WEBVTT

METADATA
Video-Count: 1
Video-1: youtube.com/watch?v=feO4MrgYGTg

Part: 1

1
00:07:24.400 --> 00:10:51.839
recording in progress. That was Thank you. We're ready, Mr. Mayor. Good morning. I'd like to welcome everyone to the July 7th, 2026 commission meeting. Uh, first and foremost, uh, thank you for being here

2
00:10:51.839 --> 00:11:06.880
with us. Uh, there will be ample opportunity for everyone to engage in the process. either you can send an email, many of you are here in person, uh you can also get engaged through Zoom, but most importantly, we're incredibly grateful that you're here to

3
00:11:06.880 --> 00:11:24.480
enjoy and to partake in our democracy. So, thank you so much for being here with us. Moving on, today we have a special invocation. uh we don't have um a member of the clergy to join us, but we have somebody who's just as equally important and a person who I have an an

4
00:11:24.480 --> 00:11:40.399
immense amount of admiration and respect for and I actually love her a lot. A person who I brings me a smile to my face every time I have the opportunity to see her and that is from the city clerk's office, our deputy Yolanda Davis. Sometimes I wonder I've told you before I prefer you more more than I

5
00:11:40.399 --> 00:11:56.800
prefer the clerk. So that's okay. He won't get mad. He won't get mad. He won't get mad. It's okay. >> Good morning. >> Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Good morning, honorable mayor, vice mayor, commissioners, Mr. Manager, Madame City

6
00:11:56.800 --> 00:12:12.959
attorney, city clerk, in the audience, those in the audience, and those participating by Zoom. I pray you all had a wonderful Fourth of July with family and friends celebrating this

7
00:12:12.959 --> 00:12:28.079
great country, the United States, we call home. Thank you for the honor of standing before you to give the invocation. Galatians 5:13 states, "Serve one

8
00:12:28.079 --> 00:12:43.839
another humbly in love." Philippians 2:4 states, "Look not only to your own interests, but also to the interests of others." Heavenly Father, we thank you for this

9
00:12:43.839 --> 00:13:01.519
day and our elected officials and come before you humbly asking for your forgiveness of our sins and wisdom to guide these proceedings. Grant them clarity and sound judgment on every item

10
00:13:01.519 --> 00:13:17.040
before them today. We know these decisions aren't always easy, but with your guidance will serve the good of this community. Thank you for the sacrifice of time and

11
00:13:17.040 --> 00:13:34.079
family that public service requires. Help everyone in this room and participating on Zoom to act with humility, integrity, and respect, especially when there is disagreement,

12
00:13:34.079 --> 00:13:50.079
so that together we pursue the greater good for all. Bless the city of Coral Gables and all who live, work, and do business here. In Jesus' name I pray. Amen. >> Amen. Amen. Madame Deputy Director,

13
00:13:50.079 --> 00:14:06.800
thank you so much as always. As we move on to the pledge of allegiance, uh, I'd like to have the vice mayor read a dear friend and resident, Judge Snook's introduction and bio, which I think everyone here will be very proud to call him a resident here once you hear his bio and his engagement

14
00:14:06.800 --> 00:14:22.399
here in the city. As we con continue this transition in our commission meetings, we are honored to recognize individuals whose service to our nation and community reflects the very best leadership, patriotism, and civic responsibility.

15
00:14:22.399 --> 00:14:36.480
This morning, we are proud to welcome Judge Thomas W. Snook, a distinguished veteran, attorney, and jurist, and a longtime civic leader in Coral Gables. Judge Snook graduated from the United

16
00:14:36.480 --> 00:14:54.480
States Coast Coast Guard Academy in 1967 and began his military career as an icebreaker at US uh CGC Estito out of Boston, participating in two Arctic missions to break ice and

17
00:14:54.480 --> 00:15:11.279
resupply fuel air force base in Greenland during the height of the Cold War. Although he had anticipated an assignment in to Antarctica, the Vietnam War changed those plans. In 1969, he submitted what

18
00:15:11.279 --> 00:15:28.880
he has described as a five-word wish list that simply read, "Any ship going to Vietnam." He was subsequently assigned as damage control assistant aboard the USG USCGC

19
00:15:28.880 --> 00:15:46.720
Bendota and served on combat patrol off the coast of Vietnam. It was during that deployment that he dedicated decided rather to pursue a legal career later saying he wanted to bring about change within the system.

20
00:15:46.720 --> 00:16:02.800
The Coast Guard later sent Judge Snook to law school in his hometown of Syracuse, New York, where he graduated with honors from Syracuse University College of Law and served as editor and chief of the Syracuse International Law

21
00:16:02.800 --> 00:16:17.680
Journal. Over the course of a remarkable 26-year Coast Guard career, Judge Snoop held numerous leadership positions, including assignments on Governor's Island during the nation's bsenial celebration,

22
00:16:17.680 --> 00:16:34.079
government appellet council at Coast Guard headquarters in Washington, DC, staff judge, advocate for the 8th Coast Guard District in New Orleans, chief trial judge for the Coast Guard. and finally staff judge advocate for the

23
00:16:34.079 --> 00:16:49.680
commander of the Atlantic area before retiring from military service in 1993. Following his military career, Judge Snook settled in Coral Gables, practiced maritime law and later served as a US

24
00:16:49.680 --> 00:17:04.480
United States administrative law judge with the Social Security Administration until his retirement in 2016. Today he continues his dedication to public service as the immediate past president of the Gable's good government

25
00:17:04.480 --> 00:17:22.000
committee, the immediate past president of the local chapter of the military officers association of America and a member of the Mamey Dade Commission on Human Rights. Judge Snook, thank you for your extraordinary service to our nation, your lifelong commitment to

26
00:17:22.000 --> 00:17:35.840
justice and public service, and your continued leadership with the Coral Gables community. It is truly our pleasure to invite you to lead in the pledge of allegiance. Thank you. >> Thank you very much.

27
00:17:35.840 --> 00:17:55.200
Please stand if you are able. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and

28
00:17:55.200 --> 00:18:14.640
justice for all. >> Thank you very much, >> judge. We have You're not done yet. Okay. So in addition, we have a token of of thanks for your participation in today's pledge of allegiance. I want to thank

29
00:18:14.640 --> 00:18:31.600
you for the friendship that you've given to everyone in this community uh and leadership for the next leaders to uh be on this commission. So if you if you mind, I'll I'll come meet me. I can come to you. We know you're

30
00:18:31.600 --> 00:19:46.320
very athletic, so Let's take a photo. Now we move on to America's semiquentennial moment. I'd like to invite Joanne to please join us. Again, for many of you who are not aware of what we're doing is over this 250 year

31
00:19:46.320 --> 00:20:03.280
anniversary, the greatest country in the world, we're celebrating important moments in our history. And we have individuals that join us at every commission meeting over the over this year uh to make sure that we have this moment memorialized and we get these experiences on record. Thank you for

32
00:20:03.280 --> 00:20:18.640
being us with us this morning. >> Thank you. >> If I may, as we continue our semiquentennial moments at commission meetings, as I've said, it is especially fitting to welcome back a familiar face and a true friend of Coral Gable's history, Joanne Meager. Many of you will

33
00:20:18.640 --> 00:20:33.360
remember Joanne for her tremendous work in helping bring us the Merrick moment during our city's centennial year. Through those presentations, Joanne and the volunteers of the Mira House governing board helped us reflect on the people, places, and stories that shaped

34
00:20:33.360 --> 00:20:49.280
Coral Gables over the past century. Today, we're honored to welcome Joanne back as part of our semi-quincentennial moment as we continue expanding that reflection from our local history to our national story. This morning's presentation is especially timely as the

35
00:20:49.280 --> 00:21:05.360
Coral Gables Museum recently opened local leadership national legacy Coral Gables mayors across the century. The exhibition recognizes the 25 individuals who have served as mayors of Coral Gables and connects their leadership to a broader American story.

36
00:21:05.360 --> 00:21:22.080
As a nation commemorating 250 years of independence, this exhibit reminds us that democracy is not only shaped in Washington DC or in the state capital. It is also shaped right here in our cities through civic responsibility, public service, and a commitment to community. And we saw that right now

37
00:21:22.080 --> 00:21:38.320
with Judge Snook as a prime example. For over 100 years, the mayors of Coral Gables have helped guide the city beautiful through moments of growth, challenge, and transformation. Their service reflects the strength of local government and the important role that cities play in preserving and

38
00:21:38.320 --> 00:21:55.400
advancing the ideals of our great nation. Joanne, thank you for once again helping us tell the story of Coral Gables in such a meaningful way. We are grateful to have you with us this morning and we look forward to hearing today's semi-quentennial moment. >> Thank you.

39
00:21:55.520 --> 00:22:11.120
>> Here's a little image of our very first mayor, Edward Doc Dammers. The theme running through the Coral Gables Museum's semi-quincentennial mayor's exhibit is that our city's leaders have worked through times of

40
00:22:11.120 --> 00:22:27.440
challenge and times of change. Perhaps our first mayor, Edward Doc Dammers, did both. Dammers, the showman, described as the iron man of real estate, conducted all of George Merik's land auctions. He

41
00:22:27.440 --> 00:22:45.440
was the only mayor to be elected by unanimous consent by the brand new city commission formed in 1925. He faced the challenges of establishing governance practices and municipal services in a newly incorporated city

42
00:22:45.440 --> 00:23:02.480
and in very short order dealt with the changes brought on by Miami's railroad embargo, a three-month Miami Harbor blockage when the Prince Valdemar Brigantine ran a ground in government cut and the 1926 hurricane. Construction

43
00:23:02.480 --> 00:23:20.000
floundered. Miami's boom had become a bust. But Dammers had the management skills, the energy, the bulldog tenacity for the job. At the peak of Coral Gable's promotion, he had overseen a national sales force of 3,000.

44
00:23:20.000 --> 00:23:37.200
Journalist Theodore Wel described him thusly. Edward Dammers, enormous and genial, humorous and shrewd, was a man with more experience of living than 10 men would have if rolled into one. Before we had

45
00:23:37.200 --> 00:23:53.200
been talking for two minutes, he knew exactly what I wanted and why I was there. And in three, he had signed my papers, shoved a handful of cigars into my pocket, clapped me on the back, and waved me cheerfully away, and was already signing more checks and

46
00:23:53.200 --> 00:24:08.880
conducting a shouting conversation with a salesman about another land deal. In a 1927 photo, which will come up in a moment, uh Doc Dammers demonstrated his cheeky style, dressed in Spanish

47
00:24:08.880 --> 00:24:26.240
military uniform, he penned a sentiment to his friend, George Merrick, and signed it from his mayor, the best mayor Coral Gables ever had. At that time, the statement couldn't be refuted.

48
00:24:26.240 --> 00:24:40.640
Thank you. >> Thank you, Joanne. As always, it's a pleasure to have you here and uh we're beyond grateful for your commitment to the city. Beautiful, especially what you're doing with Mer House. Um two quick points before we give a nice little token of appreciation to Joanne.

49
00:24:40.640 --> 00:25:02.480
If you haven't visited uh the Mer House, uh I had the pleasure of taking our pages who are here with us today. Please rise pages to be recognized for pages. So, the PACE program is a program that I started a few years ago here in the city of Coral Gables and it's continued to

50
00:25:02.480 --> 00:25:19.200
grow. Um, and these are tomorrow's future leaders. They're rising stars. Some of them are joining us for a second year like I see the gentlemen in the back and uh we welcome you here and thank you for all the hard work. Especially thank you to staff, our ACM, our DCM and our manager. Thank you for making this an incredible experience.

51
00:25:19.200 --> 00:25:34.799
So, they went to see the Merit House and they were incredibly impressed and I joined them and I want to thank our staff, our public works team, our construction team, the manager. Uh, thank you for making the corrections that were required that we had talked about over the last two years. Um, at

52
00:25:34.799 --> 00:25:51.279
the Mer House, it's never looked better. It was amazingly well put together, clean. Uh, some of the some of the pending issues that were addressed, we had a leaky roof, we had a leaky chimney that was addressed, the drywall had been damaged. So, I want to thank you for that. Uh, thank you for that hard work. And the second thing is I have a small

53
00:25:51.279 --> 00:26:43.520
token of appreciation for you. May I give it to you and have the commission take a photo? Just a a moment of personal privilege. Back in May, the Pelican Harbor Seabird Station made a presentation and um the

54
00:26:43.520 --> 00:27:01.279
hope is that the city has the commission has um given given thought to that and we look forward to hearing about the city's support. Just a reminder, the ask is $5,000 per year. So, I'm hoping we will

55
00:27:01.279 --> 00:27:17.600
hear soon. Thanks. >> Thank you very much. First, I'd like to say a few words before we move on to the agenda about the devastating earthquake in Venezuela. The city of Coral Gables is collecting donations at all four Coral Gables fire station support relief efforts through

56
00:27:17.600 --> 00:27:32.720
global empowerment mission. Um, I've made a request and thank you to the manager and the DCM while the manager was away on the ACM uh for moving expeditiously. Uh, thank you to Chief Dear Rosa. I'm not sure if he's here. Oh, he's in the back. Uh, thank you with

57
00:27:32.720 --> 00:27:48.559
your entire team, all the firefighters. Uh thank you for your hard work. Uh we moved very very quickly. Uh you guys moved heaven and earth and we were able to deliver on an opportunity uh to really uh get as much support as possible. Thank you to Martha Panting who's in the back along with the entire

58
00:27:48.559 --> 00:28:03.919
IT team uh for getting the message out there very very quickly. With South Florida being home to many Venezuelan families, the crisis is deeply personal to many in our community. Several employees have friends, relatives, or loved ones who

59
00:28:03.919 --> 00:28:19.120
have been impacted by this horrible tragedy. Everyone is encouraged to donate new unopened approved emergency relief supplies to any Coral Gables fire station. Donations will be transported to Venezuela through GEM. Uh this morning, uh we had our first initial

60
00:28:19.120 --> 00:28:36.000
pickup and the firefighters uh told us that it was, you know, a good show support that they were actually impressed with the amount of uh the amount of support that was provided by residents here in the city. beautiful. Uh we're we're an incredibly blessed community. I mean, Coral Gables, the city beautiful. We have so much to give

61
00:28:36.000 --> 00:28:51.600
thanks for. So, this is the moment to just take a few seconds when you stop by Publix or Milums or Whole Foods or Trader Joe's. Hope I didn't miss anybody. Um just buy an extra canned good, you know, buy something on the list, drop it off at a fire station.

62
00:28:51.600 --> 00:29:09.039
Just remember how blessed we are to live in the greatest country in the world. uh we have so much and at a moment when people are in pure despair, panic uh in Venezuela, it's an opportunity to give back to that community. So, thank you to our firefighters, to our city manager, ACM, DCM, Marta, Banting, and all the

63
00:29:09.039 --> 00:29:26.240
all the members of our community who who have been so gracious and have uh really stepped up to the plate to make sure that we can move quickly and get these donations in place. So, thank you very much. Uh moving on to our first item on the agenda, item A1, presentation of a

64
00:29:26.240 --> 00:29:43.520
resolution of condolence to a bereief family of of Daniel Rau. Mr. Ramul, will you please join us? I'd like to read a quick resolution on the record and then I'd like to hear from Olga Ramulu, a dear friend and a resident, a person who uh

65
00:29:43.520 --> 00:29:59.279
she's not only a colleague but a person who I hold in incredibly high respect who has is involved in countless amounts of boards and uh chambers and is constantly engaging in just the benefit of the community. Your only interest is make pushing Coral Gables forward. Um,

66
00:29:59.279 --> 00:30:15.039
and I felt that uh on multiple occasions when we invited from prime ministers to uh ambassadors, you're front and center. You're making sure that their visit here along with Belkis and her entire team is just flawless and you're making the city

67
00:30:15.039 --> 00:30:32.080
corables look, you know, again like we always do because of the hard work of individuals like yourself and Belie's team. So, you deserve all the credit. Whereas the community mourns the passing of Daniel Ramulo, a beloved resident of Coral Gables, Florida, whose warmth, dedication, and zeal for life touched

68
00:30:32.080 --> 00:30:47.360
all who knew him. And whereas Danielle built a distinguished career marked by dedication and versatility from his years as a trading associate in New York to founding his own real estate technology venture. And whereas Daniel's greatest joy in life was the time he

69
00:30:47.360 --> 00:31:04.720
spent with his daughter, a bond that he cherished above all else. And whereas in more recent years, Daniel found particular joy in working alongside his mother, sharing in what in that special bond and partnership. And whereas Daniel posed an adventurous and curious spirit,

70
00:31:04.720 --> 00:31:20.559
delighting in discovering new restaurants and exploring new places, embracing travel as a way of experience, experiencing the richness of life. And whereas Daniel's kindness, warmth, and love for those around him leave a lasting impression on his family, friends, and all those lives that he

71
00:31:20.559 --> 00:31:35.120
touched. Now therefore, be it resolved by the commission of the city of Coral Gables, Florida, that we extend our deepest consol condolences to the family and loved ones of Daniel Ramudo, and that we join together in celebrating a life well-lived, filled with hard work,

72
00:31:35.120 --> 00:31:52.480
love, curiosity, and connection. and a witness whereof I have here unto you placed my hand and caused the great seal of the city of Coral Gables to be affixed on the 7th day of July 2026. >> Thank you very much. Um my son lived,

73
00:31:52.480 --> 00:32:09.039
worked and played in Coral Gables just like me. He loved this city and I know that this moment would be very very loved by him. Thank you. and uh he went fast, but I'm sure he's up above looking

74
00:32:09.039 --> 00:32:25.519
at us and thanking you all. Thank you, >> Olga. This is just a small resolution of condolences for your son. I had the pleasure of spending time with him. We broke bread. Um super smart, kind, um even in some very

75
00:32:25.519 --> 00:32:40.000
difficult moments that he had in his life, he was always resilient. He always had a smile on his face. And I think that's a testament to the incredible person that you are. Thank you. >> Um, well, I'm very sorry that I wasn't able to uh to make uh the funeral. I

76
00:32:40.000 --> 00:32:56.000
apologize. I was out of town. Um, but this is the simplest gesture that we as a city can give uh to honor his legacy and to honor the hard work and um he has a beautiful daughter uh that will continue that legacy and that is

77
00:32:56.000 --> 00:33:12.399
something to hold on to tight and to look in her eyes and always remember uh your incredible son. >> Thank you. So on behalf of the city, we extend our deepest condolences to your family. >> Thank you very much. >> Thank you. >> We love you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Want to take a quick photo, please? May

78
00:33:12.399 --> 00:34:32.159
we May we take a photo, >> please? Item A2, a presentation or proclamation declaring July 2026 as Taste of the Gables Restaurant Month in the city. Beautiful. Good morning, Bis.

79
00:34:32.159 --> 00:34:47.679
>> Good morning. Um, we're here for TASA Gables. July 1st started. Um, if you haven't been to the website, please go taste thegables.com. Just want to get that out of the way. Um, so Taste the Gables has become one of Coral Gable's signature summer

80
00:34:47.679 --> 00:35:04.560
initiatives designed to drive businesses to our restaurants, specifically in the very um, slow months that we have. Um, so this year marks the fourth consecutive year that we've had Taste the Gables. When we started, we had 30 restaurants. We currently have 75

81
00:35:04.560 --> 00:35:20.960
restaurants participating. Um, and the reason, of course, that we did it again is because we wanted to get our restaurants through the slower months. And what we've learned from them is from those that did take the survey um last year, they said that 70% uh 70% of those that took the survey

82
00:35:20.960 --> 00:35:38.320
said that their uh revenues went up 5 to 20%. And in the summer months, that's that is um that is very good. And some saw even more of an increase. So, like I said, 75 restaurants. It's really a great way to uh experience Coral Gables

83
00:35:38.320 --> 00:35:55.599
and everything that we have to offer. Um there are prefixed menus. Something that we're very proud of this year is that the department secured more than $24,000 in uh sponsorships and that's in kind and also cash donations. So, we were able to use that money to promote the

84
00:35:55.599 --> 00:36:12.320
city in a in a in a more uh higher light. I do want to recognize um our partner that is here today. So um it's also an introduction to you all of you. Um Gloria Bayz uh is the new VP of the Chamber of Commerce and she's here with

85
00:36:12.320 --> 00:36:28.560
us. Um and we also have the a couple of restaurants that are here. Cojen, I don't see him right now as chef, but um we have Aromas Peru that are here and uh let them have cake as Stephania was supposed to Oh, there you are. if I can

86
00:36:28.560 --> 00:36:45.119
have you come up as well for a second Peru as well. >> And so um I just want to have Gloria if it's okay mayor to say a few words. >> No great. >> I want to welcome you to the city beautiful. We had a pleasure of having multiple conversations. >> Yes. >> And it's a real blessing to have you here in the city.

87
00:36:45.119 --> 00:36:59.920
>> Thank you so much. I am so honored to be here. Thank you mayor, vice mayor, commissioners, um and the rest of the city. On behalf of the chamber and the board, I just want to say that our partnership with the city is is magnificent and I truly look forward to

88
00:36:59.920 --> 00:37:15.520
working with all of you individually and collectively. So, thank you. >> We want to hear Also, by the way, don't be shy. By the way, I don't know if you've had this young lady's cakes. I had the I had the opportunity to cut the ribbon at her at her uh establishment.

89
00:37:15.520 --> 00:37:32.480
It's on located on Alhamra. Um, and let me tell you, I've ordered from them before. Amazing amazing cakes. delicious cakes. She I'm You're an architect. >> You're an architect, correct? >> Yes. >> I remember that from about two years ago when we cut the ribbon. >> Yes. >> And she's more of an artisan than an

90
00:37:32.480 --> 00:37:48.800
architect. She is amazing. Amazing at what she does. Uh and if you haven't eaten at Ama de Peru, one of the best the best restaurants here we have locally. Uh delicious and it's also very healthy food too also. I enjoy it. Uh so please uh make sure you go out there and

91
00:37:48.800 --> 00:38:04.320
try these incredible restaurants. The floor is yours, please. >> Yeah. Well, I let them have cake and as the mayor was saying, um I I love to work with sugar flowers and design cakes. Um but I guess after this meeting, all of you will need some some

92
00:38:04.320 --> 00:38:21.040
cake, some cookie, uh coffee. So, you guys can walk over there. Hope to see you there. >> What is the exact address on all? Uh >> it's 367 Alhhamra Circle. >> Yes. And by the way, they have coffee there also. >> Yes, we have coffee. We have tea. >> I feel like I'm part of like your team. I'm like selling it. >> Yes, exactly.

93
00:38:21.040 --> 00:38:37.520
>> I just want They're not just selling cakes and cookies. You can stop by there and have a coffee. You can enjoy yourself. It's in a great location on Alhamra. Make sure you go there. I've stopped by for coffee >> through the mayor. So, so you don't get too singled out. You know, I've been there many times and my wife is a huge fan as well. And you you did come in

94
00:38:37.520 --> 00:38:52.160
with the save because while the the pastries are excellent, I'm a big fan of the coffee. Yeah. Right. You got that beautiful machine that's very well uh administered by your barista. So everyone should check it out on Alhhamra right by the the globe, you know, not too far from there. >> Appreciate that. Yeah. Yeah. The shop is

95
00:38:52.160 --> 00:39:09.599
super cute and I marketing it is hard, but yes, I would appreciate if people came by and, you know, um got to sit there. Uh we really did a a hard work with um making it super cute and super pink and everything is super nice and girly. >> Very welcoming. >> Yes, very

96
00:39:09.599 --> 00:39:24.560
please. >> Hi, good morning everyone. Um how are you mayor? >> Good to see you. Thank you. Um, so I mean we're we're so excited to be part of, you know, news trip here in Geralta. Um, I think that the Taste of Cables is

97
00:39:24.560 --> 00:39:40.960
super creative and something new. It's bringing in so many people. I have a lot of clients and guests who are coming in that are so excited over the opportunity. I think what what we're doing here is almost a better version of Miami Spy, but something a little more locally. >> Sorry. >> Yeah. Uh, and I just welcome any of you

98
00:39:40.960 --> 00:39:57.280
who want to come and visit us. We'd be super grateful to have you. Yes. and it's been 16 years we're here in Coral Gables and we hope to keep being here for even longer. Thank you. >> Do you want to talk a little bit about your move? Your your >> Oh, yeah. >> I just want to make sure I mean I visit your restaurant so I just want people to know that you're no longer at the same

99
00:39:57.280 --> 00:40:11.920
location. >> Yeah. >> So, we we opened in 2010 in Pon Leon, the location here next to Target. And we moved about 7 months ago to Geralta, right next to Lucereio. Uh so we've been there. It's been phenomenal. The foot

100
00:40:11.920 --> 00:40:27.520
traffic that that we have is amazing. I mean, the works that you guys do just to bring in more foot traffic. It's absolutely great. I mean, I I can't complain. I'm I'm so grateful. So, thank you so much. >> By the way, if I may, thank you for giving us credit for the foot traffic

101
00:40:27.520 --> 00:40:44.240
and I worked on the manager deserves all the credit for Hialda. He was there first day. I was with him at 10:00 at night as we were working. It was really miracle mile that first day when we were there, but it was part the project miracle mile were the same project. the streetscape project, but you deserve all the credit. Let me tell you why. So,

102
00:40:44.240 --> 00:41:00.000
thank you for giving us credit on Hialda and all the programming that Belkis does and Martha and all our team does. That's a great thing. But your food is amazing. >> Thank you. >> The quality of your food is amazing. Now, you have an amazing setting because you have you had a you had a location that was already built out and you

103
00:41:00.000 --> 00:41:15.359
basically now are able to enjoy that. You don't have to spend too much money on that. The second gen space, so it's really nice. Um, but your food is top-notch. The quality is impeccable, the ambiance, the service. I slip in and

104
00:41:15.359 --> 00:41:30.880
slip out. I go eat I eat there. If I want something healthy, if I want to eat some fish, it's really really good. So, I want to congratulate you on on if you're a restaurant owner and you had a restaurant for almost 20 years. It's a testament that you that you're doing something right. So, uh continue to work

105
00:41:30.880 --> 00:41:46.400
with the chamber uh that we I have a I think the chamber has an incredible bright future uh under Gloria and the new team that we have there. So um I'm excited that both of you could join us. We have two different spectrums. We have dessert and we have a main course. So uh thank you Belis for all your hard work.

106
00:41:46.400 --> 00:42:01.920
>> Thank you so much everyone. >> Well I do have the proclamation but I do want to commend each each one of you. You know our economic development department belies Perez as well as the chamber because we're blessed in our city that we have a chamber that works

107
00:42:01.920 --> 00:42:17.599
with our city and city that works with the chamber. That doesn't always happen. Uh where you have put the businesses on a pedestal basically and understand that this is critically important for the economic uh health of our city all the

108
00:42:17.599 --> 00:42:34.000
way around and attracting great businesses like this. Our economic development pro uh department's done a great job. Our mayor has done a fabulous job of introducing our city to many many companies that have decided to make this

109
00:42:34.000 --> 00:42:49.760
their home for both their employees and their businesses. So without further ado, I'll I'll read the proclamation. And whereas the city of Coral Gables is renowned for its vibrant culinary scene, featuring a diverse array of restaurants

110
00:42:49.760 --> 00:43:05.760
that contribute significantly to the local economy and community. And whereas the month of July has been designated Taste of the Gables Restaurant Month, an annual activation aimed at driving business to Coral Gables restaurants during the traditionally slow summer

111
00:43:05.760 --> 00:43:21.599
season. And whereas this year marks the fourth year of Taste the Gables program under the economic development department's showcasing of the city's commitment to supporting local businesses and promoting culinary excellence. And whereas Taste the Gables

112
00:43:21.599 --> 00:43:38.560
offers an extraordinary opportunity for residents and visitors alike to explore the city's dining establishments with more than 75 participating restaurants in 2026, including Michelin Star and local favorites offering specially priced Pix

113
00:43:38.560 --> 00:43:56.960
Fix menus and exclusive promotions. Whereas there's there is no cost for restaurants to participate in this program, ensuring that all local dining establishments have the opportunity to benefit from increased visibility and patronage. Now therefore, I Vince Lago

114
00:43:56.960 --> 00:44:12.720
as mayor of the city of Coral Gables and on behalf of the city commission do hereby proclaim July 2026 as Taste Gables restaurant month. Congratulations and let's take a picture. >> Thank you. Thank you so much.

115
00:44:12.720 --> 00:45:39.599
>> I do want to point out uh my staff, so Salange Lopez and Danielle Cordova, they have to input all of those pictures and menus manually. So, I just want to give them a shout out. Moving on to item A3. Congratulations to Lieutenant Carlo Milito, recipient of

116
00:45:39.599 --> 00:45:55.760
the City of Coral Gables Firefighter of the Month Award for the month of July 2026. Chief, you have two items. Item A3 and item A4. You want to take them both? >> Yes, take them both. >> Thank you. >> So, good morning, mayor, ladies and gentlemen of the commission. Uh, I'd

117
00:45:55.760 --> 00:46:11.760
like to just echo what you said earlier. Thank you for the recognition, but I'd like to thank our residents for putting out uh turning out and providing all the supplies. Uh, everything that we succeed in this city is usually and and for the

118
00:46:11.760 --> 00:46:26.640
most part, and that's what makes us unique, is a team effort. So, as you stated, I'd like to thank Martha who spearheaded the communications and our police and fire PIO's, our firefighters for uh receiving and making sure that

119
00:46:26.640 --> 00:46:42.560
all the uh supplies got to station one and our public works and green space that not only provided the truck, but are on our way to deliver the first round of supplies to Venezuela. So, it's

120
00:46:42.560 --> 00:46:59.280
definitely a unique city as to how everyone bands together for the same cause. >> I just want to echo what you just said right now, but I want to make it very, very clear. Um, the tax collector and myself had a conversation. We immediately, Dar Fernandez and I were

121
00:46:59.280 --> 00:47:15.920
talking back and forth about doing something here in the city. I immediately called the manager, the DCM, um, that evening in the ACM and we had a conversation, said, "What can we do?" The next day we had an on-site meeting with Laura and Martha Panting and the IT team. We put together a quick clip. We

122
00:47:15.920 --> 00:47:31.440
got it out there and everything was rolling. So I, you know, our our staff moves incredibly quick, cohesive under the leadership of the manager and um I don't think any other city can move as quickly as that. We had I think we had that conversation man was like 9:00 at night, 10 o'clock at night. Uh and the

123
00:47:31.440 --> 00:47:47.440
next day we were set for an 8:00 meeting at the fire station. So, um, that's a testament, uh, to the manager's leadership, to your leadership, Mr. Mr. Chief, DCM, ACM, and the entire team, all the employees, all directors, every single one of the firefighters here, uh, that was present that obviously had paid

124
00:47:47.440 --> 00:48:07.920
played a hand in this. So, thank you for that. >> And I'd just like to welcome Chief Aardo back. He had deployed with Task Force 2 and he returned late on Monday. So, with that, I'd ask uh Chief Jones to

125
00:48:07.920 --> 00:48:23.520
present our firefighters of the month. >> Good morning, everybody. It's always a pleasure to highlight the amazing work that is done by our staff. And today, we want to highlight uh two individuals that serve as a team. I once read a

126
00:48:23.520 --> 00:48:39.680
quote that says, "You don't go as far as your dream, you go as far as your team." These are two exceptional individuals that has done amazing work in our newly formed emergency medical services division. Most recently, uh because of

127
00:48:39.680 --> 00:48:56.480
their preparation and attention to detail, uh these individuals ensured that we not only had a site inspection by the state of Florida, but ensured that there was zero deficiencies. uh and in addition they have identified

128
00:48:56.480 --> 00:49:24.720
areas of process improvement as well as efficiency and have excelled in that area. So today we'd like to highlight Lieutenant Carlo Molo and Captain Christina Musera. >> Morning. Good morning, sir.

129
00:49:24.720 --> 00:49:40.960
>> Good morning, commission. Uh, councilman's, thank you so much for the honor. Um, truly honored to be here today. And I'd like to thank first and foremost my wife and my daughter in the back. Good job. >> Um, and chiefs and everybody here to

130
00:49:40.960 --> 00:49:59.480
gave me the ability to do what I do every day here. I took a lot of pride out in the streets now and in administration. um delivering that to our new recruits and everybody throughout the department. So with that, I say thank you.

131
00:50:03.920 --> 00:50:19.040
>> Not a great public speaker, but I will do my best. I'd like to thank Chief Del Rosa and Assistant Chief Jones and Assistant Chief Lero um for their outstanding leadership and dedication. I appreciate the opportunity and trust they've extended to me to serve as EMS captain for Corg's fire. I also

132
00:50:19.040 --> 00:50:34.400
appreciate Chief Fletcher and Lieutenant Alto for their guidance and support. We couldn't have accomplished as much as we have in the last seven months without them. Receiving Firef is an honor that reflects the great team I work with and I look forward to continuing to serve this department and this community. Thank you. >> Thank you to both of you for your hard

133
00:50:34.400 --> 00:52:24.240
work. Thank you so much. >> Let's take a quick photo. Item A5. Congratulations to Officer Christopher Challenger, recipient of the City of Coral Gables Officer of the Month for the month of April 2026. And we also are going to do item A6.

134
00:52:24.240 --> 00:52:40.400
Congratulations to Officer George Bennas, recipient of the city of Gable's officer of the month for the month of May 2026. Good morning, Chief. >> Good morning, Mayor. >> Good morning, Vice Mayor. Good morning, commissioners. Um,

135
00:52:40.400 --> 00:52:58.160
first up will be officer Challenger. Um again, we appreciate this forum to be able to give some just a little bit of taste of what our officers do on a daily basis. And uh in this case, Officer Challenger. Back on April 14th, 2026, a

136
00:52:58.160 --> 00:53:13.680
he responded to a burglary in progress at 5526 Majority Street. Uh the homeowner revised they were not home, but they received the alert on their on their u zoom the Ring camera. Um she described a subject who was wearing a

137
00:53:13.680 --> 00:53:30.559
white hoodie and a black had a black beard and two brown backpacks that was trying the back door of the home. Subject fled prior to the officers arriving. Officer Challenger uh looking at uh getting the bolo started to look around the area and

138
00:53:30.559 --> 00:53:46.720
found a subject in the area of 400 block of Ko Avenue that matched the description. Uh the victim was brought over, positively identified the subject. Uh officer Challenger read him Miranda and he waved his rights and he asked the

139
00:53:46.720 --> 00:54:02.079
subject what he was doing. He said he was hungry looking for food. So due to his great observation skills and his detective skills, he was able to apprehend this subject and take him into custody. So for that, he received officer of the

140
00:54:02.079 --> 00:54:27.839
month for April. Thank you uh chief command staff uh commission for having me up here, Mr. Manager. I also want to thank uh Sergeant Saledo and uh Lieutenant Guasto for nominating me for officer of the

141
00:54:27.839 --> 00:54:45.200
month. And as with anything with the with our police department, it's a team effort. Uh pretty much I just happened to find him first. But even if none of us found him that day, uh one of our officers identified the subject the day

142
00:54:45.200 --> 00:55:01.440
before and conducted an FI, that was uh officer Castanada who was also on scene. And not only did he identified him, he was with his uh his trainee. U when he heard the call go out, he shared a photo

143
00:55:01.440 --> 00:55:17.200
of the guy. So, it was pretty easy to to find him along with the help of Officer Molina. And honestly, uh, Lieutenant Bayana, if he were 5 seconds quicker, he'd be up here accepting this nomination cuz he

144
00:55:17.200 --> 00:55:33.520
was right behind me. So, it's a it's team work and I appreciate it. Thank you very much. Every >> to the mayor. >> Yes. >> Officer Challenger, thank you so much for your service. I don't think it's a surprise to anyone that the police holds a very special part in my heart, but you

145
00:55:33.520 --> 00:55:48.960
in specific have sacrificed and served this community with all your strength and I want to thank you for that. I've saved these centennial coins for very special moments and for very special people and I have one for you today. Not

146
00:55:48.960 --> 00:56:05.359
only a centennial coin, but I also I'm also giving you the 250 coin. So, if you would, I have a little note in here for you. Congratulations for being named officer of the month. Thank you for your outstanding service and dedication during the city centennial celebration

147
00:56:05.359 --> 00:56:22.559
and the 250 anniversary of the United States. Your your professionalism and commitment are sincerely appreciated. Thank you so much for your service. >> Thank you. I appreciate that. >> I'll give it to you when we're taking a picture. >> And and before I go, I just want to say another shout out. Thank you to Aaron

148
00:56:22.559 --> 00:56:39.119
Glasser who's with uh he just left but he's behind the scenes with every officer of the month. Uh he celebrates it every year. Officer of the year. He doesn't get enough notoriety but uh the police department, the FOP, everybody

149
00:56:39.119 --> 00:57:03.839
appreciates Aaron Glasser. Thank you. Our next recipient is officer George Brenice. He was nominated for May of 2026. Officer Long, between April 21st and the 30th, a total of about 20

150
00:57:03.839 --> 00:57:20.000
incidents were generated in an area involving property crimes. Uh subject was going through the backs of residents off the golf course. He was uh going into cars and there was several cases that we identified through the subject.

151
00:57:20.000 --> 00:57:35.920
There was a he was identified in one photo and we were able to put out a probable cause flyer for him. We looked in that area. We put together different groups. We had the drone flying up all of this uh areas. We were still searching for the subject. And then on

152
00:57:35.920 --> 00:57:54.400
May 6th, Officer Brenis was at the uh 350 Bird Road at the 7-Eleven. He was still on writing assignment with his field training officer when he observed a subject walk into the store and recognized him immediately from the flyer. Uh the subject was detained.

153
00:57:54.400 --> 00:58:12.000
Search incident arrest uh revealed that the offender was in possession of several credit cards IDs and he was subsequently placed in arrest by the detectives. Officer Bren Brennes is a new officer who is still on writing assignment whose

154
00:58:12.000 --> 00:58:28.720
his sense of keen awareness and thanks to him to the intel from the detectives along with training by his FTO led to the apprehension of prolific criminal to the city of Coral Gables. I believe in the end we closed about 14 cases involving this subject. Uh he not only

155
00:58:28.720 --> 00:58:51.680
uh had broken in here, he was on Miami Beach, city of Miami, several of these cases. So our closure helped them close their cases. For his efforts, he's recognized as officer of the month for May 2026. >> Hello. Good morning. >> Good morning.

156
00:58:51.680 --> 00:59:09.040
>> That's Sunday. >> Morning, sitting officials, deputy chief, command staff, fellow officers, and guests. I'm standing here to receive officer of the month. so early in my career is an incredible honor to which I'm humbly accepting. I

157
00:59:09.040 --> 00:59:25.119
know for a fact I wouldn't be standing here without the incredible support system I received around me. We were able to identify that subject within an hour. And without that identification, we would have never apprehended him. To my FTO's, Detective Rivera, Officer

158
00:59:25.119 --> 00:59:42.319
Becker Rosalt, and Officer Louis Lopez, thank you for your patience, setting rigorous standards, and sharing your wisdom and passion with me. The award and recognition is a direct reflection of your membership. To our command staff and city officials, thank you for your leadership and providing us with the resources to do

159
00:59:42.319 --> 00:59:58.640
our job effectively and for placing your trust in me. This award may have my name on it, but it belongs to several officers as I rely on the support of my fellow officers daily. That day, I was riding with Lewis Lopez and officer Alex Rodriguez. Without them, I would have not been able

160
00:59:58.640 --> 01:00:15.839
to do it. We set up sort of a perimeter. We blocked the back exit, the front door, and one went in and apprehended. It was a teamwork effort. No incident could have gone could have gone the wrong way, but it went it was very smooth. Luckily to them, I'm proud to

161
01:00:15.839 --> 01:00:38.079
wear this uniform, proud to serve the city of Coral Gables, and I look forward to continually serving our community each and every day. Thank you all. Thank you to both gentlemen. Uh great work. Officer Challenger Brenis, thank you so much for your hard work and uh making sure that we can sleep easy at

162
01:00:38.079 --> 01:02:06.920
night knowing that your hard your team is working out there uh in pursuit of all these criminals and making sure that uh again uh this is the safest place to live not only in South Florida but in the country. So, thank you for your hard work. Thank you. before. Thank you.

163
01:02:10.720 --> 01:02:25.839
Moving on to item 87. Congratulations to Javier Romero from the city manager/communications department, recipient of the part-time employee of the second quarter for 2026. Sir, >> mayor, vice mayor, commissioners, uh Jose Rodriguez, assistant HR and risk

164
01:02:25.839 --> 01:02:41.599
director. Um, we're going to continue with the employee recognition. So, this is the best part of my job. We get to recognize employees on a quarterly basis. So, for our part-time employee of the quarter, we have Javier Romero. He actually joined the city last fall. He's a part-time producer and editor. He was

165
01:02:41.599 --> 01:02:58.480
nominated by Martha. Martha wrote a phenomenal nomination. So I'm gonna have Martha come up with Javier so they can be recognized. >> Congratulations. >> So as Jose said, Javier joined us recently, but he has something that I

166
01:02:58.480 --> 01:03:15.839
can't teach. He has great initiative. So as part of his in part of the examples of his initiatives are when we started having the meetings here he thought we were didn't like how the drop thing looked back here and before we got the

167
01:03:15.839 --> 01:03:32.240
curtains he was the one that came up with the solution and we actually got it done in less than 24 hours. He also came up with to us with the idea of having a fun educational series for Instagram and

168
01:03:32.240 --> 01:03:49.839
social media called Did You Know? And it highlights and city pro programs etc. like what green space management does or uh and other examples. And this is a good way to

169
01:03:49.839 --> 01:04:08.079
educate our residents about programs that the city does do but that we can highlight them for social media. Uh in our conference room uh we had cables running down the floor. We were having people coming over here uh for meetings

170
01:04:08.079 --> 01:04:23.119
and he took it upon himself to get that done. So one of the greatest things of having an employee is one that has his own initiative and we are really lucky that he joined us recently. So thank you

171
01:04:23.119 --> 01:04:43.839
Javier. Of course. >> Yeah, it's a it's a little odd to be in front of these cameras. I'm usually behind them. Um, but first and foremost, I want to thank Martha Pantene for this nomination and for her exceptional leadership. She plays such an important

172
01:04:43.839 --> 01:04:59.680
role in guiding the work that we do, and I'm incredibly grateful for her support. Um, I also want to thank Michael Rocha for his mentorship and guidance and all of my incredible colleagues who I have the privilege of working with every single day. Each of you has helped me grow and get me to where I am today. To

173
01:04:59.680 --> 01:05:14.799
my friends and family and my amazing girlfriend, thank you for always pushing me to be the best version of myself and for supporting me every step of the way. And to everyone here and the entire city of Coral Gables, thank you for the privilege letting me do this job. I'm truly grateful to be a part of this

174
01:05:14.799 --> 01:06:23.039
organization to be recognized in this way. So, thank you. >> Congratulations. Welld deserved. Let's take a photo. Moving on to item A8. Congrats to Robert Chang from the parking department, recipient of the employee of the month

175
01:06:23.039 --> 01:06:40.079
for April 2026. >> So our, as you said, mayor, April winner is Roberto. He comes to us from the parking department. He's a parking enforcement specialist with nearly 20 years of service. So employees are often nominated for going above and beyond and this is a very unique case of going

176
01:06:40.079 --> 01:06:56.559
above and beyond. So um I'm going to call up Martha. So >> Monica >> so she can tell the unique story of of how Roberto went above and beyond and is deserving of this reward. So Roberto if you could join us. >> Good morning.

177
01:06:56.559 --> 01:07:10.880
>> Good morning. >> Monica Beltran director parking sustainability and mobility services. First, I want to start by thanking all of you for this wonderful program. It's not every day that our staff gets to

178
01:07:10.880 --> 01:07:27.599
come out here, uh, look at our leaders and share a moment. Today, in particular, some of my employees here, our employees here are rather new to the city, having joined us in the last two, three months. so they get a taste of

179
01:07:27.599 --> 01:07:44.319
what a commission meeting is and also of the appreciation that we have for the work that they do. And I'm going to take this moment to remind them that more than an enforcement officer that does parking and preserves parking for the use of residents and visitors and

180
01:07:44.319 --> 01:08:00.079
businesses that we're also ambassadors and we're out there to make a difference. Robert Chang um on or about 9:30 in the morning was driving his vehicle um city vehicle to get washed.

181
01:08:00.079 --> 01:08:15.839
He saw a a he heard a honking coming from a school bus. It was about 9:30 like I said and he stopped. Now, nobody else had stopped. He stopped and he got closer

182
01:08:15.839 --> 01:08:32.480
and realized there was a child in this bus that was trying to get people's attention for about 2 hours. It was 7:40 or so. The child told him he had been left in the bus. The driver had gotten

183
01:08:32.480 --> 01:08:50.960
out. He apparently fell asleep and but the driver apparently was aware that he was there. But anyway, left and left the child in the bus with the doors secured. Officer Chang stopped, got out, pried

184
01:08:50.960 --> 01:09:05.679
the doors open, and got the child out. He was crying and nervous, etc. Now, imagine the parent not knowing where this child was. So, Officer Chang called the parent,

185
01:09:05.679 --> 01:09:23.600
called his supervisor, who called PD, and it was all coordinated. Officer Chang then tried to appease the child, offered to buy him food. The kid was hungry, called the parent again to

186
01:09:23.600 --> 01:09:40.719
find out if the kid had any food food allergies so that he could get him something. and he stayed with the child until the mother who was very desperate and crying um came to the scene. Now if this had happened in a peak heat or hot

187
01:09:40.719 --> 01:09:57.480
day um the child may not have survived. So many people drove by but nobody was aware enough to stop and render aid and for that officer Chang is recognized today.

188
01:10:03.920 --> 01:10:20.239
Good morning. Thank you. >> Thank you for going above and beyond. Uh it's truly a pleasure. We've had the pleasure of meeting before along with all the employees behind you who do an amazing job on behalf of the city. So I want to thank you for your hard work. um

189
01:10:20.239 --> 01:10:37.360
who knows um the damage that could have been caused by leaving that child any longer uh inside that school bus. At the end of the day, it could have been one of these brutally hot days. Uh we got very lucky that you were there. Uh and that luck comes with the pride that you take in

190
01:10:37.360 --> 01:10:52.080
being an employee here at the city of Grog Gable. So, we're beyond grateful for that. And uh this is just a small token and a and a gratitude on behalf of the city. Thank you uh for you know taking that extra step you know making an extra you know corner you know not

191
01:10:52.080 --> 01:12:12.800
just doing your scope of work but you know doing what we here in the city of Coral Gables uh are known for which is going above and beyond. So thank you for that sir. Thank you very much. Moving on to the final item before we take on approval of

192
01:12:12.800 --> 01:12:28.640
minutes. Item A9. Congrats to Jose Var from community recreation department, recipient of the employee of the month for May 2026. >> Sir, Jose Var comes to us from the community recck department. He is the aquatics manager. So, he's come up through the ranks of the Venetian pool.

193
01:12:28.640 --> 01:12:44.719
Um, starting as a lifeguard, coming as assistant supervisor and now he's the manager of the pool. Um, he's a pleasure to work with. You know, we do a lot of recruiting, a lot of hiring for the pool. So, working with him, it's a pleasure working with him. He was nominated by Karolina, our ACM. So, I don't know if she wanted to join us.

194
01:12:44.719 --> 01:13:11.440
Yeah, she she wrote a very nice nomination as well. Um, so if you could, Jose, please join us. Be recognized. Sorry, I I apologize that I jumped before the director, but this is very very personal and uh long overdue. Um

195
01:13:11.440 --> 01:13:26.960
earlier this year, and this is very very rare, in uh January, he reached out to have lunch and share some news with me. And uh that news was that you know he had worked on a different career path

196
01:13:26.960 --> 01:13:44.239
for the last couple of years and made the decision that it was time to leave the city. But he understands the responsibility and training his new staff and his replacement and said he would give the city a 10 months notice

197
01:13:44.239 --> 01:13:59.600
before leaving us which is extremely rare. So, he's worked very hard to find his replacement and like I said, this recognition is long overdue. So, I wanted to make sure he is recognized before he leaves the city. And I wanted

198
01:13:59.600 --> 01:14:20.080
to share some words about Jose and what he's accomplished with the city. If you will let me. Jose's commitment to aquatics, public safety, and public service is deeply rooted and dates back to his earliest days on learning how to swim at the

199
01:14:20.080 --> 01:14:37.440
Venetian pool under the toutelage of our very own Venetian Aquatic Club members and volunteers. He carried that experience forward and paid it back by serving as a Venetian Aquatic Club aid where he spent many summers volunteering his time and

200
01:14:37.440 --> 01:14:52.400
teaching swim lessons. This work is especially meaningful as swim instruction remains the number one preventative measure against drowning. That early dedication to water safety has defined his career and continues to

201
01:14:52.400 --> 01:15:09.120
shape his leadership approach today. For more than a decade, Jose has been entrusted not only with the stewardship of one of our most iconic, historic, and hightraic facilities, but also with the safety and well-being of thousands of visitors who pass through the pool each

202
01:15:09.120 --> 01:15:26.080
year. This is a significant responsibility and has consistently met with professionalism, vigilance, and a deep sense of duty. His leadership has ensured that safety remains the top operational priority while maintaining a welcoming and enjoyable environment for

203
01:15:26.080 --> 01:15:42.719
all patrons. Beyond his operational excellence, Jose's commitment to his team is equally noteworthy. He is an individual who fosters a culture of accountability, mentorship, and continuous improvement. He leads by example, investing in the development of

204
01:15:42.719 --> 01:15:59.520
his team and encouraging to pursue training, certifications, and professional growth opportunities. His emphasis on education as a driver of innovation has elevated not only his own performance, but that of his entire aquatics team. Jose's dedication to the

205
01:15:59.520 --> 01:16:14.400
city is evident in his proactive approach to challenges, his willingness to go above and beyond, and his consistent pursuit of excellence. He has positioned himself as a forward-thinking leader who embraces new ideas, best practices, ensuring that our aquatics

206
01:16:14.400 --> 01:16:31.000
operation remain both safe and progressive. In every respect, Jose exemplifies the values of public service, leadership, and innovation. His contributions are invaluable, and he is most deserving of this recognition.

207
01:16:35.040 --> 01:16:52.640
>> All right. Well, good morning. Uh, very humbled to be here. Uh, I'm on season 18 of the show. So, uh, the original cast, most of them are already gone. But, uh, I couldn't ask for a better team blessing, family, co-workers, or anything. I've I I have nothing to say

208
01:16:52.640 --> 01:17:17.760
except thank you. This, uh, all these years have been a blessing, and I'm very happy and proud to be here. Thank you. Mr. Var, we wish you God speed, good luck in your next adventure, and hopefully, God willing, you you'll join us soon again. >> Thank you.

209
01:17:17.760 --> 01:19:13.440
>> Thank you. There you Okay. All right, moving on to the approval of minutes. B1, regular city commission meeting of May 19th, 2026. May I have a motion? >> I'll move it. >> A second. >> All in favor? >> I >> I.

210
01:19:13.440 --> 01:19:30.400
>> Item B2, regular city commission meeting of June 2nd, 2026. May I have a motion? >> I move it. >> May I have a second? >> Second. >> All in favor? >> I >> I >> I. Moving on to public comment. First speaker this morning, Jess

211
01:19:30.400 --> 01:19:51.199
Osborne. For those who will be appearing, please remember to state your name and address for the record. And also, please, I'd like for everyone to be concise and also to be aware that if you speak on an item during public comment and it comes up later in the

212
01:19:51.199 --> 01:20:05.920
agenda, we won't give you a second bite of the apple. So, >> thank you. >> Thank you for respecting the city's time and your time. >> Absolutely. >> Good morning. >> Good morning, everybody. Thank you for having me. Uh my name is Jess Osborne. Um I'm a resident of Miami. Uh my

213
01:20:05.920 --> 01:20:22.800
pronouns are they and he and um uh born and raised here in Miami. Uh graduate of M. Uh living and working in and around uh the current area. Uh sorry, excuse my demeanor. I'm a

214
01:20:22.800 --> 01:20:41.040
little sick. But I'm here to speak about um LGBTQ protections for our residents here. Um especially as being a member of the of that tribe. Um, uh, I want to thank you for having a really good score on the HRC's MEI, um, index of 92. Um,

215
01:20:41.040 --> 01:20:57.360
and I'd like to keep and and uphold those protections for folks like myself and my team. Uh, it is currently being threatened by SB 1134, the anti-Dei. Uh and so I just like for the council, the city, uh my team here who is also

216
01:20:57.360 --> 01:21:13.199
going to speak just to be um aware of what's happening and uh get creative on how to uh keep those protections. Um it doesn't just affect LGBTQ people, it affects everybody, all types of minorities. Um

217
01:21:13.199 --> 01:21:28.719
I'm also a proud Hispanic American. uh and um I'd like to add that uh the importance to this is every uh what I'd like to try to say is uh I've also traveled a lot around the

218
01:21:28.719 --> 01:21:45.199
world and what I have gathered in my years is that no matter who you are, what your culture is or your political affiliation, uh everybody just really wants love and safety and I'd like to um see that reflected in our city's laws.

219
01:21:45.199 --> 01:22:02.080
so that um people feel that um in their community. Um I' I'd like for um politics to not get dangerous and change the way that um I need to live um especially being from here. There's no other place that I belong than here and

220
01:22:02.080 --> 01:22:19.440
I'm never leaving even though I have been around the world. Um shooting a little off the hip here, but uh I think that's about it. just uh please consider um how we can help one another um in regards to SP1 1134. Thank

221
01:22:19.440 --> 01:22:42.800
you so much for your time. Thank you, >> Leonardo Montenegro. >> Good morning, sir. >> Good morning, Mayor and Commissioners. My name is Leo and I'm here as a member of the community to speak in support of LGBTQ plus inclusion in Coral Gables. I

222
01:22:42.800 --> 01:22:59.280
um live here and I work at the University of Miami where I conduct research on HIV and mental health. And so I've dedicated my entire life to understand how we can implement equity in our communities. And I'm here to express my strong opposition to SB134 which is relating to official actions of

223
01:22:59.280 --> 01:23:14.320
local governments. This bill is deeply concerning because, you know, it restricts counties and municipalities from funding, promoting, or taking official action related to diversity, equity, and inclusion. In practice, this could make it harder for local

224
01:23:14.320 --> 01:23:30.719
governments to respond to the real needs of the communities they serve, especially communities that already face barriers to safety, health care, housing, employment, and public services. Diversity, equity, and inclusion are not abstract political concepts. They are practical tools that

225
01:23:30.719 --> 01:23:46.560
help local governments understand who is being served, who is being left out, and how public services can be made more accessible and effective. Whether we're talking about language access, culturally responsive health outreach, LGBTQ plus inclusion, racial and ethnic

226
01:23:46.560 --> 01:24:02.880
disparities, or support for underserved neighborhoods, local governments need the ability to address inequities cyberly. I'm especially concerned that this bill could create fear and confusion among lo local officials, nonprofit partners, contractors, and service providers. When the law

227
01:24:02.880 --> 01:24:19.920
threatens local officials with with misfeasins or malfeasants for actions related to um DEI, it discourages public servants from doing the very work needed to ensure that all residents are treated fairly and have access to essential resources. Florida is diverse. Our local

228
01:24:19.920 --> 01:24:36.560
communities know their residents best and they should not be prevented from creating policies, programs, trainings or partnerships that reflect the needs of those residents. Preventing local governments from supporting inclusion does not make the government more neutral. It makes it less responsive to

229
01:24:36.560 --> 01:24:53.840
the people who rely on it. So I just urge lawmakers and local leaders to oppose efforts that limit equity focused work and to protect the ability of counties, municipalities and community official organization to serve all Flidians with dignity, fairness and respect. So I expect something to happen

230
01:24:53.840 --> 01:25:15.920
and I expect it to happen soon. Thank you. Thank you. >> David Lloyd. Good morning, sir. Good morning, mayor, vice mayor, and commissioners. My name is David Gary Lloyd, and I'm here to express my support for the inclusion and visibility

231
01:25:15.920 --> 01:25:30.960
for the LGBTQ plus community here in Coral Gables. My husband and I are residents here, and we absolutely love this city. However, I was shocked when we moved here from downtown Miami because I realized there's actually a very large LGBTQ plus community that

232
01:25:30.960 --> 01:25:48.960
resides here in Coral Gables. And it wasn't obvious to me at first, but over the years, I've met so many neighbors, families, business owners, employees, churchgoers, students, all kinds of people in our community that identify as LGBTQ plus.

233
01:25:48.960 --> 01:26:05.360
The recent SB134 bill that was signed into law specifically targets any government funding that falls under the very broad term of DEI. Our LGBTQ plus community contributes so much to this city and state and we all just want to make the place we call home a better

234
01:26:05.360 --> 01:26:22.480
place for us all to enjoy and live in. This past June for Pride Month, I produced an art show with the local networking group Gay in the Gables and the historic Congregational United Church of Christ, which is the church that's directly across from the Builmore Hotel. It's beautiful, very iconic. Uh

235
01:26:22.480 --> 01:26:37.520
we transformed the sanctuary into an art gallery featuring queer Florida artists. The show was only open for 3 days and we had about 700 visitors over that very short time frame. Um, that really touched my heart to see how much support

236
01:26:37.520 --> 01:26:54.239
exists between the LGBTQ plus community and our local residents here in Coral Gables. To target humans because of race, gender, or orientation is not what I believe this city stands for. I'm asking for your legal counsel to review anything that can be affected by the

237
01:26:54.239 --> 01:27:09.760
SB134 bill and find ways that we can protect the programs and policies that help bring essential inclusion for members of our community. I can't tell you what it means to see my city show support with visibility like illuminating uh city hall with the

238
01:27:09.760 --> 01:27:26.320
rainbow colors during June. It makes us feel safe, welcomed, and part of the city we love to brag about. Coral Gables has has received a 92 out of 100 on the municipal equality index scorecard via the human rights campaign

239
01:27:26.320 --> 01:27:45.760
that shows that the policies and programming that we already have are working. Now we just need to protect them. Thank you so much for your time and your service to our community. >> Thank you, sir. >> Lane Tidwell. Lane, good morning.

240
01:27:45.760 --> 01:28:02.320
Good to see you. Before Lane comes up here and speaks, Lane and I have been friends for a long time. I've had the pleasure of uh visiting Lane at his home. And Lane is the is the individual along with his husband who are responsible for the beautiful

241
01:28:02.320 --> 01:28:19.600
fountain that you see adjacent to uh the Granada Country Club. The one adjacent to the country club. He one of one of the works that he's been working on is to make sure that fountain is up and running. He writes me emails and text messages. Uh if there's ever a tree in the way or the

242
01:28:19.600 --> 01:28:36.560
fountain stops working or he sees something that's not right in that park, uh he's one of the individuals that when we found that park, advocated for that park, really takes care of it and make sure that he's a community advocate on fronts just in that little slice of heaven that he has right there between the little park on Granada and Alhamra

243
01:28:36.560 --> 01:28:51.679
and the uh the fountain. So Lane is a big advocate for the city. Beautiful. Thank you for being here. It's nice to see you. Oh, and by the way, he also makes a mean banana chocolate cake. Just you. >> Thank you. Uh, good morning, mayor and

244
01:28:51.679 --> 01:29:07.280
commissioners. I'm terrible at this. My name is Lane Tidwell, and I live in 933 Mayorca Avenue, Florida, 33134. First of all, I'd like to thank you for all you've done for our community. Uh, I

245
01:29:07.280 --> 01:29:24.480
applaud you and I absolutely love living. Um, I'm a proud I'm so proud when people ask me where do you live? I live in Coral Gables. It's it's a great place to live. This morning I am also here to

246
01:29:24.480 --> 01:29:44.400
support save and its advocacy is pride campaign. I just want to say that together we can move mountains. divided. We can only see or hope we can see the top of the mountain from a

247
01:29:44.400 --> 01:30:01.760
different view. And I think you guys have done a great job and I like I say, I just appreciate all you've done. Thank you. >> Thank you, L. >> Robert Johnson. Mr. Johnson, good

248
01:30:01.760 --> 01:30:30.239
morning. Good morning, uh, mayor and, uh, commission members and, uh, the officers of the city of Coral Gables and all the staff who make this meeting possible. I want to thank you for what you've done. My name is Robert Johnson. I live at 933

249
01:30:30.239 --> 01:30:46.960
Mayorca Avenue. I support SAVE's advocacy is pride campaign and I want to thank Coral Gables as a city uh for its past support and urge that you take action before uh Florida SB1 1134 takes

250
01:30:46.960 --> 01:31:02.239
effect and limits our city's abilities to respond to the uh programs that they have been advocating in the past that makes us all live so well and stay so well in this city. I also uh recognize

251
01:31:02.239 --> 01:31:18.320
and um regret that this law will affect not only the residents well-being but also will place the city at uh risk and liability uh from uninformed uh uh individuals who might want to bring a

252
01:31:18.320 --> 01:31:35.840
lawsuit and that it places each of you at a personal responsibility and liability for what is done. Uh I think that's very important given the good work that you do. What you need is congratulations, not threats. A state cannot run without the well-run cities

253
01:31:35.840 --> 01:31:51.440
that uh are in it and to be shackled this way is a shame. Um the threat obviously uh that I see first of all does uh is aimed at the LGBTQ community, but Florida SB134

254
01:31:51.440 --> 01:32:07.760
uh goes much further than that. The bill is triggered by ethnicity and several other uh uh identities that individuals within this city oftentimes express through their participation in civic endeavors and through recognition

255
01:32:07.760 --> 01:32:23.280
by the city itself. Because the bill is triggered by ethnicity, there are many festivals and programs that may be at risk. Um and we should seriously consider uh the impact that that might have on the city. I have spent nearly 50

256
01:32:23.280 --> 01:32:39.199
years now studying the distribution of health uh illness, disease and death in society. This is my profession and I can tell you that the pattern of that distribution is not random. It is predictable and it varies by

257
01:32:39.199 --> 01:32:54.400
communities. Our community happens to be a very favorable community in that we benefit uh from things that the city itself does to promote the health, well-being, and safety of its citizens. Those may be in jeopardy, and I want us

258
01:32:54.400 --> 01:33:11.280
to think about them um clearly. I also think that the bill might uh give us some opportunities to implement those programs in non-discriminatory ways because of the carveouts particularly with regard to federal law dealing with health like the Americans with

259
01:33:11.280 --> 01:33:27.840
disability act providing appropriate care um for those um which include some of these uh um identities and the affordable care act. Um, local governments can also limit harm in other ways. And one of the ways that um, I've

260
01:33:27.840 --> 01:33:44.400
studied particularly that we don't always recognize is that you can limit the harms of loneliness. The attorney general of the United States said that after COVID, uh, the public in the United States was facing a loneliness epidemic and the programs that you offer

261
01:33:44.400 --> 01:33:59.920
provide connection and ties to the community and that defeats the impact that loneliness has. And so congratulations uh for that. I want you to urge you to continue to do that as part of a public uh safety and health

262
01:33:59.920 --> 01:34:16.000
infrastructure that the city can undergur its uh citizens with um and uh keep active in that regard. What I'm asking for today is for uh the city council to took an uh look at an inventory of all of the things that you

263
01:34:16.000 --> 01:34:32.239
do that have this public health focus and figure out ways in which you can preserve them. Of course, I'm also very interested in preserving what you've done in the past for the LGBTQ community. And uh with that, I thank you. Belonging is good. It's good to be

264
01:34:32.239 --> 01:34:48.920
seen. So once you're seen, it's good to be welcome. It tells you that you belong and I think we all belong. >> Thank you. >> Thank you, Dr. >> Miles. Savius, >> Mr. Davis. Good morning.

265
01:34:49.120 --> 01:35:05.600
>> Good morning, mayors, vice mayor, commissioners, city staff. My name is Miles Davis. I serve as director of advocacy and communications at SAVE. We're South Florida's leading LGBTQ plus advocacy organization. I'm here to recognize Coral Gables for earning a 92

266
01:35:05.600 --> 01:35:21.520
on the Human Rights Campaign's 2025 municipal equality index. That is a strong case and it reflects very meaningful work by the city to treat residents, employees, families, and visitors with fairness and respect. But a 92 is not just a score to celebrate.

267
01:35:21.520 --> 01:35:37.280
As you've heard from many folks here already, it is a foundation that we must protect. Coral Gables is a city that values planning, stability, and thoughtful governance. That is exactly why this moment matters. As new state restrictions come into play, cities across the state will need to understand

268
01:35:37.280 --> 01:35:52.400
what they mean for local services, partnerships, contract, our advisory boards, funding agreements, and community initiatives. Our ask is simple. We're asking the commission to direct city staff and legal counsel to review the MEI scorecard along the new

269
01:35:52.400 --> 01:36:09.360
state law and identify what may be impacted, what can be preserved, and most importantly, what steps the city can take now to protect local decision-making. At its core, this is about home rule. And we know Coral Gables should be able to make decisions that reflect, of course, Coral Gables,

270
01:36:09.360 --> 01:36:25.120
its residents, its workforce, our families, and our local needs before services are disrupted or local authority is narrowed. Our team will be following up with everyone. And we hope that the constructive partnership that the city has had in the past will

271
01:36:25.120 --> 01:36:42.080
continue as we help you review the laws, understand what options are available, and um chart a practical path forward. A 92 is a strong score, but a strong score still needs a strong defense, and SAFE is here to work with you on that. Coral Gables has the opportunity to protect

272
01:36:42.080 --> 01:36:57.840
both its progress and its right to govern locally, and I thank each and every one of you for your time and commitment to public service. Thank you. >> Thank you, Mr. Davis. >> Maria Cruz, >> before we move on to the next person, Madam City Attorney, will you do me a favor, please? you schedule time with me next week uh to go over the MEI

273
01:36:57.840 --> 01:37:14.000
scorecard and I want to review uh the preeemption legislation and I want to be very clear to our friends at Save aid and all the members of the community. Uh preeemption is not something new as you're aware you're very aware of it. Uh it handcuffs us on many different fronts. I'm just going to throw a few

274
01:37:14.000 --> 01:37:29.199
out there and I know I'm going to forget the most important ones. Uh for example, we're the city beautiful. Correct. Now there's new state legislation that came through preeemption where trees can be cut down without uh approval from the city. And we also have our state legislative direct director here who's

275
01:37:29.199 --> 01:37:45.360
going to speak a little bit about that. But also uh we can no longer now control the issue of whether full grass goes in the front of the house or in the sides in the back like we've allowed in the past. Uh so preeemption is something that again that we're dealing with as a city. Um but I'm going to be very candid with you. Our hands are tied uh in

276
01:37:45.360 --> 01:37:59.760
regards to a lot of the preeemption that comes. I will review I will review uh the report card the MEI report card which I think is critically important to review it and I will draft a memo uh with the help of my city city attorney and our and our director of legislative

277
01:37:59.760 --> 01:38:15.679
legislation uh at the state uh to make sure that we can address through the whole commission these issues and we can make a strong case of how we advocate for the entire community as a whole. And I'm beyond grateful especially to see my friend Lane here who I haven't seen in a

278
01:38:15.679 --> 01:38:33.040
few months. uh to have you here uh raising your voice because we don't work for just one individual. We work for the city as a whole. And when you tell me that you were actually impressed that there was a rather large LGBTQ uh community here in Coral Gables, you

279
01:38:33.040 --> 01:38:48.639
know, I've known that for a long long time, especially when you knock on doors and u that community is very vocal, is very proud again to be residents here of the city of Coral Gables and we're very proud to have you here in the city. Beautiful. So, I will sit down with our city attorney and our director and our

280
01:38:48.639 --> 01:39:05.119
city manager uh to review the MEI scorecard and see what we can do uh to continue advocating on behalf of the entire community as a whole. Madam director. >> Hi. Good morning, mayor, vice mayor, course. My name is Chelsea Grenell and I'm the director of government affairs. I just wanted to um put out on the

281
01:39:05.119 --> 01:39:23.199
record that um we are staff is um this is very important to us and we have been actively meeting to make sure that we adhere to the state requirements but also think of creative ways that we can circumvent um certain um prohibitions.

282
01:39:23.199 --> 01:39:39.760
Um so we would be happy to include you in those meetings, Mr. mayor, but I just wanted to say that we have been on it and we do very much care um about how to preserve what's important to the city. >> Yeah, >> I'm not surprised at all that the manager's team is already on it because

283
01:39:39.760 --> 01:39:55.040
this is again we're addressing every single every single email that comes from the state of Florida. our director of government affairs is on it along with the manager uh not only looking at funding issues but also looking at preeemption issues uh which again are extremely painful for us as a city

284
01:39:55.040 --> 01:40:11.360
because there is nobody and I want to be very clear and I've told this to our leaders who I have the utmost respect at the state of Florida there is nobody closer to the residents than the individuals that you see here in front of you and in this room and I'm not talking about only elected officials I'm talking about staff we're the ones

285
01:40:11.360 --> 01:40:27.600
that deal with the potholes the ones that deal with the fountains that are broken We're the ones that deal with the trees that need to be trimmed when a crime is committed in your neighborhood. So, at the end of the day, Mr. Manager, if you'd allow me to engage in that process, also be kind and we can bring back uh along with the vice mayor, if she wants

286
01:40:27.600 --> 01:40:44.480
to get involved, we can bring back a memo uh to the commission. Madame Vice Mayor, >> well, I I wanted to be involved too because uh the type of litigation I've done under the ADA, it's very very clear uh that federal law uh offers a preeemption as well. So, I'd like to

287
01:40:44.480 --> 01:41:15.600
explore that with the city attorney's office. >> Thank you, >> Mr. Clerk. Maria Cruz. Mrs. Maria Cruz, 1447 Miller Road, 305323

288
01:41:15.600 --> 01:41:32.960
2154. This is the day the Lord has made. Let us rejoice and be glad in it. There is an item on the consent agenda.

289
01:41:32.960 --> 01:41:51.840
And since the consent agenda, I've been told, is not something that we can talk about unless somebody pulls it, I am going to talk about it now. It's item D7. Item D7

290
01:41:51.840 --> 01:42:08.239
is a development agreement the annual report 2425 prepared by the University of Miami for the city of Coral Gables August 26 2025. It's a very lengthy

291
01:42:08.239 --> 01:42:27.360
um report. I it took a little time to go through it but I managed it. On page 12, on page 12, it talks about the fact that the university was going

292
01:42:27.360 --> 01:42:45.760
to fund some public realm items for $250,000. The only problem is that when we, the residents, discussed it with the university, it was a million dollars. Now it's down to $250.

293
01:42:45.760 --> 01:43:03.760
And at the time that we discussed it, we wanted we wanted uh lightning because of anybody that goes in that area next to the university from Miller uh north is very dark at night,

294
01:43:03.760 --> 01:43:22.400
extremely dark. So on page 12, it talks about 250,000 for public realm improvements. On page 13, it mentions that there's a 10y year date uh there's 10 years of the date of

295
01:43:22.400 --> 01:43:40.400
the adoption for this to expire. Okay, this was 2016 to December 2026 that will expire.

296
01:43:40.400 --> 01:43:56.719
On page 14, it says that they're waiting for the city to identify the improvement that is going to be done with that money. So page 12, 13, and 14, we talk about

297
01:43:56.719 --> 01:44:16.239
that. On page 20, we talk about annual payments that the university was going to pay the city. is very interesting because it says annual payments annual payments and the last payment was

298
01:44:16.239 --> 01:44:33.920
November 9 November 29th 2024. So what happened to the payment in 25? There's no record according to them there's the last payment was November 29, 2024.

299
01:44:33.920 --> 01:44:50.159
Okay, it's over a over a million dollars. Okay, and the last thing that I have is we talk about the Wasco Center.

300
01:44:50.159 --> 01:45:07.679
Okay, I want to remind those of you that were here then, and if you were not here, I can tell you, you can find it on the records, that the Wasp Center was supposed to be a convocation center for the university. It was not supposed to

301
01:45:07.679 --> 01:45:22.960
be a venue for conventions, concerts, etc., etc. And it says it on the documents at that time. I have the original documents if anybody wants to see them. convocation center. Then somewhere along the line, our

302
01:45:22.960 --> 01:45:38.159
administration somehow because this is the problem when you have covenance agreements with the city that they sign in goodwill and then people come back and say, "Oops, I couldn't do it. Then I

303
01:45:38.159 --> 01:45:53.520
need a break. I need a an amendment. I need a waiver." And our elected people go for it. >> We've gone over a minute and 40 seconds. >> I'm sorry. Other people went over it too, >> but they didn't go over one minute. I'd ask you to please bring it in for a line. >> Okay, I'm going to close it up. I

304
01:45:53.520 --> 01:46:08.719
suggest that any of you that are interested to know since it's going to be approved today that you need to go online and pull it and read it so you can see what I've said and it's there. >> Thank you very much.

305
01:46:08.719 --> 01:46:32.000
Two minutes time. >> Yes. >> Good morning, sir. Thank you. Uh Jackson Holmes, 35 Sidonia Avenue, Coral Gables, Florida. Um I um hope we can pull up the first

306
01:46:32.000 --> 01:46:54.480
picture here. >> If cable TV can please share my screen. Thank you. Maybe you can slide it up. Can you slide it up? So, okay, there we go. So, for uh as you all can see, that's me with maybe you need to slide

307
01:46:54.480 --> 01:47:09.840
it down a little bit. Sorry. Uh uh that's me with former United States Senator Bob Graham. And I'm going to put myself under penalties for perjury. And what I'm going to say today, I'm asking that the residents watching this pay

308
01:47:09.840 --> 01:47:25.679
close attention. Bob Graham, I'm saying this under penalties for perjury, opened the door for me to discover free energy. And I'm saying that under penalties for perjury. Um, so can we go to the next

309
01:47:25.679 --> 01:47:48.719
slide? Now what is the proof of free energy? This came in a 60 minutes broadcast which you can see a slide from here. Um, how about the next one? Or did do you have that threads video that we that I

310
01:47:48.719 --> 01:48:17.040
just sent you? >> It's it's a separate email. I sent you threads to click on >> I did not receive your separate email, Mr. Holmes. >> No threads video. I just sent it. >> I haven't received it, sir. >> Okay. So, I'm gonna ask the people with

311
01:48:17.040 --> 01:48:32.480
the it to try and get the camera to zoom in here. I'm gonna play it off of my iPhone. See if you can pick up the feed. This is the proof of free energy, right? You know, somebody comes to you say, "I got proof of free energy." You say, "Yeah, I know a good psychiatrist." But

312
01:48:32.480 --> 01:48:49.679
if the US Department of Defense comes to you and says, "Yes, there is free energy." Then you listen because it's United States Department of Defense. That's what this video is. It's too bad we couldn't get it uh synced properly here. And within the Department

313
01:48:49.679 --> 01:49:05.520
of Defense, uh, guess who inter invented the internet? DARPA, Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency. They invented the internet. People at home, Watson web links here that I'm be showing. Uh, and

314
01:49:05.520 --> 01:49:22.480
DARPA, who invented the internet, is the one that says there is free energy. So, I'm going to see if this, uh, can be picked up by the cameras. real. >> Are you surprised to hear yourself saying this? >> Very much pick it up.

315
01:49:22.480 --> 01:49:39.639
>> And we found that the Pentagon is saying it too. >> The Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency known as DARPA did its own analysis and this internal memo that concludes there is >> please bring it in for a landing

316
01:49:40.560 --> 01:49:55.040
experiment will have the video. You're going to keep the Coral Gables people from learning about free energy. >> You have played it before, but no one's going to be able to see it from your phone. We have another meeting coming up in a month. >> They they can pick up on it and follow

317
01:49:55.040 --> 01:50:12.880
it up later. Do you have the next slide? >> Your time is up and we have it. How many people waiting to speak? >> You're suppressing free energy from the people of Coral Gables. Could you play the next slide, please? >> Mr. Mr. Holmes, the next slide I have for you is not a video. Once again, it's

318
01:50:12.880 --> 01:50:29.119
>> right. It's a slide, right? >> We We need to move on allow some other people to speak. We have many things on >> people at home. You can see the city commissioner is is suppressing your ability to know that there is free energy that I got through the help of US Senator Bob Grant.

319
01:50:29.119 --> 01:50:45.040
>> I I understand we spoke about it. The sun is free as well. It does cost money when >> suppression of information from the citizens of Coral Gibbs. Okay, next meeting. You can have the video. >> Marina Pman. Braymond.

320
01:50:45.040 --> 01:51:15.440
>> Thank you, Madam Vice Mayor. >> Good morning. Uh, good morning, Mayor Lago commissioners and city staff. Uh my name is Marina Brain and I'm here on behalf of SAVE this morning. My colleagues and I and of course the Coral uh Gables

321
01:51:15.440 --> 01:51:31.920
residents who came to join us. Um we do of course uh want to encourage the city to examine all the events programs like we've already mentioned that could fall under um SB 1134. Just a few items that could be on the chopping block in the

322
01:51:31.920 --> 01:51:48.480
city of Coral Gables. Uh the city has a sponsored Women's History Month uh celebration. Pearl Gables also has an annual Hanukkah Festival of Lights. There's also a citywide clergy prayer breakfast and as well as a Black History

323
01:51:48.480 --> 01:52:03.920
Month programming including a Junth commemoration. Now, in terms of the LGBTQ community, um I'm not sure if residents knew this, but uh something that you can see on your MEI, um is that the city of Coral Gables

324
01:52:03.920 --> 01:52:21.119
has an LGBTQ liaison in the city manager's office and in the police department. As a city employer, Coral Gables also offers samesex partner benefits and inclusive healthcare. in a show of support as one of your uh residents mentioned the city of Coral

325
01:52:21.119 --> 01:52:37.920
Gables also has lit up city hall in uh in celebration of pride month. So all of these events and policies um it won't just affect LGBTQ people, it could affect um any category that falls under the DEI umbrella. Now like you said,

326
01:52:37.920 --> 01:52:54.480
Mayor Lago, state preeemption does exist. Of course, we right, we know that. Um, and it does tie the hands of our municipalities. However, uh, attorneys at the ACLU, um, uh, former legislative staff who used to

327
01:52:54.480 --> 01:53:11.920
work in the state, including myself and Miles who spoke before, um, as well as other organizations who, if they haven't already reached out to you, will be, uh, offering other options for municipalities like yours. Um, we believe that they that there are

328
01:53:11.920 --> 01:53:27.840
options. As your staff mentioned previously, uh, Cruel Cables can still enter into long-term contracts, funding agreements, and partnerships that protect these programs and services for future years before January 1st.

329
01:53:27.840 --> 01:53:44.400
Another option that other South Florida municipalities are considering is joint legal action. These are still options before the bill takes place in January 1st. So we stand of course ready to uh partner in this process. Um our goal is

330
01:53:44.400 --> 01:54:01.599
not to change the identity of Coral Gables uh but to uplift our residents that live here. Um and of course to prevent the state from uh controlling what our local governments can do because they are of course closest to the people. Um, so we will of course be

331
01:54:01.599 --> 01:54:17.199
reaching out to your office and the city manager's office and we really just appreciate your support and uh the time that you've given us here today. >> Thank you. >> Thank you so much for being here with us. >> That's it, Mr. Mayor. >> All right, we'll close the public comment. Uh, may I have a Now we're

332
01:54:17.199 --> 01:54:34.719
moving on to the consent agenda. >> Before the vote adoption, the consent agenda is taken. Is there anyone who wishes additional discussion or review of any item on the consent agenda? May I have a motion? >> I'll move it. >> I'll second. All >> in favor?

333
01:54:34.719 --> 01:54:53.360
>> I I >> Thank you. >> Thank you. All right. Moving on to time certain at 10:30 a.m. Agenda item G1. >> G1 is a resolution of the city commission approving fiscal year 2026 to 2027 cultural grant recipients and

334
01:54:53.360 --> 01:55:09.199
setting in place a funding mechanism contingent on the city's approved budget. Good morning, Miss Cathers. How are you? >> Good morning, mayor, vice mayor, commissioners. Katherine Cathers, arts and cultural coordinator with the city. Um, we do have a presentation.

335
01:55:09.199 --> 01:55:25.840
So, one of the responsibilities of the city's cultural development board is to recommend to the city commission the annual allocation of cultural grant funding. I want to thank the members of our cultural development board who had the role of reviewing and scoring each application. Board member Eric Fliss is

336
01:55:25.840 --> 01:55:40.880
here today to speak on behalf of the board and he will come up and just say a few words um after the presentation. I would also like to thank our cultural partners, the culture, the Coral Gables Chamber of Commerce and the Arts and Business Council who provide

337
01:55:40.880 --> 01:55:57.840
professional development opportunities and support to our grantees. As a reminder, um the city commission adopted amendments to the cultural grant guidelines and included a process to um have bonus points for the following

338
01:55:57.840 --> 01:56:16.000
scenarios, five additional points for principal address and Coral Gables, five for applicants who include programming that is free, and two for organizations whose operating budgets are $50,000 or less. The board applied the same uh

339
01:56:16.000 --> 01:56:33.239
funding recommendation as last year, maintaining the dedicated funding of youth arts program at 50,000 and $228,228 for Coral Gable's core cultural organizations and cultural programs.

340
01:56:33.599 --> 01:56:51.199
So this year on May 14th, the Cultural Development Board reviewed and scored 53 applications for the allocation of grant funding in all categories with one of the applications required by the Coral Gables Museum, which is funded separately. Of the 52 remaining

341
01:56:51.199 --> 01:57:08.400
applications, five did not meet the 80 point threshold established to recommend funding and two were disqualified for not submitting required documents. The proposed funding for of the eligible 45 applicants and their scores plus the

342
01:57:08.400 --> 01:57:24.080
Coral Gables Museum have been provided in your exhibit A that's attached to the proposed resolution. The board is recommending funding for these organizations which represent a diverse range of the arts including music, theater, film, dance, opera, literary

343
01:57:24.080 --> 01:57:41.920
arts, performance, poetry, gardens and museums. So we have quite the opportunities for culture here. Um we have a few slides that are interspersed and then just representing these here we see a gallery opening a book reading and a garden tour and then of course a

344
01:57:41.920 --> 01:57:57.119
summary demonstrating the actual impact of the cultural grant program and benefit to Coral Gable's residents and visitors. So you can see here and and this is similar to last year the total number 1,38

345
01:57:57.119 --> 01:58:14.560
programs overall the percentage of events of that are in Coral Gables of course is always 100%. Uh percentage of free events is 40% which is very high and the number of Coral Gables venues that are used is 28 and that's a

346
01:58:14.560 --> 01:58:31.760
significant increase. You'll see the economic impact of total expenditures by the grantee organizations and their audiences is well over $20 million and the local benefit uh rate of return for the the local government itself is

347
01:58:31.760 --> 01:58:48.000
over $800,000. So again, just a few more images showing the cinema, some sim uh children's programming, dance, an orchestral concert. These are just a few. Um, so as I said, we have Eric Spliss with us

348
01:58:48.000 --> 01:59:04.080
today to speak on behalf of the board and answer any questions from the commission. >> Good morning, sir. >> Good morning, Eric Fliss, Cultural Development Board. Um, mayor, vice mayor, commissioners, and staff. Uh, I just wanted to say thank you for your support for this program. Last year, you

349
01:59:04.080 --> 01:59:19.040
provided some additional funding for the youth programs, which had a major impact on those organizations. their funding levels were raised and the amount of work they can do within the city of Coral Gables was increased by those directly by those funding. It also

350
01:59:19.040 --> 01:59:34.880
provided additional funds for our major uh cultural organizations in Coral Gables. Um it was also as a panel member easier to uh review all of the grants as we were not competing children's orchestras with professional orchestras

351
01:59:34.880 --> 01:59:52.480
and we were able to make clear um evaluations of all the applications. So I just want to say thank you and ask to please accept the package that was provided to you. >> Uh first and foremost, thank you for your service to the city. Pleasure. A great impact and we're grateful for the

352
01:59:52.480 --> 02:00:09.119
work that you do along with the director. Uh Miss Cathers, may I ask you just a few questions very quickly. My questions, one of them is a question and one is just reiterating it to bring it home. Number one, what is the percentage of the money that's spent of this grant

353
02:00:09.119 --> 02:00:24.639
money that is spent in the city beautiful? >> 100%. >> Can you repeat that again? >> 100%. >> That's number one. And number two, where does that money come from? >> It comes from the general fund. >> Want to be clear. So what we're doing

354
02:00:24.639 --> 02:00:40.000
here right now is if you look at the numbers, over $20 million of economic impact here in the community. So when you have an event for example like a World Cup game and then everybody disperses after two hours where do they go? They go have lunch. They go have dinner. They go have a drink. Maybe they

355
02:00:40.000 --> 02:00:56.639
do some shopping. They maybe go see a the you know the miracle theater. Uh the cinema. Maybe they go to books and books. Maybe go have a coffee somewhere. But they spend their hard-earned dollars here in our community. So we are already respected as the cultural destination in South Florida. And it's an incumbent on

356
02:00:56.639 --> 02:01:12.800
us in making sure that we continue to spread spread this message because this is an economic driver in our community. You know, if we're not investing in art, if we're not investing in theater, in the cinema, you know, if we're not investing in that, at the end of the day, um I think that it will only hurt us. So, I want to congratulate you and

357
02:01:12.800 --> 02:01:29.360
the board, the city manager, and all the work that you're doing uh in regards to making sure that we're very careful. We're very methodical. We're auditing. We're auditing. Like for example, the previous year these individuals who got a grant submit an audit. Correct? >> Yes. They submit a final report.

358
02:01:29.360 --> 02:01:44.159
>> Final report which basically says this is when the event happened. This is proof that the event happened. This is how much money was spent. This is you know this is a receipt so that people understand that that the taxpayer dollar is being used for the appropriate uh the

359
02:01:44.159 --> 02:01:59.679
appropriate venue or event that we that we as a board and as a as a city dictated and approved. Correct. >> Okay. Want to be clear of that. Okay. Any further comments? >> Just to the mayor, just thank you for

360
02:01:59.679 --> 02:02:15.920
the hard work that you do evaluating each and every one of these applications because it does take a lot of time and effort to go through them one at a time and you bring so much back to our city, so much richness. Thank you. >> Thank you, Madam Vice Mayor. Mr. Clerk,

361
02:02:15.920 --> 02:02:32.880
do you have any public comment? All right, we'll close the public comment. May I have a motion? I'll move it. Second. >> Vice Mayor Anderson? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Castro? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Fernandez? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Lada? >> Yes. >> Mayor Logo?

362
02:02:32.880 --> 02:02:48.560
>> Yes. Let's go to G2. Let's take G2 right now since we're here. Thank you, sir. Thank you, Mr. Flu. >> Thank you, Mr. Mayor. G2 is a resolution of the city commission approving intervals of Coral Gables based art series as part of Miami Art Week and for an application to Art Basle for an

363
02:02:48.560 --> 02:03:03.599
official event further approving funding up to $110,000 from the art fund toward the program and marketing materials and authorizing an amendment to the fiscal year 2025 2026 operating budget to recognize the transfer of funds from the art and public places reserve and to appropriate such funds to put toward the cost of the project.

364
02:03:03.599 --> 02:03:19.599
>> Just really quickly, she said 210. It was 110 or 200. >> Okay. I'm just trying to make sure. But we'll take 210. >> I know. >> Trust me. I know you will. >> Good morning. Um, so following up on the success from last year, the arts

365
02:03:19.599 --> 02:03:36.719
advisory panel and cultural development board discussed the city's Miami artwork 2026 program and unanimously supported continuing intervals, which is a public art exhibition we programmed in partnership with Coral Gable's public spaces and with galleries presenting at

366
02:03:36.719 --> 02:03:52.320
Art Basel Miami Beach. So, Intervals is designed to present a minimum of five artists in sight responsive installations are open and publicly accessible, including partnering businesses and hotels. In compliance with Art Basel Miami Beach program

367
02:03:52.320 --> 02:04:07.520
requirements, galleries affiliated with Art Basle are being approached to present their artists and we already have some commitments. If this is approved, artists are provided funding to create to create the sight specific installations for exhibition that lasts

368
02:04:07.520 --> 02:04:23.920
about eight weeks and then we last year we ended up um extending at least two of those beyond that. So again building on the established relationship with Art Basle, we would like to submit an Art Basle VIP event application to celebrate intervals at one of the locations with

369
02:04:23.920 --> 02:04:39.040
an invitation to visit all the sites. Funding of 110,000 is being requested for the recommendation related expenses and marketing and is proposed through the art fund which is funded through private development projects. Today we

370
02:04:39.040 --> 02:04:56.960
also have Dr. Jill Dupy with us who is the chair of the arts advisory panel and is available to also discuss the program and answer any questions. >> Thank you doctor for being here with us >> Mr. Mayor, Madame Vice Mayor, commissioners. Thank you so much for

371
02:04:56.960 --> 02:05:14.960
your enlightened leadership. My day job, as you may know, is the executive director and chief curator of the Low Art Museum. So, thank you also for your support in that channel. But because of the work I do, I really understand that art contributes to quality of life and

372
02:05:14.960 --> 02:05:31.840
it is also an economic driver. It's not just a frill. So I am really grateful for again your enlightened and visionary leadership and I think that this program is very much in line with that same vision. As I'm sure you are aware, Art

373
02:05:31.840 --> 02:05:49.760
Basil has a tremendous impact that resonates far beyond Miami Beach. Those who are a part of those proceedings really are elevating their own programs and in this case their own cities. So I think that uh as we discussed on the

374
02:05:49.760 --> 02:06:06.800
arts advisory panel that this is a really important opportunity to extend uh because it does bring relevance, impact and engagement that reverberates far beyond the city of Coral Gables and even South Miami. So I speak for the

375
02:06:06.800 --> 02:06:22.400
panel in giving our full support to this resolution. >> Thank you. Doctor Mr. Cler, do you have any public comment? >> No, Mr. Sir, >> close the public comment. Uh, do I have a motion? >> I move it. >> I'll second.

376
02:06:22.400 --> 02:06:39.159
>> Mr. Clerk, >> Commissioner Castro, >> yes. >> Commissioner Fernandez, >> yes. >> Commissioner Lada, >> yes. >> Vice Mayor Anderson, >> yes. >> Mayor Lago, >> yes. Again, thank you and send my best to the board. We're grateful for your work on the board. Thank you so much. >> Well done.

377
02:06:39.679 --> 02:07:03.840
>> 11 o'clock. We have a time certain thing for once. This is a world record. We're going to start on time. Time certain 11 a.m. Agenda E7, E8, E9, and E11. Mayor E7, uh, or mayor and commissioners. E7 is an orance of the

378
02:07:03.840 --> 02:07:19.920
city commission amending the future land use map and mixuse overlay district map of the city of Coral Gable's comprehensive plan pursuant to zoning code article 14 process section 14-213 comprehensive plan text and map amendments and smallcale amendment procedures from religious institutional to commercial mid-rise intensity and to

379
02:07:19.920 --> 02:07:36.320
include within the boundaries of the north ponds mixeduse district overlay block 21 revised plat of Coral Gable's Douglas section Coral Gables Florida providing for repealer provision severability clause and providing for an effective date E8 is a norance to the city commission making zoning boundary changes pursuant to zoning code article

380
02:07:36.320 --> 02:07:51.520
14 process section 14-212 zoning code text and map amendments one from special use to mixuse 2 and two to include within the boundaries of the north pond's mixeduse district overlay block 21 revised plat Gables Douglas section Coral Gables Florida providing free provisions of ability clause and

381
02:07:51.520 --> 02:08:09.040
providing for an effective date E9 is an ordinance of city commission granting approval of planned area development pursuant to zoning code article 14 process section 14-206 general procedures for planned development for a mixeduse project referred to as Crystal Residences, including a private school on property legally described as block

382
02:08:09.040 --> 02:08:25.199
21 revised plat Gables Douglas section, Coral Gables, Florida, superseding ordinance number 1909 and ordinance number 2962, including required conditions, providing for repeater provision, severability cause, and providing for an effective date. E1 is not going to be voted on today. It's on

383
02:08:25.199 --> 02:08:41.520
for your information, but it is a resolution of the city commission requesting mixed use site plan review and an encroachment agreement pursuant to article 14 process section 14-203 conditional uses for a proposed mixeduse project referred to as crystal residences including a private school and live work units on property legally described as block 21 revised plat

384
02:08:41.520 --> 02:08:57.599
Gables Douglas section Coral Gables Florida superseding ordinance number 1909 and ordinance number 2962 to permit the current accessory school as a principal use including required conditions providing for repeater provisions of ability clause and providing for an effective date. Um, mayor, we will consolidate these items for purposes of the public hearing. And

385
02:08:57.599 --> 02:09:15.920
this is a quasi judicial hearing. So, I would ask that the clerk please swear in everyone who will be testifying today. >> Those who will be testifying on this item, please stand and raise your right hand. Do you swear or affirm the testimony you'll provide today will be the truth and nothing but the truth? >> I do.

386
02:09:15.920 --> 02:09:34.159
>> Thank you, >> madam city attorney. How much time are we allotting green side? >> So mayor I think as as as is typical you can you can ask members of the public who have well first you're going to hear from the applicant of course and then from staff and then when you have

387
02:09:34.159 --> 02:09:49.599
members of the public you should you I think it's appropriate to ask that they keep their remarks to the three minute time limit as as they can. But of course, you know, if some people have additional information, given that this is a quasi judicial proceeding, please, I would ask that you be flexible and allow them the opportunity to fully make

388
02:09:49.599 --> 02:10:05.360
their their comments. >> Thank you very much, sir. Councelor, good morning. >> Good morning. >> Powerful speaker. Uh good morning, Mr. Mayor, commissioners. Uh as mentioned by your city attorney, I think we're taking these items all together. So, all of the testimony that we're presenting will

389
02:10:05.360 --> 02:10:20.639
relate to all uh three of the items that are before you today. >> Mr. clerk, if I may, because I've been accused before um of not providing enough time, even though what I've been doing lately in all the meetings is basically taking both sides and making sure that I track the time very

390
02:10:20.639 --> 02:10:37.119
carefully. So, I'd like to even put a timer on the applicant and uh also on Mr. Wanker if possible, please. I want to make sure we provide as a public record how much time each each individual was given. >> Mayor, can I just add one thing in terms of public comment? I think it would be

391
02:10:37.119 --> 02:10:53.599
appropriate for you as as the chair to to recommend and suggest and remind folks that if their comments are repetitive, perhaps they can keep them brief, you know, and and just summarize instead of going into detail if they're being repetitive. >> Madam certain attorney, what I will do is what I've been doing lately is I will provide everyone with three minutes. I

392
02:10:53.599 --> 02:11:10.239
will ask it for you to be be concise and respectful. And once you go over I would just at the end when you're finished speaking I will say you went over a minute you went over two minutes and then at the end I will consolidate it and I will tell you what both sides spent in regards to the time because at the end of the day that's the way that you can tell you know when someone comes

393
02:11:10.239 --> 02:11:25.760
to you and says hey you didn't give me enough time but I want to do the same thing with the applicant and with Mr. Winger also. So please can I have a a time just so I can keep track Yes sir. >> of the applicant's time. >> Yes sir. >> Thank you sir. >> Thank you. So uh Mr. Mayor uh commissioners good morning. My name is

394
02:11:25.760 --> 02:11:41.840
George Avaro with offices at 333 Southeast Second Avenue. I'm here this morning on behalf of F FRC Realy and Crystal Academy. Uh we're excited to be here today to present what we hope is the final uh stage of approvals for this

395
02:11:41.840 --> 02:11:57.599
important and unique mixeduse project. This is a project that has been more than five years in the making. It's gone through an extensive um We could put the presentation up for the commissioners on the screen. Thank you. Um, it's a project that's gone through an extensive

396
02:11:57.599 --> 02:12:12.800
historical, architectural, and public re review process over the last 5 years. And as a result of that project, it's also been as a result of that process, it's also been a project that has been evaluated, refined, and improved uh

397
02:12:12.800 --> 02:12:28.079
based on feedback from city staff, residents, and city boards. The proposal before you today is a mixeduse project. It has residential live work. It has open space, but most importantly what it does is that it's anchored by a new

398
02:12:28.079 --> 02:12:45.040
permanent home for Crystal Academy. And before getting into the project, I'd like to take a step back and explain how we got here today. For many years, this property was owned by a church and they leased space to Crystal Academy. Uh Crystal Academy is a

399
02:12:45.040 --> 02:13:00.880
nonprofit school that has operated on this site for 17 years. They've served over 600 families in Coral Gables uh by providing specialized therapeutic programs and education for children with learning disabilities and development delays.

400
02:13:00.880 --> 02:13:17.599
When the church decided to sell the property in 2021, Crystal Academy was faced with the reality uh that they may have the possibility of losing their home and no longer be able to provide these services that they give to our residents in Coral Gables. At the time,

401
02:13:17.599 --> 02:13:33.119
my client uh realizing the importance of this institution made a promise that they would keep Crystal Academy on site, build them a brand new facility and give it back to them rent-free for 99 years. This is a commitment that my client

402
02:13:33.119 --> 02:13:49.040
today has honored and now you will see it implemented in this project. Um, this commitment is especially important when you think about how how the high demand for these programs are and just the limited availability that they are in

403
02:13:49.040 --> 02:14:04.400
this community. The CDC reports that one in six children, one in every six children are diagnosed with a development disability. However, there are very few schools that provide this specialized program. In Coral Gables, this is the only institution in the city

404
02:14:04.400 --> 02:14:18.880
that provides these services. And this project gives Crystal Academy a permanent home to continue to provide these services for generations to come. So with the community benefit in mind, I'd like to walk you through some of our public benefits. Uh this project

405
02:14:18.880 --> 02:14:36.079
includes 184 new residential units, 16 live work units. As I mentioned, a new ground floor uh facility, educational facility for Crystal Academy. You can see it here in the rendering. This is the rendering from Galliano Street. They will be located on the ground level fronting Galliano in the same location

406
02:14:36.079 --> 02:14:52.480
that they are today and have been operating for the last uh two decades. This is all integrated into a ninestory mixeduse building. This project provides a 5,000 square foot publicly accessible community uh courtyard that is

407
02:14:52.480 --> 02:15:09.199
accessible through a po a pedestrian po that connects Phoenicia and Antella Avenue uh as well as a 4,000 square foot children's park that will be used by the school during school hours and available to the public after school hours. So

408
02:15:09.199 --> 02:15:23.520
overall the project just to give you an idea in terms of open space this was discussed lengthy at the uh pub at the planning and zoning board this project as designed provides three times the amount of open space that will be required for a similar project in the

409
02:15:23.520 --> 02:15:39.520
north pon area and provides 55% more open space than is required by your p a regulations in terms of location and I think this is one of the most important items uh that was discussed by the board of architects and and the planning and zoning board

410
02:15:39.520 --> 02:15:55.520
when they recommended approval of this application. It's the context of this block. So this con so this block encompasses an entire city block beneath uh between Phoenicia Avenue and it fronts onto East Pon and East Pon is the main commercial corridor that connects

411
02:15:55.520 --> 02:16:13.280
Pon Leon Boulevard to Douglas entrance which is one of the largest commercial centers in the city and to Southwest 8th Street. As a refresher, and I know that many of you were involved with the North Pon overlay creation, but the goal of the North Pon overlay when it was created in

412
02:16:13.280 --> 02:16:29.040
2016, it had a clear vision, which was encouraged new housing, expand open space and civic amenities, and create a more active and walkable neighborhood. The city identified this area after multiple planning studies as a place that was appropriate for growth

413
02:16:29.040 --> 02:16:44.399
because of its proximities to employment centers, transit, and commercial uses. So the goal of the North Pon overlay was to activate this area with foot traffic. They wanted to bring residents within walking distance of commercial, within walking distance of schools, within walking distance of jobs, and within

414
02:16:44.399 --> 02:17:02.719
walking distance of parks. And this is exactly what this project accomplishes. As shown on the zoning and land use maps here, uh this property sits in the middle of what we have to our east, which is the MF2 area of the North Ponds

415
02:17:02.719 --> 02:17:19.200
overlay that allows heights up to 100 ft in height. And as you will see, our project is substantially below that, below what's allowed today to our east. And to our west, you have the North Pond's mixeduse overlay district that allows and currently has today, as you'll see, uh, building heights ranging

416
02:17:19.200 --> 02:17:36.960
between 150 to 190 ft in height. What's also interesting here is that the city's 1926 zoning map shows this block was originally planned for multifamily residential development as we're proposing today with the western portion

417
02:17:36.960 --> 02:17:52.479
which is highlighted in red here allowing for building heights up to 150 ft and the eastern portion which is highlighted in green allowing for up to 60 feet. So before this property was reszoned in 1970 by the then owner for

418
02:17:52.479 --> 02:18:07.679
religious uses, this property was historically already planned for residential development with building heights up to 150 ft in height. So historically under today's planning framework, this block really always served as a transition between the

419
02:18:07.679 --> 02:18:26.719
commercial corridor to the west and the mid-rise residential neighborhood to the east. So the request today, our request is for MX2 zoning and a midrise commercial designation that follows the same planning principle that you saw in the

420
02:18:26.719 --> 02:18:43.120
North Pond's visionary workshop and the 1926 zoning map. It creates that appropriate transition between the MX3 district to our west and the MF2 district to our east. And how do we accomplish that transition? So, what we've done is that we have uh in working

421
02:18:43.120 --> 02:18:59.280
with many residents in the area and based on their feedback, we have reduced the height along the eastern portion of this property to create a height transition and step the height down from nine stories on the west to eight stories on the east. This is, as you

422
02:18:59.280 --> 02:19:16.880
could see here, both of these heights are well below the height that is currently allowed today in the North Ponds Conservation District. This is the context I was telling you about that was looked at carefully by the planning and zoning board and the board of architects. As you can see in

423
02:19:16.880 --> 02:19:32.800
this area of the north pond overlay, we already have buildings that are approved or built today to a height that greatly exceeds what we are proposing. What you're seeing here is buildings that range from 130 ft in height to 190 ft in height within this portion of North

424
02:19:32.800 --> 02:19:49.840
Ponds. So I say this to say that this proposal is not a departure from the planning framework that was established for North Pines, but rather it's a continuation of it. And with that, I'd like to introduce Albert Cordovas, who's our lead designer, to walk you through the project uh and what we've been able

425
02:19:49.840 --> 02:20:06.720
to accomplish with the proposed land use, zoning, and pad requests. >> Good morning, sir. >> Thank you, George. Morning, Mr. Mayor, Vice Mayor, Commissioners. Albert Cordovis with Corwood Architects. Uh first and foremost, I want to thank you for your time in reviewing our

426
02:20:06.720 --> 02:20:23.359
application this morning. Extremely happy to be here. This has been uh a very long process but a a great process when we truly believe that at the end with all those uh meetings we had with staff with our client with the collaborative nature of the board of

427
02:20:23.359 --> 02:20:39.439
architects with that it's culminating into what we truly believe is an incredible project for the community and for the city of Coral Gables. Um George spoke about the vision of North Pond and that's that's exactly where we started um with that particular vision having

428
02:20:39.439 --> 02:21:05.200
the dream of having a city block in the city. We wanted to take this pedestrian realm to truly another level. And in doing that, our goal was to bring the quality of openness, the open space, the articulation of the massing itself

429
02:21:05.200 --> 02:21:20.880
from 8 to nine stories, from east to west. Um and we we said to ourselves the the one goal that we want to make sure we do is to bring this pedestrian realm to another level. Um we started with actually anchoring the building in the

430
02:21:20.880 --> 02:21:43.040
corner of the site and you'll see here some of our site plans. Uh we'll go to the site plan the main corner of the site on right here. So we started anchoring the site in the very main visual corridor with the main lobby access that views directly into

431
02:21:43.040 --> 02:21:59.680
that beautiful courtyard that we spoke about. Uh and in doing the perimeter we wanted to make sure that these were established active spaces or our 16 lift work units the deer school to the west uh and anchoring with another great open

432
02:21:59.680 --> 02:22:15.439
space on the northeast corner of the site which is the park. So essentially 90% of our project is activated fully activated at ground level. In addition to that we actually stepped the building back in some of those areas from minimum setbacks to another 10-ft setbacks uh to

433
02:22:15.439 --> 02:22:32.240
create more green and open space areas and that theme was followed through in the interior. That's why the reason we created that cory, we wanted to bring that quality of life to the interior of the project. And then again connecting all these pieces, we generated the cross

434
02:22:32.240 --> 02:22:50.240
through uh block pel uh which actually generates an incredible connectivity from north to south through the middle of the block itself. Again connecting all those beautiful open spaces that we took from the minimum 20% required to over 32% require over 32% provided on

435
02:22:50.240 --> 02:23:06.960
this project in open space requirements. We were careful to analyze the parking scheme and as you can see essentially is completely linered from all sides with active uses. As we come up the building, the

436
02:23:06.960 --> 02:23:24.080
project as we mentioned breaks itself up into eight stories in the rear, nine stories n eight stories in the east, nine stories on the west. And and one of the things that going back to the ground, I I forgot to mention the the interior u interior loading facilities

437
02:23:24.080 --> 02:23:40.000
uh again was done in order to protect that pedestrian quality uh on the project itself. the school itself as a drop off area at ground level uh which is totally internalized as we can see here. Uh and the entrance to our parking

438
02:23:40.000 --> 02:23:58.240
is also totally internalized again minimizing the curb cuts only two in the entire block one in one out on the north. Again, the articulation as you go up, you saw from our renderings uh that we shared with you um is very key in making

439
02:23:58.240 --> 02:24:13.680
sure that it met all the Mediterranean boards as approved by the board of architects. Uh and when we thought really that the project had conceived a beautiful nature, we come up with a the ability to meet with staff and they have

440
02:24:13.680 --> 02:24:29.920
recommended uh one or two conditions which we thought could be very well implemented into the project. We've taken the lead to do that. One of them was to essentially take that colony from the lift work units on the west and on

441
02:24:29.920 --> 02:24:45.439
the south and push it back to the building, creating a more residential look and feel for these areas. And I'll share some of the uh just recently developed uh renderings that we have of these areas. As you can see here, this

442
02:24:45.439 --> 02:25:01.680
is basically the same building, but stepping the colony back. still featuring an articulation to the building but generating a more uh soft and residential look along those pedestrian realms. Again, by stepping it back, we went from a total of 20 ft of

443
02:25:01.680 --> 02:25:18.240
green area between from the back of car to the building to almost 30 feet of green areas. Now, uh which really really enhances that that complete perimeter of uh of the building as you can see in these pictures. So again, by by the comments of staff uh and working

444
02:25:18.240 --> 02:25:35.040
together, what we thought was good, it got even better because I think now we have a an even more appealing pedestrian realm on the project as we can see here. The other comment that we've uh received from the planning board was to take the anchoring park that we have on the

445
02:25:35.040 --> 02:25:50.080
northeast corner of the building and instead of instead of aligning the park on a north south axis uh to think of aligning it on an east west axis, same square footage, we didn't lose any open space by doing this, but it generates more of a buffer between the women's

446
02:25:50.080 --> 02:26:06.399
club and and the building itself. Uh I we thought that was another uh great recommendation. And as you can see here, we started implementing this already into our project. But again, all in all, I think from from the onset, the vision, the North Pond's vision, the the

447
02:26:06.399 --> 02:26:22.240
multiple meetings with staff, the board of architects approvals, I think we're truly truly culminating with an incredible project for this city and for this community. Thank you. >> Before you end, just a quick question. What is what is the slide number on this page? I want to I want to refer back to

448
02:26:22.240 --> 02:26:52.560
it later. And through the mayor, I'm going to ask that between the presentations, we take a fivem minute restroom break. >> Mr. Mayor, that's slide 48. >> 4 48. >> 48. Mhm. >> 48.

449
02:26:52.560 --> 02:27:12.000
>> 48. Okay. 48. >> Yes, sir. >> So, just to wrap up, um I know we have uh some residents that would like to speak, but uh while we like to take credit for many of these design solutions that you saw today, they were obviously the result of, you know, a lot of collaboration with residents in the

450
02:27:12.000 --> 02:27:26.720
area, with city staff, with your city boards. Um I'm happy to report that we have actively been uh meeting with residents in the area. We have 500 petitions of approval. These petitions are, as you can see here, only eight

451
02:27:26.720 --> 02:27:44.000
blocks. Only an eight block radius. We did not travel, you know, to uh to South Gables or north of 8th Street. This is really from the neighborhood. 500 residents who are in support of this project and its mission. As I uh as Albert mentioned, there's

452
02:27:44.000 --> 02:27:59.840
three conditions of approval. We are in agreement with all three conditions of approval. If this project moves forward, we would ask that they be incorporated into the approval so we could work with your city architect to make sure they're implemented as as part of the final design process.

453
02:27:59.840 --> 02:28:15.920
Um, I'd also like to reaffirm on the record some of the commitments that we have made throughout this 5-year process. The first is the preservation of the oak tree that's on site. We are committed to relocating it to the southwest corner of this site, making it a prominent feature of this project.

454
02:28:15.920 --> 02:28:31.760
We've already started the work. We're starting it early to make sure it's done properly and correct. Second of all, I want to reaffirm our commitment to relocate the statue of Christ that currently sits on the property. We have been in communication with the Church of the Little Flower. And if this project

455
02:28:31.760 --> 02:28:47.280
is approved, we will be relocating the statue of Christ to the Church of the Little Flower and creating a first communion garden so it could sit in a prominent location that could be enjoyed and appreciated by the community. We're also committed to, which we have currently preserved, the uh the plaques

456
02:28:47.280 --> 02:29:02.240
within within the property. Uh we will be uh happy to donate the war plaques to the Coral Gables War Memorial so they could be preserved in a second in a setting that recognizes their importance. And we've also, as we mentioned during the historic

457
02:29:02.240 --> 02:29:19.439
preservation uh review process that was early on in this project's uh history, we will be implementing and incorporating the rest of the plaques within the property throughout the common open spaces. So, as you could see, this project represents a unique opportunity to accomplish a lot of goals

458
02:29:19.439 --> 02:29:34.399
of the North Pon overlay and accomplish something truly special in terms of community benefits. It's a project that's been designed and extensively reviewed and significantly improved recently through collaboration with city staff and your planning and zoning board. And for all these reasons, we

459
02:29:34.399 --> 02:29:49.920
recommend we request your approval in accordance with the staff report and the recommendation of your planning and zoning board. Thank you. >> Thank you very much. Uh Mr. Clerk, I have 11:23 starting at 11:04. That's 19 minutes. Am I off?

460
02:29:49.920 --> 02:30:06.000
>> I had them starting at 11:05, but you're not off by then. >> Okay. Well, we'll give him 11:05. So, what do we have? I wanted to come from you so I can write this down. >> 18 minutes, sir. >> 11:23 is a total of 18 minutes. Okay,

461
02:30:06.000 --> 02:41:45.560
we will take a 5m minute break at the request of the vice mayor and then we'll hear uh from our dear friends now. See you in five minutes at My ready. >> Yes, sir. We're ready. Okay.

462
02:41:46.960 --> 02:42:14.319
>> All right. I'd like to welcome everyone back. It is 11:35. >> Ready? Perfect. Let me just wait to our room. >> Madam director. >> Good morning. Jennifer Garcia, planning and zoning director. If I could have a

463
02:42:14.319 --> 02:42:35.520
PowerPoint, please. When you're ready. Thank you. So as we know this is the entire block of 21 in the Douglas section highlighted here in yellow. This is an aerial looking down with an existing u former

464
02:42:35.520 --> 02:42:51.760
church um the existing home of the crystal academy um bounded by the north uh Phoenicia Galaniano on the south and then east pon to the west. This is a view looking south. You can see Pon Leon

465
02:42:51.760 --> 02:43:06.640
on the right side of the project and you can see Gallaliano running along the left side. So in 1967 the property was reszoned from apartment use to special use zoning

466
02:43:06.640 --> 02:43:22.640
to allow a church as well as to allow a kindergarten. that was expanded in 1971 to I believe to third grade and then again in 1991 to cap that student enrollment to 75 students along with other conditions. Um

467
02:43:22.640 --> 02:43:39.200
staff is recommending that a condition of 75 students still remain for the property but to allow the Crystal Academy to be a principal use and no longer an accessory use. There are three requests that you're going to be considering today. The fourth will be considered if it's

468
02:43:39.200 --> 02:43:55.200
approved on first reading. The first one is a a change the future land use map for the concurrent of plan. The second one is a zoning map change. The third one is the plan area development. So the the current property the currently is uh future land use

469
02:43:55.200 --> 02:44:10.560
designation of religious institutional and they're proposing to change that to commercial commercial mid-rise intensity and also to include that uh property within the mixeduse um district of the north ponds and that is to allow the

470
02:44:10.560 --> 02:44:27.120
school to be a principal use um within the project. So looking at massing models, this is existing conditions. All those white buildings are the current building heights of the of the area. The subject property is the green property zoned S

471
02:44:27.120 --> 02:44:43.279
and around it are the white buildings at existing heights. So if you overlay the current allowed zoning for your land use, you have um the brown um being 70 feet in height or 97 with the Mediterranean bonus. So you

472
02:44:43.279 --> 02:45:02.000
can see that on the brown to the east and to the south of the jud property on the left side on Bont Leon. You can see the red which of course is significantly higher heights of 97 where that step back is up to 150 or 190.5 ft along Pon

473
02:45:02.000 --> 02:45:19.359
Leon. This property is settling between the um lower medium intensity of North Ponds which again is 70 feet or 97 feet in height and then the more intense uh heights along Pon Leon.

474
02:45:19.359 --> 02:45:34.880
The applicant is proposing to change the zoning here from special use, as you can see right here, to a um to mid-rise, commercial mid-rise, again commercial to allow the school to remain there on site, matching the same height as the

475
02:45:34.880 --> 02:45:52.080
browned. So the height would be 70 ft or 97 ft of height. So again, this is existing with the white buildings of what the massing is today with the current allowed zoning. You can see pockets of those white buildings are

476
02:45:52.080 --> 02:46:08.240
historic properties, but the rest have height allowed of 70 ft or 97 ft. They're proposing to do MX2 or commercial midrise land use intensity and that would allow a height of 70 or 97 ft.

477
02:46:08.240 --> 02:46:23.920
The zoning map is also proposed to change from S zoning to MX2 zoning. Also incorporating the property into the North Pond's mixeduse district, which of course is removing them from the North Pond's conservation district. A little

478
02:46:23.920 --> 02:46:39.760
history about that. The North Pond's neighborhood conservation district is for conserving those apartment buildings in the area. They applied to MF2 properties. So they allow for additional uses. conditional uses for designated historic properties. They have a

479
02:46:39.760 --> 02:46:56.880
historic preservation benefits program for properties that are built before 1964 that exempt parking that allow for TDR or transfer development rights sending sites as well as um allowances and signage. There's a garden apartment conservation benefits program as well as

480
02:46:56.880 --> 02:47:13.520
properties built before 1964 to allow for variance requests and reduce um parking requirements for new construction. your um there are additional requirements for landscape for front yards. There's no walls or fence allowed. There's maximum driveway

481
02:47:13.520 --> 02:47:31.120
widths as well as um parking setbacks behind habitable space. So for new construction under the conservation district, you are required to follow the zoning, the height, the FIR, the density, the setbacks. They still apply for any new construction within the

482
02:47:31.120 --> 02:47:47.279
neighborhood conservation overlay. So the third request is the pad the planned area development. So the site plan that I have I did not I not know about the new site plan of retaining the park. Um so the park is on the northeast

483
02:47:47.279 --> 02:48:02.319
corner. The crystal academy is facing Galliano. There are crosswalks on all four sides of the property. Um there's a public plaza on the south uh west corner. a public courtyard and po an

484
02:48:02.319 --> 02:48:19.680
interior block of the of the site plan. The pickup and drop off of the school is located with inside the um the property across the po and the courtyard internally accessed. So the applicant is requesting two code

485
02:48:19.680 --> 02:48:35.359
deviations. The pad allows you to request deviations from the code in exchange for pug benefits. So right now you are only allowed to have eight stories of height or uh MX2 properties. Um they are proposing to do nine stories

486
02:48:35.359 --> 02:48:53.120
on East Pon Leon and then scale down to eight stories when facing Galliano. The other uh deviation they're requesting is a slight deviation. This is based of course on the plans that I have submitted, not the new rotated park plan. um they only have 27% of

487
02:48:53.120 --> 02:49:08.160
transparency or glass that's facing Bonicia across the street from the back of house of the women's club. Other benefit that they're that they're offering is a 5,000 foot educational facility for Crystal Academy or any few

488
02:49:08.160 --> 02:49:24.399
future uh nonprofit organization. Um they are offering the school to be there without any cost rent free for 990 years. and they're offering that in a covenant that's included in your packet today. They're also providing a 4,000

489
02:49:24.399 --> 02:49:41.680
foot park for daytime uh learning for the school as well as public access after hours. And that's the same for the courtyard and the pedestrian pass through. The conditional uses for the site plan and for the school and for live works.

490
02:49:41.680 --> 02:49:58.479
are all required to do conditional use um review and and approval. This is not being considered by you, but we're going to explain it anyway because it's all cont connected to the pad and the request change of land use and change of zoning. So again, the park is in the northeast corner today. It's been

491
02:49:58.479 --> 02:50:16.720
rotated as u required or recommended by the flying zoning board. Uh the school is facing Galliano. The pickup and drop off is internally accessed. You have a vehicular uh one way access from Antia from the south and going north and emptying out onto Phoenicia. There's a

492
02:50:16.720 --> 02:50:35.520
courtyard and the love work surrounds uh most of the property. So again, the existing uh property is almost 1.5. It's 1.49 acres large. The F is at 3.5, which is they're allowed to do. They're requesting uh 93 feet of

493
02:50:35.520 --> 02:50:51.600
height when they're allowed to have 97 feet with Mediterranean bonus. And they're requesting do nine stories instead of eight stories which are allowed to do through the pad request designation. They're doing the nine stories again on east ponds and then eight stories facing the Galliano.

494
02:50:51.600 --> 02:51:08.720
They're allowed to do 184 units with 125 units per acre. They're requesting to do 184 units. Um 16 live work units. the school of 500 square feet and the parking spaces uh 301. They're um

495
02:51:08.720 --> 02:51:23.520
providing 20,000 square feet of open space. There's a rendering looking northwest. That's entrance of the school. This is outdated. It is not showing the rotation of the park which would look a little

496
02:51:23.520 --> 02:51:40.240
bit different today. So reviewed by DRC back in January of 2022. a review by the board of architects later that year with approval in October 2023. They had a neighborhood meeting officially uh earlier this year

497
02:51:40.240 --> 02:51:55.600
in May. Panzian board reviewed this property, this application uh last month, recommended approval and you were here looking at this for first reading for today. We'll come back to you if approved for second reading. letters were mailed to the property

498
02:51:55.600 --> 02:52:10.880
owners and current occupants within 1500 feet of the property as required by the zoning code and that was mailed three times. The property was posted nine times. Website was posted nine times as well and that new super was advertised

499
02:52:10.880 --> 02:52:26.640
once. So staff has determined that this application is consistent with the comp plan. is providing housing in area that we want to encourage more and more workforce housing um to keep with the increase in of housing demand in the

500
02:52:26.640 --> 02:52:42.880
area. We recommend approval with conditions. These conditions are outlined in the PADD ordinance at the very end. But briefly, it's um capping the height at nine stories or 93 feet of height uh 500 square ft for Crystal

501
02:52:42.880 --> 02:52:59.840
Academy with 75 students maximum. Um to rotate the corner park to be east and west as recommended by the plans board which they have done. I have not been able to review that at length. Um they will remove the arcade, provide stoops

502
02:52:59.840 --> 02:53:16.800
and porches to have front yards to be more in character with the north ponds conservation district. Uh they're going to incorporate landscape a setback on the north side which is Phoenicia and then have a public accessible courtyard covered walkway and corner park. Um they

503
02:53:16.800 --> 02:53:34.520
also have off-site improvements as well including underground utility lines along Phoenicia as well. That's it. Thank you. Thank you very much, Madam Director. Mr. Winker. Good morning, sir.

504
02:53:41.040 --> 02:54:06.080
>> Good morning, >> Mr. Clerk. What time is it? >> 11:47, sir. >> Thank you very much. >> I have a PowerPoint I'd like to present. >> Yes, sir. Cable TV put up Mr. Winker's presentation. There you go. >> Thank you. David Winker, law offices at

505
02:54:06.080 --> 02:54:20.000
4720 South Leune. I represent Bunny Bolton who lives adjacent to the property. Here we go again. Another developer wanting to build an

506
02:54:20.000 --> 02:54:35.680
out of scale project by getting the city to grant it special concessions, waiverss, exceptions, and a massive upzoning. Here we have an out of town developer

507
02:54:35.680 --> 02:54:51.600
who wants the city to relieve it from its obligations under our city code and our master plan to build more than double what it would otherwise be allowed to build.

508
02:54:51.600 --> 02:55:06.399
And this is a problem that keeps happening again and again in our city and it's frustrating residents. And that's what you're going to hear today in public comment. And it begs the

509
02:55:06.399 --> 02:55:24.319
question, what are we getting in return as residents and taxpayers for these massive upzonings? Neighborhood context matters. This property sits within an established residential neighborhood. Four single

510
02:55:24.319 --> 02:55:41.279
family homes directly abut this project. The current use is special use religious. The current height limit is four stories. The surrounding development, as you saw in the maps, is predominantly one and

511
02:55:41.279 --> 02:55:57.359
twostory structures. This project puts puts our historic resources at risk. Six historically designated structures are located on Phoenicia Avenue near the project. Three historically designated structures are

512
02:55:57.359 --> 02:56:13.200
located on Antia. The neighborhood is currently being studied for historic district designation. Historic preservation includes protecting the historic neighborhood scale and context.

513
02:56:13.200 --> 02:56:30.880
This ninestory structure permanently will alter that context. And let's get down into the code. We're not asking you guys to do us a favor. We're asking you to enforce the city code. Section 11 103 of the zoning code

514
02:56:30.880 --> 02:56:46.319
says the purpose of the code is to implement the comprehensive plan. The comprehensive plan's goal is to protect Coral Gable's historic and architectural character, preserve George Merrick's vision, protect residential

515
02:56:46.319 --> 02:57:04.240
neighborhoods from incompatible uses, and require compatibility with surrounding architecture and development. This project conflicts with section 103. 226,000 square foot of development, 184

516
02:57:04.240 --> 02:57:21.439
residential units, 93 foot tall building in a low-scale neighborhood. The intensity, the massing, and the scale are incompatible with the surrounding development. There is no argument against that. The this project undermines the stated purposes of the

517
02:57:21.439 --> 02:57:39.120
zoning code. It also conflicts with the North Pond's conservation overlay. The overlay district was adopted to preserve neighborhood character, protect the historic garden apartment fabric of the neighborhood, maintain traditional development patterns. The applicant

518
02:57:39.120 --> 02:57:55.439
seeks removal from the overlay because the project cannot comply with it. I talked earlier about asking for favors. They're asking the project be removed from the overlay because they can't comply. If the project was compatible,

519
02:57:55.439 --> 02:58:11.200
they would comply. Conflict with Coral Gable's historic city plan. The city plan was unanimously adopted. Calls for preservation of neighborhood character. Encourages development compatible with surrounding residential areas supporting lowscale

520
02:58:11.200 --> 02:58:28.240
development patterns. Again, nine stories is inconsistent with these objectives. conflict with the North Pon's community vision. The vision workshop recommended preserving the garden apartment character of this neighborhood, recommended maintaining building heights

521
02:58:28.240 --> 02:58:43.359
between two and four stories, encouraged preservation of neighborhood scale, supported exploration of public park and open space opportunities. And we're going to get into the problem with this project visav public park and open space

522
02:58:43.359 --> 02:59:00.240
opportunities. It is inconsistent with our comprehensive plan. It converts a religious institutional site into dense residential commercial development. It res removes existing neighborhood

523
02:59:00.240 --> 02:59:16.240
protections. There is no affordable housing commitment despite reliance on housing policies. Fails to preserve neighborhood character and overall the approval will undermine long-term planning goals.

524
02:59:16.240 --> 02:59:32.720
The compatibility analysis. South and east properties are residential. The existing campus is low intensity. The proposed project dramatically increases density and activity, scale, and massing out of character.

525
02:59:32.720 --> 02:59:50.000
Traffic and concurrency. The staff acknowledges in its report there's additional traffic and delays in an area that already has streets that that struggle to handle the existing traffic. 301 space parking garage

526
02:59:50.000 --> 03:00:06.399
is going to result in significant traffic generation. Residential traffic, school traffic, visitors and deliveries are going to compound those impacts. These narrow residential streets are not designed for this level of intensity.

527
03:00:06.399 --> 03:00:23.840
This project does not take into account nor the traffic study take into account the changes that are currently happening on ponds. Infrastructure concerns again street network is constrained. The school drop off and pickup activity creates

528
03:00:23.840 --> 03:00:45.120
additional congestion. Traffic mitigation is deferred. Now, I want to get to what I think is probably the most important part of this. We as a neighborhood, we as a community can, we as residents can decide

529
03:00:45.120 --> 03:01:00.479
to forego or grant exceptions to developers. The question is what are we getting in return? And this project really brings into focus how little we're getting back for

530
03:01:00.479 --> 03:01:16.160
what we're giving. Remember, we're letting them build twice what they could otherwise build otherwise build. So, let's look at what we're getting. They're going through the PAD process. It's intended to reward exceptional public benefits.

531
03:01:16.160 --> 03:01:31.279
The additional story count and design deviations only benefit the developer. Let's go into the code 3-501. The purpose of PAD encourage creative development that goes beyond standard

532
03:01:31.279 --> 03:01:47.920
zoning. Allow additional development rights only when the project provides quote substantial additional public benefit. What does this mean? The purpose of PAT is not simply to allow a larger

533
03:01:47.920 --> 03:02:05.439
building. It is to ensure that any additional height, density or intensity is justified by a meaningful benefit to the public. The city must find equivalent public benefits under 3-502.

534
03:02:05.439 --> 03:02:22.399
Before approving a PAD, the city must find that the project provides public benefits, quote, to a degree at least equivalent to what standard zoning regulations would otherwise require? Question before the commission is, what

535
03:02:22.399 --> 03:02:38.640
public benefit is being provided in exchange for what they're getting? additional height, additional density, increased intensity and departure from the standard zoning li limitations. If the benefit is not equivalent, the pad

536
03:02:38.640 --> 03:02:57.600
must be denied. This project has morphed. There was some talk of the public benefit being the p the the the green space that was being provided. They've moved past that. They're now saying that Crystal Academy is the public benefit.

537
03:02:57.600 --> 03:03:14.479
The claimed benefit to the community is Crystal Academy. What is Crystal Crystal Academy? It's a private school, $38,000 tuition. It currently, I believe, has 75 students, last time I checked, paying almost $3 million in tuition, not open

538
03:03:14.479 --> 03:03:31.200
to the general public, and it's accessible to the families who are enrolled at the school. This is nothing against Bristol Academy. Crystal Academy is being used by the developer to justify what's happening.

539
03:03:31.200 --> 03:03:46.479
So, it's important to look at does it qualify and provide the broader benefits that are required to satisfy the PAD code. A private school serving a small number

540
03:03:46.479 --> 03:04:04.399
of paying students is a private benefit, not a public benefit. The public benefit being offered in exchange for a n-story building is a private school. Section 3-502C6 requires that at least 20%

541
03:04:04.399 --> 03:04:22.560
landscaped open space. the courtyard that they're providing does not meet that requirement. What the developer attorney did not mention when it said that this project was approved by the PAP was we

542
03:04:22.560 --> 03:04:39.439
were asked, I was specifically asked, would you agree, would you be happy if we condition approval on this on reorienting the garden in a way that saves as much of the garden as

543
03:04:39.439 --> 03:04:55.279
you're going to hear a lot of residents talking about that. That was seen as a victory for this project and we were expecting to see reorientation of the garden, a reorientation and be able to save as much of the garden as possible.

544
03:04:55.279 --> 03:05:11.439
You saw from the drawings, nothing's changed. They're not saving any more of the garden. The slide they showed was 48. Uh Mayor Loggo asked for which the one was. If you look at it, it's over on this side. The garden's on this side on the east side. It has nothing to do. It

545
03:05:11.439 --> 03:05:28.240
has not it has not taken into account what PAB asked for. The courtyard is not meaningful public space. The proposed courtyard is associated with a private school. Public's access is limited, conditional, unavailable during school

546
03:05:28.240 --> 03:05:44.640
hours. It's not equivalent to a public park. In some, this is a bad deal for taxpayers. Restricted access is inconsistent with the concept of public space. Part-time access does not constitute a

547
03:05:44.640 --> 03:06:01.359
substantial additional public benefit. Occasional access should not justify these massive increases in destiny density. This creates a dangerous precedent. approval removes conservation

548
03:06:01.359 --> 03:06:17.040
protections, over provides planning policies, creates the tallest structure of the immediate neighborhood, and is going to invite similar upzoning throughout North Ponds. We ask the commission to independently evaluate the consistency and

549
03:06:17.040 --> 03:06:32.479
compatibility, and we believe that must recommend denial when evidence demonstrates inconsistency with the city's plans and regulations. Protect our neighborhoods is the core request.

550
03:06:32.479 --> 03:06:48.560
Thank you very much, >> Mr. Clerk. What time is it? >> 12. >> 12:0, Miss Mayor. >> So, that's 13 minutes. >> Yes, sir. >> Would you like to speak a little further on anything else? >> Thank you,

551
03:06:48.560 --> 03:07:05.040
>> All right. Perfect. Want to make sure. >> All right, Mr. Clerk. Uh, do we have any public comment? >> We do, Miss Mar. Good. All right. >> If I would if I could reiterate what I said in the beginning, let's try to be as concise as possible. We have a very

552
03:07:05.040 --> 03:07:20.800
long meeting today. Um, we're willing to listen to all your issues and your concerns and we're very grateful that you're here. Uh, let's keep it professional. Uh, remember that we're here discussing this project. We're not talking about anything else outside of the project scope. And let's keep it to

553
03:07:20.800 --> 03:07:37.319
that project. Okay? And when I ask you very kindly if you could bring it in for a landing, please try to bring it in for a landing. Not a rough one, but let's bring it in for a smooth landing. Thank you. First speaker, Maria Cruz.

554
03:07:46.479 --> 03:08:03.920
Mrs. Maria Cruz, 1447 Miller Road. I just heard that the principal use of this project is the Crystal Academy. Interesting. Nine stories, they get the ground floor. 20,58

555
03:08:03.920 --> 03:08:19.040
ft, they get 5,000, not even a quarter of the project. The second item, a public park. a public park that designed obviously for little small kids, not for

556
03:08:19.040 --> 03:08:34.720
teenagers. Well, I don't know many small kids that will be taken there after school hours when they're supposed to be taking a bath and going eating and going to sleep. That is not a public park. That's a park for the convenience of the

557
03:08:34.720 --> 03:09:00.399
school. Period. The end. That is not a good idea. is not what is presented to be and I'm sorry it should not be approved >> Kelly child >> good afternoon Kelly Shield 905

558
03:09:00.399 --> 03:09:17.200
University Drive before I give my statement I'd like to make a general comment regarding civic involvement in our city residents that oppose this project may not be here today. Unfortunately, they are resigned to the fact that there's no use in getting involved and have even predicted the

559
03:09:17.200 --> 03:09:33.680
vote. Comments include, "It's a done deal. Going to the city commission is an exercise in futility, and what's the use?" Personally, I feel and I'm optimistic that maybe my voice matters. So, with that, thank you for the opportunity to offer my comments

560
03:09:33.680 --> 03:09:51.279
regarding 110 Phoenicia Avenue. Today you're being asked by the current property owner who has owned the property for 90 days and a real estate developer from Chicago to rewrite Coral Gable zoning code in an attempt to save their $16 million

561
03:09:51.279 --> 03:10:07.680
investment. This is a company that states on their website that they have hard-nosed solutions to maximize proceeds for our partners. The current owners took a risk and bought 1.5 acres in the North Pines Conservation District with full

562
03:10:07.680 --> 03:10:23.760
knowledge the proposed plans are not in compliance with current zoning. Today they're asking you to ignore the rules and bail them out. What is sad is that these owners are using Crystal Academy, their students, and families as pawns,

563
03:10:23.760 --> 03:10:40.319
expecting that their pledge to provide space at the bottom of a ninestory building should be enough to rewrite our city's laws. For the price of 5,000 square feet, the applicant is expecting an additional five more stories and 170,000 square

564
03:10:40.319 --> 03:10:57.920
feet. I spent my career in nursing homes, so I know better than most the importance of caring for vulnerable populations. Crystal Academy has known since 2022 that their school property was sold and they must vacate the premises. The

565
03:10:57.920 --> 03:11:14.800
school and the students will need to move when that land is developed. I can't imagine that Crystal Academy is putting all their faith in this Hail Mary plan and sincerely hope that they have taken responsible steps to secure a future location. This is not a vote for or against

566
03:11:14.800 --> 03:11:30.880
Crystal Academy. In fact, the developer could be altruistic and provide space for the school while at the same time following the current zoning codes. Coral Gable's residents are held to strict zoning codes to preserve the integrity of our neighborhoods. But this

567
03:11:30.880 --> 03:11:46.800
does not seem to apply to developers. For the promise of a school or a park, exceptions are made despite the loud protests of those that live in our city. The sad reality is that many Coral Gable's residents are of the opinion that this is a done deal. And they may

568
03:11:46.800 --> 03:12:01.279
be right, but your decision will put you on the record of where you stand. Is the city of Coral Gable's commission with developers or residents or somewhere in between? I did provide a slide that

569
03:12:01.279 --> 03:12:17.279
shows a rendering of what could the next one please, city clerk. Thank you. This is a rendering of what could be put onto that property under the current conservation overlay.

570
03:12:17.279 --> 03:12:46.399
Thank you, Nicholas Cabrera. >> Good afternoon, sir. Afternoon. >> Good afternoon, mayor, members of the city commission. My name is Nicholas Cabrera and I reside at 45 Antia Avenue. And I'm here today in support of the Crystal Residence Project. This project

571
03:12:46.399 --> 03:13:02.319
has been in the public process for nearly 5 years. 5 years of reviews, hearings, and appeals. At some point, the question stops being whether the process was followed and becomes whether we're willing to respect it when we don't like the outcome.

572
03:13:02.319 --> 03:13:18.319
Last month, I published a post on Asop's Gables in which I addressed three arguments against the project. Incompatibility, loss of green space, and lack of public benefit. In fact, I also address many of the uh arguments made in Mr. Winker's presentation today.

573
03:13:18.319 --> 03:13:33.840
So, let's deal in facts. Let's start with compatibility because that's the foundation of everything else. The North Pon neighborhood is the last and most appropriate area in Coral Gables for this type of development. This area has little to no historical significance

574
03:13:33.840 --> 03:13:50.319
aside from a handful of sites, including the women's club, a carriage house, Douglas entrress, and a few homes. This is not a historic district. The property at 110 Phoenicia is not historic. The Garden of our Lord is not historic. That

575
03:13:50.319 --> 03:14:07.040
argument has been made. It has been reviewed and it does not apply. Second, this is one of the most accessible areas of the city. It is bounded by Southwest 8th Street, Douglas Road, and Lun Road. It is connected. It is walkable and it's exactly where density belongs if we're serious about

576
03:14:07.040 --> 03:14:23.520
smart planning. Third, this is the most transient part of Coral Gables. It is dominated by rental apartment buildings with very few single family homes. Many of these buildings are older, undermaintained, and not reflective of the architectural identity people claim to be protecting.

577
03:14:23.520 --> 03:14:40.160
This is not a fragile, lowdensity enclave. It is already an evolving urban corridor. And let's be honest, this project is not out of scale. There are buildings in the immediate area and adjacent to the property that are equal to or larger than what's being proposed

578
03:14:40.160 --> 03:14:57.359
today. Let's take 911 East Pon Leon Boulevard as an example. It is over 12 stories or 12 stories. The idea that this is somehow incompatible simply doesn't hold up on green space. The current condition is private. I can't

579
03:14:57.359 --> 03:15:14.000
just jump over the fence. I'd be trespassing on private property. The public cannot access it. This project introduces true publicly accessible green space in the form of a plaza, a courtyard, and a park. Real space that residents can actually use. and on

580
03:15:14.000 --> 03:15:28.560
public benefit. This is where the conversation should stop. At the center of this project is Crystal Academy, a school serving children with profound autism. 40 children, 40 families, teachers and staff who are doing incredibly difficult, incredibly

581
03:15:28.560 --> 03:15:44.479
important work every single day. I'm going to be going over time. I apologize. The developer has committed to providing them with a brand new purpose-built facility under a 99-year lease at no cost. That is not a talking point. It is not a promise. It is a commitment. And

582
03:15:44.479 --> 03:15:59.840
yet somehow this has turned into a reason to oppose the project. That's not just misguided. It's backwards. Before I conclude my comments, I'd like to talk about George Merrick because his name has come up more than once throughout this entire process. I've heard a lot about preserving Merrick's

583
03:15:59.840 --> 03:16:16.319
vision and I think it's worth remembering. George Merik himself was a developer. He didn't preserve Coral Gables, he built it. If we're truly honoring his vision, then we should be focused on thoughtful, wellplanned development like the Crystal Residences,

584
03:16:16.319 --> 03:16:33.439
not freezing the city in time. Because here's the truth. If George Merrick had approached Coral Gables the way we approach development today, this city would not exist. >> I'll leave you with this. At some point, we have to decide whether we are a city that plans or a city that stalls.

585
03:16:33.439 --> 03:16:49.279
Whether we follow our process or allow it to be weaponized against itself, whether we build thoughtfully or not at all, I respectfully ask you to vote in favor of crystal residences. Thank you, Mayor, and I apologize for going over time. >> 68 seconds.

586
03:16:49.279 --> 03:17:04.720
>> Commissioner Ralph Cabber, >> if we if we could um first and foremost, let's eliminate the clapping if possible. Thank you, Commissioner. Thank you for being here with us. It's always an honor and a privilege to have you here with us. >> I'm not here often. It it happens infrequently and I hope it would happen

587
03:17:04.720 --> 03:17:19.520
more. >> I don't know about that. >> Welcome welcome back to your home. Thank you. >> I like your I like your temporary gigs. Uh so good afternoon Mr. Mayor. Good afternoon members of the city commission. Mr. Manager, always a pleasure to see you as well as you, Mr.

588
03:17:19.520 --> 03:17:34.640
Clerk. For the record, my name is Ralph Cabrera. I live at 1300 Ponellion Boulevard. So, I consider myself a stakeholder in this particular application.

589
03:17:34.640 --> 03:17:51.120
I've got some comments to make and observations to make. And I'm going to leave you with one last piece of advice uh because I spent 12 years up there and we we dealt with many many similar projects. But first, let me give you

590
03:17:51.120 --> 03:18:07.840
some background. When I first came to this country, my mother insisted that we live in Coral Gables. And the only place that my dad could afford was a small two-bedroom, two-bath apartment on Douglas Road between Phoenicia and

591
03:18:07.840 --> 03:18:22.960
Calabria. So, I'm one of those kids in the 60s. I know it's hard to believe I'm that old. I'm one of those kids in the 60s who played in that immediate area. I I would go to the Coral Gables library, which is

592
03:18:22.960 --> 03:18:38.640
today the Coral Gables uh women's club, and I would venture into the Garden of Lord with my friends because we would like we enjoyed feeding the koiish uh with Cheerios. And uh about half the

593
03:18:38.640 --> 03:18:52.960
time we were asked very promptly by either the minister or a member of the church to vacate the premise. So I can attest to the fact that even in the 60s it was not a public space.

594
03:18:52.960 --> 03:19:08.880
Now let me take you to 2000 2001 when I decided to run for office and I made a emphasis about development because in those days we had two types of developers.

595
03:19:08.880 --> 03:19:25.520
We had a group of developers that will go unnamed that simply wanted to develop for the sake of development. And then we had another group of developers who were thoughtful, who planned the development, who worked with the city, who worked

596
03:19:25.520 --> 03:19:42.560
with the stakeholders and built a better project. I'll give you two examples of those developers. One is Mr. Armando Cadina who is a local developer but the second it's actually an out of town developer. Can you believe that? An out of town developer coming to the city of

597
03:19:42.560 --> 03:19:59.520
Coral Gables. That was the Rouse Company who built an introverted mall for a lack of a better word or a park called the village of Merrick Park that worked hand inhand with the community. Now, my son mentioned the part about the

598
03:19:59.520 --> 03:20:15.040
Northeast Quadrant. While in office, I felt that the Northeast Quadrant was probably the most suited space for development. Why? Because it was indeed transient. Why? Because it provided exceptional

599
03:20:15.040 --> 03:20:31.120
infrastructure. I'm sorry, the 12 years maybe gives me another minute. >> You got time. >> Okay. and it provided exceptional access as it's been pointed out. Lun Road, Douglas, Southwest 8th Street, Windwood,

600
03:20:31.120 --> 03:20:47.120
Miami Beach, downtown, those are all areas that are highly, highly accessible to this particular area. And finally, I'm going to comment on a couple of false narratives. The first one is

601
03:20:47.120 --> 03:21:03.120
this is going to have a public area for all of those who live in that area. I am one of them and I'm looking forward to being able to go to that park. Secondly, this nonsense about the students who

602
03:21:03.120 --> 03:21:18.880
attend Crystal Academy being from wealthy families, the person who made that comment should be ashamed of themselves. So I ask you, look at the developer that's before you. Someone who's done everything the right way.

603
03:21:18.880 --> 03:21:35.359
Five years, possibly six years. You heard about the church. You heard about the the cross being relocated to St. Teresa. You've heard about the 100year lease that Crystal Academy will be receiving. So this is the institutional

604
03:21:35.359 --> 03:21:51.120
part of my commentary today. While I was up there, there were no hard decisions to make. There were only right and wrong decisions. And I sincerely hope that today you make the right decision on

605
03:21:51.120 --> 03:22:10.000
behalf of this applicant. Thank you very much. >> Thank you, Commissioner Armando Oliveros Jr. >> Good morning, Mr. Mayor, Madame Vice Mayor, and commissioners. Uh my name is Armando Liberos. I also live at 1300

606
03:22:10.000 --> 03:22:26.880
ponds. Uh I don't envy your position there as I was on the city commission of South Miami for many years back in the 90s my prior life. Uh and I understand the situation before you. However,

607
03:22:26.880 --> 03:22:44.319
that project is going to enliven that area. I live what 200 yards from it. Uh I don't see the issue with not being compatible. We have larger buildings, we have dilapidated buildings, old apartment buildings, and this will bring

608
03:22:44.319 --> 03:23:00.239
new life to this area of Coral Gables, which has is I think the last bastion of uh more development. We've developed the south part of Bon and now we're moving a little bit north. And I see that as a beautiful future for this community. I

609
03:23:00.239 --> 03:23:15.760
moved here from South Miami after 40 years there because I loved the area of Coral Gables. It had something to offer me that South Miami didn't at that time, which is pedestrian areas to walk to. I can walk the Miracle Mile, which is at

610
03:23:15.760 --> 03:23:32.160
my age, a little long walk, but I still do it. I thank God for the trolley. Uh, but this will bring more life to this part of the community, to this area where I can walk, where I can see other people. that area unless you live there. And I understand that people in Coral

611
03:23:32.160 --> 03:23:48.160
Gables who live far away are objecting to this project. But what you have to consider is the people who live in the area who want it, who need it, who need more life and more uh ability to move around in this little section because

612
03:23:48.160 --> 03:24:04.000
it's not a big section. It's a little section. So I don't want to reiterate the fact that it's been before the board, it's been before staff. It's been contemplated all the different issues and it's past muster with everything that the city has to provide. Now, I

613
03:24:04.000 --> 03:24:19.920
only suggest that you take into consideration the fact of the people in the surrounding areas are all in favor of this project. And my only query is and I understand some questions about the school that some people may say what are they going to do when the construction where are they going to

614
03:24:19.920 --> 03:24:36.720
move the school and I would ask the applicant to maybe explain a little bit what they are willing to do with the students during that period of time because that worries a lot of the people but other than that other than that this project should be a go it's going to be beneficial for the community it's going

615
03:24:36.720 --> 03:24:59.040
to be beneficial for the city and it's going to be mostly beneficial for the residents in that particular area. Thank you very much. >> Thank you, Maria Longo. >> Good afternoon. My name is Maria Christina Longo and I live in a historic

616
03:24:59.040 --> 03:25:17.520
single family home on the same street at 16 Phoenicia Avenue where the proposed project is. I support preserving the school and I respect its mission wholeheartedly.

617
03:25:17.520 --> 03:25:33.439
Actually, I used to be a teacher. But if this commission is going to approve a project of this size, approximately 200 units and a ninestory building, I respectfully ask that approval be

618
03:25:33.439 --> 03:25:48.960
condition on three things. first require the developer to fund a corridor or streetscape study coordinated by the city's public works department for the

619
03:25:48.960 --> 03:26:06.479
east pawns Galliano Phoenicia and Antigga area to address the dangerous intersections circulation patterns turning movements pedestrian safety crosswalk walks,

620
03:26:06.479 --> 03:26:22.239
sidewalks, and landscaping. Second, require setbacks that allow that follow the multifamily to form, including a substantial buffer of large

621
03:26:22.239 --> 03:26:39.439
trees on those setbacks. Third, require meaningful and functional open public space that is truly accessible to the surrounding neighborhood, not simply a private courtyard for the

622
03:26:39.439 --> 03:26:54.880
residents and the school. These three conditions matter because this project is not being proposed in a vacuum. It will have a lasting impact on the

623
03:26:54.880 --> 03:27:10.800
surrounding neighborhood. First, the corridor study. The intersections at East Pawns, Gallaliano, Phoenicia, and Alijah are already difficult and very dangerous. I have personally witnessed

624
03:27:10.800 --> 03:27:29.120
walking my dog two accidents and two horrible accidents which I have already um I sent emails to public works about it se for several years I haven't heard anything back so

625
03:27:29.120 --> 03:27:45.680
because also of the new median configuration on pawns this is a new problem cars exiting the project will not be able to move west through Phoenicia as easily, which means

626
03:27:45.680 --> 03:28:02.239
Phoenicia to the east, my side, I live on the east side of the project, is likely to become one of the easiest exit routes. That will place even more pressure on nearby residential streets and

627
03:28:02.239 --> 03:28:17.040
intersections that are already strained. That is why the developer should fund a corridor or streetscape study coordinated by public works. Second, setbacks and trees. The setbacks

628
03:28:17.040 --> 03:28:34.319
proposed here are simply too tight for a project of this scale. For example, the setbacks proposed along Galliano are far too narrow for this type of building and location. In some instances on the

629
03:28:34.319 --> 03:28:53.040
Galliano side, there are zero setbacks. A building of this height and mass should not sit nearly on top of the street and the neighboring properties across from it. If the applicant wants the benefit of the resoning, then the

630
03:28:53.040 --> 03:29:10.319
project should also be required to use the multifamily two form for the setbacks along Galliano. >> Could we please wrap it up? Thank you. >> May I you can finish almost finished. >> Third, public open space. What is

631
03:29:10.319 --> 03:29:26.640
currently being offered does not amount to minimum f public open space for the surrounding neighborhood. A private internal courtyard or green space effectively reserved for the project's residents and the school is not the same

632
03:29:26.640 --> 03:29:41.600
as a meaningful public open space for the neighborhood. This is a large blockcale project and is not aligned with the city's visions of maintaining meaningful green open space to help

633
03:29:41.600 --> 03:29:57.840
mitigate the impact of development at this scale. I want to be very very clear. The school and good neighborhood planning do not have to compete. A better design can preserve the school

634
03:29:57.840 --> 03:30:14.000
and still provide safer streets, better setbacks, more trees, and real open space. So, if this project is approved, I respectfully ask that you condition approval on these three items.

635
03:30:14.000 --> 03:30:31.439
Just want to add the developer has not negotiated these issues with good in good faith. That means it falls to you as commissioners to protect this neighborhood and require the public benefits the project should deliver. I

636
03:30:31.439 --> 03:30:48.479
just want to end by saying that they keep talking about that it has taken a very long time in the process but if this project just let me finish this please. I live I I I live in this street. I have been at this for five years and I just want to tell you that

637
03:30:48.479 --> 03:31:03.359
if the project would have been a good project and a good design from the get-go, it would have passed with flying colors. And thank you for letting me speak for longer. Thanks. >> Thank you. 3 minutes and 4 seconds over,

638
03:31:03.359 --> 03:31:30.000
>> Mary Palasio. Good morning. >> Um, good morning, Miss Mayor, vice mayor, commissioners, city clerk, attorney, and Mr. Peter Eiglesius. This is uh I had something in written already, but

639
03:31:30.000 --> 03:31:48.000
hearing all of you um makes me realize even more that yes, the Crystal Academy is in the middle of all of this. For more than five years, our parents have been in limbo. And yes to some of your comments that we knew that we had

640
03:31:48.000 --> 03:32:06.399
to move. Yes. Even before century bought um the the land, the Lutheran church was already selling the land. As a matter of fact, we live through many changes in the Lutheran church and we knew that change was coming. So now that we're

641
03:32:06.399 --> 03:32:23.760
here facing the reality that is not only a um a uh Chicago developer, that Chicago developer actually is following what Century Builders did and and was approved um and they have in good faith uh kept the promise of keeping the

642
03:32:23.760 --> 03:32:40.399
school. We we deal with very difficult situations every day because this is part of what we do and the children that we serve. But hearing all of these two sides has really um taking a dent in all

643
03:32:40.399 --> 03:32:57.520
of us. I thank my parents. I thank the staff. I thank uh all the good uh comments that have been said at Crystal Academy. And I'm really proud of what we have done in the city of Corey Gables. And um if this is the day that we have

644
03:32:57.520 --> 03:33:15.040
to realize that we're not going to have a home here in the Gables, then in part of me then so be it. Because there is a moment when you have to say and stand strong and said we're just going to turn this page and we need to

645
03:33:15.040 --> 03:33:32.960
have a new beginning. My my position here today was to really ask you for that was to really ask for certainty on foreclosure about after all these years of litigation and every time our parents have to go to a hearing that is delayed,

646
03:33:32.960 --> 03:33:48.080
every time we see something in the newspaper about the future of Crystal Academy and to your point, we don't have a place to be. We have been looking for a place but it's really difficult to say to answer a question like when are you moving? I don't know because this hasn't

647
03:33:48.080 --> 03:34:05.359
been going on for years. So yes, we have been in that situation. We love the gables and we have used the gables as part of what we do with our children and it would be a pity to leave this amazing city. So my my my my cry to you today is

648
03:34:05.359 --> 03:34:22.319
to make a decision so we know where we stand. I thank you so much for listening to this. I thank you Field for making that agreement and um I thank you for listening to all those bars. Thank you. >> Thank you, Miss

649
03:34:22.319 --> 03:34:46.000
>> Bonnie Bolton. >> Hello. Um, I I think it's very important to state that the PNZ gave their approval under the condition that quote they save as much as possible

650
03:34:46.000 --> 03:35:03.600
of the Gordon of our Lord. And um the rendering that was showed today showed 0% of the garden of our Lord as being saved. They have violated the most

651
03:35:03.600 --> 03:35:20.239
fundamental principle upon which this project was approved. So I think just on the basis of that you have to deny it. Um, and my attorneys talked about how

652
03:35:20.239 --> 03:35:34.479
it's a violation of the North Pon neighborhood conservation overlay district ordinance. It violates the historic city plan. It violates zoning

653
03:35:34.479 --> 03:35:51.760
code section 101 03. Um, and also it contradicts the North Pond's planning process and it contradicts the city's

654
03:35:51.760 --> 03:36:09.840
um current study to designate the neighborhood historic. And I also want to mention that the infrastructure does not exist in that neighborhood for that project. They're

655
03:36:09.840 --> 03:36:29.439
basing their feasibility on a traffic study that was done in 2022. Um, the area has changed dramatically and they do need a new traffic study.

656
03:36:29.439 --> 03:36:45.920
And I also want to mention that the pad, the planned area development benefit is claimed that's claimed is fraudulent and has never occurred before in this city.

657
03:36:45.920 --> 03:37:05.520
Um the pad is the school. It's also the green space. The school serves only 40 students. The tuition is 30 to $40,000 per year. Um, and as the PNZ board

658
03:37:05.520 --> 03:37:23.840
pointed out, it's only 2% of the entire project. And um, the green space is really the school's playground. It's only going to be open to the public after 5:30 p.m. during the week and on

659
03:37:23.840 --> 03:37:40.479
the weekends. Also, I want to compare it to Alan Morris's Pon Circle project. He's donating $11 million today for improvements to Pon Circle

660
03:37:40.479 --> 03:37:55.920
Park. an immediate benefit that will benefit benefit the entire city, not just Crystal Academy, which benefits 40 families.

661
03:37:55.920 --> 03:38:11.279
Um, also the developers stated they're giving $6 million over 99 years um for the school. That adds up to $60,000

662
03:38:11.279 --> 03:38:26.479
per year. Not very much when you compare it to Alan Morris's um benefit. Also, I want to mention the Coral Gables Women's Club has a free

663
03:38:26.479 --> 03:38:44.479
dental clinic that serves underprivileged children throughout our community. They have served in that capacity since 1939. Over 49,000

664
03:38:44.479 --> 03:39:00.479
children have been served at the Coral Gables Women's Club Dental Clinic. um they are going to really be under threat because of this project

665
03:39:00.479 --> 03:39:15.760
especially during the demolition and the construction. The dental clinic relies upon the revenue generated by the events held at the women's club. when this project

666
03:39:15.760 --> 03:39:33.359
starts and even after it's finished, it will severely threaten the the women's uh club free dental clinic. Okay, that's all I want to say. Thank you. >> Thank you. 1 minute and 55 seconds over.

667
03:39:33.359 --> 03:39:50.479
>> Thank you, >> Victor Anton. >> Good morning, sir. >> Afternoon, mayor. >> Good afternoon. Excuse me, >> commissioners. I'm Victor Antunes and I'm an autism dad. I'm not here about zoning code. Sir, because >> you might speak directly into the mic.

668
03:39:50.479 --> 03:40:05.520
>> Can you also give us your your address also? >> Okay. Victor Antunes, 5276 Southwest 153rd Court, Miami 33185. >> Thank you. As I said, I'm an autism dad and I'm not here about zoning code. I'm here because

669
03:40:05.520 --> 03:40:20.560
somewhere in this debate, a school for children with profound autism turned into a bargaining chip and I want to talk about that. Crystal Academy serves 40 children, not 40 units, not 40 variances, 40 kids who need care and education and life skills almost nowhere

670
03:40:20.560 --> 03:40:36.560
in this city can give them. I challenge anyone in this room to name another school inside Coral Gables that exists specifically for children with profound autism. A commitment was made to Crystal Academy. Century made it. Field honored it. A 99-year lease at no cost. A

671
03:40:36.560 --> 03:40:52.720
state-of-the-art facility. Crystal Academy didn't lobby its way into a development deal. It was promised a home and the developer kept their promise. Now, I was just complained that they only served 40 kids, but they're complaining it's too big of a project. So, if it served 80 kids, would that be better? So, like that argument about

672
03:40:52.720 --> 03:41:08.640
it's only 40 kids doesn't make any sense. And in fact, when it's approved, it's going to be like 75 kids. I understand the parts of this that are about a building. Reasonable people argue about height and president. That's your job here. And I respect it. But that's not all that's been said. A

673
03:41:08.640 --> 03:41:24.640
leader of the opposition described these children as quote severely autistic and very wealthy. The first half is true. That's why Crystal Academy exists. It's the second half that should embarrass the people repeating it. Crystal Academy takes insurance. It takes Medicaid. An

674
03:41:24.640 --> 03:41:41.760
average staff salary $48,000 a year. A single child's tuition does not cover even one teacher's pay. The school employs two people whose entire job is chasing payments. That isn't a gold mine. That's a school running close to the bone for kids the rest of the system gave up on and calling those families

675
03:41:41.760 --> 03:41:59.359
wealthy to score a zoning point is beneath this commission and beneath the city of Corables. Some have asked how a school of 40 serves a whole city. Here's how Crystal Academyy's founder Marty Palasio made this school part of how Coral Gables

676
03:41:59.359 --> 03:42:15.279
trains its police. When the Coral Gables Police Department wrapped an interceptor in an autism message, the school designed it and the department handed the keys to Officer Andrew George, whose brother is on the spectrum. Coral Gables police and fire send their cadetses to spend time with these children. The

677
03:42:15.279 --> 03:42:31.920
school works with 11th judicial circuits criminal mental health project on crisis intervention team and mental health training. In 15 days from today, 25 officers from the Miami date school's public police department will walk through that school's doors. an officer who has spent time with these children

678
03:42:31.920 --> 03:42:48.640
recognizes autism on a call. And that recognition can be the difference between a safe encounter and a tragedy where every autistic person in this city, not just 40 students. Lose a school, lose the model. Now, I was just said that Crystal Academy can relocate where not in the city of Coral Gables.

679
03:42:48.640 --> 03:43:05.040
5,000 square feet at current rents, that school doesn't make sense here. So, if that school has to relocate, it won't be here. So, then when were you going to send your police and fire to train? Not in the city of Coral Gables. So lose that school, we lose the model. Nobody asked this on June 17th, so I

680
03:43:05.040 --> 03:43:20.479
will. When construction starts, where do these 40 children go? For a child with profound autism, routine isn't a preference. It's the ground they stand on. Make the continuity of this school part of your decision, not an afterthought. You can argue the building all you want. That's democracy. But

681
03:43:20.479 --> 03:43:36.479
don't let 40 vulnerable children become the thing you trade. And remember, this was never about letting something new in. It's about keeping what's already yours. Keep that promise that was made to them. Another thing, it was said that this school isn't open to the public. Of course, it's not. It's a It's a school

682
03:43:36.479 --> 03:43:52.239
for little kids. Those of you that have kids through uh kindergarten and 12th grade, if your school was open to the public, how irresponsible would that be? I don't care if it's public, private, or charter. No school is open to the public. And saying that it's not doesn't

683
03:43:52.239 --> 03:44:12.720
make any sense. Thank you for your time. 1 minute 11 seconds. Thank you, sir. >> Katherine Cow. >> Good morning. Good afternoon. >> Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Katherine Cow and I live at

684
03:44:12.720 --> 03:44:29.359
14944 Southwest 59th Street. While I do not reside in Coral Gables, I have dedicated more than 12 years of my life to Crystal Academy and the children we serve. It is not 75 children. It is 40, but hopefully we will be able to reach

685
03:44:29.359 --> 03:44:46.720
more families. I am not here today as an expert in planning, zoning, or development. I am here as somebody who is fully invested in the lives of the children we serve every single day. not only the families that are currently enrolled, but the many families we hope

686
03:44:46.720 --> 03:45:04.160
to serve in the years to come. While Crystal Academy is a private school, we are also a nonprofit organization whose mission is to provide individualized education and support for the children with specialized needs. We are the only

687
03:45:04.160 --> 03:45:21.439
school of its kind in Coral Gable that provides a true one-to-one education and therapeutic setting for children who require that level of individualized support. What makes our program successful is not only the love, hard work, and dedication

688
03:45:21.439 --> 03:45:38.880
of each of our staff, but the unique community that we live in, the Coral Gables community. For our students, Coral Gables is much more than a location. It is their classroom. It is the community they know and the community where they have grown. Not

689
03:45:38.880 --> 03:45:54.239
necessarily because they live here, but because their families have made the sacrifices necessary to make that commute daily to bring them. Some from Miami Beach, some from Kendall. They don't all live in Coral Gables.

690
03:45:54.239 --> 03:46:11.199
They have chosen to do this commute because it offers the best opportunities that are essential for our children's development. It was stated that the women's club has served over 49,000 uh individuals. I think that's great and

691
03:46:11.199 --> 03:46:26.880
I'm hoping that today if this gets approved, Crystal Academy will be able to serve many more thousands of families given that opportunity. The walkability of the city, its transportation options, nearby businesses, parks, and safe

692
03:46:26.880 --> 03:46:43.040
environment do allow our students to practice real life skills that simply cannot be replicated within a classroom. They learn how to cross the street safely. They learn how to shop at Target and Publix, order their lunches at local

693
03:46:43.040 --> 03:47:00.880
restaurants, browse for books, inter uh interact with cashiers, and navigate the world with increasing confidence and independence. These are not field trips. These are lessons that prepare our students for the things that we take sometimes the most for granted. Those

694
03:47:00.880 --> 03:47:17.680
experiences are possible because Crystal Academy is part of this community. Coral Gables has become an extension of our classroom and that partnership has been invaluable in helping our students achieve meaningful independence. I apologize, I'm almost done. Throughout

695
03:47:17.680 --> 03:47:34.160
many years at Crystal Academy, I've also watched our staff and families work through this aging building and the leaks and the constant pipe burst and the issues are very unsustainable. Do we look forward to a new building? Absolutely. Not because we want

696
03:47:34.160 --> 03:47:50.080
something new only, but because we want something safe and a modern environment where we can put our time and energy and not focusing on repairs, but focusing on our students. Many of our families do face tremendous obstacles. It has been

697
03:47:50.080 --> 03:48:06.880
said that our families are wealthy and this is not accurate. We fight alongside with them with the insuranceances that deny them for their medically necessary services. But we continue that fight and we hope that you will continue the fight and approve this. Crystal Academy is not

698
03:48:06.880 --> 03:48:22.560
just a place where we work. It is a place that we deeply believe in the mission that we do. It is our home because Coral Gables is our home and we respectfully ask for the support of continuing to allow Coral Gables to be their classroom. >> Thank you.

699
03:48:22.560 --> 03:48:40.319
>> Thank you. >> 1 minute and 12 seconds over. >> Daniellea. I ask everyone please if you could please stay within the threeminut time. Thank you very much. >> Good afternoon uh Mayor Lago, Madame Vice Mayor and commissioners. My name is

700
03:48:40.319 --> 03:48:58.560
Daniela. I live at 9135 Southwest 125th Avenue, Miami, Florida. And I had the privilege of working at Crystal Academy for the past 10 years and exceptional at student education teacher. During those 10 years, I have watched children who once struggled to communicate learn to

701
03:48:58.560 --> 03:49:14.720
express themselves and have watched students who were once afraid of unfamiliar places gain the confidence to participate in their community. Those are the moments you never forget. And they are only possible because of the environment we've been fortunate

702
03:49:14.720 --> 03:49:30.560
enough to be here in Coral Gables. Crystal Academy is much more than a school. It is a place where students with special needs are given the opportunity to develop academically, socially and independently. Our location in Coral Gables has played a tremendous

703
03:49:30.560 --> 03:49:47.680
role in this case in their success. Pardon? For many of our students, learning does not stop at the classroom door. We teach life skills by becoming a part of the community around us. We ride the trolley together. We walk the local restaurants to participate ordering meals, practice

704
03:49:47.680 --> 03:50:04.880
ordering meals, pardon, interacting with staff and building confidence in real world situations. We visit books source to p to choose books, practice making purchases and experience the joy of reading. Every outing becomes a lesson in independence, communication,

705
03:50:04.880 --> 03:50:21.600
and belonging. To many people, these may seem like ordinary activities, but for our students, they are extraordinary milestones. I've had the privilege of seeing students who once couldn't tolerate leaving the classroom eventually walk

706
03:50:21.600 --> 03:50:37.120
confidently through Coral Gables, greet business owners by name, and become comfortable members of this community. Those me m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m moments happen because they are surrounded by a safe, welcoming and subordinate environment.

707
03:50:37.120 --> 03:50:51.920
Crystal Academy has become part of a fabric of Coral Gables. Our students aren't vis visitors here. They're members of this community. They deserve the opportunity to continue learning, growing, and building relationships in the place that embraced them for so many

708
03:50:51.920 --> 03:51:07.520
years. I understand that development projects can bring concerns and differing opinions, but I hope that you consider this project. You also consider the children whose lives are changed every day within our school. The building itself matters because of what

709
03:51:07.520 --> 03:51:24.560
makes possible a place where children with unique needs can receive an education, gain independence, and become active participants in their community. As someone who has dedicated the last decade of my career to these students, I can say without hesitation that Crystal

710
03:51:24.560 --> 03:51:46.680
Academy has transformed lives. I sincerely hope it can continue doing so here in Coral Gables for many years to come. Thank you for your time and your consideration. >> Thank you, >> Carlos Felipe Deupi. Good afternoon, sir.

711
03:51:49.040 --> 03:52:04.239
Good afternoon, mayor and commissioners. It's an honor to be here. My name is Phelip Dupy and I live a few blocks from the site at 118 Menoris Avenue. I grew up between Coral Gables and Coconut Grove. So, I've seen how both

712
03:52:04.239 --> 03:52:20.960
communities have changed over time and how they've grown when that change is done the right way. I'm here today because this kind of project is exactly why I chose to live in this neighborhood. What drew me here wasn't just the buildings. It was the direction

713
03:52:20.960 --> 03:52:36.720
the area is heading. A place where you can walk, where you can spend time outside, where there's a sense of activity and connection. That's what makes a neighborhood feel alive. And that's what this project adds. I'm especially looking forward to the public

714
03:52:36.720 --> 03:52:53.680
spaces that come with it. the park, the plaza, the courtyard. Those are the kinds of places people actually use. Places where you run into neighbors, sit for a while, bring your dog, or just spend time outside without having to leave your own neighborhood.

715
03:52:53.680 --> 03:53:10.560
Right now, that doesn't really exist on this site. So far, from my perspective, this isn't about losing something. It's about gaining something we don't currently have. I also think it's important to recognize where this project is located. This part

716
03:53:10.560 --> 03:53:25.840
of Coral Gables already feels different from other parts of the city. It's more active, more connected, and more suited for this type of environment. To me, this clearly fits. And beyond that, the inclusion of Crystal Academy

717
03:53:25.840 --> 03:53:40.960
gives the project a deeper purpose. It connects it to something meaningful and rooted in the community. At the end of the day, I want to live in a place that continues to evolve in a way that brings people together and creates a stronger

718
03:53:40.960 --> 03:54:02.160
sense of community. This project moves in that direction. For that reason, I respectfully ask that you support Crystal Residences. Thank you. >> Thank you, >> Michelle Saka. >> Good afternoon.

719
03:54:02.160 --> 03:54:19.680
Hi everyone. Thank you. Uh my name is Michelle Sacka, 3711 Chase Avenue, Miami Beach. I have not prepared anything today. Um I'm a parent at Crystal Academy. I've been been there for the last 14 years, two children there,

720
03:54:19.680 --> 03:54:36.080
profoundly autistic, profoundly. And I know this is about the building. This is not about the school, but it is about the school. It is about having a future for the school because children are small and then they grow up and they have to real live real lives and become

721
03:54:36.080 --> 03:54:52.800
real people. And Crystal Academy has been able to help my child, my children do that because of Coral Gables. The community outreach and the inclusion that you guys are offering these children, they take the trolley, the walkability. The same reason why you

722
03:54:52.800 --> 03:55:08.960
want to live in Coral Gables is a reason why we want Crystal Academy to stay in Coral Gables. Our children are able to go to a restaurant. They go to Morellas. They go to Ben & Jerry's. They go to Target. I was never able to do this with my son before. He could never go

723
03:55:08.960 --> 03:55:23.600
anywhere with me. I couldn't take him to a restaurant. We couldn't function as a family. We couldn't go to family events. We couldn't live our lives to our fullest potential. But because of the life skills and the training and the love and the therapy that they're getting from Crystal Academy

724
03:55:23.600 --> 03:55:39.840
and the inclusion of Coral Gables, your city has become synonymous with inclusion. You are the example of Miami Beach and all these other cities. Look at the autism, the police caravan that comes and ends

725
03:55:39.840 --> 03:55:56.800
every year in Coral Gables at Crystal Academy. You guys are the example. I'm very involved in the city of Miami Beach. Thank God. It's wonderful there. I love it there. But they look to you guys for inclusion. And I really feel that not passing this

726
03:55:56.800 --> 03:56:13.199
new home for Crystal Academy is kind of like turning your back on inclusion. And these children we need, as a parent, I need a place for my child where they can thrive. They can be a real adult. They can get a part-time

727
03:56:13.199 --> 03:56:29.199
job. They can have a life coach. They can have a job coach. They can be a regular person. And that's what you guys have been giving them. And I can't thank you guys enough for that. I really can't. Again, I've been at Crystal Academy for over 14 years. And for them to have the opportunity where they can

728
03:56:29.199 --> 03:56:45.920
get a new facility and the overhead is really minimal, that's phenomenal. And for everyone out there who's saying that it's only a bunch of wealthy children who are going to this school, excuse me. First of all, there is a voucher for children to attend any private school

729
03:56:45.920 --> 03:57:03.199
that they want with unique abilities. So, you get money if you can't afford it. And I have tried effortlessly and tirelessly with other parents to help raise money to make sure that kids who need financial need can attend the school. So, thank you so much for

730
03:57:03.199 --> 03:57:25.920
everything you've done for our kids and I pray that you guys will let this pass and we can continue to be here in Coral Gables. Thank you. Maria de Leon Fletes. >> Good afternoon. >> Afternoon. How are you? Thank you for

731
03:57:25.920 --> 03:57:42.560
your time. My name is Maria Deon Fletes. I live at 825 Missina Avenue and I'm also speaking on behalf of my daughter who's at work. She is at 49 Phoenicia directly Katty Cornick from the proposed structure and there's no doubt that

732
03:57:42.560 --> 03:57:59.600
Crystal Academy is doing a wonderful job. No doubt and I don't think anybody in this room can question what they are doing but we also know that they are being used to increase the size of the building, the density of the building to

733
03:57:59.600 --> 03:58:15.520
the developer's advantage. We also know as architects, I'm an architect and adjunct professor at the University of Miami, that this building could have been designed in a manner that was more cohesive to the neighborhood. They could have worked more with the community uh

734
03:58:15.520 --> 03:58:30.560
last month at the planning and zoning board. There was approved conditionally on the basis of their creating maintaining or preserving more of the garden. And what they have done is

735
03:58:30.560 --> 03:58:45.920
essentially just rotate the park. They have not touched the garden. We thought well this is a wonderful opportunity for them to make amends with the neighborhood. As a matter of fact when they asked the neighborhood or the representative for the neighborhood uh

736
03:58:45.920 --> 03:59:03.279
would they would be good with that and that was a very positive uh response to do that. But what essentially has been done by the architects and the developers and the attorneys is just rotate simply just rotating the green which is really it's almost a slap in

737
03:59:03.279 --> 03:59:19.760
the face um to the residents who have worked diligently uh trying to maneuver some kind of compromise with the neighbors and with the developer. Again, no doubt that Crystal Academy is

738
03:59:19.760 --> 03:59:34.640
a wonderful institution. The building could have been designed in a much smaller scale, more cohesive. And the statement that says that every neighbor in that area is in favor of this large building is incorrect. There are many

739
03:59:34.640 --> 03:59:50.479
neighbors that are against it as well. Um, in terms of what it's going to provide the neighborhood, traffic, it will provide more residential, so it will provide more pedestrian activity, but it's not going to provide the neighborhood with any kind of amenities.

740
03:59:50.479 --> 04:00:06.720
It's not there's no commercial use. So, it will essentially just bring more people into the neighborhood and create no open space. Um the statement that it's got a park, it's partially opened. The PO is really a glorified alley um

741
04:00:06.720 --> 04:00:21.120
which you could see on the um on the uh slide um you know it's an alley with some green space. Um so it's really not providing a lot in return for what they're getting. Please reconsider this.

742
04:00:21.120 --> 04:00:38.160
Please um really take the neighbors comments into place, the people who live there every day. Uh and please have this building redesigned in such a manner that's more cohesive with the neighborhood. Thank you so much for your time. >> Thank you very much,

743
04:00:38.160 --> 04:01:02.160
>> Cheryl Acriman. >> Good afternoon. >> Good afternoon, Mr. Mr. Mayor, Vice Mayor, and commissioners. Can you hear me? >> Yes, ma'am. >> Oh, good. I live at 8:16 and my name is Cheryl Acriman and I've

744
04:01:02.160 --> 04:01:18.960
lived in the Gables for 54 years. Yes, I'm that old. So I have heard other speakers speaking uh on all the projects uh problems in that uh the zoning problems.

745
04:01:18.960 --> 04:01:34.319
North Pon's neighborhood and Coral Gaya's historic city plan. Um Merik, Mr. American design garden apartments which were not overwhelming to the entire

746
04:01:34.319 --> 04:01:51.120
entire uh block as I feel this one is. This project is overwhelming for the neighborhood and I believe attorney Winker stated it best to say preserve our neighborhood.

747
04:01:51.120 --> 04:02:16.319
Thank you. >> Thank you Judith Packard. Good afternoon, Miss Packard. >> Good afternoon. My name is Judith Packard. I live at 911 East Pond Stadium Boulevard and I'm here today

748
04:02:16.319 --> 04:02:33.199
to express my support for more thought with this. I've lived in the North Pon neighborhood for over 43 years. I am here this afternoon because this project concerns me deeply as a resident and as someone who cares about the

749
04:02:33.199 --> 04:02:48.880
future of Coral Gables. Time and again, the residents of the city have stepped forward to protect what others failed to value. The Douglas entrance, the Alra Water Tower, the Builtmore Hotel. Because of them, those landmarks still

750
04:02:48.880 --> 04:03:05.760
stand today. They understood that once something special is lost, it cannot be replaced. Those efforts helped shape the Coral Gables we know today and remind us that progress and preservation should go hand in hand. No one here is against the development.

751
04:03:05.760 --> 04:03:23.439
No one is against Crystal Academy or the children they serve. There's a path forward where the garden of our Lord is protected. Crystal Academy Academy Academy continues and a developer builds something that actually belongs in this neighborhood. That path was within reach

752
04:03:23.439 --> 04:03:40.160
at the end of the planning and zoning meeting, but instead of taking it, this developer is back here today pushing the same project this community has opposed for 5 years. Progress and preservation can coexist in Coral Gables. They always, but it requires a developer

753
04:03:40.160 --> 04:03:57.600
who's willing to listen. I also want to speak to the question of the public benefit because that is what PAD requires and that is where this application falls apart. The developers asking for special approvals in exchange for a private school serving 40 students

754
04:03:57.600 --> 04:04:13.520
whose families often do not even live in the area. That is a private benefit for a small group of people. The truth is the community already has a public benefit benefit on the site. It's called the garden of our Lord. Why destroy a

755
04:04:13.520 --> 04:04:28.880
garden that has already been part of the community for over 75 years? Why not work with the community? In closing, I'm asking this board to uphold the rules that were created to protect this community and to listen to the residents

756
04:04:28.880 --> 04:04:57.199
who live here and will be affected by this decision long after today's meeting is over. Please vote no. Thank you. Thank you Kel Carbonel. >> Good afternoon G. How are you? >> Hello everyone and um happy to see

757
04:04:57.199 --> 04:05:14.800
everyone. Hope you had a wonderful July 4th weekend. I am here representing the historic preservation association of Coral Gables and you have all received the letter

758
04:05:14.800 --> 04:05:32.399
that we sent uh opposing this project as proposed. So I will reiterate the points that was made in the letter. On behalf of the Historic Preservation

759
04:05:32.399 --> 04:05:48.560
Association of Coral Gables, please accept this letter in opposition to the project as presented. And here are the key points. Zoning violation. The block is zoned

760
04:05:48.560 --> 04:06:05.800
special use religious with a fourstory max height. A ninestory building clearly exceeds this. It's incompatible with the neighborhood. It has historic sensitivity.

761
04:06:06.000 --> 04:06:26.880
There's the Coral Gables Woman's Club across the street and the Douglas entrance down the block. It violates section 1-103 which the zoning code requires new development to be compatible with the

762
04:06:26.880 --> 04:06:44.160
surrounding architecture and the protection of residential neighborhoods. It violates two additional ordinances. the North Pines Neighborhood Conservation Overlay District

763
04:06:44.160 --> 04:07:02.880
and the Coral Gable's Historic City Plan Ordinance. These two ordinances call for lowrise, lowcale development in the neighborhood.

764
04:07:02.880 --> 04:07:18.640
It contradicts the community vision workshop. And of course, the infrastructure, as you've heard, really can't support it. And finally, and the most important is

765
04:07:18.640 --> 04:07:35.760
that the pad request is misleading. The courtyard offered as a public benefit is only accessible when the adjacent school is in in session, which has never been accepted as a

766
04:07:35.760 --> 04:07:54.720
qualifying green space under PAD rules. The garden of our Lord can serve as the PAD requirement to meet this zoning code. The garden area can be carved out and

767
04:07:54.720 --> 04:08:11.279
saved as part of the allowable green space for for development. I just have a few more uh just another few seconds. The area of the garden is 23%

768
04:08:11.279 --> 04:08:26.239
of the total square footage. The minimum landscape open space required for a pad quote shall be not less than 20% of the pad site. This is

769
04:08:26.239 --> 04:08:43.520
directly under section 3-502 which states that the pad requires a minimum of 20% landscaped open space of the total site and critically that open

770
04:08:43.520 --> 04:09:00.399
space must be genuinely acceptable accessible. The garden site technically sits within the pad requirements. So, please keep that in mind as you're going through this project. Um,

771
04:09:00.399 --> 04:09:19.359
and thank you. >> Thank you. >> Omar Packard. >> Good afternoon. My name is Omar Packard. I reside at 911 East Pon Boulevard. I am a lifelong Coral Gables resident who has

772
04:09:19.359 --> 04:09:35.359
spent more than 40 years living in the North Pon area. I have to say I'm getting tired of coming up here and speaking against this proposed development. This has been going back and forth for over 5 years. Not because it is a complicated project, but because

773
04:09:35.359 --> 04:09:51.920
it is a bad one. A project that the community overwhelmingly opposes. a project that seeks to destroy what it means to live here and further burden an infrastructure that is already struggling to keep up. What makes it worse is the developers

774
04:09:51.920 --> 04:10:07.680
complete unwillingness to work with the community. Rather than finding a solution that works for everyone, they have hidden behind Crystal Academy using a school that serves autistic children as a shield against accountability for what they are trying to do to this

775
04:10:07.680 --> 04:10:24.720
neighborhood. This is the reason why we spend 90% of the time talking about it, yet it is 2% of the project. Last meeting, the developer had an opportunity to work with this community to protect the Garden of Our Lord, a beloved and historic landmark that has

776
04:10:24.720 --> 04:10:43.840
been part of this neighborhood for over 75 years. Instead, they are back here today looking for another way to push this through. There is a world where the Garden of our Lord can exist, where Crystal Academy can exist, and the developer can build a

777
04:10:43.840 --> 04:11:01.040
project in this neighborhood, but it requires the developer to actually work with the community instead of steamrolling it. This world almost existed at the end of the planning and zoning meeting as it is exactly what was recommended. And yet this billiondoll development firm out of Chicago is too

778
04:11:01.040 --> 04:11:17.920
greedy to meet us halfway. I want to ask this commission a simple question. Why are we bending over backwards to appease this developer? The PAD case alone should have ended this application. How is a private school a public benefit? How is a school that

779
04:11:17.920 --> 04:11:34.640
largely serves families outside of this neighborhood a public benefit? How is a park that is inaccessible during the exact hours when most people actually use the park considered a public benefit? And why are we relying on a traffic study from 20 thou from 2022?

780
04:11:34.640 --> 04:11:50.160
This neighborhood has changed dramatically since then. That study was conducted before a significant influx of new residents into the area. These are not complicated questions and they have obvious answers. The commission has an opportunity today

781
04:11:50.160 --> 04:12:06.560
to do what the zoning board could not to to fully deny this project outright and send a clear message that in Coral Gables the rules mean something. The community's voice means something and a wealthy developer from out of state cannot simply buy his way through our

782
04:12:06.560 --> 04:12:36.960
zoning code. The Garden of Lord has been a part of this neighborhood for over 75 years. It deserves better than this and so do we. Please vote no. Thank you. Doris Alamora. >> Good afternoon. >> Good afternoon.

783
04:12:36.960 --> 04:12:54.479
>> My name is Doris Salamora. My address is 235 um Mayorca Avenue in Corables 33134 and I support the project uh for the school and the other supporters. Thank

784
04:12:54.479 --> 04:13:41.040
you for your time. >> Thank you. Yeah, >> that's it. >> Yeah, thanks. Maria Essen Wanganger, good afternoon. Um,

785
04:13:41.040 --> 04:13:55.920
okay. Um, good evening. My name is Maria Sbangar. I live in 800 Douglas Road. um corable 33134. This project has gone through years of

786
04:13:55.920 --> 04:14:12.159
review and has met every legal requirement. The property is privately owned and the process has already confirmed that it can move forward. Corable like many cities across Miami is

787
04:14:12.159 --> 04:14:27.760
changing growing and is something we cannot stop. But we can choose projects that grow responsibly. I believe this project does exactly that.

788
04:14:27.760 --> 04:14:45.279
It's preserve meaningful green space, creates new public area for everyone to enjoy and improve pedestrian safely. It also continues to support the crystals academy a school that has provide

789
04:14:45.279 --> 04:15:01.199
invaluable care and education for childrens with special needs and it has been in tremendous resources for many family over the years. The developer has showed good faith by agreeing to relocate

790
04:15:01.199 --> 04:15:17.120
the historic tree demonstrating and willingness to work with the community. I believe these projects respect both our community and the law and I respectfully ask you to vote yes. Thank you

791
04:15:17.120 --> 04:15:39.840
>> Karen Lopez. >> Good afternoon. >> Good evening. >> My name is Karen Lopes. I live at 291 Navar Avenue here in the Gables. I've watched downtown Gables evolve over the years and I think most of us would agree

792
04:15:39.840 --> 04:15:57.880
it's evolved well. East Pon today is a real corridor. Offices, hotels, retail, restaurants, apartments, it works. This property sits directly off East Pon Leon. one of the major north south corridors running through the downtown gables.

793
04:15:58.880 --> 04:16:14.080
That corridor and tell me that you see office buildings, retail condominiums, rental apartments, that's the context of this site. It's not tucked into a quiet residious street. It's on the spine of the busiest, most urban part of our city

794
04:16:14.080 --> 04:16:29.760
and the north ponds neighborhood around it. Already already contains buildings of similar and larger scale. 1300 ponds is 12 stories. This proposal is nine stories and 93 feet. If this building were being proposed on a single family

795
04:16:29.760 --> 04:16:44.960
block, I'd be standing on the other side of this podium. It isn't. It's being proposed exactly where a building like this belongs. So the honest question is in front of you is whether the energy of that corridor extends into North Pawns

796
04:16:44.960 --> 04:17:00.080
in a thoughtful planned way or whether the neighborhood just sits there aging while everything around moves forward. The church on this side has already closed. The property has reached the end of chapter. Something is going to happen eventually.

797
04:17:00.080 --> 04:17:15.680
The question is what? nearly 200 rental homes on this corridor built to carry them in a building of scale that's already around it. That's the right answer to this location. It's not someone who supports every project, but this is the right project in the right

798
04:17:15.680 --> 04:17:44.000
place. Please vote yes. Thank you. Thank you, >> Alexis Santos. >> Hello. How are you? >> My name is Alexis Santos and my address is 1300 Pona De Leon Boulevard, apartment 308. We've heard many parents,

799
04:17:44.000 --> 04:18:00.080
teachers, staff, and families from Crystal Academy come before you today. And after hearing from them, we've also heard opponents say this isn't about the school, but it is. The reason so many people connected to Crystal Academy are here is because the project directly

800
04:18:00.080 --> 04:18:16.399
impacts their future. Crystal Academy is an aging building, and the proposal gives the school a brand new facility, more than 6 million in investment, and rent-free space. something it simply cannot accomplish on its own. Opponents

801
04:18:16.399 --> 04:18:32.800
argue the school is being used to justify the project. The truth is the project is what makes the investment in the school possible. Without it, there is no new building, no 6 million investment and no rentree space.

802
04:18:32.800 --> 04:18:49.479
This project just doesn't preserve Crystal Academy. It secures its future. That's why so far many families this is absolutely about the school. Thank you. Please vote yes. >> Thank you. >> John Carlo Vara.

803
04:18:58.800 --> 04:19:13.359
>> Good afternoon. >> Good afternoon. >> My name is Jan Carlo. I live in 235 Anti Avenue, apartment 7. One of the reason I love Cora Gables is because it's never been a city afraid to dream a little bit bigger. Someone had a

804
04:19:13.359 --> 04:19:29.279
vision for Miracle Mile. Someone had a vision for the Bilmore. Someone had a vision for so many places we now take pride in. If every generation say no to thoughtful change, eventually the city stops moving forward. That's not the

805
04:19:29.279 --> 04:19:59.439
carables I want. I hope we continue building a city future nations will be proud of. Thank you so much. >> Thank you, sir. >> Maria Maria, >> good afternoon. >> My address, well, my name is Maria Mari.

806
04:19:59.439 --> 04:20:15.439
My address is 800 Douglas Road, apartment 904, Kora Gables. I would like to express my support for this project. I believe this development will bring positive growth to Kora

807
04:20:15.439 --> 04:20:32.239
Cables and provide additional housing opportunities while contributing to the vitality of our community. I think this project will be beneficial for the neighborhood and for those

808
04:20:32.239 --> 04:21:04.640
reason I fully support it. Thank you. >> Thank you Lisette Arango. >> Hi. Good afternoon. My name is Lisette Arango. I reside at 4152 Southwest 13th Street, apartment 3 in

809
04:21:04.640 --> 04:21:19.840
Coral Gables. One of the reasons I enjoy living in Cora Gables is because I can walk to grab a dinner, grab coffee, or stop into a local business. Those businesses do not survive by themselves.

810
04:21:19.840 --> 04:21:36.080
They need customers. Thoroughly adding new residents near downtown helps keep those local businesses healthy. More people living within walking distances means more people eating locally, shopping locally, and supporting the

811
04:21:36.080 --> 04:22:02.960
businesses that make Coral Gables special. That is good for me. I thank you for your time and I hope you approve this project. Thank you. >> Thank you very much for being here, Vanessa Salas. Good afternoon. My name is Vanessa

812
04:22:02.960 --> 04:22:21.760
Sales. I live in 13 Civil Civo Street number four. I'm here to support this beautiful and necessary project Crystal Academia School. I think it's a

813
04:22:21.760 --> 04:22:38.960
great opportunity to help um people that with really need it and help others especially with the kids that they needed. Um

814
04:22:38.960 --> 04:22:57.760
so I I was here in the past follow all the meetings. I'm very passion for this project and I going to it's going to be a beautiful school with a beautiful building for this beautiful

815
04:22:57.760 --> 04:23:14.640
um city of the Coral Gables. I working in that Builmore Hotel for 10 years and I love Coral Gables and I'm so proud of this community and we need something to

816
04:23:14.640 --> 04:23:43.920
be more uh especially for this um this city. Thank you. >> Thank you very much Anna Hullman. Hello, my name is Anna Hman. I reside at 235 Antia Avenue, apartment 2, Coral

817
04:23:43.920 --> 04:24:01.040
Gables 33134. One of the things I admire most about Coral Gables is that every generation has left something behind. Beautiful streets, wonderful parks, great architecture, neighborhoods people are proud to call

818
04:24:01.040 --> 04:24:17.359
home. They didn't do that by refusing every opportunity to improve the city. They do it they did it by choosing projects that reflected the values of Coral Gables. I believe this project is one of those

819
04:24:17.359 --> 04:24:34.800
opportunities. I hope I'll continue that tradition and build something future generations will appreciate. I support this project for its purpose to serve a lasting impact the same way Crystal on the Coral Gables community the same way

820
04:24:34.800 --> 04:24:50.560
Crystal Academy has served the lasting impactful transformations in people's these children's lives. Let's let this development shine the same light and liveless to this whole community. Thank you. >> Thank you very much.

821
04:24:50.560 --> 04:25:18.399
>> Orao. >> Good afternoon. >> Good afternoon. How are you? >> Thank you for being here. >> My name is Aarino and I live on 335 Nari Avenue, apartment number five. I live here for two years and I drift this

822
04:25:18.399 --> 04:25:35.439
street every day. I'll be honest with you, when I first heard about this project, traffic was my concern, too. So, I don't the neighborhood who bring it up. It's a fair question. But I took the time to learn more about this. A traffic study was done for this project

823
04:25:35.439 --> 04:25:51.760
and when I looked at the actual site plan, I saw things that address exactly what worry people. The project W provides on site drop off and pick up keeps traffic circulation within the property and at any cross wall and

824
04:25:51.760 --> 04:26:07.439
weather sidewalks to improve safety for pedestrian. That's a better setup than what exists today where everything happened on the street and parking is handled on the side 301 space within the project

825
04:26:07.439 --> 04:26:25.359
itself. I think what about the traffic sometimes get used as a reason to post everything everywhere forever. When a project includes solution like inter drop off, full size circulation, parking and pedest

826
04:26:25.359 --> 04:26:50.640
benefits should be recognized. My concreted and satisfied and I support this project. Thank you. >> Thank you Dominica Farardo. Good afternoon. >> Hey, good afternoon. How are you?

827
04:26:50.640 --> 04:27:06.720
>> Um, my name is Dominica. I live in 271 Majora Avenue, Kodak Gables, 33134. And I regularly walk through this neighborhood. I've been hearing many concerns that this project will take away green space. But I think it's

828
04:27:06.720 --> 04:27:22.000
important to look at the what I is actually there today and what is being proposed. The garden that some people want to preserve is on a pro private property. It's not a place where the community can walk in, spend time or

829
04:27:22.000 --> 04:27:38.640
enjoy it. It belongs to that property. What this project brings is green space that the public can actually use. an early 4,000 square foot park available to the community after school hours along with a public courtyard, a public

830
04:27:38.640 --> 04:27:53.520
plaza and a pedestrician walkway that connects the block. The numbers also support this. The project includes about 20,500 squaret of the ground level open space

831
04:27:53.520 --> 04:28:09.680
um which is 31.6% 6% of the site, more than 20% required by the proposed zoning. City staff re review the project and confirm that it provides real public benefits, including more open areas and

832
04:28:09.680 --> 04:28:26.399
improvements for pedestrians. Regarding the three that concern was here and addressed the developer agree to preserve it be relocating a few hundred feet and their experts determinite that the three can be successfully

833
04:28:26.399 --> 04:28:44.239
translated. So when I compare what exist um today, a private garden behind a fence with a what this project offers, a park plaza, good yard, a wider sidewalks that my neighborhoods and I can actually

834
04:28:44.239 --> 04:29:00.800
enjoy. I see this as a real improvement for the entire community, not only for the people who will live in the building. For these reasons, I support this project and I respectfully ask you to approve it. Thank you so much. >> Thank you very much,

835
04:29:00.800 --> 04:29:28.319
>> Herman Tin. Tinco. >> Good afternoon everybody. >> Uh my name is Herman Dino. I live in 888 Douglas Road and I has been living in this area for many years and I see uh

836
04:29:28.319 --> 04:29:44.640
Miami everywhere growing brick or all many areas and I think the projects like this that I really support brings the opportunity to this city to grow bring the opportunity to our childrens to have

837
04:29:44.640 --> 04:30:00.640
places to live at least to choose Um, Miami became that uh a place that you need to move for farther north or farther south to look for a house, apartments. So everywhere that makes you

838
04:30:00.640 --> 04:30:16.800
to commute longer and make expense is you know higher for every family. um for this and also the benefit of the school for a small population that need a special treatment like the Otis

839
04:30:16.800 --> 04:30:37.040
uh school crystal academy and I'm here to support this project. I appreciate if you approve it. Thank you. >> Thank you, sir. >> Scott Pearson. >> Good morning, sir. Good afternoon, Steve.

840
04:30:37.040 --> 04:30:52.800
>> Thank you very much for having me here. I'm Scott Pearson. I'm 411 Santa Marorrow. I've lived in the Gables since 1974 for most of the time. And forgive me if my memory is failing,

841
04:30:52.800 --> 04:31:08.159
but it seems like many of the past administrations tried to protect our green spaces, our zoning laws, and tried to improve our traffic uh problems.

842
04:31:08.159 --> 04:31:24.800
And I'm uh hoping that we can uh continue that tradition of helping our citizens preserve their way of life. Uh I've noticed in the times I've traveled,

843
04:31:24.800 --> 04:31:41.439
some of the greatest cities have big green spaces right near the downtown areas. Places like San Francisco and New York. I think, you know, we can do better with

844
04:31:41.439 --> 04:31:59.040
our green space preservation and making more of it, but it's going to be too late as the land prices rise if we don't start thinking about that really seriously. Strict zoning and height requirements

845
04:31:59.040 --> 04:32:16.800
are part of great cities as well. 15 years ago, I remember there was a house for sale on Alhhamra near where I live and I called about it and uh they said, "Oh, this is a tear down house. It's dilapidated." Well, the next

846
04:32:16.800 --> 04:32:32.319
thing I know, the city owns the land and bu and built a beautiful park on Alhhamra near Blue Road where children just enjoy and use that park all the time. a really

847
04:32:32.319 --> 04:32:49.920
nice place. I'd love to see more of things like that happen. Uh I know none of you ran for office with a slogan, we put developers first. No, you you made promises to your public

848
04:32:49.920 --> 04:33:06.639
who voted for you to help us. And uh we don't see how increased traffic, taking away trees, taking away green space and zoning for

849
04:33:06.639 --> 04:33:25.520
uh you know big buildings helps the citizens you promise to represent. Uh several people have said this area is the best and last place for development. One would have to be very gullible to

850
04:33:25.520 --> 04:33:43.359
believe that. All we have to do is look around as at what has happened with big buildings going up all over Cables to know that this is not the last place and this is not the best place. The, you

851
04:33:43.359 --> 04:34:00.719
know, if the developers want it, my question is, will they get it regardless of what the people want that voted for you? As the lovely lady in red said, "Is this a done deal or do the voices of your

852
04:34:00.719 --> 04:34:17.760
voters matter?" >> Thank you. >> Uh Scott, before you leave the podium, do you mind if I use your information and reach out to you via via the city? >> Sure. because I'd like to show you uh what this city has done in in the last

853
04:34:17.760 --> 04:34:35.520
um 14 years in regards to parks and green spaces. Uh just this year alone, this year we're adding 30 acres of green space to the city, including the underlying >> That's great, great news. and a six and a six acre almost a six acre parcel of

854
04:34:35.520 --> 04:34:51.039
land that I've been working on for 10 years that we're about to bring into the city. Uh which is the largest will be the largest park in the city's history. >> And when I when I was elected when I was elected 14 years ago, we had one park in the downtown which was Pawn Circle Park.

855
04:34:51.039 --> 04:35:06.561
In the next two years, through the leadership of the manager and this commission, nobody was elected. maybe Rhonda was the vice mayor, but now we're going to have seven parks in the downtown. Um, these are negotiations

856
04:35:06.561 --> 04:35:23.359
that we've done uh with developers uh to ensure that we get green space in turn for uh certain projects that were approved in the downtown. They will be forthcoming um in the next two years as these projects are finalized and you'll see these projects. I'd like to give you

857
04:35:23.359 --> 04:35:40.561
a copy of all the projects that are forthcoming. That's not to mention all the other parks that we've been able to purchase in the residential neighborhoods, which are almost I would say probably about more than 10 more than 10 uh parks over the last uh 13 14 years. So, and there's another piece of

858
04:35:40.561 --> 04:35:57.439
legislation that I've sponsored today that will not allow us to sell a green space in the city unless it goes before the residents and they vote in favor or against it as a referendum. And that also includes um the youth center and it will also include Granada Golf Course

859
04:35:57.439 --> 04:36:13.520
because these two um pieces of property have been used as you know bargaining chips amongst the blogs to scare people to say that we're going to sell and and redevelop Granada Golf Course or we're going to sell and redevelop the youth center. So th that will be ironclad and

860
04:36:13.520 --> 04:36:29.520
the decision will be made by the residents if somebody were crazy enough to even bring that up uh in the future. So, I just want you to make you aware that there are a lot of parks that are already approved and on the way for the downtown because I I agree with you. If you're a world-class city, you want to pretend to be a world-class city, you

861
04:36:29.520 --> 04:36:44.959
need to have open spaces and green spaces. Those have already been negotiated. And I negotiate every single one of those projects, every single one of those green spaces along with the 5.6 acre parcel. Um, the manager and I worked on that for 10 years together. So

862
04:36:44.959 --> 04:37:01.039
when you talk about when you talk about protecting green space and understanding the value of green spaces and understanding the value and I wrote another piece of legislation >> that requires that all these green spaces at a minimum be 70% green space not concrete. So, you're going to see

863
04:37:01.039 --> 04:37:16.959
over over our downtown almost two handfuls of parks hopefully and my colleagues once I'm done will continue um fighting for for parks in the downtown uh and in the residential neighborhoods. >> That's great news. I I just hope that

864
04:37:16.959 --> 04:37:33.680
you know this place we're talking about today >> can take some of that into account. >> Again, I just want to make sure you're aware. Thank you very much for being here. I appreciate it. Thank you, sir. >> All right, Mr. Mayor, we're going to go to Zoom next. Uh, first speaker on Zoom is Laa Monise.

865
04:37:33.680 --> 04:37:50.160
I'm asking Miss Monise to please turn on her video. Ma'am, if you could please raise your right hand. >> Do you swear affirm that the testimony you'll provide today will be the truth and nothing but the truth? >> Thank you.

866
04:37:50.160 --> 04:38:05.520
>> Good afternoon, Mr. Mayor, vice mayor, and commissioners. My name is Adam Monise. I reside at 3505 on Edgra Street. I am both a resident and employee of the city of Corables, specifically here at Crystal Academy. I have had um the privilege of watching

867
04:38:05.520 --> 04:38:20.799
the city grow and develop through the years. I have always seen Corables as a role model for other cities including promotion um promoting inclusion, progress, and opportunity. I am here in support of the new Crystal Residences Project. Crystal Academy is a nonprofit

868
04:38:20.799 --> 04:38:36.320
school and therapy center that has served this community for over 16 years. Before that, the property was also a private school supporting local families. Crystal sustains its work through endless hours of battling insurance companies, community donations, a deep commitment to children

869
04:38:36.320 --> 04:38:52.561
with autism and their families. Our students are not separate from Carables. They're a part of it. They walk the neighborhood weekly. They clean up the surrounded areas. They pick up trash as part of learning responsibility and community involvement. Crystal Academy uses the services of the free dental

870
04:38:52.561 --> 04:39:08.160
clinic located right next door at the women's club. We use a trolley. We also work with the city of Corables and Miami date police departments to train responding officers supporting individuals with special needs and using the escalation techniques. While I see the concerns about traffic, the building

871
04:39:08.160 --> 04:39:24.879
height, the garden with Lord and public green spaces, and they all deserve consideration, similar projects are moving forward currently without the same objections. These individuals that have come forward today and over the last five years addressing these issues currently do not have access to a green

872
04:39:24.879 --> 04:39:39.520
space and in the media in the media vicinity and they're now demanding they get one based on a grad on a private project. At Crystal Academy we have been using Philips Spark for years. It provides opportunities for students to interact with neurotypical peers. These

873
04:39:39.520 --> 04:39:56.958
individuals have also um not taken care or come to clean the garden of our Lord in over a decade that I have been working here. All of a sudden, they want to preserve it. The garden is attached to our current school. It is a private property. It is close to the public. It has been close to the public over the last decade. It is truly sad and

874
04:39:56.958 --> 04:40:13.360
embarrassing to see and read comments and hearing statements that diminishes population and their immediate needs. Special needs affect everyone whether directly or through someone they love. This project is not just about a building because yes, as an institution, we could move anywhere. we could we

875
04:40:13.360 --> 04:40:28.878
would continue to succeed in the work that we do because as professionals we are passionate and caring. This project is meaningful to us because it is about continuing the core legacy as a city beautiful by making it more inclusive for autistic children, their their parents and the community as a whole.

876
04:40:28.878 --> 04:40:45.958
Thank you all for listening. Have a good one. >> Mr. Mayor, the next speaker is going to be Thomas Mooney. Asking Mr. Mooney to please turn on his video. >> Mr. Mooney, good afternoon. How many more speakers we have?

877
04:40:49.520 --> 04:41:05.040
>> Mr. Mooney, please raise your right hand, sir. >> Do you swear affirm the testimony you'll provide today will be the truth and nothing but the truth. Sir, >> I do. >> Thank you. >> Good afternoon, uh, Mr. Mayor and members of the commission. I'm sorry I

878
04:41:05.040 --> 04:41:22.160
couldn't be there in person today, but I was able to send a fairly detailed email to each of you and so I don't want to take up too much time given the length of time that this hearing has taken. I think as it pertains to the urban planning issues, your professional staff

879
04:41:22.160 --> 04:41:37.920
has provided a very detailed and objective analysis as to why this proposal in and of itself is highly compatible uh with the surrounding area. What I do want to emphasize though is the role that Crystal Academy has played

880
04:41:37.920 --> 04:41:54.958
and and the importance of that role. First, I think it's important to um underscore that there are not a lot of options for the population of people that have autism and intellectual and developmental disabilities. From

881
04:41:54.958 --> 04:42:12.400
personal experience, I can tell you that the public schools unfortunately just don't have the uh options. And more importantly, the cost of providing this type of care is significant. You're talking about ratios of one instructor

882
04:42:12.400 --> 04:42:28.798
to one student up to a maximum ratio of of three students per one instructor. And the sheer cost of that is something that um is not difficult is very very difficult to accommodate. A lot of families including my own have had to

883
04:42:28.798 --> 04:42:44.480
sacrifice and even with assistance from scholarships, it's still something that um is not easy to um to finance over time. So this is not something that that is in any way, shape or form a luxury.

884
04:42:44.480 --> 04:43:02.480
Crystal, as a lot of you are aware, and I think a lot of you have visited and and for those out there who haven't visited it, I I would strongly encourage you to to take a look at it, has grown with the neighborhood. When they started, it was a very small therapy center and now it's grown into servicing

885
04:43:02.480 --> 04:43:17.600
um a number of different families. And this has had a very positive impact. But this type of institution unfortunately does not have a $40 million endowment. In a perfect world, it would be great if Crystal could purchase the property

886
04:43:17.600 --> 04:43:33.200
outright and have unlimited funds to make sure that they could uh keep up with the updates that are needed to um to to run the uh establishment. But unfortunately, that's not the case. And

887
04:43:33.200 --> 04:43:49.680
so for uh organizations like Crystal that provide this type of service to continue, these types of public private partnerships are in most cases the only way that this can happen. So with that said, um I thank uh each and every one

888
04:43:49.680 --> 04:44:07.840
of you for your time and and your diligence and um I strongly encourage you to approve all of the applicable ordinances at first reading. Thank you. >> Thank you, Mr. M. >> That's it, Mr. Mayor. Okay. All right. Um, just for the record, I

889
04:44:07.840 --> 04:44:24.240
want to again something that I've been doing lately, especially during I don't want to say contentious, but we have a lot of speakers. Uh, the nos went over by 6 minutes and 30 seconds and the yeses went over by 6 minutes and 51 seconds. Would anybody else like to

890
04:44:24.240 --> 04:44:40.320
speak just to add an extra 21 seconds so we can make it equal? Anybody on the no side? Anybody? Go ahead. Go ahead. We got We give you another 21 seconds, but we got to stick to 21 because then I got to invite them over for another >> I need to run. >> Okay. >> So, 20 So, 21 seconds.

891
04:44:40.320 --> 04:44:56.480
>> Okay. >> Start the clock. >> Um, you mentioned all of the wonderful parks and and we certainly appreciate as residents. I like I want to be fair. >> 43 years I've lived in Coral Gables. My husband was practically born here. I went to St. Teresa University in Miami.

892
04:44:56.480 --> 04:45:12.400
What park are you proposing in that North Douglas area? How are you going to provide the the parks and how are you going to negotiate? What area will you negotiate as a park as you have done in other areas of Coral Gables? >> Fair enough. >> Okay. >> Well,

893
04:45:12.400 --> 04:45:27.760
>> thank you. >> Now, we got to go to the Now we got to go to the yeses for one second. I'm just kidding. Um, very simple. I am looking for parks. If anybody would like to sell more parcels, we're always looking for parcels throughout the city. Uh we just bought recently the last parcel we

894
04:45:27.760 --> 04:45:43.440
bought was a $3 million parcel uh in Salvador Park that I have been chasing for since I got here and we're fortunate enough to buy it so we can expand on Salvador Park. We haven't decided yet what we're going to do there. But we just spent I think it was $10 million on Phyllis Park and you're going to see a

895
04:45:43.440 --> 04:46:00.160
massive amount of improvements that were that were accomplished there and all all the thanks and the and the accolades go to the manager, the DCM, the ACM and his amazing staff who've gotten it done. So, we have a lot of parks. We have a lot of parks um right now throughout the city, but we're continuing to expand. My

896
04:46:00.160 --> 04:46:15.440
understanding is we have over 300 plus acres of green space uh in the city. Beautiful. Uh I don't think any any city in Miami County can compete with us on that front. So, if anybody has any ideas of any private owners of property that would like to uh potentially sell their property, make sure they speak to the

897
04:46:15.440 --> 04:46:32.160
city uh because we'll we would love to be the first in line to take a look at those properties. All right. Um, madam madam, I >> I just want to note for the record that the absence of Philips Park is on Galliano, the same street that borders the east side of this property, and it's

898
04:46:32.160 --> 04:46:48.798
on minorities, which is a few blocks uh further south. >> And by the way, there is a there is a green space uh located on Pon, one block away from this property, which is where the fountain is. It's I forgot the name. It's a green space located on Ponds. I think it's probably about maybe about

899
04:46:48.798 --> 04:47:03.520
25,000 square feet. It's a pretty large piece of property. Again, not the most appropriate because it's located on ponds, but there are green spaces within less than 150 200 feet away. >> Are you referring to Rotary Park? >> No, that's the one that's the one down pond. I'm talking about the one next to

900
04:47:03.520 --> 04:47:18.958
the Greek restaurant. >> Oh, >> the one the one across from Dintan Cafe. Right next to Dintan Cafe. >> It's So, there are parks right adjacent to that. Okay. Uh moving on. Uh for the good of the order, Madame Vice Mayor,

901
04:47:18.958 --> 04:47:36.840
let's start with you. >> Comments on the record. >> Yeah. Before that, let me let me Madam City attorney, should I have should I have the app uh the applicant if he has any responses or anything we like to go? >> I'm not sure if he reserved any time for rebuttal, but you're certainly more than welcome to uh you rebuttal.

902
04:47:37.200 --> 04:47:54.000
>> Start the clock. >> I'm going to keep my comments short. I think uh over period of five years and nine hearings, I think we've addressed a lot of these items. I'm just going to clarify the record. Um you know, the characterization of North Ponds as a

903
04:47:54.000 --> 04:48:11.440
low-rise area is factually and legally inaccurate. This area is zoned today for 100 feet in height. Um this property is surrounded by zoning that allows 190 ft in height. And when you're looking at compatibility from a planning perspective and what's appropriate for

904
04:48:11.440 --> 04:48:26.878
your consideration today, you need to consider that adjacent land use. You need to consider that adjacent zoning and you need to look at the future and existing asbuilt environment. That's what compatibility is. The one item I'd like to just mention which um thank you

905
04:48:26.878 --> 04:48:42.638
for for I will not go over two minutes is the Garn of our Lord has been something that's been discussed for 5 years. It's been litigated. It's been determined by your historic preservation officer, historic preservation board, this city commission to judicial courts.

906
04:48:42.638 --> 04:49:00.000
It is not a historical resource. It does not be it does not need to be preserved. Is a private garden and it is not relevant to these proceedings today. Lastly, I want to conclude with what I said at Planning and Zoning Board. Coral Gables

907
04:49:00.000 --> 04:49:16.480
is known as a city beautiful. Well, what makes this city beautiful is not just it worldclass architecture. its parks, its public art, or its rich history. What makes our city beautiful and sets it apart are the values that we share as a community. It's the commitment to excellence in the service that we

908
04:49:16.480 --> 04:49:33.600
provide to our residents. It's why so many people, including myself, choose to call Coral Gables home. This city is home to some of the best educational institutions in the nation. And that's because Coral Gables has long recognized that education is a important public

909
04:49:33.600 --> 04:49:50.480
investment. And that investment should extend to every child with no exceptions. This project reflects those core Coral Gables values. It preserves a school that serves our most vulnerable children. And if that is not a public benefit, then I

910
04:49:50.480 --> 04:50:06.080
don't know what is. So today, we have the opportunity to do something truly beautiful. We have the opportunity to create a pro a project that's thoughtfully designed and that is meaningful and impactful. We ask that you uphold your planning staff and your planning and zoning board

911
04:50:06.080 --> 04:50:22.638
recommendation and approve a project that not only makes Coral Gables more aesthetically beautiful, but a community that's even more beautiful to live in. Thank you. >> Thank you. 2 minutes and 35 seconds for the record. >> Through the mayor, I do have some questions for the applicant.

912
04:50:22.638 --> 04:50:48.240
>> Can I can I just go through Mr. Winker and then we'll absolutely >> um may >> would Mr. Winker like any additional time for >> rebuttal? >> He had to step out. >> Okay, >> Mr. Let's wait for Mr. Winker to have

913
04:50:48.240 --> 04:51:06.878
his moment. I want to make sure I'm fair because in that I'll face the wrath of the blogs tomorrow. Mr. Winker, welcome back. >> Thank you so much. Apologize. I got called into another hearing for a second. Um, thank you for your time and patience listening to this. Uh, a couple

914
04:51:06.878 --> 04:51:23.680
things on rebuttal. It's unrebuted that they did not take into account what they were asked to do by the PAB on the conditional um, approval. I would ask that you make them do that. I think there is a solution there to save as much of the

915
04:51:23.680 --> 04:51:40.958
garden as possible. That's what we agreed to. And then further this idea, everyone keeps saying that the garden isn't open to the public right now. The garden is not open to the public is Crystal Academy owns the property and does not open the gu I'm sorry, Crystal

916
04:51:40.958 --> 04:51:57.440
Academy is there. The developer owns the property and they locked the fence. You know that that was it was open prior to that. So, I just want to make sure everyone knows that >> if if I may just I don't and I don't want to interrupt you, >> but if I have a garden in my backyard and I lock the fence because I don't

917
04:51:57.440 --> 04:52:12.878
want anybody to come in, it's private property, right? >> Correct. But they private 100%. >> But it's it's private property. They don't make I don't choose to make my property private. My my property belongs to me. It belongs to me. So, you know, let's let's let's use some reasonable

918
04:52:12.878 --> 04:52:29.200
arguments. I understand. Please, will you please sit down? Please, let's sit down. We're not going to do this today. We've given we've we've done this before. We're not going to have outbursts from from from the gallery. We're going to do this professionally. That's why I've given everybody all the time they need. Everybody's had the time. We're going to do this professionally. But I I also want to

919
04:52:29.200 --> 04:52:44.718
make sure we put factual statements on the record. Crystal Academy did not make this private. It's private property. They just close a gate because they have children who are part of that institution. And obviously, these children need to be supervised. And sometimes things happen and you want to make sure there's barriers to entry and

920
04:52:44.718 --> 04:53:01.040
barriers to escape. So, Let's be very thoughtful about about that comment because they're not choosing to make it private. It already is private property because they're paying rent to a landlord. >> Okay. Well, but back up. It's not it's the developer that locked it >> again. And two, it was open when it was

921
04:53:01.040 --> 04:53:17.680
with the church. It was open. And we we we have my Herald articles talking about how it's it was open to the public. So just to be clear, >> whether whether it's the developer, it's Crystal Academy, it's owned by someone. It's private property. They can do to protect their property, they can close

922
04:53:17.680 --> 04:53:33.440
the gate and they can say, "We want to protect the property to ensure the safety of not only the individuals that are inside the property, but those outside." >> Correct. >> Right. So moving on. Would you like to add anything else to the record before? >> That's it. Thank you so much. >> Sure. You have you have I'd like to give

923
04:53:33.440 --> 04:53:49.760
you more time, please. I >> I I appreciate effort. I would just ask that you take the advice of your Pab. Um, they very carefully weighed this. They gave the advice. Do your best to save the garden. Reorient the garden. Have the buffer with the women's center.

924
04:53:49.760 --> 04:54:07.200
The garden is there. It's ready to go. We ask that you basically have them do what they were asked to do before. Thank you so much. >> Thank you very much, sir. All right, Madam Vice Mayor, the floor is yours. >> Yeah. And before I begin, um, you know, this has been a journey. It's been five

925
04:54:07.200 --> 04:54:22.240
years, spoken to a lot of residents that have passionately come in and expressed their views, and it's it's evolved. This this project has evolved. So, I do have some questions for the applicant. I see that some of it you've done, but I

926
04:54:22.240 --> 04:54:36.560
need some clarity. Um, we talked about removing um earlier today the arcade. has it been completely removed from the drawing so that we can have additional green space and setbacks that is uh more

927
04:54:36.560 --> 04:54:53.520
consistent with an MF um zoning setback. >> So uh I'll let the uh project architect Albert Cordov is explain where we are. What we have done is we are agreeing to those conditions. We uh would like for them to be incorporated in the approval.

928
04:54:53.520 --> 04:55:10.240
We have a conceptual plan that shows what that will look like. It does result in additional green space and planting areas along the frontages. Um we have as we showed you which we can show again some conceptual images of what that does. I think it completely transforms

929
04:55:10.240 --> 04:55:25.520
um that streetscape into a more residential feel but it will require us to work with your city architect to incorporate those changes and apply them to all the different drawings that we have. So with the uh working with the city architect, is the developer

930
04:55:25.520 --> 04:55:43.520
agreeable to providing that additional green space? >> Yes, we are. >> Okay. >> So um the playground area, I see that in one of the drawings you've already rotated it. I think there was also an ask for a um a kitchen for teaching the

931
04:55:43.520 --> 04:55:59.520
children. Has that been incorporated as well? So, um, we have rotated the park and and I have a copy of the minutes from the planning and zoning board meeting which are important. Uh, the motion was to rotate

932
04:55:59.520 --> 04:56:16.400
the orientation of the park on the northeast corner. It was very specific to go instead of a north south direction an east west direction. It was rotating. It wasn't, you know, relocating which are two different words. >> Correct. >> Um, we are agreeing with that condition.

933
04:56:16.400 --> 04:56:32.000
I know that we told the board at that meeting that we needed to study it. We have um and we agree with that. We think it does provide what they intended, which is a better buffer from the women's club. That change, I believe, increases the square footage uh that

934
04:56:32.000 --> 04:56:46.000
will be able to be used by Crystal that we've committed to them by 500 square feet. So, they will have space now for for the kitchen that they needed for their operations. >> Right. Um, talking a little bit about that area, I'm going to call it the the

935
04:56:46.000 --> 04:57:05.760
children's park just for a shortand on that. Um, what are the hours of operation of Crystal and what hours would this be open for the general public afterwards? >> I'm gonna have Mary come up. >> Mio, thank you for being here and being

936
04:57:05.760 --> 04:57:20.560
able to answer those questions. >> My pleasure. Uh school operation starts at 8:00 until 4:30. >> Staff uh arrives more more or less at 7:30 in the morning. >> Okay. So for the evening hours, after

937
04:57:20.560 --> 04:57:37.120
school hours, you know, kids that don't go to the school uh can access the park after hours. Is that correct? >> Correct. >> Okay. Um, and I'm I'm just going to note while

938
04:57:37.120 --> 04:57:54.080
we're talking about access to parks and access to gardens, there was, as I recall, a resident stepped forward and explained that when he was a young man and used to go there and try to feed goldfish that faced out of the the Garden of Lord area where the koi were

939
04:57:54.080 --> 04:58:10.560
were swimming. So, I don't know of any other area that has a pond in there unless you are. >> No, that was there's only one pond. There's only one part and it was before I arrived in Cor Gables. So I wouldn't have any personal knowledge of either

940
04:58:10.560 --> 04:58:28.240
the the courtyard. Okay. And this is not presenting to the Crystal Academy. Mary, thank you for coming up. Um public access to the courtyard. Is it locked at any point in time during the day? >> Not during the day. No. >> Okay. I think traditionally, and this is

941
04:58:28.240 --> 04:58:43.760
not the first project that has done this, that has access to a public space through a po. Uh, usually that's the preferred route unless they have direct frontage on a street. Uh, I believe they have them locked normally uh in the evenings just for security.

942
04:58:43.760 --> 04:58:58.240
>> Okay. >> I think that's a standard condition. >> What hours to your knowledge? Locked after dark. Is that what you're talking about? >> Yeah. Uh it it's usually at uh at

943
04:58:58.240 --> 04:59:16.080
sundown. Um but we could set a time if it's preferable. I would say 9:00 p.m. >> Um down to dusk is usually what we do. >> It's usually I think that runs consistent with the city's parks. Uh >> correct >> hours as well.

944
04:59:16.080 --> 04:59:32.878
>> Onisha. Um Phoenicia, you have um the women's club in in front of you. You're going to be landscaping the south side of the street. Is the developer willing to also landscape consistently on the north side of the street where women's

945
04:59:32.878 --> 04:59:48.878
club is provide an amenity on both sides of the street? >> My client is nodding their head. So, yes, we would be willing to do that. I think um you know our intent and Albert mentioned is to create a really nice pedestrian environment and obviously uh we've been speaking with the women's

946
04:59:48.878 --> 05:00:06.000
club throughout this process and uh we'd be happy to do that. Okay. So there has been a lot of talk about you know one particular oak tree on the site and where it's going to be relocated. Uh there's a second specimen oak on site.

947
05:00:06.000 --> 05:00:21.280
Is developer willing to move that specimen up as well over to the east pon corridor to create that that vision in the future planning for Coral Gables to have a green corridor through there.

948
05:00:21.280 --> 05:00:40.718
>> And where would this tree be located? It would be could we put it in the rightway through like a bumpout or something? >> Yes, that's what I'm talking about. To create, you know, the mature canopy appearance. Uh so our uh our um arborist is saying

949
05:00:40.718 --> 05:00:55.360
that we've that he's evaluated that tree actually and that it is a good candidate for relocation. Um and and my clients agree able to to move that as well. Right now just so that we have an idea of what is happening on the east ponds

950
05:00:55.360 --> 05:01:10.240
corridor. Um, originally we pulled back our building on the northwest corner in order to preserve I believe it's a large mahogany tree. >> Correct. >> We are relocating the uh larger oak tree

951
05:01:10.240 --> 05:01:27.920
to the southwest corner and I think um the idea that you're proposing is to then relocate the additional oak tree in the middle of those two trees onto uh east ponds. >> It is. And I just want to make sure too that there's adequate root ball space left so this tree

952
05:01:27.920 --> 05:01:45.120
>> I'm going to introduce uh Michael McCoy who's our arburst. >> Hello. How you doing? Uh Michael McCoy. Um so we're actually asked by city staff to consider a few trees and there's a few spots in the ride ofway. So right now we're just coordinating with the city staff to make sure that there's not

953
05:01:45.120 --> 05:02:00.958
conflicts with uh other proposed rideway improvements or infrastructure. Um, but that tree is uh one of them and was evaluated for potential relocation uh to areas within the rightway making sure that meets with the landscape concept uh

954
05:02:00.958 --> 05:02:18.798
for those areas and it is a good candidate and as far as I'm aware the developers I'm meanable to locating that uh once a suitable space is identified. >> You mentioned that you're uh considering some other trees as well. Um, which trees would those have been or are

955
05:02:18.798 --> 05:02:35.280
>> uh there uh are two other uh smaller trees that are within the uh garden of our lord uh area and again that one uh we're just offered at this point the city has not uh asked for those trees to be relocated but we're asked to see if

956
05:02:35.280 --> 05:02:50.718
they were viable candidates uh as they're looking at uh areas within the surrounding rightway and planting spaces to see if they could uh fit there, but that will be at the city's discretion if that actually fits with the uh use and design of the rightway.

957
05:02:50.718 --> 05:03:07.760
>> Okay. Do you have details about which trees those are and what are the gumbo limbos on Phoenicia? >> I believe it was two gumbo limos that they were looking at. >> Okay. Oh, they might be on Phoenicia, right? I'm I'm just trying to go off the top of

958
05:03:07.760 --> 05:03:23.840
my head right now, but uh yes, there's two other uh two other trees. Uh, I think we did look at several in the uh garden of our lord, but they didn't uh have the form that would relocate them as easily and they didn't have a good destination site. So, it was the the two oaks and then the two gumbo

959
05:03:23.840 --> 05:03:39.760
limbos. >> Okay. All right. I I I've walked the property so I know some of the gumbos were unfortunately damaged considerably um by FPNL. That is a is a whole other challenge that I constantly face to try to get uh

960
05:03:39.760 --> 05:03:56.560
FPL to play nice with trees, but there were two gumbo limos that were suitable candidates and so we're we're looking to see if there's an opportunity to relocate them. >> Okay. Well, thank you for the those details. >> Of course. No problem. >> Anything else, Vice Mayor? >> Um yes.

961
05:03:56.560 --> 05:04:13.200
Um we talked about landscaping both the north and south side of Phoenicia. Um I want to talk to you also about residential parking units. We do have historic buildings around especially on

962
05:04:13.200 --> 05:04:29.920
the Antia side u with uh apartment units in them that depend upon having some residential parking. Um, is this something that the uh developers willing to work with the the city and establishing a residential parking

963
05:04:29.920 --> 05:04:46.080
permit program for um those buildings that are already existing on the street? I think you have a single one single family home and you have an 8-unit apartment building there on India that depend on that parking. >> So, um we wouldn't have an objection to

964
05:04:46.080 --> 05:05:03.840
that. One of the things we did was um one of the earlier iterations of the plan it was using I know that the women's club uses the parking on the east side uh which we're not impacting for their valet operations on weekends. >> Um we were using portions of the abuing

965
05:05:03.840 --> 05:05:19.840
uh parking there for our school pickup and drop off but we've completely revised that as Albert showed. It's all internalized now. So we wouldn't have a objection to that >> on >> all of our parking is completely internalized now. So those spaces are free and I know that several residents

966
05:05:19.840 --> 05:05:37.240
actually brought up that comment during our um our neighborhood meeting a few months ago. >> Right. I that's very beneficial especially in this neighborhood where you have historic buildings that have zero parking available. Um,

967
05:05:39.040 --> 05:05:54.400
let's talk about traffic for a moment in Galliano. Um, notice that there's a couple of intersections where there's no crosswalks and I've heard a number of complaints about speeding on Galliano.

968
05:05:54.400 --> 05:06:10.080
Um, no high intensity markings for the pedestrian crosswalk, no stop signs, no speed tables, nothing to slow down traffic. Is this something that the the developer is willing to have the traffic study done and follow staff's

969
05:06:10.080 --> 05:06:26.798
recommendations on the signs, etc.? Yeah, I believe our so our traffic study calls for a study of that area as part of the permitting process >> uh to discuss with Miami date county improvements on the um on the Galliano side

970
05:06:26.798 --> 05:06:42.000
>> on G >> because of the school. Yeah. So I think that's one of the conditions in the in the uh recommendations of the traffic study. >> Yeah. you have at least four blocks straight that people can go without any stop signs and there have been complaints and

971
05:06:42.000 --> 05:06:58.400
>> there is that risk. >> They u part of the recommendations of the traffic study is actually for us to uh undertake that study and work with Miami date county to see if it meets the threshold for it. >> Okay. Can you also look at the traffic flow westward in the traffic study

972
05:06:58.400 --> 05:07:14.878
because there was one comment um based upon that is the is the traffic is coming out on both Phoenicia and Adia there's any recommendations that uh can be made to improve the conditions well >> in that area

973
05:07:14.878 --> 05:07:30.560
>> I think that condition that that situation is going to be addressed I understand that's that's currently in process this application has a condition that after CO we need to do a whole another traffic study and if there's any

974
05:07:30.560 --> 05:07:45.280
improvements that are recommended from that study we would implement them. >> Okay. >> Um so actually uh I understand that's currently under underway that will likely get captured in that traffic study.

975
05:07:45.280 --> 05:08:01.760
So, um, in the size of the trees that you're going to be installing, you meaning the developer, have you committed to put in trees that are at least how tall? >> So, uh, there's a condition in your staff report that provides that, and I

976
05:08:01.760 --> 05:08:18.320
know this is something that we always show trees that are much larger in the renderings that they actually are. There's a condition in your staff report that those trees be 16 feet at the time of planting along the streetscape. So, the idea is to create that beautiful landscape pedestrian experience on day

977
05:08:18.320 --> 05:08:34.958
one. Okay. >> Mayor, I do have additional comments, you know, before we take a vote, but um I wanted to get some of these uh questions answered before we move forward. >> Thank you, Madam Vice Mayor. Commissioner Castro.

978
05:08:34.958 --> 05:08:52.400
>> Yeah. First, I want to thank every resident that was here and spoke pro and con of this development. And the other thing is that this is a quasi judicial case. So I would want to put on the record that there has been communication via emails and in person regarding this

979
05:08:52.400 --> 05:09:07.600
development. I also want to put on the record that I lived in this area for nearly 10 years. So I know this area very well. And I also want to be very sensitive to Crystal Academy. I spent nearly 12 years

980
05:09:07.600 --> 05:09:22.638
practicing in this field treating children and young adults with developmental disabilities or unique abilities. So this is very close to my heart. But I'm also sitting here as a commissioner and I'm putting my hat for the

981
05:09:22.638 --> 05:09:37.520
responsibility I owe to my constituents to quality of life of this neighborhood. So, as much as I do love this community and and and the school, right now I need to make a decision, not on Crystal Academy. That's not the

982
05:09:37.520 --> 05:09:58.718
vote. It's on this development. Um, this is an out of scale project. It's a massive upzoning and it keeps on happening in this community. and my colleagues are the ones

983
05:09:58.718 --> 05:10:14.878
responsible for what's happening to this city when it comes to development. It falls on us to protect this community. So my duty and my responsibility is to protect and preserve this community and their quality of life.

984
05:10:14.878 --> 05:10:34.878
We made promises to our residents when we took an oath and when we were elected. One of my promises in specific had to do with development. A gentleman here said, "The voices of our residents matter, and

985
05:10:34.878 --> 05:10:56.878
they do matter. I'll go ahead and I reserve the rest of my comments for when I'm voting." >> Commissioner Fernandez. >> Thank you, Mr. Mayor. >> I've been here now close to three and a half years. And in 3 and 1/2 years, this

986
05:10:56.878 --> 05:11:12.080
is really the first development project that has come before us that has had any opposition. What we've seen for the last three and a half years is developers sitting down with residents finding a path forward

987
05:11:12.080 --> 05:11:28.240
that has been beneficial not just for their means as a developer and their goals, but also for the neighborhood that they're coming into. And look, you you cannot take away the fact that it is extremely noble to find a spot for

988
05:11:28.240 --> 05:11:44.798
Crystal Academy uh and give them a no cost 99-year lease. Um I think saying that there is no benefit to that, there is a benefit to our community because we do have a lot of autistic children in this community.

989
05:11:44.798 --> 05:12:00.160
However, is that the one thing that makes this project a good project for this neighborhood? It is not. The um attorney for the developer was

990
05:12:00.160 --> 05:12:16.240
talking about the adjacent land use. You have single family residences right across the street from this project. Uh one of the concerns that was brought up and Commissioner Castro brought up, you know, having conversations. I've spoken with residents in this neighborhood about the project. I've spoken with the

991
05:12:16.240 --> 05:12:31.680
development team as well or the prior development team about the project. So I have had exparte communication about this. Um but they are concerned about the impact that these that this project is going to have

992
05:12:31.680 --> 05:12:48.400
on their enjoying their properties. there's a house across the street which will have the driveway coming out right in front of their home and that has been their concern and as far as what I saw in the designs and you know I could be

993
05:12:48.400 --> 05:13:05.840
corrected that has not been addressed. Um I don't think giving Crystal Academy 5,000 square feet for 99 years is enough. I think Crystal Academy, the need for Crystal Academy and its growth

994
05:13:05.840 --> 05:13:22.718
already exists today. I mean, the autism numbers, and Mary, you know these better than I do, are concerning. This is an issue that is not being addressed at levels which are way higher than ours. We have no ability to address them, but we really need to

995
05:13:22.718 --> 05:13:38.560
tackle the autism issue, ensuring that the number of autistic children does not continue to rise. Um, I think we're right now at one out of every 36 children. Is that the Is that correct? One out of one out of 31. And

996
05:13:38.560 --> 05:13:53.920
the last time we spoke it was 36. This was a couple years ago when I visited Crystal Academy. The need for schools like Crystal Academy continues to grow every day. You're capping it at 5,000 square feet. Crystal Academy in 10 years, 15 years is

997
05:13:53.920 --> 05:14:10.798
going to be maxed out. And we need to ensure that Crystal Academy has the ability to grow within its campus so that in 15 years Crystal Academy isn't again in a situation where they don't fit or they don't have the ability to provide the services to additional students who need it. The Crystal

998
05:14:10.798 --> 05:14:27.840
Academy model works and it has worked for many children in our community. So I think we're kind of trapping them into a situation where they're limited. And it's unfortunate that crystal has been used during during this whole process and has been dragged along for 5 years

999
05:14:27.840 --> 05:14:45.280
with uncertainty because the parents are correct. Uncertainty is not something that's good when you have a child in this situation where they've grown accustomed to this environment and readjusting to a new environment is going to be extremely difficult. So

1000
05:14:45.280 --> 05:15:08.560
I I mean are you even uh able to make decisions today about changes to to this plan? Uh Mr. Navaro, >> I have my client here and uh we are I mean I think you know we went ahead and as you've seen >> uh have made three three significant

1001
05:15:08.560 --> 05:15:24.718
changes to the to the project already with the conditions that we've agreed to. >> All right. So I have a couple of things. Um, one, is there any flexibility in the amount of space that's being given to Crystal Academy for growth? Whether it's current growth or whether it's space

1002
05:15:24.718 --> 05:15:41.520
that can be uh, I guess repurposed in the future for the ability for growth for Crystal Academy. >> So, with the recent change, there's been an additional 500 square foot added to the I mean, it's I mean, we've been working with Crystal Academy throughout

1003
05:15:41.520 --> 05:15:57.520
this process. This is what they need. I mean they have the ability now to be able to program that space a lot more efficiently. As you see one of the conditions of approval is that actually there'll be more children than they currently have today. So they have the opportunity to grow. I think if I'm not

1004
05:15:57.520 --> 05:16:15.040
mistaken here 65 or 70 children that now could be accommodated in the conditions of approval 75 actually. So 30 additional kids. They're almost doubling the capacity. >> Right. But again, if we go over the autism numbers, I think that need is going to continue to grow year overyear.

1005
05:16:15.040 --> 05:16:30.240
I want to make sure the Crystal Academy is set up to have the ability to grow if they need to grow in the space or in the building where they're in. I >> mean, I think we cross that bridge when we get there. Right now, it's uh trying to preserve an organization that if it's

1006
05:16:30.240 --> 05:16:48.160
lost, it's impossible to replicate. And right now, they are in a facility that is essentially falling apart. They have no ability to repair it. I mean, it's very rough situation and this is going to be probably the top uh autism

1007
05:16:48.160 --> 05:17:03.280
facility in South Florida when it's completed with this buildout. Um, obviously this is rentree. Right now, they have a huge overhead every single month. Uh, not only with repairs, but with the cost of just maintaining this

1008
05:17:03.280 --> 05:17:20.160
property. um that will go away and at that point they maybe have more opportunities to do different things and right now I think when we started this project five years ago it was urgent right to get to get them a new facility and now 5 years later it's we're up

1009
05:17:20.160 --> 05:17:37.200
against the clock um we can't solve all these problems at once but this is going to you know really put a big dent uh into what's needed out there in terms of creating a new facility for 75 uh children who really need the service.

1010
05:17:37.200 --> 05:17:54.240
>> Um as far as the park, what is the objection to placing the park at the location where the garden of our lord is? I mean, I think when we're talking about the intent of the planning and zoning board to have that buffer with the women's club, the open space of

1011
05:17:54.240 --> 05:18:11.280
the women's club is on that same I guess par across the street from where the garden of our lord is located. that would add that open space to the front uh of the building and really alleviate the main concern that the residents in

1012
05:18:11.280 --> 05:18:28.480
the area have about preserving uh that uh that piece of land. >> We understand those concerns that residents have with the garden of our llord. It has been a battle that has gone on for way too long. Unfortunately, the architectural process and the zoning process were used, you know, as reasons

1013
05:18:28.480 --> 05:18:45.200
to try and preserve the garden. uh the women's club facility where they actually have the facility is actually on the east side. Uh the planning and zoning board wanted a buffer from that facility. That's what the the open space is not historic, you know, has been trying to alleged here. What's historic

1014
05:18:45.200 --> 05:19:03.120
is the actual building which is on the east side which is why the planning and zoning board wanted that buffer. So from a planning perspective and a compatibility perspective, that's why we put it there. The school is obvious is is is on the east side of the property today. Um that's where they've operated.

1015
05:19:03.120 --> 05:19:18.080
Uh the internal circulation to accommodate internal pickup and drop off for the school and not have it going on on the street requires them to be on the east side of the property. Um and and it's just the way this, you know, when you're looking at a project that's trying to integrate a school into a

1016
05:19:18.080 --> 05:19:35.840
mixeduse project, you know, there's a lot of things at play. or the um back of house, electrical vaults, access, open spaces, all these things going on. That is the location um that makes this project work and rotating it. We, you

1017
05:19:35.840 --> 05:19:52.400
know, when we said we'd study it, I know Albert could attest to this. We thought it was going to be a pretty easy thing. You just flip it right on the page. But it is a big redesign which is why we said listen we will agree to the condition but please you know make sure that's done as part of the final design

1018
05:19:52.400 --> 05:20:07.760
stages because it is going to be a big rework for this project internally. Uh moving that completely across to the other side of the property. Um you know I don't think it accomplishes much. You actually lose I think that buffering

1019
05:20:07.760 --> 05:20:23.920
effect from the women's club. And I know that people have talked a lot about garden of our Lord. I don't know how many people who actually say let's save the garden of our Lord. I've actually been there. I've been there a hundred times in the last 5 years. I

1020
05:20:23.920 --> 05:20:39.120
could tell you, I mean, if that was my backyard, I'd be calling someone immediately to come scrape that and and landscape it. There is nothing of value there to preserve. So, I just don't know what, you know, moving it. There might

1021
05:20:39.120 --> 05:20:55.600
be some, you know, nostalgia about it, but there really is nothing that we're effectively preserving. And I think it leads to not such a great design project if it was to be moved, which is why I actually agree with the recommendation of the planning and zoning board. When we looked at it,

1022
05:20:55.600 --> 05:21:10.240
it was actually a very good recommendation in terms of design. But if you look at it from the perspective of the neighbors who live there, this is something that they have treasured whether they've been able to use it or not because of the condition it's been in. We know that the church

1023
05:21:10.240 --> 05:21:26.798
had huge financial issues for many years and they were unable to maintain it. Um for them it does mean something and I think that that is uh a goodwill gesture that the developer can make towards the neighborhood that they're putting this project in uh and really making an

1024
05:21:26.798 --> 05:21:42.958
impact. And I think you may even be able to get a few extra square feet for uh Crystal Academy if you move the location to the of the school to the other side, giving them that extra space. I think we're still in a design pro. I'll let

1025
05:21:42.958 --> 05:22:00.878
you finish. >> Um I can tell you this. Um it's been five years. Uh we had those discussions early on and there were some things we could have done. not putting it exactly there but a lot of things if we could have done that that easily and make this

1026
05:22:00.878 --> 05:22:16.480
project work we would have done it because you know we uh it's been a long journey but it just it does not work for the project to have that open space at that corner I'm going to let Albert >> yes I I would like to view it this way commissioner because we have been a part

1027
05:22:16.480 --> 05:22:33.520
of this process this collaborative process with the city and our staff we see that the neighbors and the community is getting a lot more than they have today. Today is a private property, a private garden. Today they don't have the wider sidewalks, the wider streetscape that we are implementing on

1028
05:22:33.520 --> 05:22:48.798
this project. Uh today they don't have the park after hours that they have in the corner, 4,000 square ft. Today they don't have access to a beautiful courtyard through a beautiful pel. Today they don't have all that connectivity, all that beautiful pedestrian realm that

1029
05:22:48.798 --> 05:23:04.560
we're bringing forth on this project. So I think we are lending a lot to the neighborhood and to the that's how we as an architect as as someone who has had the opportunity to design uh a project in this beautiful city views it

1030
05:23:04.560 --> 05:23:19.760
>> and and and I understand that perspective but it's like going to buy a car. You know you want one specific feature and in order to get that feature they throw in 20 others thinking that those are features that you want. You don't necessarily want it. Um, I don't

1031
05:23:19.760 --> 05:23:35.120
think that's what the community is asking for here. I think the one thing they're asking for is for the preservation of that open space at that location. And if we are having an open space, all I'm asking is why not just move it over to that other side. I'm not

1032
05:23:35.120 --> 05:23:51.760
even asking you to do the exact same footprint. I'm asking you to keep the same square footage that you've designated for the park. Just move it to that location. And again, it's a goodwill gesture to to to the residents who live in that neighborhood. Uh let's

1033
05:23:51.760 --> 05:24:08.320
end this five-year process on a happy note where people feel like they were able to work with you to get the one thing that they've been asking for all this time. Because the end of the day, they're going to have a nine-story building in front of their homes, in

1034
05:24:08.320 --> 05:24:40.798
front of their their their windows. Let's give them that park. just move it over to the other location. That is the request that I'm that I'm making to you. That's the simple request that I'm making. >> Mr. Navaro, just a brief question. Piggy

1035
05:24:40.798 --> 05:24:55.360
back off what Commissioner France was saying. Just so I can get a little bit more clarity. >> How large is the Garden of our Lord? How many square feet is it? >> Depends how you define it. Today it's zero, but that area, the open space, 20,000 square feet.

1036
05:24:55.360 --> 05:25:17.120
>> Yeah, but I mean I not not where the playground is. Not where the playground is. >> We have our neighbor. Yeah, just the area where where where the actual garden is. How many square feet is it? >> Probably less than 3,000 square feet.

1037
05:25:17.120 --> 05:25:32.638
>> Okay. All right. Um, is is the just kind of I want to give more context to Commissioner Francis. Is the issue having to do with the fact of the way that the residential is stacked on top of the area that the PAP may be requested and that all those

1038
05:25:32.638 --> 05:25:47.600
residential units would be lost if that park was installed? Is that is that I mean let's we're having a frank conversation here. We're trying to get to a trying to bring this in for a landing. Yeah. And I'm trying and I'm trying to give more context because if you if you put a let's say a 5,000 foot

1039
05:25:47.600 --> 05:26:05.280
park just using 5,000 is kind of the smallest park we have in the city, right, Mr. Manager? would you say 5,000 ft? Um, when you put a 5,000 foot park, how many units do you lose on that vertical stack that if you wanted to if you wanted to

1040
05:26:05.280 --> 05:26:20.240
have a park there? You'd say, let's shift that density and intensity on top of the building and maybe add an additional floor. I know nobody wants to add an additional floor, but I'm asking you got to find a way to skin the cat here and find a resolution. So, what do

1041
05:26:20.240 --> 05:26:38.160
you think? Tell me. So that would be approximately 25 units. >> 25 units. >> And that's a conservative estimate. >> Just want to put that on the mix here. >> And the way this project is worth, I mean works is that obviously

1042
05:26:38.160 --> 05:26:53.680
uh there is a certain threshold where we're making the significant financial investment course that it just won't work anymore. >> No, I understand. And that's my next point. I mean again you're going to make a significant investment and I have and I have my asks that I'm going to ask you which are not as complicated as this one even though after reading the PAB

1043
05:26:53.680 --> 05:27:09.680
minutes I kind of agree with PAB um that but let me ask you a question on the one of the Comm Commissioner Finish what you're saying I have I have sorry >> well I guess I never got an answer >> I don't think that's possible I mean I really don't not only now at this stage

1044
05:27:09.680 --> 05:27:24.558
um we don't even know what that would do it would just put the project on pause again and you've heard from a lot people today. Actually, if you took count today, I think there was only nine people that spoke against maybe 10. There was 22 people in support. 500

1045
05:27:24.558 --> 05:27:40.958
petitions of in support and not from I, you know, from around here. This is in the neighborhood. 522 people in support of this project from that neighborhood. When we first showed up here four years ago, there was probably 100 people against us.

1046
05:27:40.958 --> 05:27:57.120
>> The issue of the gar of our Lord is not really the issue anymore. Yes, there are a few people that um you know are passionate about it, but it's not a big community issue. You've heard from the residents. They want to see a site activated. You've heard from the parents. They need this school

1047
05:27:57.120 --> 05:28:12.958
today. All this we need to make a decision. We can't keep going back and forth because we're just putting this project at jeopardy and this project unfortunately for Crystal has a ticking clock. >> But Mr. Navaro, this is not about pinning one resident versus another because of what their demands are, what

1048
05:28:12.958 --> 05:28:29.760
the requests are, what they would like to see. This is a simple request. I'm not asking you to get rid of units because you already have an area designated as green space, as open space. So, you're not losing it. You're just shifting it to a different location. >> If this project was a perfect square, if

1049
05:28:29.760 --> 05:28:44.638
the site was >> I understand there are dynamics in this project which are different from others. I understand that >> property is like a trapezoid. So the moving of that over there is not as simple. The fact that we rotated it and in 3 weeks we're able to come up with a

1050
05:28:44.638 --> 05:29:00.160
conceptual site plan of it. Shifting it to the complete other side. What happens to Crystal's public open space then? Just we're going to have children that don't get to have open space amenities for their for the children which you know we're discussing how important you

1051
05:29:00.160 --> 05:29:17.120
know the need for autistic programming is and outdoor recreation is a critical component of that. What happens to that open space amenity? Where where do we get the space for that? >> But let's take it back five years. You've had five years to design this project

1052
05:29:17.120 --> 05:29:32.558
with the park at that location. >> Yes. And the developer could do it and again has never done that >> because it's not possible. >> It is possible. It absolutely is. >> Anything is possible. >> It is possible. You're just not going to make as much money as you'd like to make. That's that that's the bottom line.

1053
05:29:32.558 --> 05:29:48.320
>> Making as much money is that being able to make as much financial sense. >> It would it would basically the project could not afford to have Crystal Academy come in be completely built out and brand free for 99 years. >> What percent what percentage of the project is Crystal Academy?

1054
05:29:48.320 --> 05:30:04.638
>> It's not a percentage. It's the cost of the construction. >> You know what? Okay. I'm >> I mean you're saying it like Crystal Academy is the majority of the pro of the project. It is not. It is a a small footprint which is again my other concern is the

1055
05:30:04.638 --> 05:30:21.638
fact I don't think you're giving Crystal Academy enough space long long run. >> You're talking about 99 years where Crystal Academy is going to be bootstrapped to to 5,000 square ft. So, you know, I I think

1056
05:30:25.760 --> 05:30:40.798
Yes. Again, Commissioner, if I may, Albert Corves, um, we started working five years ago on this, and the first things we did is we looked at the possibility of leaving the garden where it's at. Logistically, it

1057
05:30:40.798 --> 05:30:58.798
wasn't possible for many reasons. We were trying to allocate the parking system, a two- bay parking system, which serves the entire building, and to be linered only to be adequately urbanistically with the best solution possible. that has to happen on the east

1058
05:30:58.798 --> 05:31:14.638
where the site has the ability to grow right or to establish a parking circulation. The other one is basically cut off by the angle. So by doing that the school needed to be on the double height areas of the parking to the east. By doing that the circulation to the

1059
05:31:14.638 --> 05:31:29.360
school and the drop off areas needed to be to the east and by doing that the associated open space needed to be with adjacency to the school. moving the use to the other side, it would destroy the com the logistics of

1060
05:31:29.360 --> 05:31:46.080
having what we have today which is a complete liner system of active spaces on Antia and on East Pon right to establish that that you know what we all want the urbanistic active spaces introducing in the middle of that

1061
05:31:46.080 --> 05:32:01.760
another space which is the school would destroy the adjacy would destroy the internalized parking circulation the actual lineering of the parking on the upper floors. We looked at it from the very beginning. I can tell you we looked at it so many times through this

1062
05:32:01.760 --> 05:32:18.400
process. Uh we went five times to the board of architects and they consider we had the appropriate the appropriate massing elements, the appropriate placement of of the parking. Uh and we enjoy that collaborative effort because that's what made what we truly feel is

1063
05:32:18.400 --> 05:32:34.718
today a project that it's it's all the check marks have been checked. I can honestly tell you from our side and from from a planning stand for an architectural standpoint. Moving that to the other side for implementing a portion of of property that is private

1064
05:32:34.718 --> 05:32:49.280
and it's a garden. We thought that all the other elements that we could offer the community as we mentioned before you know the additional open space. Now we have 32% of the property being open space instead of nothing. Today we have the wider prop the wider sidewalks, the

1065
05:32:49.280 --> 05:33:06.000
wider pedestrian elements. I think that that makes a a unique project and a unique opportunity for that area for that for that particular city block. I really do. >> I mean I I understand and I appreciate you breaking it down to the the needs of the project as well.

1066
05:33:06.000 --> 05:33:21.680
>> There's logistics involved. >> Mr. Navaro and I worked on on another project one north ponds and I got similar concerns at that point from the architect that we couldn't relocate the the entrance because residents didn't want it in the residential neighborhoods and it was done and and we had zero

1067
05:33:21.680 --> 05:33:37.680
opposition to that project when that project was approved by by the commission three months ago. Um it took work uh it took a lot of meetings with residents and it took a lot of concessions on both sides. Uh but we were able to come up with a project that

1068
05:33:37.680 --> 05:33:54.878
preserved the green space, gave the residents the the buffers that that they were looking for, uh uh removed the uh the uh entrance ramps from the residential or the single family streets. So where there's a will, there's a way. Um

1069
05:33:54.878 --> 05:34:09.600
I'm not going to pretend to be an architect. I'm not going to pretend to tell you, you know, this is what you can and cannot do. My requests, I think, are simple. I think there needs to be additional space for Crystal Academy and I think the garden or or the park area

1070
05:34:09.600 --> 05:34:28.878
should be moved to the other location. >> Right. So I want to also thank everyone for expressing their views. I mean that's why we're here um as uh commissioners to represent the will of the people to the best of our ability. But not all people share the same

1071
05:34:28.878 --> 05:34:45.200
thoughts, views, or opinions at the same time. So we're not here to make the the easy decision. We're here to make the difficult decisions. I I I happen to, you know, respect very much all the sides that were represented here today. Um, you know, but for me, one of the

1072
05:34:45.200 --> 05:35:00.320
most important things to consider, right? And and it's not, as many have said so far, it's not about Crystal Academy. That's not the the main focus here. even though that's the only one that I'm aware of where you have uh a

1073
05:35:00.320 --> 05:35:16.240
dedicated staff to help out the people who need the most help right now. And that that's that's that's something that's important to me, you know, that the children who are getting the care, the unique specialized care when you suffer from a disability like autism,

1074
05:35:16.240 --> 05:35:34.400
you know, and uh and I'm I uh I've been involved for over a decade with Easter Seals. So I'm the chair of development, you know, and that's one of the leading uh organizations around the country to provide uh that kind of support as well as raise awareness. So that's a real um

1075
05:35:34.400 --> 05:35:50.638
existing uh unique and vital uh service that's being provided today. The by comparison, you know, the garden of the Lord, I think it was created sometime in 1951. It certainly is not the kind of um

1076
05:35:50.638 --> 05:36:08.480
landmark designated iconic uh historical locations that came from the 1920s as part of Merrick's plan and vision. It simply wasn't. Uh I'd be the first one to say, "Let's find a new place to start a new Garden of the Lord, right?" Um not so simple to start a new Crystal

1077
05:36:08.480 --> 05:36:24.240
Academy. Certainly not as impactful. And uh while I share uh Commissioner Fernandez's concerns about wanting to open and provide as many uh opportunities for Crystal Academy as uh can be provided.

1078
05:36:24.240 --> 05:36:40.320
Um you know, the applicant is a private business. Crystal Academy is a private business. As was said before, it's an amazing opportunity to be provided a rent-free 99-year lease when in this environment, there's tremendous overhead

1079
05:36:40.320 --> 05:36:57.360
that Mary and her team are are taking on. Increased overhead also means increased cost to the parents, you know, to be able to use those services. So I think that the applicant has done a laudable gesture uh to provide the space to

1080
05:36:57.360 --> 05:37:12.080
modernize improve and make it a bigger and even a a bigger space and a bigger uh group of of children that can use it. Um I don't think the Crystal Academy and who am I opine uh besides saying is constrained

1081
05:37:12.080 --> 05:37:28.638
or uh prohibited from growing. Uh perhaps who knows what the future holds for now. there isn't a foreseeable increase to the uh square footage allotted, but um if Crystal Academy wanted to open up another location, no one's prohibiting them from doing that

1082
05:37:28.638 --> 05:37:43.920
as well, depending on the needs and financial circumstances, they may unfold. From my perspective, you you've got to make a decision based on what makes the most sense under the circumstances. And I believe that from what I have seen

1083
05:37:43.920 --> 05:38:00.240
over this um uh somewhat tortured period of time is that the will of the people is more reflective of being in support of this of this development. Not everyone is going to be in alignment. Not everybody wants the same thing. But I have seen and heard uh quite a bit of

1084
05:38:00.240 --> 05:38:16.718
support for it. and why, you know, some of the obvious reasons are there's a high uh demand for uh housing in particular in Coral Gables and specifically in that area.

1085
05:38:16.718 --> 05:38:33.440
We would be then approving a project that can provide additional housing when the demand is so high. And when you can meet that demand by providing the additional supply, I believe that you would you would then be providing the economic support to drive the economic

1086
05:38:33.440 --> 05:38:51.520
engine for the small businesses not only in the in the pon area um but uh Coral Gable's downtown district in general. I I see a lot of upside to this project. Is it perfect? No. But if we wait for perfect, if we wait for everyone to be

1087
05:38:51.520 --> 05:39:07.040
uh in agreement, no matter how idiosyncratic, personal or unique your view is on it, then um we we would never expand. We would never develop. We would uh I believe uh uh go

1088
05:39:07.040 --> 05:39:25.680
static and then regress. And that's how a city does not grow, does not improve. uh Merrick's original version was to develop Merik was the first developer of Coral Gables and uh and and and I I would

1089
05:39:25.680 --> 05:39:41.680
consider him to be from Coral Gables. He moved here when he was 12, you know, but they're from out of town that family originally as well. So, uh I I have one specific question though for the applicant, Mr. Navaro. >> Commissioner,

1090
05:39:41.680 --> 05:39:58.000
>> so good to see you again. Good to see you as well. >> You know, it has been raised that um Crystal is unsure about its future. Should this be approved um for the period of time that the construction will be ongoing? Do you can you shed

1091
05:39:58.000 --> 05:40:15.440
some light on what maybe perhaps can be done to accommodate or I miss something along the way? Is there some plans that are being discussed or something that's been already decided? So, the timing is important, which is why we're trying to um get this project approved. Uh we're

1092
05:40:15.440 --> 05:40:31.680
behind schedule on what we have planned, but Crystal Academy um the relocation period has to be in the summer and we've been working with Mary uh Field and her team, we're targeting next July, next

1093
05:40:31.680 --> 05:40:47.200
July as the move date. We're currently working with other governmental agencies and ourselves uh to find an alternative location where they could move to while this project gets constructed. Uh idea

1094
05:40:47.200 --> 05:41:04.400
to have this space um ready, you know, and we'll work with your manager to see co that space first so they could come in while the rest of the building is completed. >> Right. That's important because I mean there a lynch pin of this, right? and you know is is that this space be

1095
05:41:04.400 --> 05:41:21.200
provided for the 99 year 99year period but there there must be a crystal academy to take occupancy. >> Yes. And there and there will be there will be continuity. Uh we need to move quick because um July is when and Mary's looking at me I know July of next year

1096
05:41:21.200 --> 05:41:38.798
is the date that we have to um uh do the relocation. So I've said this before on several occasions from the dis that um an infirmity that we have been dealing with um on the P&Z was delay delay and

1097
05:41:38.798 --> 05:41:56.240
and delay and I think that sometimes it uh takes on the appearance if not the actual form of weaponizing in order to to to kill not not not irresponsible development but just any development. Right? Right. So I am not in favor of

1098
05:41:56.240 --> 05:42:12.080
that. I thought we saw that occur in a way in a distinct way when u the mark on US1 was being uh debated endlessly uh with the idea that time will wound all deals.

1099
05:42:12.080 --> 05:42:30.160
So this has been a very long period 5 years. I I note that the PNZ hasn't been voting in in lock step on the various ordinances. It's a 4-3 and then with a 5-2 vote and then a 6-1. What that

1100
05:42:30.160 --> 05:42:46.000
reflects to me is that there's been great consideration made by the members of that board. Each has provided their view. Each has voted according to their their charge and it has been the majority in each of the ones that have come before us. not done overnight, not

1101
05:42:46.000 --> 05:43:03.440
done uh you know in a hurry um but measured and um and in the end uh providing variable guidance for us here on the commission. So thank you for your your your participation. Thank you all

1102
05:43:03.440 --> 05:43:19.520
for your comments that came today. I I will be supportive. >> Thank you. Thank you uh commissioner. Um my comments will be brief. But I want to touch on something that Commissioner Lada brought up and I thought he spoke very eloquent and I

1103
05:43:19.520 --> 05:43:36.080
agree with most of his comments. The mark is a perfect example. It was an it was an item that went before the PAB was stricken down unreasonably and was later taken up by the county using the

1104
05:43:36.080 --> 05:43:51.440
RTZ and we ended up with a building I want to be correct on the record I think two floors taller than what was being proposed on the planning and zoning board. I know nobody wants to face that but members of the planning and zoning board instead of working collaboratively

1105
05:43:51.440 --> 05:44:07.680
um they ended up going towards the RTZ route of the county and it is a public record and it was when they proposed it was a six-story building and they ended up going the RTZ route and going eight stories. So that is the kind of situation that we're in. We've lost control due to preeemption both at the

1106
05:44:07.680 --> 05:44:24.520
state through live local and at the county with the RTZ. But we have to be very methodical moving forward. Very methodical doesn't mean we approve things to approve things, but we have to be very methodical moving forward. So

1107
05:44:25.120 --> 05:44:40.400
to say that I'm fond of of Crystal Academy and the work that they've been doing there fall short. Um when you think about Coral Gables and what makes Coral Gables special, this is what makes Coral Gables special. I have spent a lot of time at Crystal Academy, lots of

1108
05:44:40.400 --> 05:44:57.520
time. I've invested my own time, my own money, um, selfishly. Why? Um, I won't ruin it for you. Spend some time at Crystal Academy and you'll figure it out really quick. When you walk in

1109
05:44:57.520 --> 05:45:13.920
there, step onto that campus and spend some time with those kids. Run into them here at city hall. run into them on the miracle mile on ponds when you're grabbing your lunch.

1110
05:45:13.920 --> 05:45:28.958
Spend some time with Mary. She is an amazing human being. She is an exceptional human being. Sometimes I wonder how she does it. Truly a gift from God and I'm grateful

1111
05:45:28.958 --> 05:45:52.320
to have you as a friend. Um, I do have some questions for you, Mr. Navaro. >> Uh, and I'm happy that after 5 years, this is coming to an end one way or another. >> Mhm. >> When we were looking at I think it was

1112
05:45:52.320 --> 05:46:10.160
page 68 or page 48. Can we go back to that? We can. Commissioner Franis talked about having some opportunity for growth. I noticed that there was some there was a there was an adjacent living space.

1113
05:46:10.160 --> 05:46:25.920
I'm not going to ask you to give me 25 units of the green space, but I'm going to ask you to give me one of those living spaces next door for Crystal. You have that Do you have that up there? Page 48. and I'm going to give you the opportunity to consider it between first

1114
05:46:25.920 --> 05:46:40.798
and second reading. Okay. >> I appreciate that. >> Um I'd >> like to pull up if we could um the slide because I don't know if page >> I think it's one of the li work spaces. >> Yeah. I just don't know. >> I know that it's going to cost money. I know it's going to cost money on the

1115
05:46:40.798 --> 05:47:00.400
bottom line. I know it will. But >> I want you to think about it between first and second reading. And the second thing I'm going to ask you being in construction while we wait that up. So it's beautiful that you give uh Crystal the opportunity to stay here

1116
05:47:00.400 --> 05:47:17.040
in the city 99 years rent free. I think it was the area. Can you open it up a little bit more >> because I think if it was in the original plan we have given that live work unit uh to Crystal in this updated plan. Can you

1117
05:47:17.040 --> 05:47:35.440
open it up a little bit more? The one adjacent to the park up there. What's that? What's that next to the park? My eyesight is nothing. That's to the Go to the left. No, no, no, no. The ramp. But no, but underneath that next to the park.

1118
05:47:35.440 --> 05:47:51.120
No, no, go here. I just can't see. My eyesight is terrible. Right there. >> That is >> Is that the road is that? That is the first landing of a brand. I think >> that's over. >> Yeah. >> Okay. Let's go down then. That's going to stay that way.

1119
05:47:51.120 --> 05:48:06.878
>> All right. What about here? >> We we do have a an idea based on what you're requesting. >> You see where we have a drop off of the cars independently of a pass through for the buildings. >> Okay. >> There's quite an apron that we have there based on this new rendition where

1120
05:48:06.878 --> 05:48:24.000
we moved the school. Uh as you notice there's about possibly 30 30 something feet there >> that for a drop off of even 75 students is very large. >> Okay. >> But we could potentially expand the school square footage into there

1121
05:48:24.000 --> 05:48:38.878
>> uh and still allow a beautiful >> adequate drop off area. >> Okay. Uh >> and that's a pretty big significant >> it it is significant. It is significant. And the one of the things that came out of this uh change also is that on the

1122
05:48:38.878 --> 05:48:56.000
north side where we rotated the park, we eliminated the back house areas that we had. So across the women's center now we have no back house areas. We actually internalized them on the lower portion

1123
05:48:56.000 --> 05:49:12.558
if you see them. Um, so I think there's a lot of positives that came here from from this particular request from the planning zone. >> If you would you would assist me between first and second reading. You would allow maybe provide the commission with conceptual

1124
05:49:12.558 --> 05:49:29.120
drawing of what that would expansion would look like and what you feel comfortable with >> absolutely >> expanding there. So that's one that's one thing. The second thing is obviously there's there's no buildout that I see. What are you Mr. Commissioner Navaro, what are you providing? Are you

1125
05:49:29.120 --> 05:49:44.400
providing with a buildout um right now for Crystal Academy? >> Not the internal components of it, just just the um internal building shell. >> So, they're responsible for paying for that. >> Currently, that's the way the covenant is drafted.

1126
05:49:44.400 --> 05:50:00.958
>> Can you do me a favor? Can you include that in the deal? >> I know obviously we're talking about it was 5,000. Now it's going to be about 6,000 because not not 6,000 but it's between it's going to go up now. Let's say it's $150 a foot. Um, you know, I

1127
05:50:00.958 --> 05:50:20.240
think it's important that that where is where is um where is a school going to get the money to pay for that? They'd have to raise the funds and I'd rather have them raise the funds for an endowment. We could definitely come back to you on those two items and get you finality on

1128
05:50:20.240 --> 05:50:36.958
it on second reading. But >> okay. And the third item that I have a request. Okay. Because the vice mayor already took care of traffic calming. She took care of the setbacks on Gallaliano which by the way that's where my grandfather lived. He lived on Galan in a small little parking.

1129
05:50:36.958 --> 05:51:01.600
>> I didn't know that. Yeah. >> That was his that's where he lived his whole life when he came to this great country. Um, the final point is, excuse me, I apologize. Okay, crazy idea.

1130
05:51:01.600 --> 05:51:16.320
Just give it some thought. >> Mhm. >> Maybe we can find somebody generous in the community. Maybe the city can pitch in. There's a photo that I saw that somebody put up that showed a two-story building across the street that had a little sign

1131
05:51:16.320 --> 05:51:32.160
on it. I pray it's a for sale sign and not a rent sign. I know the building is not historic because and then I'll have my dear friend Marik coming to me and tell me we can't tear it down. Of course not because it's historic and I agree. But that little building, can we find

1132
05:51:32.160 --> 05:51:49.520
out if that building's for sale? I believe it may have been recently sold. >> Can we find out >> it was >> because we were looking at it as well. >> Is it historic? >> Uh I don't know if it's historic. >> It is. >> Oh, it's historic. But it was available

1133
05:51:49.520 --> 05:52:04.878
and one of the many options that we did in an effort over the last 5 years try to uh find a new home for the garden. that site became available but it was sold before we >> somebody used that photo before and I saw a little for sale sign the building

1134
05:52:04.878 --> 05:52:21.520
looked obviously over 50 years old >> so I was wondering if potentially that building was was >> I was hoping it wasn't the one that you were talking about but yes that's the one that we had looked at >> yeah in the photo >> and it's sold yeah >> at the end of day it's historic not going >> um I'd like to see through the manager if

1135
05:52:21.520 --> 05:52:36.320
possible that we look for something similar to that in that vicinity if we could have your team and see what we could find. Um, because I think that could be something that potentially we could work on as a

1136
05:52:36.320 --> 05:52:54.480
relocation for some of the Garden of the Lord artifacts. Again, maybe it's a possibility, maybe it's not. But in closing, before I know the vice mayor had some further comments, I'm

1137
05:52:54.480 --> 05:53:12.600
ready to vote. Um, I think after five years, the community has spoken. I think we've had uh a lot of individuals who have partaken in this beautiful democratic process that we're blessed to enjoy here in this great country. Um,

1138
05:53:13.600 --> 05:53:30.878
I'm a firm believer that Crystal Academy belongs in community, not because of the work that Mary and all the employees are doing, because I think it makes our community better. truly makes our community better. And I want to commend Fieldfield for upholding

1139
05:53:30.878 --> 05:53:48.400
the bargain. You didn't have to do that. Um the deal that was struck between the previous developer, thank you for that and for all your concessions today because I know that between the commission, we've asked for a lot. This is a private piece of property. This is not a public piece of property.

1140
05:53:48.400 --> 05:54:04.320
We will be we will be dealing with public pieces of property soon within a few hours on a piece of legislation that I wrote which will protect green spaces, which will protect the youth center, which will protect golf courses like the Granada Golf Course. But this is a

1141
05:54:04.320 --> 05:54:19.520
private piece of property. I will be voting yes to protect Bristol Academy, which I think is a true treasure in our community. But I would like between first and second reading to address the three points that I made.

1142
05:54:19.520 --> 05:54:34.558
>> We will um if you'd be so kind, obviously let's not wait till till the day of the of of the hearing. >> Mhm. >> Let's send the memo through the manager and his team and copy the commission. >> We'll start looking at it right away >> so we can be uh on the same page. Madam

1143
05:54:34.558 --> 05:54:53.840
Vice Mayor, >> push the button. Uh thank you mayor and u thank you all for being present and providing your comments. Um great cities require great schools and that's something that George Merik

1144
05:54:53.840 --> 05:55:11.600
strongly believed in. How we got to University of Miami land was donated there. It's a big sacrifice that Merrick made. Coral Gables Elementary School was built and so was Pon Leó which was then both the high school and the junior high

1145
05:55:11.600 --> 05:55:28.638
and um serves our still serves our community to this day in a junior high capacity and a direct route for Coral Gable's residents or anybody to go to Coral Gables High. This school provides a missing gap. When

1146
05:55:28.638 --> 05:55:46.000
I knocked doors six years ago, that was one of the areas that people expressed our community lacked sufficient resources. keeping Crystal Academy in our community and allowing it to grow. And I agree, it

1147
05:55:46.000 --> 05:56:00.878
does need to grow um and allowing it to expand on this site right now to be able to essentially double its capacity is a great service to this community that I think America

1148
05:56:00.878 --> 05:56:16.718
would be extremely proud of for our community moving forward on. And the voices of the people do matter, including those who have contributed to the ideas who were totally opposed.

1149
05:56:16.718 --> 05:56:33.040
Their voices were heard. The folks that spoke today, I did take account. 24 were in favor, nine were against. We have 500 in your petition. Um, a lot of people that were nos became

1150
05:56:33.040 --> 05:56:52.638
yeses as they understood the project better and the importance of Crystal Academy. Watching these children develop in this school and participate in our community is magical and it gives me hope about

1151
05:56:52.638 --> 05:57:09.680
the humanity of our community to embrace them because many of the folks that started out as a no understood the importance that Crystal Academy brings to our community and humanity that we express that. So

1152
05:57:09.680 --> 05:57:24.160
I'm Yes. And as I told some folks that I met with yesterday that they prefer no development, we have to be careful what we wish for

1153
05:57:24.160 --> 05:57:39.920
because that happened down on US1. And as you heard, we ended up with RTZ zone, 5 foot sidewalks, minimal stepbacks. I'm just going to call them ugly buildings because they, you know, the

1154
05:57:39.920 --> 05:57:56.320
county is not going to do what our board of architects does. The quality is not going to be there. Live local has been amended every single year and is now allowed to be on sype

1155
05:57:56.320 --> 05:58:12.160
properties or church type properties and we already have one on South with a street. There's no park or green space. There's no community benefit. There's no pad.

1156
05:58:12.160 --> 05:58:30.480
And um my last um comment because people focus on stories as opposed to height. When you're dealing with height, more affordable housing has lower ceilings. So, you're going to be able to fit more stories in there. The more

1157
05:58:30.480 --> 05:58:47.280
expensive units have taller ceilings, so fewer units, more expensive, less affordable. If you look at the historic fabric of this North Ponds area, and my father-in-law had four buildings, God

1158
05:58:47.280 --> 05:59:05.200
rest his soul, he's gone. They were all sold in the early 2000s. Those units ranged from 375 square feet. That's the 102 Menor's building on the corner of Manor and Galliano.

1159
05:59:05.200 --> 05:59:23.200
And buildings such as 114 Menoris, 118 Menoris, those build those historic buildings had about 650 square feet. This building provides the missing middle. It's going to provide housing that

1160
05:59:23.200 --> 05:59:39.520
historic preservationists point out is necessary to be able to have more affordable places for folks to live. And it does something more that no other project has done. It brings a great community benefit that we can look back

1161
05:59:39.520 --> 05:59:57.600
on decades from now and say we did not forget. We did not forget these children. We did not fail to support them. We did not fail to provide them a place to call home and I hope that there's more

1162
05:59:57.600 --> 06:00:12.958
developments out here in the future that can help contribute to help solve these problems. Thank you. >> Thank you, Madam Vice Mayor. Um, may I have a motion? >> I'll move it. >> Second. >> Just to be clear, Mr. Mayor, this is on

1163
06:00:12.958 --> 06:00:29.760
E7, the land use map change. Thank you, >> Commissioner Fernandez. >> I'm a no today. Um, I'd like to see what happens between first and second reading. Uh, I think we

1164
06:00:29.760 --> 06:00:46.240
can make up some of that ground. Um, and I would still like for you to consider the potential of moving that park um to the location where the garden is. Um, but I can't support it as it is today. So, I'm a no. >> We'll look at that.

1165
06:00:46.240 --> 06:01:03.440
>> Thank you, >> Commissioner Lada. >> So, my vote is for responsible intelligent development, for helping to drive the economic engine in the Pon area and it's for Crystal

1166
06:01:03.440 --> 06:01:17.760
Academy. So, I'm a yes. >> Vice Mayor Anderson. For all my reasons previously stated, yes. Commissioner Castro, >> I want to put something into perspective and it's that this body is going to

1167
06:01:17.760 --> 06:01:34.718
approve this development which is double the size of what our zoning code permits. So my question here is why do we have a zoning code? Is a zoning code only for residents or is it to make exceptions

1168
06:01:34.718 --> 06:01:50.240
for developers? I think we need to keep that into consideration a little bit. The other thing is the question today is very simple. Do we protect the neighborhoods we represent or do we rewrite their protections just for one

1169
06:01:50.240 --> 06:02:08.000
project? My votes going to be no. >> Mayor Lago. >> Mr. manager. One of the items that I forgot to touch upon was the map, the 1926 map that was discussed and that was shown that there was a change in zoning and then it was downzoned uh to

1170
06:02:08.000 --> 06:02:23.200
religious. Uh can we have that prepared for staff uh to really kind of send us a memo in preparation for the second reading of this project? because I think that's something that my colleagues on the commission I was I wasn't aware of and I'll be honest with you that the

1171
06:02:23.200 --> 06:02:41.600
1926 zoning was the current zoning that's being requested today. Correct. Well, it's kind of vague. I understand, but I need a little more clarity on that. It's not going to affect my decision, but I found that very interesting and I think people are going to ask me that question. So, I just want to be a little more clear on

1172
06:02:41.600 --> 06:02:58.400
>> Hello. I guess shown was a height map. So, we have a height map from the 1926 and also a use map. Um, what was shown is the height map would have the higher heights on East Ponds as well as a lower on the east side. >> Okay. So, what I would >> research that >> what I would like for you to research

1173
06:02:58.400 --> 06:03:16.160
that through the manager's office and provide provide the commission with a memo just explaining that and I'd like to showcase that at the next commission, please. >> Thank you, Mr. Manager. Um, you know, I know it's it's politics season and elections are in November.

1174
06:03:16.160 --> 06:03:34.080
Thank God they're not in April. But I understand we can disagree on projects. We can disagree on style, use, height, units. But I think we can hopefully agree on one thing, and that is we're a better city with Crystal

1175
06:03:34.080 --> 06:03:52.160
Academy here. But my vote is a yes. on F8. >> I'll move it. >> E8. Mr. Mayor, just to be clear, >> I apologize. Excuse me. >> Thank you. >> Can I I have to start wearing my glasses. Apologies. >> Commissioner Lada.

1176
06:03:52.160 --> 06:04:07.040
>> Yes. >> Vice Mayor Anderson. >> Yes. >> Commissioner Castro. The majority might have the votes to go ahead and approve this, but I would not vote to remove neighborhood protections to try to fit a ninestory building into

1177
06:04:07.040 --> 06:04:23.280
a lowrise residential area. Absolutely not. >> Commissioner Fernandez, >> no. >> Mayor Lago, >> yes. >> Uh E9, >> I'm going to move it.

1178
06:04:23.280 --> 06:04:40.320
>> I'll second it. And before we take the vote, I just want to note that if you look at the height, a lot of people talk about stories. We're actually talking about less height than what the adjacent properties have

1179
06:04:40.320 --> 06:04:57.360
both on the east and west side. So before my colleague left distorts the facts, that is the basis for my moving this forward. >> We have a motion, a second. >> Vice Mayor Anderson,

1180
06:04:57.360 --> 06:05:13.280
>> yes. >> Commissioner Castro, >> no. >> Commissioner Fernandez, >> no. >> Commissioner Lada. >> So my vote is in furtherance of the clear will of the people who live in that area. So my votes a yes.

1181
06:05:13.280 --> 06:05:28.480
>> Mayor Lago, >> yes. E1 does not require a vote. Correct. >> Correct. That'll be coming back with this item on second reading. >> We will take a 45minut break for lunch. Commissioners uh and mayor, we appreciate your support. We have a list of items that we'll be back. Uh this is

1182
06:05:28.480 --> 06:05:44.798
a project that obviously I'm very passionate about, but we um it's an honor to be be working with Crystal and we appreciate your support and we'll see you on second reading. >> Thank you very much. >> Thank you. Um, just to mention, there are over 3,500

1183
06:05:44.798 --> 07:02:16.840
people who've spoken out against this project. The people who have been against this project are still against it. >> Thank you very much. >> Recording stopped. Recording in progress.

1184
07:02:23.840 --> 07:02:41.200
>> All right. And we're back. Let's Mr. Clerk, if we can, let's start with our F1, which was time ser for 2:00, but we'll take it now. >> F1 is a resolution of the city

1185
07:02:41.200 --> 07:02:57.200
commission authorizing the city to act as the official host and festival sponsor for the 2026 2027 Junior Orange Bowl festival season and authorizing the city's annual financial and inind contributions as determined by the city manager or his designate to the Junior Orange Bowl and providing for an effective date.

1186
07:02:57.200 --> 07:03:11.520
>> Uh, thank you for being here. I'm the sponsor of this item. I'm very proud to be a sponsor. Uh, thank you for joining us. Our friends from the Junior Orange Bowl. Take it away for yours. >> Thank you for having me. Good afternoon, Mayor Largo, Vice Mayor Anderson,

1187
07:03:11.520 --> 07:03:27.600
Commissioner Lara, Commissioner Castro, Commissioner Fernandez, and city staff. My name is Mimi Bum, and I have the privilege of serving as the executive director of the Junior Orange Bowl, a Coral Gables-based nonprofit. I'd like to begin by thanking the

1188
07:03:27.600 --> 07:03:43.360
commission, the city manager's office, our police and fire departments, and every city employee who helps make our events possible. Your continued partnerships allows us to empower our youth through sports, arts, academics,

1189
07:03:43.360 --> 07:03:59.760
and community programming. The resolution before you today represents much more than an annual sponsorship. It reflects a 78-year partnership between the city of Coral Gables and one of its longest standing youth organizations.

1190
07:03:59.760 --> 07:04:16.638
Together, we have created opportunities that have shaped generations of young people whilst showcasing Coral Gables to the world. Over the past two weeks, I had the privilege of attending two FIFA World Cup matches, Australia vers Paraguay and Australia vers Egypt. What

1191
07:04:16.638 --> 07:04:33.200
stayed with me wasn't the football. It was the passionate, united supporters. I looked around the stadium and saw thousands of people who on paper had very little in common. Different cultures, different languages, and different beliefs. Yet for 90 minutes,

1192
07:04:33.200 --> 07:04:49.360
they stood together, united by one game. Families stood shoulderto-shoulder. They celebrated together, comforted one another after heartbreak. And when the final whistle blew, rival supporters shook hands, shared stories, and walked

1193
07:04:49.360 --> 07:05:05.840
away with respect. When the match ended, the scoreboard told one story, but the stadium told another. Australia's World Cup journey was over, and Egypt had earned a moment of national pride. Yet, amid celebration, there was respect. Applause

1194
07:05:05.840 --> 07:05:22.958
for the Australian players, recognition of their fight, and a shared understanding that both teams had given everything. It was class recognizing class. And it reminded me that sport's greatest lesson is character, the humility to win graciously, the

1195
07:05:22.958 --> 07:05:38.798
resilience to lose with dignity, and the respect to honor those who stood across from you. In a world that often feels divided, sports creates common ground. It turns differences into conversations and strangers into teammates. In that

1196
07:05:38.798 --> 07:05:54.320
moment, I was re reminded that this is the very impact the Junior Orange Bowl has been making in Coral Gables for nearly 80 years. Every year, more than 7,500 people participate in Junior Orange Bowl programs, including athletes

1197
07:05:54.320 --> 07:06:12.000
from over 70 countries who travel here to compete on our courts, courses, and fields. They arrive carrying their flags with pride, and they leave with something even more valuable. friendships that cross borders, confidence in themselves, memories that

1198
07:06:12.000 --> 07:06:28.080
last a lifetime, and a greater understanding of people whose lives may look very different from their own. Over the past 78 years, those experiences have helped shape some of the world's most recognizable athletes, including Roger Federer, Coco Golf,

1199
07:06:28.080 --> 07:06:44.080
Tiger Woods, Andre Agassi, and Chris Everett. But our greatest legacy is not measured in trophies. It is measured by the thousands of young people who leave Coral Gables more confident, more resilient, and better prepared to make a

1200
07:06:44.080 --> 07:07:01.200
positive impact in their own communities. This partnership does more than inspire young people. It strengthens Coral Gables. Our International Tennis Championship alone brings more than 600 athletes and nearly 2,000 visitors to Coral Gables.

1201
07:07:01.200 --> 07:07:18.160
They stay in our hotels, dine in our restaurants, shop in our local businesses, and over the years have generated millions of dollars in economic activity whilst experiencing everything that our city has to offer. Through international media, live

1202
07:07:18.160 --> 07:07:34.000
streams, and social media, Carl Gables is showcased to families around the world as a community that welcomes the world and invests in young people. That is the necessity of this partnership. It empowers our youth, strengthens our

1203
07:07:34.000 --> 07:07:50.000
local economy, and reinforces Coral Gable's reputation as a community committed to the next generation. Because when we invest in young people, we are not simply funding events. We are creating future leaders, teachers,

1204
07:07:50.000 --> 07:08:06.400
entrepreneurs, parents, and citizens. That is a return on investment that simply cannot be measured in dollars. So on behalf of our board, our volunteers, and the thousands of young people whose lives are touched by the Junior Orange Bowl each year, thank you

1205
07:08:06.400 --> 07:08:22.080
for your continued partnership and commitment to preserving one of Coral Gable's greatest legacies while investing in the next generation. Thank you. >> No, thank you. Do my colleagues have anything they'd like to add? Is there any public comment?

1206
07:08:22.080 --> 07:08:54.478
>> Yes, Mr. Mayor. Are we cruise? Good afternoon. This is Maria Cruz, 1447 Miller Road, 305 323 2154. This is I guess because of my proximity to

1207
07:08:54.478 --> 07:09:11.200
living to the university and that area. I have been uh very lucky to meet some of the people involved and I'm going to tell you if there's one program that we do that we sponsor that

1208
07:09:11.200 --> 07:09:27.120
we support in the city of Carl Gables that makes us look very very good is this one. So I really really support and I think we should be doing for them what we've done all along for what over 40

1209
07:09:27.120 --> 07:09:41.840
years or so. >> Thank you. >> That's it. Mr. Mayor, >> perfect madam vice mayor. >> Um just quick summary. I'm very proud to help for our city to help support the

1210
07:09:41.840 --> 07:09:58.400
Orange Junior Orange Bowl and um Miss Bon has done an excellent job during her leadership on on this role. So I'm a yes vote on this. >> Anything else >> through the mayor? >> Yes, sir. So um what can be said about

1211
07:09:58.400 --> 07:10:13.680
the Junior Orange Bowl that hasn't already been said and welldeserved other than to say I want to direct my comments to you uh Mimi Balum um as our or the executive director I want to thank you on behalf of myself my colleagues on the

1212
07:10:13.680 --> 07:10:29.440
dis and the city for your tireless leadership your vision and your dedication to this worthwhile and um longstanding organization. Thank you. Your force and uh we're very very very lucky to have you at the home. Thank

1213
07:10:29.440 --> 07:10:44.798
you. >> Through the mayor. >> Yes. Um it is my understanding after speaking to the city attorney and to the city manager that really what this legislation is doing is cutting the three-year contract to a one-year

1214
07:10:44.798 --> 07:11:02.240
contract. This has been a tradition since 1948. And I think Coral Gables prides itself on history and tradition. I think right now with what's happening in Tallahassee, we are in a difficult

1215
07:11:02.240 --> 07:11:19.200
predicament and I understand why this is coming through. But I also understand that we do need to preserve this that this is important that this is a tradition and instead of um cutting the contract to one year, I think what we should be doing is

1216
07:11:19.200 --> 07:11:34.718
negotiating as it is right now. Our cash trunk our cash contribution per year is $33,250 for this organization and for this parade. Our inind is $25,000

1217
07:11:34.718 --> 07:11:51.360
in kind contributions. What we should be doing is renewing the three-year contract and negotiating those terms, not cutting the contract to one year. My vote for this would be no.

1218
07:11:51.840 --> 07:12:06.958
As the sponsor of the item, I fully support what the executive director in the Orange Bowl is doing. Amazing work, especially under your leadership. Let me tell you why my colleague is not aware of speaks without knowing. Um,

1219
07:12:06.958 --> 07:12:23.840
everyone across the board, every city is slashing contracts in preparation to the massive, massive tax implications that are forthcoming. If in 2028 the referendum that is set forth by the state legislature passes, this is just

1220
07:12:23.840 --> 07:12:40.400
making us more agile and more nimble. I vote I will continue to support this organization, especially with the executive director at the helm because like Commissioner Lada and the vice mayor said, you have taken this to new heights. Um it's the event continues to

1221
07:12:40.400 --> 07:12:56.160
grow and it's a positive mark in our city and I will continue to support this organization. But like I'm doing across the board with all our contracts, I want to make sure that they're in the best interest of the city as a whole. And you can count on me on going on a

1222
07:12:56.160 --> 07:13:11.680
year-to-year basis uh to ensure that we're as nimble as possible, that we support your organization, but we don't know what's going to happen in a year and a half in regards to uh our tax base. So, I want to be very, very careful and make sure that promises that

1223
07:13:11.680 --> 07:13:28.638
we make, we can keep those promises because don't forget some of us on this commission voted for a cola that puts a city back $2 million a year. Thank God I didn't vote for that because that is going to hurt the city for the next 10 years. So, if you want to concentrate on

1224
07:13:28.638 --> 07:13:43.440
contracts, that's a contract that we can't break, right, Mr. Manager? That's a $20 million contract over the next 10 years for not our current employees for past employees that are receiving a pension and are also receiving social security. So moving forward, you have my

1225
07:13:43.440 --> 07:14:00.478
wholehearted support. Any way that I can help you, you can count on me. But at the end of the day, I want to make sure and you know that we are as nimble as possible moving forward because there's a litany a litany of requirements here in the city. Case in point, our

1226
07:14:00.478 --> 07:14:15.520
insurance costs, our health insurance costs went up double digits this year. And uh I have to make sure that I can pay for my my employee healthcare. Uh and and a litany of other things that continue to go up that we're addressing here. So that has nothing to do with the Orange Bowl. We're supporting the Orange

1227
07:14:15.520 --> 07:14:31.280
Bowl. We're grateful for the Orange Bowl and I look forward uh to this year's festivities. May I have a motion? >> I'll move it and I'll second. Mr. clerk. >> Commissioner Castro >> for the reasons that we're actually slashing the three-year contract and

1228
07:14:31.280 --> 07:14:47.040
only approving one. My vote is no. >> Commissioner Fernandez. >> Yes. >> Commissioner Lada. >> Right. I I guess you can look at it in a strained way using a weird set of filtered glasses. Um I choose to see it

1229
07:14:47.040 --> 07:15:02.478
as we're once again supporting you, the Junior Orange Bowl, and its leadership for one more year. and I look forward to one year from now seeing you as well up there, accepting another year from us. So, I choose to see things a little bit

1230
07:15:02.478 --> 07:15:20.958
more positively. So, I'm an enthusiastic yes. >> Vice Mayor Anderson? >> Absolutely. Yes. >> Mayor Lago. And just like we support, like you saw a few moments ago, the grants that we supported for dozens of wonderful

1231
07:15:20.958 --> 07:15:37.840
organizations, every single year, they go up before the board. They present before the board. They tell us what they want to do, and we grant them the opportunity to win scholarships and win these grants. Uh that happens every single year. It's not a two to three

1232
07:15:37.840 --> 07:15:55.440
year basis. you can count on me. If you perform like you performed last year, which was amazing, I can only expect it's going to only get better, especially with you at the helm. I have full faith and confidence. I'm looking forward to many more years of the Orange Bowl. So, thank you very much. And my vote is a yes. Thank you.

1233
07:15:55.440 --> 07:16:19.040
Moving on to item time certain at 2:30 p.m., which is agenda item F12. I'd like to uh call Laura from my office to come up here. She doesn't want to come up here, but I'm going to ask her to please come up here. And

1234
07:16:19.040 --> 07:16:35.920
again, this is something important in our office and that I hope that all of you enjoy this opportunity. Um and and it's something that I want Laura to talk talk a little bit about. Uh I started this program a few years ago and and the program is basically to highlight and

1235
07:16:35.920 --> 07:16:52.478
give opportunities to students who have an interest in government. We want people to think about working in government, not only running for office, but being tomorrow's ACM, DCM, city manager, director, public works director, you know, being in the accounting and finance department. And

1236
07:16:52.478 --> 07:17:08.958
this is an opportunity that hopefully uh gives these young men and women the opportunity to immerse themselves here in the city of Coral Gables and get an idea of what it is to work at the city manager's office, to work at the city attorney's office, at the city clerk's office. These opportunities, we're one of the few cities that do this at this

1237
07:17:08.958 --> 07:17:26.080
level with these many pages. And I take a lot of pride uh in this legislation and this programming that we've been doing it for such a long time. And all the credit goes to the directors, my city managers who have done an amazing job, who have been incredibly proactive taking them to sites, doing

1238
07:17:26.080 --> 07:17:43.360
site visits, and to Laura who has, you know, taking this program in her first year in my office and has done an amazing job. Just to give you an idea, one of the perks is, for example, the clerk bought him lunch today, and I want to thank the clerk for that. Another

1239
07:17:43.360 --> 07:17:59.200
thing that we've done in our office was I bought them all books, the AR arvore parks books from George America and they'll take that home and they'll read about that. That's part of their that's part of their homework while they're here in the city of Coral Gables for a few weeks. But at the end of the day, they're left

1240
07:17:59.200 --> 07:18:15.280
with a lasting imprint of what it is the city of Coral Gables and many of them are residents. So, it's a priceless opportunity that hopefully will pay dividends in the near future. So, Laura, will you take it away, please? >> I didn't prepare anything. I know you did. That was the whole point and I'm happy that you didn't prepare.

1241
07:18:15.280 --> 07:18:31.520
>> My first time at the podium and I have nothing to say. >> Well, what's your name? >> Oh, Laura Lstra. >> Where do you live? >> Uh 1537 Sarraosa Avenue. >> Oh, you're a resident. I am. >> Oh my god, that's amazing. That's amazing. >> I guess nobody nobody likes my jokes, but it's fine. It's okay. Take it away.

1242
07:18:31.520 --> 07:18:46.558
The show's yours. >> Um well, thank you for allowing us to have this program. Um the kids are well prepared and they have presentations ready. So, they've done a great job. Okay. Well, first we'll start with Dominic and

1243
07:18:46.558 --> 07:19:17.120
Isa. Issa. Um, so we would like to thank the committee and the mayor for having us here and giving us the opportunity to be pages. So today we have pre prepared an overview on public records and the seven

1244
07:19:17.120 --> 07:19:33.440
new exemptions that have recently been added to the sunshine law. Uh, my name is Dominic Silva and I'm a rising junior at Ben. My name is Seville and I am a rising junior at Coral Gable Senior High School.

1245
07:19:33.440 --> 07:19:52.878
Hi. >> Like Dominic said, we have prepared a presentation of public records and the seven new exemptions that have been recently added to the sunshine law. But what exactly is the sunshine law? Well, as one can see, it allows citizens

1246
07:19:52.878 --> 07:20:11.680
to access the governmental proceedings of boards or commissions at the state and local levels. The law is made up of three basic requirements which are listed in the next slide. The sunshine law first mandates that the

1247
07:20:11.680 --> 07:20:28.718
meeting of public boards or commissions such as this one must be open to the public. Hence why our attentive audience is able to attend our meetings today. Now the second requirement establishes that reasonable notice of these meetings

1248
07:20:28.718 --> 07:20:45.520
must be given which goes handinhand with the third requirement as it states that said meetings must be timed. >> So exemptions depend on the field of employment that somebody's involved in.

1249
07:20:45.520 --> 07:21:00.558
But according to section 119, chapter 71 of the Florida statutes, the following information in the next slide is confidential and exempt from being shared. Six of the most common exemptions to the Sunshine Law are social security

1250
07:21:00.558 --> 07:21:18.638
numbers, bank information, medical records, home address, cell phone and cell phone information of certain individuals, and a security and/or fire safety plan. Now we will be explaining the seven new

1251
07:21:18.638 --> 07:21:37.040
exemptions that we mentioned earlier. They are listed in the slide with the first one being the Senate bill um 1716 which has to do with small business loan data. It creates a permanent public

1252
07:21:37.040 --> 07:21:52.400
records exemption for specific information related to how an economic development agency administer small business loan programs. House Bill 655 provides an exemption to

1253
07:21:52.400 --> 07:22:08.478
meetings between agencies and their attorneys about certain private property rights claims from public meetings. requirements specifying discussion scope, requiring transcription, and making transcripts public records at set

1254
07:22:08.478 --> 07:22:23.840
times. It also exempts related transcripts, recordings, minutes, and records from public records requirements. Subject to it's also subject to future legislative review and repeal.

1255
07:22:23.840 --> 07:22:42.400
Senate Bill 506 exempts body camera recordings made by code inspectors from public records requirements under circum certain circumstances with with exceptions retroactive application and a set retention period.

1256
07:22:42.400 --> 07:22:56.320
It directs the division of library and information services to set a retention schedule for these recordings and it is also subject to future legislative review and repeal.

1257
07:22:56.320 --> 07:23:13.440
Now I will talk about Senate Bill 1724 which has to do with cyber security and technological infrastructure. Because of the increased usage of technology in in today's society, it is crucial that online data remains

1258
07:23:13.440 --> 07:23:29.280
protected, which is exactly why this bill has been established. It restricts access to public records and shields public meetings that reveal information regarding an agency cyber security,

1259
07:23:29.280 --> 07:23:49.200
information technology, IT, and operational technology OT setups. Next up, we have Senate Bill 7000, which is related to emergency shelter contact information. This bill permanently protects the home

1260
07:23:49.200 --> 07:24:04.320
addresses and telephone numbers of individuals who use public emergency shelters, preventing this data from being disclosed through public records requests. House Bill 1,113

1261
07:24:04.320 --> 07:24:19.920
expands the public records exemption for crime victims to cover their name, ID number, and any other identifying information, plus similar protections for a victim's family members or representatives. It also makes a law law

1262
07:24:19.920 --> 07:24:39.600
enforcement officer's identity confidential and exempt for 72 hours when when when they're a crime victim under specified circumstances. Senate Bill 726 states that the bill permanently exempts trade secrets and

1263
07:24:39.600 --> 07:24:57.440
proprietary business information held by state agencies from public disclosure and update states laws to make those protections consistent. As our presentation is wrapping up, it is extremely worth mentioning what the

1264
07:24:57.440 --> 07:25:14.320
sunshine law has done for us in our community as it has made transparency between communities and their governing bodies possible as it rightfully allows citizens to openly attend commission meetings and access a wide variety of records whenever they desire, obviously

1265
07:25:14.320 --> 07:25:33.440
with a few exceptions. Before we officially wrap up, we would like to thank the city commission for giving us the opportunity to participate in this program. But most importantly, we would like to thank the amazing people in the city attorney's office for

1266
07:25:33.440 --> 07:25:57.440
welcoming us and guiding us for the past three weeks. Christina, you're amazing. Thank you. Thank you. All right, our next team is >> through the mayor if I can real quick. >> We had a lot of presentations so you know. >> Oh, but real quick, Dominic and

1267
07:25:57.440 --> 07:26:16.558
Isabella, you guys did an amazing job. Isabella, I want to say that you really knocked it out of the park and you're making Coral Gables senior high school very, very proud. >> He's biased. He went there. So at the end of the day, now we have Cecile Slesnik. I think everyone knows that last name. And

1268
07:26:16.558 --> 07:26:40.558
Camila Esiero regarding the city manager's office. Ladies, please join us. The floor is yours. Good afternoon, mayor, vice mayor, and commissioners. We are interns with the city manager's office, and we thank you

1269
07:26:40.558 --> 07:26:55.440
for giving us the opportunity to present for you today. Today, we'd like to give you a closer look into ways to engage our community with the city of Coral Gable's upcoming project, the mobility hub. My name is Camila Saniso and I'm a rising junior at St. Barton High School. And my name is Cecilia Slesdic, and I'm

1270
07:26:55.440 --> 07:27:10.320
a rising sophomore at Coral Gable Senior High School. To start, we'd like to introduce the goals of the mobility hub. The mobility hub serves to replace the current parking garage behind the Miracle Theater, but the goal is to make it more than just a parking garage,

1271
07:27:10.320 --> 07:27:27.440
emphasizing modernity and opportunity in its design. The building will include space for businesses on the ground floor as well as restaurant space on the top floor, both of which will serve to elevate the property beyond its initial value. It is a massive undertaking for the

1272
07:27:27.440 --> 07:27:43.120
city, compromising a two-year long effort to build this new facility. But the potential that it holds as a center of entertainment, dining, and convenience makes it essential to promote this development to the community. With this in mind, we'd like to provide

1273
07:27:43.120 --> 07:27:58.718
our suggestions for how to increase community interest in the mobility hub, as well as collect feedback from the city's residents on the construction. Firstly, giving citizens access to the design renders of the mobility hub would allow them a first look at what exact changes will be coming to their community. By posting the design

1274
07:27:58.718 --> 07:28:14.320
renderings of the hub on the city website, citizens can view the plans for the change as well as see the tangible benefits this construction could offer for their community. On our first week interning with the city manager's office, we attended a meeting with the contractors from the mobility hub, members of the city, and local business

1275
07:28:14.320 --> 07:28:31.040
owners. The intent of the meeting was to showcase the mobility hub to the business owners who would be affected by the construction of the of the facility and our attention was immediately drawn to the design renders that have been placed at the front of the meeting room. Giving the public access to these renders could help residents gain a clearer idea of the vision for this

1276
07:28:31.040 --> 07:28:48.398
facility. Meanwhile, showcasing new partnerships with businesses will draw people into the mobility hub, bringing essential business and activity into the area. The retail that the mobility hub can offer are one of the more unique opportunities that the city of Coral Gables can capitalize on to boost um community engagement. As seen with new

1277
07:28:48.398 --> 07:29:03.120
restaurants in Coral Gable, such as Buchanan or Stand, when people are informed about new and upcoming business, it causes an influx of new customers into that area. Applying this principle to the mobility hub could help draw in residents who are more reluctant to utilize it or even newcomers from neighboring cities such as the city of

1278
07:29:03.120 --> 07:29:18.638
Miami or city of Miami Beach. Once the public has a better idea of how the mobility hub will operate, consistent updates as to how the project is moving along will serve to demonstrate the progress of this construction. For the average residents, two years can feel like an extensive amount of time to wait to see progress

1279
07:29:18.638 --> 07:29:34.798
in their community. As such, frequent updates can help feel residents help residents feel more excited about what is to come and demonstrate the work the city is putting into this facility. These updates could be centralized in the city's newsletter, a platform that already has a large audience of invested readers. Furthermore, the city of Coral

1280
07:29:34.798 --> 07:29:49.760
Gables has a number of active social media accounts through which these updates could be posted. I'm sure many of you know as you see Maril Logos post on Instagram quite often. Social media is a particularly unique platform to engage citizens because it not only allows for people to learn about the mobility hub but also for people to

1281
07:29:49.760 --> 07:30:06.558
engage feedback on construction. With this in mind, we'd like to transition into how we can get feedback from citizens starting with social media. As we have discussed, social media is unique in that citizens can engage with the construct with the construction of the mobility hub while also providing

1282
07:30:06.558 --> 07:30:23.200
their feedback on the project. For example, making a series on the city Instagram with monthly updates on the construction could provide residents with a quick and easy way to see the progress of the mobility hub. Instagram allows for interactive engagement with posts like these through their comment

1283
07:30:23.200 --> 07:30:40.080
sections, which can serve as a very accessible way for residents to share their thoughts about the project. This could be especially useful for early stages of the project because of the number of commenters could be used to gouge the public's interest as time goes by and as the mobility hub progresses

1284
07:30:40.080 --> 07:30:56.958
further. Furthermore, Coral Gables is known for its community events from the farmers market to the literary festival which attract interested members of the city. The city of Coral Gables is often present at these events with booths filled with memorabilia and information.

1285
07:30:56.958 --> 07:31:12.240
These stands already provide so much visibility for the city. So using it to present the mobility hub and ask for feedback in the moment will serve to inform people about the project while gaining genuine points of contention for residents.

1286
07:31:12.240 --> 07:31:27.280
Meanwhile, having online surveys will give a chance for people to show how they feel about the project and leave feedback for the city. Knowing how the citizens and or business owners are feeling about the construction can be very very beneficial

1287
07:31:27.280 --> 07:31:43.120
at the affforementioned in-person events. Links to such surveys could also be provided in order to grow the amount of feedback that is available. In the end, we feel that these suggestions would greatly improve how the community views this project and keep them excited

1288
07:31:43.120 --> 07:31:59.440
for the new steps. Now, we'd like to discuss the impact of our time with the city manager's office, and we found that this department had three central focuses: adaptability, leadership, and accountability. Firstly, the city manager's office has one of the most varied roles in the city of Cro

1289
07:31:59.440 --> 07:32:14.718
Gables. The city's manager's office manages every city department from the police department to city development to historical preservation. No two days were the same here, and it's clear that being able to adapt to each new challenge is essential for the job. With the city manager's role in overseeing

1290
07:32:14.718 --> 07:32:30.320
every department, leadership is fundamental to how this office operates. In our days shadowing the members of the city manager's office, we have seen this in action implementing new policies and managing the daily operations of each department.

1291
07:32:30.320 --> 07:32:46.798
And finally, accountability is a major aspect in the city manager's role. The time that the city puts into building personal relationships with business owners, residents, and city staff that they communicate with is crucial to keep things running smoothly. Not everything will go perfectly all the time. And maintaining honesty with the people that

1292
07:32:46.798 --> 07:33:03.040
they work with on a daily basis makes it easier to navigate challenges with grace and optimism. All in all, during our time in the office, we had the opportunity to shadow many people throughout the office and learn about not just what the city manager does, but lots of other city officials as well.

1293
07:33:03.040 --> 07:33:18.638
From going to city meetings for the mobility hub to touring historic facilities, we got a full picture into Coral Gable's government and all the aspects that go into managing su such a successful and beautiful city. Thank you so much for the city manager's office to guide us through this incredible

1294
07:33:18.638 --> 07:33:41.520
opportunity. >> Congratulations ladies. Well done. Amazing, amazing presentation. I hope I hope this experience was as worthwhile for you that as it was for me. >> Very insightful. >> I'm so happy you guys are here. >> Thank you. >> And I'm happy that your grandfather, Mayor Slesnik, was able to catch catch

1295
07:33:41.520 --> 07:33:58.080
your presentation. I can see uh I can see where the where the leadership runs. >> Good to see you. >> So much. >> Thank you, ladies. Now, next up is Audrey Prahabakar and Jaden Lee. So, I'm I'm familiar with uh Mr. Jaden Lee. And if you're keeping tabs over the

1296
07:33:58.080 --> 07:34:15.040
years, this is the second time that we have Mr. Lee here. >> Yeah. >> So, obviously, we're doing something right. If he's coming back for a second bite of the apple, >> the floor is yours. >> Good afternoon, Mayor Loggo, Vice Mayor Anderson, commissioners, city clerk,

1297
07:34:15.040 --> 07:34:31.200
city attorney, and city manager. I would like to thank you all for the guidance and opportunities throughout these past few weeks. It's been an honor serving the city beautiful. My name is Jaden Lee, a senior at Gulver Preparatory School. >> My name is Audrey Pbacher and I am a

1298
07:34:31.200 --> 07:34:46.558
rising senior at Carolton School of the Sacred Heart. >> We're the clerk's office summer interns and we're here to present our project we completed this summer. A project we believe will save staff time, strengthen the city's official record, and

1299
07:34:46.558 --> 07:35:03.000
modernize the production of minutes for all 37 of the city's boards and committees. >> Over the past few weeks, we identified a real operational problem in the clerk's office. And then we built the solution.

1300
07:35:03.360 --> 07:35:21.360
>> Thought you were perfect. >> Of course, real quick. Okay, so here's what we found when we got there. The city clerk's office keeps the official record for 37 different boards and committees, 37 different

1301
07:35:21.360 --> 07:35:39.040
layons, 37 meeting cycles, and as we discovered working alongside staff, essentially 37 different ways of writing minutes. That inconsistency has real costs. Deputy clerks were spending hours reformatting and correcting drafts

1302
07:35:39.040 --> 07:35:54.638
before anything could be finalized. Public record requests took longer because a motion or a vote might live in a completely different place in every document. And when a new board liaison came on, there was no clear playbook to

1303
07:35:54.638 --> 07:36:11.200
hand them. We saw this not as a paperwork problem, but as a records integrity problem and one that was fixable with a sing with a single summer. So, we fixed it. >> Confidence fixed it. >> I love

1304
07:36:11.200 --> 07:36:26.638
>> So, our first deliverable is complete and ready for citywide use today. A single standardized minutes template for every board and committee paired with plain language step-by-step instructions that any liaison can follow even on

1305
07:36:26.638 --> 07:36:42.320
their first day. And this does a lot for the city. The drafts will arrive meeting ready. And this limits the amount of editing required by the deputy clerk. Also, motions and votes now sit in the same place for every document, which

1306
07:36:42.320 --> 07:36:59.200
means cleaner responses to public record requests. Third, and this is something we'd argue is most important, a consistent format strengthens a city compliant posture under Florida sunshine and public records laws. A uniform official record

1307
07:36:59.200 --> 07:37:15.840
is a defensible official record. And fourth, the instruction series doubles as an onboarding tool. Every future liaison inherits a repeatable process instead of a blank page. So our project looks forward towards the

1308
07:37:15.840 --> 07:37:32.000
future. The template standardizes the format of all minutes. Our proposed app which we will call shortcut transforms how the first draft gets written at all. The process is simple. The board liaison records the meeting exactly as they do

1309
07:37:32.000 --> 07:37:47.120
today. Right after adjournment, the recording is uploaded into the app. The app generates a full transcript and then drafts the minutes automatically on the standardized template we just showed you. Staff review and correct that draft

1310
07:37:47.120 --> 07:38:03.680
and only then does it go to the commission for approval. We want to be very clear about one thing, one design principle because we built it very deliberately. People stay in charge. The clerk's office staff review every generated draft before anything reaches

1311
07:38:03.680 --> 07:38:20.240
the dis. The app accelerates the first draft. It does not replace the professional judgment that exists today. And it does not touch final approval. What this means in practice, the slowest, most repetitive part of the minutes production, listening back and

1312
07:38:20.240 --> 07:38:38.080
typing up that first draft gets compressed from hours to mere minutes while the official record stays fully under human control. So, you may be wondering what's next. Step one, adopt the templates citywide.

1313
07:38:38.080 --> 07:38:54.798
The instructions and templates are finished and can roll out to every board liaison by the end of the summer. Step two, pilot the app with a single board. Test transcription and draft generation on one committee's meetings, for example, maybe the board of architects

1314
07:38:54.798 --> 07:39:11.840
before expanding. This is low risk and provides real data. Step three, we're going to measure it. Track staff hours per set of minutes before and after the implementation of the app and report the results back to the clerk. If this works the way we

1315
07:39:11.840 --> 07:39:28.558
believe it will, the numbers will make the case for us. And before we close, we want to thank the city clerk Billy Rukia, the deputy clerk, Yoli Davis, and agenda coordinator, Emily Sanores, who mentored us throughout the summer, and who trusted two interns with the ideas

1316
07:39:28.558 --> 07:39:45.680
that touched the city's official record. That trust is why we were able to deliver finished work, a real product, not just suggestions. We came in as interns. We're leaving having built something the city can use on Monday morning. Thank you to everyone who made

1317
07:39:45.680 --> 07:40:04.638
these past two weeks a wonderful experience and showed us what makes Coral Gables the city beautiful. >> Thank you. >> So, >> Mr. Lee, first and foremost, you look very professional. >> Thank you. >> Very well put together. So do you, young

1318
07:40:04.638 --> 07:40:22.878
lady. Um my question to you is to both of you especially to you between your first and second year what is the difference? >> So the biggest difference for me um I started off working on your reelection campaign. So now I actually understand

1319
07:40:22.878 --> 07:40:40.000
the inner process of what makes our city the city beautiful. So, it's made me understand and appreciate the process that goes behind the scenes and it's been a wonderful experience for me. >> Young lady, what is your what is your opinion of being after being involved in

1320
07:40:40.000 --> 07:40:54.798
this program? >> Well, for personally, I think my favorite part was attending the pre-aggenda meeting and just seeing I mean, I've lived in Corables my whole life, but I've never really understood the inner workings of government. So being able to be in the same room as

1321
07:40:54.798 --> 07:41:10.478
Commissioner Castro, Commissioner Lara, and seeing how they asked questions, how they made sure that everything in the agenda was properly there for a reason. I think that was the most important part for me to see that the amount of um yeah, the amount of effort that is

1322
07:41:10.478 --> 07:41:25.120
placed in to make sure every single thing is thought out thoroughly. >> Thank you for joining us. Congratulations. Thank you so much. >> Are they going to be consulting for the uh >> UK? We'll figure it out. We We'll do a

1323
07:41:25.120 --> 07:41:50.240
one-year contract. We'll figure it out. Uh great work. Daniela Oorio and Martina Hoyos, Office of the Mayor. Ladies, show them what you got. Good afternoon, mayor, vice mayor, and

1324
07:41:50.240 --> 07:42:06.798
commissioners. Thank you for giving us the opportunity to present in this meeting. My name is Danielo. I go to ISPA. I'm a rising senior. And my name is Martina Oios and I go to Immaculata Lasal and I'm also a rising senior and we are interning in the mayor's office. And today we're going to be presenting

1325
07:42:06.798 --> 07:42:22.000
our project on Miracle Mile and downtown Coral Gables. Our goal was to better understand why many young people choose places like Cocoa Walk over Miracle Mile and what opportunities exist to attract more visitors while continuing to support local businesses.

1326
07:42:22.000 --> 07:42:39.360
And our main research question was, why do many young people choose destinations like Cocoa Walk over Miracle Mile? And what opportunities exist to increase engagement while supporting local businesses? And rather than just relying on assumptions, we actually did research

1327
07:42:39.360 --> 07:42:55.280
to answer our question. This topic matters because today's young people are tomorrow's residents, customers, and business owners. A vibrant downtown benefits local businesses, strengthens the local economy, and understanding youth preferences today can help guide future

1328
07:42:55.280 --> 07:43:13.120
planning decisions. So, we actually had three different research methods. So, the first one, we conducted a youth survey of high school students between the ages of 16 and 17, and we asked them where they like to spend their time and why. And we visited Coco Walk and

1329
07:43:13.120 --> 07:43:27.840
Miracle Mile on Saturday afternoon at 5:30 to see the differences and the similarities. And we actually interviewed with the Coral Gables economic development team and we asked them what challenges Miracle Mile and

1330
07:43:27.840 --> 07:43:47.120
Coral Gables face. So from the youth survey results, when we asked these students what came to mind when thinking about Coconut Grove, they used words like fun, beautiful streets, and good restaurants. Whereas for Miracle Mile, most of them responded

1331
07:43:47.120 --> 07:44:03.440
that they rarely go there or that they simply didn't know much about it. And this kind of just suggests that Miracle Mile has a lower visibility among many young people. We also asked what factors matter most when choosing where to spend their time. The top responses were atmosphere and

1332
07:44:03.440 --> 07:44:19.280
good food. Shopping and nightlife were less important than simply enjoying the overall environment. And when asked which area they visit most often, Coconut Grove was by far the most popular destination. Our survey suggested that the atmosphere plays an important role in attracting

1333
07:44:19.280 --> 07:44:36.398
young people. And to see whether that matched reality, we visited both locations ourselves. So these are the pictures we took on from Miracle Mile on that Saturday at around 5:30. And we noticed fewer foot traffic. It was generally like an older crowd and there

1334
07:44:36.398 --> 07:44:52.478
were many stores appeared vacant and overall the area just felt quieter than we expected for a weekend afternoon. And these are photos from Coconut Grove at approximately the same time. Um the contrast was that we observed many more

1335
07:44:52.478 --> 07:45:08.878
young people groups sitting together, busy sidewalks and public spaces where people stayed even without actively shopping. the atmosphere effect felt much more active and social which closely matched our survey findings. And next, we interviewed the city's

1336
07:45:08.878 --> 07:45:24.080
economic development team and they explained that retail has become increasingly challenging and that many of the office workers actually leave downtown after business hours. The city's goal is to create more reasons for people to stay longer through events

1337
07:45:24.080 --> 07:45:41.040
through events, business support, retail recruitment, and increasing the residential population. So what we learned, one thing that surprised us was that many of the storefronts that appeared vacant aren't actually vacant and only 6% are true vacancies. And many of those wrap

1338
07:45:41.040 --> 07:45:57.280
storefronts are actually leased and the businesses are preparing to open them. And this helped us realize that the challenge isn't just filling empty stores, but it's encouraging people to stay longer once they arrive. During our visit to Coconut Grove, we noticed many

1339
07:45:57.280 --> 07:46:13.680
interactive public spaces with places to sit, open gathering spaces, playgrounds, temporary installations, and comfortable public seating. People weren't only shopping, they were spending time together. These spaces encouraged visitors to remain in the area longer. And these pictures also show the park

1340
07:46:13.680 --> 07:46:30.558
that Coconut Grove has where people can socialize and have fun. And we know that there is a new park coming soon thanks to our mayor next to Miracle Mile within the Publix that they're gonna like tear down. And our idea is that we think an

1341
07:46:30.558 --> 07:46:46.398
interactive popup would attract youth in addition to just maybe the workers that will come to the park on their lunch breaks or an older crowd. Well, our goal isn't to create a replica with soccer or a playground, but it's to create a space that can be equally as interactive and

1342
07:46:46.398 --> 07:47:03.280
inclusive. Based on everything we learned, we developed recommendations. Our short-term recommendations are more free seating um for games like pingpong, foosball, pool, and weekend programming. And our medium-term

1343
07:47:03.280 --> 07:47:19.840
medium-term recommendations are um interactive public spaces that can be implemented with youth activities and pop-up events that can encourage local and tourists and also the long-term measures which are residential growth,

1344
07:47:19.840 --> 07:47:35.680
diverse retail, and the preservation of Miracle Miles historic identity. Our recommendations are supported by what we call third places, best described as public spaces where people can gather outside of home or work. Research shows they reduce loneliness, strengthen

1345
07:47:35.680 --> 07:47:50.718
communities, help friendships develop naturally, and even improve physical and mental health. And studies have also found that even small daily interactions can increase happiness and a stronger sense of belonging. And as these spaces have become less common today,

1346
07:47:50.718 --> 07:48:07.680
loneliness has increased, making them more valuable. These spaces also create something called commercial spillover which happens when people have comfortable places where they can spend time without feeling to pressure feeling pressured to buy something. They usually stay longer

1347
07:48:07.680 --> 07:48:24.320
in return. The longer people remain in an area, the more likely they are to explore nearby businesses and eventually purchase a coffee, snack, meal, or other product. In other words, creating places to gather can also support local commerce. And our research led us to

1348
07:48:24.320 --> 07:48:41.440
four main conclusion. The first one is that atmosphere is the biggest factor influencing where younger people tend to spend their time. And the second is that Miracle Mile already has strong foundations but needs more reasons for visitors to stay longer. Our third

1349
07:48:41.440 --> 07:48:58.398
conclusion is that public gathering spaces can benefit both the community and surrounding businesses. And finally, that investing in youth engagement today can help strengthen downtown and Coral Gables for years to come. Our goal isn't for Miracle Mile to become Coconut

1350
07:48:58.398 --> 07:49:16.280
Grove. It's simply for Miracle Mile to become the best V version of itself and reach its fullest potential. >> And thank you for giving us the opportunity to be interns and have this learn so much and try to help the city.

1351
07:49:20.398 --> 07:49:35.920
So I want to commend both of you because for the simple reason you could have taken a much easier task. You took one of the most difficult tasks I could possibly think when Laura told me what you were going to embark on. It's going to be very difficult to uh kind of establish those metrics so you can

1352
07:49:35.920 --> 07:49:51.680
deliver on a presentation. But I think you did an amazing job. Uh and this is incredibly important to us and I think that sense of place is coming to the city. We're going to have five to six new green spaces already in the downtown. I think that's going to be a gamecher, significant game changer for

1353
07:49:51.680 --> 07:50:07.520
us in the near future, probably in the next two years. Those those uh open spaces are delivered and I think you're going to see that transformation and I think it's only going to get better as as the city continues to grow in a very positive way, especially our downtown. So, I want to thank you both for engaging with the city, especially the

1354
07:50:07.520 --> 07:50:24.478
mayor's office. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. Uh, Yasim Align from the office of the mayor's. Sir, >> good morning everyone. I'd like to thank Mr. Mayor uh Miss Lara of course for

1355
07:50:24.478 --> 07:50:40.798
helping me uh complete this project. Uh good morning and um I'm ready to present. >> Perfect. So, here um I talked about the trash can because whenever I'm going downtown, you

1356
07:50:40.798 --> 07:50:55.760
can always see litter and I don't like litter because it makes the city very disgusting and I really really throw up sometimes when I see disgusting places. And the um the reason why I chose this

1357
07:50:55.760 --> 07:51:12.638
topic is because there's sorry uh there's like no reason why you should be doing litter. And I chose it the AI because it can help you take the trash and could pick

1358
07:51:12.638 --> 07:51:29.920
up trash, litter, anything. It can also um go to a recycle to throw the trash itself. And that's it. So the main uh reason why again I chose this was because of the smart

1359
07:51:29.920 --> 07:52:24.558
management. And if you could scroll down there should be more. >> Scroll down. >> I don't have the Can cable TV put it back Well, just very briefly, I I think that the concept and idea of of garbage

1360
07:52:24.558 --> 07:52:43.840
management and >> there is >> and additional Similar to that, um since the AI will be needing charging instead of using uh charging stations, it'll use solar charging

1361
07:52:43.840 --> 07:53:01.280
um like solar power tops to get energy. Um and it could also use USBC ports as well as um it could it could generate whether it's plastic, paper, or food

1362
07:53:01.280 --> 07:53:19.120
wraps. and opens the correct lid for you. >> All right, >> that's it. >> Yeah. >> All right. Well, first I want to congratulate you. Thank you uh for for embarking on this process over the summer. Um I think that this is something that again I'm very interested in also and so is the commission. Uh the

1363
07:53:19.120 --> 07:53:34.320
manager we've we've brought we brought forth a plan of action uh to address litter. Even though I think we're pretty clean in compared to other cities, we can always be better. Um the manager right now is working with an outside consultant that he is in the process of

1364
07:53:34.320 --> 07:53:50.160
I think signing a procurement agreement with where we're going to find ways to clean the sidewalks more efficiently. Instead of having each and every single vendor or business owner have to clean their own, you know, 50 feet, 30 feet,

1365
07:53:50.160 --> 07:54:05.920
25 ft, we're actually going to have a vendor go there and do all the streets at once. It's going to be more uniform. It's going to be more cost effective. uh and also the issue of addressing garbage and landscaping. What can we do to make sure that you know that we're we're

1366
07:54:05.920 --> 07:54:21.360
putting our best foot forward in an effort to attract, for example, like the two young ladies were saying before, how do we bring more young people? How do we bring more businesses? How do we bring more people to spend their hardearned money into the city? I think it all has to do with minimizing the amount of garbage, public safety, and just putting

1367
07:54:21.360 --> 07:54:41.440
our best foot forward so that we're inviting as possible. I want to commend you uh for being involved in the mayor's office. Thank you for joining us. >> Thank you. >> So now we have three projects, Evan Coulter and Jacob Finley which are going to be working on septic to sewer

1368
07:54:41.440 --> 07:55:00.558
benefits of living seaw walls and small businesses. >> Hey gentlemen, how are you? >> We're doing good. We appreciate the opportunity to be able to speak in front of all of you. And um just before we begin, I wanted to give a special thanks to the mayor, the vice mayor, and

1369
07:55:00.558 --> 07:55:17.200
commissioner Castro for taking the time to speak with us, sit down with us, and give us encouragement and guidance on how to do these projects. And also the incredible people that work at the commission's office. A huge thanks to them. This project would not have been able to be completed without them. So,

1370
07:55:17.200 --> 07:55:33.520
thank you guys. Uh, we have three projects. By the way, my name is Jacob Finley. I'm a rising senior and I go to True North Classical Academy. >> My name is Evan Coulter and I'm a rising senior at Ransom Everglades School. And we have three projects here today. And

1371
07:55:33.520 --> 07:55:48.478
the first one we'd like to present to you is about septic to sewer conversion. So, first things first, oh, liquor. I got it. First things first, we need to talk about the cost versus the environmental crisis that is taking

1372
07:55:48.478 --> 07:56:04.958
place. Why is converting from septic to sewer so important right now? And the big thing is, and the key is pollution. We have seen increased amounts of pollution polluting the Coral Gables waterway because of these septic tanks. This has led to massive amounts of

1373
07:56:04.958 --> 07:56:22.000
dangerous algae and dead fish as you can see up there. However, there is a high cost associated for the homeowner and the city when it comes to converting from septic to sewer. So, this isn't more of a short-term investment. This is a long-term investment that's good and beneficial for the community, for your

1374
07:56:22.000 --> 07:56:36.638
home, and for everyone and the people of Coral Gables. So, let's talk about the right now. It is good for the environment and it is also good for your home and it prevents the nutrient pollution. Standard septic systems have no way of filtering

1375
07:56:36.638 --> 07:56:52.398
nutrients from waste like sewage does. Along with that issue, Florida has porous rock underneath the soil um beneath which is also beneath the septic systems, meaning that there are thousands of holes for the polluted waste to leak through hurting soil and

1376
07:56:52.398 --> 07:57:09.040
the ground beneath us. So when the waste does leak through the porest rock, it pollutes our drinking water which is found in our aquifer. Next, why should households convert from septic to sewer? And for that, I have two words. Sea levels. Traditional

1377
07:57:09.040 --> 07:57:24.160
septic systems require at least 6 ft of dry dry soil beneath them, which doesn't seem like a big deal at first. However, with rising sea levels and the amount of hurricanes and storms Miami gets, we know that water gets pushed up and therefore so does waste and it can end

1378
07:57:24.160 --> 07:57:38.798
up in your home, in your yard, and in the roads. It's really disgusting when you think about it. If you're sheltering down for a hurricane, for for a big storm, and all of a sudden it starts flooding, which it often does in Miami, waste comes up, which is awful, and it's

1379
07:57:38.798 --> 07:57:54.958
awful for the community of Coral Gables. Luckily, there have been various regional success models financially that have worked across the country. So starting with Barnstable County in Massachusetts, they use the Betterment loan assessment to sort of tackle their

1380
07:57:54.958 --> 07:58:10.638
septic to sewer conversion and also cover the cost of households converting. Next, Miami Dade County right in our backyard used or provided homesteaded properties which already established sewer systems with up to $15,000 to

1381
07:58:10.638 --> 07:58:25.920
cover the upfront costs of converting from septic to sewer. per the city's a um estimate for how much converting would be per household. It's around $16,000, which would mean that each household would have to pay roughly $1,000 to convert from septic to sewer if we

1382
07:58:25.920 --> 07:58:41.920
adopted a similar plan. Uh this slide right here just sort of outlines the exact format and plan which you would have to take when converting from septic to sewer in Miami Dade County. Um but I'll skip over that for now because I just provided a brief overview. Next,

1383
07:58:41.920 --> 07:58:57.360
some Florida success models. Um, in Bvard County, they offered a taxation program to cover up to $24,000 per household to cover the cost of converting from septic to sewer. And then Monroe County in the Florida Keys uses federal and state grants to fund

1384
07:58:57.360 --> 07:59:13.440
the connection of sewer infrastructure between islands using horizontal directional drilling to stay environmentally sustainable. So, what should the financing mechanism look like in Coral Gables? Well, most likely and probably it would be special assessments. The city will issue bonds

1385
07:59:13.440 --> 07:59:28.798
backed by household assessments and then basins will be able to choose their repayment structure once a majority of homeowners opt in to the process for shovelready projects. And luckily through the vice mayor's help specifically, we've realized that we already have a resolution in place which

1386
07:59:28.798 --> 07:59:44.398
she wrote herself to help us gain access to statebacked funds. The problem right now is just getting access to the funds to begin with. So once we are able to get funds, then we'll be able to solve the upfront problem of converting from septic to sewer. Next, we want to talk about state

1387
07:59:44.398 --> 08:00:00.798
funding. How can we get it? What can we do? And what are some approaches we can take? The Florida Department of Environmental Protection provides funding for cities just like Coral Gables if they have shovel ready projects, meaning the projects have already completed their preliminary plans. The approach is already

1388
08:00:00.798 --> 08:00:16.718
scaffolded by providing funding for different phases of the project. And if you don't believe me, there have been countless examples already nearby us like Miami County, the city of South Miami, and the city of Homestead, which have all gotten uh state funding and state grants.

1389
08:00:16.718 --> 08:00:33.440
So, what are some ne next steps this um the community of Coral Gables can take? Acting now provides for a better future for drinking water and the Coral Gables waterway. We also want to secure commitment from residents and then we aggressively seek FD funding to gain

1390
08:00:33.440 --> 08:00:50.520
more traction and money to this crucial project. Once we coordinate with the FD and receive necessary funding for the shovelready project, there will be a financially accessible model for almost all residents allowing them to convert from septic to sewer. Thank you.

1391
08:00:56.718 --> 08:01:12.000
Thank you. That was that was a lot of information to to understand. >> No, >> any questions or >> No. Well done. >> Okay. Uh for our next presentation, we'd like to talk about living seaw walls.

1392
08:01:12.000 --> 08:01:27.920
So um this presentation is going to be about the benefits and the imperative of switching from traditional seaw walls to living seaw walls here in our city and why it should be more uh present in our community. So firstly what are seaw walls? Seaw walls are a hard smooth

1393
08:01:27.920 --> 08:01:44.398
vertical barrier of concrete or steel built to prevent shore erosion. But who actually needs seaw walls? Well anyone who lives on the shore that doesn't have a natural barrier to the water definitely needs a seaw wall. And pretty interestingly, I'm sure that every single one of us here in the audience

1394
08:01:44.398 --> 08:02:01.040
has seen a seaw wall at least once in their life. Whether it be at a friend's house or on the city shoreline, they're present in all over our community as long as you look on the shoreline. But the benefits of seaw walls are twofold. First, we see preventing erosion of the shore. But second, it protects the

1395
08:02:01.040 --> 08:02:16.000
coastal buildings that are so imperative to our community. Next, seaw walls. The problem with um traditional seaw walls is that they have um many like pollution impacts. >> Yeah. And and like Evan was saying, they

1396
08:02:16.000 --> 08:02:31.520
leak toxins into the water that they're actually protecting. It's awful for the environment, creates poor allergy, poor water quality. And so we have a new question that needs to be asked. How do we keep all the great benefits of seaw walls while fixing the issues they currently have? And for that we have an

1397
08:02:31.520 --> 08:02:48.240
answer. Living seaw walls. What is a living seaw wall? It is a exactly how you would think of a normal seaw wall except it comes in many different shapes and forms. But what I want to tell you is that it will do the exact same thing as traditional seaw walls except it has some sort of habitat friendly design and

1398
08:02:48.240 --> 08:03:04.558
in this case in the picture up there a textured wall which allows for the environment to thrive. Who has living seaw walls? Many communities here in Florida and across the United States have living seaw walls and have already implemented programs to incentivize them. Miami

1399
08:03:04.558 --> 08:03:20.398
Dade, Fort Lauderdale, Satel and Pompo Beach and Maryland. They have all taken some sort of step forward whether be it through grants or educational programs and they understood the assignment and they took that step and leap forward in order to promote living seaw walls. So

1400
08:03:20.398 --> 08:03:36.478
what are the benefits of seaw walls living seaw walls? Why should we implement them here in Coral Gables? Uh, first, biodiversity. Second, improved water quality. And third, they're cost-effective. Number one, biodiversity. Those textured and habitat friendly designs that I spoke about

1401
08:03:36.478 --> 08:03:52.958
before have many purposes, but the key thing they deliver on is a mini reef in your backyard. In this design shown in the image, those grooves serve a purpose. It allows algae and other organisms to grow in it and survive. Compared to a traditional seaw wall with its smooth, flat design, it does not

1402
08:03:52.958 --> 08:04:08.240
allow for any growth. But this simple change fixes everything that a regular seaw wall lacked in. It allows organisms to flourish and live a healthy life without fear of toxins or the slow decay of their habitat. Next, improved water quality. Remember

1403
08:04:08.240 --> 08:04:24.160
how I just talked about those textured panels that allow organisms to flourish? Well, that's not just beneficial to them, it is beneficial to you and the community. Uh by having all these organisms living on the wall and around it, it creates a natural filtering process that cleans your water. not only

1404
08:04:24.160 --> 08:04:40.638
making it a better ecosystem for the animals, but also making it clear and clean, which looks amazing for your property. And lastly, and finally, living seaw walls cost the same as traditional seaw walls, which means they're cost comparable. But more importantly, the marine growth on the walls adds another

1405
08:04:40.638 --> 08:04:56.958
protective layer from erosion and wave energy, so that over time, the repair and maintenance costs will be lower. where a traditional seaw wall might need to be replaced in 30 to 50 years, a living seaw wall has a lifespan of over 50 years. Thank you and we appreciate your time on

1406
08:04:56.958 --> 08:05:14.478
this matter. And I just want to clarify that this is it from my research it seems like a win-win for the community to implement living seaw walls compared to traditional seaw walls. Thank you. >> Well done. >> Very well done. One last point to add is

1407
08:05:14.478 --> 08:05:29.680
we have reduced the permitting fee for living seaw walls in order to try to incentivize residents to utilize them >> which which um I did find in my preliminary research and huge thanks to you vice mayor. It was very important and I know Miami day did something

1408
08:05:29.680 --> 08:05:46.398
similar. So thank you vice mayor. And now we have our third and final presentation supporting small businesses. So why should the community of Coral Gable support small businesses? Number one, it keeps money local. Local businesses recirculate a significant

1409
08:05:46.398 --> 08:06:02.478
percentage of revenue back into the city where they are located. Second, it brings life back onto the streets. Our downtown and walkable areas are filled with small businesses. Let's bring back life to them by supporting them. And third, government functionality. The

1410
08:06:02.478 --> 08:06:19.200
impacts here are three-fold. First, by supporting local businesses, we see local financial success. Second, when businesses are succeeding in bringing in greater amounts of tax revenue, the local government receives more money that they can then use. And thirdly, to

1411
08:06:19.200 --> 08:06:35.680
improve the community around them. So, what can we take away from other cities around us? The first one I'd like to point to is Georgetown and Washington DC. Georgetown allows local businesses to set up in the outdoor spaces using attractive mechanisms like pop-ups to

1412
08:06:35.680 --> 08:06:50.638
promote their businesses. Next is Coconut Grove, which gives their central downtown area um given their central downtown area, they're able to really capitalize on freebies and pop-ups and storefronts that promote small businesses. And finally, Winter Park

1413
08:06:50.638 --> 08:07:06.958
here and also also in Florida, offers once a month workshops on marketing through their economic development team, which we also have and which is certainly something we could utilize. So, what are some general incentives that the city of Coral Gable should try to promote? Well, first would be

1414
08:07:06.958 --> 08:07:23.120
creating more shop local rewards apps or incentives. Many cities have used the rewards app where if you spend a certain amount of money at one local business and then send in your receipt to the city government or economic development team, then you can then receive a gift card to shop at other local businesses,

1415
08:07:23.120 --> 08:07:37.760
therefore promoting this never-ending cycle where all the local businesses around you are succeeding and residents are happy with the goods and services that they can shop for. Second would be continuing to capitalize on the nighttime. Although many businesses around our city close before the

1416
08:07:37.760 --> 08:07:53.040
dinnertime hours, a lot of our residents only actually get to the Miracle Mile or Geralda area during the times of the night for dinner. So therefore, at least supporting small businesses and trying to keep their lights on at later hours, perhaps through an ordinance would make

1417
08:07:53.040 --> 08:08:08.638
um small businesses far more visible to the community and therefore promote their successes in the future. Lastly would be including Apple Pay in garages and other parking areas that previously didn't have them. Many younger populations rely entirely on Apple Pay

1418
08:08:08.638 --> 08:08:25.600
to get their goods and services to begin with. And especially if you want them to come to your area at all, then it needs to be accessible from a parking um standpoint. So earlier last week, Jacob and I had a meeting in the downtown area and we only had Apple Pay on our phones

1419
08:08:25.600 --> 08:08:41.200
and we parked in one of the city garages and their only response to us was that we would have to go down the street to Publix to get a gift card to then pay for the parking which was a little bit inconvenient at the time. Um, next would be some specific events

1420
08:08:41.200 --> 08:08:57.840
that the city could capitalize on. First would be more restaurant weeks and initiatives with a diverse local business population. The city should try to promote uh certain corporations during the district distinct months or weeks of the year. For example, promoting Latin businesses during

1421
08:08:57.840 --> 08:09:14.958
Hispanic Heritage Month or blackowned restaurants during Black History Month. Also, parking incentives could be a very interesting initiative for the city to take on. Allowing certain garages off the beaten path of Miracle Mile or Deralda to offer lower rates could help promote local businesses in those areas

1422
08:09:14.958 --> 08:09:31.600
and allow them to become more visible because if residents go to those garages to park because if it's cheaper then they able then they're able to gain more exposure to those local businesses. Perhaps even keeping parking much lower of a rate on Sundays or even free altogether could also help the city

1423
08:09:31.600 --> 08:09:47.760
given that Sunday is a typically slower day of the week and therefore could be capitalized on to at least promote small businesses given that parking revenue on that day is nearly a net zero to begin with. So to conclude with this presentation, we would say allowing local businesses to take advantage of

1424
08:09:47.760 --> 08:10:04.398
the space that they have on Miracle Mile would be a great um promotion and incentive. Just in New York City, the sidewalks are probably a third the size of those on Miracle Mile. And when you walk around, all the local businesses have little tables set up offering perhaps samples or free food or clothing

1425
08:10:04.398 --> 08:10:20.718
to the people walking by, which really helps them promote their goods and services. The city should also continue to work with the economic development team to promote local businesses through apps and marketing workshops. And lastly, continue to incentivize younger populations to try and reach Miracle Mile and Geralda to try to promote the

1426
08:10:20.718 --> 08:10:43.120
future of the city. Thank you so much. I I want to congratulate both of you again. You did the you did an incredible job on all three presentations. And I want to just give you a, you know, kudos and a little bit of testament and congratulations because if you noticed the manager when you were giving your

1427
08:10:43.120 --> 08:10:58.478
final presentation, he was taking notes on the Apple Pay and it's something that it's something that again maybe it's in the works, maybe it's not. >> But, you know, having all these young individuals in the room gives you a

1428
08:10:58.478 --> 08:11:14.000
completely different perspective. Yeah. >> Like my my 15-year-old daughter pays with Apple Pay. I don't have a way on my phone. I never even thought about it. So, um, you know, I'm being candid. Try to try to talk to my parents about paying with like a debit card or

1429
08:11:14.000 --> 08:11:30.080
something. They don't even they don't understand that. So, >> again, uh, the the great thing about this is not only the exposure that you get because a lot of you, and we have a few more presentations, we're almost done. But the but the point is, and this is why we started this a while back ago,

1430
08:11:30.080 --> 08:11:46.718
was because many of you walked in and it's okay to admit it. You know, you were nervous about speaking in public. You were nervous about engaging with an elected official or a director, an ACM, DCM, city manager, but the whole point is for you to for that to become commonplace, for you to feel empowered in these positions. Because if it's not

1431
08:11:46.718 --> 08:12:01.840
maybe one day as the mayor or the manager, maybe it's one day as an executive at a big firm, you already have a step up when you walk into your first, you know, college or you walk into your first job opportunity. You're going to take control of the situation and, you know, truly be a leader. So,

1432
08:12:01.840 --> 08:12:19.120
here's a clear example of of an idea the manager is going to follow up on. That's great. I mean, that to me is what this is all about. We're learning from each other. So, I want to congratulate you. >> Thank you very much. >> Thank you so much >> through the through the mayor. >> I want to thank you very much for working on this last presentation for

1433
08:12:19.120 --> 08:12:34.000
me. You guys did an exceptional job. I pay with Apple Pay everywhere. Sometimes I don't take my purse. I don't only pay with my phone, but I am also able to pay with my watch. I was stuck in the cocoa walk garage with my grandfather that's

1434
08:12:34.000 --> 08:12:50.398
very impatient and I forgot my credit cards and cash. So I was stuck with a lot of people behind me not being able to pay pressing the little button for somebody to come and help me. So I think we're working on renewing our garages. I

1435
08:12:50.398 --> 08:13:06.798
think Monorca is going to be the first one and I think we're going to be incorporating that technology. That is a wonderful idea. Thank you. >> Thank you guys. >> Great job gentlemen. Um, Robert Marena, Jacob Desa, and Charlotte Rutkins, Lucas Mansano, Community

1436
08:13:06.798 --> 08:13:25.840
Recreation. >> How are you? >> Happy to have you guys. >> Good afternoon. >> Afternoon. >> All right, gentlemen. Ladies and gentlemen, go ahead. >> Good afternoon, Commission. Mayor Lago, thank you so much for this opportunity. We all really learned a lot from this internship. So, we interned with the community recreations department, and we

1437
08:13:25.840 --> 08:13:42.398
really learned a lot, as you'll see in our presentation. I'm Lucas Matsano. I'm a rising junior in Ban Jesuit. And you guys >> Hi, I'm Charlotte Reikens and I'm a rising junior at Carolton School of the Take Heart. >> I'm Robert Merena and I am a rising senior in ISBA.

1438
08:13:42.398 --> 08:13:59.120
>> I'm Jacob Tza and I'm a rising senior at Christopher Columbus High School. >> Take it away. >> All right. This is community recreation. Let's all start. Let's start with how it all began. The Paige program. I joined this program because I was extremely interested in my government. I've lived

1439
08:13:59.120 --> 08:14:14.558
in Coral Gables my whole life and I've always been interested in how this government works. What I wasn't expecting was what I learned. I learned the importance of parks and recreations on this community. I joined this program because I wanted to learn more about local government and how I could directly impact my

1440
08:14:14.558 --> 08:14:29.680
community. This program was recommended to me by my counselor and I believe it to have been extremely helpful in developing my love for public service. I joined this program because I want to understand how government operates from the inside beyond what we can learn in

1441
08:14:29.680 --> 08:14:46.798
textbooks. I want to see the day-to-day work that goes into running a city and how decisions are made in real life. And I joined this program because I wanted to learn more about how government works on a local level. My expectations were mostly on the legisl legislative aspect of government. But

1442
08:14:46.798 --> 08:15:01.600
this program showed me how much there is to government and how much it keep takes to keep recreation going. >> Now what we learned my first week at this internship was spent in the youth center. Although I was reluctant to be at the youth center because it was a lot

1443
08:15:01.600 --> 08:15:17.280
about camps and gyms and stuff. I really got to see the importance of the youth center on the community. But more importantly, I learned later the importance of parks on the community. For example, Lamar Louise Curry Park, which is a very small park, one of the smallest in Coral Gables, located near

1444
08:15:17.280 --> 08:15:32.638
the Venetian pool, which is usually overlooked. But this park is extremely important. It's dedicated to the gardening club, and it's very important for them. They care for the park and appreciating it, showing that even the smallest park can have the largest impact. Not only that, I also got to see

1445
08:15:32.638 --> 08:15:49.600
the stewards of the community in action. I met an incredible amount of great people that are extremely passionate and that really wanted to uplift the community. One instance in them wanting to up this the community was in door hangers for uh these workers would come in and go around the community hanging

1446
08:15:49.600 --> 08:16:07.520
door hangers to announce parks which demonstrates their commitment to the community. I've truly learned a lot from them. Another important experience during our internship was our field trip to the construction site of Philips Park. Lucas and I left the youth center to attend a meeting with the parks department heads

1447
08:16:07.520 --> 08:16:23.360
and project leaders where we gained firsthand experience into the effort required to create a new community space. During the meeting, we met with the teams responsible for different aspects of the project. We also talked about different design elements of the park such as the color selections for

1448
08:16:23.360 --> 08:16:38.718
the restrooms and the exterior of the various facilities. This experience gave us a greater appreciation for the many decisions and the extensive collaboration that go into building a park that will serve the community for years to come. >> Another important experience from this

1449
08:16:38.718 --> 08:16:54.558
internship was in the accredititation meetings. Accreditation is a five five-year long process that requires full team participation. I learned a lot through this process. I learned the importance of working together as a team and it demonstrated that it demonstrated and showed me the work that is put into

1450
08:16:54.558 --> 08:17:11.040
maintaining our prestigious parks. We've been accredited since 2001, which is such an incredible feat and it really shows the beauty of all our parks. Through the accredititation meetings, we got to see not just the beauty of the parks, but the work put into creating and maintaining them. These meetings take a couple days to

1451
08:17:11.040 --> 08:17:26.718
complete because the process is very extensive. Department leaders walk through every chapter and discuss important factors of maintaining our beautiful city like budgeting and management as well as showing the accredititation team the unique features each park has. For example, Dorothy Park

1452
08:17:26.718 --> 08:17:42.320
named after the first and only female mayor of Coral Gables in which has a Wizard of Oz theme highlighting how parks can bring such joy and livelihood into the city. My time at the Coral Gables country club was focused heavily on leadership operations and community service. On the

1453
08:17:42.320 --> 08:17:58.718
leadership side, I supervised daily summer camps and organized activities. I also handled front desk operations and reception workflows using rec track. This gave me great experience with customer service. Most importantly, this showed me the community engagement with this country club and showed me how much

1454
08:17:58.718 --> 08:18:13.840
this country club represents the friendly standard of our city. For this part of the program, I was actually working at the Venetian pool, the one you see right here in the photos. It was an amazing experience because I got to see firsthand how much

1455
08:18:13.840 --> 08:18:31.120
work goes into managing a play like this. I learned about their strict water safety protocols, how they handle life rotation, and how they manage the crowds. It was really interesting to see how the city managed to keep a nearly 100 years old historic landmark running

1456
08:18:31.120 --> 08:18:47.200
perfectly and safely for the public every single day. >> In summary, all in all, this internship has taught me very valuable lessons. When I first came into the internship, I did not understand the impact of parks and recreations on the community. But I learned that with parks and recreations, the city beautiful would not be as

1457
08:18:47.200 --> 08:19:03.360
beautiful. I started this internship with very little knowledge of what community recreation actually did. However, over the past two weeks, I've gained a much deeper appreciation for how community recreation plays a vital role in shaping and supporting this beautiful city.

1458
08:19:03.360 --> 08:19:20.160
>> Initially, my expectation was that everything will be strictly tied to traditional politics. However, I discovered something much more valuable. The recreation department is the silent engine that makes everything else work. It's what maintains the essent of this city and keeps it iconic.

1459
08:19:20.160 --> 08:19:34.798
When I first came into this internship, I expected an office with a lot of paperwork. But through community and recreation, I realized how important the local government is and how much work it takes to keep the community together and have a common area for residents. Thank you all for listening to us.

1460
08:19:34.798 --> 08:19:55.200
>> Thank you. Well done. Well done. Thank you very much. Welcome to the city, >> Gabby Vidz. And then we have one more development services. >> Gabby, welcome. >> Thank you. >> Good afternoon, mayor, vice

1461
08:19:55.200 --> 08:20:16.638
commissioners. My name is Gabriela Vidz and I'm a rising senior at Mast Academy. For the past two weeks, I've been working at the develop development service department and this opportunity has helped me strengthen my passion for architecture. During my internship, I had the opportunity to experience many different

1462
08:20:16.638 --> 08:20:34.080
aspects of development services. I shall the city architect Juan Resco attended two board of architect meetings, observed project reviews, and learned about the process that projects go through before construction ever begins. Before this internship, I thought architecture was mainly about designing

1463
08:20:34.080 --> 08:20:52.478
buildings. I but I quickly realized that architects also have the responsibility to think about how every project affects the surrounding community. One of my highlights of the internship was attending two board of architect meetings. I watched architects and

1464
08:20:52.478 --> 08:21:08.398
homeowners pre present projects ranging from home additions to complete renovations. I expected the discussions to focus mostly on whether design looked nice, but I was surprised how much attention was given to how each project would affect the surrounding

1465
08:21:08.398 --> 08:21:25.280
neighborhood. The port carefully considered things like scale, proportions, architectural style, and compatibility with nearby homes. Watching this process helped me understand that architecture isn't only about individual buildings, but it's also about preserving the identity and

1466
08:21:25.280 --> 08:21:43.600
character of an entire city. One concept that I learned a lot about during my internship was massing, especially in the board of architect meetings. Masking refers to the overall shape, size, and arrangement of a building. At first, it seemed like a simple design

1467
08:21:43.600 --> 08:21:58.798
concept, but I learned that it has major impact on how a building fits within its surroundings. In Coral Gables, massing is carefully reviewed because it influences how people experience a neighborhood. Good massing creates balance and helps a building complement

1468
08:21:58.798 --> 08:22:15.520
the homes around it instead of overpowering them like improper massing. These digital models help me better understand the difference between improper and proper massing. On the left, the building appears as one large block. Because there isn't much

1469
08:22:15.520 --> 08:22:32.320
variation in its form, it feels bulky and can overwhelm the surrounding homes. On the right, the building is divided into smaller forms with different roof lines and setbacks. Even if both buildings have similar square footage, the second one feels much more balanced

1470
08:22:32.320 --> 08:22:46.558
and fits naturally within the neighborhood. This was one of the concepts that really changed how I look at architecture. And this is another example. I made paper models. As you can see on the left, it's improper massing and on the

1471
08:22:46.558 --> 08:23:04.160
right there's the proper massing. Another thing that stood out to me was how much Corables values historic preservation. Many of the city's homes and landmarks were built nearly 100 years ago as part of George Merrick's vision for Coral Gables. Because these

1472
08:23:04.160 --> 08:23:18.958
buildings defined the city's identity, even relatively small exterior changes are carefully reviewed. At first, I thought these regulations were restrictive, but I came to understand that they're one of the reasons Coral Gables has such a unique and

1473
08:23:18.958 --> 08:23:36.240
recognizable architectural character. Another valuable experience was shadowing the architectural reviewers. This gave me a behind thescenes look at what happens before many project projects ever reached the board of architects. I watched reviewers

1474
08:23:36.240 --> 08:23:51.360
carefully examine building plans, identify areas that needed improvement, and work with the architects to ensure projects meet the city standards. It showed me how much collaboration and attention to detail goes into every

1475
08:23:51.360 --> 08:24:08.958
project long before construction begins. Overall, this internship completely changed my perspective on architecture. I learned that architecture shapes entire communities, not just individual buildings. I also saw how successful projects require collaboration between

1476
08:24:08.958 --> 08:24:26.958
architects, reviewers, homeowners, and the board of architects. Something else that stood out to me was that every detail matters. Whether it's massing, historic preservation, or architectural designs, even small decisions can have a lasting impact on a neighborhood.

1477
08:24:26.958 --> 08:24:42.320
Most importantly, this internship strengthened my passion for architecture. It showed me that architecture combines creativity, his story, history, problem solving, and public service. and it made me even more excited to pursue this field in the

1478
08:24:42.320 --> 08:25:03.440
future. Therefore, I would like to thank the mayor, vice mayor, and commissioners for this amazing opportunity. >> Thank you for joining us this summer and it really excites me to know that this opportunity only strengthen your opinion in regards to what do you want to chase

1479
08:25:03.440 --> 08:25:18.798
professionally. So, uh, we're excited that you're here and hopefully one day you'll become part of the team. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. Have a wonderful summer. Thank you for being here with us. And the last one is Maria Benites and she had the honor of working with a finance

1480
08:25:18.798 --> 08:25:33.680
department. Last but not least, we save the best for last. >> Of course. >> Yes. That's what I like to hear. That's what I like to hear. >> I like to hear that. >> Good afternoon. My name is Maria Josees.

1481
08:25:33.680 --> 08:25:50.240
Um I'm a rising senior in Immacula Lassal and as a mayor said I was interning with the finance department. So during my time here I mostly worked on the budget which tomorrow there's a

1482
08:25:50.240 --> 08:26:08.958
big meeting. So the budget is a financial >> you going to be joining us tomorrow for the meeting. >> If they invite me I will come. Didn't But didn't you work on it? >> Yes, but they haven't. Oh, wait. You did tell me to come, right? >> Oh, then I'll come.

1483
08:26:08.958 --> 08:26:25.280
>> We need somebody We need somebody to present the budget. >> No, no, thank you. >> Okay. So, the budget is a financial plan for city operations and capital projects. The budget determines how financial

1484
08:26:25.280 --> 08:26:45.840
resources are used to support municipal operations. How do I change the slide? Where? >> Oh, there's a clicker. >> Oh, oops. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> We all suffer from that same problem.

1485
08:26:45.840 --> 08:27:01.520
>> So, the budget is used to cover types of services for the city such as culture and recreation, transportation, public safety, general government, economic environment, and physical environment.

1486
08:27:01.520 --> 08:27:18.718
So, but to fund the budget, the city relies on revenue. And as you can see, property taxes are the largest source of revenue, about 49.2%. So,

1487
08:27:18.718 --> 08:27:35.040
I'm going to where So, I'm going to show you how property taxes are calculated. So Coral Gaywell's current millage rate is 5.59 mills on every taxable dollar. So the

1488
08:27:35.040 --> 08:27:50.000
formula to find how much the city receives in property taxes is a taxable property value divided by a,000 times the mill rate. And that gives you how much the city receives from property

1489
08:27:50.000 --> 08:28:06.558
taxes. So the city's residential owns I mean values there's nonhomested residentials and homesteaded residentials. So the average taxable value of

1490
08:28:06.558 --> 08:28:27.120
nonhomesteaded residentials is 1 mill62,286. And if we plug that into our formula, divided by 1,000 * 5.59 MS, the city receives $5,911

1491
08:28:27.120 --> 08:28:42.798
on nonhomestead residential properties. But 45% of residential properties have the homestead exemption. So the average taxable value of homestead residentials

1492
08:28:42.798 --> 08:29:05.200
is 1,12,564. So in the formula we divide that number by a,000 times our millage rate and the city receives $5,629 from nonhomesteaded residentials. But

1493
08:29:05.200 --> 08:29:22.558
since property taxes is the largest source of revenue, any changes will have an impact on revenue. For example, if the proposed constitutional amendment to raise homestead exemption to 15 sorry $150,000

1494
08:29:22.558 --> 08:29:38.558
in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028. If the proposed bill passes, the city is estimating an approximate loss of $5.7 million

1495
08:29:38.558 --> 08:29:55.520
to to impact the fiscal year 2028 budget. So, in conclusion, I learned that the budget is more than just a financial plan. It is what allows the city to grow, function, and provide essential services to the community. Thank you.

1496
08:29:55.520 --> 08:30:11.280
>> Great work. >> Thank you. >> You're not going to be late tomorrow, right? >> Sorry. You're not going to be late tomorrow, right? >> You know what time it starts tomorrow? >> No. >> Okay, I'll be here. >> Be here at 8:45. Be here at 8:45. >> Yes. Okay.

1497
08:30:11.280 --> 08:30:27.440
>> Congratulations. >> That Let me tell you what you just talked about right now is incredibly complicated. >> It is. >> And you have an amazing handle of that >> and we should use that cheat sheet across the board to explain to people because >> you should. >> Sometimes people don't understand. Sometimes people don't understand and

1498
08:30:27.440 --> 08:30:42.718
they ask you and it's okay and they you don't expect people to understand a millage rate you know people ask you what are my taxes what are my taxes >> so what you explained right there you you did it with grace you did it you know you simplified it >> and I want to tell you that I'm very proud of you

1499
08:30:42.718 --> 08:30:58.080
>> uh for getting up there and doing a great job >> thank you for this opportunity >> no please in closing um I'd like to to thank Laura um for her hard work she's amazing and we're blessed to have her at the commission office. She is an amazing

1500
08:30:58.080 --> 08:31:14.398
an amazing individual who always makes me look good. U I want to also thank Nora, Gabby, and Gabrielle. Gabrielle, who's here, um the rest of the staff members in the commission, um who have done also a great job. And I'd like to take a picture with the pages if I possibly can. Can we get you guys up

1501
08:31:14.398 --> 08:33:50.638
here really quick for a picture? >> Awesome. All right. That's How you doing? All right. Uh, moving on. We have our mayor here. So time sir in item F8 and

1502
08:33:50.638 --> 08:34:13.760
G3 >> running a little late I apologize we're running a little late but thank you for your patience. >> I think you w enjoyed watching the presentations especially since was your granddaughter there? >> Yes.

1503
08:34:13.760 --> 08:34:29.120
Well let me say this. I hope I can be as clear and concise as all those students were. So, that was very impressive and very impressive for you all to give them that opportunity. >> A lot of fun. >> So, Mr. Mayor and Madame Vice Mayor and

1504
08:34:29.120 --> 08:34:46.718
commissioners, I also would like to ask Commissioner Castro to help me set up Apple Pay on my phone. So, >> I um >> A pleasure. >> Have no earthly idea what what that is. >> You and me both. I've I have to get an Apple phone first, I guess. Mayor, we've

1505
08:34:46.718 --> 08:35:02.558
been doing this I I think it's been like five or six years that we've been doing the page program and it's steadily it's growing and growing and growing. >> And one of the interesting things that you heard was >> one of the one of the individuals mentioned very clearly. She said that I think it was I think it was a young lady

1506
08:35:02.558 --> 08:35:19.120
that said, "My counselor told me to join this program." >> Yes. And I think that to me that to me verifies that what we're doing here as a city and bringing this program together is makes sense. You know, it's not too long and it's not too

1507
08:35:19.120 --> 08:35:34.160
short. Three weeks, four weeks is right about the right time and you culminated with having them come before the commission. I think it's just builds it. It's it's character building and I think it's just huge. >> I also thought it was good that you had such a cross representation of high

1508
08:35:34.160 --> 08:35:50.718
schools here. I mean, you covered the waterfront. Ma, Mr. Mayor, if I may just take a moment of personal privilege before I get to the reason I actually came here, >> but this is something I thought that I'd share with you because I have before great news because last night I opened

1509
08:35:50.718 --> 08:36:07.120
up the brand new Florida Trend magazine and I thought the commission would be proud to hear that in this year's rankings of 125 biggest public companies in the state of Florida, two in the top 20 list Coral Gables as their

1510
08:36:07.120 --> 08:36:23.040
headquarters and six in the top 100 list Coral Gables. This doesn't include all the ones that are in Miami, but two in the top 20 Coral Gables, six in the top 100 of the biggest public companies are here. And in private companies, three of

1511
08:36:23.040 --> 08:36:42.798
the top 20 list Coral Gables as their headquarters. So, I'll give this to the manager. >> Thank you, mayor. And now for the reason I'm here or at least when it has to be here. Okay. I am

1512
08:36:42.798 --> 08:36:59.440
offering to you the commission our charter review committee's final recommendations. And as you know this is the culmination of three years of work on the committee's part and uh it has for all of us been an honor and a privilege to

1513
08:36:59.440 --> 08:37:15.200
serve our community in doing this. And also earlier this year we gave you some of our recommendations. Some were accepted, some were not. Some were put on the ballot and most were uh accepted by the public. Uh some were modified

1514
08:37:15.200 --> 08:37:31.120
from your committee's recommendations, some were accepted as we recommended and some uh are coming back to you now as final recommendations. So first let me tell you just to show you the extent of the conversation in the committee. two things that we

1515
08:37:31.120 --> 08:37:48.160
discussed in detail but did not come up with recommendations and that is changing uh the percentage of voter requirements for instituting initiatives and referendums. Um Miss Moscowitz actually was very very uh set on us

1516
08:37:48.160 --> 08:38:04.718
talking considering and working on that and we did talk at length about it many times but we do not have a recommendation in that area. So, uh I guess you could say with no recommendation. The recommendation is to not do anything with that subject. Uh

1517
08:38:04.718 --> 08:38:20.478
the other one is um the uh thing that we did not give you a recommendation on was uh changing the um estimated expenses and revenues report uh and non- tax

1518
08:38:20.478 --> 08:38:37.920
revenues that have to be cited in the uh budget uh proposals. and that it was considered to be talked about to be a change in the charter to actually change what has to go into the budget estimates in the budget proposals. But we finally

1519
08:38:37.920 --> 08:38:53.920
came up with the recommendation that if you desire to do that, it should be done in the city codes and not in the charter. So those two were talked about. They're in your final report. Discussions are available on our transcripts, but we are moving forward with leaving those alone. As far as our

1520
08:38:53.920 --> 08:39:10.240
recommendations, the two recommendations that you'll find in the final report that we do now give you again that we give you as part of that is changing the residence requirement for qualifying for office. At the current time, uh, if you

1521
08:39:10.240 --> 08:39:26.718
live a year in the city, from the year of the from the date of the election, you can qualify for office, which in this case could mean from the end of the qualifying period to the time you moved in, you could be a resident for only six months because a year from the the

1522
08:39:26.718 --> 08:39:42.318
qualifying is about six months before the election. Uh, as it currently stands with the November election. So our recommendation is and is in your report that the qualifying uh period be the judge of whether you've lived a year so

1523
08:39:42.318 --> 08:39:58.638
that you must live a year con consecutively before the end of the qualifying period. So in this case when we qualified people in June it would have been a year ago June and we felt that that was and that by the way was a unanimous decision the committee. So all

1524
08:39:58.638 --> 08:40:14.558
of the people that each of you appointed voted in favor of doing that to make sure that the people who run for office have lived here for enough time to really understand their city and to contribute to the future of the city. The other one that we uh unanimously

1525
08:40:14.558 --> 08:40:32.240
approved to send to you is on the public works contracts. For many years, the amount of uh in the charter that you had to go out and solicit uh bids and then have competitive bidding before you can issue the contracts is 25,000, which is,

1526
08:40:32.240 --> 08:40:49.440
as we decided, based on recommendations by both the city managers we worked with and by all the people on the committee was just way out of date and far too low and holds up the city's progress in moving forward. And so we recommend to you in our final report that that amount

1527
08:40:49.440 --> 08:41:05.840
be raised to 300,000 and that is in accord with state statute. So if it's in accord with state statute, we felt that was a safe recommendation for you to consider which would facilitate the work of the city and let it move uh aggressively forward on projects that

1528
08:41:05.840 --> 08:41:21.120
are less than that without having to go through the bid solicitation procedure. Uh we did have a final meeting on June the 4th. Unfortunately, we could not get a quorum because of uh illnesses and also there was a death which affected

1529
08:41:21.120 --> 08:41:38.080
several of the families uh who serve on our committee. And uh in there in the materials that the city attorney has provided you besides the final recommendations she has also given you a report of that meeting which includes our discussion of a number of different

1530
08:41:38.080 --> 08:41:54.558
things and uh but there was no action taken but I offered to you the discussion it's in your report and there's some backup materials uh some of which I think that you will be looking at maybe at one of the suggestions of a member of this commission. One was our

1531
08:41:54.558 --> 08:42:11.600
concern for parks land that our parks are so precious. listening to the report of the uh students and your interns, I think that I was reinvigorated uh in this subject that how critical and important parks are and uh one of our

1532
08:42:11.600 --> 08:42:28.080
city one of our commission our committee members uh told us that many cities are taking action to doubly protect their parklands before future commissions who may be running short on money and see a real opportunity to sell off parklands.

1533
08:42:28.080 --> 08:42:44.160
So our recommendation though is that it would take a four-fifth uh vote of the commission before you could move to sell parklands. Now I know that maybe suggested to go to public vote but I do want to say that and this is not to be

1534
08:42:44.160 --> 08:43:00.478
contradictory of that but our committee expressed all of us have always expressed and we saw this in my last report confidence in our commission. We and we know we've had some disagreements. We know that we've had some disruptions, but we express the

1535
08:43:00.478 --> 08:43:17.600
general idea of confidence in our elected officials. So, as opposed to having to go to an election every time that maybe Parkland is supposed to be sold, which by the way protects Parkland greatly, don't get me wrong, but we suggested a four-fifth vote, which is difficult to get as you may know. Uh, we

1536
08:43:17.600 --> 08:43:34.478
also talked again about initiatives and referendums and we again moved on without any any solid discussion on that. And finally, we did talk about the mayor's term. Uh the possibility of going back to the electorate to consider a four-year mayor's term. And I cannot

1537
08:43:34.478 --> 08:43:50.240
stand here and propose to you that because we didn't take any action. But in your materials, our background and one of the things that we talked about was that in 2007 or so forth, the city did vote for a four-year mayor's term

1538
08:43:50.240 --> 08:44:05.840
based on the information before the electors, and it was about a 52% approval of the four-year term. Several years later, it went back to the voters and was turned back to a two-year term with a slightly less approval of a 50%

1539
08:44:05.840 --> 08:44:22.240
to turn it back to two years. So, you kind of got a standoff of one yes and one no. Basically, a break even point. And we thought it was worthwhile, the three of us that were in meeting. It was not a quorum to give you the materials, let you discuss that and let you

1540
08:44:22.240 --> 08:44:38.478
consider it. And as you all may know if you read the background materials, I have strong opinions on it which I'm not going to express because I think it would be very inappropriate for me to do so. But that's the committee report. What I would like to say, Mr. Mayor, vice mayor and commissioners, is that it

1541
08:44:38.478 --> 08:44:54.318
has been an honor and a pleasure working with the following members of this committee over the last three years. Our vice chairman, Mayor Raul Belali, our board member, former state representative Annie Bitten Court. uh board member Eve Bhas. And I have to

1542
08:44:54.318 --> 08:45:12.318
tell you that Eve is a great resource for this city. She's a city attorney in another city in South Florida but lives in the Gables and a very knowledgeable person. Nester Menendez who joined our committee lately was a positive force. Jane Moscowitz was a solid wellspoken

1543
08:45:12.318 --> 08:45:29.200
force throughout. At the beginning we had Tom Wells on the committee and of course throughout that time we had Felix Bardau. All of your committee members served with uh with dedication and with commitment and I think they all showed in their own way whether we agreed or

1544
08:45:29.200 --> 08:45:46.958
not their love for the city, their love for the city, beautiful Coral Gables and our commitment to fulfilling the obligations of the committee that you all assigned to us. And with that, Mr. Mayor, I am proud to say is our final report. And we are waiting for sunset.

1545
08:45:46.958 --> 08:46:03.280
We ask for sunset. We are anxious for sunset, but we have we have it was a completely enjoyable act to to sit and I have to tell you the best part was the public hearings where we heard from the public

1546
08:46:03.280 --> 08:46:18.718
loud and clear at the beginning. The u unfortunately the public lost interest in us after that. But those first meetings were lively. Uh debates were good. there was great diversity of opinion and all of that was compiled and

1547
08:46:18.718 --> 08:46:35.840
then taken into consideration and I know that you've been given all the materials that represent all of that. So I hope that each of you may reach out and thank your appointees because they represented you well. They uh made you should have made you proud because they were good

1548
08:46:35.840 --> 08:46:51.600
members of this committee. And I thank you Mr. mayor for my appointment and uh I personally look forward to continuing to help the city in the future. Uh at a shorter meeting. >> Mayor, if I may, if I may, uh first and

1549
08:46:51.600 --> 08:47:08.160
foremost, thank you for always saying yes. Um when I call you, you have a million things going on. You're running your law career. You're engaged in a lot of philanthropy. You're throughout the state. you're traveling for a lot of Gator causes, a lot of philanthropy

1550
08:47:08.160 --> 08:47:23.680
causes, philanthropic causes, excuse me. Uh, but you said you need me, the city needs me, I'd be honored to serve. You've done you served for two years with incredible distinction. Uh, you've been through you've been through the roller coaster over the last two years

1551
08:47:23.680 --> 08:47:40.000
and you came out the other side and we've accomplished a lot. uh the referendums that you saw at the last election uh received overwhelming support from the residents of this community and a lot of that comes as a result of your hard work and the committee's hard work. I want to thank

1552
08:47:40.000 --> 08:47:55.520
you so much for your service. Thank you sir. >> Thank you. And I would asked to be excused in the sense I would love to stay here for any further discussion that you might do but I have to go present a movie for the members at the Coral Gable Cinema this evening. So >> that's that's what I'm saying exactly.

1553
08:47:55.520 --> 08:48:11.040
And if you all would adjourn fast enough, you can get there to see it again. >> Mayor, why don't you tell us what it is that they're showing tonight? >> It's the Harvey Girls with Judy Garland. And um we bring back musicals for membersh

1554
08:48:11.040 --> 08:48:27.440
uh and we have some great theater. And by the way, I'll put a plug in. I know that I probably am way off base now, but your cinema is just doing great. It's a wonderful uh place and it brings together so many good citizens and they and they come and they love it and

1555
08:48:27.440 --> 08:48:42.958
>> and we're about to expand. I've been working on that project with you for the last I can't even remember how many years and the manager. We're right there, right? We're in the procurement process. >> So, it's taken a lot of heavy lifting and I want to thank you for that and thank everybody in the center. >> Hope to see you. Hope to see you all at the movies.

1556
08:48:42.958 --> 08:48:58.558
>> I will see you in the movies. Uh >> and and at the polls. >> Yes, at the polls. Uh, can I have a motion to accept F8? >> Can I just read it for the record, mayor? So, F8 is a resolution of the city commission expressing gratitude for the work and dedication of the charter review committee and dissolving the

1557
08:48:58.558 --> 08:49:13.680
current charter review committee due to the completion of the committee's work. >> I'll move it. >> I'll second with a correction of a typo on Menendez's last name. There's an extra M. We'll fix that. >> Perfect.

1558
08:49:13.680 --> 08:49:28.798
>> Clerk, >> Commissioner Fernandez. >> Yes. Commissioner Lada, >> yes. >> Vice Mayor Anderson, >> yes. >> Commissioner Castro, >> yes. >> Mayor Lago, >> yes. Mayor, thank you so much. We're eternally grateful as always. God bless you. >> Thank you.

1559
08:49:28.798 --> 08:49:45.840
>> Uh we're going to take items E12 and E13, which I think are related. >> At 4:30, >> take it after after the time, sir. So E12 is a resolution of the city commission amending resolution number 2024-107 as amended by resolution number 2025-463

1560
08:49:45.840 --> 08:50:00.798
which approved the mixeduse site plan and encroionment plan for the project referred to as Pon Park residences on a property legally described as lots 8 through 21 bless the west half of lot 8 block 29 craft section together with that portion of the 20 foot platted alley lying east of lots 11 and 19 said

1561
08:50:00.798 --> 08:50:16.318
block 29 for Gables Florida by specifically amending condition number three to reflect an increase in the estimated cost of the pawn circle park project, an increase in the amount of the city contribution towards such costs, and an increase in the profit applicant contribution, which is sub certain conditions towards such costs,

1562
08:50:16.318 --> 08:50:36.718
providing for provisions, severability costs, and providing for an effective date. And E13 is a resolution of the city commission approving an amendment to the development management agreement with Pon Park Residences LLC regarding enhancements to Fredbe Hart, Pon Circle Park, and certain roadway improvements. >> Mayor Fernandez, welcome back,

1563
08:50:36.718 --> 08:50:51.840
Mr. Mayor. Good afternoon, members of commission. It's a pleasure to be before you. For the record, Javier Fernandez with offices at uh 2011 on Hamburg Circle and glad to be on two feet this time. So, >> yeah, I I was just going to comment on

1564
08:50:51.840 --> 08:51:08.478
that. I see you're out of the boot. >> Thank you, Madam Mayor. Yes, it feels a whole lot better. Um again, uh you'll recall in the last presentation, we brought before you the conceptual design for approval. We are currently working through the board process. will be going to BOVA BOA later this month already

1565
08:51:08.478 --> 08:51:23.680
have gone to DRC and excited to be advancing that design work in conjunction with your staff. Uh today's documents are intended to reflect the change in the budget which with the design modifications that we've been working on has increased by about $2.3

1566
08:51:23.680 --> 08:51:40.798
million. Um the you'll recall there was an original $1.6 million gap. The documents reflect how we've filled that gap through a combination of additional contributions by my client as well as some reallocated monies that were available uh from the

1567
08:51:40.798 --> 08:51:57.920
Agavei project that were went unspent. So with that, by way of summary, if you have any questions, I'm happy to take them at this time. >> Do you have any public comment? >> No, Mr. Mayor. >> I will close the public comment. Any any comments from the commission?

1568
08:51:57.920 --> 08:52:14.000
It's it's a beautiful project and I I take it that the comment we had earlier today that Alan Morris was contributing in total additional 11 million was >> was not it's not 11 million. >> I didn't want to bring it up. I >> make that clear for the record. No. >> Well, I I can't believe I can't believe

1569
08:52:14.000 --> 08:52:29.200
the vice mayor brought that about 11 million. Wow. We're feeling generous. >> I couldn't resist. >> Maybe someday. I know you could. I know you couldn't. Um perfect. Um listen again thank you. Um,

1570
08:52:29.200 --> 08:52:46.240
I want residents to understand what's about to happen here. The manager and your team have worked on delivering probably one of the most beautiful parks you're going to see in Florida. It's going to be reminiscent of what you

1571
08:52:46.240 --> 08:53:03.760
see in like Washington, you know, where it has real stone. It's not faux coina. It's not just concrete. It's real stone. It's going to have worldclass art and it's going to be a beautiful, beautiful location that's going to be the envy of

1572
08:53:03.760 --> 08:53:19.440
every community here in South Florida, >> including mine for the record. So, I'm just I just want people because it's little it's a little bit difficult and we've been working on this for years. It's a little bit difficult uh to really encapsulate it and really explain it because you until you see the materials

1573
08:53:19.440 --> 08:53:35.360
and you understand and you touch it and you really get to see the banisters and you get to see, you know, the the actual structures that are built out of marble. Uh this is not your typical concrete structure. This is something incredibly tasteful. It's beautiful and it's very well done and it'll stand the test of

1574
08:53:35.360 --> 08:53:53.200
time. I also want to um thank you because you worked incredibly hard not only with a project across the street um but you've worked like a statesman uh to get these things done uh with the manager. You've been incredibly patient.

1575
08:53:53.200 --> 08:54:09.520
You led by example along with your client Alan Morris and Spencer. It has been breath of fresh air uh to deal with a developer who has impeccable taste and understands and is willing to spend the money to leave to leave to truly hit new

1576
08:54:09.520 --> 08:54:24.638
milestones. And let me just give you an idea. You want to charge $1,800 a foot, $1,700 a foot, then you better put forth a product out there that commands that amount of money. And that's what the Morris company did. Um, and they're

1577
08:54:24.638 --> 08:54:40.878
reaching the highest numbers we've seen in the Gables ever per square foot, but they're spending money on quality and it's g and it's going to mean not only in their building, but it's going to be also reflected in Palm Circle Park because this is going to be an extension all that. You know, you have Pon Circle

1578
08:54:40.878 --> 08:54:57.280
Park, you have uh obviously the the Agave project, there's forthcoming projects adjacent to that. They understand that to hit real numbers in regards to per square foot per square foot rentals and square foot sales, you've got to invest and you know what

1579
08:54:57.280 --> 08:55:13.280
your client has done is to be commended. Um they've spent the money and I want to thank you for that because you you've done an amazing job. >> We're grateful to all of you. We're grateful to the manager. My thanks to uh your city attorney and her deputy who I pestered with this agreement. Thank you for leaning in and getting this done.

1580
08:55:13.280 --> 08:55:29.360
and we're excited to hopefully get started with construction which we're kind of targeting for the beginning of next summer. >> Incredible. Thank you. >> Thank you, Mr. Manager, for leading the way. Thank you for that. Uh we have Yes, Madam Vice Mayor. >> So, just on a more serious note, I I'm

1581
08:55:29.360 --> 08:55:48.478
sorry I couldn't resist the early one. what your client and you did best was listen to the comments that were received >> really enhancing this part to the next level and the architecture that was put in um really stepped it up to excellence

1582
08:55:48.478 --> 08:56:05.600
and that's what we're looking for in this park and we'll get we'll get it done right and I think that it will be the showcase for our city the band shell is going to answer a lot of questions a lot problems in our city uh for making

1583
08:56:05.600 --> 08:56:22.000
it a spectacular area for people to gather. So, thank you for all your efforts. >> But thank you for making the introduction to Mr. LaGuardia who we are having a fantastic time working with. She's been a lot of fun. >> Very, very capable. >> Uh we have a motion.

1584
08:56:22.000 --> 08:56:37.680
>> I'll move it. >> I'll second. >> And this, just for the record, this would be on E12. >> Yes. >> Commissioner Lada. Yes. >> Vice Mayor Anderson? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Castro? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Fernandez? >> Yes. >> Mayor Lago?

1585
08:56:37.680 --> 08:56:56.160
>> Yes. Moving on to item E13. >> I'll move it. >> I'll second. >> Do we need public comment? >> No, Mr. Mayor. >> All right. We have a motion in a second. >> Vice Mayor Anderson? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Castro? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Fernandez? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Lada? >> Yes. >> Mayor Lago?

1586
08:56:56.160 --> 08:57:16.398
>> Yes. Mayor, thank you very much. Thank you all. Best to the more. Thank you very much. Uh let's do item E6 and E10. E6 is an ordinance to the city commission amending ordinance number 2022-14 as amended which approved a planned area development for the

1587
08:57:16.398 --> 08:57:33.200
property property legally described as lots 5 through 27 block 28 Coral Gables craft section Coral Gables Florida to allow for completion of the public park following issuance of a certificate of occupancy subject to posting of a performance bond for such work and to require that the public park be dedicated to the city with the deed for the public park to be executed and held

1588
08:57:33.200 --> 08:57:49.360
in escrow with the city and then E10 which you will not be voting on today, but you'll you'll vote on um second reading. It's just on for your information. It's the resolution amending resolution 2022-81 as amended by resolution 2025-468 which approved the mixeduse site plan for the property

1589
08:57:49.360 --> 08:58:06.558
legally described as lots 5 through 27 block 28 Coral Gable's craft section Coral Gables, Florida to allow for completion of the public park following issuance of a certificate of occupancy such as the posting of a performance bond for such work and to require the public park be dedicated to the city with the deed for the public park to be executed and held in escrow. So, this is

1590
08:58:06.558 --> 08:58:23.440
where it all started. >> So, Mr. Manager, thank you very much. As we worked through this process, this is one of the six or seven parks that we're going to have now forthcoming in the downtown. And I don't know how, but it slipped through the cracks in regards to making sure

1591
08:58:23.440 --> 08:58:40.398
that this became that we own the park and we are here. And after we made after we made that misstep, every park moving forward, the manager and I made sure as we negotiated that it belonged to the city of Coral Gables. So >> this was a pilot program. That's >> Yes. Which is going to have which was a

1592
08:58:40.398 --> 08:58:56.798
pilot program which we learned a lot from the vice mayor, you know, relocating massive trees to a beautiful von span sculpture from New York uh to a park in an area that people thought was never going to get a park. Uh again, um

1593
08:58:56.798 --> 08:59:12.318
this is >> it's a beautiful beautiful park, but I wish you would have called this item before the mayor's item because now when you compare those parks. >> No, but I mean that that's this is a beautiful it's a beautiful park. >> No, it's a gorgeous park. >> It's a beautiful park and and it's purpose and it's a block away from Pon

1594
08:59:12.318 --> 08:59:28.080
Circle Park. >> It is. So again, the whole point is to put as many of these parks in the downtown, which again will pay huge dividends across the board for our property values, quality of life, and this is just an example of great art. We, you know, the vice mayor was able to save three trees uh that again,

1595
08:59:28.080 --> 08:59:43.040
>> which look beautiful, >> which are huge, >> huge going over the rightway. It's >> going right away, massive oak tree. >> Um and now with the art, with the trees, with the public public open space, and now as that building becomes more and more full of residents, you're going to see that area become more activated. So,

1596
08:59:43.040 --> 08:59:59.280
I think that's a that's an area in our core business district, which I think is going to just just really blossom with all these parks and all the art and all the things that are forthcoming over the next two years. So, >> it was great to work with you and the manager on this. I know it hasn't been easy, but I'm glad that >> Well, we got it to the finish line. >> We got it to the finish line.

1597
08:59:59.280 --> 09:00:15.040
>> Thank you, Mr. Manager. I appreciate that hard work. Thank you. >> Thank you, mayor. >> Been a pleasure working with the manager on this one. >> Anything else you like to say for the good of the order? >> That is all. I mean, we hope to have the park delivered within the next 30 to 60 days and then it will be uh conveyed over to the city. So, we're very excited

1598
09:00:15.040 --> 09:00:30.958
for it. >> When do you expect to have the artwork installed? >> So, the artwork right now, the foundation is there and they are assembling it at the warehouse to bring it over. >> Perfect. >> So, good. >> We want to make sure before the artwork is installed that all of the all of the turf is installed first. So, that'll be

1599
09:00:30.958 --> 09:00:46.638
the last item going in. the mayor, I just want to thank you and your client once again for being willing to save the trees that were healthy. I mean, it wasn't easy. And if any of you have doubts about how much effort was

1600
09:00:46.638 --> 09:01:01.520
put in, Paul Gable's magazine did cover this. And the sausage tree came from one side of Lune to the other side of Lun. And >> I'm still amazed we got it over there. >> Not only got it, >> but the crane lifted it over the

1601
09:01:01.520 --> 09:01:18.798
building. It was spectacular, but it show also shows the level of commitment that your client and you worked on to make it happen. So, thank you. And thank you on behalf of the community. >> We have a motion. >> I'll move it.

1602
09:01:18.798 --> 09:01:35.280
>> Second, Mr. Any public comment? >> No, Mr. Mayor. >> All right. >> Commissioner Castro, >> yes. >> Commissioner Fernandez, >> yes. >> Commissioner Lada, >> yes. >> Vice Mayor Anderson? >> Yes. Mayor Lago. >> Yes. Thank you all so much. >> Thank you very much. Good to see you.

1603
09:01:35.280 --> 09:01:52.318
Take care. All right. We're going to have uh F13, which is our final time serving item of the day. Please come up, sir. So, let me let me introduce you all uh to a young man that I've had the privilege of knowing for some time. Um he's going to introduce

1604
09:01:52.318 --> 09:02:08.318
himself and give a little background in regards to who he is. He's here with his lovely mother who is his biggest fan, and I can see why. uh he's worked at my office uh for some time. I think we've known each other for how long now? >> It's been almost a year I think >> year. Yeah. and we've kept in touch from

1605
09:02:08.318 --> 09:02:23.920
last summer and we've you know we've had the opportunity uh to work together and he took a semester off from from high school and he went to Washington to work and I wanted to talk a little bit about about um why he's here what he's doing

1606
09:02:23.920 --> 09:02:40.160
how he went in Washington what are his what are his uh his objectives uh what is he seeing for the near future and the reason why I asked him to be here is because I could have presented this idea but he brought me the idea idea and at the end of the day, another piece of legislation under

1607
09:02:40.160 --> 09:02:55.520
my belt is not going to make or break me. But the opport but the the ability to give this gentleman the opportunity to be up here and speak after how much he's impressed me over the last year, I think it's the best interest of the commission to hear from him. Sir, take it away.

1608
09:02:55.520 --> 09:03:12.080
>> All right. Thank you so much, Mayor, uh to the commission as well to the city manager, city clerk, and city attorney's office. And today, I just wanted to introduce myself first. My name is Diego Balstrini. I am a rising senior at Balen Jesuit Preparatory School. I just spent

1609
09:03:12.080 --> 09:03:28.638
a semester in Washington DC as a Senate page. So, with the mayor's help, I was able to apply and get nominated by Senator Tim Scott from South Carolina. And I served six months over there. We woke up at 5:00 a.m., went to school early in the mornings, and went to work

1610
09:03:28.638 --> 09:03:44.958
in the Senate on the floor. It was an amazing experience and I couldn't be more grateful for him to make for making it happen, for helping me make it happen. And today I think I just wanted to kind of touch on something that I've been thinking about for a while. I got inspired and during my time in DC, I

1611
09:03:44.958 --> 09:04:00.638
actually had a great friend who his city Kansas um a suburb of Kansas City has an existing um youth council, a teen council. And he told me all about it. how about like he was a community impact

1612
09:04:00.638 --> 09:04:15.040
director and how all the great things that he he'd done there. So I think I really it really inspired me to kind of try to make that initiative happen here in Coral Gables. Um and it just echoes like all that I learned from that experience. So a little bit more on the

1613
09:04:15.040 --> 09:04:31.680
experience itself. Um I was able to actually um meet my senator obviously I met um the team of Artemis 2. I met um the Olympic hockey team and I had so many great experiences there. So I just wanted to kind of touch on it a little

1614
09:04:31.680 --> 09:04:47.040
bit. It really inspired me to kind of think more about the importance of legislation and being responsible while um developing it. And uh it also kind of showed me how municipal and state government officials can actually make a lot more impact in our lives than

1615
09:04:47.040 --> 09:05:03.120
sometimes even federal officials. So, um that's another thing that I really wanted to echo here um today while I presented and first of all um I really wanted to thank the city for having that page program. I think it's a great initiative and I really wanted to

1616
09:05:03.120 --> 09:05:18.878
congratulate each and every one of the me the members that spoke today of the pages interns because they did a great job and it's hard to follow up on that but um I'll try my best. So, I'm going to hand out my um memorandum and an executive summary of what I'm here to present today. So what I requested from

1617
09:05:18.878 --> 09:05:36.160
this young man was to pass it up uh was to put forth a presentation that encompasses his desire um to have this program started here in the city of Coral Gables which is a little bit of a spin-off from what we have at the youth center which I was very clear with him

1618
09:05:36.160 --> 09:05:52.798
that we have something similar to this but to put together something that's all-encompassing in regards to Coral Gables and having as you saw how effective these young pages were today with the ideas that they came forward. I don't think it's I don't think it's anything again that wouldn't help the

1619
09:05:52.798 --> 09:06:09.520
city. At the end of the day, you get a completely different perspective uh from from as we saw today a multiple multiple opportunities that they come up with ideas that are right in front of us, but at the end of the day, we don't implement it. So, sir, the floor is yours. >> Thank you so much.

1620
09:06:09.520 --> 09:06:26.238
Um, I kind of wanted to talk today about the city of Coral Gables, what it means to me, and some of the values that I see echoed in in this proposal. So, I think Coral Gables always distinguish itself through thoughtful planning, civic engagement, and commitment to excellence above all else. And even now, like

1621
09:06:26.238 --> 09:06:41.918
involving the youth and having those programs is definitely a big priority for us as a city. I think I'm a lifelong Coral Gables resident and I couldn't say I'm more proud of of the city I live in and what we've done. So, um, I just kind of wanted to talk about expanding what

1622
09:06:41.918 --> 09:06:58.000
we currently have in the parks and recreation youth advisory board. Um, it kind of builds upon the foundation. I'm not proposing here to create another youth advisory board. I'm kind of talking about transforming the one that already exists and recommending to expand it into something called the

1623
09:06:58.000 --> 09:07:14.320
Coral Gables Teen Council. So, this will be a broader citywide advisory board and it's going to really reflect kind of a broader range of of issues including public safety, sustainability, transportation, historic preservation, economic development, innovation, and

1624
09:07:14.320 --> 09:07:30.960
civic engagement among other things. And I think that it could really just build upon what they already do in um parks and recreation. I think broadening that to having a youth kind of forum to kind of talk on and discuss every single aspect of living in Coral Gables could

1625
09:07:30.960 --> 09:07:46.558
be really good for our city. And in other words, it would give them um an official forum to participate in the future. And I think it would create really responsible and civically informed adults in the future. So u a little bit about the structure of my

1626
09:07:46.558 --> 09:08:02.078
proposed um council. So it would consist of 12 students grades 9 through 12 and they would serve two terms consistent with other city boards. U members would be appointed through the existing appointment process. So that would be

1627
09:08:02.078 --> 09:08:17.438
city manager, city commission and the mayor's office. And basically I'm thinking of proposing um an Instagram like online application so that we have a really diverse board um kind of from kids with from all over the city that come from all types of different

1628
09:08:17.438 --> 09:08:34.160
backgrounds and just like a merit-based application process where they can kind of apply and and become part of this of this initiative. So, um, some of the logistics of it, it would meet once a month during the school year and the quorum is 50 plus 1% kind of mirroring the board that we

1629
09:08:34.160 --> 09:08:49.840
already have. and um virtual attendance would count towards attendance towards the quorum because I know that transportation issues are definitely a big thing for for many young residents and I don't I don't want that to be an obstruction to

1630
09:08:49.840 --> 09:09:06.558
to attending meetings consistently and I don't really want to just create another meeting on the calendar. I just want to introduce an institution where people who want to be civic leaders in the future or want to make an impact on their community kind of have that voice and have the guidance of each and every

1631
09:09:06.558 --> 09:09:21.200
member of the people who are here today and and the community overall. So I think that across the country we have municipalities like the one in Ole Kansas even here in Miami we have Miami Lakes and and cities like that who who kind of have entities like this that

1632
09:09:21.200 --> 09:09:37.520
mirror their their commissions their city commissions. And I think it could be a great initiative just more of a year- round thing similar to the PACE program but that actually lasts throughout the academic year and provides a consistent opportunity. So I

1633
09:09:37.520 --> 09:09:53.918
think that I'm I'm really fortunate to have received all this guidance and mentorship from the mayor and I kind of want everyone to have that experience and and just not be a summer thing but maybe a year round thing. So I think that we have a lot to contribute when we are given meaningful responsibility as

1634
09:09:53.918 --> 09:10:10.480
youth and I think that proposal makes all that the more possible here in Coral Gables and my home. So it's more of a partnership and recognizes everything. I'm very grateful for what the city already does and expands opportunities for all the students who call Coral

1635
09:10:10.480 --> 09:10:25.680
Gables home. So, thank you again for your time, each and every one of you, for your service to Coral Gables and your consideration of this proposal, and I would be more than happy to answer any questions. >> Uh, thank you, Diego. What I'm going to request is, well, I'm going to talk about two things. First and foremost, uh, one of the things that we after

1636
09:10:25.680 --> 09:10:41.520
doing some research, we noticed that uh, the current council, which is with the youth center, hasn't met in in many months. Correct. They've been having some forum issues, right? Uh, do do we do we have uh, currently any openings on that board? >> Not as of today, sir. Did we have any

1637
09:10:41.520 --> 09:10:56.640
openings from last time? >> Yes, we did. But we those openings were filled during today's consent agenda. >> How many openings did we have? >> Two. >> How long were those openings there for? >> I couldn't tell you right now, Mr. Mayor. >> So, um, at the end of the day, we've had openings on that board. That's why that

1638
09:10:56.640 --> 09:11:11.840
board hasn't met for months and months and months. We weren't able to have quorum. Um, so I think it's again critically it's incumbent of the elected officials number one to put people on these boards. you're not if you're not putting people on the boards uh when there's an immediate opening. Again, at

1639
09:11:11.840 --> 09:11:26.480
the end of the day, we can't do can't do the business at hand because we depend on those boards. So, that's uh number one. Number two, um I'd like for my colleagues to review this and I'm going to put this item on the next agenda. >> Perfect. >> And I'd like further input. So, Mr.

1640
09:11:26.480 --> 09:11:42.398
clerk. Um, through the manager, I'd like to put this item on the next agenda, but I want all my colleagues to provide input to the manager so we can all be on one page and talk about this. Uh, this young man has put a lot of work into this. Very proud of you.

1641
09:11:42.398 --> 09:11:58.160
>> You're always very concise and on and on point. You take things very very seriously. Um, that's why it was an honor for me to recommend you uh for that position in the Senate. And I've had the pleasure of spending time with Senator Tim Scott. Uh, he's a national treasure. If you learn a little bit more about him and what he stands for and

1642
09:11:58.160 --> 09:12:14.320
what his family's been through uh in this country, um it's a truly amazing uh success story on what it is to be an American. His f his brother's a physician. Um and they they came from I think it was great great

1643
09:12:14.320 --> 09:12:30.238
grandparents were slaves. >> Yeah. >> And uh if you get a chance to read his book and understand a little bit about his background, he's an amazingly accomplished individual. uh and he has a a real love affair with this great country. So, I'm so happy you got to

1644
09:12:30.238 --> 09:12:45.122
experience something that I envy you that I didn't get a chance to experience. I've had the pleasure of experiencing time with him, but not at the level that you did. >> Uh so, I congratulate you on that. >> So, I'd like for my uh I'd like for this to be on the next agenda. >> Yes, sir.

1645
09:12:45.122 --> 09:13:02.320
>> Um for my colleagues to review these comments and see how we can see how we can adopt this. I'd like for this board to have more teeth and to engage young professionals uh across the board uh you know who are willing to come here like the page we have these great young men

1646
09:13:02.320 --> 09:13:18.558
and women who are here who have given up a month of their summer to be here with the city and I worked on these presentations I'd like for them to engage in this board you know maybe we don't have one person per commissioner maybe we name two people per commissioner you know what would it hurt these are young young kids that again the more the marrier the more

1647
09:13:18.558 --> 09:13:34.718
experienced the more minds in in a room that are willing to give up their time, I think is a great idea. Uh, so I congratulate you once again and this will be on the next commission and hopefully my colleagues will will give it the attention it deserves and we'll be able to restructure restructure uh

1648
09:13:34.718 --> 09:13:51.122
this board and uh, you know, really give it the teeth it needs so that we can get some input from the future leaders of tomorrow. >> Yeah, perfect. That's exactly the mayor. >> Yes. Um, well, I'm gonna go along the lines of what you were

1649
09:13:51.122 --> 09:14:07.040
doing earlier. I have to boast about our Wolverines who have been in the room today. Um, uh, you did a great job. Um, I think just going through this, uh, the level of detail that you put into this, how you should we should format it, how we should make it work is incredible.

1650
09:14:07.040 --> 09:14:24.480
Um, I think Mr. Mayor, today has been a perfect example of why this board uh could really help our city. uh the things that were recommended by our pages uh are are things that we didn't even think about uh or we didn't even consider because it's affecting a new generation and our role as commissioners

1651
09:14:24.480 --> 09:14:40.960
here is to ensure that we're setting it up for that next generation. So it's important that you are also part of that process making sure that you're setting up the city for what you want it to be. Uh so I appreciate you bringing this up and thank you for all the time that you devoted to this and taking the time to

1652
09:14:40.960 --> 09:14:57.598
to serve up there in DC. Uh, I had the privilege of starting off as an intern in Congress myself with Congresswoman Ross Leightton, worked my way into into her office, and that's really the reason that I'm here today. Uh, I was going to study meteorology, and I changed my major because of that experience. So,

1653
09:14:57.598 --> 09:15:15.160
um, it's a life-changing experience, and I'm glad that you were able to do it, and uh, I look forward to continuing to work with you on this project. >> Thank you so much. >> May I have a motion? >> I'll move it. I'll second.

1654
09:15:17.438 --> 09:15:34.160
>> So, it's a it's a motion to bring this back next meeting. Okay. >> Yes. >> I want to make sure it's that we bring it back. >> So, it's a direction for >> a direction to bring it back and obviously for my colleagues to review this and give input to the manager so that we can put together a board that again is reflective of all the hard work that this young man has put together.

1655
09:15:34.160 --> 09:15:51.278
>> Commissioner Fernandez. >> Yes. >> Commissioner L. Um just um to the mayor if um if the if the clerk would maybe mind sending I know you do this periodically but just before the next meeting as soon as practical to send each and every one of

1656
09:15:51.278 --> 09:16:06.718
the commissioners an email identifying any o open positions on >> absolutely yes sir we'll do >> actually I've been asked by people hey do you have an opening in this or and uh he says an extra step so maybe just send one of those before the next one so we

1657
09:16:06.718 --> 09:16:22.398
can keep them filled so that with that He said yes. Thank you, sir. Vice Mayor Anderson, >> yes. >> Commissioner Castro, >> yes. >> Mayor Log, >> yes. Diego, enjoy the rest of your summer. >> Well done. >> Thank you so much. >> Thank you for making me look good. >> All right, we're going to take a

1658
09:16:22.398 --> 09:25:53.680
two-minut break, bathroom break, and then we're going to do E1 and E2. Correct. Well, E1. Yes. recording stopped. developer. >> Change of plans. Let's start with E2 really quick because that takes up

1659
09:25:53.680 --> 09:26:09.680
>> through the mayor. >> Yes. >> Um I would I found out during the break that I do have a vacancy on the youth advisory board. So if my colleagues would entertain it, I would like to make a motion to appoint Mr. Balstrinia's uh my appointee to that board. >> Perfect. Sir,

1660
09:26:09.680 --> 09:26:25.436
is there a second? I'll second. All in favor? >> I >> I >> Thank you. >> Thank Congratulations. >> Thank you. >> Well done. Moving on to item E2 and then we'll do E1. >> E2 is an ordinance of the city commission amending zoning code article

1661
09:26:25.436 --> 09:26:42.160
14 process section 14-208 appeals and section 15-103 reconsideration of city architect administrative determination to revise appeal procedures extension deadlines and notice of appeal requirements limiting the scope of stays. Establishing provisions regarding consolidation related approvals finality and abandonment of appeals providing for

1662
09:26:42.160 --> 09:26:58.320
severability providing for repeated provision providing for severability clause and an effective date. >> Good afternoon Mr. Mayor vice mayor commissioners to the city attorney Gusa Bios. So only one change on second reading. We did we were going through the code and we realized that the

1663
09:26:58.320 --> 09:27:15.360
appeals for city architect was tucked in under section 15-103. So, we found that we've added it to this and we also making it consistent with the staff appeals which is 15 days. >> Perfect. >> Um, any public comment? >> No, Mr. Mayor. >> May I have a motion?

1664
09:27:15.360 --> 09:27:31.200
>> May I have a second? >> Second, >> Mr. Clerk. >> Vice Mayor Anderson? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Castro? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Fernandez? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Lada? >> Yes. >> Mayor Logo? >> Yes. Thank you, Mr. City Attorney. Item E1. E1 is an ordinance to the city

1665
09:27:31.200 --> 09:27:47.200
commission amending ordinance number 1952 as amended which change the zoning on lots 1 2 3 20 21 22 23 and 24 block 120 and lots 1 through 5 block 131 country club section 6 Coral Gables Florida remove certain conditions of approval for lots 1 through 5 block 131

1666
09:27:47.200 --> 09:28:01.360
that limit the use of the property to overflow parking and two that revert the zoning of the property under certain circumstances to single family zoning. All of the conditions of approval contained in ordinance number 1952 shall remain in in effect. Mr. Clerk, please swear and everyone who will be

1667
09:28:01.360 --> 09:28:34.000
testifying today. Those who will be appearing on this item, please stand and raise your right hand. Do you swear or affirm the testimony you'll provide today will be the truth and nothing but the truth? >> Thank you, >> Madam Director.

1668
09:28:34.000 --> 09:28:52.240
>> Good afternoon. There have been no changes since first reading and we're here for questions. >> Thank you very much. Mr. Kirk, you said there was so many point I wanted to present. On the other side, >> there are multiple speakers. One of them

1669
09:28:52.240 --> 09:29:24.320
has a Okay, perfect. Let's hear the public speakers. >> First speaker is Jackson Holmes. >> Yes, sir. >> Okay. Okay. So, um the the best moment I had in the last thing that we did on this

1670
09:29:24.320 --> 09:29:39.120
was I got a laugh out of you all about a the most beautiful dog in the world. Uh let's see if we can bring up that picture because this dog that you're going to see lives in Coral Gables on Cordova Street and I'll see if anyone can remember what type of dog it is. the

1671
09:29:39.120 --> 09:29:57.840
most beautiful dog in the entire world. It's a type of dog. Oh, you got Oh, yeah. Okay. So, can y'all y'all look at that one? >> You may remember Mr. >> Okay. So, you you see this is a dog right here on Kabay whatever street it

1672
09:29:57.840 --> 09:30:12.800
is there. Cordova, >> his name is Justin and that's a blue merl collic. And this is why among a thousand reasons, uh, Miss Anderson, I support

1673
09:30:12.800 --> 09:30:28.960
the dog park because when you get out to South Beach and you see these beautiful dogs from around the world, it's it's it's an elevating experience. We we think, you know, well, I shouldn't make this joke, but I talked too much.

1674
09:30:28.960 --> 09:30:44.480
You have beautiful women on South Beach walking beautiful dogs and then at some point you say which is better? Not really. You but but the thing is it's uplifting. And if we have a dog park which like they have on South Beach, you

1675
09:30:44.480 --> 09:31:01.436
see the most beautiful dogs in the world, right? Forget the women. I'm just think of the dog. No joke. And anyway, so with that, I I want to just say, as I did before, I support this dog park. Um, one final thought.

1676
09:31:01.436 --> 09:31:18.320
Uh, I think there's no doubt that dogs are man's best friend. Uh, but I wonder sometimes if man is dog's best friend. Let's prove that men and women are dog's best friend. Let's

1677
09:31:18.320 --> 09:31:40.240
have this dog park. Thank you, sir. Mr. Clerk, >> Rose Power. >> Rose Power Bower. >> Good evening. >> Hello. My name is Rose Bower. I live at 3716 Segoia Street. I'm a Gable's resident

1678
09:31:40.240 --> 09:31:56.000
specialist real estate broker with 30 years of experience. I appreciate the opportunity to speak on my concern. The commission's responsibility is to protect the public health, safety, and welfare. First and foremost is safety. This

1679
09:31:56.000 --> 09:32:12.240
location is on a heavily traveled roadway with fastmoving traffic for safe pedestrian crossing. Families with young children, seniors, and dog owners would be expected to cross the street to reach the park. Children could act impulsively. Often, dogs can

1680
09:32:12.240 --> 09:32:28.240
unexpectedly pull away from their owners. In fact, my own cat was run over and killed on University Drive a few years ago. This proposal creates an unnecessary and foreseeable high risk of injury or death to both people and

1681
09:32:28.240 --> 09:32:45.436
animals. I respectfully ask you carefully consider whether this location meets that standard. I also believe the commission should consider the potential effect on the surrounding residential community. Buyers evaluate the noise levels, traffic patterns, parking

1682
09:32:45.436 --> 09:33:02.960
issues, and the quality of the neighborhood. Residents have invested significantly for their homes with the expectation that surrounding land uses will remain compatible with the residential character of the neighborhood. A dog park generates homeless traffic security concerns.

1683
09:33:02.960 --> 09:33:19.200
Parking congestion and parking immediately adjacent to homes will likely make all nearby properties lose value. I respectfully ask the commission to place public safety, neighborhood compatibility, and the long-term welfare of this community at the forefront of

1684
09:33:19.200 --> 09:33:44.880
its decision. Thank you. >> Thank you, Sylvia King. My name is Sylvia King. I live at 3617 Harlana Street and am an attorney assisting the University Green case against the city. With all due respect,

1685
09:33:44.880 --> 09:34:00.320
I renew my motion for Vice Mayor Anderson to abstain from voting on this and all issues related to the proposed Bark Park at 520 University. I incorporate by reference my previous motion and the one filed with the clerk and city attorney last week and ask that

1686
09:34:00.320 --> 09:34:17.596
both be made part of the record. When I first raised this issue, the city attorney advised that recusal is the vice mayor's own decision whether she believes she can be fair and impartial. With respect, the question is not whether she subjectively believes she is unbiased, but whether the association

1687
09:34:17.596 --> 09:34:32.960
has a reasonable, wellfounded fear that she is prejudiced. That is an objective standard. Under either standard, one thing is clear. The vice mayor's mind was made up long before this application to amend ordinance 1952.

1688
09:34:32.960 --> 09:34:49.360
First, she has been pushing for a dog park on the lot adjacent to the library irrespective of the residents wishes since at least October 11th, 2022. At that meeting, she forcefully advocated for this location without notice to the

1689
09:34:49.360 --> 09:35:06.400
affected neighbors. That is not the posture of a neutral decision maker. that is an advocate who has already chosen an outcome. Second, at the second at the July 2nd reading, she removed any doubt herself, acknowledging on the record that she was

1690
09:35:06.400 --> 09:35:22.800
voting for the majority who wanted a dog park, not on the merits of this application. That is vote counting, not adjudic adjudicating. And third, before that reading, she was seated in the gallery alongside the Dark Parks proponents. I've attached a photo to my

1691
09:35:22.800 --> 09:35:39.360
motion where a decision maker sits and with whom before hearing a word of testimony speaks volumes. She prejudged this four years ago and her actions since confirm she is not impartial. Vice Mayor Anderson should recuse herself. If

1692
09:35:39.360 --> 09:35:54.640
the commission denies this motion and proceeds with the vice mayor voting, we ask in the alternative that this matter be continued. Just yesterday in open court, the city admitted there are no funds and no donors for this project and

1693
09:35:54.640 --> 09:36:10.320
represented it would be at least three years before it could move forward. Given that, the city should not single out 520 University from the other parcels in ordinance 1952 and hastily advance a project with no funding and no

1694
09:36:10.320 --> 09:36:26.800
private sponsor. Finally, should the commission approve this matter today, we ask that implementation be stayed pending cersuri review. The issues in we intend to raise include, but are not limited to, whether adequate notice was

1695
09:36:26.800 --> 09:36:42.160
given to all affected parcels, whether 520 can lawfully be treated separately from the rest of ordinance 1952, whether the city's action is arbitrary and capriccious, and whether vice mayor Anderson should have recused herself. We

1696
09:36:42.160 --> 09:36:57.596
respectfully ask in the order presented recusal first, a continuence in the alternative, and a stay pending review if all else fails. In addition to more parking photos and um

1697
09:36:57.596 --> 09:37:16.360
um petitions to not have a dog park, uh I would like to exhibit to submit, excuse me, exhibits from our case that support recusal. Thank you. Thank you very much, >> Lyn W part.

1698
09:37:36.160 --> 09:37:52.880
There's a PowerPoint that goes along with this. Thank you. >> And the clicker should be there with you. >> They told me all I had to do was say next, but >> you could do that as well. >> It's a center one. >> Yes. >> Thank you. Good. Good evening. My name

1699
09:37:52.880 --> 09:38:08.960
is Lin Guardo. I live at 421 Kadima Avenue. I've lived there for over 36 years and I am a member of the uh University Green Neighbors Association. We have a presentation which offers a truly legal and compatible option to the

1700
09:38:08.960 --> 09:38:25.520
destruction of 520 University Triangle. As it exists today, the Triangle is open to many dogs who enjoy it every day. But some dogs, as you can see, are not candidates for dog parks, and they will no longer have access to be able to walk

1701
09:38:25.520 --> 09:38:43.040
the Triangle daily. We have a solution or a suggestion for a better location which is closer to home and it moves the dog park closer to the supporters who signed the original petition.

1702
09:38:43.040 --> 09:39:02.720
That would be the youth cent's west parking lot. As you can see in the picture, that west parking lot is uh an area that we feel we have 20 reasons why this new location works. This location complies with city and

1703
09:39:02.720 --> 09:39:18.400
county codes. Dog parks in Miami Dade are allowed only as a minor use within a larger park. This location does not share a property line with single family residences. It also would not change the property from passive green space to a

1704
09:39:18.400 --> 09:39:34.320
dog park. This location is zoned for park use. Really, it really is not uh unlike University 520 University where there are restrictions.

1705
09:39:34.320 --> 09:39:51.200
This has no restriction that would prevent a park use. This location falls within the city's preferred geographic boundaries of Bird Road to Coral Way and Lejun to Granada. And this location is located closer to many of the pro- dog

1706
09:39:51.200 --> 09:40:06.320
park petition signers, ensuring an easy walk for neighborhood dog owners and their pop pups. As you see in this graphic, the black dots are people who signed that original petition.

1707
09:40:06.320 --> 09:40:27.520
By moving this dog park to the west lot of the U Center, it's closer to where the majority of those black dots exist. In addition, repurposing this lot will not impact the library or the church or

1708
09:40:27.520 --> 09:40:43.916
the school parking. This lot is currently reserved only for youth center patrons and staff. This lot already has access to water, electric, and drainage, making startup and maintenance costs more affordable.

1709
09:40:43.916 --> 09:41:00.560
The lot size is consistent with customary neighborhood dog park dimensions. The city could meet with dog owners in the area to prioritize amenities. This site could provide one entrance from Riviera and another one from Anastasia.

1710
09:41:00.560 --> 09:41:16.800
Though small and dog large and small dog park dogs would have their own spaces to run and play on natural grass, there's room for benches to watch pups at play and neighbors to chat. And installing backless benches east of the

1711
09:41:16.800 --> 09:41:32.880
fencing would allow two views. As you can see in the picture, there are two access points to this area. The site can accommodate two separate doublegated entrances for large and small dogs.

1712
09:41:32.880 --> 09:41:48.000
Riviera from the south and Estasia from the north. This lot has a row of mature shade trees offering shade and sunlight. No artificial turf is needed at this site unless it's desired. This lot is away

1713
09:41:48.000 --> 09:42:03.756
from the library, the youth center, and church and school entrances. It's also away from University Drive, making it a much safer location. This lot has low parkage usage. Overflow parking is also available. It's the Christmas tree and big box recycling

1714
09:42:03.756 --> 09:42:18.960
station each January. The location will not disrupt microhabitats or sensitive areas. It is not near the butterfly garden and 520 university microhabitats. Replacing asphalt and bumpers with

1715
09:42:18.960 --> 09:42:34.000
natural grass is good for the planet. Perimeter fences can be drilled into the inside of curbs to prevent digging. As you see in the picture, there already exists shade for cooler temperatures,

1716
09:42:34.000 --> 09:42:58.640
and there's also sun for natural turf. Having an on-site youth center grounds team ensures convenient frequent attention. >> Miss Part, will you do me the pleasure? You've gone over by over two minutes. >> I have four more points if you don't

1717
09:42:58.640 --> 09:43:15.200
mind letting me finish. >> Not a problem. I'm just making you aware you've gone over by two minutes. Thank you very much. >> Having an on-site youth center grounds team ensures convenient, frequent attention. Executive oversight is also available. The youth center staff can open and close the gates daily except

1718
09:43:15.200 --> 09:43:31.596
when the center is closed. Coordinating with neighborhood policing when the youth center is closed would help with that option. Maintenance and operational costs are more sustainable and affordable. There's also no need to install and maintain a 25 ft landscape

1719
09:43:31.596 --> 09:43:47.120
buffer. Siggoia Street has lower traffic volumes than University Drive, making it safer for dogs and their owners, youth center, and library patrons and commuters. And last, but not least, this site provides a powerful naming

1720
09:43:47.120 --> 09:44:04.080
opportunity to honor military dogs killed in action, which is consistent with the War Memorial Youth C Center's original and central purpose. This is an opportunity to move forward for the dogs, the people, and the place.

1721
09:44:04.080 --> 09:44:20.080
This plan honors the wish for a nearby dog park, maintains the flexibility of overflow parking for the library, preserves the city's commitment to the neighborhood, and protects the microhabitat. We ask you, the commission, to continue

1722
09:44:20.080 --> 09:44:37.360
this item to a future meeting so you and your staff can study the benefits of this alternate site. I appreciate the extra minutes. I have watched all of this commission meeting. I know that other um commenters had extra time also. I

1723
09:44:37.360 --> 09:44:58.000
appreciate mine. Thank you. >> William Ryvenbark. >> Good evening. My name is Bill Ryvenbark and I am a member of the University Green Neighbors Association, a 501c4.

1724
09:44:58.000 --> 09:45:15.596
I live at 3616 Harlano Street and I have an amazing rescue dog who has got extremely strong beliefs of his own. He is a Belgian Malinino named Merrick and I can assure you that he does not want a

1725
09:45:15.596 --> 09:45:33.040
dog park to be at 520 University Drive. This process has been riddled with inconsistencies, none of which make a good look for you all, I'm afraid to say. On November 18th, 2025, as the city commission voted

1726
09:45:33.040 --> 09:45:49.120
on a resolution to develop a dog park at 520 University Drive, Vice Mayor Anderson told the supporters in the room, "This is for the neighborhood so neighbors can walk their dogs to the B dog park. But something very important

1727
09:45:49.120 --> 09:46:05.916
was missing. People, residents, homeowners from the actual neighborhood, including those like me that already walk their dog around the triangle. When the neighborhood learned about the vote after the fact, we were told, "You

1728
09:46:05.916 --> 09:46:22.400
should have checked the agenda." Are we really to believe the people in the room on November 18th knew about the meeting because they checked the agenda? an item this consequential to the neighborhood and the passive green space. And there

1729
09:46:22.400 --> 09:46:38.960
was no posting, there were no mailed letters, there was no notification to the nearby residents. Commissioner Laura, on January 13th, you said, "I can't for the life of me know why you didn't know, but I have no reason to

1730
09:46:38.960 --> 09:46:55.200
doubt you." Sir, did you ever ask staff if they had reached out to the neighborhood about a dog park on the property before it was placed on the agenda? Feel free to ask them now, but we all know what the answer will be. And

1731
09:46:55.200 --> 09:47:12.080
it's interesting to note when there was finally an after-the-act community meeting on the dog park, it was widely publicized on a citywide level. Yet nothing, excuse me, yet nothing for the resolution to approve the dog park

1732
09:47:12.080 --> 09:47:28.320
itself. The parks director told you door hangers were standard for neighborhood notifications. Yet, not only our entire street, but our entire neighborhood was skipped. The parks director said he would look into it. Yet, we heard nothing and still have

1733
09:47:28.320 --> 09:47:43.360
not. Speaking of hearing nothing, a report was going to be written about the meeting and presented to the commission. The parks director has reported several times to the parks advisory board that they are still working on it.

1734
09:47:43.360 --> 09:47:59.436
The city's handling of petitions in favor of this property was greatly flawed. If given more time, it would be easy to prove the flaws. Throughout the process, we spoke about

1735
09:47:59.436 --> 09:48:14.800
the national criteria for dog parks. This included developing a dog park master plan rather than creating them peace meal. Don't pick a site where the neighbors don't want it. Don't locate it near single family homes. Don't locate

1736
09:48:14.800 --> 09:48:32.800
locate it on hightra streets. Locate it where there is ample parking. Don't pick a site that is environmentally sensitive or a site that has meaning to the neighbors. Due to the time, I will jump uh to something hopefully more important that

1737
09:48:32.800 --> 09:48:51.436
that is quite noteworthy to us. The information is helpful uh well researched for when studying where to place a dog park. But several cities have

1738
09:48:51.436 --> 09:49:08.160
rules where they outright disqualify a site from consideration if it is closer than 200 ft from a home. Yet your proposed dog park calls for a 25- ft landscape buffer and you treat it as if

1739
09:49:08.160 --> 09:49:24.240
it's lush and gorgeous and generous. Today you are voting on a zoning change to make 520 a park. For the last several months, we have been repeatingly told that this is already a park. It has

1740
09:49:24.240 --> 09:49:44.000
never been zoned as a park. 520 University site has specific restrictions which preclude it from being a park. So rather than admit someone made a mistake, you are seeking to change the zoning so it can be a

1741
09:49:44.000 --> 09:49:59.596
park. Words smmithing and rationalization aside, this process now requires a zoning change. And while the city has said you are following the process, she failed to disclose the requirements leading up to today's vote

1742
09:49:59.596 --> 09:50:15.756
and have not been followed in the least. >> Excuse me. before going to planning and >> you've gone over by 2 minutes and 15 seconds. Would you bring it in for a landing? Thank you. >> Yes, sir. I can do that. >> Thank you. >> While we can document doc, excuse me, document over 100 errors and false

1743
09:50:15.756 --> 09:50:31.596
statements, I would rather use this time to encourage you to consider a better location as outlined in the PowerPoint you just saw. It's closer to supporters, complies with Dade County codes, and is safer for pedestrians and dogs. They're

1744
09:50:31.596 --> 09:50:50.120
environmentally and financially more responsible. Please take that suggestion seriously. Thank you for the extra time. >> Thank you, sir. >> Mr. Clerk. >> Gene Davis. >> Good evening.

1745
09:50:52.320 --> 09:51:09.520
>> My name is Ganne Davis and I'm a member of the University Green Neighborhood Association. I am a full-time resident and owner of 3710 Harlano Street. I would like to address the need to preserve the microhabitat ordered by University

1746
09:51:09.520 --> 09:51:25.520
Riviera and Katama. It's home to butterflies, bats, and birds. It's home to a number of different types of butterflies. To name a few, they're monarchs, large or orange sulfers, and

1747
09:51:25.520 --> 09:51:40.720
my personal favorite, the dainty sulfers. Recently, the Miami chapter of the North American Butterfly Association conducted a census on the property. They noted the relationship between the butterflies

1748
09:51:40.720 --> 09:51:57.276
on the library site which has a butterfly garden and the site that is being considered in today's meeting. They expressed that irreparable harm would be created to the microhabitat

1749
09:51:57.276 --> 09:52:13.120
by a fenced off leash dog park with artificial turf. There is talk in our neighborhood that we may well have bats in the neighborhood. Nocturnal sounds have been heard and observational studies are

1750
09:52:13.120 --> 09:52:29.680
underway. The Florida bonneted bat is a protected species and it may be making itself at home in our neighborhood. As a member of a garden club, I've had the privilege of hearing the distinguished professor from the

1751
09:52:29.680 --> 09:52:47.276
University of Miami School of Architecture, Joanna Lumbard, present on gardens, greens, and schools. And here is a memorable quote from one of her the research papers. In naturalized areas versus areas

1752
09:52:47.276 --> 09:53:03.596
constructed with playgrounds, children exhibit more imaginative roleplaying, fantasy, and exploration of the environment for longer periods of time with greater variety in different types of play and a reduction in

1753
09:53:03.596 --> 09:53:20.400
conflict behavior. So this area provides an unstructured love of nature. The property under review today offers a great variety of birds. We have

1754
09:53:20.400 --> 09:53:37.596
cardinals, blue jays, even eastern screech owls, but my favorite is the ibis. The ibis often arrive after a rain and they feed in the grass. the grass that the city is contemplating putting

1755
09:53:37.596 --> 09:53:55.276
artificial turf over. It would be a shame to eliminate eliminate the habitat of this majestic bird. Besides, it's not nice to hurt Sebastian. I stand before you

1756
09:53:55.276 --> 09:54:12.520
committed to maintaining the quality of my neighborhood and to remind you of the hypocratic dictim. first do no harm. Thank you for your time and attention. >> Thank you very much, >> Maria Cruz.

1757
09:54:29.040 --> 09:54:49.596
Mrs. Maria Cruz, 1447 Miller Road, 305 323 2154. Sitting here thinking, and I know that some people do not like when I say here we go again, but this is

1758
09:54:49.596 --> 09:55:11.120
a perfect example of here we go again. There is a court date in December. Why are we pushing this today? I know the answer. The sooner we push it, the sooner we can start doing what the neighbors don't want and then we'll

1759
09:55:11.120 --> 09:55:26.160
claim that we've already spent too much money. So, we must keep doing it. That's one answer. The other other answer is who cares? We don't care what the neighbors want. we want this and we're

1760
09:55:26.160 --> 09:55:42.560
going to do it one way or the other. But I was smiling and laughing when I when I was coming up because today we had another big project that had a lot of people on both sides and we were

1761
09:55:42.560 --> 09:55:57.756
impressed because there were lots of people here that weren't supporting the project. Well, I don't know where the supporters are now. I wonder if they miss reading the agenda because they certainly did not

1762
09:55:57.756 --> 09:56:13.756
show up tonight. Either that or I guess they think that is a done deal and they don't have to come and talk because somebody has assured them is going to happen regardless what the people want because it's not what the people want.

1763
09:56:13.756 --> 09:56:28.960
It's what individuals want. you were giving an opportunity today to consider an alternate site. It made a lot of sense. What's the pressure to get this going

1764
09:56:28.960 --> 09:56:46.240
when there's a possibility if you look into it that you may be able to do it in a better place with happier people and in reality pleasing those that are asking for it, which are not the ones that live right next door. I think it's

1765
09:56:46.240 --> 09:57:03.680
time for you all to think about what uh residents, the one that pay the taxes want and not the people that only want it but not next to their house. >> Mr. Clerk, >> that's it. Mr. Ry, >> before we move on, madam city attorney,

1766
09:57:03.680 --> 09:57:20.000
will you please clarify what the purpose of E1 is? >> Yes, mayor. So, I will read the the title, but I think if I may suggest, maybe we can have the planning and zoning director kind of kind of u >> remind us um as she did last meeting what what clarify because I've heard accomplished here because I've heard the

1767
09:57:20.000 --> 09:57:35.436
same over over and over. >> So, mayor, just just to kind of um review the title. So, it's an ordinance that would amend ordinance number 1952, which changed the zoning on lots 1 2 3 20 21 22 23 24 block 120 and lots 1

1768
09:57:35.436 --> 09:57:50.960
through 5, block 131 country club section 6. So, it's the addresses that we know as 430, 440, 450, and 520 University Drive to remove certain conditions of approval for lots 1 through 5, block 131, which is the 520 University Drive. And that is to remove

1769
09:57:50.960 --> 09:58:06.080
the conditions, one that limit the use of the property to overflow parking. two that revert the zoning of the property under certain circumstances to single family zoning and um maintaining all the other conditions. >> Madam director, >> so yes, before you today is an amendment

1770
09:58:06.080 --> 09:58:21.360
to that ordinance. It's not changing the zoning. The zoning remain to be special use zoning. What you're doing is you're looking at page two. You can see but we're suggesting to change in that ordinance um only applying to 520 University Drive. We're removing the

1771
09:58:21.360 --> 09:58:38.720
condition that has to be closed for those lots when not used for overflow parking and to allow it to be not only overflow parking but also to be allowed to be used as a park. Not specifically any kind of park with any kind of kind of amenity but a park in general for public use without it being gated or

1772
09:58:38.720 --> 09:58:56.160
penc. And and then also removing that reverber clause that if it's not being used for parking then it would revert back to to single family. Removing that al together. >> Thank you very much. Um, anything else for the good of the order? Commission?

1773
09:58:56.160 --> 09:59:12.800
If not, may I have a motion? I'll move it. And I'll just reiterate that um, this talks about the property not being, you know, used for off- streetet parking. It shall not be paved, which will be consistent with

1774
09:59:12.800 --> 09:59:30.880
maintaining um, the property for birds and and ibis. all this this particular um ordinance does. I'll move it. >> Yep. >> We have a second.

1775
09:59:30.880 --> 09:59:49.916
>> Second. Anyone? >> Mr. Clerk, we have a motion and a second. >> Commissioner Castro. >> Commissioner Fernandez. Consistent with my vote on the first reading, uh, I believe if it ain't broke, don't fix it. No.

1776
09:59:49.916 --> 10:00:06.160
>> Commissioner Lada. >> Yes. >> Vice Mayor Anderson? >> Yes. >> Mayor Logo? >> Yes. Um, Madam City attorney, will you also go go over Will you also go over uh today's court proceedings? >> Yes, Mayor. So, um, in the lawsuit that

1777
10:00:06.160 --> 10:00:21.596
was filed by the association and one individual um, resident, >> which association was that? the University Green Neighbors Association. >> Um, and there's an individually named plaintiff as well. Um, >> who is that? >> Jose Val Cohen. >> I just want to make sure we put on the record.

1778
10:00:21.596 --> 10:00:38.640
>> And, um, there was, uh, the plaintiffs filed an emergency motion seeking injunctive relief to, among other things, stop the second reading of this ordinance. Um, the court scheduled an evidentiary hearing for yesterday. There was six hours of evidentiary hearing yesterday evening. Um it was concluded

1779
10:00:38.640 --> 10:00:55.680
today with um closing arguments via Zoom and the court ruled from the bench and denied the motion for injunctive relief. Okay. >> The emergency motion for injunction. >> Okay. >> What is the next what is the next steps moving forward? >> So the lawsuit proceeds but we were able to have today's um second reading and

1780
10:00:55.680 --> 10:01:11.360
but the lawsuit proceeds. So we are you know essentially proceeding with the lawsuit. There's been no um final determination. I just want to make sure we put on the record because the media asks. Want to make sure that we have the appropriate information on the record from the city attorney. >> All right, moving on. >> Mayor, >> yes.

1781
10:01:11.360 --> 10:01:27.276
>> I have a request from city manager. We received today um an alternative location which staff has not had an opportunity to look at. I'd like for staff to look at this and provide feedback.

1782
10:01:27.276 --> 10:01:48.240
>> So, the mayor, >> yes. Uh uh. Yes, Vox mayor. We'll be happy to look at it and and and give feedback. >> Thank you. Thank you. All right. Moving on to item E3. E3 is an ordinance of the city commission amending chapter 54 solid

1783
10:01:48.240 --> 10:02:04.560
waste article 3 collection and disposal to amend section 52-121 rolloff waste contractors franchise agreements of the city code updating certain requirements and establishing requirements for the securing removal and emergency management of rolloff containers during tropical storm and hurricane events providing for penalties cost recovery

1784
10:02:04.560 --> 10:02:19.436
and non-renewal franchise agreements for non-compliance providing for severability repeated provision codification and providing for an effective State mayor, if you allow me, it's my pleasure to, you know, introduce to you all in person our new assistant city attorney, Yenia Alonso. Um, Yenia

1785
10:02:19.436 --> 10:02:35.200
Alonso um was actually an intern with our office back in 2018 when Miriam Moramos was city attorney. So, we're very happy that she's come back to the city. She um spent some time in the public sector at the Broward County Attorney's Office and in the private sector as well. And so, we're very happy

1786
10:02:35.200 --> 10:02:50.800
that she's now part of the team and she's hit the ground running. So, she's the one who drafted this ordinance that's before you today. >> Welcome home. Welcome back. >> Thank you. Thank you. Um good evening, mayor, vice mayor, commissioner. So, like Christina, city attorney said, this

1787
10:02:50.800 --> 10:03:06.640
um item is an ordinance on first reading. So, it requires franchise to remove empty and otherwise secure rolloff containers um during a tropical storm or hurricane event. This item came up during the city's emergency hurricane drill. Um, we do currently require this

1788
10:03:06.640 --> 10:03:24.400
under our emergency powers. However, we did think that we would have a stronger requirement if we include it in our city code as well. I'm here if you have any questions. >> Uh, thank you. I'm happy you brought this up because I've been meaning to speak with the manager about potentially just embarking on a study. If if you go

1789
10:03:24.400 --> 10:03:41.120
through the city of Miami, for example, adjacent to Mer Park where all the warehouses are, that's the city of Miami. I go to the gym there. When I'm running through that area, you used to have a major issue with the rolloff dumpsters in the alleys. Used to be, it was an epic nightmare. You had illegal

1790
10:03:41.120 --> 10:03:57.200
dumping. You had the roll offs all through the alleys. Something interesting that I noticed last month that was implemented, I don't know if it was through some sort of legislation or what it was, was that now all those rolloff dumps dumpsters, which obviously the new projects that you're seeing buil

1791
10:03:57.200 --> 10:04:12.880
being built are requiring them to be housed indoors, air conditioned, obviously to control the smell. But if it's an old building, they're outside. They don't have a place to put them like the little car car uh you know, the body shops, they all have the dumpsters in the back basically clogging up the

1792
10:04:12.880 --> 10:04:28.080
alleys. If you drive through those alleys now, you'll see that they built they pushed the dumpster all the way against the back wall and they built an enclosure, a very tight enclosure with with basically like a like barn doors. Some of them are made out of wood and

1793
10:04:28.080 --> 10:04:44.080
some of them made out of like some sort of like re recycled plastic. So, it's an actual fence structure around them. Again, it beautifies it and it contains the dumpsters inside there and it probably stops a lot of the illegal dumping. Can we look into that? Can we look into that? and see if that could be

1794
10:04:44.080 --> 10:04:59.520
a potential or find out what city Miami did. Yes. >> Yeah. Because that way you'll know where those dumpsters have to be and they have to be placed back in there and those fences have to be maintained. Um I'll take some pictures of it in the morning u when I go to the gym. Um and and I'll send you some pictures. But if you get a

1795
10:04:59.520 --> 10:05:15.436
chance just right by the Douglas station in that area where those warehouses are, you'll see all all those warehouses now no longer have their dumpsters basically free and clear in the alley, roaming the alley, being rolled out. And sometimes you'll see them in different areas uh because you know when they when they

1796
10:05:15.436 --> 10:05:31.040
clean them out they don't put them always in the same spot so they become more of a nuisance. Even for example my gym you know what they made them do they made them take it out of the alley and they made them use one of their parking spaces. And I'll take a picture of that tomorrow. Again

1797
10:05:31.040 --> 10:05:47.436
I understand that people want that parking space and I get it because there's a lot of traffic. But getting those alleys cleared up is a very big deal. cleaner, more efficient, you know, people can drive through them. I'm gonna take some pictures of tomorrow morning and um I'll send them I'll send them

1798
10:05:47.436 --> 10:06:03.276
your way. >> Uh Mayor, you and I have talked about using air conditioning conditioning compressed units uh in all these in all these stores if we're going to activate our alleys. >> So, we'll take a look at and see. >> But it's an interesting way. It's an interesting way. I'll I'll take some pictures of of the

1799
10:06:03.276 --> 10:06:18.480
>> I I will drive by and I'll I'll I'll find out what's going on. Thank you. >> Okay. Uh, mayor, I do have a question for you. Are those locked? >> Yeah, they're locked. >> Okay. Because like St. Mary's is having a problem with that. A lot of illegal dumping. I mean, if Waste Management can

1800
10:06:18.480 --> 10:06:34.880
work with businesses to have them locked, unlocked, that'd be >> I'm going to show you that. I'm going to take some pictures tomorrow so you can see them. >> Some of them are some of them if if they have to be in the alley because, for example, it's a small warehouse and you have no other choice. They don't have a park. They don't have parking spaces.

1801
10:06:34.880 --> 10:06:49.756
They have it all the way against the back of of the warehouse with, you know, probably about this much sticking out of the wall and it's one of those small smaller containers. The bigger the container, obviously, the bigger the enclosure. But at my gym, what they did was they it's a bigger it's a bigger container. So, what they have, they took

1802
10:06:49.756 --> 10:07:04.720
one entire spot. They required them to put it there. Again, it's game changer. Game changer aesthetically, you know, for illegal dumping. just you would see a bunch of dumping around because you would see people that the the the the

1803
10:07:04.720 --> 10:07:20.960
actual containers were full. So people would stop the cars in the middle of the alley and they would dump illegally dump adjacent to the dumpsters. That is eliminated completely. So I want I've been meaning to bring that up to you. >> Happy to take a look. >> Sorry. Please share it. >> I'll share some pictures of that. And if

1804
10:07:20.960 --> 10:07:37.040
you want if you have a chance just drive by it's literally I will >> next to Mer Park. >> I know exact in that warehouse district. I know exactly where you're talking about on the >> where Countage is. >> Yes. >> Body and Soul is >> on the back of Countage. >> Right there on that area. >> Okay. Um, thank you. By the way, I

1805
10:07:37.040 --> 10:07:52.720
appreciate that. Sorry I took over. I just you you brought something up to my mind that I've been meaning to talk to the manager. >> No, that's great. >> Do you have a motion? >> I'll move it. >> You have a second. >> Second. >> Do you have any public comment, Mr. Clerk? >> No, Mr. Mayor. >> All right. We have a motion in a second. >> Commissioner Fernandez, >> yes. >> Commissioner Lada,

1806
10:07:52.720 --> 10:08:09.360
>> yes. >> Vice Mayor Anderson? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Castro? >> Yes. Mayor Lago. >> Yes. Moving on to E4. Thank you very much, >> Mr. Mayor. Before you move uh forward, at the request of the sponsor, >> uh would like to re defer agenda items E5, F3, and F10.

1807
10:08:09.360 --> 10:08:26.560
>> So E5 is deferred. >> F3 and F10. >> And through the mayors, those are those are my items. Tomorrow we have an early early budget hearing and I think this meeting is going to go to like midnight right now. Also, if anybody else wants to refer any items, I think it'd be a

1808
10:08:26.560 --> 10:08:45.276
great idea. >> Was it F3? You said >> E5, F3, and F10. >> Thank you, Mr. May. >> All right, so we go back to E4. >> Thank you. E4 is an ordinance of a city commission

1809
10:08:45.276 --> 10:09:01.120
approving a purchase and sale agreement to include certain key terms with 475 Builmore MO LLC for the purchase of an office building located at 475 to 495 Billmore Wayey waving certain requirements pursuant to section 2-1089 or division 12 of the procurement code authorizing an amendment to the fiscal

1810
10:09:01.120 --> 10:09:17.040
year 2025 2026 budget to appropriate funds from the building reserve providing for severability clause repeated provision and providing for an effective date. Madam director, good evening. >> Good evening, mayor, vice mayor, commissioners, Paige Perez, asset manager. This ordinance for your consideration

1811
10:09:17.040 --> 10:09:32.480
and approval would authorize the city to enter into a purchase and sale agreement with for with 475 MOB LLC for the acquisition of the property located at 475 and 495 Builtmore Way. Because the property is uniquely situated adjacent

1812
10:09:32.480 --> 10:09:47.840
to the development services department, the proposed purchase would support the city's long-term goal of consolidating multiple municipal functions into a single facility, improving operational efficiency, and enhancing service delivery for residents. The key terms of

1813
10:09:47.840 --> 10:10:04.000
the agreement include a purchase price of 24 million, earnest money deposit in the amount of 500,000, closing on or before October 30th, 2026 with a due diligence period of 60 calendar days with one 15-day extension

1814
10:10:04.000 --> 10:10:19.680
option. We have obtained appraisals for the property. This is an established property with stable annual income. Adequate data was utilized by Integra realy resources for proper evaluation utilizing the direct capitalization

1815
10:10:19.680 --> 10:10:36.240
method. Therefore, we feel that their valuation was a preferred and most justifiable concluding with a value of 23.3 million. Thank you. >> Thank you very much. Good job. Um Mr. Manager, I want to thank you first and foremost. We've been chasing this

1816
10:10:36.240 --> 10:10:51.436
property for a long time. Again, it's another testament to your hard work here in the city. Uh I brought this property uh with the previous city manager who was here and we didn't purchase it which I thought was a shame at that point. Um we made some other great purchases but

1817
10:10:51.436 --> 10:11:07.040
we didn't uh purchase this property. Uh but this again finishes closing out the loop in the entire block. We control our destiny at the end of the day. And uh again, this is an asset that in the best place in the state of

1818
10:11:07.040 --> 10:11:21.840
Florida, Coral Gables. Uh and I congratulate you for your hard work and um thank you for diligently going after this for the last few years and uh bringing this home. Thank you, Mayor. Do >> you have any public comment?

1819
10:11:21.840 --> 10:11:55.520
>> Yes, Mr. Mayor. Okay. Maria Cruz. Mrs. Maria Cruz, 1447 Miller Road, 305 3232154. Like I've said before, I think it's a wonderful idea to buy it. But knowing

1820
10:11:55.520 --> 10:12:10.720
how much time and money was spent getting the 427 building ready, the question is where is the money coming to reurpose

1821
10:12:10.720 --> 10:12:27.120
it to remodel to get it ready because pretty soon I know that it's rented now. Some of the some of the rent is paid by the city by the way because we have somebody there already. But

1822
10:12:27.120 --> 10:12:44.320
the other people once they know that eventually they're going to have to move, they're going to start planning to move. So the rent is not going to be there. Okay. So this is my concern. I know that we can find the money. I've been around long enough to know that

1823
10:12:44.320 --> 10:13:02.400
when we need money, we find money because that's why we have money that was not used the previous year and on the second year we can use it for whatever we want. We gone that route before. I guess that's how we pay for things that we want and we don't want to

1824
10:13:02.400 --> 10:13:19.916
get permission for. Thank you. >> That's it, Mr. M. >> All right. Perfect. I have a motion. I'll move it. I >> have a second. >> Second. >> Commissioner Lada, >> yes. >> Vice Mayor Anderson, >> yes.

1825
10:13:19.916 --> 10:13:34.880
>> Commissioner Castro, >> yes. >> Commissioner Fernandez, >> yes. >> Mayor Lago, >> yes. Thank you. Moving on to item F2. F2 is a resolution of the city commission directing city cop to extend

1826
10:13:34.880 --> 10:13:50.480
the resident parking rate pilot program through the date of the second city commission meeting in January 2027 to collect additional data in order to better determine the long-term feasibility of a resident parking rate. >> Thank you very much. I am the sponsor of this item. The reason we put it back up

1827
10:13:50.480 --> 10:14:07.436
here is to still we still need a little more time since there's um this ongoing Alahasi homestead exemption. Um I think the fiscal impact as it is right now is minimal. However, I think it would be

1828
10:14:07.436 --> 10:14:22.400
fiscally responsible to keep on evaluating the fiscal impact. Monica, good afternoon or good evening, right? uh Monica Beltran um parking

1829
10:14:22.400 --> 10:14:38.640
sustainability and mobility services director just to provide information on on this program. It's been wellreceived currently and and by the way this is no different than other uh municipalities or

1830
10:14:38.640 --> 10:14:54.080
um cities with these programs. There are 2,130 registered residents for this program to date. So I'm going to include data for 14 months.

1831
10:14:54.080 --> 10:15:10.640
We have waved $25,000. However, the total revenue was 16 million. So the impact is.16 of a percent.

1832
10:15:10.640 --> 10:15:26.480
And all I can say is that it's it's been for those residents that use them. By the way, our our brilliant students today concentrated on parking. Hey, I felt good about that. >> That's a beautiful >> but they they also proposed some parking

1833
10:15:26.480 --> 10:15:42.960
cuts of which this is the least impactful >> and we will have Apple play. >> Perfect. Okay. >> Thank you, Monica. I'll move it. I have some some question. >> Well, let's um before you move it, um do

1834
10:15:42.960 --> 10:15:59.916
we have any public comment? >> No, Mr. Murphy. Madame Vice Mayor, you had a question or a statement or something? >> I do have some questions and uh while the director is up there, it's a appropriate time. um because we do have the mobility uh hub coming and we've

1835
10:15:59.916 --> 10:16:15.200
breaking ground on a particular date and I wanted to hear your um evaluation of the impact on availability of parking and recommendations. >> So thank you for asking and I'm

1836
10:16:15.200 --> 10:16:32.080
formulating a program to present to my bosses and uh it's a multi-prong approach. So first thing we did is we evaluated what is the the impact right what is the true delta between one and

1837
10:16:32.080 --> 10:16:48.640
four when can garage 4 accommodate the parking that we're going to lose at garage one and we did that by evaluating the vacancy or or the space availability and found not surprisingly that weekends

1838
10:16:48.640 --> 10:17:05.200
at certain times it would be the the um supply of parking would exceed the demand. However, what we are doing is we're reaching out to the private um garages, one in particular, so that we

1839
10:17:05.200 --> 10:17:22.160
can remove from G4 the um city vehicles that are parking there so that we can then move the permites from G1 to G4. So that's one measure. Um the other one is

1840
10:17:22.160 --> 10:17:40.560
we've we've looked at valet the the issue here is that we have to accommodate the staff right the transient use we have to accommodate the food pickup and delivery which is a big part of what they do. So, not one

1841
10:17:40.560 --> 10:17:58.160
solution, but um multiple choices of solutions. And really, we're looking at certain days at about 2:00 in the afternoon and as well as weekends, Fridays and Saturdays at 700 p.m. Those are the

1842
10:17:58.160 --> 10:18:15.360
times that right now we're exceeding capacity. So, I think the first part of the question needs to um ask when is the actual day we're going to be closing down garage one for available parking

1843
10:18:15.360 --> 10:18:30.960
>> through the through the mayor. >> Yes, sir. The uh problem that we're having that we just resolved was that the uh the uh power from for the north for the uh south side of the mile which is on the north side of of the of garage

1844
10:18:30.960 --> 10:18:46.000
one is coming from garage one. We had all kinds of issues with the existing facilities. We've worked every it's been it's been a nightmare because we have we cannot allow uh those that part of that that block of of of the mile to have no

1845
10:18:46.000 --> 10:19:02.400
power. So we are we've we've created a situation where we are building transformers on the alley to actually power that that part of miracle mile and then come back and do a switch when we do the actual mobility hub and power back from the transformers at the

1846
10:19:02.400 --> 10:19:17.360
mobility hub. This is something that we found out um when we when we started when we started doing the uh the project. highly unusual to have a city facility be the transformer location for private property, but but that's all we

1847
10:19:17.360 --> 10:19:34.160
have. These these projects were done in the 50s and things were done a little bit differently. We'd like to get probably uh provide that area uh five uh fiveyear period or 10 year period to go ahead and switch back to have their own transformer. and mayor, we've we've also

1848
10:19:34.160 --> 10:19:50.720
talked about using compactors and and and refri and refrigerated trash areas so we can activate the alley. Uh and uh so so it's we've we we have it resolved. We finally figured everything out. FPNL actually had issues because they weren't sure what was there. So we had our own

1849
10:19:50.720 --> 10:20:05.120
electrical engineer figure that out. We're in the process of getting that that resolved. Uh, Vice Mayor, we have the new parking lot, the the green area now is being converted into into parking lots at the Davidson property, which is

1850
10:20:05.120 --> 10:20:23.360
a property uh just just north of seasons 52. That that's that that green area. And what we have now is going to add 130 cars that we did not have before. So, we have we have 284 cars in garage one. That takes care of of about 130 of that.

1851
10:20:23.360 --> 10:20:39.436
So, we have about 150 cars that that are still pending and that's something that that that we're working uh with with our parking director on. We're also looking at maybe bringing back uh the freebie circulator. That was very very helpful

1852
10:20:39.436 --> 10:20:56.240
uh doing d doing streetscape. Right now, that circulator system is has has um a uh a pickup time of about 20 minutes. It just or more. It just doesn't work. But we're looking at that. Uh we're going to have major projects in in the area. We've got city hall under construction,

1853
10:20:56.240 --> 10:21:13.120
Publix under construction, and garage and the mobility hub under construction at at the same time. So we are looking at that some cir at a circulator that's that is uh we'll be bringing that to the uh commission that just deals with the downtown area. When we did that uh for

1854
10:21:13.120 --> 10:21:29.680
streetscape, our our our times were six six minutes. So that that is doable, but people can't wait 25 minutes. Uh so so we are we we're also looking at that. So we have a number a number of alternatives that that we'll be presenting to the uh to the commission,

1855
10:21:29.680 --> 10:21:46.160
but we're certainly looking at the downtime. We're also uh fixing uh garage 4. Uh it's it's up it's it's an obsolete garage. It doesn't have an elevator, but I think people are going to have to be using the third floor now. people don't like to use it because you there's no

1856
10:21:46.160 --> 10:22:04.080
elevator access but we have a uh but I think uh garage one will excuse me garage 4 will be more highly used now and we are providing the uh all the work required for the 40-year 30 years uh reertification of of of that garage. So

1857
10:22:04.080 --> 10:22:21.040
we are working uh with various plans including looking at at certain options in the private in the private garages to see if we can accommodate more vehicles there and some garages where we have excess but we are we we are working with this dynamic now. >> So let me let me see if I can put my

1858
10:22:21.040 --> 10:22:36.480
concerns in in a nutshell. Um this proposal runs the pilot program which we're evaluating numbers through January and hypothetically let's say we break ground in October. So it's going to skew

1859
10:22:36.480 --> 10:22:52.800
the results. So really the analysis gets altered and from what I'm hearing you're still working on trying to figure out where to put people. >> I'm sorry. What did you say? >> You're trying to figure out where to put people. you're 150 cars short,

1860
10:22:52.800 --> 10:23:09.756
>> right, at certain times. So my suggestion at least to keep this moving for right now is to instead of pick picking January uh pick a date before the groundbreaking and bring this back um

1861
10:23:09.756 --> 10:23:25.120
when you're ready for your report and make suggestions on how much longer um and you know can you run it through January without skewing the numbers. I think we need to look at where the numbers are before we break ground

1862
10:23:25.120 --> 10:23:41.840
and lock them in there and then move forward on it. Hopefully, we have enough parking. It's a Davidson lot, as far as I know, is a private parking >> to the mayor. >> So, that wouldn't that wouldn't be available. >> Yes. >> Thank you. Uh thank you, mayor. Uh we have about 2,000 and that's about

1863
10:23:41.840 --> 10:23:58.080
$13,000. Our discussions with Commissioner Castro have have been that for instance, if that goes to 20,000, it would be $130,000 which which uh depending on on what happens uh with w with the state can be

1864
10:23:58.080 --> 10:24:13.596
can be something that uh can be substantial. So uh so so that's the idea about deferring it for some time to look to see uh what happens at the end of the year and uh and and how much use is this going to actually get. Right now it's

1865
10:24:13.596 --> 10:24:30.080
not significant but is will it be significant a year from now? uh for that. So so that that's our discussions uh with with Commissioner Castro. So that's why we we are looking at at extending it.

1866
10:24:30.080 --> 10:24:46.960
>> So So going back to my question, that's January 27, okay? And we're break ground in October. I'd like to get a clean set of numbers to be able to show this is how many people are participating. This is how

1867
10:24:46.960 --> 10:25:03.436
many more people were drawing down in. This is how many more people are coming to park. So really the discount is resulting in additional revenue as opposed to being impacted by the fact that we've broken ground on a parking

1868
10:25:03.436 --> 10:25:19.916
garage and then we can reset the study after that to have a clean set of numbers. >> That's that's my concern >> through the mayor. >> Yes. Um, if you go ahead and second my motion, I'll accept your amendment. >> Yeah. No, I'll second I'll second the

1869
10:25:19.916 --> 10:25:36.000
motion, but you understand? >> I'll accept your amendment. >> I mean, so is it correct to say hypothetically that we're going to break ground in October >> some sometime this year? It looks like it right now. Uh, we uh we are wrapping up the the issues with FPNL. They've

1870
10:25:36.000 --> 10:25:51.680
been a lot more problematic uh quite problematic, but I think we have them wrapped up now. uh FPNL is is working on that on that on that design. So I would have to come back and give you a little better better number uh as far as as as

1871
10:25:51.680 --> 10:26:07.916
far as the uh start date. >> So from a design perspective from uh we we have actual plans we have actual plans that are permitted right now and we can start construction tomorrow. Actually if we had if it wasn't for for the FPNL issue, we've we've we've made

1872
10:26:07.916 --> 10:26:24.160
it very clear to them that that's that's that that is they're holding back our project by the way and they've been they've been very cooperative. It just been just been a little bit of a nightmare. Uh we currently have have a have a permit. This project will be a

1873
10:26:24.160 --> 10:26:42.080
revision to that permit and that so we already have a permit because it's gone through Durham. All we have to do is is is have a contractor to actually pull the permit on on the job. uh our intent is to pull a permit on the old set of drawings and and then provide a revision

1874
10:26:42.080 --> 10:26:56.320
for the new skin and the and the new work at the at the at the ninth floor. >> So, I'm going to second the motion. And I think it's real important for this to run, especially during the hot summer months, get more people downtown,

1875
10:26:56.320 --> 10:27:13.840
you know, to set extended until you're ready to break the month before you're ready to break ground, whether that's the end of September, October. It's it's the language would cover it just by saying the month before you're ready to

1876
10:27:13.840 --> 10:27:29.916
break ground. Stop the program there and then we can discuss what to do with it after. All right. So basically we'll the program will be frozen and stopped in three months. Right. July, August, September.

1877
10:27:29.916 --> 10:27:47.916
>> There's another. >> All right. So we have a motion, a second. >> Vice Mayor Anderson? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Castro? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Fernandez? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Lada? >> Yes. >> Mayor Lago? >> Yes. Thank you very much, Madam

1878
10:27:47.916 --> 10:28:07.596
Director. All right, moving on to item F4. >> F4 is a resolution of the city commission calling a special election on the proposed ballot question and city charter amendment to be held on November 3rd, 2026, providing for submission to the electors for approval or disapproval of a ballot question asking if the charter should be amended to raise the

1879
10:28:07.596 --> 10:28:24.080
value of public work projects that require formal solicitation and providing the threshold value be amended consistent with Florida statutes. Providing for notice, providing for inclusion in the city charter, providing for related matters, providing for an effective date. >> Good evening, mayor, vice mayor, commissioner, Stephanie Throck, deputy city attorney. This item is sponsored by

1880
10:28:24.080 --> 10:28:39.276
the mayor and sets forth a ballot question to be held on a special November 3rd, 2026 ballot. A question regarding this public work threshold value. Mayor Slesic mentioned this when he mentioned the charter review committee recommendations, and this question was one suggested by city staff

1881
10:28:39.276 --> 10:28:55.200
and the charter review committee. As mentioned, the current $25,000 threshold is rather low. And what this would do is allow the city, if approved by the voters to um solicit bids under 300,000 without following formal solicitation procedures. Obviously, anything

1882
10:28:55.200 --> 10:29:11.680
requiring city commission approval would still come before you all. It's just the manner of soliciting. And the question put to the voters would be, shall section 24 of the city charter be amended to increase the threshold for public work projects requiring formal solicitation from 25,000 to $300,000

1883
10:29:11.680 --> 10:29:28.240
with that amount adjusted as specified in section 25520 of Florida statutes. As mentioned by um Mayor Slesnick during the charter review committee summary, Florida statutes provides that same $300,000 threshold as um adjusted annually by the engineering news record.

1884
10:29:28.240 --> 10:29:43.596
So that would be the same for the statute here. I believe now the 300,000 is already around 400. I'm going to I'm not an engineer. Uh 400 some thousand. So that was that's what um the actual amount would be, but it would be adjusted annually based on that record.

1885
10:29:43.596 --> 10:29:59.680
>> Okay. Pretty self-explanatory. Mr. Clerk, do you have any public comment? >> No, Mr. Mayor. >> All right. We'll take a motion. >> I'll move it. >> Second. The >> clerk. >> Commissioner Castro. >> Yes. >> Commissioner Fernandez. >> Yes. >> Commissioner Lada. >> Yes. Vice Mayor Anderson? >> Yes. >> Mayor Log,

1886
10:29:59.680 --> 10:30:15.680
>> yes. Moving on to item F5. >> F5 is a resolution of the city commission calling a special election on the proposed ballot question and city charter amendment to be held on November 3rd, 2026, providing for submission to the electors for approval or disapproval of a ballot question asking if the charter should be amended to require continuence residency immediately preceding the conclusion of the

1887
10:30:15.680 --> 10:30:32.320
qualifying period for the offices of mayor and city commissioner, providing for notice, providing for inclusion in the city charter, providing for related matters, providing for an effective date. >> Thank you, madam city attorney. Again, this item is sponsored by the mayor and thank you to Mayor Slesnik for doing my presentation for me. This is another um small change to the city charter which

1888
10:30:32.320 --> 10:30:48.560
would require if adopted by the voters continuous residency in the city for a minimum of one year immediately preceding the end of that qualifying period. As noted, now that elections are in November, that qualifying period is in June. So, um, by the end of the qualifying period, any, um, candidate

1889
10:30:48.560 --> 10:31:05.120
for position in the city would need to have been a resident for a continuous year immediately prior to the end of that. Um, this is similar language to questions adopted in nearby municipalities and would be on the November 3rd, 2026 ballot. >> Thank you. Any public comment? >> No, Mr. >> May I have a motion?

1890
10:31:05.120 --> 10:31:20.160
>> I'll move it. >> May I have a second? >> Second. >> Clerk. >> Commissioner Fernandez? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Lada? >> Yes. >> Vice Mayor Anderson? >> Yes. >> Commissioner Castro? Yes, >> Mayor Lago. >> Yes. Uh, item F6. >> F6 is a resolution of the city commission calling a special election on

1891
10:31:20.160 --> 10:31:36.000
the proposed ballot question and city charter amendment to be held on November 3rd, 2026, providing for submission to the electors for approval or disapproval of a ballot question asking if the charter should be amended to provide for the mayor to be elected to serve a 4-year term commencing with the November 2020 election without changing the associated mayoral term limit, providing

1892
10:31:36.000 --> 10:31:51.120
for notice, providing for inclusion in the city charter, providing for related matters, providing for an effective date. >> Thank you again. This item is sponsored by the mayor. As mentioned previously in this meeting, there has been um there have been two votes in the last 20 years or so on this item, both of which were

1893
10:31:51.120 --> 10:32:07.120
very close as um previously discussed by Mayor Slesnick and the charter review committee. This question would be put forth to the voters in November 3rd, November 3rd, 2026. And it calls for changing the charter to reflect a mayoral term of four years consistent with the commission term beginning in

1894
10:32:07.120 --> 10:32:23.120
2028. Um, it's noted here that our current mayor, if reelected in November, would not be eligible to serve in November of 2028. And the associated term limits would not be changed. Our current term limits are eight continuous years as mayor. So rather than being four two-year terms, if adopted, this

1895
10:32:23.120 --> 10:32:39.436
would be two four-year terms. So there would be no changes to the associated mayoral term limit. >> Thank you for clarifying. May I have a motion? >> I'll move it. >> I have one one second. >> I'll second. U Mr. Clerk. >> Yes, Mr. Mayor.

1896
10:32:39.436 --> 10:33:10.800
>> Pul. >> Yes, Mr. Mayor. >> Thank you. >> Maria Cruz. All right. Now, we're pay Maria, Mrs. Maria Cruz, 1447 Miller Road, 305 323 2154. Now we're playing pingpong.

1897
10:33:10.800 --> 10:33:28.480
The shutter said the original shutter was two years. So somebody came up with the idea of changing it to four. It was voted to four. Then we change it back to two. So now we're going to uh suggest four

1898
10:33:28.480 --> 10:33:45.520
again. And 3 years from then we're going to go back to two. But when it's not broken, why are we trying to change it when obviously we changed it and it didn't work. Number one. Number two, I

1899
10:33:45.520 --> 10:34:03.120
know there are many rumors going around, but as far as I know, nobody present or not present has expressed an interest in running for mayor in 2028.

1900
10:34:03.120 --> 10:34:27.040
But you never know, there may be somebody in the wings waiting and we may be trying to set it off to that person. Bye, >> Jackson Holmes. Greetings. Uh, I I wasn't even planning on commenting here, but then I started

1901
10:34:27.040 --> 10:34:42.000
thinking about it. Um, I I can appreciate uh that for any mayor having to run every two years is um shall we say be aggravating, right? Uh

1902
10:34:42.000 --> 10:35:00.800
and I I I don't contest that. But what what strikes me is that I think there's something good about our having three people on the ballot every time because if there is um an upswelling of public

1903
10:35:00.800 --> 10:35:18.640
opinion about if you have a shall we call it a change election. Um for some reason I'm thinking of the election in 2001. Um some people don't want to think about that. I'm not trying to get back to that issue, but what am I trying to say with

1904
10:35:18.640 --> 10:35:36.160
when you have it every two years, then if the public is really upset about something, they can they can say, "Okay, we're electing three people who will actually change it." Whereas if the mayor's term

1905
10:35:36.160 --> 10:35:54.000
is four years, then maybe the public can only express their let's just for the sake of argument call it outrage and but they can't change anything. So that that's why I prefer to keep it two years. I'm I'm not contesting that it's it's got to be aggravating for any mayor

1906
10:35:54.000 --> 10:36:09.916
to have to run every two years. I I agree that that's that's a lot of wear and tear on a mayor. It's just that I think it's better to have the public able to in any single election say, "Okay, we've had enough. We're going to change things and then they can actually

1907
10:36:09.916 --> 10:36:25.120
get it done because they can elect three people to change it." >> Thank you. >> Thank you very, Mr. Mayor. >> All right. May I have a motion? >> Have a motion. Second, Mr. Clerk. >> Commissioner Lada. >> Yes. >> Vice Mayor Anderson.

1908
10:36:25.120 --> 10:36:41.840
>> Yes. Commissioner Castro, >> I disagree with changing it to to four years, but I do agree with putting it out for on a referendum for having the people vote. So, yes. >> Commissioner Fernandez, >> yes. >> Mayor Lago, >> yes. >> I'm moving on to item F7. F7 is a

1909
10:36:41.840 --> 10:36:57.120
resolution of the city commission calling a special election on the proposed ballot question and city charter amendment to be held on November 3rd, 2026, providing for submission to the electors for approval or disapproval of a ballot question asking if the city charter should be amended to require a vote of the electors prior to the sale of certain city-owned properties, providing for notice, providing for

1910
10:36:57.120 --> 10:37:12.320
inclusion in the city charter, providing for related matters, and providing for an effective date. Thank you. Again, this item is sponsored by the mayor. As mentioned um previously in this meeting, this question um came up in discussion with the charter review committee and the mayor has put forth this ballot question. So the question would require

1911
10:37:12.320 --> 10:37:28.080
that the city charter be amended to require that the sale of a city-owned park, recreational facility, golf course, or open park space be approved by the city's electors with this requirement to be further outlined in an ordinance adopted by the city commission where those definitions of sale, park,

1912
10:37:28.080 --> 10:37:44.800
open space could be better fleshed out. Um this question um arose after discussion at the charter review committee based on some of our neighboring municipalities having similar restrictions though as mentioned by the um chair Slesnik that was a four-fifth vote. This proposal is for a vote of the electors rather than a vote

1913
10:37:44.800 --> 10:38:01.916
of the commission. >> So thank you very much and I'm this is a message to my colleagues and uh one person in particular who's here. Um what we have done here and I'm happy that Harold is listening to this. Well, what we've done here is we've weaponized social media as a community. So, we have

1914
10:38:01.916 --> 10:38:18.160
blogs here and what we do certain people on the commission and certain people in this room is they leak false information to these blogs. Let me give you an example and then they run with it. They run with it and before you know it, snowballs. You're knocking on someone's door and they're saying, "Listen, I

1915
10:38:18.160 --> 10:38:34.400
can't support you because I hear that you're going to sell off Granada Golf Course. First and foremost, Granada Golf Course is a historic golf course. Okay, you you can't redevelop Granada Golf Course even if we wanted to. Okay,

1916
10:38:34.400 --> 10:38:51.520
that's number one. Number two, the latest joke that was being told here in this town was ah the reason why you want to overturn the reverter, I think even the herald mentioned it is because want to redevelop and sell a portion of the youth center off. Think about how

1917
10:38:51.520 --> 10:39:08.000
ridiculous that sounds. Think about how people get into these little echo chambers and they believe this insanity. I can say this on the record. I'm the elected official that I can't even remember there being an elected official

1918
10:39:08.000 --> 10:39:23.276
that brought more green space to this community than any other elected official. I give name me one more elected official. >> That's it. >> He never was mayor. >> No, but elected official. >> Okay. George Merrick. I'm fine. I'm being I'm fine being second to George

1919
10:39:23.276 --> 10:39:37.276
Mayor from Commissioner Fernandez. It's okay. Just this year alone, it's 30 acres. How many acres have we brought to the downtown? How many acres have we brought to the residential communities through legislation that I've written? And it's

1920
10:39:37.276 --> 10:39:54.960
the constant, you know, BS, lies, innuendos, scare tactics that are used to get people, oh no, they're gonna scare the reason why they want to do the things in the Granada golf course because they want to sell it. So, you know what I did? Let's take it to an extreme.

1921
10:39:54.960 --> 10:40:11.436
Let's take it to an extreme. And here's your extreme. The voters will decide now, by the way, green space, golf courses, and youth center. So, what's the point of a reverter? What's the point of a reverter

1922
10:40:11.436 --> 10:40:28.000
if you have now an ironclad? If the residents vote by over 60% to sell the youth center, which will never happen, never happen to sell the Granada golf course. I mean, I've had people tell me that I'm gonna make the Granada golf course into a park. That's why they don't vote for me because I was told you're going to make the Granada Golf

1923
10:40:28.000 --> 10:40:44.400
Course a park that it's a historic golf course. You understand that? You can't make it into a park. But people believe it because it's on the blogs or they hear from somebody and that's the assumption they make.

1924
10:40:44.400 --> 10:41:00.480
So this I don't want to put this forward. I don't want to tie the hands because at the end of the day, what's the point of being having an elected official? And I talked to the manager. The manager asked me, Vince, what's the point of being an elected official? Well, you have no other choice. You have to do

1925
10:41:00.480 --> 10:41:16.400
this because people will implicate you in things like for example raising your salary. I think it's absolutely insane that an elected official would raise their own salary.

1926
10:41:16.400 --> 10:41:32.240
We did it here. We did it here in the middle of a budget hearing. So, what do I do now? Residents are the ones that will make the decision. By the way, and I and I think we should be able to raise our own salary in a way that is transparent, in a way that I tried and

1927
10:41:32.240 --> 10:41:48.080
said, let's have a public discourse. Let's have a a conversation. By the way, I think we should, not in this agenda, but maybe in the next election, we should put forth a plan of action. I'll leave it up to my colleagues to raise your salaries. And by the way, just for the record, it won't be during my time

1928
10:41:48.080 --> 10:42:04.240
here. Okay? I think elected officials should make more money here, especially when you're dedicating the amount of time you are. But now, we've left it up to the residents. So, I have no other choice but to present this type of legislation to protect not only my integrity, my

1929
10:42:04.240 --> 10:42:21.120
reputation, but the idea and the concept of that elected officials will do actual damage and harm and sell the youth center. They're going to sell the youth center. No. Let me tell you why I want the reverter clause removed. Because a group that for 5 years doesn't file

1930
10:42:21.120 --> 10:42:35.840
their 501c3 documents, you don't know how much money they have in the bank account. You don't know if they filed their taxes, have they not filed their taxes, are they following the rules? But the most egregious of it is how is the makeup of their board, the

1931
10:42:35.840 --> 10:42:54.800
compos, the composition of their board decided? We're decided here in an election that happens every two years or four. We're voted on by the residents. But you have a board that has power over the youth center that can say, "Well, my wife, my

1932
10:42:54.800 --> 10:43:15.276
daughter, my friend is on this board. If people don't vote my way, I'll just remove them." That's not the way that in my eyes we should allow any public asset that's worth over $und00 million be transacted.

1933
10:43:15.276 --> 10:43:32.320
That to me is a fact. And now you can have all the reverters you want. They're meaningless. You want to know why? Because the residents will make the decision. So that's why I have this here before before uh the community and before the commission because this is the way to

1934
10:43:32.320 --> 10:43:47.436
truly put this to rest. It's over. The conversation ceases to exist just like we've had with the November elections. just like we've had with with the raises and a litany of other things that the

1935
10:43:47.436 --> 10:44:04.320
residents overwhelmingly supported when many on this commission for example the IG would not support and now we are going to have an IG. So that's why I'm putting it forward and I ask for every one of my colleagues on this commission to support it because

1936
10:44:04.320 --> 10:44:20.160
it's the right thing to do. Madam Vice Mayor, >> I fully support it and it gives me peace to know that when I finish my time here that the hard work that's been done by this commission to secure these

1937
10:44:20.160 --> 10:44:36.400
properties is not going to be unraveled by a future commission. >> Okay. or by a board with a reverter clause that decides to have a litigation case and

1938
10:44:36.400 --> 10:44:53.120
spend a lot of taxpayer money in court with whether or not particular actions do or do not violate the river. So, I'll move it. >> I'll second it through the mayor.

1939
10:44:53.120 --> 10:45:08.080
>> Yes. Um I would actually ask I think this is very important legislation. I agree with the vice mayor. I think that for many years commissions our commission commission before commissions

1940
10:45:08.080 --> 10:45:26.320
before that have worked to build on the number of neighborhood parks that we have on parks in the downtown. uh we've been able to get the city to where it is today and I think we need to set that protection going forward uh for for the

1941
10:45:26.320 --> 10:45:42.320
city. My recommendation would be to add an extra word or two actually which is sale or transfer because commissions could get creative and transfer it to another entity and do it that way. I

1942
10:45:42.320 --> 10:45:58.720
think the protection should exist for residents so that there is no sale or transfer of of parkland >> through the mayor through if I may I did cover that with the city attorney and about transfers and land swaps and all that and no it's covered >> it's covered I did that also I did that

1943
10:45:58.720 --> 10:46:14.160
also look my point is that we can go back and forth about simple words here but this has nothing to do nothing to do with the commission this has to do with stopping the abuse

1944
10:46:14.160 --> 10:46:31.756
on individuals reputations in this town. And it's enough because I tired of hearing the assault that happens on people's reputations here on blogs and anonymous people who I don't read any of that stuff. They send me screenshots. I stop sending me this stuff. I don't care what

1945
10:46:31.756 --> 10:46:48.400
any of these people say. Put your name front and center. Don't be anonymous. Front and center. So my point is that I read it when they send me the gazette and they send me the other uh uh garbage that's out there political

1946
10:46:48.400 --> 10:47:05.040
or or the gazette which is now used to be Gable's Insider. When they send that all that stuff to me and it says the same thing over and over again, you read it in the comment section. They send it to me. Vince, you're saying that you're thinking about selling the youth center and that's why you want to get rid of murder. It's it's it's infuriating to even think that we've gotten to that

1947
10:47:05.040 --> 10:47:22.240
point in this community. Well, you will scare people will scare people that this commission which has worked myself which I have worked 13 years of my life to write legislation so the city has money through permit fees to buy parks like the Dorothy Thompson park like the one

1948
10:47:22.240 --> 10:47:39.276
against to uh Saledo Salvador Park excuse me I can go on M parks like the one in Granada I don't want the one of you many of you have gone to ribbon cutings there and enjoyed those ribbon cutings all those parks have been bought have been bought lot through money through legislation that I've written or through properties that

1949
10:47:39.276 --> 10:47:56.480
I have found myself and brought to >> back I remember when I was in property advisory board uh way back in the day the city purchased six properties in one year. >> Yeah. >> Was Venanishia Park uh the one on uh Alhamra um I think Lisbon was on that uh on that

1950
10:47:56.480 --> 10:48:12.960
list as well. the the product the product that the project that was split because Venny Tory >> uh redeveloped the the not redeveloped he he he beautified this exceptional historic home and he split the lot he's going to sell it and we bought it >> we bought that lot we bought the one on

1951
10:48:12.960 --> 10:48:27.436
37th Avenue in Alhamra we bought the one on Granada adjacent to the Coral Gables country club we bought the the the big the big piece on Salvador we bought Dorothy Thompson Park >> North Ponds >> we bought the North Ponds I mean and and

1952
10:48:27.436 --> 10:48:44.720
then goes on and on and on and on. But this right here should never you should have faith and trust in your elected officials. But when people start with that rhetoric and they start using that in campaign material that we're going to sell Granada Granada golf course and we're going to sell the Coral Gables

1953
10:48:44.720 --> 10:49:00.800
youth center, I mean it's it's it's ridiculous. It's insulting to a person's commitment to come and run for public office and you're going to start selling public assets. I mean again in a in a in how many weeks, Mr. manager, through your effort and my effort that we've been dealing in for 10 plus years, we're

1954
10:49:00.800 --> 10:49:16.400
going to bring in the largest park into the city's hands. And it didn't cost a city a dollar. And what did we do? We put a covenant on it, right? You're laughing because we put a covenant that restricted our ability to

1955
10:49:16.400 --> 10:49:31.200
even develop it. You know, the first thing I heard and if you read it because I because it was put online, I had people tell me they they misunderstood what the Herald printed. That said, that a portion of it, I'd like to return it back to its original old Florida

1956
10:49:31.200 --> 10:49:47.756
splendor with pine trees and, you know, pine rock lands and, you know, low-lying areas where where you can have uh pomemetto pomemetto brush and that and that kind of stuff. Maybe some land orchids, you know, maybe the maybe the vice mayor can help me with that. And they thought, oh, well, they're just going to take a little portion of it

1957
10:49:47.756 --> 10:50:03.276
going to they're going to bring it back to his old splender, maybe about 10,000 square feet, and the rest of they're going to develop it. I literally tried to explain to people and they're like, "Oh, you're a liar because you're an elected official." You know, it's it's useless. It's useless to even try to explain. Not the Herald's

1958
10:50:03.276 --> 10:50:18.160
fault. They just quoted me and the quote was taken as small portion. Yeah. A small portion because I think that the rest of it should be kept as a green space where people can enjoy. So, I apologize for taking you more time than I should. Mr. Manager, go ahead.

1959
10:50:18.160 --> 10:50:34.640
>> So, the mayor, we had a a a perpetual easement and a title restriction. I don't know what else can >> the chances and now we have this >> and now we have this. I don't know what else we could do >> and now we have this. I mean outside of you know I don't know what else we could do. You know the mayor Celelesni was here. He's like listen don't he wasn't

1960
10:50:34.640 --> 10:50:49.120
saying it but he was kind of saying hey you can do a forest vote. No no we're taking it even further. Taking even further. I don't I don't think it gets I don't know what else we could do. So, um, our intent, and I think we're pretty clear for the youth center, for the Granada golf course, and

1961
10:50:49.120 --> 10:51:05.916
for all our green spaces, for the youth center, for Granada, for the golf courses, and for all our green spaces is to never allow them to be developed. Never. Because that is the asset that defines along with our canopy, defines the city. Beautiful. That defines who we

1962
10:51:05.916 --> 10:51:21.756
are. And by the way, I got to give credit where credit is due because I always like to do that. Vice Mayor Mana was a champion for parks. He was responsible for the redevelopment of of Salo Park. Salvador Salabador Park, excuse me. Sabador, correct? >> Yes. Salvador. >> Sabador Park.

1963
10:51:21.756 --> 10:51:38.240
>> Salvador. >> Salvador. And he was always advocating on behalf and he was the one that basically asked me to change my legislation from 100% going to acquisition to 6535 where 35% of it went into renovation of existing parks and 65 went to acquiring new parks. So, just

1964
10:51:38.240 --> 10:51:52.800
want to give him a little shout out >> through the mayor. >> Yes. Okay. You said you wanted to take this to an extreme and I have an idea. I think the reason you really brought this up is to protect your reputation regarding the golf course and the youth

1965
10:51:52.800 --> 10:52:08.880
center. Um, the reverted clause is here to protect the youth center exclusively for the youth and I understand where you're coming from, but I think there's something that we need to keep into consideration and not only the sale of a

1966
10:52:08.880 --> 10:52:25.040
property is going to protect these properties because we can lease it for example 99-year lease, right? Also, we can change the land use of these properties as we have done in the past. The city

1967
10:52:25.040 --> 10:52:40.560
can absolutely do something else that exists. There are a lot of city pro there are a lot of city owned properties that are leased in Coral Gables that are artists. So, if you really really want to take this to an extreme, go ahead and

1968
10:52:40.560 --> 10:52:57.040
add that language. >> Let me correct you. Okay. Number one, u I already talked to this with the with the city attorney. um 99 year leases. We don't 99 le parks and we don't have any parks that are leased here in the city. So, let's let's be very careful with the things that we say because again,

1969
10:52:57.040 --> 10:53:13.756
they're misleading and people believe them just like we're going to redevelop uh the youth center and we're going to redevelop uh the golf course. So, this is as extreme as it gets. There's nothing. You're not there's no sales, there's no leases, there's no rents, there's no nothing. It's you cannot sell a city-owned piece property that is a

1970
10:53:13.756 --> 10:53:29.200
green space, a park, or the youth center. It's clear as day. I know you want to like find a way to tweak it in a sense of to find some weak point on it, but this is as strong as it gets. Madam City Attorney, can I make this any stronger >> there? I mean, this is pretty strong. It

1971
10:53:29.200 --> 10:53:44.320
would require, like we said, of >> the lawsuit. >> Go ahead. >> It would require approval by a majority of the voters. So, so that that is pretty strong. >> Can you think of anything else? >> There's always different things that could be done here. >> Go ahead. >> You could make it a supermajority requirement for

1972
10:53:44.320 --> 10:54:00.000
>> supermajority. Add it. Go ahead. >> So, >> what else would you like, Tommy? Go ahead. >> I I It's up to you all. It's not my I'm not the policy, >> mayor. Super majority. Let's go. Let's add it. Let's add it. Super majority. How about that? Anything else you like to add? Thank you. Okay. So, my point is

1973
10:54:00.000 --> 10:54:16.000
this. Whether it's a sale, lease, rent, no green space in the city of Coral Gables will be sold. None. Now, it will be now it will be a golf course or the youth center.

1974
10:54:16.000 --> 10:54:32.080
That's what I'm proposing >> through the mayor. The language on this legislation specifically states city owned properties isn't only state parks or golf courses. >> Madam city attorney, will you please correct commissioner?

1975
10:54:32.080 --> 10:54:46.800
>> I'm going to ask the deputy senator to please read the question. >> Sure. If you don't mind, I'll read the question and I think an um the last line is an important one here too. So the title the title of the question would be sale of certain city-owned property and the question is shall the city charter be amended to require that the sale of a

1976
10:54:46.800 --> 10:55:03.200
city-owned park, recreational facility, golf course or open park space be approved by the city city's electors with this requirement to be further outlined in an ordinance adopted by the city commission. With that in mind, the intention of the sponsor was that there be an ordinance that spells out exactly

1977
10:55:03.200 --> 10:55:19.200
what sale would be, exactly what we mean by those open park spaces, etc. Just further clarify as day. Clear as day. Let's stop let's stop playing around with semantics here. >> Um, may I have a motion? >> You have a second. Do

1978
10:55:19.200 --> 10:55:51.720
>> do you have any public comment? >> Yes, sir. We do. >> Okay. Public comment. Thank you. >> Maria Cruz Mrs. Maria Cruz, 1447 Miller Road, 305 323 2154.

1979
10:55:52.240 --> 10:56:10.640
I understand how we try to preserve our image, our legacy, etc., etc. The problem is that some of us that listen carefully

1980
10:56:10.640 --> 10:56:28.400
know that sometimes we do not mean what we say or we say what we don't mean whatever it is. I think this discussion has made me think because you know what

1981
10:56:28.400 --> 10:56:44.160
it says the sale of certain properties we could sell a building I guess because it's not a park or a recreational facility and it doesn't say and I'm sorry but

1982
10:56:44.160 --> 10:56:59.360
listen we're known for breaking covenants agreements settlements anytime anything and case in point University of Miami every time they come

1983
10:56:59.360 --> 10:57:16.880
they get something changed or or taken off. So I'm sorry it's not what is written is how we have learned not to trust because we say one thing today and

1984
10:57:16.880 --> 10:57:33.840
tomorrow that's not what I meant or that's not what I said and that is the issue. I think this will be a very valid uh thing to to I know that the attorney already says oh it's as strong as it can be.

1985
10:57:33.840 --> 10:57:51.596
I it says not to sell. It does not say I cannot lease it for 99 years. It doesn't say that I cannot transfer it to another entity. There's many opening questions here and I know that some people do not

1986
10:57:51.596 --> 10:58:08.160
want to accept that but yes we have been burned before and that's why we want it to be absolutely positively what it means. If we own a park, it'll be ours unless somebody puts it on a referendum

1987
10:58:08.160 --> 10:58:23.040
and the people say get rid of it. It doesn't make any difference whether I want to transfer it, uh, lease it, um, I don't know what other words because, you know, there are too many attorneys in the pot and we can come up with

1988
10:58:23.040 --> 10:58:46.640
something creative when we want to and that is the problem. >> Mr. Jackson Holmes. So, uh it's toward the end of the day and I think people's nerves are a little bit frayed.

1989
10:58:46.640 --> 10:59:04.080
Um, however, uh, I am personally very upset about this, uh, talk about suing the the youth center and trying to, uh, nullify the reverter clause. I I

1990
10:59:04.080 --> 10:59:19.916
find that uh, maybe my nerves are afraid. I don't know. But it's an, as far as I'm concerned, that's an attack on children. Uh we've seen developers do things that we never thought possible. Um Commissioner Mena, you're praising that

1991
10:59:19.916 --> 10:59:35.756
he he did parks, but he also was uh called out by the former United States Attorney Leon Kelner as being uh criminally indictable, I guess, over the Greco parking. Um uh as Maria Cruz says,

1992
10:59:35.756 --> 10:59:51.520
we've been there before. We have been burned. We got so many burns uh that we can't count them. And so whether this thing goes on the ballot is, you know, it doesn't there's no reason to be going

1993
10:59:51.520 --> 11:00:07.840
after the reverter at the use of I think that would solve the problem. You want to solve that false accusation, then stop that talk about the lawsuit. Talk stop talking about a reverter. That'll that'll put the the issue to the end.

1994
11:00:07.840 --> 11:00:22.320
That's it, Mr. Mayor. >> All right, we have a motion a second. Madam Vice Mayor, >> so I'm just since we've gotten a little off the rails on what the actual ballot language is, I'm going to read it out into the record. Shall the city charter be amended to

1995
11:00:22.320 --> 11:00:40.000
require the sale of city-owned park, recreational facility, comma, golf course, comma, or open spa park space be approved by the city electors, which means our voters with a requirement to be further outlined in an ordinance

1996
11:00:40.000 --> 11:00:58.240
adopted by the city commission. The word sale means actual transaction or transfer of a piece of property. This is something I discussed with the city attorney ahead of time. So no land swaps, no other

1997
11:00:58.240 --> 11:01:15.840
types of means of sale could occur. >> Vice Mayor, as we discussed, that can be fleshed out as much as you all would like in the ordinance specifying what sale means. >> Right. And we're limited to 75 words on ballot language. >> Correct. But that's something that we can work on over the next few weeks.

1998
11:01:15.840 --> 11:01:29.680
>> So, >> and at the end of the day, >> this particular question fits within the the box covers this particular issue. There's additional issues that other people want to put another >> item on the ballot for, we can have that

1999
11:01:29.680 --> 11:01:48.320
discussion at the next meeting. Again, I would hope I would hope that members of the commission, members of the of who are here of the community would be ecstatic about this, would not be finding ways to, you know, take shots at

2000
11:01:48.320 --> 11:02:05.680
it. That just goes to prove my point that it's not about the legislation or actually stopping the constant attacks. It's about, you know what, at the end of the day, let's continue it. Let's continue it so that we can continue to proliferate the lies and all

2001
11:02:05.680 --> 11:02:22.080
the, you know, accusations about that are ridiculous in nature about the youth center and about the golf courses. So, we have a motion in a second. Mr. Clerk, let's let's put this on the for the voters. >> Vice Mayor Anderson. >> Yes. >> Yes. >> Commissioner Castro, >> can you go ahead and clarify the motion

2002
11:02:22.080 --> 11:02:37.680
because I believe the mayor said the fourth fifth vote. So, what is the motion exactly at this point? >> My said I never said the four fifth vote. The motion was very was clarified was clarified by the vice mayor. Let's stop wasting time. Let's vote already. >> As I read it here, it's right.

2003
11:02:37.680 --> 11:02:53.200
>> You can read it again. >> I know. But the mayor next to me after I spoke >> said that's what I said, >> right? But she didn't she didn't read it into the record. Super majority was the word that he asked to amend it. >> That's the only thing. >> Yeah, that's the word. >> So, Mr. Mayor, we're happy to amend that question if you want to say 60% or 7%

2004
11:02:53.200 --> 11:03:08.800
>> 60%. 60% with a vote with the So we would change the question to be to be approved by over 60% of the city's electors or we can tweak that language. Exactly. >> Is it going to be over 60% or 60? We we need >> or 60%. And if that's part of the motion, right? >> 60 plus one

2005
11:03:08.800 --> 11:03:26.080
>> the approval of 60% of the electors. Again, the amendment >> to to my colleagues, remember, please for those of you that oppose the IG, for those that opposed sending us to the sending the raises to the residents, for those of you that oppose November, to my left, to my right, um, again, join in on

2006
11:03:26.080 --> 11:03:41.840
this. Stop trying to nip at the heels of things. Join in and let's do something good together. I have the votes anyways because this is common sense legislation. Again, don't be on the record opposing this. All right. So, we I think we're clear now, right? Super

2007
11:03:41.840 --> 11:03:58.240
majority 60 plus one. The vice mayor has accepted the amendment. Okay. >> We will amend the question and the um strike through to the charter to reflect the 60% of the voters voting in that election is required. The approval of 60%.

2008
11:03:58.240 --> 11:04:14.640
>> In any way that I whatever way I vote, this has nothing to do with me accepting the reverted clause for the youth center. Once again, that reverted clause there is to protect the youth center strictly for the youth. And the other thing I want to go ahead and put on the

2009
11:04:14.640 --> 11:04:30.640
record once again, this could still be leased to somebody else and you can still change the land use. So, this is all smoke and mirrors, but I'm going to go ahead and vote yes. Yes to no selling parks or recreations as as it's stated

2010
11:04:30.640 --> 11:04:45.520
in the resolution. Commissioner Fernandez, >> I Mr. Mayor, I don't know where you got the idea that I was not in support of it. I was in support of it from the beginning and I mentioned it in my comments. So my vote is yes. I think this is a necessary protection that we

2011
11:04:45.520 --> 11:05:03.116
have for our city's parkland. >> Commissioner Lada. >> Right. So if this was anything other than um taking it to the voters, if it had to do with just the disposition of any property, I would vote no. But since this is as strictly limited to well what

2012
11:05:03.116 --> 11:05:19.916
it calls for, right? Parks, green space, golf courses. Yeah, it's it's it's as close to a no-brainer as I can imagine, right? Um we killed ourselves to try and add to the green space, to add to parks, to add um what's so precious and so

2013
11:05:19.916 --> 11:05:36.960
limited. Um so I would have assumed an hour ago we all would have just been unanimous. So my votes yes. Mayor Lago. >> Okay. Um, madam city attorney, we need to clarify a few things again in an effort to to cloud the waters here and,

2014
11:05:36.960 --> 11:05:51.840
you know, I guess make comments for the blogs. We just heard right now, can we change the land use of a PE? Can we change the land use of a park in an effort to avoid >> this this this type of this type of situation? Tell me. I'd like to know.

2015
11:05:51.840 --> 11:06:10.160
>> So, changing the land use is a process that requires public hearings, etc. So that process, you know, potentially could could occur. Um I don't think that this prohibits that process. >> Let's prohibit it. >> Add it to it. I want to prohibit it.

2016
11:06:10.160 --> 11:06:28.000
>> We may be. So mayor, if you want to say the sale or change sale or change of zoning or change of use or change of right land use designation or or all of the above. Um if so we would ask a

2017
11:06:28.000 --> 11:06:44.160
little bit of time to make sure that that question be very clear and and get some very clear direction from you all about um exactly what changes >> let me ask you a question because I asked both of you in a conversation about this. >> What's the point what's the point of of finding an endound on of having this

2018
11:06:44.160 --> 11:07:00.000
piece of legislation go to the voters and then finding an endound on on land use? >> You're always still going to have public hearings about any change >> that's not what I that's not what I asked. I'm I'm not I'm not sure I understand the question and I'll I'll clarify it for you. Let's use let's use

2019
11:07:00.000 --> 11:07:14.640
um let's use the blue road open space for example right next to my house. So this commission this legislation has been enacted for years. Uh we want to sell that property

2020
11:07:14.640 --> 11:07:31.520
park designated park we want to sell it. So I would put it on the agenda to do a land use change on that property. change the land use in two readings and then it wouldn't have to go to the voters for approval. Correct. >> Correct. As as written, it's just the sale. Though the city could always

2021
11:07:31.520 --> 11:07:46.320
convert it back to a park. I think the permanent nature of a sale is um what's maybe a little bit different than the change of use or change of zoning. That can always be reszoned or rechanged or the use could be reconsidered in both ways. But if you change the zoning of a

2022
11:07:46.320 --> 11:08:02.320
park of an existing park, you change the zoning and you sell it, you're not going to have to face the 60 plus one voters. >> Correct. As written, that's that's what it says. >> So I asked you, but I I wanted something ironclad.

2023
11:08:02.320 --> 11:08:18.240
That's why I'm taking it to the voters. >> Very simple. I want on the next agenda. Obviously, the problem is that we have a deadline. >> Yeah. And so I'm not sure we would meet the the I want I want it but I I we can do it. We can do we'll call special meeting. >> Okay,

2024
11:08:18.240 --> 11:08:34.960
>> Mr. Mayor, the deadline is July 24th. >> Not a problem. I'll call a special meeting >> which I know that I'll hopefully my colleagues will support. If you want to protect green space, it will take it will be 15 minutes. >> I would support it. >> So understood. Mayor, we are happy to take the direction. We will draft the

2025
11:08:34.960 --> 11:08:51.680
question to address the sale reszoning um reuse. I'm just want to get some clear direction. the use >> again. >> My intention is to make sure that there can never be a discussion ever again about a park,

2026
11:08:51.680 --> 11:09:07.276
a golf course, or the youth center being used for anything else than what it's intended for. >> Understood. >> Which is a park, the youth center, or a golf course. >> Very simple. If you want to make it

2027
11:09:07.276 --> 11:09:23.276
even, we would like to make it even more difficult. Maybe that's just trying to see what ironclad really could look like. >> So before it could I'm just talking out loud. Before it could be proposed on a ballot, if you wanted to sell a green

2028
11:09:23.276 --> 11:09:40.160
space, then you would need a four-fifth vote before it could be even considered for being on the ballot. Would that make it more would that make it even more strict? Anything requiring a supermajority vote is always a stricter process. >> Yeah, it's just a friendly suggestion

2029
11:09:40.160 --> 11:09:56.640
there. Listen, >> I I accept anything that again makes it even harder. Yes, Commissioner. >> Through the through the mayor. Um what if we just change the wording so that it's any property that has ever been used as a park? Because

2030
11:09:56.640 --> 11:10:12.320
then it doesn't matter. you can change the land use and you still can't sell it because it's tied to the property's use in history. Would that >> and I think that was the intent of saying that the that those details would be fleshed out in the ordinance because we could define it as parks in our parks inventory

2031
11:10:12.320 --> 11:10:27.520
>> etc and so forth. So that was the intent of defining that via ordinance. >> As the vice mayor mentioned 75 words is really difficult to encompass. Obviously, this is very important and very um large piece of legislation that would be fleshed out and all those

2032
11:10:27.520 --> 11:10:44.000
details, rightway easements, vacation, utility easements, that would all need to be fleshed out in an ordinance as would open park spaces is a term we use in our comp plan. We have open park spaces that are not on our park inventory, some that are, some that aren't. And so to to flush that out at

2033
11:10:44.000 --> 11:10:59.276
at you know at the mayor's direction but again we're happy to flush that out as much as we can in 75 words and a charter. >> Again I left a safety valve when we talked about our reserves which was at the manager's discretion for emergencies. Right. You have an emergency you you can't wait for the

2034
11:10:59.276 --> 11:11:15.680
next election. I want to make this ironclad. So but I want to make this election. So, so >> I'm going to make I'm going to make a suggestion pass this now. >> If we can find that we can add more to

2035
11:11:15.680 --> 11:11:31.840
it within 75 words, fine. But it might be clear if we break it down into more than one question. >> That's what other municipalities have done. They have separate questions about long-term leases or um other transfers. It's just >> difficult to fit in one question

2036
11:11:31.840 --> 11:11:47.116
>> and it would be less confusing for the voters and think about whether we should call v voters electors or voters. I've had those questions. What are electors? >> We'll say voters. >> Okay. >> We're happy to take that that edit. And

2037
11:11:47.116 --> 11:12:04.160
um I think we can clarify as as mentioned, mayor, that it would be 60% the approval of 60% of the voters voting in that election. Yes. >> Which is the case. And I want to make it clear. I want to take the the commissioner commissioner Lada's comments about four fifths

2038
11:12:04.160 --> 11:12:20.640
supermajority. If potentially if we can add it into the mix, I'm all f in favor of that. And also the vice mayor's comments about let's move forward with this. But in the next week, if we need to come up with second question or third question

2039
11:12:20.640 --> 11:12:37.200
to make it ironclad, I have no issues with that. I will call a special meeting. It will take 15 minutes and we can pass. But I is that fine? >> It's fine. >> So something should be able to get it done >> and I think it's something simple. >> Understood. So this the item and I know we're in the middle of calling role but

2040
11:12:37.200 --> 11:12:53.756
so just to clarify the item being voted on would still include that language about 60% of the voters voting in that election. Yes. And we can discuss in the meantime if we want to make any future changes before the deadline. But if not, stuff like the four fifths and definitions could be fleshed out in the ordinance. >> Because if I may, just one last thing.

2041
11:12:53.756 --> 11:13:08.720
Because we can say all the ridiculously insane, you know, uh, assumptions, leases, and property and transfers since I've been here and I've lived in the city almost my entire life. Um,

2042
11:13:08.720 --> 11:13:24.800
I I don't think we've ever leased leased a park. I know we've leased a parking lot. We leased a parking lot. And by the way, the funny part about when we sold that parking lot, I'm the one on the record that what did I tell make them do, Mr. Manager? Yes. >> When we sold the What do we do with the proceeds?

2043
11:13:24.800 --> 11:13:41.116
>> Uh, buy parkland. >> We had to buy parkland. So, I made it on the record. You're going to sell the You're going to sell the parking lot. Well, guess what? The money has to be used to buy more parks. >> 65% >> 65% of it. So, even when we got money from properties that we sold, which is I think the only one that I've ever seen

2044
11:13:41.116 --> 11:13:56.640
is that one that that we sold, and it made sense because we got what we were going to make in I don't know how many decades up front, and we ended up buying a bunch of parks with it. It was around $3 million. And we also got all the improvements around Doctor's Hospital, the drainage, the sidewalks. I put that

2045
11:13:56.640 --> 11:14:12.880
in as part of the negotiations on the commission floor. >> $100,000 mayor and sidewalk. >> Yeah. >> Plus, plus the drainage. >> Plus the drainage. So my point is that I I can't make I don't know how to make this any more ironclad. I leave it up to the attorneys. I'm more than willing work with the manager, work with my my colleagues, and if we need another

2046
11:14:12.880 --> 11:14:29.116
meeting, we'll have another meeting to do it. Commissioner Fernandez, you have something to say? >> You know, I was just going to say I don't think the concern is any of the five people up here. I think our intent is never to to do any of that. I think the concern is we don't know who's going to be up here 20 or 30 years down the

2047
11:14:29.116 --> 11:14:45.520
road after as Commissioner Lara said, we've put all this effort to get us to where we are today. Um the question that I had is would you have enough time to flush this out by tomorrow at the end of our budget hearing where we can maybe have a special meeting at the end of our budget hearing?

2048
11:14:45.520 --> 11:15:01.840
>> We have we have we don't have enough time to formally notice it. >> Yeah, I think that's the issue is the noticing of a special meeting. Not if we don't if we defer this item. >> Is it a meeting or a workshop? >> Tomorrow's a meeting because there's there will be action. Um I guess we could continue this

2049
11:15:01.840 --> 11:15:17.840
>> tomorrow >> commission meeting. We don't adjourn the commission meeting and we continue it to tomorrow. >> But out of respect for you, I don't have a problem doing that. But out of respect to your staff, do you have enough time? >> We could certainly get something together flesh out a little bit more tomorrow. I think this direction has

2050
11:15:17.840 --> 11:15:33.520
been helpful and to the extent you want to give us even more explicit about if you want to talk about 99-year leases and easements and all of that stuff we can address everything in one. Okay. >> Again, my intent when I brought this up, my intent when I brought this up is I

2051
11:15:33.520 --> 11:15:49.116
don't want any transfers, leases, 99year leases, uh sales. I don't want any of that. Zero. Zero. When it comes to parks, youth center and golf courses, I don't

2052
11:15:49.116 --> 11:16:06.560
want any sales. Zero leases. Um, you know, any trading. You know how you used to trade baseball cards? I no trading of baseball cards. >> Uh, no, no, no. Like, >> so, mayor, I just want to be clear. Are you explicit about the youth center? because we have in the past had other

2053
11:16:06.560 --> 11:16:23.116
recreational facilities like the Kurdike Tennis Center or the Coral Gables Country Club where we have had >> recreational facilities >> leases so that's different than >> leases is different they're not leasing the whole facility >> operating agreements and leases we've had so I just think

2054
11:16:23.116 --> 11:16:38.640
>> but we don't lease a facility as a whole for x amount of time the youth center has different leases for example we have a lease we have a lease with a gymnastics organization >> sure I'm thinking more of the country club for instance that's a recreational facility where We had a a fairly long-term lease with somebody in in mind

2055
11:16:38.640 --> 11:16:54.960
and again happy to take any and all directions >> doesn't have green space. How about green space? >> So if you want to remove recreational facility or just be specific about which facilities we could be more specific, >> right? >> Yeah. I want you we our intention was that that would cover facilities such as the country club

2056
11:16:54.960 --> 11:17:12.640
>> or the adult activity center or >> what else do we have? Kurdike tennis center >> again. But the adult activity center is part of a building that has a 99 year lease with that we own the land. So it gets a little more complicated. That's why I said green spaces. That's why I wanted to make sure it was pinning green

2057
11:17:12.640 --> 11:17:28.880
spaces which is a youth center. >> Okay. >> Okay. So yeah, I think I think it would be helpful if if we feel it's appropriate to continue this meeting till tomorrow. Perhaps we can um speak with you as >> any property that has green space. I don't want to lose it. >> Understood.

2058
11:17:28.880 --> 11:17:44.240
>> Any property. Just think about it. Simple. Anything that has green space, >> that's it >> through through the mayor. I mean, we have a country club Prada. We have lots of green space >> that makes this city special. >> Yeah. >> And no, I don't want to have to worry about

2059
11:17:44.240 --> 11:18:00.160
>> what happens after I leave. >> So, madam city attorney, do I >> do I vote on this issue or no? >> Do I vote on this issue? >> The commission took a vote. >> I haven't given my final votes. We stopped mid vote.

2060
11:18:00.160 --> 11:18:15.276
>> So, >> so just want to be clear on what we're doing. So, the deputy city attorney had another suggestion if you all want to hear um her additional suggestion. >> So, it sounds a little bit like what you were suggesting is a covenant that be executed for each of these facilities that they must remain

2061
11:18:15.276 --> 11:18:31.596
>> facilities and park spaces. >> Parks and spaces. So, that a park remains a park, an open space remains an open space, etc. And that those covenants can only be released after a vote of the electors. Again, whatever you like to do, it's fine with me. As long as it goes before, as long as >> these decisions are yours to make.

2062
11:18:31.596 --> 11:18:48.320
>> Again, again, this is what happens when you bring it. It gets more and more complicated the more lawyers that get involved. Okay? So, >> it's our job, mayor. >> I understand that, but it's also that's why you guys make so much money because you drag the process on. Trust me, I have a lot of you on payroll. Um, so my

2063
11:18:48.320 --> 11:19:05.276
point is this. I want to make sure, be very clear, okay? haven't voted yet to make sure that no green space in the city, parks, plazas, country club, prao, the youth

2064
11:19:05.276 --> 11:19:23.040
center, and our historic golf course and not be sold. When you sell something, there's multiple different types of sales. A 99y year lease, trade, a transfer. You know,

2065
11:19:23.040 --> 11:19:39.680
my daughters are trading those those FIFA cards now everywhere they can. No, no trading. No trading any green space for FIFA cards. None. >> Some of them are pretty valuable. >> I know. But but but in two weeks they'll be not valuable.

2066
11:19:39.680 --> 11:19:55.756
So my point is that I don't care. No trading, no bullion, no transfers, no Bitcoin, none of that stuff. Okay. >> And certainly not Apple Pay. >> Yeah. No and no Apple Pay either. Okay. >> So, mayor, if if you all withdraw that

2067
11:19:55.756 --> 11:20:11.680
motion and we continue the item, we will come back with another we will come back with another >> I withdraw the motion. >> Okay. >> All right. >> We'll we'll enjoy um budget tomorrow morning bright and early at 9:00. >> Yes. >> Maybe after the budget hearing we hear this, but we'll be ready. >> We may we may we maybe at the end of the

2068
11:20:11.680 --> 11:20:26.880
meeting we want to because also we have the prohibition in our code um from continuing a meeting beyond 9 p.m. without a vote of the of the commission. So perhaps at the end of the meeting today, we decide >> I think >> we're extending this meeting right to a certain time. >> We can but we can get through it. We move we move quickly.

2069
11:20:26.880 --> 11:20:42.640
>> No, no, but I'm saying if we're going to continue today's commission meeting till tomorrow until after the budget meeting, we should address that at the end of today's meeting. >> Through the mayor. >> Yes. >> Sorry to be the contrarian, but I I I I think the better course would be that we vote, right? Can't we take care of the details in the ordinance?

2070
11:20:42.640 --> 11:20:58.240
That was the intention, but I'm I think if you give me 10 minutes, I think I could work on a question in return while you guys keep addressing this and maybe we could get it done today. >> I would prefer today or tonight or just bring a C.

2071
11:20:58.240 --> 11:21:14.960
Commissioner, I I I wholeheart agree with you, but that was the reason why I made the comments that I made. >> No matter what you vote on, they'll say, "Ah, you know what?" And look, one of the comments we made up here, you know what? But it'll it'll be somehow someway they'll paper rock scissor and they'll they'll you know they'll they'll sell

2072
11:21:14.960 --> 11:21:31.040
they'll sell the facility, you know, something insane. They come up with a ridiculous ideas to basically undermine the commission. We got to stop that. >> Your your your record is clear. I don't know if the city has ever sold a park to anyone. I I don't even know the answer

2073
11:21:31.040 --> 11:21:47.116
to that question. There's no basis if what you believe is that people are making accusations that have any sort of basis to them. There there is no basis to it. and all the effort you've just spent and this commission has spent debating how we're going to make this as ironcloud as ironclad as practical right

2074
11:21:47.116 --> 11:22:02.720
is is more than enough proof right against anyone and I just personally I don't give power to people >> no I don't give power but may I give you may I give you just with due all due respect may I give you an example multiple examples did you ever believe that somebody would vote against an IG did you ever believe that somebody would

2075
11:22:02.720 --> 11:22:17.680
raise their own salary and vote against giving residents uh the ability to control to control salaries did you believe that people will vote against a November election. Did you believe that? No, I didn't believe that. I didn't think you I didn't think in my lifetime I would see after being up here 13 years to see somebody raise their salary the

2076
11:22:17.680 --> 11:22:34.320
way that I saw it happen here 101%. I don't believe that would happen here. And it happened. I never believed that somebody would say, "Hey, up here, you know what? Let's let's dip into our reserves." After when I got here, we had $15 million in cash and we left and now we have over 60 plus million dollars. I

2077
11:22:34.320 --> 11:22:51.520
never believed somebody would say that after it took us 13 years to go from a double A to a to aa. So, I mean, I've seen I've seen some pretty wild things happen up here. >> Your point is very very well taken. I would suggest that um our attorneys craft away while we can finish out the

2078
11:22:51.520 --> 11:23:07.040
agenda as much as we can right now. >> I'm all in favor of that. >> Yeah, I think we have what, two other items? >> Let's do it. >> No, more than that. I'm >> No, we're good. We're almost there. The city manager items will be quick. You told me. All right. Well, we'll we'll like vice mayor.

2079
11:23:07.040 --> 11:23:22.160
>> Thank you. Thank you, city team, city attorney team. Um F9 >> F9 is a resolution of the city commission directing the city manager to develop and implement a same day permit program for certain small-cale residential work, providing for flexibility and program design, eligible

2080
11:23:22.160 --> 11:23:38.080
permit types, reviewing disciplines and administrative procedures, and providing for an effective date. So, uh, as the sponsor of this item, I think that, um, this is one of those that I don't think is particularly complicated. It's one that I experienced when I knocked on doors during the

2081
11:23:38.080 --> 11:23:53.756
campaign last year that came up often of how we could um, take meaningful steps to try and simplify the permitting for those items that are uh, simpler than a complicated structural renovation or improvement to one's home. So, you know

2082
11:23:53.756 --> 11:24:09.436
what what I'd like to do um is ask the uh city staff to evaluate and bring back recommendations for a same day or an expedited um permitting program for eligible programs here in Coral Gables because this is the type of practical a

2083
11:24:09.436 --> 11:24:25.840
resident focused initiative that can make a real difference for many people in a community. Other municipalities do this, right? So, city of Miami Beach does this. So does um the city of Miami. You just want to help the residents move through the permitting process more efficiently for certain eligible pro uh

2084
11:24:25.840 --> 11:24:43.040
projects. Um for homeowners, permitting is not a um a delay that's abstract. They they feel it uh every single time. Uh it affects an a family's ability to be able to make minor replacements of doors, windows, shutters, make

2085
11:24:43.040 --> 11:24:58.400
improvements to the bathroom or the kitchen, repair a driveway, or complete other work. It's important to their home and their daily life. I think every one of us here who are um homeowners have obviously experienced this in one respect or another. So we have very high standards here in Coral Gables. There's

2086
11:24:58.400 --> 11:25:15.360
no question about that and those standards should never be compromised. But where the work is limited in scope it's nonstructural in nature otherwise you know appropriate for expedited review. Um we should look for ways to make that process more efficient more predictable and more responsive. I'm not

2087
11:25:15.360 --> 11:25:31.840
asking that we remove safeguards. To the contrary, any program that we come up with needs to be designed to protect the city's standards. It should address historic preservation where it's applicable, of course, and ensure that the projects requiring more detailed review, continue to receive it. But for

2088
11:25:31.840 --> 11:25:46.960
the right types of residential permits, it should be able to create create a process that moves us along that respects the resident's time and helps them to move forward more efficiently. So, those are those are my thoughts. You know, I is really a direction to the administration. Uh we have Doug here to

2089
11:25:46.960 --> 11:26:03.116
help give me his thoughts on this um to see whether or not we have the sufficient staffing and operational needs uh so that we can do this and maybe come back with my colleague support um and see some ordinance along those lines. >> The mayor, Mr. Manager,

2090
11:26:03.116 --> 11:26:18.560
>> I think we we can do this. Uh we can we look at various at at the permits that don't have a structural issue and things like this. And I think we have we have additional staffing that that we've that we've um hired. So, we'll be happy to look at this and and have a whole a

2091
11:26:18.560 --> 11:26:35.916
series of of one-day permits. Uh and and uh I think we can do this and I think we can do it effectively. >> That's great to hear, man. I I can almost hear the peels of hallelujah from the hills of Corables, you know, if we can get this thing through. >> May I commission a lot of first I love

2092
11:26:35.916 --> 11:26:50.880
the idea. Thank you. And Mr. Manager, thank you for being so quick on the draw there. Um, I'm all in. But let me ask you a question. What do you do about projects like for a simple project, for example, a re-roofing 3090 3090 with a tile, all these tiles have to be

2093
11:26:50.880 --> 11:27:06.720
approved by the BOA or the city architect, maybe we can streamline the process and say if you pick from this board and you just say, "Listen, this is what I'm doing on the permit." It can be part of the process >> through the mayor. >> Yeah. >> If the color is is one of the colors that's selected, it doesn't have to go

2094
11:27:06.720 --> 11:27:22.000
to the board. It's it it can be a one day permit. Awesome. Okay, good. Perfect. It's a big deal, especially during the rainy the rainy month. The rainy months, excuse me. >> Great. That's a simple one. If we can get those out of the way, it opens up system. >> You're the mayor. >> Yes, >> I agree. It's a no-brainer. You want to

2095
11:27:22.000 --> 11:27:38.240
move on? Second. Let's go. Okay. I so move. >> Do we have any public comment? >> No, Mr. Mayor. >> All right. We have a sec. We have a second. Move and a second. >> Commissioner Castro, >> yes. >> Commissioner Fernandez, >> yes. >> Commissioner La, >> yes. Vice Mayor Anderson, yes. Mayor Lago,

2096
11:27:38.240 --> 11:27:53.916
>> yes. Um, do we have F11 next or was that was that moved? >> F11. >> F11 is a resolution of the city commission supporting an economic development partnership between the city of Coral Gables and the town of Ball Harbor to encourage reciprocal promotion of each municipality's respective business districts, restaurants,

2097
11:27:53.916 --> 11:28:09.200
cultural institutions, retail destinations, and community events. >> Yes, I I'm the sponsor of this item. I went ahead and I wrote a memo to the commission. Um this came about because Commissioner Levy reached out to me actually through

2098
11:28:09.200 --> 11:28:26.880
social media. He um he spoke to his administration. This is from town of Ball Harbor and they would love to partner with us not spending any taxpayer funds and using the actual resources that we have. I think it would be a great opportunity, especially in

2099
11:28:26.880 --> 11:28:44.400
the summer months, to go ahead and have their constituents come to our city and ours our constituents go to their city. On July 14th, um, Town of Bay Harbor will be presenting this in their city commission as well, and we will hear

2100
11:28:44.400 --> 11:28:59.436
um it's it's not a specific idea. The idea here is that city staff from town of Val Harbor gets together with city staff here and they come up with the best marketing or whatever resolution to

2101
11:28:59.436 --> 11:29:22.240
help the city. Does anybody like to say anything before I speak? >> Um, >> okay. So, >> I was wondering if we had any staff input. >> Yeah. So I I two things. Number one, has our staff reviewed it, Mr. Manager? >> No, Mayor, we have not.

2102
11:29:22.240 --> 11:29:39.200
>> Okay. So, number one is that number two, um I I don't I don't know, maybe I maybe I'm sounding selfish, but our resources are our resources are our resources. I want our staff working to

2103
11:29:39.200 --> 11:29:54.720
market our restaurants, to market our businesses, to market our stores. Why would I want our resources to market our harbor? Our harbor. How big is Bar Harbor? Does anybody know as a city?

2104
11:29:54.720 --> 11:30:11.276
>> It's 12 to 13 miles away. It's not >> But how big is the city, though? How many people live in Bar Harbor? Does anybody know? You want me to look it up? >> According to a quick Google search, it's about 3,000. 3,000 plus. So, we have a city that

2105
11:30:11.276 --> 11:30:26.800
we're going to do an agreement with to market their city and their shopping center with 3,000 people, but they're going to benefit of the fact that the city of Coral Gables has 51,000 residents that we're going to tell them to go to Bar Harbor instead of come to the city of Coral

2106
11:30:26.800 --> 11:30:43.756
Gables. I'm I'm kind of wondering whether people are just figuring out where Bar Harbor is and where the Bar Harbor shops are. So, at the end of the day, um I can't support this because our resources should be spent here in the city uh promoting restaurants. We just saw kids that came up here and that

2107
11:30:43.756 --> 11:31:01.200
showed pictures of Miracle Mile storefronts uh that need marketing, that need promotion. So, at the end of the day, I'd rather spend that effort and our and our staff resources um and our marketing efforts. Again, I don't know how we would market them. We put them on social media. We give them our our our

2108
11:31:01.200 --> 11:31:16.960
um our email list. uh what would our plan be to to help out Bar Harbor? Uh my goal and the reason why I was elected as mayor of the city of Coral Gables and commissioner and then vice mayor uh was to promote and protect our city and to make sure that we spend our hard-earned

2109
11:31:16.960 --> 11:31:32.960
monies. When I mean monies, our resources, our staff, uh to make sure that we promote and protect the city beautiful. So, um I'm trying to figure out a reason why we want to promote a 3,000 person city and then are they going to provide the resources and besides the fact that staff hasn't

2110
11:31:32.960 --> 11:31:47.680
reviewed this, there isn't a plan attached to it. Um I I can't support this >> to the mayor. >> One second. Anyone else before >> my my comment as well is, you know, our staff hasn't looked at it. I don't this doesn't make sense to me. It's 12 or 13

2111
11:31:47.680 --> 11:32:04.000
miles away. It's not adjacent. There's a lot of people from South Miami that come in here every single day, which is why with staff, we've been working on developing a plan to have

2112
11:32:04.000 --> 11:32:19.840
trolley service eventually that'll facilitate people moving to and from South Miami to decrease traffic and make it much easier for M students to come here and downtown and patronize our stores.

2113
11:32:19.840 --> 11:32:35.520
>> Anyone else? Yeah, I um I got to say that I'm I'm not supportive of this and it's kind of bewildering to me. Wh why why in particular, Commissioner Caster, why are we why are you selecting Bal Harbor? Do you have any particular connection to Bal Harbor or or have any

2114
11:32:35.520 --> 11:32:52.480
any particular insight into Bal Harbor? You know, perhaps in your your your permitting days, you know, when you used to be a permanent expediter, any connection to Bal Harbor that that we should be aware of? Of course, full disclosure, maybe three years ago or more, they BA shops of B Harbor were my

2115
11:32:52.480 --> 11:33:09.916
clients. They're not my clients anymore. That was before I was commissioner. So, there's no ties to actually there's no benefiting to it. I thought that question was going to come up. And um what the mayor said that how do we benefit? We're mutually going to benefit

2116
11:33:09.916 --> 11:33:26.480
because staff is going to get together with their staff and there's no taxpayer funds really being used for this. This is a benefit to our city at the same level. We're not giving more to them than they are giving to us. And the

2117
11:33:26.480 --> 11:33:42.880
other thing is this is really embarrassing. This is the city of town, the town of Bay Harbor that actually reached out to us, city of Coral Gables, for us to be good neighbors to work with them. And what this commission is saying right

2118
11:33:42.880 --> 11:34:00.400
here, I'm embarrassed that they would even hear it. This is already on their agenda. >> Commissioner, you said Bay Harbor or Bah Harbor? >> B Harbor, I'm sorry. If I can finish answering or providing my comments then um mayor the um the I

2119
11:34:00.400 --> 11:34:17.200
agree with you and that's exactly why I was running is to do everything I can and take all available time resources and support that the city has and direct it to the the promotion of the city only. I mean, this is almost akin to wanting to

2120
11:34:17.200 --> 11:34:33.520
find a way to increase affordable housing outside of the city of Coral Gables. I wouldn't spend one minute doing that as a commissioner. maybe in my private life, you know, but not as an elected official with uh finite time on

2121
11:34:33.520 --> 11:34:50.640
this dis and uh and charged with the singular the singular uh responsibility to promote the the the the health, safety, welfare of the residents of the city of Coral Gables. So, I see nothing in what you're proposing that would lead

2122
11:34:50.640 --> 11:35:07.436
me to want to devote devote time, resources, or support to to in essence assist somebody or or an entity that directly competes with our own affluent shoppers, diners, and people seeking

2123
11:35:07.436 --> 11:35:22.640
entertainment. I I don't see the distinction um you know, in any way. It's we would be devoting time, effort, and resources to promote someone else that's doing, I'm sure, with their own commissioners and councilmen the same thing to trying to promote their own

2124
11:35:22.640 --> 11:35:39.756
city. So, I I I think uh you know, there's there's there's a lot there that's missing and um and uh and and I'm still a little bewildered why, you know, or what it was that Bal Harbor said to you when they reached out to you

2125
11:35:39.756 --> 11:35:55.116
that made you feel that there's a metric you can point to or some measurable um denominator, right, that will show how this would improve Coral Gables >> through the through the mayor. One of the things that they discussed was maybe

2126
11:35:55.116 --> 11:36:11.040
like one day the constituents of Bah Harbor can visit Coral Gables and we can give them a discount or something like that. I said that you know our restaurants are privately owned and that I would find that to be difficult but that I would leave it up to staff to

2127
11:36:11.040 --> 11:36:28.400
decide what is the best way that we can partner with each other. Um, >> if I can give you a bit of advice, if you'd like to do something, if you'd like to do something else, >> finish really quick. >> I thought you had finished, but let me just add something to that. If you if you'd like,

2128
11:36:28.400 --> 11:36:45.436
>> why don't you work with the chamber so you can connect the M Harbor Chamber with the Coral Gables Chamber and connect the business community and hopefully that will drive drive some synergies between the business community. Um, I I just I understand

2129
11:36:45.436 --> 11:36:59.916
what you're trying to do and and to promote our businesses and our community, but there's just such a finite amount of resources here in the city and I think we have to concentrate on on the city of Coral Gables first and foremost, not another community. >> Okay. If I can go ahead and finish my comments. >> Go ahead.

2130
11:36:59.916 --> 11:37:16.240
>> Um, one of the reasons here was to go ahead and bring constituents or visitors of Ball Harbor. They have a lot of visitors that normally do not visit Coral Gables. And that was one of the points to bring different people in into Coral Gables. And maybe we can use the

2131
11:37:16.240 --> 11:37:30.720
same strategy to do the same, but at the same level, it's not that they're going to benefit more than us or we're going to benefit more than them. It's a mutual agreement to benefit both. And I wasn't proposing nothing crazy. Maybe putting it on our

2132
11:37:30.720 --> 11:37:47.116
calendar or our social media. That's minimum. I I really do not see why we wouldn't want to bring more people into Coral Gables that I think we have similar constituents in both. Not an

2133
11:37:47.116 --> 11:38:03.596
amount, but in things that they like or the restaurants they like to dine in. >> Okay. Um would you like to make a motion? >> I will move it. >> You sub it? You said >> I will move it. >> You move it. Do we have a second?

2134
11:38:03.596 --> 11:38:18.400
>> Through the mayor. >> Go ahead, sir. I don't think we should have a vote on an item that is going to pin us against another municipality. Um, >> Commissioner, with all due respect,

2135
11:38:18.400 --> 11:38:34.160
>> if I was if I was if I was putting on this agenda, I would >> defer it, bring it back, uh, after talking to maybe Belkus and trying to see if there's a plan that would make the rest of the of our colleagues comfortable because I think having a

2136
11:38:34.160 --> 11:38:49.840
vote up here that's not going to go a positive way, it's just not going to look good with another M. If I may, I'm not I'm not disagreeing with you, but my job as the as the mayor and the person who runs the meeting, I got to call a vote when it's a resolution. I hear you. >> So, at the end of >> Okay, commissioner,

2137
11:38:49.840 --> 11:39:06.080
>> I'll second for a vote. >> Okay. Uh, do we have any public comment? >> Perfect. We'll close the public comment. So, we have a motion, a second. >> Commissioner Fernandez, >> no. >> Commissioner Lada, >> no. >> Vice Mayor Anderson? >> No. >> Commissioner Castro?

2138
11:39:06.080 --> 11:39:22.480
>> Yes. Mayor Lago, >> you want to make a comment before? >> My comment was uh going through the chambers I think is the appropriate route. >> Thank you for that. I also vote no. Uh moving on to the next item. Uh F14, I'm going to defer. It's a it's a longer conversation. It

2139
11:39:22.480 --> 11:39:38.480
deals with code enforcement and it's a simple one. Um I just want my colleagues, you know what? I'm not going to defer it. I'm just going to tell you really quickly. I'm just going to tell you, just get out of the way. Just get out of the way. It's very simple. I would love my colleagues. Don't worry. I would love my colleagues just to not that they're not paying attention. They

2140
11:39:38.480 --> 11:39:53.360
have their eyes and ears on everything, but just to pay special attention to the waterfront. I'm going to bring it to the next commission meeting. I'm going to bring this out to the next commission meeting. I'm getting calls from residents and emails. They have gotten two emails from residents if I remember

2141
11:39:53.360 --> 11:40:09.436
correctly. Laura will have to remind me where they're saying there's a lot of code enforcement issues on the waterways. It gets overlooked. Again, it's it's not, you know, we're doing a great job in the front facing properties, but and on the sides because I know people have been caught for canopies when they don't have canopies

2142
11:40:09.436 --> 11:40:26.080
on the side. So, that have installed illegal canopies, but the back they're having some code enforcement issues. And I'd like to see, Mr. Manager, if we can get some input from the commission and from your team to basically just I don't know how we can do it. I don't know if it's I know our police have have code

2143
11:40:26.080 --> 11:40:44.640
enforcement have a have excuse me have um have boats but do our code enforcement team have boats on the water >> microphone >> uh mayor I think what we can do is team up with the police department and ride the waterway with them >> great idea >> and and have code enforcement ride along

2144
11:40:44.640 --> 11:41:00.640
with with our waterway patrol and and and make sure that we that we uh a lot of times it gets overlooked because that's really the back that's the back of house, but it's not really back of house when you have when you have a waterway. So, so we can ride with a with a police department and have code ride

2145
11:41:00.640 --> 11:41:16.720
and uh and and and take care of that issue. >> And also maybe we can have someone from Greenspace Vegetation look at the overgrowth in certain areas because you have certain areas, for example, on Blue Road that I've seen some very large invasive species that are on people's properties that, you know, we can figure out a way hopefully remove them like

2146
11:41:16.720 --> 11:41:33.916
those uh pines, those large pines, Australian pines and stuff like that. >> Happy too. We're going to have green space and code, >> right? >> Can we talk about that at the next commission meeting? Yes, ma'am. >> Give it a little bit more smoke after you've talked to to your staff. >> Yes, ma'am. >> Mr. Clerk, we'll we'll defer this item to the next commission meeting. >> Um F15.

2147
11:41:33.916 --> 11:41:50.720
Um Mr. Clerk, this is an item that discusses the cost of April referendums. I'd like for you to briefly uh give us an overview and um >> Absolutely. >> because there's been again a lot of misinformation. a lot of misinformation.

2148
11:41:50.720 --> 11:42:07.916
>> Just wanted to uh brief the commission leading up to the April vote by mail referendum election. There was a lot of conversation about what the cost of the election would be. The commission requested or the city requested from the supervisor of elections an estimate of what the election would cost. The number

2149
11:42:07.916 --> 11:42:24.240
that the city said throughout the whole process was $82,000. That was the estimate that we received from supervisor of elections. I brought it to the attention of the mayor. the city finally received the invoice from the supervisor of elections. It was $81,650. >> Okay, you can take credits. Okay.

2150
11:42:24.240 --> 11:42:40.240
>> So, it's not about saving $350 or anything like that. >> It's okay. I got it. I got it. >> It was about the fact that, you know, we we received an estimate. We stuck to that estimate and the, you know, when the final invoice came, it was below the estimate. Uh projecting at the November

2151
11:42:40.240 --> 11:42:57.116
election, the estimate is supposed to be less than $15,000. So, if you combine the cost of the special vote by mail referendum election we had in April, the cost of moving now having a second election in November of 2026, those two elections would still be

2152
11:42:57.116 --> 11:43:12.960
cheaper than having an election next to Gables. It may not be a lot, but we're a small department and when you move those elections from April to November over the next five years, we're talking over $600,000. >> And we have a slide. There's a slide here.

2153
11:43:12.960 --> 11:43:30.960
>> Yes, there is, sir. And by the way, I I'd like to uh give credit uh to somebody who's watching, a resident by the name of Tom Wells. Um I did this I did all this work to just to showcase uh the actual savings because he came to multiple meetings and refuted

2154
11:43:30.960 --> 11:43:47.680
the actual savings over the long run. So this is especially for for that resident so that he can see very clearly what the numbers are and um that he and this thing I apologize, Mr. Mayor. And this savings would only be for the regular election. If there is no runoff

2155
11:43:47.680 --> 11:44:04.080
election, then the savings will be doubled. >> Yep. Look at those numbers. Look at those numbers. So, that's what we said for a long time for for about a year when I was harping about moving elections in November and I remember I got pummeled pummeled for this, but here it is. The proof is in the pudding.

2156
11:44:04.080 --> 11:44:19.116
>> Thank you, Mr. Mayor. >> Oh, thank you, sir. Thank you. And I'm very, very proud to put that up there. So, I hope everybody sees the facts of the facts. All right, moving on. F-16. This one I'm very proud of.

2157
11:44:19.116 --> 11:44:37.436
um as the sponsor of the FIFA soccer watch party with the amazing work of staff. Staff deserves all the credit. ACM, DCM manager, the directors, all our public works team, our police, our firefighters in the back, all our IT,

2158
11:44:37.436 --> 11:44:55.360
public works, parks. Mr. Director, you guys deserve all the credit. Can you give us a quick recap with some photos to show how successful that is and tell us what are the next watch events that are forthcoming? >> Thank you. So, here is some of our team that made it

2159
11:44:55.360 --> 11:45:12.160
possible um before the game. Got a fire chief there, our ACM. >> So, there was a lot of yellow shirts. A lot >> there was a lot of Colombia versus Portugal. >> They didn't fare so well today, right? They lost against Switzerland. They just

2160
11:45:12.160 --> 11:45:28.080
lost penalty kicks. >> Brutal >> penalty kicks. >> No, it was penalty kicks. Four to three. >> Brutal. Yeah. Four to three penalty kicks. >> So, we did get there was a lot of spirit. Um, what you're looking at right now is kind of the >> You know what was awesome? >> The calm before the storm. >> You know what was awesome about this? And we took this early. This place was

2161
11:45:28.080 --> 11:45:42.880
packed. >> That's what I'm saying. This is the calm before the night the night photos. >> You know what was amazing about this, Mr. Director? The amount of families, kids that were out there. >> Yes. >> And everybody, you know, they were in full force. Look at this. It was a great environment. We had some items for the

2162
11:45:42.880 --> 11:45:58.160
children, bounce houses, but it got to that point, we started having to get rid of the bounce houses. We were running out of space. >> We had our staff sitting on it trying to get the air out. But, uh, it was great. We were able to, we had our vendors, our

2163
11:45:58.160 --> 11:46:14.480
vendors were great. They, uh, followed all the FIFA rules of no branding. Um, and they were very supportive and they were very happy. Um, they can't wait for the next one. I want to take a quick moment and I forgot to mention uh the plaza the plaza

2164
11:46:14.480 --> 11:46:31.680
who helped us sponsor uh this event uh along with everyone at the city. Look at this at night. Look how this was >> it it was packed. >> Yep. >> There was an energy there. People were enjoying the game. People were going to the plaza. They were buying food. They were having drinks at the plaza. They were coming back. So these are the type

2165
11:46:31.680 --> 11:46:48.560
of events that again in my opinion are when we've done these events in the downtown, they energize the downtown. These people leave here 8:00, 9:30, they go have dinner. People are walking all over the downtown with the Columbia jerseys on, having dinner, going to bars, you know, going to books and books. Uh, look at that. I mean, that's

2166
11:46:48.560 --> 11:47:04.800
amazing how many people are there having a great time. Families. So, >> great job. Thank you. >> Great job. So, we do have we're going to have some more. Um, so the third place game, which is on that Saturday of the

2167
11:47:04.800 --> 11:47:21.436
18th, and the final, which is the 19th, we're going to have watch parties there as well. So, there'll be two more coming our way. >> So, Mr. Director, >> yes. >> I want to talk to the manager and through the manager, I'd like to see if we can promote it again as heavily as possible. Start now. Yes.

2168
11:47:21.436 --> 11:47:36.960
>> Put it on our newsletter. Uh, Martha Madin does a great job. You know, start putting it on email. Start getting people out there. I mean, we did this on such short notice. DCM crushed it. >> Yep. >> The DCM crushed it. I mean, it was incredible the work that you guys did along with your team, all the public works.

2169
11:47:36.960 --> 11:47:52.640
>> The public works team was out there in full force. Those guys were amazing. >> Great. >> Amazing. Firefighters, police. There was a there was a huge presence. Everybody felt safe. >> And we did that in how many days would you say? >> Eight, nine days.

2170
11:47:52.640 --> 11:48:08.880
>> Maybe. Yeah, it was quick. >> How much media? How much media did we How much social media time did we do? >> Uh we didn't have that much time. We we uh we had Martha's help. We had all the park sites. We did as much as we could, but it was quick and we still got really good turnout. >> I mean, we got a lot of people. >> Yeah.

2171
11:48:08.880 --> 11:48:22.720
>> So, >> through the mayor. >> Yes. But it seems to me from looking at this that um and like you said this at night it was super explosive with the the turnout >> that far more uh families, visitors and

2172
11:48:22.720 --> 11:48:40.000
seems like a far more inclusive event was held on uh at Pawn Circle than than one would imagine would be held in one single private establishment, you know. >> But you know what's incredible? People who wanted to go have a let's go let's have an alcoholic beverage. They walked

2173
11:48:40.000 --> 11:48:55.520
over and they had it at the plaza and they walked back. They had multiple different bars open at the Lowe's. They had the Salosa bar open. They were able to have drinks there. If you wanted to have if you didn't want to eat for example the food that was in Pono Park you walked over to Sang Sanguage or you

2174
11:48:55.520 --> 11:49:10.800
walked over to Joe in the Juice or you walked over to you know follow the chow or you walk >> so it was more inclusive for anyone of people who want alcohol somebody who have kids you you everybody did something for and then it it benefited a far larger group of uh of businesses as well

2175
11:49:10.800 --> 11:49:25.840
>> and by the way the parking was amazing I didn't hear one complaint about parking people got there everybody was it was a controlled crowd People were excited. This is the type of event that is only going to grow exponentially once we

2176
11:49:25.840 --> 11:49:43.520
deliver on Pon Circle Park. This is what I foresee Pon Circle Park being at at least once a month. Could be something really special. Really special. >> You're the mayor. >> Yeah. >> Um is there a way cuz you you're saying you had to get rid of the bounce houses.

2177
11:49:43.520 --> 11:49:59.360
>> Yeah. Do we have the resources to close down the street as we do for the pumpkin patch in order to keep them running and have that area for the kids or maybe move the vendors out there so that we have more space for people to to be in the in the park? >> I think it's more resources in terms of

2178
11:49:59.360 --> 11:50:16.000
police. Um, for us, I think from a practitioner's standpoint, I'm not so sure we needed the the all the bounce houses, the little kitty play area, which was the small one that doesn't take up enough space. Um, and you can always do like a bounce house and not an

2179
11:50:16.000 --> 11:50:30.880
obstacle course. So, we were looking at at how we can minimize that footprint um to make sure that we have a little bit of kid activities and not take up too much space. >> Could I add let me let me add something to that? Yeah. Because maybe it's not the bounce houses, but look at the

2180
11:50:30.880 --> 11:50:46.960
turnout that we had. We didn't have any time to really promote this. >> Correct. >> If we're going to start promoting now for the 18th, >> you know, >> and we're talking about 11 days away. >> People that experienced this, >> whether you're Colombian or you're you're American or whatever it is that

2181
11:50:46.960 --> 11:51:02.560
you are, you want to enjoy the World Cup and they're going to say, "We're coming back here. Look at the experience that we had. The weather's going to be better. You know, the atmosphere is going to be livelier. It's going to be the World Cup final. It's going to be the third place game." Y >> So maybe we close off that street if it works out. I'm just putting it out there. It's up to leave it up to the

2182
11:51:02.560 --> 11:51:17.200
manager. >> We close out the street and we put our vendors there so we can fit more people in in the actual park itself so they can have more seating. Nobody complained about there seats. Everybody brought their own seating. Everybody brought their own like you saw that young baby

2183
11:51:17.200 --> 11:51:33.756
out baby on a on a on a beautiful blanket enjoying themselves. So maybe we close and we re and we push the traffic away from from one side of Pon Circle Park or we close both sides of Pon Circle Park and we divert traffic. I know it's difficult. I know it's difficult. We push traffic.

2184
11:51:33.756 --> 11:51:48.240
>> Yeah, it's just resources. We can we can look at it and see >> it allow people to it'll allow people to walk >> from the plaza on one side easier and we could put vendors on the other side or both sides or regions on regions on the region's bank side and we just closed it

2185
11:51:48.240 --> 11:52:03.520
off and we push people um towards Ljun and we push people towards 37th Avenue and we put up those signs. I'm just giving ideas that because I have a feeling that it was so successful and people are going to be here just like Fourth of July. How many >> the second time it's been successful >> and I'm going to give you an example right now when we talk about Fourth of

2186
11:52:03.520 --> 11:52:19.756
July. I heard Fourth of July was packed. All I received was phone calls of people telling me, "I've never seen so many people here." >> So, if that was successful, imagine after we had this event, >> what people are going to be coming to. >> Yeah. And uh couple of important points.

2187
11:52:19.756 --> 11:52:35.200
Fanfest is closing up. So, now there's going to be need to be more outlets for people to watch the games if they want to watch in this kind of atmosphere. One thing I did want to mention because you mentioned the design of the park. Um Maria Deuia was actually there. um the designer of the park. So, take a look

2188
11:52:35.200 --> 11:52:51.040
and see how how we do events there. So, as we work through the design and everything, um she's able to see what a what an event looks like there with placements of tents and everything else. So, that was good, too. >> Okay. >> Yep. So, we'll get started. >> Amazing job. Amazing job.

2189
11:52:51.040 --> 11:53:06.640
>> Uh moving on to uh item F17, the recap of Fourth of July festivities. All I got was phone calls and photos from people talking about uh the drones. I'd like to give credit to the vice mayor. She came up with that idea a few years ago and

2190
11:53:06.640 --> 11:53:22.400
she brought it to fruition. Amazing. I I can show you text message people writing me. They were making bets. They were making bets how many drones there were. And I said and I 350 drones because I wrote I wrote staff and I said, "How

2191
11:53:22.400 --> 11:53:39.276
many drones do we have out there?" And it was 350 drones is what they told me. The amount of people, how many people do you think were there? >> We think at least over 30,000, maybe more. >> Largest ever >> could be close. We'll have to see what

2192
11:53:39.276 --> 11:53:54.000
the numbers are when we get it. We we don't have them yet. Um but yeah, it was, you know, at 5:00 we were like, it's a little. And then by seven, we were like, >> it was it was it was quite packed. >> You know what? And I had people I had two two uh owners on on the golf course

2193
11:53:54.000 --> 11:54:10.000
call me and say next year we need the drones to be higher >> and the music to be louder. I said you've lost your mind. >> Yeah. Yeah. >> You I told it to the manager. >> I don't know if we can connect speakers all the way on but they but they said we want to hear the orchestra >> through the mayor. Yeah. >> And actually that's an issue that we've

2194
11:54:10.000 --> 11:54:25.756
talked about it every year because the folks who are not in front of the stage cannot hear any of the music. So, if you're on the uh where the food trucks are, there was in the past there was no sound. The other complaint that I got was not enough uh drink stations to purchase drinks.

2195
11:54:25.756 --> 11:54:40.160
>> Yeah. >> Uh we had a family uh from church. They told me they were in line for 45 minutes to buy drinks. >> Well, >> so we we may need to look to expand that. But Mr. Mayor, at 5:00, Fred and I were talking about it. It looked empty. And by the time the fireworks show

2196
11:54:40.160 --> 11:54:54.560
started, but people waited until the weather conditions cuz at one point we were expecting thunderstorms. >> It never happened. Never material is the thunderstorms were at the airport and people just came out. Y >> it was it was that and the heat. >> Yeah.

2197
11:54:54.560 --> 11:55:00.960
>> So I mean it turned out fantastic. Um,