WEBVTT

METADATA
Video-Count: 1
Video-1: youtube.com/watch?v=qp9kxPhd8dE

NOTE
MEETING SECTIONS:

Part 1 (Video ID: qp9kxPhd8dE):
- 00:01:51: Meeting Called to Order; Pledge of Allegiance
- 00:02:42: Roll Call; Entering Closed Session for Personnel Matters
- 00:14:21: Student Representatives Report: Prom, Events, AP Tests
- 00:17:23: Student Reports: Arts, Culture, Final Remarks
- 00:21:01: Student Reports: Reflection on School District Experience
- 00:21:49: President's Report: Student Representatives' Vital Role
- 00:23:45: President's Report: Recognition of Student Representatives
- 00:26:11: Advice for Future Student Representatives
- 00:33:20: President's Report: Thanking Law Enforcement for Support
- 00:36:15: Approval of Personnel Addendum; New Team Members
- 00:41:02: Superintendent's Report: State of BRRSD - Progress
- 01:11:56: Superintendent's Report: Discussion and Further Questions
- 01:18:10: Committee Reports Begin - Academic Committee Report
- 01:24:31: Accusations of Disrespect; Defending School Professionals
- 01:30:48: Academic Committee Report: Textbook Recommendations
- 01:32:59: Academic Committee Report: High School AI Committee
- 01:38:10: AI Usage Limits, Enforcement, and Academic Integrity
- 01:42:40: Finance, Facilities, and Transportation Committee Report
- 01:49:37: Personnel Committee Report: Staffing, Contracts, and Pay
- 01:53:39: Community Relations Update and Liaison Reports
- 01:57:20: Public Comment: Political Grandstanding and Fiscal Responsibility
- 02:00:56: Public Comment: BREA President Retires and Safety Concerns
- 02:04:42: Public Comment: Communication, Curriculum Recommendations, AI Access
- 02:10:14: Public Comment: Board Behavior and Process Gaps
- 02:12:08: Public Comment: School Board Appreciation and Support
- 02:15:08: Public Comment: Transparency, Collaboration, and Intention
- 02:17:56: Approval of Minutes and Personnel Action Items
- 02:23:05: Approval of Curriculum and Business Action Items
- 02:35:02: Approval of Special Services and Other Action Items
- 02:36:39: Old Business: Motion to Rescind and Policy Amendment
- 02:40:17: New Business: Typing Program, Special Education Policy
- 02:50:42: New Business: Moving Board of Ed Elections to April
- 03:00:50: Adjournment to Close Session


Part: 1

1
00:01:51.840 --> 00:02:07.119
Right. Good evening everyone. I'm going to call the meeting to order. in compliance with the open public meetings law of New Jersey notice of this May 19th, 2026 meeting of the Bridgewater Ronin Regional Board of Education was posted electronically on the district website and provided on January 14, 2026

2
00:02:07.119 --> 00:02:25.280
by sending the annual written notice to the Courier News, Star Ledger, Bridgewater Township Clerk, Raron Burough Clerk, and by posting on the bulletin board in the Harman v. Wayade administration building. At this time, I ask that everyone please join me in the pledge of allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the

3
00:02:25.280 --> 00:02:42.720
United States of America and to the republic for which it stands. One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> Right. Mr. Lomsky, would you please call the role? >> Mr. Singer, >> here.

4
00:02:42.720 --> 00:02:57.920
>> Miss Lan >> here. >> Dr. Lee. >> Mr. Lee >> here. >> Mr. Maloney >> here. >> Mr. Joshi >> here. >> Mr. Walker >> here, >> Mr. Sunna >> here, >> Mr. Pepe >> here. We have a quorum. >> Right, everyone, we do need to go into

5
00:02:57.920 --> 00:03:13.920
close session very briefly to start the meeting. So, I apologize for that, but we should not be back. We should not be out much longer than 10 minutes. Uh so at this time whereas discussion by the board is required on matters that are exceptions whether the requirement that a public body hold its meetings in

6
00:03:13.920 --> 00:03:30.959
public and whereas the topic for discussion is personnel and whereas is it is expected that the details of the discussion may be made public as soon as the issues may be acted upon publicly be it resolved that the board enters into close session at this time. Do I have a motion? >> So moved. >> Is there a second? Motion and a second.

7
00:03:30.959 --> 00:14:21.199
All those in favor. >> Anyone opposed? All right. The motion carries. We are in close session. We'll be back in about 10 minutes. Thank you for your patience. Oh, hold on one moment. >> We want to give you >> Now we're we're back from >> air time here.

8
00:14:21.199 --> 00:14:40.800
>> All right, we're up to section five of our agenda, the student representatives report. >> Hello everybody. This is our last student representative meeting. That's so sad. Well, I guess we'll start with the report and then we'll carry on with everything else. I don't really know what's intended, but um this Friday for

9
00:14:40.800 --> 00:14:57.760
seniors, it's prom. Wow, big night. Um I'm very excited. It's at 7 to 10:00 p.m. at Westmont Country Club. I'm very excited. Um I just picked up my suit today, actually. Got the corsage baneer, all that kind of stuff. I'm I'm excited.

10
00:14:57.760 --> 00:15:12.399
Um and then >> Men's Warehouse. >> Men's warehouse. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Pretty good. >> Yeah. It's going to rain. That sucks. But then we're going to the Poconos's after. Um it's going to be fun. I'm excited. So great great weekend ahead

11
00:15:12.399 --> 00:15:27.839
for all seniors. Um also the week after is a junior dinner cruise. They're kind of labeling it as a junior prom almost this year. Um great event for the juniors. That's next weekend on Friday. Um and then PE partners prom. I'm in PE

12
00:15:27.839 --> 00:15:43.680
partners with Isan actually Mr. Joshi Sun. Um great program. We work with special needs kids uh in their gym classes and they are also hosting a prom as they do every year. So, I will also be attending that on June 12th.

13
00:15:43.680 --> 00:16:00.079
>> Okay. Um some other things I want to bring up are the past two weeks we've had a bunch of like AP tests and I know it's been a lot of work like trying to study for them and I took three this year and they were both like all right and it's just like kind of hard. It's

14
00:16:00.079 --> 00:16:15.279
kind of like a good way to like for all the kids just to like take this test and see how they've been doing for the past year and see what they've learned. And it's good for your college stuff, too. And I'm just really glad I never have to take an AP test again cuz cuz they're

15
00:16:15.279 --> 00:16:31.519
not the best. Um, other things to look forward as like we wrap over wrap up the year, we're preparing for graduation. We have like the senior awards on June 10th, which I'm pretty sure there's going to be a bunch of like scholarships and like awards for kids and I'm excited

16
00:16:31.519 --> 00:16:47.839
to see who gets what. Um, also the NHS induction on June 9th. Um, um, we're going to be like cuz I I'm secretary of NHS, so we're going to be like introducing the new class, the junior class this year who will be seniors and they'll be kind of the new members of NHS and I think it'll be

17
00:16:47.839 --> 00:17:02.800
really exciting. It's like a good moment for them and like you know it's like this new step for the juniors. And then last thing like graduation's coming soon. We're going to be getting our like caps and gowns soon and then we're going to be practicing for graduation and then you know we're going to go to like the

18
00:17:02.800 --> 00:17:23.760
Ruckers and it'll be fun. So yeah. >> All right. Good evening everybody. Uh thank you so much for having me. As usual, I'll just be wrapping up with a couple of arts programs and overall just language uh range related programs and events. Uh first up, we have the World Language Honor Society induction happening this Thursday in the high

19
00:17:23.760 --> 00:17:40.160
school auditorium where the honor societies for French, uh German, Chinese, and many more are going to be recognizing new students that have uh had a lot of accomplishments within the language. Um as the president for the French honor society, I'll be speaking and having a little ceremony just like all the other honor societies to kind of recognize the um rising students that

20
00:17:40.160 --> 00:17:54.880
are doing really well in their respective languages. It's a really great cultural night. There's a lot of food um perspective and music and music that's respective to each culture. A very fun night from the time I attended uh two years ago. Additionally, there are a couple of arts programs events. For example, today uh as we speak is the

21
00:17:54.880 --> 00:18:10.240
orchestra concert, which I will be going to very briefly after this. Um so, that's a great event to kind of wrap up the orchestra season. It's been a very uh fun and memorable year, and I would not have wanted to end my orchestra career any other way. Additionally, we have the band concert on May 28th, which is next week, and the day before that is

22
00:18:10.240 --> 00:18:26.080
the choir concert. So all the arts programs going to be wrapping up their overall um events for the year and then closer to the end of the year in near June um each program will respectively have their end of year banquetss. Uh we also have a visual arts exhibition at the high school on June 4th from 6:00 to 8. So they'll be u displaying different

23
00:18:26.080 --> 00:18:43.360
student works in um like 3D models or even uh paintings, oil paintings, etc. So overall, the arts are going to be flourishing and having a lot of great events from now through the end of the year. And lastly, the theater arts program will be having a showcase on June 5th from 7:00 to 9:00 p.m. kind of as like a final goodbye to the overall theater program. I attended their spring

24
00:18:43.360 --> 00:18:59.679
musical. It was really great and overall I think that it's been a great year for every single arts program in the department in the entire high school. So, it's great to see all this success across the board. Thank you. And then I'll hand it off to Matt, I guess, for some final remarks from us as the reps.

25
00:18:59.679 --> 00:19:15.760
>> Okay. Well, um, it's been a pleasure this year. This was definitely an experience I did not expect to have going into my high school career, but I'm very grateful that I did have. It kind of gave me insight into what decisions have been going on and shaping my education through my entire my entire

26
00:19:15.760 --> 00:19:31.039
education history. I've been attending Bridgewater High School and so to see how it really works. But like behind the doors, you know, it's cool. It's cool to see. Um, and I hope that every single year we can continue to keep getting closer and closer to, you know,

27
00:19:31.039 --> 00:19:46.400
achieving more and more, right? I see the community, as you were talking about a couple of the meetings, like it's growing. It's definitely growing. Bridgewwater is becoming a more tight community. I feel that and it's it's exciting, especially for you guys where you guys can continue to keep making

28
00:19:46.400 --> 00:20:03.679
decisions. Um, I'm graduating now and I'm I'm very excited to see where Bridgewwater goes in the future. I take pride in this town um in this education system. I think it's put me in a good place and I'll be able to carry that that base of knowledge with me for the

29
00:20:03.679 --> 00:20:23.919
rest of my life and I'm very grateful. So um thank you guys. I appreciate it. >> Okay. Yeah. I just wanted to add on to that and say that this has been a really great year and has given me a lot of experience in just like the world of

30
00:20:23.919 --> 00:20:40.559
like um politics a little bit and just like what goes behind the scenes from like when I was in first grade to now just like what so much of what we don't we aren't able to see that so much time and effort that you guys put in into making sure that our district is is

31
00:20:40.559 --> 00:20:57.559
running efficiently that our students are like being put first and I'm just really like it's been a really fun exper experience to get to watch all the like all the magic behind and like I'm excited to see like in the future how how far Bridgewater can become.

32
00:21:01.039 --> 00:21:17.360
>> Uh like my fellow representatives here, I'm also a homegrown student. Uh I started back in kindergarten and I'm still now up to the high school. It's been a really wonderful ride. I'm really grateful to be a part of a district and community as strong as this one. I've really seen uh like how much the community has involved and I'm honestly is so fortunate to be able to say that

33
00:21:17.360 --> 00:21:33.200
I'm from the Bridgewwater res community. I'll be carrying that throughout the rest of my life wherever I go. I think that it's I'm really grateful to also be in this position to be a student representative speaking on the board. At the end of the day, I believe that education is going to be for the students no matter what it is, whether it's today, 10 years from now, or 100 years from now. So, I think that it's

34
00:21:33.200 --> 00:21:49.120
really important that we have voices like ours on here and I'm very grateful to be able to share my insight over the past academic year. I hope that it could have added some more nuance, some more uh I guess dialogue to the conversation because at the end of the day, students are the foremost most important part of a district in my opinion. So, I'm very grateful for this opportunity. I thank

35
00:21:49.120 --> 00:22:07.440
you all for being wonderful board members and I'm grateful for everything you guys have done for the district. Thank you. >> Thank you so much. Well, for my president's report, I just want to say it's a little bit wild to hear uh these three individuals tell us that we spend a lot of time on something because the

36
00:22:07.440 --> 00:22:22.559
number of activities that they're involved with um in the schools and beyond is really impressive. And you know, one of the great things about serving on the board is that we get to hear a lot about the great things that students are accomplishing every day. And um sometimes board members even get to, you know, see some of it, whether

37
00:22:22.559 --> 00:22:38.000
it's like a big chorus or a big game or the opening night of a musical. But what we don't always get to see or experience is everything that goes into making those moments happen which is why these student representatives are such a vital element of this board. Uh through their

38
00:22:38.000 --> 00:22:52.320
reports which have touched on every facet of the student experience here at Bridgewater Raridan. Uh the rest of the board and the public gets a window into everything that goes in to everything our students are achieving. It's the hard work, the teamwork and the learning that t that takes place each day and

39
00:22:52.320 --> 00:23:08.480
their feedback good or even bad is some something that I know our board and I think the administration uh values very very much. So Crystal Paratosh Matt have been you've been outstanding members of our board. Um, your messages haven't just touched on a list of sports clubs

40
00:23:08.480 --> 00:23:25.120
and routine activities, though that is always exciting news and very useful information for everyone here and in the public, but they also express express, in my judgment, your genuine care and concern for every student that you represent at the high school. Uh, we heard a little bit of that in in your

41
00:23:25.120 --> 00:23:45.520
most recent report. So, you're exemplary representatives of our district, of the board, and of our communities. So Matt, Crystal, and Paratosh, it's been an a privilege to serve alongside you. Thank you. Um, and I know we have something for

42
00:23:45.520 --> 00:24:01.760
you. So, uh, Mr. Beers, can we do that now and then take comments for the rest of the board? >> Let's do it. >> All right. >> Take a photo. Right. >> One more round of appl applause for Crystal Chen. These all read in recognition of service as a student representative for the Bridgewater Rariton Regional Board of

43
00:24:01.760 --> 00:24:25.760
Education 2025 2026. Thank you so much. CONGRATS. >> With the same commenation, Matthew Harrison. Come on up, Matt. >> Congrats. >> Thank you. >> Congratulations.

44
00:24:25.760 --> 00:24:44.400
and Paratosh Ble, come on up. I hope I got your last name right. I apologize if I didn't. Congrats. >> Right. Would we like I know you may have to run. Uh do we Would you like to get a picture first to make sure everyone's here >> here in front? We We could have the

45
00:24:44.400 --> 00:26:11.440
board members kids in front of us here. So, Crystal, Matt, Paras, I understand you you may have to run. If you do, we understand. But I did just want to open it up to the board if anyone had any uh brief things they'd like to say in in recognition of your service. Paradage. So long. >> Thank you.

46
00:26:11.440 --> 00:26:27.840
>> Round applause for Paradage. Thank you. So long. >> I actually did have a question, Mr. Go ahead. >> Thank you. Um, I usually am the one who asks questions here, but you know, from your experience being student

47
00:26:27.840 --> 00:26:44.720
representatives, what's a piece of advice that you have for future student representatives who want to be in the roles that you're in today? >> Um, I could go. Uh, I'm very grateful that our district actually has Okay, so

48
00:26:44.720 --> 00:27:00.159
I have a friend that goes to Ridge and I told him that I was on the board of education. and he's like, "Oh, that's sick. Like, I don't even know if we have that." And I was like, "Oh, well, you you definitely do. Like, every every school in the state has to have that." And so, we looked at his his board meetings on YouTube to see who his board

49
00:27:00.159 --> 00:27:17.360
rep was. And it was the president of the school. And while that's cool and all that they also get this position, um, I think that it's cool that we have it separate and that we also act as like kind of kind of like a different position that we wanted to be in, right?

50
00:27:17.360 --> 00:27:34.400
So I would in knowing that like that I put myself into this position that's just that I want to be here right for future board members which I wish I did. I would have looked more into what each meeting is actually talking about and probably open up a

51
00:27:34.400 --> 00:27:51.200
student perspective to you guys about what this meeting is actually going to be about before coming to you before like rather than just telling you what's going on in the school because it's great what's going on in the school. You guys could also look up on the website and see headlines if you really wanted to, right? So, I think it would have

52
00:27:51.200 --> 00:28:07.120
been more beneficial if my role was more tailored towards actually talking about the things that the board is talking about. Um, but that's something that that we can work towards and definitely in the future start talking about because I know we have meetings with Mr. hamburger before each meeting and like

53
00:28:07.120 --> 00:28:23.200
in those in those meetings that we have, we can talk about, you know, what the board is going to talk about, our takes on it, maybe, you know, oh, we talk to him about, oh, we might think this is it should be this way, it should be that way. And he's like, well, you know, you might not know the backstory, and that's okay, right? But just providing little

54
00:28:23.200 --> 00:28:40.080
insights to different issues that you guys may be talking about in the meetings may be a little more beneficial. and just you know taking the interests that we did take to apply to a position that I would know was highly competitive to get into with an interview process and all that. So that like applying yourself would would be a

55
00:28:40.080 --> 00:28:57.919
lot a lot better if that was also kind of a route that we could take. So, thank you. Anyone else? >> This is SA. >> Oh, I'll go. I just want to thank you both, all three of you, but the two of you who are still here, um, so much for everything that you brought to the

56
00:28:57.919 --> 00:29:14.000
meetings and I know I have seen a lot of talk on Facebook about the memory walks and I hope that that's being shared with the student like with all the seniors because I know the parents have set up memory walks at all the elementary schools in June. Um, so if you don't

57
00:29:14.000 --> 00:29:30.159
know about them, call get in touch with me and I want to make sure that all the students are aware of them because it's we had hoped to do this years ago and it's really great that it's kind a little bit official now and have a great time at prom. >> Mr. Singer,

58
00:29:30.159 --> 00:29:46.159
>> thank you. Um, Matt, to your point, I just want to say that um, over a number of meetings, all all three of you, you didn't just report. you really added your voice. You were involved in discussions. Um, and

59
00:29:46.159 --> 00:30:03.360
that is probably the greatest achievement that you guys can do here is when you add that perspective and we we really do appreciate that. Um, and you guys did it very well and it was always appreciated. So, thank you. I wish you all the best. Um, the reports were

60
00:30:03.360 --> 00:30:19.600
excellent. Um, it is a way for us to uh remain invested in the schools. Um, but your voice is just cannot be replaced. So, thanks. >> I have some final words. >> I'm just go with Miss Lockan first. Thank you, Mr. Lee. Miss Lockan.

61
00:30:19.600 --> 00:30:35.919
>> Yeah, I I'll echo what Mr. singer said, but but also I've been here since they first uh added student reps to our board and every year I tell them they're my favorite, but every year the there's just an element of contribution that

62
00:30:35.919 --> 00:30:51.360
just ups the game and and quite honestly I I just respect you guys so much for not not just coming to report but the it's kind of it's it's a bravery that to to share your opinion and and and put your thoughts forward before to this

63
00:30:51.360 --> 00:31:07.679
board and I think your parents must be incredibly proud for a lot of reasons and I hope this just adds to their list and I wish you guys the best of luck. You got it. Yeah, I know it's one thing I wanted to thank you guys, all three of you for putting in the hard work

64
00:31:07.679 --> 00:31:25.200
>> and uh hopefully you know in the future you stay engaged, >> right? And the meetings are online. So any comments, any suggestions you may have, stay engaged. You know, you're leaving here doesn't mean you're leaving this, right? Um so thank you and Matt,

65
00:31:25.200 --> 00:31:41.039
stop by. Don't be a stranger. You know where we are. >> Yeah, of course. >> All right. Thank you. >> Thank you. >> And then Mr. Lee. And then I guess since you guys gave some advice as well, you know, I do have a little bit of advice for you guys. Um not like I'm the most

66
00:31:41.039 --> 00:31:56.640
successful guy in the room or anything like that, but um one piece of advice that I always hear from people, but I always want to just reiterate is, you know, whatever part of your educational career you go through or whatever you do from a career perspective or anything,

67
00:31:56.640 --> 00:32:12.080
you know, just always be curious. always ask questions and and question everything because that's the only way you're going to learn and grow as a person. So, always remember to ask questions and don't feel afraid don't be afraid to ask even the dumb questions. So,

68
00:32:12.080 --> 00:32:27.840
>> thank you. Anything else? >> Yeah, Mr. >> Thank you. You guys have uh represented yourselves well. Um you are you you came here were fearless and smart and you showed us what what our students are like in the district. And then Mr. Hamburger said, "I picked some great

69
00:32:27.840 --> 00:32:43.600
candidates for the board of ed." And he was completely right. And so it's been a pleasure. And every year you you um you enlighten us, your genuiness, your honesty, and I carry that in life. You guys are going to be successful. You know, you always run for the board of ed

70
00:32:43.600 --> 00:32:58.960
too if you want to. So that's another option. Also stay in touch. I wish you all the best in what you're doing. Have a great celebration the last couple weeks. Enjoy yourselves. You know, the rack is fantastic for graduation. And so we'll enjoy that in this weekend. But thank you so much. You've done it. You

71
00:32:58.960 --> 00:33:20.080
should be proud of what you've done and way you've served your your students. So thank you. >> All right. Thank you very much. Anything else before before we move on? >> As always, you're welcome to stick around, but as we've heard, there's a lot going going on. So um feel feel free

72
00:33:20.080 --> 00:33:47.200
to peace out whenever you're ready. Sorry to use the phrase peace out, but great. >> Thank you. >> All right. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. One more round of applause for Matt and Chris. All right. Uh just to continue on with my president's report, I have one more

73
00:33:47.200 --> 00:34:04.559
uh brief item and it's just um just I I do recognize that earlier this month, our community faced a challenging couple of days uh as a law enforcement operation responded to a a dangerous situation in a neighborhood where many students live and near school buildings.

74
00:34:04.559 --> 00:34:19.520
Uh I know that I cannot begin to properly thank law enforcement for their response in in containing and resolving the situation and uh I couldn't possibly name every agency involved. But of course I starts with the Bridgewater Township Police Department and their

75
00:34:19.520 --> 00:34:36.480
chief uh John Mitsac um for their efforts to keep all of us safe, particularly our students and our school buildings. Um, I thank them for being great partners, you know, along with the Raren Police Department every day, but particularly during that, um,

76
00:34:36.480 --> 00:34:53.359
challenging period and for being great partners with the district and ensuring that schools were able to open and, uh, to run on a regular schedule. Um, I particularly thank Chief John Mitsac for acknowledging the the work of the officials of the Bridgewater Raridan

77
00:34:53.359 --> 00:35:09.760
Regional School District in his statement um after things settled down and he thanked um you know everyone in the district for working closely with the police department to safely reroute buses and I'm read I'm quoting him exactly here to safely reroute buses and students around

78
00:35:09.760 --> 00:35:25.520
affected around the affected area without disrupting the school day uh that Friday. uh their cooperation helped maintain normaly for our children during a difficult time. And I certainly um echo the same sentiments from the administration um to the building

79
00:35:25.520 --> 00:35:40.640
principles to the counselors to the teachers who uh not just during this um unfortunate event um make the schools places where our students feel safe day in and day out and the police and our

80
00:35:40.640 --> 00:35:55.839
law enforcement that make all of us more safe day in and day out. So, I just wanted to acknowledge uh them and the good work done um on behalf of our students at a difficult time. It shows our schools at their best and our students at our best too. I give them a lot of credit

81
00:35:55.839 --> 00:36:15.359
particularly everyone who was directly or indirectly impacted. Uh that is it for my uh president's report. Uh with that, we will move on to the superintendent report. Mr. Beers, Yes.

82
00:36:15.359 --> 00:36:31.280
>> Thank you for the reminder, Mr. Beers. We are going we're going to move uh one item up. Do you mind if I grab that since you're looking at it? >> Right. At this time, I would like to move one item up in our agenda and that is personnel 2632, which is approval of

83
00:36:31.280 --> 00:36:48.560
the personnel addendum. Is there any is is there a motion? Motion >> second. >> There's a motion and a second. Any discussion? any any discussion that wouldn't be in close session. Uh seeing none, Mr. Lomsky, would you please call the role on personnel 2632? Again, this

84
00:36:48.560 --> 00:37:04.960
is not the entire personnel uh agenda. >> Mr. Singer, >> yes. >> Miss Lan, >> yes. >> Mr. Lee, >> yes. >> Mr. Maloney, >> yes. >> Mr. Joshi, >> yes. >> Mr. Walker, >> yes. >> Missa, >> yes.

85
00:37:04.960 --> 00:37:24.320
>> Mr. Pepe, >> yes. The motion carries. any >> Okay. Thank you. I I'd like to take a a few minutes here to to introduce the the board of education and the community to

86
00:37:24.320 --> 00:37:40.160
two new members of the administration team. The first person, I shouldn't say, is a new member, but he's in a new role. So, it's David Googlied. And it's my pleasure to introduce him here tonight. And um Dave brings a wealth of experience in health and physical

87
00:37:40.160 --> 00:37:55.440
education leadership to Bridgewater Raritin. He's no stranger to our district, having served as our health and physical education supervisor since 2022, where he's already made a meaningful impact on curriculum, instruction, and in the culture of our

88
00:37:55.440 --> 00:38:12.000
schools. Prior to joining Bridgewater Raritin, David served as a vice principal at St. Leo the Great School in Lraftoft where he helped her earn that school the prestigious National School of Character designation and before that he was an educator in the Orange Public

89
00:38:12.000 --> 00:38:28.880
Schools. Kain University graduate who earned his mers in educational leadership from Concordia University. David is a passionate advocate for student achievement, character education, and innovative instruction. We're thrilled to have him continue growing as a leader in our community and

90
00:38:28.880 --> 00:38:49.760
are excited about the contributions he'll make to the students and families of Bridgewater Ritan. So, Mr. Googlied, if you could stand up and take a bow. There you go. So, and and then afterwards I have to torture these folks with taking a

91
00:38:49.760 --> 00:39:05.920
picture for the uh website, etc. But Bruce is on that. Next is uh Matthew Mourn. So it's uh it's with great enthusiasm that I introduce uh you to Dr. Matthew Mourn who's an accomplished educational leader whose depth of

92
00:39:05.920 --> 00:39:20.720
experience and commitment to student success makes him an exceptional addition to the Bridgewater Ritan team. Dr. most recently served as an assistant principal at Roxbury High School where he led a school of over,300 students and

93
00:39:20.720 --> 00:39:37.200
founded an innovative aviation academy that earned national recognition as an ITA STEM school of excellence. He holds a doctorate in curriculum and instruction from Liberty University and brings a strong background in

94
00:39:37.200 --> 00:39:52.800
instructional leadership, data-driven school improvement, teacher development, and grant writing, having secured over $100,000 in competitive funding uh to expand learning opportunities for the students at Roxbury. A recognized leader at the state level through his work with

95
00:39:52.800 --> 00:40:09.520
NJ, SD, NJPSA, and multiple county and state committees, Dr. Dr. Mann is also an active presenter and thought leader on topics ranging from AI and education to school culture and student support. We're proud to welcome Dr. Mann to our

96
00:40:09.520 --> 00:40:30.160
community and look forward to to the energy, expertise, and vision he'll bring to our students and staff. If you could stand up and be and and I really want to give kudos to Dr. 's wife who is here tonight with

97
00:40:30.160 --> 00:40:45.599
with two little ones, one who's really little and and gosh, thank you so much for taking the time to visit us and be with us tonight on this special day. We really appreciate you taking the effort to uh to do that because it's not easy. So again, welcome and um if you could

98
00:40:45.599 --> 00:41:02.319
bear with me just for a minute or two, I'll do the photos with uh Mr. Moran and we'll go from there. You want to go? >> Let's go outside and then I'll back for Does anyone need like a two-minute break before we can >> start? Yeah, we'll do a two-minute

99
00:41:02.319 --> 00:46:05.680
break. We'll come back in in 2 minutes. We're good. >> Okay, everyone. Thank you. And um and really th this is my favorite presentation of the year where um every year in case the public wonders the board of education and the district we

100
00:46:05.680 --> 00:46:23.520
set annual goals and um our annual goals are are based off our long range plan. If you remember a few years ago we had community come together. We set up four major goals and and our year-to-year goals are based on are based on um the

101
00:46:23.520 --> 00:46:39.599
major themes from from uh that time. So, it's always fun to take take us through the pathway uh that we've traveled this year and really make that comparison from a data standpoint as far as where we stand now versus where we were. So uh

102
00:46:39.599 --> 00:47:12.640
so I'm proud to to uh give to you the state of BRRSD progress, promise and uh performance. So, our four district goals um were were based in in four specific areas. Climate and culture, student experience,

103
00:47:12.640 --> 00:47:28.960
finance, facilities, and communications and engagement. And and there are some smaller goals that are attached to to each force. So, we'll go through these uh during the presentation. When when we start off with academic achievement, this is something we're

104
00:47:28.960 --> 00:47:44.560
really proud of and uh and there there's no getting around this. there there has been some real progress made in specific areas throughout the district. Specifically, our AP progress ha has been incredible.

105
00:47:44.560 --> 00:48:00.960
27% uh gain in the number of AP students since 2021 and 41% more of those students scored three or above. Our dual enrollment has really exploded. the numbers have gone from 40 uh 40 students

106
00:48:00.960 --> 00:48:16.560
a couple of years ago to 288 students. And then finally, the career concentrations that we approved and and implemented two years ago continues to grow. So, so in some of these key data points, we are certainly pushing the

107
00:48:16.560 --> 00:48:34.079
envelope, exposing students, and and it's obviously what the students are asking for and what they're looking to do. Another part and and this goes to our whole idea of of equity and and building a a system for every learner throughout

108
00:48:34.079 --> 00:48:51.359
the district. One of the things that that I'm especially proud of is is the rise in our graduation rate. No offense to anyone at our graduation rate here was embarrassing for a long time. Um there's no way a a a district like us

109
00:48:51.359 --> 00:49:06.880
should have been in the low 90 in the low 90s for uh graduation rates, but that's where we were. So 92.7 in uh 2022 and and it's risen to 97%. Right? It's not exactly where we want to be. We

110
00:49:06.880 --> 00:49:23.119
believe there's more growth. But if we look at the average class size of approximately 700 students in Bridgewater Raritin, a five a four and a half to 5% gain means you're talking about 30 to 35 students who are getting across the line on a year-over-year

111
00:49:23.119 --> 00:49:40.880
basis, right? That those are real kids um with real futures and we've done a lot to to help them. Um because as we know if if you if you do not graduate high school and you drop out it's it's really a struggle for quite some time to to get back to that level.

112
00:49:40.880 --> 00:49:55.839
NJSLA we've gone through these presentations throughout the year. We're consistently 15 to 17% above the state averages in ELA math and science. We experienced 5% year-over-year growth in ELA. Our mathematics achievement is stable year-over-year and we have

113
00:49:55.839 --> 00:50:13.280
targeted some specific areas that can be addressed for additional growth and and um one of the initiatives that's been taken on by by uh the curriculum department as well as the high school administration is really uh is really pushing kids to

114
00:50:13.280 --> 00:50:31.920
to take the seal of biiteracy. And those numbers have gone up almost 100% over a two-year basis. Coming off of COVID, Bridgewater Raritim was no different than a lot of other places. We were experiencing student

115
00:50:31.920 --> 00:50:47.520
behaviors that were atypical for an institution like us. All right. And and uh the spikes in in things like HIV and disciplinary referrals, it was a trend nationwide, statewide, etc. where where student

116
00:50:47.520 --> 00:51:03.040
behaviors, you know, who who would have thought that being isolated in your house for a year to a year and a half would have a negative effect on um student interactions, but it certainly did. Um but with that being said,

117
00:51:03.040 --> 00:51:20.160
we we put in a number of programs and and we've seen an HIV decline that's that's really uh impressive. 78% decrease in investigations and a 77% decrease in founded incidents. That's

118
00:51:20.160 --> 00:51:37.680
from 2023 24 to the present. And and I've got listed here a few of the uh the programs that we initiated. Some are related to HIV, but otherwise it's it's related to wellness, the lifeline suicide prevention curriculum, the lead program in the fifth grade, and

119
00:51:37.680 --> 00:51:55.760
the character education programs that are implemented consistently and and um they're implemented consistent consistently and with fidelity the primary and middle school levels, right? We build values, responsibility, community, etc. And it's really had a

120
00:51:55.760 --> 00:52:11.040
positive effect on student behaviors. One of the other things that's not listed here which has helped with HIV and the reduction in student behaviors is really taking a look at our code of conduct, right? And and making sure that there

121
00:52:11.040 --> 00:52:28.240
are clear consequences and standards for student behavior. It took some time, but I really applaud the efforts of the administration and all the buildings and the teachers who are involved with that um to to bring us to a better place.

122
00:52:28.240 --> 00:52:44.160
Another part of of improving improving discipline, improving climate is with our safety and security team. We made a large investment in in people right to and and this works for the community,

123
00:52:44.160 --> 00:53:00.960
for the students and for our faculty. We've made a a number of uh capital improvements in physical infrastructure and and I think the major change that we have is that investment in personnel, right? Although things like your your um

124
00:53:00.960 --> 00:53:17.040
secure vestibules, all of these things, they're they're nice to have, but you need people on the ground to make sure that it's used with with fidelity, that we maintain certain protocols, whether it's visitors, etc. and and this group of of uh of people we've hired really do

125
00:53:17.040 --> 00:53:32.720
an excellent job and they're visible throughout the district and I know there's a positive uh positive feedback we continually receive on our security team and what they bring and uh as as Mr. Pepe had had mentioned a few minutes back, we have really dramatically

126
00:53:32.720 --> 00:53:49.920
improved our communication with local PD since the time I came until now. And these people are are a part of that. And it really came across loud and clear two weeks ago when there was an incident uh locally. We were in constant communication and it wasn't just through

127
00:53:49.920 --> 00:54:07.760
me. It was through some of our contacts, whether it was Mike, whether it was Ted. Um, and we were able to keep everyone safe, route our buses, and do what we needed to do to keep school open. So, look here. Here is the big the big thing we've been working on this year

128
00:54:07.760 --> 00:54:24.160
and and and it's going to be awesome next year when this happens. So, I'm finishing up my fifth year and I know that these conversations about full day kindergarten have been going on for at least a decade before I got here.

129
00:54:24.160 --> 00:54:38.880
When I started, I I believe the board of education had just completed the facilities analysis and we were sorting through this this enormous list of projects to figure out what we wanted to do. And and I do want to go back to the

130
00:54:38.880 --> 00:54:56.480
process and I I I give the board a lot of credit for this and and you can't forget it. Before we did the community survey, we all had in our minds what we were going to sp spend money on. But there w there was no avoid avoiding

131
00:54:56.480 --> 00:55:12.000
the the results of the survey really to a tea. Full day kindergarten was at the top of everything. So when we looked at at our charge to to really have a successful referendum, we knew that we had to include full day kindergarten in

132
00:55:12.000 --> 00:55:28.240
that and and it's occurring in September. But I think the the whole board and prior boards of education need to give themselves a pat on the back because they started the process to do this five, six years ago. And um

133
00:55:28.240 --> 00:55:45.359
there was a lot of patience. There was a a lot of things we had to figure out, but but we're here and we're ready to implement it. The classrooms are ready, the spaces are ready. Um the kids are ready. I'm sure the families are ready as well. gifted and talented uh services are are

134
00:55:45.359 --> 00:56:02.079
implemented across all schools and are going to be expanded next year. We've gone through this uh debate before and this is a great thing for all kids. We've increased instructional time for for science and social studies. World language program has been expanded into the fourth grade and we we're meeting

135
00:56:02.079 --> 00:56:17.440
our physical education requirement of 150 minutes per week. So when we look when we look at what we've done for the primary schools, it's not just adding full day kindergarten. It's adding a program that is enhanced

136
00:56:17.440 --> 00:56:33.440
to what existed 3 to 5 years ago. So it that was a heavy lift from curriculum from the supervisors and for the teachers right who who um right there are going to be changes and there's some adaptation. People are moving around

137
00:56:33.440 --> 00:56:50.319
there. There are big-time changes and I want to just uh give kudos to everyone involved in this process. As we continue with equity and access um how this relates to to equity is now in

138
00:56:50.319 --> 00:57:08.400
music all all fifth grade music classes are during the school day. There's not band or orchestra practice before school. All right? And that's incredibly important because if a kid didn't have a ride or parent who could get them there, him or her there before school, then

139
00:57:08.400 --> 00:57:25.680
they couldn't participate. So, we've worked out the schedule to make sure that that these things take place during the school day. So, all kids have access to that activity. Fourth grade choir was added to student schedules where students are not going to be pulled out of academic subjects to take choir.

140
00:57:25.680 --> 00:57:42.400
We've added new AP courses, multiple pathways uh for students to to uh access advanced C coursework and uh the next bullet is about the structured learning labs and and the bright program. So I'll take you through really quickly as far as what that is.

141
00:57:42.400 --> 00:58:00.319
the structured learning labs essentially it I mean different schools call them different things but if we have young people who are struggling in their uh academic subjects what we do is they get referred through guidance it's an MTSS um uh

142
00:58:00.319 --> 00:58:17.040
accommodation in order to make that young person successful in their coursework we pull them out of their study hall and they go to there's a room off the library where they get tutoring in in the subjects that they're struggling in. So when we hear about highintensity tutor t tutoring, that's

143
00:58:17.040 --> 00:58:33.440
kind of the buzzword, we do it and and it's really had quite a bit of success. So when we track students who who get placed in the program who have two or more failures in their their uh

144
00:58:33.440 --> 00:58:51.119
coursework at the end of six months we've got nearly a 70% success rate where kids are failing zero classes. So a lot of times it's it's the tutoring but also it's helping kids with executive functioning and and giving them a lifeline and a

145
00:58:51.119 --> 00:59:07.520
connection at school. Now the bright program that is our alternative program. These are the kids who are in danger of not graduating um for a variety of of reasons. They may need they may need credit recovery and and bright is more of a therapeutic

146
00:59:07.520 --> 00:59:22.960
program. It offers kids the supports to be successful. offers them a pathway forward versus just saying you fail and and you're done. And uh and again we have close to 100% success rate with the bright program. And then finally for

147
00:59:22.960 --> 00:59:39.760
next year with full day kindergarten one of the one of the uh major initiatives with the state of New Jersey and and we've been ahead of the the curve on this. The multi-tered systems of support the enhancements are going to focus on providing supports to the youngest

148
00:59:39.760 --> 00:59:56.000
learners. So what that means is when kids walk in the door in kindergarten, not too long after, we do an assessment on where they are with things like first sound fluency, etc. using a Dibbles assessment and then we see where these kids are, what's the skill that maybe they they need help on. And we offer

149
00:59:56.000 --> 01:00:11.920
them that extra support right there. And there are plenty of there's plenty of research and study that shows that if you can get those kids when they're four years old, well, kindergarten, five years old, that's the time you really want to want to uh assess them and and

150
01:00:11.920 --> 01:00:29.440
offer that that uh enhancement because that's when you're going to see the greatest result. And and there's this other thing that's been going on while we're improving the curriculum, and that's our $155 million referendum. We continue to change the face of

151
01:00:29.440 --> 01:00:44.960
Bridgewater Raritin Regional School District. Um I I don't think people at at the table would agree with me and um I remember the walk down memory lane five six years ago even during my interview process. I think Mr. Walker

152
01:00:44.960 --> 01:01:00.000
asked me what did I think of the facilities and there was a little bit of a pause. Um but it's true our facilities were a disaster, right? We needed the funding to update things uh to really create learning environments that we could be proud of

153
01:01:00.000 --> 01:01:15.839
and that are condu conducive to student learning and and this referendum I believe was constructed the the right way. It took a a bunch of iterations, but but now we've been working through things with our architects with with uh

154
01:01:15.839 --> 01:01:33.520
different contractors and we do we have been able to keep construction on time and on budget and we address changes in the field and and we resolve them as they come up. It's quite an effort and and I want to really commend the business office as well as Mr. BTSO who

155
01:01:33.520 --> 01:01:51.440
gave us a tour of the um the site today because this is like a second job for Mr. Lomsky his his department as well as other people within the operation. So we've provided regular public updates on these times at these times and as

156
01:01:51.440 --> 01:02:06.640
part of the referendum next year next September is really when when we make this enormous shift of reconfiguring the grades. We took a tour today of the middle school. So, sixth grade is going to transition to the middle school. Fourth grade is going to move to the

157
01:02:06.640 --> 01:02:24.240
primary schools. And and September 2026 is really going to be an exciting time for all of us because we've been planning for this, planning for this, planning for this, and now it's going to happen. So, I can't with that, I can't promise you that everything's going to be smooth.

158
01:02:24.240 --> 01:02:42.960
All right? But whatever does come up, whatever bumps in the roads are going to arise, we're going to be there to address it, smooth it out, make it right, and go from there. And here's another area that I really want to commend the board of education,

159
01:02:42.960 --> 01:02:58.640
the business office, and all of the ad the admin team. Our our budget was especially challenging this year and we're not unique. It was challenging for schools all across the state of New

160
01:02:58.640 --> 01:03:16.319
Jersey. And and look, there there's no getting around this fact. The rise in health care costs is an existential threat to the education we provide on a day-to-day basis. I'll say it again. The

161
01:03:16.319 --> 01:03:32.960
rise in health care costs are threatening the entire system. And and that's not just here. It is everywhere. It's not just in the education sector. It's everywhere. So, it's one of those issues that's coming in our doorstep and we have to find a

162
01:03:32.960 --> 01:03:49.440
way to deal with it. So, over the past year, we were able to really find some efficiencies. We ended up with a 3.04 04 tax levy increase, third lowest amongst all 17 county school districts for 2026 27 budget

163
01:03:49.440 --> 01:04:05.520
cycle. And we also compare that to the local municipalities. I believe Bridgewater Township was 10%, Rarenboroough was 12. So when we we can talk about fiscal conservatism, but we we're really the ones that are demonstrating a level of fiscal

164
01:04:05.520 --> 01:04:20.319
conservatism here. So this budget was uh maintained right with the difficult cycle that that we talked about and um within this we redesigned our transportation. It's been ex executed simultaneously with the reconfig

165
01:04:20.319 --> 01:04:35.839
configuration of grade levels. Okay. School start times. This is one of the issues that that uh was at the forefront when I started. I believe that the district was close to to going in this direction and then

166
01:04:35.839 --> 01:04:53.039
COVID hit in 2020. So, this was something that we we made a promise that we would explore um when we were shifting grades and we took a look at everything and decided to move in this direction of a later high school start start time and um it's a

167
01:04:53.039 --> 01:05:08.559
commitment we we've made uh you know I know the board uh you know was behind this and uh along with this it required a complete redesign of our transportation and and it's not just to the high school but it's to every school in the entire

168
01:05:08.559 --> 01:05:24.240
district and again Mr. Lomsky's office, transportation office and everything. This has been quite an undertaking and um community engagement was central to the process. We did have a a public forum on one evening. Um I believe the

169
01:05:24.240 --> 01:05:41.920
board of education we asked for every single person's input before we made this final decision. Um and and here we are. So we're moving we're moving towards in this direction next year. And I do believe overall it's going to be a better shift for everyone involved. And

170
01:05:41.920 --> 01:05:58.559
and along with that, we know that that uh it is incon going to inconvenience some people, right? You can't make a shift like this and say everyone's 100% on board. They're going to be people who are vehemently against that, right? And

171
01:05:58.559 --> 01:06:14.240
uh and we have to be cognizant of that as we uh move ahead. So investing in third spaces, we know that the most critical thing for kids and and I hate to use the words COVID,

172
01:06:14.240 --> 01:06:31.680
but coming out of COVID and even now, look, there is a lonely a loneliness ep epidemic in the United States and across the world. It's well documented. We need to create these spaces. And what we mean by third spaces are areas where

173
01:06:31.680 --> 01:06:48.240
kids can interact with each other in a positive way. Whether it's a club or activity, whether it's music, the arts, athletics, etc. I'm really proud of the the programs that we have here. I'm proud of the ones that we've added, the ones we've supported. And I want to

174
01:06:48.240 --> 01:07:05.200
thank the board of education for for sharing that view that I don't think there's a single time where we've said, "Hey, we need this for kids. this group wants to do X. I I've never heard the word no from this group. And uh and you have to we should be

175
01:07:05.200 --> 01:07:21.359
proud of that. All right. That that we're working, right? Whether it was the group last week talking about the model UN. Hey, we'll we'll find a way to fund it a little more effectively. All right. can't promise I'll give 100% but we're we're going to make inroads just to make

176
01:07:21.359 --> 01:07:37.440
sure that that uh people have access to to to uh the clubs and activities that suit them. And look, one one of the positives we have as a as a large school district is I really believe there's an activity or a club essentially for any

177
01:07:37.440 --> 01:07:53.920
kid in this whole system, right? For any interest you have, there's a little niche that you could potentially find. and and uh the board of education has done an excellent job in in supporting that. And look, connecting with with our community, we have a district newsletter

178
01:07:53.920 --> 01:08:10.640
that the new format that was launched in 2025-26. Uh Mr. Moran does a great job getting that out every month. Uh it's a team effort. Again, uh the website's been enhanced. Again, Mr. Moran, uh Dr. Fonder,

179
01:08:10.640 --> 01:08:26.719
you know, lined up a a uh, you know, a company that came and took took shots of every school, and I think it's a far more professional looking uh, landing page that we have now. And and look, we've had multiple in-person uh, communications throughout

180
01:08:26.719 --> 01:08:41.040
the year. Obviously, it's something we want to enhance as we go along. And and what we've really tried to do is set up our board of ed presentations for clarity and that are accessible for all uh, community members. And um

181
01:08:41.040 --> 01:08:58.159
finally is just my my uh uh conclusion and this one and all that that that's been the motto since before I got here. I I know people came up with the symbol and and I I don't like the poem, but I I like the saying. I think

182
01:08:58.159 --> 01:09:13.279
the poem's a little much, but that's me. Um but I I want to take a moment to really express my gratitude. not not just for this year but for five years of sustained work uh from from all the

183
01:09:13.279 --> 01:09:27.839
people up here. School improvement is never easy, right? It requires all of us to look honestly at our organization with clear eyes and with a genuine level of property, right? And and in that we've got to see ourselves and what

184
01:09:27.839 --> 01:09:44.080
we're doing the way it is, not the way we wish it to be. And then having done that, we have to have the courage or the audacity to challenge people, our practices, and the status quo in the service of something better. All right? And and it's hard work. It's difficult

185
01:09:44.080 --> 01:09:58.800
conversations. And ask a great deal of everyone in this room and across the district. See, the bis the the largest misnomer, the biggest misnomer school districts have, and I've told people this, they want change, but when you get down to the real

186
01:09:58.800 --> 01:10:14.880
nitty-gritty as far as changing things, like everyone wants change. They want a change in results, but they want to keep the status quo in their process. Well, well, that doesn't line up because systems produce the results they're designed to produce, right? So it takes

187
01:10:14.880 --> 01:10:32.400
a lot to look at it and be truthful and honest and move in a different direction. So look I want to give kudos to to the uh to the cabinet to the and and it's not in any particular order to the teachers to the staff principles

188
01:10:32.400 --> 01:10:48.080
administration the board of education and uh for the w willingness to make these difficult decisions. I'm profoundly grateful to the Bridgewater Ariton community for placing their trust in us year after year to do right by their children.

189
01:10:48.080 --> 01:11:03.760
And it's been a heavy lift and I don't use that phrase lightly, but I'm thankful every day for the opportunity uh to have been a part of reshaping this district, building a culture of excellence. We're not where we want to be, but we're getting there. And creating a climate where every student

190
01:11:03.760 --> 01:11:19.840
has a chance to succeed. All right. And our promise and the promise we make to every student who walk through our doors is captured in these three simple words of one and all. All right? This isn't collectivism. This isn't some political thing.

191
01:11:19.840 --> 01:11:36.080
This is a belief that every student who walks through the door deserves a fair shot. And it doesn't matter if they're from JFK school, Crim School, etc. and and I'm going to fight for that every day that that I'm here. So again,

192
01:11:36.080 --> 01:11:56.320
it's not a slogan, it's a standard and and as we look ahead, let let us all continue to rise to meet it together. So thank you for your time. Appreciate it. >> Thank you, Mr. Beers. Anything further before we move on? >> Nope. >> Okay. >> Good.

193
01:11:56.320 --> 01:12:14.960
>> All right. We are up to committee reports section. >> Excuse me. >> Were you planning on taking any questions or >> uh if it's for clarification? >> If you have a question or two real quick. Sure. Um I know that

194
01:12:14.960 --> 01:12:31.600
you mentioned that there were an increased number of career concent or there's been an increase in the number of career concentrations and students participating in these career concentrations. So, I'm just curious, you know, how are we leveraging these career concentrations and these new

195
01:12:31.600 --> 01:12:48.960
programs uh to build effective, you know, potential public and private partnerships with businesses or organizations um to give some of these students the opportunity to maybe gain some real world real world experience or perhaps

196
01:12:48.960 --> 01:13:04.880
any sort of shadowing experiences um because they have some of these career concentrations. It's a work in progress, but it's something that we're continually working on to to add those real life experiences. We're taking this from from nowhere to somewhere. So again, we're

197
01:13:04.880 --> 01:13:21.840
going to continue to make different iterations, improve on it, do what have you. But we share the same goal, Mr. Lee, thank you for the question. Um, >> did you have one more question, Mr. Lee? >> Well, I have a few questions about different parts of the >> Yes. >> Yeah. I just want to if it's a

198
01:13:21.840 --> 01:13:36.159
discussion, fine. If it's for clarification, fine. But it we gave a presentation on really the positive things that are going on in the district. >> Yeah, I would like to talk about that. >> All right. Thank you. >> Um I do want to say I think it's great to see that the graduation rate has gone

199
01:13:36.159 --> 01:13:53.360
up to 97%. So I do want to commend our staff and our teachers for helping us reach that milestone. But I'm also curious as well, how does the district track long-term student outcomes beyond our classroom and beyond graduation? um looking at where they are in terms of

200
01:13:53.360 --> 01:14:14.400
maybe post-secary education or career um earnings, anything like that that the district tracks in particular relating to our students. And we're not unique where any institution, right, the data that you can get is how

201
01:14:14.400 --> 01:14:29.440
many kids are still enrolled in a in a two or four-year college or or uh trade school, etc. I I believe it's 18 months after you could get a certain interval. Um after that it's it's survey data which we know survey data is really not

202
01:14:29.440 --> 01:14:46.080
accurate because most times in a survey you get 10%. etc. So are we tracking our students afterwards? No, we track our students when they're here because we want to set them up for success after and and give them the springboard. So I understand >> I know if I could just interject on that

203
01:14:46.080 --> 01:15:01.840
the school I work at I think there was a federal study that was being done that had one grade level that they were going to follow >> throughout their lives wherever they went. So they came to our school and um started the study to see where they are and see where they went in their education whether they stayed in our

204
01:15:01.840 --> 01:15:17.440
district or wound up in California or I think they said they would even try to go across the world. Um I think that the funding for that was was recently cut. So, uh, un unfortunately because it sounded like a really interesting study, but I think that, uh, data is hard to find once they're out of our, uh, hands,

205
01:15:17.440 --> 01:15:32.560
but it's a good question. It's a good topic for people to think about. >> Has the district considered doing any sort of surveys, even if they're not necessarily 100% reliable, has that been something that the district has considered? >> I mean, is are you saying that we should

206
01:15:32.560 --> 01:15:47.679
do a survey? >> I'm just asking if that's something that the district has at this point. >> Um, >> all right. And then Mr. Lee, this is a pretty broad ranging presentation on a lot. >> Well, there's a lot of topics and I think the public would like to hear a little bit about it. >> Just just a moment. This is a pretty

207
01:15:47.679 --> 01:16:04.880
broad ranging uh presentation on just about every facet of the district. So, I think the board I think anyone could probably pull up any slide um and ask everyone could come up with 20 questions that they have. And I'm not saying you don't have good questions, but I'd rather not get bogged down in that right

208
01:16:04.880 --> 01:16:21.199
now, especially when we have a lot to go. And I do want to I do want to offer a an invitation which I I believe I do after every meeting and that's if if you want to go into any of these appointments uh topics in depth, make an

209
01:16:21.199 --> 01:16:37.360
appointment, come by the office. We can really get into the weeds a little bit. >> But don't you think the public should hear about this as well? >> They just did. >> Yeah. And and I'm trying to get some more clarification on those topics that you discussed because there's a lot of important things and I think it's worth considering and discussing. >> Thank you. How many questions do you have, Mr.

210
01:16:37.360 --> 01:16:52.640
I didn't count the number of questions I have. I have questions >> because I I will say this and and I know it's it's right. Let's keep them on topic and moving because I I will say this. >> We're talking about student achievement. >> Let's make sure they're high level. >> I don't think and say that this this is

211
01:16:52.640 --> 01:17:07.520
the superintendent's report. >> It's not an action item. There's not does not have to be board discussion. Uh Mr. Beers did offer to take a couple questions. >> So, may I want to ask a small question? I'm in the I'm in the middle of a a sentence, respectfully. Thank you.

212
01:17:07.520 --> 01:17:23.600
Right. Um like you just said, you have quite a quite a few questions, but that wasn't um planned for the evening. There was not a question slide on there. It's the superintendent's report. He's given his report. Is there anything further on your report, Mr. Beers?

213
01:17:23.600 --> 01:17:38.800
>> Okay. Uh if there's not if there's anything you'd like to bring up in new business and or old business that's appropriate, we can a little bit >> we can address a little bit of it later in the meeting if there's one or two pressing things you have. But again, if we went down the rabbit hole of looking

214
01:17:38.800 --> 01:17:54.480
into every single thing on that slide, which did talk about a lot of the good things that are going on, >> why not? Why not talk about it? >> We could be here for quite a while. So, uh the super >> I think I think there should be some questions that should be answered. I think the public deserves to hear about them. Um, you've made your you've made

215
01:17:54.480 --> 01:18:10.320
that point and I respect that point for the moment. We're going to move on. Mr. Beers has invited you and anyone else to talk more about it. I'm happy to be part of that of of those discussions with you, but we do need to keep the meeting move moving on and you're welcome to

216
01:18:10.320 --> 01:18:27.679
here or elsewhere. Uh, give us your thoughts about give us and the community your thoughts about that. So, uh, we are going to go to committee reports starting with the academic committee and Mr. Jooshi. >> Yeah. So the committee met um on May 18th yesterday at 5:00. In attendance

217
01:18:27.679 --> 01:18:44.239
were my were myself, Mrs. Hassuna, Mr. Walker, Mr. Pepe, Dr. Jones, Mr. Beers, Mrs. Madia, Miss Edge, and Mr. Hamburger. The first topic was the overview of explorations.

218
01:18:44.239 --> 01:19:00.239
Uh Miss Mrs. Madia, director of elementary education, reviewed the implementation of the new exploration module modules for students in grades 1 through 5. She explained that the uh period is designed to provide learning

219
01:19:00.239 --> 01:19:15.920
opportunities beyond typical or tier 1 curriculum uh tier 1 curriculum based instruction and will take place daily within the students schedule. Mrs. As Madia noted that the program is intended for all students and will focus on

220
01:19:15.920 --> 01:19:31.120
exploratory instructions and engaging learning experiences that spark curiosity and creativity. She also emphasized that the exploration period is designed to be interactive, meaningful, fun while encouraging

221
01:19:31.120 --> 01:19:51.840
students um interest and participation. Any questions on that? Uh a question on that. So no, we have the explorations. I'm just curious, are there any other districts that also offer explorations? >> Do they Dr. Jones?

222
01:19:51.840 --> 01:20:07.920
>> Yes, it's it's a form of schoolwide enrichment. So people call it all different things, but many other districts do offer a period for students wide enrichment. Yep. >> Is that a is there what other there what sort of specific districts offer it?

223
01:20:07.920 --> 01:20:23.679
>> You know what, Jeremy, I I honestly don't know off the top of my head. It's things we've looked at and then I don't remember them unless I'm okay down. I'm just curiously common. >> What what's that what kind of you know I'm just from my background because I I didn't get to see the minutes until very

224
01:20:23.679 --> 01:20:38.400
recently. I don't know the depth of the discussion that was had at the academic committee meeting, but what sort of discussion did you have about like how this would improve student outcomes and hopefully improve uh you know long-term

225
01:20:38.400 --> 01:20:56.000
student success and academic achievement >> at academic committee you're asking? >> Yeah, you talked about what we did. We gave an overview of what it actually looks like and it kind of explained here are modules and we showed some samples of what the modules are so that people

226
01:20:56.000 --> 01:21:11.360
would be able to kind of visualize it. >> Was there any kind of research that you guys did maybe that kind of illustrated, >> right? It's the schoolwide enrichment model. >> Yeah. So, I'm just going to I'm going to interject because it's a lot of questions I think you that it seems like you have your own thoughts on. So, if

227
01:21:11.360 --> 01:21:27.199
you have your own thoughts that you would like to express, I can give you some time later. But again, I'm not going point by point and saying let's name 10 other districts in New Jersey and what do they do and let's I mean unless >> No, I just want to say so it is research

228
01:21:27.199 --> 01:21:43.120
based. I do want to point out that this we just met yesterday academic committee so we had to turn this around quickly but the actual slideshows that we use which should have links and stuff in them should are in the board drive already in the committee folder. So, I know you wouldn't have had time to look at them today because like I said, the

229
01:21:43.120 --> 01:22:01.040
turnaround was quick, but you can certainly look through them. If you have questions, you can email me if you'd like. >> Okay. Any others? Nope. Okay. Item two were was the overview of Title One summer learning program. Mrs. Madia provided an

230
01:22:01.040 --> 01:22:18.639
overview of the summer learning program which will be funded through title one. The program is targeted to approximately 100 students from Adamsville and JFK in grades K through two who are currently receiving intervention services. The uh

231
01:22:18.639 --> 01:22:36.639
program will run through July. Any questions? >> Yeah, I have a similar question to before. Um I know that Title One and I'm sure this is something that you know obviously it's good that it's grant funded for students that get intervention. Um but you know what sort

232
01:22:36.639 --> 01:22:52.800
of when you look at maybe other districts where sort of the research out there, what sort of research has shown that you know some of these programs work or has that is that something that you guys looked at? >> No. Why would we ever look at research, Jeremy?

233
01:22:52.800 --> 01:23:06.800
>> What do you think? We're professionals or something who know what we're doing? No. Let me fill you in on it. >> Okay. >> There are programs that run that are researchbased. And and if I can respectfully say this, every point we we can't have an

234
01:23:06.800 --> 01:23:23.840
interrogation here. Summer programs, if you put it through your computer, summer programs and enhanced instruction and tutoring is one of the best interventions you could do for any student. Thank you. >> I'm just curious.

235
01:23:23.840 --> 01:23:39.840
>> So I would appreciate in the future >> to to walk away from the condescending tone where you're like, have you thought of it? I don't know. We have a director of curriculum with a doctorate. >> I don't know. I I >> I'm sorry. >> An assistant superintendent with a

236
01:23:39.840 --> 01:23:57.199
doctorate. No, but your questions are condescending and quite frankly, they're getting borish. So, have have we looked at research? Of course, we have. >> I'm just curious, which research? So, if you have a question, like I say all the time on the actual program to get into

237
01:23:57.199 --> 01:24:15.600
the weeds of this, you can set up an appointment and and do it. But anytime I send you that, you say, "Yeah, I want to discuss it here in public." So, now we're discussing it. It's inappropriate. >> I don't think so. >> And I I Yeah, that's your problem. So

238
01:24:15.600 --> 01:24:31.679
what we've got to stop doing, I'm not going to tolerate condescending questioning and behavior towards members of the cabinet. >> Can you explain how it's condescending? >> Okay. >> Mr. Mr. Singer has a question. Go ahead. >> No, I don't have a question. I I can explain how it's condescending because

239
01:24:31.679 --> 01:24:47.600
we have professionals here who have gone through >> I agree. >> Tears upon tears of education and are experts in their field. and you come and ask questions with no intention of actually getting the answers because while they're answering, you're still

240
01:24:47.600 --> 01:25:03.840
talking and formulating your next question. If you actually want answers to your questions, we have a board norm that says provide your questions to the administration. And the reason that we do that is so that our administration has the opportunity to investigate the questions. and you complained that you

241
01:25:03.840 --> 01:25:19.520
didn't have the time to review this today, but you've got the time apparently to make questions about materials that you didn't review. So, I'm kind of curious how how that works out. I have I'm not Please, Mr. Lee. >> We have professionals who work in this

242
01:25:19.520 --> 01:25:34.639
field. This is what they have dedicated their lives to and it's not for money. It's not for you know the adation. It's because it is a calling for them and this is what they want to do with their life. And to sit here and have someone

243
01:25:34.639 --> 01:25:53.679
say, well, I mean, is it research based? I mean, I can't I can't imagine that. >> Yes, you did. >> I asked what sort of research was looked into. >> I can't imagine asking a professional suggesting in this manner that they're

244
01:25:53.679 --> 01:26:10.080
not doing their job >> professionally. That's it's >> Yeah, but that's I never said that. That's definitely the You don't have the floor. That's that's certainly the implication, Mr. Lee. No, it's not the implication at all. >> You don't have a right now. >> So, that's the implication as I see it. And if that continues to be the line of

245
01:26:10.080 --> 01:26:25.679
questioning, I'm not going to recognize you at this stage of the conversation. >> Well, I think it's fair to ask what kind of research was observed. Can I just make one comment please just so that everybody understands how we do the application process when we um are um

246
01:26:25.679 --> 01:26:40.719
applying for these grants. So when we do title 1 2 3 4 right and we're completing the grant one of the requirements other than that you have to have a need for it and state what your need is and how you're going to identify students. It must be researchbased. It's a

247
01:26:40.719 --> 01:26:56.159
requirement of all the programs. So when we submit something, it's approved at the county superintendent level and then it's approved at the state level. So they approve it at two levels. They review all your work. And everything you do must show that it's evidence-based.

248
01:26:56.159 --> 01:27:12.800
And you have to actually cite it and provide the the links to the evidence right in your application in order for it to be improved. So I would be able to provide it if I looked up our application, but I don't have it all memorized. But that's just a requirement of all the title money that you see.

249
01:27:12.800 --> 01:27:29.600
It's checked on us in two places. >> Okay. I mean, I was just asking what kind of research. I wasn't saying did you do research. I know you did and I know you guys are the experts. That's why I want to learn exactly what came into making a specific dis decision and why the committee discussed what they discussed and what they discussed because I think the public deserves to

250
01:27:29.600 --> 01:27:43.679
hear that >> and and I think what the public also deserves >> is answers >> is a level of respect. >> Yes. at at this board and one of the board and it's also respect for this public body because one of the board

251
01:27:43.679 --> 01:28:01.360
norms and honestly norms are made up >> excuse me Mr. Lee you don't have the floor >> board norms are improved upon it's how organizations run >> it's no surprises if you have questions and we have access to information make an appointment come and see come and see

252
01:28:01.360 --> 01:28:18.480
me come and see Dr. Jones, we can figure this out, right? >> Doesn't the public deserve the >> Mr. Lee? Please stop interjecting. >> That's our board norms if you don't respect them, which which you don't. >> Well, the board doesn't either. I >> Is the public sending you questions?

253
01:28:18.480 --> 01:28:34.480
>> I'm going to stop because it's like I'm back teaching eighth grade again. >> No, no. I I just have before I >> So, there are a couple of people there. Mr. Jooshi, if I could interject real quick. Is there Let's try to stay on track here. I think this could be a discussion we could have another time. Mr. Josh, you are on

254
01:28:34.480 --> 01:28:49.920
>> um summer title one summer learning programs. Is there anything else you'd like to say about that or any questions from the board >> on? >> I'm going to move on to number three. >> Okay. >> The high school AI committee recommendations. Uh Mr. Hamburger, uh high school

255
01:28:49.920 --> 01:29:06.320
principal, and Miss Edge, social studies supervisor, provided an overview of the Bridgewwater Ren High School AI committee structure and outcomes. an AI as an artificial intelligence not the other AI. The committee which included teachers uh representing a variety of

256
01:29:06.320 --> 01:29:24.159
content areas work collaboratively to develop a clear vision guiding principles and the Bridgewwater RAN High School generative AI usage scale. In addition to committee work, focus groups and multiple opportunities for stakeholder feedback were incorporated

257
01:29:24.159 --> 01:29:39.920
throughout the process. The AI usage scale was developed as a guide for students and teachers to use artificial intelligence purposefully to enhance learning and critical thinking rather than bypassing the educational process.

258
01:29:39.920 --> 01:29:57.120
The framework provides clarity regarding when and how AI tools may be appropriately integrated into instruction while maintaining academic integrity. Item number four was textbook

259
01:29:57.120 --> 01:30:13.840
recommendation for science. The final phase of 2025 2026 grade 6 through 8 science textbook pilot which included the collection and review of student feedback was shared. Feedback was gathered from 176 students and included

260
01:30:13.840 --> 01:30:31.920
both uh quantitative survey results and written comments regarding their preferred science textbook resource. The student feedback served as the concluding component of the pilot process. Savas is the final textbook recommendation. We adjourned at 6:20 and

261
01:30:31.920 --> 01:30:48.560
our next meeting is on June 8th. >> Can I have some questions that I'd like to ask? >> Mr. Jooshi, it's your report. Would you care to take questions at this time? >> Can I ask questions? >> Miss Lock. >> Oh, I'm sorry. Miss Lock. >> Yeah, Miss Lock. >> We'll go to Miss Lock. Yep. Can can we

262
01:30:48.560 --> 01:31:04.719
respectfully keep our mic? >> Uh, so I had a question about the survey. I don't remember. >> I'm sorry. I have a point of order. I've gotten feedback from the community that are listening in and watching our feed, but the extraneous noises from

263
01:31:04.719 --> 01:31:20.320
microphones that are on from people who aren't speaking is actually distracting and they can't hear the speakers who are speaking. So, if we could all keep our microphones off. >> Okay. Thank you. >> Thank you, >> Miss Locker. I'm sorry. I know you've been waiting to get in for a while. I apologize for not calling you on your initially.

264
01:31:20.320 --> 01:31:36.320
>> You're fine. Um I could always save it for new business if I want to. >> Uh so my question was about the um I'm sorry, what was the last thing that you just >> textbook recommendations? >> Yes, textbook recommendations. I don't remember in the past that there was a a survey before. Was this a new initiative

265
01:31:36.320 --> 01:31:53.840
or is this been done before and I just don't remember? >> Okay, go ahead. >> Um we always try to survey students. So when we do pilots of textbooks, not we don't always have like every classroom. So generally, you know, you seek volunteers and you get a cross-section

266
01:31:53.840 --> 01:32:08.960
of teachers and that's actually in the board drive from last time because that's when they did the overall presentation. But what happened was um you know we had the presentation explaining the committees the what they had looked at the two finalists they had

267
01:32:08.960 --> 01:32:25.760
after having four initial you know possible textbooks they had narrowed two to two. they were leaning towards the Savas actually the teachers. So we already had that. We just didn't have the student feedback yet. So we did go back and collect the student feedback from the students who had been involved

268
01:32:25.760 --> 01:32:42.560
in the pilot. Um so we we typically do it is typically you know something that we would have >> and also the textbooks are not um you know purchased on a you know every year or two year basis. Some of these books go for years at a time. So when that

269
01:32:42.560 --> 01:32:59.520
rotation comes back, the surveys are done. So I I do remember a couple of years ago we did I forget which subject item of history I think it was >> that we did the the similar thing. >> I thought it was really helpful to see the commentary. So thank you. >> Yeah, I have a question about the AI

270
01:32:59.520 --> 01:33:14.800
committee. Uh it's good to hear that this something that the high school is considering. Um but you know obviously seems like students and teachers were involved. What are maybe some specific uh areas of feedback that you heard from students and teachers that you thought

271
01:33:14.800 --> 01:33:29.920
was maybe common between all of them? And how did that funnel into the actual framework that you guys built and discussed? And maybe talk a little bit about what that framework is um and how that applies to uh some of the learning standards for students right now in the

272
01:33:29.920 --> 01:33:45.840
high school and even across the district potentially. So one of the things um that was and I believe it's in our folder as well is uh and this was very innovative I think in that there are scales as I said in my report where

273
01:33:45.840 --> 01:34:00.719
certain um certain usage of AI will be accepted. So you know the teacher may say there is zero usage you know scale of zero that means no AI support will be um needed in

274
01:34:00.719 --> 01:34:17.520
classroom or being used by the students and so on and so forth you know level one level two where you can use some AI version of it but basically you know the the purpose of this is to have students you know like the old days you know

275
01:34:17.520 --> 01:34:34.000
think for themselves instead of relying basically on the AI component of it. Um, you know, there is such a thing, this is my opinion, there is such a thing as now, you know, too much technology, right? Kids stop thinking. So, I think what this does is basically teaches them

276
01:34:34.000 --> 01:34:52.400
that look, yes, it is a tool. Um, and it can be useful in certain extent or or certain cases, but not all the time. Um the other thing that is very interesting is the u you know the last item I read maintaining academic integrity right so

277
01:34:52.400 --> 01:35:08.400
a lot of the the reports that kids may be using you know AI for or CAD ZPT or what whatever it may be so this is you know showing kids you know limiting the the use of AI um and having them think

278
01:35:08.400 --> 01:35:23.280
for themselves instead of having you know AI do the work for them. So this is what it it's based on. >> Would you mind if I just add? >> Yeah, go ahead. >> Um, so this actually probably was initiated by the teachers at the high school because you know the use of AI

279
01:35:23.280 --> 01:35:40.320
suddenly became um so widespread that um I think people were concerned, teachers were concerned that you know people were handling it in all different ways and they wanted something that was consistent so that everybody had the same they were creating a common

280
01:35:40.320 --> 01:35:56.400
understanding across the school. So across teachers, across students, common language that they could use to discuss it. And when they so part of the work was initially done with the English and history departments at the high school and then what happened was they worked with the building principal who created

281
01:35:56.400 --> 01:36:12.800
really a steering committee across all the content areas. And so this way they got feedback of how AI looks and how it could be used across different content areas. Um and then they provided opportunities to get additional feedback from teachers. So like during the lunch periods they had focus groups or

282
01:36:12.800 --> 01:36:30.159
stakeholder feedback groups. Um the steering committee presented things at faculty meetings and basically what they came up with was their mission kind of what their vision is for how to use it some guiding principles and this is on the document that's also in the board drive again it was put there today and

283
01:36:30.159 --> 01:36:47.280
then the most exciting part was really this AI usage scale that they created and the idea is that people are going to be really intentional about intentional about how and when they're using AI. So a teacher might be a zero on the scale and say for this particular project you

284
01:36:47.280 --> 01:37:02.880
can't use AI at all. So the teacher will be able to explicitly say that to students and they'll have an understanding of the expectations. Someone else might be working at level one and you'll use it for brainstorming or creating outlines. But you shouldn't be using it to clarify or to assist in

285
01:37:02.880 --> 01:37:19.199
editing which would be you know at a level two. And it goes up through um four levels from zero to four. And this way there's this really um explicit common understanding for students and teachers so that they're talking about

286
01:37:19.199 --> 01:37:35.600
this and and everybody understands when it's appropriate and to to use AI as a tool for something >> in the uh folder if you look um there's a colorful the scale the second

287
01:37:35.600 --> 01:37:53.119
page is the vision for you know Gen AI in teaching and learning. So take a look at that as well. It's very informative why this is being implemented and what the mission of this goal is. >> Is this is this presentation something we can make public potentially for or

288
01:37:53.119 --> 01:38:10.239
make make publicly available? So >> I I think the tool will absolutely be publicly available because they'll definitely have it on the district website and you know created to connect it to the student handbook and >> that's what I was going to say that it will be added into the student handbook

289
01:38:10.239 --> 01:38:26.159
as well. >> Okay, got it. Um so I guess my understanding is that from going back to the scales that you discussed u this is up to teachers. Teachers can decide to what extent AI is used. Is there any kind of limit on the extent to which

290
01:38:26.159 --> 01:38:42.080
there is where it's like regardless it shouldn't be used to this extent? >> I I I think this might be getting a little bit when when we're delving into the classroom itself and what limits teachers have. >> I think people deserve to hear about it. I think the public >> deserves what limits teachers have and don't have. I think that's going to I think this has to filter its way down to

291
01:38:42.080 --> 01:38:58.080
the teachers and then the administration will kind of put those barriers and at that point I think if we have any questions this isn't hasn't been implemented yet officially at least >> and it's got to be a case by case basis so there's not going to be an answer >> I'm I'm just wondering is there any sort of limits that were agreed to by you

292
01:38:58.080 --> 01:39:13.520
know this stakeholders >> it's on the bottom of the document it's prohibited like when you use it without editing so you're using it like in its entirety just to solve a problem or write a paper. It's always prohibited in those instances. >> And I'm I'm just curious as well, you

293
01:39:13.520 --> 01:39:29.679
know, there's obviously a lot of guidelines here in scales. Did the committee and you know, the stakeholder group also talk about any sort of enforcement framework um for how they would enforce these scales and how they'd look for certain things that show that perhaps whatever guidance was

294
01:39:29.679 --> 01:39:45.440
provided by the teacher was being violated by a student. >> Yes. So we have already an academic integrity um procedures right and there's a document that explains what happens at each level when someone breaks academic integrity. This is the

295
01:39:45.440 --> 01:40:01.520
same using AI is like a different way to you know um >> cheating >> right but but it's not like Thank you Barry I was trying to think of the best word cheating is it >> but it's but it's not new to us right in

296
01:40:01.520 --> 01:40:17.760
education I mean I've been in education for like 30 something years and when I taught middle school I had to tell students that they were writing the papers in front of me because I didn't want them to go home and have somebody else write them. Um, and so this is not new to us. So it will still be aligned with our current academic integrity

297
01:40:17.760 --> 01:40:33.760
policy. >> Is there any kind of like I guess maybe training that teachers have done on sort of how to really look out for the signs of AI? Is that something that >> do you wanting? >> Look, Mr. Lee, >> I think I'm asking perfectly appropriate questions. to the point that was made

298
01:40:33.760 --> 01:40:49.760
before about >> kind of the >> about asking question point of the questions. Do you seriously think that the teachers are not going to be trained in an appropriate way to use this new tool? >> I don't think that's what I said at all. >> That's what was implied though. It goes

299
01:40:49.760 --> 01:41:05.679
back to Mr. Singer's point before about >> courtesy and about not being condescending not the superintendent and the assistant superintendent of curriculum. Well, are you going to teach? Are teachers going to know what to do? The answer is of course teachers are going to know what

300
01:41:05.679 --> 01:41:21.679
to do. It may not. That was what that was how I interpreted. >> That's never what I said. >> That was that that that was my take away from your comments and that's what I think a lot most people's take are. So, is there anything else on AI from somebody else before we move on or anything else on the academic?

301
01:41:21.679 --> 01:41:38.320
>> I'm done. I'd like to ask about the textbooks. Can I ask about the textbooks? >> Muna to make a comment. >> Go ahead. >> Can you please turn off your microphone first? Thank you. Um, first of all, if you would bring the questions forward, I understand that you'd like the public to be aware of all the things that you're

302
01:41:38.320 --> 01:41:53.920
thinking of, but if you would give them the questions in advance, we could all move through this quicker and the public could hear all the information because there would be time to include it in the presentations as opposed to this back and forth thing that we're going through. And in addition, this isn't a

303
01:41:53.920 --> 01:42:11.119
back and forth. Turn off your mic, please. In addition, there are 12 other people at this table. And if 12 people are giving you feedback that what you're saying is condescending or coming across the right wrong way, take that feedback personally because you are amongst peers

304
01:42:11.119 --> 01:42:26.480
here and we are telling you what you are saying is condescending. >> You can disagree, but you have 12 adults saying it is condescending with a lot more experience. So take that information back and

305
01:42:26.480 --> 01:42:40.960
>> well I I'd like you to explain how >> Okay, with that we are going to move on to the uh finance facilities and transportation committee with Mr. Singer. >> The committee met on May 13th at 5:30 p.m. In attendance was Mr. Maloney, Miss

306
01:42:40.960 --> 01:42:57.440
Lchran, Mr. Pepe, Mr. Lumsky, and Mr. Lo was also in attendance. Up first was a referendum budget update. Mr. provided an update to the status of the referendum budget by reviewing some comp some some completed projects including the newly completed windows phase 1 and

307
01:42:57.440 --> 01:43:14.320
intermediate toilet renovation projects which were closed out with a $23,000 and $53,000 allowance credit respectively. Also discussed were that the exception of the windows replacements, I'm sorry, also discussed were that with the exception of the windows replacements

308
01:43:14.320 --> 01:43:30.400
and HVAC upgrades, projects have been coming in very close to or below budget. The district is overall under budget 1.7 million and it's currently in the design phase for the high school gym and districtwide multi-purpose room HVAC upgrade bids. There was no

309
01:43:30.400 --> 01:43:46.800
recommendation at this time. Are there any questions? I have a question. Go ahead. >> Um, I'm just curious looking out. I know there's a good chunk of HVAC work that's already been done, but how much more on the HVAC side do we have from a

310
01:43:46.800 --> 01:44:04.880
referendum perspective? In general, >> we have the intermediate schools, so Hillside and Eisenhower, that's still um being designed. Uh, the multi-purpose rooms, as Mr. Stinger stated and the high school gym.

311
01:44:04.880 --> 01:44:21.840
Um I believe that's all that's >> the air handling units need to be installed, right? >> We need to have the air handling units delivered and installed or no the the AC units >> for most of the schools.

312
01:44:21.840 --> 01:44:37.920
>> Some of the schools are already in place. Okay. um the ones that are currently under construction um this summer will be starting the middle school that will just be starting and Adamsville Crim has been ongoing throughout the

313
01:44:37.920 --> 01:44:55.119
year um and is mostly complete. Um so a lot of the work has been completed um but what still needs to be awarded and designed to go out to bid are the intermediates and the multi-purpose rooms and the high school gym. >> Got it. And I'm just curious as well, I

314
01:44:55.119 --> 01:45:10.960
mean, looking at sort of our expectations and maybe there's any leading indicators, um, maybe there's been any changes. I feel like I know there's been a lot of adverse economic effects on the cost of HVAC HVAC material, but are there any indications

315
01:45:10.960 --> 01:45:26.239
or you know expectations on how much overbudget or you know probably unlikely underbudget uh you know the multi-purpose uh room HVAC upgrades and the other uh HVAC projects you discussed

316
01:45:26.239 --> 01:45:42.400
that would be coming up for bid any indication on that? My understanding is that as a referendum, you can't go over budget. You have a certain amount of money to spend and you can either then supplement with capital reserve or you can make hard decisions that we're going

317
01:45:42.400 --> 01:45:59.679
to have to look at. Right. So, for the HVAC projects, they've been coming in consistently over budget, sometimes 30%. Uh we we don't anticipate that going down. So, what as we design them and we're actually have walkthroughs

318
01:45:59.679 --> 01:46:17.040
tomorrow in the multi-purpose rooms, uh we're going to look at if we need to scale back um so that it's still completed but maybe in a different capacity um so that we can accomplish all the projects that were approved in the referendum. Once all the funds of

319
01:46:17.040 --> 01:46:33.360
the referendum have been spent, then we can utilize um district funds, capital reserve, budget it, however. >> So, I I know you guys I'm going to I'm going to acknowledge Miss Lockman. >> Can can you just give an update on >> on the overview of the budget because I

320
01:46:33.360 --> 01:46:50.239
believe that when >> that that there was room where if you're over here and under Can you just give an overall update of where we stand? >> Right. So although we're over on you know the windows and HVAC projects, we have been coming in under on renovation

321
01:46:50.239 --> 01:47:10.080
type work. So that is offsetting. So, as we come in under on all those other projects, we can then help offset the increases in the HVAC bids. >> So, I have an a follow-up question. >> Is it on is it

322
01:47:10.080 --> 01:47:25.840
>> it's on what was discussed during the committee. Um, and I know there we've been considering uh or at least the administration has obviously worked on figuring out how we can modify some of the bids. I'm just curious, you know, what kind of bed modifications are being considered or potentially being

323
01:47:25.840 --> 01:47:41.040
considered relating to some of these upcoming uh over budget potentially HVAC projects. >> I think it's a very specific question. Um I I don't know if Mr. LSK is going to have all that information at the uh at his fingertips. >> All right. Whatever information >> Excuse me. I'm in the middle of a

324
01:47:41.040 --> 01:47:57.840
sentence, Mr. Lee. Mr. LSK, would is that a question you'd like to feel now or get back to Mr. Leon? >> Microphone's on. I could shed some light on one example. Um, for a partic one particular HVAC project, we instead of choosing to completely replace the

325
01:47:57.840 --> 01:48:13.760
exhaust outlets that come out of the roof, um, we chose to keep the existing ones and just put certain adapters on them, which um, was a significant cost savings. So, we're looking at areas where if it's

326
01:48:13.760 --> 01:48:29.520
calling for something brand new, but if it's in good shape, we're going to change the specifications to keep what we have to help trim down some of the cost. So, that's one example. Um, if I don't know any other specifics really.

327
01:48:29.520 --> 01:48:45.600
>> All right. Thank you. >> Anyone else on that item? >> I'm sorry, Mr. Singer, I interrupted your report. >> Not at all. Up next was the business agenda review. The business administrator reviewed the draft business action items for tonight's meeting with special attention to the general education transportation bid

328
01:48:45.600 --> 01:49:03.040
award for the upcoming 2627 school year which came in slightly over budget primarily due to rising fuel prices. The recommendation of the committee was to approve the action items. Are there any questions? Up next was the review of the policy

329
01:49:03.040 --> 01:49:19.199
6200 and 6300 series. The committee discussed their review of these policies with brief discussion on the budget related policies as the committee felt it was relevant considering the board had just adopted the 2627 budget. Consensus was to leave the policies as

330
01:49:19.199 --> 01:49:37.119
they are and the committee will review the policy review of the well continue the policy review of the 6400 series for the next committee meeting scheduled in June. There were no other matters discussed and the ne they adjourned at 7:15 p.m. with the next meeting at on

331
01:49:37.119 --> 01:49:54.719
June 10th at 5:30 p.m. >> Right. Thank you, Mr. Singer. Now we kick it over to Mr. Walker uh with the personnel committee. >> Thank you, President Pepe. Uh Army, we met on May 12th here at the Wade building at 5:30 and attends with Dr. Fonder, Mr. Beers, myself, Mr. Maloney,

332
01:49:54.719 --> 01:50:10.560
Mr. Lee, and Mr. Pepe. The first item on first we discuss the personal addendum for this evening. Um the discussion the committee discussed the personal addenum items. Dr. Fonder reviewed specific sections of the addendum and answer questions. The committee supported the action. The recommendation was the committee support the action items. Next

333
01:50:10.560 --> 01:50:26.400
in the agenda was the reappointment of non-bargaining unit staff members. The committee reviewed the non-aligned staff staff list and the and the work and the work that informs the reappointment process. The committee also reviewed the central office administration contracts that were approved by the county circ superintendent. Recommendation the

334
01:50:26.400 --> 01:50:42.000
committee support the action items. Next we discuss the administrative structure of the district discussion. Mr. Beers and Dr. Fer discuss the administrative structure changes moving into next year including those related to the elimination of positions. Recommendation the committee supported the related action items.

335
01:50:42.000 --> 01:50:58.320
Um uh item four on the agenda was BRR BRSA sidebar agreement. Dr. Dr. Funer discussed the rationale for the BRSA sidebar agreement in relation to the next year's administrative structure and the recommendation of the committee was to support this on the action items.

336
01:50:58.320 --> 01:51:15.440
Fifth, a personal legal update. Dr. Fun reviewed the confidential legal matter. The committee will discuss it discuss the issue further at the next meeting. Um item six was substitution rates of pay. Mr. Beers and Dr. Fonder outlined the ration for increasing some of the substitution rates. The recommendation

337
01:51:15.440 --> 01:51:32.080
the committee will discuss this issue further at the next meeting. Seven other matters. Dr. Fer update the board of education about the district's job fair and the overwhelming success we have had because there are many hires that came on the evening. We adjourned at 7:02 and our next meeting is June 9th at 5:30.

338
01:51:32.080 --> 01:51:47.119
Thank >> I have some questions. >> Thank you very much. >> Can I ask some questions? >> Mr. Walker, would you like to take any questions at this time? >> Sure. I'll take one. Okay. Mr. Well, I know we we discussed this in

339
01:51:47.119 --> 01:52:04.080
committee. Um, but maybe can you talk a little bit about how raises are determined for some of the non-bargaining unit employees, which is going to be on the agenda tonight? >> Mr. Beers, go ahead.

340
01:52:04.080 --> 01:52:20.000
>> If you were at the committee, >> wouldn't you be able to let us know how that's done? This is where I get confused. like we're like there are such things as dumb questions and >> I think the public deserves to know

341
01:52:20.000 --> 01:52:35.840
>> when when you're at the committee if you'd like to comment there's a time at that at the end of of the agenda but wait you were at the committee right >> you you were there >> yes >> okay so

342
01:52:35.840 --> 01:52:51.119
you have a question about the committee that you attended and were a part of >> on the behalf of the public I think they'd like you can make a comment on your web page or whatever, but let's get on with business. >> So, I mean, it's not a difficult question, but I'd like I think the

343
01:52:51.119 --> 01:53:06.719
public would like to hear about how that's determined. >> How how does how >> Well, you'd like me to answer? >> So, you're welcome to give your thoughts, M. You're a member of this >> question and answer. >> I I >> You're a member of this board. We would love to hear your thoughts. >> Actually, I just have a point of order.

344
01:53:06.719 --> 01:53:23.520
Are we allowed to talk about the methodology for raising? >> Exactly. I can't even talk about it, but you were asking Dr. talk about it. >> Well, I didn't ask about it publicly. >> Yes. And we have not voted on it yet, Mr. Singer. That's a good point. So, we should probably uh move on from here. Uh

345
01:53:23.520 --> 01:53:39.920
especially because that could give, >> you know, >> negotiations that >> So, let me let me ask you, Mr. Let me ask on we going to move on. >> I can't ask questions. No, you had your one question that Mr. Walker. So, we're going to move on to community relations

346
01:53:39.920 --> 01:54:00.320
committee. with Miss Lockan. >> Please don't yell at me. >> It's pretty ironic. >> How was it? >> Okay, ladies and gentlemen, >> accuracy is not irony. >> Let's folks, we could please pause the cross talk if I've done any. I

347
01:54:00.320 --> 01:54:16.639
apologize, but let's stay with the agenda. Miss Lran, community relations. >> Uh, we have not had a meeting since our last board meeting. Uh but I would really like to get one on the calendar before the next one. So we'll make that happen.

348
01:54:16.639 --> 01:54:33.679
>> That'd be great. Thank you. All right. Uh we are up to liaison and delegate reports. I'm just going to jump in with one item from the burrow of Ritan. There was a uh maybe it still is a club at Bridgewater Raritan called uh Pinoise of Today, which is a Filipino cultural club

349
01:54:33.679 --> 01:54:49.679
that um uh went before the uh Burough Council in Raritan to ask them to consider opening up or closing down rather a part of Somerset Street to host a Filipino uh festival. And that was I'm very happy to say that that was approved

350
01:54:49.679 --> 01:55:05.199
uh for next October. So uh I'll be saving up my appetite for that. But it looks like an exciting event and it's good to see that our uh students are continuing to be involved in our local community not just the broader community after they graduate and there might be some students involved with that as

351
01:55:05.199 --> 01:55:22.480
well. So I wanted to uh let everyone know about that because right any other any further uh leazison delegate reports Mr. Singer >> on uh on May uh I'm sorry on May 4th I attended along with uh Mr. Pepe, Mr.

352
01:55:22.480 --> 01:55:38.560
Maloney, Mr. Jooshi, and Mr. Assuna the Somerset County School Board's meeting uh at which they honored uh Hillside's Karen Massud as Somerset County Teacher of the Year. Uh and they also recognized our own AJ Jooshi for his 15 years of

353
01:55:38.560 --> 01:55:56.880
service to boards of education. Um, as an aside, I just want want to thank the board members for attending that meeting because as we were walking up um to take a picture with Miss Massud, I heard another board member comment how nice it was that we came out to support

354
01:55:56.880 --> 01:56:11.840
Miss Massud. Um, so I appreciate everyone's being there. In addition, uh, news on the Somerset County School Boards Association level, uh, our own Miss Lan has been appointed as the Somerset County School Board's second vice president for legislation. So

355
01:56:11.840 --> 01:56:32.320
congratulations to you. Uh I don't think there's another meeting until September October. So uh and I also want to recognize we had a number of um every time we have an inerson meeting at VOTE. Uh we are treated to uh excellent food that our

356
01:56:32.320 --> 01:56:48.560
VOTE students um uh prepare and serve. And I recognize the number of them there. And uh just want to say that our students are doing a great job there. and of course in all facets of the votech. On May 16th, uh myself and Mr. Pepe

357
01:56:48.560 --> 01:57:05.040
attended the delegates assembly. I previously sent out a summary of the resolution, so I'm not going to go over them here. Um with the exception of the ranked choice voting resolution, all of the other resolutions passed and uh otherwise that was that's it. If anyone

358
01:57:05.040 --> 01:57:20.320
has any questions about those resolutions, please come see me separately. Thanks. Right. Any further uh liaison or delegate reports at this time? >> All right. Seeing uh seeing none, we're going to close uh that section of the

359
01:57:20.320 --> 01:57:36.719
agenda and move on to item number nine. Open to the public. Individuals and/or groups are invited to present their concerns, comments, and requests to the board of education at this time for any matters. In accordance with board policy, members of the board are allotted one opportunity to address the

360
01:57:36.719 --> 01:57:53.360
board for a maximum of five minutes. during this period of the meeting. And please be advised that a video recording of this meeting will be posted on the district's website. And if you could just please uh let us know your name and town of residents, it would be much appreciated.

361
01:57:53.360 --> 01:58:08.639
>> Good evening. >> Hey everyone. Um Stacy Freedellander, um longtime resident, past board member. I had to come out of retirement to be here tonight because I really want to address the continued political grandstanding

362
01:58:08.639 --> 01:58:24.880
that we're seeing during board board of education meetings surrounding such things as insignificant budget line items like therapy dogs, cheerleading choreography, and even piano tuning. These comments are being presented as fiscal responsibility, but they are not

363
01:58:24.880 --> 01:58:41.520
serious budget analysis. They're performative distractions. They create outrage over minuscule expenses that directly support students while consuming valuable meeting time that should be focused on meaningful district business, student achievement, educational priorities, and the actual

364
01:58:41.520 --> 01:58:58.880
needs of this community. At some point, taxpayers should ask themselves, what is costing this district more? A therapy dog visit or the endless speeches designed to manufacture controversy and generate political sound bites? What makes this even more frustrating is the

365
01:58:58.880 --> 01:59:13.679
hypocrisy behind it. Public records have exposed that a board member has sought financial reimbursement from the district for travel and conference expenses connected to board service despite this being a volunteer position where other members routinely absorb

366
01:59:13.679 --> 01:59:30.320
those costs themselves. Meanwhile, same individual likes to publicly lecture everyone else about fiscal conservativism like with the piano tuning and student activities. We simply cannot have somebody position themselves as the sole guardian of

367
01:59:30.320 --> 01:59:47.040
taxpayer dollars while simultaneously being the only person submitting expenses back to taxpayers. And quite frankly, this person needs to spend less time staring at his computer, drafting rebuttals, and preparing theatrical

368
01:59:47.040 --> 02:00:02.880
responses for social media clips. And if he was paying attention, he might actually hear and comprehend the comments being made by members of the public and even fellow board members. This board was elected to serve students, families, and the district as

369
02:00:02.880 --> 02:00:19.280
a whole, not to audition for political relevance through manufactured outrage and performative attacks over microscopic line items in a multi-million dollar school budget. The constant dramatics are exhausting. They're unproductive and beneath the

370
02:00:19.280 --> 02:00:35.119
level of seriousness this community deserves from its elected officials. I am seriously concerned. It's a bad look. And I want to thank those of you who are looking at me, who are paying attention, who are hearing me. I want to

371
02:00:35.119 --> 02:00:51.400
thank those of you who look at each other during meetings, who listen to each other and engage professionally. You are true colleagues. You are the representatives of this community. Thank you. >> Thank you, Mrs. Freedellander.

372
02:00:56.880 --> 02:01:14.000
Good evening. Laura Crest, >> president soon to not be of the Bridgewater Rarit and Education Association. And now and I really just probably the last time I'm going to say anything at a meeting. So I mean I can't follow that up. But I can add to the fact that yes,

373
02:01:14.000 --> 02:01:29.679
it has become much more controversial. The meetings last longer. Uh I don't find that productive. this is these aren't productive conversations that are happening. Um, and I think that probably emailing questions to the board ahead of

374
02:01:29.679 --> 02:01:47.280
time like used to be done or still is done by other members really will get the the message out to the public in a much more streamlined, less argumentative, aggressive and condescending manner. Now, having said that, I would like to move on for a

375
02:01:47.280 --> 02:02:02.400
second and just think, you know, it's been great working here for the last 26 years. I have to say that I've learned a whole lot about myself and other humans um that I will take with me. Um and

376
02:02:02.400 --> 02:02:17.119
you know, big change, right? Doing something else, moving on. So, I appreciate all of you. We don't always agree on everything, but I appreciate all of you. I think great things have happened are continuing to happen here.

377
02:02:17.119 --> 02:02:35.040
Um, and you know, Frank will be uh the next president and he'll probably show up sometime in after watching. Well, no, uh, he's supposed to show up sometime in July, but um, yeah. So, just thank you. And, uh, oh, one last thing I need to

378
02:02:35.040 --> 02:02:51.679
bring up just real quick. I mean, I I mean, I think that our building has did a good job in the heat wave the last couple of days, but I'm just kind of reaching out and saying if we could, you know, if we have another one of these heat waves, if there's a way we can,

379
02:02:51.679 --> 02:03:06.400
which I know is not a popular question, a popular statement, but maybe shorten the school day because it does get to be near 100° in the upper wings. And um although you know it's coming and I just knew I wouldn't be here when it

380
02:03:06.400 --> 02:03:22.719
happened. I just have to say. But I did get new windows. I will say that. And they're beautiful windows and there's no breeze coming through my windows that moves my overhead projector anymore. So kudos to that. Um but I will say the one

381
02:03:22.719 --> 02:03:39.440
downside to the windows without air condition is they don't open as much. And that is just the nature of the beast that this happens now, right? So, I mean, climate change is real. It's happening. It's hotter now than it's been in the last 26 years I've been here. So, um I was just throwing that

382
02:03:39.440 --> 02:03:54.639
out there because nobody's really learning anything when it's 100° and miserable. But I do understand it's a pressure on the parents too, right? To sort of, you know, make that leave that balance there. So, um anyway, that's it.

383
02:03:54.639 --> 02:04:09.840
have a great night. And uh you know, my phone now goes off now that I'm almost 60 at 9:00 to remind me to go to bed. So, I'll be here for a little while longer. But thanks everybody. >> Thank you, Mrs. Crest. Miss Crest, best

384
02:04:09.840 --> 02:04:42.159
wishes. Good evening. >> Starting my timer. Sorry. >> No, it's fine. >> Sorry. Hi, my name is Carrie Jenza. I'm a Bridgewater resident, uh, mom of four students in the district and a former

385
02:04:42.159 --> 02:04:57.360
employee in the district as well. And I want to thank you for allowing the public to share their thoughts. So, I just typed out a bunch of stuff, so I hope I don't run out of time. Um, I really appreciate the way that the district and the board handled the day

386
02:04:57.360 --> 02:05:13.199
of the shelter in place. I have a child in four building. I have one child in four separate buildings. And I did receive a text from Eisenhower. I received a text in an email. All the parents of students at Eisenhower did at 7:33

387
02:05:13.199 --> 02:05:30.000
a.m. explaining that there was some event going on. I would encourage the district to have a plan in place for a district delivered communication for any kind of events if they happen in the future. Uh that would avoided the social

388
02:05:30.000 --> 02:05:46.639
confusion that was on media social media all day. Uh I do want to point out that this meeting did conflict with the high school orchestra program. Um, and that was really heartbreaking for me as an orchestra teacher and I really wanted to go, but I thought this would be more

389
02:05:46.639 --> 02:06:03.119
important. So, um, I don't know if it if the board meetings set their meetings ahead of time and then the concerts were scheduled, but if that could just be, um, thought over for next time that the schedules are made so that there's less conflict and more people can come and speak.

390
02:06:03.119 --> 02:06:20.480
Uh, lack of communication, um, especially around the gifted and talented that we've been discussing last few weeks or months. um it does increase the frustration and it causes more opacity and less transparency. So I'm not sure how that can be improved, but

391
02:06:20.480 --> 02:06:38.320
there was a lot of frustration from parents who have children in the AI program that this was blindsiding them and that's not fair. argumentative persons in certain meetings um do waste time to piggyback on what Stacy said and it does increase

392
02:06:38.320 --> 02:06:53.280
hostility amongst the board members and the public and infighting on camera looks terrible. It's embarrassing for our district and it teaches our children, our students that this is acceptable and it is not. So that does

393
02:06:53.280 --> 02:07:09.760
need to change. I would encourage um adding a thorough typing component to the district curriculum. Our students as of right now get one to one Chromebooks in fifth grade. That will change next year. They won't, I believe, until sixth grade. But

394
02:07:09.760 --> 02:07:25.040
my children have a hard time typing because they don't know how. They've never been taught how to type. They still hunt and peck. And when state tests are administered through the computer and they have only certain number of time certain amount of time to

395
02:07:25.040 --> 02:07:41.679
type things out if they don't know how to touch type it takes them a lot longer. So I think that before we give them that Chromebook or when we give them that Chromebook part of that process is incorporating a teaching typing part of a class I'm not sure

396
02:07:41.679 --> 02:07:58.320
which class it probably technology. Um, regarding Chromebooks, we had mentioned the um, AI, generative AI features. There are still AI features on the Chromebook. And my own children, though they do have academic integrity,

397
02:07:58.320 --> 02:08:14.960
like to play around with AI because it's fun when they get done with their schoolwork and they're with their friends, they like to, you know, write silly stories and whatnot using AI to see what it can do. But it is not appropriate for those students to be able to have such access to generative

398
02:08:14.960 --> 02:08:31.840
AI. And hopefully the technology department could find a way to get rid of that generative AI in the Google homepage when they open up their Chromebooks because I do not think oh um any programs by the district faculty that

399
02:08:31.840 --> 02:08:47.840
are in use should not be collecting student data or student behavior that is used to train AI models because it exploits our children's information and their intellectual property. There are some programs out there that have been dealing with this. I don't think our district uses it, but I want to point

400
02:08:47.840 --> 02:09:04.480
that out just in case we haven't double checked. In terms of clubs, there are wonderful clubs at every building in all levels, especially the enrichments at the intermediate schools. Teachers are often reticent to commit more of their time and responsibilities, especially if

401
02:09:04.480 --> 02:09:19.679
they are not financially compensated. And even if they are financially compensated, it's time. So, um I don't know if there's a pos process to volunteer to help sponsor these kinds of activities, but I know the middle school in the past has had a DND club and my

402
02:09:19.679 --> 02:09:35.679
son has been trying to get it off the ground this year and there are no staff members willing to take on that task of advising. So, that is one question I have. Um quickly, I a curriculum recommendation. I recommend that starting in 2027, chorus be offered at third grade at all primary schools and

403
02:09:35.679 --> 02:09:51.840
fourth grade chorus should be offered weekly at intermediate schools and that education instrumental education should begin halfway. >> Thank you very much for your comment. I'm going to have to I'm have to pause you there just to be fair to everyone. If you have any further thoughts, you're welcome to email them on to the board and we'll pass them along or to ask the

404
02:09:51.840 --> 02:10:14.880
questions at the school level. But thank you for uh thank you for those thoughts tonight. >> Is there any further public comment this evening? Thank you. Good evening. >> Good evening. My name is Mary Robbins. I live in

405
02:10:14.880 --> 02:10:32.560
Bridgewater. Um I came here tonight, had some observations as as we're as I as I was experiencing tonight. And when I uh watched the video of last month, I did enjoy um the reports um Mr. Joshi and

406
02:10:32.560 --> 02:10:47.440
Dr. Jones, I I really appreciated the answers um because I really do like some of the questions. I really do. Um and I know that um one of the board members that everyone is talking about did

407
02:10:47.440 --> 02:11:03.280
receive 9,071 votes out of this community. And I think it's important to um at least be kind with each other, have some compassion. Um I like to hear other um points of view and

408
02:11:03.280 --> 02:11:19.840
argument. I mean, arguing is not always bad. Um um I'd just like to just kind of mention that and just I it is kind of disheartening sometimes to just seeing people go at it um and shut and shutting

409
02:11:19.840 --> 02:11:35.199
communication down. So, um, and and I'm thinking too that as I was sitting there that maybe there's a process gap, you know, in terms of maybe there's too many questions, um, but we want we would like to see answers and it's always good to

410
02:11:35.199 --> 02:11:53.480
know that there are references um to any of the material that is being um, presented. So, and that's it. >> Thank you. >> Thank you very much for your comment, ma'am. Any further public comment this evening?

411
02:12:08.960 --> 02:12:25.599
>> Hi, good evening. Uh my name is Andrew Bucko and uh in addition to being a resident of Bridgewater, a parent of a child in uh Bridgewater schools, I'm also uh Bridgewater Township Councilman and uh the uh Bridgewater uh council's

412
02:12:25.599 --> 02:12:43.920
uh liaison to the uh Bridgewater Ridan uh Board of Education. Um uh unfortunately time uh did not allow uh me to attend other uh meetings until until tonight. Um, but I would like to um uh reiterate the uh uh proclamation

413
02:12:43.920 --> 02:13:01.360
that uh the council was uh able to issue earlier this year in uh support of our uh school board here uh for uh school board appreciation month in January. Uh, and since it was um two weeks ago uh

414
02:13:01.360 --> 02:13:18.800
teacher appreciation week, I'd also like to reiterate uh our appreciation of all the teachers within the district um and and and to make sure uh that uh the um uh the recognition is is uh universal to

415
02:13:18.800 --> 02:13:34.239
everyone. uh not just uh home room or primary class teachers but the uh special uh class teachers as well such as art and um technology and music uh in

416
02:13:34.239 --> 02:13:52.239
the school librarians. Um they all uh work extraordinarily hard to make uh the educational experience for the uh students in our district uh a very positive one. Uh so I'd like to uh make sure that the the thanks uh is is passed

417
02:13:52.239 --> 02:14:08.320
out. Um uh and um as I said, I'm also a parent of a child in the school. And um since um uh therapy dogs have apparently become a hot topic, uh I I would like to

418
02:14:08.320 --> 02:14:22.960
um uh convey a message that I've heard from other parents um at uh at Adamsville School where uh my child is a student that they are very helpful for these students who uh who need them. So,

419
02:14:22.960 --> 02:14:40.320
um uh just like to to point that out and uh again, thank you uh very much uh both for a a successful school year uh as uh we wrap this up and uh look forward to uh even better next year. Thank you very much.

420
02:14:40.320 --> 02:15:08.079
>> Thank you very much, Councilman, and thank you for serving as liaison to our board this year. Thank you. Right. Is there any further public comment this evening? Good evening. Um, my name is Jo. My name is Joyce

421
02:15:08.079 --> 02:15:25.280
Lynn. I'm a bridge residence. Um, I kind of agree because the time of the meeting is short. So a lot of time you cannot have a question that go in so detail that but my question is let's say

422
02:15:25.280 --> 02:15:42.320
that if he the member make appointment with another member say okay I like to have a detail would that information be made public or that's just a private conversation okay that's my question >> so so ma'am at this time this is strictly public comment so your thoughts

423
02:15:42.320 --> 02:15:58.480
or concerns or ideas you're welcome to present the board but we're not able to go into a question and answer if you have specific questions you can always email us and we can answer them as appropriate if appropriate but for for this section of the meeting if you we would love to hear your your thoughts and your comments. >> Thank you. >> Thank you >> on that or anything else.

424
02:15:58.480 --> 02:16:16.639
>> Okay. And so if uh the board members made appointment with another member say okay I'd like to go through the details and uh I whatever the detail information regarding the subject right it's very important I think every every item every

425
02:16:16.639 --> 02:16:32.240
subject is important for the community so I would like to see that kind of information the private conversation will make public so people knows that exactly what the question and what the answers are. Okay, that's my idea and

426
02:16:32.240 --> 02:16:46.880
and it my second thought is it's just my personal feeling because if um sometimes you ask a question and then another party would uh interpret it

427
02:16:46.880 --> 02:17:04.479
as a condescending. Okay. And but the person that ask the question might not have the intention. Okay. So in order to have the good relationship between human beings um the um presumption of the intention

428
02:17:04.479 --> 02:17:19.439
of the other party should not put into the picture otherwise the hostility will expand. Okay. Because I would like to see the board works very peacefully and for the public of Bridgewater public uh

429
02:17:19.439 --> 02:17:37.040
residents public. So maybe just you know that's that's my own personal personal philosophy. Okay. Somebody ask me a very could be a little bit hostile question but I don't want to assume that that's very condescending because the person might not have the

430
02:17:37.040 --> 02:17:56.319
intention. That's just my personal suggestion. Thank you. Thank >> thank you for your comment ma'am. >> Any further uh comments from the public this evening? Right. Seeing none, I'm going to close the portion of public comment. And we

431
02:17:56.319 --> 02:18:12.639
are going to move on to section 10 of our agenda, which is approval of minutes. Do I hear a motion for the approval of the minutes? >> Second. >> There's a motion in a second. Any discussion? Seeing none, Mr. Lamsky, could you

432
02:18:12.639 --> 02:18:28.479
please call the role on the minutes? >> Mr. Singer, >> yes. Miss Locker, >> yes. >> Mr. Lee, >> no. On the regular session meeting minutes, yes on close session. >> Mr. Maloney, >> yes.

433
02:18:28.479 --> 02:18:45.120
>> Mr. Jooshi, >> yes. >> Mr. Walker, >> yes. >> Mr. Asuna, >> yes. >> Mr. Pepe, >> yes. The motion carries. We are up to uh approval of action items section 11. Uh we are up to personnel. We uh earlier

434
02:18:45.120 --> 02:19:00.880
in the evening approved the personnel addendum 2632. So do I have a motion for uh personnel 2633 through 2635? >> So moved. >> Motion. Is there a second? Motion and a second. Any discussion on the personnel addendum?

435
02:19:00.880 --> 02:19:15.840
>> I have a motion. >> Um well would depend on the we would depend on the topic and we'll um we can handle that as we need to. Dr. or jump in if it's a question that needs to be in uh close session if if you wouldn't mind if or if I rule the other way.

436
02:19:15.840 --> 02:19:32.319
>> Mr. Lee, go ahead. I move to postpone definitely personnel resolution 2635 approval of administrator agreements to the next regular board of education meeting during old business and to publicly release the administrator agreements with the personal address

437
02:19:32.319 --> 02:19:47.200
information of administrators being redacted for public transparency and scrutiny while protecting the private information of administrators pursuant to bylaw 0164 conduct of board meetings which requires a public agenda and public material

438
02:19:47.200 --> 02:20:02.880
to be posted for the community. >> There's a motion on the floor. Is there a second? >> Okay, seeing no second. >> Point of order. >> Yes, Mr. Lee. >> Under our parliamentary authority, Robert's rules of order section 49 col

439
02:20:02.880 --> 02:20:19.600
21 clearly outlines procedures for small boards of fewer than 12 members. And under those specific rules, motions do not require a second to be debated and voted upon. Since this board has only nine members, my motion is properly on the floor and I would like to discuss

440
02:20:19.600 --> 02:20:34.399
it. >> Okay. Um, so looking at Robert's rules, I mean, I haven't read the entire thing, but there is a section at the beginning that does talk about small boards and it gives small boards considerable latitude as to how to run their meetings within while still abiding by the precepts of

441
02:20:34.399 --> 02:20:51.600
Robert's rules. Um, I I saw the section that that you're referring to. I don't consider it a mandate and indeed this board and I think every board of education and probably every uh town council and burough council across the state requires a second to move forward

442
02:20:51.600 --> 02:21:06.880
with business. That's to ensure that there is sufficient support before taking the time of the community. >> Parliamentary inquiry. Parliamentary inquiry. >> Well, I'm sorry. I I haven't finished. I haven't given a rule yet. So, I'm going to rule that >> Turn your mic off, please. >> I'm going to rule that out of order at

443
02:21:06.880 --> 02:21:22.560
this time. Um, this board has always has always operated under the bulk of Robert's rules that a second is required to conduct business. If you'd like to bring that up at another time, we could um talk about it, but I'm not

444
02:21:22.560 --> 02:21:38.160
going to undo 100red years of precedent um just because there's something that you found uh in in that. We could talk more about it if you'd like, but for the moment um that requires a second. So, is there a >> parliamentary inquiry? I have a parliamentary inquiry.

445
02:21:38.160 --> 02:21:56.720
>> My parliamentary inquiry is that is it correct or not that according to Robert's uh that according to bylaw 0164 conduct of board meetings that we follow Robert's rules of order and the newest newly revised version. Is that correct?

446
02:21:56.720 --> 02:22:13.359
>> Yes. >> Okay. So I just cited a portion of it and you said you read it. >> Okay. And I would like to know what specific aspect >> of Robert's rules are you making your ruling as a chair based off of? >> I have made a ruling. Motions for this

447
02:22:13.359 --> 02:22:28.800
board have always run that a second is required. So unless there is a second, that motion is >> I appeal the decision. I appeal the decision of the chair. >> Is there a second on a motion to appeal the decision of the chair? Seeing none, we are moving on. Is there any further uh discussion on is there any

448
02:22:28.800 --> 02:22:44.800
discussion? We haven't had any yet on the personnel addendum. Okay. Mr. Seeing none, Mr. Lomsky, can you please call the role? >> Mr. Singer? >> Yes. >> Miss Lan? >> Yes. >> Mr. Lee?

449
02:22:44.800 --> 02:23:05.840
>> Abstain on personnel 2635. Yes. On the rest, >> Mr. Maloney. >> Yes. >> Mr. Jooshi. >> Yes. >> Mr. Walker. >> Yes. >> Muna? >> Yes. >> Mr. Pepe? >> Yes. The motion the motion carries.

450
02:23:05.840 --> 02:23:24.080
Moving on to curriculum. Uh curriculum 2649 through curriculum 2651. Do I have a motion? >> There's a motion and a second. Any discussion on the curriculum? Seeing none, Mr. Lamsky, could you

451
02:23:24.080 --> 02:23:39.200
please call the role? >> Mr. Singer. >> Yes. Miss Lockan, >> yes. >> Mr. Lee, >> no to the Carol Washler conference. Yes on the rest. >> Sorry. Can you clarify? >> No.

452
02:23:39.200 --> 02:23:58.240
>> On the Carol Washler conference. Yes. >> Folks, it's the vote. Please, no commentary during the vote. Mr. Lee, is that you you've got your vote across? >> Yes, I have it. >> Thank you. All right. Thank you, Mr. Lumpsky. Please continue continue with the role. >> Mr. Maloney. >> Yes.

453
02:23:58.240 --> 02:24:17.680
>> Mr. Jooshi. >> Yes. >> Mr. Walker. >> Yes. >> Mr. Sunna. >> Yes. >> Mr. Pepe. >> Yes. >> The motion carries. >> We're up to B. We're up to business 26127 through business 26139.

454
02:24:17.680 --> 02:24:34.880
Do I hear a motion? >> Second. >> There's a motion and a second. Any discussion on the business agenda? I have some discussion. >> Mr. Lee, go ahead. Mr. Lee, go ahead. >> Just I know this was in uh some of our notes for the board, but um I'd

455
02:24:34.880 --> 02:24:54.720
appreciate if there's any sort of clarification on what the alternatives one and two are for the revised bid for the hillside classroom innovations. >> Sure. The alternate one and two in the revision to the hillside classroom renovations resolution. Therefore,

456
02:24:54.720 --> 02:25:11.920
asbestous abatement of ceiling tile and floor tile. Um they were not originally part of the referendum, but in uh designing the classroom renovations, it was um discovered that this work needed to be done. Um as the classrooms

457
02:25:11.920 --> 02:25:28.640
would be kind of torn apart during renovations, it would have you know disturbed the asbestous. So this kind of had to be included. So, I'm I'm just curious like if we now this is just me trying to be honest here like if the district decided I guess not

458
02:25:28.640 --> 02:25:47.439
to in the beginning pass the referendum and to renovate the hillside classrooms would we still be doing this asbestous abatement right now? >> If there were any type of disruption to the floor tiles or the ceiling tiles then it would have to be done. So I I

459
02:25:47.439 --> 02:26:04.000
mean I can't >> I can't yeah predict or theorize what would happen down the road if you know we had had issues with the ceiling and a tile came loose then we would have to shut it down and abate it. So but

460
02:26:04.000 --> 02:26:18.640
there's a lot of whatifs. >> I know we have we build in contingency into a lot of our referendum projects. So, was there any contingency built in for any sort of potential asbestous abatement issues relating to classroom renovations at Hillside?

461
02:26:18.640 --> 02:26:36.000
>> There were. I know there's contingencies for um there's asbestous wrap insulation around piping for plumbing um things like that for HVAC projects. Um, I don't know the scope of how much ceiling tile

462
02:26:36.000 --> 02:26:51.680
were included, so I can't answer that. >> All right. Um, and I guess, you know, we look at alternatives one and two here that are part of asbestous abatement for the hillside classroom renovations. Obviously, as you mentioned, it wasn't part of the approved referendum

463
02:26:51.680 --> 02:27:08.319
language, but you know, I guess why was it recommended? And I guess at the last board meeting um when the board originally approved this bid, why was it still part of the referendum back in March? >> It was just the >> I think as best as causes cancer and

464
02:27:08.319 --> 02:27:22.880
getting rid of it might be a good idea. >> No, I'm not I'm not I'm not disagreeing with that. >> Cancer there, Jeremy. >> I'm not disagreeing with that. >> Okay. >> I'm just I'm just asking. I know we originally approved this and now this is a revised bid. So before it was

465
02:27:22.880 --> 02:27:39.040
originally under referendum funds, well why was it originally under referendum funds in the first place within March? >> It was just an oversight on my part and as I was looking back at the >> at our purchase order and looking at it,

466
02:27:39.040 --> 02:27:54.000
I realized that the funds are coming out of referendum which was inaccurate. So that's what the revision is for to clarify that the bid award is not fully funded by referendum and that a portion of it is capital reserve.

467
02:27:54.000 --> 02:28:11.760
>> All right. And um so I I mean it's >> Mr. I give you one more question I'm going to open up to anybody else. I'm just curious um if you happen to talk with the board attorney or bond council or even our architect of record uh relating to like formally revealing this and seeing and making sure that it's

468
02:28:11.760 --> 02:28:27.840
okay that we're now moving from using referendum funds to now using capital reserve which was now part of the original referendum. >> I did uh speak with council and um got clarification that this is allowable.

469
02:28:27.840 --> 02:28:44.000
>> Got it. All right. Um and Mr. William, I'm going to pause you there. >> Like, can I just make a point? >> I'm going to pause you there and you asked your question. I'm going to pause you there to see if there's any other uh points or questions. >> Just one thing. Um, >> as it relates to asbestous, even if it

470
02:28:44.000 --> 02:29:01.920
was not part of the referendum and ifus is found, it would have to be removed. So, the funds to remove asbestous would have to come from somewhere on an emergency basis. So whether Mr. Lomsky did did

471
02:29:01.920 --> 02:29:17.600
not, the main point is it has to be removed. Um so if a contingency was in there, I'm sure a lot of the larger projects like this do have contingency for some emergency removal and what have you. So

472
02:29:17.600 --> 02:29:31.520
I'm sure it was part of that contingency in there. >> Yes, we have a general contingency on all projects. Um but this the volume and scope of this one

473
02:29:31.520 --> 02:29:48.560
uh was just too large that we felt it's not really part of the referendum. Referendum is for the cont contingencies for kind of the unknown minor things like that. You know you remove a wall and you might expose some asbestous or

474
02:29:48.560 --> 02:30:04.640
um some floor tile gets damaged during a renovation. But this was clearly not in that little scope. >> But I guess >> I'm going to see if anyone else has a comment first. Thank you.

475
02:30:04.640 --> 02:30:21.120
>> Any further uh any other com? Any further discussion, >> Miss Lockan? >> Uh yeah, you mentioned that the um transportation bid went up. uh this is a point like it's more of a thought and then followed up with a do you agree but

476
02:30:21.120 --> 02:30:36.319
I'm going to assume that like the state of our our our current uh you know global politics is impacting the cost of a lot of different consumables in the energy world is that what is causing the

477
02:30:36.319 --> 02:30:53.200
increase in the bus contracts? Yeah, rising fuel cost and uncertainty did we believe cause the bids to come in a little higher. Um they're you know the contractors are trying to build in a cushion in case there is escalation in

478
02:30:53.200 --> 02:31:09.280
fuel cost. So that's what we believe caused it. I just I just want to note I mean now this is my belief is that this should be coming out of referendum funds because even

479
02:31:09.280 --> 02:31:25.600
if it's a big line item the reality is that the asbesus payment is related to construction related to the referendum projects. And this kind of is it's kind of like you know buying a car but you know the wheels are a non-car expense. um you

480
02:31:25.600 --> 02:31:39.920
know it doesn't necessarily make sense to me. Um, while I do support aspous abatement relating to any construction projects and I recognize that it does cause cancer, so we have to address it, you know, I'm I'm skeptical of whether it should be coming out of capital

481
02:31:39.920 --> 02:31:55.359
reserve. Um, and I and I I don't think that we should be just taking money out of capital reserves to fund things like a spec abatement that's related to referendum projects so that we can just come to the public

482
02:31:55.359 --> 02:32:12.880
and just say our referendum is on budget even though the reality is that we're actually taking a lot of money out of capital reserve to address things like asbesus abatement. Uh, that's my main concern. >> And Mr. thing. >> Yeah. Well, that's not why this is happening this way. That's a ridiculous

483
02:32:12.880 --> 02:32:29.760
statement. It's not so that we could just say that our referendum budget is coming in under. It's because this has been deemed to not be related to referendum. And to the point question that was asked before, you asked board counsel if this is the proper way to do

484
02:32:29.760 --> 02:32:46.720
it and you were informed yes. In addition, I have to imagine, Mr. Lumsky that you have some experience in business administration in here. So maybe perhaps you would be in a better position to know what should and should not come out of capital reserves than

485
02:32:46.720 --> 02:33:03.120
say me. So I defer to your judgment in that and appreciate your uh informing us of this. >> I think it's also worth noting that this does allow us to stretch the referendum budget not further but to the things that we committed to the community that we were looking to do.

486
02:33:03.120 --> 02:33:19.359
>> Any further discussion? Any further discussion on the business agenda? Mr. >> I would like to go back to my point and I talking about this referendum. I think it's important because this is you know related to finance facilities. This is just related to a district goal. Um we've been moving interest out of our

487
02:33:19.359 --> 02:33:35.840
referendum accounts to the general fund. And you know I I think that if we hadn't been doing that we would have the money in the referendum accounts to actually cover this project in the first place. And I think that I mean to bring it to

488
02:33:35.840 --> 02:33:51.840
talk about Steve Mr. Singer's point about this not being a referendum. >> This is as I said the same thing as saying we'll buy a car and now we've got to buy the wheels and the wheels are a non-car expense. >> This is referendum related. >> Yep.

489
02:33:51.840 --> 02:34:06.960
>> You disagree. Any further discussion on the uh on on the rest of the business agenda? Seeing none, Mr. Lomsky, please call the role. >> Mr. Singer. >> Yes. >> Miss Lockan. >> Yes. >> Mr. Lee.

490
02:34:06.960 --> 02:34:24.720
>> On business 26131, abstain on Venus Tile. And on uh 26132, approval of bid awards, no to the CMG bid group bid revision. And yes on the rest. >> Mr. Maloney.

491
02:34:24.720 --> 02:34:45.600
>> Yes. >> Mr. Jooshi. >> Yes. >> Mr. Walker. >> Yes. >> Muna. >> Yes. >> Mr. Pepe. Yes, the motion carries, which brings us Sorry, we have a lot of pages to flip through here. Sorry, just one moment on that. I would

492
02:34:45.600 --> 02:35:02.000
just like to uh go back and thank the Crim Primary School, PTO, for their donations of TACboards to that school. Uh very generous gift and thank you to them. Right. Moving on, I believe to special services 2632 through 2634. Is

493
02:35:02.000 --> 02:35:17.520
there a motion? >> So moved. >> Motion and a second. Any discussion? >> Seeing none, Mr. LSky, please call the role. >> Mr. Singer, >> yes. >> Miss Lockan, >> yes. >> Mr. Lee, >> yes. >> Mr. Maloney,

494
02:35:17.520 --> 02:35:32.479
>> yes. >> Mr. Jooshi? >> Yes. >> Mr. Walker? >> Yes. >> Miss Hassuna? >> Yes. >> Mr. Pepe? >> Yes. The motion carries. Moving on to other 2623. Other 2624. Is

495
02:35:32.479 --> 02:35:50.080
there a motion? >> Is there a second? >> Second. >> A motion and a second. Any discussion? We need to be in close session. Seeing none, Mr. Lomsky, please call the role. >> Mr. Singer. >> No. On other 26 24 specifically 305448.

496
02:35:50.080 --> 02:36:06.640
Yes. On the rest. >> Miss Lan. I I had exactly the same vote, but I'm just going to vote no for 2624 flat and yes to 2623. >> Mr. Lee,

497
02:36:06.640 --> 02:36:23.280
>> abstain on 2624. Yes on 2623. >> Mr. Maloney, >> yes. >> Mr. Jooshi, >> yes. >> Mr. Walker, >> yes. >> Mr. Sunna, >> yes. >> Mr. Pepe, >> yes. The motion carries. Yes, I'm

498
02:36:23.280 --> 02:36:39.359
correct. Thank you. Right. There is no policy which brings us to item number 12, old business. Is there any old business? >> I have old business. Okay. Please wait to be recognized. Is there any old business? >> Mr. Mr. Lee, go ahead.

499
02:36:39.359 --> 02:36:58.399
>> Thank you. I have a motion to rescend other 2622 denial of appeal from the April 28th meeting. >> Okay. Can you please just restate your motion one more time? So, so we're all clear. >> Motion to rescend

500
02:36:58.399 --> 02:37:16.640
resolution other 2622 denial of appeal from the April 28th meeting. >> Okay. Is there a second for that? This is something that came up at the last meeting. Is there a second? >> Okay.

501
02:37:16.640 --> 02:37:33.600
Seeing none, that motion uh does not move forward. But thank you. Right. >> I have another motion. >> Mr. Lee, what is your motion? But at some point, I'm going to start to rule these dilatory, which is allowed under Robert's rules. >> Well, they're different topics, so they're not dilatory at all.

502
02:37:33.600 --> 02:37:51.040
>> Well, no, Robert's rules specifically spells out that board members using policy and using the bylaws and using Robert's rules to obstruct. And for example, a member couldn't motion make a motion to adjurnn 10 times in a row when there's not support. So, I think some of

503
02:37:51.040 --> 02:38:08.080
these motions are not because you plan on having them enacted, but because we're looking to waste time. So, go ahead and make your motion, but just be forewarned. I may rule these at at some point dilatory. >> Well, Mr. President, I have a motion, and I actually move that the board amend policy 2464, gifted and talented

504
02:38:08.080 --> 02:38:23.120
students, for first reading with the policy language I shared with the board relating to policy 2464. Um, I just sent an email of the same copy that I sent multiple times in a row to the board. And I'd like to make that motion.

505
02:38:23.120 --> 02:38:38.800
>> Thank you. Is there a second? Seeing none, the motion does not move forward. Is there any other old business? Miss Lan, I just wanted to comment on um the security response.

506
02:38:38.800 --> 02:38:55.040
Uh, and I wanted to share that like having just experienced for firsthand from dropping my my student my my own students off at two different schools, there was just a palpable difference. And um, you could you could feel the

507
02:38:55.040 --> 02:39:10.160
seriousness uh, in which they they took that event. And I bring it up mostly because I'm just so appreciative that it was responded to in that way with that level of professionalism both by security and uh the principles in the building as

508
02:39:10.160 --> 02:39:31.680
well as the police department. So thank you for that. >> I just wanted to chime in real quick. Um I I know we had a lot of performances. Uh we heard about some of them here tonight. We've come to the end of the district's um uh performing arts, the plays and the musicals. So, now that

509
02:39:31.680 --> 02:39:45.920
they're all done, I just wanted to acknowledge everyone who was involved in, you know, Little Shop of Horrors and uh Shrek the Musical, which just took place at the middle school and the Adams family at Eisenhower and Frozen, which was at Hillside. The the time and effort

510
02:39:45.920 --> 02:40:02.000
that goes into those must have been um beyond what I could pick, significant. And the the benefit to the students involved and the happiness they had while performing in all those shows was uh really really something and um I I I

511
02:40:02.000 --> 02:40:17.680
know the community enjoyed a great number of people from the community en enjoyed them. Particular shout out to I believe Miss DeFazio at the middle school. This is her 30th production there. So I think that's worth a tip of the cap um for the great work over there and a funnier musical you'll never see

512
02:40:17.680 --> 02:40:32.960
um at least in at least for my money. Right. Any further old business? Is there any new business? >> As a new business, >> Mr. Lee, go ahead. >> Thank you. I know a member of the public um raised a couple of concerns to us and

513
02:40:32.960 --> 02:40:48.399
I would like to move to instruct the academic committee to discuss a potential or existing uh keyboard typing program or curriculum and for the committee to report back on any committee recommendations and rationale behind any potential committee

514
02:40:48.399 --> 02:41:03.600
recommendations. Yeah, I'm I'm that's a motion I am going to go ahead and rule dilatory. We don't get involved at that level. There are state standards and those recommendations come from the administration down to the academic committee. It wouldn't be appropriate for the academic committee to say we need this, we need that. So for the

515
02:41:03.600 --> 02:41:19.120
moment to discuss to discuss I'm going to rule that dilatory for the moment. I think Mr. Jooshi has heard your recommendation. I'm sure it's something we could discuss, but I don't think that requires a motion. I think that requires Hey, uh Dr. Jones, Mr. Jooshi, Mike, Mr. um would you be willing to to take this

516
02:41:19.120 --> 02:41:34.800
up? I'm sure the answer would be yes. >> We'll take that advisement. Why not? >> I'd like to was a good comment. I think it's a good point, but there's no reason for a motion for that. So, the motion's dilatory, but the point is well taken. Um especially since, you know, tests it it is a it it is a there's a disparity,

517
02:41:34.800 --> 02:41:51.359
right? I mean, districts are looking at maybe winding down technology, but testing is still on computers. So, and you know, a lot of the world is too. So, it's an important skill. So, thank you for that. Um, thank you for that comment. >> I have another motion.

518
02:41:51.359 --> 02:42:06.640
>> Go ahead. >> I move to amend Bridgewater Road and Regional School District policy 2460 titled special education by adopting these revisions. In item four, to insert

519
02:42:06.640 --> 02:42:22.160
the following bold text at the end of the clause. To ensure transparent and meaningful parental participation, the district shall provide parents with draft copies of proposed IEPs, including goals, objectives, and evaluation reports at least 5 days prior to the

520
02:42:22.160 --> 02:42:37.760
scheduled IEP meeting. and to insert a new item eight reading entirely in bold. Parents, guardians are expressly permitted to openly audio record all IEP 504 and identification meetings to ensure transparency, accurate

521
02:42:37.760 --> 02:42:54.240
recordkeeping, and mutual understanding. The right of parents, guardians to audio record shall be communicated verbally prior to the start of IEP 504 and identification meetings. To ensure transparency, parents or guardians are required to disclose that they are or

522
02:42:54.240 --> 02:43:11.359
intend to audio record meetings to strike and update all the subsequent numberings for all the clauses so that they make sense numerically and in the newly numbered item 16 subsection E to insert the following bold text at the end. These activities shall explicitly

523
02:43:11.359 --> 02:43:27.200
include training on parental advocacy rights, navigating the IEP 504 process, and fostering propar collaborative partnerships, and to strike the entirety of the old item 18 reading. The school district will not accept the use of

524
02:43:27.200 --> 02:43:43.920
electronic mail from parents to submit requests to student officials regarding referral, identification, evaluation, classification, and the provision of a free appropriate public education. and to insert a new item 19 reading entirely in bold 19. The school district will

525
02:43:43.920 --> 02:44:00.479
accept the use of electronic mail in addition to physical mail or hand delivery from parents to submit requests to school officials regarding referral identification evaluation classification. How farision how far along are you approximately? >> I'm close there. Okay. Revision of a

526
02:44:00.479 --> 02:44:15.520
free appropriate public education. The district shall treat such emails as foreign written requests triggering all applicable statutory timelines upon receipt and in the newly numbered item 21 insert the following bold text at the end of the clause. Furthermore, the

527
02:44:15.520 --> 02:44:32.720
child study team shall actively >> All right, there's a point of order. Mr. Maloney, >> turn off your microphone. Mr. According to our bylaws 0131, all proposed new and revised bylaws, policies, and regulations shall be submitted to the superintendent. The

528
02:44:32.720 --> 02:44:49.840
superintendent or design will review all new and revised draft bylaws, policies, and regulations prior to the board receiving a draft of new or revised bylaws, policies, or regulations for board consideration? >> Has this been submitted to the superintendent? >> I'm uh not as far as I know. just

529
02:44:49.840 --> 02:45:05.120
considering it came up to us just well no it hasn't come to us we have this hasn't come to anyone in writing so I'm going to sustain that objection all right uh is there any further new business >> I'm sorry >> kind of jumps on to what you were just

530
02:45:05.120 --> 02:45:22.880
talking about with um just accolades for arts programs but I wanted to make a special note that little shop of horrors u received some not um nominations from the paper mill rising star awards our our program, our actors, our scenic,

531
02:45:22.880 --> 02:45:39.040
everything was submitted and we had three people from the Paper Mill Playhouse that came out to review the show uh on three different nights and it was very exciting for the kids and very nerve-wracking. Um, but in the end, we had two mentions. First, Evan Andrews received an honorable mention for

532
02:45:39.040 --> 02:45:55.920
outstanding performance in a male identified leading role. And then >> Stanley, right? >> Oh, no. >> It's a This is a rising star award. >> Right. Right. That was the the character Stanley in the play for anyone who saw it. >> Seymour. >> Oh, Seymour. Seymour. I'm sorry. Suddenly Seymour, not Stanley. Thank I

533
02:45:55.920 --> 02:46:09.120
apologize. >> Um and then also even more exciting is Miss Nason, one of our art teachers, received um an nomination for outstanding achievement in scenic design. And that award, I believe, is

534
02:46:09.120 --> 02:46:27.040
going to be given on Tuesday, June 10th. >> That sounds right. >> I believe that's why. and we will find out if we win. Um, and in addition, all of the budget that we used to go into the amazing scenery that was put up on the stage, um, including the four

535
02:46:27.040 --> 02:46:45.120
puppets are all now for sale. So, we are trying to recoup the money, um, to put back into the budget. So, we're working on it, >> right? Is there any further new business? >> I do have some new business, Mr. Walker. Um, I'd thought about this before. or

536
02:46:45.120 --> 02:47:02.560
I'm going to make a motion to move our board of our elections to the April date. >> Can you be just a little bit more specific? >> So So moving our elections instead of the November ballot will be an April for the board of ed elections. >> Okay. Um do do you know if it's a simple

537
02:47:02.560 --> 02:47:18.000
I Well, first of all, let me see if there's a second for that. >> A second. >> Objection to the consideration of the question >> which does not require a second. >> I I agree with that. Um, so there's a motion on the floor to move

538
02:47:18.000 --> 02:47:33.600
the date of our board elections, which is currently in nove, which are currently every November, to April, which is permissible under law. I don't know what the procedure for that is. I don't know if there's any notice requirement or any specific draft language we would need to have. I don't

539
02:47:33.600 --> 02:47:50.000
know if it's that simple, but there is a motion to object to consideration of the question. >> Mr. am I correct that a motion to object to the consideration of the question requires a 2/3 majority? >> I'd have to look that up.

540
02:47:50.000 --> 02:48:06.560
>> Okay. I I can thumb through here first. >> That is I believe I believe that's correct. >> Thank you, Mr. Lee. >> So, you have to ask roll call. >> Yeah, I would just give us a second. We're confirming that that's right before we >> request two >> 2/3. So, that would uh kill any discussion at least for this meetingable

541
02:48:06.560 --> 02:48:23.680
>> on that. So, uh Mr. So there's a motion to move the election date and a subsequent motion and a second. >> Rebecca second >> and Rebecca seconded it. Thank you. And now there's a motion to object to the consideration of the question. So >> parliamentary inquiry um well it's

542
02:48:23.680 --> 02:48:39.439
actually more of a point that actually so for this is an interesting motion actually because the question is shall the question be considered. So if you vote yes, that means you want to actually consider the question. And if you vote no, that means you don't want to consider the question. So just

543
02:48:39.439 --> 02:48:54.240
>> I'm going to interpret as your original motion, which is just to keep it simple, which is an objection to consideration of the question. So if you vote yes, you want to consider or at least don't object to considering it. If you vote no, >> it stops. >> Okay.

544
02:48:54.240 --> 02:49:09.520
So there's a Do do you understand the underlying motion? >> Yeah. >> Okay. That that I think is clear. So Mr. made a motion to object to considering it. Basically, I basically interpret that as the way we usually handle this as a motion to end discussion, except it's a little bit different because

545
02:49:09.520 --> 02:49:25.439
there wouldn't be a vote afterwards. So, >> so yes, continues. >> So, yes, potenti Yes. Yes, continues discussion. A no does not does not continue discussion. Um, >> I don't I still don't understand.

546
02:49:25.439 --> 02:49:42.000
>> But if it's a motion to if it's a motion to >> object to the cons Oh, wait a minute. So I I think I understand now. >> Then yes is an objection. >> Yes. The Mr. Lee, was that your point a second ago? >> So I object to consider carefully enough. That's on me. >> Objective to consideration. So if you

547
02:49:42.000 --> 02:49:57.040
vote yes, >> yes, you are objecting. It requires two to >> Yeah. twothirds vote to stop. >> Just to be clear, >> just to be clear, >> yes, >> in this circumstances now, >> yeah,

548
02:49:57.040 --> 02:50:12.160
>> we're gonna vote on the motion to objection. >> Yes. >> Yes. Kills the discussion. Never continues the discussion. >> Yes. Thank you for that clarification, Mr. Singer and Mr. Lee. Mr. Are there any questions about that? Thank you for explaining that much better. >> Comment on that.

549
02:50:12.160 --> 02:50:28.479
>> Uh, no. No. Excuse me, Mr. Lee. I'll I'll answer the question. It was directed to the chair. Mr. Mr. LSky, please call the role on the motion to object to the consideration of the question. >> Mr. Singer, >> no. >> Miss Lockan, >> no. >> Mr. Lee,

550
02:50:28.479 --> 02:50:42.960
>> yes. >> Mr. Maloney, >> no. >> Mr. Jooshi, >> no. >> Mr. Walker, >> no. >> Muna? >> No. >> Mr. Pepe? >> No. Okay. So, that motion does not carry. Mr. Walker, would you like to comment uh discuss your motion at all?

551
02:50:42.960 --> 02:50:58.960
Well, I I'd like it's been in 2012, it changed and I think it it's time to make education a priority in the election process. It's become being on the November ballot a more of a partisan type scenario than an independent

552
02:50:58.960 --> 02:51:14.160
focusing on education and and doing it in the spring. So, in the case of the referendum, if we had done the spring, we wouldn't need the fall vote. We could have done everything in the spring if we had the April election. It also allows the opportunity. We do around

553
02:51:14.160 --> 02:51:30.160
two to five two to three two to five million dollars a year in regular operated budget capital projects and there's an opportunity to put that on the April ballot and is in the referendum style talked to discussing with Kevin that we could receive the 40%

554
02:51:30.160 --> 02:51:45.200
from the state. So we would be actually getting getting oursel a 40% plus in our our budgeting from those areas coming through the state and doing it. There's a cost associated with with the election. I understand that there's a cost associated in doing it that way. But then we can extend our taxpayer

555
02:51:45.200 --> 02:52:02.240
dollars better and also receive more back from the state. I think it prioritizes education as the ballot in April. >> I have some >> Okay. >> I I have a motion. >> Mr. Lee, please wait to be recognized. I know I know sometimes I let you jump in, so I apologize if I'm being

556
02:52:02.240 --> 02:52:19.600
inconsistent, but you have to give everyone a chance to go first. >> Microphone. >> Thank you. >> I would like to speak. Miss Locker, >> first I find it ironic that the same board member that is constantly saying they're being silenced is constantly silencing discussion of others. So I

557
02:52:19.600 --> 02:52:35.920
wish that would stop. Um Mr. Walker, uh is is the deadline for moving the election to April coming up? Is this the last board me board meeting before that deadline? Do you know? >> I'm not sure. I know that there there's

558
02:52:35.920 --> 02:52:51.279
like a certain amount of >> It's like 85 days. >> It's 85 days >> I give or take. I can't remember exactly. I didn't check all the details. >> 85 days before the scheduled election, right? >> 85 days prior to the third Tuesday in April. >> But we but we already have an election

559
02:52:51.279 --> 02:53:07.760
coming up. So we couldn't we'd be moving. >> So we couldn't do it like we couldn't do this on November like October 31st for instance. We would be too late to cancel. So, we're doing it >> the the other election >> gives also doing it this early gives people warning and heads up. So, we do be pro be being more proactive and being

560
02:53:07.760 --> 02:53:22.800
more advanced ahead of the schedule. >> If I could just say for for my part, I intend to vote no on this tonight. I would want to look and do some more research and find out the process to learn a little bit more about the process and the deadlines and the implications. Broadly speaking, my

561
02:53:22.800 --> 02:53:39.840
concern is partially coming from Raridan is that if we were to move to an April election, Bridgewwater would have an election every year. There would at least be two or three board members up in in Raridan. There's only a board member up every third year. So that

562
02:53:39.840 --> 02:53:55.200
could lead to the possibility of of of some voter confusion. At least as I sit here now, especially if we might be putting things up for the public approval of funds. There could be in any given year there could be an election for a board member, an election for just

563
02:53:55.200 --> 02:54:12.240
a just a financial question, no election, or an election for both. And I would worry without considering that we haven't had April elections in a long time. I think we would need to give a little bit more of of a heads up for me to feel comfortable about it, but I'm interested in learning more about it

564
02:54:12.240 --> 02:54:28.080
because I hadn't thought about this too much before tonight. Um, so those are my thoughts, but thank you for the motion. Mr. Singer, >> with that in mind, I'd move to table this motion. >> Second. >> Jesus. >> Okay. A very eager motion and a very

565
02:54:28.080 --> 02:54:44.720
eager second to table this. Um, Mr. Lansky. >> Well, before we do that, I have >> There could be discussion on that. >> Is it just >> I'm I'm not asking you. >> Yeah, Mr. Singer, I have a point of order. >> Okay. So, >> excuse me. I have a point of order. >> Just take take a deep breathing.

566
02:54:44.720 --> 02:55:01.520
>> No, I have a point of order. Mr. You have to hear a point of order. you have not been recognized and the chair is the one that recognizes and the chair is recognizing me. Um I am fully open to this discussion. Uh I just would like to have some information on it beforehand uh before so I don't think a vote

567
02:55:01.520 --> 02:55:17.279
tonight is appropriate. Rather than voting no on it, I would rather table it until either June or July uh discussion. >> Yeah. At the very least, I would like, at least me personally, I would like our attorney to weigh in on it to see if he had any thoughts about the process and

568
02:55:17.279 --> 02:55:33.680
anything like that. Um, so there's a motion to table. Any discussion on the motion to table? >> Point of order. Point of order. >> What's Yes, Mr. Lake. >> Point of order. The motion to table is not debatable. >> Okay. Thank Thank you for letting me know. We're But we're having a discussion and this is actually a productive one. >> I appeal the decision of the chair.

569
02:55:33.680 --> 02:55:50.160
>> Is there a second? No second. Um, we're not moving. That doesn't move forward. All right. Um, any other discussion? >> All right, Mr. Lumpsky, could you call the role on the motion to table uh Mr. Walker's motion regarding the election

570
02:55:50.160 --> 02:56:06.240
date? >> Mr. Singer? >> Yes. >> Miss Lockan? >> Yes. >> Mr. Lee? >> Yes. >> Mr. Maloney? >> Yes. >> Mr. Jooshi? >> Yes. I'd like more information. >> Mr. Walker? >> Yes. >> Muna? >> Yes.

571
02:56:06.240 --> 02:56:22.560
>> Mr. Pepe? >> Yes. say we all agree that worked out. All right. Any any further uh new business? All right. Oh, Miss Lockchan. Oh, I'm sorry. M Miss Lan, you mind if I call on Mr. Beers? He was asking >> Oh, you're pointing at Miss Lock. Sorry,

572
02:56:22.560 --> 02:56:39.439
I haven't turned this way in a while. Miss Lockchran, go ahead. I just wanted to um to address the board about a comment that was made by a member of the public where the question was if we ask questions

573
02:56:39.439 --> 02:56:56.240
does the public find out the answers or is it a closed room deal like some imply. Um, but as I've been on the board for a number of years, uh, anytime that I've asked a question, whether it was via email or phone call, all it took was

574
02:56:56.240 --> 02:57:11.520
a simple conversation and and and and if I needed an an acknowledgement in public or perhaps the chair of that committee would acknowledge those statements in public on their own. It was a simple

575
02:57:11.520 --> 02:57:31.399
matter of asking for or mentioning that acknowledgement. It wasn't this drawn out, timeconsuming, obsessive, compulsive need to control the entire meeting by one board member. Thank you, >> Mr. Beers.

576
02:57:32.080 --> 02:57:46.560
>> Thank you. there there's just an issue that's out there in the public that I feel I need to address because it it hints at potential misappropriation of dollars by our business office. All right. And and

577
02:57:46.560 --> 02:58:06.080
this has come from uh Mr. Lee. So things have been posted online uh and it's specific to uh account 1100251-61034. um where he he was commenting on we

578
02:58:06.080 --> 02:58:24.240
budgeted $17,000 for he says lanyards um but he we failed to talk about the second half of the name of that line item and it's ID badges right so it is true in a given year

579
02:58:24.240 --> 02:58:39.279
right when we give these things out to all high school kids etc we we spend approximately $1,000 on lanyards But thus far, we spent $12,950 on ID badges. They they go for about $5

580
02:58:39.279 --> 02:58:54.960
to $7 a pop. And we use this account as well to uh like we have a printer. So, you need replacement ribbon, etc. to print these out and get it done. So, I just want to clarify for the board and for the public that that the information

581
02:58:54.960 --> 02:59:10.800
that's out there is is factually incorrect. And I think that's a kind way of of putting it. Um, and and likewise, it was a perfect segue as to what Mrs. Lchran said. Instead of sending Oprah requests and doing all these things and

582
02:59:10.800 --> 02:59:28.640
creating this chaotic situation, it it's a simple uh conversation to say, "Hey, look, Kevin or or Bob, can you explain to me what comes out of this account?" and and the answer I know I receive from the business office is well of course we

583
02:59:28.640 --> 02:59:44.960
can go through this and and show you what expenditures uh come from there. So I just want to clarify that I I don't want to back and forth at all but uh I'm saying I'm being incredibly kind by saying that it's factually incorrect because I do believe it's more than

584
02:59:44.960 --> 03:00:03.040
that. And um and I I'm here look one of one of the things uh parts of my job which I actually enjoy is I'll take the arrows for the people who work in this department and and um I I just I absolutely do not like this connotation

585
03:00:03.040 --> 03:00:18.560
that somehow we're lying, we're cheating, we're doing this that or the other thing because it couldn't be farthest from farther from the truth. So Mr. Lee, I I hope you do make the adjustments to your website to make it factually correct, and I'm not looking for a back and forth. Thank you. >> I would like to address some of the

586
03:00:18.560 --> 03:00:35.760
remarks made to me. I deserve to address the remarks made to me because I >> You have not been recognized. We're like to be recognized >> for the moment. We're going to leave it at that. >> I would like to be recognized. You're not letting me explain. >> We are going >> You're just letting him talk and I can't say anything. >> Right now, you're not recognized.

587
03:00:35.760 --> 03:00:50.399
>> May be recognized. >> Is there any further new business? Okay, seeing none, we are going to move into close session item six 14 on the budget. Whereas discussion by the board is required on matters that are exceptions to the requirements that a public body

588
03:00:50.399 --> 03:01:06.560
hold its meetings in public and whereas the topics for discussion are superintendent evaluation and personnel. Whereas it is expected that the details of the discussion may be made public as soon as the issues may be acted on publicly be resolved that the board enters into close session at this time.

589
03:01:06.560 --> 03:01:22.720
Do I have a motion? Second >> motion and a second. All in favor? Uh, anyone opposed? All right, we are in close session. We will come back into close into open session at this point only to adjurnn. So, >> can we head down to the other room

590
03:01:22.720 --> 03:01:25.520
because you can kind of hear