WEBVTT

METADATA
Video-Count: 1
Video-1: youtube.com/watch?v=1mkqVFRFa64

Part: 1

1
00:12:10.000 --> 00:12:45.279
Anybody down there? Um, it is just a little after 9:00 a.m. and I will now call this meeting to order. As is customary for this board, we will begin our meeting with a moment of silence followed by the pledge of

2
00:12:45.279 --> 00:13:34.560
allegiance. >> I pledge allegiance Thank you. It's a full house here. Thank you all for coming out to Reynolds uh Community College. Thank you again for hosting. Um, I'm going to just take a moment to recognize one of our board

3
00:13:34.560 --> 00:13:50.160
members. Uh, today is the last meeting of our board vice president, Mr. Bill Hansen. Um, as a monument, as a monument to his dedicated service, the board has a resolution to present to him, which I

4
00:13:50.160 --> 00:14:08.320
will read. So, it'll be patient because we're going to read it. Be patient out there. says, "Resolution of appreciation presented to Bill Hansen to the Virginia Board of Education, member from 2022 to

5
00:14:08.320 --> 00:14:24.079
2026." That's four years, but it really feels like 20 years, I'm sure, um because we've done a lot of work. Uh and vice president from July 2023 to June 2026. Whereas it is with profound respect for

6
00:14:24.079 --> 00:14:39.440
his professional and personal accomplishments that the members of the board of education recognize Mr. Bill Hansen for his distinguished service as a member of this body from July 2022 until June 2026.

7
00:14:39.440 --> 00:14:56.000
And whereas Mr. Hansen has shown steadfast leadership by serving as vice president of this body from July 2023 until June 2026. Whereas his professional work in has shown a dedication for to improving the lives of

8
00:14:56.000 --> 00:15:11.519
children and families and earn him the respect and admiration of his peers. Whereas he has been an unwavering advocate for the transformation of education across the Commonwealth, thereby contributing to the betterment

9
00:15:11.519 --> 00:15:27.839
of the lives of all current and future Virginiaians. Now therefore, be it resolve that the members of the board of education extend to Mr. Hansen our valued friend and colleague our highest regards and gratitude for his unfailing

10
00:15:27.839 --> 00:15:43.600
service, integrity, and collegiality and professional manner in which he has performed his duties. Be it further resolve that the members of the board of education extend to Mr. Hansen, our warmest best wishes for continued

11
00:15:43.600 --> 00:16:01.839
success in his future endeavors. Adopted Virginia, Richmond, Virginia this 25th day of June in the year 2026. With that bill, there's no truer words that have been whoever wrote this did a good job um about your service. Um but

12
00:16:01.839 --> 00:16:16.800
it says here in your continued future endeavors, which we won't let you go, we'll still call on you for future work. And with that, Bill, would you like to share some words? >> Thank you, Madam President. Just it has

13
00:16:16.800 --> 00:16:34.079
been an honor to serve the families and children of Virginia these last four years, and just um grateful for Governor Yncan for the opportunity to serve, grateful for all of the board members. um

14
00:16:34.079 --> 00:16:49.839
quite a few over the last four years of different uh changes, but just really appreciate the the friendships, but also just uh really getting to take a look at just everybody up here on the Deis right now and everything that was just said and there could be said

15
00:16:49.839 --> 00:17:05.760
about every uh body here and including the leadership at the Department of Education. So just um very much appreciate um the opportunity to serve and just as I told the governor when he asked me to serve it it is personal.

16
00:17:05.760 --> 00:17:22.720
I've spent my whole life and my whole career involved in education and whether it's been in the the business sector, the nonprofit or philanthropy or government service. And um but most importantly, I've had six married

17
00:17:22.720 --> 00:17:37.919
children who all were raised up in Arlington and Fairfax counties and 17 grandkids and up until now are all Northern Virginia students. And so it is personal. That's to me and just grateful to have

18
00:17:37.919 --> 00:17:54.480
been able to just have a a little part in the efforts that we all care so much about uh in having our school systems uh engaged in a way that will give our students and families the best

19
00:17:54.480 --> 00:18:11.080
opportunities for their their growth and their future endeavors. And so just thank you, Madame Chair, and uh the helping anywhere I can down the road. >> So, thank you.

20
00:18:22.480 --> 00:18:38.640
>> First, is there a motion to approve the agenda as presented? Move. >> Second. Uh Dr. Bridges. >> I >> Miss McFersonson. >> Hi, >> Mr. Hansen.

21
00:18:38.640 --> 00:18:55.600
>> Hi, >> Dr. Northern. >> Hi, >> Dr. Wilson. >> I >> Mr. Robinson. >> Hi, >> Mrs. Kilgore. >> I and Sher Bros. I >> Okay, we we're going to uh we're approval of the

22
00:18:55.600 --> 00:19:11.919
minutes. So, staff have uh provided the members of the board with draft minutes before this meeting. Is there a motion to approve the minutes as presented? >> There a second. >> Second. >> Okay. Dr. Bridges. >> I.

23
00:19:11.919 --> 00:19:27.120
>> Miss. McFersonson. >> I. >> Mr. Hansen. >> Hi. >> Dr. Northern. >> Hi. >> Dr. Wilson. >> I. >> Mr. Robinson. >> I. >> Mrs. Kilgore. >> I. >> And chair votes. I. Okay. This is our favorite part of the day. Um, the board

24
00:19:27.120 --> 00:19:43.360
always appreciates being able to feature the wonderful arts programs across the Commonwealth by having students perform at our meetings, particularly in the summertime, which is your time off. So, we really appreciate you t being here today. I will now ask Miss Kilgore to

25
00:19:43.360 --> 00:19:59.919
provide us with an introduction of our guests. >> Good morning. The Cavalier Quartet under the direction of Miss Mary Sinenball from Lakeland High School in Suffach Public School Division is comprised of sophomores, juniors, and seniors. This select

26
00:19:59.919 --> 00:20:16.640
ensemble of advanced and highly motivated orchestra students dedicate significant time each week to practice, rehearse, and perform. Known for their commitment to excellence, the Cavalier Quartet is frequently invited to perform at events

27
00:20:16.640 --> 00:20:34.080
throughout Suffach and Chesapeake. Their performances reflect both their technical skill and their dedication to musical artistry. The group would like to thank the Virginia Board of Education for extending the honor of performing today. Their quartet will be performing two pieces, Magical Gardens by Austoa

28
00:20:34.080 --> 00:31:14.080
Reed Thomas and Voyage of the Sunchasers by Matthew Yeler. >> [snorts] >> We go back. >> [laughter] >> Just want to take a moment to again thank our performers, but thank for all of our student um performers, musicians,

29
00:31:14.080 --> 00:31:30.880
singers, dancers. There's just so many countless hours that goes into that presentation and then to stand in front of your family and friends is a tremendous um opportunity, but we are also tremendously grateful. So, thank you. Um I have been reminded that we did

30
00:31:30.880 --> 00:31:46.799
we had a wonderful resolution for Mr. Hansen, but we didn't actually vote on it. So, uh with that, I would love for someone to uh make a motion to officially adopt the resolution that was read in honor of Mr. Hansen. >> So moved. >> Is there a second?

31
00:31:46.799 --> 00:32:01.840
>> Second. >> Okay, great. Dr. Bridges, >> I. >> Miss McFersonson, >> I. >> Mr. Mr. Hansen, can you vote for yourself? [laughter] >> Same. >> Okay. >> Dr. Nor, >> hi. >> Dr. Wilson, >> I

32
00:32:01.840 --> 00:32:16.240
>> Mr. Robinson, >> I >> Miss Kilgore. >> Hi. >> And chair enthusiastically votes I. All right. Wonderful. Um, we also love to recognize our uh 2026 principles of

33
00:32:16.240 --> 00:32:40.399
distinction. With that, Dr. Wilson, will you please read the recognition? >> Good morning. >> Morning. In April, the board recognized 25 members of the inaugural class of the principles of distinguished of the

34
00:32:40.399 --> 00:32:56.720
principles of distinction program. Today, we are honored to recognize an additional four distinguished school leaders whose exemplary dedication, visionary leadership, and steadfast commitment to students have earned them statewide distinction through the

35
00:32:56.720 --> 00:33:13.760
principles of distinction program. This program honors the exemplary leadership of Virginia's principles by offering a structured pathway to earn specialized credentials on their Virginia teaching licenses. These credentials are noted in meaningful

36
00:33:13.760 --> 00:33:28.640
professional learning experiences aligned with the school performance and support framework emphasizing data literacy and improved outcomes for every student. To complete the program, each participant attended a professional

37
00:33:28.640 --> 00:33:44.159
training symposium and carried out an independent capstone project within their school. For the capstone, principles identified a problem of practice and created datainformed solutions to address it, focusing on

38
00:33:44.159 --> 00:33:59.919
demonstrating measurable gains in student outcomes. These exceptional educators represent the highest standards of school leadership across the Commonwealth of Virginia. It is our honor to introduce the four additional principles who have

39
00:33:59.919 --> 00:34:15.520
successfully fulfilled all requirements and are recognized as part of the inaugural class of the principles of distinction. They will become they are here I think in the wings and so we'll ask that they come forward. Sha D. Rose

40
00:34:15.520 --> 00:34:44.560
from Fairfax County Public Schools. Victoria Galbert, Co Pepper County Public Schools. S Kembar Kashaba, Fairfax County Public Schools. He was unable to be with us. and Brandon

41
00:34:44.560 --> 00:35:04.880
Wolf, Lowden County Public Schools. On behalf of the Board of Education and the Commonwealth of Virginia, we extend our deepest congratulations to each of these extraordinary leaders. Your work inspires schools across Virginia, and

42
00:35:04.880 --> 00:35:45.400
your impact will be felt for generations of students to come. Thank you for your service. Thank you for your leadership. And thank you for your unwavering dedication to excellence in education. We'll be back.

43
00:38:38.240 --> 00:38:53.359
just congratulate our principles who were recognized, but also all of our principles and leaders across the Commonwealth. Um, for many who don't know, this is actually the busiest time for principles and leaders as they prepare for the fall to return back. And

44
00:38:53.359 --> 00:39:08.960
so, just want to extend tremendous gratitude to our leaders who wake up every day supporting our teachers and our school communities. Um uh we will now shift to public comment. As stated in the board bylaws,

45
00:39:08.960 --> 00:39:24.960
it is the pleasure of the board to accept public comment on all matters related to public education in Virginia. Before we begin our public comment today, I want to share about the manner in which public comment will be conducted. I ask that you model

46
00:39:24.960 --> 00:39:41.520
professionalism, dignity, and respect for others as you share your thoughts today. As adults, it is important that we model respectful, civil, and public discourse for our students and children who are either in attendance today or

47
00:39:41.520 --> 00:39:57.920
viewing the stream now or in the future. When you begin, please provide your name, role, or affiliation, and where you live in Virginia. All remarks must be directed to the chair, not to any

48
00:39:57.920 --> 00:40:15.440
other individual. speakers will have 3 minutes to share their remarks. You'll notice that a timer on the screens in front there um will begin 3 minutes in green. At 1 minute, the screen will turn yellow. The screen will turn red when

49
00:40:15.440 --> 00:40:32.480
time is up. At that point, please close your remarks promptly. Speakers may provide copies of their comments to Mr. Dro right up front. the department's regulatory and board coordinator. Joe just raised his hand.

50
00:40:32.480 --> 00:40:51.520
Thank you. All written comments received during public comment will be collected and provided to the board as soon as possible after public comment. You may also email a copy of your remarks to the board at BOE doe. Virginia.gov gov

51
00:40:51.520 --> 00:41:07.280
that I have a list of board members uh those who have signed up for co public comment. Uh Scott Brayban I can't see and I'll call you in order is Scott Brayban uh Kathy Halverson

52
00:41:07.280 --> 00:41:27.359
Alexander Halverson and then Dr. Justin Hensley. Good morning, President Ashton, Superintendent Conway, and members of the board of education. My name is Scott Braybrand, and I'm executive director for VAS. I live in Lynchburg, Virginia,

53
00:41:27.359 --> 00:41:44.000
and I want to thank all of you for your dedicated service to the Commonwealth of Virginia. And thank you, Mr. Hansen, very much for your distinguished service. On behalf of Virginia School Division Superintendent, we respectfully submit the following feedback around today's agenda. First FAST strongly

54
00:41:44.000 --> 00:42:00.079
supports your final review of the simplification and streamlining of the yearly accreditation report. We look forward to continuing to work with you to refine and simplify all reporting requirements for our school divisions. Mass also appreciates the

55
00:42:00.079 --> 00:42:15.599
final review around the use of value tables to measure growth and their transparency and ease of use for both students, teachers, and parents. We also appreciate the final review of revisions to the school construction assistance

56
00:42:15.599 --> 00:42:30.960
program that provides greater flexibility to school divisions to access these important state funds. We also appreciate the first review of the assessment and accountability roadmap. While there's time for additional feedback and engagement, we

57
00:42:30.960 --> 00:42:48.400
continue to support high expectations for all students. We also continue to support VDOE's commitment to additional data modeling and sharing whatif data calculations that will give school divisions multiple opportunities to prepare for these expectations.

58
00:42:48.400 --> 00:43:04.880
We also strongly support the change in the SPSF school performance labels from offtrack to approaching expectations and from ontrack to meeting expectations which are in alignment with the JARK recommendations around this issue.

59
00:43:04.880 --> 00:43:21.760
Finally, in order to treat elementary and middle schools fairly and in alignment with JARK's recommendation, we support the reallocation of the EL progress indicators weight proportionately across all other indicators when a school does not have a sufficient number of EL students to

60
00:43:21.760 --> 00:43:37.200
produce a valid score. Thank you for your engagement with us and with so many other stakeholders and we look forward to our continued partnership with you in the months and years ahead. Thank you. >> Thank you. Um, let's see.

61
00:43:37.200 --> 00:43:56.720
No, Dr. Justin Hensley. No. All right. Uh, stands. Thank you. >> Good morning, board. Uh, my name is Dr. Justin Hinsley. This is my son Kevin. We're both citizens of the city of Lynchburg. Um, Kevin is an AB honoral student with dyslexia, disgraphia, and

62
00:43:56.720 --> 00:44:13.839
dcalculia. And like many students with learning disabilities, he relies on assisted technology accommodations to access and demonstrate what he knows. Uh for the second year in a row though, uh the only so he's failed is mathematics. Today, I'm not here to argue about scores. I'm here to ask you all a simple

63
00:44:13.839 --> 00:44:30.319
question. What is a student required to demonstrate or why is a student required to demonstrate math differently on the state's most important test than he does every other day at school? So, Lynchburg City Schools has worked really hard to implement Kevin's accommodations. This

64
00:44:30.319 --> 00:44:47.119
is not a local school issue. This is a state issue. Um, so rather than hearing from me like you did last year, uh, I want you to hear from Kevin today. Uh, and so Kevin, tell us how many computers do you normally use uh, when you're in math in your regular class?

65
00:44:47.119 --> 00:45:02.000
>> One. >> One. How many computers did you have to use when you took your math lesson? >> Two. Um, what did you have to do between those two computers when you >> I had to balance out the work between one and >> Okay, so you have to switch back and

66
00:45:02.000 --> 00:45:16.640
forth between the two computers and that's different than what you do in class. So, which of those ways is easier? >> Using the one computer. >> Why? because I don't have to squab back and forth between two.

67
00:45:16.640 --> 00:45:39.200
>> Um, how does it make you feel when you have to switch back and forth between the two machines during an SO >> because it just makes it so much harder. >> So, you work hard in school. You earn A's and B's. You're on the National Junior Honoral Society. How do you feel?

68
00:45:39.200 --> 00:45:55.359
How did you feel when you found out that you failed the math as well again this year? >> I'm mad because I know I know all the stuff on it just that I don't >> not support but stuff that I can do.

69
00:45:55.359 --> 00:46:11.680
>> Okay. >> So, do do you believe you know the math that was on the so >> and it's similar math or same math what you were learning in class where you make A's and B's but then you fell. So if you could change one thing about the way that you take the math at so

70
00:46:11.680 --> 00:46:29.119
what would it be to get rid of >> you have any other comments you want. >> So thanks for listening. Um if y'all want to review this this is case 26 uh 572

71
00:46:29.119 --> 00:46:45.599
um with you all right now. Um it here's my final reflection in my 15 seconds. after this meeting, if your schedule's allowed, invite I invite you to reach out, talk to Kevin first. I'm happy to coordinate that. Okay. Um,

72
00:46:45.599 --> 00:47:03.480
this is about his experience. Students like Kevin are the reason that accommodations exist and their voices should help shape how those accommodations are. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. Next, I have uh Dan Zucker.

73
00:47:12.907 --> 00:47:27.440
>> [snorts] >> Well, good morning, President Ashton and Secretary Conway and or Superintendent Conway, pardon me, and members of the board. I'm Dan Zacharias. I'm director of the Old Dominion Association of Church Schools. I live still live in the

74
00:47:27.440 --> 00:47:44.960
beautiful Shannondoa Valley where I plan to go as quickly as I can when I'm done here. Um I haven't been able to uh be uh at one of these meetings in a few months. I was last uh in your meeting in January and then December before that.

75
00:47:44.960 --> 00:48:00.640
And my oral comments here will supplement what is be what Joe is handing you right now. Um in December you had an agenda item I which dealt with first and final review of outdated guidance document for the

76
00:48:00.640 --> 00:48:16.079
standards of accreditation. Um and I addressed the board in December about just one specific um matter of interest to us in the guidance document. Uh in that meeting, the board took no

77
00:48:16.079 --> 00:48:31.440
action. They deferred it to the future, which is understandable given some of the weightier matters that you're working with right now. I understand your plate is full. uh the particular guidance section that we were interested dealt with uh section

78
00:48:31.440 --> 00:48:50.160
60 uh D and the and uh it dealt with credit transfer from nonacredited private schools to Virginia private uh public schools. Uh there's language in that guidance that the board adopted 20 years ago that um we support and has

79
00:48:50.160 --> 00:49:05.839
served very well. It it doesn't seek a guarantee of credit transfer, but it does try to establish a reasonable and academically sound decision-making process. And for the past 20 years, that language has been very helpful to us

80
00:49:05.839 --> 00:49:21.280
even this spring, just very recently when we encountered a problem with a credit transfer issue that was uh positively resolved just a few weeks ago. And so this is just a simple reminder whenever you get around to that agenda

81
00:49:21.280 --> 00:49:38.960
item I again in the future. This is a little piece of it that we're interested and would appreciate your um consideration. So thank you for listening to our perspective and hope you have a great summer. >> Thank you. I have

82
00:49:38.960 --> 00:50:20.880
Banner Slack and Emma Lobo. Next up will be Jen Slack and then Caroline Wagner. You're here. Hi, my name is Emma Loa and >> thank you for letting Herbert our total

83
00:50:20.880 --> 00:50:47.119
stay at school and thank you for letting us stand up while drinking water. I believe that would have an easier time learning if they are with someone who has been or

84
00:50:47.119 --> 00:51:04.960
they are and knows about it. Babies and toddlers can also teach older children. I would like it if there was no rule about keeping toddlers, infants, and preschoolers preschool friends separated. I feel like

85
00:51:04.960 --> 00:51:21.839
the learning studio friends can would keep the younger friends safe even without being separated. at our school communication and it is important to make sure

86
00:51:21.839 --> 00:51:37.599
everyone is getting what they need. And we like we like to play with the and check out the younger siblings that they are like

87
00:51:37.599 --> 00:51:54.079
to check in with and spend time with. I'm hoping there will be more climbing chances in the classrooms. A little bit of climbing space isn't enough.

88
00:51:54.079 --> 00:52:12.160
I wouldn't like to have teachers have to keep a list of each friend with them. Having to carry something with our name or picture would make it hard to learn because if you're having to carry around

89
00:52:12.160 --> 00:52:33.200
around something that would be distracting. >> Thank you for letting us me and Emma speak even though we are younger than most of the people speak. >> Thank you Banner and Emma. Well done. Again, thank you Banner and Emma. You

90
00:52:33.200 --> 00:52:51.520
did a great job. Um, Jen Slack and then Caroline Wagner. I want to express support for all my colleagues speaking today about the childcare licensing standard. Um, and shift our attention now to line 314 of

91
00:52:51.520 --> 00:53:08.640
the new screen time limitations. These proposed standards require that programs get parental consent for everything from emergency medical care to the use of sunscreen and diaper cream. But the department doesn't see a fit to protect the rights of parents to limit children's visual media use. As a

92
00:53:08.640 --> 00:53:23.760
parent, I can withdraw my child from a field trip at any time. I can prevent them from waiting in water. I could not consent to the use of hand lotion at school, but these standards are okay with my 18-month-old watching 15 episodes of Blueie a day. A competent

93
00:53:23.760 --> 00:53:39.040
regulatory framework stops things that are harmful. So, I applaud the banning of screens for infants, but this body should use its power to put knowledge and control into the hands of parents. Requirements that programs report media use and require parental consent for

94
00:53:39.040 --> 00:53:55.760
media use is simple. It's not a burden to add these regulations. I've been an early childhood educator for 22 years. I'm a program owner and a director for the last 15 here in Virginia. And I'm also a mom. I had the luxury

95
00:53:55.760 --> 00:54:11.680
of starting my own program where I know my kids will get [laughter] the care and protection that they deserve. But all the parents that take the risk to put children into our early childhood programs need us to [laughter] advocate for

96
00:54:11.680 --> 00:54:28.559
common sense screen regulation. It's the best thing for our young children. Parents don't often have a choice in their child care because access and affordability seriously limits choice. It's not a burden for these regulations to require informing parents of the

97
00:54:28.559 --> 00:54:44.160
screen use as they do for other general center policies, lunch menus, or injuries that occur or require screen time permission as required for transportation, swimming, and field trips. Language for those amendments are in the handouts I provided along with

98
00:54:44.160 --> 00:55:00.000
one final concern. I'm unsure what's leading to this, but there are seven new regulations around strings and chords in this draft. My [snorts] experience in this process is things are written and rewritten and often get better and simpler with time. These additions which

99
00:55:00.000 --> 00:55:17.119
are detailed in the paperwork I provided you are in many different sections. They're confusing and they reference ages reference nowhere else in the standards. In my opinion, these chord regulations are more than confusing. They're also overbearing. There are many childhood toys that would be unnecessarily restricted by these

100
00:55:17.119 --> 00:55:33.040
standards. I urge you to take a look at them and either adjust the language or send them back to the ECAC for further review. I appreciate all that have worked on these standards. They're good. I don't want to dismiss that, but I do think it's worth taking another look to make them great before moving them

101
00:55:33.040 --> 00:55:56.913
forward. >> Thank you. Uh, Caroline Wagner. Uh, good morning. I'm so grateful for all the work that I know has gone into the standards before you today and I appreciate the department considering and making some of the changes already in previous commentators. Um, I know that we're getting closer and I would

102
00:55:56.913 --> 00:56:12.480
[clears throat] really like to see another round of comments and changes standards forward. I'm here today as a teacher in a mixed age 3 to 8year-old classroom. Uh my biggest concern at the moment is to is the momentto moment tracking of children list um in line

103
00:56:12.480 --> 00:56:28.720
2250. Anything that requires addition ongoing maintenance of a physical list is a significant burden for educators with minimal benefit. Teachers absolutely need to know who they have, who's with them. Um and the maintenance of physical list would be challenging. Our school

104
00:56:28.720 --> 00:56:45.520
for example allows children to flow freely between grips. We have systems for communication and always keep sight and sound supervision. But maintaining a physical list as children flow from teacher to teacher would be a serious burden and create more stress and unneeded limitations on children's work throughout the day. It's not just in our

105
00:56:45.520 --> 00:57:01.119
context though. Many programs split their classrooms during the day and one teacher might take a smaller group for a project uh while another takes a larger group outside. If I were to split my class of 14 three-year-olds so that 10 go outside while four helpers stay inside to clean up before transitioning,

106
00:57:01.119 --> 00:57:16.799
I would need two lists. If two classes are on the playground together, they would need to combine lists or what if somebody has to go inside and get their lunchbox or go to the bathroom. I know the intention is safety and this is not a simple thing. Teachers are already tracking so many things including

107
00:57:16.799 --> 00:57:32.880
knowing where all the children are already. They don't need a physical list to keep track. We can trust that our teachers are competent and care about children's safety, learning, and day-to-day flow. I'm requesting a full review of these uh licensing standards one more time to delete what we can

108
00:57:32.880 --> 00:57:48.160
that's [clears throat] not needed and fix some other things before moving forward. Um there's a list of things on my handout. Um but a few things to name. The definition of waiting would seem to include just splashing in puddles and having to get permission for that. Uh

109
00:57:48.160 --> 00:58:04.000
the definition of staffing would include people who are coming to provide services like OT, play therapy, uh SLPs. The use of the term physical barrier in the supervision standard is confusing. There's seven new cord regulations and there's language that would prevent us

110
00:58:04.000 --> 00:58:20.960
from washing children's clothes at school if they had an accident. So, um thank you for your time this morning and share consideration of feedback from parents, teachers, and children who will be impacted by these teachers. Thank you. Um Neilie Minton and then

111
00:58:20.960 --> 00:58:48.960
Derek Max. Good morning, members of the board. I am Neie Minton and I'm president of the Virginia Social Studies Leaders Consortium. I'm speaking today on behalf of members who couldn't be here because of a conflict with VDOE sponsor PD. Over

112
00:58:48.960 --> 00:59:04.799
the last several years, Virginia social studies educators have faced two battles over the future of our discipline. The first was over our standards of learning. Hundreds of experts in social studies education came together to develop rigorous standards. Then much of

113
00:59:04.799 --> 00:59:20.160
that work was set aside through an 11th hour rewrite by individuals with little knowledge of our discipline. Today, we face a second battle. Individuals with little expertise in social studies are questioning decades of research and

114
00:59:20.160 --> 00:59:37.839
practice around inquirybased performance assessment. Yet on July 1st, SB200 will take effect. This law continues Virginia's move toward rigorous knowledrich performance assessment in social studies. Performance assessment raises expectations for every student.

115
00:59:37.839 --> 00:59:54.000
Consider the Virginia studies inquiry. Was reconstruction a success? Fourth graders read Frederick Douglas. They examine the 13th, 14th, and 15th amendments to the Constitution. They study voting records, black codes, and sharecropping contracts. Then they

116
00:59:54.000 --> 01:00:10.960
construct an evidence-based historical argument to answer the compelling question. This is contentri. It's literacy rich, and it reflects the complexity that defines history and civics. This is AP level rigor for every student. Reducing these complex

117
01:00:10.960 --> 01:00:27.359
historical and civic questions to selected response items oversimplifies both the rich content and the critical thinking we expect every student to master. Some have suggested that performance assessment lacks accountability. But the opposite is true. There are shared rubrics, common

118
01:00:27.359 --> 01:00:42.640
scoring expectations, and common grading scales. These tools allow divisions to analyze and publicly report student performance. We are asking for accountability based on a series of performance assessments that measure the full range of knowledge and skills

119
01:00:42.640 --> 01:00:58.240
students are expected to demonstrate. We are asking for rigor for every student. The question is, will we trust the social studies experts this time? We urge the board to honor the intent of the law and provide a pathway for divisions ready to implement permissive

120
01:00:58.240 --> 01:01:13.440
local alternative assessments in lie of so test during the 2026 2027 school year. Um many divisions are making preparations right now. So time is of the essence in terms of getting guidance to divisions. Thank you so much. I

121
01:01:13.440 --> 01:01:32.160
appreciate your time. >> Thank you. Uh, Derek Max. >> Thank you. My name is Derek Max. I'm the vice president at the Jefferson Forum, formerly known as the Thomas Jefferson Institute. I want to start by thanking you all for your service and Bill, you'll be missed. Knowing you for a long

122
01:01:32.160 --> 01:01:48.000
time. Uh, your work matters more than you may realize, and I pray that you are rewarded for that effort. Virginia spent too many years telling parents that children are doing better than they actually are. This is not compassion. It's not equity. It's not good education

123
01:01:48.000 --> 01:02:04.240
policy. In fact, it's a failure of honesty. And the students most hurt are the children most in need of your help. It is reported that you are considering to delay the long overdue increase in the standard of learning cut scores for another three years. If that happens, Virginia will continue using some of the

124
01:02:04.240 --> 01:02:18.880
lowest proficiency standards in the country. By the time the new scores are fully reflected in public reporting, Virginia could have spent nearly a decade operating under weak benchmarks that mask the true academic conditions of our schools. That would be a serious

125
01:02:18.880 --> 01:02:35.680
mistake. This should not be a partisan question. Governor Banberger has said the right things about accountability. As a candidate, she put it plainly. I know accountability is vital to ensuring that our kids are learning, getting the education they deserve, and getting additional help they need. She is right.

126
01:02:35.680 --> 01:02:50.079
But accountability without honest standards is not accountability at all. For years, Virginia's test scores have painted a much rosier picture than the National Assessment of Education Progress. That difference is often called the honesty gap. Virginia has one of the largest honesty gaps in the

127
01:02:50.079 --> 01:03:05.680
country. That gap is not a technicality. It means thousands of parents believe their children are on grade level when they are not. It means schools may appear to be succeeding when they are not. It means policy makers congratulate themselves while childrens continue to struggle. The federal data on cut scores

128
01:03:05.680 --> 01:03:22.880
is just as troubling. The NCES comparison of state proficiency standards shows that Virginia students are being given low expectations and their poor performance is being masked. In every other aspect of school life board, expectations put before students is higher. No football coach is telling

129
01:03:22.880 --> 01:03:39.039
their team their goal is to rank at the bottom third. The students who performed here today were not told by their band director or orchestra instructor to just try to be on beat and in tune a third of the time. The theater director is not telling her students just to try to get some of their lines right. No, they are

130
01:03:39.039 --> 01:03:55.280
pushing perfection and the hard work that that entails. I can still hear my marching band instructor telling me to get in step, get in line, and stay in tune. Changed my life. Before joining the Jefferson Forum, I founded a private school in one of the poorest communities in Washington DC where I was principal.

131
01:03:55.280 --> 01:04:10.319
There was nothing more painful than to tell a parent who had been has a student getting straight A's and had performed well on the fairly weak DC standards that their student was two or three grade levels but two or three levels below grade. It is a painful and

132
01:04:10.319 --> 01:04:26.480
troubling fact. We need to tell the parents the truth so they can take action. My fear and I hope it is not true is that you guys are afraid that these parents will take other options into account. That is not a reason not to have high standards. Thank you.

133
01:04:26.480 --> 01:04:47.520
>> Thank [clears throat] you. Um Thomas Johnson, then Philip Abu Zaki. Good morning, President Ashen, Vice President Hans, members of the board. Thank you for your time today and the

134
01:04:47.520 --> 01:05:03.760
opportunity to speak before you. As I mentioned, my name is Tom Johnson. I'm a resident of Chesterfield County. I'm a dad of multiple kids in Virginia public schools and I work for one of the largest employers in the Commonwealth. I come here today wearing both of these

135
01:05:03.760 --> 01:05:19.599
hats. When I learned last fall that the board of education had finally raised its proficiency proficiency standards and expectations for kids like mine and they were actually going up, I was highly encouraged. That is what our kids deserve and that's

136
01:05:19.599 --> 01:05:35.359
what they need. But then I read this weekend about the road map the department is proposing for accountability and proficiency implementation. The fine print makes it clear my kids will have graduated before expectations ever get raised for them.

137
01:05:35.359 --> 01:05:51.119
The message this sends to my kids and their friends is your generation can wait. There are additional items being removed, eliminated or with multiple years of delay without any consequences attached. I'm a parent.

138
01:05:51.119 --> 01:06:07.760
I know what happens when there's no consequences. Nothing happens. When my other head as a manager and employee, we are desperate for prepared candidates. This is not abstract. We have open roles. We have a talent

139
01:06:07.760 --> 01:06:24.960
pipeline problem. And that is both real and urgent. Every year we see applicants who graduated from Virginia schools, good, hardworking kids at that, who simply were not prepared for what we need them to do. This plan does not fix that pipeline. It

140
01:06:24.960 --> 01:06:41.839
delays fixing it by years. So, I'm standing here as a dad who won't see his own kids benefit from higher expectation this board says it believes in. as an employer who will spend the next several years again working around preparation gaps that this roadmap

141
01:06:41.839 --> 01:06:57.920
decided was not urgent enough to begin to solve in this upcoming school year. And finally, our kids are students right now and their preparedness for the future depends on a board of education and state department of education that treats urgency like it actually beats

142
01:06:57.920 --> 01:07:18.799
something. Again, thank you for your time today. I wish you the best. Have a great day. >> Thank you. Phillip Abu Zaki. >> Good morning, President Ashton, Vice President Hansen, members of the board, Superintendent Conway. My name is Philip

143
01:07:18.799 --> 01:07:35.359
Papazaki. I'm a resident of Mlotheian. I've spent the last 21 years in the plumbing and pipe fitting industry. I was here last year urging this board to raise proficiency expectations for our students. You heard me and others like me, you moved in the right direction for kids. But I have to be honest with you this

144
01:07:35.359 --> 01:07:50.480
morning. I'm concerned about this new road map. In fact, it has not raised expectations for years. Let me remind you about my industry. Modern plumbing and pipe fitting is not a wrench in a leaky pipe. My teams use 3D modeling software, read complex technical

145
01:07:50.480 --> 01:08:07.200
blueprints, make calculations that require algebra, geometry, and trigonometry daily to construct hospitals, universities, life science buildings, and data centers. Precision isn't optional. It's the job. Right now, we cannot find enough young people who

146
01:08:07.200 --> 01:08:24.960
are ready for it. We hire motivated, hardworking kids, genuinely good people who want to build a career, but they are behind in the fundamental math and technical reading they need. We could ask, who told them they were ready? A system that was measuring them against a bar set too low. That's not preparing

147
01:08:24.960 --> 01:08:40.400
kids. That's misleading them. So when I learn the higher proficiency scores may be pushed back to 2028 and beyond and giving schools consequencefree years for student outcomes, I want to remind the board and the department what this means in the real world. With billions in

148
01:08:40.400 --> 01:08:55.520
infra, it [clears throat] means another year of two two my industry loses young Virginiaians to a skills gap we could have closed. With billions in infrastructure investment coming to this state, we have a once in a generation opportunity to grow this workforce. But

149
01:08:55.520 --> 01:09:11.359
that window does not wait for a high for longer transition timeline. I came here last year asking you to believe in our kids. Coming back today asking you not to stop believing in them. Don't lower the bar. Do not delay higher expectations. Our students and Virginia

150
01:09:11.359 --> 01:09:36.799
industries are counting on you. [clears throat] So much for your time. >> Thank you. Um Amante Smith and then Angela Harrison. Good morning. My name is Amante Smith and I am a teacher in Charlottesville at our neighborhood. Um, I'd like to start

151
01:09:36.799 --> 01:09:52.719
online 2472. I want to invite you for a moment to think about the best and the worst training you've attended in your careers. Nothing against our department of education, but as a required government training

152
01:09:52.719 --> 01:10:08.159
ever truly impacted the engagement of anyone or the quality of anything. As a new teacher, I have found this career can be extremely overwhelming as well as rewarding. In my experience, the requirement of 16 hours of ongoing

153
01:10:08.159 --> 01:10:25.120
training has flourished my confidence and strengthened my ability to be proud of the way I show up in the classroom. Ongoing training provides educators with the ability to connect with experienced colleagues, build supportive learning spaces, and forge professional relationships.

154
01:10:25.120 --> 01:10:41.120
This requirement is powerful. It helps educators keep learning and growing and benefit students by creating classrooms that are safe, engaging, and rich with opportunities of growth. I'm concerned, however, that in the last 10 years, there has been a push towards more

155
01:10:41.120 --> 01:10:58.000
specific state required training, starting with their pre-ervice training for subsidy providers in 2016 and then all providers in 2021. Now, this regulation continues that trend by adding the annual health and safety update course to the required training.

156
01:10:58.000 --> 01:11:13.840
We beg you to reconsider. A recent FOYA request shows that this pre-ervice and annual update led to 2003 I'm sorry 237,49 hours of training provided by the state

157
01:11:13.840 --> 01:11:30.960
in 2025. What if those training hours were happening in early childhood membership organizations, conferences, infant toddler networks, communities of practice, and in the local programs themselves. This online state trainings are not how we build a robust thriving early

158
01:11:30.960 --> 01:11:47.280
childhood system. Please stop this layering one of more requirements for teachers and trust that there are much more qualified providers of highquality early childhood training than the department. Please consider the cost of asking tens of thousands of early

159
01:11:47.280 --> 01:12:02.880
childhood teachers in Virginia to take a three-hour governmentmandated training each year. I know the intention is good, but this is a terribly inefficient way for the department to distribute health and safety information in a reduced educators seeking the training that they

160
01:12:02.880 --> 01:12:27.280
might need to improve their quality of care. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. Then Angela Harrison. >> Morning, Chair Ashton. Vice Chair Hansen, Superintendent Conway, and members of the board. I am Angela

161
01:12:27.280 --> 01:12:42.880
Harrison, superintendent of the Dam Public Schools, and I'm here today with representatives from the school community. I recognize that today you're taking an important step to consider voting to allow our school division to exit theou corrective action plan

162
01:12:42.880 --> 01:12:59.679
status. When we entered this agreement with the Virginia Department of Education, it provided the urgency that our community needed to transform the community and better serve our children. Our journey towards systemic change has

163
01:12:59.679 --> 01:13:14.960
not been a solitary one. We have benefited from tremendous support and guidance from the VDOE through access to resources, technical assistance, and increased accountability. Our school board represented here today by Mr.

164
01:13:14.960 --> 01:13:32.880
Kessle Walker, uh, city council, our city manager, our business community, and our nonprofit partners joined in collaborative efforts to support our educators as we implemented the corrective action plan and became a powerful learning journey for us all.

165
01:13:32.880 --> 01:13:50.719
our external partners including the UVA uh work through science of reading and our partnership for leaders in education, Cognia, Hampton City Schools as a mentor division for reviewing data. The Virginia School Boards Association with strategic planning and the Virginia

166
01:13:50.719 --> 01:14:06.000
Association of School Superintendent through leadership development have all contributed to a better Danville. Most importantly, our students and families wanted better. They engaged in a meaningful and robust manner to hold

167
01:14:06.000 --> 01:14:21.920
themselves accountable and continue to grow as a community of students. Your vote today does not mean that we're done. We still have much work to do. However, this process has demonstrated to our community that the belief that

168
01:14:21.920 --> 01:14:38.480
all children deserve a better education through high expectations as well as in Virginia as a whole certainly evident in Danville, Virginia. I would be remiss if I did not thank the office of school quality and specifically Dr. Ballard and

169
01:14:38.480 --> 01:14:54.480
Miss Britt as they have become a part of team Danville. On behalf of the Dam Public Schools community, I would like to thank you and the more than 30 individuals that drove left at 5:00 am this morning. I'd like them to stand. Parents, school leaders, district

170
01:14:54.480 --> 01:15:17.520
leaders, and schoolboard members who drove to be >> Thank you. Thank you for driving five hours. Um is uh that is that has that is my complete list. Is there anyone who would like to um add public comment?

171
01:15:17.520 --> 01:15:45.679
Please come to the mic. >> Good morning, Superintendent Conway and members of the board. My name is Todd Truit and I'm speaking today on behalf of Arlington Parents for Education, a grassroots bipartisan organization with a community forum with more than 12,200 parents, educators, and community

172
01:15:45.679 --> 01:16:02.719
members. We are committed to educational excellence in Virginia's public schools. First, we want to thank the superintendent and members of your team for meeting with us during your listening sessions and for your team's prompt attention to our follow-up questions. During our discussion, we emphasize the importance of parents

173
01:16:02.719 --> 01:16:19.440
receiving honest information as soon as possible about their child's academic performance through higher cut scores. Therefore, we strongly oppose the last minute proposal to delay the scheduled increase in Virginia's English and math cut scores this fall. Children and parents are the primary stakeholders in

174
01:16:19.440 --> 01:16:35.040
our public education system. Schools exist to serve students and families, and decisions about academic standards should reflect that reality. When parents see the comparison between Virginia's cut scores and those of other states, they are shocked. Parents want

175
01:16:35.040 --> 01:16:51.679
high expectations and an accurate picture of whether their children are meeting them. What parents don't understand is a lack of any urgency to raise cut scores in this proposal. Parents were promised in November that the first small increase would be this fall. School is now out for the summer

176
01:16:51.679 --> 01:17:07.760
and most parents are not paying as close of attention. Even with this small increase, Virginia would still have some of the lowest cut scores in the country. Notably, when scores were lower to the lowest in the country in 2019 and 2020, it was done immediately midschool year.

177
01:17:07.760 --> 01:17:22.960
It was encouraging to hear yesterday that little work is required to implement this fall small increase. That increase should go forward to prepare students for the the event or prepare parents for the eventual final cut scores. The VDOE was working with

178
01:17:22.960 --> 01:17:39.120
learning heroes on a plan to include Napleign performance information and so reports to families. Yet that effort does not appear anywhere in the board slides. In fact, parents are not mentioned at all in the board slides and accountability and cut scores. As a

179
01:17:39.120 --> 01:17:55.199
result of the new accountability system, Arlington Public Schools is now devoting more resources to its schools identified as needing support and taking a laser-like focus on English learners. Those efforts would not be occurring had had the account new accountability

180
01:17:55.199 --> 01:18:11.920
system been delayed as some in the education establishment had advocated. Virginia should be a leader in education and none of us should be satisfied with continuing with the lowest cut scores in the country for any longer. We urge the board to reject this proposed delay and

181
01:18:11.920 --> 01:18:42.480
move forward with higher expectations for Virginia students this fall. Thank you. >> Thank you. Is there anyone else who would like to add public comment? Please come to the microphone. My name is Mim Lrange. I'm a proud and

182
01:18:42.480 --> 01:18:58.800
unapologetic Democrat, an ardent supporter of Governor Spanberger, and I'm here to strongly oppose the proposal to continue with Virginia's math and reading cut scores that are the lowest standards in the country. I'm proud to have voted for the first woman governor

183
01:18:58.800 --> 01:19:14.400
of of Virginia, and I'm proud of what her administration has accomplished so far on women's and immigrants rights and affordability. That said, one of the many things that sets us apart from the opposing party is that we hold our elected officials accountable. And

184
01:19:14.400 --> 01:19:29.760
today, I'm here to do just that. Governor Spanberger campaigned on the promise of upholding academic excellence and rigor in our schools. And yet, here you all are today about to fumble a bipartisan policy on education reform at

185
01:19:29.760 --> 01:19:46.640
the behest of the special interest groups in this room. Raising cut scores and academic standards for students not only align with Democratic values, it has strong bipartisan support. If you delay raising cut scores for two more years, you'll be right back here in 2028

186
01:19:46.640 --> 01:20:01.920
doing it again for these same special interest groups. Meanwhile, the kids who pay the highest price are the least advantage, the ones that the students that our party claims to fight for. If you continue with this delay, you better have a redeemable answer for

187
01:20:01.920 --> 01:20:19.520
constituents on both sides of the aisle come 2029. Because the reason you have today that the adults who run the system here need a break is frankly pathetic, especially when we have Republican states like Mississippi and Alabama who spend much less per student than us and

188
01:20:19.520 --> 01:20:36.960
are still outperforming Virginia. That's embarrassing. Today, I live in one of the most affluent areas of the state. I feel fortunate that my partner has the knowhow, access, and ability to provide supplemental education for his kids where the state has fallen short. But my

189
01:20:36.960 --> 01:20:53.760
background as an English learner and having come from a very humble, economically disadvantaged community, I know that not all children have the same privileges. This state has put those kids, we're talking about English learners, student of bluecollar workers, and lash key kids on the back burner for

190
01:20:53.760 --> 01:21:09.040
long enough. Guaranteeing access for all students to high academic standards and providing an education pathway that supports that is the job you all signed up for. I lost my way. Sorry.

191
01:21:09.040 --> 01:21:26.239
Um it should high academic standards should not be afforded only to children who have special access. After all, we're not asking for every school to have an elite lacrosse program. It reminds It pains me to say that as much as I hate policies coming out of Texas,

192
01:21:26.239 --> 01:21:43.320
I'm starting to understand why private school choice has the political appeal that it does. If our public school system can't guarantee high academic standards for all students, then I can see how many people would support vouchers for students to access private schools that do.

193
01:21:43.600 --> 01:22:01.360
>> Thank you. I think that concludes our public comment. Right. Thank you. We are now going to go transition into presentations from the student advisory committee.

194
01:22:01.360 --> 01:22:28.239
I believe there are two presentations from our student advisory. >> Four. >> Three. Okay. Will the first group come on up? Do you need a couple of minutes? Let's we're gonna

195
01:22:28.239 --> 01:23:13.840
>> pres should work. You go. >> Thank you. >> Hello, my name is Wilson Lucas and unfortunately my partner Laura Aliser couldn't be here today. So I'll be presenting the Virginia STEM Pathways Initiative proposals. So a little bit about ourselves. I'm the region one

196
01:23:13.840 --> 01:23:30.560
representative and live about 10 minutes down the road in Reicho County. I recently just graduated from Freeman High School and in the fall I'm going to the University of Virginia to study engineering. In the future, I want to go into an engineering profession and eventually use my knowledge and experience from that career to give back either through education or policy or

197
01:23:30.560 --> 01:23:46.880
some kind of humanitarian work. I'm on this board because I want to use my experiences now to make a change. I want to use what the lessons I've learned and what I've observed K through 12 to give back for those who will follow after me. Laura is the region 6 representative and lives in Montgomery County. >> [clears throat] >> She recently just graduated from Auburn

198
01:23:46.880 --> 01:24:04.080
High School. In the fall, she's Virginia Tech to study aerospace engineering. She's on this board or in the future, she wants to go into an engineering career and do um creative writing on the side. She's on this board because she wants to help develop areas around her um using STEM. And that leads into our

199
01:24:04.080 --> 01:24:21.120
issue. So Laura and I identified that regional Virginia have a large disparity in their access and participation to STEM. Specifically, urban and suburban schools have much stronger focus in their classes and extracurriculars on math and science compared to rural regions. This is a problem because one,

200
01:24:21.120 --> 01:24:36.159
not all students in Virginia have equal access to classes and career opportunities, and two, those regions with lower participation rates have are disadvantaged economically and don't experience all the benefits that STEM professions bring. So, what does this

201
01:24:36.159 --> 01:24:52.000
look like specifically? As you can see, using the percent of schools offering an AP math as a benchmark for STEM accessibility, there's a 30% disparity between regions, there's a 30% disparity between urban and suburban schools and rural schools. That's a statistically

202
01:24:52.000 --> 01:25:07.360
significant number and proves that a student in Northern Virginia has a much greater access to STEM classes and therefore STEM careers than a student in Southwest Virginia has. The policy that most directly relates to this right now is the board of education standards of accreditation. Specifically, the school

203
01:25:07.360 --> 01:25:22.719
and students support framework. This framework requires schools to not only track student performance on math and science as well as how much they grow over time. So, it's not just tracking how well a student does, but if they're improving, if the school's policy is actually helping students also re recent

204
01:25:22.719 --> 01:25:39.040
legislate legislation that relates to this issue is the recent house bill that was passed in 2025. What this house bill requires is for schools to provide multiple pathways into advanced math and science classes. And it also requires any student who forms advanced on a math or science as well to be placed into

205
01:25:39.040 --> 01:25:54.719
advanced class. And since it was 2025, we still have yet to see the full effects of this house. So why is all this a matter? Like how is this really affecting students? In the short term, students become very discouraged by math and science. I'm

206
01:25:54.719 --> 01:26:10.320
sure we've all said it and well, I'm sure we've all heard it and probably said it that I'm just not a math person. Like that's not for me. My brain doesn't function that way and that can be more far from the truth. Students get discouraged easily and they start to participate less in those classes and less in those extracurriculars. And so

207
01:26:10.320 --> 01:26:27.040
as they start to participate less, they demand less from the teachers and so teachers know have no incentive to go to these regions and that turns into a cycle. Students aren't interested. So teachers don't go and without teachers there's no one to support the students and that's why we see some of these voids in schools and regions that just

208
01:26:27.040 --> 01:26:43.840
have low STEM participation rates. In the long term students miss out on the key crucial like cognitive skills that STEM provides. STEM doesn't just help you in math or science class. It physically alters your brain. It builds more neural connections and develops

209
01:26:43.840 --> 01:27:00.080
your critical thinking and problem solving skills. Even if you're not going into a STEM career, these benefits are still crucial in any career or walk of life you choose to take. And finally, as I mentioned earlier, these regions miss out on the economic benefits and workforce benefits, social benefits that

210
01:27:00.080 --> 01:27:16.880
STEM profession brings. Take Northern Virginia for an example, a region with a very high STEM participation rate. They have a booming industry because companies want to go there. Companies want to go there because they know they'll have a workforce that can support them. For regions with struggling economics, this can be a white flop. Just increase their STEM

211
01:27:16.880 --> 01:27:32.719
participation and companies will follow. And so the board of education is important all this because we have the ability to make a change and to just increase STEM participation and the effects will follow. So some pausing considerations we can take to address this issue. We of course can go through estimates raise or lower

212
01:27:32.719 --> 01:27:48.000
standards or change how they're administered. But what Laura and I found more interesting was using teacher professional development. So, of course, right now teachers are required to do license renewals and as a part of that renewal, they must earn 180 points um either through publishing or books or

213
01:27:48.000 --> 01:28:03.920
conferences or so forth. But what we found interesting was connecting teacher professional development to STEM accessibility. So, we benefit both teachers and students at the same time. And before I go into our proposal, I want to give one last um or convey one

214
01:28:03.920 --> 01:28:20.000
last message about how STEM has how this issue has really affected people because statistics don't say everything. So Laura, who of course lives in Southwest Virginia, had to travel to a regional governor school for all of her math and science classes because her school didn't offer what she needed and she was only able to do so for her junior and

215
01:28:20.000 --> 01:28:36.239
senior year. And so freshman and sophomore, she was stuck with whatever schools offering was whatever her school offered, which was limited. For me, as a resident of Enreo County, I'm grateful I've always had access to the AP or college prep or honors or um dual

216
01:28:36.239 --> 01:28:51.360
enrollment classes I've wanted to take. However, when I've talked to my peers from Northern Virginia and Virginia Beach, they talk about flight simulators and electrical engineering classes, and it's a foreign world to me in Freeman. And finally, I think one of the most

217
01:28:51.360 --> 01:29:08.480
influential testimonies we had was from my um physics 2 teacher, Orion Alman. He grew up in Southwest Virginia, and [clears throat] out of the 120 students in his graduating class, 20 went to college, 10 actually graduated. Two with a STEM degree. He told me, quote, "Many

218
01:29:08.480 --> 01:29:24.639
students don't consider STEM a possibility." And that's not to overgeneralize. He's talking about students and his peers in Southwest Virginia, but what he's saying is that many students don't consider a possibility because they don't have the role models and mentors and experience around them to make them interested in them. And that is what Laura and I want

219
01:29:24.639 --> 01:29:41.120
to address. So, our proposal, Laura and I are are proposing using professional development to incentivize STEM engagement. And we want to do so by amending the teacher license renewal policy to allow teachers with a math and science background to earn professional development points by giving

220
01:29:41.120 --> 01:29:57.840
presentations to students about their past work workforce experience. So these presentations would entail how they got into that career what they did in the job in their work and how students can get there today. And so what we hope this will do is expand STEM exposure. We what we know

221
01:29:57.840 --> 01:30:14.560
it'll do is expand STEM exposure. It'll create personal connections with students and give them the role models that they're missing to just create their interest because all of these students are capable of going into the into these fields. They just don't have the support that waits in them. And I could go on about all the theoretical

222
01:30:14.560 --> 01:30:31.360
ways this can help students. But I think the best way I can convey this is one last story. So my AP physics one teacher Freeman by the way has outstanding physics teachers. My AP physics one teacher Thomas Gallon um did a partnership with the CERN particle

223
01:30:31.360 --> 01:30:47.360
physics lab. And as a part of that partnership, he's required to give a presentation to his students every year about his work there. And so when it was our year and when I was in his class and he was telling us about it, five students put their hands up to attend it. And when he told us it was a homework grade or not an extra homework

224
01:30:47.360 --> 01:31:04.560
grade, extra credit, everybody put their hands up. And so it was pretty miraculous. During a study hall at Freeman, we had a classroom full of students literally sitting on tables waiting to hear about particle physics. It sounds like an oxymoron. And Mr. Galla didn't just tell us about

225
01:31:04.560 --> 01:31:20.800
particle physics. He told us about his job there and what he did and how it was at CERN and introduced us to a whole new world. Students who didn't even raise their hand regularly in physics class were asking about particle physics. It was truly incredible and what inspired us a lot in our proposal. And so what

226
01:31:20.800 --> 01:31:37.199
Laura and I hope to do with this proposal is bring just a part that same inspiration that Mr. Galla gave me to all students of Virginia. We want to make STEM the we want to make the benefits of of STEM accessible to all regions of Virginia, all students, not just Thank you. And I want to give a

227
01:31:37.199 --> 01:31:57.520
special thank you to Ryan Alman, Robert Peek, Wy Honka, and Ryan Alman who all helped me greatly this presentation. >> Well done. you. Do any board members have questions? Yes, Dr. Wilson. >> Wilson, thank you very much for the

228
01:31:57.520 --> 01:32:13.280
presentation. Um, and uh, a question, not necessarily a question, but a comment. We heard yesterday from our partners at JARK. uh they presented a report about access and your observation, your and Laura's

229
01:32:13.280 --> 01:32:29.040
observation about the access that students have to programs and courses amplifies [clears throat] and is consistent with what our state partners are saying, our research partners are saying. So, thank you for bringing uh that personal connection,

230
01:32:29.040 --> 01:32:44.800
that personal testimonial to what the data is also showing us. Um and I also appreciate the um solution potential solution and the impact that you've described and the stories that amplify again amplify the value of this

231
01:32:44.800 --> 01:33:01.360
particular particular issue. So, thank you very much and wahoo wa wah wah [laughter] >> superintendent Conway. >> You thank you Wilson for a very thoughtful presentation uh that included data which is just about as this board

232
01:33:01.360 --> 01:33:18.480
can attest my my favorite thing. Uh when uh Dr. Smith and I were going around the state on the listening tour. We talked with a lot of high school students um who uh noted that the only way that they could get access to higher level math

233
01:33:18.480 --> 01:33:35.120
and science or dual enrollment courses was through technology. um uh whether that was coming to school and then participating in a virtual class or doing that from home if there simply wasn't an educator or the distance was too tr too far to travel to

234
01:33:35.120 --> 01:33:51.120
a governor school. I'm curious, did you all come across that uh in terms of uh particularly for Lara students in Southwest Virginia who were able to access some more STEM and whether it felt like it was as high quality as that

235
01:33:51.120 --> 01:34:07.440
kind of those in-person experiences? >> Yeah. So, we actually did look into the virtual option using Virtual Virginia and it is a good lifeline for what it has. um it provides those classes and allows students to get that access but of course the experience isn't as beneficial as having a teacher there to

236
01:34:07.440 --> 01:34:23.520
share their personal experiences. It's still over computer and oftent time you just end up doing homework. Um so it's a good option for getting into those classes and getting AP and dual enrollment classes. But um what we were looking for is creating the more

237
01:34:23.520 --> 01:34:38.239
inspiration for the students that maybe don't are aren't inclined to go take those classes. >> Thank you. Thank you board members. Any other questions? >> Hey, you're off the hot seat. Well done.

238
01:34:38.239 --> 01:35:12.159
Thank you. >> We'll have our next presentation. Thank you. [clears throat] Oh guys this which one is left. >> Okay. Thank you guys. Good morning President Ashton, Vice President Hansen, members of the board, peers and those in

239
01:35:12.159 --> 01:35:28.960
the audience today. My name is Kyla Leget and today I will be presenting a proposal to strengthen and modify reading interventionist policies. Before I begin, I would like to introduce my partner who unfortunately could not be here today. Her name is Olivia Tarbell and she's from K,

240
01:35:28.960 --> 01:35:44.960
Virginia, where she attended Fort Defiance High School. She plans to attend Blige Community College to major in business management and hopes to become a licensed esthetician. I am from Newport News, Virginia, where I attended Mitchell High School. I will be attending Harvard College in the fall where I plan to study sociology and

241
01:35:44.960 --> 01:36:00.560
global health and health policy. I hope to become a gastronurologist. We both care deeply about reading interventionist policies because of our firsthand experiences witnessing the positive impact they can have on our students and their academic performance.

242
01:36:00.560 --> 01:36:16.960
Today, we are proposing improvements to reading interventionist policies that will help ensure all Virginia students receive the literacy support they need to succeed. Moving on to the issue at hand. On January 29th, 2025, the National

243
01:36:16.960 --> 01:36:32.719
Assessment Governing Board reported continued declines in reading achievement among US students. Moreover, according to the 2024 National Assessment of Educational Progress, Virginia reading scores remain stagnant among fourth and eighth grade students.

244
01:36:32.719 --> 01:36:50.480
Only 31% of fourth graders and 21% of eighth graders were reading at or above the national proficiency level. This brings us to our current situation. The Virginia Board of Education has raised standards of learning expectations to better align with national standards.

245
01:36:50.480 --> 01:37:05.679
While this is an important step forward, it also raises concerns that the percentage of students achieving proficiency in reading and writing may decrease without additional support from reading interventionists. It is imperative that we continue building upon the success of the Virginia

246
01:37:05.679 --> 01:37:22.000
Literacy Act rather than becoming complacent with its progress. If we settle for less, we put Virginiaians at a disadvantage as reading is a fundamental skill necessary for success in school, the workforce, and everyday life. A weak foundation in

247
01:37:22.000 --> 01:37:36.800
reading places individuals at a greater risk of poverty and unemployment. challenges that can be compounded by systemic failures within our education system. Today, approximately 43 million adults in the United States read below a

248
01:37:36.800 --> 01:37:52.400
third grade level. This literacy gap is estimated to cost the nation $2.2 trillion annually. Again, let me restate that this literacy gap cost our nation $2.2 trillion annually.

249
01:37:52.400 --> 01:38:08.480
However, this issue is not just about statistics. Those numbers represent real students facing real challenges. And Olivia and I have witnessed that firsthand. In my hometown, a fourth grade teacher personally shared with me that she

250
01:38:08.480 --> 01:38:25.119
spends more time on reading and writing remediation than is allotted because many incoming students are reading below grade level. In more rural counties, reading interventionists face additional barriers. With only one interventionist serving approximately 550 students,

251
01:38:25.119 --> 01:38:40.239
according to the code of Virginia, these educators are stretched thin. In Augusta County, where Olivia resides, the difference between Craigswell Elementary School and North River Elementary School's distance is approximately 45

252
01:38:40.239 --> 01:38:56.000
miles. That equates to a 36 minute drive. That is 36 minutes spent on the road instead of working directly with our students. Every minute lost to travel is a minute that could have spent helping a struggling reader develop the

253
01:38:56.000 --> 01:39:12.080
skills they need to succeed. So, how can we improve board? Olivia and I have developed three solutions. Our first solution is incentivizing teachers to obtain reading interventionist certifications. No one knows their students better than

254
01:39:12.080 --> 01:39:26.719
their own teachers. By encouraging teachers to earn their certifications through grants for class classroom equipment, bonuses, or pay raises, we could create a culture in which teachers are better equipped to address literacy deficits in the classroom during

255
01:39:26.719 --> 01:39:42.800
instructional downtime on a personalized level. Second, we should reimburse reading interventionists for their travel between schools. In rural areas, schools are often further apart and serve fewer students. As a result, many reading

256
01:39:42.800 --> 01:39:59.440
interventionists spend significant amounts of time and money traveling. To ease these financial burdens, school budget should include funding for travel expenses incurred between schools for reading interventionists. Finally, we need to establish an afterchool program that includes

257
01:39:59.440 --> 01:40:14.880
literacy centered instruction. Most public schools already offer after school programming for students whose parents enroll them. We can invite parents of children who perform below grade level in reading and writing to enroll their students in these programs.

258
01:40:14.880 --> 01:40:30.560
If we allocate time for a reading interventionist to visit the program and provide targeted instruction, we could seamlessly offer additional support without disrupting students daily routines. To conclude, these proposals aren't

259
01:40:30.560 --> 01:40:47.840
revolutionary. They're not flashy. They're not groundbreaking, but they are necessary because the further students slip through the cracks, the greater the educational and economic consequences become for our communities, our great commonwealth, and our beautiful nation.

260
01:40:47.840 --> 01:41:03.119
I urge you to strongly consider these proposals and continue building upon our great progress of the Virginia Literacy Act. The future of Virginia's students depends on the decisions we make today and it's your responsibility to make

261
01:41:03.119 --> 01:41:25.920
them. Thank you very much. >> Thank you, Fila. Board members, do you have questions? >> Well, I will comment that I very much appreciated your presentation. At my school, we typically say everyone is a reading teacher and you really emphasize that it's not going to be one person,

262
01:41:25.920 --> 01:41:41.040
but it's going to be a whole approach to it. And I particularly appreciate the data that you use and your passion. So, thank you. Um, good luck as you go off outside of Virginia. We won't say where the to uh represent us uh in your future endeavors.

263
01:41:41.040 --> 01:42:07.360
>> Thank you guys so much. >> Thank you. I believe there is one more presentation. Thank you. >> Uh good morning. My name is Carmen. My name is Sophia Robinson. And today we

264
01:42:07.360 --> 01:42:24.400
want to talk about rethinking graduation requirements in Virginia to make them more student aligned and help with attendance flexibility. Before we start, we want to introduce ourselves. I'm Carmen Pond. I'm from Rapahanic County High School. Um I'm representing region 4 and I'm headed to

265
01:42:24.400 --> 01:42:41.360
JMU um to potentially become a physician's assistant. and I'm really interested in um increasing student morale and um helping students get ready for after high school. My name is Sophia Robinson. I'm from Bluefield, Virginia and was a student at

266
01:42:41.360 --> 01:42:56.560
Graham High School and I'm currently representing region 7. This upcoming fall, I'll be attending the University of Kentucky, double majoring in political science and journalism with a minor in communications on the path to become a lawyer lawyer or work in public policy. And what I'm really interested

267
01:42:56.560 --> 01:43:15.920
in is personalized plans for students. The issue we wanted to talk about today is that currently Virginia's education system is still heavily centered around traditional education structures such as seat time, standardized testing credits, and accreditationdriven scheduling

268
01:43:15.920 --> 01:43:31.040
decisions. Although these systems were created to ma maintain consistency across schools, they unintentionally reduce flexibility for students pursuing different post-secondary pathways. Students may feel that parts of their education are focused more on

269
01:43:31.040 --> 01:43:49.320
institutional requirements rather than the meaningful preparation for life after graduation. I saw this firsthand in my school where seniors were required to take classes that they did not need for after graduation. And it required it made them skip school. And um

270
01:45:06.560 --> 01:45:21.360
I'll give you a real world real world example. While I was in high school, I was earning my associates degree and DE was strongly encouraged as a way for students to accelerate their education. However, current policies in my division

271
01:45:21.360 --> 01:45:37.440
uh made DE courses no longer count as a high school class and required students to take extra classes as they did not need to satisfy their high school requirements. Experiences like this can discourage discourage students as a

272
01:45:37.440 --> 01:45:52.719
student can feel like the extra effort required to pursue advanced opportunities are not always recognized or valued. On paper, Virginia has created multiple pathways for student success, but implementation can vary across divisions. If the three E are all

273
01:45:52.719 --> 01:46:10.639
considered valuable outcomes, students should receive equal recognition, support, and opportunity. This issue matters because it impacts students, schools, and communities across Virginia. Rigged graduation requirements can increase student

274
01:46:10.639 --> 01:46:27.920
stress, burnout, and disengagement while limiting access to career focused opportunities like internships, apprentips. English language learners and students with disabilities may face even greater challenges in systems lacking flexibility. These issues also affect schools

275
01:46:27.920 --> 01:46:47.679
abilities to support individualized learning and can leave commuters with workforce shortages and high demand careers. Overall, graduation requirements should focus more on meaningful learning and preparing students for life after graduation. Currently, the standards of quality and

276
01:46:47.679 --> 01:47:04.639
accreditation standards, um, the profile of a Virginia graduate and the 3E readiness framework already supports flexibility through opportunities such as dual enrollment, CTE programs, virtual learning, and wor workbased learning experiences. However, the main

277
01:47:04.639 --> 01:47:20.560
issue is not necessarily the absence of flexibility, but large larger issue in the gap between policy and implementation. Because schools are naturally influenced by the matrix they are judged on, many local systems prioritize traditional

278
01:47:20.560 --> 01:47:39.520
structures. Virginia has already laid most of the groundwork needed to support student centered pathways. The challenge now is ensuring that local implementation um fully reflects their goals. Students experience shows that real impact of

279
01:47:39.520 --> 01:47:55.280
these policies. Many students are required to take classes unrelated to their future goals. While internships, jobs or job shadowing opportunities often conflict with school schedules. Students balancing work, caregiving, or mental health challenges may struggle

280
01:47:55.280 --> 01:48:09.600
with strict attendance policies. Research also shows that chronically absent students perform worse academically, especially those facing economic disadvantages. Overall, the current system does not equally support all students or reflect

281
01:48:09.600 --> 01:48:31.040
the realities many learners face today. We have three recommendations for how to move forward. Um, our first recommendation is allowing students to formally declare a graduation pathway by 10th grade aligned with one of the three E. This will not eliminate core academic

282
01:48:31.040 --> 01:48:46.960
requirements like English and math, but provide students with greater flexibility in electives and career aligned opportunities. For example, a student going into healthcare could prioritize dual enrollment sciences, internships, or healthcare certifications, while a student entering

283
01:48:46.960 --> 01:49:02.239
the workforce could focus more on CTE experiences or industry credentials. Our [snorts] second recommendation is that students should be able to earn graduation credit through the meaningful education experiences like internships

284
01:49:02.239 --> 01:49:18.880
um volunteering dual enrollment courses service learning or job shadowing. Our third recommendation is instead of relying primarily on seat time and traditional testing, students should have additional opportunities to demonstrate mastery through portfolios,

285
01:49:18.880 --> 01:49:37.679
performance assessments, capstone projects, presentations, and industry recognized certifications. Our final recommendation focuses on attendance and accreditation reform. Attendants should recognize meaningful education engagement beyond classroom

286
01:49:37.679 --> 01:49:52.719
seat time, including internships, virtual learning, employment, volunteering, job shadowing, and dual enrollment. We also recommend accreditation systems that value post-secary success such as workplace readiness, apprentichips, credential

287
01:49:52.719 --> 01:50:10.280
attainment, and employment placement. Reducing the focus on seat time metrics would create more flexibility, improve student engagement, and better prepare students for life after graduation. >> Thank you for listening to our presentation. Do you guys have any questions?

288
01:50:12.000 --> 01:50:29.199
>> Mr. both and just wonder if there's a experience that you've had with um an apprenticeship or some other engagement volunteer activity that has had an impact on your path.

289
01:50:29.199 --> 01:50:45.040
I'll speak um not personally but um through my friends a lot of them um didn't feel like their classes aligned with their graduation um a after life after graduation. So, um they instead of

290
01:50:45.040 --> 01:51:01.440
coming to school, they would skip and go work or they would skip and go get CTE certifications or um I live in a rural area so they found more value in going and getting those work experiences than um sitting down and taking that art

291
01:51:01.440 --> 01:51:20.800
class that they don't need or um um a personal experience I've had with an internship is this past session I had the opportunity to be an intern for the Virginia General Assembly during my school semester, which took away seat time for my classes. In the future, I want to go into public policy and

292
01:51:20.800 --> 01:51:38.719
politics. And so, from gaining that firsthand experience was really valuable to me compared to from sitting in a classroom learning about government when I can see it really in person. >> Northern. >> Um, Carmen, I just wanted to get some clarification from you. you were talking

293
01:51:38.719 --> 01:51:54.800
about the dual enrollment course you're taking and I thought you said it wasn't credit it didn't count for credit for high school but to my knowledge dual enrollment gives you credit for community college so can you explain that a little bit to me again

294
01:51:54.800 --> 01:52:11.679
>> yes um when I I was told that I could earn my associates degree while in high school so um I was taking my dual enrollment classes to earn that and um this current year they changed policy so that my classes that I was taking were not counting on my high school

295
01:52:11.679 --> 01:52:27.840
transcript and they told me I wasn't eligible to play sports and so I had to pick up extra classes. Um like I was a TA just so that I could um be in the school building because they weren't counting my dual enrollment class. Um >> didn't count as an elective either.

296
01:52:27.840 --> 01:52:44.639
>> Yeah, they they weren't counting it at all. Um but yeah, >> I think you guys did a great job and you surfaced a real problem. We're often looking for uh industry to step up and provide our kids with more apprenticeships and work-based learning

297
01:52:44.639 --> 01:53:00.480
opportunities. Um but it's really difficult on their end as well reliability and you know they worry a lot about you know how this works for them. So I just encourage you guys to continue to try to problem solve on the employer

298
01:53:00.480 --> 01:53:18.880
side. I think that you know as a board we're definitely open to that but often it seems like we're not getting you know the problem solving needs to occur on the other side as well. >> Wonderful. >> Thank you both for uh this presentation.

299
01:53:18.880 --> 01:53:35.440
Uh glad to know you spent some time in session and that you even came back as you know and are willing to deal with this other public body. says something. Um, uh, did you for those dual enrollment classes, did you have to pay tuition or did the school division pay for it? Because I think it seems to me

300
01:53:35.440 --> 01:53:51.360
that there's both a uh an element of access. Does it work for my schedule and sort of transportation? There's the tuition or sort of the cost impact. And then there's do I get credit for it where I need to get credit for it in

301
01:53:51.360 --> 01:54:08.639
terms of either the graduation, the diploma or the uh associates degree. And I'm just curious about uh the the sort of covering tuition. Yes. Um, my school is a little bit different than every other school because we're so small.

302
01:54:08.639 --> 01:54:25.679
There's 68 in my graduating class. Um, but we were we were told that if it wasn't through the future educators academy or um Mount Vista Governor School that your dual enrollment was not going to be counted. Um, so, you know, I was required to take five classes

303
01:54:25.679 --> 01:54:41.360
instead of four. Um, but I was still able to earn my associates through it. >> Great. Thank you, uh, Mr. Robinson. >> Thank you both for the presentation. Uh Sophia, you spoke about how you were able to have flexibility to do the the

304
01:54:41.360 --> 01:54:58.400
internship. Um uh so I'd like to better understand did you receive credit for that? And when you speak about the attendance reform in some students not receiving uh credit for their internships or job or virtual learning experiences, could you give us a little

305
01:54:58.400 --> 01:55:15.280
bit more flavor into the experiences of your peers uh to help us understand when in your experience students receive credit and when students do not receive credit? >> So um I had two different situations where I was an intern. So, I interned my sophomore year and also my past senior

306
01:55:15.280 --> 01:55:31.360
year and I did not receive credit for either of those internships. Um, I actually had less seat time. Um, so it counted as an absence instead of me being away for an internship and so it was not counted for credit. >> Thank you. Um, in general, thank you for

307
01:55:31.360 --> 01:55:45.920
these three very clear recommendations really from all three student committees. And I I encourage whenever the board receives our next updates in these three topics, the uh Virginia Literacy Act, STEM, as well as pathways,

308
01:55:45.920 --> 01:56:03.520
um, uh, I request that the the staff speak to the these recommendations to help us better understand where practice is. >> Uh, yes, Miss Kilgore. I just want to do like a summary of thanking all four individuals and the other people, young

309
01:56:03.520 --> 01:56:18.560
people in the audience too, who weren't talking, but I'm sure have a lot to say. As someone who spent 36 years of my life, a lot of my time with high schoolers, teenagers. Uh I am so proud to see the representation that you were giving your

310
01:56:18.560 --> 01:56:34.960
age group. I always told my students that when I'd meet somebody for the first time and I told them I taught high school, they'd either look at me like, "Oh, wow. That's just wonderful." or they'll be like, "Oh, wow." And I always tell students, you know, that you're great. You're wonderful. And you four

311
01:56:34.960 --> 01:56:52.000
probably six are reflecting what's good about our young people. And I'm just so proud of all four all four of you for your presentation. Very, very impressive. >> Thank you, Mrs. Kilgore, Dr. Bridges. >> The the poor last presentation, y'all are getting all of the comments about

312
01:56:52.000 --> 01:57:08.320
the process overall, but I did have some questions about the process. Have y'all been meeting since September of this past year? It says monthly meeting since last year. >> Yes, we've been meeting virtually on Teams, >> right? And this program was has transferred is

313
01:57:08.320 --> 01:57:24.480
it this from the governor's student advisory committee to the secretary of ed. Is that right? >> Yeah. Um, and so, uh, that I just want to encourage all of the students who who, uh, did these presentations and are heading off to find institutions, two of

314
01:57:24.480 --> 01:57:40.080
which I'm an alumnest of, um, to wander the campus and hit up the school of ed at your um, and your school of public policy because even if you're a STEM major, engineering, pre-public health, um, that you you all have demonstrated

315
01:57:40.080 --> 01:57:55.440
um, really great insights into public policy through these presentations. and into public education. So, take a class over there, y'all. And um and you just never know, career paths shift and you've got a long life of career ahead of you. If you can bring some of this

316
01:57:55.440 --> 01:58:12.159
back to Virginia's public policy and education system, we would love to have y'all. So, thank you very much and thank you to um Secretary Smith for shephering um such a fabulous program. >> Great. So, just closing out, I want to also just um echo our appreciation for

317
01:58:12.159 --> 01:58:27.840
Carmen, Sophia, Wilson, Kyla, Olivia. I know there were two who are not here. Um I echo Miss Kilgore's comments just around the belief around what's possible for our young people. Uh we have been deliberating over these policies at

318
01:58:27.840 --> 01:58:44.800
least feels like for centuries. Um, and the way that you have so articulately talked about uh, literacy and graduation requirements and STEM requirements really makes it very real for us. And so again, thank you for your comments. I

319
01:58:44.800 --> 01:59:00.480
want to thank also to the parents of these young people. You did a very good job. Um, as well as to the teachers that you all have had over these last 12 years and we really do wish you the very best in what you uh, pursue next. And I

320
01:59:00.480 --> 01:59:15.599
echo Dr. Bridges, please stop by the school of education for each. We need you back here teaching in the next generation. So thank you with that. If all the young people just presented, we're going to take a picture outside and we will also take uh about a

321
01:59:15.599 --> 02:17:00.960
10-minute break. So thank you. going to convene back in session. Thank you for allowing us a brief break. Um going to the agenda, we have um two items proposed for the consent agenda.

322
02:17:00.960 --> 02:17:17.280
Is there a motion to wave first review and approve the items on the consent agenda? >> So moved. >> Second. >> Great. Let's do roll call. Dr. Bridges. >> I. >> Mrs. McFersonson.

323
02:17:17.280 --> 02:17:33.840
>> Hi. >> Mr. Hansen. >> Dr. Nor. >> Hi. >> Dr. Wilson. >> I. >> Mr. Robinson. >> I. >> Mrs. Kilgore. >> And chair votes I. Thank you. Okay, now we are now moving to uh our

324
02:17:33.840 --> 02:17:55.399
action discussion items. Um we have a final review of the divisions eligible to exit a memorandum of understanding with the Virginia Board of Education. Dr. Ballard, welcome. >> Yes, ma'am.

325
02:18:00.479 --> 02:18:17.040
Good morning, President Ashton, uh, Superintendent Conway, and members of the board. I am Quinton Ballard, and I serve as the director in the office of school improvement. Today, I will present for final review information about three school divisions

326
02:18:17.040 --> 02:18:38.559
eligible uh, to eligible to exit their respective memorandum of understanding with the Virginia Board of Education. Today's final review will include uh an overview and history of the use uh ofus

327
02:18:38.559 --> 02:18:53.200
to improve student outcomes, information about the three divisions eligible uh to exit theirou with the board and then finally recommendations to the board for consideration. Hold make sure

328
02:18:53.200 --> 02:19:09.840
it was this. Okay. And so as shared during the April board meeting, a memorandum of understanding is a formal agreement that defines responsibilities of the board, the local school board, the division superintendent, and Virginia Department

329
02:19:09.840 --> 02:19:26.800
of Ed staff to strengthen implementation of the standards of quality and improve student outcomes. When the board determines that failure of schools to meet standards is related to division level failure to implement the standards of quality or other division level

330
02:19:26.800 --> 02:19:43.120
action or inaction a division level academic review may be required. Uh the division level review uh intends to refers to the process that is actually used to analyze a school division's systems and practices to determine uh

331
02:19:43.120 --> 02:20:01.439
the degree to which the local school board is meeting its responsibility as prescribed uh in the standards of quality outcomes from this division level academic review inform the development of theou between the board and the local uh school board.

332
02:20:01.439 --> 02:20:18.880
And so since 2004, just to reorient ourselves, there were eight school divisions that have entered an MOU with the board. uh after implementing interventions to build local capacities for improvement for these divisions uh exited theirou status. The board has been instrumental

333
02:20:18.880 --> 02:20:38.240
in the process by establishing division level uh review processes and selection criteria in 2004 2012 with the latest occurring in 20 and 204. And so from July of 2000 through uh

334
02:20:38.240 --> 02:20:54.399
September 2025 of 2024, uh Virginia school accountability system included an integral integration, if you will, of of uh pre-acreditation compliance standards and student pass rates on the uh standards of learning and other alternative assessments. This

335
02:20:54.399 --> 02:21:11.840
resulted in an overall accreditation rating for individual schools uh such as fully accredited conditionally accredited credit with war credit accreditation denied and so in 2024 the regulations were revised which separated the accountability from uh accreditation

336
02:21:11.840 --> 02:21:27.520
and current the currentou exit criterias were established under the prior unified accountability and accreditation system and so therefore these divisions operating under theou [clears throat] status. Uh uh therefore divisions

337
02:21:27.520 --> 02:21:43.840
operating I'm sorry underou status are currently measured against criteria aligned to a system that is actually uh no longer uh in effect. And so it is in September the board updated uh its regulations and set forth updated

338
02:21:43.840 --> 02:22:00.640
criteria for a division level uh academic review and clarify that such review includes both academics and what's called a resource allocation review. And so the regulation specifies in particular that if a division has 40% of schools identified for comprehensive

339
02:22:00.640 --> 02:22:16.399
or additional targeted support or 10 or more schools identified for comprehensive support, then it is eligible for a division level academic and resource allocation review. Based on these criteria, Danville City,

340
02:22:16.399 --> 02:22:35.600
Greensville County, and Prince Edward County no longer qualify for MOU status based on their performance as illustrated on the slide that you see presented. And so the department, the Virginia Department of Ed conducted a virtual uh we conducted virtual exit interviews

341
02:22:35.600 --> 02:22:51.200
with uh division superintendent and their board chairs of Danville City, Greensville County, and Prince Edward Prince Edward County to gather feedback and information about their experience with theou process. Um the VDOE staff

342
02:22:51.200 --> 02:23:07.840
were uh honored to be joined by President Ashton uh or Vice President Hansen during each of the exit interviews. Uh during these structured interviews, uh participants reflected on successes and challenges uh of theou

343
02:23:07.840 --> 02:23:23.520
process, divisionwide strategies implemented to improve systems and processes uh and plans to sustain progress uh subject to release from uh theou. The uh VTOE plans to certainly use this

344
02:23:23.520 --> 02:23:39.040
information gleaned from the exit interviews to evaluate the effectiveness of its support, inform the design of future support, and certainly address assess if you will the contextual fit of professional learning activities uh by considering factors uh a number of factors that include division size,

345
02:23:39.040 --> 02:23:56.000
demographic and other factors. And so, uh, the appendix, uh, included in today's board presentation contains the individual exit interview findings for Danville City, Greensville County, and Prince Edward County. Uh, the, uh, VODE

346
02:23:56.000 --> 02:24:12.319
analyzed the exit interview findings and identified several common themes, uh, which I'll certainly take an opportunity to review, uh, briefly. Uh the first theme that was identified uh was a VODE oversight and technical assistance

347
02:24:12.319 --> 02:24:27.600
benefited the division by creating certainly a sense of urgency uh building capacity uh and monitoring uh progress. And so these divisions shared how theou requirements uh certainly did create a

348
02:24:27.600 --> 02:24:45.840
certain sense of inj uh urgency for them and a point of emphasis of rallying uh school and division and community leaders uh to engage uh if you will uh in the work of improvement together. They talked about the needs assessment and corrective action plans uh uh

349
02:24:45.840 --> 02:25:03.840
serving uh as a model and using data and aligning stakeholders around if you will these common actions that were inquire required to uh lead improvement. They talked about the uh support that was gathered from the VDOE and provided from

350
02:25:03.840 --> 02:25:20.560
VDOE. Uh whether that was through the office of school improvement or the office of instruction or any office uh that was at the agency and how they felt that you know as it relates to on demand support uh their needs certainly were uh a priority. Uh and they spoke of a

351
02:25:20.560 --> 02:25:35.840
variety of professional learning resources again and grants that were provided uh toou divisions uh to support their work. And so that really speaks to uh some positive impact of theou support that these divisions have received from

352
02:25:35.840 --> 02:25:50.720
uh the VDOE. Uh as it relates to uh on the flip side of that some challenges andor limitations. The second theme they identified were uh some bureaucratic delays, unclear or inconsistent communication, overly ambitious

353
02:25:50.720 --> 02:26:05.600
corrective action plans andor uh staff attrition uh caused uh some challenges. And so to that extent uh these divisions talked a little bit about how um there were delays in the accountability results if you will that subsequently

354
02:26:05.600 --> 02:26:21.840
had an impact on uh the approval of their um school improvement grant funding. Um they talked about the time to receive feedback from VDOE on prospective licensed administrative candidates and and certainly being conscientious of the uh awareness that

355
02:26:21.840 --> 02:26:37.760
uh uh those transition and hiring of individuals not only have on it their division but also uh if it was such that leaders were transitioning from other divisions. Certainly um you know it was an impactful if you will uh and important that they got uh those

356
02:26:37.760 --> 02:26:54.000
approvals and notifications in a timely manner so that the other divisions could certainly work uh to fill vacancies that were subsequent as a result of individuals transitioning in. Um and then they talked a little bit about the communication processes uh and limited knowledge of theou process subject to

357
02:26:54.000 --> 02:27:08.880
you know transitions uh in whether that was in leadership roles um in terms of division leadership andor certainly there have been changes uh in board members as well um that have been serving in these divisions uh since uh

358
02:27:08.880 --> 02:27:23.680
the the inception of theou and so uh they talked a little bit about the protocols and orienting them to the process and then certainly uh staff attrition that both within the division and also um

359
02:27:23.680 --> 02:27:39.200
uh uh here at the agency as well. And so from a sustainability standpoint, the third theme that emerged from our meeting um identified was that division's plan to continue systematic processes related to the routines, data

360
02:27:39.200 --> 02:27:55.760
analysis, engagement uh and uh human resources that um uh they they've worked on. And so we attempted here uh theou uh divisions have all indicated uh just a relentless focus on they they talked

361
02:27:55.760 --> 02:28:12.160
about being in the business of of supporting people uh and certainly recruitment uh development and retention of staff. You'll see that there was a focus on they've talked about focusing on data analysis to inform instruction and monitor the impact of practices on student performance improvement

362
02:28:12.160 --> 02:28:28.399
graduation rates and to address student and teacher attendance. They also are talking about sustaining taking some measures to ensure that they continue to implement community engagement practices. Uh there was emphasis and references around uh uh outreach efforts

363
02:28:28.399 --> 02:28:44.720
uh with town halls, listening sessions and confirm with experts related to family engagement. Uh and then the the division plans to certainly continue human resources practices for again as I've mentioned recruitment development uh and retention of highly qualified licensed staff. Uh and there was also

364
02:28:44.720 --> 02:28:59.840
another point of of of emphasis around restructuring key positions in operations and instructional oversight to enhance the organizational effectiveness uh and to help drive the student achievement uh efforts for sure. And so

365
02:28:59.840 --> 02:29:14.960
uh although these uh the three school divisions have met if you will the criter the exit criteria are being recommended for release uh from uh their respective. The department intends to continue to provide support uh uh to

366
02:29:14.960 --> 02:29:30.000
these school divisions identified for uh to to their schools, I'm sorry, identified for improvement based on federal accountability and uh the support performance and support framework. And so uh that support would certainly include but not limited to uh

367
02:29:30.000 --> 02:29:46.960
continuation of access uh to use of school improvement grant funding uh invitations to participate in learning network opportunities for their principles and teachers. uh continuation with on demand technical assistance subject to their identified need any identified needs prioritized placement

368
02:29:46.960 --> 02:30:03.359
in VDOE sponsored professional learning opportunities and then monitoring certain visits for their schools that are uh federally uh identified. And so based on the information provided uh in this presentation,

369
02:30:03.359 --> 02:30:19.840
uh the superintendent of public instruction um would recommend to the board to accept for final review the uh recommendation to release the Danville City School uh school board from the memorandum of understanding with the Virginia Board of Education that was

370
02:30:19.840 --> 02:30:37.040
enacted on June 18th of 2020. released the Greensville County School Board from the Memorandum of Understanding with the Virginia Board of Education that was enacted on March 22nd of 2018 and released the Prince Edward County School Board from the Memorandum of Understanding with the Virginia uh

371
02:30:37.040 --> 02:30:53.600
school board that was enacted on June 18th of 2020. And so at this time, I will answer any questions from the board if you permit me. Before I do, uh you've heard from Dr. Hariston uh and uh during public comment who is present here

372
02:30:53.600 --> 02:31:08.800
today, if you'd allow me a moment of privilege to also share that representation from all three of these divisions are here today. Uh we do have uh the division superintendent uh Dr. uh Jones who is here from Prince Edward

373
02:31:08.800 --> 02:31:25.439
County Public Schools. He's joined by uh his board chair, Mr. Townsen, vice board vice chair, Miss Kimbro, and board member Miss Simpson. And then he's also joined by his director of instruction, uh, Miss Garrett, who's also here with us. And then certainly representing

374
02:31:25.439 --> 02:31:41.200
Greensville County Public Schools. We have the new superintendent effective May 4th of 2026, uh, uh, Dr. William Wright Jr. is certainly present here uh, today as well. And I do have a colleague of mine who is also here from the office

375
02:31:41.200 --> 02:31:57.120
of school improvement, Miss Brick, who you heard Dr. Harris did mention a little bit who has been very instrumental in doing a lot of the work around improvement and graduation and individual. So I would want to take an opportunity to acknowledge and thank her for being here as well. And at this time I entered any questions from the board.

376
02:31:57.120 --> 02:32:11.680
>> Superintendent Conway. >> Wonderful. Thank you Dr. Ballad and just uh want to make sure the board understands in addition to all of the important insights that Dr. Ballard shared just how much time uh was spent

377
02:32:11.680 --> 02:32:29.120
with us in preparing this. I know at the April board meeting we talked about the eligibility criteria, but then this body asked us to really explore what did we learn from theou process and how would we know as a body that this work would be sustained. And so each of these

378
02:32:29.120 --> 02:32:45.359
superintendent, board chairs and respective uh local leaders came together with us for 90 minutes took question after question. many of them came prepared with slides and data and insights just demonstrating their

379
02:32:45.359 --> 02:33:00.479
commitment to the students uh within their communities. And so just deep appreciation for not only those 90 minutes and all we learned from you, but just all the preparation and all uh the work done over recent years to improve

380
02:33:00.479 --> 02:33:18.000
outcomes for your students. >> Great. Thanks, Superintendent Conway. Mr. Hansen. >> I just would really like to um thank the department for its leadership and working with these three districts and just had the opportunity to

381
02:33:18.000 --> 02:33:34.720
participate in the Danville uh city school board um exit interview. And I just really wanted to shout out to Angela Haristen and her leadership. It was um you know I had a

382
02:33:34.720 --> 02:33:51.680
couple of takeaways from the meeting and just how uh you got from there to here and you know the things that jumped out at me was that it's leadership and um but it's also community engagement uh which uh

383
02:33:51.680 --> 02:34:09.640
was very prevalent. It's also the the partnership with the department and again I think it's incredibly important when you're going through this type of a process that it's not viewed as punitive. It's not a gotcha. It's how do we um

384
02:34:09.840 --> 02:34:26.080
solve the problems but also build for the future um where we're going and what needs to be done. And so I, you know, in many ways too, I just in terms of everybody being here too, it's just, I think, such a reflection of the resiliency and hard work and teamwork

385
02:34:26.080 --> 02:34:41.600
that has gone on over the years. But I just wanted to take a minute and just say thank you to um all of the leadership at Danville, but also to the the department. It just it was very apparent um sitting in that meeting that

386
02:34:41.600 --> 02:34:59.120
um I was just witnessing all of the you know hours of drives and the binders of preparations and the data and uh that you know went into getting the results of where you are today. I just really wanted to commend you and

387
02:34:59.120 --> 02:35:16.479
thank you to hard work and especially to Sar's leadership that you've brought to the table for the the kids and the families of Vandel. >> Great. Um I would like to also add my

388
02:35:16.479 --> 02:35:31.359
appreciation first to Dr. Ballard. you know, it's like seven lines that has this motion to uh release you all from an MOU, which has no indication of so much work that has been put into this process. So, thank you for your

389
02:35:31.359 --> 02:35:48.960
leadership and your thoroughess. And you know, the board asked uh as we were going into this to really to share the lessons learned and you went through all of them, but there are a couple of them that really stuck out to me and I think um for for any school division that is,

390
02:35:48.960 --> 02:36:06.880
you know, is, you know, close or maybe close to this, like they really need to take some lessons from you all and I want to share them. Um and the the first is radical transparency um and honesty. Um we talk a lot about the honesty gap

391
02:36:06.880 --> 02:36:23.760
and in all the conversations that I had with you all um you were radically clear um you were honest, you were hopeful um but you didn't shy away from the real data and facts about what was happening for our young people. And I think that

392
02:36:23.760 --> 02:36:39.920
for me was particularly inspiring. Um the second thing that really stood out is the relentless focus on what's actually happening in classrooms. And so uh at times you can be so high level performance frameworks, accountability,

393
02:36:39.920 --> 02:36:56.560
high quality instructional materials and you all really said what is happening daytoday in our classrooms um for our young people. Uh the the next thing that stood out is a relentless focus on the data. And so whether it was making sure

394
02:36:56.560 --> 02:37:13.200
that you had the right staffing and the capac the capacity but that you looked at the data and used that to inform the decisions that you were making. Uh and then I think some lessons that we need to consistently think about um and you

395
02:37:13.200 --> 02:37:28.960
all did incredibly well on this is communication with key stakeholders. um there because you mentioned some of the transitions and staff and board the need for consistent and constant communication around exactly what does

396
02:37:28.960 --> 02:37:46.479
this does this mean that we are anou um and making sure that there's yearly communication from the staff from the board that really overcommunicates to make sure that we don't lose time um as as you're working towards this. Um and

397
02:37:46.479 --> 02:38:03.200
then the last thing was again just the compliment to the staff in terms of the involvement and specifically the hiring um whether it was superintendent thinking through staff changes because there was so much change. I think I was on a call with someone had you literally

398
02:38:03.200 --> 02:38:19.600
been in like two weeks on the job. And so you you understand the number of changes that requires communication with a lot of stakeholders so that we don't lose time and our and our young people don't lose time. And again, I just want to echo how much I appreciated your

399
02:38:19.600 --> 02:38:34.720
transparency, your honesty, and your really just relentless focus on what our students and families need. So congratulations. >> Yes, Mr. Robinson. Thank you. Um, building on those themes,

400
02:38:34.720 --> 02:38:50.160
I I want to first of all express gratitude for the divisions again for uh giving your time and for the board chair, vice chair, superintendent, uh, uh, Quinton and team, Mr. Ballard and team uh, for helping us shape these

401
02:38:50.160 --> 02:39:04.640
lessons to help us inform how to improve this process going forward. It's just so beautiful to see the collective ownership shown here that's been made possible. uh through uh you know the the collective commitment to not accepting

402
02:39:04.640 --> 02:39:20.960
the status quo and to believing in your students and getting in systems and structures and collective effort and collaboration to to do [clears throat] something about it and uh so I can't express enough gratitude to those in the room who've been standing up for our students through your efforts. Um uh I

403
02:39:20.960 --> 02:39:37.439
think the state should use this process more. Uh I think this the lessons show uh the power of partnership between uh the VDOE and divisions what it looks like when done incredibly well. Um a lot of lessons learned are exactly what we

404
02:39:37.439 --> 02:39:52.880
want to see. Greater urgency, greater focus on instruction, greater focus on data, greater focus on systemic ownership versus saying it's on the teachers and on the individual schools to do something about our students who aren't seeing success. saying no, this is a collective effort that we're

405
02:39:52.880 --> 02:40:07.439
actually going to hold accountable uh systems as well as the state and what we're collectively doing in partnership differently to better serve those furthest from opportunity. And so uh as I think about the lessons learned about how we could improve going forward, I

406
02:40:07.439 --> 02:40:24.640
really uh encourage us to um as we get more experience with this new framework to um to to rethink the criteria uh because I think the criteria were established you before we had experience with the framework and so you're seeing

407
02:40:24.640 --> 02:40:41.600
again great effort across all three divisions and I am seeing a a difference as well in Danville. I'm seeing um the number of schools out of 13 that are needs intensive improvement or off track is actually below the percentage of schools in the state that that qualify

408
02:40:41.600 --> 02:40:58.160
for the same piece. And uh uh in Greenville, you know, I'm seeing zero of their three schools in the needs and needs intensive improvement category. In Prince Edward, I'm seeing a lot of great improvement. that's in that's uh great for students uh and result of incredibly

409
02:40:58.160 --> 02:41:14.000
high effort and still two out of three schools either in needs and improvement or comprehensive support and improvement. And so if this process is good and helpful to divisions uh then I would personally like to see um you know

410
02:41:14.000 --> 02:41:30.479
that partnership continue in divisions that are in such situations uh uh in the future when we have different criteria. not advocating for change of the criteria midstream right now. So that that's number one, keep the bar high because it's a good thing to be part of this. We're designing it well. Um uh

411
02:41:30.479 --> 02:41:46.160
number two, uh the you lifted up the duplicative requirements and the corrective action plans uh as well as um the other plans required by the division in Greenville. It said there were 108 essential actions.

412
02:41:46.160 --> 02:42:01.840
Um, obviously there were not 108 essential actions to be done. If you're focused on uh so many things, you're not focused on anything. And um and I commend the Greenville leaders for despite uh the VDOE requiring 108 essential actions obviously having

413
02:42:01.840 --> 02:42:18.960
greater focus than than we provided them. Um [gasps] and so really encourage us to look at those lessons learned from the divisions for going forward. And finally, the piece about knowledge transfer. Again, back to collective ownership. It sounds like a lot of great efforts done at the front end of establishing these MOUS on

414
02:42:18.960 --> 02:42:35.040
on establishing expectations and what we're going to co-create together, but it sounds like there are a lot of lessons in terms of how as as board members change at the division level, as superintendents change, as principles change, how do we have a process to ensure continued collective ownership?

415
02:42:35.040 --> 02:42:52.080
Um, uh, again, these are all things that are made possible thanks to the result of everyone who participated in those interviews. And I just wanted to stamp those lessons. Um and uh thank you for the time. >> Great. Thank you, Mr. Robson. Um Mr. McFersonson,

416
02:42:52.080 --> 02:43:10.240
>> um we talked about the exit of the memorandum understanding and the accomplishments there. But I also wanted to point out that it as it relates to these three school divisions, obviously it was not all their school systems that caused them to enter into memorandum of

417
02:43:10.240 --> 02:43:25.280
understanding and we got to always remember that there were a whole lot of bright spots um as it relates to these three divisions. And what's um really key that sometimes maybe we overlook as we were going through accountability standards and looking at proficiency,

418
02:43:25.280 --> 02:43:42.720
all three of these divisions um were spotlighted for programs that they had that we could look at and that we could model after. So I just want to celebrate your achievements as well. So, you've done well in terms of correcting some deficiencies, but we also want to

419
02:43:42.720 --> 02:43:59.359
celebrate all of the good things that were done and the fact that we found those as we were going through this process in all three of those divisions. >> Thank you. Any other board members? >> Yep. >> Dr. Bridges, >> just probably echoing some of what my colleagues have said about um coming out

420
02:43:59.359 --> 02:44:16.479
of theus. I just wanted to amplify a couple of things. um the the theou process creating a sense of urgency I think is a really critical piece but I also want to echo something that I a mantra from when I teach sustainable improvement um and that is urgency

421
02:44:16.479 --> 02:44:33.279
without resources strategy and capacity building is energetic chaos um and so we talk a lot about a sense of urgency and I I know y'all had to actually use that urgency kind of corral that urgency and really think strategically about as some

422
02:44:33.279 --> 02:44:49.520
of my colleagues have said, what do you prioritize? Because if you're if you're doing all the things, you're you're prioritizing none of the things, right? So, um with that in mind, I think it's really helpful to see from those exit interviews, uh the levers that really made a difference for each community

423
02:44:49.520 --> 02:45:03.680
because you can see in that it's not a one-sizefits-all. There are definitely elements that y'all have in common in terms of that focus on curriculum, focus on instruction, focus on good governance, right? um focus on stakeholder communication and

424
02:45:03.680 --> 02:45:20.720
collaboration, but the extent to which uh different le levers were being pulled in these respective communities show you got to be really targeted and focused on what the community needs. Um, so congratulations to all of them and thank you to the department for getting this

425
02:45:20.720 --> 02:45:37.920
data so that we can learn to continually improve and support districts cuz uh I'm not sure I agree with my colleague uh William that we want moreus. We want more support on the front end so that nobody has to have anou, right? like that that that you're that you're

426
02:45:37.920 --> 02:45:54.800
continually being supported in a way that you feel you can target the state support to the needs that each local community has. And I do note in y'all's um exit interview data, the sustainability piece is going to be critical. And there are resources

427
02:45:54.800 --> 02:46:11.680
embedded in each of those elements that y'all talked about. the professional learning for Prince Edward, the PLE program and monitoring through Cognia for Danville, the technical assistance that y'all got in um Greenville through the literacy grants, the innovation grants, the math grants, all of that is

428
02:46:11.680 --> 02:46:28.000
that's resources, right? And so for y'all to keep us posted on how you're able to sustain when some resources from the state perhaps get directed in other directions. So, please keep keep the state posted on how the resource piece

429
02:46:28.000 --> 02:46:44.080
is going because that's critical to sustainable improvement. We can have short-term success um through lots of hard work, but it's only going to sustain if you again strategy, capacity building, resource support, right? Um, and I would say one of the hard lessons

430
02:46:44.080 --> 02:46:59.279
I learned when I was a local schoolboard member was um, until the community embeds these practices, you you will have things erode anytime there's leadership turnover, schoolboard turnover, classroom teacher turnover.

431
02:46:59.279 --> 02:47:15.439
And so really thinking deeply about how do we keep the community really bought into what's going on in our schools? Um, because they're the keepers of best practices. Um, and so you didn't ask me for advice and y'all are certainly doing a lot of things really, really well. And

432
02:47:15.439 --> 02:47:31.920
I'm looking forward to just don't don't not stay in touch. Keep us posted on how sustainability is happening because that's really the key for every school division in this Commonwealth. We want to be able to see everyone sustainably successful and y'all are on the path to leading the way for that. So, I look

433
02:47:31.920 --> 02:47:46.720
forward to hearing more and thanks to your office and all of y'all who are trying to gather the information so that we can make sustainable improvement a reality across the Commonwealth. >> Thank you all. I know it was so hard work. >> Okay, let's get to the action. That um

434
02:47:46.720 --> 02:48:02.640
being said um one other thing that you all did mention I did want to raise for the for the group is the differences between the rural um and more suburban and urban like the having different experiences and making sure that we are mindful of I think what you talked about

435
02:48:02.640 --> 02:48:19.439
Dr. Bridges the resources and the the constraints that they experience. So I did want to raise that. Um, but with that, is there a motion to approve the release of the Danville City School Board from the memor memorandum of understanding with the Virginia Board of

436
02:48:19.439 --> 02:48:36.560
Education enacted on June 18th, 2020, the Greensville County School Board from the Memorandum of Understanding with the Virginia Board of Education on March 22nd, 2018, and of the Prince Edward County School

437
02:48:36.560 --> 02:48:52.319
Board from the Memorandum of understanding with the Virginia Board of Education enacted on June 18th, 2020. >> So moved. >> Is there a second? >> Okay. Roll call. Dr. Bridges. >> I. >> Mrs. McFersonson.

438
02:48:52.319 --> 02:49:07.720
>> Hi. >> Mr. Hansen. >> Hi. >> Dr. Northern, >> Dr. Wilson, >> I. >> Mr. Robinson, >> I. >> Mrs. Kilgore. Hi. >> And chair votes. I. Congratulations.

439
02:49:11.920 --> 02:49:26.479
I'm gonna ask you guys to stand up. Yes, you guys should stand. Absolutely. Congratulations. Now you get to do even more work. So, congratulations. And thank you, Dr. Bowen. >> Thank you, ma'am.

440
02:49:26.479 --> 02:50:15.040
>> So, thank you. Thank you. >> Thank you. We're gonna go ahead and uh get back in session. Uh we'll take a couple more actions before lunch break as our uhou

441
02:50:15.040 --> 02:50:41.279
exited divisions are celebrating. I was wondering who all those people were. Okay, we have up for up for consideration final review of the guidelines for 2026 27 of the early childhood unified

442
02:50:41.279 --> 02:50:58.160
measurement and improvement system. >> Yes. Yeah. Excellent. Thank you so much uh members of the board for having us here this morning. We're technically still in the morning. Um I'm Erin Carroll, deputy superintendent of early childhood and

443
02:50:58.160 --> 02:51:12.640
I'm joined by Chris Meyers, director of quality measurement and improvement. Um and we are excited to be coming back to you for the second time to talk about the Virginia quality uh birth of five system otherwise known as VQB5 and our

444
02:51:12.640 --> 02:51:30.160
proposed guidelines for the 2627 school year. Um so this is a brief overview just talking uh high level and offering some reminders. We did have of course um as you all remember the in-depth discussion uh related to VQB5 and the

445
02:51:30.160 --> 02:51:46.960
birth of five system overall uh in April. Um, so want to just offer a few refreshers this morning about our system, some of the major proposed uh revisions that are included in the 2627 guidelines and give you some updates on the work we have been doing since April

446
02:51:46.960 --> 02:52:03.439
to get ready for those. Um, so as we uh talked about in April, there are several uh guiding principles that we have embedded in our VQB5 system since its initiation. So we are closing out right now our third full year of VQB5 required

447
02:52:03.439 --> 02:52:19.439
participation. It's really our fifth year though because we had multiple practice years before that. Um and from the beginning uh we have focused our system on uh some shared principles. Those are uh a system that is focused on improving school readiness. So tying to

448
02:52:19.439 --> 02:52:35.279
outcomes and uh what is um seen in preparing uh children for kindergarten. Um we have built a system that focuses on providing actionable data. Um so making sure that what is coming out of the system is useful for educators, for

449
02:52:35.279 --> 02:52:52.240
program leaders and for families. Um we have built a system that we uh focused on making affordable and scalable knowing the vast scope of the early childhood landscape um and number of teachers that we are um including. and

450
02:52:52.240 --> 02:53:07.760
then uh primarily a system that is focusing on increasing opportunity and access for all children. Um as we are closing out our third full year operating statewide, we are really uh feeling like we are in more of a steady state. uh things are slightly

451
02:53:07.760 --> 02:53:24.240
more predictable and that has enabled us to come to you with a set of uh two revisions that we think are building on the momentum and the solid foundation that we uh have in place in our statewide uh measurement and improvement system. Um so again two kind of key

452
02:53:24.240 --> 02:53:40.560
changes that we talked about in April. The first was moving from a three rating system to a five rating level system. Um so we have rolled out the system thus far with three levels. Those have been need support meets expectations

453
02:53:40.560 --> 02:53:56.319
and exceeds expectations. Um and this has been critical I think in the early years to help folks get familiar with the rating system and the tool um the tools that are embedded within it. Um however what we see after several years

454
02:53:56.319 --> 02:54:14.000
of data now is that the vast majority of our programs are scoring in that middle meets expectations bucket. Um and so we have proposed to shift to a fivelevel system that will uh differentiate that middle which currently has about 99%

455
02:54:14.000 --> 02:54:31.279
998% of programs in it uh to a system that would include five levels. So that would be distinguished, exceeds expectations, meets expectations, approaching expectations, and needs support. Um, this will help families understand that there are distinctions

456
02:54:31.279 --> 02:54:50.720
in quality. It will better reflect meaningful differences um and give families and providers more information about what is taking place in each of the sites they are. Um the second key proposal that we talked about in April is somewhat

457
02:54:50.720 --> 02:55:05.359
related to this also. Um so we are proposing to expand uh the requirements for improvement planning. So as it is right now we have required improvement planning for uh the lowest performing sites that fall into the need support uh

458
02:55:05.359 --> 02:55:22.319
bucket. Uh in this next uh iteration of the system we would also have requirements for those that are in the bucket right above that. Um we think this is really important. Those sites are demonstrating some needs and we want to make sure that that is where we are prioritizing our resources, prioritizing

459
02:55:22.319 --> 02:55:39.680
our coaching services um and our TA services that have proven to be uh very successful thus far with our programs who have participated in it via uh the need support uh system. Um so since April we have continued to

460
02:55:39.680 --> 02:55:57.040
uh socialize these and be in the field for this proposal. Uh we have continued with overall communication and field preparation uh through newsletters, webinars working very closely with our ready regions. Uh we have done 18 engagement events since

461
02:55:57.040 --> 02:56:14.319
April. Um and have had over 2,000 webinar views of our uh webinar that goes through these proposals that we delivered to the field in April or March. I think we have also continued to prepare our system. So there's a set of updates that need to be in place for

462
02:56:14.319 --> 02:56:30.560
some of our technology systems for next year. Those are getting ready in our on the go. Um and we have been notifying providers or preparing to notify providers of these proposed shifts. So importantly, these shifts will all affect the ratings that are coming out a

463
02:56:30.560 --> 02:56:46.960
year from this fall, fall 2027, following uh the upcoming year of observations and uh data. So following the 2627 year, but we want providers to have a chance to really um understand what this would mean for them. Uh we're

464
02:56:46.960 --> 02:57:02.240
preparing for this summer uh when we share the rating that folks will have privately with providers to also let them know what this would look like on the five level system next year. So not not that that will be their rating but just so they can kind of envision what

465
02:57:02.240 --> 02:57:18.720
that would look like a year from now. Um and then of course we've also completed our uh year three uh a successful year three of statewide implementation for VQB5. So, this has involved um completing class observations in over

466
02:57:18.720 --> 02:57:35.040
3,200 sites um completing over 9,000 coaching sessions uh and preparing to share that in the fall. Um so, in summary, uh these proposed updates uh strengthen the clarity, fairness, and usefulness of the VQB5

467
02:57:35.040 --> 02:57:50.880
system uh while ensuring that all sites receive supports and focusing those on those that need them most. Um and with board approval today uh the department will finalize the FY27 BQB5 guidelines um and continue preparing the field uh

468
02:57:50.880 --> 02:58:06.640
for the next year. Questions? >> Great. Great. Thank you board members. Are there any questions? Dr. Wilson. >> Deputy Superintendent Carol. Thank you for this presentation and the reminders of the path that you all have been on. I

469
02:58:06.640 --> 02:58:23.520
have a couple of maybe a question and an observation. um an observation in the board uh material. I noticed that the spring engagement events, it looks as if compared to prior events that most of

470
02:58:23.520 --> 02:58:39.600
them most of those events were not available for virtual participation. So live events versus recorded views. So I'm assuming that in the earlier um introduction to the public there were virtual options for

471
02:58:39.600 --> 02:58:57.439
attendance and then in the spring or recently there have not been. Can you speak if that is the case and then can you help us understand you know kind of the the logic and thinking about how to um have that opportunity and then I do have a question as a followup.

472
02:58:57.439 --> 02:59:14.720
>> Sure. So um oops these are all virtual actually I think they are all virtual. >> Yes they are not all recorded. So depending on where they were >> um so most of these were um I'm looking

473
02:59:14.720 --> 02:59:29.359
down at the list. Most of these were delivered specifically to like a Head Start director meeting or like a a specific occurrence. So they were to a targeted group. our main way of getting to the public and we do have a ton of

474
02:59:29.359 --> 02:59:45.279
engagement with that is um through that proposed guidelines webinar. So again um we had about 200 people attend that and then it's been viewed over 2,000 times since then. Um we we also have a survey that we collect after that and read and

475
02:59:45.279 --> 03:00:01.040
and respond to those comments as appropriate from that. Um we have not done a ton of virtual or inerson only events. um a few conferences here and there >> that clarifies so live attendees. Yes. >> Not necessarily. >> Yeah. Yeah.

476
03:00:01.040 --> 03:00:16.399
>> Okay. Great. Um and then the only other observation was uh during public comment today, we did hear some concern about some of the um changes. And so I do note here in the materials the opportunity

477
03:00:16.399 --> 03:00:33.520
for the public to continue to weigh in. Yeah. As this moves >> to its next stages. >> Yep. Absolutely. And we um you know continue to be open and receptive to feedback as we refine the system year-over-year. Um we think it's really

478
03:00:33.520 --> 03:00:48.000
important. We've we've come to the board every year. I think for five years now uh or four maybe I don't know a [snorts] good number of years. Um uh again, not necessarily with huge changes, but just with an opportunity to reflect some of

479
03:00:48.000 --> 03:01:08.880
what we're hearing um and hope to continue to >> Thank you. Uh and thank you, Dr. Wilson, Deputy Superintendent Carol, and Director Myers. Thank you all so much for all of the work that has gone into this presentation and this engagement

480
03:01:08.880 --> 03:01:24.560
over the course of the spring. uh for members of the board. I know we discussed this at length um in an earlier session, but just noting that this is a nationleading measurement and improvement system year-over-year

481
03:01:24.560 --> 03:01:41.600
progress um and this ability to kind of work with uh all of our public private partners. You know, as a as a reminder, it is always a choice to take public funds to serve uh early childhood children and that because of some of the

482
03:01:41.600 --> 03:01:58.160
uh priorities for those funds, it is by design children and families who are furthest from opportunity. The Commonwealth has never uh served more children than before uh and it in its history with public dollars. And so to be able to roll out a rigorous

483
03:01:58.160 --> 03:02:13.600
measurement system while continuing to grow access and to do that in partnership with providers who always have the option to walk away represents a significant accomplishment for the team, for our ready regions, our uh our

484
03:02:13.600 --> 03:02:28.479
partners in the field who help us uh build these relationships, complete these observations, gather all this data, engage our families. There's a family council in each of our of our regions and all of the improvement partners. At the end of the day, this is

485
03:02:28.479 --> 03:02:44.080
about changing levels to create, as we just talked about in the prior presentation, greater urgency, but as Dr. Bridges noted, with resources, with capacity, with strategy, and to improve. And so, year-over-year, you see that

486
03:02:44.080 --> 03:03:00.640
floor being lifted. And what that means is if you need to rely on a public dollar to access early childhood in the Commonwealth, you can count on it being quality and being experience that will prepare your child for kindergarten. Thank you all so very much. >> Thank you, Dr. Dor.

487
03:03:00.640 --> 03:03:16.479
>> Um reiterating comments here from my colleague. Um I think in terms of the feedback that we received, one of the things that stuck out to me was this visual media. we're seeing such a backlash against small children being exposed to visual media at such a young

488
03:03:16.479 --> 03:03:33.040
age. Um I obviously honestly haven't gone through detail through your long document. Um but to me you know they they are suggesting media use up to two hours per day. Um not more than you know if they are in operation for more than

489
03:03:33.040 --> 03:03:48.720
six. No more than total of two hours per day for children two years of age and older. I'm like, "Yes." Like, my goodness, let's not be putting kids two and three years old, hours on end in front of visual media. So, if that's not in there, I'm not saying it is or isn't,

490
03:03:48.720 --> 03:04:05.359
but just do continue to encourage you to get as specific as you can about the dangers of too much media at such a young age. >> Yep. Superintendent Conway, >> uh, that is actually related to the child care licensing regulations coming later in the agenda. So it will be it

491
03:04:05.359 --> 03:04:25.200
will be deputy superent Carol again but I just you know >> we are bringing you two giant documents. >> Okay. Um any question board members? Any question? >> Okay. Uh then is there a motion to approve the guidelines for 2627

492
03:04:25.200 --> 03:04:41.439
of the early childhood unified measurement and improvement system VQB5? >> So moved. Is there a second? >> Second. >> Oh, okay. We're very excited here. Okay. Dr. Bridges. >> Hi, >> Mrs. McFersonson.

493
03:04:41.439 --> 03:04:57.600
>> Hi, >> Mr. Hansen. Hi, >> Dr. Northern. >> Hi, >> Dr. Wilson. >> Hi, >> Mr. Robinson. >> Hi, >> Mrs. Kilgore. >> Hi, >> and Chair Rose. I thank you. Okay, we can get a couple more in before lunch

494
03:04:57.600 --> 03:05:15.520
here. Uh, we have upped the final review of the Virginia textbook and high quality instructional materials process. Welcome. Just came out of nowhere [clears throat] >> in the holding room back there. You know, just here. So, good morning,

495
03:05:15.520 --> 03:05:30.960
President Ashton, Superintendent Conway, and members of the board of education. Um, and just prior to me getting started, I just want to tie in an update for Dr. bridges um and the board and the recentou item and as related to this high quality instructional materials but

496
03:05:30.960 --> 03:05:46.560
we have um region 8 is actually having some training today on high quality instructional materials as related to their math innovation grant. So here's your timely update of the ongoing support that those divisions are still receiving and Greensville and Prince Edward are participating in that today

497
03:05:46.560 --> 03:06:01.840
as part of the regional training. So that support is still ongoing as Dr. Ballard mentioned. Uh and so as you've been hearing through various presentations over the last two days, Virginia is moving in the direction to ensure that students have access to highquality instructional materials

498
03:06:01.840 --> 03:06:18.640
commonly referred to as HQIM. These materials are curricula and educational materials that are aligned to standards, our standards of learning and reflect evidence-based practices for teaching and learning. standards and HQIM work together to fulfill the many expectations defined by the code of

499
03:06:18.640 --> 03:06:35.680
Virginia and the priority set forth by the board of education. Virginia legislation now defines textbooks in HQIM and has directed the board to review and revise the existing process to align with such definition and expectations. Through a series of

500
03:06:35.680 --> 03:06:51.439
feedback, we had overwhelming support for the existing process and then to also expand that process to bring in the tenants of high quality instructional materials as well as to provide additional support to the field in how they should process and how the process

501
03:06:51.439 --> 03:07:06.319
should be run in their local school divisions as they look to make their final adoptions locally. Since the last meeting, there were no recommendations from the field. However, there was a recommendation shared by a board member which was reviewed and considered. Uh

502
03:07:06.319 --> 03:07:21.040
those final recommendations can be found in attachment one which should have been updated uh this morning and also in your packet. So, I'll kind of point you to where those recommendations are and where we landed with those recommendations.

503
03:07:21.040 --> 03:07:36.880
Um, page 10, which actually might be page 12 of the PDF, but page 10 of the document at the at the footer, uh, is just a slight wording change, um, that focuses on the the impact of student

504
03:07:36.880 --> 03:07:54.560
outcomes and then a slight rearrangement of the the the phrase building on the understanding and rationale for curriculum components. Kind of shifted that language up. It's highlighted in in a blue color like that seafoam blue color uh for you to see. Um on page 12,

505
03:07:54.560 --> 03:08:12.319
which would be possibly page 14 of your PDF is um we added in the review of evidence of effectiveness and that this would um be formally included in the review. But as you look down at the second part near the end of

506
03:08:12.319 --> 03:08:28.960
page 12, section 3 information, um we we felt that that evidence of effectiveness would be best to be shared with board members upon the recommendations for adoption as well as with division leaders as they consider when they are

507
03:08:28.960 --> 03:08:47.040
reviewing and adopting materials locally. Um we we felt that evaluating that that that level of the research that's already taken place would be um might be a little difficult for our teachers to do, our teacher committees as they're

508
03:08:47.040 --> 03:09:02.720
not really trained in that. But we know that divisions have experts that do that and then we have experts on staff that can kind of review that and then we'd provide that to the board so that you could see what research was presented in relation to the adopted materials. We

509
03:09:02.720 --> 03:09:19.920
thought that was a a nice compromise to the recommendation. Um, we like the recommendation and certainly love the support of the evidence of effectiveness. Um, but just want to make sure that we put that in the appropriate place for division leaders to consider. Um, there are were no other changes. Um,

510
03:09:19.920 --> 03:09:36.000
so the attachment one would be the version that we would be considering today. Um, and so you have before you the final review for the Virginia textbook and high quality instructional materials process. The superintendent of public instruction recommends that the

511
03:09:36.000 --> 03:09:51.279
board of education approve the revisions as outlined in the boilerplate. And I'm not not going to read all of them because it's many. Um, but you can see what those out uh those recommendations are uh to the Virginia textbook highquality instructional materials

512
03:09:51.279 --> 03:10:07.120
review process. And then action by the board today allows the department to proceed with informing school divisions on the updated adoption process for textbook and high-quality instructional materials in Virginia as required by the code of Virginia. And then also the

513
03:10:07.120 --> 03:10:22.640
process will inform current ongoing adoptions for materials to support the Virginia Literacy Act as well as future adoptions which we plan to bring to you a timeline a couple of timelines at our August board meeting. >> Wonderful. Thank you board members. Are

514
03:10:22.640 --> 03:10:40.399
there questions? Mr. Robinson, thank you for your responsiveness to the field to the board. Love the and love the thoughtful process that you've laid out here. Uh my question is in the superintendent's recommendations uh and this was in your presentation April as

515
03:10:40.399 --> 03:10:58.560
well. Uh the process includes in one um bullet three assessments to monitor student mastery of curriculum content. I I wanted a quick clarification for comment on um whether that's new in the past, India, after we passed the the

516
03:10:58.560 --> 03:11:15.920
higher standards in literacy and math and if so, what's new about that compared to prior adoptions? >> So, great question. Prior adoptions really focused on textbooks themselves, just really the teachers edition and the students edition of textbooks. Um the

517
03:11:15.920 --> 03:11:32.560
the bullet that you're referencing is actually part of the code of Virginia, the legislation that was passed last year in 2025 through House Bill 2777. And um what it does is, you know, when we talk about HQIM, we've already been training divisions on HQIM over the last

518
03:11:32.560 --> 03:11:49.200
6 months. Um and when we talk to divisions about this, you know, you think about the the teachers edition and the student edition. It's really for teachers, it's just the book, right? The textbook. Um but the high quality instructional materials components come in when we add in those layers of

519
03:11:49.200 --> 03:12:04.399
support for teachers. The assessments would be those ongoing assessments that support the lessons that teachers are teaching. And so that that is new. We're looking at a package. We will be looking at a package to to evaluate versus just

520
03:12:04.399 --> 03:12:18.960
that standalone textbook. And so it's like it's like the whole kitten kaboodleoodle, right? But it's it's everything that the teacher would need, including supports for them to learn more about the curriculum and the content. >> Um well, I'm all in favor particularly

521
03:12:18.960 --> 03:12:36.560
as legislatively required um of um [laughter] of uh of curriculum based assessments that you know align to uh high standards and that provide teacher support etc. I I just want to uh uh notice the

522
03:12:36.560 --> 03:12:53.040
Commonwealth listening tour finding about modernizing and reducing assessments is important to um uh stakeholders across the community. And so again, I've seen in many schools the uh these type of curriculum based assessments be incredible tools to help

523
03:12:53.040 --> 03:13:08.160
uh but I've also seen many schools that the addition of these curriculum based assessments further reduce uh uh uh clarity about what's most important with standards further enhance confusion about when do I use diagnostics versus

524
03:13:08.160 --> 03:13:24.160
other formats versus interims versus and uh so I I think based on your comments in April your team's already doing a great job of this. Uh but want to further encourage specifically as I fear that more divisions will have more confusion with more assessments that

525
03:13:24.160 --> 03:13:40.720
they think are fully required uh towards how do we help divisions and schools provide them with with templates and guidance and other advice about how to streamline and make coherent their assessment strategy. >> Yeah. So that's actually part of the

526
03:13:40.720 --> 03:13:56.560
some of the training that we've been doing around instructional coherence and ensuring that once um once a division has selected those HQIM that they are looking at those materials, they're looking at our standards of learning. Um one of you know just point out no core

527
03:13:56.560 --> 03:14:11.040
instructional program is going to be 100% aligned to our standards of learning all the time. Um you can look at other states that also have other standards and they've adopted these materials. they also have to kind of fill in where the core does not meet

528
03:14:11.040 --> 03:14:27.520
their standards. And so, um, when we're talking with school divisions, we're we're encouraging them. I mean, these this is the whole kitten kaboodleoodle, but their local curriculum is going to their local adoption and then their local implementation will really inform which assessments they're going to use

529
03:14:27.520 --> 03:14:42.560
from those products or from, you know, the that textbook and HQM package. and they have to really carefully think about the assessments that they are already given students. You know, these in assessments with the HQM are really intended to inform instruction on a

530
03:14:42.560 --> 03:14:58.479
regular basis on that formative regular basis rather than the summitative at the end of the the year assessments. And while I do agree the the listening tour pointed out the the need to reform assessments, um I think that most of the

531
03:14:58.479 --> 03:15:14.960
field is talking about the endofyear so assessments um related to those reformations and so um certainly divisions have lots of assessment policies that they have locally adopted and we would encourage them always to look at them as they're looking at this

532
03:15:14.960 --> 03:15:30.560
implementation at the local level for that instructional coherence. Superintendent Conway. >> Thank you, Dr. Wallace. I'd also like to add uh Mr. Robinson that this law which is incredibly explicit about the

533
03:15:30.560 --> 03:15:47.200
importance of HQIM and the requirements for it is also very specific about that focus on coherence ensuring that it's used in a way uh that is aligned with promoting student mastery of content [clears throat]

534
03:15:47.200 --> 03:16:04.479
prioritizing our schools in greatest need. And so going back to the point you made previously about uh the 108 essential items or action items and the risk that that then does not create a clear path forward. I also think you will hear us come back to this body and

535
03:16:04.479 --> 03:16:19.840
talk about when we think about agencywide school improvement and that mandate from another law um that tying these two laws together and thinking about what that means in each of our classrooms, not just our systems, but each of our classrooms in our federally

536
03:16:19.840 --> 03:16:35.680
identified schools and that HQIM and how it's used and the extent to which the system understands how it's being used and is giving that feedback to educators will be a key piece of it. And so you'll see these different pieces of law coming together and but ultimately towards the

537
03:16:35.680 --> 03:16:52.000
end of school improvement >> you um [clears throat] Dr. Northern. >> So thank you for integrating the evidence of BIT. Um I really appreciate that and I like the way that you guys did that. I think it was important because we kept talking about evidence

538
03:16:52.000 --> 03:17:08.319
base but then we didn't say like that we're actually looking at evidence. Um so that's key. Um just three quick things. Um, I just would caution us generally to keep the list tight. You know, um, Louisiana has five K5 core

539
03:17:08.319 --> 03:17:26.080
programs at tier one. Uh, let's see, Tennessee has five core programs across K5, and these are two states that have generally taken a more restrictive approach to curriculum quality reviews, and they tend to have made pretty significant gains on NAPE. Um to your

540
03:17:26.080 --> 03:17:41.920
point about coherence, um you know, not to [clears throat] plug a recent study that my organization did, but we recently did a study on a nationally representative sample of um of literacy teachers across the country. Um and they're telling us they're doing, you

541
03:17:41.920 --> 03:17:58.479
know, looking at three and four curriculum, right? And so there's not coherence. And even though they say they're just using supplemental or intervention, like teachers are just, you know, often times they don't they're not really doing what we want them to do between like just using intervention,

542
03:17:58.479 --> 03:18:14.640
supplemental in this limited tiny way. Um so anyway, I think we should keep the list tight and I think over the years as continued research comes out on these curricula, we should continue to tighten the bolts. Um, I just feel like we need to start separating the wheat from the

543
03:18:14.640 --> 03:18:29.600
chaff. Like HQIM is like, oh, HQIM is like this national thing now and the evidence hasn't caught up with it yet. So, just quickly, another little plug. um when we actually looked at the knowledge of the standards of the knowledge of the science of reading and

544
03:18:29.600 --> 03:18:46.479
the curriculum um letters which is not a curriculum but it's a PD letters uh the the teachers who took letters knew far and away more about the science of reading than other teachers who I mean they're all correlations it's not a random study um you fly the teachers who participate in UFly knew more so letters

545
03:18:46.479 --> 03:19:03.520
UFly uh CKLE Amplify so like to me like I think CKLA amplify is on our So great. Um I don't know how many of our divisions are participating in letters or you fly but like that's what that's what's now pushing that's that's what evidence is showing us is making uh

546
03:19:03.520 --> 03:19:19.200
teachers um at least correlated with more knowledge. And the last thing I'll say um is just that the um the uh where was my last point? Oh, actually, no. Oh, the alignment that you can have alignment, but it can still be

547
03:19:19.200 --> 03:19:35.279
a crummy curriculum, right? Because you have no evidence of effectiveness even though it's aligned. Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. Uh, any other questions for board members? If not, is there a motion to approve the revisions to Virginia's

548
03:19:35.279 --> 03:19:52.560
textbook and highquality instructional materials review process as described in the item presented to the board? Second. >> Okay. Uh, we'll do roll call. Dr. Bridges. >> I. >> Mrs. McFersonson. >> Hi.

549
03:19:52.560 --> 03:20:08.160
>> Mr. Henson. >> Dr. Northern. >> Hi. >> Dr. Wilson. >> I. >> Mr. Robinson. >> Hi. >> Mrs. Kilgore. >> Hi. >> And Chair RHS. I. Thank you. >> Thank you. >> All right. We have We're going to keep going

550
03:20:08.160 --> 03:20:24.319
until we So, we have to break. Here we go. Um so now we're considering final review of the revisions to guidelines for the school construction assistance program for the 202426 bianium. >> Thank you President Ashton. Good morning

551
03:20:24.319 --> 03:20:40.000
or good afternoon. Good afternoon board members and good afternoon Superintendent Conway. Um this item was presented to you in your April board meeting. There have been no changes to the proposed uh revisions to the 202426 bianial school construction assistance

552
03:20:40.000 --> 03:20:56.319
program guidelines. Um for reference, by the way, I am Christina Bird, a chief operations officer. Sorry, I forget to do that uh all the time. Uh just for the public and for you all as a reminder, the key changes and highlights to the proposed guidelines are adjustments to

553
03:20:56.319 --> 03:21:11.920
the points to score for poor B building conditions to enable some of our divisions that were slightly short of the qualifying points previously to potentially qualify for new funding considerations. We have added based on feedback from you all a criteria for

554
03:21:11.920 --> 03:21:27.680
division enrollment trends using our VDOE fall enrollment numbers allowing divisions to score five points for increased enrollment or if their enrollment remains unchanged from the previous year. Um also allowing uh to make that change we had to make some

555
03:21:27.680 --> 03:21:43.680
reductions in three areas. one being a reduction for ADA uh an ADA question uh debt capacity maximum score and condition of all school buildings score. Uh we have made adjustments to the individual student percentage in our

556
03:21:43.680 --> 03:22:00.960
school nutrition programs fiscal stress designation and poverty percentages also to en enable some school divisions that were slightly short of the qualifying point requirements to potentially qualify. We have also added language in the procedures on the final project cost

557
03:22:00.960 --> 03:22:17.439
um that are below what the estimated costs were to make sure that we are ensuring that we get funds back if we overawward at the beginning of the process and the actual project does not result in that uh uh cost that you have approved. Um they have to achieve a minimum score of 65 points out of 100.

558
03:22:17.439 --> 03:22:35.120
Upon your adoption, we will uh issue the award notification to you and hopefully at your August board meeting be bringing back um proposals for you to consider. So with that, um happy to answer any questions, but we are asking you today to approve the changes in the guidelines

559
03:22:35.120 --> 03:22:52.000
so that we can issue our grant application process. >> Thank you. Board members, are there any questions? Okay. Oh, Dr. I um I just there were two small things I just wanted to bring bring to

560
03:22:52.000 --> 03:23:09.600
discussion. Um one we talked about last time the enrollment issue the fact that we have just dropping enrollment everywhere. And I do see thank you that you guys added um an indicator in there for three points for building enhancements and flexible space concepts after schools consolidate or close. Um I

561
03:23:09.600 --> 03:23:25.840
was just wondering if we could bump that up a little bit. Like that should be six or seven. I feel like that should give more weight um than maybe some of these other things or maybe that's just a subjective judgment, but I felt like we, you know, it would be nice if we give them a little bit. And the other place

562
03:23:25.840 --> 03:23:41.359
um that I thought that might be helpful is um I think they got the same points for unchanged enrollment. Yes. >> And dropping enrollment. And to me, unchanged shouldn't be the same as >> it's unchanged and increasing. >> Five points for unchanged and

563
03:23:41.359 --> 03:23:58.080
increasing. Can we do three for unchanging? >> Um, we looked at that, but it's hard for us to program that in the back end. Um, for us to have variable and quite honestly, there are not that many that are unchanged. Most of them are either a positive or a negative. There aren't

564
03:23:58.080 --> 03:24:14.479
very many that are unchanged. Certainly, we can look at that. And to your first point, what I would recommend is school construction assistance program funding is in the budget for 27 and 28. So, we're going to have to go through this process again. I would recommend with these changes, let's see what it results

565
03:24:14.479 --> 03:24:29.920
in, see how we can impact school divisions, and then potentially we could consider that as a change for the the next iteration if that's acceptable to you. >> Okay. Any other questions? >> Okay. Is there a motion to approve the proposed amended guidelines for school

566
03:24:29.920 --> 03:24:46.560
construction assistant program for the 2426 banum as shown in attachment one to the item as presented to the board? So moved. >> Is there a second? >> Second. >> Second. >> Okay. Dr. Bridges. >> Hi.

567
03:24:46.560 --> 03:25:05.359
>> Mrs. McFersonson. >> Hi. >> Mr. Hansen. >> Dr. Northern. >> Hi. >> Dr. Wilson. >> I. >> Mr. Robinson. >> Hi. >> Mrs. Kilgore. >> Hi. >> And chair votes. I. Thank you. We're going to go one more and we'll

568
03:25:05.359 --> 03:25:23.239
have lunch. Okay. Is there someone? Oh, yes. There we go. Um, we have the final final review of the Virginia School Accreditation System report for school year 2526. >> Good afternoon, Mark. >> Good afternoon.

569
03:25:24.080 --> 03:25:40.000
>> Oh, good afternoon, Board President Ashton, Superintendent Conway, and board members. Today, I will be presenting uh the final review for Virginia's school accreditation report for 2526. Uh, this is available to the public as item G, attachment one. In addition, the board is going to be asked to accept for final

570
03:25:40.000 --> 03:25:55.760
review the accreditation appeal process also for school year 2526 available as item G attachment 2. Uh at the April 23rd board meeting, we requested first review of this item and since then uh there has been an addition to the

571
03:25:55.760 --> 03:26:12.000
report. Uh this follows well after Dr. Wallace's report. We are asking school divisions in accordance with House Bill 2777 and the standards of quality one that goes into effect July 1st, 2026 to provide for the department the highquality instruction materials that

572
03:26:12.000 --> 03:26:27.359
they are using. We are very clear in the report. This is strictly forformational purposes. It does not affect a school's accreditation status. It does not affect a division uh sort of you know any of the findings. It's it's simply for information gathering and it's a good way to do it because the superintendents

573
03:26:27.359 --> 03:26:43.840
are signing off on this and collecting it. So that was a revision since the April uh report that we shared with you and it is on the redline version available to the public. Uh from here if the board adopts this, we'll be sending communication out to the schools uh to the superintendent and their design uh

574
03:26:43.840 --> 03:27:00.319
with a timeline, the materials they would need uh and then the window for them to complete this report. So at this time I turn to you for any questions and just request the public the superintendent of public instruction would recommend that the board would receive for final review Virginia's school accreditation system report and

575
03:27:00.319 --> 03:27:20.080
appeal process for the 2526 school year. >> Thank you board members. Are there questions? Okay. Uh then is there a motion to approve I'm sorry. >> Oh yeah. Go ahead. >> Dr. on the literacy plans. Remember you guys

576
03:27:20.080 --> 03:27:35.040
showed it us last year. Just make sure we're not duplicating the HQ. >> Excellent. So, excellent point that that did come up given sort of the when the literacy plans were developed in sort of the years of when the textbooks were adopted and that were strictly for literacy. We're looking for all content

577
03:27:35.040 --> 03:27:54.000
areas and we're looking for all grade levels. So, this would be more expansive. So for this part, we're looking to see that divisions, you know, from what they offered at that time that this would be the most updated information and with any new uh revised list that the board has adopted. >> Right. This will include your reading,

578
03:27:54.000 --> 03:28:09.920
math, science, and history. Whereas the literacy plan was strictly around literacy. >> Just one quick followup. When they have to report all this, is this all just yes or no? Like >> when they get to the question, it's yes or no. They answer no. Then they give us more information about why they were out

579
03:28:09.920 --> 03:28:26.520
of compliance. They tell us which schools and then what they're going to do to be in compliance for obviously for the HQIM. It's open response. They're able to put information there and they can designate by school level, division level, uh grade level for that part. >> Thank you.

580
03:28:26.720 --> 03:28:44.160
>> Yes. >> Absolutely. So you'll see there at the end the superintendent will need to certify with a wet ink signature and that was something coordinating with the office of attorney general uh to make sure they've seen this reviewed it and signed off. Uh in coordination with this we also do a report for the standards of quality. I mean that's separate than

581
03:28:44.160 --> 03:29:00.399
this. This is standards of accreditation uh and that's a separate report division superintendent has to do and you see in the red line where some of these items were removed for that reason that they're also certifying there. Uh but we want to be specific that these are regulations the board has adopted for accreditation for their schools.

582
03:29:00.399 --> 03:29:16.720
Great. Um, Superintendent Conway. >> Yeah. Thank you, uh, Mr. Jennings. So, Dr. Northern, just to lay this out, it is in the literacy plans, but it sort of it's not just the name, it's sort of how it's being used and a broader explanation. So, our team under the

583
03:29:16.720 --> 03:29:33.520
leadership of Dr. Wallace has gone back and told we have, for example, an internal spreadsheet of everything being used. And so, we'll go back and look for CKLA, CKLA, uh, and and and UFly and can come back to you on that. Um so but this will be in one place in spreadsheet format from

584
03:29:33.520 --> 03:29:50.239
the outset and again it will not be asked in the same way in the literacy plan but the literacy plan is really about the how you're using it and kind of the the the sort of the more narrative description. So we we'll we'll we'll double check that there's not redundancy because I know we heard from the superintendent association this

585
03:29:50.239 --> 03:30:06.560
morning on the desire for streamlining reporting to the department but there's slightly different contexts. Um uh and this will be our uh source of truth on HQIM going forward. >> Dr. Bridges, >> can you just talk about um the timeline

586
03:30:06.560 --> 03:30:22.640
for collecting once this is adopted or approved by the board? How soon do you think that you'll be able to get the data? And then how do y'all publicly report out this report? >> So once if this is adopted by the board, we will send communication in two weeks

587
03:30:22.640 --> 03:30:37.680
to the division superintendent and their design. uh we open the window for around 5 weeks for them to complete this. We realize you know we have new superintendents to start July 1st. We make sure they get acclimated. They have to you know get their reports settled. Uh we then give a time uh to collect the

588
03:30:37.680 --> 03:30:52.720
data, analyze it and then we have part of this appeal process. Uh we share back with them our initial preliminary results. If there's misunderstanding on the questions sort of we we you know they they scored it this way we're seeing it this way. Uh that happened last year based on interpretations of

589
03:30:52.720 --> 03:31:08.399
the regulations. So we do all of that before we even submit to preliminary reports that's in our internal system. Uh and that that's their first look to see it and then again uh once they go public uh we're anticipating that for uh part of our our joint release with the

590
03:31:08.399 --> 03:31:24.800
school performance support framework uh in October then it's on the school quy profiles and what you see on that report there is by each school you will see the status of accreditation. If they're not accredited, uh we have a coding system to show that uh they might be conditionally accredited and why, which

591
03:31:24.800 --> 03:31:41.040
specific area of the 11 items. And if the school had to submit additional information, we show that as well. So, you know, sort of a approaching progress, uh there's an icon that we use. It's like a little yellow symbol to say the school was not in compliance, but they have a corrective action plan.

592
03:31:41.040 --> 03:31:57.359
They're making efforts in this area. So, they are fully accredited. Uh but it's something the department and the school are monitoring. And so, that is public facing. It's one of the first uh pages on this the uh school quality profiles >> October. >> It would be in October. But again, part of this appeal process before you is to

593
03:31:57.359 --> 03:32:12.000
make sure there are multiple feedback loops before we get there so divisions can appeal. Um they can, you know, make sure we're all on the same understanding and if it goes to go to the October, then the official appeal will go to the board to say they want to submit more information to you.

594
03:32:12.000 --> 03:32:30.080
>> Great. Thank you. Um, with that, is there a motion to approve Virginia's school accreditation system report and appeals process for school year 202526? >> Is there a second? >> Roll call. Dr. Bridges. >> I.

595
03:32:30.080 --> 03:32:45.120
>> Mrs. McFersonson. >> I. >> Mr. Hansen. Dr. Northern. >> Hi. >> Dr. Wilson. >> Hi. >> Mr. Robinson. Hi. >> Mrs. Kilgore. And Cher's eye. Thank you. Right. This will be our last one before

596
03:32:45.120 --> 03:33:01.279
we uh break for lunch. And this is for final review of amendment nine to Virginia's >> Oh, we're Okay, great. So, we'll break for lunch now. Okay. Wonderful. We're going to uh go ahead and break for lunch. It is

597
03:33:01.279 --> 03:33:20.000
12:24. I'll say we'll come back at 1:30. Wonderful. And we're going to have our students join us. >> A Okay. 112 1:15. Okay. 1:15 we're going to go for lunch. Sorry, the

598
03:33:20.000 --> 03:33:33.960
math is Yes. Okay. And our our our students from our panel, we do invite you to join us for lunch upstairs. We'll be back at 1:15 uh on the dot.