experiences that deeply shaped who I am as an educator and leader. I believed in what we were doing, and I still really honor that work. But then I had children and I watched them experience something completely different.

835
04:08:10.080 --> 04:08:26.960
They entered a learning environment built on relationships, curiosity, and community. A place where children were deeply known, where their questions shaped the curriculum, where teachers co-created learning with students instead of delivering it to them. And I

836
04:08:26.960 --> 04:08:43.120
saw something powerful. I saw children who were confident in their ideas. Children who asked thoughtful questions, children who worked through disagreements and learned to listen to one another. I saw learning that felt joyful but also deeply rigorous.

837
04:08:43.120 --> 04:08:58.640
Students were reading, writing, researching, collaborating, and solving problems because they cared about what they were exploring. It changed what I thought about what school could be.

838
04:08:58.640 --> 04:09:15.040
At the same time, I began to reflect on the broader world our children are growing up in. We're living in a moment where our society is struggling. We're struggling to talk, to listen, to think critically together. We're

839
04:09:15.040 --> 04:09:31.040
flooded with information, yet rarely taught how to question, analyze, or understand nuance. Skills that are vital for a healthy democracy, empathy, and leadership. These are not extra skills. They are foundational. So I began to ask

840
04:09:31.040 --> 04:09:46.720
myself, what would it look like to build a school around these ideas? A place where curiosity drives the learning. Where students are deeply known, where academic rigor and joyful exploration coexist. Where children learn not only

841
04:09:46.720 --> 04:10:03.359
content, but they learn how to think, question, and work together. Our school is named in honor of Frederick Douglas and Flora Ruffen Ridley, leaders who believe deeply in education as a pathway to empowerment and social progress.

842
04:10:03.359 --> 04:10:18.319
Their legacies remind us that education is not only about individual success, but about preparing young people to contribute meaningfully to their communities. The Douglas Ridley School is a reio inspired inquirydriven

843
04:10:18.319 --> 04:10:33.439
elementary school designed to expand access to interest driven learning here in Boston. Our approach is grounded in the belief that children are capable, curious, and creative. And that when students have a voice in their learning,

844
04:10:33.439 --> 04:10:50.560
they develop ownership, agency, and a lasting love of learning. This does not mean less academic rigor. In fact, the opposite is true. Our classrooms are aligned to the Massachusetts State standards with strong foundations in literacy and

845
04:10:50.560 --> 04:11:06.239
mathematics. Students engage in daily small groupoup reading instruction, problembased math exploration, and interdisciplinary inquiry in science and social studies, all connected to the students questions and interests, making

846
04:11:06.239 --> 04:11:21.600
learning more meaningful and memorable. Work from Harvard's Project Zero demonstrates that when students engage in inquirybased learning, they develop deeper understanding, stronger reasoning skills, and greater ability to transfer

847
04:11:21.600 --> 04:11:38.239
knowledge to new contexts. Social emotional learning is also embedded throughout our design. Students participate in daily community meetings, collaborative problemolving, and realworld in the- moment conflict resolution. And with small class sizes,

848
04:11:38.239 --> 04:11:53.279
two teachers in each classroom, flexible small groups, and the ability to utilize equitable services through Boston public schools and outside providers will be able to thoughtfully meet the needs of all learners. But beyond just the

849
04:11:53.279 --> 04:12:11.600
research, this work is deeply personal. I want to build a place where kids are seen and heard, where curiosity drives the learning, where we grow together. across lines of difference. A place that equips children not just to succeed, but

850
04:12:11.600 --> 04:12:26.399
to shape a more just and con and connected world. We will launch with a single kindergarten class and grow responsibly over time. Our slow, measured growth allows us to build systems thoughtfully, ensure quality,

851
04:12:26.399 --> 04:12:43.120
and remain fiscally responsible as we expand. By adding just one grade level at a time, we're able to al align staffing, enrollment, and resources in a sustainable way that per that prioritizes long-term stability.

852
04:12:43.120 --> 04:13:00.720
And our tiered tuition model ensures that the Douglas Ridley School remains accessible to all families. This work is also guided by a deeply experienced and engaged board of directors with members from education,

853
04:13:00.720 --> 04:13:16.800
business, law, and nonprofit leadership. The board provides active oversight of our financial planning, governance, and strategic growth, ensuring that we remain accountable, missiondriven, and responsible stewards of resources as we grow.

854
04:13:16.800 --> 04:13:33.520
This intentional approach allows us to prioritize both quality and sustainability from the very beginning. We are also grateful to be launching within Temple Israel a partnership that provides not only a beautiful and accessible space, but a supportive

855
04:13:33.520 --> 04:13:49.520
environment for thoughtful growth. We are inspired to be starting in the same building where Beacon Academy first launched and we hope to follow in those footsteps growing intentionally within a community that has already supported innovative school models. With the

856
04:13:49.520 --> 04:14:07.359
support from the temple, pro bono support from Baker Hostetler and critical mentorship from the Boston business mentors. we can focus our resources on students, teaching and community while growing within a stable and supportive environment.

857
04:14:07.359 --> 04:14:23.680
Ultimately, this work is about possibility. It's about creating environments where children feel safe to ask questions, where they learn to listen to perspectives different from their own, where they develop both academic skills and a sense of responsibility to one another. where

858
04:14:23.680 --> 04:14:41.359
they see themselves as thinkers, collaborators, and problem solvers. That is the vision behind the Douglas Ridley School. Thank you for your time. >> Thank you. We'll now open it up to questions and thoughts from members.

859
04:14:41.359 --> 04:14:57.439
>> I'm going to start uh same question. How the students are chosen? What is the process? >> Yes. >> Have two questions. Okay. >> Yes. So, my goal is to make the enrollment process as low barrier as possible. I want this to this school to

860
04:14:57.439 --> 04:15:14.159
be accessible to any family that wants to be a part of it. There's a very simple application form online where you can record a video if you want to, where you can type if you want to, where you can like record a video or an audio

861
04:15:14.159 --> 04:15:32.479
message because I want it to be accessible to any families. Then we have like um an inquiry session where like families come and they can sign up for a zoom and we have like an info session together and then they apply online. Um

862
04:15:32.479 --> 04:15:46.880
and right now because we're starting right it's like most of the families who are applying are being welcomed to our community. Um, but it is more important to me to know that the families want to

863
04:15:46.880 --> 04:16:04.080
be there and that they're invested in this kind of a model. >> Is there tuition involved? >> Yes. Yes. So, we have a tiered tuition model. Um, so the max tuition is $35,000, but the tiered tuition model ensures

864
04:16:04.080 --> 04:16:21.040
that it is accessible to all families. I did not want to set up like a scholarship model so that it forced this like you're a full pay family, you're a scholarship family, but there is a tier tuition model so that all families pay their own fair share. And so it's all

865
04:16:21.040 --> 04:16:38.239
based on a percentage of your adjusted gross family income um and your the number of dependents um determines what your tier is for your tuition. >> Go ahead. No questions for you.

866
04:16:38.239 --> 04:16:54.239
>> No, no question. >> I just have a a question. Could you speak a little bit to the special education supports that you all are able to provide? >> Yes. So, we will be able to utilize the like equitable services through BPS. We're less than a mile from the tobin.

867
04:16:54.239 --> 04:17:10.640
Um so, we can walk students over there to receive services there. We have some families who have reached out who have enrolled and they their students already have IEPs and they already have service providers that they want to bring with

868
04:17:10.640 --> 04:17:28.080
them and all they're asking is like is that okay? And of course like they can bring whatever service providers we have like I think we have like the perfect model um for OT and speech um and like self-regulation support to happen within

869
04:17:28.080 --> 04:17:48.880
the context of our model. So I think a combination of both the service providers that families already have relationships with and utilizing services through BPS. Yeah, I think the part um I think you heard first of all, good to see you.

870
04:17:48.880 --> 04:18:05.040
>> Um I think the the part I um am going to poke at the most is the financial s sustainability. >> Yes, >> it works particularly in the tiers you lay out when you have full enrollment. >> Correct. But when you don't, which is

871
04:18:05.040 --> 04:18:21.199
the problem that schools are having, >> that's when it becomes harder to fund the model without raising dollars. And so, can you just talk a little bit about >> your approach to the finances,

872
04:18:21.199 --> 04:18:36.960
>> how much you're anticipating needing to raise each year to make it sustainable, >> what the enrollment needs to look like, what the backdoor plan is if the enrollment falls. >> Yes, for sure. So, we are a nonprofit and so we will be

873
04:18:36.960 --> 04:18:55.040
able to raise money. Um, we have committed support from our board members already, long-term committed support from our board members. Um, I have written several grants already and waiting for those to come in. Um, so

874
04:18:55.040 --> 04:19:12.960
part of our financial model will rely on fundraising. Um, and part of our financial model will rely on tuition. Um, and I like I've seen the Morgan Oliver School in Georgia has a similar

875
04:19:12.960 --> 04:19:30.239
tier tuition model and they have at each tuition tier there's a certain number of spots that you could like directly apply for a tier one spot or a tier three spot and that ensures that they have like a balanced financial model. Um, and that I

876
04:19:30.239 --> 04:19:47.680
think after year one is what is what we are aiming for. so that just based on our enrollment and application process, we will ensure a balanced financial model. Um, and I think like to be totally honest

877
04:19:47.680 --> 04:20:04.000
like at the beginning we're going to be small and scrappy and we're going to make it work with me and our pedigogista and one teacher and we're very lucky to be in Temple Israel and the support that they're giving us with um the rent that

878
04:20:04.000 --> 04:20:20.239
we're paying there really supports us being able to get off the ground in a responsible way. And I think like you I have no that way like we will wait to

879
04:20:20.239 --> 04:20:39.439
add a second strand um in each grade level after we see enrollment and demand and we will prioritize supporting the students that are there currently over trying to expand. Um,

880
04:20:39.439 --> 04:20:55.359
so our financial model will be a mix of like the tuition and raising money. >> Got it. Great. Thank you, >> Scarlet.

881
04:20:55.359 --> 04:21:11.760
um uh appreciate the the thoughtfulness around access um and the expertise you bring as a career educator um that has like deep experience and commitment in public schools up to this point. Um so I

882
04:21:11.760 --> 04:21:28.080
guess I'll ask just one question the same one of the same questions I asked um to the other team which is um you talked a little bit about your impetus to go in this direction but can you just clarify a little bit what the unique

883
04:21:28.080 --> 04:21:43.920
delivery model is of this program that could not be found in like the variety of schools that you've served at such high leadership levels yes >> to this point. >> Yep. Yeah. So the Reio Amelia philosophy

884
04:21:43.920 --> 04:21:59.680
believes that children are capable, curious, and creative and full of so much potential. And it's the job of the teacher to see that and notice that and see what kids are genuinely excited about and interested in and build the curriculum around that. So instead of

885
04:21:59.680 --> 04:22:16.399
having a scripted curriculum where all teachers are teaching the same exact thing to the same to all the students in the second grade, this second grade will have a curriculum that is designed around what these second graders are really excited about and really

886
04:22:16.399 --> 04:22:33.279
interested in and will weave in the second grade standards >> into whatever that topic is. >> Yes. So, for example, like if you have a class where you notice that they're really into the Titanic and this group of kids, they're really excited about

887
04:22:33.279 --> 04:22:49.520
reading about the Titanic, then the teacher will take that and build a curriculum and build learning experiences around that topic that connect to math and science and literacy and social studies. >> So, it's the it's the agency and

888
04:22:49.520 --> 04:23:05.840
autonomy of the teacher to design curriculum. that that true >> you. >> Um, yeah, I think it's it's it's challenging because as a system >> we're obligated to ensure that consistency of experience, especially with our transient students and moving

889
04:23:05.840 --> 04:23:20.720
from school to school and having kind of a a a set curriculum that we can guarantee families and being that small. um there's just an ease in kind of quality inspection of whether that

890
04:23:20.720 --> 04:23:36.000
teacher created curriculum meets those expectations. And so I think um I think it's just another another place that feels like such a disconnect between the state's guidance around instructional

891
04:23:36.000 --> 04:23:52.399
materials and the direction that we're expected to go as a set of school systems and then the agency um that you know schools with a smaller footprint have to um you know go in different directions and then for us to establish

892
04:23:52.399 --> 04:24:10.080
whether it's um whether it's beating the need is just a a a really um odd task I think for the committee. Yeah. >> Um but I appreciate um what you shared. >> Yeah. >> I'm fine. >> Yeah. And one of my hopes is that this

893
04:24:10.080 --> 04:24:26.960
model will prove that there is a different way that we can do school. That it doesn't have to be this standardized model where we're delivering this scripted curriculum. that we can honor the the questions and the curiosities of kids and still meet

894
04:24:26.960 --> 04:24:44.560
the the second grade standards, third grade standards. And I'm really grateful that our pedigogista is a PhD student with a background in research. And so part of what she's going to be doing with us is this research piece so that

895
04:24:44.560 --> 04:25:02.000
we can show that there is another way that you can do school. I think I think we know there are other ways to do school. I think a a a school this small scaling up >> is just a difficult proof point for us

896
04:25:02.000 --> 04:25:19.359
to adopt as a system. Um while I totally believe that all schools can learn from each other regardless of school type. I think we we do need to break down silos that way. I think to identify something as small as a proof point is a little challenging. um with the work in front

897
04:25:19.359 --> 04:25:35.840
of us and this the scope in front of us. Um but but I but I understand where you're coming from. >> Yeah, >> it's great. So I'm very familiar with Reio Millia at the preschool level. >> Um so I'm interested in understanding

898
04:25:35.840 --> 04:25:52.800
how this gets implemented into the elementary school and if there are other I know that there are a number of >> Rejoins inspired preschools in the greater Boston area. Are there others who have also taken on moving the model into the elementary grades?

899
04:25:52.800 --> 04:26:09.120
>> Yes. And I think that's sort of part of my hope or part of how we want to show that there is another way to do school. That why is it in preschool that we can capitalize on the curiosities and the

900
04:26:09.120 --> 04:26:26.479
excitement of kids and then once they get to kindergarten, first grade, we no longer care about their questions and their curiosities and their excitement. And so I I see this in first, second, third grade the same way that I would see it in preschool that for the same

901
04:26:26.479 --> 04:26:43.120
example, if the kids were really excited about the Titanic, great. Like we can read about we can read second grade texts about the Tit Titanic. We can incorporate science stand second grade science standards about the Titanic. We can incorporate math standards about the

902
04:26:43.120 --> 04:27:00.960
Titanic. So I think like we can still do the same model that is so effective and successful in preschools in first, second, third, fourth up through sixth grade. Um because I think we see like

903
04:27:00.960 --> 04:27:18.640
kids are so excited in preschool about learning. they're so excited to be there and then by the time they get to second, third, fourth grade, they're like school is not no longer an exciting and fun place for them to be. Um, and so we want to make sure that that happens,

904
04:27:18.640 --> 04:27:35.279
that kids continue to have this love of learning and curiosity um, and autonomy. And schools like the Advent are Reio inspired schools that go up through the elementary grades. I think Shady Hill is sort of similar.

905
04:27:35.279 --> 04:27:52.880
They have more of like a topic themebased and within there they sort of go based on what student interests are. Um but there's not a lot and that's part of this like expanding access to inquirydriven instruction in Boston.

906
04:27:52.880 --> 04:28:08.800
>> Okay. Thank you. Are there any more questions? If not, thank you very much and we look forward to um taking a vote on this in a future meeting. >> Thank you very much. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Okay.

907
04:28:08.800 --> 04:28:27.840
>> All right, folks. Our last presentation tonight is the fiscal year 26 supplemental appropriation request for 22,845,672 to Boston public schools in support of a balanced budget. I'd like to turn it over to the superintendent for any final

908
04:28:27.840 --> 04:28:43.439
comments, but I want to say one thing because um this may happen at 11:00 and I know you've never experienced this. >> The lights the lights will go out, but they will come back on. So, >> will they come back on? >> Someone has to put them on. So, >> Oh, someone will have to put him back on.

909
04:28:43.439 --> 04:29:00.319
>> Deputy 15. >> All right. So, Deputy Pen is back there. Okay. He'll be our lights for the evening. I just didn't want you to Well, I'll turn our cell phone last. We'll get through it. Okay, we're going to be quick >> into the into the final stretch. Okay, so um as we presented to the school

910
04:29:00.319 --> 04:29:16.880
committee earlier this year, the district continues to address a fiscal year 2026 budget deficit due to several factors, including significant cost increases related to historically high health care premium increases and inflation impacting out of district

911
04:29:16.880 --> 04:29:32.800
special education cost, yellow bus transportation, and student food services. Since our conversation in December, our team has taken action to save funding by reviewing and managing the cost of our most expensive programming, things like transportation.

912
04:29:32.800 --> 04:29:49.359
And through first um first we did the school level pause and then the district-wide spending pause. These efforts have led to $26 million in savings. However, these actions alone are not enough to close the gap. Our current projections show a

913
04:29:49.359 --> 04:30:07.120
remaining FY26 deficit of 28 million due mostly to health insurance and utility cost. We are now asking the committee to approve a request for a supplemental appropriation from the Boston City Council for a total of 22.8 million. This will cover the projected o overages

914
04:30:07.120 --> 04:30:23.600
in health insurance and utilities. Both of these areas are budgeted in collaboration with the city and have seen very unusual and unexpected cost growth. The remaining overages should be able to be managed down over the last three months of the year through the

915
04:30:23.600 --> 04:30:39.120
continuation of our spending pause and review of available grant funding. Chief financial officer David Bloom is here to walk through the specifics of the request and to support any questions you may have. We plan to return to the committee on Wednesday, May 6th, and ask

916
04:30:39.120 --> 04:30:56.040
for your support before the measure is sent to the city council for its review and consideration. David, >> thank you, superintendent, and thank you everyone for bearing with me. I only have 35 slides for you tonight. Um,

917
04:30:56.560 --> 04:31:11.040
>> sorry, it's the kind of joke you make when your kid was up all night last night. Uh so um when we came before you in December uh we shared a financial projection that had four main cost drivers.

918
04:31:11.040 --> 04:31:27.520
Um those cost drivers are still the same ones we're seeing leading to overrun. Health insurance a decrease in vacancy rate leading to higher employee um just salaries.

919
04:31:27.520 --> 04:31:43.359
transportation costs, special education costs, and then one new item since the projection we brought before you. Um, which is utility costs over the course of this winter have significantly exceeded our expectations.

920
04:31:43.359 --> 04:32:00.319
Um, it was a very cold winter in part. Um, so so these things sort of are the same, right? Uh, than what we expected them to be more or less. What's changed is what we've been doing about them. Uh we've

921
04:32:00.319 --> 04:32:16.399
been working since uh diligently since even before we came with the committee um to identify ways to save money to be able to cover these deficits. We've saved approximately $20 million to date from our spending pauses, which started

922
04:32:16.399 --> 04:32:32.319
with a pause of central hiring, stipens, and contract spending, and then a pause on school-based discretionary spending at the end of the calendar year. We've been also been working actively with some of our bigger operational departments to save money and cost

923
04:32:32.319 --> 04:32:46.960
management. Our transportation deficit projection is continuing to decrease. Um, this is one of the areas of good news that I didn't highlight fully on the previous slide. Um, and we're hoping that will continue to improve over the rest of the year and indications are it

924
04:32:46.960 --> 04:33:03.359
will. Um, we've also been looking at grant funding um, in particular to identify areas of potential underpending on grants that can be used to help cover areas of overspending on the general fund within the allowable uses of those

925
04:33:03.359 --> 04:33:19.520
grants. So, as the superintendent said, right now, our projection, and you have sort of a memo and some spreadsheets that that give you this information, leave us with approximately $28.3 million in overages to resolve.

926
04:33:19.520 --> 04:33:35.840
Uh, as the superintendent said, there are two main drivers of this overage that is remaining. The first is a relatively consistent health insurance projection. Um the rates for this are set early in the year and it's based on the number of employees we have which is

927
04:33:35.840 --> 04:33:51.439
also pretty static over the course of the year. So we were not really expecting this cost overrun to change and it has not. Um our utility projection has increased especially uh the cost of natural gas but also electricity

928
04:33:51.439 --> 04:34:08.240
um since our initial projection we shared with you in December. Both of these items are areas we work on in collaboration with the city, but both of our parties are setting this with limited information at the time. Um, this year we've been sort of faced a

929
04:34:08.240 --> 04:34:24.240
confluence of factors that have led to these items to over to, you know, go over and we've been working with the city with the understanding that there might be some potential need for supplemental appropriation as we've worked to save funding. If that uh request is approved, that

930
04:34:24.240 --> 04:34:41.279
would leave us with a projected $5.5 million um deficit. We're con we're confident that over the last quarter of our fiscal year, we can manage that down through continued operational savings, savings from the pause and other grant available funding. And with that, I'll

931
04:34:41.279 --> 04:35:02.561
turn it back to the committee for questions. Okay. >> Thank you. You have questions? No. I I would just say that the the easiest way to sort of understand this is as we went through the 27 budget process, we

932
04:35:02.561 --> 04:35:19.199
were given an allocation and then there was an adjustment made from the city when they realized that and we realized that the projections for health benefits would be much higher than what we were given in the original allocation. They

933
04:35:19.199 --> 04:35:36.561
then gave a supplement as part of the FY27 budget process. If that had happened last year for FY26, we would not have run the $22 million deficit that we've run since the fall.

934
04:35:36.561 --> 04:35:53.439
>> Utilities. To David's point, we've done an amazing job with the buildings, adding in a great deal of AC and AC units and additional heat, but in a cold winter, those are variables, and in a warm summer, those are variables. So,

935
04:35:53.439 --> 04:36:10.480
these are the two areas that are really just beyond our control in many ways. And um we thank the city very much for recognizing in this budget in FY27 that we needed to make that adjustment before your vote. This here for FY26 is really

936
04:36:10.480 --> 04:36:30.639
just correcting that. So this is the basis for the supplemental that if affirmative from you will then go to city council for appropriation. So I just a couple of clarifying questions to build on that um context,

937
04:36:30.639 --> 04:36:45.520
superintendent, which is very helpful. Um when we have a year like this year, whether it's based on climate or needing more heat or electricity um and we have a a high point on utilities, is that going to be the budget on which we're

938
04:36:45.520 --> 04:37:01.119
basing for the next year? Is this a message that we need to not assume as many savings or being able to recoup as we have been in the past and then building on that high watermark as opposed to um historical as an extra

939
04:37:01.119 --> 04:37:15.760
protection and do we feel like we did that for the FY27 budget? >> Yes. So, um, our risk here is that often our projections lag a year behind, um, because it's hard to have perfect

940
04:37:15.760 --> 04:37:32.719
information sort of in the right year. So, for health insurance, that's why we had to go through the process the superintendent outlined. Um, I think utilities is to be quite honest the area where I have the most concern for FY27

941
04:37:32.719 --> 04:37:50.000
if for no other reason than the geopolitical factors we're seeing which will impact the price of natural gas and other issues. What I would say though is in a typical year we might see a $5 million cost overrun in any one given

942
04:37:50.000 --> 04:38:06.000
area of our budget, but we often have a savings somewhere else that will enable us to sort of offset and manage through that through either some sort of targeted spending slowdowns or just sort of the normal course of business. I

943
04:38:06.000 --> 04:38:22.959
think the thing the two things together this year that made it particularly hard for us to balance were the vacancy rate change and health insurance. Both of which we've adjusted in our FY27 budget. Those were the two major drivers. Sorry.

944
04:38:22.959 --> 04:38:39.561
And transportation which we've also adjusted. So >> So we're assuming a higher fill on vacancies. >> Yes. >> Next year. So again basing it on the higher >> yes >> marks >> correct

945
04:38:45.279 --> 04:39:03.119
>> there questions. >> Okay. Thank you. And we will vote to approve this a supplemental appropriation at the May 6 meeting. Thank you. Um we'll now return to public comment. Miss >> no public comment. No public comment.

946
04:39:03.119 --> 04:39:20.719
>> Okay. Any new business? Um my my only request will be that we can take another look at the issues around the social workers. >> Yes, I'm understand that. >> Yeah. >> Yes, chair. I will um

947
04:39:20.719 --> 04:39:36.320
Deputy Deina and I will be having conversation uh tomorrow. >> Yes. As we see one another for city council hearing. >> Yes. Thank you. All right. The next school committee meeting will take place in person on Wednesday, May 6 at 6 PM. If there's

948
04:39:36.320 --> 04:39:51.920
nothing further, I'll entertain a motion to adjourn the meeting. Is there a motion? >> So moved. >> Is there a second? >> Second. >> Is there any discussion or objection to the motion? >> None. >> Hearing none. This Oh, excuse me. Is there any objection to approving the

949
04:39:51.920 --> 04:40:02.600
motion by unanimous consent? >> Hearing none, the meeting is adjourned. Thank you all. Have a good night. >> Thank you. Thank you, Ch. >> Thank you, Ch.