WEBVTT

METADATA
Video-Count: 1
Video-1: youtube.com/watch?v=R0YUsf7-KvI

NOTE
MEETING SECTIONS:

Part 1 (Video ID: R0YUsf7-KvI):
- 00:06:35: Meeting Call to Order, Pledge, and Consent Agenda
- 00:08:01: Public Input Instructions and Guidelines Explanation
- 00:09:13: Susanna Blazek: Data Center Opposition, Lack of Transparency
- 00:11:29: Joseph Blazic: Data Center Concerns, Tax Abatement, Heat Islands
- 00:14:07: Reverend David Dirkson: Ethical Concerns, Data Center Development
- 00:16:48: Rod Lanners: Data Center Concerns, Transparency, and Impacts
- 00:19:36: Sue Flunky: Community Unity, Skyway Project Concerns
- 00:22:14: Kyle Pike: Immoral Data Center Project Condemnation
- 00:24:43: David: Hyperscale Data Center Moratorium Needed
- 00:26:53: Toby: Data Centers, AI, and Corporate Profit Concerns
- 00:29:24: Bethany Steinberg: Data Center Transparency and Trust
- 00:31:46: Nicole Mills: Disappointment, Data Center's Impact on Home
- 00:35:11: Phoebe Hoff: Hyperscale Data Center, Future Impact Questioned
- 00:37:26: Joyce Landers: City Council Diservice and Misinformation
- 01:00:11: Resolution 26-16: Lead Service Line Replacement Funding
- 01:02:20: Logic of English Development Agreement & Waiver Request
- 01:07:20: Pine Prairie Third Development Agreement Discussion
- 01:09:34: Cheese Fest Update, Firework Display Permit Request
- 01:14:29: Cheese Fest Tractor Pull Road Closure Approval
- 01:15:34: South by Southeast Temporary Liquor License Approval
- 01:16:40: Pine Island Car Show Liquor License Approval Request
- 01:17:48: Resolution 26-17: Pine Island Business Park Final Plat
- 01:23:30: Resolution 26-18: Crescent Subdivision Final Plat Approval
- 01:29:14: Resolution 26-19: 2026 Street Improvement Project Bid
- 01:46:33: Resolution 26-20: Geo Improvement Bonds Sale Approval
- 02:04:47: GIS Data Collector Tablets Purchase Approval Requested
- 02:08:32: Catch Basin Repair and Maintenance Approval Request
- 02:11:33: Resolution 26-21: Hillcrest Water Tower Rehabilitation Bids
- 02:13:18: Claims Approval and Department Updates Discussion


Part: 1

1
00:06:35.400 --> 00:06:53.360
Call me to order. First order of business will be the pledge of allegiance. Please rise if you can. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and

2
00:06:53.360 --> 00:07:09.720
justice for all. Thanks for welcoming everybody for our April 21st General Council meeting. We have a lot on the docket tonight, so we jump right into it. Uh we'll do the consent agenda first. Which includes

3
00:07:09.720 --> 00:07:25.520
March our March 17th regular Council meeting. Um April 7th special City Council meeting, April 7th Council workshop, and a request to reserve Trailhead Park pavilion and waive the rental fees, a request to approve the Castle consulting contract, and a request to approve the

4
00:07:25.520 --> 00:07:43.800
security camera use policy, uh a request to approve the Council meeting and recording policy, and a request to approve the purchase of Pine Park benches. Excuse me. A request to serve alcohol on public property. Make a motion to approve the consent

5
00:07:43.800 --> 00:08:00.840
agenda as is. Second. We have a motion and a second to approve the consent agenda. Anything else? Otherwise, Delina? Aye. Vernon? Aye. Brandy? Aye. And David will be aye.

6
00:08:01.680 --> 00:08:18.160
All right. Next, we will go to our public input, and just a reminder for the some I see some new faces out here. Um just a reminder, we give 2 minutes to each speaker, so please be mindful of your time when you come to the lectern,

7
00:08:18.160 --> 00:08:33.919
introduce yourself, and list your address as and then we do encourage um the audience out here, please be respectful to the speakers um when they're talking, so um both Council and people online can hear. And we also encourage uh the audience when you're

8
00:08:33.919 --> 00:08:51.160
speaking, please refrain from attacking uh Council members or other members of the public or um city staff. And like I said, we'll do 2 minutes, so when you see the clock hit about that 1:50, if you can just wrap up your comments, and then we can have the next speaker come up. And again, make sure you uh when you

9
00:08:51.160 --> 00:09:13.440
come up to the lectern, you introduce yourself and list your address. Susanna Blazek, you're first. Welcome. Good evening. Susanna Blazek, 1315 County Road 3 Southwest. I want to speak plainly and boldly

10
00:09:13.440 --> 00:09:29.320
tonight because the narrative that you've been selling, that it is too late to stop the data center development in Pine Island, is not true. You say, "We can't legally stop it." But every step of the way you've gone out of your way to support and approve all the necessary requirements.

11
00:09:29.320 --> 00:09:45.640
You say, "We never really knew what we were building." But in emails uncovered under the Minnesota Government Data Practices Act, one of which you received, Elizabeth, the subject line is confidential, Pine Island data center. That one is from August 8th, 2023.

12
00:09:45.640 --> 00:10:02.400
Council, I don't know how much you have known, but I do know that our city administrator knew all along, and we can't reach her because she's so afraid that Pine Island will die by stagnation. If we're not growing, we're dying, right? She's instead ruining what makes Pine Island

13
00:10:02.400 --> 00:10:17.520
Pine Island. So, I'm appealing to you, council. We do still have the power to say no. We can choose to protect our community and our environment. Progress should not come at the cost of our voice or our well-being. And money? Yes, money

14
00:10:17.520 --> 00:10:33.520
matters, but it is not everything. We do not want Ryan Companies sponsoring Cheese Fest. We do not want Google giving funds to the Chamber of Commerce. We are not pawns in a game where mega corporations pursue growth at all costs. The best predictor of future behavior is

15
00:10:33.520 --> 00:10:49.880
past behavior. These corporations have shown us again and again where their real priority lies, and it is growth, not humanity. Council, please. This is your responsibility to represent us. Help us. This is your legacy. This is how you will be remembered by our town

16
00:10:49.880 --> 00:11:06.480
and all the people in it. They write articles about councils like you who don't yet have the courage to stand up and do the hard thing, but you will be remembered for it when you do. It is not too late. You could be remembered for having stood up, for having had the courage and having had done the right

17
00:11:06.480 --> 00:11:26.040
thing, and we can still stop the data center. Thank you. Thank you. Mr. Lanners? Here? Not here? Okay, Reverend David Dirkson? Okay, here. Here.

18
00:11:29.360 --> 00:11:46.680
You have to speak a little louder and bring your thing back. Thank you. Welcome. Joseph Blazic, 1315 County Road 3 Southwest. Three things I'd like to address. What is the damage control plan when Google does not adhere to the terms of

19
00:11:46.680 --> 00:12:03.640
the tax abatement and loses its benefits, effectively leading to $24 million of lost funding to our local school and 3 million to our local betterment fund? Remember, their approximate $30 million in savings from the tax abatement amounts to 0.00075%

20
00:12:04.280 --> 00:12:20.040
of Google's market capitalization. How will Pine Island community members feel when they lose those benefits? According to Data Center Watch, 64 billion with a B dollars of data center projects have been blocked or delayed, which amounts to about half of all US data center projects.

21
00:12:20.040 --> 00:12:35.920
Number two, heat islands around data centers. Quote, using a data set of land surface temperatures produced by NASA, a research team led by the Department of Computer Science and Technology at the University of Cambridge found from 2004 to 2024 the surrounding areas of more

22
00:12:35.920 --> 00:12:51.360
than 6,000 data centers worldwide saw an average increased land temperature of about 3.6° Fahrenheit. In certain cases, nearby temperatures increased 16.4° Fahrenheit. Researchers calculated these heat islands could be felt about up to

23
00:12:51.360 --> 00:13:08.760
6.2 miles away from facilities, impacting up to 343 million people globally, end quote. Number three, information that could only be obtained by submitting a state data practices request, which is synonymous with a FOIA request at the federal level, uncovered

24
00:13:08.760 --> 00:13:25.360
data center and tax abatement discussions leading all the way back to 2024. Which leads me to my next question. Why is Rod Steel, our former mayor, who is pro data center, given special access to privileged information via a non-disclosure agreement that no one

25
00:13:25.360 --> 00:14:07.480
else in the Pine Island was aware of? Thank you, sir. Reverend David Dirkson? Reverend Dirkson? I am. Reverend Dirkson, right behind you. Welcome, sir. Reverend [clears throat] David Dirkson, I live at 340

26
00:14:07.480 --> 00:14:27.440
Prairie View Drive Northeast, Pine Island, Minnesota. Tonight, I just want to come back to where I began a few months ago, talking about the golden rule. Do unto others as you have done unto

27
00:14:27.440 --> 00:14:44.760
you. It's the bedrock of ethics. And when Jesus talked about it, he was saying this to some people that were wondering who is my neighbor? Well, we're your neighbors.

28
00:14:44.760 --> 00:15:02.320
We are literally your neighbors. And tonight, I'm sharing some hard truths cuz I've learned some things that have made me very disappointed. With my wife's public disclosure, public information disclosure,

29
00:15:02.320 --> 00:15:18.160
she found an email which was very disturbing to me. Uh it was an email that dates back to February 27th, 2025. This email was sent to the city administrator and the city engineer

30
00:15:18.160 --> 00:15:34.959
by Ryan Companies, who's entitled It was I had an attachment called Skyway Community Talking Points, final. In that attachment, there's this question and this answer about this development. And these are

31
00:15:34.959 --> 00:15:52.480
the words of the developer, not my words. The developer's words. This is 2025, before we even started the AUAR process. Who is it for? Ryan Companies will be constructing this campus for a single client.

32
00:15:52.480 --> 00:16:08.920
A single client. They had a client. It wasn't potential clients. They knew they're making it for a client. And we now know that client was Google. So, if you knew it was that client, you probably also knew it was going to be a

33
00:16:08.920 --> 00:16:47.200
data center. So, we weren't working in truth. Is that how you should treat your neighbor? Thank you. Thank you, sir. Mr. Lanners? Mr. Lanners? Mr. Lanners? Welcome, sir.

34
00:16:48.040 --> 00:17:03.520
Rod Lanners. 1890 High School Northeast, Pine Island, Minnesota. Thanks. Power to the people, not to Google. Proposed data center raises serious concerns.

35
00:17:03.520 --> 00:17:20.720
Lies, secrecy, misinformation information have eroded trust in city government. Transparency builds trust. NDAs and Project Skyway did the opposite. City leaders appear to have been misled,

36
00:17:20.720 --> 00:17:37.560
overly influenced by Ryan and Google. Short-term financial gains were prioritized over Pine Island's long-term environmental health. Critical details, water, power, waste, noise, and emissions remain unclear.

37
00:17:37.560 --> 00:17:54.720
Excel customers are not protected by rate hikes as has been stated. The AUAR shifted from air-cooled, no water, to water and chemical-dependent system. The annual

38
00:17:54.720 --> 00:18:10.720
requested 55 million gallons of water needed does not equate to the golf course usage of 100,000 gallons as stated. The rush the approval process limited scrutiny promised

39
00:18:10.720 --> 00:18:26.800
promises to pause were not kept. Residents' questions have gone unanswered, undermining democratic engagement. Decisions relied heavily on developer data and limited independent review.

40
00:18:26.800 --> 00:18:42.280
A hyperscale data center does not fit into a light industrial designation. Communication has been dismissed rather than collaborative. Threats from leadership has raised concerns.

41
00:18:42.280 --> 00:18:58.000
Environmental impacts remain insufficiently assessed. A full EIS was avoided. Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy lawsuit was disregarded. Ordinances were changed to grant a $36

42
00:18:58.000 --> 00:19:13.560
million tax abatement, shifting costs to residents and local businesses. Bottom line, your actions have been disappointing and shameful. Eroding trust in the process. Residents deserve transparency,

43
00:19:13.560 --> 00:19:36.480
accountability, and decisions that generally put the community first. Are you Are you going to send that? You'll email that? You want it? He do. >> I am. So, it was. Thanks. Thanks. Miss Flunky? Welcome.

44
00:19:36.480 --> 00:19:57.720
Thank you. Good evening, members and neighbors. I just want I'm Sue Flunky, and I live at 317 2nd Avenue Northwest. Is this on? I doesn't sound like it. >> Can hear me? Yes. I am really

45
00:19:57.720 --> 00:20:15.320
kind of tired of the us versus them rhetoric. We're all neighbors. We're all friends. And I'd like to see us continue on in that energy. I've been alarmed with the covert

46
00:20:15.320 --> 00:20:32.000
process apparently of the pending project Skyway. This project is a huge step for this small town like us. Like many others, I had not become aware of this project until late in 2025. I get the local newspaper and don't

47
00:20:32.000 --> 00:20:46.720
remember seeing anything about it before then. I feel like something of this magnitude should have come to the attention of the citizens before any contracts were signed. At a minimum, the press release should

48
00:20:46.720 --> 00:21:02.160
have been sent to the paper. But the best approach would pause the entire project knowing the magnitude of this thing to present it to the people of Pine Island with town hall meetings and

49
00:21:02.160 --> 00:21:19.160
hopefully brought to a vote by the citizens of Pine Island. Now Ryan Industries has apparently has sent a chokehold and the entire project appears to be moving forward with absolutely no recourse.

50
00:21:19.160 --> 00:21:35.120
This is beyond disappointing. The people of Pine Island have had no say in this project and will likely have no say or recourse if the data center becomes a nuisance. We can't even get any questions answered by the council.

51
00:21:35.120 --> 00:21:52.640
Just a sad echo to our cries for inclusion in this extremely impactful decision. How can we peacefully come back together as a community? We look to you, our leaders, to lead us to a peaceful, healthy future. Thank you

52
00:21:52.640 --> 00:22:14.560
very much. Thanks, Jeff. Kyle Pike. Welcome. Can you introduce yourself and your address? >> [clears throat] >> Mr. Mayor, esteemed members of the city council of Pine Island, thank you for your time.

53
00:22:14.560 --> 00:22:31.280
My name is Kyle Pike. I live at 4122 32nd Street Southeast in Rochester. About a half mile from that tornado on Friday. I have come before you today to address the same thing that many of us in this room are concerned about. This data center project that issue here

54
00:22:31.280 --> 00:22:47.080
in Pine Island has been poorly and immorally contrived and its construction must be stopped. You have that in your power. We know that you do and you're not going to do anything and we know that. Months down the road, we're going to be aware of how destructive this was

55
00:22:47.080 --> 00:23:04.040
and you will live in infamy. Project Skyway is estimated to use up to 152,000 gallons of water per day, never mind the ongoing depletion of water in the water table of the townships surrounding Pine Island, heavy agriculture and from industry. Although it is estimated to

56
00:23:04.040 --> 00:23:21.120
create a thousand temporary jobs, only about a hundred permanent jobs will arise from this construction. The Democrats and Republicans on the Pine Island City Council are effectively giving massive massive tax cuts to trillion-dollar companies like Google. The City Council appropriated

57
00:23:21.120 --> 00:23:41.480
You're good. You're good. You're good. The City Council appropriated the use of secretive non-disclosure agreements between city officials, Google and the contractors involved in this project. NDAs are a tool used by the billionaire class ruling our oligarchical country like tyrannical warlords who enforce

58
00:23:41.480 --> 00:23:56.840
their rule over the wage slaves like us not to skate their devious and sycophantic engagements with city officials like you while these companies pillfer our country's of our counties of natural resources. Every member of the Minnesota working class should reject this project on the

59
00:23:56.840 --> 00:24:11.920
basis of its immoral and compromised origins. The City of Pine Island is not representing the interests of our elected constituency as city council members and city officials advance this project. Heed us on this issue or come election season, we will remember your

60
00:24:11.920 --> 00:24:43.080
shameless capitalist pillferings in these chambers and elect representatives who genuinely care for Pine Island, Minnesota, her water and her natural resources. You here? Hello. David. Welcome. Um I'm David. Um I'm from Rochester.

61
00:24:43.080 --> 00:24:59.960
Wait. Oh, okay. Um so I'm a public sector worker and member of AFSCME. Um I'm also a member of Workers Strike Back. Across the country, cities, counties, and states are rapidly enacting moratoriums on the construction of hyperscale data centers.

62
00:24:59.960 --> 00:25:16.280
The Democrats and the Republicans on the Pine Island City Council could do this as early as today. But instead, they refuse to do what working class residents of Pine Island and across Southeast Minnesota are demanding they do, which is to immediately halt Project

63
00:25:16.280 --> 00:25:32.560
Skyway. Green-lighting this project will be detrimental to the working class people in Pine Island and everywhere and it will also take the environment with it. But this should be absolutely no surprise to working people because both Republicans and Democrats on the Pine

64
00:25:32.560 --> 00:25:47.760
Island City Council are playing an active role in making sure this project is completed. Both the Democratic and the Republican parties serve the interests of the billionaires and both are allowing data centers like Project Skyway to proliferate around the country.

65
00:25:47.760 --> 00:26:03.679
That is why I'm also a member of Workers Strike Back, which is a nationwide organization mobilizing working people for an independent fight back against both parties of Wall Street, the Democrats and the Republicans. That's also why we are supporting Kshama Sawant's independent revolutionary

66
00:26:03.679 --> 00:26:19.720
socialist campaign for US Congress. During her time on the Seattle City Council, Kshama won the highest minimum wage and defeated billionaires to win the Amazon tax and we need that type of fight back in Congress. To any working class or

67
00:26:19.720 --> 00:26:33.280
young person who is here watching this and agrees that we need to urgently break from the Democratic Party to stop the proliferation of these hyperscale data centers and I would urge you to join Workers Strike Back. Down with Republicans and Democrats. We need a

68
00:26:33.280 --> 00:26:53.240
party for the working class. Solidarity. Bethany Steinberg. Hello. You here? Here. Hello. Welcome. Thanks so much. Hello again. Uh I'm Toby. I live in Rochester and I'm also a member of

69
00:26:53.240 --> 00:27:08.679
Workers Strike Back, an independent rank and file movement organizing in our workplaces and on the streets against the billionaires and their political servants. Myself along with hundreds of Pine Island residents, both in person and in spirit, are back once again to

70
00:27:08.679 --> 00:27:24.520
shame this council for their unfettered collusion with Google, putting the trillionaire tech giant's pursuit of profit ahead of the people and environment of Southeast Minnesota. Data centers today are being used and expanded due to the increasing need for corporate data storage and the

71
00:27:24.520 --> 00:27:41.960
advancement of dystopian AI technologies that are designed to increase billionaire profits while systematically depriving workers of our basic necessities. One such instance is the pervasive use of AI in health insurance and the denial of care by corporations like United

72
00:27:41.960 --> 00:27:57.840
Healthcare. These technologies can be used in even more sinister ways like mass surveillance. Companies like Amazon, Microsoft, Google, and Palantir are all using their data storage and AI tools in part for the Israeli military to track

73
00:27:57.840 --> 00:28:14.280
and target Palestinians and journalists in the ongoing genocide in Gaza and also to help ICE target and detain immigrants here in the US. Some people will say, "Well, maybe the data center will be used in a better way." But how can working people ensure this? We simply

74
00:28:14.280 --> 00:28:29.919
can't because we don't own it. This is one reason why I'm a socialist. Working class people need to fight for democratic public ownership over big tech and the major energy corporations so that we can decide what is produced and ensure this advancement in

75
00:28:29.919 --> 00:28:45.480
technology can be used in the interest of working class people and not against us. So one way Workers Strike Back is building the fight against big tech, the billionaires, and the Democrats and Republicans that work for them is by organizing for mass strike action. This

76
00:28:45.480 --> 00:29:02.080
May Day, International Workers' Day on May 1st at 5:00 p.m., we are having a rally at Soldiers Field in Rochester. I urge everyone in this room and watching online to come out to hear how we can build this fight back together. Solidarity. Thank you.

77
00:29:02.080 --> 00:29:24.159
Bethany Steinberg. Bethany. Welcome. My name is Bethany Von Steinbergs. I live at 48610 Highway 52 Boulevard. I'm a resident of the Pine Island Township. My husband, three sons, farm animals, and I live 1 mile north of where the

78
00:29:24.159 --> 00:29:40.600
proposed data center will be built. Should these quote secretive plans for a data center continue to move forward, I will be able to see the footprint from my upstairs window. My biggest concern among many regarding this data center, I can speak to many, is lack of transparency. According to

79
00:29:40.600 --> 00:29:56.360
Gallup research, it indicates that transparency is a critical driver of trust, engagement, and retention. When political officials, community members, local businesses, and influencers forego transparency and forthrightness by hiding, sugarcoating, diluting

80
00:29:56.360 --> 00:30:11.840
information, or withholding facts, they make a grave mistake. Immediately, those individuals lose trust in their community. They disengage residents and ultimately lose them. They will leave this community with their tax dollars, with their businesses, I have one, and

81
00:30:11.840 --> 00:30:26.800
brilliant minds and spirits. Not because of the data center, but because of what it represents. Leaders and citizens in a community who didn't care about their people enough to be transparent. Had they not allowed greed, money, status, scarcity to rule their hearts

82
00:30:26.800 --> 00:30:42.800
and minds, they would have surveyed, held forums, sent letters, visited residents. If this was so good for our town, then let us in on it from the start. Transparency requires work. Not just one Facebook post or one line

83
00:30:42.800 --> 00:30:58.440
item in a city council meeting agenda. It requires ensuring multiple from multiple perspectives who will be impacted by these decisions have the full facts and are able to ask their questions before you move forward signing agreements. I don't think you understand fully how

84
00:30:58.440 --> 00:31:13.640
much you've already broken people's trust. But, positively, there is hope. Trust can be rebuilt. The exact same thing that you have withheld will help to fix your problem. Transparency builds trust, engagement,

85
00:31:13.640 --> 00:31:45.560
and retention. So, do what's right. Own your mistake, apologize, and make amends by going back to the drawing board fully transparent. Thank you. Hello. Nicole Mills, are you There you are. Welcome.

86
00:31:46.040 --> 00:32:07.440
Uh Nicole Mills, 12517 New Haven Road Northwest. As this is a recorded meeting and you can watch it 95 times if you care to, I would love if you would set down your pens and actually look at me while I'm speaking. I'm here tonight to let you know how disappointed I am that you took it

87
00:32:07.440 --> 00:32:24.200
completely upon yourselves to make a decision that will have such a potentially life-altering effect on the members of this community. Without true regard for our thoughts or concerns, you have set in motion an irreversible change to the landscape and small-town feel of Pine Island, and I am beyond

88
00:32:24.200 --> 00:32:41.000
devastated. In my life, I've moved approximately 35 times. The majority of those moves were not of my choice as I was a child. My history includes four different elementary schools, two different junior highs, three high schools, and two colleges. I swore that if I ever became

89
00:32:41.000 --> 00:32:57.040
a parent, I would not do that to my child. At our last home in Rochester, we were very happy. We loved our home and that it sat right across the street from our daughter's elementary school, but we gave it up and we moved to Pine Island for a handful of reasons. It was where I

90
00:32:57.040 --> 00:33:11.840
found my dream home. It shortened my husband's drive to work and it put me closer to the studio I was renting on Main Street. And lastly, it provided a good school system for our daughter, one that she would graduate from because it was the only school system I would ask

91
00:33:11.840 --> 00:33:29.320
of her, school change system. For 8 years now, we've been settled here and when I thought about the future, we were still here. In our future here, the building we purchased to be my studio on Main Street was at last completely renovated to reflect my vision of it. Our home, too, was still in our future.

92
00:33:29.320 --> 00:33:46.640
And why is that? Because I thought I had finally found home, that place I never wanted to leave, the place I was finally able to put down true root and relax. Now, thanks to you, it's all changed. Now, when I think of home, I once again see a giant question mark because I no

93
00:33:46.640 --> 00:34:03.760
longer see Pine Island in this picture. And I'm angry and I feel so betrayed by you, the very people that were elected and or hired to look out for our best interests because a city is its community members and I don't see evidence that you truly understand that.

94
00:34:03.760 --> 00:34:19.280
If you did, you would have asked us if we wanted to live in the shadow of the construction process and the existence of this mile and a half long data center campus. And the money? Well, what good are streets of gold if very few want to

95
00:34:19.280 --> 00:34:36.359
live here to drive on them? In closing, I want to say I hope you're feeling shame around this decision you've made. I hope it's keeping you awake at night as it is me and so many of the people behind me and listening online. Those of us that are now planning a different

96
00:34:36.359 --> 00:35:11.240
future in a different city. You did this. Never forget that because we most certainly won't. Joyce Landers, I called Phoebe. I did not Is she here? All right. If you So, they can hear their names, please Okay. Welcome and

97
00:35:11.240 --> 00:35:27.200
your name and address, please. Phoebe Hoff, 12517 New Haven Road Northwest. I'm here tonight to share my thoughts on the arranged hyperscale data center. I'm 15 and I'm a sophomore at Pine Island High School. You can probably imagine my day-to-day agenda is probably similar to your own kids. I get to school early and

98
00:35:27.200 --> 00:35:42.880
I stay late to engage in extracurriculars and I have a part-time job at the Early Learning Center. I'm proud to be a Girl Scout and help my mom run her photography business. Additionally, I'm a member of the Pine Island Roots and Shoots Environmental Club, which strives to make the difference in our community. All this to say, the city of Pine Island has gifted

99
00:35:42.880 --> 00:35:57.280
me with these opportunities to form community bonds and these experiences have shaped me into a passionately driven and opinionated person. If this data center were really for the people, then you would have listened to what the people had to say. The expected time frame for building

100
00:35:57.280 --> 00:36:12.760
this data center is 10 to 15 years. I will graduate high school in 2028 and I could return home from college in 2032 with a bachelor's degree only to find this center merely halfway completed. I could tell you why data centers are horrible, but I'm sure that after all of

101
00:36:12.760 --> 00:36:28.720
this time that you are perfectly well acquainted with the facts. I don't believe this data center will make our town more prosperous in the in the long run and in the ways that truly matter. How are you able to justify this insult to the residents of Pine Island? How does the figure on those checks from

102
00:36:28.720 --> 00:36:45.120
Google outweigh the potential devastation that you are bringing to your community and the environment? If you don't think your actions have consequences on our planet, you're wrong. Our future cannot simply be generated. We share this future, each and every one of us, and even if you won't be there, I will be and so will

103
00:36:45.120 --> 00:37:26.640
your kids and their kids. What kind of world do you want to leave for me and why is it not a better one than the world you were left? Thank you. Mrs. Landers. Welcome. The mayor, council, and especially city administrator Elizabeth Howard have done

104
00:37:26.640 --> 00:37:41.880
a grave disservice to this community. The main role of the city council, of which the mayor is a part of, is to adopt ordinances, policies, and regulations for the health, safety, and welfare of the town

105
00:37:41.880 --> 00:37:57.400
and its residents and businesses. Council members are elected by the town citizens. Likewise, the city administrator is to be responsible for implementing the policies and goals established by the council, managing city staff, and ensuring the

106
00:37:57.400 --> 00:38:14.080
cost-effective delivery of essential services such as public safety, water, sewer, and streets. The city council was is responsible for choosing and appointing the city administrator. As such, the mayor, council, and city administrator are to be upfront with its

107
00:38:14.080 --> 00:38:31.000
residents, listen to their concerns, answer questions, do their homework to learn the pros and cons of a major project, in this case the huge data center, and especially to be truthful to its residents. As many of you know, this has not happened with this project from

108
00:38:31.000 --> 00:38:47.880
the beginning. First, this project started back in 2023 with some of the city residents first hearing about it in September of 2025, in fact, most of the residents. Even when it was not called a data center, but rather the code words

109
00:38:47.880 --> 00:39:04.720
Project Skyway were used, no mention of a data center was given. When concerned citizens went in to speak with Elizabeth Howard about it, we were told that we had heard and read and researched nothing but misinformation.

110
00:39:04.720 --> 00:39:21.560
When asked what company was behind this project, we were told, "We don't know." Another lie. Elizabeth knew from the beginning that it was Google as evidenced by emails from back in 2023 as found in documents from City Hall. Most recently, an injunction was asked

111
00:39:21.560 --> 00:39:39.280
for by local citizens because the AUA argued has wasn't even given the actual numbers of water usage, etc. And or therefore had no idea and shared false information after their alleged study was conducted. They also didn't do due diligence in actually verifying this

112
00:39:39.280 --> 00:39:55.720
information that was shared to them. They left out other areas of concerns as well. Now, this is where it really gets really good. It's 2 minutes. I I'm sorry, but I know. My house is a half a mile from this site, and I need to be able to say what

113
00:39:55.720 --> 00:40:17.560
I want to say cuz our questions have not been answered. Respectfully, Respectfully? >> You're welcome to say that, but it's been 2 minutes. Everybody has 2 minutes. It's not 2 minutes long. Is that long? No. You can talk afterwards, but if you

114
00:40:17.560 --> 00:40:43.160
please uh I will. In the middle In the middle of all this, Ms. Howard asked the council for a full year of severance pay where if she lost her job and with no discussion >> there's not going to be order during the

115
00:40:43.160 --> 00:40:59.800
meeting, I suggest that you we we step out of the room. Of course, it always helps when you talk to each council member the day before the meeting. So, to discuss what's on the agenda and to tell them how to vote.

116
00:41:01.800 --> 00:41:26.760
A lot of So many lies were fed to Ms. Howard opposed to the meeting. People So many You should respect that. So many I call for So many lies fed to Ms. Howard by Ryan

117
00:41:26.760 --> 01:00:11.600
Companies and Google and when then she passed them on to the mayor and the city council. No amount of money will undo the damage caused by this behemoth data center, and you will be known as the people >> Mhm. >> Uh resolution 26-16

118
01:00:11.600 --> 01:00:26.040
which is a lead service line replacement. Are you taking this one Elizabeth? I'll pass this off on to Craig. Craig, who's Craig? All right. Good evening Mayor and Council. So um in front of you tonight is uh resolution

119
01:00:26.040 --> 01:00:41.640
2616 for your consideration. Uh this is for the uh for an application for lead service line funding. So the state has made it a point to uh replace all the lead services and um uh lead and galvanized services in the state. And

120
01:00:41.640 --> 01:00:58.240
this is uh one round of the funding. The uh uh city was included on the um public facilities authority's intended use plan uh for a million dollars worth of funding. So we do have plans um into uh the Department of Health right now for review. And uh uh by passing this

121
01:00:58.240 --> 01:01:14.040
resolution you would um uh give the authority to the staff to uh go ahead and submit the application for the funding. Uh we're expecting uh plans to be certified by the end of June. And then depending on uh um when that funding becomes available,

122
01:01:14.040 --> 01:01:30.040
uh the project may happen this year or may happen next year. So this would be for 52 lead and uh galvanized replacements. Any questions on And those lines are selected. Yep. So yep, we did an inventory. Uh we

123
01:01:30.040 --> 01:01:46.720
started that. We still have quite a few unknowns, but these are 52 that we uh are uh pretty certain are lead or galvanized lines. So yep. Yep. Great. Possible grant stuff from the state that lead. Yep. So this application would this

124
01:01:46.720 --> 01:02:04.440
would be all grant funding. So we do have to um the city would have to up front some of the uh uh costs of uh the engineering and that, but once the funding becomes available we can submit that as a reimbursable. Yep. Craig, so this is an action item.

125
01:02:04.680 --> 01:02:20.960
I'll make a motion to approve resolution 2616 lead service line replacement. I second. Motion is second. Any other discussion? Any none. Delaina. Aye. Vernon. Aye. Brandy. Aye.

126
01:02:20.960 --> 01:02:39.120
And David you'll be aye. Okay. Thank you. And we have some exciting news. We got Logic of English development agreement. Is Steven taking this or are you Steven taking this one? Um yep. So before you in the packet here we have a development agreement um that

127
01:02:39.120 --> 01:02:54.640
is proposed for a new business moving to town um Logic of English. Um they specialize in um English curriculum resources um book/cards things of that sort. They've been operating out of Rochester um recently. They're looking to upgrade the

128
01:02:54.640 --> 01:03:10.000
size of their facility um bring all their material printing in house um and they found a property here in Pine Island that they're hoping to get started on here soon. Um usually you'll see these development agreements when we're platting property. Um in this instance they are just purchasing a

129
01:03:10.000 --> 01:03:26.320
single parcel leaving it as a single parcel. There's no additional subdividing going on. Um but we thought it would be a good idea to um just include the property in a development agreement just to lay out some terms when it comes to um kind of some of the storm water infrastructure that's on there as well

130
01:03:26.320 --> 01:03:44.080
as um you do have as a a handout here a letter from um the Logic of English team um just looking for a waiver of the water storm water and sewer access fees um that they'd be subject to for building on this property. Um they're just requesting we

131
01:03:44.080 --> 01:04:00.640
discuss with them um requests for um TIF abatement things like that. None of those really fit what they were looking to do. Um they're looking for more of uh more relief up front so they can get their building running and get all the equipment in there. Um they're hoping to be uh

132
01:04:00.640 --> 01:04:17.000
up and running by the end of the year. We'll see um if we can get that rolling. So um Bob and uh Craig looked over this agreement. If they have any comments I'll open it up to them. Yeah Mayor and Council. Uh the form of agreement as Steven said is is our

133
01:04:17.000 --> 01:04:33.880
typical uh development agreement. Of course development agreements that we do are most commonly associated with subdivisions of land. Right? When a when a party owns land that they want to develop um a development agreement relates to the development improvements typically. So

134
01:04:33.880 --> 01:04:49.440
we use that as the form of agreement. Steven Steven had the idea of using that as a form of agreement and I agreed with that approach. It's not a perfect fit in the sense that this property isn't being subdivided, but it has other elements of a typical development in that there are development fees to pay and there are

135
01:04:49.440 --> 01:05:04.840
some development related changes to the property. Obviously development of the private improvements. So anyway, so I'm just telling you all that as background. This is our standard form of agreement. It just has a few of the provisions removed from it that wouldn't apply here because this isn't a

136
01:05:04.840 --> 01:05:22.000
subdivision of land into multiple lots. It's just the development of one existing parcel. So but otherwise it's your it's your standard agreement essentially. Excellent. Mr. The property that they're looking at is in the public works, right?

137
01:05:22.000 --> 01:05:39.040
Does it have access from that road or both roads along the cemetery road? Um so I believe they'll have access to both. Um I believe the way it's laid out is they will have an employee parking lot that will have access off of Third Street um

138
01:05:39.040 --> 01:05:54.960
kind of by the cemetery there. And then they will have access um across from the shop across from Trailhead Grill on Third Avenue for um their loading docks for their semi trucks um and other carriers. I know they do a lot of shipping with the uh

139
01:05:54.960 --> 01:06:11.800
USPS and FedEx. Um we did speak with them about that access point. Wanting to make sure that trucks weren't stopping on Third Avenue um or blocking any any roadway there by the shop or by Trailhead Grill. Um so they do have the building set far enough back that if trucks do have to come in turn around or

140
01:06:11.800 --> 01:06:27.000
do any three-point turns or anything like that it can all be done within their own line so they're not blocking any of the public road. I was just thinking too maybe from a standpoint of road maintenance construction cuz I know that road is in tough shape and you know I talked to the public works and they

141
01:06:27.000 --> 01:06:43.320
care. That one probably will need to be redone sooner than wanted to make sure they still have access to their business. Yep. So just like any other property owner on there if we were to go through with a street project there and and choose to assess the property owners they'd be assessed the same

142
01:06:43.320 --> 01:07:01.640
based on whatever our assessment policy is at that time. It's a good question. Any other notes? Otherwise we will take Mayor. I'll make a motion to approve the Logic of English development agreement. Uh

143
01:07:01.640 --> 01:07:20.640
sack and wet waiver fees. Second. Motion is second. Any other questions? Otherwise No no this is not public input. We have motion and second. Any other discussion?

144
01:07:20.640 --> 01:07:37.160
Delaina. Aye. Vernon. Aye. Brandy. Aye. And David you'll be aye. Brings us to our next item is the Pine Prairie development agreement. So this one is a little bit similar. Um this is more common for what has come

145
01:07:37.160 --> 01:07:53.160
before you in the past. Um so back in March a final plat was approved um for Pine Prairie Third. This is an addition to um the housing development down by the elementary school um off of New Haven Road. And more similar to our standard development agreement this one

146
01:07:53.160 --> 01:08:09.600
includes um the provisions about the improvements to the public street um the utilities that will be laid um in that right of way. So again this lays out um those public improvements as well as those whack and sack fees. Um one

147
01:08:09.600 --> 01:08:25.839
addition we made to this is there um as part of the first two phases of the development down there there was to be a pedestrian path um constructed along New Haven Road there that would connect to um the Douglas Trail. And so there is language in here um

148
01:08:25.839 --> 01:08:41.440
setting a date that that trail has to be completed by. Um if it's not completed by that date the city can construct that trail and then um bill the developer for that. So we've been in touch with them and they have every intention of completing that by the deadline we have laid out in here, but we just wanted to

149
01:08:41.440 --> 01:09:00.960
include that language just it's been a long time coming. So we wanted to get it done and and make sure that we have the ability to to do that and get uh compensated for it. Mhm. We got any other questions? Any of the public have any comments? I

150
01:09:00.960 --> 01:09:16.160
thought that. No we're we're in administration right now. Public input is done. Um this will be a motion item. Mr. Second one. I'll make the motion to uh This one now. See.

151
01:09:16.160 --> 01:09:34.120
Pine Prairie development agreement. We have a motion do we have a second? >> Second. Motion is second. Any other questions for Steven? All right, hearing none. Delaina. Hi. Vernon. Hi. Brandy. Hi.

152
01:09:34.120 --> 01:09:53.640
And David will be I. Thank you. So, we are going to be jumping into Cheese Fest, especially the request of Pine Island Firework Display permit, that's coming up. Quickly, man. Is Terry Lynn Yeah. Oh, it's Terry Lynn. Hi.

153
01:09:53.640 --> 01:10:09.400
Yes. Cheese Fest is coming to It is. Super fast. Um every year I try and give the council an update for the upcoming festival. Um so, that's my purpose here today. So, our volunteer-based Pine Island Cheese

154
01:10:09.400 --> 01:10:24.560
Festival committee is excited to be finalizing the details of our 90th Cheese Festival celebration. Festival kicks off Thursday evening with a carnival and food vendors, which was new and well received last year. Also new last year was having food vendors open up at noon on Friday, which

155
01:10:24.560 --> 01:10:40.280
was well received, so that's happening again, and we're excited to have a couple new vendors this year. Um we continue to partner with other businesses and organizations to have Cheese Festival events and assist with advertising, such as the Pine Island History Center open house, a pancake

156
01:10:40.280 --> 01:10:55.640
breakfast where proceeds go to a local organization, pickleball tournament, the Fire Department Relief Association beer gardens and Saturday night entertainment, Cheryl Head Over Heels and Lanes volleyball tournament, the Pine Island Ribbon Run 5K, a free kids day hosted by Miss Angie's Place, Pine

157
01:10:55.640 --> 01:11:11.560
Island Golf Course tournament, Pine Island American Legion events, uh and the Image Committee Cheese, Wine, and Beer Gala, and new this year will be, hopefully if approved, uh South by Southeast beer garden on Sunday afternoon. Um we continue to try and build on the cheese market with a variety of vendors

158
01:11:11.560 --> 01:11:27.360
and offerings to satisfy attendee requests and pay homage to our rich history. We continue to ideate community businesses and organizations engagement by driving awareness and traffic to them in partnership with our Chamber of Commerce. And with this year uh we're ideating with it being our 90th, we're trying to

159
01:11:27.360 --> 01:11:42.480
find a little things here and there that we can add to make it just a little more special. Uh we continue to work hard in advertising our festival community through print, radio, social media ads, and press coverage. Um and we could not be more grateful for the support of City Council, our Public Works Department,

160
01:11:42.480 --> 01:11:59.320
who will put in a very long week ahead of and the weekend of the festival with setting up, making sure garbages are emptied, bathrooms are cleaned, and last but not least, our Fire Department Relief Association, who all but completely dedicate their entire weekend to volunteering in our beer gardens and providing Saturday night entertainment.

161
01:11:59.320 --> 01:12:14.400
I personally am beyond thankful for the less than 10 volunteers that we have that puts this on every year. Um and we just look forward to celebrating with our community. Any questions? I How many years for No, it's been a No,

162
01:12:14.400 --> 01:12:30.280
it's been a while. 90 90, yeah. Very good. I've been involved with that Nice. So, they're planning to put the fireworks again down at the ball field. Yes. So, that night they have Yep, the fireworks will be down at the ball fields. Um

163
01:12:30.280 --> 01:12:45.920
everything's cleared with the schools, road closure for the garden tractor pull, and then the South by Southeast beer garden for Sunday. Okay. Hey, Terry Lynn, can you um confirm the time of the tractor pull

164
01:12:45.920 --> 01:13:04.960
and the road closure? Do you know? I believe it starts at 7:00, and can I get back to you on the road closure time? >> Yep. And that's down on third by the Right at the school. Right behind the school, yeah. Yeah. The lake And we have that in

165
01:13:04.960 --> 01:13:22.680
the memo, and we just have evening for road closure, but we can make it subject to Yes. like an hour before hour after the event. Who does the pet? Remember I These are people for, right? >> Gofer State. I have the contract in my

166
01:13:22.680 --> 01:13:41.600
in my shared drive. I can follow up with it. Um it's like Gofer State Garden Tractor Pull Association, I think, or something like that. Fun. I have a quick question for Terry Lynn. Perfect. Thank you all so much.

167
01:13:41.600 --> 01:13:57.600
So, this will be a motion item for the fireworks presentation. Make a motion to approve Terry Lynn request of a fireworks display permit for the Pine Island Cheese Festival. Second. Motion and a second for the fireworks, and they do they have a fantastic output

168
01:13:57.600 --> 01:14:13.240
there. They have a lot of protection in the fire department down there, as well as to make sure everything's safe, so And that's our insurance. And insurance. All right. Um any questions, Brandy? Nope. All right. Now, we have motion and a

169
01:14:13.240 --> 01:14:29.480
second. Uh Delaina. Hi. Vernon. Hi. Brandy. Hi. And David will be road closure for the Pine Island Cheese Festival, which is pertaining to the tractor pull. Um With Terry Lynn said she can confirm the

170
01:14:29.480 --> 01:14:45.240
exact time, but they aren't closed. No. I really like I think if we make um the motion to support closure of like an hour before or two hours an hour after after cleanup. With that one. And again, the fire department's on standby

171
01:14:45.240 --> 01:15:02.320
for that as well, so Uh motion item. Make a motion to approve the uh road closure for the Pine Island Cheese Festival for the tractor pull any time from Terry Lynn. Bring that one in. Second. We have a motion and a second

172
01:15:02.320 --> 01:15:17.320
for the road closure behind the schoolhouse there. Um and that does not interfere with parking for the people that walked down to the festival, so they got that figured out as well. Uh motion and a second. Uh Delaina.

173
01:15:17.320 --> 01:15:34.000
Hi. Vernon. Hi. Brandy. Hi. And David will be I on that one. Thank you for Cheese Fest definitely will be I. Ooh, which brings us to another Cheese Fest item, which is the that of the request for community Excuse me, the temporary liquor license

174
01:15:34.000 --> 01:15:51.120
by uh for South by Southeast on Sunday. Which that's Sunday afternoon, I'm guessing, for the parade. Right? Yep, so the temporary liquor license is for um down at the Cheese Fest grounds on the 6th and 7th.

175
01:15:51.120 --> 01:16:07.760
Is that Saturday, too, and the I think setting up, possibly. Okay. What's the time? The license is in for Saturday. No, but the fire department relief does the beer garden for Friday and Saturday. That's all. I was just making sure. Yeah. Thank you.

176
01:16:09.160 --> 01:16:25.080
We have a motion item. Make a motion to approve the temporary liquor license for uh South by Southeast for the PI Cheese Fest. Second. Motion and a second for that. We appreciate South by Southeast participation. Um we have a motion and a second. Uh

177
01:16:25.080 --> 01:16:40.320
Delaina. Hi. Vernon. Hi. Brandy. Hi. And David will be I. Um Already looking to July. We got a request to approve the one-day temporary liquor license for South by Southeast to

178
01:16:40.320 --> 01:16:56.760
the Pine Island car show, which is July 26th this year. Uh phenomenal turnout last year, a lot of fun. And it's a nice half day. Um and she had all her ducks in a row last year, so I'm guessing it's going to be the same.

179
01:16:56.760 --> 01:17:14.120
Yep, that's correct. So, very similar to last year's setup, so she'll be able to sell beer at the car show. And that's the car show is between hardware store and city hall. It might be extended to the fire hall, but yes, it would end before the fire

180
01:17:14.120 --> 01:17:31.320
hall. Down south. So, on Main Street. Thank you. They had a great turnout last year, so they're looking for it to show on parking. Nice. All right. Um this will be a motion item. Make a motion to approve the one-day temporary liquor license for South by

181
01:17:31.320 --> 01:17:48.680
Southeast for Pine Island car show July 26th. Second. We have a motion and a second. Uh Thank the uh EDA and the chamber have done a lot of work on that, so Um Delaina. Hi. Vernon.

182
01:17:48.680 --> 01:18:05.480
Hi. Brandy. Hi. And David will be I. Brings us to our Planning Commission. We have uh resolution 26-17, which is approving a Pine Island business park for final plat. This has been a work in the project Skyway. Um we

183
01:18:05.480 --> 01:18:21.600
are in we are in the Planning Commission right now. Here's your key. So, Here's your key, David. No. Hey. You have Planning Commission right now. So, resolution 26-17, who's taking this one? This would be me. So, um we have an

184
01:18:21.600 --> 01:18:37.200
application for preliminary and final plat from G Cubed. Um this is for the Pine Island Business Park. This is approximately 33 acres down off of Bioscience Drive down by the Cornerstone Baptist Church. Um kind of past Peak um down in that area

185
01:18:37.200 --> 01:18:52.120
there. Um we received a plat that plats five lots um and two outlots. This has been platted in the past. Um the lots were a little bit bigger. I believe they're garnering more interest for some smaller

186
01:18:52.120 --> 01:19:08.240
industrial lots. Um so, they're platting to shrink some of those down. Um the property is currently zoned um heavy industrial, and that's how they plan to leave it. Um we received the request for preliminary plat and final plat together. Um according to our city code, we can run

187
01:19:08.240 --> 01:19:23.440
those um simultaneously. Um kind of a quirk with the two plats tonight, this was actually submitted and reviewed by the city back in 2022. Um it went through the Planning Commission, it went through council, it was approved. However, um the way our

188
01:19:23.440 --> 01:19:38.760
code is written, the developer has 100 days to record that with the county. That never happened. So, the plat just becomes void. So, they're bringing it back around. Since this is already, like I said, been reviewed by the city, there weren't many substantive changes. We

189
01:19:38.760 --> 01:19:54.120
figured it'd be most efficient to just run them together. Um So, we did have a public hearing before the planning commission back on the 14th. And reviewed both the final and the preliminary, and they approved both, recommended both.

190
01:19:54.120 --> 01:20:12.040
We did receive title work for this to get to the city attorney for their review for the plat opinion. And then Craig put together some memos in regards to stormwater, the grading, things of that sort. If he wants to touch on those, he certainly can.

191
01:20:12.200 --> 01:20:27.840
Right. Well, Mayor and Council, so yeah, this is kind of a unique situation because the public infrastructure is already in. We have the street that's in the utilities. The one thing that the developer did look at is how the split lot or the subdivided lots can be

192
01:20:27.840 --> 01:20:44.400
served by the utilities. So, they would need to sub out new sanitary and services along with water services, too. So, that will not be done at this time because there may be they may come back if they sell more than one lot. They may combine those. So, we don't want

193
01:20:44.400 --> 01:21:01.880
too many holes in the street out there. So, when they get when they have a buyer and they they know what they're buying exactly for the lot, then they those can be accommodated with those services. So, those are really the only comments that we have. Did you have

194
01:21:01.880 --> 01:21:18.560
You know, Mayor, yeah, Mayor, I I have a plat opinion. It's basically a title opinion that I think we've sent across. Is that right? I think we've Think so. Yes. I think we put that across. So, but I guess my only question, and this is

195
01:21:18.560 --> 01:21:35.040
probably for you, Steven, is [clears throat] so I see that this was previously platted, but the plat wasn't filed and then our code it expires after 100 100 days. Yeah. Just [clears throat] I don't know if you would know this, but I

196
01:21:35.040 --> 01:21:51.246
take it there aren't mylars out in the world floating around from that prior plat. Does that seem right? Would not have been signed by the county at that point. And >> Correct. Yeah, okay. You just want to make sure we don't file inconsistent plats at some point. So, very good. Okay. Yeah, no, nothing other than that, Mayor.

197
01:21:51.246 --> 01:22:05.720
>> [clears throat] >> And then to Craig's point where he talked about um the public utilities were not already being there. Again, like we talked about earlier with final plat, sometimes come development agreements. There was a development agreement for this area

198
01:22:05.720 --> 01:22:22.880
previously with the original plat. So, all of those utilities and public improvements have already been covered in an in agreement. So, we don't need to rehash that again. That's why just the just the plats in front of you. Yeah.

199
01:22:23.520 --> 01:22:40.280
So, this That's the CC movement out there. Yeah. Back on. Um We have any questions for Craig, otherwise this will be an action item. There was a suspension to be voted. Finding zone of the nature that

200
01:22:40.280 --> 01:22:56.640
the road and everything is done in wherever. For the Something on where that Craig is on line with information here and about to approve. So, Appreciate that. Things straight. Thank you, Mayor. I make a motion to approve resolution

201
01:22:56.640 --> 01:23:11.840
2617, the final business park final plat. Second. Motion and second. Um The final plat, Brandy, any comments from you before we vote? No.

202
01:23:11.840 --> 01:23:30.800
Dwayne? Aye. Vernon? Aye. Brandy? Aye. Dwayne and the eyes have it. Thank you, Craig, for working on that. What was the topic? The final sketch to be voted. Give him Give him that thing. We have another final plat which is

203
01:23:30.800 --> 01:23:46.480
going to be out on 8th Street with resolution 26-18, which is approving the Crescent subdivision final plat. With Mr. Runner. Yep. So, we received the application again for preliminary and final plat from Rick Runner.

204
01:23:46.480 --> 01:24:03.400
This is for the property at the corner of 8th Street and County 13. It is approximately 4 acres and it would create three residential lots. Um I'm going to sound like a broken record on this, but this plat was also submitted back in 2022. The planning

205
01:24:03.400 --> 01:24:18.880
commission reviewed it, counselor reviewed it, approved it. And again, it lapsed due to it not being recorded. So, we're kind of going through the same process of consolidating the preliminary and the final. We did have again a public hearing on this at the planning commission meeting

206
01:24:18.880 --> 01:24:35.240
on the 14th. We had some comments from the neighbors on 7th Street. I believe it was. They've had just concerns with runoff. They're kind of downhill from 8th Street. So, they just wanted to

207
01:24:35.240 --> 01:24:50.240
have their voices heard regarding drainage and things as they're they're building out the subdivision just to look at ways that we can mitigate the drainage heading in that direction. And Craig did a good job of explaining to the commission and those homeowners kind of where on

208
01:24:50.240 --> 01:25:06.320
the property each lot would drain to or where it's set up to be graded to. And of course, most of the the runoff would be either back towards County 13 or to the east down 8th Street. So, there'll be a very minimum amount

209
01:25:06.320 --> 01:25:22.640
that goes towards 8th Street towards that subdivision. So, um those questions were kind of answered and then just something to keep an eye on as we get the individual grading plans for these lots will be to keep an eye on that that runoff. But again, I'll toss it over to

210
01:25:22.640 --> 01:25:39.240
Craig. He can kind of run through what he has in his reports. >> prior and hungry, right? This was it was designed a little bit differently. With access out to 8th Street there. >> Yep, correct. So, there would be one access point for the three homes and then for for the three lots and then

211
01:25:39.240 --> 01:25:55.720
they would sub off of that one access point. Um So, but yeah, like Steven was mentioning the drainage, there is a high point that's more on the west side of the property. And so, majority of the water is directed into the swale or the drainage ditch along 1st

212
01:25:55.720 --> 01:26:10.760
8th Street and then directed to the east. So, away from 7th Street. The property is out there. Voicing some concerns. So, You know, but that is an area that Todd and I have looked at as far as needing probably looking at a comprehensive

213
01:26:10.760 --> 01:26:28.320
study, drainage study just to kind of understand where where the water is coming from cuz a lot of it is coming from this whole side of 8th Street and then underneath a culvert and then going towards those properties. So, but that's that's kind of unrelated to this project through a property, but

214
01:26:28.320 --> 01:26:43.880
but that is something that we've been looking at in the future. Which With at least I mean the past we've talked about you know, make sure and I think he's done a good job thus far when he's working out there making sure that you know, soil and whatnot is not being drug out onto 8th Street, stuff like

215
01:26:43.880 --> 01:26:59.440
that for the traffic concerns. And then at some point one feedback from them about that. Brian go right ahead and stop saying what Oh, yeah. >> From that you know, at just people asking about traffic being

216
01:26:59.440 --> 01:27:15.760
and whatnot, making sure that that's which is outside you think Rick's concern right now. So, Correct. Yeah, we did and we talked a little bit about that at the planning commission as well. We looked at the reconstruction of 8th Street, which was 15, 20 years ago when

217
01:27:15.760 --> 01:27:32.560
we started to look at that. Improvements would include widening it out and also realigning that intersection so that way that it doesn't come in at goofy angles there. Come in more at a 90. And then to cut that roadway down so it eliminates a lot of that

218
01:27:32.560 --> 01:27:49.000
that elevation. Or a roundabout. Yep. But again, down down the road that could be looked at a little bit more. And the utilities are stubbed to the site. That was done a couple of years ago. So, there are sewer and water

219
01:27:49.000 --> 01:28:06.840
services out to each of those lots. And just for for the I just spoke with one of the three residents in the planning zoning movement from the town hall and said it all over there. And their concerns with the old spot there water so hot and so close. And but most of Greg's alluded to most

220
01:28:06.840 --> 01:28:23.360
of this has been draining away. So, just because of the corner of planning and everything, they're all They're not the problem. It's the city owns half of this road and County owns half. So, until this is redone, there's not a lot of change going to happen, but we

221
01:28:23.360 --> 01:28:40.040
just have to make the functions of any development up to the next town hall meeting and make sure that everything's not drainage and runoff control, you know, there'll be filtration ponds or something in all this development. But that's

222
01:28:41.120 --> 01:28:59.240
No, it's been Brandy, do you have any questions on that Runner corner there? No. No, okay. Otherwise, this will be an action item for the final plat. I make a motion to approve resolution

223
01:28:59.240 --> 01:29:14.880
2618, Crescent subdivision final plat. Second. Motion and second. Um one gets to work in that zone. Dwayne? Aye. Vernon? Aye. Brandy? Aye.

224
01:29:14.880 --> 01:29:32.200
Dwayne and the eyes have it. Thank you, Craig, for working on that. Brings us to the public works and engineering which we have our 19th resolution approving the 2026 street improvement project bid. Getting the streets going there. Who's taking this?

225
01:29:32.200 --> 01:29:49.320
Greg? Okay. All right. One more here. All right. Uh so, this is um we did open bids on the 26th uh street improvement project. We received 10 bids. Um they ranged in price from 2.1 million up to a little over uh 2.75 million. So,

226
01:29:49.320 --> 01:30:05.440
there's quite a range between the 10 bidders. Um Elcon Excavating was the uh low price bid. Um after we reviewed some of the information uh required information that they submitted along with their bid, uh we found that they did did lack um uh

227
01:30:05.440 --> 01:30:20.240
subcontractor information, which is a requirement of the bid. So, uh we did reach out to Bob. Staff uh talked about it. Um So, that's that's why there are two resolutions in in front of you here tonight. So, um I can expand on the memo

228
01:30:20.240 --> 01:30:36.200
a little bit if you would like, but um essentially the the first resolution would be would be accepting the bid of Elcon Excavating and uh waving that informality and and saying that they are a conforming they did submit a conforming bid. Um and the

229
01:30:36.200 --> 01:30:52.120
second one is to um award the contract to Fitzgerald Excavating, which was the second low price bid um as they had um complete uh submittal with their um with their bidding. So, again, there's about a little less than

230
01:30:52.120 --> 01:31:09.320
$50,000 that separates them. Um in talking with Bob, and I don't want to put words in his mouth, but um there you can waive um the that informality and award to Elcon, um or you can say that their bid was non-conforming and award to Fitzgerald.

231
01:31:09.320 --> 01:31:23.960
There um when we discovered that they did not have the subcontractor information, um I did speak with uh Ross Badger, who's the owner of um Elcon Excavating, and he submitted me a subcontractor list um

232
01:31:23.960 --> 01:31:39.080
within minutes of of me requesting it. So, um he just stated that he uh as the bids were coming in from subcontractors the morning of the actual bid, um he didn't have time to fill out the form and and didn't know who he's going to be using because they were still getting

233
01:31:39.080 --> 01:31:55.720
getting bids. So, um it's important that we know who the subcontractors are because we want to make sure that the the contractor can perform the work, and so that is why uh we make it a requirement for them to submit that. Uh but again, they did submit it after upon request shortly after asking for it.

234
01:31:55.720 --> 01:32:12.160
Okay. So, um Go ahead, Bob. Well, um Mayor and and Council, if I can, um we have um Aaron Dean, uh Mr. Dean is the attorney for Elcon, and he had requested um before the meeting tonight that he be allowed to speak on this as the attorney

235
01:32:12.160 --> 01:32:28.560
for one of the bidders and the apparent low bidder. Uh I indicated, Mayor, that I expected you to allow that since your practice is to allow parties that have items before the council uh to speak, and so I I guess I would ask you to let him do that. But maybe before he does that,

236
01:32:28.560 --> 01:32:44.280
uh I just want to summarize my view very briefly, and then maybe that will help uh narrow his comments a little bit. Uh you see that in the two alternative resolutions in front of you, we have a number of recitals like we always do. Uh the two middle recitals are the first

237
01:32:44.280 --> 01:33:01.320
one is that the low bidder Elcon, and I think this is in in both versions of the resolution, says the low bid- bidder Elcon did not include a list of subcontractors on their submitted form, basically their bid, uh which is a requirement of their bid. And then the second whereas or the third whereas then

238
01:33:01.320 --> 01:33:16.920
says the city council reserves the ability to waive bid irregularities and award the contract to the lowest responsible bidder. In other words, they didn't do it exactly right, but under your bid specifications, you have the ability to waive the way in which they

239
01:33:16.920 --> 01:33:33.960
did it wrong, uh and still accept them as the low responsible bidder. And I guess I just want to say that I agree with both of those uh recitals. Uh I think it is correct that uh submitting the subcontractor list was a requirement of the bid specs.

240
01:33:33.960 --> 01:33:48.880
I think there may be a little disagreement. I don't know if Mr. Dean's going to speak to this or not, but there may be a little disagreement. I think Elcon may take the view that they weren't required to submit that with their bid. I don't agree with that. I think they were required to submit that. I think that is a a bid irregularity,

241
01:33:48.880 --> 01:34:06.800
but I think as the next recital says, it's minor enough that you can waive it. And then at the last thing I would say about this is that I understand from Todd, from staff, that um timing here is not insignificant. The timing here is important. Uh and I am definitely not uh

242
01:34:06.800 --> 01:34:23.080
I don't want to cast aspersions at all. I don't mean to do that at all. I've talked to Mr. Dean a couple times. He's a a a good lawyer, um great reputation. And so, I'm not suggesting anything to the contrary of any of that. Um I would just say that in um his letter to us, you've seen that he's sent us a fairly

243
01:34:23.080 --> 01:34:39.640
long, detailed letter. He does threaten that if uh Elcon is not awarded the contract, litigation may result. That litigation uh would be would include uh an attempt to cause the contract with the second low to not move forward, and

244
01:34:39.640 --> 01:34:56.160
that would delay the project if that were to be successful. So, there is the threat that if Elcon doesn't get the contract here tonight, uh that things would happen that would cause um the project not to be able to move forward in timely way.

245
01:34:56.160 --> 01:35:12.200
So, I'll stop there, and Mayor, and then if you agree that Mr. Dean should get to say a few things, we could let him do that. Would you like to? I would. Come on up to the lectern. Thank you. Welcome. Thank you, Mr. Mayor and city council members, um

246
01:35:12.200 --> 01:35:27.000
city administrator, with Seth with the both of you in the public works department. My name's Aaron Dean. I'm a Twin Cities lawyer with Spencer Fane. I'm a construction lawyer. I don't know a thing about data centers. I'm not here to talk about data centers. I'm here to talk about streets.

247
01:35:27.000 --> 01:35:43.280
So, I represent Elcon Excavating Inc. and its owner, Ross Badger Jr. We are the low bidder. We represent a $2.1 million bid. We present the best value to all of the citizens here in Pine Island, and we're excited to do this

248
01:35:43.280 --> 01:35:59.840
project. It'll cost another $49,000 um if the city awards to the second low bidder. And I just want to say a couple things why I don't think the city should invite that type of controversy by awarding to the second low bidder.

249
01:35:59.840 --> 01:36:16.280
Number one, as the city attorney has already pointed out, under Article 18.01 of your bid specifications drafted by the consulting engineer, you have the right to waive any minor informalities. We are the low bidder. Our bid was responsive to the

250
01:36:16.280 --> 01:36:33.720
solicitation, and matters of responsibility regarding a potential contractor can be decided at bid opening, after bid opening, and anytime up to contract award, which is now. At the time that Ross Badger Jr. submitted his company's bid, he did not

251
01:36:33.720 --> 01:36:50.720
know whether he would be using subcontractors. He has the capacity as a company to self-perform the entire $2.1 million bid. So, really the bid the subcontractor list was unnecessary. As things have progressed since the March 26th bid opening, uh he was asked by the

252
01:36:50.720 --> 01:37:06.000
consulting engineer on April 9th to submit a list of subs, and determined at that time that if he uses subs, these are the be the ones that he would use. He may still go back and still self-perform the entire contract. Um Minnesota's competitive bidding laws,

253
01:37:06.000 --> 01:37:23.080
including the uniform municipal contracting law, really exist to protect you as public officials, to remove any discretion that you have. You have to award to the low bidder as long as that bid is responsive, and Elcon's bid is responsive. We implore you to sign the

254
01:37:23.080 --> 01:37:39.000
resolution awarding the contract at Elcon. It is never a good idea for a Twin Cities lawyer to come to a city council meeting, even though this is the most exciting city council meeting I've attended in 32 years of being a lawyer. I have nothing to do with the excitement

255
01:37:39.000 --> 01:37:54.680
that uh transpired tonight or before or may transpire afterwards. All I can say is that our last resort, our last option, is to commence a lawsuit. We do not want to. I've had other cases with with uh City Attorney

256
01:37:54.680 --> 01:38:10.040
Vose's office, and I've referenced one of them on page nine of my bid protest letter involving the city of Proctor, where we got a contempt order, injunctions, and the city had to pay over $100,000 of legal fees. That would be our last choice. We do not want to do

257
01:38:10.040 --> 01:38:25.360
that. We are excited to perform this contract for the city. We are excited to leave the city streets in better condition than they currently are. We are excited to work with the public works department, with the consulting engineer, all for the benefit of the citizens of this great city who

258
01:38:25.360 --> 01:38:41.120
obviously are very impassioned about the place that they live. So, we hope that after today, you will sign this resolution awarding the contract to Elcon, and that no litigation is necessary. This could be the least controversial thing that happens at this

259
01:38:41.120 --> 01:38:56.480
evening's city council mem- meeting or thereafter. Um you have all of the discretion that you need to sign that resolution awarding to us. Please also keep in mind, we represent the best value. We will save your citizens

260
01:38:56.480 --> 01:39:12.920
$49,000 by awarding the $2.1 million contract to us. I could go on and on, but I think you've heard enough. Thank you for your attention, and I trust and hope that you'll do the right thing awarding to Elcon. Thank you. Good driving and don't veer.

261
01:39:12.920 --> 01:39:34.360
I had to drive up from the Mayo Clinic. So there you go. It's been a great day. I think the since he was fine and you know Alcon was responsive within the final agreement. You know, I don't think you need to do the nature

262
01:39:35.680 --> 01:39:50.280
Can you talk into the mic? I can't hear you. I'm sorry about that, Brandy. Yeah, I was just reiterating that it was good that they were responsive to Craig's call about when he called them about the missing subcontractors.

263
01:39:50.280 --> 01:40:07.520
So I don't see that as a sticking point not go forward with this. But um just a warning to them next time that they need to make sure they have you know, furnish all the information if there is another street project next year. I kind of feel like we're penalizing the

264
01:40:07.520 --> 01:40:24.200
other bids then though because they submitted everything correctly, right? Everybody else did. And so Yes, but I'm also in favor of saving $49,000 for our citizens too.

265
01:40:24.280 --> 01:40:40.720
I understand that, but I also feel like we're being bullied into this. So I'm not a huge fan of it. Well, and like the gentleman reiterated too if their if their company has the capabilities of being able to perform the work without the subcontractors, you

266
01:40:40.720 --> 01:40:56.640
know, taking that into consideration as well. If they're able to do that, you know, which can make that non-void as well. So but you you're correct too, Brandy, in that you know, the other bidders also provided needed materials in that time

267
01:40:56.640 --> 01:41:13.160
and manner. So I mean you raise a good point. I just think that if we set the precedence that if something is said in this regard and they did not do it completely like everyone else did, that everybody's going to ask for an

268
01:41:13.160 --> 01:41:28.800
exception going forward. And we've seen that happen. So in the interest, yes, I know it can save $49,000 or whatever, but it can also cost us more. Mhm.

269
01:41:28.800 --> 01:41:45.360
So there's two different sides to that because we didn't know yes, they can do it on their own, understandable. I understand construction more than you would think probably, but I just feel that

270
01:41:47.160 --> 01:42:03.640
it's not fair to the other bids and it's not like yes, we have the right to be able to do that and excuse it, but I feel like it's again, I just feel like it's not right to the other bids who submitted everything correctly

271
01:42:03.640 --> 01:42:22.160
when that's the way we have our application for for a reason. I appreciate that. And I to your point too, Vernon, with with the 49,000 as well. I mean, we're fully aware that there's going to be some cost passed on to our

272
01:42:22.160 --> 01:42:36.440
homeowners, the property owners with the assessments and that's one thing I'm very mindful of right now just with there's a lot of challenges going on with you know, community members and things like that and being cognizant of being

273
01:42:36.440 --> 01:42:54.520
able to help pass that savings on to our property owners as well. Being mindful of of that and uh you know, if we especially some of the bigger properties that we collect that was

274
01:42:54.520 --> 01:43:13.040
But no, Brandy, I appreciate your points, Brandy. Otherwise, this will be an action item for 19. I make a motion to approve the bid to Alcon that they submitted all the

275
01:43:13.040 --> 01:43:31.000
responsive, you know, information and subcontractors set up for the street project. I second it. I motion a second to award that bid. Any other discussion? Yeah, Mayor, I just no need to change

276
01:43:31.000 --> 01:43:47.480
the resolution that you've just made a motion to approve and had seconded. I just for the record, the resolution doesn't say it explicitly, the resolution awarding to Alcon, but it is implicit in it and I'm going to say it out loud to the extent

277
01:43:47.480 --> 01:44:03.960
someone would argue that it is an irregularity to have not submitted the subs, you are by doing this waving that irregularity. That's implied in the resolution. So I just want to make clear that that's that is what is being approved if that's the will of the of

278
01:44:03.960 --> 01:44:20.120
the council majority. Thanks, Mayor. And we did hear from them that they were capable of doing everything themselves. Yeah, and and I I just said I was done, but I the only reason I say that is I I appreciate the council member's comment

279
01:44:20.120 --> 01:44:37.080
about we expect and we very much want parties that bid for our projects to submit everything that the bids require. And so I guess I'm just making the point that this is the very very odd case where you're waving an irregularity, but we always expect bidders to fully comply

280
01:44:37.080 --> 01:44:53.440
with your bid specs and requirements. And so I I appreciated that comment by the council member and just want to reiterate that with my comments. Mhm. I don't think Alcon's had any street projects with Pine Island in Green Towns. So as long as they're aware of this, we'll go forward.

281
01:44:53.440 --> 01:45:13.840
Hopefully they'll change that precedent. Remind me the bid. Is it a solid like they can't increase it on us or no? What was that, Brandy? They can't No, they're they can't increase the bid. Like if anything changes during the

282
01:45:13.840 --> 01:45:29.320
whole project, they cannot increase it. Yeah, Brandy, this is Craig again. So yeah, this is a unit price bid. So we we pay for the quantities that are installed or or constructed. So So that that 2.1

283
01:45:29.320 --> 01:45:45.400
million is based on the quantities that we provided. If it's if they have fewer quantities, then they get paid less. More quantities, they get paid more. So. And Mayor and Craig, just part of your role of course in your inspection and your work as an engineer, your firm's,

284
01:45:45.400 --> 01:46:01.080
you are verifying that the quantities are in fact reported to you correctly. So when you work that out at the end, whether it's a little net negative or a little net positive, that's something that you're verifying as part of the inspecting and monitoring the project, right? >> Yep. That's correct. So we'll have a

285
01:46:01.080 --> 01:46:16.600
full-time on-site observations. So we're keeping track of quantities every day going through those with foremen and then kind of reconciling that every week and then the pay requests are on a monthly basis. So yeah. Okay, good point there.

286
01:46:16.600 --> 01:46:33.760
Thank you. Yes. Um John, Delaina. Aye. Vernon. Aye. Brandy. No. Brandy. >> Regretfully, aye. Okay. And David will be aye. Thank you.

287
01:46:33.760 --> 01:46:50.680
Thanks for your work on that too, Craig. Which brings us to resolution 2620, which is going to be providing for the competitive negotiated sale of geo improvement bonds series 2626A. Is this a Mike? Oh, he's right there. He made it.

288
01:46:50.680 --> 01:47:07.160
Welcome. Good [clears throat] evening, sir. Good evening, Mayor and Council. Would you like me to just jump right in? Sure. Okay, so I'm here tonight to provide my recommendations on, you know, structuring the debt to pay for the project that you've just awarded the bid.

289
01:47:07.160 --> 01:47:22.000
I think in your packets, do you have those available to you on your laptops? I think it's page 89 where you'll see a spreadsheet that looks something like this. >> Yeah. Where is that?

290
01:47:22.000 --> 01:47:40.880
Craig's found it. And the reason I'll have you look at that is I do have a letter in your packet that lays out the recommendations, but this actually illustrates it and I'll just walk you through it quickly. Is everybody on the same page? >> We're getting there. Oh, okay.

291
01:47:46.560 --> 01:48:02.560
Yeah, just to be clear, it's on page 89 of your packet on your computer, not not in particular item. So it's 89 there at the top of the screen. Awesome. Thank you. Okay, so first of all, we got a number of recommendations and let's first start with sources and uses. And this is going

292
01:48:02.560 --> 01:48:18.920
to be a little more detailed than normal based on the action that the council just took. But in the top left-hand quadrant, you're going to see the sources and uses. I think I had a miscommunication with Craig. I had the construction bid I think at the second bid. No, that was

293
01:48:18.920 --> 01:48:35.600
that was the I said it was for the street city there. Okay. Okay, so now we understand it's $49,000 less. So before I go any further, we've got a couple of options here. One is is I could go ahead and

294
01:48:35.600 --> 01:48:51.760
reduce the borrowing by $50,000 and move forward on that basis. Or alternatively, we could just shift money from the construction number there in the top left and add it to the contingency amount down below. Um

295
01:48:51.760 --> 01:49:08.000
it doesn't really matter to me, but I would be inclined to move it to the contingency amount. The amount that's in there right now is just 5% of construction and oftentimes we see street reconstructions have as high as 10% contingency amount cuz as you tear up into the ground, you could

296
01:49:08.000 --> 01:49:22.680
run into things. Whereas Craig mentioned, um quantities, you know, could be different, and so it just provides some cushion. But that we can maybe address that at the end. Um below those capital costs are a variety of issuance expenses. The first

297
01:49:22.680 --> 01:49:38.200
one, underwriter's discount allowance. Um when the city goes to issue this debt, uh the purchaser of the bonds uh will not pay you full price. They're going to discount how much they pay you for the bonds, because they intend to piece it up and sell it to

298
01:49:38.200 --> 01:49:54.920
their underlying investing customers, and they're going to sell it for full price. So this is their profit, their their compensation. Now, we get to set, you and I, or I should say the council gets to set how much compensation is allowed through this practice. And the rule is you can

299
01:49:54.920 --> 01:50:11.000
go up to 2%. Uh 1 and 1/4% allowance is plenty. So I expect um compensation will be somewhere in that realm. Um but when this pro- when this is bid out, they might bid something less. Okay? So we're just saying that's the maximum

300
01:50:11.000 --> 01:50:28.720
discount. I'm going to touch on compensation more in a in a minute here. Uh the issuance cost down below, a fiscal fee, that's our firm, municipal advisory firm. Bond counsel, that's going to be Kennedy and Graven. Uh a pay agent, what they do is

301
01:50:28.720 --> 01:50:45.160
when these bonds are purchased, and then they're pieced up and sold to all the underlying customers, um payments are going to be due every 6 months. You're not going to want to write a check to all these underlying investors. You want to write one check. A pay agent basically is a invoicing service where you just pay them, and then they

302
01:50:45.160 --> 01:51:01.560
distribute the funds accordingly. >> [gasps] >> Uh printing and miscellaneous, that has to do with the preparation of an official statement, which is the official disclosure document that we provide to the bidders and so forth. And then the rating fee, I'm going to advise getting a Standard & Poor's

303
01:51:01.560 --> 01:51:18.800
credit rating uh for this bond issue. Um you will save potentially upwards of $100,000 in interest over the life of the deal by having the bonds rated versus non-rated. It makes bidders more warm and fuzzy about uh the creditworthiness of the city.

304
01:51:18.800 --> 01:51:34.320
Currently, the city enjoys a double A minus credit rating with Standard & Poor's, which is a very solid rating. I will point out that they have changed their criteria to be more stringent than it has been in the past. So there is a small possibility, I don't necessarily expect it,

305
01:51:34.320 --> 01:51:49.320
but there is a small possibility they could knock it down a notch to an A+. But even if they were to do that, that wouldn't be a reflection on the city. It'd be more of a reflection on the change of their formulas. Um I've seen some cities maintain their ratings. I've seen some

306
01:51:49.320 --> 01:52:04.200
get that adjustment. But regardless, you are going to do better for having the rating than not. The biggest benefit is rated versus non-rated. Whether it's double A minus or A+, the difference between those is maybe 5 to 10 basis points on the interest rate,

307
01:52:04.200 --> 01:52:21.240
but non-rated versus rated could be 50 to 75 basis points difference on the rate. So that's the important piece of it. Um capitalized interest is not an issuance cost. That's basically extra dollars um if you were to take your eyes diagonally down to the right to a column

308
01:52:21.240 --> 01:52:38.280
that says account balance, it's money that you put into the debt service fund to make the first interest payment that'll come due before your taxes next year and special assessment revenues next year. Before those start to come in, we need to have a source of funds to make that first payment.

309
01:52:38.280 --> 01:52:55.400
And so that's why that's there. Now, while that's a useful tool, capitalized interest, it's inefficient, because what capitalized interest is is you're borrowing paid money to pay borrowed money. So if you go down into the sources of funds, you're going to see a city cash

310
01:52:55.400 --> 01:53:10.680
contribution basically of the same amount. And I did speak with staff about, "Hey, could we dip into reserves to cover the first interest payment so that we're not borrowing that capitalized interest?" And we all came to the agreement that you have more than enough capacity to do so.

311
01:53:10.680 --> 01:53:25.840
So that inefficiency is a is basically mitigated by the use of that cash. Um the industry standard is to issue bonds uh in the public markets in denominations of $5,000. So you're going to see a construction fund earnings, which is basically just a rounding

312
01:53:25.840 --> 01:53:41.600
number. And so just to summarize it, recommendations so so far. Number one, offer 1 and 1/4% underwriter discount allowance in the bids. Uh number two, use cash to offset the capitalized interest. Number three, let's get a credit rating.

313
01:53:41.600 --> 01:53:56.920
Um and then number four, let's size the bonds at 2.77 million um as is shown there. Now, below the sources and uses, you're going to see an annualized uh payment schedule. I did mention the payments are every 6 months, but we mush it together

314
01:53:56.920 --> 01:54:13.600
into an annualized form just to save space on the page. And you're going to see two columns of interest rates. You're going to see coupon, and you're going to see yield. The interest that you pay is going to be based on the coupons that get assigned. So when Craig is bidding out your road projects, and they're doing quantities

315
01:54:13.600 --> 01:54:30.000
of blacktop and this and that, and you're getting unit prices, uh what we're going to do is we're going to bid out these principal payments, and then the bidders are going to assign the coupons and the yields. Now, what I'm showing you is that the coupons are equaling the yields, which is basically a par sale.

316
01:54:30.000 --> 01:54:46.560
Now, I mentioned the compensation in the underwriter's discount is limited, but there are things that go on behind the scenes where underwriters can make more money. And one of that one of those ways is through premium sales. So what we're probably going to see when

317
01:54:46.560 --> 01:55:01.520
the bids come in is that the coupons are probably going to be 4 or 5%. But those yields will stay somewhere in the realm of what I'm showing you here. And then what that does is people are underlying investors are paying the the purchaser

318
01:55:01.520 --> 01:55:18.840
money to slap a higher interest rate a coupon on the bonds. And the reason they might want to do that is um based on their expectations of where the market might be in the future. So a real crude example would be, let's say you yourself purchased a $10,000

319
01:55:18.840 --> 01:55:33.160
bond that's going to mature in 10 years with the purposes of maybe it's for a kid's college account, something like that. Uh and let's say you purchased that bond at an interest rate of 2%. 5 years down the road, long before the

320
01:55:33.160 --> 01:55:50.360
bond matures, interest rates rise, and you decided that that kid unfortunately is not going to college, so you're going to cash out, and you're going to sell that $10,000 bond at 2% interest. But the market 5 years from now is 4%. Who's going to pay you $10,000 for that

321
01:55:50.360 --> 01:56:06.600
bond with 2% interest? They're going to pay you something less, because otherwise they could just go buy a new bond at 4% interest, right? So often times what these people will do is they'll pay a premium to slap a higher coupon on there to protect themselves

322
01:56:06.600 --> 01:56:23.240
down the road from that happening. And conversely, the opposite could happen. We could see where people want to uh have the coupons lower than the yield, basically added paying us less through additional discount um for a variety of reasons. One is is

323
01:56:23.240 --> 01:56:38.880
maybe they're not interested in um in generating a lot of income in the early years, but they want to guarantee a certain payback later on. They might go the other way. And this is a long, windy, confusing uh presentation simply to say

324
01:56:38.880 --> 01:56:53.880
that the way we protect against those shenanigans between premium sales and and discount sales uh and and and the compensation of the underwriter is all of that comes into the net effective rate calculation. So if you were to go over to the right-hand

325
01:56:53.880 --> 01:57:09.360
side, I'm projecting a net effective rate of 3.77% there. All of those factors come together to determine the net effective rate. So those shenanigans, if they take place, will impact that net effective rate on their bids.

326
01:57:09.360 --> 01:57:25.800
And so that's the way we protect ourselves is through that bidding process. So ultimately, it's not so concerning, or should not be so concerning, if they're doing those things, um and if they're increasing their compensation through those background sales, because what we're ultimately interested

327
01:57:25.800 --> 01:57:42.360
in is getting the lowest net effective rate and how much we pay over time. So that's the way we control that. Um having said that, when we do the bond sale, if there's a lot of premium sales, often times what they'll do is they will give us the premium back.

328
01:57:42.360 --> 01:57:58.760
They'll they'll slap a higher coupon on it. They collect those premium sales, and they say, "You know what? Our compensation through the discount is fine. We're going to give you the premium back." And then what we do is we reduce this bond when we do the sale. So instead of doing 2.77 million, maybe it's something less. Okay? Based on

329
01:57:58.760 --> 01:58:15.360
those premiums. But all of that happens on the date of sale, which would be basically a month from now. Um I'm showing a term there of basically 15 years. Um that's consistent with prior planning. I've done some capital planning with the city in the past. Um I

330
01:58:15.360 --> 01:58:32.120
believe this project might be less than kind of what we used in our planning at that time. So the impact in terms if you're worried about what these levies and things are going to do, the impact should be less than what we showed um back when we did that work session, which would have been a couple years ago, I think, or a year ago. Yes, I

331
01:58:32.120 --> 01:58:48.080
think that or Yeah, quite a bit quite a bit more. Um in terms of what authority to use for the bonds, if you were to go to the top, and you're going to see in the title of the general obligation improvement bond, basically what that means is you're

332
01:58:48.080 --> 01:59:03.080
using special assessment authority to have the legal authority to issue the debt, and your assessment roll has to equal at least 20% of the project costs. Projected assessment roll is 635,000, so we've met that test. And the good news about having it meet

333
01:59:03.080 --> 01:59:19.880
that test is these bonds do not count against any statutory net debt limits. They're not subject to any protest petitions. There are public hearings associated with the assessments themselves and people could challenge the value of those assessments. But there's nothing that's going to prevent

334
01:59:19.880 --> 01:59:36.400
this from moving forward unless you just choose not to accept the bid. All right. Um on the right-hand side of the page about halfway up there's something called a call option. I'm I'm suggesting 2034.

335
01:59:36.400 --> 01:59:53.120
Imagine you're an underwriter or an investment banker who wants to purchase these bonds and you're selling them to your underlying customers and they do a lot of research on City of Pine Island. Do I want to invest in Pine Island? Um last thing they want to have you do is

336
01:59:53.120 --> 02:00:08.040
issue the bonds and then pay them off next week. They want the investments to be good for a period of time. So what we do in order to entice the bids to make people feel warm and fuzzy about bidding is to put out a call protection far enough meaning you cannot prepay these

337
02:00:08.040 --> 02:00:23.800
bonds until that date. And this is the date that we're seeing on most competitive sales at the moment is 2034. After that date you can prepay in whole or in part at any time without penalty. Okay. So it's just having to wait until

338
02:00:23.800 --> 02:00:41.720
that date if you do that. Um prepayment might be in the form of we just want to buy it down with cash or prepayment might be interest rates are lower at that time and we want to refinance but we would have to wait till 2034 to be clear. Okay, I threw a lot at you. I was trying

339
02:00:41.720 --> 02:00:58.520
to do that quickly. Um why don't I stop see what the questions are. So the rating then will that affect the interest rate? Yep. If we don't have that credit rating while we could reduce the bonds by the 15 or 16,000 dollars there

340
02:00:58.520 --> 02:01:15.160
your interest rate's going to go up and you're going to pay way more. Like the double A minus to A plus. Yep. >> that's going to affect too like Right. Yep. So if we maintain the double A minus credit rating we'll get a better bid than if we go to A plus but the difference like I said is probably five

341
02:01:15.160 --> 02:01:37.040
and 10 basis points. Brandy, do you have any questions for Mike? I do not. I'm not that good. There has to be questions. So are we talking about moving that extra to the contingency then? Yeah. The

342
02:01:37.040 --> 02:01:52.840
excess to go down to contingency. >> And that's what you'd recommend as well? >> I think that's good. Especially if they run closer to 10% that'll help cover some of that. Now let's go down the road where you don't maybe the quantities are just

343
02:01:52.840 --> 02:02:09.520
perfect and we have this leftover contingency money. Any money that's left over in the construction proceeds at the end of the project will get moved to your debt service fund and then what you would do is you would reduce or eliminate one of the tax levies associated with the debt to the extent we can move that money over.

344
02:02:09.520 --> 02:02:25.400
Now if we were to do that I would suggest not reducing the levy altogether. I would say reduce the debt levy by that amount but maybe keep levy the savings and put it in somewhere else in your budget. You know put some money away for a future truck or

345
02:02:25.400 --> 02:02:49.360
something, you know, if that if that happens. Okay. Anything else? You can ask the numbers guy so Yeah. I appreciate your work on this Mike but This is going to be

346
02:02:49.360 --> 02:03:06.840
uh that resolution to put that out there the bid. And the resolution won't require any amendment because we don't talk about the breakdown in the line items. I'll just go ahead and do that as we move forward into the next meeting. Oh and by

347
02:03:06.840 --> 02:03:22.640
the way, what would happen if the resolution passes, the first step is that our firm will prepare the official statement with staff's help. We'll arrange a rating call with Standard & Poor's. I'll sit in on that call along with Elizabeth and whoever else she thinks should be on

348
02:03:22.640 --> 02:03:38.360
there. Um and then we would be back on May 19th. That should be a council meeting night. That morning at 11:00 a.m. we'll open up bids. I'll have to verify the bids and so forth but by early afternoon I should be able to report to staff

349
02:03:38.360 --> 02:03:54.800
where we're at and then I'll present the results that night for the sales resolution. So you're really not past the point of no return tonight. You're basically just saying Mike go forth and make it happen and then a month from now would be the actual locking in. Okay.

350
02:03:55.400 --> 02:04:11.080
It's been a while since we did one of these so This will be an action item. I'll make a motion to approve the resolution 2620 but in the committee motion to sell from general obligation improvement bonds series 2026A.

351
02:04:11.080 --> 02:04:27.680
Second. I have a motion and a second. Any other discussion? Check with you one more time Brandy if you have anything. No, we're good. Thanks Mike. You're welcome. Uh Delaina? I. Vernon? I. Brandy? I.

352
02:04:27.680 --> 02:04:47.040
Vote will be I. Thank you. Thank Thank you all. Good night. We are going to be jumping into some GPS and data collector tablets for our GIS. Hello. How you doing? I'll return reference.

353
02:04:47.240 --> 02:05:04.920
Mayor, council, um looking for your approval to purchase uh Leica Xeno LFX100 GPS and data collector um so we can start do our own mapping in town shooting

354
02:05:04.920 --> 02:05:21.240
curb boxes, manholes, elevations. Um we we need we're well 3 years behind so we'd like to start catching up. Uh Sam and I met with Goodhue County who we work our mapping

355
02:05:21.240 --> 02:05:37.720
GIS with and uh they were pretty excited about getting us going and Sam kind of volunteered to head it up. >> bit so So if you got any questions throw them at Sam. >> [laughter] >> No. Would you like to We're Everybody's

356
02:05:37.720 --> 02:05:52.560
excited. I mean everybody's going to learn how to use it. Uh We'll just turn around and tell them what we'll do with it. And yeah, we can do our own editing. So And you're still recording with Goodhue County if you have a big need or right?

357
02:05:52.560 --> 02:06:09.480
Yep. I. Yeah, there's a resolution that has to be has to be there. I think so. Thanks for it. So how is that with uh with you and the Olmsted County just so people are curious. Are you going over into the Olmsted County side as well to be able to to do

358
02:06:09.480 --> 02:06:26.400
this data or is it strictly Yep. We can we can go on in any of the counties. I. But Yeah, so I It's it's a state bid from Leica um for

359
02:06:26.400 --> 02:06:43.440
$9,297.40. Now there's some software. Sam probably understands software's software stuff more than I do but uh So it's like a $44 a month software. Yeah. So that we need to purchase also.

360
02:06:43.440 --> 02:06:59.280
So for this subscription service I basically buy you with the the software that allows you to run the the GPS. GPS system. Yep. So Okay. You guys and just keep our here's what

361
02:06:59.280 --> 02:07:16.280
the cost and uh If I remember correctly you're what you'd be paying for this to be done essentially going to be covering the cost of Not picking on Craig but if I would hire >> [laughter] >> If I would hire his survey crew in 7 8

362
02:07:16.280 --> 02:07:33.160
days I'd have this paid paid for. That's what the cost of a survey crew and that's not time them editing and Yeah. So Mike Where does this come out of the fund? That'll be coming out of our

363
02:07:33.160 --> 02:07:57.920
utility fund water sewer storm sewer. Thanks. Any questions Brandy? This is kind of more of a maintenance stuff. So Sam's going to take care of all this so I can bother him about it. >> [laughter]

364
02:07:57.920 --> 02:08:14.640
>> Sam will be the man. Sounds good. All right, this will be an action item. I'll make a motion to approve the purchase of the GPS and data collector tablet for GIS. I second. Motion and a second.

365
02:08:14.640 --> 02:08:32.520
Uh any other questions or comments? Mike, Delaina? I. Vernon? I. Brandy? I. Vote will be I. Thank you guys for It'd be nice to see It brings you joy. I'm not going to move on but next to

366
02:08:32.520 --> 02:08:47.280
>> You're on to the next one which is GIS. Discussing our base repair and maintenance for the catch basins there. So I got three quotes uh one from Schumacher, S&L Contracting and Cats Excavating.

367
02:08:47.280 --> 02:09:03.680
Uh Schumacher came in at low 47,000. This is to repair catch basins in the streets that we're going to mill and overlay and possibly reclaim. Um There some of them are in real bad shape, so I want to get them fixed

368
02:09:03.680 --> 02:09:23.640
before we put a brand new mat down, so um So, I'm asking to The quotes came in at 47,000 low, next one was 48,800, and the high was 53,200. You just said wait a people are curious

369
02:09:23.640 --> 02:09:39.040
what that actually means when you talk about the maintenance uh in the two areas, correct? They're not in town. Yeah, I'm going to I'm doing some in in the southeast. I got five blocks in the southeast, and

370
02:09:39.040 --> 02:09:55.720
then I want to do Fish Street northeast. Um We met with a couple of contractors and our streets are This is about it for mill and overlay. We should probably start doing just total reclaim, and that's grinding up

371
02:09:55.720 --> 02:10:12.240
everything and regrading it and putting in 4 in of brand new, so It's going to be a little more costly, but And this once again going in line with our goals of uh getting ahead of the

372
02:10:12.240 --> 02:10:30.600
street repairs and keeping our streets going so you don't fall behind again, so uh And take his recommendation on that, so And I'll have some mill and overlay bids here later. Um we'll get them out. Greg helps us

373
02:10:30.600 --> 02:10:50.240
with that, getting that to the contractors, so This would be an action item for the Motion to approve. I second. Cuz we are Peters done. This one needs a pin. So, just that the request for approval

374
02:10:50.240 --> 02:11:16.120
uh two-year Yeah. Motion to approve it. Schumacher. Yes. 47,000. No. Any questions, Brandy? Nope, if I can get my mute to work. All right. Um Delaina. I. Werner. I. Brandy.

375
02:11:16.120 --> 02:11:33.000
I. And David will be I, which brings us to resolution 26-21, which is planned and ordering the bids for the Hillcrest water tower rehabilitation project, which we discussed here during our work session, which

376
02:11:33.000 --> 02:11:49.240
Yep. Mayor and Council, so this is um again, this would um authorize us to send the plans and specs out for uh bid, and then we'd receive bids on May 14th and bring it back to you on your May 19th meeting. So, um again, we're at

377
02:11:49.240 --> 02:12:06.440
at the end of the useful life of the uh coating system up there on the Hillcrest tower. There was a report that was done uh a few years back, um and so it's it's at that point where it needs to be repainted. Uh some uh minor structural um improvements are going to be made, and then some welding, too. So, um so

378
02:12:06.440 --> 02:12:22.240
it's in need of it. Mhm. I believe there was talk about lettering to it to make sure beyond it. Yep. So, I think as the way we have it right now and where we landed was uh block lettering uh Pine Island on two sides of the uh of the tank.

379
02:12:22.240 --> 02:12:41.920
So, um so it'd be a light gray like the island lights uh tower with maroon match. Uh yep. Just the maroon lettering. Very good. Any action item? Make motion to approve resolution 26-21 for the uh on ordering

380
02:12:41.920 --> 02:12:56.880
bids for the Hillcrest water tower rehabilitation project. Second. Motion and second. Brandy, anything from you before we vote? Oh, excuse me. Uh Delaina. I. Werner. I. And David will be

381
02:12:56.880 --> 02:13:18.040
I. Thank you, Greg. Let us jump to legal, Bob. I don't have anything, Mayor. Thanks. And we'll go to claims. I'm going to have one. I make motion to approve claims. Second. Motion and second on claims.

382
02:13:18.040 --> 02:13:39.800
Delaina. I. Werner. I. And David will be I, which brings us to department updates. Uh Before I forget, um did you want to go first? Or do you want to go? Go ahead. All right. So, just for if

383
02:13:39.800 --> 02:13:56.280
case people are not aware, uh we are um our council meeting falls right in uh line with National Library Week, which is really cool. And uh so, we do have proclamation which I'm going to share so you can have a copy. It needs to be printed.

384
02:13:56.280 --> 02:14:11.400
So, whereas April 19th through the 25th is recognized as National Library Week with the theme Find Your Joy, whereas communities across the United States celebrate the annual event to highlight the valuable role libraries and library professionals play in transforming lives

385
02:14:11.400 --> 02:14:27.720
and strengthening communities, whereas Pine Island has a strong and rich history with the Van Horn Public Library service serving the Pine Island and Serenity communities, whereas I Mayor David Freeze encourage our community members to visit our library and if needed, sign up for the library card, which is will

386
02:14:27.720 --> 02:14:43.960
open endless possibilities. True statement right there. Uh whereas Van Horn Public Library not only boasts a wealth of books, but also provides programming, community support systems, story time, and a path where curiosity and connections can come to life, whereas we recognize our library

387
02:14:43.960 --> 02:15:00.720
leaders as a voice for education and ensuring free access to all forms of education and information, whereas we publicly thank our local library leaders for their service. Now, therefore, in recognition of National Library Week and highlighting the service of our library director and staff, as Mayor of Pine Island on behalf

388
02:15:00.720 --> 02:15:15.960
of the city, I David Freeze do proclaim April 19th through the 25th as Library Week in Pine Island, and in witness whereof I have hereunto set my hand and caused the seal to be affixed. We will seal that. Um

389
02:15:15.960 --> 02:15:38.840
Respectfully, David Freeze, Mayor. And just want to truly thank Rachel and her staff for an outstanding service. That's Thanks. It's recognized. Thank you, Brandy. That was pretty neat. We should also thank public works for

390
02:15:38.840 --> 02:15:55.800
going out and getting rid of that hornets nest out of that my little library. >> Your little library. >> [laughter] >> Somebody alerted Somebody did Somebody did it. Thank them for that job. Do you want to read? I'll just give a quick um word about It's also National

391
02:15:55.800 --> 02:16:12.080
Poetry Month this month, so we've got a poet tree in the library right now, so come on by, write a poem, put it on our pine tree so the kids quit asking why I still have my Christmas tree up when it's actually my Pine Island. Um otherwise, we have brand new HVAC in the

392
02:16:12.080 --> 02:16:28.440
building, a brand new boiler, and brand new um mini split for AC, so hopefully that'll help us going forward. And then otherwise, the first week of June is summer reading program sign-up week, and programming will start at that second week of June, so Heidi has been really, really busy.

393
02:16:28.440 --> 02:16:44.840
And uh yeah, so looking forward to seeing all the kids and their um adults all summer long. So, the HVAC working good? So far, so good. Lot lot smaller. I like that. Thank you very much. Uh public works.

394
02:16:44.840 --> 02:17:02.120
Yeah, we got to say you guys got the park wrestling open. They they got it open now. How's the park going? It's up and down. It was still working on it. We got that park closed down. Looking at that project going, that's

395
02:17:02.120 --> 02:17:18.679
going to be really neat to see down there. Thank you guys for that. Have you started mowing yet? Yeah. Oh. Not sure if park has had to be with that one. Um EDA, we got some news

396
02:17:18.679 --> 02:17:34.920
there. Yes. I'll just give you two quick updates. Um one, the community mural. Uh so, we got that narrowed down to two concepts. Um we got some really good feedback from that committee. Um and we just heard back from Prairie Island. They were able to take a look at the two concepts as well and provide

397
02:17:34.920 --> 02:17:51.160
some feedback to the muralist. Um so, he'll be incorporating everything that was there into a couple more um concepts and get those to us, then we'll we'll look at getting that to the public for a vote on that. Um and then the other is the DNR grant. Just quick update, we're still working through that with the

398
02:17:51.160 --> 02:18:07.400
National Park Service get it find the final approval in the grant agreement. Hoping that uh this time next month, we actually have something in front of you to agree to, but still working on it. Looking so And what's the general feedback from Prairie Island? Pretty good?

399
02:18:07.400 --> 02:18:22.639
Yes. Yeah, they they really, really liked one of the concepts. Um they just wanted to uh adjust a couple of the images in there and then provide a I think it was an eagle um that symbolizes something for them as well, so a couple of those things that they wanted added in there.

400
02:18:22.639 --> 02:18:39.120
And the bison. And and the bison, sorry. Forgot about the bison. And my I wanted to see a bison sooner, so I was happy that you did. Yes. So, it'll be good. That would be good. Thank you. Excellent. Uh fire department.

401
02:18:39.120 --> 02:18:55.960
It was another busy month month of accidents, so that was um Speaking on behalf of Sam Gafke, the chief, the department did a phenomenal job responding to uh some pretty serious ones, so thank our thank our uh fire fighters for

402
02:18:55.960 --> 02:19:12.480
the work they do up there. Um anything else from any other committees? Otherwise, Rachel, thank you for stepping in tonight. That's all so. All right. Have a good year. Ready to adjourn. Make a motion to adjourn. I will second that motion.

403
02:19:12.480 --> 02:19:17.360
>> All in favor? Aye. Thank you, everybody.