stream it and you'll know here in a minute because it'll go up here and this is going to stop blinking so you always want to make sure media is now streaming live on
YouTube so you can go over here is that you all right we're closing that see that see how that happened it recorded me so what you want to do is you want to come over here and you want This
one brian we ready to proceed yes sir as you might find in the courthouse downtown but we are bound by the basic rules of due process and fairness and that all the evidence and testimony pre received today must be what is called
substantial and competent that is evidence that must be allow a reasonable person to reach a reasonable conclusion on the subject at hand uh we will be very open and allow anyone who wishes to testify in response to the city's allegations to do so and present any
evidence that they may wish to present um in the event there is no one here who is a respondent the city will proceed to make its case and we'll make a due diligence investigation make sure there's been adequate notice for the hearing uh but after that we can render a decision as to whether or not uh the
requested relief is u justified one of the requirements of the law and for substantial and competent evidence is that all testimony must be sworn i'm going to ask those persons who will be testifying today uh to please stand and we have Mr
bartelli got to learn that name mr artelli and Row are both testifying david you raise your right hand for me you slemly swear or affirm the testimony given today should be the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth yes sir all right and what the record show they both answer in the affirmative
all right we're going to take the cases uh in order to appear on the agenda understand we are down to two today yes city has been able to obtain compliance because we have the cases scheduled therefore we take it first case number
1245 property located at 113 West Oakill Drive in Pala owner of record Jesse is it re a Jesse or Jesse A jesse Ring jesse Marine okay i just came across Jesse A i want make sure I had
that in the right order so it's Jesse Ring all right is Jesse Ring present or anyone representing Jesse Green you see yes sir um Christy Lo city of Placa code
compliance officer this is going to be case number 2024 045 the address in question is 113 West Oakill Drive Palaca Florida and yes sir this case is coming back for a second hearing this was a transfer case from Mr green um this case was legally
transferred to me April 1st 2025 and the evidence that I have to present is that the same um violations or the original violations are the same that the house still has and this I first reserved these in
uh these violations April 1st 2025 let me do a little due diligence first if I may yes sir um Mr re or no one representing Mr green has answered the call i just want to make sure we have uh due process satisfied uh did you send
certified letter regarding the notice of hearing and the purpose of a hearing today to the official address of record of the property appraisering tax collector i did sir and uh also posted on the property and the pocket of daily news and on city hall all right and the address of 113 West Oak Hill Drive
Florida 32177 that is the subject property address correct that is correct sir and that's the official address of record on property appraiser and tax collector's roles that's correct sir looks like the green card from the postal service was sent back unsigned and therefore you post to the property yes sir have you
had a chance to talk with Mr ring i went by there several times um there's a vehicle there but the tag is uh the registration isn't current uh the neighbors said they haven't seen anybody in a while there is no water on at the property um I've been trying to locate
this this subject um going back on Mr green's notes he was not able to make contact either all right the original violations uh which were see the original hearing was what date the original hearing was
June 18th 2024 that's correct sir all right and since that time there've been no compliance there's been no compliance it's actually deteriorated worse and the original three violations were of section 30-171 windows with broken or missing
windows in the home is that correct that's correct sir and 3169 the municipal code building fronts and sides of budding streets or public areas paint deterioration and 30-169 building fronts and sides of budding streets or public areas mold and build is that correct that's correct sir and
the pardon the sections of the ordinances are included in the record that's correct sir all right show me what you have all right if we can go to you can go to the photos please 1b so this particular photo was taken by Mr green on June 13 2024
can we let me rotate back around so I don't get vertigo i don't know how to um rotate it and these photos by Mr green were originally entered in the record at the hearing last year correct yes sir so this is going to be 1C my photo that
I took okay and the date of this photo is what i took this on April 2nd 2025 sir and here you can see the mold of mildew that's still on the house and it's it's worse shape than what it was on 1B
sorry I can't rotate it and this is basically the go to build on both awnings and on the the shutter area of the right side windows that's correct sir okay and the solution was just have it pressure washed pressure washed
and that's worse than it was in Yes sir that it's it's gotten a lot darker since the original all right go ahead so this is going to be 3B that Mr green took on the same date uh June 13 2024
and it has a broken window and if you would go to the next slide please proceed is there a way to maybe exit when you see us going like this it's a good sign there you go no so this is going to be the same window same view this was taken on April 2nd 2025 by
myself but still has the broken window this one broken window okay this is a view from So this is right on Westfield on the roadway this is the front of the house front of the house yes sir
right and that was a um 30-171 that's correct sir very good next so 5B would be the next one um I apologize sir this is one that Mr green took on June 13 2024 it shows some
deteriorating paint thanks for the tip and if you go to my slide right here which is going to be Did you get it turned okay if you go to the next slide so we're looking at the cables yeah we're gonna be looking at
5C 5c hit it one more time so right here at the root this is the the right side elevation yes sir but you still see it from the street you can still see it from the street uh West Oakill and it just has some deteriorating pain in the front
and that's worse than it was yes sir it's deteriorated worse all this vegetation hanging off the gable was that an original violation not in the original violation no sir i'd have to start a new case on the violations that I've noticed but again that solution was pressure
washing it was pressure wash um the mold and mildew uh and repaint a fresh coat of paint on the deteriorating paint which was you have deteriorating paint view yes sir to replace the broken window which was still the only one window was
on the front element on the front yes sir very good all right anything else no sir that's all for this the paint in 5C was on the right elevation the right elevation it just make it consistent with the rest of the house so basically paint that side of the house pressure
wash the gable on the side gable on the front the two window uh shutter areas and the two awnings that's correct sir and none of that was done none of that was done sir and the total fines to date are $15,300 and today the city is seeking an
official lean of fines to place on the said property of 113 West Oakill Drive and there is somebody in there somebody fix I have not um actually we all went and um nobody came to the door there's a vehicle there it does look like there's
some foot traffic where the grass has grown up but nobody came to the door okay all right based on the evidence of testimony presented and finding that due process has been satisfied by the um service uh as required by state statute
and finding substantial incompetent evidence exists to show continued unabated violations of section 30-71 of the city code due to broken or missing windows specifically one broken window in the front elevation of the house facing West Oakill Drive a violation of
section 30-169 regarding paint deterioration on the right elevation of the house as seen from West Oakill Drive and 30-169 building fronts and sides of budding streets or public areas molded mildew on the gables on the front and right side
of the house and the awnings over windows on the front of the house and the shutter areas on the side of the windows on the front of the house correct sorry correct and finding that the city has asked uh for uh an order and I will grant an order uh authorizing
the city to place an official lean on the property uh to be recorded in the public records as of today's date the total fines $15,300 i shall continue to acrue what was the what was the daily rate $75 sir
$75 per day or $25 per violation until compliance yes sir anything else on that one no sir that's it okay turning to case number 2024077 property located at 119 North
15th Street in Palatka warren the owner of record is Warren Fels at all i presume there are some other owners of the property is that what that is i think that's his initials you're going to handle this one very good please proceed and this is a case
by the way we're also looking for lean case yes sir in position of lean all right please proceed let me ask first is Warren Fels here or anyone else who claims ownership interest in the property or anyone representing Mr fels
or anyone else represent um claiming ownership interest in the property now you can proceed um Harold Martelli City Placo code enforcement um this reference case 2024077 for property at 119 North 15th
Street in Placer um the violations that stand are deteriorating paint mold mildew roof and disrepair and missing elements uh this was a transfer case to myself from Mr david Green okay
now look at the due process yes sir the attempted to send certified letter to the official address of record yes sir that's correct and how did that turn around no green card were returned at this time the very first hearing there was one that was returned but the second time nothing was was it signed when it
was returned the first time yes I received nothing the second time sir and the official address of record is 4511 Song Sparrow Drive Middle Florida 32068 yes sir and that's the same address as occurred in the first hearing yes sir all right that's the official
address of director of the property praise the tax collector's rules yes sir any contact with Mr felds or anyone else who claims ownership of this property no sir not this time i've been by the property several times just update pictures and photos and that appears to be vacant okay was that the result of a complaint
or generated by the take i was curious if there was a complaintant when you had a chance to talk to the complainant say that it says city staff city of service in the record yes sir
showing posting both at the property here at city yes sir all right uh three four original violations 30-169 of city code regarding deteriorating paint I presume on the side on the sides of the house seen from south north 15th street
yes sir 30-169 mold and mildew 30 uh 32 subsection 10 roofing and disrepair and 30.3 subsection 30.3.2 two subsection
A10 missing components I presume of the architectural features yes sir originally when the case was in there was five charges uh upon assuming the case I went out took pictures uh there was a charge or a fine for debris and trash the time I went out there assumed
the case that was no longer there present so that case was that charge was So I noticed in the uh documents included in the file that total fines are $20,900 that's correct sir is that glue taking away the Very good
all right um do you have some photographs you're about to show yes sir did you take these photographs i have taken half of them the other half was in the file from previous one that Mr green had taken well and they're dated that you look at the ones you took are the most current yes sir all right the other photographs were taken by Mr green and
made a part of the record at the previous hearing which was held on June 18th of last year yes sir all right all right you have number the little closed captioning is right in front of the number let's see uh that was the posting of the notice
all right number these things so this was uh April 2nd 2025 yes sir all right what are you trying to show me there that was just a posting in the back uh 1 C okay and you pass some documents which were
all part of the official records of the city and part of the official records of this file yes sir correct and those are true and correct copies yes sir correct there are a lot of them so this was a picture taken by Mr green
this is 1B originally yes sir mr green's taken that was May 2nd of 24 hold on hold on go back and this was a This is reference to the violation yes sir trash and debris um rotten wood
cherry paint so this one's 30-169 deteriorating paint on the front elevation yes sir the roof in disrepair the front lane the roofing and disrepair in 30 32 sub 10
and that was the stoppet along the gable it's actually the roof riding the edging i'm sorry the roof is rotted okay so that along the top of the roof was hanging down it's part of the Yeah it's like a gable off of them okay
trying to see what part of the roof it was all right anyway Mr green took that one yes sir all right next next one these are all part of the record from Mr green yes this one right here is photo I took I have taken as of March 25th this
is one yes sir uh taken from North 15th Street standing on the street in front of the house uh the trash and debris is no longer there uh the deteriorating pain is still there and the roof in disrepair all right so the violation regarding the dis the roofing and
disrepair is the the item hanging down from the gate there's more comments well I'm just asking what's in this picture oh yes sir yeah i like to put words to pictures because this will have an audio this morning of this so that's what's hanging down off the gable from the
front elevation is is the roof and disrepair part yes sir anything regarding mold and mildew here uh no sir no uh paint the deteriorating paint okay so deteriorating paint the roofing
and disrepair no mold and mild is located on the left hand side i have pictures to come and then missing components it's on the right hand side all right so this is basically 3169 mold 30-2-3-2 missing i mean um 10 roofing
and disreaken by Mr green on May 2nd of 24 roof and disrepair this is a right hand elevation you see it from north 15 okay uh what am I looking at on the top it's just the roof shingles and so forth
yes it's basically was like a tree fell on it and it's rotted is a tree still on it no can you see where the roof is damaged from the Yes the missing what could What could you see when you when you saw the damage
what pieces part of the roof where you see towards the backside the rafters are missing so the wood was broken off as if something had fallen and went through it okay um so that section was missing and everything else is just from old and
brought it away and that was conditioned during the first hearing last year yes sir all right next uh the missing component would be back there on that back i'm thinking this garage area next one this one was taken by Mr all right go back to the missing component
again that point that we're talking Oh you talking about the gable yes sir the gable piece back there is that part of the structure of the house that is covering a section of it so it's basically you can see inside the building so the only solution there was just to fill that
Okay next and this one was taken by myself on March 25th the roof as you can see is some of it has fallen off from the first one the wood um the paint's still
in disarray or the paint is still in disrepair or deteriorating paint can you see any roof trusses exposed those lines out of um just those right there those are trust the wood trusses going across as you can see from the previous picture
half the back off is like they broke off so I'm not sure if they were removed between this time and that time or they just rotted off or somebody took them down okay next uh this one was taken by Mr green on May
2nd 24 this is the left side of the house uh the mold mildew and roofing dis um the mold mildew obvious towards the bottom side there and and so are those trusses like coming down making an overhang there is that what that's supposed to be yes they're supposed to
be overhang but they're all rotted out and the wood's no longer there so that goes to roofing and disrepair yes sir all right and what missing components are we only missing component was on the gate to the side gate yes sir uh the mold mildew on the bottom side there uh
in the center yes sir okay thanks um this is a picture myself I took on 25th of March uh left hand side i'm showing you the gable the roof still in disrepair nothing has been changed um
the moldy was still there i put you cannot see um next one this was taken by Mr green on October 17th and 24th the right hand side the house the roof the missing
components and the paint still is there a meter in that power box i don't know check i can tell you that there's no water running to this house we've checked that city water and city sewer shut off yes sir it doesn't look
like there's a meter there i just don't remember seeing one there or not i don't so from that evidence there's no way to provide necessary supplies sanitary supplies and power to the house the water there are meters run there are but
they're not not in service so it's down but it's not working good next this was a picture taken on March 25th by myself from the from North 15th Street on the road
just a over overview of it right and it's basically no better than it was correct no last no improvements and it's worse in a couple so basically we're looking at deteriorating
paint has not been improved the mold and mildo has not been reduced correct the roofing disrepair seems to have gotten worse yes sir and the missing component is still missing correct that's the one that gave Yes sir is asking for this time is asking for a
lean placed on the property at 119 North 15th Street Black Florida yeah fines so including the adjustment for the previously found violation that has been satisfied of 20,900 yes sir
last call for Warren Feld or anyone else having an interest in the property or anyone representing anyone with an interest in the property seeing attorney one and find the due process have been satisfied by compliance with requirements board of statutes regarding providing notice by
certified mail uh and posting and finds that the substantial incompetent evidence supports that there are continued violations of section 30-169 of the city code regarding deteriorating paint on the um front and right
elevations of the property of existing of mold and mildew again on I think it's on the right elevation left left side of property very good uh continued and worsened condition of the roofing being in disrepair and the continued missing
component of the gate on the garage area in the rear of the property these have remained unabated the city has asked for an order authorizing official lean will enter that order total fines as of today total
$20,900 adjusted for compliance with one of the original five violations which has been since satisfied uh bonds will continue to acrew at the rate of $25 per day per violation until satisfaction anything
else we shall conclude today's proceedings at the end of the agenda including at 156 okay okay it